Why Did Pluto Lose Its Status as the Ninth Planet? - Pluto's True Nature | Sleepy Facts About the Universe

WEBVTT
00:00:04.780 --> 00:00:12.919
Welcome to Sleepy Facts About the Universe. In
00:00:12.919 --> 00:00:17.120
1930, a faint moving dot on a pair of photographic
00:00:17.120 --> 00:00:19.960
plates confirmed a mathematical prediction and
00:00:19.960 --> 00:00:22.760
seemingly revealed a massive ninth planet at
00:00:22.760 --> 00:00:26.320
the edge of our solar system. For decades, Pluto
00:00:26.320 --> 00:00:29.800
occupied this role in textbooks and public imagination,
00:00:30.239 --> 00:00:35.409
a solitary wanderer beyond Neptune. Yet, as instruments
00:00:35.409 --> 00:00:38.950
improved and observations sharpened, the object
00:00:38.950 --> 00:00:42.409
began to shrink, change, and reveal a far more
00:00:42.409 --> 00:00:47.030
complex identity than anyone anticipated. This
00:00:47.030 --> 00:00:50.049
episode explores the long journey of understanding
00:00:50.049 --> 00:00:53.850
Pluto, from Percival Lowell's flawed calculations
00:00:53.850 --> 00:00:57.950
to Clyde Tommel's patient discovery, and onward
00:00:57.950 --> 00:01:00.509
to the eventual realization that Pluto was not
00:01:00.509 --> 00:01:04.290
a massive planetary body at all. We examine how
00:01:04.290 --> 00:01:07.670
the discovery of its moon Charon allowed astronomers
00:01:07.670 --> 00:01:10.969
to accurately weigh the system, exposing the
00:01:10.969 --> 00:01:14.349
original mathematical errors, and how the subsequent
00:01:14.349 --> 00:01:17.250
identification of other objects in the Kuiper
00:01:17.250 --> 00:01:20.310
Belt forced a formal redefinition of what it
00:01:20.310 --> 00:01:23.849
means to be a planet. I wanted to understand
00:01:23.849 --> 00:01:26.989
why a simple point of light took nearly a century
00:01:26.989 --> 00:01:30.590
to decode, and how a world dismissed as frozen
00:01:30.590 --> 00:01:33.640
and dead turned out to be incredibly dynamic.
00:01:34.120 --> 00:01:38.159
Looking closely at the New Horizons flyby, we
00:01:38.159 --> 00:01:41.560
find nitrogen glaciers, water ice mountains,
00:01:42.019 --> 00:01:45.140
and a surprising degree of geological activity.
00:01:45.780 --> 00:01:49.319
It is a reminder that the universe rarely matches
00:01:49.319 --> 00:01:52.219
our initial assumptions, and that correcting
00:01:52.219 --> 00:01:55.540
a past mistake often reveals something far more
00:01:55.540 --> 00:02:00.549
interesting than the original theory. In 1930,
00:02:00.909 --> 00:02:03.689
a moving dot confirmed a theory about a massive
00:02:03.689 --> 00:02:08.650
ninth planet. By 2015, that same dot had become
00:02:08.650 --> 00:02:11.569
a world of nitrogen glaciers and blue atmospheric
00:02:11.569 --> 00:02:15.930
haze. Almost nothing in the original theory had
00:02:15.930 --> 00:02:19.789
survived the journey. In the winter of 1930,
00:02:20.250 --> 00:02:23.889
a young man named Clyde Tomer spent night after
00:02:23.889 --> 00:02:28.080
night in a cold dome in Arizona. He was staring
00:02:28.080 --> 00:02:31.539
not through an eyepiece, but at pairs of photographic
00:02:31.539 --> 00:02:35.199
plates. He was looking for something that jumped.
00:02:36.039 --> 00:02:39.080
The dome held the chill of the high desert after
00:02:39.080 --> 00:02:43.020
midnight. The bling comparator made a soft mechanical
00:02:43.020 --> 00:02:46.599
rhythm as it alternated between plates, a heartbeat
00:02:46.599 --> 00:02:50.860
of metal and glass. Tombaugh leaned into it for
00:02:50.860 --> 00:02:54.259
hours, trusting patience more than brilliance.
00:02:55.469 --> 00:02:58.729
After months of this work, a faint point of light
00:02:58.729 --> 00:03:04.370
betrayed itself. It moved slowly. It was beyond
00:03:04.370 --> 00:03:08.169
Neptune. It was exactly where Percival Lowell
00:03:08.169 --> 00:03:10.909
had predicted a massive ninth planet would be
00:03:10.909 --> 00:03:14.990
found. To Tombaugh, to Lowell's successors, to
00:03:14.990 --> 00:03:17.050
the newspapers that carried the story around
00:03:17.050 --> 00:03:21.590
the world, this was Planet X. It was a world
00:03:21.590 --> 00:03:24.979
seven times the mass of Earth. Large enough to
00:03:24.979 --> 00:03:28.360
tug at the orbits of Uranus and Neptune. Large
00:03:28.360 --> 00:03:31.939
enough to be a proper planet. The mathematics
00:03:31.939 --> 00:03:36.620
had predicted it. The plates had confirmed it.
00:03:37.060 --> 00:03:41.560
The interpretation felt inevitable. But the object
00:03:41.560 --> 00:03:46.520
itself offered no surface to read. No disk resolved.
00:03:47.539 --> 00:03:52.949
No features. Just a pale dot, slightly reddish,
00:03:53.030 --> 00:03:56.969
wandering against the stars. Everything else,
00:03:57.210 --> 00:04:01.289
its size, its mass, its nature, had to be inferred
00:04:01.289 --> 00:04:03.849
from its motion and from the gravitational story
00:04:03.849 --> 00:04:07.729
it was presumed to tell. For decades, that was
00:04:07.729 --> 00:04:11.990
all anyone had. A point of light and a confident
00:04:11.990 --> 00:04:16.209
theory about what it meant. The theory made sense.
00:04:17.789 --> 00:04:21.750
Lowell's calculations were sophisticated. The
00:04:21.750 --> 00:04:24.470
perturbations in the outer planet's orbits seemed
00:04:24.470 --> 00:04:28.170
real. And when Tombo found his moving dot near
00:04:28.170 --> 00:04:31.009
the predicted position, the match felt like confirmation.
00:04:32.029 --> 00:04:35.230
The object was faint, yes, but that only meant
00:04:35.230 --> 00:04:39.310
it was distant. It was slow, but that, too, fit
00:04:39.310 --> 00:04:43.850
a far -flung world. The interpretation held together.
00:04:44.279 --> 00:04:46.500
because the instruments of the time could offer
00:04:46.500 --> 00:04:50.819
nothing to tear it apart. What no one could see
00:04:50.819 --> 00:04:55.420
was how small the dot really was. For 40 years,
00:04:55.579 --> 00:04:58.480
Pluto traveled through textbooks and public imagination
00:04:58.480 --> 00:05:02.319
as the ninth planet, a solitary wanderer at the
00:05:02.319 --> 00:05:05.939
edge of things. Photometers measured its light
00:05:05.939 --> 00:05:10.290
and found it varied every 6 .4 days. This was
00:05:10.290 --> 00:05:13.529
a rotation period, suggesting some kind of marked
00:05:13.529 --> 00:05:17.910
surface, though no one could say what kind. In
00:05:17.910 --> 00:05:21.769
the 1970s, spectroscopes detected methane frost,
00:05:22.029 --> 00:05:26.129
which was surprising. Methane meant ice, and
00:05:26.129 --> 00:05:29.269
ice meant reflectivity, and reflectivity meant
00:05:29.269 --> 00:05:31.930
Pluto was probably smaller and brighter than
00:05:31.930 --> 00:05:36.209
assumed, not larger and darker. The estimates
00:05:36.209 --> 00:05:40.949
began to shrink. from seven Earth masses to one
00:05:40.949 --> 00:05:45.569
to a fraction. Each revision was quiet, technical,
00:05:45.829 --> 00:05:50.449
reported in journals but not in headlines. The
00:05:50.449 --> 00:05:53.149
planet was dissolving in slow motion, becoming
00:05:53.149 --> 00:05:55.889
less substantial with every careful measurement.
00:05:56.769 --> 00:06:01.170
Yet its status never wavered. It remained the
00:06:01.170 --> 00:06:03.370
ninth planet because no one had found a reason
00:06:03.370 --> 00:06:07.399
to question the category itself. Then, in 1978,
00:06:07.899 --> 00:06:11.040
an astronomer named James Christie was examining
00:06:11.040 --> 00:06:13.500
photographic plates at the Naval Observatory
00:06:13.500 --> 00:06:16.600
in Flagstaff, not far from where Tombaugh had
00:06:16.600 --> 00:06:21.879
worked. He noticed something odd. Pluto's image
00:06:21.879 --> 00:06:27.019
was not round. It had a bump, a slight elongation
00:06:27.019 --> 00:06:29.860
that appeared and disappeared on a six -day cycle.
00:06:30.540 --> 00:06:33.540
The period matched Pluto's rotation exactly.
00:06:34.829 --> 00:06:37.769
Christie realized he was seeing not a feature
00:06:37.769 --> 00:06:41.290
on Pluto's surface, but another body beside it,
00:06:41.410 --> 00:06:44.949
orbiting so close that the two blurred together
00:06:44.949 --> 00:06:49.029
in ground -based telescopes. He had found a moon.
00:06:50.170 --> 00:06:53.069
Karan's discovery changed everything, though
00:06:53.069 --> 00:06:56.829
not immediately in the way people expected. With
00:06:56.829 --> 00:06:59.509
a satellite in hand, astronomers could finally
00:06:59.509 --> 00:07:03.829
weigh the system directly. Kepler's laws? applied
00:07:03.829 --> 00:07:06.930
to Charon's orbit around Pluto, gave a mass that
00:07:06.930 --> 00:07:10.870
was almost embarrassing in its smallness. The
00:07:10.870 --> 00:07:14.449
entire Pluto -Charon system weighed in at roughly
00:07:14.449 --> 00:07:18.430
one four hundredth of Earth. Not seven Earth
00:07:18.430 --> 00:07:25.050
masses. Not one. A tiny fraction of one. The
00:07:25.050 --> 00:07:28.189
perturbations Lowell had calculated, the gravitational
00:07:28.189 --> 00:07:31.550
anomalies that launched the search, could not
00:07:31.550 --> 00:07:35.009
have been caused by this body. They were errors,
00:07:35.310 --> 00:07:39.029
artifacts of imperfect data, mistaken masses
00:07:39.029 --> 00:07:41.930
for Neptune and Uranus, observational limits
00:07:41.930 --> 00:07:46.069
dressed up as mathematical certainty. Pluto had
00:07:46.069 --> 00:07:48.670
been found near Lowell's predicted position by
00:07:48.670 --> 00:07:53.709
coincidence. The theory was wrong. The discovery
00:07:53.709 --> 00:07:57.889
was real. The object was something else entirely.
00:07:59.180 --> 00:08:01.959
The scientific community absorbed this quietly.
00:08:02.519 --> 00:08:05.759
There was no dramatic moment of demotion, no
00:08:05.759 --> 00:08:09.899
immediate reclassification. Pluto remained the
00:08:09.899 --> 00:08:14.220
ninth planet by habit, by inertia, by the weight
00:08:14.220 --> 00:08:18.939
of 48 years of textbooks and mnemonics. But the
00:08:18.939 --> 00:08:21.439
understanding underneath had shifted fundamentally.
00:08:22.420 --> 00:08:26.699
Pluto was now a binary system. Two bodies dancing
00:08:26.699 --> 00:08:29.259
around a point in space that lay outside Pluto
00:08:29.259 --> 00:08:33.879
itself. And it was small. Smaller than Earth's
00:08:33.879 --> 00:08:38.100
moon. Whatever it was, it was not what Lowell
00:08:38.100 --> 00:08:42.000
had sought. Yet the surface remained almost as
00:08:42.000 --> 00:08:45.840
mysterious as before. The mass was known now,
00:08:46.019 --> 00:08:49.320
but no telescope on Earth could resolve any feature
00:08:49.320 --> 00:08:53.740
on a body so distant and so tiny. Then, in the
00:08:53.740 --> 00:08:57.090
mid -1980s, astronomers realized that a rare
00:08:57.090 --> 00:09:01.909
alignment was approaching. From 1985 to 1990,
00:09:02.429 --> 00:09:05.570
Pluto and Charon would tilt in such a way that
00:09:05.570 --> 00:09:08.269
each passed repeatedly in front of the other,
00:09:08.370 --> 00:09:12.269
as seen from Earth. These mutual occultations,
00:09:12.450 --> 00:09:15.769
rare and fleeting, offered a chance to build
00:09:15.769 --> 00:09:18.450
crude maps before the geometry shifted away again.
00:09:18.970 --> 00:09:22.529
The maps revealed not a uniform ball of methane
00:09:22.529 --> 00:09:26.480
ice, but a mottled surface, bright regions and
00:09:26.480 --> 00:09:29.559
dark, something complex enough to reflect differently
00:09:29.559 --> 00:09:35.220
as the world turned. Then, in 1988, Pluto passed
00:09:35.220 --> 00:09:38.000
in front of a star, and astronomers watching
00:09:38.000 --> 00:09:40.740
the occultation detected a substantial atmosphere.
00:09:41.659 --> 00:09:45.820
It was nitrogen gas, extending hundreds of kilometers
00:09:45.820 --> 00:09:49.559
above the surface, far more than the thin, transient
00:09:49.559 --> 00:09:53.639
veil anyone had expected. The frozen dead world
00:09:53.639 --> 00:09:59.879
was leaking. It was active. It was, in some fashion,
00:10:00.019 --> 00:10:05.820
alive. Still, the category held. Pluto was the
00:10:05.820 --> 00:10:09.360
ninth planet, even as its physical reality drifted
00:10:09.360 --> 00:10:12.940
further from that designation. The real crack
00:10:12.940 --> 00:10:15.639
came from elsewhere, from the slow accumulation
00:10:15.639 --> 00:10:20.419
of discoveries that began in 1992. Astronomers
00:10:20.419 --> 00:10:23.320
found other bodies beyond Neptune, not as large
00:10:23.320 --> 00:10:26.580
as Pluto but clearly related, orbiting in similar
00:10:26.580 --> 00:10:30.899
resonances, composed of similar ices. The Kuiper
00:10:30.899 --> 00:10:34.120
Belt, theorized for decades, was proving real
00:10:34.120 --> 00:10:38.639
and populous. Pluto was not a lonely outlier.
00:10:39.460 --> 00:10:42.840
It was the first known member of a vast swarm,
00:10:43.200 --> 00:10:46.500
the largest and brightest of a new class of objects,
00:10:46.820 --> 00:10:51.090
but not unique. not special in the way a planet
00:10:51.090 --> 00:10:55.429
was supposed to be. In 2005, the discovery of
00:10:55.429 --> 00:10:58.710
Eris, another distant body, slightly more massive
00:10:58.710 --> 00:11:01.809
than Pluto, orbiting in the same scattered realm,
00:11:01.990 --> 00:11:06.710
made the tension unbearable. If Pluto was a planet,
00:11:06.929 --> 00:11:10.629
then Eris must be too, and likely dozens more.
00:11:11.330 --> 00:11:14.570
The International Astronomical Union faced a
00:11:14.570 --> 00:11:17.950
choice. Expand the Planet Club to include potentially
00:11:17.950 --> 00:11:21.370
hundreds of new members, or draw a line that
00:11:21.370 --> 00:11:27.570
excluded Pluto. They chose the line. In 2006,
00:11:28.090 --> 00:11:31.350
Resolution B5 established three criteria for
00:11:31.350 --> 00:11:36.730
planethood. A planet must orbit the Sun. It must
00:11:36.730 --> 00:11:40.389
be roughly spherical. And it must have cleared
00:11:40.389 --> 00:11:44.059
its neighborhood of other bodies. Pluto failed
00:11:44.059 --> 00:11:48.620
the third test. It was reclassified as a dwarf
00:11:48.620 --> 00:11:52.059
planet, a category created to hold objects large
00:11:52.059 --> 00:11:54.919
enough to be round, but too small to dominate
00:11:54.919 --> 00:11:58.879
their orbits. The public reaction was loud and
00:11:58.879 --> 00:12:01.340
emotional, but the scientific logic was clean.
00:12:02.179 --> 00:12:06.840
The object had not changed. The understanding
00:12:06.840 --> 00:12:10.960
had sharpened. Pluto was not a failed planet.
00:12:12.169 --> 00:12:14.710
It had never been a planet in the sense Lowell
00:12:14.710 --> 00:12:18.850
imagined. It was something else, something now
00:12:18.850 --> 00:12:22.909
visible more clearly. What the New Horizons spacecraft
00:12:22.909 --> 00:12:26.730
found in 2015 completed the transformation that
00:12:26.730 --> 00:12:30.570
Karen had begun. After nine years of flight,
00:12:30.889 --> 00:12:34.830
the probe passed within 12 ,000 kilometers of
00:12:34.830 --> 00:12:39.029
Pluto's surface. And for the first time, Human
00:12:39.029 --> 00:12:42.250
eyes saw what ground -based telescopes could
00:12:42.250 --> 00:12:45.950
never resolve. The world was stunning in its
00:12:45.950 --> 00:12:50.649
complexity. A vast plane of nitrogen ice, named
00:12:50.649 --> 00:12:53.730
Sputnik Planitia, stretched across a region the
00:12:53.730 --> 00:12:59.330
size of Texas. The ice was not static. Convective
00:12:59.330 --> 00:13:03.370
cells churned beneath the surface, slowly overturning.
00:13:04.029 --> 00:13:08.210
Water ice mountains rose 11 ,000 feet. as high
00:13:08.210 --> 00:13:11.710
as the Rockies, their bases embedded in the softer
00:13:11.710 --> 00:13:15.809
nitrogen. The surface was variegated beyond anything
00:13:15.809 --> 00:13:19.210
the occultation maps had suggested. Deep reds,
00:13:19.210 --> 00:13:22.950
pale yellows, charcoal darks, all tracking different
00:13:22.950 --> 00:13:27.169
compositions and ages. Haze layers hung in the
00:13:27.169 --> 00:13:30.710
atmosphere, photochemical smog extending far
00:13:30.710 --> 00:13:33.990
above the surface, catching blue light in scattering
00:13:33.990 --> 00:13:36.769
patterns that cameras recorded as a pale sky.
00:13:38.000 --> 00:13:42.259
Most surprising was the geology. Pluto was supposed
00:13:42.259 --> 00:13:45.700
to be dead, frozen solid for billions of years.
00:13:46.240 --> 00:13:50.399
Too small to retain heat, too isolated to find
00:13:50.399 --> 00:13:53.960
energy. Yet the surface showed evidence of recent
00:13:53.960 --> 00:13:58.460
activity, perhaps ongoing. Cryovolcanic features
00:13:58.460 --> 00:14:02.899
suggested eruptions of icy slurry. The smooth
00:14:02.899 --> 00:14:06.320
plains demanded resurfacing on timescales of
00:14:06.320 --> 00:14:10.610
millions of years. not billions. Something was
00:14:10.610 --> 00:14:13.629
driving this, perhaps radiogenic heat from a
00:14:13.629 --> 00:14:17.190
rocky core, perhaps a subsurface ocean kept liquid
00:14:17.190 --> 00:14:21.070
by ammonia antifreeze, perhaps tidal interactions
00:14:21.070 --> 00:14:24.509
with Charon that had long since settled but left
00:14:24.509 --> 00:14:28.669
residual warmth. The frozen world was not frozen
00:14:28.669 --> 00:14:33.220
after all. It was active, dynamic. geologically
00:14:33.220 --> 00:14:37.240
alive in a way that no one in 1930 or 1978 or
00:14:37.240 --> 00:14:41.480
even 2005 had seriously proposed. The nitrogen
00:14:41.480 --> 00:14:45.019
glaciers flowed slowly, creeping around obstacles,
00:14:45.399 --> 00:14:48.399
filling basins, sublimating at one season and
00:14:48.399 --> 00:14:52.120
condensing at another. The atmosphere thinned
00:14:52.120 --> 00:14:55.340
and thickened as Pluto moved through its 248
00:14:55.340 --> 00:14:58.100
-year orbit, approaching and retreating from
00:14:58.100 --> 00:15:01.659
the Sun. Even the darkness of the far regions
00:15:01.659 --> 00:15:05.320
held complexity, bladed terrain of methane ice,
00:15:05.559 --> 00:15:09.440
carved by some process of sublimation and redeposition
00:15:09.440 --> 00:15:12.480
that planetary scientists are still working to
00:15:12.480 --> 00:15:15.779
understand. What did the early observers get
00:15:15.779 --> 00:15:21.639
right? They found a trans -Neptunian body. They
00:15:21.639 --> 00:15:25.580
detected methane on its surface. They measured
00:15:25.580 --> 00:15:29.340
its slow rotation. They placed it in approximately
00:15:29.340 --> 00:15:33.220
the right orbit. These were real achievements
00:15:33.220 --> 00:15:36.759
against the limits of their instruments. What
00:15:36.759 --> 00:15:40.559
did they misidentify? Almost everything else.
00:15:41.519 --> 00:15:44.740
The mass was wrong by a factor of more than 3
00:15:44.740 --> 00:15:49.100
,000. The size was wrong by a factor of several.
00:15:49.919 --> 00:15:54.000
The solitary nature was wrong. Pluto is a binary
00:15:54.000 --> 00:15:58.139
system with five known moons. The uniform surface
00:15:58.139 --> 00:16:02.399
was wrong. The geological deadness was wrong.
00:16:03.019 --> 00:16:06.740
The entire Lillian framework, the gravitational
00:16:06.740 --> 00:16:10.120
predictions that led to its discovery, was an
00:16:10.120 --> 00:16:13.820
illusion generated by measurement error. Pluto
00:16:13.820 --> 00:16:19.820
was not Planet X. It never had been. What remains
00:16:19.820 --> 00:16:24.200
uncertain even now? Whether a subsurface ocean
00:16:24.200 --> 00:16:29.289
persists, and if so, what it contains what mechanism
00:16:29.289 --> 00:16:32.350
drives the recent geological activity and whether
00:16:32.350 --> 00:16:36.730
that activity is continuous or episodic how the
00:16:36.730 --> 00:16:39.889
pluto -cheron binary formed whether by collision
00:16:39.889 --> 00:16:43.549
and reassembly by capture or by some other process
00:16:43.549 --> 00:16:48.870
these are not small questions how much atmosphere
00:16:48.870 --> 00:16:51.730
escapes to space and how that escape interacts
00:16:51.730 --> 00:16:55.580
with the solar wind at such distance what the
00:16:55.580 --> 00:16:58.120
full geological history records in its layered
00:16:58.120 --> 00:17:01.720
ice is. Whether similar worlds in the Kuiper
00:17:01.720 --> 00:17:04.880
belt share this activity, or whether Pluto is
00:17:04.880 --> 00:17:09.160
unusual even among its kind, the object endures.
00:17:09.900 --> 00:17:13.839
It orbits as it has for billions of years, indifferent
00:17:13.839 --> 00:17:17.660
to the categories we assign. The point of light
00:17:17.660 --> 00:17:21.180
that Tombaugh found in 1930 is the same world
00:17:21.180 --> 00:17:25.799
New Horizons photographed in 2015. What changed
00:17:25.799 --> 00:17:29.000
was not Pluto, but our capacity to see it, to
00:17:29.000 --> 00:17:32.519
weigh it, to visit it, to understand what a small,
00:17:32.619 --> 00:17:35.680
cold, distant body can nonetheless become when
00:17:35.680 --> 00:17:37.819
studied with patience and improved instruments.
00:17:38.839 --> 00:17:42.380
The ninth planet was a mirage built from mathematical
00:17:42.380 --> 00:17:46.720
ambition and observational limits. The dwarf
00:17:46.720 --> 00:17:49.440
planet is a real world with nitrogen glaciers
00:17:49.440 --> 00:17:52.619
and water ice mountains, and a thin blue haze.
00:17:53.579 --> 00:17:55.940
The correction does not diminish the object.
00:17:56.960 --> 00:18:01.700
It clarifies it. The blurred image sharpened,
00:18:01.700 --> 00:18:05.099
not into what we expected, but into what was
00:18:05.099 --> 00:18:06.000
actually there.