O TYM ODCINKU
If you are helping build something that might kill everyone, maybe stop doing that.
Ideally, when you do stop, tell everyone else to also stop building it.
That is certainly the obvious, first-level thing to do. You need a damn good reason to decide that no, actually you should keep building the thing that might kill everyone.
Scott Alexander is worried too many people are insisting upon this too loudly. He comes out against a strategy focused on getting people to stop. I disagree. I think many of the claims, arguments and rhetoric in Scott's post are quite poor by the standards that Scott Alexander would apply to himself.
Scott clearly continues to support advocacy for a global pause, or what he calls Plan A. His objection is to those advocating primarily or exclusively for SURA, which stands for ‘stop unilaterally and raise awareness.’ The practical differences here are smaller than they may at first appear.
This post first lays out my understanding of Scott Alexander's core claims, then gives my core reactions to those claims, then goes over various questions in detail along with gathering the resulting discussions.
Table of Contents
Outline:
(01:20) Scott Alexander's Core Claims
(05:06) My High Level Responses To Scott's Core Claims
(08:08) Briefly on Alignment
(10:11) Probabilities and How They Work
(13:25) Building a Thing That Might Kill Everyone is Deontologically Evil
(20:38) People Quitting Major Labs While Raising Alarms Obviously Works
(24:39) On AI Forecasting
(27:31) Advancing Capabilities Burns Timeline
(29:34) But China
(33:23) Ethical People Can Disagree With You
(34:45) There Are More Than Two Outcomes
(38:01) Efforts Are Complementary, Not Mutually Exclusive
(40:23) If Anyone Builds It, Everyone Dies
(41:55) Vaniver is Not Convinced
(46:19) There Is No Consensus That We Should Exclusively Focus on Plan A
(56:01) It's Not the Incentives, It's You
(58:08) Anthropic Is Not Optimally Pursuing These Plans
(01:04:00) Against Against Sura
The original text contained 2 footnotes which were omitted from this narration.
---
First published:
November 2nd, 2026
Source:
https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/ziMP83D2JYWRQ5jtu/scott-alexander-s-against-sura-seems-deeply-confused
---
Narrated by TYPE III AUDIO.
Ideally, when you do stop, tell everyone else to also stop building it.
That is certainly the obvious, first-level thing to do. You need a damn good reason to decide that no, actually you should keep building the thing that might kill everyone.
Scott Alexander is worried too many people are insisting upon this too loudly. He comes out against a strategy focused on getting people to stop. I disagree. I think many of the claims, arguments and rhetoric in Scott's post are quite poor by the standards that Scott Alexander would apply to himself.
Scott clearly continues to support advocacy for a global pause, or what he calls Plan A. His objection is to those advocating primarily or exclusively for SURA, which stands for ‘stop unilaterally and raise awareness.’ The practical differences here are smaller than they may at first appear.
This post first lays out my understanding of Scott Alexander's core claims, then gives my core reactions to those claims, then goes over various questions in detail along with gathering the resulting discussions.
Table of Contents
- [...]
Outline:
(01:20) Scott Alexander's Core Claims
(05:06) My High Level Responses To Scott's Core Claims
(08:08) Briefly on Alignment
(10:11) Probabilities and How They Work
(13:25) Building a Thing That Might Kill Everyone is Deontologically Evil
(20:38) People Quitting Major Labs While Raising Alarms Obviously Works
(24:39) On AI Forecasting
(27:31) Advancing Capabilities Burns Timeline
(29:34) But China
(33:23) Ethical People Can Disagree With You
(34:45) There Are More Than Two Outcomes
(38:01) Efforts Are Complementary, Not Mutually Exclusive
(40:23) If Anyone Builds It, Everyone Dies
(41:55) Vaniver is Not Convinced
(46:19) There Is No Consensus That We Should Exclusively Focus on Plan A
(56:01) It's Not the Incentives, It's You
(58:08) Anthropic Is Not Optimally Pursuing These Plans
(01:04:00) Against Against Sura
The original text contained 2 footnotes which were omitted from this narration.
---
First published:
November 2nd, 2026
Source:
https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/ziMP83D2JYWRQ5jtu/scott-alexander-s-against-sura-seems-deeply-confused
---
Narrated by TYPE III AUDIO.
Język angielski
Stany Zjednoczone
TRANSKRYPCJA 🔗
Are you the producer of this podcast?
Add a podcast transcript
Need Audio-to-Text?
Transcribe with Listen411 in Just 60 Seconds
WYSZUKAJ MINIONE ODCINKI
Wyszukaj minione odcinki LessWrong (Curated & Popular).
INNE ODCINKI W TYM PODCASCIE
Summary
Following an intense viral infection in 2019, I became ill with a mysterious chronic illness, which became progressively worse until mid-2024 when I became partially bedbound with dozens of debilitating symptoms that normal humans only experience in the months/weeks/days leading up to…
I gave a 20-minute talk in Delhi at the NDTV World Summit. The audience consisted of Indian policymakers, executives, and journalists. I’ve transcribed the talk and included some highlight clips. I also reflect on several rhetorical decisions I made. The talk There's an interactive element her…
My go-to conceptual metaphor of the epistemic state of AI lab employees is microdosing LSD: being in a chronically mildly altered state of mind. I think understanding this would be broadly helpful for people both inside and outside. The effect isn’t that insiders hold crazy beliefs, but a combinati…
TL;DR: Meta's open-weights model Muse Spark Open often mentions a "Charter" in its chain of thought. By eliciting it piece by piece, I reconstructed a large part of that document from the CoT. You can explore the reconstruction here, with passages linked to the transcripts that produ…
The AI Futures Project distinguishes several different plans for navigating the AI transition, which I'll lump into two broader categories: Plan A (my combination of their Plan A/S/Other) involves working for a global pause on AI development, hopefully lasting decades. During this pause, we ei…
Zastrzeżenie: Podcast i grafika osadzone na tej stronie pochodzą z LessWrong, który jest własnością jego właściciela i nie jest powiązany ani wspierany przez Listen Notes, Inc.
EDYTUJ
Dziękujemy za pomoc w aktualizowaniu podcastowej bazy danych.
