ABOUT THIS EPISODE
What happens when we measure children's learning, development and success through a narrow set of metrics? And what gets lost along the way?
In this episode, Dr James Mannion and The Real David Cameron speak to journalist Cherry Casey, author of Childhood Ltd: How We Turned Children into Data and Why We Need to Stop, about the growing influence of measurement, data and competition across childhood, childcare and education.
Cherry argues that assessment itself is not the problem. Rather, we have become so focused on what can be measured that we risk neglecting the things that matter most – children's wellbeing, self-esteem, relationships, enjoyment of learning and freedom to develop in their own ways.
The conversation explores the unintended consequences of high-stakes assessment, the pressure placed on children from an increasingly young age, and the tension between academic attainment and a broader conception of human flourishing.
In this episode, we discuss:
- Measuring the wrong things: How an over-reliance on quantifiable measures can distort practice and diminish the things that are harder to measure.
- The commercialisation of childhood: How market-driven approaches and private investment can shape childcare and education, sometimes at the expense of children's wellbeing.
- Starting formal education too early: What happens when academic expectations outpace children's developmental readiness, and why play matters.
- Reading for pleasure: Why learning to decode words is not the same as becoming a reader – and how schools can nurture a lasting love of books.
- Competition, discipline and school accountability: Whether raising the stakes genuinely raises standards, or simply encourages institutions to perform better against the measures being used.
- The hidden costs of high achievement: How pressure to succeed can undermine confidence, self-worth and engagement, even when pupils achieve strong grades.
- Rethinking assessment: How we might broaden what we assess and value, including creativity, collaboration, problem-solving, relationships and the ability to apply learning in unfamiliar contexts.
- Learning to flourish: Why education needs to attend to the whole child, rather than treating academic attainment as the primary measure of success.
The conversation also considers what we can learn from schools that prioritise relationships, belonging and a love of learning, and why listening to teachers, children and families is essential to building a better system.
If we change what we measure, we may change what we treasure.
LINKS
Cherry Casey – The UK has a forced adoption problem (Prospect) https://www.prospectmagazine.co.uk/society/60185/the-uk-has-a-forced-adoption-problem
BOOK: Childhood Ltd by Cherry Casey - https://www.amazon.co.uk/Childhood-Ltd-Cherry-Casey/dp/1837733430
SUPPORT THE SHOW
This podcast is brought to you by Crown House Publishing. It’s presented by Dr James Mannion and David Cameron, and produced by Sophie Dean. Get 20% off all titles at https://www.crownhouse.co.uk with the promo code REPOD20 (excludes bundles and existing promotions).
Become a patron at https://www.patreon.com/repod or make a one-off donation at https://www.buymeacoffee.com/repod – and help us keep these conversations coming.
In this episode, Dr James Mannion and The Real David Cameron speak to journalist Cherry Casey, author of Childhood Ltd: How We Turned Children into Data and Why We Need to Stop, about the growing influence of measurement, data and competition across childhood, childcare and education.
Cherry argues that assessment itself is not the problem. Rather, we have become so focused on what can be measured that we risk neglecting the things that matter most – children's wellbeing, self-esteem, relationships, enjoyment of learning and freedom to develop in their own ways.
The conversation explores the unintended consequences of high-stakes assessment, the pressure placed on children from an increasingly young age, and the tension between academic attainment and a broader conception of human flourishing.
In this episode, we discuss:
- Measuring the wrong things: How an over-reliance on quantifiable measures can distort practice and diminish the things that are harder to measure.
- The commercialisation of childhood: How market-driven approaches and private investment can shape childcare and education, sometimes at the expense of children's wellbeing.
- Starting formal education too early: What happens when academic expectations outpace children's developmental readiness, and why play matters.
- Reading for pleasure: Why learning to decode words is not the same as becoming a reader – and how schools can nurture a lasting love of books.
- Competition, discipline and school accountability: Whether raising the stakes genuinely raises standards, or simply encourages institutions to perform better against the measures being used.
- The hidden costs of high achievement: How pressure to succeed can undermine confidence, self-worth and engagement, even when pupils achieve strong grades.
- Rethinking assessment: How we might broaden what we assess and value, including creativity, collaboration, problem-solving, relationships and the ability to apply learning in unfamiliar contexts.
- Learning to flourish: Why education needs to attend to the whole child, rather than treating academic attainment as the primary measure of success.
The conversation also considers what we can learn from schools that prioritise relationships, belonging and a love of learning, and why listening to teachers, children and families is essential to building a better system.
If we change what we measure, we may change what we treasure.
LINKS
Cherry Casey – The UK has a forced adoption problem (Prospect) https://www.prospectmagazine.co.uk/society/60185/the-uk-has-a-forced-adoption-problem
BOOK: Childhood Ltd by Cherry Casey - https://www.amazon.co.uk/Childhood-Ltd-Cherry-Casey/dp/1837733430
SUPPORT THE SHOW
This podcast is brought to you by Crown House Publishing. It’s presented by Dr James Mannion and David Cameron, and produced by Sophie Dean. Get 20% off all titles at https://www.crownhouse.co.uk with the promo code REPOD20 (excludes bundles and existing promotions).
Become a patron at https://www.patreon.com/repod or make a one-off donation at https://www.buymeacoffee.com/repod – and help us keep these conversations coming.
English
United States
TRANSCRIPT 🔗
Are you the producer of this podcast?
Add a podcast transcript
Need Audio-to-Text?
Transcribe with Listen411 in Just 60 Seconds
SEARCH PAST EPISODES
Search past episodes of Rethinking Education.
OTHER EPISODES IN THIS PODCAST
In this episode, James and David are joined by Sue Roffey – educational psychologist, researcher, and leading voice on wellbeing, social justice, and relational approaches to education.
Sue traces her journey from working with young people facing emotional and behavioural challenges, through educat…
As the number of living Holocaust survivors declines, a profound question emerges: who carries these stories next – and how do we ensure they are heard, understood, and acted upon?
In this episode, timed to mark Holocaust Memorial Day on January 27th, James and David are joined by Hannah Wilson, O…
“It’s not about teacher-centred or student-centred. I would argue it’s dialogue-centred.”
In this episode of the Rethinking Education podcast, Dr James Mannion and The Read David Cameron explore these questions with Professor Rupert Wegerif, author of Rethinking Educational Theory: Education as Exp…
Why do so many lessons feel disconnected to students – even when the content is genuinely fascinating?
In this episode, Dr James Mannion is joined by teacher and author Hywel Roberts to explore 'botheredness' – a way of teaching that draws students into learning through narrative, curiosity and sh…
In this episode, featuring a webinar we ran this week, Tara Elie and Dr James Mannion explore a question that many school leaders are quietly wrestling with:
Why do so many behaviour initiatives fail to deliver sustained change?
Across the system, the signals are hard to ignore – rising suspensio…
Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Dr James Mannion, which is the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Listen Notes, Inc.
EDIT
Thank you for helping to keep the podcast database up to date.