TRANSCRIPTION 🔗
1
00:00:00,001 --> 00:00:12,720
[Music]
2
00:00:12,720 --> 00:00:20,160
Hello and welcome to Talk 200, a lecture and podcast series to celebrate The University
of Manchester's Bicentenary Year.
3
00:00:20,160 --> 00:00:26,160
Our 200th anniversary is a time to celebrate 200 years of learning, innovation and
research.
4
00:00:26,160 --> 00:00:32,080
200 years of our incredible people and community. 200 years of global influence.
5
00:00:32,080 --> 00:00:36,240
In this series, we'll be hearing from some of the nation's foremost scientists,
6
00:00:36,240 --> 00:00:41,920
thinkers and social commentators, plus many other voices from across our university
community
7
00:00:41,920 --> 00:00:45,200
as we explore the big topics affecting us all.
8
00:00:45,200 --> 00:00:49,920
In this episode, Nazia Afzal, Chancellor of The University of Manchester and
9
00:00:49,920 --> 00:00:56,800
former Chief Crown prosecutor for Northwest England, discusses inequalities in access
to justice
10
00:00:56,800 --> 00:01:00,160
and the steps towards fairer treatment in the legal system.
11
00:01:00,160 --> 00:01:07,280
Discover the limits to equality within our legal system and how, in the face of recent
scandals in the UK and overseas,
12
00:01:07,280 --> 00:01:10,160
we can widen access to justice.
297
00:24:14,800 --> 00:24:31,040
Okay, thanks, Nazir. Can I now invite our panellists to come to the stage please and you
can take a seat
298
00:24:31,040 --> 00:24:41,920
after telling us all about the things that we need to change in our justice system.
299
00:24:41,920 --> 00:24:55,440
Okay, so I just want to reflect a bit on what you've just said. There's a lot to take in
actually
300
00:24:57,440 --> 00:25:07,200
especially the list of things that we need to change and in fact 1989 when you were first
301
00:25:07,200 --> 00:25:18,160
practicing I was studying for my A-level law in the late 1980s and I was just thinking
about
302
00:25:18,160 --> 00:25:25,440
the fact that a lot of what I was being taught and the essays we had to write in our A-
level
303
00:25:25,440 --> 00:25:36,080
law exam I was listening to you talking about the same thing and in fact I think we're
going
304
00:25:36,080 --> 00:25:43,920
backwards so I think it's worse than it was in the late 1980s. I think in the early 2000s
there
305
00:25:43,920 --> 00:25:51,200
were money going into the system so much of our improvements happened between
about 2004 and
306
00:25:51,200 --> 00:25:56,240
2008 or something and then of course financial crash happened but you can't do this on
the cheap.
307
00:25:56,240 --> 00:26:04,880
Absolutely and in fact it was that it was during that time that I got involved in
308
00:26:04,880 --> 00:26:10,080
that sort of issues of access to justice needs what's driven sort of me professionally and
309
00:26:10,080 --> 00:26:16,400
and personally throughout my career and I suppose that you know it's the sad thing that
we're
310
00:26:16,400 --> 00:26:24,960
here today listening to you talking about many of the issues which were prevalent in the
late 1980s
311
00:26:24,960 --> 00:26:29,680
and I also so I was listening to some of the things you were saying about
312
00:26:29,680 --> 00:26:37,680
at racism, and the work that Professor Quinn has done in SALC, and myself and
313
00:26:38,800 --> 00:26:48,960
Keir Monteith from Garden Court, on racism in the judiciary and the other work that I
know that
314
00:26:48,960 --> 00:26:56,480
Professor Quinn has done on Art Not Evidence and rap and drill music being used to
convict
315
00:26:56,480 --> 00:27:04,240
minority communities so lots of things that sort of I was thinking about when you were
talking that
316
00:27:05,680 --> 00:27:14,240
that we are doing here. And the final thing that I was sort of thinking about before we
317
00:27:14,240 --> 00:27:23,120
go on to talk to the panel ask the questions is I was reading Andy Burnham's and Steve
Rotheram’s
318
00:27:23,120 --> 00:27:35,360
book recently and they were talking about the fact that we need to rewire the UK and
319
00:27:35,360 --> 00:27:41,520
underlying that is the rewiring of the legal system and that's another thing I think which
320
00:27:41,520 --> 00:27:48,800
sort of springs to mind just in that title alone so when I was reading that book I was
321
00:27:48,800 --> 00:27:56,080
very much thinking about this evening and it certainly sort of makes me think well how
can we do this
322
00:27:56,080 --> 00:28:05,280
and I suppose these are some of the questions that I'm going to sort of ask the panel
this evening
323
00:28:05,280 --> 00:28:15,280
So, so over to you first, Tom, and you’re a postmaster who's been exonerated, you've
had your
324
00:28:15,280 --> 00:28:25,360
conviction overturned and can you tell us about the day that you were wrongfully
convicted,
325
00:28:25,360 --> 00:28:33,040
and why on that day you pleaded guilty to something which you knew that you hadn't
done
326
00:28:33,040 --> 00:28:38,800
Well, thank you Claire and good evening to everybody here and those watching at home.
327
00:28:43,520 --> 00:28:50,240
It's obviously etched on my memory my, my appearance at Lincoln Crown Court which
is
328
00:28:50,240 --> 00:29:01,120
incidentally is 48 miles from my home prior to obviously going into court I'd been at
magistrate's
329
00:29:01,120 --> 00:29:12,240
court but the case was too serious for them to to look at and I did get legal aid and I did
330
00:29:12,240 --> 00:29:23,600
get a lawyer but even 15 years ago legal aid was not exactly a lot of money and it's been
eroded
331
00:29:23,600 --> 00:29:32,720
ever since and like all things in life you get what you pay for there were only two firms
332
00:29:32,720 --> 00:29:43,440
locally that did legal aid so I one of the firms there was a guy I knew work there as a
333
00:29:43,440 --> 00:29:49,120
solicitor I knew him very well because he'd lived in the village where my shop was
Load full transcript
and
Post Office
334
00:29:49,120 --> 00:29:59,680
when he moved out, he did a flit owing me 30-odd pounds with an outstanding bill that
he'd
335
00:29:59,680 --> 00:30:05,200
ran up in the shop never did pay it so I didn't want to go to him so I approached the other
firm
336
00:30:05,200 --> 00:30:12,880
and they didn't have any capacity so I ended up with the rogue and I think it sums it up
337
00:30:12,880 --> 00:30:18,800
that I ended up with a rogue lawyer and he certainly was a rogue because he owed me
money
338
00:30:18,800 --> 00:30:24,320
and he wouldn't of course he totally forgotten that by the time I had my dealings with
him
339
00:30:24,320 --> 00:30:31,120
but we discussed the case and you got to remember that on the day of my audit when
this nightmare
340
00:30:31,120 --> 00:30:43,920
Happened, within 10 minutes of them finding the shortfall, the money they claimed I
owed to them,
341
00:30:43,920 --> 00:30:52,800
they changed the alarm codes, they changed the logins on the computer, they took the
keys to the
342
00:30:52,800 --> 00:31:02,800
Safe, to the fortress area, away from me, and from that point in I had nothing I had no
means of
343
00:31:02,800 --> 00:31:07,840
getting any information because everything existed within that Horizon system
344
00:31:07,840 --> 00:31:17,120
so bearing that in mind when you go and I did go and see this lawyer and we we
discussed the case
345
00:31:17,920 --> 00:31:23,120
and I said look I didn't take this money I'm actually certain it's the Horizon system I
346
00:31:23,120 --> 00:31:30,080
complained on hundreds of occasions to anybody within the Post Office that would
listen that that
347
00:31:30,080 --> 00:31:38,960
was the case but nevertheless they, the people at the top, believed it worked and
worked well
348
00:31:40,800 --> 00:31:50,240
and he said well look, you're on legal aid, you've no means of getting any special
349
00:31:50,240 --> 00:31:57,600
accountants in to look at the figures and all the rest of it ,he said now look
350
00:31:57,600 --> 00:32:03,440
I could tell you here now if you plead not guilty in that court,
351
00:32:05,520 --> 00:32:10,000
you've got no means of defending yourself because you can't get any information,
352
00:32:10,000 --> 00:32:22,880
and the jury will not believe that that esteemed wonderful Post Office that they all love
353
00:32:22,880 --> 00:32:29,920
and have love for years would have anything other than a bomb-proof computer system.
354
00:32:31,840 --> 00:32:40,480
And he said for the amount of money that they claim you owe the tally's 4 years in jail
355
00:32:40,480 --> 00:32:49,600
that's a very sobering thing to hear 4 years, I was 58.
356
00:32:49,600 --> 00:32:58,640
He said the only thing you can do is now damage limitation
357
00:33:00,400 --> 00:33:09,120
plead guilty, get some good references, let me do the, some pleading on your behalf
358
00:33:09,120 --> 00:33:15,600
and I'll give you 95% that you I’ll
keep you out of jail.
359
00:33:15,600 --> 00:33:18,880
What would you do?
360
00:33:18,880 --> 00:33:30,080
It's a fait accompli, it is complete damage limitation and sure enough I went in I pleaded
361
00:33:30,080 --> 00:33:36,480
guilty and then it comes to sentencing and this is where the justice system can be very
cruel.
362
00:33:36,480 --> 00:33:44,720
I'm standing in the dock and the judge says you've been a very naughty boy,
363
00:33:44,720 --> 00:33:51,280
or I'm paraphrasing obviously, and this is you know the thing against the state,
364
00:33:53,120 --> 00:34:00,560
an offense against the state so I'm going to sentence you to 7 months imprisonment.
365
00:34:00,560 --> 00:34:13,360
And I'm deliberately pausing because he deliberately paused for a good 30 seconds
before saying
366
00:34:13,360 --> 00:34:20,320
but that sentence will be suspended for 2 years and he let me squirm
367
00:34:22,400 --> 00:34:33,120
that was cruel, utterly cruel. And that's, that's the reason why I pleaded guilty because I
was backed
368
00:34:33,120 --> 00:34:42,480
into a corner it was like playing poker where I had a mirror behind my head and
everybody could
369
00:34:42,480 --> 00:34:51,040
see my cards. I had no chance and I suspect the vast majority, well I know the vast
majority of all
370
00:34:51,040 --> 00:34:59,200
the other Postmasters were backed into a very similar corner and yes the system is
broken because
371
00:34:59,200 --> 00:35:08,560
the people in power, if you like, hold all the cards and we mere minions we're just
372
00:35:08,560 --> 00:35:13,200
confetti that could be thrown into the air and hopefully the wind will blow away.
373
00:35:15,440 --> 00:35:23,120
Yeah Professor Justin Brooks a friend of mine who runs a project in the US he says it's
like
374
00:35:23,120 --> 00:35:29,680
a roulette game where the stakes are just so high it's unquantifiable stakes. I mean the
other thing
375
00:35:29,680 --> 00:35:41,760
that got me on that day, when he'd given the sentence and he said oh and we'll charge
you a thousand
376
00:35:41,760 --> 00:35:53,360
pounds costs for Post Office’s costs for bringing that and the the barrister for the Post
Office
377
00:35:53,360 --> 00:36:04,720
who was there with his second person his junior, and I had a solicitor advocate,
378
00:36:07,520 --> 00:36:16,080
they, they actually claimed for four thousand pounds but give my guy his due and it’s
about the only
379
00:36:16,080 --> 00:36:23,200
good thing he did for me, he did say that's disproportionate given that you knew my
client was going to
380
00:36:23,200 --> 00:36:30,720
plead guilty before we even came here today, and the judge did drop that down to a
thousand
381
00:36:30,720 --> 00:36:44,880
pounds but I got, having been kicked, they then kick you again it's just yeah okay I'm
moving on to
382
00:36:44,880 --> 00:36:51,760
being kicked and kicked again the Post Office which he said they they took the keys off
you and
383
00:36:51,760 --> 00:36:58,240
so on but you still had the shop which was attached to the Post Office and after you
were convicted
384
00:36:58,240 --> 00:37:04,480
you had to deliver newspapers in your local village with your face on the front of those
newspapers
385
00:37:04,480 --> 00:37:11,040
how how did that make you feel and what was the reaction from people in the village?
Well of course
386
00:37:11,040 --> 00:37:17,440
you see the village where where our shop and home was was about a thousand people
so you knew
387
00:37:17,440 --> 00:37:26,480
everybody by sight, you knew most of them by name, and it was awful because the
following week we were
388
00:37:26,480 --> 00:37:35,040
all over the front page of the local paper, what a terrible man, I was accused of stealing
389
00:37:35,040 --> 00:37:45,680
the pensioners’ pensions, that's how the local paper put it, and to have my name and all
this all over
390
00:37:45,680 --> 00:37:51,680
the front page of the local paper and then to have to go and put that through people's
letterboxes,
391
00:37:52,400 --> 00:37:57,040
oh it's so humiliating. I mean half the village wouldn't couldn't believe it
392
00:37:57,040 --> 00:38:02,880
and were very supportive but the other half thought I was an utter rogue and you say we
had a shop,
393
00:38:02,880 --> 00:38:10,880
within 4 months of my conviction we had to shut the shop because all the footfall had
just
394
00:38:10,880 --> 00:38:21,200
dropped away it was unprofitable. And we were in sort of dire straits, maxed out every
credit card we had,
395
00:38:22,080 --> 00:38:31,280
we were literally living hands a mouth. It was, it was really bad. So my final question to
to you
396
00:38:31,280 --> 00:38:37,120
Tom is that perhaps some of us have seen the iconic picture of you outside the court
and you've
397
00:38:37,120 --> 00:38:42,960
got a bottle of fizzi n your hand and other sub-Postmasters around you, what did you
feel like the
398
00:38:42,960 --> 00:38:52,560
the day that you had your conviction overturned? Well I have to give a great big thanks to
the
399
00:38:52,560 --> 00:39:01,440
CCRC, who gave me a great deal of help to get that my case along with the other 39
people on the day
400
00:39:01,440 --> 00:39:09,520
and we ended up in the course of appeal down in London on the Strand there, and I
knew,
401
00:39:11,040 --> 00:39:20,640
we'd been told that it was going our way ,and the couple of days before I've been seen
my mother
402
00:39:20,640 --> 00:39:27,360
who was about 92 at the time, sadly she's passed away now but that's by the by,
403
00:39:27,360 --> 00:39:33,760
and she asked me to go and do a bit of shopping for her and she said I want you to go to
Aldi
404
00:39:33,760 --> 00:39:39,360
and here’s the shopping list, now I understand you're going to London and you're having
your
405
00:39:39,360 --> 00:39:43,840
conviction overturned next week and I said yeah that's right, she said right
406
00:39:43,840 --> 00:39:50,160
well while you're getting my shopping with my bank card she said,
407
00:39:50,160 --> 00:39:56,720
buy a bottle of Prosecco, they do a good one for $4.99.
408
00:39:56,720 --> 00:40:05,600
And she said just remember, now I want you to open that when you come out of court,
409
00:40:06,400 --> 00:40:14,320
she said just remember the name is Hedge’s, not Rothschild’s don't get their
champagne that's $9.99!
410
00:40:14,320 --> 00:40:21,760
And that's, but I mean it was a wonderful it was a wonderful day to sit there in court,
411
00:40:21,760 --> 00:40:27,360
if you watch the drama I was sitting next to Noel Thomas
412
00:40:27,360 --> 00:40:36,320
when the lead judge there started reading out the names of all the people that have
been acquitted
413
00:40:36,800 --> 00:40:47,520
and it was just wonderful, it it's up there with the day I got married I was so happy at
that,
414
00:40:47,520 --> 00:40:53,520
and the day both my children were born and I was given those little bundles of joy,
415
00:40:53,520 --> 00:41:02,160
it's up there with that that's how wonderful it was, and I was so pleased for the other 7 or
416
00:41:02,160 --> 00:41:11,680
800 people that had their convictions quashed just a fortnight ago in the last session of
Parliament
417
00:41:11,680 --> 00:41:21,680
when that headlining bill to get them all cleared out went through, but it'll never, for
them it's
418
00:41:21,680 --> 00:41:27,200
great they're going to piece paper through the post telling them that's the case but it's
not
419
00:41:27,200 --> 00:41:33,360
quite the same as being there and having the judge because it's, it, courtrooms
420
00:41:33,360 --> 00:41:40,640
are intimidating places and they're grand places and certainly those the High Courts
421
00:41:40,640 --> 00:41:48,080
of Justice in London, a fabulous building, if you've ever been there for the right reasons
422
00:41:48,080 --> 00:41:54,160
they're horrible, wouldn't go for the wrong reasons, but no, it was absolutely brilliant.
423
00:41:56,000 --> 00:42:02,160
Okay, thanks, thanks Tom, okay so over to you Suzanne for some, some questions
424
00:42:02,160 --> 00:42:11,520
before you you started your PhD, and full disclosure she's disclosure, Suzanne is my
PhD student and
425
00:42:11,520 --> 00:42:18,720
now also a colleague because she's a lecturer with us as well, and before that you had a
very
426
00:42:18,720 --> 00:42:25,120
successful career as a solicitor, you were managing director of appeal, and I don't know
if anyone saw
427
00:42:25,120 --> 00:42:31,920
the documentary last night on Andy Malkinson's conviction being overturned but that's
the charity
428
00:42:31,920 --> 00:42:40,160
that Suzanne headed up and you also worked on the Hillsborough inquiry, and going
back to what I
429
00:42:40,160 --> 00:42:48,560
said about Andy Burnham and Steve Rotherham's book when they spoke about rewiring
the UK legal
430
00:42:48,560 --> 00:42:54,560
system they also talked in in that book about a duty of candour because they talk a lot
about
431
00:42:54,560 --> 00:42:59,760
Hillsborough, and a duty to put parties, and this is something that you talked about as
well Nazir,
432
00:42:59,760 --> 00:43:07,440
as they are, on an equal footing to fund access to justice because that that is very
problematic
433
00:43:07,440 --> 00:43:11,440
and I suppose this this goes back to what you were talking about as well Tom in terms of
434
00:43:12,240 --> 00:43:20,400
that disparity and being able to defend yourself. So they talked about that parity of
funding
435
00:43:20,400 --> 00:43:26,080
and another example would be an inquest where there is that parity between the public
body
436
00:43:26,080 --> 00:43:33,280
and the families involved so how far do you think so this is my first question how far do
you think
437
00:43:33,280 --> 00:43:39,840
we are off from from coming to the stage where we will have a Hillsborough law duty of
candour
438
00:43:39,840 --> 00:43:49,360
and parity of funding and do you think that it was a critical factor in the families not
getting
439
00:43:49,360 --> 00:43:56,160
justice earlier in the original inquest when we were talking about well not just
Hillsborough
440
00:43:56,160 --> 00:44:00,160
I suppose we're talking about all the things that you mentioned tonight the
441
00:44:00,160 --> 00:44:06,320
infected blood scandal, Grenfell which we'll talk about later, and so on so that's my first
question.
442
00:44:06,320 --> 00:44:12,480
Yeah absolutely I mean firstly I think it sounds quite ridiculous to people to suggest that
we need
443
00:44:12,480 --> 00:44:17,360
a law to tell people to tell the truth, aren't we all taught that by our parents when we're
very
444
00:44:17,360 --> 00:44:26,480
very young? But we all break it. Yeah but. Have you eaten that sweet? No. But but most
of us most of us
445
00:44:26,480 --> 00:44:31,520
move on from that and I think that a lot of people were reluctant to the idea that there
should
446
00:44:31,520 --> 00:44:35,600
have to be a lawful duty saying to people you know what you you have to tell the truth
here,
447
00:44:35,600 --> 00:44:39,040
you've got to come clean you've got to put your hands up you got to say yes I did eat the
sweet
448
00:44:39,040 --> 00:44:46,240
Essentially, but when you look at the the scandals that we've spoken about here, the
common theme in
449
00:44:46,240 --> 00:44:53,360
Hillsborough, in Grenfell in the Post Office cases in all of that, it is the fact that the
institutions
450
00:44:53,360 --> 00:45:00,400
who had actively harmed people who were involved in causing harm hid hid the
evidence of that
451
00:45:01,840 --> 00:45:08,320
they hold all the cards in the sense of disclosing the information whether it's
Hillsborough, the police
452
00:45:08,320 --> 00:45:15,280
taking the statements at the time and choosing to alter the statement, that the police
officers on
453
00:45:15,280 --> 00:45:19,840
the scene at Hillsborough were told don't write everything down in your police officer’s
notebook
454
00:45:19,840 --> 00:45:25,280
as you have done from the moment you began your job, no no no write your notes
separately,
455
00:45:25,280 --> 00:45:30,880
we will then have a team go through them and tell you which bits of that should make
their way
456
00:45:30,880 --> 00:45:35,600
into your statement, so the bits where the fans will behave in badly yeah you need to
write that in
457
00:45:35,600 --> 00:45:39,760
anything where the police might have been seen to do anything wrong, no that's not to
go in your
458
00:45:39,760 --> 00:45:49,920
statement. And so the the by holding the cards, by controlling the information, they get
to set the
459
00:45:49,920 --> 00:45:57,360
course of the narrative of what goes on and if we focus on the original inquest that took
place
460
00:45:58,000 --> 00:46:05,840
in 1990-1991 just after the disaster, the truth about the reason that those people died on
that day
461
00:46:05,840 --> 00:46:12,400
was known because the the Lord Taylor's report at the time had uncovered so much of
the truth about
462
00:46:12,400 --> 00:46:18,000
the mistakes that were made that, the actions that took place and you know opening
the gate,
463
00:46:18,000 --> 00:46:24,080
all the structural issues that that caused the disaster but that didn't come out in
464
00:46:24,080 --> 00:46:30,160
the inquest and and the two key reasons for that are the fact that the families were not
told the truth
465
00:46:30,160 --> 00:46:36,480
because the information was withheld from them, and secondly because there was no
equality of arms
466
00:46:36,480 --> 00:46:42,320
and the families were not represented so as as Tom said it that how he felt in court,
when the
467
00:46:42,320 --> 00:46:48,960
the Post Office, unlimited funds for legal representation, the same for the police, the
same for all these
468
00:46:48,960 --> 00:46:54,800
other organisations we've spoken about, but in the original Hillsborough inquest the
families didn't
469
00:46:54,800 --> 00:47:01,200
have legal aid for representation at all, a few of the families could contribute a small
amount of
470
00:47:01,200 --> 00:47:08,320
money to pay for a barrister who did some work, but the vast majority of them they
471
00:47:08,320 --> 00:47:13,600
they were working-class families by and large they didn't have money to pay for lawyers
and that
472
00:47:13,600 --> 00:47:19,280
meant that they had to represent themselves and they did an incredible job you know,
people
473
00:47:19,280 --> 00:47:24,240
who'd never set forth in a courtroom of any kind having to suddenly represent their their
474
00:47:24,240 --> 00:47:29,360
children, their brothers, their mothers, their fathers and try and stand up for their
interests
475
00:47:29,360 --> 00:47:35,360
in an inquest which was far more adversarial than it should have been but the fact
that
they
476
00:47:35,360 --> 00:47:39,680
weren't represented meant that they didn't know what questions to ask and they didn't
stand a
477
00:47:39,680 --> 00:47:45,280
hope in hell of getting to the truth of why the people had died that day and that was
clearly
478
00:47:45,280 --> 00:47:52,160
one of the factors that led to those inquests coming to a finding of accidental death and
479
00:47:52,160 --> 00:47:59,520
the Hillsborough disaster was no accident and so the families could not accept that and
it took
480
00:47:59,520 --> 00:48:06,400
27 years of fighting for them to get justice and to get those inquest verdicts overturned
and to get
481
00:48:06,400 --> 00:48:11,760
the new verdicts of unlawful killing which accurately reflected what happened to the 97
people that day.
482
00:48:11,760 --> 00:48:17,840
And so the Hillsborough law which has been campaigned for by the Hillsborough
families,
483
00:48:17,840 --> 00:48:22,080
but they've also joined together with the infected blood families, Grenfell,
484
00:48:22,080 --> 00:48:30,560
so many other people are coming together to say ideally there would never be another
disaster
485
00:48:30,560 --> 00:48:35,920
in this country, no one's going to die in these circumstances, but that's not, that's not
reality,
486
00:48:36,400 --> 00:48:42,000
these things are always going to happen and so we have to have a system that can
adequately
487
00:48:42,000 --> 00:48:48,160
deal with it when it does, where we tell the truth ,where we tell people this is why your
loved one
488
00:48:48,160 --> 00:48:53,840
Died, and these these are the actions that we're going to take to stop it from happening
to people
489
00:48:53,840 --> 00:48:58,560
again in the future, because in the vast majority of these cases that's what the families
want,
490
00:48:58,560 --> 00:49:02,720
they're not out for blood, they're not out for people to lose their jobs and go to prison,
491
00:49:03,280 --> 00:49:07,440
they want the truth and they want to know it will never happen again.
492
00:49:07,440 --> 00:49:10,480
Now there are cases where people deserve to go to prison don't get me wrong,
493
00:49:10,480 --> 00:49:17,920
but by and large that the Hillsborough law the duty of candour is about taking some of
the heat
494
00:49:17,920 --> 00:49:24,400
out of that situation, making things fair, we're here to talk about equality and and that's
what
495
00:49:24,400 --> 00:49:29,440
we need in the system, we need to know that if you are the victim of something terrible
goes wrong
496
00:49:29,440 --> 00:49:33,840
to you or someone you love, that you have you have a chance of getting justice for them.
497
00:49:33,840 --> 00:49:36,080
Okay and do you think we're far off that?
498
00:49:36,080 --> 00:49:43,840
See it's a loaded question again I know, we have to be careful there's an election coming
up but
499
00:49:43,840 --> 00:49:50,640
the Labour party has promised that if they are to get in power, and
if we are to believe
the
500
00:49:50,640 --> 00:49:55,840
the electoral polls, there is a reasonable chance of that happening, they have said they
will introduce
501
00:49:56,480 --> 00:50:03,120
legislation to bring in a duty of candour. Whether the law that gets passed is one that the
family is
502
00:50:03,120 --> 00:50:07,440
happy with, you know, who knows, we know how these things these things have a
tendency to happen
503
00:50:07,440 --> 00:50:13,920
but I am reasonably hopeful that we may end up with some form of a duty of candour
504
00:50:13,920 --> 00:50:21,360
but I will hold hold my views on whether or not the law that's passed is adequate.
505
00:50:21,360 --> 00:50:28,720
You’ll believe it when you see. Yeah, good, good final point on that question Tom so my
next question
506
00:50:28,720 --> 00:50:36,160
or which we talk about a lot, so we turn into access to justice in the criminal justice
system,
507
00:50:36,160 --> 00:50:42,320
and I'm talking mainly post-conviction, now certainly Nazir talked a lot about sort of pre-
conviction,
508
00:50:42,320 --> 00:50:48,160
but I'm talking about post-conviction, and you teach miscarriages of justice here,
509
00:50:48,160 --> 00:50:56,400
and you you have worked for appeal, what do you think are the main issues ,the
problematic issues, with
510
00:50:56,400 --> 00:51:05,200
post-conviction in the criminal justice system? Okay there's really nowhere near enough
time
511
00:51:05,200 --> 00:51:10,800
for me to give my true answer on this, but the fact is when someone like Tom finds
themself in
512
00:51:10,800 --> 00:51:16,560
a situation where they've been convicted of an offense that they didn't commit, the
prospects
513
00:51:16,560 --> 00:51:23,120
of them being able to undo that harm and overturn their conviction are incredibly,
incredibly slight.
514
00:51:23,120 --> 00:51:30,160
The system as we've spoken about is so broken in terms of the pretrial situation it's
worse once
515
00:51:30,160 --> 00:51:37,200
you have been convicted, it's so much harder to get the system to acknowledge it’s
errors and to
516
00:51:37,200 --> 00:51:45,040
reverse it and to reverse it. When it works well, as Tom's found, the Criminal Cases
Review
517
00:51:45,040 --> 00:51:51,040
Commission is the body, the independent body, that was set up after the Birmingham
six cases and the
518
00:51:51,040 --> 00:51:57,440
series of miscarriages of justice in the late 80s early 90s and their role is to investigate
519
00:51:57,440 --> 00:52:01,840
alleged miscarriages of justice and send them back to the Court of Appeal and say you
need to
520
00:52:01,840 --> 00:52:05,440
have another lot, we think that there may have been a miscarriage of justice here, we
think this
521
00:52:05,440 --> 00:52:13,760
conviction is unsafe. Less than 2% of the people who apply to them get their cases as
522
00:52:13,760 --> 00:52:21,440
Tom did, as I say when it works well it can be the difference and it can, but they are the
body who
523
00:52:21,440 --> 00:52:27,680
have had the biggest cuts to their budget within the Ministry of Justice and the Ministry
of Justice
524
00:52:27,680 --> 00:52:32,720
is the government's department who've had the biggest cuts to their budget throughout
so, when
525
00:52:32,720 --> 00:52:36,880
you look at everything else that doesn't work believe me when I tell you that the CCRC is
in
526
00:52:36,880 --> 00:52:43,200
worst state and all of them because they've had bigger cuts to their budget. So the the
527
00:52:43,200 --> 00:52:48,080
chances are, I don't know if anyone got to see there was a documentary last night on
BBC2
528
00:52:48,080 --> 00:52:53,840
about the case of Andrew Malkinson, and the charity who I used to work for, Appeal, if
you haven't
529
00:52:53,840 --> 00:52:59,760
watched it, watch it on the iPlayer, it's a really good documentary, it tells the story of a
man who
530
00:52:59,760 --> 00:53:06,080
was wrongly convicted and spent over 17 years in prison for a crime he hadn't
committed, and it
531
00:53:06,080 --> 00:53:12,480
gives some indication of how hard it is to get that conviction overturned, and the
damage that it does.
532
00:53:12,480 --> 00:53:19,840
I was so proud of Andy and that he was so open and so vulnerable with with the crew
who made
533
00:53:19,840 --> 00:53:26,480
the documentary and I think it gave it gave a really really good insight into what a
wrongful
534
00:53:26,480 --> 00:53:33,840
conviction can do to somebody. But he, he had three applications he was in prison for
17 years
535
00:53:33,840 --> 00:53:40,640
for a crime he hadn't committed, and he had three applications to the CCRC and he
kept saying I didn't
536
00:53:40,640 --> 00:53:46,320
do this, there is DNA on the victim's clothing it is not my DNA, will you please do some
tests and
537
00:53:46,320 --> 00:53:51,520
find out whose DNA it is? And they kept saying no, they kept saying it's not cost efficient,
we don't
538
00:53:51,520 --> 00:53:57,680
think this is going to work, they weren't interested, and it took, he was in prison for 17
years before
539
00:53:57,680 --> 00:54:02,880
he was released on parole, and then it took a further 3 years, it was July last year that his
540
00:54:02,880 --> 00:54:08,320
conviction was overturned because the charity Appeal, that I used to work for, managed
to get
541
00:54:08,320 --> 00:54:13,920
access just to the clothing essentially and get the testing done and they found out that it
wasn't
542
00:54:13,920 --> 00:54:21,680
his DNA, but it was the DNA that did belong to somebody who was on the police
national database.
543
00:54:21,680 --> 00:54:28,320
That person hasn't been charged with the offense but when Andrew's case was
overturned in
544
00:54:28,320 --> 00:54:35,600
July last year, the Court of Appeal said the person whose DNA it was, fitted the
description
545
00:54:36,240 --> 00:54:42,560
better than Andrew Malkinson did, lived
in the area, didn't have an alibi for the lighting
question
546
00:54:42,560 --> 00:54:47,840
and had relevant previous convictions. That wasn't the person that the police sought to
prosecute for
547
00:54:47,840 --> 00:54:55,760
the crime, it was an entirely innocent man. So it shouldn't have taken a very small
charity
548
00:54:55,760 --> 00:55:02,480
having to intervene in that case, and it took it took 4 or 5 years from the moment
549
00:55:03,040 --> 00:55:09,840
Andrew first approached Appeal to get that conviction overturned when it was so so
obvious
550
00:55:09,840 --> 00:55:13,520
to anyone who looked at it that that was an innocent man sitting rotting in a prison cell
551
00:55:13,520 --> 00:55:20,320
and I think that case gives it a really good idea of quite how hard it is. We've spoken
about
552
00:55:20,320 --> 00:55:27,200
Funding, about the fact that legal aid is really really hard to get before you're convicted,
once
553
00:55:27,200 --> 00:55:32,240
you have been convicted, the circumstances in which you'll be eligible for legal aid are
even
554
00:55:32,240 --> 00:55:39,840
more limited because it's such a difficult area very few practitioners doing it
555
00:55:39,840 --> 00:55:45,360
are prepared to do that work anymore, so many have walked away from it, so you have a
situation where
556
00:55:45,360 --> 00:55:52,240
people are left in a situation where they have been wrongly convicted and they they
have nowhere
557
00:55:52,240 --> 00:55:57,360
to turn. So if there's one thing I could do about that it would be put an awful lot more
money in
558
00:55:57,360 --> 00:56:02,880
the system at every level, let's try and avoid the wrongful convictions happening but let's
accept
559
00:56:02,880 --> 00:56:06,640
that they do, there are human beings involved in the criminal justice system which
means we're
560
00:56:06,640 --> 00:56:11,120
always going to make mistakes, and let and let's get a lot better at admitting our
mistakes and
561
00:56:11,120 --> 00:56:20,160
trying to rectify them. And, and apologising. Yes. Okay so thanks Suzanne, so over to
Thalia,
562
00:56:20,960 --> 00:56:29,200
and you've also been involved in high profile cases in the UK, so the COVID inquiry being
one
563
00:56:29,200 --> 00:56:39,440
of them uh, the Grenfell inquiry, what have you identified as the major barriers to
achieving
564
00:56:39,440 --> 00:56:46,160
justice for for marginalised communities and what steps do you think need to be taken
to overcome
565
00:56:46,720 --> 00:56:53,920
these barriers? I know we sort of touched on this but... So I actually met Suzanne
566
00:56:53,920 --> 00:57:01,760
during my representation of bereaved families in Hillsborough. Yeah Suzanne was
representing
567
00:57:01,760 --> 00:57:12,080
one group of bereaved families and I was representing another, and like Suzanne I also
call for a
568
00:57:12,960 --> 00:57:24,320
legislated duty of candour, legislation that puts public authorities to account for there to
be
569
00:57:24,320 --> 00:57:36,560
disclosure in a timely manner, and also for there to be equality of arms through funding.
Tom spoke
570
00:57:36,560 --> 00:57:46,960
about the passage of time, Suzanne spoke about the 27 years, Nazir has spoken about
delays,
571
00:57:46,960 --> 00:58:00,160
justice delayed is justice denied, and a common theme in Hillsborough, Grenfell in fact
in 2017 it
572
00:58:00,160 --> 00:58:11,520
was a year after we got the conclusions in Hillsborough that put to bed the false
narrative
573
00:58:11,520 --> 00:58:19,840
that had run for over 20 years against the fans, the families and the people of Liverpool
that it
574
00:58:19,840 --> 00:58:26,480
was the fans to blame, and as one of the lawyers representing the families, not being
from England,
575
00:58:26,480 --> 00:58:34,880
I'm Jamaican, and not living in England at the time, it really struck my core that a system
could be
576
00:58:34,880 --> 00:58:46,880
so unjust that it had a city and families who lost their children, their loved ones hanging
in such
577
00:58:46,880 --> 00:58:54,160
State, living with this hanging over their heads for so long and it really really struck me I
578
00:58:54,160 --> 00:59:01,920
thought my God, having had that watershed moment that I experienced, like Tom you
know when he had
579
00:59:01,920 --> 00:59:08,400
that moment in the in the Court of Appeal, when I was with the families as Suzanne was
in Warrington
580
00:59:08,400 --> 00:59:14,720
when we got the verdicts, I remember the families jumping for joy when they got
unlawful killing but
581
00:59:14,720 --> 00:59:21,680
equally so when the question came back from the jury that the fans weren't to blame
and I thought
582
00:59:21,680 --> 00:59:32,240
England couldn't have, you know, another disaster where you have a system of of delay
and a state
583
00:59:32,240 --> 00:59:39,440
where you do not have systems in place for there to be immediate investigation that will
deliver
584
00:59:39,440 --> 00:59:47,280
answers and justice for victims and here I was in June, the 14th of June 2017, I was
actually in Jamaica,
585
00:59:48,640 --> 00:59:55,040
and I was watching on the, I think it was CNN, this fire in West London and I remember I
was
586
00:59:55,040 --> 01:00:01,760
in my aunt's house and she said you know that's, that's London and I was like oh my
goodness and I was
587
01:00:01,760 --> 01:00:09,440
on WhatsApp to my friends in England and you know we spoke about what was
happening and when I got
588
01:00:09,440 --> 01:00:16,880
back to to London a couple of weeks later I remember going down to the community to
pay my respects
589
01:00:17,680 --> 01:00:25,920
and I just could not believe that this was 2017 it felt like England was repeating 1989
590
01:00:25,920 --> 01:00:34,160
where the victims of a huge disaster in the one of the wealthiest boroughs in the world
591
01:00:34,160 --> 01:00:40,640
had to be coming
together you know ordinary citizens, just like the Hillsborough
families,
592
01:00:40,640 --> 01:00:48,000
had to be coming together campaigning for justice, you know, like the Hillsborough
family support
593
01:00:48,000 --> 01:00:54,240
group, like the Hillsborough justice campaign, Grenfell United and the other Grenfell
campaigning
594
01:00:54,240 --> 01:01:02,240
groups were born out of ordinary people seeking answers for justice and I think it's
actually
595
01:01:02,240 --> 01:01:12,880
disgraceful that we have a system which is not fit for purpose because it does not
deliver
596
01:01:12,880 --> 01:01:18,800
justice to victims in a timely manner. In the 21st century in England victims should not
be
597
01:01:18,800 --> 01:01:29,120
suffering and and having their grief and bereavement and sense of injustice
compounded by a failure
598
01:01:29,120 --> 01:01:35,600
of the state to bring accountability. This will be 7 years since the fire and we're expecting
599
01:01:35,600 --> 01:01:42,720
the report in September and we've heard that criminal proceedings will need or the
outcome
600
01:01:42,720 --> 01:01:48,240
of criminal investigations will need to await the report, and then you know further
investigations
601
01:01:48,240 --> 01:01:53,440
into that Nazir you spoke about you know the review of the F, LFB,
602
01:01:56,320 --> 01:02:05,680
when you have such a delay in bringing you know criminal investigations it will impact
on the
603
01:02:05,680 --> 01:02:14,080
sense of justice that their victims feel is delivered, it will invariably impact on the state
604
01:02:14,080 --> 01:02:22,400
of the investigation and I think that we also need to have a system that delivers criminal
605
01:02:22,400 --> 01:02:31,280
prosecutions arising from what we see mass disaster or mass feelings in a more timely
manner.
606
01:02:31,280 --> 01:02:41,200
Infected blood, how many years? So you know, coupled with Suzanne's call for
legislation that brings
607
01:02:41,200 --> 01:02:48,080
in a duty of candour, we must have a system that ensures the delivery of justice for
victims in a
608
01:02:48,080 --> 01:02:53,280
much more timely manner. Yeah, absolutely. It consumes people's lives and it's not, it’s
everyone involved
609
01:02:53,280 --> 01:03:01,840
isn't it? It makes them ill, it makes them ill. Absolutely and I met someone albeit in the
USA
610
01:03:01,840 --> 01:03:07,520
at a conference and, and, Suzanne, was there as well and he'd been in prison for 52
years and wrongly
611
01:03:07,520 --> 01:03:12,480
convicted and I couldn't take it in for a while because that's how old I am so it was my
whole
612
01:03:12,480 --> 01:03:17,280
life he went to prison when he in his 20s and he was now in his 70s and he'd been in
prison
613
01:03:17,280 --> 01:03:22,800
that whole time and he still hadn't had that apology that he was you know that he was
seeking.
614
01:03:22,800 --> 01:03:31,520
But but yeah so it's the passage of time. And also you you mentioned the apology
because you know so many
615
01:03:31,520 --> 01:03:41,600
of the Grenfell families, they wanted the apology, the acceptance of of of wrongdoing
from the
616
01:03:41,600 --> 01:03:48,000
RBKC and the TMO and it was just not forthcoming. And so my final question before we
move to
617
01:03:48,000 --> 01:03:55,040
to audience questions then so one of our research beacons at the University of
Manchester is
618
01:03:55,040 --> 01:04:01,040
is global inequalities and you've done a lot of international work as well as your your
domestic
619
01:04:01,040 --> 01:04:09,120
work, can you tell us a bit about the work you're doing in East Africa and also the work
you've done
620
01:04:09,120 --> 01:04:16,320
for Barbadian people, the Barbudan people, sorry. Yes well you don't go into Barbados in
621
01:04:16,320 --> 01:04:22,640
at some point? No when I actually did my degree so I had I did my degree at the
University of the
622
01:04:22,640 --> 01:04:27,680
West Indies and I lived in Barbados for two years so I'm a very much Caribbean person
it's er Barbudan.
623
01:04:27,680 --> 01:04:38,160
Yes the Barbudan people, yes so my involvement with Barbuda actually also came
about in 2017,
624
01:04:38,160 --> 01:04:46,480
following the passage of a hurricane Irma which devastated the island that has under
10,000 people
625
01:04:46,480 --> 01:04:56,720
and effectively there was this hurricane and at Barbuda is a part of a twin island state,
Antigua
626
01:04:56,720 --> 01:05:04,240
and Barbuda, in the eastern Caribbean, and the seat of government is based in the
capital of Antigua
627
01:05:04,240 --> 01:05:10,880
and the government evacuated the people from the island over to the mainland but this
was just
628
01:05:10,880 --> 01:05:22,240
the beginning of very sad days for Barbuda because what unfolded was a plan to
dismantle a
629
01:05:22,240 --> 01:05:32,320
state of, a system of communal land ownership, that the people of Barbuda enjoyed up
to then and to turn
630
01:05:32,320 --> 01:05:42,320
over the land on the island for, to private ownership. Now we talk about, I don't know if if
anybody here
631
01:05:42,320 --> 01:05:50,240
or there is the research centre, looks at disaster capitalism which a journalist well no
journalist,
632
01:05:50,240 --> 01:05:58,560
Naomi Klein, I think she's written pieces about this was just disaster capitalism
unfolding where
633
01:05:58,560 --> 01:06:07,920
you have a disaster, Barbuda has really really beautiful beaches you know it's just
pristine
634
01:06:07,920 --> 01:06:18,320
waters and lovely people and what the government saw was an opportunity to remove
the people from
635
01:06:18,320 --> 01:06:25,920
the island and to go into arrangements or bring to full fruition arrangements
636
01:06:27,040 --> 01:06:34,480
with private investors you know including celebrities whose name I, names I won't really
mention on the
637
01:06:34,480 -->
01:06:46,400
Stage, but surprising you know celebrity names who had invested into ventures on the
island for
638
01:06:46,400 --> 01:06:55,920
these you know developments, all-inclusive type exclusive properties that exclude the
people of
639
01:06:55,920 --> 01:07:04,720
the island from access to the land ,so that's how my involvement came about and it, it
actually
640
01:07:04,720 --> 01:07:13,200
has culminated more recently with a landmark Privy Council judgment on access to
justice
641
01:07:13,200 --> 01:07:23,760
because as a part of you know the plan to develop the island, the government
proceeded with private
642
01:07:23,760 --> 01:07:33,280
investors to to take steps to build an airport, whilst the people of the island had been
evacuated
643
01:07:33,280 --> 01:07:44,880
from the island and environmental systems were not in place. No EIA was done the, the
plans for the
644
01:07:44,880 --> 01:07:52,400
airport was being undertaken, or the airport was to be undertaken on limestone areas,
of course we
645
01:07:52,400 --> 01:08:01,440
know that's not stable and so two members, two, two Barbudans, took on the the case
and we talk about
646
01:08:01,440 --> 01:08:08,000
access to justice being access to funding you know, legally, it's a global problem,
particularly so
647
01:08:08,000 --> 01:08:15,040
in countries in the global south, you know like the Caribbean, like African countries and
so
648
01:08:16,000 --> 01:08:23,280
Garden Court, members of, of Garden Court, have been supporting a number of
Barbudans in this
649
01:08:23,280 --> 01:08:28,800
in this fight and it's become an environmental, a huge environmental challenge because
650
01:08:28,800 --> 01:08:36,800
there was you know we're... It's little David's up against the Goliath of the state and one
of the
651
01:08:36,800 --> 01:08:44,400
arguments that the government brought in opposition to the legal challenge,
environmental challenge,
652
01:08:44,400 --> 01:08:50,720
against the construction of the airway airport was oh you two Barbudans who live on
this really
653
01:08:50,720 --> 01:08:58,880
small island that are saying that you will be affected by an airport do not have standing
because
654
01:08:58,880 --> 01:09:07,120
you won't be directly affected. And really, really important Privy Council judgment
655
01:09:08,560 --> 01:09:17,600
Mussington against the government of, of Antigua if any of the students want to look at it
on
656
01:09:17,600 --> 01:09:28,320
the Privy Council website ruled that for environmental challenges ordinary citizens have
657
01:09:28,320 --> 01:09:38,480
standing and it's, it's really important because as we move forward in an age where the
climate,
658
01:09:38,960 --> 01:09:47,040
we are facing an existential crisis because of climate change, environmental activism is
now
659
01:09:47,040 --> 01:09:56,480
more important than ever, and this went across the Atlantic to East Africa because my
work there
660
01:09:56,480
--> 01:10:07,680
again you know pro bono Garden Court assistant with another NGO that's based here,
International
661
01:10:07,680 --> 01:10:15,600
Lawyers Project, that has represented Indigenous and, and minority communities, we
worked together
662
01:10:15,600 --> 01:10:25,280
in February of this year with communities in the Maasai people I don't know if people
663
01:10:25,280 --> 01:10:31,680
know of the Maasai communities in East Africa in Kenya and Tanzania we worked with
some of the
664
01:10:31,680 --> 01:10:39,600
community members in Kenya and we also did some work with the Ogiek community,
they are a hunter and
665
01:10:39,600 --> 01:10:48,560
gather group who were historically based and lived in the Mau Forest region of Kenya
and
666
01:10:48,560 --> 01:10:59,840
the issue that these communities, Indigenous community, face is that the state private
entities
667
01:10:59,840 --> 01:11:08,400
Are, similar to Barbuda, have an agenda to take their lands that they have held in
traditional
668
01:11:08,400 --> 01:11:17,360
communities in as Indigenous with Indigenous practices for private development, and a
big
669
01:11:17,360 --> 01:11:24,640
part of this of course impacts on the environment because there are developments that
are earmarked
670
01:11:24,640 --> 01:11:33,600
and are taking place the community is not engaged, the community is not informed of
developments that
671
01:11:33,600 --> 01:11:41,440
are earmarked, and you know are to take place on their lands or their adjoining lands, a
lot of which
672
01:11:41,440 --> 01:11:51,280
may very well have harmful environmental consequences for the communities and so it
was really about
673
01:11:51,280 --> 01:12:00,720
engaging with the communities, informing them and enabling them and empowering
them to assert
674
01:12:00,720 --> 01:12:06,880
their rights, particularly as they face development and environmental challenges so it's
sort of
675
01:12:06,880 --> 01:12:17,040
come full circle, but you know it just shows the importance of the global community in
this time,
676
01:12:17,040 --> 01:12:26,160
to work together to protect the environment. Yeah and this, this goes back to what you
677
01:12:26,160 --> 01:12:32,080
were saying about pro bono work and how important it is obviously nationally and
globally.
678
01:12:32,080 --> 01:12:42,000
Okay so... Thanks everyone and, now it's an opportunity to, to open up questions to
679
01:12:42,000 --> 01:12:52,400
the audience if I may. So do you want to ask a question first?
680
01:12:52,400 --> 01:13:04,000
Okay so my question is to Nazir. My name is Jawad I'm an ex-Manchester student, I work
as a GP now,
681
01:13:04,000 --> 01:13:11,360
so why is it in 2024 we still have this statistic of 9 times more likely, and why is there no
682
01:13:11,920 --> 01:13:18,080
political appetite to challenge this? What, do you think we'll ever get to the stage where
683
01:13:18,080 --> 01:13:24,640
justice is served equally
irrespective of race? Well I think well I'm always optimistic that
at
684
01:13:24,640 --> 01:13:31,120
some point we will get to the stage but the reason I said is I’m alarmed that we haven't
had
685
01:13:31,120 --> 01:13:36,320
any significant improvement. And actually the fact, we've gone backwards I think we've
touched on
686
01:13:36,320 --> 01:13:41,920
it earlier on, because of the lack of resources in the system, we've gone backwards so if
the
687
01:13:41,920 --> 01:13:47,760
government say “right, we want you to tackle crime in a particular community” which is
disproportionately
688
01:13:47,760 --> 01:13:53,920
Black or Asian, police go in there with one, one approach, to arrest, stop, search, rather
than thinking
689
01:13:53,920 --> 01:13:58,000
well actually crime happens everywhere, and they shouldn't just focus on one
community. So,
690
01:13:58,000 --> 01:14:03,440
to answer your question I don't know the answer I do think you know we're probably
going to be
691
01:14:03,440 --> 01:14:08,080
asked to later on about what the University could do, the University could do, the more
research we do
692
01:14:08,080 --> 01:14:12,800
in this field, the more evidence that supports this, because sometimes when I use that
figure,
693
01:14:12,800 --> 01:14:17,040
somebody comes back and says well it's actually 7 times right now, you know as if
somehow that's
694
01:14:17,040 --> 01:14:22,480
fantastic improvement, you know so the more research we have in this field, the better
we'll
695
01:14:22,480 --> 01:14:27,280
we'll be able to push back on those people who think it isn't a problem but to answer
your
696
01:14:27,280 --> 01:14:31,600
question will we ever get there? Yes I hope but it comes down to what others have said
about
697
01:14:31,600 --> 01:14:38,320
proper funding. We must get there, we must get there. So can I just can I just come in on
that point because I
698
01:14:38,320 --> 01:14:45,920
think that the use of joint enterprise, joint enterprise laws, contributes to the significant
699
01:14:45,920 --> 01:14:52,880
number of Black, young people in particular, who are in a criminal justice system and
we really
700
01:14:52,880 --> 01:14:58,400
need to rethink and relook at the laws relating to joint enterprise, and I think that's a very
701
01:14:58,400 --> 01:15:05,680
important aspect of working towards that sort of reduction in the over representation of
Black
702
01:15:05,680 --> 01:15:11,360
people in the criminal justice system. Yeah absolutely, and coupled with the use of
evidence
703
01:15:11,360 --> 01:15:16,880
against certain communities as well, like the, the Art not Evidence campaign yeah
rapping and
704
01:15:16,880 --> 01:15:21,680
drill music and the Art Not Evidence campaign you know it's critical really because it's
just
705
01:15:21,680 --> 01:15:26,880
the different factors together make a huge difference. It doesn't help that there's no
Black
706
01:15:26,880 --> 01:15:31,920
Chief
Constables, it doesn't help that there are no you know, if the representation is not
there
707
01:15:31,920 --> 01:15:37,120
at the top, well things are not going to change overnight are they? Yeah, okay and I think
there's
708
01:15:37,120 --> 01:15:43,200
a question there, I think somebody had their hand up there then there’s just one there.
So I just want,
709
01:15:43,200 --> 01:15:49,440
I'm like you Nazir I'm a I'm an optimist, we may have a Prime Minister soon who is legally
literate,
710
01:15:49,440 --> 01:15:55,280
Am I expecting too much to hope that we have a Home Secretary at some stage who will
be legally
711
01:15:55,280 --> 01:16:01,600
literate as well? How can they be legally literate? It's impossible to answer that question
without
712
01:16:01,600 --> 01:16:08,400
being political, I've worked with some people who might be in government in three
weeks' time and
713
01:16:08,400 --> 01:16:14,720
they are legally literate uh, so I'm hopeful, one has to be hopeful, but when you, you
know when you
714
01:16:14,720 --> 01:16:19,440
start appointing people to roles who've got no experience of that area and then they rely
upon 23
715
01:16:19,440 --> 01:16:26,480
year old special advisors, no, no disrespect to 23-year-olds in the room, but the point is
you know
716
01:16:26,480 --> 01:16:32,240
you need experience, you need knowledge, you need access to knowledge, and so you
know we used to
717
01:16:32,240 --> 01:16:36,320
Have, you know the only people that would be Lord Chancellors would be people
people who were, you know, 30
718
01:16:36,320 --> 01:16:40,080
years in the law, you know, that kind of stuff rather than somebody that's just walked in
out of
719
01:16:40,080 --> 01:16:46,640
bar school, no disrespect the current one. If I could just add it that Claire and I teach
720
01:16:46,640 --> 01:16:50,960
miscarriages of justice here, and there are very few textbooks that have been written on
the topic of
721
01:16:50,960 --> 01:16:56,080
miscarriage of justice, so one of the books that we still use is one that was written about
20 years
722
01:16:56,080 --> 01:17:02,400
ago by a professor at the University of Leeds and one of his former students who was a
young,
723
01:17:02,400 --> 01:17:08,640
radical, human rights lawyer by the name of Keir Starmer, so he literally wrote the book
on
724
01:17:08,640 --> 01:17:15,120
miscarriages of justice, he knows they exist, he knows a lot of what needs to be done to
fix them,
725
01:17:16,000 --> 01:17:22,080
is it going to be top of his priority list when, when, if, he walks into Downing Street? I very
much
726
01:17:22,080 --> 01:17:28,240
doubt it, but as you say he, he is someone who we can say absolutely knows the issues
because
727
01:17:28,240 --> 01:17:34,560
he literally wrote the book on them. Yep okay so another question, I think you've got a
question
728
01:17:34,560 --> 01:17:44,640
there and yep. Hi I think that there's like quite a big taboo against
going against
729
01:17:44,640 --> 01:17:51,920
like large corporations and groups, similar to the saying like do you know who I am?
730
01:17:51,920 --> 01:17:57,360
Do, how do we like encourage accountability and go against this?
731
01:17:57,360 --> 01:18:07,760
I mean power, power has always corrupted, an absolute power corrupts doesn't it?
732
01:18:07,760 --> 01:18:12,640
we've, we've been quite successful in recent years around sexual misconduct for
example.
733
01:18:13,680 --> 01:18:18,560
You've seen some Hollywood superstars and others who finally been brought to book
for what they
734
01:18:18,560 --> 01:18:24,160
what they've done for decades on end, but you know we haven't even mentioned the
financial crash,
735
01:18:24,160 --> 01:18:28,800
you know that was that destroyed tens of thousands of lives and there have been 2
convictions
736
01:18:28,800 --> 01:18:34,480
and both of them are currently appealing. You know so Hillsborough we've had one, one
health
737
01:18:34,480 --> 01:18:40,320
and safety conviction if I'm if I remember rightly, we've had none for infected blood
we've obviously
738
01:18:40,320 --> 01:18:44,880
now had not, apart from the miscarriages in Post Office, we were, we had none for Post
Office so
739
01:18:44,880 --> 01:18:50,800
I think the worm has to turn and that everybody should you know I thought, I thought, I
thought
740
01:18:50,800 --> 01:18:54,640
I thought, I thought, my whole point was that the law was it applies to everyone and
there may
741
01:18:54,640 --> 01:19:00,320
well be some solutions that we might touch on in a minute or two that will enable the
powerful
742
01:19:00,320 --> 01:19:03,440
to be held to the same standard that the rest of us are held to.
743
01:19:05,040 --> 01:19:12,880
Anyone else want to add to that one? Well I, I think that I mean you know there needs to
be
744
01:19:12,880 --> 01:19:22,400
legislative teeth to ensure that you know corporations are, they don't elude justice
particularly
745
01:19:22,400 --> 01:19:31,440
following mass disasters. I mean the health and safety legislation in some ways
encompasses
746
01:19:31,440 --> 01:19:38,000
That, but paying a fine, a corporation paying a fine you know when you have human
failing
747
01:19:38,000 --> 01:19:47,360
contributing to deaths or systemic feelings is quite a difficult pill for victims to swallow.
748
01:19:47,360 --> 01:19:54,640
So I do think that there needs to be some legislative change in that respect. I, I just want
to throw
749
01:19:54,640 --> 01:20:05,680
something in here, in health and safety law, if something terrible happens and
somebody loses
750
01:20:05,680 --> 01:20:10,880
an arm or or the worst case gets killed, in a workplace situation
751
01:20:10,880 --> 01:20:21,280
the actual health and safety manager director, call him or her what you will,
752
01:20:23,600 --> 01:20:32,640
it them personally they get it's hauled up into court and they can go to prison. We've had
that
753
01:20:32,640 --> 01:20:42,240
in our law here for 20 plus years and over that period thankfully the incidence of that
754
01:20:42,240 --> 01:20:51,920
type of thing happening has plummeted, because all companies know that the bosses
themselves
755
01:20:53,120 --> 01:20:59,360
can be called to account. Now surely there's a lesson that should be learned from that
756
01:20:59,360 --> 01:21:04,800
when it comes to the thing, the other things that we're talking about where people are
757
01:21:04,800 --> 01:21:13,440
obfuscating the truth and not offering all the information and all the ramifications that
758
01:21:13,440 --> 01:21:24,400
run from it, if the law stated that the bosses end up in jail, or never mind finding a
corporation or
759
01:21:24,400 --> 01:21:35,200
a body, millions of pounds, the bosses have to pay as well, I tell you what it would it, it
would square things
760
01:21:35,200 --> 01:21:40,880
up pretty quick I think. I think there's there's somebody there that wants to ask a
question.
761
01:21:41,200 --> 01:21:54,240
Hi I, I, I, I wondered whether any of you think there is a role, or could be a role, or should
be a
762
01:21:54,240 --> 01:22:03,040
role, in improving access to the law for trade unions because I think trade unions are
substantial
763
01:22:03,040 --> 01:22:08,640
commissioners of legal services on behalf of ordinary people, now mostly that's to do
with
764
01:22:08,640 --> 01:22:14,240
health and safety but I don't know that it necessarily has to be limited to health and
safety
765
01:22:14,240 --> 01:22:19,440
and I think the the good thing about health and safety isn't so much the people who get
766
01:22:19,440 --> 01:22:26,560
Prosecuted, it's the damages that get awarded to victims, but the other thing that's
relevant I
767
01:22:26,560 --> 01:22:31,920
think to workplace is the importance that you've pointed out about whistleblowers
because I think
768
01:22:31,920 --> 01:22:37,360
it's all very well to present whistleblowers with the duties to tell the truth and disclose
769
01:22:37,360 --> 01:22:43,360
whatever it is and give them a duty, but most whistleblowers are, most significant
770
01:22:43,360 --> 01:22:48,240
whistleblowers are employees in a workplace and they're afraid of the consequences
and it's the
771
01:22:48,240 --> 01:22:52,880
trade unions that can protect them from the consequences, and protecting them from
the consequences of
772
01:22:52,880 --> 01:22:58,080
saying what needs to be said is probably more to the point than giving them a duty to to
tell it.
773
01:22:58,080 --> 01:23:03,120
So you know where do trade, do you see trade unions fitting into the
774
01:23:04,160 --> 01:23:13,200
path of making this situation better? I mean if I can just weigh in on, on that question in
this way,
775
01:23:13,200 --> 01:23:22,080
i have seen first hand the value of the work of trading unions in the Covid Inquiry so the t
776
01:23:22,080 -->
01:23:29,280
of TUC is, has been, uninterested, what has been given interested person status in the
Covid
777
01:23:29,280 --> 01:23:36,640
Inquiry and I and I tell you one of the challenges that the TUC has faced is that they
haven't gotten
778
01:23:36,640 --> 01:23:44,080
funding, they haven't gotten you know, they haven't they don't have that pool of funds to
779
01:23:44,080 --> 01:23:54,880
mount a full representation and, and you know, fund a full complement of legal team
but and I don't
780
01:23:54,880 --> 01:24:01,840
know if you have been following the Covid Inquiry at all during the module one which is
the
781
01:24:01,840 --> 01:24:06,640
Pre-pandemic preparation and module two which has been the decision making stage
782
01:24:06,640 --> 01:24:15,120
I think your mic isn't working. My mic isn't working? Oh dear, thank you. Better? Yes.
Thank you. And, but,
783
01:24:15,120 --> 01:24:26,400
so we have seen a lot of material coming out from the trade union to the inquiry, it's all
in the
784
01:24:26,400 --> 01:24:37,280
Public, on the support, the warnings, the cautions that they, they have given and the
exposure and risk
785
01:24:37,840 --> 01:24:47,360
that workers who are members of the trade union faced during Covid, and some of the
workers
786
01:24:47,360 --> 01:24:53,760
who have given statements and evidence and material that we have seen in the inquiry
787
01:24:53,760 --> 01:25:00,720
Are, you know, would fall into that category of, of whistleblowers so I, I absolutely
support
788
01:25:01,680 --> 01:25:09,120
proper funding for trade unions because they, their members are really at the heart of
789
01:25:09,120 --> 01:25:17,280
evidence gathering, lobbying and information and again with Grenfell, the FBU, the FBU
and
790
01:25:17,280 --> 01:25:27,680
Matt Wrack have been very, very instrumental in bringing to light some of the failings in
791
01:25:27,680 --> 01:25:34,560
the LFB and ways that things need to be improved, particularly with the impact of
austerity, that's
792
01:25:34,560 --> 01:25:41,280
been a main theme that the trade unions have carried in calling for accountability where
793
01:25:41,280 --> 01:25:49,200
we have these huge failings. Okay thanks, did you want to add to that or, yep, okay, okay
so
794
01:25:49,200 --> 01:25:54,640
that's all the questions we've got time for but I just wanted to ask you all a final question,
795
01:25:54,640 --> 01:25:59,760
so we've finished with our audience questions because we're running out of time, and
this is a
796
01:25:59,760 --> 01:26:09,440
question to you all, so in in the areas that we've talked about this evening, what do you
797
01:26:09,440 --> 01:26:18,160
hope our sort of third century of of the university of Manchester will, will bring in in this
area?
798
01:26:18,160 --> 01:26:27,440
What do you hope might change or get, get better? Thalia, Suzanne? You want me to
start? Yes,
799
01:26:27,440 --> 01:26:35,360
go on, you know. Well I mean Nazir touched on, on research you know universities
800
01:26:35,360 --> 01:26:44,720
are you know research centres, you know your law faculty, I'm hoping that you produce
radical
801
01:26:44,720 --> 01:26:53,280
lawyers who will carry on the fight for justice because you've got to be radical to fight for
802
01:26:53,280 --> 01:27:03,040
change and you know it's not an easy road I hope that the university will, will build on its
803
01:27:03,040 --> 01:27:12,160
development support I, I look forward to perhaps having more conversations with you
guys around
804
01:27:12,160 --> 01:27:18,720
climate justice and environmental protections and safeguard but I, I mean my takeaway
from this
805
01:27:18,720 --> 01:27:29,760
is continued, your work on the over-representation of and racial inequality and
806
01:27:29,760 --> 01:27:37,280
injustice in the criminal justice system the work you've done with Keir Monteith of my
chambers on racism
807
01:27:37,280 --> 01:27:45,200
in the judiciary and your project professor Quinn, Quinn, on you know Art Not Evidence
808
01:27:45,200 --> 01:27:54,720
and the use of, of music, Black music um, so more research, radical lawyers. Yeah.
Tom>
809
01:27:54,720 --> 01:28:03,520
Well I think this is my fourth visit to the university and the one thing that I always
810
01:28:04,480 --> 01:28:11,600
are very heartened with whenever I, I sit in a room here, certainly with when it's mainly
811
01:28:11,600 --> 01:28:22,320
student, students as the audience, is the fact that it's at least 50/50 male or female, in
some of the
812
01:28:22,320 --> 01:28:34,240
some of the classes it's 70 female 30 male, and every colour under the sun, every race
appears
813
01:28:35,200 --> 01:28:44,880
to be represented here. So I think there's a great start for that dissemination and the
814
01:28:44,880 --> 01:28:53,280
the breaking down of this culture that exists certainly within legal system in this country,
815
01:28:54,080 --> 01:29:06,080
of sort of old white middle-aged men, like me, and yeah, long may that continue, and
when those
816
01:29:06,080 --> 01:29:15,360
students take up their positions as lawyers and start working for firms hopefully all that
will
817
01:29:15,360 --> 01:29:19,760
take through, and I mean all the time I come I always talk about miscarriage injustice
because
818
01:29:19,760 --> 01:29:29,520
unfortunately I'm an expert on that um, and for them, for the students to be aware of all
these
819
01:29:29,520 --> 01:29:38,560
things that can go and do go wrong with our system. Okay, Suzanne? Yeah well I think
obviously,
820
01:29:38,560 --> 01:29:42,800
there's the, there's the two key themes at the university, we've got research and we've
got teaching,
821
01:29:42,800 --> 01:29:48,000
and just to focus a little bit on the teaching that when I was a trainee solicitor the, the
822
01:29:48,000 --> 01:29:52,560
partner I worked for told me that the most important thing she was
going to do for me
was to teach
823
01:29:52,560 --> 01:29:59,520
to turn me cynical and I like that we do that with the students before they even go into
practice,
824
01:29:59,520 --> 01:30:05,920
we teach miscarriages of just as, as a module so we're teaching them right from the get-
go that
825
01:30:05,920 --> 01:30:10,880
it is a far from perfect system and we, we show them all the things that have gone wrong
with the
826
01:30:10,880 --> 01:30:16,240
system and the harm that can be done and I think that that goes a long way to turning
out that, the
827
01:30:16,240 --> 01:30:22,720
right type of radical lawyer that Thalia was talking about. The best lawyer that I ever
worked for um
828
01:30:22,720 --> 01:30:28,800
was a man named Elkan Abrahamson who, in Liverpool, he was the lawyer who
represented the Hillsborough
829
01:30:28,800 --> 01:30:36,800
Families, he worked on that case for, for about 27 years, and he got paid for maybe 2
years of
830
01:30:36,800 --> 01:30:43,360
those 27, because he represented a woman called Anne Williams and, and he fought so
hard, for year
831
01:30:43,360 --> 01:30:48,320
after year he was banging his head against a brick wall trying to get justice for the
families.
832
01:30:48,320 --> 01:30:56,720
Now Elkan his, his mantra as a lawyer is that you have to make the law work for your
clients,
833
01:30:56,720 --> 01:31:02,720
and if the law doesn't work for your client, get the law changed. And that's how that's
how he goes
834
01:31:02,720 --> 01:31:08,080
about his practice and I like to think that at Manchester we're training the next
generation of
835
01:31:08,080 --> 01:31:12,480
lawyers who are going to have that attitude, who, who are not going to just sit there and
accept all
836
01:31:12,480 --> 01:31:16,480
of these inequalities and injustices and they're going to go about trying to, trying to
change the
837
01:31:16,480 --> 01:31:22,480
Law. I mean I endorse all of that I mean as Chancellor ,of course I will, um
838
01:31:22,480 --> 01:31:28,480
Manchester is the home of the cooperative movement, it's the home of the Peterloo
Massacre, the social
839
01:31:28,480 --> 01:31:33,920
Activism, the home of the Suffragette movement, if it hasn't happened in Manchester,
hasn't happened
840
01:31:33,920 --> 01:31:39,440
anywhere else. So I think that's, that has to be said straight off. In addition to what
Suzanne said
841
01:31:39,440 --> 01:31:45,520
about teaching and research, the third core goal is of course social development and
we are number
842
01:31:45,520 --> 01:31:50,720
1 in Europe, number 2 in the world for universities in meeting the UN Sustainable
843
01:31:50,720 --> 01:31:56,240
Development Goals and that's all about ensuring that what we do impacts, and the
impact it has on
844
01:31:56,240 --> 01:32:01,040
our communities, and I hope we do much more of that, that, we remain ,well we're the
only university in
845
01:32:01,040 --> 01:32:05,600
the world to be in
the top 10 since the league table was created and I hope that we will
always
846
01:32:05,600 --> 01:32:10,160
remain number 1 or 2 because we recognise that we're not in a vacuum, that we are part
of the
847
01:32:10,160 --> 01:32:14,160
communities of the North West of England, we're the part of the communities in the
United Kingdom
848
01:32:14,160 --> 01:32:18,960
and we're part of the global community. Okay and I believe I'm to answer this question
as well so
849
01:32:18,960 --> 01:32:26,640
my hope is and myself and, and Suzanne work on the Manchester Innocence project is
we
850
01:32:26,640 --> 01:32:35,520
overturn convic-, convictions in in the next century, hopefully sooner or than later
851
01:32:35,520 --> 01:32:41,040
so that, that's the first thing and as Chair I'm going to use my prerogative have a second
wish,
852
01:32:41,040 --> 01:32:49,520
and that is that on the 11th of June the decision is being made on whether people who
are victims
853
01:32:49,520 --> 01:32:56,800
of miscarriages and justice get compensation or not in Nealon and Hallam so that the
Grand Chamber
854
01:32:56,800 --> 01:33:03,760
are handing that down on the 11th of June and that's my second wish, June, that's, that's
my second wish
855
01:33:03,760 --> 01:33:09,600
is that it goes in their favour and that victims of wrongful convictions, not the Post Office
856
01:33:09,600 --> 01:33:15,840
cases because that's separate, other victims, get compensation and get the
compensation they deserve
857
01:33:15,840 --> 01:33:22,800
to rebuild their lives so and I think that, we're, everything's there and I’ll invite Luke back
up to close.
858
01:33:22,800 --> 01:33:40,560
Well let, let me wrap up with three short phrases that that we've heard this evening uh,
one that
859
01:33:41,600 --> 01:33:47,920
Thalia was talking about a lot was sense of injustice I think that's a good word because it
shows that
860
01:33:47,920 --> 01:33:52,880
it's something that you feel as well as understand cognitively and I'm sure we've felt it as
we've
861
01:33:52,880 --> 01:34:00,560
heard all the cases from our panels this afternoon. The second one was shine a light
and that's the
862
01:34:00,560 --> 01:34:06,720
purpose of Talk 200 and I really do feel some very important lights have been shown
today.
863
01:34:07,520 --> 01:34:15,520
The last one was rewiring the justice system, that we haven't done but perhaps there's
some pointers
864
01:34:15,520 --> 01:34:20,880
for those who are going to do it, and as some have hinted there's another ex-Chief
Prosecutor out
865
01:34:20,880 --> 01:34:28,880
there and maybe we should put our hopes in that thank you all Nazir, Claire, Tom, Thalia
and Suzanne
866
01:34:28,880 --> 01:34:30,320
for your brilliant insights.
867
01:34:34,800 --> 01:34:39,760
To stay up to date with everything Talk 200, be sure to follow and subscribe to the series
868
01:34:39,760 --> 01:34:48,080
on the podcasting platform of your choice. Head to manchester.ac.uk/200 to find out
more about the
869
01:34:48,080 --> 01:34:55,360
series and all the activity taking place across our bicentenary year. Use the hashtag
#uom200 to
870
01:34:55,360 --> 01:35:01,360
engage with Talk 200 and our wider bicentenary celebrations on social media. Thank
you for joining
871
01:35:01,360 --> 01:35:13,200
us for this episode of Talk 200, a University of Manchester series.
872
01:35:13,680 --> 01:35:18,260
(upbeat music)