逐字稿 🔗
Impact(ed) S3E10: Hi, everyone, welcome. This is Eric Korvath with Lucas Turner Owens and Rodney Foxworth, the three co-hosts of Impacted. So we're really happy to be here to help wrap up Impacted's third season. we did a lot this season. we covered things around your retirement investments, venture capital, community development, finance, and just everything else under the sun that I would consider to be investments that impact people. And what we're really excited to do for the next, you know, handful of minutes is really just bring the three co-hosts who have covered the entire season together to kind of first look back and think about the the episodes and the moments that have really stuck with us. and then look towards the the future and and future seasons and what we want to talk about next. So, you know, just to kind of kick us off, let's let's let's share, guys, like what moments are really sticking with you, what episodes really stood out, and what are you thinking about coming out of season three? Well I'm happy to kick it off and say first, thanks to folks that are listening. you may have just caught this episode the season. Maybe you caught several, but in case you didn't catch all of them, hopefully this points your attention to some you might want to check out. the one that sticks for me is the conversation that we had, Rodney, with Jed Emerson, for a bunch of reasons. And I'll try to summarize what was a really robust and 30 or 40 minute conversation. One is that he said, you know, we really can't forget the impact of politics on this work. and I'll say for two reasons. One is that public policy can create tailwinds or headwinds for the industries in which we want to invest, right? Think about climate change as one example. but also you can think of impact investing as in relationship with, you know, what the federal government would otherwise spend money on. So I I think of the image of of like an estuary where like fresh water meets Saltwater, what is the responsibility of the government and what's the responsibility of capital markets? And Jed was helping us, you know, ask that question. But there's some other things that he that he said as well that I want to quickly call out. One is that maybe we shouldn't be thinking of scale as sort of our sole goal or as a definition of success. maybe more specifically, we shouldn't confuse scale with positive impact. and then, you know, one other quick thing that I'll call out is he he he also asked the question. What does it mean for folks to feel really powerless in this moment? Is that why we're seeing so many strong men elected all over the world and rise of fascism? Although I will say this week that we're recording Lula beat Bolsonaro, so that's a good sign. but I think those things are all connected, right? Like if folks are feeling disempowered and we're seeing what's happening with the rise of the right politically, how does that relate to this conversation around the concentration of power and capital in impact investing and Let's make sure we don't make some similar mistakes that we may have made in the past to further concentrate power. We don't want impact investing to just be a form of noblesse oblige. We want it to ideally be something that reflects the will of a broader base of people. And that's something that you wrote about Rodney in your Substack post and something that I think Jed kind of pointed us to in his comments. Yeah, Lucas, you know, I mean, it's not a surprise that that was one of the episodes that just quickly came to mind to you because I don't know how about the the The two of you, but that episode, I got a lot of great feedback from folks saying that was if not their favorite, one of their favorite episodes, across all seasons, by the way. And I think a big part of that, obviously everything that you named, Lucas, in terms of what Jed brought to the conversation, his incredible insights. And let's just not, you know, let's just state it plainly, man. I mean, I've known Jed for a number of years. I know you have too. He's just like a a charismatic figure, an outsized personality. He says what he means. And I think there's just so much appreciation for someone that can just like cut to the heart of like the matter, right? Someone who doesn't try to obscure like the reality of like what we're facing and is not contemplating things from a perspective of like, what does the profession need? What does the industry need? It's actually like, what is the change we're trying to make? And that is at the heart of what Jed is all about. And the fact that he has such a unique backstory in terms of the impact investing, profession, right? In terms of starting his career off as a social worker. I think this is something like, you know, Eric and I have talked about for years in terms of this sector, this industry needs like a very different set of perspectives to really shape the promise for impact investing more generally. So not surprised, I love that episode as well. I really enjoyed Our conversation, the conversation that Eric and I had with Smith Adas over at World Education Services, otherwise known as Wes, for a number of reasons. One, Eric and I had an opportunity to spend some time with Smith Smith a few weeks ago. but one, she's just a brilliant practitioner. I think the uniqueness of Wes from the perspective of being an operating not-for-profit entity that has built up a remarkable balance sheet. That it's driving towards a hundred percent mission. Smith being chief investment officer of that entity and really leading quite boldly and having this conversation about private equity, in which it was quite nuanced. It wasn't a conversation about private equity good, private equity bad, which is something I feel like so often these conversations can kind of go go into. It was really nuanced, right, Eric. And so I really appreciate that conversation. Well, one of the things I think with I love
Load full transcript
both of those episodes, but the thing with With Smith and when we talked about the pros and cons of private equity, I think one of the table stakes is we were saying that they have investments in private equity. And I think one thing we were trying to talk about was rather than I think we've all been to conferences or heard panels when in some of the some spaces in our industry where immediately people say private equity, and there's this kind of pause and laugh and rolling of the eyes, as if everyone's in on the joke that it's terrible. But And it is in many cases. But what we did with Smith, though, was we had more of an honest look at being like, but we have investments or allocations to private equity. And all of the other allocators, not all of, but a lot of the other allocators that would be in that room that would kind of roll their eyes and be like, yeah, terrible, let's move on, also have allocations to private equity. So what I loved about the episode is that we were trying to at least confront that, name its issues, and then talk about ways that there could be kind of Positive intervention. And quickly on that point, Eric, I want to say I think maybe it's important that we part of what we can do with this podcast is bring some more precision to that language and to the way that we talk about some of these asset classes because you know talk about private equity and as it relates to something like the broader stock market and how it's different. And I think about the article that just came out this week or last week about CalPers trimming their exposure to public equity, specifically to the seven companies driving the SP 500, to then rotate. out of public markets and into private equity. And the reason that they said that they did that was to have more diversification, right? To get exposure to hundreds of private companies that are quite large instead of just those seven. So when we say private equity, it's a bit of a misnomer because we have some really, really large companies that in an a couple decades ago would have been public companies that are now private. So if you just want exposure to the biggest companies in the country, you're going to have to think about private equity, right? So it's just like the the the field is changing. Maybe our language should change a little bit. A hundred percent. I feel like we're looking Ronnie, no you want to hop in. I just want to say, to this thing of I I do we're gonna talk about this, but I do hope that our podcast and community can be a conversation for that level of nuance and that level of interrogation. I'm w Rodney, you want to hop in first? I want to say something about Jed's episode, but I want you to go on to this thread. No, please do. So I really loved Jed's episode two and knowing that his background is as a social worker, it's a really good kind of umbrella. It served as a good umbrella or tie-in for a lot of the the founding story of the podcast. the first two seasons, Lucas and I interviewed a lot of people of color that worked in finance and investing, who identified as coming from non-traditional backgrounds or not coming from Wall Street or or or traditional banking backgrounds. And That has always been something that, you know, we feel that type of perspective and that type of background, the kind of space of moving capital for good would highly benefit from. So to hear someone who's such a respected leader for decades and decades to kind of look at his career path and see where he started, for me I felt like it was inspiration and definitely a huge through line for the ethos of the podcast and honestly also what we feel. the space would benefit from. it actually would make more impactful investments if Jed was less of a anomal his background was seen as less of like unique or not traditional, but if it was indeed more, more commonplace. The episode that I just want to highlight, there's some all of them are so great and so appreciative of all of our guests, but you know, was the one that I want to just bring up quickly is the first episode that we had. that was on Blackstone and your retirement. So we were talking about how alternative asset managers such as Blackstone and other large private equity firms are and this goes to the policy piece too. they're encroaching on individual retail investor 401ks. So the thing that really stood out to me in that conversation was I think one of our guests may have said this, but we talked about if you care about the how investments impact people. and if you care about how investments impact working class, middle class, non-affluent people, we should probably care about how people's retirements are invested because of how many millions and millions of working class Americans are going to be impacted by private equity filling their formal case. And I I I just you know I for me I don't I and maybe I'm not going to the right places, but I haven't heard that being a constant drumbeat in the space. and I'm glad that we were able to bring that into the conversation. Yeah, I mean, listen, Eric, that was one of my I really enjoyed that episode as well. And, you know, one of the things that comes to mind to me on that too is that the way that we had that conversation, having, you know, two individuals representing sort of what we thought might be two. Different sides of the coin actually having a lot of commonality in terms of where how they're approaching things, right? from the perspective of, you know, an investment advisor whom as seeing their clients from an institutional perspective, how they're move out, you how they're allocating in the private markets and having some deep concerns and reservations and raising questions about what does it look like for, you know, non-affluent, you know, middle class American retirement savers. investing into these alternative strategies that, as was pointed out in the conversation, don't always net out for like, you know, the most
sophisticated institutional investors either. Right. And so I just think it was really a great conversation to have with, you know, that policy perspective, right? And then also a really practical and pragmatic perspective on from someone who is is is leading the investment management field. And just bridging to the Jet episode where we talked about this this sense of feeling powerless. I think like right now in the zeitgeist, there's this sense of the haves and the have nots, right? As as we have like an increasingly K-shaped economy, there are folks who feel like they're not getting invited to the party when it comes to getting into private equity funds, when it comes to getting into crypto, when it comes to getting into whatever, right? Like that's the Robin Hood story. But it's also, I think, related to this private equity in your retirement story. But what gets lost is exactly what you said, Rodney, which is portfolio strategy that like the largest investors that participate in private equity and other things, they also are heavy into bonds. They're heavy into public markets. They're heavy into real estate. And they can they can take the shocks and the wins because those the upside is there, but they can handle the shocks too. Not someone who's going a hundred percent in on crypto or a hundred percent in on PE So gentlemen, I think you know we had a great third season. Really happy that Rodney came on to join join the team. and I feel like impacted, you know, has has evolved, has grown has grown a lot. I has evolved. we added a sub stack. we started posting bi weekly. And I know we have some big plans or big aspirations for what we want to talk about, how we wanna kind of grow the community going forward. So what are what are top of mind for both of you? I'm happy to kick off and say one thing top of mind for me is I I'm curious how the anthropic IPO is gonna impact the world of impact investing. so so they filed their prospectus this week. We're recording this in late October. I haven't read it yet, but it makes the IPO real. And when they go public, they've committed $48 billion into a new philanthropic fund. so we don't know exactly what the IPO valuation will be, but at a $2 trillion valuation, that's a hundred billion dollar fund. importantly, it's an LLC, not a foundation. as a foundation, a $48 billion commitment would have to pay out at least $2.4 billion a year. but as an LLC, there is no requirement, right? So I just wonder what where's that money gonna go? Is that gonna go into philanthropy? Is that gonna go into impact investing like alternatives and private markets? it's gonna shake up the field and it's gonna change the field for sure. Yeah, and and by the way, I'm not gonna hold it against either of you for not explicitly naming that me joining the podcast is one of the highlights. but it's it's okay. It's okay, guys. this I no, Lucas, I agree with the anthropic IPO. And also just to remind folks too, you know, was it two years ago, I believe, when a consortium of sort of impact investors, Ford Foundation, Nathan Cummings, a MidyR made that investment into anthropic Via the the the holdings from gosh, Lucas, I'm why am I blanking on it? But I know what you're talking about. They they got in relatively early. I wanna say it was it was a later stage round, but far ahead of the IPO. but I can't remember where the proceeds came from. Okay. Eric was it it was from the bankruptcy of F F T X. Is that right? yeah. Yeah, yeah. Yes, yes. Yeah, that's right. Sorry. That's what getting a little older, you know, it makes me have to remember where these things came from. But Having said all that, those those institutions for Nathan Cummings and Al Media are really explicitly stating and putting out there that hey, having an opportunity to be on the cap table as impact investors, was an exciting opportunity and it would be a point of leverage and influence. And so I think to your point, Lucas, the the way that this IPO is being developed and setting aside that public use from a philanthropic side. But not set up as a traditional foundation, but leveraging the LLC structure is something that I'm I'm really excited about and I'm curious about how the broader impact investing community thinks about it, particularly those who were able to invest. You know, on that point though, one of the things I am thinking about, and I know all of us are thinking about, is obviously like the disruptive opportunity with AI, right? In in terms of the transformative nature. That it can play in our economy and that there's obviously a lot of concerns about it. whether we're seeing pushback in communities on the development of data centers, which was not something that I was had on my bingo card a year ago, but sort of it's one of the things that's uniting so many communities is hey, we're we're not we're not quite sure if all this AI build-out is something that we want to see happen in our daily lives and obviously it's impacting, you know, our day-to-day living conditions, whether it means Power shortages, whether it means water implications in certain communities, right? And so I think looking at AI from that lens, but also from the fact that as the impact investing industry sort of continues to mature, are we on our are we on our back foot too often? Which I think we are. and there's so much fundamental shifting happening in the real economy, in capital markets. You made a point earlier, Lucas, about the fact, and this has been a longstanding thing, that private markets have actually become such a larger, you know, piece of our economy and such importance relative to the public markets. So we're seeing all these changes happening. And and so I I really am curious about how our industry responds. Are we going to be able to sort of catapult ourselves forward? Are we going to help to blaze a trail for what the economy can look like? Are we going to be leading edge, or are we going to continue to be
far behind the eight ball? and and so I have I'm optimistic, but also think there's opportunities for us to really improve how we think about things and how we behave, quite frankly. Yeah, I think that really hits on, you know, some of my thoughts of what I'm excited about going forward. I really think we have a unique opportunity and in a way responsibility to help broaden this community and kind of expand our audience. So, you know, the conversations that three of us have, and also I think the feedback that we get from our colleagues and friends, like they're not necessarily one and only focused on impact investing. We've talked about policy, a lot we've talked about more traditional finance. Like I talk a lot, you know, through some of my affiliations with community-based organizations or advocates and organizers. And I can constantly see the topics that we're talking about and the players that we're talking about and the stakeholders that we're talking about aligning with a lot of other constituencies and a lot of other audiences. So one thing that I'm so excited for is for us to reach new audiences. And I want to be very clear, like this isn't this the it's not it's not the way that you might look at it in terms of like a business strategy, in terms of like this audio this customer segment, this customer segment. I I actually really think it's just across like all of the various industries and fields that are ostensibly working towards the same goal. I live in New York City and we talk about the public sector for the public good. Ostensibly we're all supposed to be working for the public good with similar bosses or stakeholders, you know, the people, the commons, working class folks, like all of the people that are working on industries, you know, to that effect. I think that it it would behoove everyone to have more literacy and also more of a strategy around how investments impact people. So I'm so excited for us to kind of broaden our audience, our audience. And I think that the way that we do that is continue to have provocative prompts. So if you know for those that follow the season and if you haven't really encourage you to look back at at some of our some of our episodes I feel like we did a great job of trying to ground it and motivate our episodes around a provocative prompt. we talked about the episode with Smithha, like what are the pros and cons of private equity? we talked about like the the current state of community development finance under the current administration. I think some of our approaches was like, what is the material impact? Of this issue and like how do we stare at it and then try to unpack it and kind of investigate it? And I think that's a more accessible way for people that are like, I want to learn about private equity, or I care about community development, or I care about how public policy impacts resource mobilization in my jurisdiction. And I think that kind of approach that that approach to the conversation and hopefully the kind of honest integrity that we have in terms of unpacking it with our guests. I hope we continue to do more of that and I hope that continues to resonate with more audiences. Well said. Yeah, because cause these issues, in my opinion, can't be understood in isolation. And hopefully we did a good job at at bridging across some of the different vectors that you just highlighted, Eric. And we hope for folks that are listening that if you can send this to folks in your world, that you can be that bridge and say, I know I sit here and you sit there, but I think we can both talk about this and and I'd love your thoughts. So for future seasons, that's our goal. let us know what you want to hear more of. And including, we've we've tried new formats. We did a live episode. and to close this season, we're gonna have a a case study, or what is actually a post-mortem, on a specific investment that was designed with the intention of great impact, a company called Tricolore. this was an auto lender that failed dramatically, but with a noble goal of trying to lend to undocumented folks in California and Texas. So For the next twenty minutes, what you'll hear is a discussion with the three of us asking, you know, what happened, what went wrong, and what can the field of impact investing learn from it. So thanks for listening this season and hope you tune in next season. Today we're doing something we've been wanting to do for a while: taking a deep dive into Tricolore and talking honestly about its collapse, how it started, where it went wrong, where it stands now, and what it means for impact investing at large. A Treasury certified CDFI, Tricolor was the first consumer auto-issuer a social bond. It was a financial inclusion award winner, and it was backed by BlackRock's flagship impact vehicle. From 2022 to 2025, Tricolore scaled to 65 retail centers across six states, employed over a thousand people, and had about a billion dollars in annual originations. And according to federal prosecutors, it was a criminal enterprise allegedly running since 2018. This episode isn't about whether impact investing works. It's about what happened when the field's credentialing infrastructure, its labels, its certifications, and its awards. was misunderstood by capital markets as a sound credit analysis, and whether the field is willing to reckon with that. So Tricolore was founded in Dallas in 2007, and it was a vertically integrated buy here, pay here autolender. They bought used vehicles at auction, sold them to their own retail centers, originated and serviced those loans in-house, and also operated large reconditioning centers to refurbish those used cars. The customer here was often, almost always, an underbanked Hispanic borrower, Often with no credit score, sometimes no social security number, frequently no driver's license. And Tricolore really liked this borrower, insisting that this borrower needed this car to get to work so they
wouldn't default on the loan. And everyone else in the industry was ignoring them. So they felt this borrower was unlikely to refinance. They would stay with Tricolore. Just to give a little bit of context, around 45 million Americans are credit invisible or unscorable. This is not a small population. And a car is the single highest leverage asset for employment mobility in most of the US. and Tricolor really built a proprietary alternative data underwriting approach to price this population that the prime market was refusing to touch. That thesis was and remains sound, but we're here to unpack where they went wrong. So just note the sequencing: the CDFI certification came first, the institutional impact capital came after. What does that or tell us about how certification functions downstream in the capital stack? Or from an investor's vantage point, when you see a social bond second-party opinion. And a CDFI stamp stacked together like this, what signal are you actually receiving? Yeah, I think these are a great set of questions. And one of the things that I think is really important for us to consider and think about is why do community development financial institutions exist in the first place? Well, CDFIs exist precisely because mainstream traditional capital markets, financial institutions, banking institutions. Really have not invested in communities of color, rural communities, underinvested communities, particularly for the last few decades. And so CDFIs are really a policy response to the underinvestment by the traditional capital markets and financial institutions into communities of color and rural communities. And so one of the things I think is really important to consider here is that the CDFIF certification process is really meant to. implicitly make clear the intention of banking institutions and financial institutions to really deploy capital in the places that really need it. And at the same time, it's not meant to be a replacement for due diligence from a financial and business perspective. And so I think that's one of the things to really reconcile with is that CD5 certification is really a tool in which we should be considering and implementing when we make impact investing or community development financial decisions. I think that I love that point, Roddy. And that maybe the allegory I would give is that when you're shopping in the supermarket and you see some eggs are farm fresh, some are pasture raised, some are you know, natural, a lot of those terms are are meaningless and they're meant to be a proxy for you to understand the quality of the product that you're buying, but they have varying levels of sort of stricture, right? Only organic is like has its own sort of set rules and I think the same that can be said for the sort of stamping and badging and credentialing that you see in the impact investing landscape. Oftentimes folks would love to believe that those stamps can be a proxy for, as you put it, the real diligence, the loan-level diligence that needs to take place, but there is no proxy for that. And I think the the best example of of why we need to do that loan-level diligence is in the mortgage-backed security crisis of 2008, when it was only a few folks like Michael Burry and others who did the loan-level diligence to understand the credit. risk in that borrower group. so I think that's what we're here to unpack is what happens when when you're sort of pressed for time you don't do your diligence. So Tricolor Tricolore's mission and accomplishments and and scale sound great. right but let's fast forward and unpack its fall. So in late August 2025, warehouse lenders confronted executives about collateral discrepancies. Per the indictment, they first blame an administrative error. But Tricolore CEO Daniel Chu allegedly extracted $6.25 million in bonuses from the company that same month. Move forward to early September 2025, and most of the workforce was furloughed without pay. Chu quietly resigns from the board of Origin Bank, itself a Tricolore lender with $30 million of exposure. Tricolore's asset backed securities begin collapsing in secondary trading. And on September 10th, 2025, Tricolor files for Chapter 7 bankruptcy, which means, unlike Chapter 11, straight liquidation. So a thousand plus employees are terminated, 60 plus locations are closed, 10,000 vehicles, and 100,000 loan accounts are left as contested collateral. So that's a lot of adverse impact happening, right? and then in October 2025, losses are mounting at JP Morgan Chase, fifth dirt third. In Barclays, there is a Vervent is appointed to service the loan book. In December of 2025, the Southern District of New York unseals charges, Tricolores, CEO, CFO, and Finance Director all eventually plead guilty and cooperate. Daniel Chu, CEO of Tricolor, is charged under the continuing Financial Crimes Enterprise Statute, the financial kingpin provision, maximum penalty, life. Then in June 24th, 2026, the COO pleads guilty to six counts. Superseding indictment adds securities fraud against the CEO. October 19, 2026 is the current trial date for the CEO as of the taping of this episode. So to summarize, the the sort of core action that Tricolore is accused of of taking here that was so wrongful is double pledging its assets. I don't want that to get lost in this timeline. That's what these collateral discrepancies are. So Lucas is a really important point. And I'm going to ask you to break down Tree Colores core business. So what, for those that are new, what does double pledging actually mean for poop people who haven't heard about it before? And why is this particular kind of fraud so hard to catch in asset backed structures? So the what the phrase means is promising the same, in this case, auto receivable, the same asset, the value of that car, as collateral to more than one lender simultaneously. but the sort of compounding problem in this case was that it really lived in Tricolor's
business model. So they felt that they could refurbish cars and give with the loan a a tree color service guarantee. that allowed them to say, you know, you come back anytime, we'll we'll put new tires on, we'll we'll change the oil, we'll do a number of kind of light things that we think can extend the value of this car. that would allow them, or I should say emboldened them. To then say that the value of these cars is greater than the Kelly Blue Book value, because we at Tricolore can squeeze a lot more juice out of this lemon. so when you think of those two issues together, you have a real kind of house cards. You have a ten thousand dollar car being said that it's worth fifteen thousand and then being pledged to thirty thousand dollars worth of loans that was compounded over a book of over a billion dollars. So, Rodney, Jamie Diamond said lending practices at large had grown two lakhs and admission dressed up as an observation. What's your read on Jamie's response? Yeah, I think it's it's funny, you know, Eric, because when we talk about lending practices being too lax, I mean, I think this is something that can be applied to the the broadest of capital markets at this point. I mean, you know, Jamie Diamond is also famous. He talked about the the variability and significant headwinds that are facing us in terms of private credit. That we've experienced over the last several months. And if you think about it, in November of 2025, everyone wanted to be in private credit, right? And here we are, as of this taping, seeing this significant shift in in terms of how people are approaching private credit. At the same time, we're seeing this explosion in AI-driven data centers, right? In which we're not clear at all on the long-term or even the short-term financial and economic viability that's being generated by AI, and yet massive, massive expenditures happening across the tech industry, deploying capital into data centers, raising significant amount of debt to do so, and creating effectively new variations of financial instruments to do just that. I mean, it's really we're seeing being played out the great financial crisis, you know, In some ways, in terms of the types of financial tools that are being developed to generate enough capital to invest into data centers. And so when we're talking about tree color being an example of something where lending practices have gone to grown too lax, that's really something we can apply across a lot of the the investment sector. In April 2026, Treasury Secretary Bessent told a Senate hearing that the CDFI fund had lost its way. And name Tricolore specifically as justification for scrutinizing the program. One bad actor out of roughly 1400 certified CDFIs is unfortunately casting a dark shadow over the industry as an argument against the entire field's federal infrastructure. Yeah, I think that the Treasury secretary you know, these comments are to me quite alarming. One, if you look at the timeline of tricolor, For most of its history, they were not a CDFI, one, to begin with. Let's let's just recognize this. Let's let's wrestle with that fact. For the vast majority of Tree Color's existence, they were not a CDFI. At the same time, when we're talking about CDFI fund losing its way, the reality is that there's been so much in our broader capital markets where there has been very little scrutiny in into how things happen. Again, I made some earlier comments in reference to AI and data centers and private credit, for example. And yet we do not see US Treasury, you know, making these types of comments about AI, for example, right? You know, Lucas made a comment earlier about emboldening people. And I think this is an example in which there's the opposite happening, in which unfortunately there is a political response to CDFIs because of the specific focus on communities of color. In rural communities, communities that have been historically extracted from or divested from mainstream financial institutions. And we're not seeing that level of scrutiny happening in the broader capital markets. I couldn't agree more. I think, and you said this earlier, Rodney, but I want to underline it. The CDFI certification is a mission eligibility screen. It is not a safety and soundness examination. It's not a credit review. It's not an audit of collateral controls. It's not a consumer protection review. non-depository CDFIs, which is what this was. This was not a bank where you put your money. This was a lender receiving money from JP Morgan and others, warehouse lenders, and pushing it out into the community. they were being tested on their mission eligibility, which is about the market where they did their work, the financing entity, and sort of the services they offered in their mission. so I think I think the two got conflated, right? What the CDFI stamp means. I also think another thing happened here, which is they were really focused on output metrics. And I think the risk here was that they didn't think about kind of the pairing metrics that you need to measure the sort of fidelity of those output metrics. And this is, I think, a useful discussion for the broader impact investing field. I I take that phrase pairing metrics from this book, High Output Management. It's an old book by Andy Grove, the former CEO of Intel. And the the basic premise is that you always need a pairing metric to make sure that the fidelity of your of what you're measuring is there. So if you're measuring speed, you need to also measure quality. If you're measuring volume, you need to also measure precision. If you're measuring growth, also measure margin. You're measuring output, measure burnout. You're right, not just output of our sales team, but are are they are they leaving every quarter because they're burnt out? In this case, the the pairing metric to me sort of our borrowers building credit? Are they retaining the vehicle? And and those kinds of things would tell you the
the quality of this credit risk and this borrower pool and whether they were originating, you know, loans that could actually be repaid or just focused on volume. Yeah, I mean, you know, one of the things I just want to point out, one of the reasons I love this guy, Lucas, is because he's talking about Andy Grove and impact investing at the same time. That's exactly the kind of conversations we love to have. You know, I think one of the other things too is this really this the the Concentration risk of having vertical integration within Tree Color and the amount of conflict that that creates. So effectively, you have Tree Color setting the vehicle acquisition price, the retail price, the LTV, the loan terms. You're really not having an independent price discovery process within the stack, right? And so that's creating all sorts of conflict across the enterprise that. again, if we're looking at it from a diligence perspective, we're looking at it from the perspective of really examining the underlying risks of this company, none of that is going to get unearthed by the CDFI certification, right? That is going to be unearthed through rigorous due diligence, active monitoring by investors and lenders. And so again, that is one of the things that again want to emphasize this point. The CDFI certification process does not Factor into those sort of things. That is actually the responsibility of the lenders and investors to actually really get inside of the risks, the underlying opportunities of a company like TreeCalore. So given all that, this may just be a case of ordinary fraud that happened to occur at an impact labeled company. Tree Color collapsed the same month as First Brands, an auto parts maker that had no impact story at all. BlackRock's disclose lending against apparently fake receivables is an unrelated matter. The through line may be loose collateral controls across the entire credit market and not anything specific to mission-driven finance. So something I've been thinking a lot about is if there are systemic control failures here and they're industry-wide, not necessary impact specific, does that change at all what the field owes the public in response? Like As impact investors, if this is something, if what happened with Tricolore is not all that different than what happened with first brands, what is the responsibility that we have as impact investors, as advocates, to actually, you know, speak to this question, right? It's something I'm I'm wrestling with. Curious how you guys think about it. I love that question. I I think, yeah, we do have to hold ourselves to a higher standard because folks wanna know that it isn't all bullshit. Folks want to know that there isn't just virtue signaling here. I think we you you have a bigger target on your back in impact investing than you do in traditional finance. So yeah, I think impact investors will continue to be held to a higher level of scrutiny. But I'm curious, Rodney, what what do you think? Yeah, Lucas, actually, I appreciate you you you framing it that way because I actually do think that impact investors, obviously we do have a a a a higher degree and burden of responsibility here. we're trying to create positive impact. We're trying to change systems. We're trying to ensure that opportunities that would otherwise not exist are able to exist. And so I think this is correct. I think, unfortunately, we didn't have either in this situation the financial and economic rigor applied to tricolore. And at the same time, it might be an example where Yes, the CDFI certification process did its its job, but there could have been even deeper examination of the real investment opportunity and risks involved, where unfortunately that didn't happen with the lenders and investors. Yep. I think that that's right. and this next piece I want to raise isn't really a core issue for why Tricolore failed, but I think it's an interesting question that hopefully folks listening can wrestle with after this episode. Which is, think about what it means to serve an underserved person. If you otherwise can't get a loan anywhere, and your best bet is going to a loan shark or a payday lender, or you leaning on your credit cards where you're gonna pay something close to 30% interest, then anything better than 30% interest is doing you a solid. Or rather, it could be framed that way. And I think that's something that we should also wrestle with. And again, that wasn't the core of what brought down Tricolore. But there was a window of opportunity that was quite large for them to enter into where they could say, We're giving an auto loan to someone who's undocumented and wouldn't get a loan any other way. So we're gonna charge them twenty seven percent. And that could be framed as a, you know, strong social impact argument to someone who isn't digging too deep. And so I think we should wrestle with that question too of where's the line when you're serving someone who c doesn't have any other options. And one of the things I think about from that question too, Lucas, is this, you know, goes it goes back to your question. Or your point about the fact that impact investors have to really have a higher degree of, you know, responsibility here. And what makes me think is that oftentimes, you know, no matter how you fall into this, is that we as impact investors are looking to get a financial and social and economic and environmental return oftentimes on our investments, right? And there are A number of impact investors that are looking to get the most financial return as possible. And unfortunately, that can, you know, that can lead to making some very extractive decisions, right? in the name of impact. And so I think this is a a great point to to really, you know, sort of wrestle with because at the end of the day, Tricolore identified a tremendous opportunity in terms of creating impact, a really a terribly unaddressed market. And then the question then is do
you price it to such a point that it's going to be, you know, predatory to some degree, or maybe still largely inaccessible because the the the the pricing of the product, the loan, the interest rates, right? And so that's the question, right? in terms of How are we really reconciling with the return profile from a financial perspective if it could in fact lead us to predatory behavior? I think that's right. I I think it brings up questions in capital coordination, right? That there are different types of of LPs, different sources of capital that have different return expectations, who would answer this question of how much is enough differently, right? And I think I think that's that's how I would answer that question, Rodney. and I think I'll I'll I'll pose another question to all of us, which is if you're an impact LP today and you're reviewing a company like Tricolore, what specifically could you do differently after Tricolore? I think the I mean, think obviously, Lucas, the the the quick one is that you know, really doing the most rigorous, deep as financial examination as you possibly can and and really close monitoring of the situation. Know really it's really easy to get caught up in terms of and about I want to be clear about this. It's not just the impact story. I'm talking about story in general, right? because I, you know, and so you know, you can make a case that We Work was another example of people getting caught up into the story, right? This powerful narrative. So I want to just I wanna like you know unpack and separate, you know, an impact story versus just broader narratives here, but it's really easy for us to all get caught up in stories in tricolore. has a powerful, powerful story and powerful, powerful intent. And at the same time, obviously at some point, the financial diligence and rigor in examining the realities of the the business that was was happening at Tricolor, it got lost. And so I think that is the simplest response I have, Lucas, is like continuously deep, deep, deep dive of this. And by the way, point out earlier the risk of being, integrated vertically, and really having a premium from a due diligence perspective on what does that mean moving forward? Right. What does it mean when the when the the fox is watching the hen house? But it's right, Eric, what what what are you thinking? I agree, Rodney, for sure, around you know, not being sucked into the impact story and then adding to more scrutiny. But we had a previous episode on the podcast around investment committees, and we all ch serve on investment committees, loan committees. And bandwidth is a real challenge. it really different institutional investors have different well, some have investment teams or don't, or they outsource it completely, or they rely on their managers or their advisors to do that. So of course I agree we we always should be further scrutinizing, but I'm just you know being honest of Conversations that I've had over the years when people have looked at CDFIs and have basically the same pitfall of seeing the kind of certification, the stamp of being registered as a CDFI as being this is safe, this is basically a proxy for somebody underwrote this or this is reliable. And that's not I I want to be clear that that I I don't think we're trying to say that there is no merit to having a CDFI certification. We are not saying that. We're just saying that that is not shouldn't be 100% of your assessment of the creditworthiness of the institution. It's a very difficult balance because we've all just been in so many conversations around capacity constraints. And people do look for shortcuts would be a cynical way to look at it, but just honestly, efficiencies or trustworthy proxies is a more generous way to look at how people try to get things approved and get things through their committees. I think that that's right. I think, in in venture capital, folks lean on mental models to gain familiarity. They look at where you went to school, they look at who sent them the deal. All these things are proxies for understanding the investment that you're looking at. And I think it's important just to call out the quantum of capital that would like to be chasing after high return, high impact opportunities. And given that, the sort of speed and the requirement to look at things quickly and move money into things quickly, because of again the quantum of capital that's out there. $1.3 billion in Tricolore's loan book sounds like a lot of money. It's not when you look at the broader financial market and how much money would like to be invested in things that can have above market returns and also produce high impact. Lucas, can I say something that's going to be a little bit controversial as well? I'm sorry, my friends, but one thing that I think I feel like I I'm maybe welcoming eggshells on this is to that point is listen, at the end of the day, a lot of LPs, many of whom we know or have familiarity with at least, you know, they like to invest alongside or in a BlackRock entity for reasons that are quite frankly about financial rigor, that are about you know expert risk management, that typically those LPs don't believe other managers can deliver upon. And so I do want to, you know, note here that there is I don't know if irony is the right word here, but it's fascinating that, you know, it was a BlackRound that invested in Tricolore and many of the impact LPs that are out in the market. They they invest in the Black Rocks of the world precisely to ensure that these types of things don't happen from a risk. management perspective. And so I do want to I just want to point that out as well. And what that means for, I think that that that should create some opportun I would like that to create opportunity for other managers as well, right? That can say, hey, listen, actually our process is maybe even more rigorous and is is in from a multitude of dimensions here. And so I just want to make note of that. Sorry for the added controversy, but I just want to point that out. No, don't I actually I want to I want to say one thing I appreciate about that is that, I'm sure we've all been in conversations where people have talked about upcoming smaller minority-led CDFIs that like they really do rely on like the CDFI fund for like operating funds. And when I have those conversations, people say like these are quote unquote very risky. and there's truth to that because like it's it's very difficult at a sub scale to be able to fund your own operations. That's not not true. But I To to to Rodney's point around basically the cosign from from BlackRock saying like this is creditworthy and like we we believe in this investment, and the level of fraud, fraudulent activity that happened, I I'm trying to think you know, maybe the risk to the controls are stronger at those smaller CDFIs and this wouldn't have happened at a place like that if they had a billion dollars. Yeah, I I agree with both of you. I think we should leave it there. So this has been great. Let's keep doing this. Let's keep doing some more deep dives on the field. The opinions expressed in this program are those of the individuals interviewed and are for general informational purposes only. They are not intended to provide specific advice or recommendations for any individual or on any specific security. This program is intended solely to provide education about the financial industry in the broader impact investing landscape. To determine which investments may be appropriate for you, consult your financial advisor prior to investing. Any past performance discussed during this program is no guarantee of future results. Please remember that investing involves risk and possible loss of principal capital. Please seek advice from a licensed professional before making any investment decisions. All views expressed by our guests are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views of impacted or its hosts.