FINDING THE PERFORMANCE – Directing First-Timers and Non-Actors

Welcome back, Rebels!

In this episode of Low-Budget Rebels, we’re digging into one of the most intimidating — and most rewarding — parts of indie filmmaking: working with actors. When you’re making movies with tiny budgets, tight schedules, and often first-time performers, directing performances becomes less about “perfection” and more about trust, communication, and creating an environment where people feel safe to try things. This week’s guests share how they’ve learned to guide performances, build confidence, and get honest, compelling work from actors under low-budget conditions.

We kick things off with Dan Lotz, director of Chlorine, The Long Con, and Sheep Theater. Dan reflects on making movies with his friends as a kid and how those early experiments taught him what kinds of performances you can realistically get from people. He opens up about the fear of stepping in front of the camera himself and carrying a film as a performer, and how learning to act gave him empathy for what actors go through. Dan also talks about the unique challenges of directing performances within an improvisational style, where structure and freedom have to exist at the same time.

Next up, Nick Psinakis, co-director of Cheat and Valley View Motel, breaks down how studying acting changed the way he directs. Nick shares how learning performance from the inside helped him communicate more clearly with actors, listen more closely, and build real relationships with his cast. We talk about techniques for getting organic, natural performances on set, and how often actors will surprise you when you give them the space and trust to bring their own instincts into a scene.

Then Joe Sherlock, the mind behind Trailer Park Double Wide Trilogy of Terror, The Haunting of Heather Black, and the Weird House films, talks about his approach to finding and working with actors. Joe dives into the importance of being upfront about the kinds of movies you’re making and the tone you’re going for, so the people who show up are aligned with the vision. He shares how openness and communication lead to better buy-in from the cast, and how being honest about the limitations of a low-budget production helps actors give you their best work instead of feeling misled or frustrated.

Finally, Sean Ashley (R.S. Trashley), director of the Homicide McLeod films and producer of Get That Dick, talks about finding talent through festivals and community. Sean reflects on meeting incredible actors through the Atlanta film scene, including collaborations that came directly from simply showing up and engaging with people. We dig into the anxiety of bringing new talent onto a project, not knowing what they’ll bring to the table, and the techniques he uses to steer performances without crushing what makes an actor unique.

This episode is all about trust, communication, and empathy — learning how to meet actors where they are, especially when you’re working with first-timers or friends who are learning alongside you. It’s a reminder that great performances don’t come from control. They come from collaboration.Thank you so much for supporting Low-Budget Rebels. Your support keeps these conversations ad free and helps us keep bringing real, honest filmmaking discussions to the table. If you’re not already a member, you can join us at patreon.com/flushstudios.

And don’t forget to follow and support this episode’s incredible guests:
Dan Lotz – Chlorine, The Long Con, Sheep Theater
Nick Psinakis – Cheat, Valley View Motel
Joe Sherlock – Trailer Park Double Wide Trilogy of Terror, The Haunting of Heather Black, Weird House films
R.S. Trashley (Sean Ashley) – Homicide McLeod films, Get That Dick

More fearless filmmaking conversations are on the way. Stay scrappy, keep learning, and stay rebellious.<br...