逐字稿 🔗
Jennifer Palumbo: to Beyond Tech, where innovation meets insight. We're your hosts, Jennifer Palumbo and Jackie Slatt.
Jackie Slaght: Today we're taking on one of the most misunderstood topics in the industry, MES or manufacturing execution systems. If you've ever heard, it's too big, it's too rigid or we're not ready for that yet, this episode is for you.
Jennifer Palumbo: To help us separate fact from fiction, we're joined by someone who lives and breathes MES every day, Dominique Telfort, director of MES at eTech Group. He's seen every misconception in the book, and he's here to break down what MES really does, what it definitely doesn't do, and why these myths hold so many plants back.
Jackie Slaght: Let's get started with our first myth. Dom, I'm sure you've heard this before probably many times. The myth that MES is too big for us.
Dominique Telfort: Thank you, Jennifer and Jackie. And I know Shondell, she's in the background. So I want to send a big shout out for her as well. So guys, this is a great topic because MES is one of those technologies that almost everyone knows they need, but very few people feel, they don't really feel confident about it. Okay. to tell the truth, it's like, you know, most of that hesitation that I see. about is not about the technology itself, right? It's more about the misconception around it. So I'm definitely going to look ⁓ forward show you guys, you know, why it's too big, why they think, you know, it's too big. But ⁓ first, like to frame, you know, to be upfront and trying to explain to you what is MES. And then we can jump into into your first question here. So MES, ⁓ I ⁓ you sometimes, you know, customers they think it's a software decision, okay? But in reality, it's not, right? It's more of an operational decision, right? Cause it's, it, touched almost every layer of the S95, okay? So what is MES, Willie? It's, I will call it the bridge, you know, it sits on level, level ⁓ What it does Willie, it's basically, it connects the business intent. you know, in a manufacturing plant, I wanna produce, you know, this amount of tablet, for example, right? So it the business intent to the shop floor, which is ⁓ the for execution, where things happen. So the machine also connected, all right? ⁓ And that layer is broken or it's working properly, that's where ⁓ I can like the confusion ⁓ is coming okay? So now too big, okay? I think this is one of the most common ones that I hear out there. And to be fair, it used to be true. Because again, in the past, mean large, huge, enterprise deployment. And the company, approach it because it was so expensive. But ⁓ nowadays, it's no how the next-gen or modern MES work.
Jennifer Palumbo: Yeah.
Dominique Telfort: So now you can start MES in a modular way. You can start small, workflow, or probably one line of just one use case. You can just start like that, right? For example, I've seen company, ⁓ know, starting like a log book, just a simple log book that was on paper. Now
Load full transcript
they make it digital and then they can see measurable value. Okay. So in reality, you know, MES is only too big when you try to do everything at once.
Jennifer Palumbo: some more clarifying, and I appreciate you taking a step back and describing MES for us before we kind of dive in. Is this something it sounds like, because we're talking about myths around, is it good fit for my facility that manufacturers don't consider to be a need to have? Part of their stack, is that correct?
Dominique Telfort: Not really. It's not like a need not to have it. So sometimes what happened is like, especially like in a regulated environment. So they, they use a paper document to document the manufacturing process. Okay. And then by doing so it's, that's the way they used to do it for years. Right. It's easy for the operator. Cause, but again, they missing a lot, right? Especially when you get, uh, you know, when the FDA basically call you out. because of some issues and you have to pay, you know, like five, I saw like a company paying almost $5 million because of deviation exception. Remember you're making drugs for patient, right? So these have to be well documented. you know, that's where, you know, the is needed instead of, you know, ⁓ the paper doc.
Jennifer Palumbo: So yeah, anything in the way of track and trace, MES is gonna need to be a crucial part of the tech stack.
Dominique Telfort: Absolutely, especially tracking trace like you, for example, that tablet that I was telling you about, we need to know the details. What were like all the different materials that was included in that tablet, in that medicine. So this is really what we're working
Jennifer Palumbo: You Right. Makes sense.
Jackie Slaght: Okay, guys, I think you kind of ⁓ alluded to this a little bit already, Dom, but our second myth is that with an MES, they'll lose operator flexibility. And I think you spoke a little bit about this is just the way that we've always done it. ⁓
Dominique Telfort: Absolutely, So I think this one is super interesting and to tell the truth, it's more perception, okay? I can tell you, it's a perception out there. operators, sometimes they feel it will restrict them, but actually, MES will help them remove any type of ambiguity that you have in the process. Because think about it, you want a paper document, you're flipping pages back and forth, right? Because again, the SOP that you're using telling you to go to page 17 and then get that temperature and then come back and things like that, But where they create a lot of defiation and exception. Now, that is something that is critical in regulating environment. Because again, the drug you make in medicine, that has to be well documented. You don't want to go out of don't want to make a deviation in the process. So what MES does for them, it will basically provide guidance. So now you're not flipping pages. The system that the operator is using, it's a smarter system. So it's what it walked them through. It's like your GPS in car, right? Your Google map kind of, right? That's what it becomes. So MES give you the guidance, the structure, the guard wells.
Jennifer Palumbo: Right.
Dominique Telfort: And also, doesn't really eliminate ⁓ decision making. That's question you're asking. In fact, what really happened, the operator become more confident because you have that Google map you. You have that navigator telling you where to go. And then in you go out of spec, the system will tell you like there's a problem. And in real time, you can call your quality ⁓ person and then can take action in real time. So with the MES operator, they are more confident. They don't rely on their memory or the tribal knowledge. So you call operator do you know how to do this? No, no. Now you have a system that makes you follow process that tells you like, you have an exception. Your temperature should be within that range. You're out of range, you know, and things like that.
Jackie Slaght: Yeah.
Dominique Telfort: One thing that also see is like a resistance, like because you've been working on an operator, they've been using a paper for so long. Now you bring them, you you tell them that you're about to use a system. They don't like that. Right. But again, one thing that with this, we do here at E-Tech is ⁓ in the entire implementation process, they are part since day one. And then, you know, they don't get trained at the end. They are trained while we are building the system. And I know they are working, right? But we try to do like what we call the train the trainer. So one of them will be right there building the process together with us. And then they will learn. And I think, you know, once they start using it, they see that really MES is protecting them instead of being like a headache, you know.
Jennifer Palumbo: Do you have a process that you go through when you are talking to companies about opportunities to implement MES within their facility? I would imagine that you do some work with the operators or any other users just to kind of get buy-in from them. What does that process look like as you're helping companies vet an MES solution?
Dominique Telfort: Absolutely, absolutely. So one thing I can tell you, like, it's like really customer ⁓ want MES more than a system integrator wants, right? What is is ⁓ we to find out what is your pain point? What is inefficient in your current process?
Jennifer Palumbo: Mm-hmm.
Dominique Telfort: So they will tell you all that information. So one thing that we offer, you know, a package that we're building here, it's called the MES assessment, where we sit down with the customer. There's around like 250 questions that we go over all those 250 questions. We covered the entire S95 to see, you know, if you need to be fully integrated and things like that. But first thing where we really want to start is like, what is your pain point? What you're trying to achieve, right? And then once we have that, we are able to... gather all your
artifact, we talk about your processes, the stakeholder, people who are involved, the equipment, the type of ELP you're using, and then you want to be fully integrated? So do you want your MES to communicate with your ELP system and also communicate with your equipment? Remember what I told you at the beginning? So it's the middle layer. But sometimes, remember told you to, we start small and then we can start building. I like to, from that assessment, I like to build the entire system high level. And then we generate a roadmap. that usually it's like a 12 to 24 month, and then we implemented by phases. So you see like I'm basically covering and yes, too big to the first question too. So basically we're covering assessment. And then from the assessment, we come out with your maturity level where you are, are you fully paper?
Jackie Slaght: Yes.
Dominique Telfort: Are you just MES a paper on glass? Are you fully integrated? And then are you ready for the next level, which is the digital transformation?
Jennifer Palumbo: So you're not saying, hey, we need to fix everything at once. It sounds like you're saying, hey, let's look at what your needs are. Let's look at what some major pain points are, and we can actually build a plan that works for you in the facility.
Dominique Telfort: No. No, at all. Absolutely, absolutely. Because at the end of the day, any implementation, it's, you know, I can be the expert on my team, they can be the expert, but we are solving what they're looking for. We are solving their needs. We are solving the pain point, right? what we do. So basically, really, we need to know ⁓ they want to do.
Jackie Slaght: So really designing the solution around, you know, it's not a one size fits all, but just custom to what their priorities are or their pain point.
Dominique Telfort: to find the solution. Yes. 100%. Even in my proposal, like if I'm writing a proposal, it's not going to cover only cost. I like any, you know, ⁓ proposal that I put together, I like to solution. I like to provide solution. So that's why first thing I need to know your pinpoint, you try, you know, usually the, the RFP that they provide as all that information, right? So you have to really make sure that they fully understand, ⁓ you the solution. around how to solve their pain point. If that makes sense.
Jennifer Palumbo: Yeah, I think that's a nice segue into another myth, is, hey, if we're going to implement MES, we really can't afford the downtime to implement it. And so I think you can speak more to this, but it sounds like based on a phased approach, designing the right solution, not only can you justify the cost, but you might be able to control the amount of downtime.
Dominique Telfort: Yeah. I think, you nailed it, right? So again, as I said, modern MES is face. So it's like you just shut down the entire planet and you put in something together, right? Like you put in a brand new one. No, that doesn't work like that, right? So after the we know where
you are. We know, for example, which process bring you more value. Because again, return on investment, it's a big deal for these customers, right? They need to make sure that the huge investment they about put into an MES system, they will be able to make return out of it. They become profitable. So what we do really is after that we know which process is more impactful. If we can change that, how long it will take, how many resources are gonna be working on that. And then what we do, you can run your system in parallel, like your old system and the new system, right? Maybe that you take one step small. And then you start wanting fast, right? So again, what I like to do is actually changing your question to why not implemented it, right? Because like, if you don't implement MES, you are losing big time, right? Your review process, remember I told you the review process, they were on the paper putting information about the manufacturing. So when you do a review, you go page by page. It's time consuming.
Jennifer Palumbo: Yeah, I mean...
Jackie Slaght: Hahaha
Dominique Telfort: weeks of revision. Now, when you're on the digital, remember I told you we are working on a process and then whenever have to do some check and check in deviation, we already know ⁓ what and what does not work during the manufacturing process. So now the revision just focus on what didn't work. Because again, we have a system that is validated. The process has been validated. Now, when they do ⁓ research, I'm not research when they do a review, they just focus on what didn't work during the execution. So really downtime, I don't think they should take it as a myth. Downtime is not even going to create a myth because it's you can go in pilot. It doesn't exist. Right. I think the will loss opportunity is not having an MES.
Jackie Slaght: One of the things that you're saving with implementing an is time savings. But are there other hidden costs that a manufacturer can run into by not implementing an MES system?
Jennifer Palumbo: Thank
Dominique Telfort: So if you get fined by the FDA, that's a big deal, right? That would be your investment right there. it's really, know, speed to market, right? You make drugs faster, you can sell it faster. that's, know, so not implementing it, it's a problem. And then also like, say you're on paper, you ⁓ putting data on a piece of paper, but having the MES, the data goes into a database, right? So remember I told you that assessment,
Jackie Slaght: That's a big one.
Jennifer Palumbo: Yeah.
Dominique Telfort: We check if you want paper, if you just have a paper on glass, or are you fully ⁓ communicating with other system, or are ready for digital transformation, right? So now when you have a MES, it's fully integrated, you have your data store somewhere. Now you can think about predictive analysis. You can talk about digital twin. You can talk about dashboarding. You do a lot of different things because now you have the data. again, people to
move, not people, mean company, need to move forward with ⁓ MES time.
Jennifer Palumbo: That makes sense. I guess let's kind of go different route with ⁓ another myth, which is that MES replaces SCADA or PLC systems.
Dominique Telfort: Right, right. So that's that's another major one. Okay, and and the reason is that sometimes I even see automation fighting with NES or things like that and and it's not at all the same thing, right? So, anytime, you know, anytime I'm doing like a project so so ERP, right? It ERP does ERP does NES does automation. Automation it's What is happening like on your equipment? What are they doing on the shop floor during the manufacturing process? Okay. And yes, it's the basically, all of the different, step go to the, to, those process ⁓ using machine. Okay. So basically what the MES does, it gives you like visibility of what's happening on the shop floor. The machine, they are, you know, ⁓ growing if I was in a bioreactor, they are. capturing temperature and things like that. But with the MES, you are able to visualize like you are that step those cells ⁓ like growing, the temperature was that value. So that's where the integration is done. So really the MES give you the visibility of the manufacturing process. And then, ⁓ know, like the it's more about your equipment, like a bioreactor ⁓ or other equipment.
Jennifer Palumbo: So SCADA and PLC is more about controlling the process. ⁓ manufacturing execution system, as you said, kind of gives you that big picture view.
Dominique Telfort: controlling the process exactly. that big picture of you of every step in the process.
Jennifer Palumbo: Makes sense, makes sense.
Dominique Telfort: Because again, for example, on a paper document, on a paper manufacturing process, right? I mean, on a paper document, right? operator will go to the HMI, look at the value and enter the value on that piece of paper during the manufacturing process, right? But now with MES or the digital solution, because they are not integrated, they will be talking automatically. So on that iPad or that terminal that the operator is using,
Jennifer Palumbo: Mm-hmm.
Dominique Telfort: they'll be able to see the value at point of views, which is something that is really nice.
Jennifer Palumbo: That makes sense. It makes me think of, assume that a company is considering an MES solution. They've probably already, hopefully, already have a SCADA solution in place, maybe a platform or a few different platform technologies that they're using.
Jackie Slaght: You
Jennifer Palumbo: ⁓ Can you talk a little bit about like, does that process look like? Do you choose the MES depending on what the company might already have in place or would pretty much any MES integrate with any automation system? What does that look like?
Dominique Telfort: So when choose an MES, again, remember I told you about the pain point. We're talking about ⁓ also, you really want to be fully integrated? So we need to first understand what is the limit of the provider of the MES solution, right? Because again, usually the customer already have the PLC in place, the scaler in place, it's already there, right? So another service do here at eTech is the MES vendor selection.
Jennifer Palumbo: Hmm.
Dominique Telfort: So whenever like a customer, want to implement MES, we'll be able to take a look at all of the different options that they try to select. And we can do a study and find out, based on that scatter, let's say that MES already have an in-house middleware or it's easy to integrate it with your scatter of your PLC. And then it will also take care of your pinpoint faster, right? will tell you this is the one to select. But usually like most of those MES, they are able to do that because they study what kind of SCADA, PLC that is out there. And I think any MES should be able to
Jennifer Palumbo: Makes sense.
Dominique Telfort: But again, we always study through an assessment, finding out what will work best for you.
Jackie Slaght: You've spoken about how to get started and we can go through a phased approach. ⁓ one of the myths that I'm assuming heard about is that. or heard from customers is that they feel that they need to fix everything before they can think about getting an MES system in place. Is true?
Dominique Telfort: Right. That's huge means that really, you know, the lot of company off, you know, so basically it will make them not move forward because they think they need to look for what didn't work and things like that before they move forward. again, I think it's a myth, right? I think, not I think it is a myth, right? Cause it was actually like, you're looking at the life cycle, when we do the requirement gathering, the mapping,
Jackie Slaght: Yeah.
Dominique Telfort: We go into each one of these processes, the process that you're currently using. We're trying to make it more efficient. We're trying to make it leaner. For example, like an operator used to go from page one to page 15 and come back again and things like that. Now we can have loops because now it's digital. We can have loops automatically. It goes there. So sometimes you look at executable batch record, paper batch record. or not using some part of the process. So you can make the process leaner. So what I can tell you, it's like, I always tell people like, know, that 80, 20 rules, like the, the, the power to principle. You just, you just go that, that way. Right. So you find out, you know, the, MES basically the implementation process will not, not the software, right? What we do as system integrator, like that process will cover all of this. And then usually 20 % of those inefficiencies that we find out will basically give you a will resolve all your inefficiency when you go digital.
Jackie Slaght: Yeah, so sounds like when selecting this, you kind of get a level set and have the opportunity to make a lot of things more efficient and get more information and kind of streamline the process. ⁓
Dominique
Telfort: Absolutely. And I think that's the requirement gathering and the process mapping. That's what really helped them it. And then we also like to have like after even you go digital, we like to have a feedback loop, right? Where ⁓ every three months, we want to come back and double check to see if we can refine your process. So that's why you will see like, ⁓ know, any software also need to have version control. because you'll be on version one and then we found out we can make it better. And then we give you another version and then we can upgrade you to the next version.
Jennifer Palumbo: So it's probably not something to be treated as like a just plug and play and then just off you go, right? It probably requires ongoing thought and ongoing, I don't wanna say maintenance, but like just an ongoing part of planning.
Dominique Telfort: That was really in the past. Like they just make it work. You go live and moving forward. But I think the industry is moving forward right now because of all the AI and you know, AI, the data structure, it's really important, right? To get, know, again, people talk about trashing trash out, right? So now what you really want to do is you want to work with someone who's going to be able to not only implement the right solution,
Jennifer Palumbo: Mm.
Dominique Telfort: but also they basically maintain ⁓ you built. And then also you can move into that digital transformation, which is the future. And then even AI on top of certain, ⁓ on top of your MES.
Jennifer Palumbo: You mentioned costs and it does get to like just some like real direct questions for the listeners about, ⁓ you know, what it really takes implement, you know, modern MES solution. like at least where you sit, what does modern MES investment look like for a company?
Dominique Telfort: What? In terms of what? ⁓
Jennifer Palumbo: And in terms of dollars, I mean, a lot of people probably assume that this is a or millions ⁓ ⁓ of investment in an MES system. Is that accurate?
Dominique Telfort: Absolutely it is. Because again, especially in the regulated industry, right now, software, I think from what I've seen in the past, like a few years, like long time ago, They were like ⁓ really high cost, And then they were like long term, okay? now for software because of those next gen I see you know, ⁓ you know, I see for example We have like a good partner we're working with I think it's called next plus that we're breaking on board ⁓ super inexpensive, but where things become expensive, it's more with the integration, the system integrator. Cause again, customer want MES, but they don't have any idea of what they really want, right? So that's what a system integrator, it's time consuming. So you have to sit down with them, understand the requirement, map the process until you can have like the ⁓ spec, the functional spec, the configuration take times, and then the validation. take times and then go live, hypercare, the feedback lookup I talked to you about, all these costs and they take times. So that's where all the costs come. So you'll be able to see things from, for example, Tulip and Apprentice, these are all the systems. So you'll be able to see pricing starting from the 285k all the way to the $20 million, $40 million easy. It's pretty expensive. Yeah.
Jennifer Palumbo: Mm-hmm. depending on how you scale it. ⁓
Dominique Telfort: But again, like you can always approach it on a phased approach, right?
Jennifer Palumbo: Sure. Yeah, I mean, I can appreciate the integrator, like the time to do the preliminary study engineering and all of that time that the integrator spends. I mean, that's time that the business is not spending as much time doing it because the integrator is of course facilitating it. But how would you say plants can actually get value out of ⁓ an MES once ⁓ they start, they implement it?
Dominique Telfort: I would say, would say, water rate. Cause again, remember I told you about the deviation, the review by exception would definitely help you instead of going page by page. Now you'll review just exception because you know, cover the process. ⁓ you never had a stop during the execution, it means it's okay. No need to review that. But if it stopped you for a super for supervisor or a quality review, we a problem. So when things are over, we want to review, but sometimes it's only. three or ten certain things that we need to review. So that's already a value. And when we the of an assessment, we'll definitely tell like all of those return on investment what you get, right? So again, ⁓ the the batch you know, now to release a batch that's faster. you know, with paper, ⁓ you take to review the paper documents.
Jennifer Palumbo: This is the end.
Dominique Telfort: All these are things that bring return on investment pretty fast for you.
Jackie Slaght: This has been a really interesting and enlightening conversation. I've really enjoyed it. I have any more myths for us to cover. Do you have anything else before we kind of close out and go to my fun questions to close out that we should touch on?
Dominique Telfort: ⁓ you know, so I don't, I'm not really sure I have many different things to talk about, know, so, again, you know, the things that I think I'd like to ⁓ you, like, you know, us here at, at E-Tech, you know, we, we are making sure that we are changing the market again. There's a lot of system integrity out there, but what we're going to be trying to work ⁓ this and probably next year, it's making sure we build those tools. that can be used at each one of the phase the life cycle and sure we can provide better price and then give our customer the best consulting and then making sure that we clarify meet for them and making sure that they can ⁓ use the way it's supposed to be ⁓ used then move them into that digital transformation. So that's what I wanted to
Jackie Slaght: Yeah, like I said, this has been great and I have learned a lot from it and I think you're right. It
sounds like it really is something that you have to understand where you want to get to and what your goals are or pain points you're alleviating make and the best solution. ⁓
Dominique Telfort: Right. remember when I told you that pain point, right? We talk, when we talk about the customer, but the pain point, that's always the return on investment. If we can solve that, right. You always help them out because that's why they're looking for it because they had that issue at the beginning.
Jackie Slaght: So this is one of my favorite questions is if could one thing in your life, what would it be?
Dominique Telfort: One thing in my life really is to work, right?
Jackie Slaght: work or, or at home either way.
Jennifer Palumbo: personal.
Dominique Telfort: So right now I can tell you it's work. Because again, I'm always at my desk and working and especially building a vertical, it's major, right? And then you want to make sure that. think about the competition and you can provide something that the competition does not have. There's lot of things I didn't even tell my leadership. I really want to this as the first AI system integrated. I'm working on many different tools where I'm trying ⁓ to create own digital twin. If you guys what ⁓ I'm saying here. trying, I'm testing right now. requirement gathering agent, I have like a agent, okay? I have a strategy agent. ⁓ They do, but they're getting better and better, you know? So ⁓ what I want to do is automate the entire cycle. For example, the assessment, ⁓ one thing.
Jackie Slaght: I
Dominique Telfort: So what I want to do is like, uh, I spend one, one hour with my, with the customer. tell me all your, not all your requirements, the big picture of what you want to do, to do your pinpoint, your integration, uh, uh, uh, priority and things like that. Um, and then I'll feed that to my agent and then in real time, you know, I can generate your maturity assessment output and a word map.
Jackie Slaght: Well, that's amazing. is, I feel like one of the most ambitious and best answers.
Dominique Telfort: Actually, I have an output that I can even, I think I can email it to you guys. So you can take a look if you guys want to.
Jackie Slaght: I'll be so productive. will give me more things to do. Okay, and one of my other favorite questions is how would you describe your job to a child? Like a five-year-old or I guess you can pick these.
Jennifer Palumbo: . Absolutely.
Dominique Telfort: So my job here at E-TECH, I think the way I'll describe it, it looks like it's my own business. the truth, because again. ⁓ what I do is really building, a new vertical for MES here, right? Right. And then I want it to be AI. And when I heard about, you know, our, CEO thinking about making us becoming the next AI company where AI is assisting everybody, I say, ⁓ my God, okay. I can't keep that as a secret anymore. ⁓ I'm the line, I'm the line, you know, cause again, like I was doing it in pilot and things like that. So I'll work on my stuff in.
Jackie Slaght: you
Dominique Telfort: work stuff in the morning at night. try to convert it into digital, my personal computer, but I think I'm in a good spot, right? Cause again, and I'm using AI agent to basically code the solution for me. Okay. And again, I need to do a full test and to end test to make sure that those who are working properly, the output, you know, so, so we don't have hallucination and things like that. So, but I'm excited. That's what I would like to do. Basically now I can have my agent working for me and, maybe sell the software, you know, something like that and I can retire.
Jackie Slaght: be awesome. OK, those are all the questions I have. I just want to thank you for joining us today and talking with us. My last final question is, what would you like to see us cover on future episodes of Beyond Tech?
Dominique Telfort: next think we should have like probably like, let's say we get the entire agent, agentic system integrator solution working. I think we should provide like a small demo to our basic, our life demo, I would say. Or maybe we can have it, you know, we can have it not live, like something like this, and then share that with the public so they understand what AI system integrator can do.
Jackie Slaght: Yeah.
Jennifer Palumbo: That's a fun idea.
Jackie Slaght: Yeah.
Dominique Telfort: and these tools.
Jackie Slaght: That would be awesome. that is all I have. Just you for joining us and sharing a little about MES. ⁓
Jennifer Palumbo: It's great to have you on.
Dominique Telfort: You're welcome. Thank you so much, guys. Thank you so much. And you guys are doing an amazing job because education is one of the best thing ever. So educating the public so they understand what is a myth, what is hype. This is the best thing ever in 2026.
Jennifer Palumbo: Thank you.