ABOUT THIS EPISODE
Why did you start running? When is the last time you actually thought about it?
A lot of people start running for a reason that matters to them: to improve their health, to see if they can run a certain distance, to prove something to themselves, or to challenge themselves. But somewhere along the way, "I want to" or "I want to see if I can" turns into "I should."
Angie and Kevin talk about the difference between a goal that comes from your why and a goal you took on because it felt like the next right step, and why one fuels you while the other drains you. The conversation was inspired by a recent coaching call and by Simon Sinek's book Start With Why.
In this episode
- The difference between a why and a should
- The client question that started it: "What should my next goal be?"
- Kevin's story: chasing a marathon time that came from a college coach's comment, and what changed when the number stopped mattering
- Why Angie hasn't run a marathon yet, and why she won't until she genuinely wants to
- Simon Sinek's Golden Circle applied to running: the what (distance or time), the how (training plan), and the why (what the goal gives you)
- The next-right-step ladder: 5K, 10K, half marathon, and beyond
- Self-determination theory, explained through a kid learning to eat vegetables
- Manipulation vs. inspiration, and why you sometimes need a trick on a rough Monday
- Why a time on the clock is a good what but not a good why
- Permission to step off the ladder
- How your why can change over the years, and why to recheck it before you sign up for a race
Try this
Three questions to ask yourself:
- Whose goal is this?
- What does it give me?
- Would I still want it if no one knew?
Four ways to test whether it's a why or a should:
- If no one ever saw the result, with no medal and no posting on social media or Strava, would you still want it?
- Can you finish "I want this because..." without the word "should"?
- When you picture the finish line, do you feel pulled toward it or relieved it will be over?
- Whose voice is in your head, yours or someone else's?
Your action step: Pick your current goal and write its why in one sentence. Not "I want to break two hours in the half marathon," but "I want to break two hours because..." If you can't fill in the blank, take another look at the goal.
Research mentioned
- Teixeira PJ, Carraça EV, Markland D, Silva MN, Ryan RM. Exercise, physical activity, and self-determination theory: a systematic review. Int J Behav Nutr Phys Act. 2012.
- Sheldon KM, Elliot AJ. The self-concordance model (abstract). 1999.
- Self-determination in recreational exercise: associations with lapse and post-lapse emotions. Psychology of Sport and Exercise. 2019.
- How do new runners maintain their running, and what leads to others stopping? A qualitative, longitudinal study. Psychology of Sport and Exercise, volume 70.
Links and resources
- Start With Why, by Simon Sinek
- The Passion Paradox, which Angie and Kevin both recommend
- Instagram: @drangiebrown and @realliferunners
If you liked this episode, please share it with a friend. Help us reach more runners.
01:54 – Why Versus Should
03:26 – The Should Trap
05:08 – Defining Your Why
05:51 – Letting Go of the Clock
08:48 – Start With Why Framework
12:52 – Motivation Without a Race
15:49 – The Next Step Ladder
19:18 – Stress Versus Passion
21:33 – Marathon Shoulds
24:53 – Motivation Psychology
27:28 – Vegetables Motivation Analogy
29:46 – Manipulation Versus Inspiration
30:16 – Inspiration vs. Manipulation
32:27 – Motivation Research Breakdown
35:01 – Guilt vs. Enjoyment Lapses
35:59 – Internalize Your Goals
37:27 – Tests for Why vs. Should
40:44 – Reconnect to Your Why
41:18 – How Our Whys Evolve
44:39 – Choose Goals on Purpose
49:27 – Permission to Step Off
52:17 – Three Questions Action Step
53:26 – Coach Gags' Legacy
Gain access to my new secret podcast, Unbreakable: The Runner's Guide To Injury-Proofing Your Body After 40. Click here: https://www.realliferunners.com/secret
Join the Team! --> https://www.realliferunners.com/team
Thanks for Listening!!
Be sure to hit FOLLOW on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or your favorite podcast player
Leave a review on Apple Podcasts. Your ratings and reviews really help and we read each one!
Come find us on Instagram and say hi!
Don't forget: The information on this website is not intended to treat or diagnose any medical condition or to provide medical advice. It is intended for general education in the areas of health and wellness. All information contained in this site is intended to be educational in nature. Nothing should be considered medical advice for your specific situation.
TRANSCRIPT 🔗
00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:02.096
Why did you start running?
00:00:02.103 --> 00:00:04.753
When is the last time that you actually thought about that?
00:00:04.764 --> 00:00:12.307
Depending on how long you've been running, maybe it's been a little while since you've actually thought about that reason that you started running in the first place.
00:00:12.317 --> 00:00:17.329
Because a lot of people start because of a reason that matters to them.
00:00:17.339 --> 00:00:19.167
Maybe it's to imp…