เกี่ยวกับตอนนี้
Join us today for a detailed discussion on the recent decision to end US military aid to Israel, including the political timing around the midterms, the factions involved in delaying the move, and its potential effects on long-term alliances. Malcolm and Simone conversation explore historical precedents from Jewish history, civilizational differences, and strategies for navigating shifting political landscapes. Their conversation also covers the broader context of foreign policy shifts, identity considerations, and future geopolitical alignments between the US and Israel.
Episode Transcript
Malcolm Collins:Hello, Simone. I’m excited to be here with you today. Funny thing, a while back on Basecamp, I requested something. I said, this is what we as Republicans should stand for, and a bunch of people called me antisemitic. They said, how dare you? Now you hate on Israel too? And yet, about at the stupidest possible time, Netanyahu decides to go along with my suggestion. And I had laid out why they should have done it. And if they had listened when I told them to do it, Israel and the American Jewish population would be in a lot better place than they are now. Because, unfortunately, for a lot of people, this last midterm election was a referendum on Jews. That’s the way a lot of people are taking it. And even with the concession of cutting the military aid to Israel, which I had suggested in the past and got massive pushback for, Despite the fact that it’s what Jewish conservatives in Israel have wanted for a long time, it’s what Netanyahu has directly said that he wanted to pursue for a long time, and it’s obviously in our best interest. The the group that was preventing us from doing this was American Jews, not Israeli Jews. The the political factions in control wanted to end this a while ago in Israel, and we’ll talk about why they wanted to end it. but those groups, the idiotic American Jews that kept this, you know, ADL or whatever, or said, oh, how how dare you? The types of people who yelled at me when I said we need to stop this. they unfortunately have created a very dangerous situation for, the potential of a long term American Israeli alliance going into the future.
Speaker 5:And I wanna be clear about this because I said this was gonna happen regardless earlier, and I said you need to do it now. You need to do it now. And people said, oh, Malcolm, you’re being anti Semitic. Everyone who said that, you’re a threat to the Jewish people. You’re a threat to Jews because I was right and you were wrong. Okay? It did happen eventually, and it happened at the worst conceivable time.
Malcolm Collins:So when I requested that this be cut off, it was right after the Gaza war had ended. I say, let’s frame this as a day one. Like, their enemies are in disarray right now. We don’t need to move ahead with this. And if the Trump administration had done it then when I said to do it, they would have faced significantly less pushback for getting into the Iran war because they would have just made what would seem like a pretty significant concession to the don’t do what is... Whatever it is real tells you to do faction of the Republican Party. if they had done it near the beginning of the Iran war, that would be fantastic. But what Trump ended up doing was doing it the literal day of the election after most people had voted on a Fox News call in when most people, most conservatives don’t even watch Fox News.
Simone Collins:According to him, it had been he decided months ago.
Malcolm Collins:If he had, then they’re idiots. now as to the timing of it, you can be like, yeah. Shouldn’t they have waited till after the midterms? Well, they couldn’t really. Like, okay. Let... Let’s go into the various things here. If you if you were looking at the polling around the election and everything like that, one thing was very clear. Okay? There was going to be a lot of Democrats coming into power. Not a big deal. We’re gonna have a weekend episode on the midterms. I I don’t I don’t see the midterm blowout as that big a deal. The the the branch that really mattered in The United States right now is the executive branch, and the judicial branch. and we’re pretty good on both of those fronts for now, and we were actually going to probably perform much less worse in the next election cycle if the Republicans had an iron clamp on the government going into that, it it it would look very bad. Basically, you never win after something like that. so we sort of needed to lose these elections to have a shot at the next election cycle.
Simone Collins:Honestly, kind of the harder you lose, the better you are likely to be able to get a swing back of people being mad at the new establishment.
Malcolm Collins:At the new establishment.
Simone Collins:Mad at the new establishment if the new establishment isn’t your opposing force.
Malcolm Collins:Yeah. But going into this, first of all, basically, whatever Jewish faction was preventing this from happening before given that Netanyahu’s wanted this to happen for a while, I think they read the writing on the wall. Right? Like, the Democrats have become an explicitly anti Semitic party at this point. And with, you know, many ties to, you know, saying globalizing infatata, for the river to the sea, regular democratic events. Like, these are explicit calls for genocide. And, you know, they can say, oh, well, you know, not not exact... That’s the stuff. Democrats have gone out and said, oh, well, you know, the the people in the in the Middle East who are fighting this, like, the the Muslims, they don’t they don’t want explicit genocide. And leaders of those movements have pushed back, they’ve been like, I mean, we do. Like, I... You don’t speak for us, you upper class white person. Like, don’t you don’t you speak for our movement? Don’t you speak for our people? But we’re we’re seeing this more and more. It’s becoming more and more like yeah, everybody knows this is this is the play these days. And, by the way, I... I’ll just note because this gets me so annoyed with the people who are like, well, not all Jews are pro Israel. And I’m like, yeah. And the ones who aren’t don’t really often have a long term vested interest in the Jewish people. Like, it’s these these upper class, you know, wealthy reformed Jews in Manhattan with, you know, one kid or whatever that have these perspectives. Because anyone who has looked at Jewish history knows that, like, when Jews are in a country that is a non Jewish minority country, they typically had pogrom... Like, the Holocaust wasn’t like a one off event. You know? And then pogrom were constant for the Jewish people, for pretty much all of their outside of Israel history. The... To to think that, like, why would they want a place that’s their own? Like, there’s there’s a reason why you would want this if you have a vested interest in the long term success of of of the Jewish people. So I get really annoyed when when people come at me like that. I’m like, okay. Well, apparently, I care more about the long term interest of the Jewish people than you if that’s what you’re coming at me with. Because... Or or you just have... You you can’t project... Because even right now in The United you’re seeing attacks on Jewish students in schools. It’s not right wingers who are lading these attacks. Everybody knows it. But on on this topic... And by the way, one of one of the reasons why people can be like, oh, Malcolm, why why do you see any sympathy? When I see somebody going out there and protesting on a campus, you know, from the river to the sea, I I know exactly what they think about straight white men as well. Not not very... Not a lot. You know? The the the Fair. The hate’s a high overlap there. Right? You know, common enemy and all that. As I’ve as I’ve pointed out with my Harry Potter analogy. Okay? Suppose you care about the spell curve or the amount of in in the wizarding world, this is the amount of magic you have. Because…
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit basedcamppodcast.substack.com/subscribe