درباره این اپیزود
Former President Obama says the government cannot selectively target people for their politics or speech, and both hosts agree that is a bedrock American principle, rooted in the Constitution’s ban on bills of attainder. The test is whether it holds when the shoe is on the other foot. They point to the IRS denying employer ID numbers to more than 350 political nonprofits during the 2012 cycle, regulators pressuring the nine largest banks to debank an estimated 50,000 to 100,000 entities, and reports that Jack Smith subpoenaed data on roughly 650,000 MAGA hat buyers. They also play a clip of Senator Elissa Slotkin calling for a deterrence message that makes young people think twice about working for the Trump administration. With the Justice Department now investigating Rep. Ilhan Omar, and George Santos already expelled from Congress, the question is whether one standard applies to both sides. A principle you only invoke when you are out of power is not a principle.
Next, what happens to officials who abuse their power. They cite John Stossel’s examples of a $900,000 bill for a greenhouse mistaken for a marijuana grow, a $400,000 penalty for a missing one-page form, and a $100,000 fine for parking on your own property, plus a Federal Register that reached 106,000 pages. In the private sector you can sue for harm. In government you mostly cannot. One idea floated is letting citizens sue abusive regulators, with a supermajority jury and a lost pension as the penalty, and a high bar to protect honest mistakes. The Duke lacrosse prosecutor who hid exonerating evidence and lost his law license is the model. Power without personal consequences invites more of it.
California now requires large companies to disclose their historical ties to slavery, and the hosts debate how far that should go. One argues a lawsuit cannot fix an injustice from 150 years ago, citing statutes of limitations and the lack of any living wrongdoer or victim. The other asks what the limiting principle is, and suggests red states respond by making political parties write their own histories on slavery, noting every state that seceded was controlled by Democrats. Justice that reaches back four generations has no stopping point.
In France, President Macron vowed that those who destroyed and looted must pay after riots causing roughly $1 billion in damage, 2,400 arrests and 1,000 injured police. The hosts doubt anyone will pay that bill and argue empty promises corrode trust. France runs a 5.5 percent deficit, spends 2 percent of GDP on defense against a pledge to reach 4, and taxes income above $200,000 at a combined 68 percent. A proposed cut from 5.5 to 5 percent set off student protests that hard-left activists and immigrant communities then joined. Macron’s party is sinking in local votes while Marine Le Pen’s party won a plurality, even as she sits under house arrest with an ankle bracelet. Unrest has also reached Italy, and Spain’s leader called a snap election. A leader who promises what he cannot deliver spends his last credibility.
Closing, the hosts ask what could trigger unrest at home. If Democrats win the House but not the Senate, they could accomplish little, and Trump could fill Supreme Court seats if Alito and probably Thomas retire, pushing liberal hopes for the Court out another quarter century. They also back a proposal to let victims of violent crimes by illegal immigrants sue sanctuary states. They land on two linked principles, equal treatment under the law and accountability, because without accountability there is no equal treatment. Fear of consequences is what keeps power honest.
For more episodes and resources, visit fromourgeneration.com.
Dive deeper with Giants of Political Thought at giantsofpoliticalthought.com.