Demand Gen vs. Performance Max. Which One Should Insurance Agents Use?

WEBVTT
00:00:55.509 --> 00:01:02.549
Demand Gen versus Performance Max, what insurance agents need to understand about Google Ads in 2026.
00:01:03.909 --> 00:01:14.549
Welcome to the Digital Insurance Agent, the podcast where we break down the technology, marketing strategies, and AI-driven shifts that are changing how insurance agencies compete and grow.
00:01:14.709 --> 00:01:15.989
I'm Carl Willis.
00:01:16.069 --> 00:01:23.909
And today we're going to tackle something that I think is becoming increasingly important for insurance agents who are investing in Google Ads.
00:01:24.069 --> 00:01:32.469
We're going to talk about the difference between demand gen and performance max, because these two campaign types are often lumped together.
00:01:32.629 --> 00:01:42.710
They both use Google's AI, they both use automation, they both use audience data, they both use creative assets, and both can potentially generate leads.
00:01:42.870 --> 00:01:45.269
But they are not designed to do the same job.
00:01:45.349 --> 00:01:59.430
And if you're building your advertising strategy around campaign types instead of understanding the role each campaign plays in the customer journey, it's very easy to spend a lot of money without building a coherent acquisition system.
00:01:59.669 --> 00:02:01.669
So today I want to simplify this.
00:02:01.829 --> 00:02:15.189
By the end of this episode, I want you to understand not only the difference between Demand Gen and Performance Max, but where search fits into the picture and how these different campaigns can work together as part of an integrated insurance marketing ecosystem.
00:02:15.430 --> 00:02:16.629
Let's get into it.
00:02:17.270 --> 00:02:19.509
Start with the big picture.
00:02:20.389 --> 00:02:22.389
Here's the simplest place to begin.
00:02:22.629 --> 00:02:26.469
Demand Gen is primarily designed to create and cultivate demand.
00:02:26.710 --> 00:02:34.870
Performance Max is primarily designed to maximize conversions wherever Google's AI believes those conversions are most likely to happen.
00:02:35.030 --> 00:02:36.789
That's the fundamental distinction.
00:02:36.949 --> 00:02:38.949
Think about Performance Max this way.
00:02:39.109 --> 00:02:49.270
You tell Google the business outcome you want, maybe that's generate an insurance quote, schedule a consultation, submit a lead form, call my agency.
00:02:49.509 --> 00:02:51.590
Then Google starts making decisions.
00:02:51.750 --> 00:02:52.870
Who should see the ad?
00:02:53.030 --> 00:02:54.229
Which ad should they see?
00:02:54.389 --> 00:02:55.669
Where should that ad appear?
00:02:55.829 --> 00:02:57.189
How much should Google bid?
00:02:57.430 --> 00:03:02.150
Which combination of creative assets is most likely to produce the conversion?
00:03:02.469 --> 00:03:06.310
Performance Max is essentially following the conversion opportunity.
00:03:06.549 --> 00:03:08.469
Demand Gen works differently.
00:03:08.629 --> 00:03:12.469
With Demand Gen, you're more deliberately thinking about the audience.
00:03:12.629 --> 00:03:15.989
Who do we want to influence who looks like our ideal customer?
00:03:16.149 --> 00:03:20.310
Who may have a need for our products but hasn't started actively shopping yet?
00:03:20.469 --> 00:03:24.709
Who should become familiar with our agency before they reach that decision point?
00:03:24.870 --> 00:03:26.949
That's a very different marketing problem.
00:03:27.189 --> 00:03:34.069
And this distinction matters tremendously in insurance, because insurance is not always an immediate intent purchase.
00:03:34.229 --> 00:03:35.509
Sometimes it is.
00:03:35.750 --> 00:03:41.109
Someone's premium jumps 40% and they immediately search home insurance agent near me.
00:03:41.269 --> 00:03:42.469
That's active demand.
00:03:42.629 --> 00:03:45.750
But sometimes the buying process begins much earlier.
00:03:45.989 --> 00:03:57.989
Someone buys a house, someone gets married, and someone has a child, someone moves into a new community, someone becomes concerned about rising premiums, and someone starts wondering whether they have enough coverage.
00:03:58.149 --> 00:04:08.389
They aren't necessarily asking Google for a quote yet, but they are entering the market psychologically, and that's where demand creation becomes powerful.
00:04:08.949 --> 00:04:11.269
How performance max works.
00:04:12.229 --> 00:04:14.310
Let's start with performance max.
00:04:14.469 --> 00:04:18.149
The primary objective of Performance Max is fairly straightforward.
00:04:18.389 --> 00:04:21.269
Maximize conversions or conversion value.
00:04:21.430 --> 00:04:23.189
You establish the conversion goal.
00:04:23.350 --> 00:04:28.389
Google's AI then attempts to find people who are likely to complete that action.
00:04:28.470 --> 00:04:40.310
And Performance Max can operate across a very broad portion of the Google ecosystem, and that can include search, YouTube, display, discover, Gmail, Maps, and other Google inventory.
00:04:40.470 --> 00:04:45.750
The key point is this you aren't primarily deciding where the customer should encounter you.
00:04:45.990 --> 00:04:49.750
Google is, you're essentially saying, here's the outcome I want.
00:04:49.990 --> 00:04:51.110
Go find more of it.
00:04:51.350 --> 00:04:54.790
That's powerful, but there's an important trade-off.
00:04:54.949 --> 00:04:58.069
You're giving Google's AI significant control.
00:04:58.389 --> 00:05:02.790
Performance Max uses audience signals, but those signals are exactly that.
00:05:03.030 --> 00:05:03.509
Signals.
00:05:03.910 --> 00:05:07.670
You might tell Google, here are my existing customers.
00:05:07.910 --> 00:05:10.389
Here are people who visited my website.
00:05:10.629 --> 00:05:13.589
Here are the kinds of search behaviors we're interested in.
00:05:13.750 --> 00:05:16.629
Here are demographic characteristics we think matter.
00:05:16.789 --> 00:05:20.230
But Google isn't necessarily restricted to those audiences.
00:05:20.469 --> 00:05:25.750
The system can expand beyond them if its models believe another person is more likely to convert.
00:05:25.909 --> 00:05:28.230
So Performance Max is highly automated.
00:05:28.389 --> 00:05:30.550
Its priority is performance.
00:05:30.949 --> 00:05:33.189
How Demand Gen is different.
00:05:34.069 --> 00:05:36.069
Now let's look at Demand Gen.
00:05:36.230 --> 00:05:39.189
Demand Gen has a different strategic purpose.
00:05:39.430 --> 00:05:46.870
Its job is to help you reach and influence audiences through Google's more visual and discovery-oriented environments.
00:05:47.029 --> 00:05:57.509
That means environments such as YouTube, YouTube Shorts, Discover, Gmail, Maps, and increasingly Google's broader visual advertising ecosystem.
00:05:57.670 --> 00:06:06.310
Instead of simply waiting for somebody to search, independent insurance agent near me, you can begin influencing that homeowner before the search ever happens.
00:06:06.550 --> 00:06:12.550
For example, imagine someone watching content about protecting their home after a major storm.
00:06:12.789 --> 00:06:15.589
Or they're researching home ownership costs.
00:06:15.750 --> 00:06:25.110
Or they've recently moved, or they're consuming financial planning content, or their behavior suggests they resemble people who already buy insurance from your agency.
00:06:25.269 --> 00:06:29.110
They're not necessarily typing, give me an insurance quote.
00:06:29.349 --> 00:06:31.670
But they may be an ideal future customer.
00:06:31.829 --> 00:06:38.069
Demand Gen allows you to start building familiarity and consideration earlier in the journey.
00:06:38.230 --> 00:06:45.189
That's why I like this distinction that Performance Max follows the conversion opportunity, Demand Gen follows the audience.
00:06:45.670 --> 00:06:48.469
Intent versus audience development.
00:06:49.990 --> 00:06:53.269
This is probably the most important concept in the entire episode.
00:06:53.430 --> 00:06:59.189
Think about Performance Max as being heavily oriented toward capturing and converting intent.
00:06:59.349 --> 00:07:13.670
Google may detect that someone is searching, comparing, watching relevant videos, visiting relevant websites, interacting with your brand, or otherwise demonstrating signals that indicate they're getting closer to a purchase decision.
00:07:13.829 --> 00:07:18.550
Google then tries to identify the moment where conversion probability is highest.
00:07:18.789 --> 00:07:23.189
Demand gen is much more about creating or cultivating intent.
00:07:23.349 --> 00:07:25.269
Let's use a home insurance example.
00:07:25.430 --> 00:07:31.189
Someone may not be searching home insurance quote Wichita, but maybe they just purchased a home.
00:07:31.349 --> 00:07:43.909
Maybe they're consuming home improvement content, maybe they've been researching roofing, maybe they've been watching storm preparedness videos, maybe they've demonstrated behaviors that resemble your existing best clients.
00:07:44.149 --> 00:07:55.509
You can introduce your agency before they enter the traditional search funnel, and your creative could say something like, When was the last time someone actually reviewed your home insurance coverage?
00:07:55.670 --> 00:08:00.389
That's a very different message than get a home insurance quote today.
00:08:00.709 --> 00:08:03.430
One responds to existing demand.
00:08:03.589 --> 00:08:07.909
The other creates curiosity and potentially creates demand.
00:08:08.870 --> 00:08:10.629
The audience difference.
00:08:11.990 --> 00:08:14.949
Audience control is another major distinction.
00:08:15.189 --> 00:08:18.389
Performance Max allows you to provide audience signals.
00:08:18.789 --> 00:08:27.750
You can use things like customer match, website visitors, custom segments, interest, demographic information, first-party data, previous converters.
00:08:27.909 --> 00:08:33.350
Those signals help Google's AI understand who your valuable customers may be.
00:08:33.509 --> 00:08:36.629
But again, performance max can move beyond those signals.
00:08:36.789 --> 00:08:39.670
Demand Gen gives you more deliberate audience control.
00:08:39.830 --> 00:08:50.070
You can work with first party audiences, customer lists, remarketing audiences, custom segments, interest audiences, demographics, and look-alike audiences.
00:08:50.310 --> 00:08:52.310
That last one is particularly interesting.
00:08:52.470 --> 00:08:58.470
You can essentially say, Google, here are people who already look like great customers for my agency.
00:08:58.629 --> 00:09:01.029
Help me find more people who resemble them.
00:09:01.190 --> 00:09:08.550
That makes Demand Gen conceptually much closer to what many marketers are familiar with on platforms like Meta.
00:09:08.710 --> 00:09:12.870
You're not simply bidding against a keyword, you're building an audience strategy.
00:09:13.029 --> 00:09:20.710
And for insurance agencies that have developed strong first-party customer data, that can become very valuable.
00:09:21.190 --> 00:09:23.430
Creative matters much more.
00:09:24.789 --> 00:09:27.590
There's also a major difference in creative strategy.
00:09:27.750 --> 00:09:30.470
Performance Max uses an asset-driven system.
00:09:30.629 --> 00:09:36.470
You supply headlines, descriptions, images, logos, videos, and other creative assets.
00:09:36.710 --> 00:09:41.110
Google dynamically combines those assets based on what it believes will perform.
00:09:41.269 --> 00:09:43.509
Again, the priority is conversion performance.
00:09:43.669 --> 00:09:45.750
Demand gen is much more creative first.
00:09:45.990 --> 00:09:54.789
You can use video, images, carousels, YouTube Shorts, responsive visual creative, and other formats built around visual storytelling.
00:09:54.950 --> 00:09:57.189
That changes the marketing conversation.
00:09:57.509 --> 00:10:01.509
You aren't necessarily writing auto insurance quotes, call today.
00:10:01.750 --> 00:10:09.189
Instead, you could create a 30-second video around three coverage gaps homeowners don't discover until they file a claim.
00:10:09.429 --> 00:10:15.590
Or why your cheapest auto insurance quote may not actually save you money?
00:10:15.830 --> 00:10:18.710
Or bought a home in the last 12 months?
00:10:18.950 --> 00:10:21.909
Here are three insurance questions worth asking.
00:10:22.069 --> 00:10:24.389
You're not merely responding to a search.
00:10:24.549 --> 00:10:32.549
You're educating, creating curiosity, building authority, and positioning your agency before the prospect starts shopping aggressively.
00:10:32.710 --> 00:10:39.909
For insurance agents, that matters because trust is rarely created at the exact moment someone requests a quote.
00:10:40.149 --> 00:10:43.750
Trust is usually built across multiple interactions.
00:10:44.470 --> 00:10:46.389
The control trade-off.
00:10:47.350 --> 00:10:50.149
Here's another simple way to think about the two platforms.
00:10:50.389 --> 00:10:56.470
Demand Gen generally gives you more deliberate control over audiences and creative strategy.
00:10:56.710 --> 00:11:01.029
Performance Max generally gives Google more freedom to optimize toward conversions.
00:11:01.110 --> 00:11:05.909
So Demand Gen has high automation, performance Max has very high automation.
00:11:06.069 --> 00:11:09.110
Demand Gen tends to be stronger for visual storytelling.
00:11:09.269 --> 00:11:15.909
Performance Max tends to be stronger when the primary objective is direct response conversion optimization.
00:11:16.149 --> 00:11:19.429
Demand Gen is particularly powerful for demand creation.
00:11:19.590 --> 00:11:24.549
Performance Max is particularly powerful for conversion maximization.
00:11:24.710 --> 00:11:26.789
Neither one is inherently better.
00:11:27.029 --> 00:11:32.230
They simply have different jobs, and that's where a lot of advertising strategies go wrong.
00:11:32.309 --> 00:11:35.110
And people ask, which campaign should I use?
00:11:35.269 --> 00:11:36.710
That's often the wrong question.
00:11:36.870 --> 00:11:43.189
And the better question is, what job does this campaign need to perform inside the overall acquisition system?
00:11:43.990 --> 00:11:45.750
Where search fits.
00:11:47.029 --> 00:11:52.789
Now we need to bring search into the conversation because search still plays a unique role.
00:11:53.029 --> 00:11:56.069
Search captures what someone explicitly says they want.
00:11:56.230 --> 00:12:06.389
If somebody searches independent insurance agent near me, Medicare agent Wichita, home insurance quote, best auto insurance agency near me.
00:12:06.629 --> 00:12:10.870
There is a level of declared intent there that is incredibly valuable.
00:12:11.110 --> 00:12:13.429
The consumer is raising their hand.
00:12:13.669 --> 00:12:20.710
So an easy way to visualize this is at the top of the funnel, you may use demand gen to build awareness.
00:12:20.870 --> 00:12:25.269
As people become more interested, demand gen can continue building consideration.
00:12:25.429 --> 00:12:29.590
When someone actively starts searching, search becomes incredibly important.
00:12:29.830 --> 00:12:37.350
When we're trying to maximize conversions across Google's ecosystem, Performance Max can help capture additional opportunities.
00:12:37.590 --> 00:12:43.990
And then Demand Gen and Performance Max may both play roles in remarketing or re-engagement.
00:12:44.069 --> 00:12:46.069
It's not a perfect linear funnel.
00:12:46.230 --> 00:12:48.389
Today's consumer journey rarely is.
00:12:48.549 --> 00:12:52.309
But strategically, the framework is extremely useful.
00:12:53.269 --> 00:12:55.909
An insurance agency example.
00:12:56.710 --> 00:12:59.269
Let's bring this directly into the insurance world.
00:12:59.429 --> 00:13:04.230
Suppose you're an independent PC agency, you're trying to grow your home and auto book.
00:13:04.309 --> 00:13:13.509
Your Demand Gen campaign could target homeowners, new movers, parents, high-value households, custom audiences, and people who resemble your current best clients.
00:13:13.669 --> 00:13:15.029
You create a short video.
00:13:15.189 --> 00:13:20.309
Maybe the opening line is, when was the last time someone actually reviewed your home insurance?
00:13:20.470 --> 00:13:32.950
Then you explain that rising construction costs, roof exclusions, deductibles, and changing carrier guidelines can create coverage gaps that homeowners don't necessarily notice.
00:13:33.189 --> 00:13:36.789
Your call to action isn't necessarily buy insurance right now.
00:13:36.950 --> 00:13:42.549
It could be schedule a coverage review or see what you may be missing.
00:13:42.710 --> 00:13:44.149
You're creating awareness.
00:13:44.309 --> 00:13:45.189
You're educating.
00:13:45.350 --> 00:13:52.230
You're giving someone a reason to think about something they weren't necessarily thinking about five minutes ago.
00:13:52.470 --> 00:13:55.029
Now, let's look at performance max.
00:13:55.269 --> 00:13:58.549
The conversion goal might be request an insurance quote.
00:13:58.710 --> 00:14:04.950
Google uses the signals available across its ecosystem to try to locate people most likely to complete that action.
00:14:05.110 --> 00:14:09.269
Maybe they recently searched insurance terms, maybe they watched relevant content.
00:14:09.429 --> 00:14:12.069
Maybe they interacted with your agency previously.
00:14:12.230 --> 00:14:16.789
Maybe Google detects other behavioral signals indicating higher purchase intent.
00:14:17.029 --> 00:14:20.789
Performance Max is trying to find the next likely converter.
00:14:20.950 --> 00:14:26.069
Those are two very different jobs, and they can complement each other extremely well.
00:14:26.789 --> 00:14:29.350
When Demand Gen Makes Sense.
00:14:30.789 --> 00:14:33.990
So when should an insurance agency consider Demand Gen?
00:14:34.149 --> 00:14:39.669
Demand Gen becomes particularly interesting when you want to reach prospects before they search.
00:14:39.830 --> 00:14:48.950
You have strong visual creative, you have first-party customer data, you want to build look-alike audiences, you want greater audience control.
00:14:49.189 --> 00:14:59.429
You're using video strategically, you want to expand beyond limited search volume, or you want to build awareness and consideration in a specific geographic market.
00:14:59.590 --> 00:15:02.549
Think about an agency in a competitive metro.
00:15:02.710 --> 00:15:04.789
There may only be so many people searching.
00:15:05.110 --> 00:15:08.230
Insurance agent near me on any given day.
00:15:08.389 --> 00:15:17.189
If your entire strategy is limited to capturing the people already searching, you're competing for a relatively small pool of existing demand.
00:15:17.350 --> 00:15:21.509
Demand Gin gives you the opportunity to expand that pool.
00:15:22.069 --> 00:15:24.870
When Performance Max makes sense.
00:15:26.789 --> 00:15:36.389
Performance Max becomes more compelling when your primary goal is lead generation and you've built the infrastructure needed to give Google's AI good information.
00:15:36.629 --> 00:15:47.669
That means strong conversion tracking, useful first-party data, adequate conversion volume, clear business goals, and ideally an existing search strategy that is already functioning well.
00:15:47.830 --> 00:15:57.590
If Google has very little information about who actually becomes a good customer, asking the algorithm to magically find more good customers is a weak strategy.
00:15:57.830 --> 00:15:59.110
AI is a multiplier.
00:15:59.269 --> 00:16:00.789
It still needs quality inputs.
00:16:01.029 --> 00:16:05.909
Bad conversion tracking multiplied by sophisticated AI is still bad marketing.
00:16:06.149 --> 00:16:09.350
Weak data multiplied by automation is still weak data.
00:16:09.509 --> 00:16:16.309
So before giving an algorithm more control, you need to make sure the system feeding that algorithm is sound.
00:16:17.110 --> 00:16:21.189
Why these campaigns should often work together.
00:16:22.309 --> 00:16:25.669
And this brings us to the bigger strategic lesson.
00:16:25.830 --> 00:16:31.269
The conversation shouldn't necessarily be demand gen or performance max.
00:16:31.429 --> 00:16:34.230
It should be what job should each campaign perform?
00:16:34.470 --> 00:16:36.870
Search can capture explicit demand.
00:16:37.110 --> 00:16:39.909
Demand gen can create and cultivate demand.
00:16:40.149 --> 00:16:45.509
Performance Max can capture incremental conversion opportunities across Google's ecosystem.
00:16:45.669 --> 00:16:49.429
Remarketing can reconnect with people who showed interest but didn't act.
00:16:49.590 --> 00:16:51.509
Your website builds trust.
00:16:51.750 --> 00:16:55.110
Your Google business profile reinforces local credibility.
00:16:55.269 --> 00:16:57.189
Your reviews reduce uncertainty.
00:16:57.350 --> 00:17:00.149
Your educational content demonstrates expertise.
00:17:00.309 --> 00:17:03.669
Your automation follows up when someone doesn't immediately convert.
00:17:03.830 --> 00:17:05.190
That's the ecosystem.
00:17:05.350 --> 00:17:12.470
And this is why I continually push insurance agents away from thinking in isolated marketing channels.
00:17:12.630 --> 00:17:21.430
You don't have a Google Ads strategy over here, an SEO strategy over there, a social strategy over there, and a website sitting somewhere in the middle.
00:17:21.590 --> 00:17:23.590
You have one acquisition ecosystem.
00:17:23.750 --> 00:17:26.230
Every component should have a defined role.
00:17:26.390 --> 00:17:28.710
Every component should reinforce the others.
00:17:28.789 --> 00:17:35.110
And AI increasingly becomes the connective tissue that helps those systems learn and optimize.
00:17:35.590 --> 00:17:38.069
The three sentences to remember.
00:17:39.190 --> 00:17:43.910
So if everything I've covered today feels complicated, remember these three sentences.
00:17:44.230 --> 00:17:46.390
Search captures what people say they want.
00:17:46.630 --> 00:17:49.590
Demand Gen influences what people may want next.
00:17:49.830 --> 00:17:54.390
Performance Max finds wherever Google believes the next conversion can happen.
00:17:54.630 --> 00:17:55.830
That's the framework.
00:17:55.910 --> 00:18:01.750
And for most insurance agencies, I would not look at Demand Gen as some replacement for Performance Max.
00:18:01.910 --> 00:18:05.589
I would look at it as another layer of the acquisition system.
00:18:05.829 --> 00:18:12.950
Because insurance buying decisions frequently begin long before somebody types insurance agent near me.
00:18:13.190 --> 00:18:20.710
The agency that starts building trust before that search happens has an enormous strategic advantage when the search finally occurs.
00:18:21.430 --> 00:18:23.109
Final takeaway.
00:18:24.150 --> 00:18:27.430
Here's what I want you thinking about after today's episode.
00:18:27.589 --> 00:18:29.349
Don't begin with the campaign.
00:18:29.589 --> 00:18:31.269
Begin with the customer journey.
00:18:31.509 --> 00:18:32.789
Where does demand begin?
00:18:32.950 --> 00:18:34.549
Where does consideration happen?
00:18:34.789 --> 00:18:36.390
Where does active intent show up?
00:18:36.549 --> 00:18:38.150
Where does conversion occur?
00:18:38.309 --> 00:18:39.829
Where are people dropping out?
00:18:39.990 --> 00:18:44.309
And what role should each marketing system play in moving the prospect forward?
00:18:44.549 --> 00:18:45.349
That's strategy.
00:18:45.509 --> 00:18:47.190
The technology comes second.
00:18:47.430 --> 00:18:54.309
Because the agencies that win in this new environment won't simply be the agencies using the newest Google campaign type.
00:18:54.470 --> 00:19:00.069
They'll be the agencies building the most complete, intelligent, interconnected growth ecosystems.
00:19:00.150 --> 00:19:02.629
And that's where market dominance comes from.
00:19:02.789 --> 00:19:05.910
That's it for today's episode of the Digital Insurance Agent.
00:19:06.069 --> 00:19:16.629
If this episode helped clarify the difference between demand gen, performance max, and search, share it with another insurance agent who's trying to make sense of where Google Advertising is headed.
00:19:16.789 --> 00:19:22.069
And if you want to compete in the AI era, remember don't chase isolated tactics.
00:19:22.230 --> 00:19:23.029
Build the system.
00:19:23.190 --> 00:19:24.710
I'll see you on the next episode.