ÜBER DIESE EPISODE
Canada's prime minister is invoking history to explain his own policies, but glossing over the harms of the past.
By Rachel Gilmore.
Sitting in a carefully lit room, with the top button of his shirt undone and the demeanour of a father speaking to his children after a long day at the office, Prime Minister Mark Carney addressed Canadians this week amid escalating trade tensions with the United States.
In doing so, he turned to Canadian history to explain his own policies.
"Our first prime minister, Sir John A. Macdonald, recognized the threat of an expansionist United States for what it was and raced to unite this land," Carney calmly and slowly told Canadians in the YouTube video.
"Canada needed an economic and military corridor that could connect our peoples from east to west. And so, at an incredible human and financial cost, Canadians took what was a country on paper and made it real. They built an iron spine."
Carney continued to extol the virtues of Macdonald's major project.
"Almost 5,000 kilometres of railroad track from east to west, the Canadian Pacific Railway stitched together our country and made our presence undeniable and unbreakable," he said.
While Macdonald's rail project was undeniably momentous for Canada, Carney's decision to invoke this particular man, framing him as one who "raced to unite this land," was revealing — particularly given who paid the price for this unification.
Macdonald was such a virulent anti-Indigenous and anti-Chinese racist (even for the time, as historians have noted) that his statues have been pulled down and his name struck off of institutions across the country in recent years. Not only that, but the very project Carney extolled — the Canadian Pacific Railway — was achieved only because those same prejudices were put into action with the exploitation of Chinese labourers and the violent displacement of Indigenous people.
Carney has repeatedly proven to be someone who chooses his words carefully, from his use of the term "transformational" in his meeting with Donald Trump to his Davos speech heard around the world.
In this case, Carney chose to paint the history of a major project as one that may have had some vague "human and financial cost," but that this cost was necessary in order to "unite this land" in the face of U.S. aggression.
It's the same false compromise he's asking Canadians to make in the face of Trump, while Carney relentlessly pursues an extractive agenda that impresses corporate investors but largely ignores Indigenous opposition and dooms future generations to climate catastrophe.
The implications of invoking Macdonald's name
Macdonald is a controversial name for Carney to have invoked at all.
"What on earth does Sir John A. Macdonald have to do with Donald Trump? I mean, if you're going to mention struggles in Canada's creation, you literally cannot leave out the massive genocide committed against Indigenous Peoples," said Pam Palmater, a Mi'kmaq lawyer.
In recent years, his statues have been removed and some institutions named after Macdonald have been renamed, given his key role as an architect of the deadly, racist residential school system.
A right-wing backlash followed these events — one that has increasingly seen Macdonald adopted as a key figure by both mainstream and far-right movements.
In May, the Dominion Society of Canada, a racist far-right group that advocates the mass deportation from the country of millions of largely non-white people, held a rally calling for the city of Hamilton to restore a statue of Macdonald. The group also quotes Macdonald on the home page of its website. For many of these far-right figures, the push for an honest conversation about Macdonald's true legacy is emblematic of the kind of social progress they oppose.
Even for more mainstream right-wing figures, the reference Carney made to Macdonald in his recent video had significant meaning.
"It's an inflection point: the end of the quasi-official cancellation of our fou...
By Rachel Gilmore.
Sitting in a carefully lit room, with the top button of his shirt undone and the demeanour of a father speaking to his children after a long day at the office, Prime Minister Mark Carney addressed Canadians this week amid escalating trade tensions with the United States.
In doing so, he turned to Canadian history to explain his own policies.
"Our first prime minister, Sir John A. Macdonald, recognized the threat of an expansionist United States for what it was and raced to unite this land," Carney calmly and slowly told Canadians in the YouTube video.
"Canada needed an economic and military corridor that could connect our peoples from east to west. And so, at an incredible human and financial cost, Canadians took what was a country on paper and made it real. They built an iron spine."
Carney continued to extol the virtues of Macdonald's major project.
"Almost 5,000 kilometres of railroad track from east to west, the Canadian Pacific Railway stitched together our country and made our presence undeniable and unbreakable," he said.
While Macdonald's rail project was undeniably momentous for Canada, Carney's decision to invoke this particular man, framing him as one who "raced to unite this land," was revealing — particularly given who paid the price for this unification.
Macdonald was such a virulent anti-Indigenous and anti-Chinese racist (even for the time, as historians have noted) that his statues have been pulled down and his name struck off of institutions across the country in recent years. Not only that, but the very project Carney extolled — the Canadian Pacific Railway — was achieved only because those same prejudices were put into action with the exploitation of Chinese labourers and the violent displacement of Indigenous people.
Carney has repeatedly proven to be someone who chooses his words carefully, from his use of the term "transformational" in his meeting with Donald Trump to his Davos speech heard around the world.
In this case, Carney chose to paint the history of a major project as one that may have had some vague "human and financial cost," but that this cost was necessary in order to "unite this land" in the face of U.S. aggression.
It's the same false compromise he's asking Canadians to make in the face of Trump, while Carney relentlessly pursues an extractive agenda that impresses corporate investors but largely ignores Indigenous opposition and dooms future generations to climate catastrophe.
The implications of invoking Macdonald's name
Macdonald is a controversial name for Carney to have invoked at all.
"What on earth does Sir John A. Macdonald have to do with Donald Trump? I mean, if you're going to mention struggles in Canada's creation, you literally cannot leave out the massive genocide committed against Indigenous Peoples," said Pam Palmater, a Mi'kmaq lawyer.
In recent years, his statues have been removed and some institutions named after Macdonald have been renamed, given his key role as an architect of the deadly, racist residential school system.
A right-wing backlash followed these events — one that has increasingly seen Macdonald adopted as a key figure by both mainstream and far-right movements.
In May, the Dominion Society of Canada, a racist far-right group that advocates the mass deportation from the country of millions of largely non-white people, held a rally calling for the city of Hamilton to restore a statue of Macdonald. The group also quotes Macdonald on the home page of its website. For many of these far-right figures, the push for an honest conversation about Macdonald's true legacy is emblematic of the kind of social progress they oppose.
Even for more mainstream right-wing figures, the reference Carney made to Macdonald in his recent video had significant meaning.
"It's an inflection point: the end of the quasi-official cancellation of our fou...
Englisch
Vereinigte Staaten
TRANSKRIPT 🔗
Are you the producer of this podcast?
Add a podcast transcript
Need Audio-to-Text?
Transcribe with Listen411 in Just 60 Seconds
VERGANGENE FOLGEN SUCHEN
Vorhandene Folgen von The Tyee: Audio Edition durchsuchen.
WEITERE EPISODEN IN DIESEM PODCAST
Doerkson vows to overhaul NDP's top-down laws. Here's what was learned and what needs to happen.
By Patrick Condon.
When British Columbia's NDP government rushed through housing bills 44, 46 and 47 in late 2023, it did so with a clear imbalance in who got heard. Mayors across Metro Vancouver later …
Surfrider Foundation's ReSurf program has diverted 4.5 tonnes of neoprene from the landfill since May 2025.
By Adrienne Mason.
Tofino and Ucluelet might have been built on fish and timber, but a good part of today's economy is supported by neoprene and foam.
The synthetic materials clothe surfers —…
The union for striking Highland Valley Copper mine workers plans to keep fighting scab labour.
By Isaac Phan Nay.
The BC Labour Relations Board has ordered Highland Valley Copper mine owner Teck Resources to stop using replacement workers while more than 1,200 employees are on strike.
The miners, u…
'In Logan Lake, it's all copper,' observed a journalist in 1977. Today not much has changed.
By Tyler Olsen.
Highland Valley Copper is not your average British Columbia mine. And because of that, Logan Lake is not a typical B.C. community.
As more than 1,000 workers at the massive copper mine south…
The three-year contract includes wages that will reach $29 per hour by the end of the contract.
By Isaac Phan Nay.
About 800 unionized workers at a Delta, B.C. warehouse have become the first Amazon workers in North America to get a collective agreement with the retail and tech giant.
Since October…
Rechtliche Hinweise: Der auf dieser Seite eingebettete Podcast und das Bildmaterial stammen von The Tyee, das Eigentum seines Eigentümers ist und nicht mit Listen Notes, Inc. verbunden ist oder von diesen unterstützt wird.
BEARBEITEN
Vielen Dank, dass Sie uns helfen, die Podcast-Datenbank auf dem neuesten Stand zu halten.