TUNGKOL SA EPISODE NA ITO
How should we decide what laws to pass? Should majority rule, even when they are legislating values? Ken thinks this results in tyranny. What kinds of values are there? There are values that are essential to democracy, e.g. education. Ken introduces the guest, Anna Eshoo, congresswoman of the 14th district of California. Are we in a culture war? What are the casualties like in a culture war? Is the current political climate different than it historically has been? John points out that certain issues have always been contested, such as abortion.
What happens when the legislature does not act to support values it should? The Warren court ordering desegregation of the schools was not legislated but it was certainly a social good. Should we follows Rawls’s principle that only reasons acceptable to any reasonable person should be admitted when the government is involved? Eshoo thinks that Rawls’s principle is divorced from the way democracy actually works and so is not applicable. Do we need to distinguish between public and private spheres of values to allow the maximum number of citizens to be engaged politically? Is liberty or democracy a more fundamental American value? Eshoo thinks you can’t let one take precedence over the other. Both minority and majority desires are important.
Rawls thought that there was an overlapping consensus of opinion, a set of things that everyone could agree on. Legislation could proceed from that. Ken thinks that this is a problematic idea. Why should people agree to set aside fundamental beliefs in order to engage each other? Who is responsible for the divisions in society? Ken thinks the political class exploits these differences to destructive ends. Should people vote their values to the detriment of their economic status? How can we not vote our values?
Sixty-Second Philosopher (Seek to 05:20): Ian Shoales summarizes the history of Anthony Comstock’s anti-obescenity activities.
What happens when the legislature does not act to support values it should? The Warren court ordering desegregation of the schools was not legislated but it was certainly a social good. Should we follows Rawls’s principle that only reasons acceptable to any reasonable person should be admitted when the government is involved? Eshoo thinks that Rawls’s principle is divorced from the way democracy actually works and so is not applicable. Do we need to distinguish between public and private spheres of values to allow the maximum number of citizens to be engaged politically? Is liberty or democracy a more fundamental American value? Eshoo thinks you can’t let one take precedence over the other. Both minority and majority desires are important.
Rawls thought that there was an overlapping consensus of opinion, a set of things that everyone could agree on. Legislation could proceed from that. Ken thinks that this is a problematic idea. Why should people agree to set aside fundamental beliefs in order to engage each other? Who is responsible for the divisions in society? Ken thinks the political class exploits these differences to destructive ends. Should people vote their values to the detriment of their economic status? How can we not vote our values?
Sixty-Second Philosopher (Seek to 05:20): Ian Shoales summarizes the history of Anthony Comstock’s anti-obescenity activities.
Ingles
Estados Unidos
KOPYA NG SALIN 🔗
Are you the producer of this podcast?
Add a podcast transcript
Need Audio-to-Text?
Transcribe with Listen411 in Just 60 Seconds
I-SEARCH ANG MGA NAKARAANG EPISODE
I-search ang mga nakaraang episode ng Philosophy Talk.
IBA PANG MGA EPISOD SA PODCAST NA ITO
Moses Maimonides (also known as the Rambam) was a 12th century rabbi and scholar, most famous as the author of The Guide for the Perplexed. He thought that understanding the world through science and logic would lead you to knowledge, and that this in turn would lead you to love God. But is the wor…
The Philosophers talk to the authors of recent and forthcoming books that speak to our dangerous times:
Christopher Star from Middlebury College, editor of How to Face the End of the World: An Ancient Guide for Apocalyptic Times
Christian Miller from Wake Forest University, author of The Honest…
“You’re being unreasonable.” “Reasonable doubt.” The “reasonable person” standard. Talk of reasonableness is everywhere we turn, but what does it actually come to? What makes something reasonable, as opposed to unreasonable? And why does it matter? Could we hope for a society full of reasonable peo…
Hildegard von Bingen was a 12th century mystic, polymath, and composer whose work spanned visionary theology, philosophy, cosmology, medicine, botany, and music. Her extraordinary intellectual accomplishments belie her humble claim to be “just a woman”. Was her humility justified in the face of the…
Argentinian writer Jorge Luís Borges wrote some of the world’s most brilliant, mind-bending, and philosophical stories. Drawing on sources from Europe, India, China, and Persia, these stories tackled topics like time, reality, selfhood, and art. Yet Borges also said “I don’t think ideas are importa…
Paunawa: Ang podcast at artwork na naka-embed sa page na ito ay mula sa Philosophy Talk, na pag-aari ng may-ari nito at hindi kaakibat o ineendorso ng Listen Notes, Inc.
I-EDIT
Salamat sa pagtulong na mapanatiling naka-update ang database ng podcast.