TRANSCRIPTION 🔗
Morning. My name is Cor. I'm on the pastoral staff here at Hope. After service, if I haven't met you, I'd love to meet you. Have you come on down front, share your hot take on who's going to win the big game this afternoon. This morning, we get to open up Mark's gospel. Mark is one of four gospel accounts, four accounts of the life and death and resurrection of Jesus. It is unique that we call these gospels. Why? Well, gospel means good news. And back then, there in that culture and that side of the earth, this idea of good news or gospel was often referenced into the good news, not of Jesus, but of Caesar. The gospel of Caesar, the gospel of Rome, the good news of that king with that kingdom would have meant military victory. It would have meant that something has happened out there that would bring and yield good for the community. And so the fact that we've perhaps become used to the phrase, the good news of Jesus, the gospel of Jesus Christ, it defies logic. It's a bit ironic because it's news of a death. And that somehow this death would yield good for a community should surprise us. It should catch us off guard. This is not the way that gospel or good news would have necessarily been communicated back then. The death of your leader bringing good to the community. And yet that is the Christian message. The Christian message has at its heart, at its center, the death of its leader. It is the cross of Jesus that we boast in, that we come gathered around, despite all of the differences in this room. And I assure you, there are many differences in this room. What unites us as the church is Jesus died and raised. Next week, we will go more clearly into the cross of Jesus, the crucifixion. We've spent weeks building up to it and will continue to do so today. Here's a bit of a chronology. And next week, that arrow will point right down on the cross. And I think for us, just to guard against a temptation, a common temptation, which is to identify with certain characters and then maybe distance ourselves like, wow, wow i'm so glad that i'm not like that guy like judas like peter like the crowds today it might be like i'm so glad that i'm not like the religious leaders or like this roman governmental leader named pilot, it's so tempting, to distance ourselves from the mistakes of those we see and yet. Theologically, spiritually, if we were there, we in all likelihood, friends, would have made the same decisions, would have made the same declarations of the crowds. And so it might be tempting for us in the midst of this narrative to dismiss them or to dismiss Jesus, to distance ourselves from their declarations or to distance ourselves from Jesus. And I think for us, the Bible is going to beckon us to look afresh at Jesus, the one condemned, the king who is condemned by a earthly government. And for us to slow down and say, there's something about that guy. There's something about what he came to do. A king ushering in a kingdom that is revolutionary,
Load full transcript
but unlike every other kingdom that has come before it or since then. So let me read our passage for this morning, and then we'll have some time to go through it. We're going to be in Mark 15, chapter 15, verses 1 to 20. Let me read for us, beginning in verse 1. Very early in the morning, the chief priests with the elders, the teachers of the law, and the whole Sanhedrin, the whole religious council, made their plans. So they bound Jesus, led him away and handed him over to Pilate. Are you the king of the Jews? Asked Pilate. You have said so, Jesus replied. The chief priests accused him of many things. So again, Pilate asked him, aren't you going to answer? See how many things they are accusing you of? But Jesus still made no reply. And Pilate was amazed. Now, it was the custom at the festival to release a prisoner whom the people requested. A man called Barabbas was in prison with the insurrectionists who had committed murder in the uprising. The crowd came up and asked Pilate to do for them what he usually did. Do you want me to release to you the king of the Jews? asked Pilate. Knowing it was out of self-interest that the chief priest had handed Jesus over to him. But the chief priest stirred up the crowd to have Pilate release Barabbas instead. What shall I do then with the one you call the king of the Jews, Pilate asked them. Crucify him, they shouted. Why? What crime has he committed? asked Pilate. But they shouted all the louder, crucify him. Wanting to satisfy the crowd, Pilate released Barabbas to them. He had Jesus flogged and handed him over to be crucified. The soldiers led Jesus away into the palace that is the praetorium and called together the whole company of soldiers. They put a purple robe on him, then twisted together a crown of thorns and set it on him. And they began to call out to him, Hail, King of the Jews! Again and again they struck him on the head with a staff and spit on him. Falling on their knees, they paid homage to him. And when they had mocked him, they took off the purple robe and put his own clothes on him. Then they led him out to crucify him. So that's our passage for this morning. I want to take some time to walk through it. Going to hit it from three different angles. One angle is the ambiguous answer that Jesus provides in response to Pilate's questioning. Then he gives a silent answer, a non-answer answer. And then we see a type of substitutionary answer. So we're going to look at each of these. And at the end of the day, we're going to ask and be forced to answer, I think, the question individually, personally, what do you make of all this? What do you think about this Jesus character, this Jesus figure? Do you believe in him? Do you trust him with what he has shown you in today's passage? So going back to the beginning, very early in the morning, the chief priests with the elders, leaders of the law, the whole sentry, and they make their plans, right? They bound Jesus, led him away, hand him over to Pilate. Are you the king of the Jews is the first significant question posed to Jesus. So we've moved from what was a very religious context, a religious trial. Are you this Messiah? Are you the one that was promised in the Old Testament and you've come to fulfill those various prophecies? That was the religious context that we had a week or two ago, and now we've moved to more of a political context. What was previously overseen, a trial by the high priest Caiaphas, is now being overseen by a Roman governor, a prefect named Pilate. The religious leaders concern themselves with the identity of Messiah. This Roman governor is concerned about his identity as a type of political leader. Could really care less about his religious affiliation. It's just, are you pretending? Are you setting yourself up to be a political leader? Insurrectionists, a king that will oppose Caesar. Is that who you are? Is that what you have come to do? Now, a little bit more on this guy, Pilate, here. It says that, this is what David Garland says, this Roman prefect, he's called the procurator later in history, had the power of life, and death over the inhabitants of his province who were not Roman citizens. No criminal code existed for a malefactor who was a non-Roman citizen tried in the provinces. The governor was free in such cases to make his own rules and judgments as he saw fit to accept, or reject charges and to fashion within reason, whatever penalties he chose. And so we know through some historical study that this Pilate. Kind of a third-rate politician. Like he spent more than a decade on the outskirts of Roman territory. This was not a person who was working his way up. He's kind of cast aside as a third-rate politician and by Roman standards was not a big deal. Yet he's forever bound to the Christian faith because he's presiding over this trial. He is noted as being an unusually cruel leader and was quick to execute criminals. And so in the midst of that, we get this scene being played out. We know who Jesus is because he's got the circle around his head, which is helpful in old artwork for us. We can identify who Jesus is, but we see Pilate here. We see the kind of Roman guard. And then we got the religious leaders who are lined up behind Jesus. And he is asked by Pilate, are you the king of the Jews? And Jesus is going to respond in an ambiguous way. What do I mean by that? Well, maybe you've been asked, like, as I've been asked, are you a runner? Right now all of us have run at times right it's just like well i yeah i've done some running i've i've done a couple marathons. 20, 25 years ago, right? Like I do run. I can run. If I'm being chased, I will run. But are you a runner? I don't know how to answer that, right? Or do you lift? I have lifted. I can lift. I will lift. Not consistently, but right. We get a similar ambiguous answer from Jesus. He doesn't say yes. He doesn't say no. Literally, it's like his response is, as you say. Are you the king of the
Jews? You say so. That's his response to this line of questioning. Why? Because it kind of matters in what sense you're asking me, am I a king? Am I a king with the same intentions of Barabbas, an insurrectionist who's gonna take up sword and spear and try to defend myself and conquer and vanquish the ruling class and oppose Caesar? No, no, I'm not a king in that sense. That's not the kingdom that I'm trying to establish. Are you a king in the sense that you want to bring about a certain type of revolution? A revolution that will change not only Roman realities, but the realities around the world throughout history. And you will do so. You will usher in this kingdom not by conquering your enemies with power, but by laying down your life on behalf of your enemies. Yeah, yeah, that's that. I will be the king in that sense. And so here, Jesus' response, are you a king? Kind of. in a manner of speaking, depending on what you mean. And so I think for us, it's enough to just pause here and maybe even suspend judgment like Pilate. Do you hope downtown? Do you, modern person, 21st century, Midwesterner, what do you make of this Jesus? Do you believe he is a king over a kingdom that is ushering in a rule and reign, not by force, not by compulsion, not by power, not to conquer you, but rather to die for you, to woo you by how much love he has for you, a love unto death for you. These 2,000 years later, That historical event has a claim on your life. Do you believe that? An ambiguous answer to Pilate's question. Jesus' second response is one of silence. The chief priests accuse him of many things. Like, what are we talking about? Because Mark doesn't give any examples. Thankfully, we have other gospels we can look at. Luke's gospel says this. They began to accuse Jesus saying, we have found this man subverting our nation. He opposes payment of taxes to Caesar, and he claims to be Messiah, a king. And so I think there's much ink that spilled on this, you know, throughout commentators. We have found this man subverting our nation. Again, what do you mean by that? What nation? The Jewish nation? The Roman nation? He opposes payment of taxes of Caesar. That's actually a mischaracterization of Jesus' teaching. He's like, render unto Caesar what is Caesar's? Render unto God what is God's, right? So they're twisting his words. They're framing him. These are fraudulent charges. He claims to be Messiah, a type of king. And it's like, again, Pilate would have been like, I have no desire to get into the waters of your religious beliefs, this Messiah, and whether he is or is not the fulfillment of some historic prophecy. I don't care about that stuff. It's just, are you going to ruffle the feathers and stir the waters within Rome? That's what I care about. That's why he is actually in Jerusalem at this time, coming there during the Passover, during this time to just make sure the peace is kept, that nothing gets out of hand. This idea of Jesus needing to respond to these accusations, right? In a very earthly roommate situation, maybe you have been accused by a roommate of not correctly loading the dishwasher. And you had that either with your family or roommates, right? And you just summon a 20-minute defense. Like the accusation is absurd. There's no need to give a defense. And in similar fashion, Jesus was like, I don't need to give a defense. This is absurd. He could summon a defense, right? But he feels no need. Pilate asked him, aren't you going to answer? See how many things they are accusing you of. But Jesus still made no reply. And Pilate was amazed. Why would Pilate be amazed? Because he's had this conversation with so many other people that have been brought before him. Every person that's brought before him is offered an opportunity to give defense. Give defense for yourself. This man standing in front of him is on trial for his life. He's been condemned as worthy of death by his own people. And yet there's no begging for his life. There's no defense being summoned according to his own behavior. And biblically and historically, we should take his silence to be an indication of innocence, not guilt. His silence fulfills an ancient prophecy from the book of Isaiah. It reads this way, he was oppressed and afflicted, yet he did not open his mouth. He was led like a lamb to the slaughter and as a sheep before it shears his silent, so he did not open his mouth. By oppression and judgment, he was taken away. Yet who of his generation protested? Who came to his defense? No one. And so he goes silently before this judge, the one who had power to free him or to condemn him. Jesus offers no defense. Why? Because he's going to the cross in obedience. He is not lashing out in defiance. He won't defend himself because he did not come to this moment in order to be acquitted. If he were trying to set up an earthly kingdom, he might. But that's not how he's going to usher in his reign. He has come to be condemned in our place. He's come for this very moment, a trial, unjustly condemning him to death, like a sheep before its shearers is silent. So Jesus goes silently to this fate. Jesus refuses to be recruited by either the agenda of the priests or of Pilate. And yet we're constantly, friends, this is where I want to just like slow down just a moment to catch us all up in our modern moment. Because if you go and you read the commentaries and you check in with other pastors and preachers on this, this has all the makings of a sermon about politics. And we spent all of September talking about that reality. And so I'm not going to try to preach all of that in here, but I do want to slow down long enough for all of us to recognize Jesus is not trying to usher in an earthly kingdom with an earthly king. He's not trying to bring forth some sort of earthly or political power, but rather he is altogether different in his reign and his rule. I think for us to humbly submit ourselves is to consider that sometimes we claim,
to know in our current political moment, which side of the aisle Jesus would inhabit to claim he's on our side or for our agenda or for our platform. And yet, as we've said from this stage many times, Jesus and his kingdom supersedes any earthly political party. And neither political party fully inhabits all of the values that Jesus has. In his rule and his reign. And I don't want to make too much a mess of this. I know some of you are already planning which relatives to stay away from during Thanksgiving. And I'm not trying to stir up the waters any more than necessary. But the example we have from the early church, from the church that took this teaching and then applied it in life, as they engaged this dominant Roman culture, showed a couple things that I think we need to take note of. That the early church took this message and what did they do as they engaged culture? Let me give you a couple that transcends our modern political moment. The early church was more conservative than the dominant Roman culture. More conservative than the dominant Roman culture. And in what way? In safeguarding the nature and sanctity of life and in strengthening marriage. How so? I lean on Rodney Stark, who's a sociologist and historian, and Tim Keller, who's a pastor and theologian, that state that in Roman culture, it was legal for infant daughters to be discarded. So much so that it became out of balance culturally. There are 140 males for every 100 females. Why? Because females were perceived to be not as valuable as sons. And just thrown away. And the church came against that practice. The earlier church also came against society's double standard that existed within marriage. That wives were prevented from having mistresses. But that same expectation was not placed on husbands. Wives were expected to be sexually pure and husbands not. And the church, the early church, wanted to safeguard marriage in this fashion. So they come against this practice. And they say, no, no, no. Husbands, you're going to remain chaste. You're going to remain faithful. in marriage. And the early church also showed itself to be more liberal than the dominant Roman culture. How so? The early church sought an uncommon justice and compassion for the poor and the vulnerable. In the Roman world, groups took care of their own, their own family, their own tribe. They took care of their people. Christians, however, were revolutionary in that they extended their help and generosity outside of their own religion and family to the poor of every race, caste, and creed. Listen to this. This is crazy when I came across this this week. The last pagan emperor of Rome was named Julian. He tried to revive Roman paganism by comparing the behavior of that kingdom. To what the early church was doing. He tried to revive their religion, their state, pagan religion, by comparing themselves to what Christians in the early church were doing. He says this as he writes two separate letters to various pagan
priests. He says, we ought, we the Roman people, ought to share our money with all people, but more generously with the good, those of Roman paganistic belief, those of our own tribe and family, religious family, and with the helpless and poor so as to suffice for their need. And I will assert, even though it be paradoxical to say so, that it would be a pious act to share our clothes and food, even with the wicked, those of contrary beliefs to Roman paganism. For it is disgraceful that when no Jew ever has to beg, and the impious Galileans, Christians support not only their own poor, but ours as well. All men see our people lack aid from us. Do you hear that? He's like, we're getting a bad name for ourselves. Why? Well, there's no need amongst the Jewish people. They're all caring well for their poor. And the Christians, they're not just caring for their own Christian poor. They're caring for Jewish poor. They're caring for Roman poor. They're caring for Arab poor. They're caring for all the poor. How liberal their generosity and their care for the well-being of humanity. Tim Keller summarizes by saying this, what Christianity brought was not simply a spiritual movement, but a whole new culture, a counterculture, an alternate way of being a human society. To everybody looking in, except the people at the very top, that counterculture was more attractive than the dominant one. So to kind of bind up this part of our passage, It says, Jesus is not held to your, my party's agenda. He did not come to be a pawn within American politics in the 21st century. Rather, he wants us to acknowledge the political idolatry of our culture and that which exists in our own hearts. The desire to cling to party or to power. Jesus' response to that is silence. I'm not for or against that. I don't need that. That's not what my kingdom is based on. To claim allegiance is to claim allegiance to him, to trust in him, to follow him, to embrace his agenda of love and laying down of life, not just for friend, but for enemy. Could that be said of Hope Downtown? That is counter-cultural. That's crazy. in our age, is it not? Maybe it's something for you to consider in heart and mind. Have you, have we been taken captive by a political agenda? Are we being told it's okay to care for one segment of our population? That group of people, they're deserving of love and support and care. The King of Kings cares for all. the king of kings died for all he calls us to an uncommon counter-cultural, counter-political kind of love for all. Let's go to the final answer a substitutionary one It says, now is the custom at the festival to release a prisoner whom the people requested. A man called Barabbas was in prison with the insurrectionists who had committed murder in the uprising. So in this final exchange, Pilate is seeking clarity from the crowd, and they're going to provide a substitutionary answer without even realizing. This whole custom at the festival, we don't got a lot of information on that. We don't know where this came from, which is very comparable to the Thanksgiving pardoning of the Turquery that the presidents do. We don't really know where that came from. H.W. Bush in 89 was the one who like officially did it, but it could have been Reagan. It could have been JFK. It could have been Lincoln. We don't know. In similar fashion, like this whole custom of releasing a prisoner came about and it's really kind of cloaked in obscurity. Like we don't know what's really being referenced. here in this. In the case of Barabbas and Jesus, the stakes are higher than a Thanksgiving Day turkey, but Barabbas is introduced. In a pretty dark fashion. Murderer and joins ranks with insurrectionists. Goes on to say this, the crowd came up and asked Pilate to do for them what he usually did. Do you want me to release to you the king of the Jews? Asked Pilate. Knowing it was out of self-interest that the chief priest had handed Jesus over to him, but the chief priest stirred up the crowd to have Pilate release Barabbas instead. And this line in here really confused me for a lot of years in my Christian life. This idea of Pilate being confused as to who he should release. Like the religious leaders just brought Jesus. So like, why would you even ask? And so just how this is playing out for me is pretty uncommon to paradigms that I live in. I think kind of that American court of law, it's organized. There's a systemic fashion in which somebody's put on trial. That's not going on here there is a mob-like scene that's taking place and two different crowds are present one has come, to hopefully get Barabbas released that they are with him they want to have insurrection they want to have instability they want to overthrow the Romans and so they're like yes get our leader out of jail so we can go for it again, and then there's Jesus who's been brought by the religious leaders. He's being opposed, right? They're trying to stir up the crowds to join with them. And we have this kind of textual note that Pilate sees it as envy out of self-interest. They're bringing Jesus forward. And yet still, that doesn't answer the question. Like, why is there confusion? Well, it's pretty clear that most commentators believe, what was Barabbas' name? Jesus. It's like, what? So that was a common name, more common than maybe we realize. And so you have Jesus Barabbas, this insurrectionist, and then you have Jesus of Nazareth. To further complicate things, you have Jesus Barabbas. Barabbas means son of the father. So you have Jesus, son of the father, Barabbas, being put against Jesus, a son of a father, the one that we know, son of the heavenly father, right? And so you just have this further complication. And so finally, it's just like, hey, insurrectionists or king of the Jews? I can't tell you guys. I'm hearing Jesus. I'm hearing Barabbas. I'm like, who are you talking about? Do you want the king of the Jews released to you? The passage goes on. What
shall I do then with the one you call king of the Jews? Twice. Twice they reply, crucify him. And he's like, I don't see him deserving death. I don't see anything that he's done that would result in crucifixion. But yet wanting to satisfy the crowd, Pilate released Barabbas. And Jesus flogged and handed over to be crucified. There's no doubt Barabbas was guilty. He's a murderer, an insurrectionist, deserving punishment. He would have been one of those guys that you just kind of say, throw the book at him. Throw away the key, right? Just don't let him out. And yet narratively here, the guilty walks out of the prison doors. The innocent is condemned. You and I would term this a miscarriage of justice. Justice failed here. In our Monday morning meeting, Dan Zeller, who's on staff, does communications. If you see a great video, that's Dan that works with Hope on Campus. He said this, it's not right. It shouldn't happen. Shocking, really. Yet, we have to rejoice at the injustice of Barabbas being released because that's true of us. That's spiritually true of us. Salt and Gold artist Jessica Bond did this. Setting Barabbas free makes no sense until you realize Barabbas is me. That's the Christian message the only reason that makes this injustice just is God says so, this is a miscarriage of justice Jesus didn't deserve this we didn't deserve to walk out of the prison, it's a miscarriage of justice the only thing that makes it right is God says, this is just by my accounting think. My son said he will take this penalty. He will step in place for you. He will be condemned so that you might be set free. Mark sets two men side by side. One is guilty. The other is innocent. One has taken life. The other lays down his life. One will go free and the other one will die for you and me. Theologically, this means Jesus dies in our place and he dies in the place, not just of good, clean, church-going folk, but the messy of the messy, the sinners, murderers, insurrectionists. He dies for the enemies of God. Christians have a name for this. It's substitution. He takes our place. He goes to the cross in our place. Romans 5.8 says, while we were still sinners, Christ died for us. 1 Peter 3.18 says, Christ died for sins, the righteous for the unrighteous. There's an exchange. There's a substitution. Christ was made sin without committing sin. That's what the Bible says. He was made sin without committing sin. And we are made righteous without committing righteousness. Substitution. Jesus takes our place. So we might walk free. By any earthly measure, a miscarriage of justice. But in a biblical, theological sense, God says, no, no, no, I declare it just. Why? Because my son will pay the penalty. Let me read the rest of our passage here. It says, The soldiers led Jesus away into the palace, called together the whole company of soldiers. They put a purple robe on him, twisted together a crown of thorns and set it on him. They began to call out to him, Hail, King of the Jews. Again and again, they struck him on the head with a staff and spit on him. Falling on their knees, they paid homage to him. And when they had mocked him, they took out a purple robe and put it on his clothes, put his clothes on him. They then led him out to crucify him. So in closing, to segue to next week's message on the cross and to wrap up today's passage, the scene plays out like a type of royal coronation, a type of kingly enthronement ritual, but it's absolutely laced with mockery of Jesus. A purple robe signifies royalty. A twisted crown of thorns might be mimicking a Roman crown of leaves. They're going to yell at him, hail king of Jews. Where normally they would have cried out, hail Caesar, hail Caesar. And here they mock him, hail king of the Jews. They strike him with a staff. Matthew tells us they first put it in his hand like a royal scepter. They spit on him. They fall to their knees in homage to him. How ironic. They declare Jesus is king, not realizing that truthfully, Jesus is king. Next week, we'll read that Jesus is enthroned on a cross. He will be misinterpreted by religious leaders as proof that this was not the Messiah. He didn't conquer those in power, the Romans. He failed to deliver them. Pilate will take this cross and crucifixion as proof that he can't be king. He is no king who can't save himself. For the disciples, they might have thought, he can't be king. All hope is lost. But we know Jesus is Messiah. He is king and he is savior. So to bring this to a conclusion, I just want to ask each of you, we maybe suspended judgment amidst the ambiguity of his answer from before. But as you think about Jesus in his life, in his death, is he your king? Have you sworn absolute allegiance to that king? What do you believe? As you come and go, as you walk in and out of family and friends and holidays, as you engage with our community and our politics, what do you believe? Where do your allegiances rest? Who ultimately has sway over your heart? We'll invite the worship team forward. We're going to get a chance to worship God in closing. And as we do, I want to open up the table for those who have sworn allegiance to Jesus. The table is a cracker and some juice. But it is a weekly remembrance that we've sworn allegiance to Jesus in his death. The cracker is his body broken and the juice is his blood shed for us. We also have the chance to be prayed for. It's a way to remember that Jesus intercedes. And so these people are given as trustworthy people to intercede on your behalf, to pray for you, to lift up your needs. One of the ways that we respond is through giving of our resources, to say thanks to God, or we respond in worship to say thanks to God for what he has done. Typically, this is where I like to have us all bow heads and pray, gonna do something a little bit different. In a moment, I'm gonna ask you to stand. And what we're going to do together before we sing those final two songs, before we take communion, is we're going to say together a prayer. And that prayer is a mashed up combination of two historic creeds. The Apostles' Creed and the Nicene Creed, which just essentially is proclaiming, this is who God is. This is who we understand God to be, how he's revealed himself and his word and his cross. This is the king that we've sworn allegiance to and it's going to end with amen and then we're just going to go right into worship so with that i invite you to stand and to pray with me. I believe in one God, the Father Almighty, maker of heaven and earth, of all things, visible and invisible. I believe in one Lord Jesus Christ, the only begotten Son of God. For us men and for our salvation, he came down from heaven by the Holy Spirit, was incarnate of the Virgin Mary and became man. For our saint, he was crucified under Pontius Pilate suffered death and was buried and rose again on the third day in accordance with the scriptures. He ascended into heaven seated at the right hand of the Father. He will come again in glory the judge of living and the death and his kingdom will have no end. I believe in the Holy Spirit the Lord, the giver of life who proceeds from the Father and the Son with the Father and the Son is adored and glorified, who is spoken through the prophets. I believe in one holy, Catholic, and apostolic church, and invest one baptism for the forgiveness of sins, and I look forward to the resurrection of the day, and the life of the world to come. Amen.