TRANSCRIPTION 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:21.280 --> 00:00:24.559
Scripture shapes the lives of millions of people around the world.
00:00:24.640 --> 00:00:30.719
Yet scriptures, both the Bible and the Quran, only gain meaning when they are interpreted by the human mind.
00:00:31.039 --> 00:00:41.119
Minding Scripture, a podcast from the Department of Theology at the University of Notre Dame, explores the meeting of reason with the scriptures of Judaism, Christianity, and Islam.
00:00:41.280 --> 00:00:55.920
I'm Gabriel Said Reynolds, Professor of Islamic Studies and Theology in the World Religions World Church program at Notre Dame, and joining me are my colleagues, Professor Francesca Murphy, Professor Svi Novik, and Professor Mooneem Suri.
00:00:56.240 --> 00:00:56.479
Hello.
00:00:56.799 --> 00:01:00.079
And friends, our task today is to speak about Abraham.
00:01:00.479 --> 00:01:01.600
We like Abraham.
00:01:01.759 --> 00:01:08.159
We're not intending to complicate the figure, but nevertheless, some questions arise about Abraham.
00:01:08.319 --> 00:01:11.120
We see a figure who unites or divides.
00:01:11.599 --> 00:01:18.079
Today, for example, Judaism, Christianity, and Islam are commonly referred to as Abrahamic religions.
00:01:18.480 --> 00:01:25.680
But this notion has come under criticism, some severe, from scholars such as John Levinson and Aaron Hughes.
00:01:26.239 --> 00:01:27.760
And there are other questions about Abraham.
00:01:27.840 --> 00:01:32.000
One might even ask provocatively, is Abraham a good exemplar?
00:01:32.719 --> 00:01:36.799
In Genesis, he gives his wife Sarah away to two other men.
00:01:37.280 --> 00:01:40.640
And in the Quran, he seems to tell a lie on two different occasions.
00:01:41.120 --> 00:01:45.200
And a saying or hadith of the Prophet Muhammad makes this three lies.
00:01:45.599 --> 00:01:50.079
So who is Abraham and what does he mean to Jews, Christians, and Muslims?
00:01:50.879 --> 00:01:55.920
Let's start at the beginning of the Abraham story and I'll direct this question to Svi.
00:01:57.040 --> 00:02:06.319
So we turn to the very end of Genesis 11, which I think is a bit of a turning point, although you could correct me on that for the narrative in the book of Genesis.
00:02:06.560 --> 00:02:10.719
There we learn that Abraham, or at the time Abram's father, was named Terah.
00:02:11.759 --> 00:02:18.159
And Terah takes Abraham and his wife Sarai, later Sarah, out of Ur to the city of Haran.
00:02:18.319 --> 00:02:22.319
I think it says he was intending to go all the way to Canaan, but got stuck at Haran.
00:02:22.719 --> 00:02:30.960
And then in Genesis 12, um the Lord calls out to Abraham and um tells him to travel to a new land and promises to bless him.
00:02:31.280 --> 00:02:41.520
So why is this scene, I don't know, I almost want to ask, why is this scene there at all after the sort of tremendous primordial historical narratives of the first 11 chapters of Genesis?
00:02:41.759 --> 00:02:48.240
But maybe I should ask, why is this um this scene so important to the Hebrew Bible and to later Judaism?
00:02:48.639 --> 00:02:49.439
Um so sure.
00:02:49.599 --> 00:03:18.000
So um I think you're right to characterize this as a turning point, right, where we have um um maybe uh a shift from uh, in a certain sense, um a quasi-kind of mythological um first 11 chapters, um, where God behaves in certain distinctive ways, uh that uh he doesn't um uh uh uh that differ from the way he behaves in subsequent chapters.
00:03:18.240 --> 00:03:24.879
But certainly um for for Judaism, this is this is a uh a fundamental turning point.
00:03:25.199 --> 00:03:30.000
Um I mean, this is the uh the beginning really of the story of election.
00:03:30.400 --> 00:03:43.039
Um and I I think uh when I was kind of thinking about Abraham um and at the beginning of the story of Abraham, I thought uh you know it might be instructive to to compare Abraham with uh his predecessors, as it were.
00:03:43.120 --> 00:03:53.120
You've got Adam and then Noah, uh, and then Abraham as um as um um as main characters, as it were, in the story.
00:03:53.280 --> 00:03:56.719
Uh and so Noah is uh chosen.
00:03:56.800 --> 00:03:58.879
There is a kind of election in the case of Noah.
00:03:58.960 --> 00:04:06.560
He's chosen right from the flood generation, uh, but in that case, all of the others are will be destroyed or destined for destruction.
00:04:06.639 --> 00:04:10.560
And Noah really, he is chosen, but he is in fact another Adam, right?
00:04:10.639 --> 00:04:11.680
He's a second Adam.
00:04:11.840 --> 00:04:23.439
Uh he's in fact he's called uh the man of the soil in the Bible, uh, or in Hebrew, Isha'adama, um, so an Adam man, uh, he begins the world anew.
00:04:23.519 --> 00:04:26.720
Uh he's the sole progenitor progenitor of the world again.
00:04:26.879 --> 00:04:51.759
But with Abraham, we really begin this kind of more complicated dynamic in the story of divine providence or in the story of God's relationship with the world, um, uh this dynamic of election, uh, where you have Abraham called upon to separate from his family, uh go, uh God says in the beginning of Genesis 12, uh, from your land, uh, from your birthplace, uh, and from the uh house of your father.
00:04:51.920 --> 00:05:03.199
Um so he's called upon to separate from his family to originate a new nation, uh Israel in its own land, uh, but the rest of the world is going to remain um under God and in relation to Israel.
00:05:03.360 --> 00:05:11.759
Um, and so you have this new dynamic then of election uh involving a separation from the world but uh and relationship with it.
00:05:11.839 --> 00:05:42.160
Um and I was thinking almost kind of in um, you know, in in geometric terms, uh if you if you wanted to think in uh in the in the previous chapters of Genesis of God's relationship with the world, uh, you know, figuring it like a line, uh a relationship at one dimension, it now becomes a kind of a triangle, um, a set of relationships
Load full transcript
in two dimensions, uh, where God and Israel is Israel through Abraham, um, where God, Abraham, and the nations, or God, Israel and the nations are the three vertices of the triangle.
00:05:42.319 --> 00:06:02.879
Um, and so, and so it's really important then that in Genesis 12, it's this turning point um that marks that election, there's also um that that command separation, um, the same passage is insisting on points of connection um between Abraham and and the world, um, and between God and the world.
00:06:02.959 --> 00:06:07.279
Um, and so you mentioned, right, Terah, uh Abraham's father beginning the journey.
00:06:07.439 --> 00:06:09.040
I mean, for me, it's a it's a striking thing.
00:06:09.199 --> 00:06:22.319
I mean, it's a striking thing to see the Bible say that Terah, the the person who kind of begins that journey to the land of Canaan isn't Abraham, but but Abraham, but but the the but the figure from whom Abraham is separating, Terah.
00:06:22.480 --> 00:06:35.439
And so it kind of uh gestures toward this the the complication here that Abraham is abandoning his father, his his is abandoning his father's home, but he's also completing the journey, completing his father's journey.
00:06:35.600 --> 00:06:38.879
Uh that's maybe like one expression of that complexity.
00:06:39.040 --> 00:06:49.519
And then also this whole idea of you know the nations being blessed through Abraham uh also expresses this kind of complexity in election where it's a matter of separation, but also a matter of relationship.
00:06:49.600 --> 00:07:23.199
So it's it's a it's a um it is, yeah, I think uh it's it sets the terms for how Judaism um perceives of um of uh or uh of itself, I think in in relation to God and in relation to the world, um as uh as a a chosen people, but but but uh but where that where that choice or election does not involve a uh a turning away from the world, but uh um a more uh but a complicated uh relationship with it.
00:07:24.240 --> 00:07:35.920
So speaking of complications, uh just about right when Abraham shows up um in in Canaan, he proceeds to Egypt in Genesis twelve.
00:07:36.000 --> 00:07:41.680
And I'll sort of direct this question towards Yusuf, but maybe Francesca and Moonim would like to add their thoughts on it.
00:07:42.560 --> 00:07:48.399
Um he says to his wife Sarai, this is Genesis twelve, eleven, look, I know you are a beautiful woman.
00:07:49.120 --> 00:07:52.079
It doesn't say how she responds to that, but anyway.
00:07:52.480 --> 00:07:59.279
Um verse twelve, um When the Egyptians see you, they will say, That is his wife, and they will kill me, but leave you alive.
00:07:59.839 --> 00:08:09.360
Verse 13, therefore please tell them that you are my sister, so that they may treat me well because of you and spare my life out of regard for you.
00:08:11.360 --> 00:08:26.639
Well, uh this is a uh a very complicated situation and um leads to all sorts of um questions about the ethics of um Abraham and his relationship with Sarah.
00:08:28.000 --> 00:08:29.360
I don't know where we should start with it.
00:08:29.600 --> 00:08:33.039
Um how have people understood it, Jews, Christians, others?
00:08:33.679 --> 00:08:44.720
Um should we s do do people seek to defend Abraham and um find justification for this um scheming or the scheme that he has?
00:08:44.879 --> 00:08:52.159
Um or is it just uh uh uh a bad deed on Abraham's part and we should um see that he wasn't all good?
00:08:53.759 --> 00:09:15.759
When the when the um patriarchs in the Old Testament went Abraham or later on David, when they do sneaky things, generally the fathers of the church are quite concerned to iron this out, and nobody reading it ought to think that you're allowed to do sneaky stuff like that now.
00:09:16.240 --> 00:09:19.759
So they will say it was an accommodation to the time.
00:09:20.639 --> 00:09:28.879
And um the whole notion of accommodation is really developed to to to deal with the sneakiness of the patriarchs and David.
00:09:29.519 --> 00:09:34.320
Uh and it became useful as a way of understanding revelation later on in the 17th century.
00:09:34.480 --> 00:09:39.279
But in the early church fathers, accommodation is just used to iron out the sneakiness of the fathers.
00:09:39.440 --> 00:09:40.399
Would you agree, Sri?
00:09:41.200 --> 00:09:42.559
Um Yeah, well, it's interesting, right?
00:09:42.639 --> 00:09:57.840
I mean, I I think I I would agree as as a characterization of the church fathers, but I think on this point there is something of a difference between uh, say, the church fathers and their contemporaries, the uh the early rabbis, where there is uh there there is that tendency right to to to defend and justify.
00:09:58.000 --> 00:10:15.759
Um but but I think that there there is also um um uh a willingness to uh to characterize the uh the patriarchs, Moses as well, uh, as um as sinful, um as not beyond sinning.
00:10:16.080 --> 00:10:24.559
Uh and I there there is there is as as I said, yeah, that that same trend um to defend and to and to uh and to explain.
00:10:24.720 --> 00:10:29.759
Um but um I mean uh maybe perhaps maybe I I'll I'll cite one, I guess, example.
00:10:29.919 --> 00:11:00.559
Um uh that this is from uh among among the medieval commentators, uh, but there are antecedents for it in um earlier rabbinic literature itself, Nahmades, uh one of the famous medieval biblical commentators from northern Spain um in the 13th century, he um he insisted that, well, whenever you see um Jews in Egypt, as it were, um you think uh kind of typologically of the of the Exodus.
00:11:00.720 --> 00:11:09.519
Um and he sees the this the seeds of the Exodus story um in this passage uh that you read, Gabriel.
00:11:09.679 --> 00:11:27.120
Um, but but in the sense that n uh in the sense that the um uh uh in in part the the the the um the enslavement in Egypt uh should be understood as uh as a kind of a punishment for Abraham's deeds here.
00:11:27.279 --> 00:11:31.440
Uh he does he does understand Abraham to have to have sinned.
00:11:31.679 --> 00:11:42.960
Well, in interestingly, um he takes Abraham's first sin to be um a a certain lack of faith in God that leads him to to leave the land of Canaan.
00:11:43.039 --> 00:11:47.600
Uh right, um should he have left the land of Canaan at all in view of the famine, right?
00:11:47.679 --> 00:11:54.879
He leaves, he leaves because uh because there is food in Egypt um and famine in Canaan, but should he have really left the land?
00:11:55.039 --> 00:11:57.759
Um and that's the that's the first of his sins here.
00:11:57.840 --> 00:12:05.919
So yeah, so there is a certain uh willingness to acknowledge sins, and there's not there's a lot of pushback against Nachmanides's comment.
00:12:06.080 --> 00:12:13.120
Um but um but there is this willingness to see the patriarchs as as uh sinful.
00:12:14.240 --> 00:12:14.399
The
00:12:14.480 --> 00:12:26.080
the the story of uh Abraham in Genesis 11 neither occurred or is alluded in the Quran, but it is certainly treated in some detail in later uh Muslim literature.
00:12:26.240 --> 00:12:29.919
Um as you already alluded, that there is uh famous hadith.
00:12:30.000 --> 00:12:48.799
Uh Hadith is uh a statement or action attributed to the Prop, in which the Prophet is reported to have said that um that Abraham does not lie except on three occasions, including when he claimed that Sarah was his uh his sister.
00:12:49.279 --> 00:12:58.639
So uh this uh this question about um about Ibrahim being a liar uh caused some difficulties among Muslims.
00:12:58.799 --> 00:13:00.559
For Muslims because prophets are infallible.
00:13:02.080 --> 00:13:06.799
Yeah, because as a prophet, uh Abraham uh uh cannot uh do wrong.
00:13:07.200 --> 00:13:07.440
Right.
00:13:07.519 --> 00:13:12.960
And and therefore uh some some uh scholars uh develop uh at least two kinds of explanations.
00:13:13.759 --> 00:13:32.799
One is that this story about Abraham should be understood in a very specific situation, in the sense that in the danger situation uh uh you know the the the unlawful can can be lawful.
00:13:33.440 --> 00:13:40.240
So the the danger situation uh warrant um Abraham Rose that's the first explanation.
00:13:40.960 --> 00:14:06.080
And the second explanation is to understand this story not in the sense of literal meaning, but rather in metaphorical sense that you know Abraham claimed that um that that that um uh Sarah was his sister should be understood should be understood in the sense of spiritual and religious nature.
00:14:06.720 --> 00:14:22.960
So uh and then you know uh they refer to uh a verse in the Quran uh in which uh you know the Quran says brothers in religion, echwanukin, meaning that even though they are not brothers, but they are brothers in religion.
00:14:23.200 --> 00:14:23.440
Okay.
00:14:23.600 --> 00:14:29.440
So just to make sense that that that Sara, his uh his sister.
00:14:29.600 --> 00:14:29.840
So
00:14:31.279 -->
00:14:31.679
that's interesting.
00:14:31.759 --> 00:14:39.840
Yeah, I mean, maybe just to jump in there, it's it's interesting in the Bible itself, you see uh kind of are arguably different different voices on the on this very question.
00:14:39.919 --> 00:14:57.360
When A Abraham, you know, that there's another wife-sister episode in um in Abraham's career uh in Genesis 20, where he uh he goes to the land of Gerar, the land of the Philistines, on account of famine and uh with with Abimelech, Abimelech.
00:14:57.519 --> 00:15:20.720
Um, and um and there uh the uh the Bible does uh allow Abraham, as it were, to defend himself uh against the charge of um uh against the charge of lying, um, and to explain that uh that Sarah is in fact uh partly his sister, that there is a that there is a a um a relationship.
00:15:20.799 --> 00:15:23.120
Uh this is in Genesis 20, verse 12.
00:15:23.279 --> 00:15:26.960
Besides, she really is my sister, the daughter of my father, though not of my mother.
00:15:27.039 --> 00:15:27.120
Right.
00:15:27.279 --> 00:15:28.080
And she became my wife.
00:15:28.159 --> 00:15:43.600
And so for biblical scholars, they uh some some biblical scholars see here a distinct uh voice, a distinct source, as it were, um, but that that's interested in defending uh Abraham and concerned about this idea that would would Abraham uh really lie.
00:15:46.720 --> 00:15:47.840
Right, right.
00:15:48.320 --> 00:15:48.720
I think
00:15:48.720 --> 00:15:49.679
he really lied.
00:15:49.919 --> 00:16:01.279
I mean, I think it's I think I like your original uh kind of the the the trap because we have to be able to say that the founders are good and bad.
00:16:01.759 --> 00:16:06.000
I mean, you know, this is the what you know America is struggling over this right now.
00:16:06.240 --> 00:16:09.120
And we just have to be able to say, well, there's good and bad there.
00:16:10.639 --> 00:16:12.559
If we can't say that, we're in trouble.
00:16:13.279 --> 00:16:15.200
Well, there is this business about scheming.
00:16:15.360 --> 00:16:19.200
I mean, in both cases, in Genesis twelve and then again in Genesis twenty,
00:16:20.240 --> 00:16:24.559
he gets all all these possessions and he takes he he keeps them, right?
00:16:24.960 --> 00:16:27.600
He gets and he gets his wife back and he gets his possessions.
00:16:28.399 --> 00:16:45.600
So um I mean, I always tell my students here at Notre Dame, in fact, I uh uh I usually stand up on a chair to make this point and that um you know uh um the characters of the Old Testament or Hebrew Bible are generally not moral exemplars.
00:16:46.240 --> 00:16:51.200
And I guess I'm going against some of the church fathers, and so maybe I should stop standing up on a chair.
00:16:51.679 --> 00:17:02.720
But um I mean, there's something in the text which praises them not for their morality, but for their ability to outscheme the opponents.
00:17:02.960 --> 00:17:04.880
Uh would you s would you say that's true, Sweet?
00:17:05.119 --> 00:17:18.480
Um Yeah, well, I think I mean cer certainly one finds that in the case of in the in the case of Jacob, I think um um the there uh there is this uh right almost uh celebration, but uh in a in a complicated way.
00:17:18.559 --> 00:17:22.880
But but his his his capacity right to to outscheme, as it were, Esau.
00:17:23.039 --> 00:17:23.359
Um
00:17:23.920 --> 00:17:25.359
Jacob is a complete schemer.
00:17:25.599 --> 00:17:25.839
Yeah.
00:17:26.000 --> 00:17:30.880
Uh and then uh and then to to outscheme even uh Laban, who is the ultimate schemer.
00:17:31.039 --> 00:17:34.400
Um so uh yes, there is uh there is something there.
00:17:34.480 --> 00:17:59.599
And I mean, and there's uh I suppose maybe a a a realistic uh uh uh realistic, I suppose, morality, um that um or recognition that uh you know Abraham needs to be encountering these less than ideal circumstances uh when he is traveling to Egypt, uh and he he is encountering real dangers.
00:17:59.680 --> 00:18:10.079
Uh and then there is the challenge of how does one uh how does one um uh how does one uh kind of um deal with these dangers?
00:18:10.319 --> 00:18:28.000
Um and and even in Genesis 20, where the where the Bible is uh insists that uh Abraham, um uh Sarah is in fact Abraham's uh sister in a certain respect, um it's it's clear, right, that he meant to mislead um uh Abimelak.
00:18:28.160 --> 00:18:47.759
And so the Bible is kind of making this uh this subtle distinction, which we find again with uh Kant arguably, uh, between a lying outright uh and saying a partial truth uh that is going to produce um that is going to mislead, uh, and that there is a moral difference between lying and misleading.
00:18:47.920 --> 00:19:05.680
Uh and so uh yeah, I think I think uh that there's something to say for the Bible presenting a uh a complex moral picture um that recognizes uh the the matter of exigency, uh that uh that recognizes distinctions between lying and misleading.
00:19:05.759 --> 00:19:20.720
Uh and that also does actually write uh perhaps even see scheming as a um uh uh as uh as perhaps, well, I don't know, rising to the level of virtue that might uh a virtue that that be
00:19:20.799 --> 00:19:21.119
too many.
00:19:22.640 --> 00:19:22.960
I think
00:19:23.200 --> 00:19:28.960
I think ancient cultures, including the biblical culture, admired schemas.
00:19:29.759 --> 00:19:35.279
And they admired people who could use a word in three different ways, like sister.
00:19:35.680 --> 00:19:41.680
And these people are paradigms in ancient cultures, whether it's Odysseus or Abraham.
00:19:42.160 --> 00:19:46.720
And this is part of our religious tradition in the scripture.
00:19:48.079 --> 00:20:06.079
Could we turn to um another episode in Abraham's um story in Genesis, which is um maybe first brought up in Genesis 15, where um uh God promises to Abraham that he will have two things.
00:20:06.240 --> 00:20:09.200
First, descendants as numerous as the stars in
the sky.
00:20:09.839 --> 00:20:16.720
I I love this phrase where God sort of taunts, I don't know if that's the right word, Abraham and says, Count the stars if you can.
00:20:17.839 --> 00:20:25.440
Um, which of course today in in most places you you actually could count the stars because of light pollution, but back then it would have been hard.
00:20:26.319 --> 00:20:27.200
Anyway, so that's one.
00:20:27.279 --> 00:20:32.240
And then the other is you he's given this country um as a possession.
00:20:32.400 --> 00:20:38.400
So the two gifts that Abraham gets from God are lots of children and the land.
00:20:39.200 --> 00:20:49.039
Um Yeah, could maybe we'll start again with Svi, but others if uh Munim or Francesca would like to add, um what is this in subsequent thought?
00:20:49.279 --> 00:20:51.200
Um how does this play out?
00:20:51.279 --> 00:20:54.079
Um what are the importance of children and land?
00:20:54.640 --> 00:20:55.119
Well, right.
00:20:55.200 --> 00:21:25.759
I mean, so so this is um yeah, this is this is sort of again uh foundational and um you know both the both the junction of the two, they they really, I suppose, um together establish a vision for um the uh the ideal the ideal life, which um which is very much uh in the first instance uh a matter of life in this world, um, you know, life as a people.
00:21:25.839 --> 00:21:43.839
And so the the the blessing is of children, uh you know, the the famous uh uh blessing uh that that recurs in uh in the in the Psalms, uh, to see uh children to your children or to see grandchildren uh as the ultimate expression of blessing.
00:21:44.079 --> 00:21:51.599
Um uh or three generations, as it were, alive uh alive together uh is a different expression of it.
00:21:51.759 --> 00:21:59.359
Um and so uh there's a a rootedness in that, in that, as it were, vertical direction uh from generation to generation.
00:21:59.440 --> 00:22:02.880
And then also this rootedness in a in a in a place.
00:22:02.960 --> 00:22:12.559
And so it's a it's a it's a vision of a uh of a of a blessed life um that is uh a life that is lived out in this world.
00:22:12.720 --> 00:22:36.640
Uh of course Judaism recognizes uh uh an afterlife or comes to recognize uh an an afterlife um and a disembodied existence um but um the primary uh kind of beatific vision as it were uh remains the one that is laid out here in in Genesis 15 uh of children um and of um of a productive land to live on
00:22:40.160 --> 00:22:48.160
if others want to add i mean my uh an initial question although this gets us into complicated political questions as well is the promise for the land.
00:22:48.640 --> 00:22:49.519
Well right right
00:22:51.039 --> 00:22:53.599
I think the promise for the land must be taken literally
00:22:54.000 --> 00:22:56.000
literally yeah
00:22:56.160 --> 00:23:01.440
well right I mean it's it's a it's an interesting one I mean right so yes this certainly takes us uh when it comes to
00:23:01.519 --> 00:23:01.920
uh when
00:23:01.920 --> 00:25:30.240
it comes to Judaism into the uh uh into the uh complex uh uh complex question of uh of modern Zionism um but for first of uh certainly the case that that that uh traditionally uh the uh within Judaism the land promises understood quite literally um there is um um you know uh Judaism uh Judaism as we know it today you know which is uh which rests of course on scripture but also foundationally um on the uh on on the corpus of texts produced by the rabbis um you know between roughly the second and s and sixth centuries um the um the judais so Judaism as we know it today uh was largely a uh a product of exile um not necessarily outside the land of Israel because many of those rabbis who produced the canon lived in in in the historical land of Israel under uh but but in exile in the sense of uh without a um a Jewish state um and and that was the default existence of Judaism um as we again as we know it today for for all of its uh uh 2000 year existence from those foundational rabbis um and so in the in the modern period um but really uh well well right so so so the the there is this a certain um uh kind of trend or tendency within modern Judaism to kind of affirm that sort of exilic existence as um uh as the as the proper form of um of Judaism um and that so so there is that that kind of tendency but the but the but the a certain trend or voice as it were um but the the but the predominant uh weight of the Jewish tradition has certainly um uh laid in um lay in affirming the land promise and the uh the vision of Genesis 15 as an ideal uh that of course doesn't necessarily mean the affirmation of um of any particular uh form of uh uh any particular uh politics or political decisions of uh particular groups of individuals uh that's a much more complicated question
00:25:30.880 --> 00:25:39.839
right right but for for Christians this is I mean th I know there are Christian Zionists out there, but this is not the standard way of thinking of Abraham, right?
00:25:40.000 --> 00:25:43.920
I mean you you don't think of of the la the promise of the land.
00:25:44.079 --> 00:25:45.039
Um I don't know.
00:25:45.200 --> 00:25:48.480
Is that Christians think of Abraham in different ways?
00:25:48.720 --> 00:25:49.839
Um Francesca
00:25:50.480 --> 00:26:05.440
Um I I I don't think that uh I I think that even Christians who think the promise of the land should be taken literally that's not the for foremost thing they think of when they think spiritually about Abraham.
00:26:06.160 --> 00:26:15.119
Uh you can think both things that the promise is literally a a good promise that holds but also that's not what Abraham means within Christianity.
00:26:15.359 --> 00:26:15.519
Yeah.
00:26:15.759 --> 00:27:08.400
I mean if if because what happens here is that Abraham has uh uh there's several stories where God keeps telling Abraham look at the sands your children will be like this look at the stars your children will be like this I
remember my Hebrew teacher telling me that God was being ironic because you can't count the stars and um so uh there is this promise and then this promise consists in God's covenant with Abraham is a covenantal promise uh in in response to which um David circumcises himself and his household so this is the this promise is somehow connected in the text with the circumcision the whole covenant and the Abrahamic covenant is connected to Abraham's circumcision in response to this promise.
00:27:08.720 --> 00:27:25.519
Okay so in early Christianity uh in uh in the first century um there's a question of whether Christians have to be circumcised and Paul says no the uh this is in Romans uh three and four uh St.
00:27:25.759 --> 00:27:37.759
Paul says uh that um Abraham is promised all these offspring not on account of circumcision but on account of his faith and that he keeps following God.
00:27:38.079 --> 00:27:41.200
So that's in uh Romans three and four.
00:27:41.359 --> 00:27:48.400
So so here Abraham becomes a sort of divisive figure between I guess Judas, Jewish and Christian.
00:27:48.720 --> 00:28:05.279
Um but so there's Paul in Romans three and four in m medieval times um I think the foremost image of Abraham is Abraham and Isaac.
00:28:05.440 --> 00:29:05.039
You know if you know Chartre Cathedral there's a picture there's a huge statue of Abraham with a knife at Isaac's throat and Isaac is supposed to be like a forerunner for Christ and Abraham's sacrifice of Isaac is supposed to uh be a a prequel to the New Testament and that's the basic Catholic understanding of Abraham and Isaac of Abraham is Isaac's father and that's how Catholics in the middle Middle Ages think of Abraham as as the father of Isaac more than as this then in Reformation times uh Luther very much focuses on this this idea that Abraham's faith is what matters and not his circumcision and so that this is faith versus works in the Reformation and so Abraham represents faith to Luther.
00:29:05.359 --> 00:29:36.000
In modern times when I think about the question what does Abraham mean to Christians it's really hard for me to say I could say theologically he stands for faith he stands for the new covenant and the old covenant and the permanence of both covenants but I would have to say that most Catholics probably couldn't tell you because once you take out Abraham and Isaac and the whole typological thing then Abraham doesn't have much to stand for.
00:29:37.759 --> 00:29:40.880
He should be the father of faith in some sense.
00:29:41.119 --> 00:29:52.000
I mean we but I don't know how many adult Catholics who are going in for baptism, you know, adult RCIA how how many of them are actually told that Abraham is a father of faith?
00:29:52.079 --> 00:29:53.039
I think very few.
00:29:53.519 --> 00:30:01.440
So you're saying Francesca that Abraham kind of doesn't doesn't figure very very significantly in the in the modern Catholic kind of imaginaire?
00:30:02.480 --> 00:30:17.519
Exactly because the big the the huge thing was always Abraham and Isaac and if you take out Abraham and Isaac and you kind of minimize typological reading then he's not very memorable.
00:30:18.079 --> 00:30:25.440
And can you just But what I mean and why what's the logic in kind of minimizing Abraham Isaac and typological reading?
00:30:25.599 --> 00:30:27.359
What why why minimize that?
00:30:29.200 --> 00:30:36.400
Just because um people aren't taught to read the scripture typologically.
00:30:36.640 --> 00:30:56.000
They're not walking into churches like Chartre Cathedral with huge statues of Abraham strangling Isaac which tells them you know that it's not entering their imagination in some rich thick way through a through sculpture and art that Abraham and Isaac is the father and the son.
00:30:56.799 --> 00:31:00.079
You know, and they're not learning that through childhood.
00:31:00.799 --> 00:31:03.359
Um probably so
00:31:05.039 --> 00:31:10.079
well did you want to complete the thought I was going to take us to a break, but if you I don't want to interrupt
00:31:10.480 --> 00:31:20.480
No, so that um I I mean you know I try to teach every freshman year I try to teach them about typological reading and so on and it's something nobody ever told them that.
00:31:20.880 --> 00:31:21.119
Right.
00:31:21.599 --> 00:31:27.519
So I think Abraham is still important for Protestants because they still think Abraham stands for faith not works.
00:31:28.240 --> 00:31:36.160
But for Catholics I think that without typological reading Catholics don't really know what to do with Abraham.
00:31:36.720 --> 00:31:49.279
One thing I find my students saying sometimes mostly Catholic students here at Notre Dame is that um well Abraham was the first monotheist and that that's a thought I'd like to get to in conversation with Munim um when we come back from a break.
00:31:49.839 --> 00:31:50.720
Is that coherent?
00:31:50.799 --> 00:31:53.119
What does it mean to say he was the first monotheist?
00:31:54.240 --> 00:32:20.799
Now is a good time to, as we head into a break, to review and rate Mining Scripture, I'd also like to um point you towards another Notre Dame podcast, the Ethics and Culture Cast, which features lively conversations with professors, fellow scholars and friends of the University of Notre Dame's the Nicola Center for Ethics and Culture, a center committed to sharing the richness of the Catholic moral and intellectual tradition through teaching research and dialogue at the highest level and across a range of disciplines.
00:32:20.960 --> 00:32:44.160
We'll be right back to Minding Scripture.
00:32:44.480 --> 00:33:06.319
We um left off by alluding to I don't know if the right way to put it but the the vagueness maybe that some Catholics have about the figure of Abraham these days and whether it's coherent to speak about Abraham as the first monotheist I wanted to ask Munim about that question from the perspective of Islam.
00:33:09.119 --> 00:33:21.039
I don't know if it's okay Munim I just introduced the question by referring to a passage of the Quran this is in Surah or chapter six which seems to explain how Abraham became a monotheist.
00:33:21.680 --> 00:33:27.519
It says thus we showed Abraham the empire of the heavens and the earth that he might be one of those with certainty.
00:33:28.079 --> 00:33:58.240
When the night fell over him he saw a planet he said this is my Lord but when it set he said I do not love those that set then when he saw the moon rising he said this is my Lord but when it set he said If my Lord does not guide me I will be one of the erring people then when he saw the sun rising he said this is my Lord this is bigger but when it set he said O my people I am innocent of your idolatry I have directed my attention towards him who created the heavens and the earth a monotheist and I am not one of the idolaters.
00:33:59.519 --> 00:34:08.159
This seems to be a discovery of monotheism could you I don't know speak about this passage and the notion of um Abraham as the first monotheist um
00:34:09.119 --> 00:34:26.800
I think you are right that you know in Islam Abraham played the role of true monotheists um let me uh elaborate on on on this notion about how Abraham discovered God because this is an issue that has caused some trouble among Muslim exeges.
00:34:27.360 --> 00:34:45.360
Because the question is how is it possible for Abraham as a prophet to discover the truth through deductions in the sense that he discovered God on on his contemplation basically
00:34:46.800 --> 00:34:48.159
of the planet and a
00:34:48.159 --> 00:35:59.039
planet yeah yeah I mean I mean the the bigger issue actually is is uh his claim that the star uh the moon and and and the sun are his god so Muslim uh you know have struggled with this issue how is it possible for Abraham as a prophet to recognize the star the moon and the sun as his as as is his God so um so some scholars um including the 14th century ibn Qathir argue that it is not possible for Abraham to claim uh star the sun as his God and therefore he argued basically that this passage should be understood as a debating technique in the sense that Abraham conceived a false premise in order to show it falsity because it is you know an inibidor for Muslim you know to imagine that that a prophet would you know would uh claim that you know other than Allah is a God right so but it's
00:35:59.039 --> 00:36:03.199
just such a big mistake to think the son could be a God a prophet could never do something right
00:36:03.440 --> 00:36:04.800
prophet we would never do that
00:36:04.960 --> 00:36:05.199
yeah
00:36:05.440 --> 00:36:30.719
um but other scholars argue that it is possible for pro for for Abraham to discover uh the truth through deductions um and they try to reconcile this story with a theological dogma of infallibility in the sense that he discovered the truth through deduction prior to his responsibility,
meaning before he became a prophet.
00:36:30.960 --> 00:36:54.880
So here you see that how some Muslim scholars try to reconcile the the difficult story of Abraham discovering recognizing uh the moon the sun and the star as a God by looking at the fact that he did that that's that um episode happened in his life before he became a prophet
00:36:56.719 --> 00:37:17.679
can I could I ask is is Hanif right the this word that's uh that's translated as as monotheist in this passage right uh where Abraham says I've directed my attention toward him who created the heavens and the earth a monotheist and I am not of the idolaters so is that is that a good translation of that Arabic word or is that um uh or a misleading translation
00:37:18.800 --> 00:37:55.679
well hanif is uh is an enigmatic term for sure right uh it's really difficult to uh figure out where this term comes from uh it is likely that it comes from Syriac Hanfa uh which means Hathan uh or the Hebrew Hanif um but what's interesting I guess is that the Quran used the term in opposite meaning so it used the term in the sense of in the sense of through monotes because it contrasts the term hanif with those who associate others with God with Mushrikun.
00:37:56.079 --> 00:38:22.559
So here you see that the word hanif is used in the Quran not in the sense of Syriac or Hebrew sense but rather in totally opposite meaning that Hanif is the one who believed in the oneness of God in is is it's an opposite of uh of polytheist uh the mushrikun yeah it it is certainly an enigmatic term it's really really difficult uh uh to but we even
00:38:22.559 --> 00:38:35.360
have in sorry to jump in here but in Islamic tradition there's the story of the Hunafa in the days of the Prophet Muhammad right these people who before Muhammad began to proclaim the Quran by their own accord had become monotheists.
00:38:35.440 --> 00:38:37.360
They were Hanifs in their own day and
00:38:37.920 --> 00:38:52.000
yeah I mean in in the later Muslim literature in the in the later Muslim literature uh Muslims developed the idea that Hanif was neither Jew nor Christian but the one who recognized the unit the unity of God.
00:38:52.320 --> 00:39:08.000
So and therefore you you you're right that that um that the the the the term you know uh developed in in the later Muslim literature uh for those who for those who are monotheists but but neither Jews or Christians as Hunafa the the plural of the word hanif.
00:39:08.480 --> 00:39:14.480
And are is there a certain suspicion of them because they are coming to this truth independent of revelation?
00:39:15.119 --> 00:39:16.000
It's a good question.
00:39:16.320 --> 00:40:02.800
I mean are they I mean I wonder I I guess I I wonder about that because uh I mean with within the Jewish context there is a similar even though the story doesn't occur in the Bible it does occur in the Jewish interpretive tradition um idea of Abraham finding God before God finds him um and um and uh the this kind of this intervention as it were in the biblical story um uh seems to kind of see an uh see seems to kind of find in Abraham a uh to make abraham a philosopher um and uh uh and and to to make the greatness of Abraham lie in his capacity for rational thought.
00:40:03.599 --> 00:40:14.159
Is is he see in the in the rabbinic stories that have Abraham look at the the stars and the the moon and the sun and then discover monotheism is is he a child when he does that
00:40:14.639 --> 00:40:56.079
right he yes he is he's uh yes he's um right uh uh a a child and um yeah so so so it's it's uh he's um uh this is an uh evidence of his precocity and his uh right and and his great uh intelligence um but then um but then the this this story uh kind of then becomes I mean rather than well what whereas in the biblical story uh you know Abraham's greatness lies in his uh in his willingness to obey God uh here his greatness seems to lie in his ability to discern God through reason uh and so um
00:40:57.280 --> 00:41:24.239
it is the opposite it's it's it's it's like at the furthest point of opposite from the Protestant idea of of of Abraham as as faith and not you know and then uh very different from the Catholic idea uh because it's faith and um uh I don't know how different from the Jewish idea but um at least in Christian tradition in some sense both Catholic and Protestant he's a man of faith.
00:41:24.400 --> 00:41:24.639
Right.
00:41:24.880 --> 00:41:29.039
Whereas here he's a man of reason and it's quite quite the opposite.
00:41:29.280 --> 00:41:36.400
It it's really interesting because it's doing something with because obviously it really is changing it.
00:41:36.559 --> 00:41:40.159
It it's a really uh it subverts the Christian reading completely.
00:41:40.639 --> 00:41:42.880
And I think the Jewish reading that as I so far as I know.
00:41:43.360 --> 00:41:56.639
Well yeah well it's interesting right that that you you had earlier Francesco alluded to this tension between faith and works around the figure of Abraham and here here in light of this exegesis there is a certain tension around the the uh around the dichotomy of faith and and reason.
00:41:56.800 --> 00:42:46.400
Um and uh yeah the the predominant one the predominant voice as it were in the in the Jewish tradition right do is is the is the the biblical one where Abraham's greatness lies in his uh in his uh not so much in his faith but in his in his works in his obedience to God in leaving his family and then of course later on in his sacrifice of Isaac or his willingness to sacrifice Isaac um but there is this um voice and to some extent this is replaying that that tension between election and relationship to the world uh here around this story uh where um the rel relationship um if if Abraham's greatness lies in his discernment of the one God, um then he is a model for the whole world because from the perspective of Judaism everyone ought to recognize i everyone shouldn't be Jewish uh but
everyone should recognize the one God.
00:42:46.800 --> 00:42:53.280
And so from that perspective Abraham Abraham's greatness lies in as as a model for everyone.
00:42:53.679 --> 00:43:04.079
And so this is a different kind of conception of Abraham and a universalist conception of Abraham that differs from the Abraham who is the ancestor of the Jewish people.
00:43:04.639 --> 00:43:06.960
He is the ancestor of right thinking people, as it were.
00:43:07.440 --> 00:43:22.880
Yes, yes I think there I think there are analogous questions for the so-called natural monotheists known as the Honefa, the the which is again coming from that Arabic word translated in the passage we read as monotheist Hanif.
00:43:23.920 --> 00:43:32.239
Because I think there's a debate among Muslim intellectuals about should you be able to get to monotheism by your own accord or do you need revelation?
00:43:32.639 --> 00:43:43.280
There's a verse in the Quran which says we never punish a city without first sending it a messenger which to some implies that you the message is important.
00:43:43.519 --> 00:43:48.000
Without the message you can't be held accountable at least for monotheism.
00:43:48.719 --> 00:44:02.400
But then I mean there are thinkers you know I I believe that people like Mohammed Abdul and Rashid Rida, the reformist in in Egypt in late nineteenth, earliest twentieth century, would say that No, reason itself is a kind of messenger.
00:44:03.039 --> 00:44:07.599
And by reason alone you should be able to come to monotheism?
00:44:08.480 --> 00:44:09.760
Yeah, no, that's really interesting.
00:44:09.920 --> 00:44:10.079
Right.
00:44:10.320 --> 00:44:17.519
There's always the question, right, what does what if if one can come to uh the essential belief in God right through reason, then what does revelation add?
00:44:17.599 --> 00:44:17.760
Right.
00:44:17.840 --> 00:44:28.159
There are the rationalists within the Jewish tradition who reduce prophecy itself to uh a kind of cultivation of one's intellectual capacities to the point where one connects with God.
00:44:28.320 --> 00:44:36.400
And so the whole distinction between revelation and reason dissolves into reason, and prophecy is just a kind of elevated intellectual insight.
00:44:36.559 --> 00:44:36.800
Yeah.
00:44:37.280 --> 00:44:37.440
Right.
00:44:37.920 --> 00:44:47.440
In my opinion, in the Bible i in the Hebrew Bible and the Christian Old Testament, there isn't a father of monotheism.
00:44:47.760 --> 00:44:52.719
There's one God who kind of speaks who's a who's a character in the story.
00:44:52.960 --> 00:44:57.360
Uh, but nobody is shown as fathering monotheism.
00:44:57.599 --> 00:45:03.199
You've got the character of God in the story who calls Abraham and calls Moses and so on.
00:45:03.360 --> 00:45:06.159
And so there is only one true God character.
00:45:06.320 --> 00:45:10.400
Uh so there's no polytheism in the Hebrew Bible or the Old Testament.
00:45:10.480 --> 00:45:17.599
There's just this one God character, but there's no one that could be called the father of monotheism who has a great insight that there's only one God.
00:45:18.880 --> 00:45:19.199
Um
00:45:21.119 --> 00:45:29.199
we were speaking about the relationship between reason and revelation, and there are surprises in the things that God does in Genesis.
00:45:30.000 --> 00:45:46.960
Maybe the most famous of them is Genesis 22, where um God does something which seems completely counterintuitive, and yet Abraham follows God's command, namely to take I'll just read here from Genesis twenty-two, verse two.
00:45:47.519 --> 00:46:00.480
God said, Take your son, your only son, your beloved Isaac, you might want to comment on the only son bit, and go to the land of Moriah, where you are to offer him as a burnt offering on one of the mountains, which I shall point to.
00:46:00.800 --> 00:46:14.159
And Francesca was speaking earlier about the place that this anecdote has in Christian thought and how it's read typologically as an anticipation of the sacrifice of the Son of God by the Father.
00:46:15.119 --> 00:46:26.480
Um but again we have a uh an ethical dilemma, in this time not involving the actions of Abraham, but maybe more problematically involving the command of God.
00:46:26.719 --> 00:46:43.920
And I'll just set it up a little bit more, then I'll let the three of you take take over, because in the Quran we have um uh an episode that's related in Surah or chapter 37, where um the Quran says, We gave him, that is Abraham, good news of a clement boy.
00:46:44.079 --> 00:46:56.559
Then when he was old enough to accompany him, that is Abraham, um uh uh uh uh he said, O my son, I see in a dream that I am sacrificing you, see what you think.
00:46:56.719 --> 00:47:02.880
He said, That is the son, O my father, do as you are commanded, you will find me, God willing, one of the steadfast.
00:47:03.119 --> 00:47:05.280
Um I don't know who wants to start about the S.
00:47:05.840 --> 00:47:06.719
I wanted to read some
00:47:06.880 --> 00:47:07.360
quotations.
00:47:07.679 --> 00:47:23.679
Okay, so um as I said, in the Middle Ages, uh Abraham and Isaac are the great trope, not Abraham by himself, but always Abraham with Isaac slaying his son, because that's understood typologically within the story.
00:47:24.000 --> 00:47:30.559
And then uh at the Reformation, uh this is focused on as faith against works.
00:47:31.440 --> 00:47:50.079
And then later on in the 19th century, Kierkegaard, the uh the Danish philosopher Kierkegaard understands this story as like faith versus reason, uh, belief versus philosophy.
00:47:50.239 --> 00:48:07.519
And I wanted to read a three little sentences from Kierkegaard, uh Kierkegaard's book, uh Fear and Trembling and the Sickness Unto Death, which is a long interpretation of the um of Genesis 22, the Akita story.
00:48:07.760 --> 00:48:10.000
Just a few just three quotations.
00:48:10.400 --> 00:48:15.119
But when I have to think of Abraham, I
am as though annihilated.
00:48:15.360 --> 00:48:21.599
I catch sight every moment of that enormous paradox which is the substance of Abraham's life.
00:48:21.840 --> 00:48:23.519
I am paralyzed.
00:48:24.400 --> 00:48:27.519
What a tremendous paradox faith is.
00:48:27.679 --> 00:48:37.039
A paradox which is capable of transforming a murder into a holy and well-pleasing act to God.
00:48:37.280 --> 00:48:48.880
A paradox which gives Isaac back to Abraham, which no thought can master, because faith begins precisely here where thinking leads off.
00:48:50.480 --> 00:49:07.519
For faith is this paradox that the particular is higher than the universal, yet in such a way that the movement repeats itself, and that consequently the individual now, as a particular, isolates as higher than the universal.
00:49:07.920 --> 00:49:13.199
Faith is the paradox that the individual is higher than the universal.
00:49:13.920 --> 00:49:30.639
So uh the idea here is that instead of universal general laws like thou shalt not kill, you have this paradox that God orders him to kill, and it becomes an act well-pleasing to God, because God ordered it.
00:49:30.800 --> 00:49:37.920
So this individual command of God totally overrules the general natural law principle that it's wrong to kill yourself.
00:49:38.159 --> 00:49:38.239
Well,
00:49:38.320 --> 00:49:38.719
it's interesting.
00:49:38.800 --> 00:49:44.960
Uh, I mean, something stood out for me, uh, Francesca, when you were reading that about uh I think I think the way uh the way he puts it there.
00:49:45.119 --> 00:49:53.679
I mean, and then of course it is important to keep in mind that in fear and trembling, uh, as as in many of Kierkegaard's other works, he's not writing in his own voice but in a in a pseudonym.
00:49:53.760 --> 00:50:02.800
But but Kierkegaard, I suppose we can say something about um uh about faith beginning where thinking leads off uh where uh where thinking ends.
00:50:03.280 --> 00:50:04.559
Faith leads off.
00:50:04.639 --> 00:50:04.719
Yes.
00:50:06.480 --> 00:50:20.079
It's striking for me in light of I mean, this whole podcast uh minding scripture is is devoted to the idea that uh faith and thinking are uh are not um are not incompatible, but uh but that faith demands thinking.
00:50:20.159 --> 00:50:23.360
And so it's interesting to see that uh that striking formulation.
00:50:23.519 --> 00:50:33.280
Of course, there is this paradox uh that uh he's discussing this movement of faith and analyzing it, that is to say, analyzing it with thinking, um, even as he's describing it before.
00:50:34.000 --> 00:50:34.320
I mean, I
00:50:34.320 --> 00:50:43.039
guess the this particular pseudonym that he uh that uh that Kierkegaard uses in inferior and trembling is uh Johannes de Siletia or Johannes of the Silence.
00:50:43.199 --> 00:50:51.599
Uh and so I wonder right w uh whether um uh uh yeah that that uh is he's he's silent but extremely right valuable.
00:50:51.760 --> 00:51:05.360
Uh and uh
right there is that uh silence in encountering the faith of Abraham, I suppose, in Kierkegaard's taking, but on the other hand, there is this uh the the the entire effort is to uh kind of so some uh uh explain it uh in one way or another.
00:51:05.519 --> 00:51:06.079
But it is a
00:51:06.639 --> 00:51:22.000
now we have we have this variation in the Quranic version where the son, and maybe you you want to comment on this Munim, but by the majority of Muslim thinkers, especially in later centuries, think the son is Ishmael, not Isaac.
00:51:22.800 --> 00:51:25.119
But the son um joins in.
00:51:25.360 --> 00:51:27.840
He is a willing party to the sacrifice.
00:51:28.079 --> 00:51:30.639
He says, Oh my father, do as you are commanded.
00:51:31.440 --> 00:51:42.800
And there's even a passage that I didn't read a bit further on where um uh uh Abraham l lays a son down um on his forehead,
00:51:42.960 --> 00:51:43.280
yeah.
00:51:43.519 --> 00:51:48.239
Which is to some is interpreted as the son was almost in prostration before God.
00:51:48.800 --> 00:51:53.199
Um does that uh reduce the moral complexity, would you say, Munim?
00:51:53.280 --> 00:51:54.320
Or do you have other thoughts about that?
00:51:54.639 --> 00:52:06.960
Well well, that's that's really reflect, you know, that both Abraham and his sacrifice son, either Isaac or Ismail, because uh Muslim uh uh uh disagree on this on this matter.
00:52:07.519 --> 00:52:29.440
But that's reflect that both the father and the son can be seen as a model of or perhaps paradigmatic acts of obedience because this is the example of how you know um the the sacrificed son is willing to be sacrificed.
00:52:30.079 --> 00:52:44.320
So what is interesting, I guess, is is that this this uh speaking about paradox, that this story is does not cause some fear, but it uh is deepened and celebrated in the Islamic tradition.
00:52:44.719 --> 00:52:45.599
Of course it's connected to the
00:52:47.599 --> 00:52:52.880
connected to one of the two um to the the festival of holidays in Islam.
00:52:52.960 --> 00:53:12.719
And even this this this story about sacrifice can be seen as uh as uh celebrated in the in the pilgrimage, right, which is an the enactment of the life of the family of Abraham, both you know, Abraham, um his uh his wife as well as his son.
00:53:12.960 --> 00:53:22.400
So I I found this quite interesting how uh you know the son is willing to be sacrificed as as a sign of obedience to God.
00:53:22.880 --> 00:53:23.519
But that's interesting.
00:53:23.760 --> 00:53:39.679
So you wouldn't say, Mun'im then, that there is a a sort of um struggling with the uh with the fact that this is a father called upon to uh kill his son, that that um I mean I wonder, I think about the kind of the Jewish tradition.
00:53:39.760 --> 00:53:52.559
And I would I I would agree that kind of in the Jewish tradition, uh there is uh uh ultimately the or the the or the key, I guess, tenor of the Jewish reading is of celebration of Abraham's willingness.
00:53:52.719 --> 00:54:22.000
Um but uh and this comes up uh there isn't a a specific uh holiday kind of devoted to celebrating it, uh, but it does, but it is a major motif in the in the in the Jewish New Year, Rosh Hashanah, um the day of judgment, uh where um the the ram that uh um Abraham is ultimately called upon to sacrifice in lieu of Isaac um becomes uh understood to be kind of the symbolic source for the blowing of the ram's horn on the on the new year.
00:54:22.079 --> 00:54:41.199
Uh and when the ram's horn is blown on this day of judgment, it's understood then in the Jewish tradition to be um um the way of call invoking Abraham's merit so that God will uh God will um um uh judge Israel favorably um uh on this day of judgment.
00:54:41.280 --> 00:55:00.960
Um but there is a so on on the whole then it's it's there's this celebration of his willingness, but it is interesting that in the kind of in the in the details of how it's invoked, uh there is a certain acknowledgement of the struggle or the uh that that Kierkegaard, I guess, expresses in a in this modern kind of um uh um paradoxical sense.
00:55:01.119 --> 00:55:07.119
Um in the in uh the the liturgy kind of speaks of Abraham suppressing his mercy.
00:55:07.360 --> 00:55:08.880
Um so and where
00:55:09.039 --> 00:55:09.119
uh
00:55:09.199 --> 00:55:21.519
and Israel kind of calls upon God in prayer, just as Abraham um suppressed his mercy, so you God should suppress your anger uh and judge Israel uh charitably uh on the new year.
00:55:21.679 --> 00:55:29.280
Uh but there is this kind of acknowledgement there that this act of sacrifice involves the suppression of mercy, uh the suppression of love.
00:55:29.360 --> 00:55:29.920
Uh that all
00:55:30.639 --> 00:55:33.679
I remember uh I think it's Rashi.
00:55:34.960 --> 00:55:40.000
Um there's a question, why does God tell him so slowly?
00:55:40.880 --> 00:55:45.039
And Rashi says so that he wouldn't get too upset all of a sudden.
00:55:45.199 --> 00:55:51.280
If he if he if he told him a little bit at a time, he wouldn't get too upset about the Quran.
00:55:51.519 --> 00:55:51.920
Do you agree?
00:55:52.239 --> 00:55:52.480
Right, right,
00:55:52.559 --> 00:55:52.719
right.
00:55:52.800 --> 00:55:52.960
Yes.
00:55:53.039 --> 00:56:05.679
In the very beginning of Genesis 22, he says, right, uh take it uh take your son, uh your uh your your single son, um uh um whom uh whom you love, Isaac.
00:56:05.760 --> 00:56:16.400
Uh and so right, and so the the the this is Rashi is relying on rabbinic earlier rabbinic commentaries, but right, they say uh God says, Take your son, and Abraham says, but I have two sons.
00:56:16.480 --> 00:56:25.039
Uh and then God says, Well, take your single son, and Abraham says, Well, I have two wives, and each of them has one son, uh, and then whom you and whom you love.
00:56:25.199 --> 00:56:28.719
And so God says, the one whom you love, and Abraham says, Well, I love both.
00:56:28.960 --> 00:56:37.039
Uh and it's so so right, so so the rabbinic commentary here is playing of reluctance, it's thematizing this uh this reluctance of Abraham's part.
00:56:37.360 --> 00:56:58.639
On the other hand, on the other hand, interestingly, you have at the at the end of the story, the rabbinic commentary then thematizes Abraham's willingness to sacrifice, having committed to sacrifice, then because it says, um um uh it says um God tells him at the end, um, don't send forth your hand against the boy.
00:56:58.800 --> 00:57:03.760
Um and and so the rabb the rabbinic commentators ask, well, what do you mean don't send forth your hand?
00:57:03.920 --> 00:57:05.920
What about the s why the hand?
00:57:06.000 --> 00:57:07.039
It's supposed to be the sword.
00:57:07.119 --> 00:57:09.599
He has a he's holding a uh a knife.
00:57:09.760 --> 00:57:12.239
Uh a knife, not a sword, but he's holding a knife.
00:57:12.480 --> 00:57:22.400
Uh and so uh the rabbis say, right, that the uh uh that the um that the the knife had dissolved on account of angel's tears, uh right, a whole melodramatic scene.
00:57:22.559 --> 00:57:30.880
But then Abraham, kind of having committed uh to sacrificing uh sacrificing Isaac, is now attempting to uh kill him by by means of his hands.
00:57:31.039 --> 00:57:43.760
So there's a playing out there at the end, uh at the beginning then of the story, there's this playing out of Abraham's reluctance and highlighting of uh of the way in which this is unnatural, as it were, uh and then but also a playing out of his uh of his commitment.
00:57:43.840 --> 00:57:44.000
Uh
00:57:44.639 --> 00:57:58.000
and I I think the instincts of the Quran, if I can put it that way, to involve um the son in the whole or ordeal are anticipated in some writings, some Jewish writings.
00:57:58.159 --> 00:58:08.719
Um doesn't Josephus Josephus actually has Isaac, I think, build the altar himself and maybe has him as not a child, but an adolescent or even older.
00:58:09.199 --> 00:58:09.840
Yeah, sure, sure,
00:58:09.920 --> 00:58:10.000
sure.
00:58:10.079 --> 00:58:10.159
Yeah.
00:58:10.400 --> 00:58:21.280
There is right in in the Jewish tradition, beginning right, in the Second Temple period, uh, with Josephus among others, and then into rabbinic literature, um, a much, a much greater uh interest in Isaac.
00:58:21.440 --> 00:58:30.400
Isaac is definitely a um um a a secondary character in the in the biblical story, and um the real protagonist is Abraham.
00:58:30.480 --> 00:58:43.840
Uh, and then there certainly is this tendency to uh to insist upon the willingness of Isaac um in the rabbinic tradition to reflect upon his age, that maybe he is in fact uh um closer to 40 years old um than to
00:58:46.880 --> 00:59:03.519
Well, we um are getting um short on time, but there's one topic we should address briefly, which is the question of whether it is coherent, as is all the rage these days, to think of Judaism, Christianity, and Islam as Abrahamic religions.
00:59:03.679 --> 00:59:07.280
Maybe we'll have another minuscripture episode just on that topic.
00:59:07.440 --> 00:59:10.960
But um there have been some criticisms of this phenomenon.
00:59:11.039 --> 00:59:15.119
I'm alluded in the intro to books by John Levinson and Aaron Hughes.
00:59:15.440 --> 00:59:19.360
Um could we uh take a quick survey of the three of you?
00:59:19.599 --> 00:59:21.840
What do you think of this term Abrahamic religions?
00:59:22.079 --> 00:59:22.639
Is it cool?
00:59:24.239 --> 00:59:29.760
I I think as as uh as an analytical category, the the the term is certainly problematic.
00:59:30.400 --> 00:59:34.559
But on a practical level, it is still useful, although limited, I guess.
00:59:34.719 --> 00:59:50.639
I mean um it is problematic because uh certainly, you know, it's it seems to uh oversimplifies the the fact that that each religious tradition, you know, has distinct uh description about Abraham.
00:59:51.440 --> 00:59:54.000
Uh but any category is is ambiguous, right?
00:59:54.159 --> 01:00:07.760
Even the term Muslim, Christians or Jews are ambiguous, who are Muslim, who are Jews, and there is no such thing as as one um you know monolithic uh description about who are Muslim.
01:00:08.639 --> 01:00:11.039
Who invented the term Abrahamic religion?
01:00:11.920 --> 01:00:21.280
I've seen it traced back to the book of Louis Massignon, the Catholic scholar who wro wrote a book called Les Trois Prières d'Abraham, the three prayers of Abraham.
01:00:21.440 --> 01:00:22.639
That that was the beginning?
01:00:23.039 --> 01:00:25.360
That was in the mid-20th century before Vatican II.
01:00:25.760 --> 01:00:27.840
Yeah, I know I know Louis Massignon.
01:00:27.920 --> 01:00:28.079
Yeah.
01:00:28.239 --> 01:00:29.599
I didn't know it was him.
01:00:30.719 --> 01:00:32.079
Any other thoughts for you about the term?
01:00:32.480 --> 01:01:06.559
I mean, uh yeah, I I think I I think I'd uh pretty much agree with Munun that that of course the term is is is reductive and uh you know this in scholars uh um uh can and and do and do a service, I think, in uh kind of highlighting uh the the the the differences that it that it um that if that sort of term occludes and um and but but yeah what one could right uh one could scholars do um offer the same criticism of other um kind of bridging categories.
01:01:06.719 --> 01:01:34.719
Um the Judeo-Christian tradition is another one uh that has come under uh I think a lot of criticism recently, uh for um uh um yeah, for for the way in which uh you know it may present a uh well for the for the way in which it's it's exclusive of others, uh for the way in which um it uh presents Judaism essentially in Christian terms, uh at least in the certain ways in which it's used.
01:01:34.880 --> 01:01:40.800
Um and then the term, as Munim said, the term Muslim itself or the term Judaism itself is to some extent a construct.
01:01:41.039 --> 01:01:47.199
So yeah, the the terms, the categories that we use are all uh constructs to a certain extent.
01:01:47.440 --> 01:02:02.800
Um, you know, to the extent that they track um the experience and the and the usages of the communities themselves, um, they have something more to stand on, as it were, historically, and then to the extent that they don't, they have less.
01:02:02.960 --> 01:02:23.360
Um, but I think as long as it's uh understood that we are that this is a constructive act of uh finding points of commonality uh rather than a um uh a way of uh excluding others or a way of uh um uh of uh ignoring differences.
01:02:23.519 --> 01:02:32.480
Um I think as long as we approach the term in uh in an informed and self-conscious way, I I have no problem with the diet.
01:02:32.639 --> 01:02:34.639
I think it can serve a very valuable function.
01:02:37.199 --> 01:02:40.000
Francesca, any final thoughts about that?
01:02:41.280 --> 01:02:41.599
Okay.
01:02:42.559 --> 01:02:45.039
All right, well, I think that brings us to the end.
01:02:45.280 --> 01:02:46.079
Thank you so much.
01:02:46.239 --> 01:02:54.480
I think this is a topic that we'll be obliged to return to as we continue on mining scripture to engage with Judaism, Christianity, and Islam.
01:02:54.639 --> 01:03:00.079
Be sure to join us for the next episode of Mining Scripture, where Divine Word and Human Reason Meet.