TRANSCRIPTION 🔗
00:00:01
Speaker 1: Welcome to BrainStuff, a production of iHeart Podcasts. Hey BrainStuff, Lauren Vogelbaum here. The enduring image of Sparta, that of a brutal and uncultured military society hell-bent on producing the world's toughest soldiers, doesn't tell the full story of this city-state that briefly ruled ancient Greece around the 5th century BCE. In fact, it's almost impossible for us to know the real Sparta, Everything written about Sparta, and there's plenty, was penned by outsiders and enemies, particularly Athenians. Not a single text written by a Spartan author from the height of Sparta's power, that is, from around 550 to 350 BCE, has survived the millennia. For the article this episode is based on, HowStuffWorks spoke with historian Nigel Kennell, author of the 2010 book Spartans, A New History. He said, We have lots of people telling us what the Spartans think, but we don't know what the Spartans themselves believe, so we have a distorted picture. And people outside Sparta like to use Sparta as a way of working out their own intellectual, philosophical, and political prejudices. This distorted, outsider view of Sparta has created what historians call the Spartan Mirage, and is responsible for the two opposing myths passed down through history— that Sparta was either a utopian society based on communal harmony and obedience, or a dystopian totalitarian regime. Kennel says that neither one is likely true, or at least that we don't have reliable sources to back up either conclusion. The only real way to talk about Sparta is to compare it to Athens, which was its enemy in the Peloponnesian War, which led to Sparta's brief dominance. Athens was also the only Greek city-state that wrote its own complete history. Kennell said, There were hundreds of Greek cities, but we have nothing from them. The only city that we can have a connected, detailed narrative about the internal affairs of is Athens. When you compare Athens to Sparta, they're quite different. But it's difficult to say how much more different Sparta was from Athens than it would have been from any other Greek city that was not a democracy. Yes, Athens was a democracy, meaning at the time that every free adult male citizen had the right to vote and to serve in political office. Sparta was ruled by kings, slightly oddly two kings at once, called a diarchy, and citizenship was reserved for a small segment of freeborn adult men who made the cut, called the Spartiates. Kennel said, Citizenship in Sparta was not so much a right as a privilege, and you could lose it. The first requirement for citizenship was passing through the compulsory training system. If you quit out, you were labeled inferior and denied the right to vote or serve in various governing bodies. The second way to lose citizenship was failure to keep up with monthly food and wine contributions to the Spartiates' communal dining halls, where citizens continued to eat late into adulthood. As Spartans, like many ancient
Load full transcript
Greeks, had a militaristic worldview, but Kennel thinks it's unfair to say that Spartan society was single-mindedly geared towards producing soldiers. He said, it's designed to produce citizens, and in Greek terms, being a warrior is an important part of being a citizen. Every able-bodied man fights for his city, and draft dodging is a severe crime, even in Athens. While some form of military training was common in Greek city-states, including Athens, Sparta professionalized the role of the soldier. All free-born, upper-class boys were educated and trained to be lifelong soldiers as well as dutiful citizens. Boys lived in groups with a leader and were deliberately underfed to encourage them to steal food and then were punished for disobedience, including being caught stealing. What's not true is that young Spartan boys were ripped away from their families and forced to spend the rest of their lives in military barracks. Rather, their training seems to have taken place on a part-time basis. Kennel said,' Spartans were very family-oriented. There is no reliable evidence that Spartan boys were taken away from their families when they were seven and brought up by themselves in barracks and never had any contact with their families.' Spartan boys and young men were educated in a relatively limited sense. Unlike Athens, where a well-rounded education included philosophy, natural sciences, and mathematics, the focus in Sparta was athletic and military. Athletics and warfare were considered closely related, and Spartan youth would have trained and competed in all of the standard ancient Greek sporting events— running, wrestling, boxing, throwing javelin, and probably archery— Later Greek writers also talk about strange contests and high-stakes games played by Spartan youth to prepare them for battle. The Greek historian Xenophon described a game played in the sanctuary of Artemis in which pieces of cheese were placed on the altar and two teams of boys tried to steal them, running through a gauntlet of whips. The thief of the most cheese won. Spartan boys were also famous dancers. They trained and rehearsed elaborate choral dances that were apparently a must-see for visiting writers and dignitaries. However, the dancing was not purely for artistic expression. It helped Spartan soldiers keep step when they marched and coordinate advanced maneuvers on the battlefield. But okay, what about Spartan women? Compared with Athens, upper-class women in Sparta had many more rights and freedoms. In Athens, the feminine ideal was to be neither seen nor heard. The Athenian statesman Pericles famously said, In many ancient Greek societies, upper-class women were expected to stay home, out of the public eye. But Spartan women could inherit, own, and manage their own land outright, and were known throughout ancient Greece for being outspoken and intelligent, as well as physically strong. They received educations and competed in athletic events publicly. Historians think
this was probably in the interests of creating a class of women who were capable of producing strong male children to become citizens and warriors. Still, they weren't often written about. even in our scant records of Sparta. The most famous Spartan woman may be Gorgo, a princess and the eventual queen of King Leonidas, who died with his infamously outnumbered 300 Spartan warriors. As a young girl, Gorgo reportedly saved her father's kingdom by instructing him to refuse a handsome bribe from a foreign official who kept upping the amount. According to the Greek historian Herodotus, Gorgo said, Father, your visitor is going to corrupt you if you don't get up and leave. Historian Helena Schrader wrote on her website, In no other Greek city but Sparta would a female of any age have been allowed to be present, much less heard and heeded, at a meeting between heads of state. Gorgo's advice was all the more remarkable because it was good, leading some people to quip that it was easier to bamboozle 30,000 Athenian men than one Spartan girl. Upper-class Spartan women married relatively late, after the age of 18. When they did, they acted as heads of their household, perhaps because full-citizen Spartan men were essentially lifelong soldiers. Citizens didn't do any other work. Their loyalty to the state was repaid with freedom from all other labor. But upper-class women didn't participate in traditional women's work either, like spinning, weaving, or household chores. So who did the rest of the labor? Spartan society was organized like a pyramid, with a small group of freeborn Spartans at the top. Below them were the periokoi, which means those who live around, or neighbors. The kingdom of Sparta was spread out across dozens of smaller towns and villages, and the periokoi lived there as skilled artisans, making textiles, armor, bronzework, and any goods intended for export. In the 7th and early 6th centuries BCE, there was a flowering of culture in Sparta led by these artisans. Kennel said, It's long been acknowledged that the best ivory work in 7th century Greece is from Sparta, and Spartan bronzes are really amazing. A big unanswered question for historians like Kennel is why this explosion of creativity ended in the late 6th century, when Spartans appeared to deliberately cultivate a reputation for being severe, uneducated, and uncultured. Whatever the case, the lowest segment of Spartan society was called the helots. This was an enslaved class that lived similar to medieval serfs, performing all manual labor from agriculture to construction. The name helot means the captured, and Kennel believes that many helots were the former people of neighboring Mycenae, which Sparta invaded and defeated in the 7th century BCE. As we said earlier, Sparta came to rule ancient Greece following its victory in the Peloponnesian War. This 27-year war between former allies, Sparta and Athens, dragged in pretty much the entire Greek world. partially because it had a lot to do with how Sparta and Athens treated each other's allies as the two powers shouldered for resources. Kennel thinks that in some ways, winning the war was the worst thing to happen to Sparta. Lysander, the Spartan naval hero, became the most powerful man in Greek, and he forced conquered states to swear allegiance not to Sparta, but to him. Then, Sparta tried and failed to conquer Persia, while their own Greek city-states grew increasingly frustrated under Spartan rule. In the span of a single lifetime, the golden age of Sparta came crashing down. Kennel said, Sparta didn't develop any mechanism to run this big empire. They didn't have the mindset to handle it. It was nothing like the Romans, who were very successful at co-opting local elites by dangling goodies in front of them. The Spartans just wanted obedience, and people didn't like to be treated that way. Sparta fell to Thebes in 371 BCE, and the Theban army later invaded Spartan lands and freed the captured realm of Mycenae, which was happy to help Sparta's enemies, having lived enslaved for so long. Without this important agricultural base, Sparta never recovered. Although it was a free city under Roman rule, and even popular among wealthy travelers and history buffs of the era, it was sacked in the 390s CE by the Visigoths, and its remaining people largely sought opportunity elsewhere. In modern Greece, the city has been revived as a center of art, history, and culture, with festivals throughout the year to celebrate what we know and still don't know about this mysterious spectacle of the ancient world. Today's episode is based on the article, How Sparta Turned Its Men Into Super Soldiers and Dancers, on HowStuffWorks.com, written by Dave Ruse. BrainStuff is a production of iHeart Podcasts in partnership with HowStuffWorks.com and is produced by Tyler Klang. For more shows from iHeart Podcasts, visit the iHeart Radio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you listen to your favorite shows.