ABOUT THIS EPISODE
A passionate conversation with Andrew Bissel at Light Middle East reveals the growing frustration among lighting professionals fighting for recognition in the built environment. Wearing multiple hats as Ridge and Partners' lighting design head, a dark sky consultant for Red Sea Global, and past president of the Society of Light and Lighting, Andrew delivers a candid assessment of where the industry stands today.
Quote of the day:
“We need this participation of advocates, we need the certification for a business model and we need the legislation from government to drive certain industries, because they won’t drive themselves. But you also need the lighting professional.” — Andrew Bissel
This interview was recorded at Light Middle East in Dubai in 2024. Although it's been a little over a year, the insights and expertise Andrew shares are timeless and incredibly relevant today.
The discussion highlights a painful truth: despite decades of education and advocacy, lighting remains "the forgotten person around the design table." As Andrew bluntly puts it, "Every poor project didn't have a lighting professional." After years of polite education, he suggests the time may have come for lighting experts to more assertively claim their rightful place in the design process.
Perhaps most fascinating is the exploration of how the industry has evolved beyond separating "dark sky specialists" from regular lighting designers. Today's professionals simply practice "responsible design" as standard. The conversation takes a thought-provoking turn when addressing how lighting organisations themselves might inadvertently reinforce industry silos rather than breaking them down. Could integrating lighting professionals throughout built environment events rather than segregating them into dedicated sections be the way forward?
For anyone invested in the future of lighting design, this discussion illuminates both challenges and potential pathways to elevating the profession's recognition across architecture, engineering, planning, and beyond. Join us in exploring how lighting professionals can finally secure their essential place at the design table.
Learn more about our community by visiting www.vld.community
Follow us on Facebook, Instagram, and LinkedIn.
If you enjoyed this episode and want to hear more like this, please signup, subscribe and would appreciate a 5-star review!
IN THIS EPISODE
SHOW NOTES 🔗
TRANSCRIPT 🔗
00:00:00.381 --> 00:00:01.143
Hello everyone.
00:00:01.143 --> 00:00:04.692
This is Amardeep Dugar signing in for the Virtual Lighting Design Community.
00:00:04.692 --> 00:00:08.089
We are in Dubai again for the Light Middle East.
00:00:08.089 --> 00:00:09.663
It's been a great show.
00:00:09.663 --> 00:00:18.434
We have a beautiful and amazing booth here and we have an amazing guest with us for our Light Talks to continue the discussion about all the things lighting.
00:00:18.434 --> 00:00:22.951
So, andrew, can I ask you to introduce yourself and say what you do a little bit about yourself.
00:00:23.600 --> 00:00:25.342
Yeah, sure, so, thank you.
00:00:25.342 --> 00:00:34.024
I'm here with, uh, various hats on um, so I'm here as, uh, the head of the lighting design team for ridge and partners.
00:00:34.024 --> 00:00:56.154
We've been set up about 18 months ago working on a whole variety of projects prime, residential, hospitality, motor racing projects, various other office place work, but also dark sky projects, which are probably what we're known for really at the moment.
00:00:56.154 --> 00:01:20.021
The second reason I'm here is because we're working on the Red Sea project as dark sky consultants for Red Sea Global and it worked really well to tie in a meeting with ruskin hartley, with the client, andrew bates, and travel to site and see the projects that are finished, see some of the assets that are halfway through and just have a look at the good, the bad and the ugly.
00:01:20.100 --> 00:01:20.942
Where are we up to?
00:01:20.942 --> 00:01:24.090
What's worked, what hasn, what hasn't, etc.
00:01:24.090 --> 00:01:25.914
And that's been so worthwhile.
00:01:25.914 --> 00:01:33.087
And it worked to go there before coming here on the basis that it fitted with the moon cycles, we needed the moon below the horizon, etc.
00:01:33.087 --> 00:01:34.766
So this has all worked out nicely.
00:01:34.766 --> 00:01:36.364
And then I'm also here.
00:01:36.364 --> 00:01:40.290
I'm last year's President of the Society of Light and Lighting.
00:01:40.290 --> 00:02:04.269
This year the President is Helen Looms, but Brendan Keeley is here as the secretary of the Society of Light and Lighting and we have a stand here just to raise awareness of the society within this region, trying to attract new members, try and see what our current members are up to, what help they need from us, and I'm just helping Brendan out as and when he needs me.
00:02:04.269 --> 00:02:06.849
So a really full two weeks.
00:02:06.939 --> 00:02:08.242
That's a lot of hats.
00:02:08.242 --> 00:02:12.652
My god, you could be a champion at multitasking.
00:02:13.721 --> 00:02:17.812
I wouldn't say a champion at multitasking, forced multitasking.
00:02:18.580 --> 00:02:20.485
So have you been to Light Middle East before?
00:02:20.485 --> 00:02:21.408
Is this your first time?
00:02:21.408 --> 00:02:22.091
Your second time?
00:02:22.460 --> 00:02:27.402
First time at Light Middle East, middle east, um, and, and it's impressive, it's, it's huge.
00:02:27.402 --> 00:02:32.222
I mean, I mean obviously, uh, lights, this section is big, but there are other sections.
00:02:32.222 --> 00:02:35.449
You've got a smart building section, we've got security sections.
00:02:35.449 --> 00:02:39.027
It's huge, but certainly the light section is impressive, really impressive.
00:02:39.027 --> 00:02:44.284
And uh, manufacturers you know, and you've always known some of them with, uh, things you've not before.
00:02:44.586 --> 00:02:47.832
Always worth coming to these events to see things you've not seen before.
00:02:47.832 --> 00:02:54.539
But then lots of manufacturers you haven't heard of, yeah, you may have seen their products, you may not, but you didn't know it was theirs.
00:02:54.539 --> 00:02:56.929
So, absolutely fantastic.
00:02:56.929 --> 00:03:02.752
But I mean the talks, the Think Like conference, have really been the icing on the cake Highlight of the year.
00:03:02.752 --> 00:03:08.444
Oh, for sure, because you can see the products.
00:03:08.444 --> 00:03:12.500
But then to hear from so many wonderful people you know them, you know of them, you know of their work, but you're actually listening to them.
00:03:12.520 --> 00:03:17.687
There's Andrea and various other people are talking at the moment about setting up a lighting business.
00:03:17.687 --> 00:03:30.774
I mean that's not easy, yeah, yeah, yeah, that talk could go on for weeks and I think that they have a keynote speaker.
00:03:30.774 --> 00:03:34.813
Then they have five or six other speakers come and give slightly different takes.
00:03:34.813 --> 00:03:51.950
I was involved in the Dark Sky one, but we then also had Ruskin there from Dark Sky International, we had the client Andrew Bates there from Red Sea Global, then we had various lighting designers, so you know, to get all those different takes on that same subject and the questions from the audience.
00:03:51.950 --> 00:03:56.812
Clearly this is something people are working on and they want to know more about.
00:03:56.812 --> 00:04:00.831
So absolute first-class conference, first-class conference.
00:04:00.852 --> 00:04:02.349
Yeah, it has been really impressive.
00:04:02.349 --> 00:04:08.171
And I've been here I think this is probably my fifth time and I've seen this thing grow and the manner it has been grown.
00:04:08.171 --> 00:04:10.614
You can actually make out from the size of the aisle spaces.
00:04:10.614 --> 00:04:15.039
So they're just getting narrower and narrower, so you can only say the booths are getting bigger.
00:04:15.039 --> 00:04:16.384
There are more and more booths that are happening.
00:04:16.985 --> 00:04:18.673
And there are some really impressive booths here.
00:04:18.673 --> 00:04:21.053
You know, the sort of thing you normally only see at Frankfurt.
00:04:21.053 --> 00:04:26.495
It's here, you know, so people are obviously investing in coming here.
00:04:26.495 --> 00:04:30.408
But as a lighting designer, it's brilliant, you know everything's so close.
00:04:30.408 --> 00:04:39.271
The smart technology section is really useful to go into as well, which is right next door to the lighting, for obvious reasons, so first-class place to be.
00:04:39.312 --> 00:04:39.533
Great.
00:04:39.533 --> 00:04:41.694
Now the conference.
00:04:41.694 --> 00:04:43.564
You mentioned about the conference, the Think Light conference.
00:04:43.564 --> 00:04:49.112
The theme this year was Enlightened Futures and they've talked about responsibility.
00:04:49.112 --> 00:04:53.322
Responsibility is a big word and it's a very broad word.
00:04:53.322 --> 00:04:55.610
Now, you've been a lighting designer.
00:04:55.610 --> 00:05:05.370
You've had so many hats as a president of a society, a leader of your team, even things like responsibility of social and environmental responsibility.
00:05:05.370 --> 00:05:07.177
What are the ways?
00:05:07.177 --> 00:05:10.146
How would you define responsibility?
00:05:10.146 --> 00:05:10.848
It's so broad.
00:05:11.629 --> 00:05:34.906
It incredibly broad and it it's actually quite a frustration of mine and I don't know if it's age or or if it's wisdom, possibly age the longer you're in the industry, the more frustrated you get that you're learning all the time about how how much of an influence light has on the environment, on people, on wildlife, everything we touch, everything.
00:05:34.906 --> 00:05:51.432
You know without light, you know what can you do and you know it's uh, and therefore we have such um, such an impact on, on everything that everybody does, and yet it still seems to be the forgotten person around the design table.
00:05:51.432 --> 00:05:57.814
You know, people have an opinion and they chuck it in no knowledge, no training, no education.
00:05:57.814 --> 00:05:58.475
They have an opinion.
00:05:58.475 --> 00:06:08.843
Others guess you know, I'll take a guess you know others have an ego and they want to chuck something in and you're sat there and you're just thinking when, when, when do we reach a point?
00:06:08.983 --> 00:06:25.995
As lighting professionals and that was part of my talk when I gave the keynote that you know, as part of dark skies, we need this participation of advocates, we need the certification for a business model and we need the legislation from government to drive certain industries, because they won't drive themselves.
00:06:25.995 --> 00:06:27.944
But you also need the lighting professional.
00:06:27.944 --> 00:06:30.711
Yeah, every poor project didn't have a lighting professional.
00:06:30.711 --> 00:06:32.355
The one thing missing every poor project didn't have a lighting professional.
00:06:32.355 --> 00:06:35.223
And the one thing missing every poor project didn't have a lighting professional.
00:06:35.223 --> 00:06:37.687
And yet we're still saying this 30 years.
00:06:37.687 --> 00:06:49.817
We're still saying this and I really do think the industry built environment industry has to grow up and recognize they have a responsibility to get this right.
00:06:49.817 --> 00:06:52.375
We, as lighting professionals, can sit as part of that table and get this right.
00:06:52.375 --> 00:06:54.084
We, as lighting professionals, can sit as part of that table and get that right.
00:06:54.084 --> 00:07:04.733
And for some reason and I've thought about it long and hard and I think I've been polite about this issue for a long time, but maybe age- is making me reach a point.
00:07:06.704 --> 00:07:08.994
I think we need to just say stop talking.
00:07:08.994 --> 00:07:18.454
You don't know what you're talking about, but there are a lot of people who do and they will make this better for everybody who uses this building and space.
00:07:18.454 --> 00:07:20.386
We can make this better.
00:07:20.386 --> 00:07:22.069
You are making it no better.
00:07:22.069 --> 00:07:25.726
Please, you know, stick to what you know and we'll stick to what we know.
00:07:25.726 --> 00:07:31.348
And I think we are unfortunately getting to that point because I think we've done enough education.
00:07:31.348 --> 00:07:33.173
I think you know, you.
00:07:33.254 --> 00:07:43.478
You look at VLDC, society of Light and Light and International Association of Lighting Designers, institution of Lighting Professionals, lighting Industry Association.
00:07:43.478 --> 00:07:53.838
We've got so many professional bodies with so many professionals, but we can't quite find ourselves always on a project, and we should always be on a project.
00:07:53.838 --> 00:07:55.605
And so we've done enough.
00:07:55.605 --> 00:08:04.507
We, we are educated, we are knowledgeable, you know creatively, technically you know and responsible.
00:08:04.507 --> 00:08:05.870
We design responsibly.
00:08:05.870 --> 00:08:17.120
You only have to listen to all the talks you know, and one of the themes yesterday there's no such thing anymore as a lighting designer who does dark sky projects and a lighting designer who does non-dark sky projects.
00:08:17.120 --> 00:08:21.673
We just do dark sky projects, we just do responsible design.
00:08:21.673 --> 00:08:22.951
And that's what we're doing.
00:08:22.951 --> 00:08:24.990
And I don't know what the answer is.
00:08:24.990 --> 00:08:26.672
I really wish I knew what the answer was.
00:08:26.672 --> 00:08:28.290
I guess we keep talking.
00:08:28.290 --> 00:08:29.872
I guess we keep banging the drum.
00:08:29.872 --> 00:08:35.437
I guess we keep highlighting the fabulous work that is done by lighting professionals.
00:08:36.166 --> 00:08:40.496
I was at a talk last year with the Lighting Industry Association.
00:08:40.496 --> 00:08:51.475
Asia set up a beautiful lunch and AGM and I went to the lunch and she managed to secure Lord Deben as a speaker and he spoke about sustainability and circular economy.
00:08:51.475 --> 00:08:52.889
Fabulous speaker.
00:08:52.889 --> 00:08:56.386
No notes, no slides, slides.
00:08:56.386 --> 00:08:56.748
Oh wow, true speed.
00:08:56.748 --> 00:08:58.313
I mean it was one and you listened.
00:08:58.514 --> 00:09:03.595
There was no slides so you listen and it was amazing, I hadn't ever experienced that before.
00:09:03.595 --> 00:09:08.876
But but he actually stood at one point and said well, you are the professionals in the lighting industry.
00:09:08.876 --> 00:09:17.325
You can solve all of the lighting problems, whether it's manufacturing, whether it's design, whether lighting problems, whether it's manufacturing, whether it's design, whether it's engineering, whether it's technology, you can solve all this.
00:09:17.325 --> 00:09:21.404
You understand people and eyes and emotions and biology.
00:09:21.404 --> 00:09:22.504
You can solve it.
00:09:22.504 --> 00:09:25.365
And here we are a year later chatting about it again.
00:09:25.365 --> 00:09:29.523
So let's find that magic trick and then deal with it.
00:09:29.562 --> 00:09:43.466
Now, I mean, you touched upon this topic about we have a responsibility, but somehow I don't know whether it's something which I'm feeling in person, but the problem is that we live in these silos and we lighting professionals only talk to lighting professionals.
00:09:43.466 --> 00:09:46.067
Shouldn't we be talking a little bit more?
00:09:46.067 --> 00:09:53.927
Widening and broadening it, and that was one of the reasons where we worked on building this virtual lighting design community.
00:09:54.780 --> 00:10:01.346
Yeah, I think you've hit the nail on the head in the sense that when I was president last year, I had three things I wanted to look at.
00:10:01.346 --> 00:10:09.855
I was very interested in how we have more younger people doing more within the society of lighting.
00:10:09.855 --> 00:10:26.672
And we've now got Maria, who's launched the early career community for the SLL, and we need those people coming through because they're the ones who are going to have to take on this mantle of how we get lighting as a profession more accepted and out there.
00:10:26.672 --> 00:10:27.926
So let's do that now.
00:10:27.926 --> 00:10:37.649
And this seems to be along those same lines that you haven't targeted the early careers, but you certainly are attracted more of the early careers.
00:10:37.649 --> 00:10:39.528
So that's great, that's really positive.
00:10:39.528 --> 00:10:47.690
But the other idea for the Society of Light and Lighting for my presidential year was Dark Skies, which we talked about a lot.
00:10:47.690 --> 00:10:51.912
But the final thing was to get out there and talk to more people.
00:10:51.912 --> 00:11:02.600
Not talk to lighting designers but or the lighting community, but talk to um quantity surveyors, project managers, um architects, interior designers.
00:11:02.600 --> 00:11:15.230
And it was the last thing I was I targeted doing and in some respects I ran out of time and I've carried on doing it this year, in my past presidential year and I'll probably carry on doing it for as long as slL are happy for me to do so.
00:11:16.000 --> 00:11:17.086
It's really difficult.
00:11:17.086 --> 00:11:18.785
What I found is really difficult.
00:11:18.785 --> 00:11:26.193
I did a quick survey and I asked various different people have you heard of ILD, sll, vldc?
00:11:26.193 --> 00:11:28.888
Actually, very, very few had heard of us.
00:11:28.888 --> 00:11:51.033
Project managers, qss, architects very few, and the most popular or recognised body was the Institution of Lighting Professionals, and that was amongst project managers and planners who had had to deal with light pollution, because they have such a strong light pollution guidance GN01, as we all know.
00:11:51.033 --> 00:12:05.809
So they were the ones who were most well known because of planning, not because of design or because something looks pretty or works well or technically competent or all the other things we know about lighting, your biology, physiology, etc.
00:12:05.809 --> 00:12:10.905
It was actually all to do with planning and planning guidance.
00:12:10.905 --> 00:12:14.272
So we've got a huge, huge, huge task ahead of us.
00:12:14.272 --> 00:12:16.182
I think things like this work.
00:12:16.182 --> 00:12:17.445
I do wonder.
00:12:17.445 --> 00:12:23.830
I mean, just based on what you said, I'm just throwing things out there virtual lighting design community will attract lighters.
00:12:23.830 --> 00:12:29.721
Virtual design community may attract the design community that's, that's.
00:12:29.961 --> 00:12:35.426
I'm not saying I'm not saying let's go and cross out the L from your name right now, but yeah, isn't it just?
00:12:35.426 --> 00:12:45.952
But is there a danger that SLL, ilp, lia, ild, ies, now VLDC?
00:12:45.952 --> 00:12:48.134
Have we got six silos?
00:12:48.134 --> 00:12:50.876
Yeah, are we actually even worse?
00:12:50.876 --> 00:12:51.216
Worse?
00:12:51.216 --> 00:12:52.177
I don't think we are.
00:12:53.501 --> 00:12:54.894
I'm just chucking it out there, but it's always good for you.
00:12:54.914 --> 00:12:55.298
Let's explore.
00:12:55.582 --> 00:12:56.519
Let's be self-critical about it.
00:12:56.779 --> 00:12:57.922
Let's explore.
00:12:57.922 --> 00:13:05.115
Okay, how do we make sure you don't have to join six organizations to talk to all these amazing people?
00:13:05.115 --> 00:13:09.932
And then how do we all promote each other for the right reasons and not compete?
00:13:09.932 --> 00:13:13.245
We're on the same side, we are all on the same side.
00:13:13.245 --> 00:13:15.363
We want the same side.
00:13:15.363 --> 00:13:16.004
We are all on the same side.
00:13:16.004 --> 00:13:16.544
We want the same thing.
00:13:16.544 --> 00:13:17.488
How do we make sure that happens?
00:13:17.508 --> 00:13:20.442
It's a tough, tough task and one of the things I found when I was asking people.
00:13:20.442 --> 00:13:29.567
So you ask bodies such as RICS or RTPI Royal Town Planning Institute they're actually so busy looking after their own members.
00:13:29.567 --> 00:13:37.524
The thought of having to set up an event with another body and all the communication that is required.
00:13:37.524 --> 00:13:39.769
It's complicated.
00:13:39.769 --> 00:13:41.936
And do they have the resource?
00:13:41.936 --> 00:13:43.340
Do any of us have the resource?
00:13:43.340 --> 00:14:08.370
You know so and I know from SLL we are maxed out in terms of how much effort it takes to look after our members doing the things we do and to reach out, and brendan did a fabulous job with the roland conference, for example, and that did include other bodies, but but it really took up every ounce of his energy and he had a two-week lie down afterwards.
00:14:08.370 --> 00:14:16.427
It took up so much time to explore other people to create this most wonderful conference that included so many other people.
00:14:16.427 --> 00:14:24.346
Try now doing that with REBA, and then the equivalent in the Middle East, and then the equivalent in Australia, and then RICS and then RTPI.
00:14:26.083 --> 00:14:27.428
Wow, what a task we've got on our hands.
00:14:27.428 --> 00:14:28.684
What a task we've got on our hands.
00:14:28.684 --> 00:14:32.727
I don't have an answer, but that is where we need to be.
00:14:32.727 --> 00:14:50.984
As I said, I was helping out on the Society of Light and Lighting stand with Brendan and we had somebody come to talk to us about an event that might be taking place in Saudi Arabia in September and it's a built environment event and what's interesting there is.
00:14:50.984 --> 00:14:52.990
We asked about speaking slots.
00:14:52.990 --> 00:14:54.899
How do SNL get involved?
00:14:54.899 --> 00:14:56.960
How do the other lighting bodies get involved?
00:14:56.960 --> 00:15:01.479
They said they don't want a lighting section to the conference.
00:15:01.479 --> 00:15:13.966
They want everyone dispersed amongst each other and they want every panel to have an architect and a lighting designer and suddenly we were like yes, that's where we need to be.
00:15:14.067 --> 00:15:15.921
Perhaps we ought to stop coming.
00:15:15.921 --> 00:15:17.265
This is awful.
00:15:17.265 --> 00:15:18.509
I shouldn't say it.
00:15:18.509 --> 00:15:21.460
I'll get hooked off by the organisers in a minute.
00:15:21.460 --> 00:15:23.303
They won't let me fly home or something.
00:15:23.303 --> 00:15:27.812
But you know, maybe, yes, these are great For lighters.
00:15:27.812 --> 00:15:29.182
This is magical.
00:15:29.182 --> 00:15:32.250
I can see so many people I need to see quickly and easily.
00:15:32.250 --> 00:15:38.606
But perhaps and the conference is great if I want to learn from other lighting designers, but maybe it needs to be 50-50.
00:15:38.606 --> 00:15:43.086
Maybe it's a mixed bag then lighting, mixed bag, then lighting.
00:15:43.780 --> 00:15:52.125
We could talk about this so much, but we do need to become more well-known, and it's our job to do that.
00:15:52.125 --> 00:15:52.970
It's not their fault.
00:15:52.970 --> 00:15:54.135
It's our job to do that, it's not their fault.
00:15:54.176 --> 00:15:54.859
It's our job to do that.
00:15:54.859 --> 00:15:56.666
Anyway, thank you so much, Andrew.
00:15:56.666 --> 00:15:57.067
Thank you.
00:15:57.067 --> 00:15:57.629
It was great.
00:15:57.629 --> 00:15:59.404
Thank you for coming guys.
00:15:59.404 --> 00:16:00.624
It was a great conversation.
00:16:00.624 --> 00:16:03.985
We could have talked for ages, but then we have other things to do.
00:16:03.985 --> 00:16:04.807
We have a talk to do.
00:16:04.807 --> 00:16:06.873
We have a talk to do, Thank you.
00:16:06.940 --> 00:16:07.711
Fabulous, thank you.