Dehumanizing the Modern Battlefield (Bill Whittle) 8/6/26

WEBVTT
00:00.176 --> 00:03.686
This is The Catholic Current with Father Robert
00:03.718 --> 00:07.261
Matague. Aristocracy is rooted in the word arete,
00:07.646 --> 00:11.894
virtue. So aristocracy is meant to be rule by the virtuous.
00:12.118 --> 00:15.949
I don't see anyone like that on the world stage today. Why is
00:16.046 --> 00:19.556
that, in your view? There's no question that you're correct. You don't see anybody
00:19.652 --> 00:22.875
out there with that kind of moral power, and I don't see them
00:22.939 --> 00:26.000
out there either. But just because we don't see them doesn't mean they're not there.
00:26.305 --> 00:30.008
Our history is pretty much an endless, unbroken series of people that
00:30.508 --> 00:33.880
needed to be there when we needed them to be Praise
00:34.380 --> 00:37.420
be Jesus Christ. This is Father Robert McTeague of the Society of Jesus, your daily
00:37.920 --> 00:40.600
host for The Catholic Current, where we bring Christ to the world and the world
00:41.100 --> 00:43.500
to Christ. You're listening to us from the Station of the Cross Studios, your local
00:44.000 --> 00:47.940
radio station, the iCatholic Radio mobile app. We proclaim the fullness of truth
00:48.440 --> 00:51.760
with clarity and charity. As always, let's start with prayer.
00:51.880 --> 00:54.780
In the name of the Father, Son, and the Holy Spirit. Almighty God, through the
00:55.280 --> 00:58.140
intercession of Saint Ignatius Loyola, we ask that you pour forth your Holy Spirit upon
00:58.640 --> 01:01.900
us, a spirit of discernment that might hear your voice and obey your command.
01:02.400 --> 01:05.502
In the name of the Father, Son, and the Holy Spirit. Amen. Well, friends,
01:05.518 --> 01:09.100
you know that I have been a rabid consumer of
01:09.196 --> 01:12.505
news since at least junior high school, also something of
01:12.521 --> 01:16.183
a student of history. And I know that human beings spend
01:16.683 --> 01:20.664
a lot of their time and energy trying to kill each other efficiently and preferably
01:20.840 --> 01:24.936
in large numbers. That's what warfare is. It's part
01:25.436 --> 01:29.144
of the human condition right now. And every
01:29.644 --> 01:33.233
now and again, things happen that affect and reshape the battle
01:33.733 --> 01:37.273
space in ways that ripple out in a manner that people
01:37.385 --> 01:41.200
cannot anticipate. And I think we're in one of those inflection
01:41.313 --> 01:44.999
points right now. Things are changing in a way that I
01:45.499 --> 01:48.542
think we're not gonna like, and I think we're not gonna get the genie back
01:49.042 --> 01:52.261
in the bottle. So I wanted to talk to someone who shares my interest in,
01:52.758 --> 01:56.942
in history and what goes on in war now and back
01:57.442 --> 02:00.998
then. And I respect him because he's an honest man with integrity,
02:01.110 --> 02:04.717
and he's an honest and rigorous thinker, and he's one
02:05.217 --> 02:08.853
of my go-to guys when I teach rhetoric as well. You can
02:08.869 --> 02:12.252
find his good work at BillWhittle.com. Bill Whittle, welcome back to The
02:12.752 --> 02:16.260
Catholic Current. It's always a pleasure, Father, and I have such a
02:16.760 --> 02:19.739
great time on these shows and learn so much from you. Oh, you're very kind.
02:20.108 --> 02:24.452
But I want to talk about dehumanizing the modern battlefield, because on your
02:24.516 --> 02:28.091
channel, Right Angle, which you do with Scott Ott and Stephen
02:28.124 --> 02:31.779
Green, you talked about life and death on the modern battlefield, and you were talking,
02:31.891 --> 02:35.212
and particularly about autonomous drones, and that got
02:35.324 --> 02:38.596
me thinking that there are times when technology steps on
02:38.628 --> 02:41.708
the battlefield and it reshapes it. In the Civil
02:41.821 --> 02:45.638
War, there'd never been a war that had trains and telegraph
02:45.751 --> 02:49.312
before, and World War I was the age of the battleship.
02:49.521 --> 02:53.354
World War II, radar and aircraft carriers changed
02:53.387 --> 02:57.445
the world. In the '60s and '70s, you had intercontinental ballistic missiles.
02:58.039 --> 03:01.937
In the '80s, the Tomahawk missile, the first standoff platforms,
03:03.172 --> 03:07.478
are introduced into the American arsenal. In the '90s, we move into precision-guided
03:07.510 --> 03:10.836
munitions where they practically show up and ring the doorbell.
03:11.591 --> 03:13.988
In the 2010s, we had hypersonic weapons.
03:14.648 --> 03:18.721
You had cyber warfare, and now you have autonomous
03:18.754 --> 03:21.941
drones. You can send a drone loaded for bear,
03:22.231 --> 03:25.669
if you will, send them to a grid point on the
03:25.685 --> 03:29.107
map and just say, kill everything that's there.
03:29.796 --> 03:33.068
You can do that with a click of the mouse, and then it does.
03:33.726 --> 03:38.377
I think this will change human history in
03:38.877 --> 03:42.338
a way that will be, one, we don't like, and B, it'll be irrevocable if
03:42.402 --> 03:45.321
we don't stop it soon. What are your thoughts on that? Well,
03:45.594 --> 03:49.779
it's— it is without question crossing a Rubicon of moral
03:50.279 --> 03:53.981
responsibility that if we allow it to continue will take us
03:54.029 --> 03:57.943
down some very bad roads. So let's just clarify for our audience that may not
03:58.443 --> 04:01.855
be clear on this. I've seen People have seen clips of drone warfare from
04:02.432 --> 04:05.734
the Ukraine war. Virtually everybody's seen some of those. One of the,
04:06.840 --> 04:10.286
one of the earth-changing innovations back in
04:10.786 --> 04:14.695
the '70s and '80s was the suicide bomb. It was basically a guided missile
04:15.195 --> 04:19.039
aimed at civilians, and that was a revolutionary weapon.
04:19.680 --> 04:23.704
When Russia invaded Ukraine in 2022,
04:24.794 --> 04:28.096
Ukraine is quite a well-developed country technologically. In fact,
04:28.160 --> 04:31.703
Ukraine built all of the big Soviet aircraft carriers. Are all built
04:32.203 --> 04:35.774
at the Ukrainian yards. So they weren't picking on a country that didn't know
04:36.274 --> 04:39.718
how to build things. And the Ukrainians basically invented drone warfare.
04:40.343 --> 04:44.831
And at first, the drones consisted of flying over personnel
04:44.928 --> 04:47.733
and dropping essentially streamlined hand grenades.
04:48.454 --> 04:51.949
But this evolved rather quickly into something more efficient and much
04:52.061 --> 04:55.684
more terrifying. I, I don't think there's a worse situation
04:56.184 --> 04:57.800
to be in than in World War I, and I'm sure we'll come back to
04:57.816 --> 05:01.038
World War I in a minute. But this is, this is even more
05:01.538 --> 05:04.647
terrifying than in World War I, because in World one, you could at least hide
05:05.147 --> 05:08.788
in a trench or in a dugout. These first-person drones are flown
05:08.820 --> 05:12.206
by a human operator. They spot an enemy on the ground.
05:12.672 --> 05:16.010
They fly the drone directly into contact with the enemy.
05:16.523 --> 05:19.782
There are a series of just electrical probes on the front of the drone.
05:19.894 --> 05:23.441
And when these probes come into contact, it sets off the explosive.
05:23.890 --> 05:27.357
So the best way to think about drone warfare prior to
05:27.857 --> 05:31.193
what we talked about on the show was to think of it as a
05:31.306 --> 05:34.821
precision-guided heat-seeking hand grenade that
05:35.321 --> 05:38.802
there was no escape from. If you got into a bunker and
05:38.915 --> 05:41.933
underneath a berm or a tunnel, the drone would just fly in there
05:42.029 --> 05:45.769
and kill you there. It was a particularly terrifying form
05:45.818 --> 05:49.815
of death. But this is the critical point about drone warfare prior
05:50.315 --> 05:54.358
to this segment we did the show on. Those drones were being flown
05:54.406 --> 05:57.937
by Ukrainian pilots. Wearing virtual reality
05:58.001 --> 06:00.858
goggles. They were killing people one-to-one.
06:01.772 --> 06:05.319
One of the horrors of drone warfare is since
06:05.559 --> 06:09.507
you need video feedback for the pilot to see where the drone is and
06:09.796 --> 06:14.080
to guide the drone into the individual person, he's getting footage
06:14.610 --> 06:19.392
in real time back from that drone. And so these first-person
06:19.504 --> 06:22.746
killer drones that had dominated the battlefield in Ukraine for the last 2,
06:22.794 --> 06:26.722
3 years, have a human face on it, and, and the person
06:27.222 --> 06:30.345
who is operating the drone gets a very good look at the man he's just
06:30.845 --> 06:34.480
about to kill. And, and that is an important part of the equation,
06:34.576 --> 06:38.536
which we'll get to in a minute. What the Ukrainians did that caused
06:39.036 --> 06:41.790
us to do the show was they said, no, we're going to mark off some
06:41.806 --> 06:45.140
GPS coordinates, we're going to build a GPS fence where we know the enemy
06:45.253 --> 06:49.276
is, and if anything moves inside that fence, the drone
06:49.324 --> 06:52.691
doesn't have to have a human contact anymore. The drone
06:53.191 --> 06:57.083
will detect any kind of movement inside this GPS We know our Ukrainian
06:57.099 --> 07:00.642
guys are outside the fence, so it's going to go in there and
07:01.142 --> 07:04.809
it's just going to fly in and kill anything that moves. And that
07:05.309 --> 07:08.849
is the first time in human history where the
07:09.282 --> 07:12.712
human is completely out of the loop. This is
07:12.744 --> 07:16.640
the first time in history that people are being killed. Yes, first time
07:16.672 --> 07:20.487
that people are being killed without another human being killing
07:20.503 --> 07:23.725
them. Now, for the sake of our viewers who are going to be with us
07:24.225 --> 07:26.691
for the length of this program, I just would like to say this once at
07:27.191 --> 07:31.099
the beginning. All war is horrible. All war is waste and destruction and
07:31.599 --> 07:34.706
misery and grief. People die hard in war. Yes.
07:35.411 --> 07:39.290
So if I'm going to be talking about techniques
07:39.790 --> 07:43.041
and strategies and tactics and so on, that conversation
07:43.541 --> 07:46.969
can get very critical, can get very clinical and very sterile.
07:47.434 --> 07:51.024
And I don't want anybody to think that I personally believe that this is
07:51.521 --> 07:53.349
how things should be looked at. On the contrary.
07:54.487 --> 07:57.661
So we have to reduce this down to the sterile mechanics of
07:57.725 --> 08:00.852
it, but I don't want anybody to think for a minute that that means that
08:00.980 --> 08:04.702
I don't value the fact that both the person being killed
08:05.087 --> 08:08.376
and the person doing the killing are humans and they're going to pay an emotional
08:08.876 --> 08:11.953
price for this. So our argument was, our argument was
08:12.050 --> 08:16.686
with these autonomous drones was it frees the Ukrainians
08:16.942 --> 08:21.097
from having killed anybody. And my feeling
08:21.113 --> 08:24.659
is, is that you want to emerge victorious in
08:25.159 --> 08:29.615
war, but You cannot take the cost of war out
08:29.791 --> 08:33.208
of the equation, and you can't even take it out for the victors.
08:33.865 --> 08:37.153
I'm completely in favor of standoff weapons for
08:37.653 --> 08:40.938
American troops. I'm completely in favor of precision bombing for American
08:41.438 --> 08:45.236
troops. All of these things to save American lives. During Iraq and Iran,
08:45.269 --> 08:48.717
there were just endless, endless cases where they would come under fire.
08:49.198 --> 08:52.438
They'd either put out a GPS coordinate or put a
08:52.486 --> 08:56.111
laser target designator, and some bomber would fly out
08:56.611 --> 09:00.172
of the sky and wipe out that building. And if that saves American
09:00.188 --> 09:03.413
lives, I am 100% behind that because I'm, I'm a hawk.
09:03.494 --> 09:06.623
I'm a hawk because I believe in peace, and I believe that the only way
09:07.123 --> 09:10.764
to maintain peace is to, is to be strong enough not to be threatened
09:11.264 --> 09:15.113
by it. But my point is this: the pilot who drops that bomb and the
09:15.613 --> 09:18.948
guy on the ground who designates that target knows on some level
09:19.430 --> 09:22.688
that he is about to kill human beings. And he's about
09:23.188 --> 09:25.867
to kill human beings that are trying to kill him. I have no problem with
09:26.367 --> 09:30.201
this. But when weapons fly through the battle space,
09:30.602 --> 09:33.636
make a decision on their own based on AI criteria,
09:34.118 --> 09:37.698
and go in and kill human beings, it reduces the cost
09:37.762 --> 09:41.165
of warfare to the victors. Right. To the victors.
09:41.663 --> 09:44.649
Right. And see, that's the key. We're going to come up on a break,
09:44.713 --> 09:48.052
Bill. That's the key element here,
09:48.646 --> 09:50.942
is— and I do believe that even today,
09:51.873 --> 09:55.341
this very day, there can be such a thing as a just
09:55.486 --> 09:58.986
war. That's part of natural law. I accept that.
09:59.420 --> 10:02.743
But war, even a just war, should be entered into
10:02.856 --> 10:06.693
with tremendous sorrow because people
10:06.789 --> 10:10.209
are going to die horribly and people are going
10:10.709 --> 10:14.657
to kill each other horribly, and that affects human bodies and
10:14.737 --> 10:18.220
human souls and human communities Which is why
10:19.310 --> 10:22.741
it's dehumanizing to have become trigger-happy.
10:23.158 --> 10:26.204
And part of what scares me about this technology, and I think it's the basis
10:26.704 --> 10:30.325
of your hesitation too, is that it makes it too easy
10:31.335 --> 10:34.782
that we're just letting the machines do it
10:35.183 --> 10:39.480
and we never have to think about what's being done.
10:39.608 --> 10:43.264
This isn't like setting up a booby trap or a landmine or something
10:43.360 --> 10:47.480
like that. We've made a hunter predator to
10:47.528 --> 10:51.311
hunt humans, and we're not being faced
10:51.811 --> 10:55.287
with the enormity of what that means. And I don't
10:55.303 --> 10:58.845
think that's good for us as a species. That doesn't help us build a
10:59.345 --> 11:02.468
moral house in which we would want to live. Friends, when we come back,
11:02.484 --> 11:05.802
we're going to continue our conversation with Bill Whittle. You can find his very good
11:06.302 --> 11:10.082
work at billwhittle.com. He's an honest and thoughtful man. Check out his work.
11:10.386 --> 11:13.079
We're talking about dehumanizing the modern battlefield.
11:13.160 --> 11:16.082
Remember, a rallying cry at the Catholic Current is Christus Mundo,
11:16.162 --> 11:19.518
Mundus Christo— bringing Christ to the world and the world to Christ.
11:19.598 --> 11:22.890
We do it because our Lord says so, for the greater glory of God,
11:22.906 --> 11:25.764
the love of our neighbor, and the salvation of our own soul.
11:26.679 --> 11:30.196
After the broadcast today, go to thestationofthecross.com, get our
11:30.696 --> 11:33.953
resources list, download our audio, us podcast, take us to your family
11:33.985 --> 11:37.533
and friends. Together we'll take it to the whole world. Back in just 2 minutes.
11:37.598 --> 11:38.513
Please do stay with us.
12:00.865 --> 12:04.591
You're listening to The Catholic Current with Father Robert McTague
12:04.719 --> 12:08.364
from the Station of the Cross Catholic
12:08.864 --> 12:11.455
Media Network. Stay connected with the show and our guests and topics by following the
12:11.955 --> 12:15.361
show on Twitter and Gab. Just search for The Catholic
12:15.861 --> 12:16.101
Current.
12:21.070 --> 12:24.393
Praise be Jesus Christ. This is Father Robert McTeague of the Society of Jesus,
12:24.409 --> 12:27.668
your daily host for The Catholic Current, where we bring Christ to the world and
12:27.700 --> 12:30.588
the world to Christ. You're listening to us from the Station of the Cross Studios,
12:30.685 --> 12:34.804
your local radio station, The iCatholic Radio mobile app. We proclaim the fullness
12:35.304 --> 12:39.456
of truth with clarity and charity. We're talking about dehumanizing
12:39.504 --> 12:42.808
the modern battlefield. My returning guest is someone I
12:43.308 --> 12:47.603
respect very greatly, Bill Whittle. You can find his good work at billwhittle.com.
12:48.004 --> 12:51.373
But we were just getting warmed up that when you take
12:51.873 --> 12:54.404
the human element out of killing human beings,
12:54.933 --> 12:59.312
something happens, something's lost.
12:59.633 --> 13:03.292
Let's talk about that. Okay, what I'd like to do, Father, is to tie—
13:03.581 --> 13:07.306
is to tie this warfare aspect into, um,
13:07.498 --> 13:11.110
your daily life and the daily life of Catholic priests
13:11.610 --> 13:15.076
everywhere. Um, part of your duties, if not maybe your
13:15.140 --> 13:18.977
major theological duty, is absolving people
13:19.477 --> 13:23.087
of their sins. Yes. Uh, they confess their sins and then they are
13:23.587 --> 13:27.036
absolved of their sins. And you've done this hundreds of thousands
13:27.536 --> 13:31.225
of times, and so have most Catholic priests. If you
13:31.274 --> 13:34.995
have a weapon system that activates itself
13:35.123 --> 13:39.309
and goes and kills another human being on its own initiative,
13:39.775 --> 13:43.384
you have nothing to be absolved of. You have absolved yourself.
13:43.849 --> 13:47.233
And, and this is a game that you can play psychologically.
13:47.378 --> 13:50.489
I didn't kill the guy. I just put the drone in the area. The drone
13:50.585 --> 13:53.697
killed the guy. If, right, if that mentality
13:53.793 --> 13:57.162
catches on, then we all of a sudden find
13:57.662 --> 14:01.573
ourselves in a world where where the victors don't pay any price for the
14:02.073 --> 14:05.985
victory. I, I, I say things out of as much intellectual
14:06.082 --> 14:09.852
clarity as I can, and when people hear me speaking
14:10.352 --> 14:13.397
with this kind of clarity, I know it's very tempting for them to think that
14:13.897 --> 14:17.408
I'm some kind of a monster, that, that I don't deeply care
14:17.793 --> 14:21.531
about the cost on, on our soldiers. I've done a number of fundraisers
14:21.628 --> 14:25.414
for, for wounded warriors and, and talked to— saved a few lives
14:25.914 --> 14:29.665
of PTSD soldiers. Okay, just, just By being able to understand that I
14:30.165 --> 14:33.820
had to get those bona fides out there to simply say it's not that
14:33.900 --> 14:37.686
I am unaware of this cost. We lose 17 veterans a day
14:38.186 --> 14:41.520
to suicide, which is an astonishingly disgraceful number.
14:42.018 --> 14:46.525
But, but my point is, the larger point is this: war
14:47.215 --> 14:51.354
changes people and it should change them. It should make them
14:51.627 --> 14:55.156
aware of the enormity of what they've
14:55.656 --> 14:58.829
done. If you have— let's take a hypothetical situation.
14:59.422 --> 15:02.132
Where you have a highly advanced,
15:02.148 --> 15:05.498
technologically advanced military like the United States
15:06.011 --> 15:09.586
against a relatively unsophisticated one like
15:10.086 --> 15:13.433
the Houthis, let's say, for example. And let's say that we send drones
15:13.449 --> 15:17.472
over there and we don't have people making decisions about those drones.
15:17.537 --> 15:20.342
We just say anything that moves in this area, we just destroy it.
15:21.207 --> 15:24.991
Well, we, we have nothing to absolve ourselves for. We do, of course,
15:25.055 --> 15:28.742
because we put them there. But the temptation would be not
15:29.242 --> 15:31.403
only did we not pay a price for this in lives, we didn't pay a
15:31.903 --> 15:35.623
price for this in psychological damage. And I think the psychological
15:35.639 --> 15:39.730
damage that comes with victory— we all know about the psychological
15:40.230 --> 15:44.127
damage that comes with defeat, but the psychological— but victory has
15:44.239 --> 15:47.015
to come with some kind of psychological damage.
15:47.432 --> 15:50.978
And I would like for you personally, if you would just repeat the story you
15:51.478 --> 15:54.508
told us off the air about your friend who was a tank commander. Sure.
15:55.390 --> 15:58.647
Because this was a man who didn't have to actually do anything,
15:59.000 --> 16:03.479
right? But But go ahead and continue. He was a commander
16:03.495 --> 16:05.791
of, I think, a tank company,
16:06.850 --> 16:10.157
you know, US Army, NATO in the 1970s,
16:10.173 --> 16:12.629
you know, East Germany, West Germany, Fulda Gap,
16:13.528 --> 16:18.425
the, you know, the bear, the Soviet Union, all that. You know, their unit's
16:18.925 --> 16:22.743
motto was, our job is to fight outnumbered and win. And he's in his 70s
16:22.919 --> 16:26.034
now. And he says, I have to— and he never had to fire a shot
16:26.050 --> 16:29.244
in anger. Thanks be to God, but he was ready to.
16:29.726 --> 16:32.679
He oriented his whole life around that for years.
16:33.418 --> 16:37.672
And he said, I spent a good chunk of my life plotting
16:37.768 --> 16:41.187
for the destruction of property and the killing of human
16:41.219 --> 16:45.040
beings. And I'm still working
16:45.072 --> 16:49.646
that out. I still struggle with that.
16:49.984 --> 16:53.435
Since we're on the topic of making war antiseptic,
16:54.638 --> 16:57.924
I'm going to bring up original Star Trek, Bill. I don't think you'll object if
16:57.988 --> 17:01.547
I do that. Episode from the first
17:01.659 --> 17:05.443
season, episode 23, A Taste of Armageddon. The 2
17:05.943 --> 17:09.338
planets have been at war with each other for 500 years,
17:10.075 --> 17:14.387
and they've figured out that fighting with physical weapons is messy,
17:14.964 --> 17:18.619
so they do computer simulations, and then
17:18.812 --> 17:22.322
they tell each other, well, you know, our computer-simulated
17:22.354 --> 17:26.137
bomb killed 500 people, so you need to have 500
17:26.170 --> 17:29.552
people go to the extermination unit. And they would
17:30.052 --> 17:32.982
go back and forth. And your hero, James T. Kirk, says,
17:33.639 --> 17:37.567
this is monstrous. You have no incentive to stop
17:37.887 --> 17:41.317
the slaughter. And so he disrupts the cycle so that
17:41.350 --> 17:45.165
there'll be some— people will have blood on their hands, so they'll realize
17:46.078 --> 17:49.893
what they're doing. Is this development in technology moving
17:49.925 --> 17:53.179
us in the direction of that sci-fi cautionary tale?
17:53.452 --> 17:56.963
What a, what a wonderful example to pick. Yes, they come to
17:57.463 --> 18:00.987
this planet where wars are fought by computers, and then they'll say, as you said,
18:01.452 --> 18:04.643
well, there's been a strike on our city and we lost 600 people. And then
18:04.675 --> 18:08.571
600 citizens are chosen by the computer, and they willingly
18:08.763 --> 18:12.098
walk into disintegration units with the understanding
18:12.595 --> 18:16.138
that this is better than having actual cities bombed,
18:16.298 --> 18:19.601
because we lose the buildings and the rubble and the smell and, you know,
18:20.210 --> 18:23.561
and all of that. This is a cleaner way to fight a war. And,
18:23.657 --> 18:27.282
and you— and the argument is made that this is a much more logical way
18:27.782 --> 18:30.811
to fight a war because it's antiseptic. And back
18:31.311 --> 18:34.708
when we believed in ourselves as a culture in the 1960s,
18:35.302 --> 18:38.349
we were not afraid to go into a situation like that and
18:38.849 --> 18:41.525
say, no, we're going to turn the ship's phasers on your computers.
18:42.022 --> 18:45.695
Now you're going to have to fight a real war. Now instead of people cleanly
18:45.791 --> 18:49.143
walking into disintegration booths saying goodbye to their families and hugging
18:49.175 --> 18:52.448
each other and just disappearing, now you're going to have to dig through
18:52.464 --> 18:55.804
rubble to find bodies, and now you're going to have body parts lying
18:55.852 --> 18:59.368
around, and now it's going to be a messy, gory, disgusting business.
18:59.834 --> 19:03.093
And the more disgusting business it is, the sooner you're going to want to stop
19:03.222 --> 19:07.043
it. The, the point of A Taste of Armageddon was that this war was going
19:07.075 --> 19:09.853
on for 500 years because it was too sanitary.
19:10.383 --> 19:13.065
I'm virtually positive it was Robert E. Lee who said,
19:13.739 --> 19:16.774
it is well that war is such a terrible thing, or we would grow too
19:17.274 --> 19:20.112
fond of it. And it is in,
19:20.546 --> 19:24.141
in virtually every way the peak human existence.
19:24.189 --> 19:27.800
I'm not saying it's the pinnacle of human existence, right? Right. But it's the peak
19:28.105 --> 19:31.684
human existence in terms of what people will have
19:31.716 --> 19:35.488
to face during the course of a, of a young man's life.
19:36.034 --> 19:39.083
Your friend who is 70 years old is suffering from
19:39.164 --> 19:41.988
PTSD without having fired a shot.
19:43.417 --> 19:47.413
And I wish him peace. And, and the— I especially
19:47.525 --> 19:51.105
wish peace to all of the veterans that might be listening to this who have
19:51.137 --> 19:55.005
had actual bullets shot at them and shot back at actual people
19:55.505 --> 19:59.145
and in many cases killed actual people and maybe killed people that
19:59.645 --> 20:02.756
they didn't intend to kill. Maybe some kid was running across the street with an
20:03.256 --> 20:05.790
RPG and handing it to people that was going to kill his guys and they
20:06.290 --> 20:09.866
had to take that shot. Um, my point is not that I
20:09.978 --> 20:13.442
want these people to suffer. I don't want them to suffer. I certainly
20:13.942 --> 20:16.329
don't want them to suffer to the level that they suffer when they come back
20:16.829 --> 20:19.889
home and, and have no way to decompress or,
20:20.402 --> 20:24.043
or, or be trained out. We spend thousands of dollars to train
20:24.107 --> 20:27.603
people to go into the military, and we, we spend nothing on getting
20:27.635 --> 20:30.666
them out of the military. But with all of that said,
20:31.468 --> 20:34.932
there, there has to be an understanding that
20:35.076 --> 20:39.066
what is happening in war is repugnant and disgusting
20:39.403 --> 20:42.751
and needs to be ended as quickly and as bloodlessly as
20:42.864 --> 20:46.629
possible, which usually means as fast as possible. But,
20:46.854 --> 20:50.379
but the victors have to pay a price because if they don't,
20:50.972 --> 20:54.369
if they don't pay a price in psychological damage,
20:55.026 --> 20:58.439
then there is no end to war. Right.
20:58.887 --> 21:02.286
We all know my dad was a member of the Greatest Generation. We all
21:02.398 --> 21:05.626
know that the men that came back from
21:06.126 --> 21:09.448
World War II refused to discuss World War II. This is the universal
21:09.480 --> 21:13.253
trope about the Greatest Generation. They never talked to
21:13.753 --> 21:16.882
their kids. After they die, they find a case
21:16.931 --> 21:20.592
full of, you know, Bronze Stars or Silver Stars or
21:20.720 --> 21:24.253
awards for gallantry. Their fathers never talked
21:24.753 --> 21:28.653
about it because it was dirty and it was ugly and it was something that
21:29.153 --> 21:31.624
they had to do and they didn't want to do, and they paid a big
21:31.640 --> 21:34.847
price for it. They watch their friends turn into pink mist.
21:36.289 --> 21:39.752
And if we take that away, then we're going to make
21:39.800 --> 21:43.792
war much, much, much easier and much quicker to
21:43.984 --> 21:47.559
resort to. And that is a net loss for the human species.
21:47.992 --> 21:52.352
Right. I think that we used to have a sense of
21:52.481 --> 21:55.719
that. You get glimpses of it, you know, when we have, you know, the Tomb
21:55.767 --> 21:59.439
of the Unknown Soldier and the changing of the guard. And so on,
21:59.776 --> 22:02.583
the way that we bring the caskets back home. I mean, my,
22:03.049 --> 22:06.449
you know, my father was a World War II vet. He was in the
22:06.949 --> 22:10.283
Navy. And when he died, you know, the Navy sent an honor guard
22:10.364 --> 22:13.973
there that we want to have a sense, you know,
22:14.117 --> 22:17.743
the sacred is referred to as the fascinans et tremendum,
22:18.208 --> 22:21.962
you know, the fascinating and the tremendous, the terrifying,
22:22.539 --> 22:25.731
that there is something compelling about making
22:25.763 --> 22:28.937
oneself available to war. And I agree with Chesterton,
22:29.675 --> 22:32.705
you know, you fight not because you hate what's in front of you, it's because
22:32.961 --> 22:36.665
you love those who are behind you. And I think
22:37.049 --> 22:40.159
that there is something honorable in saying, I will
22:40.272 --> 22:43.542
be the buffer between my loved ones and
22:44.042 --> 22:47.422
those who would hurt my loved ones. And I think that is honorable.
22:47.951 --> 22:51.702
And I think we need to instill ceremony
22:51.878 --> 22:55.404
and tradition and respect, even while
22:55.904 --> 22:59.539
admitting we really don't want this to happen again. And if
22:59.603 --> 23:03.466
it does happen, and even if the cause is just, it's still
23:04.075 --> 23:07.457
tragic. But I'm going to ask a huge question and only give you 2 minutes
23:07.745 --> 23:11.897
before the break. Part of the problem we're in right now with technology
23:12.394 --> 23:15.663
is we've lost our sense of wonder and
23:15.695 --> 23:19.189
the sacred and ritual. Is that dangerous for us as warfighters?
23:20.023 --> 23:23.501
You can trace the beginnings of modern war back to World War I,
23:24.255 --> 23:27.605
and there are many, many things about World War I, but the most important thing
23:27.637 --> 23:31.212
about World War I germane to this discussion is World
23:31.308 --> 23:34.979
War I was the first time that artillery
23:35.075 --> 23:38.506
was used as indirect fire. And for people
23:39.006 --> 23:42.401
who aren't military historians, what that means is this: prior to this, let's look
23:42.901 --> 23:45.543
at the Civil War, which was only, you know, just half a century before.
23:46.072 --> 23:49.150
You would line your cannons up on a ridge, and you would fire them,
23:49.278 --> 23:52.774
and you could see your enemy, and you would see you're blowing holes in enemy
23:52.870 --> 23:55.886
lines and you could see the effect that your artillery was doing.
23:56.496 --> 23:59.688
By the time we get to World War I, explosives have improved to the point
24:00.188 --> 24:03.876
where guns can fire indirectly. In other words, they shoot their shells up
24:04.376 --> 24:08.255
into the air. The people that pull the lanyard on an artillery
24:08.368 --> 24:11.721
piece do not see where the shell falls. They have no idea. They have
24:12.221 --> 24:16.261
spotters and balloons and aircraft and all the rest of it. And so indirect fire
24:16.293 --> 24:19.884
was the first time that that mankind was able to kill other men in
24:19.980 --> 24:23.731
large numbers without seeing the results of what they were doing.
24:24.164 --> 24:27.321
And once we got into high-altitude bombing, we began to get that as well.
24:27.914 --> 24:31.456
So there is something ancient and sacred about
24:31.681 --> 24:34.614
the fact that you have to look the person you're gonna kill in the eye,
24:35.127 --> 24:39.005
at least, at least even if they're across the field on a battlefield.
24:39.374 --> 24:42.740
Once we get to World War I, that's out the window. Now it's just a
24:43.240 --> 24:46.812
question of let's lob a million shells at this position, which was routine
24:47.085 --> 24:50.680
towards the end of World War II. Sure, you know, across miles and
24:51.180 --> 24:54.114
so on, you know, you just kind of pull the trigger and you know it
24:54.387 --> 24:57.982
went somewhere, but you didn't know where. And then
24:58.482 --> 25:01.641
when you were on the receiving end, you said, who the heck is shooting at
25:01.689 --> 25:05.060
me? I've never done anything to him before. Friends, when we come back, we're going
25:05.560 --> 25:09.473
to continue our conversation with Bill Whittle. You can find his very good work on
25:09.973 --> 25:13.968
political, social, cultural commentary at billwhittle.com.
25:14.273 --> 25:17.340
We're talking about dehumanizing the modern battlefield.
25:17.805 --> 25:21.563
After the broadcast today, go to thestationofthecross.com, get our resources
25:21.659 --> 25:25.031
list, download our audio as podcasts. Wherever you can find audio,
25:25.432 --> 25:28.997
you can find us. Follow us on your favorite platform, write a 5-star review.
25:29.382 --> 25:32.883
We need to attract the attention of the listeners so that these conversations
25:33.220 --> 25:36.704
get the attention they deserve. Take us to your family and friends.
25:36.768 --> 25:39.391
Together we'll take it to the whole whole world. Back in just 2 minutes.
25:39.521 --> 25:40.383
Please do stay with us.
26:00.646 --> 26:04.323
This is the Catholic Current from the Station of the Cross Catholic Media
26:04.823 --> 26:08.401
Network. Catch up on an episode you've missed, or share them with your family and
26:08.901 --> 26:13.052
friends. The Catholic Current is podcasted wherever you enjoy listening: Apple
26:13.552 --> 26:17.318
Podcasts, Spotify, Podbean, TuneIn, and the iCatholic Radio
26:17.818 --> 26:21.888
mobile app. Praise be Jesus Christ. This is Father Robert McTaggart
26:22.388 --> 26:25.032
of the Society of Jesus, your daily host for The Catholic Current. We bring Christ
26:25.532 --> 26:28.223
to the world and the world to Christ. You're listening to us from the Station
26:28.723 --> 26:31.735
of the Cross Studios, your local radio station, and the iCatholic Radio mobile app.
26:32.056 --> 26:35.409
Where we proclaim the fullness of truth with clarity and charity.
26:36.147 --> 26:39.774
Hey friends, if you value thoughtful Catholic analysis, help sustain this work at
26:40.274 --> 26:44.250
thestationofthecross.com. Here on The Catholic Current, we engage issues seriously
26:44.411 --> 26:49.160
and faithfully, and that intellectual freedom exists because we are listener-funded.
26:49.641 --> 26:53.299
Support us at thestationofthecross.com. Friends, I'm talking with Bill
26:53.396 --> 26:57.198
Whittle. You can find his very good work at billwhittle.com. We're talking
26:57.698 --> 27:02.349
about dehumanizing the modern battlefield. Bill, I think
27:02.849 --> 27:05.686
we can agree if we let the machines take over war, that's going to be—
27:06.408 --> 27:10.146
future generations will curse us if we allow this to happen.
27:10.659 --> 27:14.413
And I think one of the reasons why we're predisposed to
27:14.913 --> 27:18.328
something so dehumanizing is because for decades,
27:18.360 --> 27:21.777
certainly in my lifetime, we've been letting go of
27:21.873 --> 27:25.066
what is distinctively human,
27:25.483 --> 27:29.464
and that includes ritual and reverence
27:29.817 --> 27:33.349
and being able to look people in the eye. And part of
27:33.849 --> 27:37.829
the challenge that we've had really since the advent of radio and the telegraph is
27:37.941 --> 27:41.827
we have news of horrors so far away
27:42.581 --> 27:45.856
and we don't know where to put them. I mean, if your neighbor's house burns
27:45.889 --> 27:49.533
down, that's different from, you know, there's a fire right
27:49.581 --> 27:53.178
now as we speak in a forest in Spain. That you and
27:53.678 --> 27:57.014
I can't do anything about, and we don't know anyone there. So, I was thinking
27:57.062 --> 28:01.026
about how being flooded with news of horror and then
28:01.123 --> 28:04.429
going on as if it didn't happen, even that is dehumanizing. So,
28:04.509 --> 28:08.506
I found a poem written by an American journalist.
28:08.586 --> 28:12.005
His name is Robert D. Abrams, and it
28:12.053 --> 28:15.825
was called The Night They Burned Shanghai. And he tells a story about a
28:16.325 --> 28:19.950
couple going off near Philadelphia to play bridge for the evening,
28:20.384 --> 28:24.204
and he knows that the Japanese are slaughtering everyone
28:24.718 --> 28:28.876
in Shanghai, and that's not going to affect him in
28:28.908 --> 28:32.055
the least. It won't change his evening's social plans.
28:32.505 --> 28:35.797
And the last 2 stanzas land hard, and I'd like your take on that.
28:36.856 --> 28:40.180
He says, tonight Shanghai is burning and we are dying
28:40.389 --> 28:44.483
too. What bomb more surely mortal than death inside
28:44.983 --> 28:48.481
of you? For some men die by shrapnel and some go
28:48.497 --> 28:51.901
down in flames. But most men perish
28:52.255 --> 28:55.851
inch by inch and play at little games.
28:56.686 --> 29:00.652
But if we reduce war to not even
29:00.925 --> 29:04.120
a video game, just something the machines do
29:04.393 --> 29:08.006
in the background, that takes away part
29:08.506 --> 29:11.635
of our soul, doesn't it? Isn't that something we should be
29:11.763 --> 29:15.440
alarmed about? And I think we're predisposed to go down
29:15.488 --> 29:19.230
this terrible dark road. Do you see it too, or am I just being a
29:19.730 --> 29:22.727
dark-brooding melancholic Irishman again? Well,
29:23.561 --> 29:27.296
yes, what that poem refers to is the fact that
29:27.424 --> 29:30.662
by pretending that these horrors don't exist at all,
29:32.056 --> 29:35.679
we kill ourselves a little bit because we anesthetize ourselves,
29:35.775 --> 29:39.062
and it's probably better to say almost lobotomize ourselves.
29:39.126 --> 29:42.316
We permanently take human suffering off the
29:42.816 --> 29:46.163
table and pretend it's not there. Now, to be fair to the
29:46.663 --> 29:50.684
flip side of the argument, people have a zone of concern
29:50.732 --> 29:53.937
and they have a zone of control. There are things that they worry about,
29:53.953 --> 29:57.607
and then there are things that they can do something about. And war in
29:57.703 --> 30:00.716
an East Asian country is beyond our zone of control.
30:01.389 --> 30:04.690
And if it's beyond your zone of control, but your
30:05.190 --> 30:08.632
zone of concern extends to it to the degree that you can't put it
30:08.680 --> 30:12.142
down, you'll drive yourself insane. There's— I've
30:12.222 --> 30:15.988
known a few people who are so paralyzed by all the injustice
30:16.488 --> 30:19.755
in the world that they can't live their lives. And when you have a
30:19.819 --> 30:23.122
worldwide network, it's not your friends anymore.
30:23.347 --> 30:26.634
It's people that— this is going on all the
30:27.134 --> 30:30.739
time. There are catastrophes every day. That doesn't make them less catastrophic,
30:30.803 --> 30:34.283
but it does mean if you don't have some kind of filter on
30:34.783 --> 30:38.885
your mind, you're going to go barking mad. But back to the
30:39.385 --> 30:42.894
mechanized battlefield. Let me rephrase that. We've had a mechanized battlefield for a long
30:42.926 --> 30:46.309
time. The autonomous battlefield. Um, one of
30:46.357 --> 30:51.006
the things that it removes is one of the most precious human qualities of
30:51.506 --> 30:55.190
all, and, and you could make a strong case that it is the most
30:55.751 --> 30:59.646
noble of the virtues, and that is, uh, the quality of mercy.
31:00.063 --> 31:03.573
Um, these machines do not show mercy because
31:03.670 --> 31:06.940
they have no, uh, they have no remorse, they have no,
31:07.677 --> 31:10.739
uh, particular resentment or hostility. That's— it's a program,
31:10.803 --> 31:14.602
they follow the program, and, and there's no mercy. In World War I, there was
31:15.102 --> 31:18.369
a famous Christmas truce where the soldiers were close together so
31:18.433 --> 31:21.639
that they got out and played soccer and they exchanged hats
31:22.139 --> 31:25.695
and they exchanged newspapers and they clapped each other on the shoulders and realized
31:25.711 --> 31:28.629
that neither side of these regular people wanted to be there.
31:29.109 --> 31:32.796
It was just an enormous inbred family fight that chewed up,
31:33.085 --> 31:36.275
you know, millions and millions of the best young men of their generation.
31:37.028 --> 31:40.747
During the Civil War, there were cases where the lines were so close together that
31:40.860 --> 31:44.883
one band on the Confederate side would strike up a tune and then the American
31:45.383 --> 31:47.913
band would strike up a tune and then the Confederates would play Dixie and the
31:48.413 --> 31:52.259
Americans would play the flag of freedom and the
31:52.759 --> 31:56.126
battle cry of freedom. And they would just realize that
31:56.174 --> 31:59.334
they're just regular people who have really nothing
31:59.834 --> 32:03.425
against each other that are out there for political reasons that really have nothing
32:03.473 --> 32:07.099
to do with them. The reason we're having this conversation right
32:07.599 --> 32:11.238
now is because of the fundamental humanity of
32:11.350 --> 32:15.184
2 men who were built into a machine-like
32:15.425 --> 32:18.666
command structure, and that was the Soviet Union. It's important for people to
32:18.714 --> 32:22.754
understand that the is that during the Cold War, the Soviets had a policy
32:23.283 --> 32:26.970
that removed all responsibility from the local commander.
32:27.707 --> 32:31.314
It was— their policy was very simple: if A, then B,
32:31.699 --> 32:34.937
period. If this happens, then you must do this,
32:35.386 --> 32:38.624
period. There is no room for your individual judgment and
32:39.124 --> 32:42.551
so on. I'll try to make this very brief. During the Cuban Missile Crisis,
32:43.016 --> 32:46.318
there was a squadron of 3 conventional Soviet submarines,
32:46.527 --> 32:50.149
and each one of them had a nuclear-tipped torpedo. As the conflict
32:50.649 --> 32:54.412
was being resolved diplomatically, diplomatically, the United States had detected these submarines
32:54.941 --> 32:58.658
and we dropped training depth charges to get the subs to surface
32:59.158 --> 33:02.199
so they could get the news that the conflict was over. Training depth charge is
33:02.699 --> 33:05.388
something that you drop, but it's got, instead of a huge explosive, it's just got
33:05.888 --> 33:08.673
a hand grenade in it. It just goes pop, right? It's just, it's just a
33:08.801 --> 33:12.102
pop, just to let them know that it's there. Well, it turns out the
33:12.602 --> 33:16.108
Russians didn't know that we had training depth charges, so they
33:16.608 --> 33:20.326
thought that they were under depth charge attack. And in order to fire the one
33:20.599 --> 33:24.600
nuclear-tipped torpedo that each one of these subs carried required
33:25.100 --> 33:28.167
the authorization of the captain and the executive officer,
33:28.215 --> 33:31.381
who was a political officer. This one ship was getting ready to launch a
33:31.881 --> 33:35.655
nuclear-tipped torpedo at an American destroyer at the height of the Cuban Missile Crisis.
33:36.249 --> 33:39.929
And by sheer coincidence, one out of 3 choice, the captain
33:40.041 --> 33:43.817
of the flotilla of the 3 subs happened to be on board that particular
33:44.317 --> 33:48.074
boat. And he said no. And pistols were drawn and threats were made
33:48.574 --> 33:51.673
and people had guns pointed at their heads. And the captain of the flotilla said,
33:51.770 --> 33:55.272
no, we are not launching this nuclear-tipped torpedo until we get an
33:55.288 --> 33:58.919
absolute confirmation that this war has started. Well, if he
33:59.419 --> 34:03.160
hadn't been on that boat, that submarine would have launched a nuclear-tipped torpedo and
34:03.176 --> 34:06.309
nuked an American destroyer in the middle of the Cuban Missile Crisis.
34:06.855 --> 34:11.000
And that probably would have done it. Many years later, in 1987,
34:11.193 --> 34:14.897
I'm embarrassed I'm genuinely embarrassed that I do not remember these 2 men's
34:15.397 --> 34:18.889
names. I used to. There was a Soviet missile commander who
34:18.905 --> 34:22.111
was in charge of an entire missile wing, and he
34:22.611 --> 34:25.846
saw on his radar scopes a first decapitation strike coming in from the
34:26.346 --> 34:29.036
United States, incoming warheads coming from the US,
34:29.645 --> 34:32.979
multiple reentry vehicles. And he had orders,
34:33.172 --> 34:36.249
as did the other guy, if A, then B. If you're attacked by an American
34:36.749 --> 34:40.433
destroyer, launch a nuclear torpedo. If you see incoming warheads,
34:40.786 --> 34:44.488
launch a full-scale thermonuclear counterattack against United States.
34:45.096 --> 34:48.685
And this man said no. Now, if he had been wrong, he would
34:49.185 --> 34:51.906
have been executed, his family would have been executed. There would have been probably not
34:52.406 --> 34:55.367
much left to execute by the time it was all over. But he said no,
34:55.703 --> 34:59.180
I don't believe it, I don't believe it. In both those cases,
34:59.677 --> 35:03.667
the humanity, the fundamental humanity of these 2 Russian
35:03.699 --> 35:06.374
commanders prevented World War III.
35:07.127 --> 35:11.630
And we're only here because of the, the fundamental
35:12.130 --> 35:15.530
human belief that I don't believe
35:15.642 --> 35:19.237
that this is possible. Machines don't have that instinct.
35:19.317 --> 35:23.473
They don't have that biological revulsion.
35:24.549 --> 35:27.534
If this had been run by computers at the time,
35:28.079 --> 35:31.546
we would have had 2 examples of full-scale thermonuclear
35:31.594 --> 35:35.831
war between the US and the Soviet Union. World War III was averted both times
35:36.184 --> 35:40.036
by the humanity of the people involved. And if you take that out
35:40.536 --> 35:44.131
of the equation, you also set yourself up for enormous, enormous trouble.
35:44.613 --> 35:47.985
Right. I think there's— yes, there was— oh
35:48.485 --> 35:51.807
gosh, it was a novel that came out in the early '60s and there was
35:51.839 --> 35:55.340
a movie. It was black and white and I thought it was an amazing thing
35:55.356 --> 35:58.150
when I was a kid that there were black and white movies. But it was
35:58.166 --> 36:01.956
called Failsafe and one of the computers
36:02.117 --> 36:05.537
had a glitch. Yeah, it's a good novel.
36:05.666 --> 36:09.631
It's an amazing movie. You know, a computer had a glitch. And then
36:09.663 --> 36:13.526
the other computers convinced the other computers to
36:14.167 --> 36:17.726
send missiles over to the Soviet Union
36:17.822 --> 36:21.060
and the Soviet Union said, well, you know, we're gonna end the world because you
36:21.560 --> 36:25.196
started it. Well, no, it was a computer error. And spoiler alert,
36:25.276 --> 36:28.739
I think the US president agreed to have
36:29.059 --> 36:32.185
New York City bombed by the Soviets and then stop
36:32.685 --> 36:35.599
it there to prove this was really an accident.
36:36.417 --> 36:40.377
And, you know, and that was— gosh, that was in the early '60s
36:41.002 --> 36:45.074
that that came out. So things like this have been around
36:45.574 --> 36:49.563
for a while. You know, speaking as a priest, I take
36:49.643 --> 36:53.763
human life very seriously. I really do hold
36:54.263 --> 36:57.546
it sacred. I have reverence for sacrifice
36:57.674 --> 37:01.297
and those who are ready to sacrifice. I think it was Churchill said,
37:01.602 --> 37:05.360
They also serve who stand and wait. So if you put on the uniform and
37:05.456 --> 37:09.021
you didn't fire a shot, you still did something
37:09.069 --> 37:12.585
that most people are not capable of doing. So whenever I see
37:12.601 --> 37:16.086
anybody in uniform or I see a vet, I always say,
37:17.242 --> 37:20.710
thank you for your service. So, but we've got about 3 minutes left in this
37:21.210 --> 37:25.206
segment. How do we convince people to dial it back? How do we
37:25.706 --> 37:28.910
tell them we don't want to go down this road? Well, the United States
37:29.410 --> 37:33.205
of America is a— is an exceptional country in, in so
37:33.705 --> 37:36.986
many ways that it's almost hard to measure. But one of the qualities of the
37:37.486 --> 37:41.280
United States soldier and the United States military, and, and is
37:41.392 --> 37:44.661
part of their training, is that, that the U.S.
37:44.821 --> 37:47.209
soldier and sailor, Marine and airman and so on,
37:48.106 --> 37:51.952
um, are, are instructed that if they receive
37:52.452 --> 37:55.830
an order that they believe to be immoral, they are not not required to obey
37:56.330 --> 37:59.805
that order. In fact, they're required to stand up for it. If some general
38:00.046 --> 38:03.460
orders a sergeant to gun down a bunch of civilians
38:03.508 --> 38:07.323
who are standing up against the wall, the sergeant not only has the authority
38:07.436 --> 38:10.562
to disobey that order, he has an obligation to disobey that order.
38:11.123 --> 38:15.082
That is an extraordinary aspect of any country's
38:15.582 --> 38:18.961
military. There have been obviously exceptions when Americans
38:19.461 --> 38:22.969
have gone off the rails. The My Lai Massacre was a great example of that,
38:23.450 --> 38:26.560
but the My Lai Massacre was ended by a helicopter pilot
38:27.060 --> 38:30.886
who put himself between Lieutenant William Calley's squad and,
38:31.543 --> 38:34.587
and what was left of the Vietnamese that they were just gunning down in a
38:35.087 --> 38:39.330
pit. But, but just because some individuals break down and lose their mind doesn't
38:39.830 --> 38:42.823
mean that the institution is corrupt. He was prosecuted for that.
38:43.416 --> 38:46.909
It was considered a war crime. But the Nazis, on the other hand,
38:47.006 --> 38:50.899
would give out orders to simply go into Ukraine or go into Russia and destroy
38:51.092 --> 38:54.699
entire villages, murder everybody, lock everybody up in the church and set it on fire.
38:55.261 --> 38:58.490
And if you think that these 2 systems are equivalent,
38:58.875 --> 39:02.795
then there's something fundamentally wrong with you, really something fundamentally
39:02.891 --> 39:06.360
wrong with you. So, so the way we dial it back is we,
39:06.585 --> 39:10.103
we make it clear to our military servicemen that are all volunteers
39:10.681 --> 39:14.006
that this is serious business. I was very, very fortunate
39:14.506 --> 39:17.973
to have been invited to CENTCOM during the Obama administration,
39:18.552 --> 39:22.246
and after They sterilized the screen so that there was no top-secret
39:22.746 --> 39:26.278
information in there. I got to sit in CENTCOM, and there's a young— there's a
39:26.342 --> 39:30.101
woman major, and she's just opening a Tupperware thing of chicken salad, and she's
39:30.601 --> 39:34.213
having lunch. But these guys are launching drone strikes on terrorists,
39:34.615 --> 39:38.550
and they said the hardest part for them was to have the
39:39.050 --> 39:42.743
surveillance over a village and watching these Islamist
39:43.048 --> 39:46.197
monsters raping or beheading people and not be able to do
39:46.697 --> 39:49.857
anything about it. But what they needed to do in order to launch
39:49.889 --> 39:52.938
that drone strike was they had to be sure the target was identified. They had
39:53.438 --> 39:57.110
to be sure there was no collateral damage. A full-star general had to
39:57.254 --> 40:00.929
authorize every single missile that came off of the rails of one
40:01.026 --> 40:04.716
of those drones. And that kind of human link
40:05.198 --> 40:08.648
is what protects us from becoming autonomous killing
40:09.148 --> 40:13.013
robots. That's— and that's something I want to talk about in the next segment,
40:13.061 --> 40:16.361
that ultimately this really is Uh, we're trying
40:16.393 --> 40:19.664
to achieve not just efficiency but humanity. Friends,
40:19.680 --> 40:23.224
we come back and continue our conversation with Bill Whittle. You can find his excellent
40:23.724 --> 40:26.877
work at billwhittle.com. We're talking about dehumanizing the modern
40:26.910 --> 40:30.648
battlefield. Be part of the conversation. Follow what we're following by
40:31.148 --> 40:34.890
following us on Gab. That's gab.com. The channel is
40:34.922 --> 40:37.723
The Catholic Current, and you can influence the conversation.
40:37.820 --> 40:39.847
Contact us, stationofthecross.com.
40:42.026 --> 40:44.927
Let's do this good work together. Let's be more than merely relevant.
40:45.171 --> 40:46.889
Back in 2 minutes. Please do stay with us.
41:01.142 --> 41:04.365
Have a question or feedback about today's episode?
41:04.767 --> 41:08.343
Want to suggest a guest? Or a future topic, go to
41:08.843 --> 41:13.159
thestationofthecross.com/askfather and
41:13.176 --> 41:15.225
help influence the conversation.
41:21.390 --> 41:24.579
Praise be Jesus Christ. This is Father Robert McTagg of the Society of Jesus,
41:24.627 --> 41:27.864
your daily host for The Catholic Current, where we bring Christ to the world
41:28.364 --> 41:30.489
and the world to Christ. You're listening to us from the Station of the Cross
41:30.490 --> 41:34.103
studios, your local radio radio station and the iCatholic Radio mobile
41:34.603 --> 41:37.698
app, where we proclaim the fullness of truth with clarity and charity.
41:38.115 --> 41:41.116
Hey friends, I've been talking to Bill Whittle. You can find his excellent
41:41.164 --> 41:44.919
commentary on billwhittle.com. We're talking about dehumanizing
41:45.176 --> 41:49.412
the modern battlefield. Bill, we've been talking about technology
41:49.525 --> 41:53.906
changing the way that we fight war, how we, we perceive
41:54.900 --> 41:58.736
life and death and killing and so on. And there is a danger
41:59.155 --> 42:02.906
of the machines making killing too easy
42:03.647 --> 42:07.301
and hiding from us what's actually taking place.
42:07.430 --> 42:11.156
And I bring to mind a former student of mine I taught years ago.
42:11.867 --> 42:15.643
He was— gosh, he was a big guy. He was built. But he was
42:15.998 --> 42:19.999
a sniper for the Army Rangers, and he was in
42:20.176 --> 42:23.788
Iraq, you know, the second time we went in, and he'd been through
42:23.884 --> 42:27.616
hell and back. And so now he's 24, 25 years old,
42:28.081 --> 42:32.168
and he's in a freshman Western civilization class, and he's
42:32.184 --> 42:35.727
reading Homer's Odyssey with
42:35.855 --> 42:39.526
young guys who wear their hats on backwards, never heard a shot fired
42:39.638 --> 42:43.454
in anger, never threw a punch, never took a punch. And these
42:43.550 --> 42:47.092
young kids are laughing at the
42:47.592 --> 42:51.469
very idea that men could cry over
42:51.565 --> 42:55.396
the loss of friends. And I shuddered,
42:55.572 --> 42:57.608
and I said, well, he's not in handcuffs. So I said, well, did you do?
42:57.656 --> 43:01.024
And he goes, well, I had to get up and walk out because I didn't
43:01.040 --> 43:04.166
want to end up in jail because I did do that,
43:04.952 --> 43:08.367
and I caused other people to cry over their friends when
43:08.560 --> 43:13.531
I killed them. So I think there's something lost
43:13.627 --> 43:17.635
in not even letting war become a video
43:17.700 --> 43:20.955
game, but just an abstraction.
43:21.548 --> 43:24.915
I'm afraid of the path that we're going on. What are your thoughts about this,
43:24.931 --> 43:28.787
please? Well, we've had an all-voluntary military for quite
43:29.287 --> 43:33.045
a long time now, until short— not too long after Vietnam. And I
43:33.545 --> 43:36.082
do not want to go back to a draft under any circumstances. That was a
43:36.582 --> 43:40.083
catastrophe in Vietnam. And, and there is a moral
43:40.116 --> 43:44.808
clarity that comes from going to war with volunteers that
43:45.097 --> 43:48.279
I think is, is very, very important for a democracy.
43:49.194 --> 43:53.126
But, um, when you when you reach a point
43:53.626 --> 43:57.149
where your life is so insulated from the realities of
43:57.197 --> 44:01.109
what life actually is, if you can't cry over the loss of a friend,
44:01.686 --> 44:05.773
then there's something wrong with you. They can't— they have 2,000
44:05.789 --> 44:09.524
friends on Facebook, they have no real friends, right? That is
44:09.620 --> 44:13.291
part of the disconnect of humanity that's happening because of social media
44:13.307 --> 44:16.593
and experiencing everything through this little thing that we
44:16.609 --> 44:20.681
hold in our hands. But I, I wish that the, the gentleman
44:21.181 --> 44:24.512
in, in question— and I, I feel, I, I really feel his pain.
44:25.025 --> 44:29.353
I don't pretend to understand it exactly, but I, I certainly can get the
44:29.853 --> 44:33.265
shadow of it against the wall. Um, I wish he had had
44:33.765 --> 44:38.154
a chance to talk to those kids and tell them that this guy had pulled
44:38.654 --> 44:41.632
him out of fire and had saved him, saved his life, everything.
44:42.177 --> 44:45.897
And then watching his friend die and in combat was just
44:45.945 --> 44:49.247
overwhelming. I remember when Saving Private Ryan came out,
44:49.295 --> 44:52.966
there's a scene where the typist is supposed to carry
44:53.078 --> 44:55.419
ammunition up the stairs where there's a hand-to-hand fight,
44:56.204 --> 44:59.795
and the German soldier comes down, he's just killed
45:00.295 --> 45:03.722
this American, and he's going up the stairs and they just pass each other because
45:04.222 --> 45:05.758
they got nothing else to say and nothing else to do.
45:06.383 --> 45:10.183
And the young typist guy is just paralyzed
45:10.231 --> 45:13.362
by fear And, and everybody in the audience was just,
45:13.827 --> 45:17.039
just booing. Look, come on, you coward! You know, what's the matter with you,
45:17.055 --> 45:20.380
you coward? You should have just run. You weren't there, man.
45:21.055 --> 45:24.829
You know, you're, you're not there, and you will never know unless
45:24.909 --> 45:28.619
you are there. My great fear is, uh,
45:28.860 --> 45:32.361
is not being able to act when I need to. I'm, I'm afraid of being
45:32.393 --> 45:36.135
afraid. So far so good. I've had a number of emergencies
45:36.151 --> 45:39.250
that I've, that I've dealt with. I thought pretty, pretty well.
45:39.924 --> 45:43.376
And I've actually made an effort to desensitize myself to some of the sights that
45:43.633 --> 45:47.165
these people see so that if I ever do get into a situation where there's
45:47.665 --> 45:51.627
a mass casualty event, I can do some good. But nobody knows
45:51.740 --> 45:55.223
how they're going to behave until, until the shots are
45:55.256 --> 45:59.253
actually being fired. And that, and that insipid
45:59.349 --> 46:03.427
sort of mocking kind of thing really does
46:03.539 --> 46:06.423
need to be slapped out of people.
46:08.668 --> 46:11.689
It shows how dehumanized these kids are,
46:12.448 --> 46:16.163
that they can't even connect to it, that the whole idea
46:16.179 --> 46:18.989
is ludicrous to them. It's a,
46:19.151 --> 46:22.639
it's a big warning sign, Father. And I think
46:23.139 --> 46:27.188
that the best thing possible in that particular situation
46:27.866 --> 46:31.027
would have been for the teacher to let this man sit there and talk to
46:31.527 --> 46:35.820
them for 45 minutes and tell them what actually happened in graphic
46:36.320 --> 46:40.041
detail of what happened to those friends and
46:40.057 --> 46:43.010
teach these kids a bit of a lesson that they sorely need.
46:43.427 --> 46:47.263
Right. Part of reading great literature
46:47.760 --> 46:50.954
is to expand your moral imagination,
46:51.612 --> 46:54.950
to give you windows into worlds you might not
46:55.079 --> 46:59.059
otherwise have seen, to cultivate empathy,
46:59.556 --> 47:02.186
to put yourself in another's place.
47:03.083 --> 47:06.306
And I have to believe that whatever those kids did with their
47:06.806 --> 47:10.442
time before they got to, uh, that college
47:10.538 --> 47:14.050
class, I'm willing to bet that they didn't spend
47:14.082 --> 47:17.176
much of that time reading great literature.
47:17.352 --> 47:20.495
What do you think? I think you're absolutely right. One of
47:20.995 --> 47:24.278
the problems is that in the young people, young men play a lot
47:24.778 --> 47:28.383
of war games, and when they get shot, they immediately respawn,
47:28.447 --> 47:31.623
is the They just immediately resurrected back on the battlefield
47:32.123 --> 47:34.607
and go back in, they get shot, and so on. I think they should all
47:35.107 --> 47:38.153
be forced to play a game where there's no respawn. You get hit, you're killed,
47:38.201 --> 47:40.608
you're out for the game. You just have to sit there for 40 minutes and
47:41.108 --> 47:44.394
watch other people play. They would play very differently. But no, what you're
47:44.894 --> 47:49.175
talking about with literature is correct. I grew up at a time when the Vietnam
47:49.207 --> 47:53.426
War was— the Vietnam War ended when I was 14,
47:53.458 --> 47:57.250
so I was getting I mean, you know, I was thinking about the
47:57.315 --> 48:02.151
draft and I read The Red Badge of Courage and
48:02.830 --> 48:06.191
I thought, I seriously questioned, would I be
48:06.207 --> 48:09.485
able to go through this? Well, you're gonna have to, Bill.
48:09.840 --> 48:12.891
You know, you don't have a choice about this. You don't have to,
48:13.469 --> 48:16.105
you can't sit there and say, well, no, I just don't feel like going.
48:16.298 --> 48:20.285
You're going. And never facing that
48:20.317 --> 48:23.931
reality is is very destructive for men because
48:24.043 --> 48:27.756
once you can come to a level of acceptance that you would be willing to
48:28.256 --> 48:31.857
do this, that you'd be willing to go and do your duty, you become
48:31.921 --> 48:35.432
a man on a level that you don't become otherwise.
48:36.108 --> 48:39.876
I signed up for the military after 9/11 and they told me they didn't need
48:40.376 --> 48:42.293
any 40-year-olds, but they'd give me a call if they did.
48:45.111 --> 48:48.234
And I spent 12 years trying to get into the Air Force Academy.
48:48.957 --> 48:52.488
So I was, I was more than ready to go. But the
48:52.988 --> 48:56.949
war is, is, is the most profane and sacred thing that
48:57.449 --> 49:00.785
humans do, period. It's profane because of
49:01.475 --> 49:05.985
the blood, the murder, the loss, the grief, the terror,
49:06.708 --> 49:10.945
the damages, loss of limbs, the wounds, the blinding, the psychological
49:11.025 --> 49:14.251
damage that never heals. It is an awful, awful,
49:14.347 --> 49:18.162
awful awful, awful thing. And because we have
49:18.662 --> 49:21.320
to be willing to do it sometimes to defend what we love and what we
49:21.385 --> 49:24.639
believe in, that also makes it one of the most
49:24.655 --> 49:28.165
sacred things that we do. Right. It's because
49:28.422 --> 49:31.387
human life is precious— I'm sorry, but we're just coming up on a break.
49:32.590 --> 49:35.699
Because life is precious, we're made in the image and likeness of God,
49:36.437 --> 49:39.579
war cannot be a game, and it shouldn't be
49:40.079 --> 49:43.410
dealt with irreverently. Bill Whittle of BillWhittle.com,
49:43.426 --> 49:46.938
thank you for a fascinating conversation. I have so much respect for
49:47.438 --> 49:50.791
your work and your integrity, and I do hope we can talk again before
49:51.291 --> 49:54.805
long. Me too, Father. Me as well. I'm Jesuit Father Robert McTeague,
49:54.821 --> 49:57.952
your host every day at The Catholic Current. Join us tomorrow. It's Friday,
49:58.033 --> 50:01.405
and you know what that means. Let's talk about this. We'll walk through a complex
50:01.905 --> 50:05.724
issue together. I'm gonna be going into part 4 of
50:06.224 --> 50:10.011
our ongoing series called Novel Prophecies, looking at
50:10.075 --> 50:13.816
Catholic apocalyptic literature as a way of understanding
50:13.848 --> 50:18.055
our own times. Last Friday we read through Robert Hugh Benson's
50:18.248 --> 50:21.604
Lord of the World. There is a sequel called The Dawn
50:21.941 --> 50:26.051
of All. We're going to be going through that tomorrow. After the broadcast
50:26.551 --> 50:29.664
today, go to thestationofthecross.com, get our resources list,
50:29.744 --> 50:32.651
download our audio as podcasts, take us to your friends.
50:32.715 --> 50:35.974
Together we'll take it to the whole world. Through the intercession of Our Lady of
50:35.990 --> 50:39.525
Mount Carmel, may almighty God bless you, Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. Go in
50:40.025 --> 50:42.787
peace, and please do pray for me, for I am a sinner.