ABOUT THIS EPISODE
ATTORNEYS: GUARDIANS OF JUSTICE OR SERVANTS OF THE SYSTEM?
How can a profession be entrusted with defending the American people against abuses of governmental power when its livelihood, advancement, and professional standing depend upon the very system it is expected to challenge?
There is a reason attorneys have been compared to snakes, pond scum, and worse for centuries.
But perhaps the greatest paradox surrounding the attorney profession is that we laugh at attorneys collectively, yet frequently admire them individually.
We tell jokes about their greed, their dishonesty, their manipulation of language, and their disregard for truth.
Yet when someone introduces himself as an attorney, we suddenly treat him with respect. We presume intelligence, credibility, and authority.
Why?
What happened to the joke?
Did the profession suddenly become honorable because one of its members walked into the room?
Or have we developed the extraordinary habit of ridiculing a profession while simultaneously rewarding its members with the very respect and authority our ridicule calls into question?
Perhaps the greatest joke about attorneys is not the one we tell about them. It is the one we play upon ourselves by continuing to presume that professional credentials establish personal integrity.
And that brings us to the real scandal.
We have allowed a professional class to become the gatekeeper of justice in a republic supposedly founded upon the inherent rights of the people.
Think about the contradiction.
We are told our rights are inalienable. That they do not originate with government. That government exists to secure them.
Yet when government threatens those rights, the ordinary American is frequently compelled, as a practical matter, to hire a licensed attorney to defend what was never government’s to take.
And that attorney earns his living within the very system whose authority he is expected to challenge.
Does anyone recognize the fundamental conflict?
Attorneys are trained to manipulate language, to parse, qualify, distinguish, and reinterpret words until a simple question of right and wrong becomes an exhausting contest of procedure.
They can argue one proposition today and its opposite tomorrow.
They can transform a question of inherent rights into a dispute over technicalities, deadlines, jurisdiction, standing, precedent, and procedural compliance.
Some of those distinctions are essential to justice. But others can become instruments for avoiding the very truth the proceeding is supposed to establish.
And when procedure becomes more important than truth, the judicial system ceases to be an instrument of justice and becomes an instrument of institutional self-preservation.
Now consider the financial incentives.
Law firms must generate revenue. Attorneys must manage their time. Prosecutors face enormous caseloads. Public defenders are frequently overwhelmed. Courts are pressured to dispose of matters efficiently.
And what is the predictable result?
Settlement. Negotiation. Plea bargaining.
The overwhelming majority of federal criminal convictions result from guilty pleas rather than jury verdicts.
The right to trial by jury remains celebrated as a cornerstone of American liberty, yet comparatively few federal criminal defendants exercise that right through a completed trial.
Why?
Because the system rewards negotiated dispositions, while the risks and costs of proceeding to trial can be extraordinary.
Justice is not supposed to be a production line.
Yet we have developed a system in which efficiency can become more important than examining the government’s accusations.
And the attorney class is indispensable to keeping that machinery operating.
I experienced this firsthand.
During my own confrontation with the federal government, I was represented by public defenders with impressive credentials.
One had graduated second in his class at West Point.
Yet when I sought to present arguments concerning my understanding of the federal income tax laws, arguments I believed were supported by Cheek v. United States, I was told that counsel could be sanctioned for raising them.
Understand the significance.
In Cheek, the Supreme Court recognized that a genuinely held misunderstanding of federal tax law can negate the willfulness required for certain criminal tax offenses, even if that misunderstanding is unreasonable.
The Court also distinguished such misunderstandings from claims that the tax laws themselves are unconstitutional.
But my central concern was that arguments I believed relevant to my state of mind were being excluded from the defense I wanted presented.
And that raises a fundamental question:
When a man faces imprisonment, should his ability to present a legitimate defense depend upon an attorney’s fear of professional consequences?
The answer should be obvious.
I also know of an individual who paid approximately $65,000 to a private attorney associated with the tax-honesty movement, only to be advised ultimately to accept a plea agreement.
It raises a serious concern about the difference between paying for vigorous advocacy and paying for an eventual surrender.
And now consider something even more disturbing.
The attorneys who operate the system frequently become the judges who control it.
They become prosecutors, legislators, judges, and justices.
The profession supplies many of those who write the rules, argue their meaning, determine their application, and decide whether challenges to their authority will even be heard.
Think about that concentration of institutional influence.
An attorney who spends decades operating within a professional culture of precedent, procedure, and institutional expectations may eventually sit in judgment over citizens who challenge those very expectations.
Does professional advancement guarantee impartiality?
Does membership in a bar association establish moral superiority?
Does a law degree confer wisdom, courage, or integrity?
Absolutely not.
And yet we have allowed the administration of justice to become so dominated by this profession that ordinary Americans are often treated as incapable of defending their own rights.
There is an interesting historical controversy involving the proposed Titles of Nobility Amendment of 1810, sometimes called the original Thirteenth Amendment.
Whether ratified or not, it reflected an early republican concern about titles, foreign influence, and privileged status.
That concern invites a modern question.
Have we permitted a professional class to acquire an influence over government that is fundamentally inconsistent with the principle of equal citizenship?
The Constitution itself does not require federal judges to possess law degrees.
Why, then, should we assume that only attorneys possess the judgment necessary to serve in judicial office?
The American jury embodies the opposite principle: ordinary citizens are entrusted with decisions involving life, liberty, property, and guilt.
A principled citizen, properly educated in constitutional limits, evidence, procedure, and impartial judgment, may possess greater devotion to justice than an attorney whose entire career has been devoted to protecting institutional expectations.
Knowledge is necessary.
Integrity is indispensable.
But professional credentials are no substitute for either.
I have a close friend who is educated in law but refuses to become a BAR-licensed attorney. He has made that decision deliberately because he rejects the professional culture and institutional compromises we are discussing. He believes that his commitment to truth and justice is more important than membership in a profession whose practices he cannot conscientiously embrace.
His decision illustrates an important distinction: a person can possess knowledge of the law without surrendering his principles to the professional institutions that administer it.
Now I recognize that there are attorneys who have sacrificed income, careers, and personal security to defend the innocent and confront abuses of power.
They deserve recognition.
But their existence does not excuse the institutional incentives that can discourage such courage.
Consider the physician who devotes his life to healing, the nurse who comforts the suffering, or the monk who sacrifices material wealth to serve the poor.
Their highest calling is service.
Should the highest calling of an attorney be anything less?
And yet how many attorneys are prepared to risk their careers, reputations, and incomes to challenge a judge who exceeds his authority, a prosecutor who abuses his office, or a governmental presumption that cannot withstand examination?
The question is not whether courageous attorneys exist. The question is why the protection of our rights should depend upon finding one.
So what must change?
We must make meaningful self-representation more accessible.
We must hold judges, prosecutors, and attorneys accountable for demonstrable misconduct.
We must eliminate unnecessary professional barriers that prevent qualified citizens from participating in the administration of justice.
We must examine whether non-attorney citizens, properly qualified and trained, should have greater opportunities to serve in judicial positions.
And we must demand that every exercise of governmental authority be supported by demonstrable authority, rather than professional assertion or institutional presumption.
These are not attacks upon legitimate knowledge or necessary procedural safeguards.
They are demands that those safeguards serve the people rather than become barriers against them.
The American Republic was not established to provide attorneys with employment, judges with authority, or courts with perpetual business.
It was established upon the principle that government exists to secure rights that precede government itself.
And no profession should be permitted to convert the defense of those rights into a privilege available principally to those who can afford its services.
We have confused law with justice.
We have confused professional licensing with integrity.
We have confused judicial authority with infallibility.
And we have permitted institutional convenience to compete with the fundamental rights of human beings.
A republic cannot remain free when the defense of its people’s rights becomes the exclusive business of a profession whose interests may be better served by preserving the system than by challenging its authority.
The question is no longer whether we need attorneys.
The question is whether we will continue allowing attorneys to dominate the institutions that determine the meaning, enforcement, and protection of our freedoms.
Justice does not belong to attorneys.
It does not belong to judges.
It does not belong to government.
Justice belongs to the people.
And any profession that places its own preservation above the rights of the people has forfeited its claim to be the guardian of justice.