The Sodder Fire: Five Children Vanish on Christmas Eve

WEBVTT
00:00:00.017 --> 00:00:04.197
In 1945, on a quiet hillside in Fayetteville, West Virginia,
00:00:04.657 --> 00:00:06.257
a home burned to the ground.
00:00:06.597 --> 00:00:10.417
A family stood outside, watching it collapse in on itself.
00:00:10.777 --> 00:00:13.877
But inside that house were five children.
00:00:14.377 --> 00:00:17.397
By the time the fire was over, there was nothing left.
00:00:17.817 --> 00:00:23.077
But that shouldn't be possible. So what really happened to those kids that night?
00:00:24.037 --> 00:00:27.897
Welcome back to Legends May Live, where we explore the strange,
00:00:28.177 --> 00:00:29.757
the mysterious, and the eerie.
00:00:30.017 --> 00:00:34.317
I'm Drew, and tonight's tale is one that defies explanation.
00:00:34.837 --> 00:00:40.417
Did a fire erase four children, or were they taken? Why is there no evidence?
00:00:41.137 --> 00:00:45.617
But before we begin, just a quick note that while our stories are based on true
00:00:45.617 --> 00:00:49.997
events, sometimes sources conflict and details get skewed over time,
00:00:50.157 --> 00:00:51.697
so just take this as entertainment.
00:00:59.922 --> 00:01:04.202
In the winter of 1945, the town of Fayetteville was the kind of place that seemed
00:01:04.202 --> 00:01:05.342
to stand still with time.
00:01:05.782 --> 00:01:08.282
Year after year, nothing much ever seemed to change.
00:01:08.742 --> 00:01:13.302
It sat quietly in the Appalachian Hills, surrounded by winding roads,
00:01:13.462 --> 00:01:15.662
dense woods, and long stretches of silence.
00:01:16.882 --> 00:01:21.022
It was a cozy, quiet place where people knew each other well.
00:01:21.682 --> 00:01:25.562
It was a place where you know the barber, the shop owners, teachers,
00:01:26.022 --> 00:01:31.502
their families, and just a place where really everybody knew everything about everybody else.
00:01:31.942 --> 00:01:37.202
Not because they were nosy, though some were, but really it was because it's
00:01:37.202 --> 00:01:39.362
just the kind of tight-knit place it was.
00:01:40.342 --> 00:01:46.242
And just outside the center of town, set slightly apart from everything else, sat the solder house.
00:01:46.662 --> 00:01:49.482
It wasn't hidden, but it wasn't close either.
00:01:50.162 --> 00:01:54.422
Perched on a rise, it overlooked the surrounding land in a way that felt peaceful
00:01:54.422 --> 00:01:57.162
during the day and just a little too quiet at night.
00:01:58.582 --> 00:02:02.822
From that house, you could see the road and you could watch cars pass and notice
00:02:02.822 --> 00:02:07.822
when someone slowed down or stopped, but from the road, you couldn't really see nearly as much.
00:02:08.362 --> 00:02:13.102
And that mattered more than anyone really realized because if something went
00:02:13.102 --> 00:02:15.862
wrong up there, help wouldn't be immediate.
00:02:17.002 --> 00:02:20.982
There were no neighbors just a few steps away close enough to hear a shout or
00:02:20.982 --> 00:02:23.102
see something unfolding in real time.
00:02:23.982 --> 00:02:27.862
Up that hill, if something happened, you were on your own.
00:02:28.462 --> 00:02:31.562
And Christmas Eve, 1945, that
00:02:31.562 --> 00:02:36.082
quiet little distance, it would become a problem no one could overcome.
00:02:36.462 --> 00:02:41.162
Because by that time anyone realized what was happening, it was already too late.
00:02:42.394 --> 00:02:47.694
The Sauter house was a full one. George and Jenny Sauter had a large family,
00:02:48.074 --> 00:02:52.174
10 children in total, spread across different ages, personalities,
00:02:52.494 --> 00:02:54.494
and just different rhythms of life.
00:02:55.094 --> 00:02:58.534
And like most big families, there was always something happening.
00:02:59.054 --> 00:03:03.094
Footsteps moving from room to room, voices overlapping in conversation,
00:03:03.914 --> 00:03:05.554
laughter that carried through the house.
00:03:05.914 --> 00:03:09.794
It wasn't perfect, but for them, life was good.
00:03:11.114 --> 00:03:15.174
George was the kind of man that people noticed Not because he tried to be But
00:03:15.174 --> 00:03:20.914
because he didn't back down He was an immigrant from Italy Who had built a successful
00:03:20.914 --> 00:03:24.114
trucking business from the ground up He worked hard,
00:03:24.254 --> 00:03:29.114
spoke his mind And if he believed something, he said it Even when it made people uncomfortable.
00:03:30.654 --> 00:03:36.754
But Jenny was different Where George was firm, Jenny was observant She paid
00:03:36.754 --> 00:03:41.874
attention to things that most people overlooked Small changes, subtle details,
00:03:42.434 --> 00:03:47.994
moments that didn't quite feel right, even if there was no real clear reason why.
00:03:48.514 --> 00:03:50.594
And together they created something steady.
00:03:51.454 --> 00:03:55.614
A home where children felt safe, and where routines were predictable.
00:03:56.574 --> 00:04:02.894
Where Christmas Eve meant excitement, laughter, and staying up just a little later than usual.
00:04:03.474 --> 00:04:07.634
And that night, five of their children would be upstairs, still awake,
00:04:07.814 --> 00:04:13.274
still playing, and still completely unaware of how quickly everything was about to change.
00:04:13.814 --> 00:04:17.734
And for George and Jenny, that would become the hardest part to live with.
00:04:18.094 --> 00:04:22.534
What they lost, and how normal everything felt just before it happened.
00:04:23.706 --> 00:04:27.086
It all started with a conversation. Sometime before Christmas,
00:04:27.366 --> 00:04:31.266
a man came to the solder house, and George didn't recognize him,
00:04:31.386 --> 00:04:34.666
but he was a door-to-door salesman, so that wasn't too surprising.
00:04:35.266 --> 00:04:40.266
Salesmen in the 1940s often traveled a lot, moving town to town, just knocking on doors.
00:04:40.926 --> 00:04:44.266
This man was selling insurance, and at first it was ordinary.
00:04:44.586 --> 00:04:49.126
A knock at the door, a brief introduction, but George wasn't interested,
00:04:49.366 --> 00:04:52.306
and he firmly but politely told the man, no thank you.
00:04:52.946 --> 00:04:56.406
And that should have been the end of it. But instead of leaving,
00:04:56.666 --> 00:05:01.446
the man's expression changed and his tone shifted. He seemed stern.
00:05:02.266 --> 00:05:06.466
Now, what had been a routine visit suddenly felt personal.
00:05:07.166 --> 00:05:11.866
He pointed at the house and said, Your house is going to go up in smoke,
00:05:11.886 --> 00:05:14.546
and your children are going to be destroyed.
00:05:15.626 --> 00:05:20.686
There was no confusion in his voice, just matter of fact. It didn't sound like
00:05:20.686 --> 00:05:22.586
anger. it sounded like certainty.
00:05:24.486 --> 00:05:27.926
George dismissed it as he turned to go inside and shut the door.
00:05:28.166 --> 00:05:33.126
As weird as it was, he just chalked it up to a strange encounter with a man
00:05:33.126 --> 00:05:34.726
who didn't like to be told no.
00:05:35.326 --> 00:05:39.186
Not long after the first encounter, another man came to the solder house.
00:05:39.546 --> 00:05:45.226
This time more helpful rather than pushy. He pointed out some things that George hadn't noticed.
00:05:45.506 --> 00:05:48.086
Some of the wiring on George's house wasn't done properly.
00:05:48.386 --> 00:05:52.846
He told him that there was a problem and it could potentially lead to a fire.
00:05:53.966 --> 00:05:58.406
It really did sound reasonable. Houses burned down all the time back then,
00:05:58.546 --> 00:06:00.686
and at least in comparison to today.
00:06:01.506 --> 00:06:08.826
Faulty wiring, overloaded circuits. It was not that unusual. But there was a problem.
00:06:09.306 --> 00:06:14.246
George had just had the wiring thoroughly checked recently, and he'd been told the opposite.
00:06:15.146 --> 00:06:18.146
They had told him that everything was fine. It looked great.
00:06:18.146 --> 00:06:25.806
So now there were two strange men one who made a threat possibly and one who
00:06:25.806 --> 00:06:27.506
offered an explanation to,
00:06:28.513 --> 00:06:32.113
But both of them centered around the same outcome. Fire.
00:06:33.133 --> 00:06:38.233
But at the time, it still didn't feel connected. It was just kind of one strange
00:06:38.233 --> 00:06:39.673
interaction followed by another.
00:06:40.113 --> 00:06:44.993
And it's one thing to have a strange conversation, but it's another to start noticing patterns.
00:06:45.653 --> 00:06:48.873
After those encounters, Jenny began paying closer attention.
00:06:49.253 --> 00:06:54.473
And she wasn't worried, just things kind of seemed odd, so she was more curious than anything.
00:06:55.473 --> 00:06:57.933
Although she was still a little cautious.
00:06:59.053 --> 00:07:02.753
And soon she noticed that cars were stopping on the road in front of their house.
00:07:03.213 --> 00:07:07.613
And not cars she recognized. And they would just sit there along the road with
00:07:07.613 --> 00:07:12.613
their engines off and lights dimmed, sometimes for long periods of time.
00:07:13.253 --> 00:07:17.873
At first, it was easy to explain away. Maybe someone got lost.
00:07:18.133 --> 00:07:21.553
Maybe someone's resting from a long road trip.
00:07:21.913 --> 00:07:25.053
But then it just kept happening.
00:07:25.613 --> 00:07:30.253
And then it wasn't just the cars anymore. there were people asking questions,
00:07:30.573 --> 00:07:35.553
not about George or the business or even their home, but about the children.
00:07:36.413 --> 00:07:41.873
They would ask things like how many there were, what their names were, when they were home.
00:07:42.373 --> 00:07:46.693
It was really bizarre questions that made them feel uncomfortable, especially Jenny.
00:07:48.893 --> 00:07:52.493
In the 1940s, telephones were becoming commonplace in the home,
00:07:52.493 --> 00:07:55.053
and the Sauter family had one mounted on the wall.
00:07:55.653 --> 00:07:58.693
And for the most part, it worked exactly the way it was supposed to.
00:08:00.039 --> 00:08:03.379
But in the days leading up to Christmas, it started having issues.
00:08:04.379 --> 00:08:08.859
Calls didn't always connect right away. Sometimes there was a delay or faint
00:08:08.859 --> 00:08:12.099
static. Just sort of small inconveniences.
00:08:13.139 --> 00:08:19.559
Nothing really to do about anything. But looking back, it felt like a piece to the puzzle.
00:08:20.419 --> 00:08:25.719
On Christmas Eve, 1945, the solder house felt like any other holiday night.
00:08:26.579 --> 00:08:29.999
The children were excited for Christmas Day. laughter
00:08:29.999 --> 00:08:32.819
filling the rooms and there was an energy about the
00:08:32.819 --> 00:08:36.399
house that just kind of refused to settle down even as the night grew later
00:08:36.399 --> 00:08:42.459
of course as it got late the kids didn't want to go to bed they were too excited
00:08:42.459 --> 00:08:47.099
and they begged to stay up a little bit longer and play and like a lot of parents
00:08:47.099 --> 00:08:50.879
do on nights like that george and jenny said yeah sure.
00:08:52.399 --> 00:08:57.219
Eventually though the house did begin to quiet lights went off doors closed
00:08:57.219 --> 00:08:59.819
one by one and the sounds started to fade.
00:09:00.419 --> 00:09:04.619
Only a few of the children remained awake upstairs, still talking and playing.
00:09:05.979 --> 00:09:10.339
Downstairs, George and Jenny went to bed and settled into the silence of the house.
00:09:11.179 --> 00:09:15.919
Outside, the cold Appalachian night kind of wrapped around the hillside near
00:09:15.919 --> 00:09:18.199
Fayetteville, and it was still and quiet.
00:09:19.709 --> 00:09:24.049
But sometime after midnight, that silence was broken as the phone began to ring.
00:09:24.689 --> 00:09:29.449
It jolted Ginny awake, and for a moment she just listened, kind of trying to
00:09:29.449 --> 00:09:33.889
decide whether or not to get up out of the cozy warm bed, but eventually she
00:09:33.889 --> 00:09:37.049
decided that if someone was calling this late, it must be important.
00:09:37.049 --> 00:09:40.829
So she threw back the covers and groggily made her way over to the phone,
00:09:40.989 --> 00:09:44.349
and when she answered it, on the other end was a woman's voice.
00:09:44.829 --> 00:09:50.169
It was calm and casual, and she asked for someone. It was a name that Jenny
00:09:50.169 --> 00:09:53.509
didn't recognize, and Jenny told her that she had the wrong number,
00:09:53.689 --> 00:09:55.509
and that should have been the end of it.
00:09:55.889 --> 00:09:59.749
But before the line went dead, Jenny heard someone else laughing.
00:10:00.849 --> 00:10:05.009
Not close to the receiver, but in the background, and just distant enough that
00:10:05.009 --> 00:10:06.749
it kind of felt out of place for the moment.
00:10:07.509 --> 00:10:11.249
Either way, Jenny hung up the phone, and she stood there for a second.
00:10:11.769 --> 00:10:15.449
The moment kind of felt eerie in the quiet and the dark.
00:10:16.729 --> 00:10:19.489
But she was too tired to care too much at the moment
00:10:19.489 --> 00:10:25.669
so she did go back to bed but just moments later somewhere in the house something
00:10:25.669 --> 00:10:32.949
caught fire it started slow with just wisps of smoke but it spread somewhere
00:10:32.949 --> 00:10:38.789
in the dark the fire reached the staircase and once it did it had everything it needed.
00:10:39.449 --> 00:10:46.149
A vertical path, oxygen, and dry material. It climbed faster than anyone inside
00:10:46.149 --> 00:10:47.129
could really understand.
00:10:48.562 --> 00:10:53.462
Upstairs, the children were still awake and playing, but now cut off from their only exit.
00:10:54.422 --> 00:10:58.522
Downstairs, Jenny woke up to the smell. It wasn't strong enough,
00:10:58.682 --> 00:11:02.762
just enough to pull her out of sleep and make her pause.
00:11:03.022 --> 00:11:08.402
But as she's sort of trying to figure out what the smell is and it's getting
00:11:08.402 --> 00:11:10.442
her eyes focused, she sees it.
00:11:10.982 --> 00:11:14.222
Smoke. And it's thick and building.
00:11:14.762 --> 00:11:18.722
She leapt out of bed, rushed through the house, calling for everyone,
00:11:19.222 --> 00:11:22.942
trying to figure out where the smoke was coming from. But by the time she reached
00:11:22.942 --> 00:11:25.682
the main area, the fire had already taken hold.
00:11:26.742 --> 00:11:31.222
It wasn't something that you could just put out, and it was spreading fast.
00:11:31.842 --> 00:11:36.722
George was up now, too, and the two of them were just operating on pure instinct at this point.
00:11:36.922 --> 00:11:40.722
They were trying to do these things like wake the children, get outside,
00:11:41.362 --> 00:11:44.802
call for help. But the staircase was already on fire.
00:11:45.082 --> 00:11:48.422
The flames had completely cut off the only path to the second floor,
00:11:48.702 --> 00:11:53.182
where the five children were still up there, and there was no way up.
00:11:54.152 --> 00:11:58.612
Smoke was thickening by the second, and they called out, yelled for them,
00:11:58.692 --> 00:12:02.192
but the roar of the fire was so loud that they could hardly hear their own voices.
00:12:02.532 --> 00:12:04.552
And now, time was gone.
00:12:04.972 --> 00:12:09.432
Whatever chance they had to reach those children, it was already slipping away.
00:12:10.672 --> 00:12:14.352
So George did the only thing he could think to do. He reached for the phone
00:12:14.352 --> 00:12:17.352
to call for help, to get someone there, anyone.
00:12:17.772 --> 00:12:20.172
But when he tried, the line was dead.
00:12:20.612 --> 00:12:23.072
No dial tone, just complete silence.
00:12:24.152 --> 00:12:27.232
And then he remembered there was a ladder. It was always there,
00:12:27.412 --> 00:12:28.212
propped against the side of
00:12:28.212 --> 00:12:31.452
the house. He could use that to get to the second floor from the outside.
00:12:32.052 --> 00:12:36.312
But when George ran for it, he got there and it was just gone.
00:12:37.332 --> 00:12:40.472
So without thinking about it, he turned to the trucks.
00:12:40.952 --> 00:12:45.332
There were two of them, both reliable and working fine just hours before.
00:12:45.932 --> 00:12:48.872
If he could pull those close to the house, just one of them,
00:12:49.032 --> 00:12:52.312
he could climb onto it, reach the window, and get the children out.
00:12:52.872 --> 00:12:57.212
So he rushed over, hopped in the first truck, and he tried to crank it,
00:12:57.372 --> 00:12:58.752
but the engine wouldn't turn over.
00:12:58.872 --> 00:13:03.192
So he jumped out, ran to the second, but it was the same.
00:13:03.892 --> 00:13:08.292
Neither truck would start. The phone didn't work. The ladder wasn't there.
00:13:08.592 --> 00:13:09.592
The trucks wouldn't start.
00:13:10.392 --> 00:13:14.572
Every path to those children was closing, one after another.
00:13:15.072 --> 00:13:20.092
And outside, in that cold night near Fayetteville, George stood there,
00:13:20.312 --> 00:13:24.212
watching every option he had disappear right in front of him.
00:13:25.147 --> 00:13:29.807
The fire growing, taking the house, room by room, second by second,
00:13:29.947 --> 00:13:32.987
and there was nothing left that he could do.
00:13:33.707 --> 00:13:39.127
But George kept trying. Even after the ladder was gone, even after the trucks
00:13:39.127 --> 00:13:43.547
failed, he moved closer and closer to the house, with heat pushing him back
00:13:43.547 --> 00:13:46.807
and the smoke thick enough to choke the air out of every breath.
00:13:47.327 --> 00:13:52.367
But still, he desperately tried, calling out their names as he fought the inch
00:13:52.367 --> 00:13:55.407
closer, but no voices came back through the fire.
00:13:56.227 --> 00:13:58.087
Inside, the flames had taken over.
00:13:59.247 --> 00:14:05.607
What had been rooms, walls, spaces filled with life just hours earlier were
00:14:05.607 --> 00:14:09.307
now part of something else entirely, something uncontrollable.
00:14:10.667 --> 00:14:15.367
Before long, the roof began to give way. The wood crackled under the heat and
00:14:15.367 --> 00:14:20.387
the structure weakened until it couldn't hold anymore and then it collapsed.
00:14:20.807 --> 00:14:23.687
And just like that, the house was gone.
00:14:24.607 --> 00:14:30.467
Outside, the family stood in the cold watching, frozen in the moment of heartache and disbelief.
00:14:31.447 --> 00:14:36.227
Just there, as everything they knew disappeared in front of them,
00:14:36.547 --> 00:14:40.247
including the five children that were still inside.
00:14:41.784 --> 00:14:46.804
By morning, the fire was gone, and what remained was quiet, the kind of quiet
00:14:46.804 --> 00:14:48.604
that follows something violent.
00:14:49.484 --> 00:14:54.624
Smoke still drifted from the ground, and it was thin and slow from what used to be a home.
00:14:55.584 --> 00:15:00.944
The family returned to what was left, stepping carefully through ash and splintered
00:15:00.944 --> 00:15:05.764
wood, looking for anything, any sign that could explain what happened.
00:15:06.604 --> 00:15:10.764
Officials began their assessment, and the conclusion came quickly.
00:15:11.524 --> 00:15:15.364
They said that it was an electrical fire, just an accident.
00:15:16.124 --> 00:15:19.524
And the five children, they were lost in the blaze.
00:15:19.844 --> 00:15:23.344
And under normal circumstances, that might have been the end of it.
00:15:23.644 --> 00:15:28.984
Just a tragedy, unexplainable in its timing, but not in its cause.
00:15:29.604 --> 00:15:35.544
But then they started to look closer. They searched the debris carefully and methodically.
00:15:36.264 --> 00:15:39.484
Because in fires like this, there's always something left behind.
00:15:40.264 --> 00:15:46.244
Not usually. Always. There are always bone fragments, teeth,
00:15:46.664 --> 00:15:50.284
just pieces that survive, even when everything else doesn't.
00:15:50.724 --> 00:15:52.744
But here, there was nothing.
00:15:53.264 --> 00:15:59.184
No remains at all. Not a single fragment of the remains of any of the five children.
00:15:59.944 --> 00:16:03.424
In the days after the fire, people tried to make sense of what had happened.
00:16:03.784 --> 00:16:08.224
They tried to comfort the family any way they could, but the accident story
00:16:08.224 --> 00:16:09.984
just didn't sit right with everybody.
00:16:10.644 --> 00:16:14.444
And with an explanation that doesn't fit, it's hard to find comfort.
00:16:15.224 --> 00:16:19.864
For Jenny Sauter, it really didn't sit right. And she wasn't reacting out of
00:16:19.864 --> 00:16:26.364
panic or just refusing to accept reality. She was noticing details the same way she always had.
00:16:26.704 --> 00:16:32.044
And the more she looked at what was left behind, the less it matched what she was being told.
00:16:33.104 --> 00:16:38.344
Because if five children had died in that house, there should be something left anything.
00:16:40.280 --> 00:16:45.820
There wasn't, and that wasn't possible. So Jenny began to go over everything again.
00:16:46.420 --> 00:16:51.640
The fire, the night, the details, people were already starting to forget.
00:16:52.000 --> 00:16:58.060
And as she did, a different possibility began to take shape, slowly, piece by piece.
00:16:58.380 --> 00:17:02.880
What if the fire wasn't the end of the story, but only the beginning?
00:17:04.659 --> 00:17:08.119
At first, the explanation seemed simple. An electrical fire,
00:17:08.279 --> 00:17:10.459
fast-moving, intense, tragic.
00:17:10.859 --> 00:17:13.359
That's what they were told, and in a place like Fayetteville,
00:17:13.499 --> 00:17:14.979
that was enough for most people.
00:17:15.499 --> 00:17:20.399
Fires happened, homes were lost, and sometimes the damage was so severe that
00:17:20.399 --> 00:17:22.579
there was nothing really left to recover.
00:17:23.199 --> 00:17:28.479
But Jenny couldn't let it go. Because the more she thought about it, the less it made sense.
00:17:29.339 --> 00:17:34.299
Fires destroy, sure, but they don't erase everything completely.
00:17:34.659 --> 00:17:41.179
Even in extreme conditions, there's always remnants, bone fragments, teeth, something.
00:17:41.839 --> 00:17:49.259
And yet, in the remains of that house, there was nothing. Not one fragment. Not one trace.
00:17:49.799 --> 00:17:54.319
Not even the smallest indication that five bodies had ever been there at all.
00:17:54.679 --> 00:18:00.079
And that alone was enough to raise questions. But if that was the only thing,
00:18:00.239 --> 00:18:05.159
then maybe you could just dismiss that. but it wasn't.
00:18:05.399 --> 00:18:09.419
When Ginny looked through the debris, he began to notice something else.
00:18:09.979 --> 00:18:13.739
Objects that should have been destroyed that weren't appliances,
00:18:14.099 --> 00:18:18.719
household items, pieces of the home that had survived the fire in ways that
00:18:18.719 --> 00:18:21.439
didn't really match the level of destruction being described.
00:18:21.979 --> 00:18:26.659
If the fire had been hot enough and long enough to completely eliminate five
00:18:26.659 --> 00:18:29.279
human bodies, then how could these things have remained?
00:18:29.759 --> 00:18:33.999
The logic didn't hold, and once that doubt took root, it spread,
00:18:34.179 --> 00:18:38.579
because now the question wasn't just what happened, it was what didn't happen.
00:18:38.879 --> 00:18:43.539
And if the fire hadn't done what they said it did, then something else had to
00:18:43.539 --> 00:18:45.239
explain why those children were gone.
00:18:46.079 --> 00:18:51.879
Up to this point, everything could still sort of be explained away, though not neatly.
00:18:53.541 --> 00:19:00.281
So at this point, it was already unusual, tragic, maybe even suspicious, but not definitive.
00:19:01.041 --> 00:19:04.661
That changed when they looked at the phone line. The night of the fire,
00:19:04.801 --> 00:19:08.261
when George had got up to call for help, the line was dead.
00:19:08.661 --> 00:19:13.081
And at the time, it just seemed like another failure, another thing that had
00:19:13.081 --> 00:19:15.641
gone wrong when everything else was already falling apart.
00:19:15.881 --> 00:19:20.821
But later, when the line was examined more closely, they found something that
00:19:20.821 --> 00:19:23.181
didn't fit the official story at all.
00:19:23.541 --> 00:19:28.701
It hadn't been burned. It had been cut, cleanly and deliberately.
00:19:29.221 --> 00:19:32.601
Not frayed, melted, or damaged by heat.
00:19:32.981 --> 00:19:37.461
Like, cut. And not at the house. It was further away, along the line itself.
00:19:37.761 --> 00:19:44.621
In a place where someone would have to have physically gone and climbed and made a decision to do it.
00:19:44.961 --> 00:19:50.201
And that changes everything, because an accident doesn't isolate a house from
00:19:50.201 --> 00:19:52.401
the outside world before it even begins.
00:19:53.721 --> 00:19:56.481
Someone had made sure that when the
00:19:56.481 --> 00:19:59.501
moment came no one inside that house would be
00:19:59.501 --> 00:20:02.881
able to call for help and suddenly it
00:20:02.881 --> 00:20:05.941
wasn't just a fire anymore it was something planned
00:20:05.941 --> 00:20:12.741
on the night of the fire when george had gone for the ladder and it was always
00:20:12.741 --> 00:20:18.461
there but not that night at the time it felt like chaos like maybe someone misplaced
00:20:18.461 --> 00:20:23.221
it but once the immediate shock had past, it seemed deliberate as well,
00:20:23.601 --> 00:20:28.961
because ladders don't just disappear, but days later, they did find the ladder.
00:20:29.441 --> 00:20:34.641
It had been thrown down an embankment far enough away that it wouldn't be seen and couldn't be used.
00:20:35.301 --> 00:20:40.001
That wasn't an accident, because just like the phone line, it was something
00:20:40.001 --> 00:20:42.681
that had to be done before the fire.
00:20:43.201 --> 00:20:45.301
And now the pattern was undeniable.
00:20:46.061 --> 00:20:50.241
The house had been isolated, cut off from help, cut off from access,
00:20:50.741 --> 00:20:53.381
piece by piece, option by option.
00:20:53.801 --> 00:20:57.781
Someone had made sure that no one could get to the second floor.
00:20:59.348 --> 00:21:04.408
Up to this point, the evidence suggested that something had been done to the house before the fire.
00:21:04.788 --> 00:21:08.188
The phone line was cut, the ladder was removed, the trucks had been tampered
00:21:08.188 --> 00:21:12.508
with, but there was still one missing piece. How did the fire actually begin?
00:21:13.608 --> 00:21:17.068
For that answer, investigators would eventually turn to a witness,
00:21:17.728 --> 00:21:21.808
someone who had been near the property that night, who said that they remembered
00:21:21.808 --> 00:21:23.228
seeing something unusual.
00:21:23.768 --> 00:21:27.208
According to their account, sometime before the fire was fully underway,
00:21:27.208 --> 00:21:32.788
way, a man had been seen near the house and in his hand was something described
00:21:32.788 --> 00:21:38.428
as a ball of fire, something he was carrying and then threw toward the house.
00:21:38.908 --> 00:21:43.608
At the time, the detail didn't really carry much weight. It sounded strange,
00:21:43.968 --> 00:21:46.668
easy to dismiss, and impossible to prove.
00:21:47.048 --> 00:21:51.908
But years later, as more information surfaced, that description started to make
00:21:51.908 --> 00:21:56.448
a little bit more sense because devices like that did exist.
00:21:57.268 --> 00:22:01.608
Small, handheld incendiary devices capable of igniting quickly,
00:22:01.888 --> 00:22:08.168
spreading fast, and creating the exact kind of fire that had taken the solder home, did exist.
00:22:08.708 --> 00:22:13.468
And if that account was true, then the fire hadn't started inside the house
00:22:13.468 --> 00:22:15.488
at all. It had been brought there.
00:22:15.808 --> 00:22:20.348
Which means everything that followed, the speed, the spread,
00:22:20.768 --> 00:22:24.068
the timing, wasn't random, it was intentional.
00:22:26.427 --> 00:22:30.107
If the story had ended with the fire, it would have been tragic, but simple.
00:22:30.587 --> 00:22:35.347
Five children lost, a house destroyed, and a family left to grieve.
00:22:35.787 --> 00:22:40.067
But in the days that followed, something began to surface that didn't fit the ending.
00:22:40.647 --> 00:22:44.367
People started coming forward. At first, it was one account,
00:22:44.787 --> 00:22:46.887
then another, and then more.
00:22:47.407 --> 00:22:50.407
A woman claimed that she had seen the children the night of the fire,
00:22:50.647 --> 00:22:54.647
not inside the house, trapped, but outside watching the flames.
00:22:55.467 --> 00:23:00.327
Then came another report. A waitress at a roadside diner said that she had served
00:23:00.327 --> 00:23:03.667
breakfast to a group of children the next morning, five of them,
00:23:04.087 --> 00:23:05.747
matching the ages of the solder children.
00:23:06.407 --> 00:23:09.907
They weren't alone. They were with two men and two women.
00:23:10.427 --> 00:23:13.367
And the children didn't talk much. The adults did the ordering.
00:23:13.807 --> 00:23:17.107
They controlled the interaction and kind of kept things short.
00:23:17.467 --> 00:23:21.247
The children weren't distressed. They weren't acting like they had just escaped
00:23:21.247 --> 00:23:23.227
a fire, either. They were calm.
00:23:23.987 --> 00:23:28.187
Another sighting came from a gas station attendant. He reported seeing the children
00:23:28.187 --> 00:23:33.367
traveling in a car along a nearby route not long after the fire had taken place.
00:23:33.627 --> 00:23:35.667
And again, the same details stood out.
00:23:36.007 --> 00:23:38.687
They weren't alone. They weren't trying to get away.
00:23:39.267 --> 00:23:41.587
Each of the accounts on its own could be dismissed.
00:23:42.767 --> 00:23:47.647
Misidentification, confusion, people trying to help by filling gaps with assumptions.
00:23:48.927 --> 00:23:53.727
But together they form a pattern. Multiple people, independent of each other,
00:23:53.807 --> 00:23:54.907
describing the same thing.
00:23:55.507 --> 00:24:02.087
Five children who were supposed to be dead, seen alive. And not just alive, but with someone.
00:24:02.507 --> 00:24:04.607
Which raises a different kind of question.
00:24:05.067 --> 00:24:07.807
Not what happened in the fire, but what happened after.
00:24:09.133 --> 00:24:13.173
Years passed, but the questions never left. The Sauter family refused to accept
00:24:13.173 --> 00:24:16.033
what they had been told, and they refused to stop looking.
00:24:16.633 --> 00:24:22.393
Leads came and went. Sightings were followed, investigated, and often dissolved into uncertainty.
00:24:22.613 --> 00:24:26.033
But then one day something arrived that was different.
00:24:26.513 --> 00:24:30.413
Not a rumor or a second-hand account. Something physical.
00:24:30.833 --> 00:24:36.533
It came in the mail. An envelope with no return address, and inside was a photograph.
00:24:37.353 --> 00:24:41.433
The image showed a young man, older than the child that he might have once been,
00:24:41.613 --> 00:24:44.613
but familiar in a way that was impossible to ignore.
00:24:45.073 --> 00:24:50.033
His features, his expression, the shape of his face, it all resembled one of
00:24:50.033 --> 00:24:51.733
the missing Sautter boys, Louis.
00:24:52.433 --> 00:24:57.993
The resemblance wasn't perfect, but it didn't need to be. It was close enough to stop everything.
00:24:58.693 --> 00:25:02.193
On the back of the photograph, there was a message, handwritten and brief.
00:25:02.593 --> 00:25:09.113
It just said, Louis Sauter I love brother Frankie E little boys.
00:25:11.213 --> 00:25:17.433
A90132 or 35 For the family, it wasn't just a clue, it was hope.
00:25:18.013 --> 00:25:22.873
Because if the photograph was real, if it really was Lewis, then everything
00:25:22.873 --> 00:25:25.613
they had been told about that night was wrong.
00:25:26.293 --> 00:25:29.773
The fire hadn't taken them, it hadn't taken any of them.
00:25:30.393 --> 00:25:35.473
But hope like that does come with a cost, because without answers it lingers
00:25:35.473 --> 00:25:40.773
and stretches across years and it turns every unknown into a possibility and
00:25:40.773 --> 00:25:44.033
every possibility into something you can't let go of.
00:25:44.533 --> 00:25:48.173
And in the case of this photograph, it didn't really solve anything.
00:25:48.173 --> 00:25:49.613
It just made the mystery deeper.
00:25:51.173 --> 00:25:55.753
As the years passed and answers never came, the Sauter family made a decision.
00:25:56.153 --> 00:26:00.573
They would not let the world forget what had happened on that hillside near Fayetteville.
00:26:00.573 --> 00:26:05.153
And more importantly They wouldn't let anyone quietly accept That their children
00:26:05.153 --> 00:26:09.913
had died in that fire Without proof They took their grief Their doubt And their
00:26:09.913 --> 00:26:13.293
unanswered questions And turned it into something permanent And,
00:26:14.346 --> 00:26:18.806
Along the roadside where people passed every day, they set up a massive billboard,
00:26:19.106 --> 00:26:20.526
one that you couldn't ignore.
00:26:20.786 --> 00:26:23.366
It forced everyone who saw it to stop and look.
00:26:23.846 --> 00:26:28.906
On it were the faces of the five children, young, smiling, frozen in time.
00:26:29.266 --> 00:26:34.246
And beside those faces were the details of the case, the questions that still
00:26:34.246 --> 00:26:38.546
didn't have answers, and the message that the children were missing, not dead.
00:26:39.286 --> 00:26:46.626
It wasn't just a sign, it was a statement. or a refusal to accept closure that didn't exist.
00:26:47.226 --> 00:26:51.626
For decades, that billboard stood as a reminder of something about the story
00:26:51.626 --> 00:26:56.106
that didn't add up, that five children vanished under circumstances that no
00:26:56.106 --> 00:26:58.386
official explanation could fully answer.
00:26:58.846 --> 00:27:04.866
Though the official explanation never changed, the Sauter family would forever hold on to hope.
00:27:06.026 --> 00:27:10.746
That's it for today's episode of Legends May Live. If you enjoyed today's story,
00:27:10.746 --> 00:27:13.286
please drop a like and follow. It helps a lot.
00:27:13.706 --> 00:27:18.346
And until next time, stay safe, because legends may live.