このエピソードについて
This Day in Legal History: Wickard v. Filburn
On November 9, 1942, the Supreme Court decided Wickard v. Filburn, one of the most consequential and most debated decisions about the reach of federal power. Roscoe Filburn, an Ohio farmer, grew more wheat than his federal quota under the Agricultural Adjustment Act allowed. He argued that the extra wheat never left his farm. He fed it to his own livestock and used it at home, so it had nothing to do with interstate commerce, and Congress couldn’t regulate it.
The Court disagreed unanimously. Justice Robert Jackson wrote that even activity that’s local and not itself commerce can be regulated if it has a substantial effect on interstate commerce, today’s opening quote. And the effect is measured in the aggregate. Filburn’s own extra wheat was trivial, but if every farmer did the same, they’d collectively buy less wheat on the market and undermine the program’s effort to stabilize prices. Taken together with other New Deal-era decisions, Wickard marked the end of the Court’s resistance to broad federal economic regulation.
The significance of November 9, 1942 is that Wickard became the foundation of the modern Commerce Clause, supporting federal laws on everything from civil rights in public accommodations to drug regulation, and it’s still at the center of debates over the limits of federal power, as in the Affordable Care Act case in 2012. It’s a reminder that the most important questions about government power are often decided not in dramatic confrontations, but in cases about wheat, and today, about judicial appointments, monuments, and jobs.
The President is moving to nominate James Sullivan, a Republican justice on the Texas Supreme Court who lost his reelection race last Tuesday, to a lifetime federal judgeship on the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas in Austin. Sullivan lost to Democrat Chari Kelly. In fact, Democrats won all four Texas Supreme Court seats on the ballot, narrowing the Republican majority on the nine-member court to 5 to 4. Reports say Sullivan submitted his Senate Judiciary Committee questionnaire days before the election, and the Senate is expected to take up the nomination during the lame-duck session, before Democrats take control of the chamber in January. Here’s why the timing matters. As we discussed last week, the new Democratic Senate majority will control which nominees get hearings and votes. Federal judges serve for life, so the President and the outgoing Republican majority have a strong incentive to confirm as many as possible before January 3. Doing that in a lame-duck session is legal, and both parties have done it, though it’s often criticized when the outgoing majority has just lost an election. There’s also a point worth noting about how differently states and the federal government choose judges. Texas elects its judges in partisan elections, and voters just removed Sullivan from his state seat. The federal system uses presidential nomination and Senate confirmation, with lifetime tenure designed to insulate judges from exactly that kind of political pressure. Sullivan’s path, voted off one court and appointed for life to another within weeks, puts that contrast in sharp relief. Supporters will say his qualifications haven’t changed, and that partisan state judicial elections reflect political tides rather than judicial merit. Critics will see it as a rejected judge being rewarded. Either way, expect a busy lame-duck confirmation calendar, and an incoming Democratic majority prepared to slow the pace of judicial confirmations dramatically in January.
Trump to nominate Texas Supreme Court justice who lost election to federal bench | Reuters · The Texas Lawbook · Minnesota Lawyer
Last week we previewed the fight over the President’s planned 250-foot triumphal arch in Washington. Here’s what happened. On Thursday, the National Capital Planning Commission gave its final approval. Minutes later, U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan issued a temporary restraining order barring any construction or site preparation at Memorial Circle for 14 days while the lawsuits by Vietnam War veterans, the District of Columbia, Virginia, and Arlington County proceed. Judge Chutkan found the challengers were likely to succeed because the administration appeared to have skipped required legal steps in rushing the approval, likely violating the Commemorative Works Act, the federal law that governs new memorials on federal land in Washington. She held off for now on whether to suspend the Interior Department’s approval under the Administrative Procedure Act. The White House praised the commission’s approval and criticized the judge’s order. Recall the administration’s main argument: that Congress approved the arch more than a century ago when it authorized a bridge across the Potomac. The Commemorative Works Act sets out a detailed process for new memorials, including congressional authorization and review by planning and arts commissions, precisely so that monuments on the capital’s federal land reflect deliberate national decisions rather than any one official’s preference. The judge’s preliminary view is that the shortcuts likely don’t satisfy it. A temporary restraining order is short-lived; it’s meant to preserve the status quo until the court can hold a fuller hearing on a preliminary injunction. But the timing is telling: the government was ready to begin work the same day it got approval, and the court acted within minutes. As with the trees cut at East Potomac Golf Links, the concern is that construction can create facts on the ground before a court can rule. Expect a preliminary-injunction fight within the next two weeks.
Trump’s Washington arch poised for approval as judge weighs bid to block construction | Reuters · CBS News · Washington Post
And finally, some good news for the profession: legal-sector employment climbed to a record high in October, according to the latest federal jobs data. The legal industry added about 2,400 jobs last month, as the broader economy added 165,000, beating economists’ expectations, while the unemployment rate fell to 4.1%. Professional and business services, the category that includes legal services, added about 70,000 jobs. A few observations. First, this comes during a year of real turbulence in Big Law, including the collapse of Weil, Gotshal & Manges that we covered just over a week ago. One firm’s failure doesn’t mean the sector is shrinking. When a firm dissolves, its lawyers and clients mostly move to other firms. Second, the numbers cut against a common prediction about AI. Despite rapid adoption of legal AI tools, from Harvey to the products the big tech companies are selling to law firms, overall legal employment keeps growing, at least so far. That may be because AI is changing what legal work looks like more than how much of it there is, or because the effects on hiring, especially for junior lawyers and support staff, haven’t shown up in the aggregate numbers yet. These figures cover the whole legal sector, from lawyers to paralegals to support staff, and don’t show which roles are growing and which are shrinking. Third, demand for legal services tends to rise with regulatory and political uncertainty, and there’s been no shortage of that this year, from tariffs and their refunds to the election litigation we’ve followed and the shift to divided government. Every major legal fight we cover generates work for lawyers on both sides. For anyone graduating from law school or thinking about it, the headline is encouraging, but it’s worth watching how the composition of legal jobs changes as AI tools mature.
US legal sector job growth climbs as broader economy sees gains | Reuters · Law360 · The Hill
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.minimumcomp.com/subscribe