MENGENAI EPISOD INI
Mark Phelan, Professor of Philosophy, Director of Lawrence’s Cognitive Science program, and Co-director of the AI Task Force at Lawrence, joins the show to discuss why large language models may be the biggest development in philosophy of mind in a generation. We also discuss whether LLMs can mean, intend, or know anything, the debate over AI-written philosophy, and the real risk of cognitive offloading, including what to hand to AI and what to keep for ourselves. Mark also takes us inside Philosophy 111: Computation and Cognition (offered in the Winter 2027 term) and shares advice for faculty and students on engaging with AI thoughtfully rather than reflexively.
Episode Resources
- Emily Bender [link]
- Paper that includes the octopus example Mark referenced [link]
- Journal article in Philosophy and Public Affairs written by AI [link]
- AI Philosophy Competition [link]
- Mark's presentation Can an LLM Have Communicative Intentions? at AI and Philosophy Conference, University of New Orleans, April 16, 2026 [link] and 6th International Conference on Philosophy of Mind: Artificial Intelligence, University of Porto, Portugal, May 6, 2026 [link]
- PHIL/COSC 111 course details
Synopsis:
This course is a blend of philosophy, cognitive science, and hands-on AI experimentation. The main goal of the course is to compare human thought with whatever computational generative AI systems do, exploring both their similarities and differences. To do this competently, we’ll first need to explore some aspects of human cognition. We’ll also need to spend time directly engaging with generative AI systems and critically analyzing how they respond to and are shaped by prompting.
The course is structured around three main activities:
- First 2 Weeks: Investigate aspects of how humans think.
- Weeks 3-7.5: Explore how generative AI systems work, with an emphasis on hands-on interaction.
- Weeks 7.5-10: Philosophical reflection on similarities and differences between human and AI cognition.
Learning Outcomes: At the end of this course, you should be better able to…
- Understand fundamental features of human thought and minds.
- Interact with and appreciate the strengths and limitations of generative AI systems and large language models.
- More deeply appreciate the range of possible minds and the differences and similarities between human minds and generative AI systems.
- Be better able to recognize what evidence is relevant for theoretical positions and arguments (and what is irrelevant).
- Engage philosophically with cognitive science and computer science.
Click here to view the episode transcript.
- (00:00) - Intro and welcome
- (00:42) - Meet Mark Phelan
- (01:43) - Icebreaker
- (03:29) - AI and philosophy of mind
- (05:47) - Meaning, intentions, and consciousness in LLMs
- (10:12) - Can machines produce knowledge?
- (14:21) - An AI philosophy competition
- (16:01) - Cognitive offloading: where to draw the line
- (22:27) - Inside Philosophy 111: Computation and Cognition
- (28:39) - Students who oppose AI, and being transparent about instructor use
- (32:00) - Advice for Lawrence colleagues and students
- (35:49) - Low-hanging fruit: getting started with AI
- (38:39) - Closing thanks and sign-off
Tunjukkan NOTA 🔗
TRANSKRIP 🔗
[00:00:03] Abhishek: Hello and welcome to Minding Machines, a podcast dedicated to fostering thoughtful, open dialogue about artificial intelligence. The show brings together educators, students, and practitioners to explore how these tools are changing the way we teach, work, and think. Our conversations focus on practical experiences, emerging questions, and diverse perspectives across disciplines, rather than establishing rigid right or wrong answers or settling debates ab…