ÜBER DIESE EPISODE
Allison Gerber, Vice President of the Annie E. Casey Foundation's Center for Economic Opportunity, discusses what it takes to expand economic opportunity for young people and families, and why so many existing programs and systems fall short. Allison walks through the Center's three interconnected bodies of work around education and employment, income stability, and financial health, and explains why the pandemic forced a reckoning with how these strategies had long operated in silos. She shares striking data on young parents, roughly 9 million people ages 16 to 30 in the United States, most of whom are working but not getting ahead, and explores what it would take to design education and workforce systems around the reality of their lives. The conversation explores the promising role of community colleges as a connective tissue across these systems, the potential of technology and predictive analytics to reach struggling students before they disengage, and what educators, employers, and policymakers can each do to become true forces in expanding opportunity for young people and families.
Transcript
Julian Alssid: Welcome to the Work Forces Podcast. I'm Julian Alssid.
Kaitlin LeMoine: And I'm Kaitlin LeMoine, and we speak with innovators who are shaping the future of work and learning.
Julian Alssid: Together, we unpack the complex elements of workforce and career preparation, and offer practical solutions that can be scaled and sustained.
Kaitlin LeMoine: This podcast is an outgrowth of our Work Forces consulting practice. Through weekly discussions, we seek to share the trends and themes we see in our work and amplify impactful efforts happening in higher education, industry, and workforce development all across the country. We are grateful to Lumina Foundation for its past support during the initial development and launch of this podcast, and invite future sponsors of this effort, please check out our Work Forces podcast website to learn more. And so, with that, let's dive in. Julian, in our work and on this podcast, we talk a lot about what economic mobility truly requires. Access to a quality job or a training program is one piece of the puzzle, but to build financial stability over time, young people and families need more holistic and sustained support. And the more we dig into this, the clearer it becomes that many existing programs and related systems were not originally designed with that holistic approach in mind.
Julian Alssid: And the stakes get even higher when you add parenting into the picture. The data is striking. It's very difficult for young people who are raising children to get ahead economically. There's just not enough time in the day for students who are also parents, and the pathways we have built rarely account for that reality.
Kaitlin LeMoine: We are looking forward to digging into these challenges and possible ways forward in today's conversation. In this episode, we're speaking with Allison Gerber, Vice President of the Annie E. Casey Foundation Center for Economic Opportunity. Allison leads efforts to create pathways to financial stability and economic mobility for children, youth, and families across the United States. Before joining the Casey Foundation, Allison served as Executive Director of the District of Columbia's Workforce Investment Council and as a Senior Associate with the Aspen Institute's Workforce Strategies Initiative. Allison, welcome to Work Forces. We're so glad to have you with us today.
Allison Gerber: Well, thank you both for having me. I'm so glad to be here.
Julian Alssid: Yes, Allison, it is great to have you here. So, if you will, in your own words, tell us about your background and the path that led you to your current role at the Casey Foundation.
Allison Gerber: Absolutely. I mean, no good conversation around a career pathway would be good if we don't talk about our own career pathways, right?
Julian Alssid: Exactly.
Allison Gerber: So, I've spent my career working at the intersection of education, employment, and other sort of levers for economic opportunity. I went to law school and have worked very little as a lawyer over the course of my career, which I think is interesting when we think about young people and how their education sets them up for their future job path. But I, as you said, Kaitlin, I come to this work from several different vantage points, including program management, research and evaluation, local government, and now philanthropy. My first job in workforce development was for a national nonprofit that prepared job seekers for registered apprenticeship in construction, and then from there I went to work on research and leadership development. Led the public workforce system in D.C. and now I'm here as a grant maker at the Casey Foundation. I've been at the Casey Foundation since 2013, and I've held three different roles for the foundation. First, as a Senior Program Officer, doing a lot of grant making around education and employment. Then, leading our education and employment team, and now as the Vice President for the Center for Economic Opportunity. And so, over that time, my work has touched on a range of strategies that support economic opportunity for young people and their families. So, thinking about youth apprenticeship, sector-based workforce strategies, childcare, and other supports for working families, debt, entrepreneurship, and a variety of levers.
Kaitlin LeMoine: So, we're looking forward to diving in with a discussion of some of those levers today. As we get going, we'd love if you could give us an overview of the Center for Economic Opportunity and the work the foundation is doing to expand economic opportunity for young people and families.
Allison Gerber: As you may know, the Annie E. Casey Foundation's mission is to create a brighter future for young people in the United States, and in the Center for Economic Opportunity, our contribution to that mission is really around helping young people and their families achieve their education, employment, and financial goals, and to do that by changing the programs and the systems that can make it harder to reach those goals. We have a particular focus at the foundation. About 50% of our work in grant making is focused on young people who are disconnected or at risk of disconnection from school to work. We see these as the young people who are probably furthest from opportunity, and might include young people who've had experience in juvenile justice or child welfare, have experienced homelessness, or otherwise their intersections of where they grew up or how they grew up just made it a little bit harder to access the programs and services that are helping them get on a career pathway. And we see adolescence as a really critical window into which we can help young people. I think there's increasing awareness that following toddlerhood, adolescence is the second very large window of development that we all go through on our way to adulthood, and so this is a particular period in which we can really put a lot of support and investment around young people to help them get on a strong pathway towards adulthood. And at the same time, as you mentioned in your introductions, our current policies and practices and systems haven't really kept pace with the reality of the lives that they're experiencing as they seek to navigate education and the economy. And so, really trying to think about how we modernize those opportunities.
Julian Alssid: So, you've done some research with the Urban Institute on young parents, and that paints a pretty striking picture of how difficult it is for people to achieve economic mobility when they're parenting at a young age. Can you speak to us a bit about what the data show, and then what are the implications for how we design education and workforce systems?
Allison Gerber: Yeah, absolutely. So let me back up a little bit and say just a little bit more about how we approach our work, and then how we think about the ways that parents fit in. So we have three main bodies of work in the Center for Economic Opportunity. The first is around education and employment, so really helping young people get the skills and work experiences that they need to have family-sustaining careers, and we really ground it in that family-sustaining careers. And then the second is thinking about the income, the stability of the income, and the supports available to families. So making sure that young people's basic needs are met, things like food and housing, and that they have the support they need to pursue their education and career, and so that also includes something like childcare when you think about young parents. And then the third is really around thinking about the financial health and asset building for young people and families. So helping young people manage debt, access fair financial products, save, and hopefully begin building assets that contribute to long-term financial goals and set their children up for success. And so, as we think about those bodies of work over the last year or so, we sought to do a deeper dive into understanding how these three pieces are intersecting in the lives of young parents, and I think this work at some level was sort of deeply emotional to me because it forced me to confront a lot of what I think I know about economic mobility in our country. And I think what we saw is that young parents are working, but they're not getting ahead. And when you compare them to young people at the same age, let's say 22, 23, 24, who aren't parenting, parents are much less likely to experience economic mobility, and that's kind of hard to stomach. So if you look at the numbers, there are about 9 million parents ages 16 to 30 in the United States. 7 million of them are working. So it isn't that they're not doing the things that they need to do to support their family. They are. At the same time, we see that less than three in 10 workers who are 18 to 24 have a job that gives them a family-supporting wage, that provides full-time work, that has benefits like health care, 401k, and all those things, let alone opportunities for skill building or advancement at work, and young parents are much less likely to have jobs with those features. And so if you think about what that means, it means young people early on in their trajectories, in their mid to late 20s, parents and non-parents begin to diverge. Non-parents are much more likely to be able to move into higher-paying, more stable work, and young parents are more likely to remain in lower-paying jobs with fewer opportunities. And so I'll say one more piece about this, and this will be no surprise to anybody who's parenting, is time. Our young parents are balancing work, caregiving, running a household. Childcare might be expensive, unavailable, incompatible with their schedule. Many grandparents and other relatives and family and friends are helping care for kids, but those supports can be unstable because other people are pitching in as they can, and so it's very hard to be going to school and working, which are the two things you kind of have to be doing to get ahead, and also care for your children in a high quality and stable manner, which is the thing that all parents want to do, right? And so they start to experience that tension really early on, and it's very hard to get out of that box.
Julian Alssid: Are there, in the research, are you finding any opportunities or pathways for young parents that are sort of higher yield?
Allison Gerber: Some of the work that has felt strong and increasingly strong over the last, let's say, 10 years has been work focused on student parents. So, working with community colleges to think about how campus supports, schedules, even things like co-location of childcare can better support parents. And I think last month was Student Parent Month, and it was interesting because it's really become a movement. It has gone from being a sort of small conversation that a subset of people are having on campuses to, particularly on community college campuses, a realization that the majority of their students are parenting, and that we really need to think about something beyond go back to school at night with your extra time, and that we think about flexible, better connected education that has childcare and basic needs supports and financial assistance, and that feels like a bright spot.
Kaitlin LeMoine: So I think you're starting to head in this direction, Allison. But going back to what you mentioned around those three big themes of your work around education and employment, and stability around food and housing security, and then the financial health and asset building work, how do you see those three buckets or themes tying together? And so far as which levers are most effective to pull around some of these findings?
Allison Gerber: So let me say what I think is, to be asset based, an opportunity for improvement. As we think about young parents, is really to focus more on what happens at work, to think about the structure of work. So things like predictable schedules, paid leave, flexible arrangements, benefits provided at work, childcare supports, and really opportunities for training and advancement on the job, and weaving in all three of those pieces into the work day and the work lives of parents, so that advancement can happen during the work day and not just after work.
Kaitlin LeMoine: Right, and that addresses that key piece of time and when do we possibly fit that upskilling or additional training in when you're at work all day and then have a whole other set of responsibilities once you leave. That makes so much sense. You did mention community colleges having a central role in this work. Would love to expand the conversation a little bit to talk about community colleges as a central focus of your work, and how do you see that fitting within your center's core focus areas?
Allison Gerber: So just to back up and give a little history of where we've been and where we are now. Our grant making in the center has involved community colleges in some form or fashion for a long time. But historically, the three parts of the center that I mentioned have engaged in partnerships and support for community colleges in different ways. So, as we talked about, education and employment, really working with colleges on career pathways and high quality credentialing opportunities that are aligned with the labor market, and our work with student parents and our support for basic needs really being focused on building out access to food, transportation, childcare, and other student supports on campus, and then our financial health work was looking at affordability and debt, and so thinking about the two sides of the coin around how do people currently make enough income so that they can afford to be in school, and how do they go to school in a way that doesn't impact their future financial picture. And sometime, and it was really during the early days of the pandemic, when we saw young people dropping out of colleges in high numbers because of the tension of managing all of these things, we found ourselves asking a question that we probably should have asked a long time before: why are these portfolios treating these as separate strategies when the opportunities and challenges are experienced by the same student? And so that really changed how we started to think about the ways that we wanted to support community colleges through our grant making, the ways that we wanted to partner with colleges, and like for me, I think about it — I do come out of that career pathway side of the house, and so I had to start thinking about: okay, one thing we know colleges have done a lot of really strong work on over the last two decades is healthcare pathways. I think we can all point to hundreds of really strong healthcare pathways that are helping young people prepare for a variety of jobs, but if you have to participate in a clinical placement as a part of that program, whether it be for nursing or for rad tech or whatever, you're going to be required to probably give up or adjust your work schedule several hours a week over multiple weeks every semester, depending on the length of your program, for multiple years, and the truth is that most entry level jobs students are working in don't offer that kind of flexibility, and that immediately makes that very good pathway unaffordable and inaccessible for that student. And that just seems like, well, what's the point of building all of these things if the young people that we want to access them structurally can't, and so that had us start thinking about how do we bring the career pathways, the student supports, and the strategies that address the indirect and the direct costs of attending college into the same grant making strategy, and thinking about does that improve persistence? Does that improve credential attainment? Does that improve access to well-paying careers?
Julian Alssid: Allison, are there community colleges that you can point to now that you think are effectively weaving together what you all have in mind for the community college work?
Allison Gerber: There are definitely community colleges, and I bet we would all name a handful of really well-known community colleges, and I think the challenge in that is it's not clear that it's widely available, and it's not clear that all colleges have the kind of supports and strategies in place that they need to provide those supports to students. And so I'm hesitant to call out the high flyers because I think they get called out a lot, and what I'd love to see is there being too many to name. Some of the landscaping we've been doing has shown that what we've seen, which I think is a real positive, is that many colleges have the pieces in place in each of these three domains that they need, but they need help connecting them more intentionally. So they probably have, as we talked about, a set of terrific healthcare career pathways, and maybe they have a range of student supports, and they invariably have a financial aid office. It's challenging for students though because those offerings don't sit side by side and operate within a coherent system. They sort of have to go from one to the other and piece it together. And so we've seen colleges trying to take different strategies to address that. So thinking about is there a centralized place where students can access supports? And I think we have a history of investing in more physical centralized places through our Center for Working Families. But what we're starting to ask is, does that need to be physical? Can that be virtual? What does technology enable that it never did before? And relatedly, how can colleges use their own institutional data to maybe get ahead of folks even needing to come to the virtual or the real place, to pinpoint when a student is starting to struggle and to target those interventions to them in real time through things like predictive analytics and other strategies that might modernize that holistic one-stop approach. And so I think that's the opportunity. It's not that some of these things don't exist and colleges don't have a lot of really great things happening, and I don't want to be the next person to pile on and say that instructors should do more or colleges should do more, knowing that they're constrained, and they can't be everything to every student. But are there ways that we can help connect good things that they're already doing that allow them to deliver a little more efficiently, a little more effectively?
Kaitlin LeMoine: And I really appreciate you bringing up the use of technology as part of this landscape and thinking about where to leverage technology and existing, like you said, predictive analytics to help with maybe reaching a learner before they say, I actually can't show up to this class anymore, it's just a step too far right now, and then balancing that with when is the moment when you need the in-person, on-campus support. It's a complicated balance but I think more and more the answer seems to be somewhere in there, and maybe it's different for different colleges as well, right? There's not going to be one exact right approach, but maybe the magic is in some combination of those different services and supports.
Allison Gerber: And maybe the magic is in figuring out, I guess, what the researchers would call dosage, right? What is the right combination of those supports? Not just for the college, but can they calibrate it to the learner? And what would it take to be able to do that? Does technology enable that calibration? Is it allowing us to better understand where learners are? And we've seen this in our benefits access work. We've done some work to really support the uptake of food nutrition programs, SNAP on college campuses, and a technological front door can be a great way of helping a student navigate the complexity of applying for a program, the documentation that's required, verifying their income, verifying their identity. But sometimes they need help getting to that front door through a navigator who says, you know, it's okay to access this program. This is what it's here for. You shouldn't feel embarrassed. You shouldn't feel like you're taking something from somebody else by accessing it, and kind of helping people overcome that first step of asking for help, or furthering the process when it gets complicated. And some of these public programs are complicated, even when we really want to provide the support, and helping people understand, oh, I got a notice and it says I'm not eligible. What happened, and what can I do to back up in this process, and can I address that mistake? And so I think that combination and that timing is really important.
Julian Alssid: Well, I think this is a good lead into a question that we ask all of our guests, and given that our podcast is called Work Forces, Allison, what would you recommend to our audience of educators, employers, or policymakers who want to become forces in expanding economic opportunity for young people and families?
Allison Gerber: I love this question, and I love this play on forces. So thank you so much for asking it. It feels really fun, right? It lets us all think about how we can make a difference in the world. So, I think part of the challenge in this discussion is for all of us to think about how we design around the lives of students and young workers. Many students are workers, many are also caregivers or parents, and so I think just to break it down into a couple of your audiences, for educators, I think that's around building flexible pathways that connect school and work. I think that's about finding ways to make work-based learning paid. I think that's about bringing food, transportation, housing, and childcare into core offerings on campuses in a way that really intermingles it with the career pathway, rather than it being an add-on to an academic offering. For employers, we really want to encourage employers to think beyond recruitment and to think about retention and advancement, and ask themselves: Can workers see and access the next step within your company? Is there clarity? Is there transparency about that? Do your scheduling practices, your benefits, your frontline supervision make it easier for workers to take that step? Are you doing everything you can to make it seamless in your company? And then for parents in particular, thinking about predictable scheduling, flexibility, childcare support — are those things available to really help somebody climb within a company? And then I think the biggest sort of lift of all is for policymakers: can they make these systems connect? So many systems, right? Education, workforce development and training, public benefits, childcare, financial aid, all of them administered through different agencies and different funding streams. And I often think about it like that game we played as kids, like where you bounce the ball and you pick up a jack — why do young people have to keep bouncing the ball and pick up each of these jacks separately? Can they experience all of these opportunities all at once? And so, simplifying those access points that help people stay connected to school and work. And then, lastly, because I love this question so much I had so many different answers to it, I think for all of us it is to listen to and talk to young people. They're navigating so much change in technology and work and education. The cost of living is rising, and when I really try to put myself in their shoes, I realize that the life that a 20-something is leading looks so different than the life I led as a 20-something, and however well intentioned I might be, I don't have that experience. And I think sometimes it results in these negative narratives about young people and whether they want to work or they're good workers, and I think if we stop comparing them to ourselves and really accepted that their lives are very different, we might find ourselves really thinking about what our institutions look like if we design for them in a way that would benefit everybody.
Kaitlin LeMoine: Thank you for bringing us back to who are the learners, right, and what are their stories, and how can we seek to learn and evolve and change and grow based on what needs look like today and moving forward. As we wind down our conversation today, Allison, how can our listeners learn more about your work and follow what the Annie E. Casey Foundation is doing in this space?
Allison Gerber: I would say please visit our website. It's www.aecf.org, and on our website, you can sign up for what we call e-news or e-newsletters. There's one for economic opportunity, and through that newsletter, we're trying to push out stories of young people, stories of programs and practitioners who are working with young people, sometimes some research, sometimes some data. We wouldn't be the Annie E. Casey Foundation without the data and thinking about our Kids Count work, but really highlighting those voices of young people and practitioners and the lessons that work suggests for all of us.
Julian Alssid: Well, thank you so much for taking the time to speak with us today, Allison. It's been a great discussion. I'm sure our listeners will enjoy it, as I know we have, and we look forward to being in touch and continuing to follow your important work.
Allison Gerber: Well, thank you both for the opportunity. This was a really fun conversation. I particularly loved the how do we be a force for good question, and really appreciated the opportunity to engage with you both.
Kaitlin LeMoine: Well, thank you for joining us. We appreciate this dialog. We hope you enjoyed today's conversation and appreciate you tuning in to Work Forces. Thank you to our listeners and guests for their ongoing support, and a special thanks to our producer Dustin Ramsdell. If you're interested in sponsoring the podcast or want to check out more episodes, please visit workforces.info/podcast. You can also find Work Forces wherever you regularly listen to your favorite podcasts. If you enjoyed this episode, please subscribe, like, and share it with your colleagues and friends. And if you're interested in learning more about Work Forces Consulting, please visit workforces.info/consulting for more details about our multi-service practice.