WEBVTT
00:00:00.500 --> 00:00:05.480
You'll often hear in the university is that we have a solution, but we are looking for a problem.
00:00:05.480 --> 00:00:09.074
Which is the reverse of how typically a startup should be done.
00:00:10.185 --> 00:00:13.724
I think most businesses work at human years, large organizations.
00:00:13.814 --> 00:00:15.974
Startups need to work in dog years.
00:00:15.974 --> 00:00:17.925
You need to do things seven times faster.
00:00:18.405 --> 00:00:21.045
But universities work in snail years, right?
00:00:22.990 --> 00:00:30.490
Actually taking something to production is a whole different ball game and getting a first customer is a huge challenge.
00:00:32.490 --> 00:00:34.831
Welcome to the Academic Adventures Podcast.
00:00:35.220 --> 00:00:40.381
This podcast is all about the journey from teaching, research, and innovation to real world solutions.
00:00:40.801 --> 00:00:50.341
For season two, we are joined by experienced founders and other experts who work alongside university staff and students to help create and support a culture of enterprise on campus.
00:00:52.540 --> 00:00:57.011
Hello and welcome to episode eight of the second season of the Academic Adventures Podcast.
00:00:57.220 --> 00:01:00.960
I'm your host, Sarah McLusky, and my guest today is Nanik Ramchandani.
00:01:01.720 --> 00:01:07.870
Inspired by the eighties movie Wall Street, Nanik initially became a stockbroker before discovering the world of entrepreneurship.
00:01:08.516 --> 00:01:18.126
His career in financial services has taken him around the world, including Dubai, Singapore, and Geneva before he settled in Edinburgh and developed his relationship with Edinburgh Napier University.
00:01:19.135 --> 00:01:26.495
This collaboration has included being an entrepreneur in residence and he also helped to establish the Scottish Center for Excellence in Digital Trust.
00:01:27.006 --> 00:01:33.486
He's now working alongside academic co-founder, Zakwan Jaroucheh, to spin out cybersecurity company Lasting Asset.
00:01:34.671 --> 00:01:41.540
In our conversation, Nanik shares the realities of building a university spinout from legal wrangles to building solid financial foundations.
00:01:42.081 --> 00:01:51.171
We also talk about why spin outs need more support to get beyond proof of concept and land their first customer, and how universities might attract and incentivize more commercial champions.
00:01:56.171 --> 00:01:58.010
Welcome to the podcast, Nanik.
00:01:58.031 --> 00:01:59.740
It's fantastic to have you here.
00:01:59.740 --> 00:02:04.600
I wonder if we could begin by hearing a bit about yourself, who you are, and what you do.
00:02:05.361 --> 00:02:06.051
Okay, great.
00:02:06.051 --> 00:02:06.650
Thanks Sarah.
00:02:06.710 --> 00:02:07.281
Likewise.
00:02:07.311 --> 00:02:08.061
Lovely to be here.
00:02:08.091 --> 00:02:10.320
Um, I'm Nanik Ramchandani.
00:02:10.341 --> 00:02:21.276
I'm currently the co-founder and CEO of a business that's just spun out of Edinburgh Napier University 77 days ago and I'm counting.
00:02:21.985 --> 00:02:28.895
It's a business called Lasting Asset where we are we are on a mission to stop imposter, fraud, imposter or impersonation fraud.
00:02:29.205 --> 00:02:31.575
In, in America they like to call it imposter.
00:02:31.575 --> 00:02:33.195
Here we call it impersonation.
00:02:33.536 --> 00:02:39.235
But that's why I'm, of course the long journey to get to where I'm, but we can talk about that as it goes along.
00:02:39.295 --> 00:02:39.475
Yeah.
00:02:39.836 --> 00:02:40.135
Yeah.
00:02:40.165 --> 00:02:41.186
Thanks for setting the scene there.
00:02:41.186 --> 00:02:45.686
I love that you are still counting it in numbers of days since it started.
00:02:47.075 --> 00:02:51.605
The clock starts the day you spin out and it the pace increases.
00:02:51.665 --> 00:02:51.756
Yeah.
00:02:51.816 --> 00:02:57.510
Two or three x of four x, which people don't necessarily realize, so I. I, I keep counting and keep reminding my team.
00:02:57.510 --> 00:03:02.170
It's been so many days, my God, we haven't done what we should have, so let's keep it, keep it going.
00:03:02.221 --> 00:03:02.461
Yeah.
00:03:02.790 --> 00:03:03.241
Yes.
00:03:03.241 --> 00:03:06.600
I feel like it's almost like they talk about politicians and things the first a hundred days.
00:03:06.600 --> 00:03:09.931
I imagine it's a similar, it's a similar crazy time.
00:03:10.020 --> 00:03:10.441
Yes.
00:03:10.506 --> 00:03:16.825
So this is not your first foray into doing financial technology type businesses, is it?
00:03:16.825 --> 00:03:20.156
So maybe if you could tell us a little bit about your background and how you've ended up here.
00:03:20.770 --> 00:03:21.550
Yeah, sure.
00:03:21.550 --> 00:03:22.510
It's a long story.
00:03:22.550 --> 00:03:27.941
Going back some 25 odd years and, I was in India that, that's where I grew up.
00:03:28.330 --> 00:03:41.010
And in my early teams there was a movie called Wall Street, which kind of was the movie of the era, which kind of shaped a lot of careers, including mine, where there was this character called Gordon Gekko and everybody was like, my god, this is like the hero.
00:03:41.640 --> 00:03:47.830
He was actually a villain in there, but it was like, yeah it started my career in financial services.
00:03:47.830 --> 00:03:53.906
I was always comfortable with numbers and that was very clear at that point that what I wanted to do was run my own hedge fund and so on.
00:03:54.355 --> 00:03:58.915
But, so my first job after doing my master's was working with a stockbroker.
00:03:59.216 --> 00:04:02.545
This is like 99, and my biggest client said.
00:04:02.906 --> 00:04:06.566
Hey, I've just invested in a.com, so come and run it for me.
00:04:06.566 --> 00:04:08.816
So this is 99.
00:04:08.876 --> 00:04:20.446
And so we started what was then capital market education site and and also a social media site, which was interesting because those, both those categories were exploded after.
00:04:20.956 --> 00:04:24.245
And so that was my first introduction to startups.
00:04:24.245 --> 00:04:25.415
Absolutely loved it.
00:04:25.896 --> 00:04:47.526
Then the world changed in 2001, and I continued to work on different startup ideas, including tutoring kids in the US from India, doing book reviews, Amazon was getting big then, but finally in 2003 decided to go back to business school and that started a 15 year career in financial services.
00:04:47.826 --> 00:04:52.925
Long story short, I did run the hedge fund that I always wanted to do, and Murphy's law things never go as planned.
00:04:53.696 --> 00:05:00.855
realised this was not what I really was inspired to do, and midlife crisis, I've gone back to my true love of startups.
00:05:00.855 --> 00:05:12.901
So that's been the backward journey in back 2018, 19, I was working, giving some advice, doing some consulting work with scale ups in the, mostly in the financial sector.
00:05:13.380 --> 00:05:25.391
And that was also the time we had moved to Edinburgh, which is now home, and somehow got involved with Napier and that started my new journey in entrepreneurship, commercialization, and so on.
00:05:25.696 --> 00:05:26.036
Yeah.
00:05:26.605 --> 00:05:27.925
So tell us a bit more about that.
00:05:27.925 --> 00:05:32.216
So your connection has really been with Napier University.
00:05:32.271 --> 00:05:33.216
How did that start?
00:05:33.216 --> 00:05:35.255
What sorts of things have you done together?
00:05:35.771 --> 00:05:36.310
Yeah.
00:05:36.341 --> 00:05:40.600
No it was a very serendipitous interesting story.
00:05:40.600 --> 00:05:49.821
Way back in, in 2019/20, I was working and advising different startups and scale ups and we had moved to Edinburgh at the time.
00:05:50.331 --> 00:05:57.836
And so there was a Entrepreneur in Residence at Napier at the time, Jamie Graves, who was leaving it was end of the year.
00:05:57.836 --> 00:06:06.016
It was end of 2021, and he was helping a project at the time run by a young bright PhD called Pablos.
00:06:06.295 --> 00:06:10.966
And somehow we got in touch and Jamie asked if I had time to support him.
00:06:11.505 --> 00:06:12.886
Pablos and I got along really well.
00:06:12.886 --> 00:06:23.185
I. And that just started, I became a commercial champion to support Pablos, which was now at that stage we were applying for the high growth spin out opportunity qualification grant.
00:06:23.725 --> 00:06:29.105
It went on to get the company creation grant and an Innovate UK cyber A subgrant.
00:06:29.105 --> 00:06:31.505
So kinda just grew arms and legs.
00:06:31.505 --> 00:06:34.565
And around the same time I also met Bill Buchanan.
00:06:34.625 --> 00:06:38.136
And if you don't know Bill, he's one of, he's like a force of nature in Scotland.
00:06:38.136 --> 00:06:40.625
He's been, he's one of the pillars of Napier.
00:06:40.625 --> 00:06:43.625
Been working there for 36 years as a professor.
00:06:44.105 --> 00:06:46.235
Absolutely loves what he does.
00:06:46.326 --> 00:06:49.596
Like he's got more energy than a 17-year-old on his first date.
00:06:49.966 --> 00:06:52.740
But, and just an incredible human being.
00:06:52.740 --> 00:07:06.656
And I ended up working with Bill on a bunch of things, including setting up the first centre of excellence in digital trust in Scotland, where Napier is the founding the founding university alongside Glasgow and University of Edinburgh.
00:07:07.701 --> 00:07:11.360
Bill also got me to apply for the Royal Society Entrepreneur in Residence Scheme.
00:07:11.360 --> 00:07:16.430
So I was the Royal Society EIR in 23/24 at Napier.
00:07:17.021 --> 00:07:41.886
Also got involved with the second project where Zakwan, who's now my co-founder at Lasting Asset, was working on a bunch of different problems and I worked alongside with him over the last two years and again, getting multiple rounds of funding, getting the project from what was an initial idea on crypto asset custody to now stopping financial fraud.
00:07:42.435 --> 00:07:49.490
So it's been a very intense four years where somehow I've just gotten involved with Napier and gotten intertwined in the system then.
00:07:50.271 --> 00:07:55.790
Yeah, it sounds like that really was a meeting of minds and then it's just gone off in various different directions.
00:07:56.151 --> 00:08:00.740
So this company that you're involved in now was a spin out from the university.
00:08:00.740 --> 00:08:03.081
So tell us a bit more about the story behind that.
00:08:03.081 --> 00:08:04.221
You've mentioned it a little bit.
00:08:04.836 --> 00:08:05.406
Yes.
00:08:05.466 --> 00:08:12.776
So in, in 2023 Zakwan was working on creating a better digital asset custody solution.
00:08:12.776 --> 00:08:16.375
So essentially in crypto assets, if you lose your private key, you lose your assets.
00:08:16.375 --> 00:08:22.946
So he wanted to make a better custody solution and he had made some good strides in that in that direction.
00:08:23.396 --> 00:08:32.836
But it was a really hard problem to commercialise and also, we realised that it wasn't something that really excited us, like we didn't wake up any morning wanting to protect crypto assets.
00:08:33.566 --> 00:08:42.086
And that we had applied for grants, so we got the high growth spin out opportunity qualification for that, where we explored multiple use cases.
00:08:42.086 --> 00:08:48.296
And one of the things you'll often hear in the university is that we have a solution, but we are looking for a problem.
00:08:48.296 --> 00:08:51.890
Which is the reverse of how typically a startup should be done.
00:08:52.250 --> 00:08:54.605
But it is a challenge which is not insurmountable.
00:08:54.605 --> 00:09:04.110
It just requires a lot more thinking about what problem is it that our technology can solve well versus just any technology solving.
00:09:04.551 --> 00:09:08.841
And that kind of led to this passion to stop fraud.
00:09:09.301 --> 00:09:13.711
Around the same time in 23, my mother was scammed and I saw what it did to her.
00:09:13.711 --> 00:09:22.730
So it was one of those things where just came together that this is a problem we want to solve and this is a problem we can see ourselves doing for the next 20 years.
00:09:23.120 --> 00:09:35.081
And that project went on within the university to raise almost a half a million pounds in different grants and now has spun out as of 77 days ago, as I probably mentioned.
00:09:35.630 --> 00:09:41.480
And we are now out to hopefully get our product launched in the next 60 to 90 days.
00:09:41.975 --> 00:09:42.666
Fantastic.
00:09:42.666 --> 00:09:43.625
What a great story.
00:09:43.895 --> 00:09:47.466
And yeah, it'll be interesting to see how that develops.
00:09:47.466 --> 00:09:58.535
So is this your first experience of spinning out a company from actually from a university rather than a company that was already running or doing it just completely independently?
00:09:58.865 --> 00:10:01.296
And how has that process been?
00:10:01.296 --> 00:10:02.495
Has it been different?
00:10:03.605 --> 00:10:05.796
Oh yeah that we, how many, how much time do we have?
00:10:05.796 --> 00:10:06.725
Another five hours.
00:10:06.946 --> 00:10:09.796
Yeah, it is the first one, which I've actually spun out.
00:10:09.826 --> 00:10:19.696
I was involved in the previous project as well, which was the one that I mentioned between 2021 and 2023, that hasn't spun out yet, but should spin out soon.
00:10:19.846 --> 00:10:28.510
They had some other technical and financial challenges to, to surmount but the spin out process is definitely not an easy one.
00:10:28.510 --> 00:10:30.041
I think it's getting better.
00:10:30.130 --> 00:10:38.191
Napier has done a lot of spin outs before in the cybersecurity space, so they've got history in doing it.
00:10:38.740 --> 00:10:48.431
But it's still fairly clunky in terms of the negotiation process, which happens like 24 months too late, to be honest.
00:10:48.581 --> 00:10:52.191
It should be very clear at the beginning of what it involves and so on.
00:10:52.551 --> 00:10:59.120
Even the whole legal documentation process, it just feels like it's just far too onerous for this stage it is at.
00:10:59.471 --> 00:11:10.645
If you look at startups in the US, they, there's a typical YC document template, which is a five pager for safe notes, which is how every startup literally starts in the US.
00:11:11.076 --> 00:11:11.975
It's so easy.
00:11:12.035 --> 00:11:12.875
Everybody knows it.
00:11:12.875 --> 00:11:14.346
It's a quick sign and you're done.
00:11:14.735 --> 00:11:16.706
So university spin outs are harder.
00:11:16.706 --> 00:11:27.015
I think I lost about half my hair and the rest became gray through that three month process of actually looking through about 200 pages of legal docs.
00:11:27.600 --> 00:11:27.721
Goodness.
00:11:27.936 --> 00:11:33.841
I would, I, I think that can be definitely made easier but yeah, it's not great, but I think it's getting better.
00:11:33.841 --> 00:11:33.870
Okay.
00:11:34.081 --> 00:11:35.520
I definitely believe it's getting better way.
00:11:35.885 --> 00:11:36.275
Yeah.
00:11:36.326 --> 00:11:37.076
Oh, I hope so.
00:11:37.405 --> 00:11:42.520
So how has your partner in this business, how have they found this process?
00:11:42.520 --> 00:11:43.961
Is it what they expected?
00:11:44.530 --> 00:11:47.301
This whole perceptions versus reality idea.
00:11:47.301 --> 00:11:47.961
Oh, that, yeah.
00:11:48.260 --> 00:11:52.206
I think perception versus reality is interesting because it's, I think there are two sides to it.
00:11:52.296 --> 00:11:56.150
One is as a business, what it takes to start up a business.
00:11:56.201 --> 00:11:58.495
And then what it takes to spin out.
00:11:58.495 --> 00:12:00.515
So there are two different things I look at it.
00:12:01.025 --> 00:12:10.505
I think from my, in this particular case, ro my co-founder's perspective, what really worked well with us is that we trusted each other for our domains.
00:12:10.831 --> 00:12:16.650
And this is one of the things like when I look at, I do some angel investing on the side or whatever.
00:12:16.650 --> 00:12:21.030
When I look at people who, who I would invest in would be people who are very self-aware.
00:12:21.365 --> 00:12:27.576
They know what they're good at, and then they know what that person brings to the table and they then leave each other to it.
00:12:27.576 --> 00:12:30.365
It's, there's no sense at that stage to try and do it.
00:12:30.365 --> 00:12:37.115
So I don't think basically my co-founder didn't necessarily spend much time on the legal documentation, all the stuff at all.
00:12:37.426 --> 00:12:41.010
He left that to me and I left him to focus on the deck.
00:12:41.525 --> 00:12:45.005
So the spin out process probably wasn't as harrowing for him.
00:12:45.696 --> 00:12:59.706
But in terms of, I think when it comes to how easy or difficult is it as, and what it takes to do a business in a startup, most people don't really know until they get into it.
00:13:00.155 --> 00:13:04.696
And this, it's, I think one of the biggest misconceptions is it's really easy to make money in a startup.
00:13:05.056 --> 00:13:07.336
So I think the worst way to make money is set up a startup.
00:13:09.285 --> 00:13:20.035
Like you can do so much better if you are a PhD or and qualified to get a job, which gives you those holidays and the options or whatever on the pension.
00:13:20.520 --> 00:13:28.336
Versus a startup where 95% probabilities will fail after eight years and after a hundred hour weeks and so on.
00:13:28.755 --> 00:13:34.225
And I think it helps if you've been around the block to realize that it's not it's not easy.
00:13:34.495 --> 00:13:39.775
And the only reason, therefore you do a startup is because you love the problem that you're trying to solve.
00:13:39.926 --> 00:13:43.076
Otherwise, it's very hard to survive a startup, to be honest.
00:13:43.125 --> 00:13:45.076
So yeah, I dunno if I answered that.
00:13:46.910 --> 00:13:47.150
Yeah.
00:13:47.150 --> 00:13:51.951
So you're painting a picture of a really challenging process there.
00:13:51.951 --> 00:14:01.431
Sounds like it's something that's not for the faint-hearted, but that's where I guess specialists, experts, people like you who've been through it before, are incredibly valuable.
00:14:03.171 --> 00:14:04.640
Yeah, I think it definitely helps.
00:14:04.640 --> 00:14:06.370
I, there's a lot in Scotland.
00:14:06.370 --> 00:14:10.780
Scotland's a great ecosystem, and I've lived in like more than 10 places across the world.
00:14:10.780 --> 00:14:25.561
So whether it's East Coast US or Singapore, Dubai or Geneva or whatever, like I've worked and lived in multiple parts of the world and I think the Scottish ecosystem is incredible for getting you off the ground, especially if you are within the university.
00:14:26.100 --> 00:14:34.105
But what happens is that it's not necessarily great in terms of giving your real reality check on how hard it is.
00:14:34.225 --> 00:14:40.225
Yeah, and so the way I like to put it is, in the financial world there's this thing that dentists make the worst investors, right?
00:14:40.225 --> 00:14:45.355
Because they're really good at something and it's very straightforward what they do every day.
00:14:45.745 --> 00:14:49.285
And over a period of time, you start thinking that you can do everything really well.
00:14:49.520 --> 00:14:54.260
So the reason like you in the financial world is like when dentists start day trading, it's a disaster.
00:14:54.260 --> 00:14:54.831
They lose everything.
00:14:55.311 --> 00:14:56.510
It's one of those things.
00:14:57.230 --> 00:15:05.270
So in similarly in the academic world, you're essentially, you're really good at something you've spent a lot of time focusing on, and you're really good at it.
00:15:05.301 --> 00:15:12.711
Like you're either world reknowned you've written papers, you can talk about it endlessly, but that doesn't necessarily translate into everything else in life, right?
00:15:12.961 --> 00:15:19.081
And this is what happens sometimes where the realities of a business are completely different.
00:15:19.130 --> 00:15:32.120
Which is where the self-awareness is so important that like realizing that it's you are good at something doesn't mean that you can actually run a business and a three week program on teaching you how it's not going to make you an expert either.
00:15:32.671 --> 00:15:37.985
And so it's a, I don't, I, I'm not saying that academics can be fantastic CEOs.
00:15:38.735 --> 00:15:41.645
They can, and like Jamie Graves is an incredible example.
00:15:41.645 --> 00:15:47.885
He built a company called Zone Fox, spun out of Napier, sold it after 10 years to a multi-billion dollar business.
00:15:48.216 --> 00:15:52.086
But, and he went through that 10 years to be the great CEO that he was.
00:15:52.135 --> 00:15:53.275
But it takes that time.
00:15:53.326 --> 00:15:53.926
That's what I mean.
00:15:53.926 --> 00:15:53.985
Yeah.
00:15:53.985 --> 00:15:59.556
It's it's almost saying that, okay, you've been to business school for two years and I can learn the same thing in two weeks.
00:15:59.556 --> 00:16:00.336
It doesn't work.
00:16:00.936 --> 00:16:01.326
Yeah.
00:16:01.385 --> 00:16:05.166
No, it makes absolute sense and why you need those experts and things around you.
00:16:05.586 --> 00:16:19.686
And so if that support that perhaps is out there isn't maybe hitting the spot, what else do you think might be needed to help these people who are interested in developing companies from universities?
00:16:22.130 --> 00:16:31.510
So I think that the support is, yes, it's not there as, I think there are lots of universities complain that they can't find really good commercial champions.
00:16:31.900 --> 00:16:39.551
And a part of it is a function of how do you incentivize the commercial champion because the commercial champion comes in on day one.
00:16:39.610 --> 00:16:43.240
There's no visibility on any upside on this project.
00:16:43.240 --> 00:16:46.100
So it's purely, a payment for number of days worked.
00:16:46.201 --> 00:16:55.140
So the question is, and which is typically subsidized to real market rates, and then it's typically two days a week maximum for the project.
00:16:55.785 --> 00:17:08.086
Now the commercial champion has, can't leave a full-time job to work two days on something they have to be doing, either be a entrepreneur on their own and doing be doing something else three days a week or trying to fit that with another project.
00:17:08.586 --> 00:17:17.405
And as anybody in the startup world would know, once you are in a startup, it's a, you can't do anything else, you, it is a full-time like intense job.
00:17:17.786 --> 00:17:20.395
I would say even just fundraising is a full-time job now.
00:17:20.395 --> 00:17:22.736
Forget the startup as a full-time job.
00:17:22.736 --> 00:17:29.026
So I think incentivizing the people correctly and having is extremely important.
00:17:29.605 --> 00:17:37.375
The second thing, and it's just that ecosystem buildup process where we have great programs on training.
00:17:37.375 --> 00:17:41.546
We have fairly good initial set of mentors.
00:17:41.965 --> 00:17:47.530
What could really help is getting the first customer for example.
00:17:47.980 --> 00:18:04.361
Like one of the things that most startups struggle with is it's great building in the lab and having a TRL five or six, but actually taking something to production is a whole different ball game and getting a first customer is a huge challenge.
00:18:04.411 --> 00:18:16.306
If the ecosystem helps you get that first customer, and this is where Scottish government, Scottish enterprise, all the organizations can help, it would be a game changer in, in my view for example, just give you illustration.
00:18:16.306 --> 00:18:30.105
So we wanted to do a pilot while we were within the university, and it took so many months of back and forth with the insurer of the university to figure out how we would contract with this pilot customer.
00:18:30.155 --> 00:18:31.986
We couldn't do it in the end, right?
00:18:31.986 --> 00:18:34.145
So you have classic challenge.
00:18:34.145 --> 00:18:36.036
To raise money, you need traction.
00:18:36.425 --> 00:18:41.611
But to have traction, you have to do something like sign a contract, which is, but to sign a contract.
00:18:41.611 --> 00:18:46.191
You have to actually be outside the university because today I can sign a contract in, one day.
00:18:46.205 --> 00:18:47.375
Yeah, all I need to do.
00:18:47.615 --> 00:18:52.625
But within the university, six months later, I couldn't sign the contract because it was just so complicated, yeah.
00:18:52.776 --> 00:18:54.546
Because who's taking responsibility?
00:18:54.546 --> 00:18:56.256
Where does the liability lie?
00:18:56.256 --> 00:18:56.855
And so on.
00:18:57.306 --> 00:19:01.296
So it's almost like getting that first customer is such a challenge and.
00:19:02.121 --> 00:19:06.050
I have tons of ideas on how we can make it easier, but we don't have time for that.
00:19:06.141 --> 00:19:06.260
Yeah.
00:19:06.411 --> 00:19:08.861
But like that could be a game changer.
00:19:08.911 --> 00:19:09.090
Yeah.
00:19:09.121 --> 00:19:13.026
In like how we, these spinoffs really get that acceleration.
00:19:13.385 --> 00:19:13.685
Yes.
00:19:13.726 --> 00:19:21.925
Which is so important because only advantage as a startup is velocity, within the university, like I think most businesses work at human years.
00:19:21.925 --> 00:19:25.465
Large organizations, startups need to work in dog years.
00:19:25.465 --> 00:19:27.415
You need to do things seven times faster.
00:19:27.895 --> 00:19:30.536
But universities work in snail years, right?
00:19:31.435 --> 00:19:31.645
Yeah.
00:19:31.855 --> 00:19:33.955
They're the definitely the other end of the scale.
00:19:33.955 --> 00:19:34.316
Yeah.
00:19:34.421 --> 00:19:39.991
So within the university it's even though there's so many people who are supporting you, it's just not possible.
00:19:40.372 --> 00:19:43.791
The systems don't allow it to do things at the pace that you need to.
00:19:43.791 --> 00:19:49.987
And what often happens is it's too late, the market has moved, the technology has moved, and so on.
00:19:49.987 --> 00:19:52.926
So you can't capitalize on the original opportunity.
00:19:53.196 --> 00:19:53.346
Yeah.
00:19:53.346 --> 00:19:58.957
And that must be particularly challenging in a very fast moving environment like digital technologies.
00:19:58.957 --> 00:19:59.436
Yeah.
00:19:59.442 --> 00:20:00.457
Yeah, a hundred percent.
00:20:00.892 --> 00:20:01.311
Yeah.
00:20:01.362 --> 00:20:13.422
I think another thing that you've mentioned a little bit as we've gone through is yes, there's the support, the tangible, the practical stuff, but then also the finance, getting the finance behind startup companies as well.
00:20:13.422 --> 00:20:18.961
And it sounds like that's something you've been very successful at doing for the businesses that you're working with.
00:20:19.682 --> 00:20:22.442
Are there any kind of secrets to that or.
00:20:22.771 --> 00:20:25.412
Is it all about the technology, the product?
00:20:26.342 --> 00:20:30.692
I think there, the one is of course, like I said, fundraising is a full-time job.
00:20:30.692 --> 00:20:36.196
So having a commercial champion who gets numbers, who understands that is, it really helps.
00:20:36.211 --> 00:20:38.642
So I've spent most of my life in finance.
00:20:39.051 --> 00:20:45.892
And I, most of my job during the, within the university was looking at every grant application I could find.
00:20:45.892 --> 00:20:48.342
And, connect with the right people and so on.
00:20:48.342 --> 00:20:57.231
So both these startups that I was like projects, I would say within the university, I working for managed to raise over half a million in non-dilutive funding.
00:20:57.231 --> 00:21:01.372
And this was like, it's huge because most nobody else in the university has done that.
00:21:01.432 --> 00:21:07.301
While in the project within the university, of course the ecosystems also become better and there's more money.
00:21:07.797 --> 00:21:18.717
But ah for example, the one that we've spun out now, we got another 350,000 in Innovate UK SMART Grant, which we only 2.5% get it in the UK.
00:21:19.136 --> 00:21:20.517
And it wasn't an easy process.
00:21:20.517 --> 00:21:27.086
Like we worked really hard with first time we got rejected, we were below the cutoff of 86%, we got 81.
00:21:27.386 --> 00:21:30.987
The second time, we got 88 or whatever, and we passed it.
00:21:31.366 --> 00:21:33.096
It took a lot of work.
00:21:33.166 --> 00:21:34.537
And I guess we talked through that.
00:21:34.537 --> 00:21:40.926
Listen, we need some funding on day one and we got that 350, so we managed to get another 350 to get it.
00:21:40.926 --> 00:21:54.561
So we have now one year's money or one 15 months money to spin out because the challenge on spin out is this classic thing that you need now you've out of the university you need money to get going, but you don't have traction yet.
00:21:54.622 --> 00:21:55.146
You Yeah.
00:21:55.346 --> 00:21:57.896
You couldn't do sales while you're within the university.
00:21:58.257 --> 00:22:02.037
And so this is the classic problem, like how do you now raise money?
00:22:02.666 --> 00:22:09.836
Usually you'll be drip fed in the unfortunately, in the Scottish ecosystem, you'll get say 250 or 100 or so.
00:22:10.396 --> 00:22:12.797
Now that can't pay for more than two people, right?
00:22:13.277 --> 00:22:17.896
So if you wanna build a business, you need that one million, one and a half million.
00:22:18.211 --> 00:22:19.672
How, it's a chicken and egg.
00:22:19.672 --> 00:22:24.951
How do you get the one and a half without showing some level of traction?
00:22:24.951 --> 00:22:27.971
There it becomes much it becomes really challenging.
00:22:28.321 --> 00:22:34.442
One thing is of course we have, oh, it's a much nascent ecosystem for fundraising here in Scotland.
00:22:34.892 --> 00:22:37.207
In the US completely different ball game.
00:22:37.207 --> 00:22:42.156
I just spent over five weeks in the Silicon Valley and there, it's such a different world in terms of raising.
00:22:42.636 --> 00:23:00.057
You have to be embedded in the system to raise it, but you can raise based on a really good concept with the right networks and versus here where not only do you need the traction, you need a tenure business plan and like a whole bunch of other stuff and so on, five patents and so on.
00:23:00.172 --> 00:23:03.487
So it is much more challenging in terms of fundraising.
00:23:03.487 --> 00:23:08.092
But like I said, I think the answer is just, a lot more dedicated work.
00:23:08.172 --> 00:23:10.842
And looking beyond just Scotland to raise.
00:23:11.142 --> 00:23:13.416
Those are the important things, which is what we are trying to do.
00:23:13.487 --> 00:23:15.317
Our first race is likely to be in the US.
00:23:15.416 --> 00:23:15.626
Yeah,
00:23:15.626 --> 00:23:17.372
And not Scotland, unfortunately.
00:23:17.787 --> 00:23:18.146
Yeah.
00:23:18.207 --> 00:23:29.876
Oh, well It'll be interesting to see how your company develops and whether that might be an interesting model for other people to learn whether there might be any particular lessons there, which are gonna be useful going forward.
00:23:30.176 --> 00:23:36.267
So you've got this company, now that you're spinning out, are you still involved with doing other projects at Napier University?
00:23:36.852 --> 00:23:41.231
So I was still till end of May, I was still doing one day a week.
00:23:41.352 --> 00:23:45.422
Supporting the Centre of Excellence In Digital Trust, which I helped get together with Bill.
00:23:46.126 --> 00:23:49.866
But the reality of startup is there is I just don't have time.
00:23:49.926 --> 00:23:50.136
Yeah.
00:23:50.136 --> 00:23:50.826
To do anything else.
00:23:50.826 --> 00:23:51.156
I can imagine,
00:23:51.922 --> 00:23:58.916
Like I said, Monday morning I'm already looking at my to-do list for the week and I'm like, there's no way I can finish it this week.
00:23:59.136 --> 00:24:08.787
Yeah, fortunately and unfortunately, I think one of the things which I probably directed earlier is, anything which is one day or two days which a lot of commercial champion or other things are.
00:24:09.311 --> 00:24:11.201
Don't end up being one or two days.
00:24:11.251 --> 00:24:13.561
They always stretch and it's really hard.
00:24:13.561 --> 00:24:15.541
I find it really hard to manage the time.
00:24:15.541 --> 00:24:16.561
Some people are really good.
00:24:16.622 --> 00:24:18.751
They'll say, Fridays, I just do this.
00:24:18.751 --> 00:24:18.811
Yeah.
00:24:19.051 --> 00:24:19.922
I find it really hard.
00:24:19.922 --> 00:24:24.057
If I see an email, I just want to respond now, I can't wait till Friday kind of thing.
00:24:24.106 --> 00:24:27.866
So I, I gave that up because now I'm a hundred percent on this because this is it.
00:24:27.926 --> 00:24:29.487
This is my passion.
00:24:29.487 --> 00:24:36.071
This is, what I'll be breathing and living for the next whenever till we survive, hopefully we will, so yeah.
00:24:36.261 --> 00:24:40.711
Yeah I think that's probably a good place to wrap up our conversation then.
00:24:40.711 --> 00:24:45.481
So I really look forward to seeing how this develops and where it ends up going.
00:24:45.481 --> 00:24:47.071
And good luck with that to-do list.
00:24:47.422 --> 00:24:53.152
If people want to find out more about you, the work that you do, whereabouts would be a good place to go and look?
00:24:54.196 --> 00:24:59.237
LinkedIn is the go-to resource for anybody, so that I'm fairly easy to find on LinkedIn.
00:24:59.326 --> 00:25:06.632
I'm pretty good in connecting if people write me that 300 character on, on, like why?
00:25:07.382 --> 00:25:09.182
Because otherwise it becomes too much.
00:25:09.182 --> 00:25:15.922
And but I think that's, and our website is lastingasset.com, lastingasset.us.
00:25:16.281 --> 00:25:20.241
We are going to be launching a new brand perhaps in the next 60, 90 days.
00:25:20.241 --> 00:25:24.612
Which is still in stealth mode, but it would be all over LinkedIn when it does come out.
00:25:24.981 --> 00:25:26.392
So yeah, LinkedIn is the best way.
00:25:26.392 --> 00:25:31.987
I'm also always happy to support young startup founders, entrepreneurs.
00:25:31.987 --> 00:25:42.866
I've been over the last couple of years we, at Lasting Asset, we won the People's Choice Award and we're the finalist at Santander X, which was, we made it to the top 12 out of 1,560.
00:25:43.317 --> 00:25:48.057
We won the Futures Tech Award from Cisco at Converge in 23.
00:25:48.537 --> 00:25:56.632
We've been around the block as far as pitching goes and just so if I can help, I love to help young startup entrepreneurs in any way I can.
00:25:56.961 --> 00:26:03.636
So if it anything I can do, which doesn't take up a full day I'll give very, I just like, I don't charge for any of that.
00:26:03.636 --> 00:26:06.247
So like I, I'm happy to support the ecosystem.
00:26:06.846 --> 00:26:07.057
Yeah.
00:26:07.057 --> 00:26:09.936
And so anyone reach out, please feel free to,
00:26:10.207 --> 00:26:13.747
That's a fantastic offer and I'm sure some people will take you up on it.
00:26:14.106 --> 00:26:19.662
So thank you so much for taking the time to come along and tell us about the work that you do.
00:26:20.676 --> 00:26:21.307
Pleasure, Sarah.
00:26:21.307 --> 00:26:21.967
Thank you so much.
00:26:22.537 --> 00:26:23.346
It was great chatting with you.
00:26:25.400 --> 00:26:30.079
If you've been inspired by this podcast, head over to our LinkedIn page and tell us about your biggest takeaways.
00:26:30.440 --> 00:26:34.279
You'll find a link in the show notes or just search for the Academic Adventures Podcast.
00:26:34.910 --> 00:26:43.670
This podcast is a collaboration between the University of the West of Scotland, converge and Sarah McLusky, working in partnership with Ross Tuffee and the Connect-Ed Network.
00:26:44.119 --> 00:26:49.650
The podcast team includes Orla Kelly, Adam Koka, Jen Black, and me, Sarah McLusky.
00:26:50.255 --> 00:26:55.325
This season of the Academic Adventures Podcast is supported by the Scottish Funding Council.
00:00:00.500 --> 00:00:05.480
You'll often hear in the university is that we have a solution, but we are looking for a problem.
00:00:05.480 --> 00:00:09.074
Which is the reverse of how typically a startup should be done.
00:00:10.185 --> 00:00:13.724
I think most businesses work at human years, large organizations.
00:00:13.814 --> 00:00:15.974
Startups need to work in dog years.
00:00:15.974 --> 00:00:17.925
You need to do things seven times faster.
00:00:18.405 --> 00:00:21.045
But universities work in snail years, right?
00:00:22.990 --> 00:00:30.490
Actually taking something to production is a whole different ball game and getting a first customer is a huge challenge.
00:00:32.490 --> 00:00:34.831
Welcome to the Academic Adventures Podcast.
00:00:35.220 --> 00:00:40.381
This podcast is all about the journey from teaching, research, and innovation to real world solutions.
00:00:40.801 --> 00:00:50.341
For season two, we are joined by experienced founders and other experts who work alongside university staff and students to help create and support a culture of enterprise on campus.
00:00:52.540 --> 00:00:57.011
Hello and welcome to episode eight of the second season of the Academic Adventures Podcast.
00:00:57.220 --> 00:01:00.960
I'm your host, Sarah McLusky, and my guest today is Nanik Ramchandani.
00:01:01.720 --> 00:01:07.870
Inspired by the eighties movie Wall Street, Nanik initially became a stockbroker before discovering the world of entrepreneurship.
00:01:08.516 --> 00:01:18.126
His career in financial services has taken him around the world, including Dubai, Singapore, and Geneva before he settled in Edinburgh and developed his relationship with Edinburgh Napier University.
00:01:19.135 --> 00:01:26.495
This collaboration has included being an entrepreneur in residence and he also helped to establish the Scottish Center for Excellence in Digital Trust.
00:01:27.006 --> 00:01:33.486
He's now working alongside academic co-founder, Zakwan Jaroucheh, to spin out cybersecurity company Lasting Asset.
00:01:34.671 --> 00:01:41.540
In our conversation, Nanik shares the realities of building a university spinout from legal wrangles to building solid financial foundations.
00:01:42.081 --> 00:01:51.171
We also talk about why spin outs need more support to get beyond proof of concept and land their first customer, and how universities might attract and incentivize more commercial champions.
00:01:56.171 --> 00:01:58.010
Welcome to the podcast, Nanik.
00:01:58.031 --> 00:01:59.740
It's fantastic to have you here.
00:01:59.740 --> 00:02:04.600
I wonder if we could begin by hearing a bit about yourself, who you are, and what you do.
00:02:05.361 --> 00:02:06.051
Okay, great.
00:02:06.051 --> 00:02:06.650
Thanks Sarah.
00:02:06.710 --> 00:02:07.281
Likewise.
00:02:07.311 --> 00:02:08.061
Lovely to be here.
00:02:08.091 --> 00:02:10.320
Um, I'm Nanik Ramchandani.
00:02:10.341 --> 00:02:21.276
I'm currently the co-founder and CEO of a business that's just spun out of Edinburgh Napier University 77 days ago and I'm counting.
00:02:21.985 --> 00:02:28.895
It's a business called Lasting Asset where we are we are on a mission to stop imposter, fraud, imposter or impersonation fraud.
00:02:29.205 --> 00:02:31.575
In, in America they like to call it imposter.
00:02:31.575 --> 00:02:33.195
Here we call it impersonation.
00:02:33.536 --> 00:02:39.235
But that's why I'm, of course the long journey to get to where I'm, but we can talk about that as it goes along.
00:02:39.295 --> 00:02:39.475
Yeah.
00:02:39.836 --> 00:02:40.135
Yeah.
00:02:40.165 --> 00:02:41.186
Thanks for setting the scene there.
00:02:41.186 --> 00:02:45.686
I love that you are still counting it in numbers of days since it started.
00:02:47.075 --> 00:02:51.605
The clock starts the day you spin out and it the pace increases.
00:02:51.665 --> 00:02:51.756
Yeah.
00:02:51.816 --> 00:02:57.510
Two or three x of four x, which people don't necessarily realize, so I. I, I keep counting and keep reminding my team.
00:02:57.510 --> 00:03:02.170
It's been so many days, my God, we haven't done what we should have, so let's keep it, keep it going.
00:03:02.221 --> 00:03:02.461
Yeah.
00:03:02.790 --> 00:03:03.241
Yes.
00:03:03.241 --> 00:03:06.600
I feel like it's almost like they talk about politicians and things the first a hundred days.
00:03:06.600 --> 00:03:09.931
I imagine it's a similar, it's a similar crazy time.
00:03:10.020 --> 00:03:10.441
Yes.
00:03:10.506 --> 00:03:16.825
So this is not your first foray into doing financial technology type businesses, is it?
00:03:16.825 --> 00:03:20.156
So maybe if you could tell us a little bit about your background and how you've ended up here.
00:03:20.770 --> 00:03:21.550
Yeah, sure.
00:03:21.550 --> 00:03:22.510
It's a long story.
00:03:22.550 --> 00:03:27.941
Going back some 25 odd years and, I was in India that, that's where I grew up.
00:03:28.330 --> 00:03:41.010
And in my early teams there was a movie called Wall Street, which kind of was the movie of the era, which kind of shaped a lot of careers, including mine, where there was this character called Gordon Gekko and everybody was like, my god, this is like the hero.
00:03:41.640 --> 00:03:47.830
He was actually a villain in there, but it was like, yeah it started my career in financial services.
00:03:47.830 --> 00:03:53.906
I was always comfortable with numbers and that was very clear at that point that what I wanted to do was run my own hedge fund and so on.
00:03:54.355 --> 00:03:58.915
But, so my first job after doing my master's was working with a stockbroker.
00:03:59.216 --> 00:04:02.545
This is like 99, and my biggest client said.
00:04:02.906 --> 00:04:06.566
Hey, I've just invested in a.com, so come and run it for me.
00:04:06.566 --> 00:04:08.816
So this is 99.
00:04:08.876 --> 00:04:20.446
And so we started what was then capital market education site and and also a social media site, which was interesting because those, both those categories were exploded after.
00:04:20.956 --> 00:04:24.245
And so that was my first introduction to startups.
00:04:24.245 --> 00:04:25.415
Absolutely loved it.
00:04:25.896 --> 00:04:47.526
Then the world changed in 2001, and I continued to work on different startup ideas, including tutoring kids in the US from India, doing book reviews, Amazon was getting big then, but finally in 2003 decided to go back to business school and that started a 15 year career in financial services.
00:04:47.826 --> 00:04:52.925
Long story short, I did run the hedge fund that I always wanted to do, and Murphy's law things never go as planned.
00:04:53.696 --> 00:05:00.855
realised this was not what I really was inspired to do, and midlife crisis, I've gone back to my true love of startups.
00:05:00.855 --> 00:05:12.901
So that's been the backward journey in back 2018, 19, I was working, giving some advice, doing some consulting work with scale ups in the, mostly in the financial sector.
00:05:13.380 --> 00:05:25.391
And that was also the time we had moved to Edinburgh, which is now home, and somehow got involved with Napier and that started my new journey in entrepreneurship, commercialization, and so on.
00:05:25.696 --> 00:05:26.036
Yeah.
00:05:26.605 --> 00:05:27.925
So tell us a bit more about that.
00:05:27.925 --> 00:05:32.216
So your connection has really been with Napier University.
00:05:32.271 --> 00:05:33.216
How did that start?
00:05:33.216 --> 00:05:35.255
What sorts of things have you done together?
00:05:35.771 --> 00:05:36.310
Yeah.
00:05:36.341 --> 00:05:40.600
No it was a very serendipitous interesting story.
00:05:40.600 --> 00:05:49.821
Way back in, in 2019/20, I was working and advising different startups and scale ups and we had moved to Edinburgh at the time.
00:05:50.331 --> 00:05:57.836
And so there was a Entrepreneur in Residence at Napier at the time, Jamie Graves, who was leaving it was end of the year.
00:05:57.836 --> 00:06:06.016
It was end of 2021, and he was helping a project at the time run by a young bright PhD called Pablos.
00:06:06.295 --> 00:06:10.966
And somehow we got in touch and Jamie asked if I had time to support him.
00:06:11.505 --> 00:06:12.886
Pablos and I got along really well.
00:06:12.886 --> 00:06:23.185
I. And that just started, I became a commercial champion to support Pablos, which was now at that stage we were applying for the high growth spin out opportunity qualification grant.
00:06:23.725 --> 00:06:29.105
It went on to get the company creation grant and an Innovate UK cyber A subgrant.
00:06:29.105 --> 00:06:31.505
So kinda just grew arms and legs.
00:06:31.505 --> 00:06:34.565
And around the same time I also met Bill Buchanan.
00:06:34.625 --> 00:06:38.136
And if you don't know Bill, he's one of, he's like a force of nature in Scotland.
00:06:38.136 --> 00:06:40.625
He's been, he's one of the pillars of Napier.
00:06:40.625 --> 00:06:43.625
Been working there for 36 years as a professor.
00:06:44.105 --> 00:06:46.235
Absolutely loves what he does.
00:06:46.326 --> 00:06:49.596
Like he's got more energy than a 17-year-old on his first date.
00:06:49.966 --> 00:06:52.740
But, and just an incredible human being.
00:06:52.740 --> 00:07:06.656
And I ended up working with Bill on a bunch of things, including setting up the first centre of excellence in digital trust in Scotland, where Napier is the founding the founding university alongside Glasgow and University of Edinburgh.
00:07:07.701 --> 00:07:11.360
Bill also got me to apply for the Royal Society Entrepreneur in Residence Scheme.
00:07:11.360 --> 00:07:16.430
So I was the Royal Society EIR in 23/24 at Napier.
00:07:17.021 --> 00:07:41.886
Also got involved with the second project where Zakwan, who's now my co-founder at Lasting Asset, was working on a bunch of different problems and I worked alongside with him over the last two years and again, getting multiple rounds of funding, getting the project from what was an initial idea on crypto asset custody to now stopping financial fraud.
00:07:42.435 --> 00:07:49.490
So it's been a very intense four years where somehow I've just gotten involved with Napier and gotten intertwined in the system then.
00:07:50.271 --> 00:07:55.790
Yeah, it sounds like that really was a meeting of minds and then it's just gone off in various different directions.
00:07:56.151 --> 00:08:00.740
So this company that you're involved in now was a spin out from the university.
00:08:00.740 --> 00:08:03.081
So tell us a bit more about the story behind that.
00:08:03.081 --> 00:08:04.221
You've mentioned it a little bit.
00:08:04.836 --> 00:08:05.406
Yes.
00:08:05.466 --> 00:08:12.776
So in, in 2023 Zakwan was working on creating a better digital asset custody solution.
00:08:12.776 --> 00:08:16.375
So essentially in crypto assets, if you lose your private key, you lose your assets.
00:08:16.375 --> 00:08:22.946
So he wanted to make a better custody solution and he had made some good strides in that in that direction.
00:08:23.396 --> 00:08:32.836
But it was a really hard problem to commercialise and also, we realised that it wasn't something that really excited us, like we didn't wake up any morning wanting to protect crypto assets.
00:08:33.566 --> 00:08:42.086
And that we had applied for grants, so we got the high growth spin out opportunity qualification for that, where we explored multiple use cases.
00:08:42.086 --> 00:08:48.296
And one of the things you'll often hear in the university is that we have a solution, but we are looking for a problem.
00:08:48.296 --> 00:08:51.890
Which is the reverse of how typically a startup should be done.
00:08:52.250 --> 00:08:54.605
But it is a challenge which is not insurmountable.
00:08:54.605 --> 00:09:04.110
It just requires a lot more thinking about what problem is it that our technology can solve well versus just any technology solving.
00:09:04.551 --> 00:09:08.841
And that kind of led to this passion to stop fraud.
00:09:09.301 --> 00:09:13.711
Around the same time in 23, my mother was scammed and I saw what it did to her.
00:09:13.711 --> 00:09:22.730
So it was one of those things where just came together that this is a problem we want to solve and this is a problem we can see ourselves doing for the next 20 years.
00:09:23.120 --> 00:09:35.081
And that project went on within the university to raise almost a half a million pounds in different grants and now has spun out as of 77 days ago, as I probably mentioned.
00:09:35.630 --> 00:09:41.480
And we are now out to hopefully get our product launched in the next 60 to 90 days.
00:09:41.975 --> 00:09:42.666
Fantastic.
00:09:42.666 --> 00:09:43.625
What a great story.
00:09:43.895 --> 00:09:47.466
And yeah, it'll be interesting to see how that develops.
00:09:47.466 --> 00:09:58.535
So is this your first experience of spinning out a company from actually from a university rather than a company that was already running or doing it just completely independently?
00:09:58.865 --> 00:10:01.296
And how has that process been?
00:10:01.296 --> 00:10:02.495
Has it been different?
00:10:03.605 --> 00:10:05.796
Oh yeah that we, how many, how much time do we have?
00:10:05.796 --> 00:10:06.725
Another five hours.
00:10:06.946 --> 00:10:09.796
Yeah, it is the first one, which I've actually spun out.
00:10:09.826 --> 00:10:19.696
I was involved in the previous project as well, which was the one that I mentioned between 2021 and 2023, that hasn't spun out yet, but should spin out soon.
00:10:19.846 --> 00:10:28.510
They had some other technical and financial challenges to, to surmount but the spin out process is definitely not an easy one.
00:10:28.510 --> 00:10:30.041
I think it's getting better.
00:10:30.130 --> 00:10:38.191
Napier has done a lot of spin outs before in the cybersecurity space, so they've got history in doing it.
00:10:38.740 --> 00:10:48.431
But it's still fairly clunky in terms of the negotiation process, which happens like 24 months too late, to be honest.
00:10:48.581 --> 00:10:52.191
It should be very clear at the beginning of what it involves and so on.
00:10:52.551 --> 00:10:59.120
Even the whole legal documentation process, it just feels like it's just far too onerous for this stage it is at.
00:10:59.471 --> 00:11:10.645
If you look at startups in the US, they, there's a typical YC document template, which is a five pager for safe notes, which is how every startup literally starts in the US.
00:11:11.076 --> 00:11:11.975
It's so easy.
00:11:12.035 --> 00:11:12.875
Everybody knows it.
00:11:12.875 --> 00:11:14.346
It's a quick sign and you're done.
00:11:14.735 --> 00:11:16.706
So university spin outs are harder.
00:11:16.706 --> 00:11:27.015
I think I lost about half my hair and the rest became gray through that three month process of actually looking through about 200 pages of legal docs.
00:11:27.600 --> 00:11:27.721
Goodness.
00:11:27.936 --> 00:11:33.841
I would, I, I think that can be definitely made easier but yeah, it's not great, but I think it's getting better.
00:11:33.841 --> 00:11:33.870
Okay.
00:11:34.081 --> 00:11:35.520
I definitely believe it's getting better way.
00:11:35.885 --> 00:11:36.275
Yeah.
00:11:36.326 --> 00:11:37.076
Oh, I hope so.
00:11:37.405 --> 00:11:42.520
So how has your partner in this business, how have they found this process?
00:11:42.520 --> 00:11:43.961
Is it what they expected?
00:11:44.530 --> 00:11:47.301
This whole perceptions versus reality idea.
00:11:47.301 --> 00:11:47.961
Oh, that, yeah.
00:11:48.260 --> 00:11:52.206
I think perception versus reality is interesting because it's, I think there are two sides to it.
00:11:52.296 --> 00:11:56.150
One is as a business, what it takes to start up a business.
00:11:56.201 --> 00:11:58.495
And then what it takes to spin out.
00:11:58.495 --> 00:12:00.515
So there are two different things I look at it.
00:12:01.025 --> 00:12:10.505
I think from my, in this particular case, ro my co-founder's perspective, what really worked well with us is that we trusted each other for our domains.
00:12:10.831 --> 00:12:16.650
And this is one of the things like when I look at, I do some angel investing on the side or whatever.
00:12:16.650 --> 00:12:21.030
When I look at people who, who I would invest in would be people who are very self-aware.
00:12:21.365 --> 00:12:27.576
They know what they're good at, and then they know what that person brings to the table and they then leave each other to it.
00:12:27.576 --> 00:12:30.365
It's, there's no sense at that stage to try and do it.
00:12:30.365 --> 00:12:37.115
So I don't think basically my co-founder didn't necessarily spend much time on the legal documentation, all the stuff at all.
00:12:37.426 --> 00:12:41.010
He left that to me and I left him to focus on the deck.
00:12:41.525 --> 00:12:45.005
So the spin out process probably wasn't as harrowing for him.
00:12:45.696 --> 00:12:59.706
But in terms of, I think when it comes to how easy or difficult is it as, and what it takes to do a business in a startup, most people don't really know until they get into it.
00:13:00.155 --> 00:13:04.696
And this, it's, I think one of the biggest misconceptions is it's really easy to make money in a startup.
00:13:05.056 --> 00:13:07.336
So I think the worst way to make money is set up a startup.
00:13:09.285 --> 00:13:20.035
Like you can do so much better if you are a PhD or and qualified to get a job, which gives you those holidays and the options or whatever on the pension.
00:13:20.520 --> 00:13:28.336
Versus a startup where 95% probabilities will fail after eight years and after a hundred hour weeks and so on.
00:13:28.755 --> 00:13:34.225
And I think it helps if you've been around the block to realize that it's not it's not easy.
00:13:34.495 --> 00:13:39.775
And the only reason, therefore you do a startup is because you love the problem that you're trying to solve.
00:13:39.926 --> 00:13:43.076
Otherwise, it's very hard to survive a startup, to be honest.
00:13:43.125 --> 00:13:45.076
So yeah, I dunno if I answered that.
00:13:46.910 --> 00:13:47.150
Yeah.
00:13:47.150 --> 00:13:51.951
So you're painting a picture of a really challenging process there.
00:13:51.951 --> 00:14:01.431
Sounds like it's something that's not for the faint-hearted, but that's where I guess specialists, experts, people like you who've been through it before, are incredibly valuable.
00:14:03.171 --> 00:14:04.640
Yeah, I think it definitely helps.
00:14:04.640 --> 00:14:06.370
I, there's a lot in Scotland.
00:14:06.370 --> 00:14:10.780
Scotland's a great ecosystem, and I've lived in like more than 10 places across the world.
00:14:10.780 --> 00:14:25.561
So whether it's East Coast US or Singapore, Dubai or Geneva or whatever, like I've worked and lived in multiple parts of the world and I think the Scottish ecosystem is incredible for getting you off the ground, especially if you are within the university.
00:14:26.100 --> 00:14:34.105
But what happens is that it's not necessarily great in terms of giving your real reality check on how hard it is.
00:14:34.225 --> 00:14:40.225
Yeah, and so the way I like to put it is, in the financial world there's this thing that dentists make the worst investors, right?
00:14:40.225 --> 00:14:45.355
Because they're really good at something and it's very straightforward what they do every day.
00:14:45.745 --> 00:14:49.285
And over a period of time, you start thinking that you can do everything really well.
00:14:49.520 --> 00:14:54.260
So the reason like you in the financial world is like when dentists start day trading, it's a disaster.
00:14:54.260 --> 00:14:54.831
They lose everything.
00:14:55.311 --> 00:14:56.510
It's one of those things.
00:14:57.230 --> 00:15:05.270
So in similarly in the academic world, you're essentially, you're really good at something you've spent a lot of time focusing on, and you're really good at it.
00:15:05.301 --> 00:15:12.711
Like you're either world reknowned you've written papers, you can talk about it endlessly, but that doesn't necessarily translate into everything else in life, right?
00:15:12.961 --> 00:15:19.081
And this is what happens sometimes where the realities of a business are completely different.
00:15:19.130 --> 00:15:32.120
Which is where the self-awareness is so important that like realizing that it's you are good at something doesn't mean that you can actually run a business and a three week program on teaching you how it's not going to make you an expert either.
00:15:32.671 --> 00:15:37.985
And so it's a, I don't, I, I'm not saying that academics can be fantastic CEOs.
00:15:38.735 --> 00:15:41.645
They can, and like Jamie Graves is an incredible example.
00:15:41.645 --> 00:15:47.885
He built a company called Zone Fox, spun out of Napier, sold it after 10 years to a multi-billion dollar business.
00:15:48.216 --> 00:15:52.086
But, and he went through that 10 years to be the great CEO that he was.
00:15:52.135 --> 00:15:53.275
But it takes that time.
00:15:53.326 --> 00:15:53.926
That's what I mean.
00:15:53.926 --> 00:15:53.985
Yeah.
00:15:53.985 --> 00:15:59.556
It's it's almost saying that, okay, you've been to business school for two years and I can learn the same thing in two weeks.
00:15:59.556 --> 00:16:00.336
It doesn't work.
00:16:00.936 --> 00:16:01.326
Yeah.
00:16:01.385 --> 00:16:05.166
No, it makes absolute sense and why you need those experts and things around you.
00:16:05.586 --> 00:16:19.686
And so if that support that perhaps is out there isn't maybe hitting the spot, what else do you think might be needed to help these people who are interested in developing companies from universities?
00:16:22.130 --> 00:16:31.510
So I think that the support is, yes, it's not there as, I think there are lots of universities complain that they can't find really good commercial champions.
00:16:31.900 --> 00:16:39.551
And a part of it is a function of how do you incentivize the commercial champion because the commercial champion comes in on day one.
00:16:39.610 --> 00:16:43.240
There's no visibility on any upside on this project.
00:16:43.240 --> 00:16:46.100
So it's purely, a payment for number of days worked.
00:16:46.201 --> 00:16:55.140
So the question is, and which is typically subsidized to real market rates, and then it's typically two days a week maximum for the project.
00:16:55.785 --> 00:17:08.086
Now the commercial champion has, can't leave a full-time job to work two days on something they have to be doing, either be a entrepreneur on their own and doing be doing something else three days a week or trying to fit that with another project.
00:17:08.586 --> 00:17:17.405
And as anybody in the startup world would know, once you are in a startup, it's a, you can't do anything else, you, it is a full-time like intense job.
00:17:17.786 --> 00:17:20.395
I would say even just fundraising is a full-time job now.
00:17:20.395 --> 00:17:22.736
Forget the startup as a full-time job.
00:17:22.736 --> 00:17:29.026
So I think incentivizing the people correctly and having is extremely important.
00:17:29.605 --> 00:17:37.375
The second thing, and it's just that ecosystem buildup process where we have great programs on training.
00:17:37.375 --> 00:17:41.546
We have fairly good initial set of mentors.
00:17:41.965 --> 00:17:47.530
What could really help is getting the first customer for example.
00:17:47.980 --> 00:18:04.361
Like one of the things that most startups struggle with is it's great building in the lab and having a TRL five or six, but actually taking something to production is a whole different ball game and getting a first customer is a huge challenge.
00:18:04.411 --> 00:18:16.306
If the ecosystem helps you get that first customer, and this is where Scottish government, Scottish enterprise, all the organizations can help, it would be a game changer in, in my view for example, just give you illustration.
00:18:16.306 --> 00:18:30.105
So we wanted to do a pilot while we were within the university, and it took so many months of back and forth with the insurer of the university to figure out how we would contract with this pilot customer.
00:18:30.155 --> 00:18:31.986
We couldn't do it in the end, right?
00:18:31.986 --> 00:18:34.145
So you have classic challenge.
00:18:34.145 --> 00:18:36.036
To raise money, you need traction.
00:18:36.425 --> 00:18:41.611
But to have traction, you have to do something like sign a contract, which is, but to sign a contract.
00:18:41.611 --> 00:18:46.191
You have to actually be outside the university because today I can sign a contract in, one day.
00:18:46.205 --> 00:18:47.375
Yeah, all I need to do.
00:18:47.615 --> 00:18:52.625
But within the university, six months later, I couldn't sign the contract because it was just so complicated, yeah.
00:18:52.776 --> 00:18:54.546
Because who's taking responsibility?
00:18:54.546 --> 00:18:56.256
Where does the liability lie?
00:18:56.256 --> 00:18:56.855
And so on.
00:18:57.306 --> 00:19:01.296
So it's almost like getting that first customer is such a challenge and.
00:19:02.121 --> 00:19:06.050
I have tons of ideas on how we can make it easier, but we don't have time for that.
00:19:06.141 --> 00:19:06.260
Yeah.
00:19:06.411 --> 00:19:08.861
But like that could be a game changer.
00:19:08.911 --> 00:19:09.090
Yeah.
00:19:09.121 --> 00:19:13.026
In like how we, these spinoffs really get that acceleration.
00:19:13.385 --> 00:19:13.685
Yes.
00:19:13.726 --> 00:19:21.925
Which is so important because only advantage as a startup is velocity, within the university, like I think most businesses work at human years.
00:19:21.925 --> 00:19:25.465
Large organizations, startups need to work in dog years.
00:19:25.465 --> 00:19:27.415
You need to do things seven times faster.
00:19:27.895 --> 00:19:30.536
But universities work in snail years, right?
00:19:31.435 --> 00:19:31.645
Yeah.
00:19:31.855 --> 00:19:33.955
They're the definitely the other end of the scale.
00:19:33.955 --> 00:19:34.316
Yeah.
00:19:34.421 --> 00:19:39.991
So within the university it's even though there's so many people who are supporting you, it's just not possible.
00:19:40.372 --> 00:19:43.791
The systems don't allow it to do things at the pace that you need to.
00:19:43.791 --> 00:19:49.987
And what often happens is it's too late, the market has moved, the technology has moved, and so on.
00:19:49.987 --> 00:19:52.926
So you can't capitalize on the original opportunity.
00:19:53.196 --> 00:19:53.346
Yeah.
00:19:53.346 --> 00:19:58.957
And that must be particularly challenging in a very fast moving environment like digital technologies.
00:19:58.957 --> 00:19:59.436
Yeah.
00:19:59.442 --> 00:20:00.457
Yeah, a hundred percent.
00:20:00.892 --> 00:20:01.311
Yeah.
00:20:01.362 --> 00:20:13.422
I think another thing that you've mentioned a little bit as we've gone through is yes, there's the support, the tangible, the practical stuff, but then also the finance, getting the finance behind startup companies as well.
00:20:13.422 --> 00:20:18.961
And it sounds like that's something you've been very successful at doing for the businesses that you're working with.
00:20:19.682 --> 00:20:22.442
Are there any kind of secrets to that or.
00:20:22.771 --> 00:20:25.412
Is it all about the technology, the product?
00:20:26.342 --> 00:20:30.692
I think there, the one is of course, like I said, fundraising is a full-time job.
00:20:30.692 --> 00:20:36.196
So having a commercial champion who gets numbers, who understands that is, it really helps.
00:20:36.211 --> 00:20:38.642
So I've spent most of my life in finance.
00:20:39.051 --> 00:20:45.892
And I, most of my job during the, within the university was looking at every grant application I could find.
00:20:45.892 --> 00:20:48.342
And, connect with the right people and so on.
00:20:48.342 --> 00:20:57.231
So both these startups that I was like projects, I would say within the university, I working for managed to raise over half a million in non-dilutive funding.
00:20:57.231 --> 00:21:01.372
And this was like, it's huge because most nobody else in the university has done that.
00:21:01.432 --> 00:21:07.301
While in the project within the university, of course the ecosystems also become better and there's more money.
00:21:07.797 --> 00:21:18.717
But ah for example, the one that we've spun out now, we got another 350,000 in Innovate UK SMART Grant, which we only 2.5% get it in the UK.
00:21:19.136 --> 00:21:20.517
And it wasn't an easy process.
00:21:20.517 --> 00:21:27.086
Like we worked really hard with first time we got rejected, we were below the cutoff of 86%, we got 81.
00:21:27.386 --> 00:21:30.987
The second time, we got 88 or whatever, and we passed it.
00:21:31.366 --> 00:21:33.096
It took a lot of work.
00:21:33.166 --> 00:21:34.537
And I guess we talked through that.
00:21:34.537 --> 00:21:40.926
Listen, we need some funding on day one and we got that 350, so we managed to get another 350 to get it.
00:21:40.926 --> 00:21:54.561
So we have now one year's money or one 15 months money to spin out because the challenge on spin out is this classic thing that you need now you've out of the university you need money to get going, but you don't have traction yet.
00:21:54.622 --> 00:21:55.146
You Yeah.
00:21:55.346 --> 00:21:57.896
You couldn't do sales while you're within the university.
00:21:58.257 --> 00:22:02.037
And so this is the classic problem, like how do you now raise money?
00:22:02.666 --> 00:22:09.836
Usually you'll be drip fed in the unfortunately, in the Scottish ecosystem, you'll get say 250 or 100 or so.
00:22:10.396 --> 00:22:12.797
Now that can't pay for more than two people, right?
00:22:13.277 --> 00:22:17.896
So if you wanna build a business, you need that one million, one and a half million.
00:22:18.211 --> 00:22:19.672
How, it's a chicken and egg.
00:22:19.672 --> 00:22:24.951
How do you get the one and a half without showing some level of traction?
00:22:24.951 --> 00:22:27.971
There it becomes much it becomes really challenging.
00:22:28.321 --> 00:22:34.442
One thing is of course we have, oh, it's a much nascent ecosystem for fundraising here in Scotland.
00:22:34.892 --> 00:22:37.207
In the US completely different ball game.
00:22:37.207 --> 00:22:42.156
I just spent over five weeks in the Silicon Valley and there, it's such a different world in terms of raising.
00:22:42.636 --> 00:23:00.057
You have to be embedded in the system to raise it, but you can raise based on a really good concept with the right networks and versus here where not only do you need the traction, you need a tenure business plan and like a whole bunch of other stuff and so on, five patents and so on.
00:23:00.172 --> 00:23:03.487
So it is much more challenging in terms of fundraising.
00:23:03.487 --> 00:23:08.092
But like I said, I think the answer is just, a lot more dedicated work.
00:23:08.172 --> 00:23:10.842
And looking beyond just Scotland to raise.
00:23:11.142 --> 00:23:13.416
Those are the important things, which is what we are trying to do.
00:23:13.487 --> 00:23:15.317
Our first race is likely to be in the US.
00:23:15.416 --> 00:23:15.626
Yeah,
00:23:15.626 --> 00:23:17.372
And not Scotland, unfortunately.
00:23:17.787 --> 00:23:18.146
Yeah.
00:23:18.207 --> 00:23:29.876
Oh, well It'll be interesting to see how your company develops and whether that might be an interesting model for other people to learn whether there might be any particular lessons there, which are gonna be useful going forward.
00:23:30.176 --> 00:23:36.267
So you've got this company, now that you're spinning out, are you still involved with doing other projects at Napier University?
00:23:36.852 --> 00:23:41.231
So I was still till end of May, I was still doing one day a week.
00:23:41.352 --> 00:23:45.422
Supporting the Centre of Excellence In Digital Trust, which I helped get together with Bill.
00:23:46.126 --> 00:23:49.866
But the reality of startup is there is I just don't have time.
00:23:49.926 --> 00:23:50.136
Yeah.
00:23:50.136 --> 00:23:50.826
To do anything else.
00:23:50.826 --> 00:23:51.156
I can imagine,
00:23:51.922 --> 00:23:58.916
Like I said, Monday morning I'm already looking at my to-do list for the week and I'm like, there's no way I can finish it this week.
00:23:59.136 --> 00:24:08.787
Yeah, fortunately and unfortunately, I think one of the things which I probably directed earlier is, anything which is one day or two days which a lot of commercial champion or other things are.
00:24:09.311 --> 00:24:11.201
Don't end up being one or two days.
00:24:11.251 --> 00:24:13.561
They always stretch and it's really hard.
00:24:13.561 --> 00:24:15.541
I find it really hard to manage the time.
00:24:15.541 --> 00:24:16.561
Some people are really good.
00:24:16.622 --> 00:24:18.751
They'll say, Fridays, I just do this.
00:24:18.751 --> 00:24:18.811
Yeah.
00:24:19.051 --> 00:24:19.922
I find it really hard.
00:24:19.922 --> 00:24:24.057
If I see an email, I just want to respond now, I can't wait till Friday kind of thing.
00:24:24.106 --> 00:24:27.866
So I, I gave that up because now I'm a hundred percent on this because this is it.
00:24:27.926 --> 00:24:29.487
This is my passion.
00:24:29.487 --> 00:24:36.071
This is, what I'll be breathing and living for the next whenever till we survive, hopefully we will, so yeah.
00:24:36.261 --> 00:24:40.711
Yeah I think that's probably a good place to wrap up our conversation then.
00:24:40.711 --> 00:24:45.481
So I really look forward to seeing how this develops and where it ends up going.
00:24:45.481 --> 00:24:47.071
And good luck with that to-do list.
00:24:47.422 --> 00:24:53.152
If people want to find out more about you, the work that you do, whereabouts would be a good place to go and look?
00:24:54.196 --> 00:24:59.237
LinkedIn is the go-to resource for anybody, so that I'm fairly easy to find on LinkedIn.
00:24:59.326 --> 00:25:06.632
I'm pretty good in connecting if people write me that 300 character on, on, like why?
00:25:07.382 --> 00:25:09.182
Because otherwise it becomes too much.
00:25:09.182 --> 00:25:15.922
And but I think that's, and our website is lastingasset.com, lastingasset.us.
00:25:16.281 --> 00:25:20.241
We are going to be launching a new brand perhaps in the next 60, 90 days.
00:25:20.241 --> 00:25:24.612
Which is still in stealth mode, but it would be all over LinkedIn when it does come out.
00:25:24.981 --> 00:25:26.392
So yeah, LinkedIn is the best way.
00:25:26.392 --> 00:25:31.987
I'm also always happy to support young startup founders, entrepreneurs.
00:25:31.987 --> 00:25:42.866
I've been over the last couple of years we, at Lasting Asset, we won the People's Choice Award and we're the finalist at Santander X, which was, we made it to the top 12 out of 1,560.
00:25:43.317 --> 00:25:48.057
We won the Futures Tech Award from Cisco at Converge in 23.
00:25:48.537 --> 00:25:56.632
We've been around the block as far as pitching goes and just so if I can help, I love to help young startup entrepreneurs in any way I can.
00:25:56.961 --> 00:26:03.636
So if it anything I can do, which doesn't take up a full day I'll give very, I just like, I don't charge for any of that.
00:26:03.636 --> 00:26:06.247
So like I, I'm happy to support the ecosystem.
00:26:06.846 --> 00:26:07.057
Yeah.
00:26:07.057 --> 00:26:09.936
And so anyone reach out, please feel free to,
00:26:10.207 --> 00:26:13.747
That's a fantastic offer and I'm sure some people will take you up on it.
00:26:14.106 --> 00:26:19.662
So thank you so much for taking the time to come along and tell us about the work that you do.
00:26:20.676 --> 00:26:21.307
Pleasure, Sarah.
00:26:21.307 --> 00:26:21.967
Thank you so much.
00:26:22.537 --> 00:26:23.346
It was great chatting with you.
00:26:25.400 --> 00:26:30.079
If you've been inspired by this podcast, head over to our LinkedIn page and tell us about your biggest takeaways.
00:26:30.440 --> 00:26:34.279
You'll find a link in the show notes or just search for the Academic Adventures Podcast.
00:26:34.910 --> 00:26:43.670
This podcast is a collaboration between the University of the West of Scotland, converge and Sarah McLusky, working in partnership with Ross Tuffee and the Connect-Ed Network.
00:26:44.119 --> 00:26:49.650
The podcast team includes Orla Kelly, Adam Koka, Jen Black, and me, Sarah McLusky.
00:26:50.255 --> 00:26:55.325
This season of the Academic Adventures Podcast is supported by the Scottish Funding Council.
