Double Binds & Competing Needs

Have you ever felt trapped as a white person, trying to figure out how to respond to a racist remark when people of color are in the room?
On one hand, silence is violence. You have a responsibility to speak up.
On the other hand, white people have a responsibility to amplify the leadership of people of color. You might worry about being condescending, seeming performative, stepping on toes, or saying something that hurts someone more.
If you're silent, you mess up. If you speak up, you risk screwing up, too.
Meanwhile, if you're a person of color and someone makes a racist remark, you might feel trapped in a similar — yet even more costly — double bind. If you speak up, you risk paying a price: emotional labor, lost status, strained relationships, or worse, professional consequences. If you don't speak up, you risk letting yourself or others down and not naming the truth that needs naming.
That's a double bind. And it's not the only one.
Maybe you're facing an entirely different set of competing needs in your work for change right now. The nonprofit leader feels pulled between honoring donor expectations and community needs. The newly promoted manager wants credibility with senior leaders and a sense of belonging with her team. The city councilor wants to reach across the aisle without alienating their progressive base.
Many double binds are painfully real. Right now, so many immigrants face the double bind of either losing their status if they don't attend a court appointment — or risking detention by ICE if they do. Nothing I share here will make those terrifying choices easier.
And yet, many of the double binds and either-ors that I see my clients grapple with are actually mental traps. Stories we've inherited and never questioned. Those are the ones we'll focus on here.
So why does dominant culture train us to think in false binaries?
Largely, trauma.
Millennia of imperialism, patriarchy, war, and violent separation from the land gave rise to the dominant culture we live in today. One of the primary symptoms of personal and collective trauma is rigidity — a strict adherence to behaving in certain ways in an attempt to protect ourselves from future harm. One flavor of this rigidity is left/right, good/bad, win/lose, black/white thinking.
Of course those of us who fear for our well-being — and that of our neighbors — feel pulled to identify with one side or the other. We're trying to keep ourselves safe.
But this attempt to keep us safe often makes it harder for us to come together and find creative ways to meet our needs. The coalition fractures over tactics. The leader lashes out from an us-versus-them frame. Family members stop talking to each other.
The first step toward healing the trauma of polarization is to honor why we got here in the first place. When we do this, we can begin to notice what polarities are at play.
Polarities are not merely opposites.
They're apparent opposites that need each other to form a whole. Pain and pleasure. Grief and joy. Rest and action. Giving and receiving. Stability and change. Individual and collective. Unity and division.
When we zoom out, we begin to see that life expresses itself in polarities. And simply naming them can help us see how we need both.
The tension between polarities is uncomfortable. But the tension isn't the problem. The problem emerges when we treat the poles as enemies — when we cling to one side and demonize the other. The higher the stakes, the more fear we feel. The more fear, the more we cling. And the more we cling, the more the conflict escalates.
Polarities are not problems to solve. They're forces to be navigated.
A coaching client of mine was recently oscillating between longing for one job they could devote all their attention to and the ability to pursue many creative projects. They initially saw this as an either-or they needed to choose between. But as they soon discovered, navigating polarities is like juggling balls. It's a never-ending dance.
To help them, we named the poles "concentration" and "divergence" and mapped out the upsides and downsides of each. Reflecting on both sides — and their own journey through them — my client breathed a sigh of relief. They stopped trying to choose. And started learning to honor both.
The practice I guided my client through is called Polarity Squares, which I originally learned from Barry Johnson's book Polarity Management and Leslie Temple-Thurston's book The Marriage of Spirit.
Applying this to Your Own Life
In this week's episode of Conflict Decoded, I walk you through the full practice — including how to map your own polarity square and work with what you find there.
I also share a personal story about my son that taught me something I didn't expect: What we try to exclude doesn't disappear. It boomerangs back around. The more we try to push one side of a polarity away, the more insistently it returns, in our relationships, in our teams, in ourselves.
And I close with a polarity I know intimately — the tension between solidarity and spaciousness. Between showing up for the collective and taking care of yourself. It can feel impossible to honor both. And yet, like all polarities, they need each other. Solidarity without spaciousness leads to burnout. Spaciousness without solidarity can feel empty and purposeless.
The next time you catch yourself asking "Do I honor this need or that need?" — Pause.
Ask instead: How might I honor both, not in this single moment, but over the arc of my week, my month, my life?
Embracing the both-and won't bring all the answers we long for. There will still be painful tradeoffs and choices. But when we stop demanding a perfect answer, we gain more freedom to surf the tensions in ways that make us proud.
May you discover the ease and grace of dancing in the both-and.
Navigating double binds, competing needs, or other challenging dynamics? Learn more and stay connected!
Subscribe to Conflict Decoded
Receive Love Letters to Changemakers
Get my free online course – Preparing for Difficult Conversations at Work
Submit your conflict story
Share a reflection
Episodes Related to Double Binds & Competing Needs
On Holding Conflicting Values & Realities
The Discernment Pause: How to Find Your Next Step When Things Get Tense
Awareness is Power: How to Stop Reacting in Ways You Later Regret