ACERCA DE ESTE EPISODIO
The Springfield Three: How Three Women Vanished | Haunted in Between
On June 7th, 1992, three women disappeared from a home on East Del Bar Street in Springfield, Missouri — and more than three decades later, no one has ever been charged, no bodies have ever been recovered, and the silence around what happened that night remains one of the most enduring mysteries in American true crime history.
In this episode of Haunted in Between, we tell the full story of the Springfield 3.
Sherrill Levitt was 47 — a cosmetologist, a mother, a woman her friends described as vibrant and full of energy, proud of the fresh start she was building in her new home. Her daughter Suzy Streeter was 19 — lively, independent, still in the process of figuring out what kind of person she would become. And Stacy McCall was 18 — dependable, kind, close to her parents, and known by everyone who loved her as the kind of person who always checked in.
The night before they vanished, Stacy and Suzy celebrated their graduation from Kickapoo High School — bouncing between parties, laughing with classmates, doing exactly what teenagers should do on a night like that. They arrived home sometime after 2 AM. Sherrill was likely already asleep. Nothing looked wrong.
By morning, all three were gone.
What investigators found — and didn't find — at the house on East Del Bar Street is what makes this case so uniquely haunting. No forced entry. No obvious signs of struggle. No blood. No clear indication that any of the three women had left willingly. Their purses were inside — all three. Their cars were in the driveway. Sherrill's cigarettes, her reading glasses, her open book — all there. Stacy's outfit, laid out for the next morning. The family dog, Cinnamon, trembling and distressed.
And then: an answering machine with a blinking light. A male voice on the recording. Erased automatically after playback before anyone could document what it said.
We walk through the full investigation — the early hours of discovery, the police response, the theories investigators have considered over the years, the national media attention including a feature on America's Most Wanted, and the devastating reality of what it means for three families to spend decades without a body to bury, a killer to face, or a definitive answer to hold onto.
This case is not solved. Somebody knows what happened. That knowledge may still exist — in a memory, in a conscience, in a detail that has never been shared. If you have information about the disappearance of Sherrill Levitt, Suzy Streeter, or Stacy McCall, please contact the Springfield Police Department.
If this episode moves you, please subscribe, leave a review, and share it. The best thing we can do for cold cases is keep them alive.
🎙️ Haunted in Between — new episodes weekly.
Music licensed through Sound stripe. Code: IDKQQUEFH1K1M1N2
#TrueCrime #ColdCase #Podcast #SpringfieldThree #Springfield3 #UnsolvedMystery #MissingPersons #CrimePodcast #TrueCrimePodcast #Unsolved #JusticeForVictims #Missouri #ColdCasePodcast #VanishedWithoutATrace #TrueCrimeCommunity #SuzyStreeter #StacyMcCall #SherrillLevitt #HauntedInBetween #CrimeInvestigation
