Must See IMDB

✓

Claim

Abby and Katie welcome back a favorite guest, Chris, to discuss the long awaited show we've all finally made our way through, The Americans. Will there be back stabbing and double-agent crossing as we hash it out over the best episode in this series? конечно!  Tell us about your hidden gem epi…

It's summertime and that means it's time to cover classic literature adaptations. This summer we are skipping over direct Pride & Prejudice fare (Katie is team 1995 & Abby is team 2005 for the record). Instead, we are looking at the universe of P&P adaptations and will cover 3…

We've grabbed our books, given ourselves a look, and arrived at the corner just in time to see the bus fly by. Therefore! It's finally time to dive into the world of Bayside for a Saved By the Bell debate. Will Zack scheme his way to the top in the very best episode? That's a given n…

Abby and Katie are joined by their dad to discuss the groundbreaking sitcom Roseanne. Will this family pod get together have as much drama as a Lanford gathering? Most definitely not. Which episode will elbow its way to the top? Listen on to find out! Tell us about your hidden gem episode, or anyth…

Oh, wow. It's time we cover Barry! At the end of 2025 Katie challenged Abby to watch this show so it could be discussed, and we're finally here. Which episode will be the best beignet of the bunch? Which sister will conquer the ever raging season 4 debate? Is Barry simply a "tale tol…

Abby and Katie are having a hard time sticking to one show we are so obsessed with everything you can watch on PBS, especially if you support public media with their Passport to all past shows. Are we into true crime? Not really, but if you give us an offbeat detective of any kind on a PBS show we …

Abby and Katie welcome special guest, and SATC expert, Viann to discuss this classic NYC series of fairy tale meets reality. Will we wax poetic, with Charlottesque wonder at what the IMDB voters selected as the best episode of the series? Or more likely come in swinging like Miranda, with some blun…

Abby, Katie and special guest Sam are sneaking over to Scranton before the end of the year to celebrate The Office- which our polls show is top billed by listeners, and not yet covered by us! Abby regrets not choosing The Office to take to a deserted island after revisiting this gem, Katie knows wh…

To celebrate our 50th episode we look back on our best picks of the past, but also prepare for what we should cover ahead. A poll of Castaway Bay TV shows will decide a future episode, as will Katie picking a show Abby hasn't seen, and vice versa. We are in the business of finding hidden gem e…