درباره این اپیزود
Danielle Smith really loves fast trains. Especially as a distraction.
By David Climenhaga.
It's a three-hour drive from Edmonton to Calgary — maybe less with Alberta Transportation Minister Devin Dreeshen's new higher speed limits.
So does it really make sense to spend $38 billion or more to build a high-speed passenger-only rail system between the two cities?
Of course it doesn't.
But — what the hell? — Canadians love trains! Trains are just so romantic. In the 19th century they tied the country together — never mind for a moment that the country in question was Canada, which Alberta Premier Danielle Smith is making us all vote whether or not we want to leave on Oct. 19.
Smith really loves trains, especially when talking about them provides an opportunity for a nice distraction from the fine mess she's gotten herself into with the separation referendum that everybody hates almost as much as we all love trains.
Apparently Dreeshen loves trains too — even though he's working hard to let us all drive faster on even more of the Queen Elizabeth II Highway, which is how plain old Alberta Highway 2 is now known since Smith's United Conservative Party predecessor, Jason Kenney, renamed it in 2005 in a fit of royalist enthusiasm. (Not sure what the Alberta separatists he invited into the UCP, who want to set up a republic, think of that. They'd probably rename it the Donald J. Trump MAGAway if they could.)
Plus, of course, Smith's best-known rail adviser, David Moretta, also happens to be her husband. Indeed, the two of them used to run a restaurant in an old railcar in High River.
Anyway, now it even turns out that those formerly hated Liberals in Ottawa — still despised by the separatist base of Smith's United Conservative Party, of course — also want to build high-speed passenger trains. After all, they're what Prime Minister Mark Carney calls big nation-building projects, especially when they cost a fortune. (Environmental assessments? There's a plan for that, so you can stop worrying about 'em!)
So Smith and a phalanx of Alberta and federal officials got together at Heritage Park in Calgary Monday to pose for pictures and announce that "Alberta's government is preparing to launch a formal Request for Proposal (RFP) process this fall, inviting private-sector proponents to submit proposals for a downtown Calgary-Red Deer-downtown Edmonton high-speed rail project that also includes service to Alberta's two largest airports and the City of Airdrie."
Which, when you think about it, is a wordy way of announcing that nothing much at all is happening, but... look over there! High-speed train!
Continuing with the grand-sounding but not-really-all-that-impactful announcement, Smith said that a proponent will be named by next spring and the feds have promised the putative project will be referred to Ottawa's Major Projects Office.
"We are taking the next steps toward a project that could strengthen one of Canada's fastest-growing economic corridors and support Alberta's growth for decades to come," the premier enthused in her canned quote in the press release.
Just for toots and giggles, let's think about this idea.
If the train stops at Edmonton International Airport in Leduc, Red Deer for refreshments at the Donut Mill, Airdrie for reasons no one has thought up yet, Calgary International Airport and maybe somewhere in downtown Calgary, there's just no way you'll be able to get from one terminus city to the other faster on the train than you could in your car. And that doesn't count the time you'll need to spend going through airport-style security.
Plus, you'll still have to rent a car when you get where you're going, because there's not going to be a public transit system that works in either city for a very, very long time. (This is true notwithstanding the government's claim in its news release that the fast trains will "be integrated into existing passenger rail systems in Calgary and Edmonton.")
So it's unlikely the train can succ...
By David Climenhaga.
It's a three-hour drive from Edmonton to Calgary — maybe less with Alberta Transportation Minister Devin Dreeshen's new higher speed limits.
So does it really make sense to spend $38 billion or more to build a high-speed passenger-only rail system between the two cities?
Of course it doesn't.
But — what the hell? — Canadians love trains! Trains are just so romantic. In the 19th century they tied the country together — never mind for a moment that the country in question was Canada, which Alberta Premier Danielle Smith is making us all vote whether or not we want to leave on Oct. 19.
Smith really loves trains, especially when talking about them provides an opportunity for a nice distraction from the fine mess she's gotten herself into with the separation referendum that everybody hates almost as much as we all love trains.
Apparently Dreeshen loves trains too — even though he's working hard to let us all drive faster on even more of the Queen Elizabeth II Highway, which is how plain old Alberta Highway 2 is now known since Smith's United Conservative Party predecessor, Jason Kenney, renamed it in 2005 in a fit of royalist enthusiasm. (Not sure what the Alberta separatists he invited into the UCP, who want to set up a republic, think of that. They'd probably rename it the Donald J. Trump MAGAway if they could.)
Plus, of course, Smith's best-known rail adviser, David Moretta, also happens to be her husband. Indeed, the two of them used to run a restaurant in an old railcar in High River.
Anyway, now it even turns out that those formerly hated Liberals in Ottawa — still despised by the separatist base of Smith's United Conservative Party, of course — also want to build high-speed passenger trains. After all, they're what Prime Minister Mark Carney calls big nation-building projects, especially when they cost a fortune. (Environmental assessments? There's a plan for that, so you can stop worrying about 'em!)
So Smith and a phalanx of Alberta and federal officials got together at Heritage Park in Calgary Monday to pose for pictures and announce that "Alberta's government is preparing to launch a formal Request for Proposal (RFP) process this fall, inviting private-sector proponents to submit proposals for a downtown Calgary-Red Deer-downtown Edmonton high-speed rail project that also includes service to Alberta's two largest airports and the City of Airdrie."
Which, when you think about it, is a wordy way of announcing that nothing much at all is happening, but... look over there! High-speed train!
Continuing with the grand-sounding but not-really-all-that-impactful announcement, Smith said that a proponent will be named by next spring and the feds have promised the putative project will be referred to Ottawa's Major Projects Office.
"We are taking the next steps toward a project that could strengthen one of Canada's fastest-growing economic corridors and support Alberta's growth for decades to come," the premier enthused in her canned quote in the press release.
Just for toots and giggles, let's think about this idea.
If the train stops at Edmonton International Airport in Leduc, Red Deer for refreshments at the Donut Mill, Airdrie for reasons no one has thought up yet, Calgary International Airport and maybe somewhere in downtown Calgary, there's just no way you'll be able to get from one terminus city to the other faster on the train than you could in your car. And that doesn't count the time you'll need to spend going through airport-style security.
Plus, you'll still have to rent a car when you get where you're going, because there's not going to be a public transit system that works in either city for a very, very long time. (This is true notwithstanding the government's claim in its news release that the fast trains will "be integrated into existing passenger rail systems in Calgary and Edmonton.")
So it's unlikely the train can succ...
انگلیسی
ایالات متحده آمریکا
در این اپیزود
رونوشت 🔗
Are you the producer of this podcast?
Add a podcast transcript
Need Audio-to-Text?
Transcribe with Listen411 in Just 60 Seconds
جستجوی اپیزودهای گذشته
اپیزودهای قبلی The Tyee: Audio Edition را جستجو کن.
قسمت های دیگر در این پادکست
We need to stand up to Trump! So screw those emissions goals?
By Steve Burgess.
Dear Dr. Steve,
Federal Environment Minister Julie Dabrusin says Canada is committed to meeting our targets in the Paris climate accords. But two former environment ministers, Catherine McKenna and Steven Guilbeault, ar…
To quote Leonard Cohen, 'Democracy is coming to the USA.' But there's a long road ahead.
By Crawford Kilian.
Most Canadians, and Americans, were greatly cheered by the Democrats' wins in the Nov. 3 U.S. midterm elections. Solidly Republican states turned Democratic. The House of Representatives wil…
'We got pretty excited,' say finders of an endangered sucker species. Now Surrey has Canada's newest 'key biodiversity area.'
By Sarah Cox.
Fifteen years ago, a summer intern was catching fish in a Surrey stream for a wildlife survey. She netted a slender fish with fan-shaped fins she didn't recogn…
Financial experts question AIMCo's increased investment in bitcoin firms. Part 2 of a Tyee investigation.
By Madalyn Beach.
Michael Saylor lost so much money in a single day — more than $6 billion after the dot-com bubble burst in March 2000 — that he became the subject of a Trivial Pursuit card.
T…
Candidates are required to disclose interests. Here's what we found.
By Andrew MacLeod.
The new MLA for Burnaby North, Simon Chandler, owns real estate in British Columbia assessed at nearly $70 million.
First elected last month in the Conservative Party of BC wave, Chandler is one of several new M…
سلب مسئولیت: پادکست و آثار هنری تعبیه شده در این صفحه متعلق به The Tyee است که متعلق به صاحب آن است و به Listen Notes، Inc وابسته یا تایید نشده است.
ویرایش
از کمک شما برای بروز نگهداشتن پایگاهدادههای پادکست سپاسگزاریم