•Distilled: Reopened — Brookelynn Farthing: The Disappearance They Should Have Solved

1
00:00:10,320 --> 00:00:14,160
John: When we first launched Dark
Dialog to Distill the plan was simple.
2
00:00:14,460 --> 00:00:19,800
Take our biggest episodes and turn them
into clean short versions, bite-size,
3
00:00:19,800 --> 00:00:24,900
true crime, stripped down to the essential
facts and on paper that made sense
4
00:00:25,290 --> 00:00:29,790
with all the long form investigations
we do on the network, having a quick
5
00:00:29,790 --> 00:00:34,140
version, which felt like a natural
companion, but the more I worked on it,
6
00:00:34,140 --> 00:00:36,240
the more something started to bother me.
7
00:00:36,810 --> 00:00:40,740
These cases aren't meant to be cut
apart and trimmed into summaries,
8
00:00:41,190 --> 00:00:44,760
not the ones that we've done and
not the ones we haven't touched yet.
9
00:00:44,970 --> 00:00:49,710
Victims don't become simpler because
we choose a shorter episode length.
10
00:00:50,135 --> 00:00:52,085
Families don't hurt any less.
11
00:00:52,385 --> 00:00:57,095
The unanswered questions don't shrink the
mistakes, the contradictions, the holes
12
00:00:57,095 --> 00:00:59,135
in the timeline, they don't disappear.
13
00:00:59,135 --> 00:01:01,445
Just because I hit delete on a paragraph.
14
00:01:02,135 --> 00:01:06,664
So I asked myself, why am I
shrinking these cases when what
15
00:01:06,664 --> 00:01:08,884
they really need is room to breathe?
16
00:01:09,604 --> 00:01:10,685
And that's what it hit me.
17
00:01:11,164 --> 00:01:15,965
This show shouldn't be the edited down
version of something that we already did.
18
00:01:16,505 --> 00:01:22,475
It should be the chance to reexamine
old cases, examine new cases, all
19
00:01:22,475 --> 00:01:26,914
with a sharper lens, a looser format,
and the freedom to be honest about
20
00:01:26,975 --> 00:01:29,259
what we got right and what we didn't.
21
00:01:30,195 --> 00:01:34,065
Because here's the truth, most
podcasters don't like to admit.
22
00:01:34,755 --> 00:01:36,825
Sometimes we make mistakes.
23
00:01:37,155 --> 00:01:39,525
Sometimes new information comes forward.
24
00:01:39,915 --> 00:01:43,065
Sometimes listeners catch
something that we missed.
25
00:01:43,455 --> 00:01:48,135
Sometimes months or years later,
we see the case differently than
26
00:01:48,165 --> 00:01:51,615
we did the first time around, and
those moments shouldn't be ignored.
27
00:01:51,885 --> 00:01:52,935
They should be addressed.
28
00:01:53,385 --> 00:01:58,875
This show gives me the space to do that,
to revisit cases, correct the record,
29
00:01:59,145 --> 00:02:03,885
acknowledge criticisms, dig deeper into
the parts that don't get enough time,
30
00:02:04,305 --> 00:02:06,405
and talk openly about what's changed.
31
00:02:06,405 --> 00:02:10,155
In my understanding of the
case, this isn't the main show.
32
00:02:10,395 --> 00:02:12,015
It's not Rocky Mountain Reckoning.
33
00:02:12,585 --> 00:02:17,175
It doesn't follow a strict outline, a
segment structure, or a narrative formula.
34
00:02:18,179 --> 00:02:20,339
This is a looser format on purpose.
35
00:02:20,640 --> 00:02:25,320
It allows me to talk about whatever part
of the case deserves the focus, a single
36
00:02:25,320 --> 00:02:29,730
contradiction in the timeline, a witness
statement that never sat right with me.
37
00:02:30,119 --> 00:02:34,829
A theory that needs dismantling, a
rumor that harmed the investigation.
38
00:02:35,250 --> 00:02:38,549
A detail I learned after the
episode aired, or a mistake
39
00:02:38,579 --> 00:02:40,649
I made that needs correction.
40
00:02:41,549 --> 00:02:46,529
This is me, one person, one mic,
looking at a case exactly the way I do.
41
00:02:46,529 --> 00:02:50,100
When the show script is closed,
the production pressure is gone,
42
00:02:50,399 --> 00:02:54,029
and it's just the evidence, the
questions, and an uncomfortable truth.
43
00:02:54,060 --> 00:02:59,730
Not a polished story, not a condensed
recap, a distilled investigation.
44
00:03:00,269 --> 00:03:05,310
So if you're here for the raw analysis,
the things that didn't make it into
45
00:03:05,310 --> 00:03:08,730
the big show, the second thoughts,
the unanswered questions, and the
46
00:03:08,730 --> 00:03:10,859
parts of the case, that still not me.
47
00:03:11,370 --> 00:03:13,290
Welcome to the new distilled.
48
00:03:13,725 --> 00:03:17,925
This is the Lone Researcher format,
and today we're starting with a
49
00:03:17,925 --> 00:03:19,935
case that has bothered me for years.
50
00:03:19,935 --> 00:03:24,225
One of the most baffling, frustrating, and
emotionally heavy unsolved disappearances
51
00:03:24,225 --> 00:03:30,345
in Kentucky, the vanishing of Brooklyn
Farthing at 4 26 in the morning.
52
00:03:30,465 --> 00:03:33,945
An 18-year-old from Berea,
Kentucky sent a text.
53
00:03:33,945 --> 00:03:35,535
No one ever wants to see.
54
00:03:35,955 --> 00:03:36,795
Please hurry.
55
00:03:36,885 --> 00:03:41,685
I'm scared, not annoyed,
not uncomfortable, scared.
56
00:03:42,315 --> 00:03:43,905
Her name was Brooklyn Farthing.
57
00:03:44,235 --> 00:03:47,625
Just hours earlier, she'd been
doing what a lot of small town
58
00:03:47,625 --> 00:03:49,155
kids do on a summer Friday.
59
00:03:49,515 --> 00:03:52,965
She spent the day with her family
celebrating her grandfather's birthday.
60
00:03:53,355 --> 00:03:57,105
That night she went to a field
party out on Red Lake Road with
61
00:03:57,105 --> 00:04:01,545
her sister and a cousin, bonfire
music friends, that kind of thing.
62
00:04:02,520 --> 00:04:05,070
By the early morning hours,
the party was thinning out.
63
00:04:05,400 --> 00:04:09,150
Her sister and cousin left the
friend she was supposed to stay with.
64
00:04:09,150 --> 00:04:14,370
Bailed on her after an argument in
Brooklyn, 18 years old, newly graduated,
65
00:04:14,640 --> 00:04:18,690
standing in the middle of a rural
Kentucky night, found herself stranded.
66
00:04:19,170 --> 00:04:24,330
A 23-year-old acquaintance, Josh Hensley
offered her a ride instead of going home.
67
00:04:24,330 --> 00:04:28,740
She ended up at his place, a
foreclosed house on DI court with no
68
00:04:28,740 --> 00:04:33,570
electricity, no running water, and
according to him, just enough furniture
69
00:04:33,570 --> 00:04:36,240
left for a couch from that house.
70
00:04:36,240 --> 00:04:40,230
In the early hours of June 22nd,
Brooklyn started reaching out.
71
00:04:40,590 --> 00:04:42,300
She called and texted family.
72
00:04:42,300 --> 00:04:46,530
She messaged her ex-fiancee
Jared, asking him to pick her
73
00:04:46,530 --> 00:04:48,090
up when he got off of work.
74
00:04:48,510 --> 00:04:52,830
And at 4:26 AM she sent the
message that defines this case.
75
00:04:53,370 --> 00:04:54,240
Please hurry.
76
00:04:54,360 --> 00:04:55,260
I'm scared.
77
00:04:55,469 --> 00:04:57,180
This is not a casual check-in.
78
00:04:57,390 --> 00:04:59,460
This is not a, Hey, where are you?
79
00:04:59,760 --> 00:05:04,349
This is a young woman telling someone she
trusts that something is wrong, and then
80
00:05:04,349 --> 00:05:06,599
about an hour later, everything changes.
81
00:05:07,560 --> 00:05:11,460
A final text goes out from her
phone to Jared saying, nevermind.
82
00:05:11,700 --> 00:05:12,300
I'm okay.
83
00:05:12,510 --> 00:05:14,520
I'm going to a party
in Rock Castle County.
84
00:05:14,700 --> 00:05:16,530
Her family doesn't believe she wrote it.
85
00:05:16,800 --> 00:05:19,560
Investigators don't
think it sounds like her.
86
00:05:19,800 --> 00:05:23,669
And when you look at the timing and
everything that happens next, it's
87
00:05:23,669 --> 00:05:27,570
hard to argue with them because shortly
after that message, the living room
88
00:05:27,570 --> 00:05:29,490
of the foreclosed house catches fire.
89
00:05:29,820 --> 00:05:31,140
There's no power in the home.
90
00:05:31,469 --> 00:05:33,419
No obvious accidental source.
91
00:05:33,719 --> 00:05:37,080
Yet the couch catches hot enough
to damage the floor before
92
00:05:37,080 --> 00:05:38,549
firefighters knock it down.
93
00:05:39,719 --> 00:05:43,680
Inside and around that house searchers
and investigators find some of Brooklyn's
94
00:05:43,680 --> 00:05:49,080
personal belongings, her purse, her
overnight bag, her footwear, the kinds
95
00:05:49,080 --> 00:05:51,360
of things she was known to keep close.
96
00:05:51,780 --> 00:05:52,500
The two things.
97
00:05:52,500 --> 00:05:57,840
Nobody finds Brooklyn and her
phone for nearly 12 years.
98
00:05:57,840 --> 00:06:01,710
This case has been a tangle of
unanswered questions, terrified
99
00:06:01,710 --> 00:06:04,080
text, followed by a sudden nevermind.
100
00:06:04,620 --> 00:06:06,780
A fire in a house with no electricity.
101
00:06:07,050 --> 00:06:12,060
Personal items left behind a phone
that later pings miles away, and
102
00:06:12,060 --> 00:06:16,620
the disappearance window so tight it
almost collapses under its own weight.
103
00:06:17,219 --> 00:06:20,789
Tonight we're gonna walk through the 10
parts of this case that bother me the
104
00:06:20,789 --> 00:06:25,380
most, the details that don't line up,
the decisions that don't make sense,
105
00:06:25,440 --> 00:06:29,640
and the questions that still hang over
the disappearance of Brooklyn Farthing.
106
00:06:30,600 --> 00:06:33,750
Before we get into the 10 things
about this case that don't add up,
107
00:06:34,050 --> 00:06:37,860
let's pull back and look at the
timeline as we actually know it.
108
00:06:38,190 --> 00:06:42,570
The part that isn't speculation,
rumor or hindsight, here's what
109
00:06:42,570 --> 00:06:44,400
we can say with confidence.
110
00:06:44,640 --> 00:06:49,470
On June 21st, 2013, Brooklyn
Farthing spent the day celebrating
111
00:06:49,470 --> 00:06:53,520
her grandfather's birthday, family
photos, time with her cousins,
112
00:06:53,700 --> 00:06:58,080
normal summer, evening, nothing
out of character, nothing unusual.
113
00:06:58,530 --> 00:07:02,130
Later that night, she and two
relatives, her sister Paige and
114
00:07:02,130 --> 00:07:06,630
their cousin, headed to a field party
on Red Luck Road, a typical rural
115
00:07:06,630 --> 00:07:11,430
Kentucky gathering, bonfire friends,
and a mix of people coming and going.
116
00:07:12,390 --> 00:07:16,980
At some point after midnight, a
small argument broke out between
117
00:07:16,980 --> 00:07:19,380
Brooklyn and the girl that
she was supposed to stay with.
118
00:07:19,830 --> 00:07:25,320
That friend left, her sister left, her
cousin left, and Brooklyn stayed behind,
119
00:07:25,320 --> 00:07:27,720
expecting to leave later or catch a ride.
120
00:07:29,175 --> 00:07:33,045
A 23-year-old acquaintance, Josh
Hensley, offered her a lift.
121
00:07:33,405 --> 00:07:37,665
Instead of driving her home, he
took her to a foreclosed house on DI
122
00:07:37,905 --> 00:07:42,645
court, a house with no electricity,
no running water, and minimal
123
00:07:42,645 --> 00:07:45,615
furnishings from inside that house.
124
00:07:45,615 --> 00:07:49,575
Brooklyn contacted multiple people
throughout the early morning hours,
125
00:07:50,025 --> 00:07:54,525
calls, texts, and, and one message
that stands out above all the rest.
126
00:07:54,945 --> 00:07:56,865
Please hurry, I'm scared.
127
00:07:57,675 --> 00:08:02,715
Around 4:30 AM Jared, her ex-fiancee,
agreed to come get her when he got
128
00:08:02,715 --> 00:08:06,645
off work, but by the time he arrived
in the area, he couldn't reach her.
129
00:08:06,945 --> 00:08:13,755
Sometime after 5:00 AM her phone sends
a message saying, going to a party
130
00:08:13,755 --> 00:08:16,455
in Rockcastle County, and she's okay.
131
00:08:16,845 --> 00:08:20,415
A Claimer family and investigators
have repeatedly said, does not
132
00:08:20,415 --> 00:08:21,735
sound like Brooklyn at all.
133
00:08:22,245 --> 00:08:25,605
Shortly after Dawn, the living
room couch in DI Court in the
134
00:08:25,605 --> 00:08:27,435
Dill courthouse catches on fire.
135
00:08:27,855 --> 00:08:32,205
The house has no power, no breaker
box, and no clear ignition.
136
00:08:32,205 --> 00:08:32,595
Source.
137
00:08:32,985 --> 00:08:36,645
Firefighters respond quickly and
prevent major structural loss
138
00:08:37,065 --> 00:08:39,284
inside or just outside the house.
139
00:08:39,465 --> 00:08:44,505
Investigators find several of Brook of
Brooklyn's personal belongings, her cowboy
140
00:08:44,505 --> 00:08:47,025
boots, her purse, her overnight bag.
141
00:08:47,415 --> 00:08:49,845
These were items she was rarely without.
142
00:08:50,415 --> 00:08:51,285
The items missing.
143
00:08:51,645 --> 00:08:57,045
Like I said before, Brooklyn, herself
and her cell phone, her phone later
144
00:08:57,045 --> 00:09:02,175
pings a ways away on blue, on Blue
Lick Road, a rural area with heavy
145
00:09:02,175 --> 00:09:05,985
tree cover, uneven terrain, and
plenty of places someone could discard
146
00:09:05,985 --> 00:09:10,695
evidence despite searches, interviews,
and years of public involvement.
147
00:09:11,145 --> 00:09:13,305
No trace of Brooklyn has ever been found.
148
00:09:13,740 --> 00:09:18,600
Her case remains open, active,
and deeply painful for her family.
149
00:09:18,839 --> 00:09:23,730
Now, if you want a complete detailed
step-by-step reconstruction of the
150
00:09:23,730 --> 00:09:27,660
entire night, the full episode of
Dark Dialogue walks through every
151
00:09:27,660 --> 00:09:31,740
timeline, minute, every witness
account, and every no and detail.
152
00:09:31,890 --> 00:09:36,209
It's there whenever you want to dive
deeper, but right now for this show,
153
00:09:36,839 --> 00:09:40,650
I want to take a different approach
because when you strip the case down
154
00:09:40,650 --> 00:09:45,839
to the essentials, when you remove
assumptions, rumors and noise, 10 parts
155
00:09:45,839 --> 00:09:50,310
of this story stand out so sharply
they almost demand a second look.
156
00:09:50,939 --> 00:09:56,849
10 things that bother me, 10 things that
don't make sense, 10 things that raise
157
00:09:56,849 --> 00:09:59,099
far more questions than they answer.
158
00:10:00,000 --> 00:10:05,459
Let's start with the one that haunts most
people first, those last text messages.
159
00:10:05,459 --> 00:10:08,730
I. The last messages that came
from Brooklyn Ling's phone are
160
00:10:08,730 --> 00:10:10,740
the backbone of this entire case.
161
00:10:11,130 --> 00:10:15,780
They're the only direct window we have
into her state of mind during the final 90
162
00:10:15,780 --> 00:10:20,700
minutes that she was ever heard from, and
they paint a picture that is disturbing,
163
00:10:21,060 --> 00:10:25,440
inconsistent, and extremely difficult to
line up with any innocent explanation.
164
00:10:27,300 --> 00:10:28,245
Here's what we know for sure.
165
00:10:28,965 --> 00:10:32,775
Sometime after four in the
morning, Brooklyn was inside the
166
00:10:32,775 --> 00:10:34,425
foreclosed house on DI Court.
167
00:10:34,815 --> 00:10:36,525
She lost her original ride.
168
00:10:36,765 --> 00:10:39,945
The friend she planned to stay
with had left after an argument
169
00:10:40,245 --> 00:10:44,175
and the only person around was a
23-year-old man that she didn't know.
170
00:10:44,175 --> 00:10:47,475
Well, at four o'clock in the
morning, she reached out to her
171
00:10:47,475 --> 00:10:49,875
sister Paige, asking for a ride.
172
00:10:50,205 --> 00:10:51,285
Paige couldn't come.
173
00:10:51,435 --> 00:10:54,795
It wasn't safe for her to drive,
and their cousin, who was also
174
00:10:54,795 --> 00:10:56,565
there, was too intoxicated to help.
175
00:10:57,015 --> 00:11:00,165
So Brooklyn did what a lot
of 18 year olds would do.
176
00:11:00,525 --> 00:11:01,815
She tried someone else.
177
00:11:01,995 --> 00:11:05,985
She texted her ex-boyfriend Jared,
and asked if he could pick her up
178
00:11:05,985 --> 00:11:07,485
once he got off work that morning.
179
00:11:07,995 --> 00:11:12,555
And then at 4:26 AM the
tone of everything changes.
180
00:11:13,275 --> 00:11:16,305
A series of messages come
through short and direct.
181
00:11:16,694 --> 00:11:17,385
I'm scared.
182
00:11:17,745 --> 00:11:18,555
Please hurry.
183
00:11:18,675 --> 00:11:21,645
Not passive, not subtle and not vague.
184
00:11:21,975 --> 00:11:26,204
She didn't say, I'm uncomfortable,
or Can you come soon?
185
00:11:26,204 --> 00:11:30,255
She used the word scared and
she repeated the urgency.
186
00:11:31,365 --> 00:11:33,165
These are fear driven texts.
187
00:11:33,345 --> 00:11:36,885
They read like someone trying to
keep her voice down or someone
188
00:11:36,885 --> 00:11:38,805
trying not to be caught on her phone.
189
00:11:39,525 --> 00:11:43,995
They also matched the timeline of a young
woman who was suddenly aware she could not
190
00:11:43,995 --> 00:11:48,765
leave on her own, and who needed someone
that she trusted to get there quickly.
191
00:11:48,944 --> 00:11:53,925
Now, here's where the entire case
takes a sharp left turn because about
192
00:11:53,925 --> 00:11:59,295
an hour later, somewhere between
five 30 and 5 45, another message is
193
00:11:59,295 --> 00:12:01,005
sent from Brooklyn's phone to Jared.
194
00:12:01,395 --> 00:12:02,295
This one says.
195
00:12:03,224 --> 00:12:03,974
Nevermind.
196
00:12:04,155 --> 00:12:04,814
I'm okay.
197
00:12:05,084 --> 00:12:07,035
I'm going to a party in Rockcastle County.
198
00:12:07,545 --> 00:12:09,944
And if you're thinking, wait, what?
199
00:12:09,944 --> 00:12:14,954
18-year-old goes to a party at five 30
in the morning with no ride and with her
200
00:12:14,954 --> 00:12:19,425
boots, purse, and overnight bags still
sitting at the house after telling someone
201
00:12:19,425 --> 00:12:22,064
that she's scared you are not alone.
202
00:12:22,515 --> 00:12:25,064
Brooklyn's family doesn't
believe she wrote the message.
203
00:12:25,244 --> 00:12:29,714
Investigators have said the same thing
publicly and privately for years, and
204
00:12:29,714 --> 00:12:34,334
when you line it up next to her previous
messages, the shift is so unnatural.
205
00:12:34,484 --> 00:12:36,405
It practically highlights itself.
206
00:12:36,885 --> 00:12:38,594
There are a few reasons for that.
207
00:12:38,775 --> 00:12:40,005
First, the hour.
208
00:12:40,250 --> 00:12:44,895
There are no parties at 6:00 AM in
rural Kentucky, not the kind you
209
00:12:44,895 --> 00:12:49,244
suddenly decide to head to with no
transportation, no shoes, and your
210
00:12:49,244 --> 00:12:50,984
purse sitting inside the house.
211
00:12:50,984 --> 00:12:51,734
You just left.
212
00:12:52,364 --> 00:12:54,494
Second, the language is outta character.
213
00:12:54,795 --> 00:12:57,525
Her earlier messages were
tight, urgent, clipped.
214
00:12:57,854 --> 00:13:01,364
This one reads calm, casual,
and almost rehearsed.
215
00:13:01,800 --> 00:13:03,300
Third, the motive.
216
00:13:03,660 --> 00:13:08,640
If someone wanted to buy time, if someone
wanted to push away the one person who
217
00:13:08,640 --> 00:13:13,290
was on the way to get her, this is exactly
the kind of message that you would send.
218
00:13:13,500 --> 00:13:16,800
And fourth, we know Brooklyn's
phone went missing with her.
219
00:13:16,980 --> 00:13:17,910
It was never found.
220
00:13:17,910 --> 00:13:21,960
It later pinged miles away long
after she stopped responding.
221
00:13:22,560 --> 00:13:29,130
Taking together these two messages, the
4:26 AM fear and the 5:30 AM reassurance
222
00:13:29,400 --> 00:13:34,740
form a contradiction, so sharp, it's
almost impossible to explain away.
223
00:13:35,250 --> 00:13:39,660
One message says, I'm in trouble,
and the next says, ah, forget it.
224
00:13:39,690 --> 00:13:40,620
Everything is fine.
225
00:13:40,770 --> 00:13:45,120
In cases like this, the investigators
should look at three things.
226
00:13:45,600 --> 00:13:52,890
One, content, what was said, two, timing
when it was said, and three, behavioral
227
00:13:52,890 --> 00:13:57,570
alignment, whether the message fits,
the victim's situation and personality.
228
00:13:57,975 --> 00:14:00,315
The first set fits the situation.
229
00:14:00,525 --> 00:14:06,375
The second set does not, and that is why
these messages more than anything else,
230
00:14:06,615 --> 00:14:11,355
are the heartbeat of this case, because
if Brooklyn didn't send that final text,
231
00:14:11,685 --> 00:14:16,305
then someone else had her phone, and if
someone else had her phone, then whatever
232
00:14:16,305 --> 00:14:18,585
happened to her was already in motion.
233
00:14:18,885 --> 00:14:20,115
And that's just the beginning.
234
00:14:20,715 --> 00:14:25,185
Question number two that I have, the
confusing change of plans message.
235
00:14:25,695 --> 00:14:29,505
When people talk about the turning
point in the Brooklyn faring case,
236
00:14:29,715 --> 00:14:34,935
this is it the sudden 5:30 AM text
that flips the narrative on its head.
237
00:14:35,415 --> 00:14:40,605
Everything about this message clashes with
what we know about the hour before it.
238
00:14:41,115 --> 00:14:45,855
Her fear, her urgency, her attempts
to get a ride, and her clear
239
00:14:45,855 --> 00:14:47,535
intention to leave the house.
240
00:14:47,595 --> 00:14:51,525
And that's why this single text has become
one of the most scrutinized pieces of
241
00:14:51,525 --> 00:14:53,985
evidence in the entire disappearance.
242
00:14:54,359 --> 00:14:58,319
So let's break that down With
verified information only timing, the
243
00:14:58,319 --> 00:15:00,359
message does not fit the timeline.
244
00:15:00,660 --> 00:15:04,650
After a long stretch of text messages
where Brooklyn was actively trained
245
00:15:04,650 --> 00:15:09,060
to get picked up and expressing
fear, a text suddenly goes out from
246
00:15:09,060 --> 00:15:11,160
her phone at approximately five 30.
247
00:15:11,550 --> 00:15:15,869
This message appears after her
failed attempts at finding a safe
248
00:15:15,869 --> 00:15:20,459
ride, her escalating fear, and
her final communication of panic.
249
00:15:20,550 --> 00:15:25,650
It comes at a time when the homeowner
claims he had stepped out to do chores,
250
00:15:26,010 --> 00:15:31,140
and there are no other verified human
beings documented as being with her.
251
00:15:31,680 --> 00:15:37,979
This exact overlap that his absence and
the text appearing is one of the reasons.
252
00:15:37,979 --> 00:15:41,790
This message raises so many
questions to the content.
253
00:15:42,089 --> 00:15:47,010
A total tone shift, the
text says, quote, nevermind.
254
00:15:47,280 --> 00:15:48,180
I'm okay.
255
00:15:48,390 --> 00:15:50,880
I'm going to a party
in Rock Castle County.
256
00:15:51,180 --> 00:15:51,750
End quote.
257
00:15:52,395 --> 00:15:56,145
Nothing about this message
lines up with anything that she
258
00:15:56,145 --> 00:15:57,285
had said or done that night.
259
00:15:57,555 --> 00:16:00,975
The content itself takes the
case in a different direction
260
00:16:01,245 --> 00:16:03,555
except that nothing supports it.
261
00:16:04,005 --> 00:16:06,555
Three out of character behavior.
262
00:16:06,945 --> 00:16:10,995
Her family, friends, and
investigators have all emphasized.
263
00:16:11,295 --> 00:16:14,535
There was no, no one party
in Rock Castle County.
264
00:16:15,045 --> 00:16:16,485
No one was hosting one.
265
00:16:16,665 --> 00:16:22,665
No one was attending one, especially not
at five 30 or six o'clock in the morning
266
00:16:22,875 --> 00:16:24,915
and especially not in rural Kentucky.
267
00:16:25,275 --> 00:16:26,715
She had no ride.
268
00:16:27,195 --> 00:16:28,425
Her sister couldn't come.
269
00:16:28,635 --> 00:16:30,255
Her cousin was intoxicated.
270
00:16:30,435 --> 00:16:36,915
Her ex Jared was stuck at work until
around 7:00 AM There are no calls, no
271
00:16:36,915 --> 00:16:43,875
texts, no arrangements, no witnesses,
no posts, no camera footage, nothing
272
00:16:44,205 --> 00:16:47,865
showing that she left or planned
to leave for another location.
273
00:16:48,375 --> 00:16:50,115
She was trying to leave the house.
274
00:16:50,505 --> 00:16:52,305
But not to go to another party.
275
00:16:52,844 --> 00:16:56,354
This part is confirmed
repeatedly by family and friends.
276
00:16:56,594 --> 00:16:59,564
She wasn't out looking
for another good time.
277
00:16:59,805 --> 00:17:03,104
She wanted out of the situation
that she was already in.
278
00:17:04,244 --> 00:17:04,875
Four.
279
00:17:05,175 --> 00:17:06,825
Did she actually send it?
280
00:17:07,274 --> 00:17:11,415
This is the central question, and
no evidence has ever been released
281
00:17:11,714 --> 00:17:15,075
confirming whether the message
came from Brooklyn's own hands.
282
00:17:15,524 --> 00:17:20,234
What we do know is that her boyfriend
did not buy the change in tone.
283
00:17:20,474 --> 00:17:25,454
He went from she's scared
to, she's suddenly okay.
284
00:17:25,635 --> 00:17:31,575
Even he has publicly stated that he does
not believe the 5:30 AM text was truly
285
00:17:31,575 --> 00:17:34,065
from her family doesn't believe it either.
286
00:17:34,425 --> 00:17:38,925
The message contradicts her earlier
state of fear, her attempts to
287
00:17:38,925 --> 00:17:43,784
get home, her usual behavior and
her patterns of communication.
288
00:17:44,219 --> 00:17:46,379
Investigators consider it suspicious.
289
00:17:46,620 --> 00:17:50,879
Law enforcement has repeatedly highlighted
that the message is inconsistent,
290
00:17:50,939 --> 00:17:56,610
unconfirmed, and abnormal, and the
homeowner's timeline creates opportunity.
291
00:17:56,939 --> 00:18:01,469
The man who last saw her has given
inconsistent statements about
292
00:18:01,679 --> 00:18:06,510
what time he left, what time he
returned, and why he left her alone.
293
00:18:07,020 --> 00:18:12,899
This inconsistency creates a window where
someone else had both opportunity and
294
00:18:12,899 --> 00:18:15,870
motive to send a message meant to mislead.
295
00:18:16,740 --> 00:18:21,270
It's important to note that no source
has confirmed that he sent it, only
296
00:18:21,270 --> 00:18:25,530
that the circumstances suggest the
possibility of access and motive.
297
00:18:25,709 --> 00:18:30,870
Number five, no follow up, no
confirmation, no evidence after
298
00:18:30,870 --> 00:18:33,300
that text message, nothing.
299
00:18:33,870 --> 00:18:40,110
No replies, no confirmations, no
calls, no sightings, no posts, no
300
00:18:40,110 --> 00:18:42,000
camera hits, no vehicle reports.
301
00:18:42,480 --> 00:18:45,000
Her phone goes silent
and is never recovered.
302
00:18:45,360 --> 00:18:48,419
Combined with the fact that all of
her belongings except the clothes
303
00:18:48,419 --> 00:18:52,169
that she wore and her phone were
left behind, the message does
304
00:18:52,169 --> 00:18:54,235
not appear to reflect real plans.
305
00:18:55,165 --> 00:19:01,350
Number six, the investigative significance
of this text, why it matters so much.
306
00:19:01,740 --> 00:19:06,780
The 5:30 AM text functions as
one, a potential alibi attempt.
307
00:19:07,500 --> 00:19:11,985
If someone wanted to make it look like she
left the house willingly, this is exactly
308
00:19:12,330 --> 00:19:14,024
the kind of message that they would send.
309
00:19:14,730 --> 00:19:16,920
Number two, a delay tactic.
310
00:19:17,100 --> 00:19:22,290
If someone wanted her ex-boyfriend
not to show up at 7:00 AM and I'm
311
00:19:22,290 --> 00:19:25,560
okay, I'm going somewhere else,
message would buy that time.
312
00:19:25,770 --> 00:19:27,090
And three, a diversion.
313
00:19:27,360 --> 00:19:30,660
It shifts attention away from
the house, the last place that
314
00:19:30,660 --> 00:19:32,940
she was verifiably seen alive.
315
00:19:33,480 --> 00:19:38,970
This is why the text is often described
as the moment the case quote goes dark.
316
00:19:39,480 --> 00:19:43,110
Number seven, public and
family inter interpretation
317
00:19:43,380 --> 00:19:45,300
across all credible sources.
318
00:19:45,300 --> 00:19:49,500
The overwhelming consensus is
that she did not send this text.
319
00:19:49,980 --> 00:19:55,470
People familiar with her say it's not
her tone, it's not the way she talked.
320
00:19:55,680 --> 00:20:00,720
It's not what she would've said,
and at that time, it's not something
321
00:20:00,720 --> 00:20:02,670
that she would've ever done.
322
00:20:03,270 --> 00:20:06,840
And investigators openly acknowledged
that the text is suspicious.
323
00:20:07,080 --> 00:20:10,800
There is zero evidence she
ever left that house or made
324
00:20:10,860 --> 00:20:12,990
anywhere in Rock Castle County.
325
00:20:13,440 --> 00:20:13,950
So.
326
00:20:14,385 --> 00:20:19,155
Just a summary of why this text is one of
the most concerning elements of this case
327
00:20:19,365 --> 00:20:23,805
is one, it directly, directly contradicts
everything that she expressed earlier.
328
00:20:24,225 --> 00:20:24,645
Two.
329
00:20:24,675 --> 00:20:27,975
It describes a plan that
had no basis in reality.
330
00:20:28,515 --> 00:20:29,055
Three.
331
00:20:29,295 --> 00:20:32,715
No ride, no witnesses, no
destination, no reason.
332
00:20:33,255 --> 00:20:33,705
Four.
333
00:20:33,705 --> 00:20:36,525
It appears after she communicated fear.
334
00:20:37,125 --> 00:20:40,665
Five, it aligns with a window
where someone else could
335
00:20:40,665 --> 00:20:41,955
have accessed her phone.
336
00:20:42,345 --> 00:20:42,945
Six.
337
00:20:43,065 --> 00:20:46,905
It functionally dis delays
anyone coming to help her.
338
00:20:47,445 --> 00:20:47,955
Seven.
339
00:20:48,015 --> 00:20:51,495
It does not match her behavior
or her communication patterns.
340
00:20:51,795 --> 00:20:56,025
And finally, it marks the last
verifiable activity from her phone.
341
00:20:56,475 --> 00:21:02,055
This is why the 5:30 AM message remains
one of the largest, most suspicious
342
00:21:02,055 --> 00:21:04,695
red flags in the entire disappearance.
343
00:21:04,845 --> 00:21:07,545
Question number three,
the fire on Dillon Court.
344
00:21:07,875 --> 00:21:10,575
The most suspicious hour in the case.
345
00:21:11,595 --> 00:21:16,215
If the last text message is the moment
that tells us Brooklyn was afraid.
346
00:21:16,485 --> 00:21:20,504
The fire on Dylan court is the moment that
tells us something was being covered up.
347
00:21:20,925 --> 00:21:25,545
It remains one of the most contested,
controversial, and poorly explained
348
00:21:25,545 --> 00:21:27,284
events in her disappearance.
349
00:21:27,615 --> 00:21:31,784
And every version of what happened
during that hour comes from one person.
350
00:21:32,175 --> 00:21:36,645
Joshua Hensley, the last known
individual with her that morning,
351
00:21:36,795 --> 00:21:38,985
according to his own statements.
352
00:21:39,645 --> 00:21:43,935
Let's break down what is actually
known, what is disputed and why
353
00:21:43,935 --> 00:21:46,215
this fire changes everything.
354
00:21:46,995 --> 00:21:50,865
Number one, the setting a
vacant house with no utilities.
355
00:21:51,195 --> 00:21:55,754
Hensley has been staying intermittently
at a foreclosed home in Dillon Court,
356
00:21:55,845 --> 00:21:58,155
verified across all major reporting.
357
00:21:58,754 --> 00:22:03,764
There's no electricity, there's no running
water, there's no active power sources.
358
00:22:04,155 --> 00:22:08,865
This immediately eliminates most
categories of accidental fire.
359
00:22:09,555 --> 00:22:14,085
There were no heaters plugged in,
no lamps, no appliances, no wiring
360
00:22:14,085 --> 00:22:16,425
failures in a powerless house.
361
00:22:16,635 --> 00:22:21,075
A cigarette becomes the only ignition
source Hensley has ever offered,
362
00:22:21,525 --> 00:22:26,415
and in my personal opinion, that
explanation does not withstand scrutiny.
363
00:22:26,865 --> 00:22:30,435
Hensley told investigators that
he left the house around 6:00 AM
364
00:22:30,765 --> 00:22:32,865
to feed horses at a nearby farm.
365
00:22:33,285 --> 00:22:36,225
He said that when he walked out
the door, Brooklyn was sitting
366
00:22:36,225 --> 00:22:37,845
on the couch smoking a cigarette.
367
00:22:38,745 --> 00:22:43,785
He claims that he returned around
7:00 AM and found the couch on
368
00:22:43,785 --> 00:22:45,855
fire, smoke in the living room.
369
00:22:46,035 --> 00:22:47,145
Brooklyn gone.
370
00:22:47,265 --> 00:22:50,625
Her phone missing and all of
her belongings still there,
371
00:22:50,805 --> 00:22:53,145
but here's a critical fact.
372
00:22:53,535 --> 00:22:57,465
No independent evidence confirms
that she ever left the house alive.
373
00:22:57,855 --> 00:22:59,655
Nothing corroborates his story.
374
00:22:59,835 --> 00:23:04,125
No witnesses, no video, no
vehicle sightings, no footprints,
375
00:23:04,125 --> 00:23:05,745
no confirmed phone movement.
376
00:23:05,805 --> 00:23:08,595
No calls or texts after that time.
377
00:23:09,465 --> 00:23:14,625
All we know for sure is that at
7:00 AM Kinsley reported a fire.
378
00:23:15,105 --> 00:23:20,865
Anything else relies entirely on his
word and in my opinion is that his
379
00:23:20,865 --> 00:23:23,475
version is just simply not credible.
380
00:23:23,625 --> 00:23:25,335
Then we gotta talk about the fire itself.
381
00:23:25,335 --> 00:23:28,695
How it burned, where it burned,
and why it makes no sense.
382
00:23:29,025 --> 00:23:31,965
All documented sources
agree on the physical facts.
383
00:23:32,175 --> 00:23:35,745
One, the fire originated
on or inside the couch.
384
00:23:36,105 --> 00:23:40,245
Two, it burned downward into
the floorboards beneath it.
385
00:23:40,980 --> 00:23:41,310
Three.
386
00:23:41,310 --> 00:23:46,470
It charred a focused area rather than
escalating into a full house fire.
387
00:23:46,679 --> 00:23:47,909
And why this matters.
388
00:23:48,300 --> 00:23:52,919
Most accidental fires, especially
cigarette fires, burn upward
389
00:23:52,919 --> 00:23:54,629
and behave very differently.
390
00:23:55,110 --> 00:23:59,610
Firefighters and investigators publicly
describe the fire as suspicious,
391
00:23:59,879 --> 00:24:04,530
not accidental, and inconsistent
with a careless cigarette, because
392
00:24:04,590 --> 00:24:08,939
nothing in that powerless house
provided a natural ignition source.
393
00:24:09,600 --> 00:24:14,490
And number four, why the
cigarette started its story fails.
394
00:24:14,850 --> 00:24:20,010
Fire Science 1 0 1 Hensley said Brooklyn
must have fallen asleep smoking.
395
00:24:20,340 --> 00:24:24,870
But this explanation collapses under
factual, documented fire science.
396
00:24:25,320 --> 00:24:28,169
Cigarette fires are extremely rare.
397
00:24:28,590 --> 00:24:33,810
National data shows that cigarettes
account for only around 2% of
398
00:24:33,960 --> 00:24:36,510
residential fires in the United States.
399
00:24:37,110 --> 00:24:40,800
Furniture, materials and fire
safe cigarette laws have made
400
00:24:40,800 --> 00:24:42,870
this scenario even less common.
401
00:24:43,110 --> 00:24:48,750
A cigarette can absolutely cause
a fire, but normally only when the
402
00:24:48,750 --> 00:24:54,180
person is, is asleep or impaired
by substances or is unaware of the
403
00:24:54,180 --> 00:24:58,770
smoldering or is somehow trapped in
an enclosed, highly flammable setup.
404
00:24:59,280 --> 00:25:04,110
Brooklyn's documented behavior, texting
urgently and repeatedly trying to
405
00:25:04,110 --> 00:25:06,600
leave does not match that scenario.
406
00:25:07,485 --> 00:25:09,555
Then we gotta talk about
the smolder timeline.
407
00:25:09,764 --> 00:25:11,565
Why the fire could not have happened.
408
00:25:11,565 --> 00:25:16,425
The way Hinsley described a cigarette
does not immediately ignite a couch.
409
00:25:16,754 --> 00:25:21,764
Fire science testing shows that it
first goes into what's known as the
410
00:25:21,764 --> 00:25:27,495
smoldering phase, and smoldering typically
lasts 20 minutes to several hours.
411
00:25:27,825 --> 00:25:31,274
The normal range is anywhere
between 30 and 60 minutes.
412
00:25:31,695 --> 00:25:38,235
Some burn tests show up to 89 minutes
before flame smoke is usually always
413
00:25:38,235 --> 00:25:43,305
visible during the smoldering phase,
and then it goes into the flaming phase.
414
00:25:43,635 --> 00:25:48,675
Once the material heats up enough open
flame can appear within minutes, but
415
00:25:48,975 --> 00:25:52,365
only after that long smoldering period.
416
00:25:52,845 --> 00:25:56,295
To accept Hensley's story,
all of this must be true.
417
00:25:56,415 --> 00:25:57,014
One.
418
00:25:57,375 --> 00:25:58,965
Brooklyn started smoking.
419
00:25:59,399 --> 00:26:01,560
Which is not a known habit of hers.
420
00:26:01,920 --> 00:26:07,230
Two, she fell asleep instantly in the
house where she already felt unsafe.
421
00:26:07,800 --> 00:26:08,399
Three.
422
00:26:08,399 --> 00:26:12,420
The cigarette fell perfectly
into a smolder friendly cavity.
423
00:26:12,930 --> 00:26:13,560
Four.
424
00:26:13,740 --> 00:26:19,200
It's smolder for a long period with
no visible smoke noticed, and five, it
425
00:26:19,200 --> 00:26:24,360
transitioned to a flame strong enough to
burn through the couch and into the floor,
426
00:26:24,750 --> 00:26:29,730
all within approximately a 60 minute
window that Hensley claims he was gone.
427
00:26:30,149 --> 00:26:36,060
This sequence is not consistent with
standard smolder behavior, burn patterns,
428
00:26:36,120 --> 00:26:41,879
oxygen presence, furniture composition,
or the time available fire safe cigarettes
429
00:26:41,879 --> 00:26:44,820
make it even less likely by 2010.
430
00:26:44,879 --> 00:26:48,810
All US cigarettes were legally
required to be fire safe.
431
00:26:49,350 --> 00:26:52,889
They are designed to self
extinguish when left unattended.
432
00:26:53,430 --> 00:26:58,440
All of this combined makes the cigarette
theory scientifically improbable.
433
00:26:58,754 --> 00:27:04,635
Again, it's my opinion based on
fire science and timeline analysis.
434
00:27:04,875 --> 00:27:08,024
Henley's explanation
does not match reality.
435
00:27:08,895 --> 00:27:12,435
Number six, the destroyed
evidence, the couch left outside.
436
00:27:12,885 --> 00:27:17,205
One of the biggest failures in this case
is that the burn couch was removed from
437
00:27:17,205 --> 00:27:19,635
the house and left outdoors for weeks.
438
00:27:20,084 --> 00:27:25,514
Rain, humidity, insects and handling
contaminated or erased possible
439
00:27:25,514 --> 00:27:32,024
accelerant, residues, blood evidence,
hair and fibers transfer, DNA impact,
440
00:27:32,024 --> 00:27:36,165
traces, burn patterns, tool marks,
et cetera, et cetera, et cetera.
441
00:27:36,705 --> 00:27:40,245
We have no public evidence that
a full accelerant analysis was
442
00:27:40,304 --> 00:27:43,635
ever completed before the couch
was exposed to the elements.
443
00:27:44,024 --> 00:27:47,325
This decision may have permanently
erased the most important
444
00:27:47,325 --> 00:27:49,095
physical evidence in the case.
445
00:27:49,665 --> 00:27:53,564
Number seven, why this fire
is the central red flag.
446
00:27:54,254 --> 00:27:56,085
This fire is not a side detail.
447
00:27:56,145 --> 00:27:58,455
It is the moment the story changes.
448
00:27:58,695 --> 00:28:02,415
What we know for certain is that
the fire began where Brooklyn
449
00:28:02,415 --> 00:28:04,365
was last claimed to be alive.
450
00:28:04,965 --> 00:28:10,004
It happened during the same hour that
Hensley's story places her disappearance.
451
00:28:10,635 --> 00:28:13,095
The house had no natural ignition sources.
452
00:28:13,544 --> 00:28:17,445
The burn pattern is incompatible
with a typical cigarette fire.
453
00:28:17,895 --> 00:28:22,155
Her belongings were still inside
the only account placing her at
454
00:28:22,155 --> 00:28:27,524
the house is hensley's, and it is
unverified and absolutely unsupported.
455
00:28:27,764 --> 00:28:33,254
And in my personal opinion, this fire
looks like an attempt to destroy evidence.
456
00:28:33,554 --> 00:28:37,575
Whoever set that couch on fire
wanted whatever happened on it
457
00:28:37,905 --> 00:28:40,335
or near it to disappear forever.
458
00:28:41,190 --> 00:28:43,950
Question number four, the
personal belongings left behind.
459
00:28:43,950 --> 00:28:49,440
And what they really tell us, if the fire
is the moment this case turns suspicious,
460
00:28:49,680 --> 00:28:54,630
the abandoned belongings are the moment it
becomes absolutely impossible to believe
461
00:28:54,840 --> 00:28:56,760
Brooklyn left of her own free will.
462
00:28:57,240 --> 00:29:00,840
Everything left behind inside
that house tells a story, one
463
00:29:00,840 --> 00:29:04,320
that directly contradicts the
idea of a voluntary departure.
464
00:29:04,830 --> 00:29:07,350
Let's break down what we actually know.
465
00:29:08,669 --> 00:29:12,810
Number one, what was left behind
every credible source agrees.
466
00:29:12,810 --> 00:29:18,000
Almost everything Brooklyn would never
leave without was found inside the Dylan
467
00:29:18,000 --> 00:29:20,730
Courthouse, including her cowboy boots.
468
00:29:21,090 --> 00:29:23,010
These were the boots she
was wearing that night.
469
00:29:23,040 --> 00:29:27,540
Multiple sources placed them either
inside the home or left right outside
470
00:29:27,540 --> 00:29:32,189
on the porch, and Brooklyn was not the
kind of person to walk anywhere barefoot
471
00:29:32,189 --> 00:29:37,409
At five 30 in the morning, her person
wallet, her purse, wallet id, and bank
472
00:29:37,409 --> 00:29:39,330
cards were all found at the scene.
473
00:29:39,750 --> 00:29:45,000
No voluntary trip to another party,
another house, or anywhere else makes
474
00:29:45,000 --> 00:29:49,740
sense without them being taken with
her, her overnight bag or duffle.
475
00:29:50,100 --> 00:29:53,459
She brought a bag containing clothes
and toiletries for the night.
476
00:29:53,760 --> 00:29:55,740
That bag was left untouched.
477
00:29:56,129 --> 00:29:57,120
Other items.
478
00:29:57,120 --> 00:30:01,679
Various small personal items were
also present, like toothbrush, makeup,
479
00:30:01,889 --> 00:30:04,770
hygiene items, phone charger, keys.
480
00:30:05,129 --> 00:30:08,550
This is important because it shows
both that she brought items with
481
00:30:08,550 --> 00:30:13,139
intent to stay somewhere safe, and
she did not take anything that would
482
00:30:13,139 --> 00:30:15,840
support leaving on foot or by car.
483
00:30:16,290 --> 00:30:20,790
This is one of the strongest indications
of foul play in the entire case.
484
00:30:22,080 --> 00:30:23,040
What was missing?
485
00:30:23,550 --> 00:30:25,740
Only two things disappeared that night.
486
00:30:26,070 --> 00:30:29,280
Brooklyn, herself and her
cell phone, that's it.
487
00:30:29,639 --> 00:30:33,780
Not her purse, not her clothes,
not her boots, not her money, not
488
00:30:33,780 --> 00:30:36,270
her id, and not her overnight bag.
489
00:30:36,750 --> 00:30:38,520
Only her and her phone.
490
00:30:38,850 --> 00:30:42,060
The one thing she would need
to continue asking for help.
491
00:30:42,540 --> 00:30:46,830
This is a hallmark indicator of
an involuntary disappearance.
492
00:30:48,075 --> 00:30:52,425
Number three is why this makes a
voluntary departure impossible.
493
00:30:52,935 --> 00:30:56,504
Brooklyn's family and friends have
been consistent for over a decade.
494
00:30:56,774 --> 00:30:58,875
She never left her belongings behind.
495
00:30:59,145 --> 00:31:01,605
She always kept track
of her purse and phone.
496
00:31:01,815 --> 00:31:05,085
She never walked anywhere
unfamiliar without her shoes on.
497
00:31:05,655 --> 00:31:10,004
She was trying desperately to find a
ride home, not a ride to another party.
498
00:31:10,485 --> 00:31:13,395
And national missing persons
experts say the same thing.
499
00:31:14,055 --> 00:31:17,865
Quote, when a person leaves behind
identification, wallet, money, and
500
00:31:17,865 --> 00:31:22,965
transportation items, the likelihood of
a voluntary departure drops dramatically.
501
00:31:23,264 --> 00:31:23,865
End quote.
502
00:31:24,165 --> 00:31:26,895
In other words, a runaway
doesn't leave their wallet.
503
00:31:27,195 --> 00:31:30,764
Someone heading to a 6:00 AM
party doesn't leave their boots.
504
00:31:31,155 --> 00:31:34,905
Someone leaving voluntarily takes
their purse and their money.
505
00:31:35,400 --> 00:31:38,550
Someone walking away in
fear clings to their phone.
506
00:31:38,820 --> 00:31:40,380
None of these things happened.
507
00:31:40,560 --> 00:31:43,020
Number four, the no
transportation problem.
508
00:31:43,320 --> 00:31:45,360
Brooklyn did not have a car.
509
00:31:45,600 --> 00:31:47,580
Car keys, a ride arranged.
510
00:31:47,760 --> 00:31:52,170
A known one friend headed to Rock
Castle County, or any proof that she
511
00:31:52,170 --> 00:31:54,300
was planning to go anywhere at all.
512
00:31:54,300 --> 00:32:00,390
There is no witness video or physical
evidence placing her, walking away, riding
513
00:32:00,390 --> 00:32:05,610
away, getting picked up, being seen by
neighbors, traveling in any direction.
514
00:32:06,120 --> 00:32:09,030
Her car was at another location entirely.
515
00:32:09,270 --> 00:32:13,260
She had no transportation and
no plan for transportation.
516
00:32:13,470 --> 00:32:15,840
So number five is the
investigative meaning of all this.
517
00:32:16,770 --> 00:32:20,160
From law enforcement's perspective,
the belongings were one of
518
00:32:20,160 --> 00:32:23,340
the earliest and strongest red
flags as something was wrong.
519
00:32:23,760 --> 00:32:25,830
Police have pointed to this repeatedly.
520
00:32:25,890 --> 00:32:30,330
Not leaving with essential items is
inconsistent with voluntary behavior.
521
00:32:30,750 --> 00:32:34,620
Leaving only with a phone is
consistent with being removed from
522
00:32:34,620 --> 00:32:37,080
the house by coercion or force.
523
00:32:37,650 --> 00:32:41,520
Her items were not disturbed,
suggesting an abrupt separation.
524
00:32:42,420 --> 00:32:47,550
When you combine that with her frantic,
I'm scared, text the suspicious fire,
525
00:32:47,760 --> 00:32:51,960
the lack of witnesses, the lack of a
ride, the fact that only the phone is
526
00:32:51,960 --> 00:32:56,850
missing, it becomes extremely difficult
to accept any narrative suggesting
527
00:32:56,970 --> 00:32:58,530
that she walked away on her own.
528
00:32:58,800 --> 00:33:03,120
Number six is possible staging based
on the evidence, not on assumption.
529
00:33:03,465 --> 00:33:07,695
Some analysis and community members have
have suggested the belongings may have
530
00:33:07,695 --> 00:33:12,495
been deliberately left in place to create
the illusion that she simply walked off.
531
00:33:12,945 --> 00:33:18,105
To be clear, there is no direct
evidence proving staging, but the
532
00:33:18,105 --> 00:33:22,095
arrangement and the choice of what was
missing versus what was left behind.
533
00:33:22,335 --> 00:33:23,895
Raise obvious questions.
534
00:33:24,254 --> 00:33:28,365
Why would someone frightened
enough to text, I'm scared, leave
535
00:33:28,365 --> 00:33:30,254
her boots in a stranger's house.
536
00:33:30,705 --> 00:33:34,245
Why would her overnight bag be
left neatly with nothing missing?
537
00:33:34,784 --> 00:33:36,855
Why leave money id?
538
00:33:37,185 --> 00:33:41,205
Why take only the phone the one
item needed to call for help?
539
00:33:41,445 --> 00:33:46,185
Nothing about these choices aligns
with voluntary behavior, and in my
540
00:33:46,185 --> 00:33:50,895
personal opinion, the belongings left
behind, looks staged to support the
541
00:33:50,895 --> 00:33:53,655
narrative that Brooklyn just left.
542
00:33:54,104 --> 00:33:57,705
So the bigger picture, when
viewed alongside the fire in
543
00:33:57,705 --> 00:34:01,665
the text, the belongings become
one of the clearest indicators
544
00:34:01,965 --> 00:34:03,645
that Brooklyn did not walk away.
545
00:34:04,004 --> 00:34:06,165
She did not plan to go anywhere else.
546
00:34:06,435 --> 00:34:09,764
Someone else controlled the
circumstances of her disappearance.
547
00:34:10,545 --> 00:34:14,895
Everything she needed to function in the
world was left behind everything that
548
00:34:14,895 --> 00:34:17,205
could connect her to the outside world.
549
00:34:17,415 --> 00:34:19,995
Namely, her phone was taken with her.
550
00:34:20,565 --> 00:34:24,915
So now the fifth question that just
bugs the shit outta me about this
551
00:34:24,915 --> 00:34:31,065
case, contradictory witness accounts,
what Josh says, what others say, and
552
00:34:31,065 --> 00:34:33,674
what the facts simply cannot support.
553
00:34:34,005 --> 00:34:39,344
If there is one part of this story where
the truth should be straightforward, it's
554
00:34:39,344 --> 00:34:41,864
the final hour before Brooklyn vanished.
555
00:34:42,284 --> 00:34:43,005
Instead.
556
00:34:43,364 --> 00:34:46,755
This is where things become the
most tangled because the timeline,
557
00:34:46,815 --> 00:34:49,185
everyone relies on the timeline.
558
00:34:49,185 --> 00:34:51,194
The investigation had to start with.
559
00:34:52,005 --> 00:34:57,825
Comes entirely from one man, Josh
Hensley and his account has never been
560
00:34:57,825 --> 00:35:00,015
independently confirmed in any way.
561
00:35:00,405 --> 00:35:04,695
So let's break down what he said, what
others said and what doesn't line up.
562
00:35:05,025 --> 00:35:07,455
First off, Hensley's version of events.
563
00:35:07,485 --> 00:35:12,495
The only version that we have about
that hour across interviews and police
564
00:35:12,495 --> 00:35:17,865
reports, Hensley's core statements are
he left Brooklyn alone around 6:00 AM.
565
00:35:18,255 --> 00:35:22,424
He claims she was sitting on the couch
smoking a cigarette, waiting for a ride.
566
00:35:22,904 --> 00:35:26,985
She was fine when he walked out
the door, he says she seemed
567
00:35:26,985 --> 00:35:30,404
anxious, but told him she'd be
okay until someone come to get her.
568
00:35:30,975 --> 00:35:36,404
He returned around 7:00 AM and when he
walked back inside, the couch was on fire.
569
00:35:36,404 --> 00:35:38,384
Brooklyn was gone, her phone was gone.
570
00:35:38,685 --> 00:35:41,025
Everything else she owned was still there.
571
00:35:41,205 --> 00:35:44,835
That is his complete timeline,
but here's the problem.
572
00:35:45,315 --> 00:35:50,805
Nothing in his version of events has ever
been independently verified in any way.
573
00:35:51,315 --> 00:35:55,455
Not the times, not the sequence,
not the claim that she was alone,
574
00:35:55,455 --> 00:35:59,115
not the idea that she left the
house, not even the claim that he
575
00:35:59,115 --> 00:36:03,975
returned exactly When he says he
did, everything depends on his word.
576
00:36:04,425 --> 00:36:08,655
In my opinion, his word has
never aligned well with the
577
00:36:08,655 --> 00:36:10,695
physical reality of that morning.
578
00:36:11,295 --> 00:36:13,785
Next, we have the
discrepancies in the timeline.
579
00:36:14,235 --> 00:36:16,575
The clock doesn't match the events at all.
580
00:36:16,935 --> 00:36:20,415
Multiple sources, including community
interviews and early statements,
581
00:36:20,415 --> 00:36:22,005
highlight the inconsistencies.
582
00:36:22,365 --> 00:36:24,915
The exact time that he left is unclear.
583
00:36:25,275 --> 00:36:28,185
Some accounts suggest
he left closer to 5 45.
584
00:36:28,605 --> 00:36:31,965
Others say it might have been,
might have been as late as six 30.
585
00:36:32,475 --> 00:36:38,055
The return time is also unclear about
an hour later is vague and has been
586
00:36:38,055 --> 00:36:44,745
described anywhere from 45 minutes
to 60 minutes to damn near two hours.
587
00:36:45,465 --> 00:36:49,830
This matters because like we said,
a cigarette caused fire needs
588
00:36:49,995 --> 00:36:55,245
at least 30 minutes, more likely
over an hour just to smolder.
589
00:36:56,130 --> 00:37:00,600
Another period to reach open flame
and an additional time to burn
590
00:37:00,600 --> 00:37:02,310
through a couch and into the floor.
591
00:37:02,759 --> 00:37:07,560
That timeline is extremely tight,
too tight for what he describes
592
00:37:07,860 --> 00:37:12,029
and nothing about the burn pattern
matches a casual one hour absence.
593
00:37:12,810 --> 00:37:19,650
Number three, the she was a loan claim,
absolutely unconfirmed Hensley, reportedly
594
00:37:19,650 --> 00:37:24,660
insisted she was alone in the house
when I left, but this cannot be proven.
595
00:37:25,380 --> 00:37:27,990
No witness has ever
confirmed she was alone.
596
00:37:28,319 --> 00:37:30,750
No neighbor saw him leave her alone.
597
00:37:31,020 --> 00:37:32,850
No passerby corroborated it.
598
00:37:33,480 --> 00:37:39,210
So the claim that no one else entered in
or exited during the early morning window
599
00:37:39,420 --> 00:37:42,210
rests entirely on what Hensley says.
600
00:37:42,600 --> 00:37:45,779
No witnesses, no surveillance,
no corroboration.
601
00:37:46,965 --> 00:37:50,385
Number four is the family's
response, the immediate skepticism.
602
00:37:50,745 --> 00:37:54,555
Brooklyn's family has never accepted
Hensley's version of events.
603
00:37:54,825 --> 00:37:58,875
They've said publicly that his
story never made any sense.
604
00:37:59,115 --> 00:38:00,705
His details have changed.
605
00:38:00,705 --> 00:38:04,215
His behavior afterward was
evasive or inconsistent.
606
00:38:04,605 --> 00:38:07,485
They felt information was
held back or filtered.
607
00:38:07,875 --> 00:38:11,745
They were not given a full
clear accounting of exactly
608
00:38:11,745 --> 00:38:13,455
what happened inside that house.
609
00:38:14,175 --> 00:38:19,515
None of this proves guilt, but it
absolutely undermines his reliability
610
00:38:19,755 --> 00:38:22,065
as the sole narrator of that morning.
611
00:38:22,245 --> 00:38:27,495
And again, in my personal opinion,
their skepticism is justified.
612
00:38:27,795 --> 00:38:29,265
Next, we have the law enforcement.
613
00:38:29,265 --> 00:38:31,845
FBI interviews still full of gaps.
614
00:38:32,235 --> 00:38:35,775
Kentucky State Police and the FBI
interviewed Hensley multiple times.
615
00:38:36,075 --> 00:38:40,155
They compared his timeline, phone
records, physical evidence, statements
616
00:38:40,155 --> 00:38:44,955
from party goers, what was found in
his house, the fire pattern, but.
617
00:38:45,540 --> 00:38:48,330
No agency has publicly
reinforced his timeline.
618
00:38:48,660 --> 00:38:51,450
No agency has said they
believe he was truthful.
619
00:38:51,690 --> 00:38:56,160
No evidence has emerged confirming
his movements and major gaps
620
00:38:56,160 --> 00:39:00,150
still remain around the exact
hour that Brooklyn disappeared.
621
00:39:00,359 --> 00:39:05,130
Investigators have consistently
described inconsistencies in the
622
00:39:05,130 --> 00:39:10,710
account, unclear movements, unverified
statements, all referring to him
623
00:39:11,460 --> 00:39:15,600
and why these contradictions matter
in missing persons investigations.
624
00:39:15,600 --> 00:39:19,529
The last confirmed sighting is
everything, but here's the truth.
625
00:39:19,529 --> 00:39:23,670
In this case, Hinsley claims to be the
last person who saw Brooklyn alive.
626
00:39:24,270 --> 00:39:25,275
That's not confirmed.
627
00:39:25,725 --> 00:39:30,420
There is no independent witness, no
digital evidence, no visual confirmation.
628
00:39:30,839 --> 00:39:33,810
His timeline cannot explain the fire.
629
00:39:34,290 --> 00:39:37,380
Fire, science contradicts the
speed and pattern of the burn.
630
00:39:37,830 --> 00:39:40,620
His version does not
align with her belongings.
631
00:39:41,069 --> 00:39:43,620
She would never have left
that house without them.
632
00:39:43,799 --> 00:39:49,319
His explanation contradicts her text me,
her text messages, her urgent, I'm scared.
633
00:39:49,319 --> 00:39:52,799
Mess message was sent
roughly an hour before.
634
00:39:52,799 --> 00:39:55,799
He claims that she fell
asleep casually on his couch.
635
00:39:56,100 --> 00:39:58,500
His claims contradict logic.
636
00:39:58,950 --> 00:40:02,669
Her boots, purse, wallet, and
overnight bag were left behind.
637
00:40:02,910 --> 00:40:04,680
Her phone disappeared with her.
638
00:40:05,009 --> 00:40:07,229
None of this lines up with his narrative.
639
00:40:07,680 --> 00:40:09,120
So the bottom line is this.
640
00:40:09,509 --> 00:40:13,830
These contradictions do not legally
prove guilt, but they do prove one
641
00:40:13,830 --> 00:40:18,149
thing beyond question, and that is the
only narrative that we have about the
642
00:40:18,149 --> 00:40:20,399
last hour of Brooklyn Farley's life.
643
00:40:20,685 --> 00:40:25,634
It's unverified, inconsistent and
contradicted by the physical evidence.
644
00:40:25,845 --> 00:40:29,955
And in my personal opinion,
Hensley's story should never have
645
00:40:29,955 --> 00:40:34,424
been treated as as reliable on the
first place when the only eyewitness
646
00:40:34,424 --> 00:40:36,345
account collapses under scrutiny.
647
00:40:36,645 --> 00:40:41,745
The only logical conclusion is that we
do not actually know what happened in
648
00:40:41,745 --> 00:40:47,475
that house, but what we do know is this,
whatever happened to Brooklyn did not
649
00:40:47,475 --> 00:40:50,085
happen because she got up and walked away.
650
00:40:50,505 --> 00:40:55,755
Question number six, the phone, the
ping that led nowhere, the silence
651
00:40:55,755 --> 00:40:58,694
that says everything of all the clues.
652
00:40:58,694 --> 00:41:01,335
In this case, Brooklyn's phone
should have been the one that
653
00:41:01,335 --> 00:41:02,895
answered the most questions.
654
00:41:03,194 --> 00:41:08,384
Instead, it's the one that created
the biggest void, and in that void,
655
00:41:08,654 --> 00:41:13,395
the silence from her phone after
5:30 AM might be the most chilling
656
00:41:13,395 --> 00:41:15,705
part of the entire investigation.
657
00:41:16,095 --> 00:41:17,924
So let's break down what we actually know.
658
00:41:18,375 --> 00:41:21,615
The final message and
the sharp turn in tone.
659
00:41:21,975 --> 00:41:25,754
Brooklyn's phone activity stops
abruptly early that morning at
660
00:41:25,754 --> 00:41:30,705
4:26 AM She sends the now infamous,
I'm scared and please hurry.
661
00:41:30,705 --> 00:41:34,125
Text messages, and then around 5 30, 5 45.
662
00:41:34,125 --> 00:41:36,165
A completely different messages sent.
663
00:41:36,315 --> 00:41:37,154
Nevermind.
664
00:41:37,214 --> 00:41:39,375
I'm going to a party
in Rock Castle County.
665
00:41:39,765 --> 00:41:42,825
The second message contradicts
everything that she'd been
666
00:41:42,825 --> 00:41:44,714
texting for the previous hour.
667
00:41:45,225 --> 00:41:50,325
It contradicts her known plans and it
contradicts every piece of physical
668
00:41:50,325 --> 00:41:51,795
evidence that was left behind.
669
00:41:52,125 --> 00:41:57,015
It also becomes extremely relevant
once we get to the phone's location.
670
00:41:58,290 --> 00:42:02,100
Next is the final ping, what it
tells us and what it doesn't.
671
00:42:02,550 --> 00:42:06,990
The last activity from her phone connected
to a cell tower in blue lit Kentucky.
672
00:42:07,350 --> 00:42:11,580
The tower covers a large radius,
several miles in rural condition, so
673
00:42:11,580 --> 00:42:15,690
it tells us the phone was somewhere
within that coverage zone, but
674
00:42:15,690 --> 00:42:20,010
not specifically where within that
zone, and not whether it was moving
675
00:42:20,010 --> 00:42:22,080
stationary or tossed from a vehicle.
676
00:42:22,470 --> 00:42:27,480
Some public re retailings incorrectly
state that blue lick is 30 miles away.
677
00:42:27,810 --> 00:42:31,260
In reality, it's roughly eight
to 10 miles from Dillon Court
678
00:42:31,260 --> 00:42:32,790
depending on the measurement points.
679
00:42:33,120 --> 00:42:39,390
Either way, it's not on foot walking
distance at dawn, a direction connected
680
00:42:39,390 --> 00:42:45,690
to any known ride or anywhere near Rock
Castle County, which makes the party in
681
00:42:45,690 --> 00:42:48,960
Rock Castle message even more suspicious.
682
00:42:49,290 --> 00:42:53,910
There is zero evidence the phone ever
traveled toward Rock Castle County.
683
00:42:55,440 --> 00:43:01,170
Three After that ping, absolute silence
after the final connection, no texts
684
00:43:01,170 --> 00:43:06,810
went through, no calls registered, no
voicemail activity, no app usage, no
685
00:43:06,810 --> 00:43:11,850
data pings, no wifi connections, nothing
from law enforcement tracking attempts.
686
00:43:12,090 --> 00:43:16,590
Nothing more than a thousand
calls and messages were made to
687
00:43:16,590 --> 00:43:18,480
her phone in the next 24 hours.
688
00:43:18,810 --> 00:43:23,160
Not one produced another signal,
which means one of four things
689
00:43:23,160 --> 00:43:25,380
happened, either one, the phone died.
690
00:43:25,890 --> 00:43:27,210
Two, it was destroyed.
691
00:43:27,510 --> 00:43:29,970
Three, the phone was powered off manually.
692
00:43:30,300 --> 00:43:34,200
Or four, the phone was placed somewhere
where it could not connect to a tower.
693
00:43:34,995 --> 00:43:40,995
All four scenarios point towards outside
interference, not voluntary disappearance.
694
00:43:41,384 --> 00:43:43,125
Number four, the disappearance window.
695
00:43:43,455 --> 00:43:48,075
A vacuum of data Investigators have
never released the exact minute the
696
00:43:48,075 --> 00:43:52,245
phone stopped transmitting, whether it
dropped from tower range suddenly or
697
00:43:52,245 --> 00:43:57,765
gradually whether any partial data packets
were received and whether the tower
698
00:43:57,765 --> 00:44:00,225
registered motion or handoff attempts.
699
00:44:00,645 --> 00:44:06,314
So the disappearance window is not a
clean timeline, it's a gap and a dangerous
700
00:44:06,314 --> 00:44:08,714
one because no cameras picked her up.
701
00:44:08,714 --> 00:44:09,734
Leaving Dillon Court.
702
00:44:10,004 --> 00:44:12,555
No vehicle sightings placed hurt anywhere.
703
00:44:12,975 --> 00:44:14,654
No one else saw her walking.
704
00:44:14,924 --> 00:44:19,845
No one saw her in Blue Lick, no
witnesses confirmed she ever traveled
705
00:44:19,845 --> 00:44:22,575
with her phone after 5:30 AM.
706
00:44:23,549 --> 00:44:30,000
The phone becomes the only thing that we
can track, and it barely left a footprint.
707
00:44:30,419 --> 00:44:34,500
So what does the Blue Lick Ping
suggest about the Nevermind?
708
00:44:34,529 --> 00:44:35,250
I'm okay.
709
00:44:35,250 --> 00:44:35,850
Message.
710
00:44:36,509 --> 00:44:41,279
This is where timing becomes everything
that I'm going to a party in Rock Castle
711
00:44:41,279 --> 00:44:44,129
County, text contradicts her earlier fear.
712
00:44:44,339 --> 00:44:48,149
It contradicts her belongings,
it contradicts her known plans.
713
00:44:48,450 --> 00:44:53,520
It contradicts every witness who
knew her, and it contradicts the
714
00:44:53,549 --> 00:44:57,899
actual phone ping, which placed her
phone in the opposite direction.
715
00:44:58,440 --> 00:45:02,850
It is the single least believable
message in this entire case.
716
00:45:03,060 --> 00:45:07,500
And in my personal opinion, it reads
like it was written by someone trying to
717
00:45:07,500 --> 00:45:10,529
redirect attention away from Dylan Court.
718
00:45:10,950 --> 00:45:15,450
Someone who needed more time,
someone who wanted the people
719
00:45:15,450 --> 00:45:17,819
coming to get her to stop coming.
720
00:45:18,195 --> 00:45:20,085
So why does the phone matter so much?
721
00:45:20,535 --> 00:45:23,805
Because Brooklyn's phone didn't
behave like a runaways phone.
722
00:45:24,045 --> 00:45:28,634
It didn't behave like a phone belonging to
a young woman, suddenly changing her mind.
723
00:45:28,905 --> 00:45:32,025
And it didn't behave like a phone
traveling towards another party.
724
00:45:32,475 --> 00:45:37,845
It behaved like a phone belonging to
someone who was stopped, silenced,
725
00:45:38,145 --> 00:45:43,995
or prevented from reaching help or
forcibly separated from it, and then
726
00:45:44,205 --> 00:45:49,725
the phone was disabled or destroyed or
hidden, or taken somewhere out of range.
727
00:45:49,935 --> 00:45:51,615
That is not speculation.
728
00:45:51,735 --> 00:45:53,895
That is what the data shows.
729
00:45:54,075 --> 00:45:58,634
So the bottom line is this
Brooklyn's phone provided one final
730
00:45:58,634 --> 00:46:01,755
text message that doesn't match
anything that she said before.
731
00:46:02,235 --> 00:46:04,905
One final ping that
doesn't match the text.
732
00:46:05,400 --> 00:46:06,750
Then total silence.
733
00:46:07,110 --> 00:46:08,640
It never connected again.
734
00:46:08,790 --> 00:46:14,640
It never surfaced, and it has never been
recovered in any missing person's case.
735
00:46:14,760 --> 00:46:18,870
That combination, a frightened
message, a contradictory message,
736
00:46:18,990 --> 00:46:23,040
and immediate blackout is one of
the strongest indicators of foul
737
00:46:23,040 --> 00:46:28,590
play, and in my opinion, someone
made sure her phone could never lead
738
00:46:28,590 --> 00:46:31,110
police back to where she really was.
739
00:46:32,055 --> 00:46:33,045
Question number seven.
740
00:46:33,585 --> 00:46:35,565
No suspect, no arrest.
741
00:46:35,895 --> 00:46:38,265
Why hasn't this case gone to trial?
742
00:46:38,805 --> 00:46:41,865
More than a decade has passed
since Brooklyn baring vanished
743
00:46:41,865 --> 00:46:45,795
from Dylan court and yet no
suspect has been publicly named.
744
00:46:46,095 --> 00:46:48,825
No person of interest
has ever been confirmed.
745
00:46:49,154 --> 00:46:50,955
No indictment, no arrest.
746
00:46:51,265 --> 00:46:56,005
No explanation on paper, the
case remains open and active.
747
00:46:56,335 --> 00:46:59,095
In reality, it feels frozen.
748
00:46:59,395 --> 00:47:04,345
And in my personal opinion, there
is absolutely no reason this case
749
00:47:04,525 --> 00:47:09,265
could not have gone to trial because
other nobody, homicide prosecutions,
750
00:47:09,265 --> 00:47:11,755
have moved forward on far less.
751
00:47:12,085 --> 00:47:17,125
And I alluded to this in the Dark Dialogue
episode that covers this case, and that is
752
00:47:17,125 --> 00:47:21,894
one of the best comparisons is the he is
the Heather Elvis case in South Carolina.
753
00:47:22,345 --> 00:47:23,575
So why compare the two?
754
00:47:23,905 --> 00:47:29,185
Because Heather's case was successfully
prosecuted with almost no physical
755
00:47:29,185 --> 00:47:34,615
evidence, no body widely inconsistent
witness accounts, and a timeline
756
00:47:34,615 --> 00:47:38,455
stitched together mostly from
digital crumbs and motive theory.
757
00:47:38,905 --> 00:47:43,885
Brooklyn's case by comparison, has
stronger indicators of homicide.
758
00:47:44,175 --> 00:47:49,665
So let's break down why number one, what
we actually know about the Farthing cases.
759
00:47:49,665 --> 00:47:52,905
Investigative status, no public suspects.
760
00:47:53,205 --> 00:47:57,765
Kentucky State Police have never named
anybody publicly, have never announced a
761
00:47:57,765 --> 00:48:02,775
person of interest, have never confirmed
any prosecutable suspect, and have
762
00:48:02,775 --> 00:48:05,145
repeatedly interviewed the last known one.
763
00:48:05,145 --> 00:48:08,355
Witness Josh Hensley
without bringing charges.
764
00:48:08,805 --> 00:48:11,805
This does not mean they
don't have a suspect.
765
00:48:12,015 --> 00:48:16,005
It means they haven't reached
that the prosecutorial threshold
766
00:48:16,005 --> 00:48:17,355
they believe they need.
767
00:48:18,225 --> 00:48:20,745
Case remains active each year.
768
00:48:20,745 --> 00:48:22,815
KSP makes the same statement.
769
00:48:23,115 --> 00:48:24,885
The investigation remains open.
770
00:48:24,885 --> 00:48:28,005
We continue to follow up leads,
blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.
771
00:48:28,335 --> 00:48:32,655
The public has never been given details
that show any substantial progress.
772
00:48:33,585 --> 00:48:39,015
So the truth about no body prosecutions
here is what the data actually shows.
773
00:48:39,255 --> 00:48:42,945
No body murder trials have
an 86% conviction rate.
774
00:48:43,245 --> 00:48:46,935
This is higher than the
average homicide convictions.
775
00:48:47,235 --> 00:48:47,805
Why?
776
00:48:48,165 --> 00:48:52,575
Because prosecutors only take nobody
cases forward when they already have
777
00:48:52,575 --> 00:48:54,795
overwhelming circumstantial evidence.
778
00:48:54,795 --> 00:49:00,975
This typically includes lies and
contradictions, motive and opportunity,
779
00:49:01,245 --> 00:49:07,365
phone data, witness statements, timeline
conflicts, provable, false alibis,
780
00:49:07,755 --> 00:49:13,155
forensic indicators, even minor ones,
and behavior inconsistent with innocence.
781
00:49:14,640 --> 00:49:18,270
This is where the comparison
becomes unavoidable.
782
00:49:19,080 --> 00:49:25,950
This is all my own personal opinion,
but this is the Brooklyn Farthing
783
00:49:25,950 --> 00:49:30,690
versus Heather Elvis evidence
strength comparison from me.
784
00:49:31,410 --> 00:49:36,090
The last known location Heather
Elvis was last seen when her date
785
00:49:36,090 --> 00:49:41,700
dropped her off at her apartment hours
before the crime window, and not at
786
00:49:41,700 --> 00:49:43,410
the scene of the suspected crime.
787
00:49:44,100 --> 00:49:49,650
Brooklyn Farthing was last seen inside
the home where a fire broke out.
788
00:49:49,860 --> 00:49:54,300
Shortly after she vanished, her
belongings were left in that home.
789
00:49:54,510 --> 00:50:00,360
It is a fact that Brooklyn's last
location is tighter and more incriminating
790
00:50:00,600 --> 00:50:03,240
than Heather's last known companions.
791
00:50:03,660 --> 00:50:07,740
Heather was last known to be
communicating with Sidney Moore,
792
00:50:08,250 --> 00:50:12,780
having spoken to her roommate on the
phone and had and being dropped off
793
00:50:12,840 --> 00:50:15,300
by her date earlier that evening.
794
00:50:15,990 --> 00:50:22,500
But she was not physically proven to be
with Sidney Moore that night only that
795
00:50:22,500 --> 00:50:24,690
she had talked to him on the phone.
796
00:50:25,290 --> 00:50:30,720
Brooklyn was last known to be with
one person, that person Josh Hensley.
797
00:50:30,780 --> 00:50:36,060
He admits that she was in his home
on his couch minutes before the fire.
798
00:50:36,750 --> 00:50:39,600
No one else confirms seeing
her alive after that.
799
00:50:40,080 --> 00:50:45,570
It is a fact that Brooklyn's last
contact window is far narrower
800
00:50:45,900 --> 00:50:48,600
with only one known individual.
801
00:50:49,305 --> 00:50:50,985
Then we have the contradictory statements.
802
00:50:51,315 --> 00:50:55,995
Heather, the Moores changed their
stories, but had partial corroboration.
803
00:50:56,295 --> 00:50:56,955
Brooklyn.
804
00:50:57,285 --> 00:51:01,995
Josh's account contains inconsistent
timeframes, inconsistent behavior
805
00:51:01,995 --> 00:51:07,065
explanations, a timeline contradicted
by fire behavior, no corroborating
806
00:51:07,065 --> 00:51:10,545
witnesses, no physical proof
that he ever left her alone.
807
00:51:10,935 --> 00:51:15,525
It is a fact that the contradictions
in Brooklyn's case are more direct,
808
00:51:15,765 --> 00:51:19,035
more isolated, and far more suspicious.
809
00:51:19,515 --> 00:51:20,924
Then we had the crime scene activity.
810
00:51:21,134 --> 00:51:25,575
Heather prosecutors relied on motive
and circumstantial digital evidence.
811
00:51:25,694 --> 00:51:27,435
There really was no crime scene.
812
00:51:27,645 --> 00:51:29,535
Her car was found at Peachtree Landing.
813
00:51:29,775 --> 00:51:31,035
We had phone pings.
814
00:51:31,335 --> 00:51:36,194
We had the video proof or the video
recordings of a truck matching.
815
00:51:36,194 --> 00:51:40,035
Sydney's driving past a
house both directions.
816
00:51:40,575 --> 00:51:40,860
But that's it.
817
00:51:42,330 --> 00:51:42,960
Brooklyn.
818
00:51:43,350 --> 00:51:48,090
There was a crime scene and a
mysterious fire inside a vacant home.
819
00:51:48,090 --> 00:51:52,800
With that electricity, within the
exact hour, she disappeared and
820
00:51:53,010 --> 00:51:56,820
it destroyed the only place that
she was last known to be alive.
821
00:51:57,180 --> 00:52:02,940
So it is also a fact that the existence
of a fire as a destruction event makes
822
00:52:02,940 --> 00:52:07,380
Brooklyn's case more forensically
stronger than we have the digital data.
823
00:52:07,620 --> 00:52:11,790
With Heather, the main evidence
was cell records showing movement
824
00:52:11,790 --> 00:52:14,550
calls and motive with Brooklyn.
825
00:52:14,790 --> 00:52:16,320
Her texts show fear.
826
00:52:16,590 --> 00:52:19,560
Her last message contradicts
every now and fact.
827
00:52:19,860 --> 00:52:24,030
Her phone pinged away from where
she allegedly planned to go.
828
00:52:24,570 --> 00:52:26,760
It was silent forever.
829
00:52:26,880 --> 00:52:28,050
Shortly after that.
830
00:52:28,500 --> 00:52:33,150
So it is a fact that Brooklyn's
digital evidence is more suspicious,
831
00:52:33,360 --> 00:52:36,750
more contradictory, and more
consistent with foul play.
832
00:52:36,930 --> 00:52:39,600
So why no arrest and no trial?
833
00:52:39,870 --> 00:52:41,580
The publicly disclosed reason.
834
00:52:41,850 --> 00:52:46,380
Prosecutors believe that they lack
the quote, smoking gun, forensic
835
00:52:46,380 --> 00:52:49,920
confirmation, body recovery,
or direct proof of homicide.
836
00:52:50,340 --> 00:52:55,260
In reality, in my opinion, this
case could have gone to trial years
837
00:52:55,260 --> 00:53:00,690
ago because the question in nobody
cases is not where is the body.
838
00:53:01,170 --> 00:53:05,070
The question is who had the
last verifiable contact,
839
00:53:05,280 --> 00:53:07,890
exclusive access and opportunity?
840
00:53:08,220 --> 00:53:14,190
In Brooklyn's case, by all publicly known
information, only one person was with her.
841
00:53:14,895 --> 00:53:17,265
Only one person claims she was alive.
842
00:53:17,625 --> 00:53:21,615
Only one person had control of the
scene When she vanished, only one
843
00:53:21,615 --> 00:53:26,384
person reports leaving her unsupervised
and a suspicious fire occurred in
844
00:53:26,384 --> 00:53:28,484
the exact hour that she disappeared.
845
00:53:29,475 --> 00:53:34,634
That is an evidence chain far
stronger than dozens of nobody
846
00:53:34,634 --> 00:53:38,145
cases that have already resulted
in convictions nationwide.
847
00:53:38,805 --> 00:53:44,355
There are cases prosecuted on weaker
timelines, weaker motive theories, weaker
848
00:53:44,355 --> 00:53:49,575
digital evidence, weaker contradictions,
weaker witness accounts, weaker forensic,
849
00:53:49,575 --> 00:53:52,665
find findings and weaker opportunities.
850
00:53:53,055 --> 00:53:57,105
And yes, the Heather Elvis
murder conviction happened on
851
00:53:57,105 --> 00:53:59,325
significantly less evidence.
852
00:54:00,420 --> 00:54:06,990
The bottom line, in my personal opinion,
there is no logical explanation for
853
00:54:06,990 --> 00:54:09,270
why this case has not been prosecuted.
854
00:54:09,810 --> 00:54:13,950
The evidence is absolutely sufficient
for a nobody body homicide trial.
855
00:54:14,279 --> 00:54:19,440
Many cases with less have seen conviction,
including the Heather Elvis case.
856
00:54:19,920 --> 00:54:24,690
There is only one person whose
account controls the entire final
857
00:54:24,690 --> 00:54:28,529
hour timeline, and that alone
makes this case prosecutable.
858
00:54:29,040 --> 00:54:33,569
The fire, the belongings, the fear
messages, the contradictory text
859
00:54:33,569 --> 00:54:38,700
messages, and the missing phone creates
a stronger circumstantial package
860
00:54:38,910 --> 00:54:41,190
than many successful prosecutions.
861
00:54:41,370 --> 00:54:45,674
This is a case that should have
gone to trial and it still could.
862
00:54:47,490 --> 00:54:50,670
Question number eight,
are these cases connected?
863
00:54:50,970 --> 00:54:55,140
There's a cluster of vanishing
women in and around Madison County.
864
00:54:55,560 --> 00:54:59,520
When Brooklyn Farling vanished in
June of 2013, her disappearance
865
00:54:59,520 --> 00:55:01,560
wasn't yet part of a pattern.
866
00:55:01,920 --> 00:55:07,590
It was a nightmare of one and a case
that shook a family and a community.
867
00:55:07,860 --> 00:55:11,549
But over the next several years,
something began happening in this region,
868
00:55:11,850 --> 00:55:17,400
something that terrified young women,
fueled community suspicion and triggered
869
00:55:17,400 --> 00:55:21,690
online speculation that a predator
might be hunting in central Kentucky.
870
00:55:22,755 --> 00:55:26,205
Two cases in particular were
repeatedly compared to Brooklyn's.
871
00:55:26,475 --> 00:55:30,885
They created a sense of a cluster, even
though police have never linked them.
872
00:55:31,155 --> 00:55:32,505
Here's what we actually know.
873
00:55:32,925 --> 00:55:39,255
Savannah Spurlock, the one case with
answers In 2019, Savannah Spurlock, 22.
874
00:55:39,255 --> 00:55:44,475
A petite blonde mother of four
disappeared on January 4th, 2019 after
875
00:55:44,475 --> 00:55:46,575
leaving the other bar in Lexington.
876
00:55:46,875 --> 00:55:51,705
She was last seen, separated from
friends, visibly intoxicated, getting
877
00:55:51,705 --> 00:55:53,325
into a vehicle with three men.
878
00:55:53,635 --> 00:55:58,135
Heading toward Gerard County,
which borders Madison County.
879
00:55:58,435 --> 00:56:00,685
That alone triggered
comparisons to Brooklyn.
880
00:56:01,015 --> 00:56:04,555
Two young women separated from
their support systems late at
881
00:56:04,555 --> 00:56:08,365
night with men they barely knew
heading to rural properties.
882
00:56:08,665 --> 00:56:11,635
The outcome Savannah's case was solved.
883
00:56:11,635 --> 00:56:12,835
Her remains were discovered.
884
00:56:12,835 --> 00:56:16,495
Six months later buried on a
rural family owned property.
885
00:56:16,735 --> 00:56:21,175
David Sparks, one of the men she left the
bar with, was convicted of her murder.
886
00:56:21,595 --> 00:56:25,255
The NCE to Brooklyn law
enforcement has been very clear.
887
00:56:25,315 --> 00:56:28,705
There is no evidence that Savannah's
Killer had any connection to
888
00:56:28,705 --> 00:56:32,905
Brooklyn's disappearance, but the
public connected the cases anyway
889
00:56:33,235 --> 00:56:34,885
because both victims were young.
890
00:56:34,885 --> 00:56:38,215
Blondes both vanished after
being separated from their group.
891
00:56:38,515 --> 00:56:42,085
Both were last known to be with
men in rural settings, both
892
00:56:42,085 --> 00:56:43,615
disappeared in the same region.
893
00:56:43,855 --> 00:56:45,865
Both cases drew national attention.
894
00:56:46,230 --> 00:56:50,910
Even though Savannah's killer was caught,
the fear didn't disappear because one
895
00:56:50,910 --> 00:56:53,339
case had an answer and one didn't.
896
00:56:54,390 --> 00:56:55,350
Next is Amanda.
897
00:56:55,470 --> 00:56:59,460
Is Amanda Bailey The case with
almost no public information.
898
00:56:59,879 --> 00:57:05,160
Just days after Savannah van vanished,
Amanda Bailey 26 disappeared.
899
00:57:05,490 --> 00:57:08,790
The details released to the
public are extremely limited.
900
00:57:09,120 --> 00:57:13,859
Also, a petite, blonde, young woman
reportedly last seen with her ex-boyfriend
901
00:57:14,190 --> 00:57:16,470
location connected to Madison County.
902
00:57:16,740 --> 00:57:19,500
Her body was discovered
on a remote Kentucky farm.
903
00:57:19,830 --> 00:57:23,100
The cause of death has never
been publicly explained.
904
00:57:23,515 --> 00:57:28,200
No public suspect has been named, no
widely released arrest information.
905
00:57:29,040 --> 00:57:34,500
Unlike Savannah's case, Amanda's received
little media coverage, but the timing
906
00:57:34,590 --> 00:57:39,600
within the same month combined with
age, appearance, and geography caused
907
00:57:39,600 --> 00:57:42,240
a massive surge in online speculation.
908
00:57:42,720 --> 00:57:47,220
Theories range from coincidence
to to a serial predator to shared
909
00:57:47,220 --> 00:57:51,775
traffickers, but police have never
stated that these cases are connected.
910
00:57:52,355 --> 00:57:55,770
So why do people see a pattern
even if police say there isn't one?
911
00:57:56,400 --> 00:57:57,779
Well, number one is geography.
912
00:57:57,930 --> 00:58:01,470
All three cases, Farling, Spurlock
Bailey, occurred within a tight
913
00:58:01,470 --> 00:58:07,020
cluster of Madison, Gerard County and
neighboring central Kentucky counties.
914
00:58:07,410 --> 00:58:11,460
This is an area of rural roads,
private farmland, limited surveillance,
915
00:58:11,460 --> 00:58:13,110
and isolated property houses.
916
00:58:13,770 --> 00:58:14,430
It's easy to disappear here.
917
00:58:16,334 --> 00:58:18,314
Number two is the victim demographics.
918
00:58:18,524 --> 00:58:22,214
All three were young, petite,
white, blonde women who were
919
00:58:22,214 --> 00:58:25,214
separated from their friends and
last seen in the company of men.
920
00:58:25,634 --> 00:58:29,865
This creates psychological linkage,
even if there's no criminal one.
921
00:58:30,194 --> 00:58:31,334
And then we have the timing.
922
00:58:31,665 --> 00:58:35,625
Two cases, Spurlock and Bailey
hit within days of each other.
923
00:58:35,924 --> 00:58:37,484
Public fear skyrocketed.
924
00:58:37,484 --> 00:58:41,294
Rumors spread faster than official
information, and Brooklyn's case
925
00:58:41,294 --> 00:58:46,484
resurfaced aggressively in the media
and online because many people thought.
926
00:58:46,920 --> 00:58:48,870
This has happened before.
927
00:58:49,410 --> 00:58:51,030
Then we have the law enforcement position.
928
00:58:51,300 --> 00:58:55,050
Kentucky State Police and and
municipal agencies have repeatedly
929
00:58:55,050 --> 00:58:58,920
stated, there's no credible evidence
that connects the Spurlock or
930
00:58:58,920 --> 00:59:01,440
Bailey cases to Brooklyn farthing.
931
00:59:01,770 --> 00:59:03,570
Each investigation stands alone.
932
00:59:03,840 --> 00:59:07,560
No task force has been created
to explore cross case links.
933
00:59:07,830 --> 00:59:13,170
There is no identifiable serial
predator in the region, and they are
934
00:59:13,170 --> 00:59:17,940
aware of the comparisons because the
community would not let this issue drop,
935
00:59:17,940 --> 00:59:19,530
especially after Savannah was found.
936
00:59:20,545 --> 00:59:24,295
But comparisons are not
evidence and police continue to
937
00:59:24,295 --> 00:59:26,125
publicly reinforce that point.
938
00:59:26,665 --> 00:59:29,875
Then we have the public media
and community impact, even though
939
00:59:29,875 --> 00:59:31,945
police deny any formal link.
940
00:59:32,155 --> 00:59:36,595
True crime forums, local activists,
online discussion communities, Facebook
941
00:59:36,595 --> 00:59:41,875
groups, amateur sleuth projects and
local families all maintain the belief
942
00:59:42,175 --> 00:59:47,965
that these disappearances are connected
in the sense of regional vulnerability,
943
00:59:48,265 --> 00:59:50,515
even if not identical predators.
944
00:59:51,299 --> 00:59:52,770
The shared fear is real.
945
00:59:52,890 --> 00:59:57,600
If Savannah hadn't been found, would
we still be asking the same questions
946
00:59:57,600 --> 01:00:03,000
we've been asking since 2013 about
Brooklyn and in this region of Kentucky,
947
01:00:03,299 --> 01:00:08,069
this cluster of disappearances led to
self-defense classes, ride share, buddy
948
01:00:08,069 --> 01:00:14,069
systems, increased campus safety programs,
bar safety campaigns, and widespread
949
01:00:14,069 --> 01:00:16,259
social media warnings for young women.
950
01:00:16,680 --> 01:00:21,450
Even if the cases aren't linked
legally, they are linked culturally
951
01:00:21,509 --> 01:00:26,640
because they change the behavior and
fear level of an entire community.
952
01:00:27,495 --> 01:00:32,835
In my opinion, the Farling, Spurlock,
and Bailey cases should have triggered
953
01:00:32,895 --> 01:00:38,595
a broader multi case review years ago,
even if the predators are different,
954
01:00:38,924 --> 01:00:43,755
the pattern of how these women
disappeared, isolated vulnerable moments
955
01:00:43,755 --> 01:00:49,815
in rural areas with men absolutely
warranted a coordinated investigation.
956
01:00:50,235 --> 01:00:54,345
Kentucky has charged men with far
less evidence than what exists.
957
01:00:54,345 --> 01:00:58,095
In Brooklyn's case, Savannah's
murder proves that young women in
958
01:00:58,095 --> 01:01:03,045
this region are targeted, harmed,
and killed in rural isolation.
959
01:01:03,315 --> 01:01:08,895
It proves the threat was not hypothetical,
and in my view, that alone should have
960
01:01:08,895 --> 01:01:11,085
increased urgency for Brooklyn's case.
961
01:01:11,565 --> 01:01:16,545
When one case is solved and another goes
cold, it creates a very obvious question.
962
01:01:16,845 --> 01:01:22,575
If Savannah had vanished in
2013 instead of 2019, would her
963
01:01:22,575 --> 01:01:24,345
case have gone unsolved too?
964
01:01:25,050 --> 01:01:29,640
Question number nine, Josh Hensley's
later charges what they reveal about
965
01:01:29,640 --> 01:01:31,620
his character and why they matter.
966
01:01:32,370 --> 01:01:36,990
Josh Hensley, the last known person to
see Brooklyn Fathering alive has never
967
01:01:36,990 --> 01:01:38,610
been charged in her disappearance.
968
01:01:38,760 --> 01:01:40,140
That is a fact.
969
01:01:40,590 --> 01:01:45,330
Another fact is this, years after Brooklyn
vanished, Hensley was arrested and
970
01:01:45,330 --> 01:01:47,430
convicted on child pornography charges.
971
01:01:47,850 --> 01:01:50,610
This is not rumor, this
is not speculation.
972
01:01:50,940 --> 01:01:56,550
It is documented and confirmed by Kentucky
News outlets, case Archives, and the
973
01:01:56,550 --> 01:01:58,140
Kentucky Department of Corrections.
974
01:01:58,440 --> 01:02:03,030
So let's go through the fact-based
breakdown of what is publicly known
975
01:02:03,030 --> 01:02:05,310
about this dirt bag, Hensley's arrest.
976
01:02:05,460 --> 01:02:10,170
Unrelated to Brooklyn's case in
2020, Josh Hensley was arrested
977
01:02:10,170 --> 01:02:14,100
after an investigation uncovered
child pornography in his possession.
978
01:02:14,430 --> 01:02:16,710
The materials did not involve Brooklyn.
979
01:02:16,950 --> 01:02:21,390
The investigation was not connected to
her disappearance, and police publicly
980
01:02:21,420 --> 01:02:24,330
emphasized this at the time of his arrest.
981
01:02:25,200 --> 01:02:29,970
However, his arrest reignited community
outrage because it showed that the
982
01:02:29,970 --> 01:02:34,200
man alone with Brooklyn the night
she vanished, was later convicted
983
01:02:34,200 --> 01:02:36,180
of sexual crimes involving minors.
984
01:02:36,480 --> 01:02:39,720
This is not speculation,
this is documented.
985
01:02:40,500 --> 01:02:45,060
The charges, what they actually were,
Hensley was charged with possession of
986
01:02:45,060 --> 01:02:47,970
child pornography, a felony in Kentucky.
987
01:02:48,300 --> 01:02:51,450
The charges were digital
possession, meaning minors
988
01:02:51,450 --> 01:02:53,490
depicted in explicit conduct.
989
01:02:53,520 --> 01:02:54,750
In media files.
990
01:02:55,290 --> 01:02:59,580
There are no names, ages, or
identities, because victims in childhood
991
01:02:59,580 --> 01:03:02,010
exploitation cases are protected.
992
01:03:02,520 --> 01:03:05,880
Their information is sealed
nationally across all jurisdictions,
993
01:03:05,880 --> 01:03:07,830
and it absolutely should be.
994
01:03:08,280 --> 01:03:10,410
But the important fact is this.
995
01:03:10,710 --> 01:03:13,980
The charges involved sexual
exploitation of minors.
996
01:03:14,340 --> 01:03:15,870
This is not a small charge.
997
01:03:16,050 --> 01:03:18,300
This is not a misunderstanding.
998
01:03:18,540 --> 01:03:21,540
This is not just a possession charge.
999
01:03:22,080 --> 01:03:27,420
It is a legally recognized sex offense
involving minors, and he will be
1000
01:03:27,420 --> 01:03:29,730
required to register accordingly.
1001
01:03:30,540 --> 01:03:35,700
Hensley was convicted and as of
right now, he remains incarcerated
1002
01:03:35,700 --> 01:03:37,410
in the Kentucky State Prison System.
1003
01:03:38,100 --> 01:03:43,650
His exact length is not, I don't
know his exact length, but his Public
1004
01:03:43,650 --> 01:03:48,180
Department of Corrections records
confirm that he is incarcerated and
1005
01:03:48,299 --> 01:03:50,670
he is a registered sex offender.
1006
01:03:51,029 --> 01:03:53,700
He is not, at this time, a free man.
1007
01:03:54,540 --> 01:04:00,375
So what this means for the faring case,
fact versus interpretation, the fact
1008
01:04:00,450 --> 01:04:05,580
is, police and prosecutors have stated
repeatedly that Hensley has never been
1009
01:04:05,580 --> 01:04:07,259
charged with Brooklyn's disappearance.
1010
01:04:07,500 --> 01:04:09,600
He has not been publicly named a suspect.
1011
01:04:09,839 --> 01:04:11,610
His conviction is unrelated.
1012
01:04:12,195 --> 01:04:14,715
Those are the official positions.
1013
01:04:14,865 --> 01:04:19,125
It is also a fact that he was the
last known person to see Brooklyn
1014
01:04:19,125 --> 01:04:23,205
alive, and his later conviction
involves sexual crimes against minors.
1015
01:04:23,655 --> 01:04:28,575
Those two truths do
coexist, in my opinion.
1016
01:04:29,265 --> 01:04:34,395
Hensley's later conviction for child
sexual exploitation confirms something
1017
01:04:34,395 --> 01:04:36,375
many people already suspected.
1018
01:04:36,795 --> 01:04:43,515
He is a sexual predator, not just someone
with a shady past, not someone who simply
1019
01:04:43,515 --> 01:04:48,525
partied too hard that night, but a man
who has demonstrated a capacity for
1020
01:04:48,675 --> 01:04:54,435
sexual deviance and predatory behavior
that aligns disturbingly well with known
1021
01:04:54,435 --> 01:04:56,475
patterns in sexual murder offenders.
1022
01:04:56,985 --> 01:05:02,925
This doesn't prove that he killed Brooke,
but it absolutely reinforces, at least in
1023
01:05:02,925 --> 01:05:08,415
my view, that he was the most dangerous
person in her orbit that night, and the
1024
01:05:08,475 --> 01:05:10,665
only person in a position to harm her.
1025
01:05:11,130 --> 01:05:13,530
So let's talk about how
sexual predators escalate.
1026
01:05:14,040 --> 01:05:18,300
Criminal psychologists have long
documented that many sexual murderers
1027
01:05:18,300 --> 01:05:22,590
and abductors begin with non-contact
or digital sexual offenses.
1028
01:05:23,100 --> 01:05:26,850
Child pornography possession is
considered a major risk factor
1029
01:05:26,850 --> 01:05:28,680
for future contact offenses.
1030
01:05:29,100 --> 01:05:33,540
Predators often escalate when
given opportunity, isolation,
1031
01:05:33,720 --> 01:05:35,220
and vulnerable victims.
1032
01:05:35,535 --> 01:05:38,220
This is not about Hensley specifically.
1033
01:05:38,550 --> 01:05:42,450
It is about the category of crime
that he was convicted of and
1034
01:05:42,450 --> 01:05:46,380
how that category statistically
relates to violent offenders.
1035
01:05:46,860 --> 01:05:50,490
It's why the community was not
shocked when Hensley was arrested
1036
01:05:50,490 --> 01:05:52,410
on sexual exploitation charges.
1037
01:05:52,830 --> 01:05:55,620
They were angry, but
they weren't surprised.
1038
01:05:56,010 --> 01:06:01,050
They had felt something was off with
this douche bag for years and why this
1039
01:06:01,050 --> 01:06:07,230
matters in this case, even if police
disagree with me, Brooklyn vanished alone.
1040
01:06:07,635 --> 01:06:13,215
Isolated in the early morning at a
vacant house with a man that we now know
1041
01:06:13,275 --> 01:06:19,425
is a convicted sexual offender after
sending messages saying, I'm scared, and
1042
01:06:19,425 --> 01:06:24,465
then a couch caught fire and her phone
disappeared and she was never seen again.
1043
01:06:24,915 --> 01:06:28,365
Regardless of police statements,
this combination of facts created
1044
01:06:28,455 --> 01:06:33,945
overwhelming public distrust, widespread
belief that the wrong man went free,
1045
01:06:34,335 --> 01:06:39,825
and an enduring sense that Brooklyn
was failed by the system, and my
1046
01:06:39,825 --> 01:06:43,935
job is to lay that out all clearly.
1047
01:06:44,385 --> 01:06:49,725
Which brings us to question number
10, the investigative mishandling what
1048
01:06:49,725 --> 01:06:51,405
went wrong in Brooklyn Farthings case.
1049
01:06:52,470 --> 01:06:56,819
When you talk to anyone who has followed
Brooklyn Ling's disappearance for more
1050
01:06:56,819 --> 01:07:02,549
than five minutes, family, locals,
investigators online, s sleuth, the same
1051
01:07:02,549 --> 01:07:05,279
frustration comes up again and again.
1052
01:07:05,759 --> 01:07:09,720
The investigation did not move
fast enough, did not lock down
1053
01:07:09,720 --> 01:07:14,435
evidence soon enough, and did not
treat the scene with the urgency a
1054
01:07:14,595 --> 01:07:16,740
frightened, missing teenager deserves.
1055
01:07:17,490 --> 01:07:19,080
And that is not speculation.
1056
01:07:19,350 --> 01:07:22,830
That is not rumor that
is a documented pattern.
1057
01:07:23,759 --> 01:07:26,759
Number one, the crime scene
was not secured in time.
1058
01:07:27,060 --> 01:07:30,779
The house on Dylan court was not
treated as a crime scene immediately.
1059
01:07:31,049 --> 01:07:35,669
Family accounts reporting and multiple
case archives agree on this point.
1060
01:07:36,060 --> 01:07:39,540
Police did not seal the living room
or the structure quickly enough.
1061
01:07:39,930 --> 01:07:44,669
The first hours critical for any
missing person's case were lost.
1062
01:07:45,029 --> 01:07:49,379
Forensic collection was delayed
or absolutely incomplete.
1063
01:07:50,384 --> 01:07:53,475
This delay meant the fire
area was compromised.
1064
01:07:53,595 --> 01:07:57,855
People moved items, the couch,
which was central to the fire and
1065
01:07:57,855 --> 01:08:02,564
central to Brooklyn's last known
location became degraded before
1066
01:08:02,564 --> 01:08:04,484
any analysis was was completed.
1067
01:08:04,814 --> 01:08:09,314
The result, irre recoverable,
loss of physical evidence.
1068
01:08:10,274 --> 01:08:12,134
The couch was left outside for weeks.
1069
01:08:12,464 --> 01:08:18,314
The couch, the object on fire, the
morning Brooklyn vanished, was removed,
1070
01:08:18,644 --> 01:08:23,295
placed outside, reportedly exposed to
weather and handling, and left there
1071
01:08:23,295 --> 01:08:25,934
for weeks before any testing was done.
1072
01:08:26,385 --> 01:08:29,325
This is not minor, this is catastrophic.
1073
01:08:29,774 --> 01:08:35,325
The couch could have held blood
trace, DNA, fibers, fingerprints,
1074
01:08:35,925 --> 01:08:39,675
accelerant, residue, but by the time
anyone looked at it seriously, the
1075
01:08:39,675 --> 01:08:41,804
evidence was gone or contaminated.
1076
01:08:42,165 --> 01:08:45,165
This is widely viewed as one
of the greatest investigative
1077
01:08:45,165 --> 01:08:47,115
missteps in this entire case.
1078
01:08:48,075 --> 01:08:52,064
Number three, forensic
opportunities were missed entirely.
1079
01:08:52,425 --> 01:08:56,865
Multiple objects left behind by Brooklyn,
her boots, her purse, her overnight
1080
01:08:56,865 --> 01:09:01,875
bag, and other belongings were not
immediately seized, logged, or tested
1081
01:09:01,875 --> 01:09:03,765
in the early days of the investigation.
1082
01:09:04,245 --> 01:09:07,305
Reports indicate that
some items set untouched.
1083
01:09:07,484 --> 01:09:12,015
Some were handled before forensic
processing, and some items may
1084
01:09:12,015 --> 01:09:16,904
never have been tested at all for a
missing teenager who had just texted.
1085
01:09:17,234 --> 01:09:18,194
I'm scared.
1086
01:09:18,404 --> 01:09:25,035
This is almost impossible to believe
and absolutely impossible to justify.
1087
01:09:26,535 --> 01:09:29,625
Four witness interviews lacked
rigor, depth, and follow up.
1088
01:09:29,804 --> 01:09:31,875
This is not about rumor.
1089
01:09:32,115 --> 01:09:34,934
It is about documented inconsistency.
1090
01:09:35,234 --> 01:09:37,125
Josh Hensley's timeline shifted.
1091
01:09:37,425 --> 01:09:39,944
Key interviews were not
repeated immediately.
1092
01:09:40,184 --> 01:09:42,944
Gaps in the timeline were
never publicly clarified.
1093
01:09:43,335 --> 01:09:48,194
Family members, and this is their direct
allegation, believe they encountered
1094
01:09:48,224 --> 01:09:53,835
evasiveness, stonewalling, and incomplete
explanations, whether caused by
1095
01:09:53,835 --> 01:09:56,505
limited resources or poor execution.
1096
01:09:56,715 --> 01:10:02,205
The result is the same, a shaky
timeline and a man hinsley whose
1097
01:10:02,205 --> 01:10:06,059
account was never pressure tested with
the intensity the public expected.
1098
01:10:07,290 --> 01:10:11,460
Number five, the community tips were
followed, but often poorly coordinated.
1099
01:10:11,849 --> 01:10:16,860
There were mine shift rumors claimed
sightings, potential disposal
1100
01:10:16,860 --> 01:10:22,260
locations, scattered witness reports,
families and volunteers repeatedly
1101
01:10:22,260 --> 01:10:24,780
said leads weren't followed quickly.
1102
01:10:24,929 --> 01:10:29,285
Communication broke down and
authorities didn't work collaboratively
1103
01:10:29,675 --> 01:10:31,860
with, with the search volunteers.
1104
01:10:32,250 --> 01:10:36,990
This fractured response allowed
misinformation to spread and made
1105
01:10:36,990 --> 01:10:39,090
legitimate leads harder to track.
1106
01:10:39,615 --> 01:10:42,975
Then we have the transparency
problems and the family distrust.
1107
01:10:43,215 --> 01:10:48,315
For years, Brooklyn's family has
stated that they felt, quote, kept
1108
01:10:48,315 --> 01:10:50,835
at arms length by investigators.
1109
01:10:51,195 --> 01:10:56,925
They cite unclear statements, inconsistent
updates, withheld investigative details,
1110
01:10:57,195 --> 01:10:59,625
difficulty accessing status reports.
1111
01:10:59,865 --> 01:11:03,885
This is not unusual in open
cases, but in this case it
1112
01:11:03,885 --> 01:11:05,835
becomes a defining tension point.
1113
01:11:06,195 --> 01:11:10,365
Reddit webs, sleuth, and podcast
communities have long criticized,
1114
01:11:10,695 --> 01:11:15,015
inconsistent messaging, the lack
of public engagement, the limited
1115
01:11:15,015 --> 01:11:19,425
press releases, and the absence of
detailed investigative clarification.
1116
01:11:20,025 --> 01:11:24,045
In short, people simply
did not trust the process.
1117
01:11:24,764 --> 01:11:27,105
Number seven is the systemic context.
1118
01:11:27,375 --> 01:11:29,175
Kentucky's low clearance rate.
1119
01:11:29,565 --> 01:11:31,934
This is not only about Brooklyn's case.
1120
01:11:32,115 --> 01:11:35,715
The state itself struggles
with unsolved violent crimes.
1121
01:11:35,894 --> 01:11:40,995
The Kentucky solve rates in 2013 are
as follows, in the Louisville metro
1122
01:11:40,995 --> 01:11:47,445
area, 45.6% statewide, 52 to 56%.
1123
01:11:47,865 --> 01:11:51,735
The national average
that same year was 64%.
1124
01:11:52,335 --> 01:11:56,474
Kentucky has historically
solved fewer homicides than
1125
01:11:56,474 --> 01:11:58,190
the national average Especi.
1126
01:11:59,220 --> 01:12:04,410
In rural areas involving young women
and involving little forensic evidence.
1127
01:12:04,740 --> 01:12:07,320
Understanding this context is critical.
1128
01:12:07,590 --> 01:12:10,470
And already under-resourced
state was dealing with a
1129
01:12:10,470 --> 01:12:15,030
complex case during a period of
historically low clearance rates.
1130
01:12:15,420 --> 01:12:19,290
In my opinion, the Brooklyn
Farthing investigation failed at
1131
01:12:19,290 --> 01:12:21,269
nearly every stage that mattered.
1132
01:12:21,690 --> 01:12:26,370
Evidence wasn't preserved, key
interviews weren't repeated, the fire
1133
01:12:26,370 --> 01:12:31,349
scene wasn't locked down, and the man
I personally believe is responsible.
1134
01:12:31,620 --> 01:12:35,790
Josh Hensley was never confronted
with the level of investigative
1135
01:12:35,790 --> 01:12:38,040
pressure that this case demanded.
1136
01:12:39,120 --> 01:12:43,050
This case had more to work with
than many successful prosecuted.
1137
01:12:43,050 --> 01:12:44,160
No body homicides.
1138
01:12:44,430 --> 01:12:47,820
Like I mentioned earlier, Heather
Elvis is a perfect example.
1139
01:12:48,150 --> 01:12:52,290
Far less physical evidence, far
less clarity in the timeline, and
1140
01:12:52,290 --> 01:12:56,610
yet that case went to trial, went
to conviction and established
1141
01:12:56,610 --> 01:12:58,230
guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
1142
01:12:58,785 --> 01:13:00,315
So compare the two cases.
1143
01:13:00,795 --> 01:13:06,555
The first factor, the last known location,
Brooklyn Farthing, a single empty house.
1144
01:13:06,915 --> 01:13:09,045
Heather Elvis, her apartment.
1145
01:13:09,195 --> 01:13:12,375
The last person with the
victim, Brooklyn Farthing.
1146
01:13:12,555 --> 01:13:15,075
One person, Josh Hensley.
1147
01:13:15,345 --> 01:13:18,855
Heather Elvis, multiple, but none alone.
1148
01:13:19,005 --> 01:13:23,505
With her, her, her date dropped her off,
but then we know that he left because she
1149
01:13:23,505 --> 01:13:26,295
talked to her, to her roommate after that.
1150
01:13:26,325 --> 01:13:27,315
So he's out.
1151
01:13:27,495 --> 01:13:32,445
So we have one person and multiple
people and we have a suspicious fire.
1152
01:13:32,445 --> 01:13:33,195
Brooklyn's case.
1153
01:13:33,195 --> 01:13:33,675
Yes.
1154
01:13:33,675 --> 01:13:34,125
Heather's?
1155
01:13:34,125 --> 01:13:36,705
No, the urgent I'm scared.
1156
01:13:36,705 --> 01:13:37,395
Messages.
1157
01:13:37,935 --> 01:13:39,195
Brooklyn's case, yes.
1158
01:13:39,255 --> 01:13:42,765
Heather's no belongings
left behind Brooklyn.
1159
01:13:42,765 --> 01:13:43,665
Farthings case.
1160
01:13:43,815 --> 01:13:46,305
All of her belongings left
behind Heather's case.
1161
01:13:46,365 --> 01:13:48,465
No, the victim's phone was missing.
1162
01:13:48,645 --> 01:13:52,515
Brooklyn's case, yes, Heather's
case also was missing.
1163
01:13:53,325 --> 01:13:57,915
Timeline contradictions, Brooklyn's
case, yeah, it's full of 'em.
1164
01:13:58,215 --> 01:14:04,245
Heather's case, yes, but far weaker than
Brooklyn's in the the physical scene.
1165
01:14:04,394 --> 01:14:07,304
Brooklyn's case is a
single controlled location.
1166
01:14:07,724 --> 01:14:12,075
Heather's case is multiple public
locations, and who the hell knows where.
1167
01:14:12,615 --> 01:14:17,474
So by comparison, Brooklyn Brooklyn's
case is tighter, more isolated, and
1168
01:14:17,474 --> 01:14:19,995
more focused on one key individual.
1169
01:14:20,385 --> 01:14:21,795
Yet nothing happened.
1170
01:14:22,335 --> 01:14:27,525
And it is my belief as an informed
commentator that this case should
1171
01:14:27,525 --> 01:14:29,985
have gone to the grand jury years ago.
1172
01:14:31,200 --> 01:14:37,545
So my final theory, what most likely
happened to Brooklyn Farthing based
1173
01:14:37,545 --> 01:14:41,144
on the evidence and on my opinion.
1174
01:14:41,505 --> 01:14:43,300
So let's pull everything together.
1175
01:14:44,415 --> 01:14:48,375
We've walked through the text, the
fire, the belongings left behind
1176
01:14:48,375 --> 01:14:52,185
the phone, ping the contradictions
in Josh Hensley's story, his
1177
01:14:52,185 --> 01:14:56,955
later conviction for child sexual
exploitation, the investigative failures.
1178
01:14:57,285 --> 01:15:00,015
Now, I wanna be very
clear about something.
1179
01:15:00,435 --> 01:15:03,555
What I'm about to say is my opinion.
1180
01:15:03,825 --> 01:15:07,755
It is my interpretation of the
available evidence, the timelines, the
1181
01:15:07,755 --> 01:15:13,035
fire science, and the behavior of the
one man who admits that he was alone
1182
01:15:13,035 --> 01:15:15,225
with Brooklyn when she disappeared.
1183
01:15:15,825 --> 01:15:18,975
Josh Hensley has never
been charged in her case.
1184
01:15:19,065 --> 01:15:21,765
He has never been named
a suspect publicly.
1185
01:15:22,215 --> 01:15:26,925
Legally, he is not guilty of anything
related to Brooklyn's disappearance.
1186
01:15:27,375 --> 01:15:31,725
But based on everything that we've
just reviewed, here is what I believe
1187
01:15:31,725 --> 01:15:33,255
most likely happened that night.
1188
01:15:34,650 --> 01:15:38,370
Brooklyn ends up at the Dylan
Courthouse late at night.
1189
01:15:38,820 --> 01:15:43,500
The foreclosed half moved out home,
no electricity, no water, isolated,
1190
01:15:43,500 --> 01:15:48,480
rural, dark, a place she didn't plan
to be and she didn't want to stay.
1191
01:15:49,080 --> 01:15:53,400
She was now alone in a powerless
house with a man that she doesn't
1192
01:15:53,400 --> 01:16:00,300
know well, who has all the control his
property, access his vehicle, his rules.
1193
01:16:00,660 --> 01:16:01,830
She starts reaching out.
1194
01:16:02,280 --> 01:16:06,780
Texts her sister, texts her
ex, I'm scared, please hurry.
1195
01:16:07,170 --> 01:16:10,150
Everything about her messages
say one thing, and that is.
1196
01:16:10,934 --> 01:16:13,005
I want out of here.
1197
01:16:13,245 --> 01:16:17,655
In my opinion, what happens next is not an
accident, and it's not a misunderstanding.
1198
01:16:17,985 --> 01:16:19,905
You have an isolated, powerless house.
1199
01:16:20,115 --> 01:16:24,855
A man who years later would be convicted
in a child sexual exploitation case,
1200
01:16:25,095 --> 01:16:30,315
a young woman who is scared and trying
to leave a massive power imbalance.
1201
01:16:30,615 --> 01:16:34,184
My belief is that Hinsley
made a sexual advance.
1202
01:16:34,485 --> 01:16:37,304
Brooklyn refused, resisted,
or tried to leave.
1203
01:16:37,635 --> 01:16:42,345
The situation escalated verbally
and then physically whether the
1204
01:16:42,345 --> 01:16:44,925
assault was completed or interrupted.
1205
01:16:45,285 --> 01:16:49,995
I believe that sexual violence is
at the core of this case, and not
1206
01:16:49,995 --> 01:16:54,764
violence escalated to murder, to
silence her, protect himself and
1207
01:16:54,764 --> 01:16:56,505
prevent her from reaching out.
1208
01:16:57,945 --> 01:17:01,965
Once harm was done, whether intentional
or in a moment of rage, the next
1209
01:17:01,965 --> 01:17:04,065
problem for him is the house.
1210
01:17:04,070 --> 01:17:04,230
The.
1211
01:17:04,844 --> 01:17:09,915
Per body, blood or trauma evidence,
transfer marks on the couch or on the
1212
01:17:09,915 --> 01:17:15,495
floor items showing a struggle and
what happens not long after a fire
1213
01:17:15,495 --> 01:17:20,384
starts on or inside the couch burns
down into the floor in a house with
1214
01:17:20,384 --> 01:17:25,365
no electricity in the exact location
where she was last said to be.
1215
01:17:25,605 --> 01:17:31,365
In my opinion, the fire was not accidental
and is absolutely not started by Brooklyn.
1216
01:17:31,905 --> 01:17:37,245
It was a coverup designed to burn the
area where she'd been to obliterate
1217
01:17:37,245 --> 01:17:41,474
blood, hair fibers, and contact
evidence and to set up a story.
1218
01:17:41,955 --> 01:17:46,304
She must have started the fire
with a cigarette and then left
1219
01:17:46,755 --> 01:17:48,375
when Hensley leaves that house.
1220
01:17:48,674 --> 01:17:51,764
I do not believe he left her there alive.
1221
01:17:52,424 --> 01:17:57,195
I believe she was already dead or
incapacitated and that he staged the rest.
1222
01:17:58,665 --> 01:18:01,065
Brooklyn's purse, wallet id.
1223
01:18:01,245 --> 01:18:01,934
Bank cards.
1224
01:18:02,445 --> 01:18:07,185
Boots, overnight, bag hygiene
items all are still there.
1225
01:18:07,605 --> 01:18:10,215
The only thing missing are
Brooklyn and her phone.
1226
01:18:10,575 --> 01:18:12,735
No runaway scenario fits that pattern.
1227
01:18:12,945 --> 01:18:15,645
No, I'm going to another party scenario.
1228
01:18:15,645 --> 01:18:16,605
Fits that pattern.
1229
01:18:16,785 --> 01:18:18,705
No, I just walked away.
1230
01:18:18,705 --> 01:18:20,085
Scenario fits that pattern.
1231
01:18:20,715 --> 01:18:21,495
In my opinion.
1232
01:18:21,585 --> 01:18:23,895
The belongings were left
as part of a narrative.
1233
01:18:24,285 --> 01:18:25,245
She just left.
1234
01:18:25,245 --> 01:18:26,355
She walked off.
1235
01:18:26,715 --> 01:18:28,005
I don't know where she went.
1236
01:18:28,620 --> 01:18:31,049
The evidence screams the opposite.
1237
01:18:31,320 --> 01:18:33,210
We know that her phone left with her.
1238
01:18:33,599 --> 01:18:35,940
Its sent the suspicious, nevermind.
1239
01:18:36,269 --> 01:18:39,269
I'm okay going to a party in
Rockcastle County message.
1240
01:18:39,540 --> 01:18:42,719
It later pinged the tower in
blue in the blue lick area.
1241
01:18:43,049 --> 01:18:44,580
After that, it went completely dark.
1242
01:18:44,880 --> 01:18:50,700
My best guess is that Hensley kept
her phone powered off or disabled.
1243
01:18:50,910 --> 01:18:56,639
While he deals with the immediate crisis,
he hides or temporarily stashes Brooklyn's
1244
01:18:56,639 --> 01:19:01,950
body possibly near the property that he
knows somewhere that he can return to.
1245
01:19:02,429 --> 01:19:07,110
He waits out the initial chaos, the family
calling and coming, the people looking.
1246
01:19:07,349 --> 01:19:09,389
Law enforcement beginning to stir.
1247
01:19:10,184 --> 01:19:14,565
At some point in the days after,
when the pressure pattern changes,
1248
01:19:14,565 --> 01:19:17,985
he moves her body to a more
permanent disposal location.
1249
01:19:18,344 --> 01:19:21,195
Farther out, more hidden, harder to find.
1250
01:19:21,554 --> 01:19:26,625
Around that time, he briefly powers the
phone on again or tosses it from the
1251
01:19:26,625 --> 01:19:28,455
vehicle in the blue Lit coverage area.
1252
01:19:28,815 --> 01:19:32,894
The phone hits the tower, one
last ping, and then is destroyed.
1253
01:19:32,894 --> 01:19:36,224
Submerged or left where
no one will ever find it.
1254
01:19:36,795 --> 01:19:37,905
Is this provable?
1255
01:19:38,144 --> 01:19:38,655
No.
1256
01:19:39,105 --> 01:19:41,565
Is this published as Fact Anywhere?
1257
01:19:41,804 --> 01:19:42,375
No.
1258
01:19:42,795 --> 01:19:47,715
This is my opinion, but it is
an opinion that fits her last
1259
01:19:47,715 --> 01:19:50,594
text, the stage I'm Okay message.
1260
01:19:50,835 --> 01:19:53,925
The outward movement of her
phone and the complete and
1261
01:19:53,925 --> 01:19:56,264
permanent silence that follows.
1262
01:19:56,925 --> 01:20:00,344
If you accept the idea that the
fire was staged and the phone was
1263
01:20:00,344 --> 01:20:04,545
carefully handled, then it follows
that the body was handled the same way.
1264
01:20:05,009 --> 01:20:08,969
My belief is that she was killed
at or near that couch area.
1265
01:20:09,299 --> 01:20:12,960
She was removed from the house
possibly before the fire was fully
1266
01:20:12,960 --> 01:20:14,940
set, possibly after it began.
1267
01:20:15,330 --> 01:20:19,860
She was initially hidden somewhere
that Hinsley could quickly access and
1268
01:20:19,860 --> 01:20:22,710
quietly somewhere close to Dill Court.
1269
01:20:23,129 --> 01:20:27,809
When law enforcement focus became more
diffuse and the search pattern shifted,
1270
01:20:28,049 --> 01:20:33,389
he moved her again to a more permanent
dump site, somewhere rural, somewhere
1271
01:20:33,389 --> 01:20:39,059
secluded and likely tied to land,
jobs, or geography that he knows well.
1272
01:20:39,480 --> 01:20:41,610
And there she remains.
1273
01:20:41,940 --> 01:20:45,150
So why do I believe that this
theory fits better than any other?
1274
01:20:46,065 --> 01:20:50,805
Any theory about this case
has to explain the I'm scared.
1275
01:20:50,805 --> 01:20:56,145
Text the sudden I'm fine going to
rockcastle reversal the fire in a
1276
01:20:56,145 --> 01:21:00,405
powerless house, the downward burn
through the couch, the belongings left
1277
01:21:00,405 --> 01:21:05,415
behind the missing phone, the blue
lick ping the total silence afterwards.
1278
01:21:05,715 --> 01:21:09,945
Kinsley's later conviction for
child sexual exploitation, the
1279
01:21:09,945 --> 01:21:14,235
lack of any evidence that she left
voluntarily with anybody else.
1280
01:21:15,015 --> 01:21:20,415
In my opinion, the simplest theory
that accounts for all of this is this,
1281
01:21:20,865 --> 01:21:23,475
A sexual advance, a violent response.
1282
01:21:23,475 --> 01:21:28,545
When she resisted a death, he could
not undo a fire to erase the scene,
1283
01:21:28,665 --> 01:21:30,885
a staged story with her phone.
1284
01:21:31,155 --> 01:21:34,905
A body moved, then moved again,
and a community left without
1285
01:21:34,905 --> 01:21:36,105
the answers they deserve.
1286
01:21:36,974 --> 01:21:39,825
Legally, this remains a theory.
1287
01:21:39,974 --> 01:21:44,745
Morally, it feels like the only thing
that makes sense, and until someone
1288
01:21:44,745 --> 01:21:49,125
with actual authority decides to
move this case forward to a grand
1289
01:21:49,125 --> 01:21:51,615
jury, to charges to a courtroom.
1290
01:21:51,974 --> 01:21:55,094
This theory is what many
of us are left with.
1291
01:21:55,545 --> 01:22:00,585
A young woman who tried to get home, a man
who should never have been trusted with
1292
01:22:00,585 --> 01:22:06,405
her safety, and a system that never pushed
hard enough to hold him fully accountable.
1293
01:22:07,065 --> 01:22:11,295
There's a moment in every case, one
moment where the door should have
1294
01:22:11,295 --> 01:22:15,554
swung open, where the truth should
have come crashing through, where
1295
01:22:15,554 --> 01:22:19,995
somebody in a position of authority
should have stood up and said, enough.
1296
01:22:20,325 --> 01:22:21,915
This ends now.
1297
01:22:22,335 --> 01:22:27,285
In Brooklyn Farthings case, that
moment came and went more than once.
1298
01:22:27,645 --> 01:22:33,495
We talk a lot about failures, missed
timelines, botched evidence, opportunities
1299
01:22:33,495 --> 01:22:37,365
lost because someone hesitated when
they should have acted or acted
1300
01:22:37,365 --> 01:22:38,835
when they should have slowed down.
1301
01:22:39,255 --> 01:22:43,275
But even with all of that, even with
every fly in this investigation,
1302
01:22:43,275 --> 01:22:48,255
the simple truth is this, this
case should not still be unsolved.
1303
01:22:48,555 --> 01:22:53,985
And the fact that it is, that's not fate,
that's not mystery, that's not cosmic.
1304
01:22:53,985 --> 01:22:54,705
Bad luck.
1305
01:22:55,125 --> 01:23:01,610
It's absolute failure, plain
obvious, preventable failure.
1306
01:23:02,340 --> 01:23:06,630
Let me put it in this way because
sometimes the simplest analogy
1307
01:23:06,630 --> 01:23:08,100
cuts through all of the noise.
1308
01:23:08,519 --> 01:23:14,550
If you lock two people in a jail cell,
just two, no windows, no doors, no magical
1309
01:23:14,550 --> 01:23:18,750
third visitor who slipped in through
the ceiling, and you come back an hour
1310
01:23:18,750 --> 01:23:23,580
later to find one alive and the other
murdered, you don't need Sherlock Holmes.
1311
01:23:23,850 --> 01:23:25,380
You don't need a task force.
1312
01:23:25,380 --> 01:23:28,080
You don't need a decade of speculation.
1313
01:23:28,380 --> 01:23:29,550
You already know what happened.
1314
01:23:29,610 --> 01:23:33,090
And when you look at the timeline
of Brooklyn's case, when you look at
1315
01:23:33,090 --> 01:23:37,680
the isolation of that house, the fire
conveniently starting around the exact
1316
01:23:37,680 --> 01:23:43,140
spot she was last seen the items she left
behind the last man to see her, his later
1317
01:23:43,140 --> 01:23:48,060
conviction on child sexual exploitation
charges, and the fact that not one
1318
01:23:48,060 --> 01:23:54,030
single piece of evidence points to any
unknown intruder or phantom stranger.
1319
01:23:54,540 --> 01:23:58,230
I feel like I'm staring at
the same damn jail cell.
1320
01:23:58,590 --> 01:24:02,130
Just bigger a living room
instead of concrete walls.
1321
01:24:02,340 --> 01:24:06,900
A couch instead of a bunk, a terrified
teenager instead of a hardened inmate.
1322
01:24:07,170 --> 01:24:10,019
And yet Kentucky calls this unsolved.
1323
01:24:10,500 --> 01:24:16,890
That's not just illogical, it's insulting
because while Kentucky has been sitting at
1324
01:24:16,890 --> 01:24:22,980
an unimpressive 52 to 56% homicide solve
rate, the rest of the country has been
1325
01:24:22,980 --> 01:24:28,350
proving over and over that you can solve
cases with less than what exists here.
1326
01:24:28,830 --> 01:24:33,510
South Carolina, for example, the state
that that successfully prosecuted the
1327
01:24:33,510 --> 01:24:38,040
Heather Elvis case with no conflicting
witness statements, shaky timelines,
1328
01:24:38,040 --> 01:24:43,500
and far less physical evidence than
Brook's case has an 89.7% clearance
1329
01:24:43,500 --> 01:24:45,390
rate, one of the highest in the nation.
1330
01:24:45,720 --> 01:24:48,390
Nearly 90% of homicides solved.
1331
01:24:48,750 --> 01:24:52,350
They took a no body case, stitched
together, motive, opportunity,
1332
01:24:52,380 --> 01:24:56,490
inconsistencies and behavior,
and they built a prosecution
1333
01:24:56,490 --> 01:24:57,660
strong enough to convict.
1334
01:24:58,050 --> 01:25:02,250
Meanwhile, in Kentucky, a fire damage
couch sits outside in the weather.
1335
01:25:02,610 --> 01:25:04,740
Early interviews are rushed or incomplete.
1336
01:25:05,040 --> 01:25:06,930
Phone data is misinterpreted.
1337
01:25:07,230 --> 01:25:09,450
Potential evidence goes uncollected.
1338
01:25:09,720 --> 01:25:14,580
Witness timelines shift and the
one man with opportunity later gets
1339
01:25:14,580 --> 01:25:16,260
arrested for child pornography.
1340
01:25:16,500 --> 01:25:20,130
And somehow nobody thinks
to leverage that moment.
1341
01:25:20,910 --> 01:25:23,070
That should have been
the door swinging open.
1342
01:25:23,310 --> 01:25:25,410
That should have been the bargaining chip.
1343
01:25:25,590 --> 01:25:26,970
That should have been the deal.
1344
01:25:27,180 --> 01:25:30,780
You want leniency, you want
to plea, you want anything?
1345
01:25:31,320 --> 01:25:33,330
Tell us where Brooklyn is.
1346
01:25:33,900 --> 01:25:36,390
Instead, the state wasted its leverage.
1347
01:25:36,600 --> 01:25:38,880
They blew the one piece of power they had.
1348
01:25:39,240 --> 01:25:42,930
They let the only meaningful pressure
point slip through their fingers.
1349
01:25:43,230 --> 01:25:47,460
And now here we are more than a
decade later, with a mother still
1350
01:25:47,460 --> 01:25:50,640
setting a place at the table
that her child will never fill.
1351
01:25:50,790 --> 01:25:53,790
And what really drives
the knife deeper is this.
1352
01:25:54,120 --> 01:25:57,660
Colorado is clearing
almost 77% of homicides.
1353
01:25:57,960 --> 01:26:00,210
Arizona is clearing 65%.
1354
01:26:00,510 --> 01:26:06,270
Washington DC has years that where
they recorded as high as a 91% solved.
1355
01:26:06,480 --> 01:26:11,160
Even states with brutal crime problems,
Illinois, Florida still managed to
1356
01:26:11,160 --> 01:26:15,900
push cases forward in situations far
more chaotic and violent than this one.
1357
01:26:16,350 --> 01:26:21,120
So no, Kentucky is not the worst,
but it is nowhere near the best.
1358
01:26:21,510 --> 01:26:24,930
And when you're talking about the
disappearance of a teenager, a
1359
01:26:24,930 --> 01:26:30,510
child middle of the pack isn't good
enough, average isn't good enough.
1360
01:26:30,780 --> 01:26:33,210
Maybe someday isn't good enough.
1361
01:26:33,630 --> 01:26:37,950
Brooklyn Farthing deserved a system that
fought for her with everything it had.
1362
01:26:38,310 --> 01:26:41,820
She deserved a team that secured
the scene, protected the evidence,
1363
01:26:42,060 --> 01:26:45,600
challenged the contradictions, and
refused to let silence become a
1364
01:26:45,600 --> 01:26:48,480
shield she deserved better than this.
1365
01:26:49,019 --> 01:26:53,790
If we're angry, if we're outraged,
if we're here saying what no one
1366
01:26:53,790 --> 01:26:57,960
else seems willing to say, it's
because the truth demands it.
1367
01:26:58,860 --> 01:27:01,530
This case is solvable.
1368
01:27:01,680 --> 01:27:03,660
This case should have been solved.
1369
01:27:03,960 --> 01:27:08,160
And the fact that it isn't, that
falls on the shoulders of every agency
1370
01:27:08,160 --> 01:27:10,500
that let those early hours slip away.
1371
01:27:10,830 --> 01:27:12,450
Every opportunity ignored.
1372
01:27:12,660 --> 01:27:15,720
And every year that passes
without accountability.
1373
01:27:16,140 --> 01:27:19,980
Kentucky needs to get off its
ass and treat cases like this.
1374
01:27:20,100 --> 01:27:24,810
Cases like Brooklyn's with the care,
the urgency, and the respect that
1375
01:27:24,810 --> 01:27:26,970
they deserve, her life mattered.
1376
01:27:27,090 --> 01:27:31,050
Her fear was real, and somewhere
out there someone knows
1377
01:27:31,050 --> 01:27:32,610
exactly what happened to her.
1378
01:27:33,000 --> 01:27:35,880
It's time they're finally
made to answer for it.
1379
01:27:40,155 --> 01:27:43,395
If tonight's episode moved
you, angered you, or reminded
1380
01:27:43,395 --> 01:27:44,895
you why these cases matter.
1381
01:27:45,195 --> 01:27:49,785
We want you with us as we keep
pushing forward, like follow,
1382
01:27:49,785 --> 01:27:53,985
subscribe, hit the thumbs up, hit
the bell, leave a review on whatever
1383
01:27:53,985 --> 01:27:55,485
platform you're listening through.
1384
01:27:56,025 --> 01:27:59,505
Those things help us more than
you know and remember, dark
1385
01:27:59,505 --> 01:28:01,335
Dialogue isn't just a podcast.
1386
01:28:01,335 --> 01:28:02,265
It's a community.
1387
01:28:02,265 --> 01:28:03,255
It's a movement.
1388
01:28:03,555 --> 01:28:07,545
The boots on the ground effort to
support families, search for answers
1389
01:28:07,755 --> 01:28:10,155
and make sure no victim is forgotten.
1390
01:28:10,785 --> 01:28:14,115
If you want to be a part of that
work, you can join the Dark Dialogue
1391
01:28:14,115 --> 01:28:17,865
Collective, our volunteer network
for real time support searches,
1392
01:28:17,925 --> 01:28:20,025
advocacy, logistics, and outreach.
1393
01:28:20,325 --> 01:28:23,145
You can adopt a victim through
our adoptive victim program.
1394
01:28:23,715 --> 01:28:27,645
Take on research tasks and help
families who still don't have closure.
1395
01:28:27,975 --> 01:28:31,425
Brooklyn's case is available
for adoption on that.
1396
01:28:32,085 --> 01:28:36,225
You can support the show directly
on Patreon coffee or through our
1397
01:28:36,225 --> 01:28:40,095
substack, where we share extended
case files, bonus episodes, and
1398
01:28:40,095 --> 01:28:41,475
behind the scenes commentary.
1399
01:28:42,015 --> 01:28:46,635
You can always visit the
website@www.darkdialogue.com
1400
01:28:46,635 --> 01:28:50,475
for resources, episodes,
victim tributes, and updates.
1401
01:28:50,745 --> 01:28:55,215
And if you have questions, case
suggestions, tips, or just wanna
1402
01:28:55,215 --> 01:29:00,045
reach out, you can email us
anytime at info@darkdialogue.com.
1403
01:29:00,615 --> 01:29:06,555
This is John and for dark dialogue to
still stay curious, stay relentless,
1404
01:29:06,795 --> 01:29:08,925
and don't let the truth go silent.