이 에피소드에 관해
On this episode of Talking Guitars on Johnny Beane TV, we’re talking about one of the most unusual guitar moments in Nirvana history — the original guitar solo on “Heart-Shaped Box.”
Kurt Cobain’s “Heart-Shaped Box” guitar solo has a wild history. 🎸 On the original recording sessions, Steve Albini used a one-off handmade “Pedal X” effect—a bizarre ring-modulator/overdrive-style pedal—to create the song’s strange, warped guitar sound. The original Pedal X version was ultimately replaced on the standard album mix, making the effect a fascinating piece of In Utero recording history.
Krist Novoselic recently opened up about why he hated Kurt Cobain’s original guitar solo, even calling it something that was sabotaging an otherwise beautiful song.
🎸 What happened with “Heart-Shaped Box”?
Nirvana recorded In Utero with producer Steve Albini, intentionally going for a rawer, more abrasive sound after Nevermind.
Kurt Cobain and Albini apparently experimented with a bizarre guitar effect for the original “Heart-Shaped Box” solo.
Krist Novoselic strongly disliked the effect and questioned why Kurt was intentionally making the song sound less commercial.
Novoselic recalled asking Cobain: “Why are you sabotaging this beautiful song?”
Cobain reportedly responded that he thought the effect sounded cool.
Novoselic believes the approach may have been a statement against the polished, mainstream sound associated with Nevermind.
Nirvana eventually brought in Scott Litt to remix “Heart-Shaped Box” and “All Apologies.”
The version most fans know today features a substantially different treatment of the guitar and overall mix.
🔥 Why did Kurt want it that way?
That’s one of the fascinating things about In Utero. Nirvana wasn't simply trying to make another Nevermind. The band wanted something raw, strange, uncomfortable and less concerned with commercial expectations.
And Novoselic's comments give us another look at just how far that philosophy went — even when the band's own members disagreed about what belonged in the songs.
🎸 Krist Novoselic still loves In Utero
Despite his criticism of the original “Heart-Shaped Box” solo, Novoselic says In Utero is his favorite Nirvana album.
He has described the recording sessions as a period when the band was focused, creative and working extremely well together. For Novoselic, that chemistry is part of what makes the album so special.
So what do you think?
Was Kurt Cobain’s original “Heart-Shaped Box” guitar solo a brilliant artistic decision — or did Krist Novoselic have a point?
Let me know in the comments!
Talking Guitars on Johnny Beane TV — Rock. Riffs. Real Talk.
#Nirvana #KurtCobain #HeartShapedBox #InUtero
Kurt Cobain’s “Heart-Shaped Box” guitar solo has a wild history. 🎸 On the original recording sessions, Steve Albini used a one-off handmade “Pedal X” effect—a bizarre ring-modulator/overdrive-style pedal—to create the song’s strange, warped guitar sound. The original Pedal X version was ultimately replaced on the standard album mix, making the effect a fascinating piece of In Utero recording history.
Krist Novoselic recently opened up about why he hated Kurt Cobain’s original guitar solo, even calling it something that was sabotaging an otherwise beautiful song.
🎸 What happened with “Heart-Shaped Box”?
Nirvana recorded In Utero with producer Steve Albini, intentionally going for a rawer, more abrasive sound after Nevermind.
Kurt Cobain and Albini apparently experimented with a bizarre guitar effect for the original “Heart-Shaped Box” solo.
Krist Novoselic strongly disliked the effect and questioned why Kurt was intentionally making the song sound less commercial.
Novoselic recalled asking Cobain: “Why are you sabotaging this beautiful song?”
Cobain reportedly responded that he thought the effect sounded cool.
Novoselic believes the approach may have been a statement against the polished, mainstream sound associated with Nevermind.
Nirvana eventually brought in Scott Litt to remix “Heart-Shaped Box” and “All Apologies.”
The version most fans know today features a substantially different treatment of the guitar and overall mix.
🔥 Why did Kurt want it that way?
That’s one of the fascinating things about In Utero. Nirvana wasn't simply trying to make another Nevermind. The band wanted something raw, strange, uncomfortable and less concerned with commercial expectations.
And Novoselic's comments give us another look at just how far that philosophy went — even when the band's own members disagreed about what belonged in the songs.
🎸 Krist Novoselic still loves In Utero
Despite his criticism of the original “Heart-Shaped Box” solo, Novoselic says In Utero is his favorite Nirvana album.
He has described the recording sessions as a period when the band was focused, creative and working extremely well together. For Novoselic, that chemistry is part of what makes the album so special.
So what do you think?
Was Kurt Cobain’s original “Heart-Shaped Box” guitar solo a brilliant artistic decision — or did Krist Novoselic have a point?
Let me know in the comments!
Talking Guitars on Johnny Beane TV — Rock. Riffs. Real Talk.
#Nirvana #KurtCobain #HeartShapedBox #InUtero
영어
미국
노골적인 콘텐츠
전사 🔗
Are you the producer of this podcast?
Add a podcast transcript
Need Audio-to-Text?
Transcribe with Listen411 in Just 60 Seconds
이 팟캐스트의 다른 에피소드
September 27, 2007 — Charlotte, North Carolina.
Nineteen years ago tonight, Van Halen officially hit the road with David Lee Roth for the first time since 1984! 🤘🔥
After more than two decades apart, Eddie Van Halen, David Lee Roth, Alex Van Halen and 16-year-old Wolfgang Van Halen stepped onto th…
On this episode of Exclusively Van Halen on Johnny Beane TV, we’re getting more of the conversation you thought you’d already seen! 👀
The original talk was just the beginning. The conversation featuring Robert Vargas, Alex Van Halen, and David Lee Roth went beyond what was included in the original…
On this episode of Talking Guitars on Johnny Beane TV, we’re talking about a seriously unexpected guitar collaboration: John Mayer, PRS, and Land Rover Defender have teamed up for a new Silver Sky collection featuring actual Defender paint colors — and, finally, a factory black pickguard on the Sil…
On this episode of Talking Guitars on Johnny Beane TV, we’re talking about Cheap Trick guitar legend Rick Nielsen and the incredible collection of guitars he’s putting up for auction — including one of the wildest guitars ever built!
🎸 Rick Nielsen’s famous five-neck Hamer — the 2004 “Five Neck” K…
면책 조항: 이 페이지에 포함된 팟캐스트와 작품은 Johnny Beane에서 가져온 것입니다. 이 팟캐스트는 소유자의 재산이며 Listen Notes, Inc.와 제휴하거나 보증하지 않습니다.
