Terrifying & True | Ghostwatch: The BBC Halloween Hoax and Its Real Fallout

WEBVTT
1
00:00:00.400 --> 00:00:07.730
Halloween night, 1991. Millions tuned in to watch the BBC
2
00:00:08.210 --> 00:00:13.949
investigate a haunted house. Then the broadcast suggested the ghost
3
00:00:14.550 --> 00:00:19.109
could reach them, too. It was scripted, but the frightened
4
00:00:19.210 --> 00:00:24.480
calls were real. Just how did a television drama make
5
00:00:24.550 --> 00:00:26.679
home feel like danger?
6
00:00:30.429 --> 00:00:35.380
What you are about to hear is believed to be real.
7
00:00:36.259 --> 00:00:44.259
Based on witness accounts, testimonies, and public record, this is
8
00:00:45.619 --> 00:00:48.939
Terrifying and True Truth.
9
00:00:55.030 --> 00:01:00.850
Tonight, Michael Parkinson is looking at an autocue. that should
10
00:01:00.929 --> 00:01:06.599
tell him how to end the program. Instead, it's becoming
11
00:01:06.760 --> 00:01:12.980
part of the nightmare. On screen, the studio is losing control.
12
00:01:13.840 --> 00:01:18.180
Sarah Green has been investigating a house where two children
13
00:01:18.280 --> 00:01:23.799
say something lives beneath the stairs. Now the danger appears
14
00:01:24.109 --> 00:01:28.430
to have followed the television signal back to the people
15
00:01:28.590 --> 00:01:37.090
covering the story. It's Halloween night, 1992. BBC One is
16
00:01:37.170 --> 00:01:44.799
showing Ghostwatch, a scripted drama made to resemble a live investigation.
17
00:01:45.719 --> 00:01:53.019
The haunted family is fictional. The familiar presenters are playing themselves.
18
00:01:53.959 --> 00:01:58.349
For some viewers, those familiar faces make the distinction between
19
00:01:59.090 --> 00:02:04.489
difficult to hold on to. When the credits arrive, the
20
00:02:04.609 --> 00:02:11.090
argument is only beginning. Frightened and angry viewers contact the BBC.
21
00:02:11.789 --> 00:02:16.870
The filmmakers defend their choices. A ghost invented for one
22
00:02:17.150 --> 00:02:23.490
evening becomes a controversy that lasts far beyond it. How
23
00:02:23.650 --> 00:02:29.080
did a program turn the reassuring habits of television into
24
00:02:29.120 --> 00:02:35.319
a reason to distrust the screen. And why do people
25
00:02:35.430 --> 00:02:40.169
who know exactly how it was made still find themselves
26
00:02:40.750 --> 00:02:47.250
checking the curtains? Tonight, we're returning to the broadcast, its makers,
27
00:02:47.469 --> 00:02:51.979
and the audience caught between a fictional haunting and a
28
00:02:52.139 --> 00:02:57.340
very real reaction. Not since War of the Worlds has
29
00:02:57.439 --> 00:03:03.449
something so Intense infected the public that was pure and
30
00:03:03.530 --> 00:03:09.409
admitted fiction. Make sure you're subscribed on your favorite podcast
31
00:03:09.610 --> 00:03:12.870
app so you never miss a bit of the spooky
32
00:03:13.370 --> 00:03:20.870
or the terrifying and true. Now, we're telling that story tonight.
33
00:03:33.879 --> 00:03:37.740
Sarah Green arrives at a council house on Fox Hill
34
00:03:37.819 --> 00:03:43.270
Drive with a camera crew and a practical assignment. Meet
35
00:03:43.349 --> 00:03:47.270
the family, look at the evidence, find out what has
36
00:03:47.330 --> 00:03:55.789
been making the noises. Outside, Craig Charles works the Halloween crowd. Inside,
37
00:03:56.409 --> 00:04:01.870
a mother named Pamela Early is raising her daughters, Suzanne
38
00:04:01.909 --> 00:04:05.599
and Kim. in rooms that have become the subject of
39
00:04:06.060 --> 00:04:11.500
newspaper stories. The family says something has moved in with them.
40
00:04:12.500 --> 00:04:17.439
The younger girl calls it pipes. Back in the studio,
41
00:04:17.980 --> 00:04:23.459
Michael Parkinson is ready to ask the sensible questions. This
42
00:04:23.579 --> 00:04:30.829
is how Ghostwatch introduces its investigation on BBC One, beginning
43
00:04:30.930 --> 00:04:40.089
at 9.25, on Saturday, October 31st, 1992. The film runs
44
00:04:40.089 --> 00:04:46.790
91 minutes. Its haunted family is invented, its threatening presence
45
00:04:47.329 --> 00:04:52.519
is invented, and the program was recorded in advance. What
46
00:04:52.579 --> 00:04:56.180
makes this a true story is what happened when the
47
00:04:56.220 --> 00:05:03.370
BBC sent that fiction into real homes. First, though, there's
48
00:05:03.410 --> 00:05:07.629
the house. It offers very little of the scenery that
49
00:05:07.870 --> 00:05:13.810
usually gives an audience permission to enjoy being frightened. No
50
00:05:13.970 --> 00:05:19.920
ruined abbey separates Pamela's life from ordinary life. There's no
51
00:05:20.040 --> 00:05:25.279
inherited mansion with a wing that nobody uses. Her daughters
52
00:05:25.759 --> 00:05:35.589
share a bedroom. The Pamela originally tries to explain the
53
00:05:35.649 --> 00:05:41.800
disturbances through something a parent might actually blame. The plumbing.
54
00:05:42.819 --> 00:05:48.199
That explanation gives Pipes his name. It sounds like something
55
00:05:48.259 --> 00:05:52.310
a child could say at breakfast without making the adults
56
00:05:52.889 --> 00:05:57.810
stop eating. Before long, it becomes the household's name for
57
00:05:58.310 --> 00:06:03.930
a presence nobody can explain away. Sarah listens to Pamela
58
00:06:04.449 --> 00:06:09.230
and talks to the girls. She is an unusually effective
59
00:06:09.350 --> 00:06:15.160
person to send into this particular house. Viewers know her
60
00:06:15.259 --> 00:06:21.439
from Blue Peter and Going Live, programs associated with children
61
00:06:21.660 --> 00:06:25.699
and family viewing. She can speak to a frightened child
62
00:06:25.759 --> 00:06:31.500
without making the conversation feel like an interrogation. She also
63
00:06:31.579 --> 00:06:37.899
brings a small, unspoken reassurance. Here is someone who normally
64
00:06:37.959 --> 00:06:45.740
helps television remain friendly. Her warmth follows her upstairs. That
65
00:06:46.040 --> 00:06:50.790
is more important than any announcement that a fictional reporter
66
00:06:51.370 --> 00:06:56.610
is brave. The children are played by real sisters, Michelle
67
00:06:56.670 --> 00:07:01.720
and Cherise Wesson. Pamela is played by the actor... Breed Brennan.
68
00:07:02.680 --> 00:07:09.430
Without the film, however, nobody introduces them as performers. Sarah
69
00:07:09.589 --> 00:07:13.649
uses their characters' names and approaches the visit as a
70
00:07:13.949 --> 00:07:20.029
job she's doing that evening. Parkinson appears under his own name, too.
71
00:07:20.709 --> 00:07:24.810
He has the composure of a veteran interviewer, with a
72
00:07:24.910 --> 00:07:31.500
skeptical remark available whenever the supernatural claim becomes true. Too grand.
73
00:07:32.920 --> 00:07:38.199
He can listen without appearing convinced. His presence allows viewers
74
00:07:38.259 --> 00:07:42.970
to keep their doubts and stay with the investigation. The
75
00:07:43.029 --> 00:07:48.050
studio is equipped to help. Monitors carry pictures from the house.
76
00:07:48.629 --> 00:07:53.689
A parapsychologist, Dr. Lynn Pascoe, presents the research she says
77
00:07:53.750 --> 00:08:00.319
has gathered. Mike Smith manages the phonem. Operators and equipment
78
00:08:00.399 --> 00:08:05.050
give Parkinson somewhere to turn when a question requires another
79
00:08:05.170 --> 00:08:11.509
piece of information. Smith is Sarah Green's real-life husband. For now,
80
00:08:11.629 --> 00:08:18.269
that fact belongs comfortably to the program's familiar faces. He's
81
00:08:18.329 --> 00:08:23.060
in the studio, she is on location, and television routinely
82
00:08:23.139 --> 00:08:28.209
connects people working in different places. The distance does not
83
00:08:28.389 --> 00:08:35.340
yet seem threatening. Outside, Charles supplies a different kind of comfort.
84
00:08:36.340 --> 00:08:40.120
He can joke with the crowd, find someone to interview
85
00:08:40.299 --> 00:08:45.159
and fill the time while the studio prepares its next item.
86
00:08:46.179 --> 00:08:50.860
Children in costumes and neighbors curious about the cameras make
87
00:08:50.940 --> 00:08:55.299
Fox Hill Drive feel like a street hosting a television event.
88
00:08:56.210 --> 00:09:00.070
The house still has a world around it. The program
89
00:09:00.169 --> 00:09:05.649
keeps moving between these places. A question travels from the
90
00:09:05.690 --> 00:09:11.820
studio to the house. An answer comes back. A presenter
91
00:09:11.919 --> 00:09:17.460
waits a little too long for a link. A conversation wanders.
92
00:09:17.980 --> 00:09:24.850
Those small inconveniences are recognizable to anyone who watches live television.
93
00:09:25.600 --> 00:09:29.039
They make the investigation feel as though it has to
94
00:09:29.100 --> 00:09:36.429
negotiate the evening while the evening is happening. In 1992,
95
00:09:36.429 --> 00:09:42.750
that was a powerful impression. Satellite and cable existed, but
96
00:09:43.250 --> 00:09:48.269
much of Britain's shared television life still moved through four
97
00:09:48.860 --> 00:09:54.860
terrestrial channels. A scheduled program could gather millions at once.
98
00:09:55.730 --> 00:10:00.580
There was no social feed alongside the picture, offering... instant
99
00:10:00.779 --> 00:10:05.120
explanations from viewers who had already searched for the answer.
100
00:10:06.529 --> 00:10:12.049
The program locates Foxhill Drive in Northolt, London. Pamela has
101
00:10:12.129 --> 00:10:17.009
tried to sell the house, but without success. That detail
102
00:10:17.090 --> 00:10:21.929
gives the BBC visit another purpose. If the family could
103
00:10:22.029 --> 00:10:25.759
simply leave the building behind, it would not need a
104
00:10:26.259 --> 00:10:32.019
national television investigation to come through the door. The BBC
105
00:10:32.059 --> 00:10:36.580
had also called it drama. The Radio Times described a
106
00:10:36.879 --> 00:10:42.139
Halloween drama and named its makers. BBC One introduced it
107
00:10:42.200 --> 00:10:47.100
within the Screen One drama strand. A writing credit identifies
108
00:10:47.460 --> 00:10:52.279
Stephen Volk. The film did not arrive secretly in the
109
00:10:52.320 --> 00:10:57.440
news schedule, but the opening passed and Sarah remained in
110
00:10:57.480 --> 00:11:02.230
the house. A viewer switching on afterward would find a
111
00:11:02.370 --> 00:11:08.250
recognizable broadcaster talking to a family about a problem. A
112
00:11:08.309 --> 00:11:13.879
child could recognize Sarah long before knowing what Screen 1
113
00:11:13.879 --> 00:11:18.860
even meant. Someone who understood the framing could still settle
114
00:11:18.919 --> 00:11:25.159
into the pleasure of following a convincing investigation. That is
115
00:11:25.220 --> 00:11:30.399
where Ghostwatch begins tightening its hold. It gives the audience
116
00:11:30.879 --> 00:11:38.350
a job. Listen to Pamela. Examine Pascoe's material. Decide whether
117
00:11:38.450 --> 00:11:41.830
Parkinson is right to doubt it. Keep an eye on
118
00:11:41.870 --> 00:11:46.429
the rooms while the presenters talk. The house has already
119
00:11:46.490 --> 00:11:52.509
attracted attention before the BBC arrives. Pamela disputes the way
120
00:11:52.590 --> 00:11:57.860
the newspapers have described her family. Research tapes promise something
121
00:11:58.259 --> 00:12:02.899
more dependable than a lurid headline. The cameras appear to
122
00:12:03.039 --> 00:12:07.860
offer a chance to look for ourselves. Then the tour
123
00:12:07.940 --> 00:12:11.909
reaches the space the family has tried to close off.
124
00:12:12.870 --> 00:12:17.159
Under the stairs is a cupboard. with its door boarded shut.
125
00:12:18.179 --> 00:12:22.320
In the program, the family uses an older British term
126
00:12:22.419 --> 00:12:28.440
for such an interesting storage space, a glory hole. The
127
00:12:28.500 --> 00:12:33.399
name is less important than the boards. This is a
128
00:12:33.480 --> 00:12:37.679
place inside their own home that they no longer treat
129
00:12:37.940 --> 00:12:46.230
as ordinary storage. Kim says Pipes lives there. The camera
130
00:12:46.259 --> 00:12:50.190
can show us the door. Pamela has to explain what
131
00:12:50.309 --> 00:13:01.929
happened on the other side. Pamela's account takes the investigation
132
00:13:02.129 --> 00:13:06.809
into the cupboard without opening it. Sarah is listening in
133
00:13:06.850 --> 00:13:11.110
the same house, with the sealed space still nearby and
134
00:13:11.190 --> 00:13:16.850
the children available to questions. Pamela describes an earlier incident
135
00:13:16.970 --> 00:13:22.340
when she became trapped inside. She struck the door. Kim
136
00:13:22.429 --> 00:13:27.120
called out that pipes had arrived. Then Pamela tells Sarah
137
00:13:27.220 --> 00:13:32.460
why being locked in was only part of the terror.
138
00:13:33.139 --> 00:13:35.980
The thing is, when I was in there, I swear
139
00:13:36.019 --> 00:13:42.259
as God's my witness, I felt this man in there
140
00:13:42.759 --> 00:13:48.330
with me. and breathing right up against my face, like strong,
141
00:13:48.389 --> 00:13:52.970
like rotten cabbage. I nearly died.
142
00:13:53.870 --> 00:13:58.090
Now the opening is sealed, but the family still has
143
00:13:58.129 --> 00:14:02.279
to walk past it. The staircase remains part of the
144
00:14:02.340 --> 00:14:06.700
daily route through the house. Sarah and the crew have
145
00:14:06.759 --> 00:14:12.460
brought equipment, lights, and witnesses. None of those things changes
146
00:14:12.559 --> 00:14:18.039
where the cupboard is. Pascoe has been investigating the early
147
00:14:18.159 --> 00:14:23.480
family for months within the story. She brings recordings and
148
00:14:23.600 --> 00:14:28.799
photographs into the studio, giving the night's activity a history.
149
00:14:29.639 --> 00:14:33.940
There are earlier claims to compare against anything the new
150
00:14:34.019 --> 00:14:39.230
cameras happen to catch. A local television interview shows Kim
151
00:14:39.330 --> 00:14:44.529
talking about pipes. Newspaper clippings put the family into print.
152
00:14:45.399 --> 00:14:50.590
one photograph appears to show the girls suspended above their beds.
153
00:14:51.409 --> 00:14:55.750
It recalls an image from the real Enfield Poltergeist case,
154
00:14:56.450 --> 00:15:01.799
beginning in 1977, claims from another North London council house,
155
00:15:02.399 --> 00:15:07.720
centered on a mother and her children, with knocking, moving objects,
156
00:15:07.940 --> 00:15:12.519
and a girl said to speak in a rough male voice.
157
00:15:13.470 --> 00:15:20.110
Investigators and skeptics disagreed about the evidence, including incidents associated
158
00:15:20.169 --> 00:15:26.200
with trickery. That disputed case supplied a model for Ghostwatch.
159
00:15:27.000 --> 00:15:31.220
The fictional Early family was not the Enfield family under
160
00:15:31.480 --> 00:15:36.679
new names, and the film established nothing paranormal about the
161
00:15:36.740 --> 00:15:42.830
real case. What it borrowed was a troubling situation. Ordinary
162
00:15:42.909 --> 00:15:47.970
domestic life becoming a spectacle while outsiders argued over whether
163
00:15:48.009 --> 00:15:52.899
the people inside were telling the truth. The resemblance gives
164
00:15:53.000 --> 00:15:58.919
Pamela's newspaper clippings an uncomfortable weight. Public attention has not
165
00:15:59.360 --> 00:16:04.340
solved her family's problem. It's just given strangers the ability
166
00:16:04.440 --> 00:16:10.100
to judge her. Sarah can ask a sympathetic question while
167
00:16:10.139 --> 00:16:15.529
the same camera carries Pamela into another round of scrutiny.
168
00:16:16.389 --> 00:16:22.450
Parkinson keeps asking what the material proves. Pascoe sees a pattern.
169
00:16:23.450 --> 00:16:29.970
He wants a convincing example. A skeptical expert, Dr. Emilio Silvestri,
170
00:16:30.509 --> 00:16:35.029
joins by satellite from New York and challenges her conclusions.
171
00:16:35.870 --> 00:16:39.710
There's room in this investigation for someone who thinks the
172
00:16:39.750 --> 00:16:45.929
haunting is Nonsense. Then there's someone near the bedroom curtain.
173
00:16:47.289 --> 00:16:51.529
The picture does not stop to introduce him. A pale
174
00:16:51.690 --> 00:16:55.429
human shape occupies the edge of a room where the
175
00:16:55.470 --> 00:17:01.700
camera's attention belongs elsewhere. It could be missed completely. It
176
00:17:01.789 --> 00:17:06.079
could catch the eye just before the picture moves away.
177
00:17:06.859 --> 00:17:12.039
The program allows that moment to remain unsettled If you
178
00:17:12.140 --> 00:17:16.000
notice the shape, you have something to wait for. An
179
00:17:16.059 --> 00:17:20.960
acknowledgement from Sarah. A question from Parkinson. A reason for
180
00:17:21.019 --> 00:17:27.519
a man to be standing there. The presenters continue. Calls
181
00:17:27.599 --> 00:17:32.529
eventually bring the sighting into the studio. People watching, the
182
00:17:32.569 --> 00:17:38.130
program tells us, have seen a figure. Parkinson and Pascoe
183
00:17:38.750 --> 00:17:44.420
examine the pictures again. Here, surely, is the useful part
184
00:17:44.500 --> 00:17:50.690
of having everything on tape. Go back. Find the right moment.
185
00:17:51.170 --> 00:17:57.049
Show everyone what was there. The second look refuses to
186
00:17:57.130 --> 00:18:03.279
settle it. On the replay, the figure is gone. The
187
00:18:03.359 --> 00:18:09.640
studio's uncertainty leaves the original glimpse hanging over the next scene.
188
00:18:10.769 --> 00:18:14.769
Anyone who saw it has to decide whether the experts
189
00:18:14.869 --> 00:18:21.029
missed something or whether there was nothing to see. This
190
00:18:21.130 --> 00:18:26.789
is where director Leslie Manning's choice of videotape earns its keep.
191
00:18:27.690 --> 00:18:33.440
The image has the softness and practical limitations associated with
192
00:18:33.559 --> 00:18:39.559
contemporary television. It does not offer a beautifully lit monster.
193
00:18:40.279 --> 00:18:44.059
for inspection. A face at the limit of the picture
194
00:18:44.140 --> 00:18:49.269
can dissolve into fabric or noise before the eye finishes
195
00:18:49.349 --> 00:18:55.410
its work. That roughness was deliberate. Manning came from the
196
00:18:55.450 --> 00:19:02.079
BBC's film department, but she wanted Ghostwatch to resemble factual television.
197
00:19:02.720 --> 00:19:06.500
Shooting it like a conventional movie would have warned the
198
00:19:06.640 --> 00:19:11.819
audience with every frame how to interpret it. On tape,
199
00:19:12.400 --> 00:19:16.880
a badly placed camera could look like an unfortunate limitation
200
00:19:16.960 --> 00:19:21.869
of the investigation. Now viewers have a reason to search
201
00:19:21.970 --> 00:19:28.630
those limitations. A corner that seemed unimportant becomes worth watching.
202
00:19:29.170 --> 00:19:33.069
The curtain remains in the room even when somebody mentions it.
203
00:19:33.910 --> 00:19:38.660
Sarah can be asking a perfectly sensible question. while the
204
00:19:38.799 --> 00:19:44.789
audience examines the space behind her. Then the equipment catches
205
00:19:44.880 --> 00:19:53.630
something much easier to explain. Banging. starts upstairs. Sarah prepares
206
00:19:53.710 --> 00:19:58.539
to investigate. The closed circuit views reveal Suzanne getting out
207
00:19:58.579 --> 00:20:02.740
of bed and Pasco discovering that the girl has been
208
00:20:03.319 --> 00:20:08.859
striking the pipes herself. For a moment, the cameras work
209
00:20:09.039 --> 00:20:14.829
exactly As promised, they find the hidden action behind the
210
00:20:15.289 --> 00:20:20.049
frightening sound. There's a person making the noise, and that
211
00:20:20.170 --> 00:20:24.809
person is one of the children whose experiences the adults
212
00:20:24.869 --> 00:20:31.000
have been trying to explain. Parkinson can relax into his skepticism.
213
00:20:31.559 --> 00:20:36.980
Pascoe has a much more awkward evening ahead. Whatever else
214
00:20:37.099 --> 00:20:41.009
she believes has happened, She now has to account for
215
00:20:41.049 --> 00:20:47.250
the incident the program has just exposed. The revelation changes
216
00:20:47.309 --> 00:20:52.390
how the audience watches Suzanne. It also creates a problem
217
00:20:52.470 --> 00:20:58.339
that cannot be solved by staring at her face. One-stage
218
00:20:58.420 --> 00:21:04.339
disturbance is evidence about that disturbance. Does it explain the
219
00:21:04.819 --> 00:21:08.980
other claims? Has she been making all of the noises?
220
00:21:09.779 --> 00:21:15.400
Why produce a trick while cameras are watching? The film
221
00:21:15.500 --> 00:21:19.880
doesn't need to answer every question. An exposed fake has
222
00:21:19.960 --> 00:21:25.599
already given doubt something solid to hold on to. The
223
00:21:25.660 --> 00:21:29.069
viewer who has been resisting the ghost can enjoy a
224
00:21:29.109 --> 00:21:34.569
little vindication. The viewer who saw the figure has to
225
00:21:34.609 --> 00:21:40.500
fit that glimpse around the new evidence. And Sarah is
226
00:21:40.599 --> 00:21:46.319
still upstairs with the children. There's no triumphal departure, no
227
00:21:46.700 --> 00:21:51.980
crew packing the cameras away because the evening has become pointless.
228
00:21:52.799 --> 00:22:00.809
The investigation continues. The cupboard stays boarded. The bedroom still
229
00:22:00.890 --> 00:22:07.730
contains places a camera cannot show clearly. Sounds of cats
230
00:22:07.869 --> 00:22:12.289
begin troubling the people in the house. They cannot locate
231
00:22:12.349 --> 00:22:16.930
the animals that ought to be making them. Later, Suzanne
232
00:22:16.990 --> 00:22:22.059
is found unconscious with marks across her face. The child
233
00:22:22.140 --> 00:22:26.579
caught making the noise has become the child the adults
234
00:22:27.299 --> 00:22:32.099
need to help. Reasonable doubt gave everyone a way to
235
00:22:33.009 --> 00:22:48.799
feel safer. The next picture takes that comfort away. The
236
00:22:48.880 --> 00:22:53.920
sounds have no convenient source. Sarah and the crew can
237
00:22:54.000 --> 00:22:57.559
hear the cats, but finding where the noise comes from
238
00:22:57.680 --> 00:23:03.660
proves harder than finding Suzanne at the pipes. The cameras
239
00:23:03.759 --> 00:23:08.819
now have an injured child to show Concern for her
240
00:23:08.960 --> 00:23:14.160
competes with the investigation's original purpose. A few minutes earlier,
241
00:23:14.259 --> 00:23:20.019
catching somebody making a noise seemed like progress. Now establishing
242
00:23:20.160 --> 00:23:27.640
exactly what happened is less urgent than keeping the girls safe. Outside,
243
00:23:28.069 --> 00:23:35.109
the street interviews grow darker. Neighbors describe violence and disappearances
244
00:23:35.609 --> 00:23:40.279
associated with the area. A local spiritualist tells of an
245
00:23:40.460 --> 00:23:46.019
unsuccessful attempt to help the family. The Halloween crowd is
246
00:23:46.079 --> 00:23:50.359
still there, but its chatter no longer supplies the same
247
00:23:50.900 --> 00:23:56.579
light relief. Each account adds another piece to a story
248
00:23:57.019 --> 00:24:03.369
the presenters cannot finish assembling. Someone knows something about the house.
249
00:24:04.049 --> 00:24:08.650
Someone has heard another version. a voice reaches the studio
250
00:24:08.730 --> 00:24:13.819
before anyone can go and check its claims. The film's
251
00:24:13.900 --> 00:24:19.019
callers have been scripted and recorded, of course. They're actors
252
00:24:19.160 --> 00:24:24.319
contributing to the plot, not people interrupting the finished production.
253
00:24:25.259 --> 00:24:31.829
Alongside transmission, however, a real BBC telephone service is operating.
254
00:24:32.670 --> 00:24:36.359
Viewers can use the familiar number on their screens to
255
00:24:36.430 --> 00:24:41.519
reach a message explaining the fiction and leave ghost stories
256
00:24:42.039 --> 00:24:47.700
of their own. Those two systems sit remarkably close together.
257
00:24:48.680 --> 00:24:52.690
Inside the film, a caller may know the missing name.
258
00:24:53.470 --> 00:24:57.470
Outside it, a viewer may be dialing because the same
259
00:24:57.569 --> 00:25:03.400
room has just supplied a shadow nobody seems able to explain.
260
00:25:04.569 --> 00:25:07.930
From the sofa, the telephone appears to offer a way
261
00:25:08.019 --> 00:25:12.380
into the investigation. It also gives the story a way
262
00:25:12.500 --> 00:25:18.079
to make a revelation without looking as though it was arranged.
263
00:25:19.200 --> 00:25:23.940
A caller can hesitate, wander through an account, or remember
264
00:25:24.000 --> 00:25:29.859
something the expert doesn't know. Information seems to arrive because
265
00:25:30.279 --> 00:25:34.849
an ordinary person has decided that it matters. As the
266
00:25:34.990 --> 00:25:41.000
evening's calls gradually piece together the cupboard's history, one of
267
00:25:41.059 --> 00:25:46.500
the names that comes through is Raymond Tunstall. These details
268
00:25:46.559 --> 00:25:50.700
arrive in stages interrupted by the activity at the house.
269
00:25:51.440 --> 00:25:56.269
In the drama's invented history, Tunstall was a former resident
270
00:25:56.440 --> 00:26:00.730
and a convicted child abuser. He claimed that a dead
271
00:26:00.809 --> 00:26:05.430
woman's spirit could take him over. Her story also supplied
272
00:26:05.529 --> 00:26:11.569
through the calls, involved the deaths of children. Tunstall later
273
00:26:11.670 --> 00:26:18.609
died by suicide inside the cupboard, with cats trapped there
274
00:26:18.690 --> 00:26:23.549
beside his body. The sounds in the walls have acquired
275
00:26:23.609 --> 00:26:28.170
an explanation, and it is far worse than the noise.
276
00:26:28.970 --> 00:26:32.799
Pipes begins to seem less like a single intruder with
277
00:26:32.859 --> 00:26:38.740
a name, and more like several ugly stories speaking through
278
00:26:38.819 --> 00:26:44.660
the same presence. The cupboard connects them. So do the children.
279
00:26:45.500 --> 00:26:50.880
Sarah entered the house to investigate disturbances. The information reaching
280
00:26:50.920 --> 00:26:56.990
the studio now places those disturbances inside a history of harm.
281
00:26:58.009 --> 00:27:04.089
The mythology's sensational associations belong to horror writing, not a
282
00:27:04.190 --> 00:27:09.890
diagnosis of a real person or evidence of possession. The
283
00:27:09.950 --> 00:27:14.720
callers have made the little boarded door much harder to dismiss.
284
00:27:15.460 --> 00:27:20.359
The adults try to keep up. Parkinson has pictures and
285
00:27:20.519 --> 00:27:26.019
testimony arriving from different places. Pascoe has to interpret them.
286
00:27:26.559 --> 00:27:29.900
Sarah has to move through the house itself, where a
287
00:27:29.960 --> 00:27:34.039
decision can no longer wait for the studio to finish
288
00:27:34.200 --> 00:27:40.920
discussing it. That separation was meticulously constructed. Manning recorded the
289
00:27:40.960 --> 00:27:47.029
location material before the studio scenes. The presenters later watched
290
00:27:47.119 --> 00:27:52.269
prepared sequences and timed their responses so that images from
291
00:27:52.410 --> 00:27:58.589
another day seemed to have arrived seconds earlier. For one exchange,
292
00:27:58.650 --> 00:28:03.819
the production made the timing stranger still. Pamela was shown
293
00:28:03.940 --> 00:28:08.849
leaving the house for a mobile studio. Later, Brennan sat
294
00:28:08.950 --> 00:28:12.269
out of sight at the studio recording and answered the
295
00:28:12.309 --> 00:28:17.380
presenters there. The apparent distance between them had been invented,
296
00:28:18.160 --> 00:28:23.079
but they could react to one another's actual conversation. That
297
00:28:23.180 --> 00:28:27.420
method is important at this stage because the cast rarely
298
00:28:27.519 --> 00:28:32.990
looks as though everyone possesses the same script. Someone is
299
00:28:33.089 --> 00:28:39.190
always receiving information from somebody else. A presenter can misunderstand
300
00:28:39.250 --> 00:28:45.460
a situation without seeming foolish. The necessary picture simply hasn't
301
00:28:45.539 --> 00:28:51.240
arrived yet. Manning also put working camera and sound personnel
302
00:28:51.740 --> 00:28:55.559
in front of the lens. When Sarah moves through a
303
00:28:55.640 --> 00:29:01.609
cramped room, the crew has to negotiate it with her. Bodies, cables,
304
00:29:01.710 --> 00:29:08.230
and equipment occupy space. There's no invisible observer floating ahead
305
00:29:08.369 --> 00:29:13.650
to obtain a perfect view of the threat. Small fixed
306
00:29:13.730 --> 00:29:19.099
cameras supply views from inside the rooms. The roving operator
307
00:29:19.230 --> 00:29:25.960
offers a different perspective, close to Sarah's movements. Switching between
308
00:29:26.019 --> 00:29:29.779
them can reveal something one observer missed or missed. leave
309
00:29:29.839 --> 00:29:36.089
the studio choosing between incomplete pictures. As the action becomes
310
00:29:36.210 --> 00:29:42.269
more dangerous, that physical limitation begins. to hurt. A camera
311
00:29:42.329 --> 00:29:47.019
can follow Sarah or search the space she's indicated. It
312
00:29:47.059 --> 00:29:52.279
cannot do both at once. A frightened response may register
313
00:29:52.359 --> 00:29:56.839
before the lens reaches whatever caused it. Turning toward a
314
00:29:56.900 --> 00:30:01.099
door means turning away from the people behind the operator.
315
00:30:01.880 --> 00:30:06.000
A figure can occupy the picture without becoming the subject
316
00:30:06.480 --> 00:30:11.380
of the shot. Pipes has not confined himself to the curtain.
317
00:30:12.009 --> 00:30:14.950
The film places him at the edges of its action,
318
00:30:15.309 --> 00:30:18.890
where a viewer may notice something the people searching the
319
00:30:18.930 --> 00:30:26.369
house don't discuss. Looking for him becomes almost involuntary. It
320
00:30:26.440 --> 00:30:30.190
also means looking away from the people who need help.
321
00:30:31.230 --> 00:30:36.009
Then the disturbances stop leaving so much room for debate.
322
00:30:36.650 --> 00:30:41.130
A picture frame falls and breaks. Sarah glimpses someone behind
323
00:30:41.190 --> 00:30:45.289
a door, but the camera finds no one there when
324
00:30:45.349 --> 00:30:50.359
it turns. A mirror falls and strikes the sound recordist.
325
00:30:50.730 --> 00:30:55.980
The crew is now involved, the people supposedly documenting the danger.
326
00:30:56.819 --> 00:31:02.700
have become vulnerable to it. Suzanne cowers behind furniture. When
327
00:31:02.740 --> 00:31:06.200
the adults try to reach her, the answer comes in
328
00:31:06.220 --> 00:31:09.529
the harsh voice associated with pipes.
329
00:31:10.200 --> 00:31:16.049
Suzanne, listen to me, Susie. Susie, can you hear me?
330
00:31:17.150 --> 00:31:18.329
Suzanne, do you hear me?
331
00:31:18.349 --> 00:31:18.549
Yes.
332
00:31:19.930 --> 00:31:20.950
Yes, get out.
333
00:31:21.950 --> 00:31:23.029
Get out if you don't want to be here.
334
00:31:23.910 --> 00:31:24.549
I don't care.
335
00:31:25.349 --> 00:31:26.170
You just mess things up.
336
00:31:27.509 --> 00:31:28.609
You mess everything up.
337
00:31:30.589 --> 00:31:31.119
I hate you.
338
00:31:31.839 --> 00:31:37.839
The family's departure cannot happen cleanly. The house keeps supplying
339
00:31:37.920 --> 00:31:42.680
another problem before the last one can be resolved. Parkinson
340
00:31:42.740 --> 00:31:47.380
and Mike Smith receive fragments of that emergency while remaining
341
00:31:47.819 --> 00:31:52.319
unable to reach through the monitor and help. Then the
342
00:31:52.380 --> 00:31:57.029
pictures change. Sarah and the girls appear in the living room.
343
00:31:57.779 --> 00:32:02.759
The violent interruption seems to have passed. Everyone on the
344
00:32:02.819 --> 00:32:07.819
screen looks safer than they did a moment ago. For
345
00:32:07.859 --> 00:32:11.309
the first time in a while, the studio has something
346
00:32:11.789 --> 00:32:26.339
reassuring to watch. Pascoe keeps looking. There's something wrong with
347
00:32:26.400 --> 00:32:31.130
the calmer picture. An object broken during the disturbance is
348
00:32:31.769 --> 00:32:36.500
intact again. The room has recovered something it should have lost.
349
00:32:37.259 --> 00:32:41.339
Sarah and the children may appear to be safe... but
350
00:32:41.420 --> 00:32:47.059
Pasco recognizes that the images are from earlier in the evening.
351
00:32:48.009 --> 00:32:54.170
The pictures have come back. The present has not. Until now,
352
00:32:54.269 --> 00:32:57.589
the studio could turn to the house... whenever it needed
353
00:32:57.670 --> 00:33:02.230
to know what was happening there. A bad angle was frustrating,
354
00:33:02.309 --> 00:33:07.819
but another camera might help. A disputed sighting could be replayed.
355
00:33:08.440 --> 00:33:12.140
Even an interrupted link belonged to a familiar category of
356
00:33:12.680 --> 00:33:19.380
television technical difficulties. This is different. The screen is offering
357
00:33:19.440 --> 00:33:25.000
an old moment as a new one. Sarah's reassuring presence...
358
00:33:24.950 --> 00:33:30.009
no longer establishes where she is or whether anyone can
359
00:33:30.089 --> 00:33:34.250
reach her. Mike Smith has to watch his wife through
360
00:33:34.309 --> 00:33:38.319
that picture. He cannot step into the hallway, ask her
361
00:33:38.680 --> 00:33:42.920
what happened, or go looking for the girls. The film
362
00:33:42.960 --> 00:33:45.880
has left him in the place where the audience is sitting,
363
00:33:46.519 --> 00:33:50.839
close enough to see a familiar face, too far away
364
00:33:51.519 --> 00:33:56.619
to help it. Pascoe arrives at an explanation for the
365
00:33:57.079 --> 00:34:01.940
spreading disturbances. By bringing cameras into the early house and
366
00:34:02.299 --> 00:34:07.369
carrying its story into millions of homes, the program has
367
00:34:07.430 --> 00:34:13.670
assembled something it never intended to assemble. A national seance.
368
00:34:15.110 --> 00:34:19.519
The viewer's attention has become part of the event. Calls
369
00:34:19.579 --> 00:34:23.889
have brought more voices into it. Television sets have carried
370
00:34:23.929 --> 00:34:29.170
the house into rooms across the country. In Pascoe's account,
371
00:34:29.769 --> 00:34:37.360
investigating pipes has increased his reach. The apparently helpful machinery
372
00:34:37.409 --> 00:34:41.079
has done the work of joining them together. Even a
373
00:34:41.139 --> 00:34:45.860
television set far from London belongs to the network Pascoe
374
00:34:45.940 --> 00:34:50.039
is describing. Getting the family out of the house will not,
375
00:34:50.599 --> 00:34:57.230
in her explanation... undo those connections. Reports of activity spread.
376
00:34:57.670 --> 00:35:01.969
The studio's map no longer looks like a distant catalog
377
00:35:02.030 --> 00:35:07.469
of other people's experiences. Its growing reach becomes the scale
378
00:35:07.530 --> 00:35:11.909
of the problem. Pasco can describe what has happened, but
379
00:35:11.949 --> 00:35:16.469
an explanation does not provide a way to reverse it.
380
00:35:17.800 --> 00:35:22.230
The house is being evacuated. Pamela, Kim, and the injured
381
00:35:22.329 --> 00:35:27.349
sound recordist get out while Sarah keeps searching for Suzanne.
382
00:35:28.070 --> 00:35:31.929
The family that occupied the center of the investigation has
383
00:35:31.989 --> 00:35:36.860
been separated by the effort to escape it. Sarah cannot
384
00:35:36.960 --> 00:35:41.539
complete her part of that departure while a child remains missing.
385
00:35:42.380 --> 00:35:46.980
The cupboard beneath the stairs has become the center of
386
00:35:47.019 --> 00:35:53.480
the emergency. And she goes toward it. The camera follows
387
00:35:53.579 --> 00:35:58.280
the search instead of joining the people leaving. The film
388
00:35:58.420 --> 00:36:03.059
keeps us inside with her. The audience has been carrying
389
00:36:03.119 --> 00:36:08.400
Pamela's account of that enclosed space since the beginning. Now
390
00:36:08.480 --> 00:36:13.760
the reporter who listened to it reaches into the cupboard herself.
391
00:36:15.400 --> 00:36:19.510
The door slams. Cats cry out on the soundtrack, The
392
00:36:19.550 --> 00:36:24.210
connection fails before the studio can establish what has happened
393
00:36:24.670 --> 00:36:30.230
to her. Sarah's disappearance leaves an absence that no other
394
00:36:30.329 --> 00:36:35.679
camera repairs. The program has used her warmth to make
395
00:36:35.719 --> 00:36:40.119
the house approachable. Without her, the people at the end
396
00:36:40.159 --> 00:36:43.800
of The Other Link have lost their guide as well
397
00:36:43.860 --> 00:36:48.579
as their colleague. Smith's wife is somewhere beyond the picture.
398
00:36:49.809 --> 00:36:54.690
Then the studio begins to fail around him. Wind moves
399
00:36:54.769 --> 00:36:59.849
through the enclosed broadcasting space. Papers lift. Lights die. The
400
00:36:59.909 --> 00:37:03.239
monitors return fragments of the evening, but the people working
401
00:37:03.300 --> 00:37:06.679
among them are losing the ability to tell the audience
402
00:37:07.639 --> 00:37:11.900
what they are seeing. The room that has been explaining
403
00:37:11.940 --> 00:37:16.940
the house now needs an explanation of its own. Crew
404
00:37:17.000 --> 00:37:23.519
members disappear, into the darkness. Parkinson tries to continue. His
405
00:37:23.599 --> 00:37:27.739
composure has served the film for most of the evening.
406
00:37:28.719 --> 00:37:33.550
An observation, a skeptical question, a small joke while another
407
00:37:33.769 --> 00:37:38.369
item is being prepared. Those habits offer little help when
408
00:37:38.409 --> 00:37:42.829
there's nobody left to prepare the next item. He cannot
409
00:37:43.050 --> 00:37:46.849
even be certain which camera is working or whether an
410
00:37:47.010 --> 00:37:52.139
audience remains at the other end. He keeps describing the studio,
411
00:37:52.559 --> 00:37:57.280
trying to turn the failure into a report. The equipment
412
00:37:57.360 --> 00:38:00.659
is still around him, but the people who normally make
413
00:38:00.719 --> 00:38:05.400
it useful are gone. Every attempt to address the audience
414
00:38:05.800 --> 00:38:12.409
leaves him speaking into that uncertainty. He turns toward the autocue.
415
00:38:13.989 --> 00:38:20.230
The teleprompter offers him a Familiar children's rhyme. A piece
416
00:38:20.309 --> 00:38:26.000
of equipment has finally given him something to say. He
417
00:38:26.059 --> 00:38:31.900
looks toward the waiting words. He begins to recite it.
418
00:38:32.679 --> 00:38:38.630
Round and round the garden, like a teddy bear. Tiffany's
419
00:38:38.650 --> 00:38:43.630
a story of a son of tissue.
420
00:38:43.929 --> 00:38:44.610
Viva!
421
00:38:44.710 --> 00:38:45.070
Viva!
422
00:38:49.190 --> 00:38:53.750
The trusted presenter is still facing the camera, but the
423
00:38:53.809 --> 00:38:59.780
voice now belongs to the threat the crew went looking for. Then,
424
00:39:00.800 --> 00:39:07.340
Ghostwatch ends. There is no rescue scene after the cupboard.
425
00:39:07.659 --> 00:39:12.269
The film does not take Sarah outside, reunite her with Smith,
426
00:39:12.409 --> 00:39:18.280
or let Parkinson return with an explanation. Within its fiction,
427
00:39:18.820 --> 00:39:24.260
the final image is defeat. The investigation has carried the
428
00:39:24.320 --> 00:39:29.829
danger farther than the people conducting it understood. The credits roll.
429
00:39:30.329 --> 00:39:34.630
providing the cast and production information that belongs to a
430
00:39:35.530 --> 00:39:40.730
television drama. But they do not offer the emotional relief
431
00:39:40.880 --> 00:39:45.219
of seeing the endangered people step out of character together
432
00:39:45.320 --> 00:39:50.489
and take a bow. BBC continuity moves to Match of
433
00:39:50.530 --> 00:39:55.590
the day. That is an ordinary transition in the schedule.
434
00:39:56.469 --> 00:40:04.239
After 91 minutes of invented catastrophe, football is next. Anyone
435
00:40:04.300 --> 00:40:07.820
who has been enjoying the program as a horror film
436
00:40:08.019 --> 00:40:13.199
can appreciate the audacity of leaving it there. For a
437
00:40:13.260 --> 00:40:17.610
viewer who still believes some part of the emergency, the
438
00:40:17.690 --> 00:40:22.920
change is imminent. harder to follow. A familiar reporter appears
439
00:40:23.000 --> 00:40:27.599
to be missing. The studio has apparently been overwhelmed. Now
440
00:40:27.699 --> 00:40:32.719
the same channel is discussing what comes next on television.
441
00:40:33.739 --> 00:40:37.590
The audience has no shared final moment in which Parkinson
442
00:40:37.670 --> 00:40:42.550
explains the trick. Every household has to make its own adjustment.
443
00:40:43.690 --> 00:40:47.869
Some have already made it. Others are still working through
444
00:40:47.949 --> 00:40:53.139
what the ending has asked them to accept, and a
445
00:40:53.179 --> 00:40:59.639
telephone number has been available all evening. People begin trying
446
00:40:59.699 --> 00:41:04.519
to reach the BBC. The makers have finished their ghost story,
447
00:41:04.599 --> 00:41:07.900
but they're about to discover that the end of the
448
00:41:07.980 --> 00:41:19.800
film is not the end of the night's events. At
449
00:41:19.860 --> 00:41:23.519
a gathering in Chiswick, members of the cast and production
450
00:41:23.579 --> 00:41:28.619
team watched their finished work go out. Sarah Green's disappearance
451
00:41:28.679 --> 00:41:34.219
had been a performance. Parkinson's final transformation had been rehearsed.
452
00:41:34.719 --> 00:41:38.219
The people responsible for the nightmare were together on the
453
00:41:38.280 --> 00:41:42.599
other side of it. The terrible voice had a thoroughly
454
00:41:42.699 --> 00:41:48.489
human source. Manning herself supplied pipes guttural sound after another
455
00:41:48.809 --> 00:41:52.329
Recording had failed to give her the effect she wanted.
456
00:41:53.809 --> 00:41:57.250
The people who made this ending knew exactly how it
457
00:41:57.289 --> 00:42:01.309
had been assembled. The audience receiving it had to find
458
00:42:01.429 --> 00:42:07.559
its way back without their company. Producer Ruth Baumgarten was elsewhere,
459
00:42:07.980 --> 00:42:12.179
monitoring the response from the BBC. Her absence left the
460
00:42:12.219 --> 00:42:15.920
gathering with a little distance from the audience it had
461
00:42:15.980 --> 00:42:20.469
just reached. For Stephen Volk, The night was the end
462
00:42:20.530 --> 00:42:23.670
of years of hard work. It had begun with a
463
00:42:23.710 --> 00:42:29.449
proposal sent to Baumgarten in 1988, a supernatural serial about
464
00:42:29.550 --> 00:42:35.250
an investigation of a contemporary haunted house. Conventional dramatic episodes
465
00:42:35.289 --> 00:42:40.289
would establish the characters and their own world. An apparent
466
00:42:40.389 --> 00:42:45.699
live broadcast would provide the climax. The BBC did not
467
00:42:45.800 --> 00:42:50.869
commit to that series. Baumgarten asked whether the idea could
468
00:42:50.909 --> 00:42:57.300
become one 90-minute film for Screen 1. Volk's solution was
469
00:42:57.380 --> 00:43:00.480
to build the whole thing around the broadcast that had
470
00:43:00.559 --> 00:43:05.699
originally belonged at the end. That decision removed the earlier
471
00:43:05.829 --> 00:43:09.150
episodes in which an audience would have learned who the
472
00:43:09.190 --> 00:43:15.360
characters were. Viewers would enter directly into the special. Everything
473
00:43:15.400 --> 00:43:18.400
needed to make the family seem established had to be
474
00:43:18.480 --> 00:43:24.099
supplied inside it. The research footage, newspaper articles, interviews, and
475
00:43:24.420 --> 00:43:30.289
recollections of events that supposedly happened before the cameras arrived.
476
00:43:31.130 --> 00:43:35.670
Those artifacts gave the film a past. The broadcasters gave
477
00:43:35.710 --> 00:43:39.949
it a present. A broader proposal involving reports from around
478
00:43:40.010 --> 00:43:45.639
the country narrowed to one household. Manning helped make that
479
00:43:45.960 --> 00:43:52.369
concentration possible. Instead of introducing another location, whenever the drama
480
00:43:52.429 --> 00:43:56.230
needed to expand, the film could make the same staircase
481
00:43:57.130 --> 00:44:02.610
even more dangerous. Volk drew on television forms that already
482
00:44:02.730 --> 00:44:10.090
mixed reconstruction with factual presentation. Crime Watch and 999 brought
483
00:44:10.170 --> 00:44:15.219
recreated events into programs that associated with real people and
484
00:44:15.320 --> 00:44:20.739
real emergencies. Nigel Neal's The Stone Tape offered a ghost
485
00:44:20.800 --> 00:44:26.340
story in which technology helped shape the encounter. Infrared coverage
486
00:44:26.380 --> 00:44:31.380
from the Gulf War supplied another recognizable way of seeing
487
00:44:31.460 --> 00:44:36.780
through darkness. None of those ingredients required a viewer to
488
00:44:36.820 --> 00:44:43.769
believe in ghosts. Only familiarity with television. The production could
489
00:44:43.849 --> 00:44:49.110
borrow a format the audience understood, then make something impossible
490
00:44:49.690 --> 00:44:54.570
happen inside. The national séance reached back to another of
491
00:44:54.650 --> 00:45:00.280
Volk's inspirations, the Canadian experiment in which a group invented
492
00:45:00.340 --> 00:45:06.000
a ghost called Philip, concentrated on his biography, and reported
493
00:45:06.079 --> 00:45:12.639
activity during séances. Whatever one makes of those disputed claims...
494
00:45:12.619 --> 00:45:18.050
their dramatic possibility is unsettling. People can gather around a
495
00:45:18.130 --> 00:45:22.730
story they created and begin to experience it as something
496
00:45:22.989 --> 00:45:28.769
outside of their control. Ghostwatch enlarged that idea until its
497
00:45:28.869 --> 00:45:34.369
circle of participants included everyone receiving the broadcast. There was
498
00:45:34.449 --> 00:45:39.880
practical work behind the ease of performance. Parkinson could read
499
00:45:39.940 --> 00:45:43.480
the opening from an autocue, but Manning wanted the more
500
00:45:43.900 --> 00:45:49.539
relaxed manner of his interviews for the studio exchanges. According
501
00:45:49.619 --> 00:45:53.219
to her later account, she encouraged him to work through
502
00:45:53.300 --> 00:45:56.800
the points he needed to make instead of waiting on
503
00:45:57.139 --> 00:46:03.070
exact lines. Jillian Beavan, playing Pascoe, had to respond to
504
00:46:03.110 --> 00:46:07.690
that freedom. Her scene partner might reach the required idea
505
00:46:07.769 --> 00:46:13.110
without delivering the precise cue she expected. The exchange could
506
00:46:13.179 --> 00:46:17.579
remain faithful to the story while preserving a little uncertainty
507
00:46:18.059 --> 00:46:22.900
between the people speaking. That gave the skeptical interruptions a
508
00:46:23.059 --> 00:46:29.320
life a perfectly memorized argument might lack. Parkinson could tease
509
00:46:29.420 --> 00:46:33.590
Pascoe without sounding as though a screenwriter had assigned him
510
00:46:33.690 --> 00:46:39.860
the next skeptical sentence. Bevan could interrupt. defend the investigation
511
00:46:39.940 --> 00:46:44.269
while genuinely listening for where he was taking the conversation.
512
00:46:45.469 --> 00:46:51.969
Pipes required a different kind of performance. Keith Ferrari supplied
513
00:46:52.050 --> 00:46:55.840
the figure placed at the edge of the pictures. He
514
00:46:55.880 --> 00:46:59.940
could be present without receiving the close-up or introduction an
515
00:47:00.159 --> 00:47:05.079
actor normally expects. A small placement in a crowded image
516
00:47:05.139 --> 00:47:08.730
did more for the film than a long demonstration of
517
00:47:08.809 --> 00:47:13.260
what the ghost would look like. Manning later recalled planning
518
00:47:13.260 --> 00:47:20.699
13 glimpses, though the final count remains disputed. Additional placements
519
00:47:20.860 --> 00:47:25.800
and editing can complicate the number. That uncertainty has become
520
00:47:25.900 --> 00:47:30.099
part of the film's appeal, but the practical principle was
521
00:47:30.239 --> 00:47:35.239
simple enough. Let the audience discover something the cameras, does
522
00:47:35.300 --> 00:47:39.690
not seem to be showing on purpose. Even the Halloween
523
00:47:39.769 --> 00:47:45.190
setting involved a gamble. Volk later remembered that the transmission
524
00:47:45.230 --> 00:47:50.789
slot was not guaranteed while shooting was underway. Manning decorated
525
00:47:50.849 --> 00:47:55.010
the house for the holiday anyway. Pumpkins and apples on
526
00:47:55.130 --> 00:47:59.349
strings would look very different if the BBC postponed the
527
00:47:59.429 --> 00:48:05.260
film until December. The date held The final approach to
528
00:48:05.320 --> 00:48:11.440
transmission was still uneasy, though. According to the maker's later recollections,
529
00:48:11.860 --> 00:48:16.840
executives insisted that the drama framing and writing credit be clear.
530
00:48:17.659 --> 00:48:22.269
The resulting broadcast contained those signals. Its creators could point
531
00:48:22.309 --> 00:48:26.269
to the listing, the announcement, and the name of its writer.
532
00:48:27.090 --> 00:48:30.650
They believed they had made a ghost story whose unusual
533
00:48:30.809 --> 00:48:36.440
form an audience would recognize and enjoy. Their expectations were
534
00:48:36.539 --> 00:48:41.659
also shaped by knowing every device from the inside. A
535
00:48:41.699 --> 00:48:45.840
hidden performer was someone booked for a day. A frightening
536
00:48:45.929 --> 00:48:50.949
voice was a recording. Sarah's disappearance was a sequence the
537
00:48:51.010 --> 00:48:55.150
crew had constructed. By the time a film is finished,
538
00:48:55.789 --> 00:49:00.719
its makers have lived with its explanations for months. The
539
00:49:00.760 --> 00:49:05.139
first audience receives the explanations and the allusions in a
540
00:49:05.760 --> 00:49:12.010
different order. At Chiswick, that difference was about to become visible.
541
00:49:13.110 --> 00:49:18.110
Volk later recalled Baumgarten arriving with news that the BBC's
542
00:49:18.170 --> 00:49:22.769
telephone lines had jammed. In one account of the evening,
543
00:49:23.110 --> 00:49:29.579
he remembered initially laughing before realizing she was serious. The
544
00:49:29.659 --> 00:49:33.420
film had reached far beyond the room where the team
545
00:49:33.500 --> 00:49:36.860
was watching it. People were trying to get through to
546
00:49:36.900 --> 00:49:41.739
the institution whose presenters had They had just seen, threatened,
547
00:49:42.389 --> 00:49:48.750
and possibly worse. Whatever mixture of pleasure, outrage, and fear
548
00:49:48.909 --> 00:49:53.610
prompted those calls, it had exceeded what the production anticipated.
549
00:49:54.849 --> 00:49:59.800
On November 15th, Sue Lawley introduced the controversy on the
550
00:49:59.840 --> 00:50:05.159
BBC's Bite Back. Her recap shows how quickly the telephone
551
00:50:05.219 --> 00:50:08.320
traffic had become part of the story.
552
00:50:08.840 --> 00:50:12.800
On Halloween night, it was Ghostwatch. It may seem laughable
553
00:50:13.000 --> 00:50:15.179
now that we know it was all a spoof, but
554
00:50:15.389 --> 00:50:19.889
on Saturday, October the 31st, thousands of people weren't so sure.
555
00:50:20.789 --> 00:50:23.949
It said it was live. It said it wanted to
556
00:50:24.010 --> 00:50:27.889
show us irrefutable proof that ghosts exist. And it gave
557
00:50:27.929 --> 00:50:30.920
us a telephone number to ring with our experiences of
558
00:50:30.940 --> 00:50:34.920
the paranormal. At one point, 20,000 people were trying to
559
00:50:34.960 --> 00:50:37.059
get through to the presenter, Michael Parkinson.
560
00:50:37.690 --> 00:50:41.650
The people at the gathering could explain how every ghostly
561
00:50:41.730 --> 00:50:46.099
effect worked, but they were only beginning to find out
562
00:50:46.619 --> 00:50:58.809
what the effects had done after leaving their hands. An
563
00:50:58.889 --> 00:51:04.570
engaged telephone line gives very little information. It doesn't tell
564
00:51:04.610 --> 00:51:08.630
you why everybody else is calling. It can't say whether
565
00:51:08.670 --> 00:51:13.269
the woman you saw disappear is safely at home. It
566
00:51:13.329 --> 00:51:18.480
can't explain that the apparent studio disaster happened during a
567
00:51:18.599 --> 00:51:23.340
recording with a director deciding when to end the shot.
568
00:51:24.219 --> 00:51:29.159
For viewers trying to get reassurance after Ghostwatch, that absence
569
00:51:29.300 --> 00:51:34.969
was deafening. The program had spent the evening inviting people
570
00:51:35.030 --> 00:51:41.480
to telephone, Its fictional callers had supplied observations, personal histories,
571
00:51:41.619 --> 00:51:46.429
and reports from other houses. A real viewer making the
572
00:51:46.469 --> 00:51:50.150
same gesture could meet a line that would not answer.
573
00:51:51.130 --> 00:51:55.869
The telephone service was meant to provide an explanation. Anyone
574
00:51:55.909 --> 00:51:59.750
who connected to the advertised operation could be told that
575
00:51:59.789 --> 00:52:04.010
the program was fiction and invited to leave a ghost store.
576
00:52:04.809 --> 00:52:09.349
When the system was overwhelmed, that intended route, leaving the
577
00:52:09.409 --> 00:52:17.219
illusion behind, became unreliable. Inside the film, communications had failed
578
00:52:17.340 --> 00:52:22.019
as the haunting expanded. Outside it, too many people trying
579
00:52:22.079 --> 00:52:27.179
to use the communication system could prolong the uncertainty. No
580
00:52:27.280 --> 00:52:31.679
ghost was necessary to make the night's last coincidence unsettling.
581
00:52:32.590 --> 00:52:36.670
the volume became a story of its own. Later accounts
582
00:52:36.789 --> 00:52:44.360
offered increasingly dramatic numbers, sometimes collapsing at every attempted call, inquiry, response,
583
00:52:44.500 --> 00:52:50.460
and formal complaint into one enormous expression of terror. The
584
00:52:50.519 --> 00:52:55.610
contemporary categories were more revealing. On the November 4th edition
585
00:52:55.650 --> 00:53:00.349
of Points of View, Anne Robinson presented viewers' responses and
586
00:53:00.829 --> 00:53:07.579
the duty office tally. The reactions ranged from delight to disgust.
587
00:53:08.099 --> 00:53:09.159
Did it look convincing?
588
00:53:09.539 --> 00:53:11.150
OK, I'm not ashamed to admit it.
589
00:53:11.219 --> 00:53:13.860
Ghostwatch totally fooled me and scared me half to death.
590
00:53:13.969 --> 00:53:16.090
I've never been so terrified in my whole life. So
591
00:53:16.110 --> 00:53:17.650
has Linda Beach of Liverpool and.
592
00:53:17.829 --> 00:53:18.789
Absolutely brilliant.
593
00:53:18.869 --> 00:53:20.349
So has Richard Stewart of Brentwood.
594
00:53:20.570 --> 00:53:22.750
My wife and I sat riveted to our seat, believing
595
00:53:22.769 --> 00:53:23.889
it was all truly happening.
596
00:53:24.210 --> 00:53:26.449
I'm so pleased we didn't spoil the illusion in advance
597
00:53:26.489 --> 00:53:28.829
by looking in the radio times and realising.
598
00:53:28.380 --> 00:53:28.949
It was a spook.
599
00:53:29.340 --> 00:53:31.980
Or, if you prefer, MP Parker of Dorset. An arrogant
600
00:53:32.019 --> 00:53:35.280
and clumsy dissection of the paranormal. Prejudice for the trivial
601
00:53:35.340 --> 00:53:37.480
purpose of providing family entertainment.
602
00:53:37.679 --> 00:53:38.619
A sick joke.
603
00:53:39.000 --> 00:53:40.699
And for the record, there were on the night a
604
00:53:40.760 --> 00:53:45.139
total of 835 calls to the duty office. 382 viewers
605
00:53:45.199 --> 00:53:47.070
rang to say it was an insult to their intelligence.
606
00:53:47.070 --> 00:53:48.909
275 thought it in poor taste. Another 62 just had
607
00:53:48.949 --> 00:53:50.530
a general moan. And 116 rang to say they thoroughly
608
00:53:50.550 --> 00:53:50.929
enjoyed it.
609
00:53:56.809 --> 00:54:05.340
The Broadcasting Standards Council later recorded 35 formal complaints. Lawley's 20,000-figure
610
00:54:05.719 --> 00:54:11.420
described people trying to get through. Robinson's tally concerned calls
611
00:54:11.539 --> 00:54:16.460
to the duty office. These figures describe different channels of response.
612
00:54:17.199 --> 00:54:21.659
They can't establish how many individual viewers believed the events,
613
00:54:22.519 --> 00:54:26.219
and they can't be added together as a count of complaints.
614
00:54:27.050 --> 00:54:32.750
They do show that the reaction included enthusiasm alongside objections.
615
00:54:33.590 --> 00:54:38.949
An audience of approximately 11 million had watched. That gave
616
00:54:39.050 --> 00:54:44.110
Ghostwatch an extraordinary reach, but it did not give those
617
00:54:44.230 --> 00:54:50.769
viewers a single shared experience. Some recognized the drama immediately.
618
00:54:51.469 --> 00:54:57.260
Some were briefly uncertain. Some understood the trick and being
619
00:54:57.519 --> 00:55:02.550
subjected to it anyway. Volk later recalled a friend who
620
00:55:02.630 --> 00:55:05.789
knew he had written a drama for that evening, yet
621
00:55:05.869 --> 00:55:10.590
found Parkinson's presence so convincing that she doubted what Volk
622
00:55:10.630 --> 00:55:15.159
had told her. The anecdote is his recollection, so take
623
00:55:15.179 --> 00:55:18.440
it with a grain of salt. It captures the particular
624
00:55:18.599 --> 00:55:23.679
absurdity of this illusion. Advanced knowledge could compete with a
625
00:55:23.800 --> 00:55:29.059
familiar television face and and lose he also remembered a
626
00:55:29.119 --> 00:55:32.159
woman in a local shop telling him that her son
627
00:55:32.239 --> 00:55:35.989
would not settle to sleep until a luminous skeleton was
628
00:55:36.050 --> 00:55:41.670
removed from his bedroom door that account concerns one frightened
629
00:55:41.730 --> 00:55:46.090
child as recalled by the writer it brings the response
630
00:55:46.170 --> 00:55:49.869
down from the scale of a national switchboard to a
631
00:55:49.949 --> 00:55:57.119
recognizable household task take the decoration away so bedtime can resume.
632
00:55:57.980 --> 00:56:02.719
Others found the escalation itself reassuring. A figure in a
633
00:56:02.800 --> 00:56:08.280
curtain might belong to an investigation. A studio apparently overtaken
634
00:56:08.360 --> 00:56:12.409
by a ghost could announce the horror film more plainly.
635
00:56:13.349 --> 00:56:17.610
The point at which a viewer stopped believing would therefore vary,
636
00:56:18.210 --> 00:56:23.150
even among people watching the same images together. There was
637
00:56:23.230 --> 00:56:27.750
room for fear after recognition too, Knowing how a story
638
00:56:27.829 --> 00:56:32.150
was made did not require a viewer to enjoy walking
639
00:56:32.230 --> 00:56:38.619
past a dark staircase afterward. The public disagreement was never
640
00:56:38.780 --> 00:56:44.320
simply divided between people who understood television and people who didn't.
641
00:56:45.400 --> 00:56:48.989
Soon the producers were being asked to answer for the
642
00:56:49.030 --> 00:56:55.849
broadcast on television. Baumgarten and executive producer Richard Broke appeared
643
00:56:55.989 --> 00:56:59.730
on bite back. The format placed them in a real,
644
00:57:00.110 --> 00:57:05.789
factual studio, responding to viewers' objections about the fictional one.
645
00:57:06.630 --> 00:57:11.590
Clips of the drama became material to examine. The opening
646
00:57:11.659 --> 00:57:14.900
warnings and the treatment of the audience were now the
647
00:57:14.980 --> 00:57:20.860
subjects under investigation. Baumgarten defended the intention to make an
648
00:57:21.260 --> 00:57:26.730
effective Halloween Ghost Story. The production had not, in her account,
649
00:57:27.309 --> 00:57:32.130
set out to simply fool the public. The program occupied
650
00:57:32.150 --> 00:57:36.599
a drama slot, carried credits and aired after the 9
651
00:57:36.599 --> 00:57:41.940
o'clock watershed. On the November 15th edition of Bite Back,
652
00:57:42.539 --> 00:57:47.059
one viewer explained what the BBC's familiar faces had made
653
00:57:47.139 --> 00:57:48.079
him believe.
654
00:57:48.579 --> 00:57:51.119
You saw it, you were taken in, what's your reaction?
655
00:57:51.429 --> 00:57:55.349
Yes, thank you. Firstly, I must just say the kind
656
00:57:55.369 --> 00:57:57.969
word is that it was actually, theoretically, a brilliant piece
657
00:57:58.010 --> 00:58:00.590
of television. That's the nice part out of the way.
658
00:58:00.929 --> 00:58:03.809
But I also think that you betrayed the trust that
659
00:58:03.849 --> 00:58:06.849
the audience has within the BBC. You toyed with the
660
00:58:06.889 --> 00:58:10.289
emotions of the audience because the audience weren't actually sure,
661
00:58:10.449 --> 00:58:13.610
or I wasn't, actually sure if it was fact or fiction,
662
00:58:13.670 --> 00:58:15.670
if it was live or if it was in fact
663
00:58:15.710 --> 00:58:18.670
a drama. There were illusions before the programme and in
664
00:58:18.730 --> 00:58:20.800
some of the papers. I don't get the radio times,
665
00:58:20.880 --> 00:58:23.929
many people don't either. I hate to say, that it was,
666
00:58:24.289 --> 00:58:26.570
you weren't sure because it was Michael Parkinson and the others,
667
00:58:26.590 --> 00:58:28.489
whether it was fact or fiction. And as the program
668
00:58:28.530 --> 00:58:31.469
went on, it became obvious you were getting sucked in.
669
00:58:32.429 --> 00:58:36.829
The disagreement was about an experience as much as a label.
670
00:58:37.489 --> 00:58:41.590
The makers could identify where they had signaled fiction. The
671
00:58:41.639 --> 00:58:45.780
viewer could describe how the next 90 minutes had worked
672
00:58:45.860 --> 00:58:50.559
against those very signals. Each answer left something in the
673
00:58:50.699 --> 00:58:55.340
other's account unresolved. The critics were not all approaching the
674
00:58:55.400 --> 00:59:00.099
film from the same direction either. Maurice Gross, who had
675
00:59:00.400 --> 00:59:05.130
investigated the Enfield case, objected to the way Ghostwatch turned
676
00:59:05.230 --> 00:59:12.219
material resembling that very case into exaggerated horror. Guy Lyon Playfair,
677
00:59:12.340 --> 00:59:18.139
another Enfield investigator, had served as the production's consultant. An
678
00:59:18.199 --> 00:59:22.679
interest in paranormal claims did not produce agreement about how
679
00:59:22.760 --> 00:59:28.059
they should be used in entertainment. The familiar comparison to
680
00:59:28.239 --> 00:59:33.389
Orson Welles' War of the Worlds quickly suggested itself, a
681
00:59:33.449 --> 00:59:40.230
broadcast borrowing factual presentation followed by headlines about a deceived audience.
682
00:59:41.010 --> 00:59:45.969
But treating either story as a whole nation panicking hides
683
00:59:46.070 --> 00:59:51.840
the uneven evidence. The comparison could make Ghostwatch sound famous
684
00:59:51.949 --> 00:59:56.920
before anyone had worked out the proportions of its actual response.
685
00:59:57.659 --> 01:00:01.070
There was also the matter of What had not followed
686
01:00:01.110 --> 01:00:05.670
the film? No immediate discussion had brought the audience back
687
01:00:05.769 --> 01:00:10.650
into the company of the makers. Baumgarten had reportedly explored
688
01:00:10.769 --> 01:00:14.929
such a program, but it did not happen. By the
689
01:00:14.989 --> 01:00:19.869
time television offered a forum for explanation, viewers had already
690
01:00:19.949 --> 01:00:24.570
supplied their own accounts of the night. Near the end
691
01:00:24.630 --> 01:00:29.010
of that discussion, Sue Lawley, put a final question to
692
01:00:29.119 --> 01:00:29.829
Richard Brooke.
693
01:00:30.389 --> 01:00:32.750
I just want to say one thing to Richard Brooke. Richard,
694
01:00:32.849 --> 01:00:34.150
would you do the same thing again?
695
01:00:35.230 --> 01:00:38.710
We'd make the same programme again, but we would frame
696
01:00:38.750 --> 01:00:41.309
it almost certainly in a completely different way and we
697
01:00:41.329 --> 01:00:43.550
would take the lessons that we've learnt on this occasion
698
01:00:43.869 --> 01:00:46.869
to heart because we have. We set it up possibly
699
01:00:47.289 --> 01:00:51.730
inadequately and perhaps the criticism that was made about nothing
700
01:00:51.750 --> 01:00:54.739
happening at the end of the programme... or not enough happening,
701
01:00:54.820 --> 01:00:56.860
I think maybe that is a perfectly valid one. But
702
01:00:56.980 --> 01:00:58.840
I believe it was a great drama, and I think
703
01:00:58.860 --> 01:01:02.429
that Michael Parkinson and Sarah Green did a sensational job
704
01:01:02.449 --> 01:01:03.550
in it. I'm very proud of it.
705
01:01:04.130 --> 01:01:09.429
For some, that account was a favourite Halloween fright. For others,
706
01:01:09.570 --> 01:01:14.239
it was an evening the BBC should have handled more responsibly.
707
01:01:14.980 --> 01:01:21.139
The argument moved through telephone responses, newspapers and factual programmes.
708
01:01:21.690 --> 01:01:26.340
accumulating more weight each time the original pictures were shown
709
01:01:26.460 --> 01:01:30.900
as evidence. Eventually, some of that evidence would come from
710
01:01:31.460 --> 01:01:38.929
outside television altogether. Families, clinicians, and the Broadcasting Standards Council
711
01:01:39.389 --> 01:01:43.690
would ask questions that could not be answered by explaining
712
01:01:43.769 --> 01:01:54.469
where the man behind the curtain had stood. For the
713
01:01:54.510 --> 01:01:59.789
Denham family in Nottingham, the argument about Ghostwatch belonged to
714
01:01:59.829 --> 01:02:06.739
the last days of someone they loved. Martin Denham was 18.
715
01:02:06.739 --> 01:02:11.360
Contemporary newspaper reports described him as a young man with
716
01:02:11.519 --> 01:02:17.659
learning disabilities. Five days after the broadcast, he died by
717
01:02:17.760 --> 01:02:23.769
suicide near his home in Bestwood Park. Later accounts identify
718
01:02:23.829 --> 01:02:29.699
him as a factory worker. Beyond those sparse details, the
719
01:02:29.739 --> 01:02:35.139
public record tells us little about his everyday life. Most
720
01:02:35.219 --> 01:02:39.320
people who encounter Martin's name now encounter it through a
721
01:02:39.500 --> 01:02:44.199
television controversy, with almost everything else about the young man
722
01:02:44.840 --> 01:02:49.820
left outside the story. At the inquest, his father, Percy,
723
01:02:50.570 --> 01:02:56.929
described how absorbed Martin had become while watching the program. Afterward,
724
01:02:57.210 --> 01:03:01.440
the family said, he worried about ghosts in their home.
725
01:03:02.760 --> 01:03:07.559
Noises from the central heating troubled him. The harmless explanation
726
01:03:07.619 --> 01:03:11.300
that had given the fictional ghost its name had become
727
01:03:11.420 --> 01:03:16.809
frightening inside a real house. April and Percy Denham believed
728
01:03:16.909 --> 01:03:22.420
the BBC was responsible. For their son's death, their complaint
729
01:03:22.480 --> 01:03:28.170
would continue long after the newspapers moved beyond the original broadcast.
730
01:03:29.369 --> 01:03:34.670
The coroner recorded suicide and made no attribution to Ghostwatch
731
01:03:34.869 --> 01:03:40.800
or television in general. Martin's parents connected the broadcast with
732
01:03:40.840 --> 01:03:44.920
the fears they had witnessed. Neither the inquest nor the
733
01:03:44.960 --> 01:03:52.559
later broadcasting ruling established causation. Suicide is complex. We can't
734
01:03:52.659 --> 01:03:58.219
reconstruct an explanation for Martin's death from one television program,
735
01:03:58.699 --> 01:04:04.289
his disability, or the few details preserved in newspaper reports.
736
01:04:05.590 --> 01:04:09.210
The distinction mattered as the family tried to have its
737
01:04:09.269 --> 01:04:14.340
complaint heard. They argued that the BBC had misled viewers
738
01:04:14.780 --> 01:04:18.929
about the nature of what they were watching. the Broadcasting
739
01:04:18.989 --> 01:04:26.210
Standards Council initially refused to consider their complaint. In September 1994,
740
01:04:26.210 --> 01:04:31.230
the High Court granted the Denham's permission to challenge that
741
01:04:31.309 --> 01:04:37.559
refusal through judicial review. It was a procedural opening rather
742
01:04:37.619 --> 01:04:42.179
than a judgment against the makers of Ghostwatch, but it
743
01:04:42.239 --> 01:04:46.840
kept the family's objection before an institution with the authority
744
01:04:46.920 --> 01:04:54.340
to examine the broadcast. Halloween 1992 was receding. The question
745
01:04:54.389 --> 01:04:58.230
of what the BBC should have anticipated was still waiting
746
01:04:58.769 --> 01:05:03.769
for an answer. Meanwhile, another part of the aftermath had
747
01:05:03.889 --> 01:05:10.090
entered a very different kind of record. In February 1994,
748
01:05:10.090 --> 01:05:15.829
clinicians D. Simons and W.R. Silviera published two case histories
749
01:05:15.909 --> 01:05:20.679
in the British Medical Journal, Separate referrals had brought two
750
01:05:20.699 --> 01:05:26.059
10-year-old boys to their child psychiatry service about four months
751
01:05:26.500 --> 01:05:32.969
after the broadcast. The clinicians diagnosed post-traumatic stress disorder using
752
01:05:33.010 --> 01:05:38.150
the criteria then current. One boy had been so frightened
753
01:05:38.210 --> 01:05:41.949
that he had refused to watch the ending. Afterward, he
754
01:05:41.969 --> 01:05:48.219
would not go upstairs alone. Nightmares and intrusive images troubled him.
755
01:05:48.880 --> 01:05:54.550
Separation from his mother became difficult. His difficulties eventually required
756
01:05:54.610 --> 01:05:59.730
admission to a child and family unit. After eight weeks
757
01:05:59.809 --> 01:06:04.730
of treatment, the report described him leaving happier, more confident,
758
01:06:05.230 --> 01:06:09.309
and free of symptoms. The second boy feared his bedroom
759
01:06:09.969 --> 01:06:14.510
and began sleeping in his parents' room. He received outpatient
760
01:06:14.570 --> 01:06:19.920
care After three weekly appointments, with telephone support between them,
761
01:06:20.579 --> 01:06:23.500
he was sleeping in his own room again, and the
762
01:06:23.539 --> 01:06:29.250
family seemed more relaxed. Those endings deserve a place in
763
01:06:29.289 --> 01:06:34.769
the story alongside the symptoms. The children received help. Their
764
01:06:34.829 --> 01:06:39.110
lives began moving beyond the fears for which they had
765
01:06:39.190 --> 01:06:44.349
been referred. For clinicians, that movement was the work. They
766
01:06:44.409 --> 01:06:50.429
were dealing with bedtimes, separation, reassurance, and the ordinary routines
767
01:06:50.489 --> 01:06:54.750
that had become difficult. In the broadcast, a staircase was
768
01:06:54.849 --> 01:06:59.960
part of a carefully staged horror set. In these accounts,
769
01:07:00.099 --> 01:07:04.360
the challenge was helping a child move comfortably through his
770
01:07:04.480 --> 01:07:11.119
own home again. The article prompted a professional argument. Subsequent
771
01:07:11.159 --> 01:07:16.949
correspondents said, described other children with severe anxiety after the
772
01:07:16.989 --> 01:07:23.150
program and considered how personal or family vulnerabilities might affect
773
01:07:23.489 --> 01:07:30.829
its persistence. Another physician challenged the PTSD diagnosis itself, arguing
774
01:07:30.889 --> 01:07:36.670
that watching fictional television did not meet the necessary trauma criterion.
775
01:07:37.590 --> 01:07:42.699
Serious distress could require care, even when clinicians disagreed about
776
01:07:42.780 --> 01:07:48.460
its classification. These were individual case reports, never a survey
777
01:07:48.519 --> 01:07:53.280
of the entire audience. They offered no reliable count of
778
01:07:53.619 --> 01:07:59.920
how many viewers experienced comparable problems. Their value lies in
779
01:07:59.960 --> 01:08:06.190
their specificity, particular children, particular difficulties, and the effort to
780
01:08:06.250 --> 01:08:10.360
help them recover. Expanding them into a claim about a
781
01:08:10.519 --> 01:08:15.039
permanently damaged generation would erase the limits that made the
782
01:08:15.079 --> 01:08:21.359
reports useful in the first place. On June 28, 1995,
783
01:08:21.359 --> 01:08:28.600
the Broadcasting Standards Council issued its adjudication on Ghostwatch. Its
784
01:08:28.699 --> 01:08:33.350
focus was the BBC's handling of the program. The council
785
01:08:33.409 --> 01:08:39.220
criticized inadequate advance warnings and the deliberate cultivation of menace.
786
01:08:40.260 --> 01:08:45.300
It considered scenes involving the children's marked faces and references
787
01:08:45.399 --> 01:08:51.819
to violence against an animal excessively frightening and distressing. The
788
01:08:51.890 --> 01:08:56.449
timing after the nine o'clock watershed also mattered, as did
789
01:08:56.489 --> 01:09:02.220
the presence of the presenters associated with children. television. Their
790
01:09:02.300 --> 01:09:07.100
familiarity had taken some parents off guard when deciding whether
791
01:09:07.140 --> 01:09:12.890
their children should continue watching. The last point reached back
792
01:09:13.010 --> 01:09:17.680
into the design of the show. Sarah Green's presence had
793
01:09:17.720 --> 01:09:22.699
helped make the early house approachable. Viewers already knew her.
794
01:09:23.479 --> 01:09:27.539
The program could begin with that relationship already in place.
795
01:09:28.460 --> 01:09:32.390
The council was examining what happened when parents used the
796
01:09:32.449 --> 01:09:38.390
same familiarity to judge the evening's suitability. This was a
797
01:09:38.449 --> 01:09:44.140
criticism of the precautions surrounding a particular broadcast. The ruling
798
01:09:44.189 --> 01:09:48.409
did not prohibit frightening drama, order a ban on the
799
01:09:48.449 --> 01:09:55.260
program itself, or establish responsibility for Martin's death. It required
800
01:09:55.300 --> 01:09:59.380
the BBC to confront how the presentation had affected the
801
01:09:59.479 --> 01:10:04.960
audience's ability to understand what was being offered. The conflict
802
01:10:05.000 --> 01:10:10.939
had traveled a considerable distance from the television studio. Viewers
803
01:10:11.010 --> 01:10:15.260
had sought explanations by telephone, A family had pursued a
804
01:10:15.319 --> 01:10:20.550
complaint through the courts. Doctors had treated children and debated
805
01:10:20.630 --> 01:10:26.649
their diagnoses. A regulator had examined warnings, scheduling, and content.
806
01:10:27.510 --> 01:10:32.520
Each stage asked something different of the same 91 minutes.
807
01:10:33.479 --> 01:10:38.720
An artist's explanation of intention could illuminate the production without
808
01:10:38.779 --> 01:10:44.649
resolving a parent's objection. Identifying a program as Fiction could
809
01:10:44.750 --> 01:10:49.609
settle whether its ghost existed without settling whether its presentation
810
01:10:50.109 --> 01:10:54.329
had been responsible. The broadcast could be examined in a
811
01:10:54.390 --> 01:10:59.310
hearing or discussed in a doctor's office. There was one
812
01:10:59.569 --> 01:11:04.880
obvious place, however, where British audiences would not find it again.
813
01:11:05.779 --> 01:11:16.770
Back in the television schedule. For years, there was no
814
01:11:16.909 --> 01:11:21.199
repeat to wait for. Someone who missed Ghostwatch could hear
815
01:11:21.279 --> 01:11:24.699
about it from someone who had seen it. Someone who
816
01:11:24.760 --> 01:11:28.380
remembered the curtain could argue with someone who remembered a
817
01:11:28.899 --> 01:11:33.060
different part of the room. Unless a recording was available,
818
01:11:33.460 --> 01:11:37.930
neither could settle the disagreement by turning the program back on.
819
01:11:38.970 --> 01:11:44.449
Copied videotapes circulated according to later accounts. The film survived
820
01:11:44.470 --> 01:11:48.989
until the ordinary routine in which a successful television drama
821
01:11:49.069 --> 01:11:53.630
might return to the schedule. Its absence helped give it
822
01:11:53.689 --> 01:11:58.890
the reputation of something forbidden. The familiar claim is that
823
01:11:58.930 --> 01:12:04.229
the BBC banned Ghostwatch for ten years. Manning has used
824
01:12:04.600 --> 01:12:09.760
that very description. Volk has questioned whether a formal order
825
01:12:09.840 --> 01:12:14.829
existed and said he never saw one. The accessible record
826
01:12:14.909 --> 01:12:20.739
does not settle every internal BBC decision. The clearest history
827
01:12:20.819 --> 01:12:25.500
is that the complete program received no British television repeat
828
01:12:26.039 --> 01:12:31.359
and no official home release for a decade. During that gap,
829
01:12:31.899 --> 01:12:37.420
its images kept moving in people's memories. Documentary maker Rich
830
01:12:37.500 --> 01:12:42.640
Loudon later encountered viewers asking about scenes the program had
831
01:12:42.760 --> 01:12:47.350
never contained. Pipes dancing on the lawn was one of them.
832
01:12:48.470 --> 01:12:51.770
An audience that had been encouraged to search the picture
833
01:12:52.270 --> 01:12:55.850
could carry away a much more elaborate picture than the
834
01:12:56.010 --> 01:13:02.340
one the BBC had transmitted. It's easy to understand how
835
01:13:02.420 --> 01:13:07.699
the argument could feed itself. A friend remembers something you missed.
836
01:13:08.239 --> 01:13:11.850
A copied tape is hard to make out. The version
837
01:13:12.010 --> 01:13:17.000
everybody discusses becomes the one you expect to see, even
838
01:13:17.079 --> 01:13:23.260
before you have another opportunity to watch it. In 2002,
839
01:13:23.260 --> 01:13:28.300
the British Film Institute released Ghostwatch on VHS and DVD.
840
01:13:29.100 --> 01:13:33.649
The broadcast could finally be revisited through an official edition.
841
01:13:34.479 --> 01:13:38.069
A viewer could pause at the curtain, examine the replay,
842
01:13:38.210 --> 01:13:43.170
or start again from the opening credits. the makers returned
843
01:13:43.250 --> 01:13:48.409
with it. A commentary brought Volk, Manning, and Baumgarten into
844
01:13:48.430 --> 01:13:53.119
the home viewing experience, able to discuss choices that had
845
01:13:53.199 --> 01:13:58.579
disappeared beneath the film's apparent accidents. The work could be
846
01:13:58.659 --> 01:14:03.850
examined alongside the people who had constructed it. That changed
847
01:14:03.909 --> 01:14:07.569
the kind of question a viewer could ask. Instead of
848
01:14:07.630 --> 01:14:12.180
relying on a frightening memory, someone could compare a remembered
849
01:14:12.300 --> 01:14:18.720
scene with the actual frame. The discussion could include performances, editing,
850
01:14:18.939 --> 01:14:23.220
and the handling of the cameras. The scandal no longer
851
01:14:23.300 --> 01:14:27.239
had to stand in for the film. Repeated viewing also
852
01:14:27.380 --> 01:14:32.159
offered a new pleasure, looking for pipes while knowing perfectly
853
01:14:32.239 --> 01:14:36.600
well who put him there. The hidden figure became an
854
01:14:36.689 --> 01:14:41.869
invitation to search again. Finding one appearance could send a
855
01:14:41.909 --> 01:14:47.449
viewer back through another scene, wondering what else had escaped notice.
856
01:14:48.770 --> 01:14:55.430
The documentary Ghostwatch Behind the Curtains, completed in 2012, gathered
857
01:14:55.489 --> 01:15:01.350
participants from the original production. Anniversary screenings and discussions brought
858
01:15:01.399 --> 01:15:05.199
the story into rooms where the audience had deliberately come
859
01:15:05.260 --> 01:15:11.060
to see it. In 2022, The BFI included Ghostwatch among
860
01:15:11.060 --> 01:15:17.939
100 programs it identified as BBC television game changers. The
861
01:15:17.979 --> 01:15:21.779
makers were still willing to play with that audience. Manning
862
01:15:21.819 --> 01:15:26.819
described anniversary events in Sheffield and London, where screenings were
863
01:15:26.859 --> 01:15:31.829
followed by a question-and-answer session designed to go wrong and
864
01:15:32.310 --> 01:15:36.069
frighten the room. Even a discussion with the director could
865
01:15:36.109 --> 01:15:40.279
become part of the performance. the audience had come to
866
01:15:40.380 --> 01:15:44.699
examine the illusion, and the people explaining it had another
867
01:15:44.800 --> 01:15:50.340
trick prepared. The film's place in horror history became easier
868
01:15:50.420 --> 01:15:55.310
to discuss without pretending it had invented every technique that followed.
869
01:15:56.069 --> 01:15:59.409
The Blair Witch Project arrived seven years later with a
870
01:15:59.449 --> 01:16:04.909
related documentary illusion, but co-director Eduardo Sanchez has said his
871
01:16:04.989 --> 01:16:10.149
team learned of Ghostwatch after their own film's release. Similar
872
01:16:10.210 --> 01:16:14.920
methods do not, by themselves, prove a direct line of influence.
873
01:16:15.720 --> 01:16:20.840
Other connections are more explicit. The creators of the 2020
874
01:16:20.840 --> 01:16:25.390
screen-based horror film Host have named Ghostwatch as a reference.
875
01:16:26.369 --> 01:16:30.850
Vogue described Darren Brown crediting it as an inspiration for
876
01:16:30.909 --> 01:16:36.859
the seance, and reported Reese Shearsmith calling... Live Halloween inside
877
01:16:36.920 --> 01:16:41.939
number nine, episode deadline, a love letter to it. Those
878
01:16:42.000 --> 01:16:48.810
connections are fascinating because Ghostwatch's method can survive the disappearance
879
01:16:48.909 --> 01:16:54.770
of its original equipment. A new film can use the waiting, interruptions,
880
01:16:54.930 --> 01:17:00.159
and failures familiar from another kind of screen. It can
881
01:17:00.199 --> 01:17:05.850
let audiences recognize the ordinary inconvenience of before revealing why
882
01:17:05.930 --> 01:17:12.470
this particular interruption is dangerous. But the most fitting response
883
01:17:12.970 --> 01:17:18.439
came from viewers who wanted the original evening back. Beginning
884
01:17:18.520 --> 01:17:24.720
in 2010, fans organized an annual event called the National Seance.
885
01:17:25.420 --> 01:17:30.119
On Halloween, people in different places synchronized their own copies
886
01:17:30.199 --> 01:17:36.470
around the original broadcast hour, and commented together online. They
887
01:17:36.529 --> 01:17:41.760
supplied the shared appointment that British television had never repeated.
888
01:17:42.460 --> 01:17:47.159
The ritual could be surprisingly attentive to the ordinary details.
889
01:17:47.800 --> 01:17:53.539
The event's instructions offered original continuity and identification material for
890
01:17:53.979 --> 01:17:58.930
people who wanted to recreate the transmission's very framing. An
891
01:17:58.989 --> 01:18:03.949
announcer and a familiar BBC introduction became Part of the pleasure,
892
01:18:04.649 --> 01:18:09.560
rather than obstacles to the scare. That is a wonderful
893
01:18:09.640 --> 01:18:13.579
turn for a film whose controversy centered on how it
894
01:18:13.619 --> 01:18:18.520
had been introduced. These viewers knew exactly what they were summoning.
895
01:18:19.260 --> 01:18:22.659
They chose the date, found the recording, and brought the
896
01:18:22.699 --> 01:18:27.399
missing context with them. In the drama, an audience becomes
897
01:18:27.520 --> 01:18:34.060
part of a national seance without understanding the consequences. Years afterward,
898
01:18:34.619 --> 01:18:39.399
fans knowingly linked their screens to bring the same program back,
899
01:18:40.470 --> 01:18:46.369
almost speaking from the grave. The collective ritual became real
900
01:18:46.750 --> 01:18:51.989
without requiring anyone to believe in Pipe. The cupboard could
901
01:18:52.149 --> 01:18:56.979
open again. Sarah could walk into the house again. Parkinson
902
01:18:57.060 --> 01:19:01.000
could begin another viewing of sensible questions with the people
903
01:19:01.060 --> 01:19:06.880
watching already aware of where his confidence would lead. That
904
01:19:06.979 --> 01:19:12.189
foreknowledge changes the experience. It doesn't remove the suspense of
905
01:19:12.609 --> 01:19:17.069
waiting for the curtain, the false comfort of the recovered picture,
906
01:19:17.270 --> 01:19:22.069
or the pleasure of noticing a shape someone else has missed.
907
01:19:22.909 --> 01:19:28.119
For returning viewers, the evening can contain two overlapping stories.
908
01:19:28.840 --> 01:19:33.180
The film the makers recorded and the strange history of
909
01:19:33.260 --> 01:19:36.720
what happened when it reached its audience. We can know
910
01:19:36.819 --> 01:19:41.960
both stories and still, Come back for more. The lights fail.
911
01:19:42.560 --> 01:19:46.460
The monitors flicker. Parkinson searches for the words that will
912
01:19:46.500 --> 01:19:51.050
let him finish the broadcast. This time, we know what
913
01:19:51.109 --> 01:19:57.050
is waiting on the autocue. Pipes did not escape through
914
01:19:57.130 --> 01:20:04.359
the television. Ghostwatch did. So, my spookies, I ask, this
915
01:20:04.579 --> 01:20:09.329
Halloween season, why not give it a watch? Trust me,
916
01:20:10.029 --> 01:20:13.000
it'll creep you out. It creeped me out all alone,
917
01:20:13.319 --> 01:20:17.399
without any idea of this history. So I think it'll
918
01:20:17.439 --> 01:20:22.100
bring a great Halloween time to you too. As of
919
01:20:22.180 --> 01:20:25.930
this recording, it's available to stream with your subscription to
920
01:20:26.069 --> 01:20:30.329
Shudder or AMC +, but I'm not sponsored by them.
921
01:20:30.750 --> 01:20:33.970
You can also rent it wherever you get your movies online.
922
01:20:34.770 --> 01:20:37.939
It's so worth your time. Consider it a little generous.
923
01:20:38.380 --> 01:20:43.850
Halloween gift from me and all the fine folks who
924
01:20:43.890 --> 01:20:46.640
put it all on the line creatively back in 1992
925
01:20:46.640 --> 01:20:46.810
to you.
926
01:20:51.189 --> 01:20:55.189
Terrifying and True is narrated by Enrique Couto. It's executive
927
01:20:55.229 --> 01:20:59.789
produced by Rob Fields and bobbletopia.com and produced by Dan
928
01:20:59.829 --> 01:21:03.229
Wilder with original theme music by Ray Mattis. If you
929
01:21:03.270 --> 01:21:05.850
have a story you think we should cover on Terrifying
930
01:21:05.909 --> 01:21:10.399
and True, send us an email at weeklyspooky at gmail.com.
931
01:21:10.619 --> 01:21:11.199
And if you want to.
932
01:21:11.159 --> 01:21:13.079
Support us for as little as $ 1 a month, go
933
01:21:13.100 --> 01:21:17.640
to weeklyspooky.com slash join. Your support for as little as
934
01:21:17.640 --> 01:21:18.479
$ 1 a month keeps.
935
01:21:18.279 --> 01:21:19.000
The show going.
936
01:21:19.319 --> 01:21:21.340
And speaking of, I want to say an extra special
937
01:21:21.380 --> 01:21:24.439
thank you to our Patreon podcast boosters, folks who pay
938
01:21:24.479 --> 01:21:26.060
a little bit more to hear their name at the
939
01:21:26.100 --> 01:21:28.939
end of the show. And they are Johnny Nix, Kate
940
01:21:29.050 --> 01:21:33.609
and Lulu, Jessica Fuller, Mike Eshkewi, Jenny Green, Amber Hansford,
941
01:21:33.689 --> 01:21:36.829
Karen Wemet, Jack Kerr, and Craig Cohen. Thank you all
942
01:21:36.890 --> 01:21:39.329
so much, and thank you for listening. We'll see you
943
01:21:39.409 --> 01:21:42.909
all right here next time on Terrifying and True.