TRANSCRIPTION 🔗
Ryan Stern (00:00):
I think potentially that we are swinging a little bit back more into user curation or control of what you're seeing and not as much just purely like, "Hey, the algorithm's going to do all the work for you. You don't have to worry about anything here. I'm just going to send you everything you want." I think that we're naturally curious as humans and we are naturally relationship oriented, and so there really does need to be a balance.
Natalie Silverstein (00:27):
Creators aren't just another media channel. They're influencing everything from product development and creative strategy to paid media, cultural relevance, and how brands build relationships with their consumers. The biggest shift in creator marketing may not be what's happening on the platforms. It might be what's happening inside the organizations themselves. Today I'm talking with Ryan Stern, co-founder and CEO of Collectively, a leading creator marketing agency that's been around since 2013, long before most brands started taking the practice seriously. So here's what I want her perspective on. If creators are becoming central to marketing, do brand leaders need to rethink how their teams and strategies are structured? This is Collectively Verified, a creator marketing podcast. I'm Natalie Silverstein. Let's get into it. I am so happy to have Ryan Stern, co-founder and CEO of Collectively. Ryan, how you doing?
Ryan Stern (01:17):
I'm doing well. Thank you for having me. I'm very excited to be here.
Natalie Silverstein (01:20):
Yeah, excited to have you. So we're going to talk a lot about how you started this agency, what you're seeing in the space today, and where you think things are going across all the different dimensions of the creator economy and really specifically creator marketing. But why don't we start by taking it back to the beginning and to 2013 when you founded this organization, can you tell us a little bit about what the impetus was for that and what you were seeing in the market that really drove you to take that risk?
Ryan Stern (01:50):
Yeah, absolutely. So going back to 2013, the creator economy and the creator landscape as we know it today was very, very different. And at the time I was working with my co-founder, Alexa, at an MCN, essentially, a multichannel network, an ad network where our bloggers and YouTubers were working with us to monetize their channel, mostly through banners, popups that no one really liked. It was a really media focused revenue partnership. And we'd been working in this way for about six years, bringing our ad clients, our media buying clients, added value through our creators. So what that looked like is you might do a media buy and we might work with those creators to get a few additional blog posts that integrated your brand or talked about the product in a creative way more on the editorial side. So it was really kind of advertorial is the way I like to think of it.
(02:45):
I have a magazine publishing background and so we were really focused on those kind of unique advertorial partnerships that sat outside of the ad buy. And in 2012, we noticed that clients and our advertising community, they actually wanted to buy more of the content. The content was working really well, but it was early days of what is now social media and the creator economy. And so we noticed that trend and we started doing more and more content partnerships. And at the time, Instagram, Facebook, Pinterest, Vine, when Vine was alive. And so it was really bloggers and YouTubers at this moment. And the content piece was becoming more interesting and more valuable to our brand advertising community. And we were sort of in the halls showing the numbers and getting really excited to blow this partnership style out of the water and say, "Hey, let's sell more content.
(03:34):
Let's build models around that." And we weren't really taken very seriously, even though it was one of the fastest growing revenue lines. We were actually starting to charge for it. It wasn't just added value anymore, but the inherent business model was built on rev shares. And at the time, media was also going through a massive commoditization and the rates and the CPMs that a blogger or YouTuber could get for banner ads was going down. The monetization wasn't as lucrative for those partners. They didn't just want to put five more banners on their blog posts to make more money. And so it was a disruptive moment in the space. And I remember Alexa and I sat down and had a conversation and said, "We're really good at bringing the right creators to the right brands. And if the brands want to work with the creators to make content, maybe we should just try that as a business and consult and help them find the right creators and sell just the content piece if this kind of organization doesn't want to sell content, that's not what they're interested in." And so we sat down and we were having drinks and we said, "Hey, let's try this.
(04:35):
I think we can do it." And we cheersed and we said, let's try it. Let's start what we thought was going to be a small consulting firm. And that was 13 years ago.
Natalie Silverstein (04:43):
Amazing. So take us into the room and some of those early meetings that you had with potential clients. What was the vibe? What was the conversation about? What did that look like?
Ryan Stern (04:52):
Yeah, it was so interesting because we launched on LinkedIn with a LinkedIn post and had a very basic website and were really interested to see what would happen next. We kind of put all this thought into this. We created the name collectively because we really believed in bringing brand and creator together, which we still absolutely believe in today. And we had no idea what was going to happen. And as soon as we posted that, we had friends reach out and say, oh my gosh, we're so glad you did this because we have been sitting here in these offices wondering how we can work with you
Load full transcript
again. You created great content opportunities and packages. And we were like, wow, if only there was a company that just did that. And that was our early receptive kind of friends and family network, but that turned into a paid partnership with Ford within two months of us launching the company.
(05:43):
And we ran a six-month long program focused on bringing the Ford Fiesta kind of custom content through YouTubers together with a team there. And we knew we were onto something and each meeting we would have, it was mostly PR and communications teams saying, oh my gosh, we're so glad you're here. This is such a pain point for us. It is so hard to figure out who to work with, if they should be posting on blogs, how much we should pay for tweets at the time, if we should be testing Pinterest, if so, how? And so we really understood that the space was changing. Creators were multichannel publishers. It was not just a blog or a YouTube channel that creative publishers were more managing. And so many more people were coming into the creator economy at the time and messing around on Instagram and starting to create a real brand and business around their creativity.
(06:33):
So the time was really right, but we also very much closed a gap in the market, which was that there was no creator agency that was focused on servicing the brand side outside of the media network model at the time. So we quickly grew and just continued to really work in that space.
Natalie Silverstein (06:52):
How much do you think being in San Francisco had to do with the early success? Just knowing that, again, going back to the early 2010s in San Francisco, it was sort of beginnings of web 2.0, several bubbles back or trends back, but I'm curious if you equate any of our success as collectively to just being in the epicenter of that tech boom.
Ryan Stern (07:13):
Absolutely. I mean, there is an optimism and an entrepreneurialism here that is, I feel like unmatched in the sense of breaking some rules, doing things differently. I came from Conde Nast where we do not have bloggers contributing to the magazine at the time. It was very much old school publications and they were incredible. They still are incredible, but it was a really different model and novel at the time that an independent creator could decide to create their own channel, generate advertising, and actually command upwards of the reach of vogue.com in the matter of a year. And so the space was changing. And what was really fun about that is ideating around different ways that we could bring a creative profession to talented individuals who had a point of view. And that wasn't necessarily intense journalism, but this was lifestyle. And you could connect with people for the first time through social media and leave a comment and have a direct relationship with the creator.
(08:11):
I think in the editorial world, everything is very closed off and exclusive and you don't always get to have a relationship with the
author or the creator. And so I think all of that energy really prompted different ways of thinking and taking some risks. I mean, when we first started doing this, there were headlines in the New York Times about how brands don't trust bloggers. And a lot of folks were like, "What's a blogger? Why do we care about this?" And you fast-forward 25 years and here we are today and the creator economy is just unparalleled in terms of the way that creators and humans can connect directly to audiences on behalf of brands. So I do think San Francisco DNA had a big part in this. And I also come from a family of entrepreneurs and small business owners, and so I think I got a lot of healthy advice about just try to do it on your own.
(08:59):
What would stop you? What can you do if you have an idea and you want to do it on your own or you can't access that in the company that you're in? Go ahead and try.
Natalie Silverstein (09:08):
I also wonder if being pretty far from the Madison Avenue advertising agencies, traditional advertising agencies also, and traditional creative agencies at that time and not having that DNA, the kind of agency life background coming to collectively, how does that impact our success and the success of the business overall?
Ryan Stern (09:29):
Also, I think really, I didn't know it at the time, but I'd never worked at an agency. I don't have any personal experience working in more of the traditional agency environment and neither did Alexa. And when the two of us came together, again, we kind of had the benefit and the freedom of just how do we want to do this? What does an agency for us look like? What are the principles we can manage and lead around and how can we set a different tone for an agency? Because one of the reasons we hadn't worked at agencies is they had a terrible reputation for working conditions and you're working constantly and it's a grind and it takes forever to have any upward mobility. And I think there was just some negative connotations we had, whether that was accurate for all agencies or not, but we knew we had an opportunity when starting our own company that we can set a tone that we decide.
(10:13):
And I think that not having the imprint of historical places that we'd worked at was a benefit and that we didn't have a preexisting blueprint. So I think that's been a benefit and sort of a cultural differentiator for collectively as we've become the agency we are today and something that I'm very proud of.
Natalie Silverstein (10:31):
Yeah. It seems like not having tradition to be standing on has really been embedded in the DNA of the company. Yeah. Constant innovation because there's like, well, this industry didn't exist. Yeah, we've really helped make it. So everybody sort of has a hand in making it and let's focus on being good to each other, being good to our clients, being good to creators and just making this industry bigger, right?
Ryan Stern (10:58):
Absolutely. And I think creators for a while were like the underdogs, right? They're not seen as the creative professionals in the industry as many were. And I've always loved the underdog and seeing a lot of talent create just really incredible content and work and opportunities for themselves and their families through social media and the creator economy. And so that's important to me and it's equally important that collectively we really brought the spirit of that together with our brand marketers who are equally as passionate about the brands and the products that they're working at and want to communicate with creators through the authenticity of real people that are following these creators. And so I've always been attracted to opportunities to bring those groups together for the benefit of the consumer and having that kind of trusted dialogue. And a lot of people ask me what's changed?
(11:51):
And one thing that hasn't changed in the industry is the commitment of the creator to maintain their audience integrity. And so that's something I really love in creator marketing is that brand is coming to the table, creator is coming to the table. The creator is really the arbiter of what the audience is looking for and wants and knows their audience. They kind of know the boundaries of, well, I'm not just going to be able to talk about any brand. It really has to feel real. And I think that still is maintained today in the best creator marketing partnerships.
Natalie Silverstein (12:23):
Yeah. I'm curious if you think that there are shifts that are happening just with the proliferation of different types of creator marketing from channel perspective, platform perspective, brands are partnering with everyone from streamers on things like Twitch to even live selling that's happening on TikTok or on Instagram. Well, less on Instagram, but on TikTok to big, almost like celebrities essentially, the line between celebrity and digital celebrity or influencer is super blurry now, all the way down to things like affiliates and the long tail of creator marketing. Would you say that the relationship has shifted at all between brands or how brands are really thinking about managing all those relationships?
Ryan Stern (13:02):
Back in 2013, influencer marketing was adding an influencer program onto a campaign after it had been produced, there's a TV spot, there's creative, and then you have the creator component. And what's really changed is I think more and more brands are putting creators in the center of their planning conversations. They're thinking long-term. They understand that creator in a way is like digital. It needs to be kind of core to how you're thinking about communicating and in every marketing channel. And even between digital and out of home or experiences, there's a role that a creator plays now today in every part of your marketing mix. And so that is a fundamental change and that has required marketing organizations to change around that to really unlock the potential of
the creator, whether that's early R&D input and conversation about what products or product collaborations we should be launching all the way through to who is starring in your TV spot and is that more of a digital celebrity versus a model or actor?
(14:01):
And so it really has changed the way we think about creator marketing and the permeability of creators to show up in multiple channels is challenging to keep tabs on. That's something that we really like to do for our clients long term is really help build their communities over time and help answer the question of which creator, for which channel, for which initiative? Where can we unlock that partnership value? Because there are several ways to do that well.
Natalie Silverstein (14:27):
You mentioned that brands have to be organized slightly differently than they used to be or very differently than they used to be to be able to manage creator marketing.What are you seeing the best brands doing in terms of their teams and the way they're divvying up the work?
Ryan Stern (14:39):
Yeah, so I think that's a great question. What we're seeing in I think the brands that are winning and really unlocking that creator potential across so many different channels is removing some of the silos and planning and operating a little differently. And so an example would be that you have brands now bringing kind of a creator specialist or a creator lead that is helping connect dots between what the social team is creating for their channels and what the communications and PR team might be doing to push a message out and what the paid team is doing and thinking about, okay, we have creator content, we've licensed creator content. What media buys should that go into? How is that performing? Who's communicating that back in to make sure that if a creator's content is doing really well in a paid capacity, that we understand that and we're reactivating that creator.
(15:30):
Maybe we're asking them to do more assets and not necessarily asking them to do more sponsored content or a combination of both. So the right brands are understanding that a deep understanding of the creator economy needs to sit inside of the team and needs to really be a connector role in the organization. It can't just be tucked into one marketing channel or another. So that's one thing we're seeing. We're also seeing greater connectivity between what we say is creator upper funnel content that's going out in feed and the media relationship and how that's getting boosted and distributed and that's impacting creative. So again, it's really kind of a dot connecting role and we're seeing our marketing organizations reorient around that shift because it is kind of a red thread that cuts across so many disciplines within marketing.
Natalie Silverstein (16:16):
Yeah. In a way, it reminds me of early days of just digital marketing. It used to be like digital was sort of its own thing and then it just became kind of a part of almost everything.
There's some digital dimension. Would you say that that's something similar to what you're seeing with creator?
Ryan Stern (16:30):
Very similar. And I think once upon a time there was digital accelerators and leaders who really said, "Hey, I'm going to evangelize for the acceleration of thinking this way in the organization." And we see that today too. That's one of the things we do at Collectively is really tap into more of an acceleration way of thinking and work with key leaders to say, okay, if we want to go from activating a hundred creators a year to 4,000, and this is kind of a real life example, what would that look like? How would we set the teams up to manage that scale, to manage their agencies to that scale? It requires looking at ways of working, reporting connectivity. And then now we have CMOs or leaders that are across several brands and they're all activating several creators, several thousand. So from an enterprise perspective, is everyone reporting generally the same metrics?
(17:19):
Does brand A report the same way brand B does so that it can roll up to a senior business leader and say, this is the output we were able to drive from this channel? So I think that's something that we're really well positioned to help organizations through that change, establish best practices, make sure that is rolled out not just across one brand, but across several brands and make sure that it's working as hard as it can for your business. That's one of the things that we take very seriously and see the potential for creator to really bring efficiencies and really strong marketing impact to the business.
Natalie Silverstein (17:51):
So a brand that's doing all of that creator marketing, what are we talking about in terms of budgets?
Ryan Stern (17:58):
I mean, they're significant and I'm
Natalie Silverstein (18:02):
Laughing. I'm just wanting to understand where it started in 2013, what was the typical budget versus junk report? We
Ryan Stern (18:09):
Were happy to do a $50,000 campaign add-on. And I think now a big brand that is marketing in North America, we're seeing eight figures is not unheard of annually on creator marketing. And that depends on the level of celebrity that you might be tapping into. It can get even bigger. And so I think what we see now is actually the deployment of investment. So let's say a brand has a $8 million annual influencer budget. We're seeing that be divided and deployed in different creator channels. So there's the affiliate programming that is happening. There is the awareness and brand communications work, more advertising work that is happening. We have our events, we have out of home. Creators are in all of that. Then that's kind of sequenced and there's always on content. You always have to be playing in trend. And we have a lot of agility budgets where if we see something on social that's sort of popping, we want to make sure a creator can build on that quickly.
(19:08):
So we might have a team
of 10 creators ready to go, understands the brand and can play in social very quickly. We talk about that as agility or trend always on programming. So there's so much different programming that is happening to take that kind of annual investment and make sure we're flexing in at key moments. We're sort of everywhere the brand needs to be. We're with our gamers, we're with our lifestyle parents, we're with our fashion and beauty cohorts. I think today there's a lot of kind of niche cultural opportunities for brands in social media. And so it's less about what the big campaign is and more about can you execute several really small but highly visible and fun campaigns that catch with a creator in the feed.
Natalie Silverstein (19:54):
It's interesting that you say that focusing on content that catches is the most important thing. I think there's been such a shift in the way that many of the social platforms, particularly the video platforms, operate from an algorithmic perspective where mostly content is being served not necessarily to a creator's followers, but to people who are interested in that type of content. These systems are just becoming much more sophisticated in terms of identifying what this piece of content is and who's going to like it. So in a world where, okay, we move from focusing on a creator's specific following to a creator's content mainly and really focusing on entertaining and breaking through, how does that change how you think about strategy or how the teams act collectively are engaging with selecting creators?
Ryan Stern (20:42):
That's a great question. I think it's raising the bar on the content creator expectation to be more entertaining and to be more creative. So we see a lot of experimentation around this. And then when we know, for example, a really unique format that a creator might come up with, that is going to feel a little different. It's going to pop in the feed. And so how are we A, encouraging creators to think a little differently about content all the time? I think that's kind of part of the job. And then B, how are we looking at results and unpacking what's working really well and saying, "Hey, there's some creative themes here." So everything from how many seconds in we need a really strong creative hook to, "Oh, we're noticing that when we use this type of green screen creative format to talk about this message, we're getting through." We're actually seeing more in comment feed about that message.
(21:31):
And so people are paying attention in that format a little differently. So there's different ways to evaluate, I think, success and I think engagement rate, view rate are so great, but don't overlook the comment feed because I think there's kind of two audiences in a way for a creator. There's the audience that gets served your content because it's like content that they've liked from other creators, and that needs to be entertaining and can kind of look at more of an engagement or view rate model. But then there's your core audience is like, "I really like this creator, so I'm going to come find their content. I want to make sure I don't miss any of their content." And they're leaving comments about that content that are really, really valuable for a brand marketer to understand. And so when we do a sponsored content post with that creator and we're seeing their core audience give us feedback about the product, oh my gosh, I never knew this existed or that looks amazing, we're seeing that there's a really good value in that stream of comments.
(22:24):
And so we like to look at both, I think is another way to think of it.
Natalie Silverstein (22:27):
Yeah. The comments are almost like an experience unto themselves on the social platforms now. Sometimes I look over people's shoulders when I'm traveling, I'm just watching them watch content and see how they interact, not to be a stalker on my fellow seatmates on my flights, but it is interesting just to watch flipping through videos, how quickly do people go and actually look at the comments? Same for on e-comm, people look at the comments about a product. We want to know what other people think.
Ryan Stern (22:53):
Yeah, absolutely.
Natalie Silverstein (22:55):
That's an interesting dynamic. And I think depending on the platform, the comments are really entertaining and in and of themselves and there's engagement happening there. There's, as you were saying, product insights that can be derived from there. Unmet customer needs can sometimes come out of that. We've seen really interesting creative ideas for content series or again, even product innovation has come from the conversation that is happening online, like social listening more broadly. I feel like creator marketing is just, it's kind of like a nucleus for a lot of these other dimensions of the social web just because creators are sort of the language of social platforms. And as people go to those tools less to connect with their family and friends and more to watch and be entertained or learn, there's just these interesting new dynamics that are possible. Yeah,
Ryan Stern (23:40):
Absolutely.
Natalie Silverstein (23:41):
As things are maturing and evolving, AI is obviously a big part of everything that's happening. And I think brands are increasingly curious about AI as it intersects with creator marketing. They are asking about what do we think about AI creators? What do we think about AI in the feed? Curious if you just have perspectives on where you think things are going in that respect.
Ryan Stern (24:05):
Yeah, I mean, there's a lot of different, I think, reactions happening around AI and AI content in the feed. I think right now, I think, again, one of the biggest values of creator marketing is that it feels very real and it's trusted and there's sort of this one-to-one human relationship aspect. So I think that inherently is intention with AI to a degree. And what we're seeing is that for right now at least,
AI is becoming really an accelerant and a tool that a creator has access to, is leveraging in their content creation process. As an agency, there is technology and tools and systems that help us do our work better and faster. And so we are very much embracing AI technologies where possible, but we haven't seen it really take over in terms of developing a trusted audience relationship. And so we get this question a lot of like, oh my gosh, are there going to be just a bunch of AI creators and it's just going to be fake people?
(25:01):
And I'm like, I don't think so. I think there's going to continue to be a lot of experimentation around how AI contributes to the process of creating something engaging that someone wants to engage with. But I think a big part of social media is that it is social and when there's a person or a personality that you have a sense of a relationship with. And so
(25:23):
I think it's a little too early to say exactly what's going to happen on the AI creator front, but we're definitely seeing a lot of creativity come out of the tools. And I think it's really interesting to think about some of the just production opportunities. So if a creator has an idea and they want to put a bunch of their looks, what would this look like in a different city? How can I bring some different creativity to my content experience? And that provides value to my readers or listeners or subscribers or followers. I think that's where we're at right now, and I am continuing to see a lot of experimentation and fun come out of that. And then I think it's really the wild west, and so there's a lot to discuss around disclosure and whether or not it's clear enough if it isn't a person, that are we saying that it's not a person.
(26:14):
And there's different levels of disclosure and approaches of the different platforms we're taking. So I think there's a lot to still be seen in those discussions and where we land on that. But yeah, it's good to think about.
Natalie Silverstein (26:26):
Yeah, it is. I feel like the ground is sort of shifting underneath everybody. Every three or four months, it feels like there's a major paradigm shift in just what is possible with different AI tools and how accessible they are. So I think my observation - And it's
Ryan Stern (26:40):
Moving so fast. It's moving so fast. I think that's what's unique about this moment in time because again, I think about, oh, once upon a time we didn't have FTC disclosure and then we had FTC disclosure. And I think the pace of going from the rise of influencer marketing in a meaningful way as an industry and then having the FTC have a point of view on that, and then the pace of how fast AI is changing and is how we can keep up with the pace is unique, I think, to this moment in time.
Natalie Silverstein (27:10):
So knowing that there's all this new content flooding into feeds, the way that creators are discovered is really different now depending on the platform based on the algorithm. I'm curious where you see creators really building the most durable audience relationships because there is still so much value in that true trusted relationship. What platforms do you feel like are interesting in that respect?
Ryan Stern (27:31):
Yeah, so this is such a great question. I love this question. And I actually, whenever I'm out and about and I see people who are younger than me, which is a lot of them now, I'm always curious where they're spending time. And it's interesting because lately what I have been hearing from, I would say probably the Gen Z cohort, they're not on TikTok as much anymore. They're saying, oh yeah, we're not really as interested in TikTok. We're really doubling down on Instagram, on Reddit, and on Substack. And that was surprising to me, and I sort of was asking why. I didn't realize how common it was to run a lot of college projects through Substack and use that as a communication tool in early career communications with friends. And then what is interesting is that I think with Instagram, there is still a little bit more of that community orientation and your ability to follow the stories of the people you're choosing.
(28:20):
And the algorithm is still there and I think the reels experience, but what I was hearing some of these young folks tell me is that they prefer that duality over just the, I'm mostly going to see what the algorithm is telling me I should see. And I sort of think potentially that we are swinging a little bit back more into user curation or control of what you're seeing and not as much just purely like, "Hey, the algorithm's going to do all the work for you. You don't have to worry about anything here. I'm just going to send you everything you want." I think that we're naturally curious as humans and we are naturally relationship oriented. And so there really does need to be a balance and we'll probably see platform experimentation around that. And then Reddit is a whole different beast, but just so much passion and ideas and communications and conversations.
(29:09):
And so I think it wasn't surprising to hear that they're spending a lot of time in Reddit.
Natalie Silverstein (29:15):
Interesting. So how do you think brands then should be thinking about these spaces, like Reddit and Substack in particular? I'm curious if you've seen any experimentation there, sort of ways that brands can be participating in Reddit without being kicked out of subreddits by mods who are just like, "This is that," right?
Ryan Stern (29:30):
Yeah. I think we have to experiment. We have to find how to be where our customer is. And so I would say don't stop experimenting and take some risks. They need to be calculated risk. But I think social media and the different platforms allow us to experiment a bit and find out what's resonating. We don't have to sprint at Reddit. We can start with one test. And we've done this with some of our clients where you have to really rip the bandaid off and be
okay with some real talk and be okay with a little bit less control. And in that, I think there is a lot of power in the brand saying like, "Hey, we are okay if there are different opinions about us and our brand in these forums and these environments," because that's sort of expected, right? There's discussion and debate that happens in these experiences.
(30:16):
And so I think to play in that well it comes from a position of strength. And so I think brands can think about how can I be strong and bold in these communities and how can that be a value add to my creators as opposed to just not being there? Because someone is going to decide to go in and play and if you're not there and your competitor is, then there could be a lost customer. And so just continually think about evolving and taking some risks. And the internet gives you feedback. So take the feedback and do it in a calculated way, but don't be afraid of that.
Natalie Silverstein (30:50):
So you're lucky to have a lot of legacy brands and storied companies that have been meaningful in people's lives for decades, let's say, Americans' lives for the most part. Those are our clients. How do you think they respond when they see innovative upstarts that don't have the weight of that legacy on them, participating in spaces, taking big creative risks, working with really unexpected creators? What's the conversation that you hear amongst clients when they're seeing that? How are they navigating, advocating for taking bigger risks or bigger swings with their leadership or just navigating the kind of brand transformation that's required to operate in this current landscape?
Ryan Stern (31:31):
I mean, I think nothing will get a heritage organization to move faster than healthy competition. And so I think the smart marketers, these companies, they're seeing what's happening and really thinking about, okay, we're a different company and we have some different ways that we're set up and constraints, but how do we think differently and how do we push for that thinking? And so I think it is continually a conversation and saying, okay, what are we learning? How are we then thinking about what that might change in our strategy and how we're playing where we can own as a brand, but maybe play a little differently in taking some risks and feed or thinking a little bit differently about how to talk to different customers in different feeds? I think some of these teams are thinking then they're really having to push internally for that agility and the ones that are really pushing for that and using the data and saying, this is what's happening, this is where we're losing market share, here are some marketing tacks that these companies are taking.
(32:27):
I think we need to play louder here. I think we have an opportunity to move over here. I think that is the work we see our clients doing and doing well.
Natalie Silverstein (32:34):
The perception of cultural relevance, accent on perception is so important because that perception can be driven by relatively small budgets, relatively few activations, but that have the ability to really break out. I think that's where some of the challenger brands are really successful against the behemoth marketers that are spending hundreds of millions of dollars a year on media. It's really an interesting leveling of the playing field in a way.
Ryan Stern (33:03):
Yeah, I think some of the newer breakout startup brands, they have speed, they have small teams, they're making quick decisions. They
Natalie Silverstein (33:11):
Don't have much to lose, frankly, and taking big swings, right?
Ryan Stern (33:14):
Yeah, exactly. And I think customers are receptive to that. They're, I think, more forgiving for a newer brand that is just starting out and figuring things out. And so again, I think it's good pressure to keep us sharp in terms of how we're showing up and how we can push the boundaries of creativity and communication in the face of pressure and competition. But there are going to be different sets of constraints across both teams.
Natalie Silverstein (33:42):
Rounding us out here, I'd love to get a little bit of your advice. Can we ask guests to share some of their wisdom, knowing that we have a lot of marketers who are listening to this, folks who are really in deep in creative marketing. So first, what's one thing that most brands are still really getting completely wrong about creator marketing?
Ryan Stern (34:00):
I think undervaluing the comment feed. We talked about this a little bit earlier, but I still think there's not enough emphasis and focus on what we're learning from the actual conversation. And I think if we got in a room and we really unpacked the comment feed more and looked at those insights, I think a lot of opportunity and creative ideas are sitting in that feed.
Natalie Silverstein (34:22):
If you had to give listeners three changes to make right now to their creator marketing strategy, what might they be?
Ryan Stern (34:28):
Yeah, and this kind of goes back to what we were talking about earlier, Natalie, but break more rules, take more risks, I think in general, and really experiment beyond the Instagram, TikTok, YouTube go-tos. Push your teams to experiment and find out how you should be showing up in secondary platforms. I think that's really important. And then I think one change too is really empower and be bolder in how you define for your brand what it means to be in community with your creators. I think that the creator marketing has started from a point of view of a relationship and trust, and I don't think that we invest enough in maintaining that sense of human relationship, events, recognition, engaging with the creators outside of the job or the hire or the post. I think that as more tech transformation and disruption happens, creators will be seeking that human connection and brands are a big part of that picture for them today.
(35:31):
And so really
thinking through, are we disrupting that now? Are we thinking differently about how we show up in community with our creator community? Because I think that will be a differentiator for brands going forward.
Natalie Silverstein (35:42):
What is your boldest prediction for where creator marketing will be in five years?
Ryan Stern (35:48):
New apps, new platforms we haven't even dreamed of. And again, going back to 2010, it was all about the blogs and we do not talk about blogs today. So I think with the pace of change in five years, we could be doing creator marketing on entirely new platforms. And I think that's a little wild to think about, but also fun. What will the internet and people come up with next?
Natalie Silverstein (36:12):
Okay, wild card. Who's a follow that you recommend?
Ryan Stern (36:15):
On a more personal one, so I'm a mom of two, and so I have been following more Reddit conversations specifically that are like age and behaviors of your tween and just leveraging that community for the shared parenting experience. I find that for me, I'm doing less of that on Instagram because I need a break from visuals and for people talking at me. And I really appreciate, I'm talking to people all day, I'm looking at content all day, and I just want to, with my cup of tea, understand how other moms or dads or parents are engaging in this interesting place that we are raising teenagers in this world, whether that's when to get an iPhone or when not to get an iPhone. There's so many things you have to navigate as a parent. So being able to just read that and absorb the conversation is one of my favorite ways to be on social media today.
Natalie Silverstein (37:14):
I love that. I think thinking about where your nervous system is, having that kind of dictate which platform you're spending time on and having lots of modes I think is amazing, right?
Ryan Stern (37:25):
Yeah. And some days I've been on Instagram or TikTok. Again, I love all the platforms for different reasons and it's our business, but sometimes you're on it and you might see content that doesn't help your nervous system and it wasn't by choice. And so I do feel a little bit of like I can gain a sense of control over what I want to learn about and how I'm going to do that on Reddit. So that can be where I'm spending a little bit of my personal time.
Natalie Silverstein (37:47):
Love that. Well, Ryan Stern, thank you so much. It was so great to chat with you and appreciate your time.
Ryan Stern (37:53):
Yes, Natalie, always a pleasure. I loved the conversation and thank you so much for having me.
Natalie Silverstein (37:58):
You're welcome. So Ryan's perspective makes one thing pretty clear. Creator marketing hasn't just gotten bigger, it's become something fundamentally different. When creators were just an add-on to a campaign, it may have made sense to manage them like a channel. I think when they're influencing product development, creative, paid media, PR, cultural relevance, consumer insights, et cetera, that model starts to break down. And that's the shift I think marketers need to pay attention to. You can't put creators at the center of your marketing strategy while keeping them at the edges of your organization. The brands that are getting ahead are connecting teams, breaking down silos, and building creator expertise into the way marketing decisions get made. And as Ryan pointed out, we've seen this transition before with digital. Eventually something becomes so fundamental that it stops belonging to one team and starts shaping how everybody works. So maybe the next evolution of creator marketing isn't another platform or format or technology, it's actually organizational.
(39:00):
That's what I'm going to carry forward from this conversation. If you enjoyed this episode, follow and subscribe for more conversations with the leaders shaping creator marketing. You can also find us at collectivelyinc.com to learn more about our work. I'm Natalie Silverstein and this is Collectively Verified. Thanks so much for listening. If you enjoyed this episode, follow and subscribe for more conversations with the leaders who are shaping Creator Marketing. You can also find us at collectivelyinc.com to learn more about our work. I'm Natalie Silverstein and this is Collectively Verified. Thanks for listening.