ABOUT THIS EPISODE
The Bill of Rights, 1789–1791: What Congress Added and What It Declined
On June 8, 1789, James Madison rose in the First Congress to move amendments to the Constitution. A Georgia member answered that the Constitution was a vessel just launched, untried, and that he was not for amendments at this time.
Madison carried them anyway. Congress wrote down the rights the state conventions had asked for most consistently, and very little of the limits they had asked for on the government itself. The line between the two followed one word Madison would not accept: "expressly."
Companion to Article 21, published Sunday, November 8, 2026. The full article is free, with every source in its endnotes, and a new article arrives every Sunday.
Madison had called written rights "parchment barriers," and Jefferson answered that a declaration put a legal check into the hands of the judiciary. A winter race against James Monroe, won by 336 votes, and the threat of a second convention brought Madison to the House floor. There, Roger Sherman made the amendments a supplement rather than part of the text, the House voted down "expressly" 17 to 32 and a requisition before direct taxes 9 to 39, and the Senate cut seventeen articles to twelve, striking the restraint on the states Madison called the most valuable amendment in the whole list.
Much of the language came through George Mason and Virginia, from the Eighth Amendment's "ought" becoming "shall" to the Fourth's searches and seizures. "Due process of law" came from New York, and the takings clause from no state at all. The Virginia Senate called the amendments inadequate in 1789 and completed them on December 15, 1791. In Barron v. Baltimore (1833), the Supreme Court held that they bound Congress, not the states. Three objections then get a full hearing: a campaign promise, a tub thrown to a whale, and Hamilton's warning about listing rights.
Does a government that recognizes only the rights written down leave Americans more free, or more governed?
⏱️ CHAPTERS
0:00 — Cold Open: "A Vessel Just Launched"
1:40 — What Congress Added, and What It Declined
3:41 — Madison, Jefferson and the "Parchment Barriers"
6:55 — Orange County: Madison Against Monroe
9:56 — June 8, 1789: Madison Moves His Amendments
15:23 — Sherman's Draft and a Supplement to the Constitution
19:13 — What the States Did Not Get: "Expressly"
24:32 — Seventeen Articles, Then Twelve
28:00 — Where the Words Came From
31:44 — Three-Fourths of the States
35:04 — Protection or Parchment
38:20 — The Skeptic's Case
42:38 — The Liberty Test: Rights Retained
43:43 — Closing: Articles in Addition
📚 Article 21, "The Bill of Rights": https://www.consequentialactions.com/post/the-bill-of-rights-articles-in-addition-to-the-constitution-1789-1791
📩 Subscribe free: https://www.consequentialactions.com/subscribe
🎙️ Self-Evident: The Road to 1776 — Episode 21, "The Bill of Rights"
Next: Episode 21B, Tuesday, November 17, carries the argument into our own time.
—
Consequential Actions is a libertarian, non-interventionist analysis of American constitutional and foreign policy. New episodes weekly.
🌐 https://www.consequentialactions.com
#billofrights #jamesmadison #constitution #tenthamendment #ninthamendment #antifederalists #firstcongress #americanhistory #libertarian #consequentialactions