逐字稿 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:00.240 --> 00:00:06.371
Shows avoiding Babylon, and it frustrates me because I really like the producer of the show but I can't stand the host of the show.
00:00:06.371 --> 00:00:10.971
The host, anthony, just constantly says the absolute dumbest I've ever seen.
00:00:10.971 --> 00:00:17.532
Example one of his tweets was that the, the one criminal on the cross who was saved, was saved because Mary prayed for him.
00:00:17.532 --> 00:00:25.873
And I'm like I don't know if he's just trying to piss Protestants off or if he genuinely believes that or what, but it's just constant with him.
00:00:25.873 --> 00:00:30.367
I stand by that.
00:00:30.367 --> 00:00:32.765
I stand by that.
00:00:32.765 --> 00:00:35.688
That was what got me to say the thing.
00:00:38.960 --> 00:00:41.890
We had to start with that, of course.
00:00:42.009 --> 00:00:42.310
I know.
00:00:42.859 --> 00:00:45.640
Thank you to Taffy for putting that little intro together for us.
00:00:45.640 --> 00:00:47.908
Um, yeah, that it's it is.
00:00:47.908 --> 00:00:54.167
It is interesting because it did absolutely start as a little bit of a troll, so much so that it got james white's attention.
00:00:54.167 --> 00:01:03.122
And james white did like an entire two-hour sermon on my tweet and it was like wait, I was just, this was just like a throwaway line.
00:01:03.122 --> 00:01:04.534
It was like here's what it is when you a throwaway line.
00:01:04.534 --> 00:01:05.200
It was like here's what it is.
00:01:05.400 --> 00:01:09.329
When you even texted me you're like I can't believe that throwaway tweet got that much attention.
00:01:09.751 --> 00:01:27.200
It's because, okay, so my issue with the thief on the cross thing, that evangelicals I'm not going to say Protestants there's a very big difference in like historical Protestantism and evangelicals and we'll get into.
00:01:27.200 --> 00:01:30.427
You know, your um, what you, what you were saying with the uh, anglo Catholics on the debate and stuff, we'll get into that.
00:01:30.427 --> 00:01:46.659
But the evangelical approach to finding like the lowest common denominator and it's like, well, the thief on the cross was saved, but, and it's like, well, okay, but just because the thief on the cross was saved that way doesn't mean you should just base your entire theology off of one throwaway line in scripture.
00:01:46.659 --> 00:01:57.287
So it's like I just wanted to annoy a Protestant so I like I just I was like, you know, the thief was saved because Mary was praying from the foot of the cross and that freaking it worked.
00:02:01.248 --> 00:02:03.766
It got all of us we were like what are you talking about?
00:02:03.807 --> 00:02:06.186
man, the funniest part was is I was.
00:02:06.186 --> 00:02:13.966
I was because you did that on one of your monday podcasts yeah and I was listening to it the next day and all of a sudden I hear avoiding babylon.
00:02:13.966 --> 00:02:17.073
And then, and then you rip on anthony.
00:02:17.073 --> 00:02:18.942
I was like, oh, this is this is.
00:02:19.042 --> 00:02:23.909
Oh, we were so excited to play it on the show, I'm sure.
00:02:23.909 --> 00:02:27.735
All right, so you just were on Tim Pool's show.
00:02:27.735 --> 00:02:35.451
It was you, Jay Dyer, Tim Gordon and I said to you in the green room like I personally would not want to debate either of those guys.
00:02:35.451 --> 00:02:39.251
They both like regularly do debates.
00:02:39.251 --> 00:02:46.659
Tim, if he specializes in a very particular area, he will like obliterate his opponent.
00:02:46.659 --> 00:02:51.572
But Jay, I knew, I kind of knew Jay was going to do what he did where?
00:02:53.120 --> 00:02:53.441
Jay?
00:02:53.441 --> 00:03:14.406
Because he spent time in traditional Catholicism and then went to orthodoxy, he knows the internal arguments amongst traditional Catholics, amongst traditional Catholics, and because Tim is like kind of caught in a position of having to defend some of the things that Catholics find controversial within the church since the Second Vatican Council.
00:03:14.406 --> 00:03:18.884
Jay knew that was a tricky spot for Tim to defend, so he jumped right into that.
00:03:18.884 --> 00:03:24.243
But he wound up going into such minutiae that it kind of ruined the conversation for the whole show.
00:03:24.243 --> 00:03:30.022
In my opinion, like for the normie listener, Like I don't think the average person had any idea what the hell you guys were talking about.
00:03:30.424 --> 00:03:34.217
No, I mean also the thing was going into the debate.
00:03:34.217 --> 00:03:43.546
My understanding was that it wasn't going to get so into ecclesiology, that it was going to be a lot more about sociology and the church's place in the modern world.
00:03:43.546 --> 00:03:46.533
You know, and I know that's where Tim was.
00:03:46.533 --> 00:03:51.592
Tim Poole was going especially was how, how does the Catholic church fit in?
00:03:51.592 --> 00:03:52.805
How does the Orthodox church fit in?
00:03:52.805 --> 00:03:54.463
Which one is best for society?
00:03:54.463 --> 00:04:07.580
Basically is, I think, where Tim was kind of at, and then Jay and Tim Gordon used it just as an opportunity to go at each other about very specific little bits of orthodox and catholic.
00:04:07.580 --> 00:04:13.252
Uh, it wasn't even theology, it was ecclesiology yeah, yeah, it was very esoteric.
00:04:13.633 --> 00:04:15.567
Uh, for for like, so it was.
00:04:15.567 --> 00:04:25.745
It was entertaining for a guy like me because I understand those debates and it's interesting to watch like a catholic and orthodox and you know both of them and I know both like like we've had jay on the show twice.
00:04:25.805 --> 00:04:31.300
Tim gordon is like one of my good friends, so it's like um, like for somebody like me.
00:04:31.300 --> 00:04:36.401
I was interested in it, but I know like the average listener was like, what the hell am I tuning into here?
00:04:36.401 -->
Load full transcript
00:04:38.524
But I did.
00:04:38.524 --> 00:04:52.130
I was interested um to know, okay, so like the everybody's throwing around that you're a freemason like I'm, I am curious like how you came about to your anglo-catholic position.
00:04:52.130 --> 00:04:52.952
Was this was like?
00:04:52.952 --> 00:04:53.961
Was this through study?
00:04:53.961 --> 00:04:54.403
Like what?
00:04:54.403 --> 00:04:57.048
How did you arrive at the, at the conclusions you have?
00:04:57.490 --> 00:04:57.730
sure.
00:04:57.730 --> 00:05:03.300
So, as I was telling you guys before the show, uh, I in college studied medieval studies and religious studies.
00:05:03.300 --> 00:05:07.612
I also I got I had a whole bunch of minors because I just had a very interdisciplinary major.
00:05:07.612 --> 00:05:18.432
But while I was in college, I had grown up non-denominational and after studying a little bit more, I came around to Methodism because I felt like it was the I like.
00:05:18.432 --> 00:05:29.848
I like a lot of the theology, I like a lot of the way that it views scripture, and I had some serious problems with Catholic history, more than anything, more even than theology.
00:05:29.869 --> 00:05:41.225
And then, as I got out of college, I was a 2020 graduate, so COVID year, and I was sitting around watching National Treasure in my parents' living room in probably like April of 2020.
00:05:41.225 --> 00:05:42.848
And I went.
00:05:42.848 --> 00:05:43.209
You know what?
00:05:43.209 --> 00:05:45.274
I wonder what the whole Freemasonry thing is about.
00:05:45.274 --> 00:05:50.892
So I decided you know what's what better way to to learn about Freemasonry than to become one?
00:05:50.892 --> 00:05:52.201
My?
00:05:52.341 --> 00:05:58.583
My curiosity, primarily, was coming from a place as a historian of oh, so there's the, the Templar connection.
00:05:58.583 --> 00:05:59.603
How real is that?
00:05:59.603 --> 00:06:00.285
Do?
00:06:00.285 --> 00:06:07.315
Is there actually a connection between what we know of as Freemasonry today and the Knights Templar post-1314?
00:06:07.315 --> 00:06:09.704
And I'll be honest, as I have gone through it.
00:06:09.704 --> 00:06:11.790
I have not found much of a connection to exist.
00:06:11.790 --> 00:06:13.326
It seems like it's mostly symbolic.
00:06:13.326 --> 00:06:17.906
There is a very interesting poem from around the year 1400 called the Regius Poem.
00:06:17.906 --> 00:06:23.735
That might be the connective tissue, but we don't know so far.
00:06:23.735 --> 00:06:29.725
But yeah, so I was a Freemason for a while, I still am, and my priest doesn't like that.
00:06:29.725 --> 00:06:30.487
He's not happy with me.
00:06:31.529 --> 00:06:58.802
But no, over the last year or so I started, as I got a little bit more into the apologetic sphere, as I started learning a little bit more about how the church works and functions, it occurred to me that there is a reason that Protestant evangelicalism, some of the mainline churches, have fallen so far away from what Christianity was up until about a hundred years ago and in my opinion that reason is that we left behind the apostolic succession.
00:06:58.802 --> 00:07:17.172
We left behind having an actual structure of the church that allows for a group of bishops, a group of priests, when somebody is out of line, to go and kind of pull them back in and say, hey, you either need to stop teaching heresy or you're going to be excommunicated from the church.
00:07:17.172 --> 00:07:29.846
So I decided, all right, I want to go and look at the apostolic churches and I have to be honest, I have a long history of not gelling with the roman catholic church, so that wasn't exactly on the table.
00:07:29.846 --> 00:07:36.033
But I started looking into lutheranism, orthodoxy, anglicanism, and I was baptized episcopalian.
00:07:36.033 --> 00:07:39.002
So when I I was like, oh, maybe I'll just go back to that.
00:07:39.002 --> 00:07:42.581
It's methodism sprung out of that anyway, so maybe I'll go back to the episcopal church.
00:07:43.023 --> 00:07:45.129
And then I went and looked and I was like what happened here?
00:07:45.129 --> 00:07:45.951
It's?
00:07:45.951 --> 00:07:54.420
It's like the uh, the community, the TV show community, the episode where Donald Glover walks into the room and I everything's on fire and people are.
00:07:54.420 --> 00:07:56.947
I was like what happened to this church in the last 30 years?
00:07:56.947 --> 00:07:59.802
So I decided that couldn't be it and I was really frustrated.
00:07:59.802 --> 00:08:02.807
And then somebody in my audience was like, hey, have you ever heard of Anglican Catholicism?
00:08:02.807 --> 00:08:04.810
And I went no, what's that?
00:08:04.810 --> 00:08:06.012
Started looking into.
00:08:06.012 --> 00:08:10.927
It Turns out there's a church right up the street, and one of the only three in Pennsylvania, I guess.
00:08:11.488 --> 00:08:12.331
And I was like, well, that's a sign.
00:08:12.331 --> 00:08:16.208
So I went for Easter service and I was like you know what?
00:08:16.208 --> 00:08:16.928
This is awesome.
00:08:16.928 --> 00:08:21.146
I like that we have a lot of the Catholic aesthetic and the liturgy.
00:08:21.146 --> 00:08:26.540
I like that we have a book of common prayer and the liturgy.
00:08:26.540 --> 00:08:27.783
I like that we have a book of common prayer.
00:08:27.783 --> 00:08:35.687
I like that the priest is so open and involved in the congregation and it was kind of cool to see a congregation that was people my age, with kids up through, people who can barely walk anymore.
00:08:35.687 --> 00:08:48.788
So I decided that was something I really liked and I started diving into it and at the end of the day that's where I feel the most at home Did you grow up with a lot of uh, anti catholic is there's different types of like.
00:08:49.009 --> 00:08:54.947
If you're growing up in the american church, there's a lot of anti-catholic sentiment in the american protestant church.
00:08:54.947 --> 00:08:55.789
Is that, is that like?
00:08:55.789 --> 00:08:57.464
Is some of that stem from that?
00:08:57.464 --> 00:08:57.784
You think?
00:08:58.408 --> 00:08:59.331
no, I actually.
00:08:59.331 --> 00:09:01.801
I had a very good relationship with catholicism growing up.
00:09:01.801 --> 00:09:08.668
Uh, half of my family are Italian Catholics, half of my oh, we don't like those here.
00:09:08.668 --> 00:09:15.245
Well, so my grandfather and my grandmother were very Catholic.
00:09:15.245 --> 00:09:16.048
A lot of my aunts and uncles still are.
00:09:16.048 --> 00:09:26.832
About half of them ended up switching over more towards Protestantism and ended up pretty much non-denominational, because I think they had that experience of Catholicism growing up where they were like I don't know that I like what I'm doing here.
00:09:32.259 --> 00:09:34.744
So for me, most of my resistance to the Roman church came about in college.
00:09:34.744 --> 00:09:35.504
What was it about?
00:09:35.504 --> 00:09:36.446
Catholic history?
00:09:37.808 --> 00:09:38.549
What is it about?
00:09:38.590 --> 00:09:41.715
Catholic history that kind of gave you that opposition.
00:09:43.279 --> 00:09:43.822
There's a few key moments.
00:09:43.822 --> 00:09:45.268
One is the donation of Constantine.
00:09:45.268 --> 00:09:46.682
I don't like that.
00:09:46.682 --> 00:09:58.893
The church forged a document in order to secure temporal authority over the kings of Europe and then, of course, the Dictatus Pape just piling on to that same thing and then it turning out to be a forgery many years later.
00:09:58.893 --> 00:10:05.051
Another one is I did not love the way that the church conducted the European Crusades.
00:10:05.633 --> 00:10:15.232
I felt like reading about specifically the Siege of Bitsie and what happened there, arnaud Amalric saying the admittedly badass line kill them all, god will recognize his own.
00:10:15.232 --> 00:10:19.525
But when you realize what that meant and what happened there, that bothered me a lot.
00:10:19.525 --> 00:10:22.491
So I felt like looking back at.
00:10:22.491 --> 00:10:26.803
And then, of course, the murder of Jan Hus and some of the other early reformers.
00:10:26.803 --> 00:10:40.976
It looked to me like there was a period between the end of the 11th century and up through the 16th century where I felt like the Catholic Church fell away, like there was something going wrong.
00:10:40.976 --> 00:10:42.746
Maybe the schism had something to do with it.
00:10:42.746 --> 00:10:47.691
But I looked at it and I said, ok, you have to admit, the Protestant Reformation didn't come out of nowhere.
00:10:47.691 --> 00:10:52.768
It was bubbling for 500 years before eventually, martin Luther nailed 95 theses to a door.
00:10:52.768 --> 00:11:07.182
So there were a few things, and I think most of all it's probably the dogmatism about certain things that just don't seem like they should necessitate excommunication and things like that, like the bodily assumption of Mary.
00:11:09.346 --> 00:11:09.586
Okay.
00:11:09.586 --> 00:11:13.971
So what convinced me?
00:11:13.971 --> 00:11:29.697
Because, like you were saying, like a lot of the things that you see, like you know, churches falling away from like their historic Christianity, things like that One of the big things that convinced me was seeing the church stand firm on the moral stance on contraception.
00:11:29.697 --> 00:11:38.403
It was like I watched every single Christian denomination give into this, this thing, right, like it was like, oh well, married couples.
00:11:38.403 --> 00:11:42.621
You know it started with the Lambeth conference in 1930, the Anglicans allowed it first.
00:11:42.621 --> 00:11:49.134
Then every single Protestant denomination, one by one, basically fell to it and said, okay, we'll allow for contraception.
00:11:49.134 --> 00:11:52.410
And it was only the Catholic church that stood firm and said no, no, no.
00:11:52.410 --> 00:11:54.721
You guys don't understand what you're doing here.
00:11:54.822 --> 00:12:00.403
If you allow for contraception, what you're doing is allowing a spouse to use their spouse.
00:12:00.403 --> 00:12:08.548
You're separating the procreative act from the unitive act and once you do that, you're using sex just as an act of pleasure.
00:12:08.548 --> 00:12:13.248
Now, if a married couple can use sex as just an act of pleasure, who's to say an unmarried couple can't?
00:12:13.248 --> 00:12:13.649
And it would.
00:12:13.649 --> 00:12:25.947
Just, I see every problem we have in modern society stems from that issue, and part of part of me, seeing catholicism as true, was like man.
00:12:25.947 --> 00:12:36.756
It just took such moral courage to stand up in the face during, during the sexual revolution, to not cave into the pressures that were coming upon the church, because it was everywhere that pressure, you know.
00:12:36.756 --> 00:12:56.956
But so that was like the start of it, and then the further I went back, just seeing how the church actually formed the Western world and seeing how even the church's stance on the relationship between men and women.
00:12:57.639 --> 00:13:08.313
So if you go back to like the Roman Empire, a lot of people think like, because you'll hear people talk about how we get democracy from the Greeks and you know we all have this Romanitas in us.
00:13:08.313 --> 00:13:13.621
Like we still speak of the Roman, like this question that goes around.
00:13:13.621 --> 00:13:15.725
It's like, oh, how many times a day do you think of the Roman empire, about men?
00:13:15.725 --> 00:13:29.109
So we have this idea of like being Roman that makes us, makes a lot of people in the modern world think that the world we're in today just kind of came about, but they don't recognize how much of a part Christianity and the Catholic church specifically played in that.
00:13:29.109 --> 00:13:38.201
It's like, um, the like women were seen as, uh, a receptacle for
men to dump their fluids in in the Roman world.
00:13:38.201 --> 00:13:43.907
Like they had the same name for their mouth, anus and vagina Like a woman was just a a toilet for a man.
00:13:44.489 --> 00:13:49.565
It took the catholic church actually starting to teach on marriage and things like that.
00:13:49.565 --> 00:13:54.464
That actually forms the western mind and like gets men away from that savagery.
00:13:54.464 --> 00:14:00.802
But it, as you get further on and you start getting these groups start breaking away.
00:14:00.802 --> 00:14:04.128
You kind of do see exactly what you were saying with the Protestants.
00:14:04.128 --> 00:14:20.452
And it happens with every single group, including the Orthodox, including, I mean, every group I can think of, where they just find something that they're willing to buckle on, whether it's remarriage in the Orthodox Church and contraception or whatever it is.
00:14:20.452 --> 00:14:31.164
It's just like it seemed like the Catholic Church is the only one who maintain that moral foundation throughout all of history, even after the crazy changes that happened in the sixties that Jay and Tim were getting into.
00:14:31.706 --> 00:14:33.711
Sure, yeah, and I I respect that a lot.
00:14:33.711 --> 00:14:37.850
I, like I said, you know there's a reason I ended up Anglican Catholic and I'm still learning a lot.
00:14:37.850 --> 00:14:51.868
I've been talking a lot with priests and and other faith leaders in the community, trying to understand more and more where everything comes from, what our positions are on things, because coming from a Methodist background, it's like we have a lot of the same stuff, but also obviously it's a lot more liberal.
00:14:51.868 --> 00:15:02.729
Um, you know, I think and for example, with the contraception issue, I asked my priest about that when, when I first started looking into the church and he told me that there is not.
00:15:02.950 --> 00:15:09.669
The basically the Anglican Catholic position on it is that you should not avoid having children in general.
00:15:09.669 --> 00:15:23.423
So vasectomy is not a good thing, hysterectomy is not a good thing, using contraception all the time, even once you're in a position to have children, not a good thing but also that you know there is something of pleasure to that experience.
00:15:23.423 --> 00:15:29.851
God created it that way for a reason, and that if you're a husband and a wife, you know you don't.
00:15:29.851 --> 00:15:35.668
You don't have to be trying for a kid constantly, all the time, just as long as you're not avoiding being fruitful and multiplying.
00:15:35.668 --> 00:15:46.129
So, like you know, don't have just one kid, don't just have two kids and then stop, but also like don't have 12 kids If you can't afford to have them was kind of where, where.
00:15:46.188 --> 00:15:47.530
I think that's a slippery slope.
00:15:48.192 --> 00:15:51.216
I think that's a slippery slope, but, um, all right.
00:15:51.216 --> 00:15:56.785
So I will say also one thing that I I think you might appreciate about.
00:15:56.785 --> 00:16:01.802
I don't know how much you know about Anglo Catholicism, but it actually was a step back, it was a step towards conservatism out of the Episcopal church.
00:16:01.802 --> 00:16:09.328
So the 1978 Missouri Synod we basically said, okay, ordination of women, that's, that's a bridge too far.
00:16:09.328 --> 00:16:11.501
We're leaving a lot of things up to pious opinion.
00:16:11.501 --> 00:16:13.125
But that that's too much.
00:16:13.125 --> 00:16:22.187
So we're going to step away, we're going to separate, and we, in doing that, maintained our ordination, going back to both Aristobalus of Britain and Augustine.
00:16:22.287 --> 00:16:30.721
So that was kind of the way that we look at it yeah, no, I know, because calvin robinson's a uh, he's like an anglican catholic, so that's what they were.
00:16:30.721 --> 00:16:32.509
So that's why I was I wanted to get to like.
00:16:32.509 --> 00:16:43.806
So they started bringing up the branch theory and that's kind of calvin robinson's position, where they it seemed like you really didn't even know where they were going with that like I wasn't familiar with the terminology.
00:16:44.267 --> 00:16:57.490
Yeah, it's basically like it's basically what you're describing, where they try to trace their lineage back to a bishop and say that the catholic church branches off into all these different branches but they still have valid ordinations and things like that.
00:16:57.490 --> 00:17:11.135
But there is something to even with calvin robinson when he got ord, he wanted to make sure he was ordained by a bishop whose ordination was recognized by the Catholic church.
00:17:11.135 --> 00:17:26.402
It's like because what it comes down to for me essentially is people can claim whatever they want, but if you don't have a valid priesthood, then even if you claim to believe in the sacraments and stuff like that, you're going to run into problems.
00:17:26.402 --> 00:17:37.053
Now with Jay, I watched you brought something up to Jay where, um, you even pointed out to him that his bishop or something recognized yeah.
00:17:37.559 --> 00:17:38.123
You're right.
00:17:38.123 --> 00:17:39.106
And what did he say to that?
00:17:39.559 --> 00:17:55.373
Yeah, I found a document that comes from the Anglican Catholic Church and it basically was going through in 1922 through 1936, I believe, there was a movement within the Orthodox community to decide do we recognize the ordination of the Anglican Church?
00:17:55.373 --> 00:18:10.480
And this is, of course, before any of the stuff that happened to the Episcopal Church and the Church of England, the Anglican community as a whole church and the church of england, the anglican communion as a whole, and basically unanimously they went yeah, we don't see any problem with the, the ordination process of the anglican church at all.
00:18:10.480 --> 00:18:12.950
Uh, I so I
posted that and it was.
00:18:12.950 --> 00:18:17.746
It started with the ecumenical patriarch of constantinople and that was, uh, milletios at the time.
00:18:18.406 --> 00:18:27.767
And I posted that and I said, hey, jay, you know, I know, I granted you had me during the bait, the debate, like I'll fully admit that I will cede, you won that debate, but you might find this interesting.
00:18:27.767 --> 00:18:40.373
And I posted a couple of screenshots from that letter and I think he only read the very first one because he said Maledios was a Freemason and the opinion of one ecumenical patriarch doesn't matter.
00:18:40.373 --> 00:18:43.509
And then I said well, you really should have read the rest of the thread where it goes through.
00:18:43.509 --> 00:18:54.104
You know, the patriarch of jerusalem, the patriarch of alexandria, uh, the hierarch of cyprus, the hierarch of romania, they all agreed with this and he just said goodbye and then blocked me yeah, I think.
00:18:54.263 --> 00:18:55.810
I think there's a tendency now.
00:18:55.810 --> 00:19:07.432
So this is kind of how I see everybody, everybody kind of just wants to disregard what the hierarchy says and just follow their own thing.
00:19:07.712 --> 00:19:11.707
So it's, it's which sounds a lot like branch theory to me, to be honest.
00:19:11.727 --> 00:19:20.382
Yeah, I agree, I think I think jay, as much as he wants to claim the orthodox church is the one true church, sounds to me like he's just a set of a contest.
00:19:20.382 --> 00:19:21.703
Essentially like he's.
00:19:21.703 --> 00:19:24.548
He's a set of a contest with a couple of differing opinions.
00:19:24.548 --> 00:19:29.914
But, um, all right, we'll get off this topic because I it's just whatever.
00:19:29.914 --> 00:19:34.127
But um what, uh what, unless you got stuff.
00:19:34.147 --> 00:19:35.009
Well, I was curious.
00:19:35.009 --> 00:19:36.192
So you said you came, you.
00:19:36.192 --> 00:19:39.586
You first came to um, uh, the method.
00:19:39.586 --> 00:19:40.426
You know methodism.
00:19:40.426 --> 00:19:43.192
In college, what like what were you raised as what?
00:19:43.192 --> 00:19:44.141
What did you grow up in?
00:19:44.561 --> 00:19:47.648
kind of non-denominational but with a Baptist.
00:19:47.648 --> 00:19:49.152
My stepdad was a Baptist.
00:19:49.152 --> 00:20:02.162
My mom was a, grew up a Catholic uh, and probably wouldn't call herself a Catholic anymore, but she's just kind of the same kind of thing, like just non-denominational Protestant, um, because it's just, it's not that big.
00:20:02.162 --> 00:20:04.145
They're like God's a big deal in their lives.
00:20:04.145 --> 00:20:11.142
They're definitely Christians, they care quite a bit, but the the church structure itself hasn't really mattered.
00:20:11.142 --> 00:20:13.093
And I've been trying to actually get them to come to church with me.
00:20:13.717 --> 00:20:18.310
Uh, start going back, cause they didn't have the same church to go to and my mom didn't love my stepdad's church.
00:20:18.310 --> 00:20:29.627
My stepdad didn't want to go to the churches my mom was okay with, so it just was a whole thing.
00:20:29.627 --> 00:20:31.113
So I was raised non-denominational for all intents and purposes.
00:20:31.113 --> 00:20:31.703
I went to a lot of different churches.
00:20:31.703 --> 00:20:34.561
I've been to Catholic masses, I've been to Orthodox masses, I've been to Protestant sermons, just kind of.
00:20:34.561 --> 00:20:42.766
Once I got to college I was like I think that there's, there's gotta be a way of doing this properly and I decided that I just really liked what John Wesley and Charles Wesley were about.
00:20:44.430 --> 00:20:45.833
Yeah, I think you're going to keep.
00:20:45.833 --> 00:20:50.826
Look, the reason I don't want to keep pressing you is just cause I don't want to have like an argument or a bait on here.
00:20:50.826 --> 00:21:16.840
I think you should just keep keep going, Like you, I think if you just keep going and looking back to like how, especially cause you're a history major like if you, if you study the early centuries of catholicism in the catholic church, like you kind of see how, like the kingdom of heaven on earth is very much a part of the gospel and what the church is actually doing is spreading the kingdom on earth.
00:21:16.840 --> 00:21:22.425
Yeah, so when the church is building those cathedrals, like those cathedrals are meant to be the the kingdom on earth, you know.
00:21:22.425 --> 00:21:24.792
And and the the pope wearing all of his garb is meant to be the kingdom on earth, you know.
00:21:24.792 --> 00:21:29.726
And and the pope wearing all of his garb is meant to signify the kingship of Christ and all those things.
00:21:29.946 --> 00:21:39.784
Like the symbolism of Catholicism is unmistakable, and I think even even the non Catholics, like you, watched it during the election of Pope Leo.
00:21:39.784 --> 00:21:41.930
It's like the whole world was looking to Rome.
00:21:41.930 --> 00:21:43.481
It's like what the hell is going on here.
00:21:43.481 --> 00:21:50.429
It's like like, regardless of what any ecumenical patriarch in the East says, or regardless of whatever an Anglican bishop says.
00:21:50.429 --> 00:21:55.304
Everybody still looks to the Bishop of Rome, including, like the secular West.
00:21:55.304 --> 00:21:59.432
When Francis was in and he would change something, they'd be like oh that's it.
00:21:59.432 --> 00:22:00.099
The church has changed.
00:22:00.099 --> 00:22:10.674
Like everybody's waiting on the Church of Rome to make a decision on things even to this day, and it has a lot to do with how much the Church of Rome played a part in forming the culture we're in today.
00:22:13.559 --> 00:22:14.882
Oh, definitely, and I wouldn't disagree with that at all.
00:22:14.882 --> 00:22:31.605
I think that what I find attractive about the Anglican position is basically that up until the 1500s we're part of the Catholic church and
we we didn't consider ourselves Protestant, that Anglicans don't consider themselves part of the reformation in the same way that Lutherans and Calvinists do, because it wasn't.
00:22:31.605 --> 00:22:37.191
It really was just about the council of Trent and some of the issues of people supremacy.
00:22:37.191 --> 00:22:42.410
Well, the Henry VIII was his own thing, Okay.
00:22:44.201 --> 00:22:45.105
We don't look to him.
00:22:45.144 --> 00:23:09.651
We don't look to him we don't look to him yeah, no, but he did start something he did and I and, and then that winds up coalescing in in his successors, with mary coming back in and then elizabeth after her which and elizabeth's interesting because we don't know a ton about what her personal beliefs were it seems like it at that point became a very much, very much a political thing.
00:23:09.651 --> 00:23:25.151
But I think what I appreciate about the, the philosophy of the time within the Anglican church, was basically then saying like hey, we, our biggest problem here is is the Pope claiming to be just unquestionable in so many aspects.
00:23:25.151 --> 00:23:42.903
Because if the entire catholic church just follows along with whatever the pope says, then that early church formula of the various bishops being able to have opinions and argue about things and kind of needing to respect the opinions of everybody, if everybody's just in lockstep with the pope, that that kind of takes away.
00:23:42.983 --> 00:23:50.602
the church ever functioned that way, Even after papal supremacy was announced, though there's always, you know, we still have church councils that we come to In anything.
00:23:50.662 --> 00:23:54.048
it's only functioned that way in the last 60 years, yeah.
00:23:54.381 --> 00:24:14.819
It's been a bit rough in the past 60 years, but I don't think even after papal infallibility was declared, things like that, like the church, has never functioned as a total monarchy where the pope just unilaterally makes decisions.
00:24:14.819 --> 00:24:17.465
Until recent history it's always been, you know, a collegial type thing, and especially when it comes to doctrine and things like that.
00:24:17.465 --> 00:24:18.700
But you know, the church it really would come down to.
00:24:18.700 --> 00:24:23.672
Does peter have a special grace given to him to not err?
00:24:23.672 --> 00:24:24.773
I?
00:24:24.794 --> 00:24:25.695
mean the.
00:24:25.777 --> 00:24:49.825
The anglican position is that there is papal primacy, but that it has gone too far into people, at least as I understand it, uh, but it's gone too far into papal supremacy, where it should basically peter was the the top guy, but an entire church council would overrule a pope, and I think that that's kind of where where things got off the rails and why the Anglican Church came about.
00:24:49.825 --> 00:25:14.577
Was this this recognition of, even if it wasn't at the point of being total yet, trying to stem that tide and say wait, I think you'll, you'll see, a lot of Anglicans will say that, especially Anglican Catholics will say that they would be, they would welcome communion with Rome and returning to the, the fold of the Roman Catholic Church if a few things were addressed.
00:25:16.661 --> 00:25:18.067
Do you not see the absurdity of that?
00:25:18.067 --> 00:25:22.520
Though I don't like, we'll come back to you if you do what we want, it's like?
00:25:22.520 --> 00:25:26.599
No, the seat of Rome is the one who says what you need to do.
00:25:26.599 --> 00:25:27.060
But that's my point.
00:25:27.060 --> 00:25:28.063
You know that it's.
00:25:28.063 --> 00:25:33.112
If the seat of Rome is wrong, what are you going to?
00:25:33.112 --> 00:25:34.761
And we believe it's wrong, I mean.
00:25:35.384 --> 00:25:44.528
Yeah, well, the thing is you are kind of new to the whole, looking even deeper into apostolic Christianity, so keep going.
00:25:44.528 --> 00:25:45.167
That's all I'm saying.
00:25:45.167 --> 00:25:47.865
Like just because you feel comfortable in a specific place.
00:25:47.865 --> 00:26:05.057
Like because what, what it should come down to is the truth, like if something's true or not, it shouldn't come down to, um, I don't like this thing like the, the hardest things in catholicism, like even like you were saying, like the um, uh, the assumption of mary or the immaculate conception, things like that.
00:26:05.057 --> 00:26:06.048
Like if you, if saying like the, the assumption of Mary or the Immaculate Conception, things like that.
00:26:06.188 --> 00:26:24.021
Like if you, if you think about the churches that don't believe in the Immaculate Conception or the churches that don't believe in the sinlessness of Mary, you look at what, what, the actual fruits of this, of the church's belief that Mary was sinless were, and it is monasticism Right.
00:26:24.021 --> 00:26:25.452
Belief that Mary was sinless were, and it is monasticism right.
00:26:25.452 --> 00:26:31.655
So, like the, the idea of holy virginity actually spurts from the belief that Mary was a perpetual virgin.
00:26:31.655 --> 00:26:51.186
So these monks would go out to the desert and take vows of celibacy and go live out in monasteries and you wind up getting some of the, the most profound, um, uh, the profound understanding of prayer and, uh, just the deepening of the western mind into, into, in theology, things like that.
00:26:51.186 --> 00:26:58.391
Then, once you break away from that, once you get to the time of the reformation, that's when feminism starts encroaching in and like it.
00:26:58.391 --> 00:27:00.040
I mean, it's just whatever.
00:27:00.040 --> 00:27:04.386
I'm not, I'm not a great debater, I'm just saying these are the things that I had actually.
00:27:04.667 --> 00:27:10.175
These are the things that had sparked me, like my thinking along the way.
00:27:10.175 --> 00:27:16.392
What did you so you got out of college as a history major?
00:27:16.392 --> 00:27:17.683
What made you start a
podcast?
00:27:18.788 --> 00:27:19.048
COVID.
00:27:19.048 --> 00:27:24.291
I was working a digital marketing job because that was all I could really get.
00:27:24.291 --> 00:27:26.467
I was waiting to go to grad school.
00:27:26.467 --> 00:27:30.550
I had actually gotten accepted to Bangor University in Wales.
00:27:30.550 --> 00:27:33.548
I was going to go get my master's and end up being a professor.
00:27:36.280 --> 00:27:50.527
I was sitting at work my last Friday at work, I think it was, and nothing to do, just scrolling on TikTok on my phone and I saw a video that was like what's a conspiracy theory you 100% believe in but you can't prove.
00:27:50.527 --> 00:27:56.450
I had been working on a concept for a script, I think, for like a TV show or a novel.
00:27:56.450 --> 00:28:08.925
I can't remember exactly what I was working on, but it was the idea that, like, the national parks exist because they're a containment area for monsters, and so I made a little stupid tick talk about it.
00:28:08.925 --> 00:28:16.048
It got 7 million views and so people were like hey, you know, you should start a YouTube channel, you should start talking more about this stuff.
00:28:16.048 --> 00:28:28.015
And I did that and I at first it was just hey, this is kind of cool, we have extra beer money for for going out to the bar on the weekend, which isn't really something we could even do that much at the time, cause it was June of 2021.
00:28:28.836 --> 00:28:30.936
Um, but no it was like hey, beer, money, cool.
00:28:30.936 --> 00:28:42.989
And then after a few months it started to grow and then it got to a point where my my best friend and I were like hey, maybe, maybe we can do this, maybe this is something we can actually do as a full-time job.
00:28:42.989 --> 00:28:47.525
We were both working 40 hours a week at the time, um, and yeah, it just kind of grew.
00:28:47.525 --> 00:28:50.271
We, we sat down and went is this a risk that we can take?
00:28:50.271 --> 00:29:13.960
And we decided to go for it and it was the best decision we ever made what was the first one that like blew up, besides that tiktok oh man, um, it was really once we started diving into Um.
00:29:13.980 --> 00:29:16.606
It was really once we started diving into missing 411 stuff, uh, when we were probably a year and a half in um.
00:29:16.606 --> 00:29:17.589
I can't remember if there was any one big, huge.
00:29:17.589 --> 00:29:18.451
I have to give so much credit to Wendigoon.
00:29:18.451 --> 00:29:29.365
I don't know if you've watched any of his stuff, but he took us under his wing and exposed his audience to our stuff and that just kind of all at once in November of I want to say, 2022, just like skyrocketed it Suddenly.
00:29:29.365 --> 00:29:33.988
We were getting, you know, we, we went from 75 to a thousand subscribers to a hundred thousand in like three weeks.
00:29:33.988 --> 00:29:35.792
Um, wow, yeah.
00:29:35.792 --> 00:29:39.189
So it just right place, right time, knowing
the right people.
00:29:39.189 --> 00:29:42.923
Um, I think that was definitely what it was was working with him.
00:29:42.923 --> 00:29:54.916
But, yeah, after that it was just kind of a steady growth period and trying to do our best and going from being a channel that was just kind of talking about fun, scary stories to basically doing academic research on them.
00:29:55.780 --> 00:29:57.288
So how much time would you guys spend?
00:29:57.288 --> 00:30:00.087
How often do episodes come out and how much time do you guys spend doing them?
00:30:00.087 --> 00:30:10.039
Oh God, them.
00:30:10.060 --> 00:30:10.221
Oh god, I.
00:30:10.221 --> 00:30:13.454
I I'd say probably, probably 80 hours of work goes into each episode between the two of us at least, if, if not 100, really depends on which one?
00:30:13.474 --> 00:30:13.977
what do you put about?
00:30:13.977 --> 00:30:16.825
Once every other week or something once every week, once a week?
00:30:17.125 --> 00:30:33.615
yeah, so it's usually me doing, me doing about 30 to 50 and my co-host doing about 30 to 50 uh, on either end of it, depending on what we're looking at, like the john benet ramsey stuff, I'll sit there and stare at my screen probably for 70 80 hours writing a script, and then he has to go do the same thing to edit it.
00:30:33.615 --> 00:30:34.960
Have you guys had any?
00:30:35.000 --> 00:30:39.073
blowouts like video you guys been doing this since 2020 right.
00:30:39.093 --> 00:30:40.176
Have you guys had any 2021?
00:30:40.196 --> 00:30:45.076
2021 have you guys had any arguments, yeah, like big blowouts where you guys are just like.
00:30:45.096 --> 00:30:46.401
I don't know if we can continue with this.
00:30:47.685 --> 00:30:51.546
Honestly no, we trust each other a lot.
00:30:51.546 --> 00:30:54.226
We've known each other since we were 16.
00:30:54.226 --> 00:30:56.432
So we're now 27.
00:30:56.432 --> 00:31:02.769
There have been a few tense moments, I'll say, but most of the arguments we've had have been in our personal life.
00:31:04.944 --> 00:31:07.491
If I knew Anthony when he was 16, that would not have been good.
00:31:09.240 --> 00:31:12.470
If most of the people I know knew me when I was 16, they would not have liked me.
00:31:12.470 --> 00:31:17.395
I've definitely become a lot more mellow All right, they want me to fight with you.
00:31:17.435 --> 00:31:19.667
Everybody, everybody's telling me they're going to take my man card away.
00:31:19.667 --> 00:31:21.826
Everybody wants me to get get ruthless with you, all right.
00:31:21.826 --> 00:31:23.107
Wants me to get get ruthless with you, all right.
00:31:23.107 --> 00:31:24.589
So bobby asks all right, you guys want me to fight with him?
00:31:24.589 --> 00:31:25.570
I'll fight with him a little bit.
00:31:25.570 --> 00:31:28.753
I don't like confrontation on a show that I invited somebody on, but we could do it.
00:31:28.773 --> 00:31:32.557
We disagree on like this much stuff bobby wants to know.
00:31:32.557
--> 00:31:35.287
By what authority do your bishops declare the successor of peter wrong?
00:31:35.287 --> 00:31:36.840
Okay, you guys want me to ask questions?
00:31:36.941 --> 00:31:43.111
ask them let's go, we'll fight with our guests, you guys want it yeah, I think that the response to that would be like well, why is?
00:31:43.111 --> 00:31:45.154
Why is he the valid successor of Peter?
00:31:45.154 --> 00:31:51.880
Is, if the successor of Peter is saying things that are heretical, is he a valid successor?
00:31:53.324 --> 00:31:54.207
Who declares heresy?
00:31:54.909 --> 00:31:59.907
The church councils the church declares heresy yes.
00:32:00.107 --> 00:32:13.799
The church declares heresy and if they have a valid successor from I mean we say it in the Roman canon like we've had a continuous successors to the chair of Peter since since Peter.
00:32:13.799 --> 00:32:15.207
So I mean I don't know how you can.
00:32:15.319 --> 00:32:17.565
The manner of succession has changed a number of times.
00:32:17.565 --> 00:32:18.989
There's been times when there were two popes.
00:32:18.989 --> 00:32:25.801
There's been times there was a time there were three popes, and then we get times when, like Pope honorius, the first was a an out and out heretic.
00:32:25.801 --> 00:32:31.481
Um pope alexander the sixth, who we mentioned earlier, you know, wasn't a heretic, but he was a fornicator.
00:32:31.481 --> 00:32:39.554
So I think I have no issue with that, though, yeah, looking looking at the, the catholic church, and saying like hey, is this, is this person?
00:32:39.554 --> 00:32:43.486
Is the direction things are going really the way that christ intended it?
00:32:43.486 --> 00:32:47.444
Because I I think that that's really where the, where the orthodoxy splits off.
00:32:47.444 --> 00:32:55.752
Where the Anglican split off is, is the chair of Peter and sitting in that seat enough to make somebody the successor of Peter?
00:32:57.882 --> 00:33:00.790
I bet you there's some Catholics that would declare that questionable too.
00:33:00.790 --> 00:33:08.904
No, but I would say that the church, the catholic church, is the only one who has the ability to call a church council.
00:33:08.904 --> 00:33:11.612
Right, so, even the orthodox are like they.
00:33:11.612 --> 00:33:17.862
They try to make the claim that they paused in the 11th century and their liturgy is unchanged and all these things are unchanged.
00:33:17.862 --> 00:33:25.259
But yeah, but the world has changed a lot and only the catholic church is able to call a council to bring the world's bishops together to address these issues.
00:33:25.640 --> 00:33:29.846
I think what you mean when you say that only the Catholic Church is able to.
00:33:29.846 --> 00:33:35.796
I think you're really saying only the Catholic Church has successfully done so since the Seventh Ecumenical Council.
00:33:35.796 --> 00:33:56.731
Right, Because I think the Orthodox would say they could, but yet they haven't, they could not call a world council I, I agree, I agree with you, but they would, I think they would claim otherwise is that because they can't?
00:33:56.972 --> 00:33:59.380
or because, if they did, the catholic bishops wouldn't attend?
00:33:59.380 --> 00:34:15.469
Um modern bishops probably would attend that's the thing is like if if leo the 14th said hey, we're pulling together an ecumenical council, we want constantinople there, we want canterbury they did want missouri.
00:34:15.469 --> 00:34:19.367
There they did go in the second vatican council there were.
00:34:19.507 --> 00:34:26.532
There were eastern patriarchs at the second vatican council, so it's like so they have a vote though I don't know if they were voting members.
00:34:26.532 --> 00:34:29.208
But that's not really how a council works either.
00:34:29.208 --> 00:34:31.186
It's not like it's not a democracy.
00:34:31.186 --> 00:34:38.088
It's more like documents are produced from the council and then the Pope will sign off on them after the.
00:34:38.420 --> 00:34:39.987
after the college of bishops.
00:34:39.987 --> 00:34:42.943
The college of bishops sign off on also sign off on them.
00:34:42.985 --> 00:34:45.168
There has to be agreement upon what they're putting forth.
00:34:45.168 --> 00:34:46.891
But that's the thing.
00:34:46.891 --> 00:35:08.025
It's like the times where the church actually, where the Pope actually acts in the manner you're saying, where he's spouting heresy, like that would be, when the Pope is speaking infallibly is very, very rare, and when he's speaking ex cathedra, so from the chair, and he's saying this is binding on all the Christian faithful.
00:35:08.025 --> 00:35:12.965
So now, if you don't have that position in the church, how can there be unity?
00:35:12.965 --> 00:35:14.110
It's like cause.
00:35:14.150 --> 00:35:28.896
I like Jonathan Peugeot a lot, but he's always talking about hierarchy and how things kind of work up and they have to cut Like if Christ doesn't have a prime minister upon the earth who does get to say this is heresy, this is not.
00:35:28.896 --> 00:35:34.108
Like I don't see how any ecclesiology outside of Roman Catholicism could actually work.
00:35:34.108 --> 00:35:43.768
And when I say Roman Catholicism, I don't mean the Latin church, I just mean with the Pope as head of the government, you know, as the governing body over the entire church.
00:35:43.768 --> 00:35:50.967
It kind of it then comes down to oh, we don't like what the Pope says, so we're going to break off and start our own thing.
00:35:50.967 --> 00:36:03.530
I'm not saying you don't have a closer relationship to historical Christianity as an Anglo-Catholic, of course you do than a modern evangelical, because modern evangelicals, that theology is literally 100 years old.
00:36:03.530 --> 00:36:10.811
But I don't know how you can justify just saying well, I don't agree with this thing, so we're going to go start our own thing.
00:36:12.641 --> 00:36:30.842
I
mean, I guess I can understand where you're coming from, but at the same time, do you understand the Protestant position that if the Catholic Church, under the Pope, says something that really seems to be at the very least improper, if not heretical, why should we respect that office?
00:36:30.842 --> 00:36:33.204
I mean, if the Pope were to, can you think?
00:36:33.304 --> 00:36:36.885
of something offhand that you could Give me an example on that.
00:36:36.885 --> 00:36:40.882
As a heresy that you think that the Pope is.
00:36:42.302 --> 00:36:42.923
The current Pope?
00:36:42.923 --> 00:36:51.512
I can't think of one, but, like I said, anoreous monothelitism right, okay, uh, but his successor corrected that right?
00:36:51.512 --> 00:36:52.614
Yes, exactly.
00:36:52.614 --> 00:36:57.951
But what if he had declared ex cathedra what, what he did, but, but what?
00:36:57.951 --> 00:36:58.753
But if he had?
00:36:58.753 --> 00:37:01.001
That's my point is, and even and even honorius.
00:37:01.021 --> 00:37:01.320
I don't know.
00:37:01.320 --> 00:37:04.344
I don't know the history of Honorius too well, but I don't know.
00:37:04.344 --> 00:37:05.264
I think his was.
00:37:05.264 --> 00:37:16.597
I'm pretty sure it was more just like a conceding to keep for the sake of unity type of thing, but he didn't pronounce it or anything.
00:37:16.597 --> 00:37:17.865
I don't know Honorius that well.
00:37:17.865 --> 00:37:22.360
Yeah, he wouldn't declare it ex cathedra.
00:37:22.360 --> 00:37:25.728
I got Tim Gordon texting me but he could, you know, no, but he wouldn't declare it ex cathedra.
00:37:25.748 --> 00:37:26.878
I got Tim Gordon texting me, but he could you know.
00:37:28.965 --> 00:37:29.668
No but he couldn't.
00:37:29.668 --> 00:37:31.460
Yes, that's the claim, right.
00:37:31.460 --> 00:37:44.501
So the Catholic position is that the office, like the claiming, the Pope has infallibility when speaking ex cathedra is not saying the Pope can declare anything to be doctrine, it's saying that.
00:37:44.501 --> 00:37:47.530
God prevents him from proclaiming a heresy Right.
00:37:47.719 --> 00:37:48.786
It's a negative charism.
00:37:50.884 --> 00:37:53.231
And that just doesn't do it for me.
00:37:53.231 --> 00:37:55.025
I don't know what to tell you.
00:37:55.025 --> 00:37:58.684
Beside that, it's just saying that it can't happen.
00:37:58.684 --> 00:38:00.608
Because it can't happen is circular reasoning.
00:38:00.608 --> 00:38:03.094
Well, it hasn't.
00:38:03.094 --> 00:38:14.536
That's why I'm saying it can't happen because god prevents it but god didn't prevent the college of cardinals from electing multiple popes who were flagrant sinners yeah, but that's not what.
00:38:14.597 --> 00:38:16.681
That's not what we claim like you can have.
00:38:16.681 --> 00:38:16.902
That's.
00:38:16.902 --> 00:38:30.940
The point is that you can have a guy like pope alexander the six, who clearly had um, uh, had mistresses and he had children out of wedlock and all these things, but what he wasn't doing is changing church teaching to suit his lifestyle.
00:38:30.940 --> 00:38:33.594
Sure, but again.
00:38:33.974 --> 00:38:40.699
somebody who is representative of Christ on earth should be as Christlike as possible, and like with Irvin too, he was literally insane.
00:38:41.489 --> 00:38:42.574
They elected an insane man.
00:38:42.574 --> 00:38:46.538
We've had gay pedophiles as popes, but they didn't change.
00:38:46.978 --> 00:38:54.300
The teaching of the church is the point Until they did, and that's when things like the Council of Trent come about and the Anglicans go OK, no.
00:38:55.931 --> 00:39:00.902
OK, so if the church council like Trent, because you said the church councils are the ones who claim heresy.
00:39:01.130 --> 00:39:02.150
The Protestants weren't given a vote there.
00:39:02.150 --> 00:39:04.452
The Protestants didn't have a say at the Council of Trent.
00:39:04.952 --> 00:39:08.157
The whole point of the Council of Trent was to correct the Protestant errors.
00:39:08.157 --> 00:39:10.780
But it was still a valid church council, right?
00:39:10.820 --> 00:39:22.833
So like, I understand that, but if you're, if you're going to have a council and say, hey, we need to discuss these things, and then you don't give the people who are arguing with you a say that's not.
00:39:22.853 --> 00:39:24.556
They address their arguments specifically, though.
00:39:25.097 --> 00:39:25.217
Like.
00:39:25.217 --> 00:39:26.039
That's what the Council of.
00:39:26.059 --> 00:39:32.862
Trent is is addressing the Protestant arguments specifically and saying this you, if you believe this, you are cursed.
00:39:32.862 --> 00:39:40.780
Right, so so, but like even you as an Anglo-Catholic right Like well, that's a good question.
00:39:40.880 --> 00:39:41.081
Why?
00:39:41.081 --> 00:39:42.929
Why is our ordination declared invalid?
00:39:42.929 --> 00:39:44.043
Our ordination?
00:39:44.063 --> 00:39:44.630
declared invalid?
00:39:44.630 --> 00:39:46.358
I actually think there's.
00:39:46.358 --> 00:39:51.617
Isn't there a document specifically saying from the Catholic Church that the Anglican ordinations are invalid?
00:39:52.110 --> 00:39:52.331
Yes.
00:39:52.331 --> 00:40:04.900
I can't remember it off the top of my head, if I remember correctly, it came about in the 1560s and the reasoning was that we took out the submissiveness to the Pope.
00:40:04.900 --> 00:40:08.043
That bishops must be subservient to the Pope.
00:40:08.043 --> 00:40:09.009
That's about all.
00:40:09.028 --> 00:40:16.641
I believe that wouldn't invalidate their ordination though, because the Orthodox ordinations are still valid and their sacraments are still valid.
00:40:17.932 --> 00:40:38.585
It was actually Leo XIII in 1896, and the papal apostolate curé concluded that Anglican ordinations were absolutely null and utterly void due to defects in the form and intention of the Anglican ordination rite, particularly following
changes made during the Reformation.
00:40:39.110 --> 00:40:41.920
I very much love Leo XIII because he's always extremely vague.
00:40:44.052 --> 00:40:45.469
I bet the document is more specific.
00:40:45.570 --> 00:40:47.657
I'm sure if you've read the document, it's not that big.
00:40:49.072 --> 00:40:50.695
I have read his uh.
00:40:50.695 --> 00:40:53.619
I was it him that did inhumanum genus?
00:40:53.619 --> 00:40:57.612
Uh, or was that pious, uh, whichever one, when?
00:40:57.672 --> 00:41:05.152
when pope leo generous yeah, uh, when that's yeah, that that's that's the one I was thinking of for when they originally banned freemasonry.
00:41:05.152 --> 00:41:18.887
But when Pope Leo XIII comes along and reaffirms the papal ban on Freemasonry, his reasoning came entirely from a con artist who lied to him and everything he said was like all of these things, and then he didn't actually give examples and evidence.
00:41:18.887 --> 00:41:30.614
More from a a logical point of view than a theological point of view is I.
00:41:30.614 --> 00:41:34.661
I need to see the explanation of why something is wrong, not just we decided this is wrong.
00:41:34.661 --> 00:41:37.195
And I think that that's the way a lot of Protestants feel is.
00:41:37.195 --> 00:41:45.193
There's a lot of church decisions that they just say and we have declared this anathema, and then they don't explain why I would take the opposite approach.
00:41:45.275 --> 00:41:48.956
I would say that the church is actually very thorough in explaining why those things are wrong.
00:41:50.333 --> 00:41:56.777
So, for instance, in the papal bull about the Anglican ordination, there was two main reasons given.
00:41:56.777 --> 00:42:13.626
One is that the Anglican Rite of Reformation, as revised during the Reformation, removed the references to the priest's role in offering the Eucharistic sacrifice, in other words, removed the references to the priest's role in offering the Eucharistic sacrifice, in other words, removed the references to the role in offering it as a propitiatory sacrifice.
00:42:14.791 --> 00:42:27.376
And then the second was that there was not enough elaboration to signify the order being conferred in the ordination.
00:42:27.376 --> 00:42:33.664
So in the Catholic ordination it is specific whether that person is being ordained a deacon, priest or bishop.
00:42:33.664 --> 00:42:38.760
And it was judged that the Anglican Rite lacked that specificity.
00:42:40.150 --> 00:42:41.594
But we do have deacons, priests and bishops.
00:42:42.177 --> 00:42:42.318
Right.
00:42:44.434 --> 00:42:55.494
It says that the phrase— it's the same reason why they call deacons fathers in the anglican church, like like father calvin robinson was father calvin robinson when he was just a deacon interesting.
00:42:56.195 --> 00:43:09.282
Yeah, to be honest, I'm I'm too new to it to really argue on that, on the finer points of it um, hang on, let me just say, uh, um, okay, so what?
00:43:09.402 --> 00:43:10.583
uh, what is your position?
00:43:10.583 --> 00:43:11.710
What is your take on?
00:43:11.710 --> 00:43:13.197
Have you ever read the ultima nida?
00:43:13.197 --> 00:43:15.385
I can't say that I have.
00:43:15.385 --> 00:43:16.730
You've never read the ultimate.
00:43:16.730 --> 00:43:29.704
Indeed, rob, bring the ultimate nida, because I I've heard you say um that catholics oh yeah I didn't know by that name.
00:43:29.764 --> 00:43:31.827
But yeah, I, I've read some of it.
00:43:31.827 --> 00:43:33.954
It's, it's nonsense.
00:43:33.954 --> 00:43:51.784
It's not masonic, it was created by the church you think the ultimate data was created by the church and not by, not by freemasons unless, hang on, I might be mistaking it with something else, but ah, yes, it's the 100-year plan to get their own guy in, essentially so that's the thing.
00:43:52.130 --> 00:44:04.684
Freemasonry never had a problem with the Catholic Church Like actual, to this day regular Freemasonry, which is mainly just the United States, canada and Britain, has no problem with the Catholic Church.
00:44:04.684 --> 00:44:06.951
There's no ban on Catholics, there's no.
00:44:06.951 --> 00:44:11.335
There was actually a ban on discussion of religion in the lodge and the discussion of politics in the lodge.
00:44:11.335 --> 00:44:21.862
What the, what the Illuminati and the French Masons and and, to an extent, the Italian Masons were doing in the the 18 and 1900s actually is why we denounced them as a group.
00:44:21.862 --> 00:45:05.858
So, and like I said on on the show last night, if I come to a point where I see something that is essential to freemasonry, that is a core doctrine of freemasonry, not just, you know, personal opinion about something that were to contradict christianity, I I would walk away, I would leave in a heartbeat, I think I think the god rob I was just gonna say I do think, um, there is a conflation between, like english and scottish right freemasonry with, like the oriental lodges yeah um, now I I would say that the, the, the big problems with the oriental lodges are still somewhat there in in the, the english and scottish right, sort sort of I'm in the scottish right for that
00:45:06.739 --> 00:45:30.525
yeah, um, but in, in terms of those who you know were responsible for, say, a lot of the, the violence against the church, and like the french revolution, yeah, and in, you know, the italian freemasons that, like garibaldi and those who fought against the church, those, yeah, those are the Oriental Lodges and they are the extremists in a sense.
00:45:31.329 --> 00:45:41.324
I take a much more hardline stance on this than most Freemasons that I know, in that I don't think that Oriental Lodges should be recognized as Masonic at all.
00:45:41.324 --> 00:45:55.085
I think that anything that isn't in perfect lockstep with the English branch basically is wrong, almost in a very similar way to the way Catholics view Protestantism.
00:45:55.085 -->
00:46:02.583
I don't think that the French lodges are Masonic, because Masonry has a few core requirements.
00:46:02.583 --> 00:46:03.492
You have to believe in a God.
00:46:03.492 --> 00:46:04.614
The French don't require that.
00:46:04.614 --> 00:46:05.757
You have to be a man.
00:46:05.757 --> 00:46:06.898
The French don't require that.
00:46:06.898 --> 00:46:09.231
You're not allowed to talk about politics or religion in the lodge.
00:46:09.231 --> 00:46:12.240
The French actually encourage you to foment insurrection in the lodge.
00:46:12.240 --> 00:46:16.422
All of that is disgusting to me and I hate it For me.
00:46:16.963 --> 00:46:20.052
What I like about Freemasonry is the stuff that goes back really far.
00:46:20.052 --> 00:46:23.936
I think that after the year 1800, things kind of went off the rails.
00:46:23.936 --> 00:46:32.626
I think that the people who deny that the Illuminati influence remained within Freemasonry and that it permeated are insane.
00:46:32.626 --> 00:46:34.840
I think that that's exactly what the Scottish Rite is.
00:46:34.840 --> 00:46:40.858
I think that most Freemasons probably don't realize how bad the things they're involved in are.
00:46:40.858 --> 00:46:50.483
But on the other hand, if you're going to become a member of the Commandery, the Knights Templar and Freemasonry you must be a Trinitarian Christian.
00:46:50.483 --> 00:47:06.385
So there's a very stark difference between the kind of almost more universalist I wouldn't say Gnostic, but universalist position of the Scottish right, as opposed to the explicitly Trinitarian viewpoint of the York right.
00:47:06.405 --> 00:47:13.856
As opposed to the explicitly Trinitarian viewpoint of the York Rite To me even the idea of secret societies and stuff like that are.
00:47:13.856 --> 00:47:19.824
I don't know enough about this, but I would think this is why the church was condemning them.
00:47:19.824 --> 00:47:21.210
For hundreds of years.
00:47:21.210 --> 00:47:23.503
The Catholic Church has been condemning Freemasonry yes, in 1788.
00:47:23.503 --> 00:47:26.327
The Catholic church has been condemning Freemasonry yes, the the.
00:47:26.327 --> 00:47:36.556
The idea that Protestants would like would mock the rituals of Catholicism and then go into these secret societies and then have their own rituals.
00:47:36.556 --> 00:47:40.199
It just seems so like contradictory to me.
00:47:40.469 --> 00:47:41.755
I'm curious what you mean about mockery.
00:47:43.690 --> 00:47:48.760
The Protestants in general don't like.
00:47:48.760 --> 00:47:54.518
I'm talking about american protestants, I'm not talking about like anglican and stuff like that, like american protestantism.
00:47:54.518 --> 00:48:04.400
They don't like liturgical christianity, but then they came here, like the puritans came here and they started all these secret societies with it and doing all these rituals behind closed doors.
00:48:04.400 --> 00:48:10.960
But I think ritual is actually inherent in
humanity, like God made us to perform rituals and stuff like that.
00:48:10.960 --> 00:48:18.202
But I mean, I just, I just know the church has explicitly condemned Freemasonry for the past 300 years or so.
00:48:18.610 --> 00:48:20.954
Yeah, and and, to be honest, in a in a weird way.
00:48:20.954 --> 00:48:27.795
Like I said, if if I found Freemasonry to be in contradiction with my Christian faith, I would walk away immediately.
00:48:27.795 --> 00:48:48.130
But in a weird way, one of my biggest issues with Catholicism has come through the way that they have responded to Freemasonry over the years for it.
00:48:48.130 --> 00:48:54.186
But what Pius wrote in 1738, if you read it, his reasoning is literally just they meet in secret, therefore they must be doing evil and perverse things.
00:48:54.186 --> 00:48:56.552
But in reality it was a membership only organization.
00:48:56.552 --> 00:48:57.896
You couldn't be in it if you.
00:48:57.896 --> 00:49:00.210
You couldn't come into a meeting if you weren't a member.
00:49:00.210 --> 00:49:05.677
It wasn't that they were deliberately keeping secrets from each other or from the outside world.
00:49:05.677 --> 00:49:17.655
It was like this is a membership society that helps each other do things, that discusses things that are kind of close to the best for the members, things that you know might be private.
00:49:17.655 --> 00:49:24.815
And so we you can't come into the lodge if you're not a member, because the lodge does things with its money, like to support each other.
00:49:25.170 --> 00:49:39.380
So why would you be able to just walk in, you would take an issue with the, the documents where the church was trying to say we like, we view the Muslims with esteem, and things like that.
00:49:39.380 --> 00:49:45.257
So you're like, adamant that Muslim, I agree, muslims do not worship God.
00:49:45.257 --> 00:49:48.251
But then you'll.
00:49:48.251 --> 00:49:50.440
You're like adamant that muslim, I agree, muslims do not worship god, they don't um.
00:49:50.440 --> 00:49:51.043
But then you'll, you're in.
00:49:51.043 --> 00:49:56.646
You're a freemason where you're specifically in a group that's saying like, because they push human fraternity, like amongst like, you're not allowed.
00:49:56.646 --> 00:49:58.594
So how, how do you have that contradiction?
00:49:58.594 --> 00:50:04.135
That and that like, you want to be part of a christian church that that explicitly says the muslims don't worship god.
00:50:04.936 --> 00:50:07.971
Then you're I don't know, oh no.
00:50:07.971 --> 00:50:13.123
I think that is a major contradiction within Freemasonry that developed later on.
00:50:13.123 --> 00:50:21.023
When, in 1723, the Masonic Constitution comes about and it says that Freemasonry is open to all faiths.
00:50:21.023 --> 00:50:24.012
I think that there's something very important to recognize about that.
00:50:24.012 --> 00:50:26.036
I think that there's something very important to recognize about that.
00:50:26.036 --> 00:50:34.286
All faiths for practical purposes in England in 1723, was Anglicanism and Roman Catholicism.
00:50:34.286 --> 00:50:45.742
That was why they opened up to all faiths was because they were in the midst of a severe series of civil conflicts over the Protestant and Catholic positions.
00:50:45.742 --> 00:50:52.130
So what they were doing is saying, hey, we're not going to let whether or not we're Protestant or Catholic divide us, because we're all Christians.
00:50:53.434 --> 00:51:04.157
Over time, as the diversity of religion grew, there were probably some moments where Freemasonry should have stopped and said no, we're not going to let Hindus in.
00:51:04.157 --> 00:51:08.242
No, we're not going to let Muslims in, no, we're not going to let Norse pagans in.
00:51:08.242 --> 00:51:10.847
And I think I can't.
00:51:10.847 --> 00:51:15.538
There are things I can't defend about the way modern Freemasonry operates in a lot of ways.
00:51:15.538 --> 00:51:21.902
There are a lot of people I know through Masonry who are good people, but I don't think that they belong in Freemasonry.
00:51:21.902 --> 00:51:30.400
I think that they are bringing things into it that they want to see justified, when in reality that's not what Freemasonry was supposed to be about.
00:51:30.400 --> 00:51:46.226
It was supposed to be a group of Christian men working together in concert to both keep each other safe and provide for one another in times of hardship, and to also go out and do charity and to work together to better their communities.
00:51:46.226 --> 00:51:50.016
I think that was the original intention and we've fallen away from that.
00:51:50.016 --> 00:51:52.257
So as far as Freemasonry goes, I'm a reformist.
00:51:55.353 --> 00:51:57.873
You're a Protestant Freemason, I'm a Protestant Freemason.
00:51:57.873 --> 00:51:58.936
Yeah, In a way.
00:51:58.936 --> 00:51:59.117
Yeah.
00:52:01.771 --> 00:52:25.382
And I've gotten to a point recently where I feel like if I get through and this really is where I'm sitting on it If I get through up through Knights Templar, and I'm sitting up there, the tippy top of that chain of Freemasonry, and I look down and I see that there's no hope for it, I'll walk away.
00:52:25.382 --> 00:52:27.478
That's kind of how I felt for years.
00:52:27.489 --> 00:52:30.036
Christian Marion wants to know if you'll debate Freemasonry with him.
00:52:30.860 --> 00:52:31.481
Yeah, I'd be willing to.
00:52:35.490 --> 00:52:36.460
Yeah, I don't know.
00:52:36.460 --> 00:52:37.349
Oh, man, I don't know.
00:52:37.610 --> 00:52:40.119
I think Albert Pike was the worst thing to ever happen to Freemasonry.
00:52:43.574 --> 00:52:44.317
He was a weird one.
00:52:44.570 --> 00:53:00.902
Yeah, he's a weird, weird, incredible scholar, by the way, like as far as ethnography goes, like it as as an ant I this is like an ancient anthropologist term, but as as an anthropologist basically incredibly important figure, very important in
recording.
00:53:00.902 --> 00:53:05.637
I think it was the language of, I want to say it was the seminoles, some of the Muskogee and Creek languages.
00:53:05.637 --> 00:53:17.614
We know a lot of what we know because of Albert Pike but at the same time he got way too into the feeder kid aspect of Freemasonry and forgot that you're supposed to be a Christian and he does say.
00:53:17.614 --> 00:53:20.195
He says I'm a Christian, he says I believe in God.
00:53:20.195 --> 00:53:25.601
He's just a little too into the mysticism, a little too into the mysticism.
00:53:25.621 --> 00:53:28.045
What's your, uh, what's?
00:53:28.045 --> 00:53:34.713
Your position on uh what's your position on the?
00:53:34.733 --> 00:53:35.876
people of the old covenant being involved in free masonry.
00:53:35.876 --> 00:53:38.643
Um I, I haven't had any issues with any of them.
00:53:39.204 --> 00:53:45.958
No well, I mean a lot of people are saying that it's very cabalist, Like so.
00:53:47.521 --> 00:53:51.978
I think that has more to do with Christians, Christian mysticism, than it does Jewish influence.
00:53:51.978 --> 00:54:06.990
Looking back through it, like like Albert Pike, when he talks about Kabbalah he's talking about Christian Kabbalah, which of course is based upon Jewish Kabbalah, but he wasn't doing it as like Judaism is you know, like Christian Christianity is wrong Judaism is, you know, like Christian Christianity is wrong, Judaism is right.
00:54:06.990 --> 00:54:09.918
Kabbalah, all of that, it was kind of the extension of it.
00:54:09.918 --> 00:54:15.740
So I don't think that the, the changes to Freemasonry are the result of Jewish influence so much as Christian mystic.
00:54:18.110 --> 00:54:24.987
And I, I just see, uh, I see the oh man, we can't do this on this side.
00:54:24.987 --> 00:54:28.318
We'll have to do this on the other side, because we'll talk about world events too.
00:54:28.318 --> 00:54:35.940
I think all of us are pretty disgusted with what we're seeing happening in the world right now, so we can probably agree on that.
00:54:37.271 --> 00:54:39.860
All right, guys, have you got a couple last questions before we jump over to locals?
00:54:39.860 --> 00:54:41.974
Yeah, it was.
00:54:41.974 --> 00:54:52.460
The thing is we wanted to have Aiden on just to shoot the crap at him before the debate, just to talk about his podcast and stuff, and then the debate happened.
00:54:52.460 --> 00:55:01.704
I do think that Tim Gordon did really the best out of the three of you on that debate.
00:55:01.704 --> 00:55:03.530
I think you were kind of outmatched.
00:55:03.530 --> 00:55:06.219
You didn't know what you were getting yourself into.
00:55:06.219 --> 00:55:07.362
I think you were kind of outmatched.
00:55:07.362 --> 00:55:07.764
You didn't really.
00:55:07.764 --> 00:55:09.489
You didn't know what you were getting yourself into.
00:55:11.889 --> 00:55:16.762
I think Jay jumped in way too deep and got way too esoteric to even make the the, the conversation like cognizable for the average person watching.
00:55:16.762 --> 00:55:27.900
But Jay does that when he debates and then you know that's just because we've had Jay on twice and I refuse to have a discussion about orthodoxy with him Cause I know it'll just get like that.
00:55:27.900 --> 00:55:36.105
But I think Tim came out looking like he actually understood the arguments the best and had the best replies for everything.
00:55:36.105 --> 00:55:44.809
And I think that Jay purposely chose the hardest things for a Catholic like Tim, who's tradition minded to defend those positions.
00:55:44.809 --> 00:55:49.742
So let's see if we got any quick questions before we go.
00:55:49.742 --> 00:56:00.121
Does Aiden know that the Dictatus Pape was never an official document of the church and has stuff that Catholics don't believe in and have never believed in?
00:56:01.150 --> 00:56:02.936
I'd say it was never an official document.
00:56:02.936 --> 00:56:05.280
I feel like is is a cop out.
00:56:05.280 --> 00:56:05.481
It was.
00:56:05.481 --> 00:56:06.327
It was put together is a cop out.
00:56:06.327 --> 00:56:08.577
It was put together by Gregory VII.
00:56:08.577 --> 00:56:11.398
It was the positions he held.
00:56:11.398 --> 00:56:20.856
While the document itself wasn't published, most of the stuff in it was in other encyclicals and indexes and papal documents.
00:56:20.856 --> 00:56:26.353
So, yes, the Dictatus Papae itself wasn't published as it stands in I think like 27 articles.
00:56:31.920 --> 00:56:33.286
But most of those articles were published elsewhere.
00:56:33.286 --> 00:56:38.516
All right, let's see if you guys got any others before we jump to the other side, because I want to talk.
00:56:38.516 --> 00:56:42.003
I want to talk about the war that we seem to be getting pushed into right now.
00:56:42.530 --> 00:56:44.074
Yeah, I'm draft age.
00:56:44.074 --> 00:56:51.490
Yeah to right now.
00:56:51.490 --> 00:56:51.952
Yeah, um, I'm draft age.
00:56:51.952 --> 00:56:52.956
Yeah, yeah, I'm, uh, I'm getting closer to not being.
00:56:52.976 --> 00:56:54.742
I'm gonna be 28 in a few months, oh, all, right, bobby's got one.
00:56:54.742 --> 00:57:02.451
Uh, what's the point of the hidden teachings and veiled symbolism restricted to masons if it's just supposed to be a christian fraternity like?
00:57:02.451 --> 00:57:06.690
It sounds to me like you were saying like, uh, what freemasonry was supposed to be?
00:57:06.690 --> 00:57:10.240
Just sounds like you guys should all just been catholic, and that's exactly what you had.
00:57:11.592 --> 00:57:19.253
I think to an extent the reason freemasonry became possible, popular, was because it was a way for christians to meet.
00:57:19.253 --> 00:57:28.755
While you weren't supposed to discuss religion as an official business of the lodge inside of the lodge, like building building you could meet as Protestant and Catholic and talk about things.
00:57:28.755 --> 00:57:39.791
Um, so it was a way to kind of keep, keep the faith together, even with that that split going on, which is probably more popular with Protestants than it is with Catholics.
00:57:39.791 --> 00:57:47.376
But when the organization began around 1400, in the uh, the Regius poem, it's an explicitly Catholic document.
00:57:47.376 --> 00:57:49.612
Everybody, everybody, was still Catholic at the time.
00:57:49.612 --> 00:57:55.135
Um, so what they say is that, you know, a Mason must love God and the Holy church with all his heart.
00:57:55.135 --> 00:58:03.150
It's a very explicitly Christian fraternity at the time and a lot of that, the symbolism and everything wasn't supposed to be hidden or secret.
00:58:03.190 --> 00:58:07.679
Uh, it was more a matter of, was more a matter of teaching lessons.
00:58:07.679 --> 00:58:13.101
Without just teaching lessons, everything in masonry is a play.
00:58:13.101 --> 00:58:21.161
All of the degrees and everything are just play acting that is meant to teach a lesson about such and such thing.
00:58:21.161 --> 00:58:31.103
And at least in the York Rite I haven't done the Scottish Rite stuff, I've read some of it, but in the York Rite, there was nothing in it that wasn't purely based in the Bible.
00:58:31.103 --> 00:58:33.117
Most of it's based around the Temple of Solomon.
00:58:33.117 --> 00:58:37.637
Actually and I saw that on the screen my grandfather was a third degree knight of Columbus.
00:58:37.637 --> 00:58:45.541
Realistically, for me, it's like I think it's a little silly to join the Catholic version of the thing that already exists.
00:58:45.541 --> 00:58:48.516
It's like I think it's a little silly to join the catholic version of the thing that already exists.
00:58:48.516 --> 00:58:59.612
I would prefer to see masonry return to its roots and be the be the organization it was meant to be, rather than be something weird, which is what it's become all right, all right, we're gonna go over to the other side.
00:59:00.255 --> 00:59:01.561
Um, yeah, I'm sorry.
00:59:01.561 --> 00:59:03.188
Sorry, we didn't have a fight over here, guys.
00:59:03.188 --> 00:59:07.614
I know you guys were all hoping I'm not gonna invite somebody on my show and have a fight over here.
00:59:07.614 --> 00:59:08.896
Guys, I know you guys were all hoping for that.
00:59:08.896 --> 00:59:10.398
I'm not going to invite somebody on my show and have a fight.
00:59:10.398 --> 00:59:16.565
It's different if you set it as a debate, but we specifically said we weren't having a debate tonight.
00:59:16.565 --> 00:59:17.525
We were just having a moment to talk.
00:59:17.525 --> 00:59:23.039
Yeah we all know what our positions are None of us are theologians.
00:59:32.289 --> 00:59:37.436
Yeah well, especially because you are kind of just delving into apostolic Christianity and you've found the Anglican Catholic communion, that's just where you are right now.
00:59:37.436 --> 00:59:39.356
I don't think you'll stay there.
00:59:39.356 --> 00:59:47.577
I think you're going to have to see the preposterous nature of breaking away from Rome always kind of devolves into sign.
00:59:47.577 --> 00:59:52.170
You'll see it like even within the Anglican community it's like oh well, they went too far, let's go start our own group.
00:59:52.170 --> 00:59:54.056
Oh well, they went too far, let's go start our own group.
00:59:54.056 --> 00:59:57.695
And that can only go on for so long, like it.
00:59:57.795 --> 01:00:18.916
There has to be a final authority in the end there is a conservative movement in the Episcopal church right now and I was talking to somebody about it and I was like, well, why not, instead of trying to reform the Episcopal Church from the inside, why not everybody switch over to the Anglican Church, the Anglican Catholic Church, and just overwhelm them with numbers?
01:00:19.981 --> 01:00:21.610
Well, that's my position on the Catholic.
01:00:21.710 --> 01:00:22.090
Church.
01:00:22.090 --> 01:00:26.159
I guess the Episcopal Church has a really good job of like keeping everything it owns.
01:00:27.300 --> 01:00:34.498
You should check out the Anglican ordinary and if you like the, if you like the, the, the patrimony.
01:00:34.538 --> 01:00:36.295
Yeah, yeah, the Anglican patrimony.
01:00:36.295 --> 01:00:38.217
Check out the Anglican ordinary.
01:00:38.217 --> 01:00:40.958
It's like the best of both worlds.
01:00:40.958 --> 01:00:48.056
You get to be in communion with Rome and keep all of the things you like about the Anglican Catholic communion communion with Rome and keep all of the things you like about the Anglican Catholic communion.
01:00:48.056 --> 01:00:49.577
But all right, we're going to go over to the other side, guys.
01:00:49.577 --> 01:00:50.818
Go to recusencesellerscom.
01:00:50.818 --> 01:00:53.242
Use code BASE at checkout for 10% off.
01:00:53.242 --> 01:00:55.806
They have a fine assortment of wines and fruit over there.
01:00:55.806 --> 01:01:01.612
They're our sponsor.
01:01:01.612 --> 01:01:01.871
We love them.
01:01:01.871 --> 01:01:03.635
You have an obligation to support Catholic businesses that support us.
01:01:03.675 --> 01:01:05.358
I don't care, it's a mortal sin to not buy wine from them.
01:01:05.358 --> 01:01:08.605
To clarify what Anthony just said you should support Catholic businesses.
01:01:08.605 --> 01:01:10.815
You don't have an obligation to support them.
01:01:10.815 --> 01:01:11.818
That support us.
01:01:12.197 --> 01:01:12.719
No, you do.
01:01:12.719 --> 01:01:13.581
Don't listen to Rob.
01:01:13.581 --> 01:01:15.856
He's always trying to undermine our grift.
01:01:15.856 --> 01:01:16.940
Don't listen to him.
01:01:16.940 --> 01:01:19.833
All right, we're going to go over to locals If you guys want to come over there.
01:01:19.833 --> 01:01:21.378
I want to talk about current events.
01:01:32.231 --> 01:01:36.942
So we'll see you guys over on the other side, take us out, rob, okay I'm just going to remove the streams here for
those we don't need.
01:01:36.961 --> 01:01:37.443
Give me just a moment.
01:01:37.443 --> 01:01:39.628
Yeah, I knew we were going to catch crap from everybody on that one.
01:01:39.628 --> 01:01:41.012
They want.
01:01:41.012 --> 01:01:53.914
They wanted us to like go for your jugular, but it's like I don't, I just didn't want to do that I don't know why so many catholics online seem to think that you can convert protestants by being mean to them but that's, that's kind of the point.
01:01:53.914 --> 01:01:57.463
It's like and it's not gonna work, it's not and I don't.
01:01:57.463 --> 01:02:02.289
I don't know if those conversations are even like fruitful for anybody like our audience is all catholic.
01:02:02.309 --> 01:02:03.192
They all agree with us.
01:02:03.192 --> 01:02:07.885
Like you're kind of preaching to the choir, and actually that that is my girlfriend.
01:02:07.925 --> 01:02:10.150
I'm guessing she's just gotten home, which is perfect timing.
01:02:10.150 --> 01:02:11.833
God, do you think that's really quick?
01:02:11.853 --> 01:02:17.472
yeah um, the uh, yeah, he's got to go open the open the door for his girl.
01:02:17.472 --> 01:02:21.199
Um, I had tim gordon texting me the whole time.
01:02:21.199 --> 01:02:23.449
He's like uh, saying the same thing.
01:02:23.449 --> 01:02:25.775
We were that a pope wouldn't declare that ex cathedra.
01:02:25.775 --> 01:02:31.677
Then he said St John Damascus, st Thomas Aquinas Pope, st Gregory VII, all said Islam worships the one God.
01:02:31.677 --> 01:02:33.356
So that's the thing.
01:02:33.356 --> 01:02:41.552
The way those documents are worded are annoying.
01:02:41.552 --> 01:02:47.880
But they but, because they are a bit vague.
01:02:47.880 --> 01:02:55.942
But yes, islam worships one god, but they don't worship the one god and it's like they don't even worship.
01:02:56.784 --> 01:02:57.405
You know what I mean.
01:02:58.126 --> 01:03:08.315
Like they don't offer sacrifice but they're monotheists, right, in a natural sense they don't believe in, they're not like, uh, they're not polytheists.
01:03:08.434 --> 01:03:29.505
So okay, fine, they worship one god, but I don't believe the jews worship the triune god like, like I get the whole philosophy, philosophy aspect of it, where if there is only one god, then anyone who is giving worship to what they believe is one God then has to be giving worship to the one God.
01:03:29.505 --> 01:03:32.880
But how is that possible if everything they do is demonic?
01:03:33.570 --> 01:03:42.860
Demonic and they're giving attributes to God that he doesn't have Right Like they're claiming he has attributes that he just doesn't have.
01:03:42.860 --> 01:03:43.391
It's like.
01:03:43.391 --> 01:03:44.898
It's insane to me.
01:03:44.898 --> 01:03:48.420
So I get what the church was trying to do.
01:03:49.990 --> 01:04:03.485
And it would have been better if they had said something like the Muslims and the Jews attempt to worship the one God or, you know, intend to worship the one God, or something like that.
01:04:03.505 --> 01:04:06.409
Yeah, whatever, I don't want to discuss council documents tend to worship the one God or something like that.
01:04:06.409 --> 01:04:08.434
Yeah, whatever, I don't want to discuss council documents.
01:04:08.434 --> 01:04:11.916
Yeah, when he comes back, I do want to talk about.
01:04:11.916 --> 01:04:21.320
I want to talk about Israel and what the mess that they're getting us into, because I'm just like beside myself.
01:04:21.710 --> 01:04:34.884
It will be interesting to get his opinion Cause, like obviously, you and I have long, well, not long ago, but we've come around to well, I don't know how to describe it.
01:04:34.884 --> 01:04:41.811
What many people would describe as anti-semitism, you know, but what is someone who is more normie in that regard?
01:04:41.811 --> 01:04:42.992
What do they think about what?
01:04:43.012 --> 01:04:44.293
yeah, because I think that.
01:04:44.293 --> 01:04:50.822
I think that israel is the the kingdom of satan on earth at this point.
01:04:50.822 --> 01:04:53.692
So I want to see I want to see what he thinks.
01:04:55.394 --> 01:05:04.114
Tim gordon giving me crap on twitter see I'll be like, I'll be honest, like so I enjoy his channel, right, I enjoy watching his channel.
01:05:04.114 --> 01:05:08.661
I enjoyed the content he makes when it's about the missing people and stuff like that.
01:05:08.661 --> 01:05:10.324
Yeah, it's entertaining.
01:05:10.324 --> 01:05:11.514
That's what I watch it for.
01:05:11.514 --> 01:05:14.936
I would have never said we should have a monitor.
01:05:15.659 --> 01:05:30.322
Well, no, look, the thing is I I didn't want it to be a, uh, an argument the whole time, because I'm hoping the conversation leads to something that sparks his, sparks, his thought process that he's never thought of before.
01:05:30.322 --> 01:05:32.152
You know, it's like so okay, he's back.
01:05:32.152 --> 01:05:36.481
I didn't want it to just be us arguing with him the whole episode.
01:05:36.481 --> 01:05:42.059
You know, yeah, um, I and aiden, I am curious what?
01:05:42.059 --> 01:05:43.641
What is your?
01:05:43.641 --> 01:05:47.155
What is your Like?
01:05:47.155 --> 01:05:57.030
Because I'm seeing a lot of younger guys Starting to come around on the Israel question and starting to see how Israel seems to be the one Provoking us into all of these foreign conflicts.
01:05:57.030 --> 01:06:00.199
Like I do see that you want nothing to do with war with Iran.
01:06:00.199 --> 01:06:05.228
Are you Like, is your position that Israel is getting us into?
01:06:05.228 --> 01:06:06.032
That Is your position?
01:06:06.032 --> 01:06:07.538
You just don't want us in foreign wars?
01:06:07.538 --> 01:06:10.731
Do you think, like, do you support Israel's right to do this?
01:06:10.731 --> 01:06:11.992
Where are you at with that question?
01:06:11.992 --> 01:06:14.637
You're muted.
01:06:16.521 --> 01:06:23.851
For as
long as I can remember, as long as I've really been a conscious adult, as far as politics goes, I was a lot more involved in politics in college.
01:06:23.851 --> 01:06:25.235
I was vice president of college Republicans for a hot minute.
01:06:25.235 --> 01:06:26.760
Um, as far as politics goes, I was a lot more involved in politics in college.
01:06:26.760 --> 01:06:28.606
I was vice president of uh, college Republicans for a hot minute.
01:06:28.606 --> 01:06:33.420
I got impeached for calling a neo-Nazi gay somehow, Um, but I was vice president of college Republicans.
01:06:33.420 --> 01:06:34.831
I was president of young Americans for Liberty.
01:06:34.831 --> 01:06:40.032
So I was very involved back then and I had a very firm stance that foreign wars are bad.
01:06:40.032 --> 01:06:44.099
We should not be sending our military anywhere unless we're actually threatened.
01:06:44.099 --> 01:06:51.972
So I think the Iraq war was a mistake.
01:06:51.972 --> 01:06:52.893
I think Afghanistan was a mistake.
01:06:52.893 --> 01:06:55.599
I can't really think of a war we've been in in my lifetime that wasn't a massive error.
01:06:56.141 --> 01:06:57.304
With this one specifically.
01:06:57.304 --> 01:07:05.862
This is the first time that I've really been able to see a Middle Eastern war developing in real time, because the Syrian war was ending as I was getting into college.
01:07:05.862 --> 01:07:11.501
What I'm seeing now is I understand Israel is scared of Iran having a nuclear weapon.
01:07:11.501 --> 01:07:12.331
I get that.
01:07:12.331 --> 01:07:18.003
If if we were next to Iran and they were chanting death to America, I would be terrified.
01:07:18.003 --> 01:07:22.190
At the same time, that doesn't mean that America needs to be involved.
01:07:22.190 --> 01:07:26.438
If Israel wants to go in and hit Iran, that's a regional conflict.
01:07:26.438 --> 01:07:28.802
The second we get involved, it's a global conflict.
01:07:28.802 --> 01:07:33.710
We don't need that.
01:07:33.710 --> 01:07:35.735
If Israel can keep around from getting a nuclear weapon on their own, why do we need to be involved?
01:07:35.775 --> 01:07:37.358
I think that it's just an escalation.
01:07:37.358 --> 01:07:44.141
It's just going to see the same thing, potentially worse than what happened in Ukraine, where that war should have been over years ago.
01:07:44.141 --> 01:07:49.880
I mean, the UN should have come in and said hey guys, let's have a referendum and end this.
01:07:49.880 --> 01:07:50.864
Do you guys want to be part of Russia or Ukraine?
01:07:50.864 --> 01:07:51.449
Okay, cool, make your decision.
01:07:51.449 --> 01:07:51.670
It's over.
01:07:51.670 --> 01:08:03.302
That should have happened years ago and I think with Iran and Israel right now, I don't know what Israel's motivation is here beyond taking out their nuclear capabilities.
01:08:03.302 --> 01:08:11.257
I understand wanting to get rid of the Ayatollah and and get rid of Islamic rule of Iran, especially because Persia is such an ancient and beautiful country.
01:08:11.257 --> 01:08:20.442
I mean the history of Persia is so rich and from a Christian perspective, I mean Cyrus was the one who sent Daniel and the Israelites back to Israel to rebuild the temple.
01:08:20.442 --> 01:08:23.538
Like Persia should be our friend.
01:08:23.538 --> 01:08:31.313
You know, even if they're not christian, they they were a friend to the, the abrahamic faith and prior to the mongols, they were christian.
01:08:31.675 --> 01:08:36.393
They were at the heart of a lot of christians there of a huge christian civilization so we're.
01:08:36.393 --> 01:08:42.789
We have no reason to be fighting with them, aside from islam and israel's handling that on their own.
01:08:42.789 --> 01:08:43.831
Why do we need to be involved?
01:08:45.212 --> 01:08:47.095
Well, the thing is they, they make it.
01:08:47.095 --> 01:08:56.363
They make it as if this is a war against Islam, but in reality, it's the Christians who suffer there, right?
01:08:56.363 --> 01:09:04.381
So before we went into Iraq, there was a very big Christian population in Iraq that got completely decimated.
01:09:04.381 --> 01:09:05.649
After we went over there, the same thing happened in Syria.
01:09:05.649 --> 01:09:13.823
They told us all these things about Bashar al-Assad, and as soon as Assad got out, the new guy that came in literally went around murdering all the Christians.
01:09:13.823 --> 01:09:17.460
Assad said the only ones you could actually trust were the Christians.
01:09:18.150 --> 01:09:23.823
It's kind of crazy how, every time we kicked out the secular ruler of an Arab country or a Middle Eastern country, they started murdering.
01:09:23.842 --> 01:09:24.163
Christians.
01:09:24.163 --> 01:09:28.034
It's Christians that wind up getting killed.
01:09:28.034 --> 01:09:40.975
From a theological standpoint, there is enmity between Jews and Christians right so like you guys were arguing and I did this on locals because I don't want anybody putting it out there on you, Like nobody's trying to get you I know.
01:09:42.570 --> 01:09:47.470
I'm already taking flack because Sam Cedar took 30 seconds of stuff I said and misrepresented it to his audience.
01:09:47.590 --> 01:09:58.516
So yeah, no, well, from a theological standpoint, like because my thinking on this whole topic has really changed over the last few years, I mean, if you were to talk to me five, 10 years ago, I'd have been.
01:09:58.516 --> 01:10:01.484
I mean, I, I supported the war in Iraq.
01:10:01.484 --> 01:10:04.659
I freaking Israel's the only democracy in the Middle East.
01:10:04.659 --> 01:10:22.158
But theologically understanding this issue, it's really come down to seeing it like through scripture and seeing how every single story in scripture is about the birthright supposed to go to the older brother and then it winds up going to the younger brother.
01:10:22.158 --> 01:10:48.833
So it's like, and it's just this same
pattern happens throughout scripture, over and over, even when jesus is telling the the parable of um, not even the power, yeah, the parable of the of the um prodigal, the prodigal son, right, so the prodigal son is the younger brother, goes off and spends all his stuff, his birthright comes back and the father throws a party from.
01:10:48.833 --> 01:10:50.659
The older brother is the one that's upset with them.
01:10:50.659 --> 01:10:52.494
You have cain kills abel.
01:10:52.494 --> 01:10:58.128
Yeah, it's about jacob and esau every single one of these.
01:10:58.189 --> 01:11:11.309
It's about the father giving it to the youngest brother, or the younger brother, the one who wasn't supposed to get the birthright, and that actually happens with the gent brother, or the younger brother, the one who wasn't supposed to get the birthright, and that actually happens with the Gentiles.
01:11:11.309 --> 01:11:15.590
Get the new covenant right Now.
01:11:15.590 --> 01:11:23.779
That story plays out in real time and after the Ascension, and the Gentiles now claim the God of Abraham, isaac and Jacob has blessed us with the covenant and there's this enmity between Jews and Christians for 2000 years.
01:11:25.582 --> 01:11:33.457
And yeah, I mean I said on Tim cast IRL the default position of the church in the middle ages was antisemitism Like it was, and it went the other way around as well.
01:11:34.471 --> 01:11:44.590
It had to be, though like the idea of and I'm not going to get into like the, the conspiracy stuff of they control this, they control that.
01:11:44.590 --> 01:11:45.490
It's not even about that.
01:11:45.490 --> 01:11:57.720
It's like, since they have gotten a foothold in Israel, what they have done is infiltrate countries and like managed to set this thing up in Israel.
01:11:57.720 --> 01:12:10.081
That's dragged every single nation into war in their land, and it seems to me like what they're trying to do is set up a davidic kingdom, like a kingdom bigger than the davidic kingdom, which is kind of like what herod did.
01:12:10.081 --> 01:12:16.391
Herod went and he actually expanded the herodian empire bigger than david did, and it's just what it seems like to.
01:12:16.391 --> 01:12:18.398
I'm talking on a theological level here.
01:12:18.398 --> 01:12:20.712
I'm not even trying to get into conspiracy.
01:12:20.752 --> 01:12:21.895
Well, I believe that they.
01:12:21.895 --> 01:12:32.479
I believe the jew, jewish position is that the Messiah will be a human king, not God and man as one.
01:12:32.479 --> 01:12:35.358
Yeah, so that might have something.
01:12:35.358 --> 01:12:39.135
They don't have a Davidic king, they don't have somebody to fill that role.
01:12:39.135 --> 01:12:43.652
So I don't understand what's going on over there, what the thought process is.
01:12:43.652 --> 01:12:51.501
I wonder if it's just about like restoring the old, what they believe should be the true Israel.
01:12:52.421 --> 01:12:55.466
I'm just watching everything Trump's doing and I'm like I voted for this guy.
01:12:55.466 --> 01:13:12.398
I was so excited I remember being so freaking excited that like, oh, he's got Tulsi Gabbard in there and he's got he's got RFK Jr in there and we're're gonna get all these changes and every single freaking thing he has done has been dick cheney.
01:13:12.398 --> 01:13:12.779
It's like.
01:13:12.779 --> 01:13:14.865
It's like you, literally, no matter who you vote for, you get dick cheney and it's just none of his.
01:13:14.865 --> 01:13:17.292
None of the things he said he was gonna do has he done.
01:13:17.292 --> 01:13:17.953
They have any?
01:13:17.953 --> 01:13:20.036
I'm still whatever.
01:13:20.036 --> 01:13:23.820
It's just to watch him then talk.
01:13:23.820 --> 01:13:27.326
He ran on ending the war between Ukraine and Russia.
01:13:27.326 --> 01:13:32.171
He ran on ending the hostility between Israel and Iran and he gets in.
01:13:32.171 --> 01:13:41.341
Ukraine and Russia are blowing up even worse and now we're starting a war with Ukraine and I don't see how this doesn't end catastrophically, with the entire world at war soon.
01:13:43.354 --> 01:13:43.815
I don't know.
01:13:43.815 --> 01:13:44.920
I don't know what the goal is.
01:13:44.920 --> 01:13:46.591
I mean it's.
01:13:46.591 --> 01:13:50.198
I genuinely don't understand.
01:13:50.198 --> 01:13:52.413
I don't, I cannot.
01:13:52.413 --> 01:13:55.157
I'll give this to you guys.
01:13:55.157 --> 01:14:00.100
Sorry about dispensationalism, our bad.
01:14:01.951 --> 01:14:30.003
Probably should have nipped that one in the bud, but I don't know if the average like american who is like into politics, understands how much of our foreign policy is based on retarded protestant theology like evangelical dispensationalist theology like that that we are being dragged into this crap because like uh, what's his name's uh text to to trump um like, bring that up bring that freaking.
01:14:30.024 --> 01:14:31.190
Bring that off.
01:14:31.190 --> 01:14:33.796
It is complete insanity.
01:14:33.796 --> 01:14:38.649
If you guys have not seen this, it's um, I'll look for it.
01:14:38.649 --> 01:14:39.310
Just keep talking.
01:14:39.310 --> 01:14:41.033
Um, no, I have it.
01:14:41.033 --> 01:14:41.474
Hang on.
01:14:41.474 --> 01:14:43.438
Uh, here it is, I got it.
01:14:43.438 --> 01:14:51.613
Um, this is mike huckabee trump's uh, uh, m, m, m emissary to israel, or whatever the hell he is.
01:14:51.694 --> 01:14:59.037
Mr president, god spared you in butler pa, to be the most consequential president in a century, maybe ever.
01:14:59.037 --> 01:15:05.738
The decisions on your shoulders I would not want to be made by anyone else.
01:15:05.738 --> 01:15:11.289
You have made many voices speaking to you, sir, but there is only one voice that matters, his voice.
01:15:11.289 --> 01:15:19.324
I am your appointed servant in this land and I'm available for you, but I do not try to get in your presence often because I
trust your instincts.
01:15:19.324 --> 01:15:24.069
No president in my lifetime has been in a position like yours, not since Truman in 1945.
01:15:24.069 --> 01:15:26.671
No president in my lifetime has been in a position like yours, not since Truman in 1945.
01:15:26.671 --> 01:15:27.153
I reach out to persuade.
01:15:27.153 --> 01:15:29.694
I don't reach out to persuade you, only to encourage you.
01:15:29.694 --> 01:15:35.038
I believe you will hear from heaven, and that voice is far more important than mine or anyone else's.
01:15:35.460 --> 01:15:40.484
You sent me to Israel to be your eyes, ears and voice and to make sure our flag flies above our embassy.
01:15:40.484 --> 01:15:42.786
My job is to be the last one to leave.
01:15:42.786 --> 01:15:44.167
I will not abandon this post.
01:15:44.167 --> 01:15:49.992
Our flag will not come down.
01:15:49.992 --> 01:15:50.634
You did not seek this moment.
01:15:50.634 --> 01:15:51.076
The moment sought you.
01:15:51.076 --> 01:15:52.059
It is my honor to serve you, mike Huckabee.
01:15:52.059 --> 01:16:05.761
Mike Huckabee, who wants the third temple in Jerusalem built, because these people think that if the third temple is built, the Antichrist will come and they will be raptured into heaven before the great uh, uh.
01:16:05.761 --> 01:16:06.121
What is it?
01:16:06.121 --> 01:16:07.923
The freaking tribulation?
01:16:07.923 --> 01:16:09.351
The great tribulation?
01:16:09.372 --> 01:16:10.774
yeah it's very funny.
01:16:10.774 --> 01:16:20.338
When I was, I took an entire 400 level college course on uh, on the book of revelation, and it was taught by an orthodox christian.
01:16:20.338 --> 01:16:22.842
He was not a priest, but he was an orthodox scholar.
01:16:22.842 --> 01:16:33.152
I pretty universally agreed throughout the class upon doing a reading of it and going through everything that pre-tribulation rapture is not in there.
01:16:33.152 --> 01:16:36.599
No, yeah, uh, you can't get it from the text.
01:16:36.599 --> 01:16:39.104
You have to read things into it.
01:16:39.104 --> 01:16:40.833
It's not a real concept.
01:16:40.833 --> 01:17:01.242
It wasn't something in something in Christianity until like 1870, something I genuinely don't understand why, why this is so pervasive in the United States, but it's definitely the problem and that's what I said on Tim cast too is I was like this this whole thing comes from a very specific form of uniquely American Protestantism.
01:17:01.242 --> 01:17:05.479
Um, and unfortunately I don't know if there's a way to put the genie back in the bottle.
01:17:06.721 --> 01:17:07.182
I don't either.
01:17:07.182 --> 01:17:35.273
I think like if you go back and you read the early church fathers, they talk about how, when the Antichrist does come, there will be throngs of heretics awaiting his arrival, thinking they are following Christ Like there's going to, and I don't know, man, the stuff with trump kind of scares me also, that you know he's sitting there
reading that text from mike being, like this guy's, gay.
01:17:39.377 --> 01:17:49.527
It's such a weird that that it makes me think of like it's almost like a Lord of the Rings, like Wormtongue talking to Saruman level of psychopathy.
01:17:49.527 --> 01:17:55.382
It feels uncomfortable to hear that and to hear a president described that way.
01:17:56.369 --> 01:18:02.619
Watching like every single politician come out when they it's like it's.
01:18:02.619 --> 01:18:07.671
It's this crazy evangelical support for israel that gives them like a bloodlust.
01:18:07.671 --> 01:18:11.600
Like they, they want to see the war escalate so bad.
01:18:11.600 --> 01:18:13.911
Bill mitchell, why do I support israel?
01:18:13.911 --> 01:18:15.775
It's simple genesis 12 3.
01:18:15.775 --> 01:18:17.118
I will bless those who bless you.
01:18:17.179 --> 01:18:23.561
Like these people are nuts, as if and they really think that they're talking about the modern geopolitical state of israel too.
01:18:23.561 --> 01:18:24.069
Yeah, it's, he's talking.
01:18:24.069 --> 01:18:25.252
That's about the modern geopolitical state of Israel too.
01:18:25.252 --> 01:18:26.033
Yeah, that's about the church.
01:18:27.154 --> 01:18:37.905
Yes, and it doesn't matter how many times you tell them that and this is a position I held when I was a Methodist Like this is something I've held for years that Israel in the New Testament is very obviously the church.
01:18:37.905 --> 01:18:47.189
It wasn't even Israel as a nation at the time, it was Judea, it was Judah before that a nation.
01:18:47.189 --> 01:18:48.332
At the time, it was judea, it was judah before that.
01:18:48.332 --> 01:18:51.476
I mean, israel was not a thing after like 720 something, dc.
01:18:51.557 --> 01:18:53.260
What was israel like?
01:18:53.260 --> 01:18:55.904
What were the jews doing in that initial diaspora?
01:18:55.904 --> 01:18:56.390
Like where?
01:18:56.390 --> 01:19:15.538
Because it's it's interesting that, like you don't really hear about them popping up into, like the like around the reformation, like that whole period between when they get thrown out of jerusalem to the reformation you like do you mean after the barkovka revolt in the 120s, or that?
01:19:15.698 --> 01:19:15.878
what?
01:19:15.878 --> 01:19:16.180
What do I?
01:19:16.220 --> 01:19:20.891
think so, yeah, after after 133 ad, okay, yeah, so yeah, I mean the roman.
01:19:20.891 --> 01:19:22.694
That's the funny thing too, is it's all I?
01:19:22.694 --> 01:19:29.413
I don't say this in next company, because I know how it'll sound, but from a from a theological standpoint.
01:19:29.413 --> 01:19:45.792
Like you look at it, jesus comes, he does his work, he dies, he's crucified, he dies, he rises from the dead and then, about 35 years later, rome smacks the shit out of the Jews yeah.
01:19:46.655 --> 01:19:51.993
And then another seven years later, they do it again.
01:19:51.993 --> 01:19:53.650
And how do you like?
01:19:53.650 --> 01:19:59.734
How, as an Israelite, as a Jew living in the first century and the second century, how do you not sit there and go?
01:19:59.734 --> 01:20:06.220
Hmm well, the Christians are everywhere and we're just getting our ass handed to us by Rome repeatedly.
01:20:06.220 --> 01:20:08.457
It doesn't seem like God's on our side.
01:20:08.457 --> 01:20:11.037
Maybe we were wrong to deny the Messiah.
01:20:11.149 --> 01:20:13.578
Maybe that was the time to come around.
01:20:14.371 --> 01:20:15.336
So I don't get that.
01:20:15.336 --> 01:20:25.891
But yeah, to answer your question about what was going on, the Romans did not really persecute the Jews beyond kicking them out of Israel, because the Jews would offer.
01:20:25.891 --> 01:20:34.661
Uh, this is a really interesting little bit of minutiae about how Christianity and Judaism were perceived differently in the early, the early period of the church.
01:20:34.661 --> 01:20:50.039
Rome did not have a problem with Judaism, even though Jews would not sacrifice to the emperor and to the roman gods, because they were sacrificing to their god on behalf of the roman emperor and the roman empire.
01:20:50.039 --> 01:20:55.801
So they took that and they said all right, well, if you won't sacrifice to our emperor, we'll tolerate this version of doing things.
01:20:55.801 --> 01:21:00.257
The christians, on the other hand, don't, don't sacrifice we.
01:21:00.257 --> 01:21:02.802
We eat our god on sundays, uh.
01:21:02.802 --> 01:21:08.261
So they, they saw that a little bit differently and they didn't get it because to the Romans, religion involved sacrifice.
01:21:08.261 --> 01:21:10.596
The gods demanded sacrifice.
01:21:10.596 --> 01:21:18.224
So Christians were being persecuted, while Jews, as long as they were doing their sacrifice on behalf of the emperor, they were tolerated, they were allowed to do whatever.
01:21:19.010 --> 01:21:27.109
And then, once the Roman Empire converted to Christianity which wasn't an immediate thing, that didn't just happen in 325, didn't happen in 382.
01:21:27.109 --> 01:21:31.130
It happened, I think, 395 or 385, 395.
01:21:31.130 --> 01:21:42.905
So once that happens and the empire slowly becomes completely Christian, the Jews started to fill roles that Christians didn't want or could not perform.
01:21:42.905 --> 01:21:44.134
So banking, for example.
01:21:44.134 --> 01:21:46.731
We couldn't do interest on loans.
01:21:46.731 --> 01:21:48.676
I wish that we still behaved that way.
01:21:48.676 --> 01:21:51.131
But Christians couldn't charge interest on loans, jews could.
01:21:51.131 --> 01:21:52.274
So Jews became the bankers.
01:21:53.315 --> 01:22:03.154
A lot of Christians outside of the church did not want to practice medicine, but, and part of it was that you weren't allowed to perform autopsies, you weren't allowed to mortify the flesh after death.
01:22:03.154 --> 01:22:04.698
The Jews didn't have that.
01:22:04.698 --> 01:22:05.840
So they could become
surgeons.
01:22:05.840 --> 01:22:08.551
They could practice things that Christians couldn't practice.
01:22:08.551 --> 01:22:11.359
They also got very involved in law.
01:22:11.359 --> 01:22:22.822
So a lot of these things that are stereotypically Jewish today derive from Christians in the middle ages not wanting to or not being able to do these jobs, and the Jews performed them throughout the medieval period.
01:22:23.329 --> 01:22:31.398
But then every there are some times when, like we have documentation that proves that, yes, the Jews were doing coin clipping, uh like on mass.
01:22:31.398 --> 01:22:35.701
And then there are other times when the Jews just got blamed for things because somebody needed a scapegoat.
01:22:35.701 --> 01:22:47.938
Uh, you know, the whole 109 countries thing is nonsense, but there were a lot of times where Jews were kicked out of someplace, uh, where Jews were accused of things, um, and times when Jews accused Christians of things.
01:22:47.938 --> 01:22:55.672
It was a lot of conflict and it's why you see them kind of getting moved around so much and you see them intermixing with with European populations.
01:22:55.672 --> 01:23:03.695
Yet what Ashkenazi Jews are today, um, and then eventually, obviously, zionism starts to become a thing in the 1800s.
01:23:03.695 --> 01:23:04.617
Yeah, for a long time there.
01:23:04.636 --> 01:23:07.902
They were just doing whatever jobs we didn't want to do.
01:23:08.802 --> 01:23:09.384
Zionism.
01:23:09.384 --> 01:23:10.765
I can understand if you're Jewish.
01:23:10.765 --> 01:23:15.113
I just don't understand that if you're not Jewish.
01:23:15.113 --> 01:23:41.659
What worries me is that, because the Jews do have this 2,000 years of what they perceive as, because they see it as enmity between christians and them, and they finally do have their land back, like there's no scenario like we talked about russia being backed into a corner, like if, if you know, if they're backed into a corner and the world puts them in a tough like, they'll release nukes, like israel will literally do that.
01:23:41.659 --> 01:23:48.842
If they think that they're going to lose this land that they finally acquired, they will scorch the entire earth.
01:23:48.842 --> 01:23:54.957
So I don't know how we get this conflict to back down, unless it's just really just a quick, easy thing.
01:23:54.957 --> 01:23:58.934
Iran is incapacitated and this just is a quick war.
01:23:58.934 --> 01:24:07.858
But if this thing escalates and Iran really does try to do something, crazy it's I just don't see how this, this whole progression, ends.
01:24:08.359 --> 01:24:13.895
I think the the only real solution to the Iran situation is Christian mission work.
01:24:13.895 --> 01:24:15.860
The problem is that it's really dangerous to do that.
01:24:15.860 --> 01:24:27.786
I think the Iranians are probably one of the most almost genetically predisposed people to Christianity on the planet.
01:24:27.786 --> 01:25:01.019
You see, you see the inner, the inter, the interplay for thousands of years in Persia, with them being one of the most multicultural accepting of outside influence places on the planet and Zoroastrianism what they had before Islam and Christianity definitely had there at some point along the way, indo-european religion and Judaism mixed together to form something interesting, which is Zoroastrianism, which holds, is very similar to Christianity in a lot of ways.
01:25:01.019 --> 01:25:06.198
I very similar to the the way that we perceive the heavenly realm.
01:25:07.712 --> 01:25:11.333
I think the answer to Iran is convert them back to Christianity.
01:25:11.333 --> 01:25:12.958
Just how do you do it?
01:25:12.958 --> 01:25:14.442
Yeah, it's rough.
01:25:14.442 --> 01:25:18.252
You said I get it if you're Jewish Zionism.
01:25:18.252 --> 01:25:21.550
I think you've got to look back to the 1800s and put yourself in that mindset.
01:25:21.550 --> 01:25:31.295
I think a lot of people were sitting around going well, if they have their own country, they won't be here yeah, yeah, I understand why people were anti-semitic at the time.
01:25:31.354 --> 01:25:48.175
It was just a thing like they probably looked at like well, if we give them their own spot, they'll leave yeah, I think that was like hitler wanted to do that get rid of them entirely hitler wanted to just banish them from from germany, and that plan didn't work out and he had to go plan b.
01:25:48.175 --> 01:25:58.202
Oh my gosh I wouldn't say he had to go to plan b, I would say that was, that was probably a decision he could have not made um, what was your?
01:25:58.362 --> 01:26:06.417
uh, all right, because we're gonna wrap it up in a few minutes, but, um, if somebody was gonna go and watch a show, uh, your podcast, which episode would you would you recommend to them?
01:26:06.417 --> 01:26:08.140
Well, obviously, the freemasonry one.
01:26:08.381 --> 01:26:13.947
Um, uh, no, I would say, uh, torteria was a fun one, we just put one out on that.
01:26:13.947 --> 01:26:16.172
Just the whole history is a lie conspiracy.
01:26:17.215 --> 01:26:28.154
Um, if not that, then I think the john benet ramsey series is my best work that's a that's probably an interesting one to check out, yeah, especially for the younger guys, cause you guys don't most.
01:26:28.154 --> 01:26:30.877
You probably didn't even know that story until you researched it.
01:26:30.898 --> 01:26:40.456
Right, yeah, and I've been going into like extreme depth with with everything we are five episodes in and they average, I'd say, about 45 minutes each.
01:26:46.229 --> 01:26:47.472
We have covered about 14 days of the investigation.
01:26:47.472 --> 01:26:48.574
They never, they never, found out who did it right.
01:26:48.574 --> 01:26:49.095
Nobody was ever.
01:26:49.095 --> 01:26:50.158
Nobody was ever convicted.
01:26:50.158 --> 01:26:52.302
But was it the father, the brother?
01:26:52.302 --> 01:26:52.671
Who was it?
01:26:52.671 --> 01:26:53.171
Who do you think?
01:26:53.872 --> 01:27:06.573
I'm working your way up to that my hypothesis right now and this this is subject to change as I go deeper and deeper into it but my hypothesis right now is that, uh, burke hit her in the head with something flashlight hammer, I don't know.
01:27:06.573 --> 01:27:08.396
Burke is her older brother, he was 10.
01:27:08.396 --> 01:27:19.195
And then John who was the father, I think found her, realized that he either had to take her to the hospital or put her out of her misery.
01:27:19.195 --> 01:27:21.411
And if he took her to the hospital, there were going to be a lot of questions.
01:27:21.411 --> 01:27:24.698
So I think that he staged the whole kidnapping thing.
01:27:24.698 --> 01:27:26.222
I think Patsy, the mother, wrote the note.
01:27:26.222 --> 01:27:29.219
So I think that all three of them were involved in some way.
01:27:29.739 --> 01:27:38.310
I I don't think that how it went that night was necessarily evil on the part of the parents.
01:27:38.310 --> 01:27:42.112
I think they were in shock and panicking and and not in their right minds.
01:27:42.112 --> 01:27:55.391
What I think is evil is everything that happened afterwards, the number of people they blamed, the lives they destroyed, rather than just coming out and being like I did this, I'm sorry.
01:27:55.391 --> 01:28:16.497
So, yeah, that was evil of them, but there's little things like John Ramsey, 30 minutes after his daughter's body is discovered in his basement, calling his private pilot to arrange a flight to Atlanta and then saying, when the police asked him like why are you trying to go to Atlanta, he was like I have a business meeting.
01:28:16.497 --> 01:28:17.239
No, he didn't.
01:28:17.239 --> 01:28:18.181
He didn't have a business meeting.
01:28:18.203 --> 01:28:19.846
He definitely didn't have a business meeting.
01:28:20.949 --> 01:28:22.555
I think he was trying to get his family out of Colorado.
01:28:23.095 --> 01:28:25.382
Once he realized the FBI was getting involved yeah, he was trying to get his family out of Colorado.
01:28:25.382 --> 01:28:27.609
Once he realized the FBI was getting involved yeah, that's a really shady scenario.
01:28:28.493 --> 01:28:30.703
Anthony is shocked they're not in his right mind.
01:28:30.703 --> 01:28:35.019
Well, that's just usually correct.
01:28:35.078 --> 01:28:39.577
Yeah, did you ever read Tom Holland's book?
01:28:39.577 --> 01:28:40.880
What the hell is it called Dominion?
01:28:43.069 --> 01:28:43.109
No.
01:28:43.130 --> 01:28:43.452
I've heard of it.
01:28:43.471 --> 01:28:44.496
Not the Spider-Man actor.
01:28:44.777 --> 01:28:45.137
No, I know.
01:28:46.131 --> 01:28:53.039
Tom Holland's book Dominion, because if you're a history major, especially Rob and I did a two-part series based on his book.
01:28:53.039 --> 01:29:02.340
That was really good, just going into the pagan world and as Christianity starts coming in and how the Catholic
Church developed.
01:29:04.131 --> 01:29:07.902
I think I have one of his books on my shelf and how the Catholic Church developed.
01:29:07.921 --> 01:29:10.289
I think I have one of his books on my shelf.
01:29:10.289 --> 01:29:11.773
Well, he's got a couple of good ones.
01:29:11.773 --> 01:29:13.198
His book on Islam is really good too.
01:29:13.198 --> 01:29:15.936
Something Under the Sword or something.
01:29:17.131 --> 01:29:21.402
Yeah, I think I have one of his books on the Viking era.
01:29:21.402 --> 01:29:23.369
Yeah, he's a good historian.
01:29:23.369 --> 01:29:24.104
I will say that was one thing I definitely had going for me.
01:29:24.104 --> 01:29:24.408
The Viking era.
01:29:24.408 --> 01:29:24.664
Yeah, he's a good historian.
01:29:24.664 --> 01:29:28.452
Oh yeah, I will say that was one thing I definitely had going for me.
01:29:28.452 --> 01:29:30.458
I had incredible professors at Penn State.
01:29:30.458 --> 01:29:33.875
Utterly incredible history program there.
01:29:33.875 --> 01:29:35.661
It's a hard school to get into.
01:29:35.661 --> 01:29:38.471
It's a hard school to get into the main campus.
01:29:38.471 --> 01:29:40.458
It's a very easy school to get into overall.
01:29:40.458 --> 01:29:52.000
Yeah, I did get into the main campus when all four years, but there is no better value for an education, especially if you're in Pennsylvania and it's in state tuition.
01:29:52.000 --> 01:29:55.377
Oh yeah, if you're in PA.
01:29:55.670 --> 01:29:56.432
Where in PA are you?
01:29:56.432 --> 01:29:57.798
What area Outside of Philly?
01:29:57.798 --> 01:30:01.317
Alright Aiden, it was fun meeting you, man.
01:30:01.317 --> 01:30:06.720
I hope the Catholics are dying down with teasing you for everything.
01:30:07.890 --> 01:30:10.198
They'll find somebody new to make fun of in a few days.
01:30:10.198 --> 01:30:10.739
It'll be fine.
01:30:11.930 --> 01:30:13.216
Yeah, things like this do blow over.
01:30:13.216 --> 01:30:15.438
Thanks for coming on with us, man.
01:30:15.850 --> 01:30:17.934
Yeah, thanks for having me, yeah, and what is it?
01:30:17.934 --> 01:30:19.739
Lore Lodge, yeah, the Lore Lodge.
01:30:19.739 --> 01:30:21.577
Yeah, go check out the Lore Lodge guys.
01:30:21.577 --> 01:30:32.179
Outside of my theology, I think you guys might appreciate what I do rob does.
01:30:32.179 --> 01:30:34.912
Rob watches your show regularly, so it's entertaining, yeah, and I think that you're on a theological journey right now, so I'm not.
01:30:34.912 --> 01:30:39.270
That's why it's like I didn't want to have you come on and start fighting with you about stuff I've you had to talk about the debate.
01:30:39.270 --> 01:30:43.560
It was like, yeah, of course, kind of had to, but, um, yeah, I don't know, we'll probably we'll.
01:30:43.560 --> 01:30:44.603
We'll, we'll talk in the future.
01:30:44.603 --> 01:30:45.592
We'll figure some other stuff out.
01:30:45.592 --> 01:30:46.475
It was nice meeting you, man.
01:30:46.475 --> 01:30:47.279
Nice to meet you too.
01:30:47.279 --> 01:30:48.390
All right, take us out, rob.
01:30:48.390 --> 01:31:15.436
Thank you.