Spearfactor #81: Dr Ray Hilborn, MPAs & Fisheries Science

In this episode of the SpearFactor Podcast, I talk with Dr. Ray Hilborn, a fisheries scientist at the University of Washington, about the state of fisheries worldwide and the real-world data behind marine conservation.

Ray has spent decades studying fish populations, fishing fleets, and management systems across the globe. He walks me through what his research shows about which fisheries are healthy, which are in trouble, and what separates the two. Many of the assumptions people hold about overfishing don't match the data, and Ray explains where the gap comes from.

We also get into marine protected areas. MPAs are often presented as the default tool for ocean conservation, but Ray argues the picture is more complicated. We talk about where MPAs help, where they fall short, what they cost in terms of food production and displaced fishing effort, and why catch limits, gear rules, and stock assessments often do more for fish populations than closing off areas of the ocean.

Ray explains that the best way to manage fisheries is not through MPAs, but through active fisheries management and enforcement — science-based catch limits, gear restrictions, stock assessments, and monitoring. He points to his own research showing that where fisheries are managed and enforced, stocks are at target levels or rebuilding, and where management is weak, stocks decline.

Papers referenced in the episode:

• Hilborn, R. et al. (2020). Effective fisheries management instrumental in improving fish stock status. PNAS 117(4): 2218–2224.
• Hilborn, R. (2016). Policy: Marine biodiversity needs more than protection. Nature 535: 224–226.
• Hilborn, R. (2013). Environmental cost of conservation victories. PNAS 110(23): 9187.
• Hilborn, R. & Kaiser, M.J. (2021). Critique of Sala et al., Protecting the global ocean for biodiversity, food and climate, Nature (which was subsequently corrected).
• Hilborn, R. (2021). Increasing fisheries harvest with MPAs: Leaving South and Southeast Asia behind. PNAS — reply on Cabral et al.

Topics covered:

• The state of global fisheries based on actual stock data
• Common myths about overfishing and where they come from
• How fisheries are managed in the U.S. and abroad
• Marine protected areas: where they work and where they don't
• Trade-offs between MPAs, food supply, and displaced fishing effort
• Why active fisheries management and enforcement outperform area closures

Sources:

• Effective fisheries management instrumental in improving fish stock status — PNAS
• Policy: Marine biodiversity needs more than protection — Nature
• Environmental cost of conservation victories — PNAS
• Critique of Sala et al. 2021 — Sustainable Fisheries UW
• Increasing fisheries harvest with MPAs: Leaving South and Southeast Asia behind — PNAS

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices