文字稿 🔗
00:00:03
Speaker 1: This is Outsiders.
00:00:07
Speaker 2: Good morning and welcome to Outsiders, the show that is to exposing the insidious powers buried within Labor's Orwellian Digital Duty of Care Bill, what Communications Minister Annika Wells is to hiding the insidious powers buried within Labor's Orwellian Digital Duty of Care Bill.
00:00:29
Speaker 3: Critics like Michael Schellenberger, you'd be aware, and others say that it would give a government the power to control the flow of information, the power, for example, to effectively spread propaganda. I know you say that's not the intent, but I'm wondering if you could address those concerns explicitly of why this could not be used in that way.
00:00:47
Speaker 4: There is nowhere in the bill that gives the government, and by the government in this instance, the independent regulator, that power.
00:00:56
Speaker 2: It's just not there. Does it prevent that from happening?
00:00:59
Speaker 4: There is nothing in what you've just said out there as a worst case scenario that is.
00:01:03
Speaker 5: In the bill.
00:01:05
Speaker 6: Really, Annika? Are you quite sure about that? I have to wonder, do you even know what is in this bill?
00:01:14
Speaker 3: That sock puppet power says that there aren't limitations around how that can be used in the bill.
00:01:21
Speaker 4: Yeah, looking at the eSafety Commissioner, the look that she's giving you. I do not accept the premise of this argument. I don't think the eSafety Commissioner or I accept that that is something that could happen. Yes, these people claim to know what is deep within my heart better than myself or the government or the eSafety Commission or the Office of Parliamentary Council.
00:01:42
Speaker 2: That's their right.
00:01:43
Speaker 4: And they will still have the right to make those points online after a digital duty of care is legislated.
00:01:51
Speaker 7: And why does she have to keep looking at the e-safety commissioner for reassurance? Thank goodness for our News24 colleague Cameron Redden for asking the questions no other journo dared ask.
00:02:04
Speaker 3: Would you just say in the bill they can't be used for those purposes, government propaganda and so forth?
00:02:09
Speaker 2: It can't. In a worst-case scenario. It can't.
00:02:11
Speaker 3: The worst person you imagine gets the power of the e-safety commissioner one day, for example.
00:02:17
Speaker 7: It cannot.
00:02:19
Speaker 8: I don't know how to be more emphatic.
00:02:20
Speaker 2: It It doesn't exist. It is not possible.
00:02:23
Speaker 1: All right.
00:02:24
Speaker 2: You're welcome. It does not exist. It is not possible. It's a live parrot. It's just sleeping. It's probably pining for their fjords. And while we wait for Annika Wells to admit that her bill stinks to high heaven, let's grab the latest Outsiders news. Later on in the show, we're going to have Margaret Chambers talking to us about this very bill. It is an absolute disgrace, Caroline and
Load full transcript
James. The way that Annika Wells seems to think it's all about her. This is the Labor thing. Oh, you don't know what's in my heart. Oh, the e-safety commissioner, I keep looking at you and wondering why you think... It's not about you, Annika Wells. It's not about you. It's about us and our ability to be able to say and go online and do the things that we want to do without the government interfering. That's what this is all about, Caroline.
00:03:21
Speaker 7: Look, as the parent of young children, I am concerned about them growing up and their safety online and, you know, being exposed to things that, They shouldn't be, like, child sexual abuse material. That is deeply concerning. But I also have concerns about this bill because, frankly, it is... deep overreach for a government to say we should control what we consider to be harm. That is very dangerous territory because I may not know what is in Annika Wells' heart, but trust me, I don't trust her for a moment. This is someone who tried to say that going to birthday parties was a business meeting. How are we supposed to trust anything she says about limiting our freedom of speech.
00:04:07
Speaker 2: But with all due respect, they keep saying it's all about child safety and that, but, Caroline, you're falling book, line and sinker. But I'm not. I have concerns still. Of course everyone cares about those, and those laws already exist. But the problem here is that they are giving themselves the power to have these so-called sock puppets, which is just propaganda. This is what it's all about.
00:04:26
Speaker 6: We need to separate a few things here. And, you know, that speech, which Annika Wells gave at the Press Club, was one of the most dangerous and disingenuous things I have seen in all of my years of watching Australian politics there. This creation of a false notion of consensus, you know, oh, all decent people agree that we need this. And, you know, this is this thing the left always does, digital duty of care. Who could be against caring? Well, I mean, you know, Caroline, to your point, and I get what you're saying, but we have laws about that sort of material. We have an Australian federal police that does very hard and very good work every day of the week, busting people involved with that sort of evil stuff. No one is questioning that. This, however, what we're talking about here, is an attempt to regulate what we see.
00:05:15
Speaker 5: This goes back to COVID.
00:05:16
Speaker 6: This goes back to the government as your single source of truth. This is a thing that they want to be able to do. You know, we've already seen how the e-safety commissioner has tried to dial down things that she doesn't like because it goes against the government's narrative about, you know, multiculturalism or whatever.
00:05:35
Speaker 5: The thing is of the day.
00:05:36
Speaker 6: But you cannot give them this power. This bill, the revision, they say, oh, well, the minister will no longer have the power. That now arrogates to an unelected e-safety commissioner and this whole idea that they could use what are called sock puppets.
00:05:50
Speaker 5: Let's just call them what they are, bots.
00:05:53
Speaker 6: To go out there and try and push their government official line on things.
00:05:57
Speaker 2: We'll ask Margaret about this, explain how this works.
00:06:00
Speaker 6: So, basically, you know, they're talking about, with all of these different sort of accounts and social media and AI, using things called... what would be called sockpops. They look like they are fake accounts or other accounts, but they're.
00:06:13
Speaker 5: Actually being controlled by the government. So it looks like it's an account from Mrs.
00:06:15
Speaker 2: Kfoups of wherever, but it's actually the government.
00:06:18
Speaker 5: Government propaganda.
00:06:20
Speaker 6: And, you know, we talk about, oh, Russian bots or this sort of bot or that sort of bot going out there and spreading what they call... misinformation or disinformation. Well, they're trying to do the same thing here. This is the old mis- and disinformation bill on steroids, as you would say, Rowan, because what we're doing here, not only are we talking about being able to give the government and the e-safety commissioner, an unelected bureaucrat, the power to throttle back on what is out there, but also, amazingly, the power to go and propagandize. Now, Annika Wells denied that, But if you read the exposure draft legislation, it's in there. And this whole thing she did, she did this whole thing, oh, you know, if you want to watch Andrew Tate or say the moon landing is fake, then, you know, you can still do that.
00:07:10
Speaker 5: That's nonsense. It's disingenuous.
00:07:12
Speaker 6: And this is all about control, control, control, because they know they've lost control of the narrative. People are posting things about immigration and other issues they don't like, posting real things happening. and they're talking about it on social media and they don't like it. In the same way, you know, and we're going to talk about France in a little bit, we're seeing all of this footage out of France with the incredible riots and destruction and looting and vandalism, and that's not getting a lot of pick-up in the mainstream press, but it's getting press out there because people want to talk about it, but it doesn't really go with all the narratives of glorious multiculturalism and integration and, you know, religions of peace and all of that.
00:07:52
Speaker 7: Well, the other aspect, the other issue that the eSafety Commissioner, I've done a lot of reporting about this and we've covered this a lot on this show. We had Celine Baumgartner on a few times, of course. She tried to, this is the woman who tried to criticise and expose a primary school in Australia for having a queer club. And for that, the e-safety commissioner dragged her through court for her right, Julianne Grant's right, to shut that
down completely. Now, I'm absolutely opposed. What I'm trying to say... perhaps clumsily, is that I think she is exploiting very real concerns that parents like myself have about the safety of our children.
00:08:35
Speaker 2: That's exactly what they're doing.
00:08:36
Speaker 7: There are laws about it. I did agree with the government introducing a social media ban for under-16s, as difficult as it is to police and kids. We'll find a way, and I know all that. But I do agree with that in theory, and I know you guys probably don't.
00:08:53
Speaker 5: Don't worry.
00:08:54
Speaker 1: Don't worry.
00:08:54
Speaker 2: It'll come back and bite you, but don't worry about that. But it's a different issue.
00:08:57
Speaker 5: It's a different issue.
00:08:58
Speaker 2: It is a different issue. Surely, as a journalist, you must have been horrified, Caroline and James, that the eSafety commissioner was sitting there in the National Press Club by Annika Wells, the minister's own admission, pulling faces. We don't know what she was doing, but she had some expression on her face. I don't know if she was rolling her eyes or doing this or whatever. Who knows? But the minister, a government minister, was sitting there in a room full of journalists looking for the reaction from a bureaucrat as to what another journalist said. was asking the questions and reacting in a negative way. This is an absolute disgrace. It shows you precisely what sort of totalitarian, Orwellian, Soviet-style mob this Labor Party are, that they have their chief censor, the kind of talk-a-mater, sitting there in the room, eyeing out... Oh, don't listen to that one. That one's a bit dodgy. oh over there oh yeah that's a nice one we'll listen to that absolute disgrace the e-safety commissioner is an absolute disgrace to this nation the laughing stock of the world got to be punted a one nation or coalition government the first thing they have to do is strike that job off the books and send that sort of Chief censor packing for all time from this country, in my opinion.
00:10:16
Speaker 6: Well, Rowan, it's funny that you talk about, you know, that sort of Annika Wells looking to the e-safety commissioner to see what.
00:10:23
Speaker 5: Look she had on her face.
00:10:24
Speaker 6: This was... I mean, yeah, OK, fine. On one level, it's Orwellian, you know, it's Stalinist.
00:10:29
Speaker 5: It's also.
00:10:30
Speaker 6: This is the politics of the high school cafeteria. Yes, but it's in Parliament. Well, yeah, it's in the press club.
00:10:36
Speaker 2: It's in government.
00:10:37
Speaker 6: But that's what's so laughably pathetic about this. We actually have to laugh at the absurdity of this.
00:10:43
Speaker 5: You know, you're talking.
00:10:44
Speaker 2: You're not laughing at the absurdity.
00:10:45
Speaker 5: No, you are, Rowan.
00:10:46
Speaker 2: You're Celine Beaumgard.
00:10:47
Speaker 5: No, but Rowan.
00:10:47
Speaker 9: You're Sussex, Jasmine Sussex, whose entire career is destroyed because Julie Inman Grant pulled a face, metaphorically, sitting in government.
00:10:58
Speaker 2: Ooh, don't like the look.
00:10:58
Speaker 5: Of that tweet.
00:10:59
Speaker 2: Cancel it and their livelihood is destroyed. No-one's laughing then.
00:11:03
Speaker 5: I'm not laughing. No, no, no.
00:11:05
Speaker 6: But we have to laugh because humour is a potent weapon.
00:11:08
Speaker 5: Sure... against these people.
00:11:09
Speaker 6: And it is laughable that Cam Redden, Sirius News 24 journalist, up there asking a very serious question. Frankly, I'm going to be really honest there, I think Cam might have been the only journalist who got.
00:11:20
Speaker 5: Up to that microphone... Of course he was.
00:11:22
Speaker 6: He did... and had read the bill. You know, I think that an awful lot of the other... journalists who... There were some other journalists from the ABC and elsewhere who asked questions that were so, don't you agree, Minister, that this is just fantastic and everybody on the right are just terrible? These sort of horrible kissing-up-to-teacher questions that you got from, like, the likes of the ABC. But this Cameron, he did a great job there with that question. And the minister, a minister of the crowd, this is so ridiculous. Well, you know, her answer was not, you know, I'm going to engage with you intellectually about what you said. It's like, well, don't you see? Me and the East Safety Commissioner think you're wrong. You know, so, like, that is high school cafeteria-level politics.
00:12:05
Speaker 5: It is lame.
00:12:07
Speaker 2: It is sinister.
00:12:09
Speaker 7: Look, the government says there are carve-outs for journalists. and the media, but every journalist needs to take.
00:12:15
Speaker 2: Issue with this. Only certain journalists.
00:12:17
Speaker 7: But they should, because we should always be against censorship.
00:12:21
Speaker 6: But this is the thing, Caroline. So who determines who is a journalist?
00:12:26
Speaker 5: Exactly.
00:12:26
Speaker 6: If a Mike Schellenberger, who has been out talking about this stuff, does he count as a journalist? This gets to the point now where do you have to have a journalistic license? Do you have to have a press license to get these exceptions? This is why, and this was the same provision that was in the mis- and disinformation bill that was so sinister.
00:12:45
Speaker 5: You're creating.
00:12:46
Speaker 6: two classes of Australians with two classes of speech rights.
00:12:51
Speaker 5: That is absolutely unacceptable.
00:12:52
Speaker 7: I was just going to make the point that I think any good litmus test for legislation is what would happen if the other side got into politics. And the government should consider, what if Pauline Hanson, as the polls are increasingly showing, was the next prime minister, and she decides the ABC, the Guardian, does not fit into the media carve-out system? and all of their stuff needs to be censored.
00:13:15
Speaker 5:
How would they feel about that?
00:13:17
Speaker 2: That's a brilliant point.
00:13:18
Speaker 5: James Ashby for East Safety Commissioner. How about that? I like that idea. Heard it here first. But you're 100% correct.
00:13:23
Speaker 2: And, you know, Sarah Henderson was.
00:13:30
Speaker 2: Earlier on this network, talking about this very same thing, that these powers, you have to... Any responsible government has to think, well, how are these powers going to be used by the other side if you're introducing them, and what are the dangers and what are the risks? And this is why I come back to the fact that a minister is sitting there in a room full of journalists taking cues from a bureaucrat and taking an indication of what point of view or what question is acceptable or not acceptable or on the fringe or whatever from a bureaucrat. That is the perfect metaphor for everything that is wrong with this. Because we saw it then in that room, but what goes on behind closed doors every time in a multimillion-dollar bureaucracy of e-safety, so-and-so, they're all sitting there with their little bun ponytails and their kale muffins going, oh, oh, I don't like that journalist. Ooh, ooh, oh, let's ban that account and let's do this. because they're doing it.
00:14:27
Speaker 5: That's what they're doing. They're doing it already.
00:14:29
Speaker 2: And if they've got more power to do so, they will destroy freedom of speech in this country, which barely exists, which is on life support to begin with anyway.
00:14:38
Speaker 5: Now, let's move on.
00:14:38
Speaker 2: I want to talk about this nonsense in Victoria where you had the Labor Party come out and say, we're going to get free abortions. Come and vote for us and you're going to have an abortion on the House. I was sickened by this. I was absolutely sickened, particularly because it came in the same week. We had this discussion last week about, you know, the live streaming of the execution, blah, blah, blah, and all sorts of pearl clutches going, how disgusting, how revolting.
00:15:04
Speaker 5: Oh, I've never heard of anything.
00:15:05
Speaker 2: Anyway, Trump's dumped that. The same people are sitting there going, oh, isn't this nice? The government's going to give free abortions. You're killing people, folks. That's what you're offering to do. You're offering to kill fetuses. You think that's a great idea, good luck to you, but you don't go around bribing people to come to you, vote for you in Parliament by offering to kill people. That's my opinion, and I'm not even particularly religious.
00:15:29
Speaker 5: Caroline?
00:15:30
Speaker 7: Well, I think there are some very complex.
00:15:34
Speaker 7: Individual cases where it could be warranted, for example, when it's putting the woman's life, the mother's life, in danger and abortion.
00:15:42
Speaker 2: Of course, no-one's arguing that.
00:15:43
Speaker 7: No, and perhaps there should be... No, of course.
00:15:46
Speaker 2: Blanket-free abortions.
00:15:47
Speaker 5: No, no, I'm.
00:15:48
Speaker 7: Talking about where they should be subsidised, when they might be for life-saving purposes.
00:15:53
Speaker 2: Sure, but they're talking about free for everybody.
00:15:55
Speaker 7: What was really disappointing is that the Liberals have become.
00:15:58
Speaker 2: Thank you, yes.
00:16:00
Speaker 7: so scared of any sort of political fight and debate in this country that they would rather jump on board because Labor thought, OK, we're going to try and wedge the Liberals on this issue, which is very sinister in itself to use this issue.
00:16:17
Speaker 2: I agree.
00:16:18
Speaker 7: to try and wedge another political party. But instead of putting up the fight and debating this point, because they're looking at even offering free abortions up to 12 weeks, they're going to do a review. And that is when... Usually you announce the pregnancy to everyone because that is a point where the fetus is considered, you're considered in the safe territory generally. It is quite sick stuff. I'm disappointed in the liberals.
00:16:45
Speaker 5: I was more than disappointed. I was actually.
00:16:47
Speaker 6: frankly, appalled by the lack of principle here of Jess Wilson and the Liberals here. It shows that they want power so badly. And all the polls show that they're going to win anyway, so they didn't need to do this. But, you know, this is Moloch. This is child sacrifice for power. That is ultimately what we're talking about.
00:17:04
Speaker 5: I'm sorry.
00:17:05
Speaker 6: I know people will be upset that I said that, but really, that is true. And it's so bizarre. I mean, Where this takes us, everybody thinks, oh, this is so enlightened. This is so wonderful. This is so good. But once you start to devalue life and potential life like this, you know, Australia will go down the road of Canada.
00:17:24
Speaker 10: Yep.
00:17:26
Speaker 6: Tens of thousands of people are killed, you know, death by government. You talk about Nidal Hassan in the US. You talk about, you know, they're going to shoot this one guy who killed 13 of his fellow soldiers, you know. Well, they killed tens of thousands of people in Canada, and they call this mercy, you know. This is where the lack of respect of life goes. And to bring it into what we've been talking about a lot in the culture for the last months now is this whole idea of AI. And you've got these people out there, the effective altruists who are behind Anthropic and all of this. They say, oh, well, maybe these clawed things, maybe these clawed agents have rights. Maybe they have more rights than humans. Well, I say to them, they're just a clump of bits and bytes, if you're going to say we're just a clump of cells. But the fact of the matter is, when you start to trade principle around life and human life and human dignity... which the West has, because of its Judeo-Christian roots, in a way that no other cultural or civilisation has. You are lost, you
are heading down a very dangerous road, and you know what? It looks enlightened now, but for the weakest in society, it will be a disaster.
00:18:33
Speaker 2: It's a total disaster.
00:18:34
Speaker 7: I find it sick, as a woman, that we have people on the left cheering for abortion.
00:18:40
Speaker 1: Mm-hm.
00:18:41
Speaker 2: Like.
00:18:42
Speaker 7: That it is a wonderful thing. I mean, I don't think most of the women who decide on abortion, it is a very fraught decision that they have to face. But we have the progressives who are cheering it on. I have a novel idea. Why don't governments suggest subsidising abortion? Adoption. Making adoption easier. Encouraging people.
00:19:05
Speaker 2: Well, why didn't the Liberals come up with that as an idea? Exactly. Because they're completely... The Victorian Liberals are completely without any moral values or centre. They are a joke. And they've made themselves to be seen as a joke.
00:19:17
Speaker 5: Carry on, Caroline. I agree with you totally.
00:19:19
Speaker 7: I just think... As James points out, it is a really topsy-turvy society that we've become. When we cheer for death, when it involves fetuses, unborn babies, and we say about capital punishment... I mean, that wasn't the issue. It was a livestreaming issue. But we have had that argument here in Australia before. Having grown up in Singapore, I'm not squeamish about capital punishment at all. I've seen it work as a deterrent. Well, haircuts.
00:19:47
Speaker 2: Compulsory haircuts.
00:19:48
Speaker 7: But, you know, when the... Bali 9 traffickers were facing the death penalty in Indonesia, there were vigils in Australia for that, to protect drug traffickers. It's ridiculous. And yet we have the left here... saying, let's make abortion even easier and free and subsidised.
00:20:07
Speaker 2: You offer free lollies, you offer free bribes in politics, you don't offer free killing, in my opinion. It's a disgrace. Let's also talk about something else which... came up this morning with Sarah Henderson, but also was obviously a big story over the weekend, was Matt Canavan in The Nationals saying no to the EU trade deal, quite correctly, in my opinion. And now the squeamish bedwetters within the Liberal Party, not Sarah Henderson, she supported Matt Canavan in his call that the Liberals and the Coalition should not support the EU trade deal.
00:20:42
Speaker 5: Why?
00:20:42
Speaker 2: We'll get onto that in a second. But the point is the libs are split all over again. And what does it boil down to? We told you here, folks, on this show, the Paris Agreement. We told you, Angus, we told you, Matt, that the Paris Agreement would come back and bite you hard, and that's exactly what has happened. You should have ditched it when you had the chance because now you don't have a leg to stand on because this entire split... about the EU trade deal is because of the Paris Agreement. It's because the trade deal says that you have to follow the Paris Agreement's rules and regulations on climate change, net zero, et cetera, yada, yada, yada, all of which the Coalition is trying to move away from to get closer to one nation's position, all they had to do was say, we're going to pull out of the Paris Agreement. And this would not have happened. You didn't listen, did you? Again, you didn't listen. How often do we have to tell you? And now it's come back and it's going to split the coalition again. Great work, backroom boys. You're so clever, aren't you? James.
00:21:45
Speaker 6: Well, you know, it's more than that. It's more than just the EU agreement in Paris and all of that. This is about the whole question of globalism versus national sovereignty.
00:21:54
Speaker 2: Yep.
00:21:54
Speaker 6: All of these trade deals that we have been entering into over the years, they all represent erosions of our national sovereignty, our ability to think and do and decide for ourselves. I agree with you 100 percent, Rowan. Paris is right up there because, you know, that's the thing that drives the whole economy one way or the other.
00:22:14
Speaker 5: That's how.
00:22:15
Speaker 6: You know, you wind up with the kind of communism by stealth of all of these so-called capitalists going in there doing all the renewables warts that we're paying for to the tune of hundreds of billions of dollars.
00:22:26
Speaker 5: Why?
00:22:27
Speaker 6: None of us ordinary people can get ahead. But you look at other free trade agreements. Our free trade agreement with India... for example, which has all these provisions in it for visas. We have to issue a certain number of visas to people from India to come here and study or stay or whatever because that's what we need to do to get the free trade. So we've sold out our immigration policy to a foreign country because we want the money. And this is where we really get into trouble. Free trade with like-minded economies is crazy.
00:22:58
Speaker 5: Great. I'm all for that.
00:22:59
Speaker 6: And, you know, between similar sorts of economies with complementary strengths and so on, that's great. That enriches everybody. But when you start to load on all of these other issues that, you know, hey, maybe just quite a wild idea here, maybe us citizens would like to have a vote on. You know, I know this is a really wild, anti-movie, an antiquarian idea here that maybe citizens get to vote on these things like, you know, immigration or Paris.
00:23:26
Speaker 5: But here we are.
00:23:27
Speaker 2: Caroline, I want to move on from that. We can talk about that again later. But I was fascinated with all the stuff about Victoria Barracks and all that's been going on with Labor wanting to sell off all our military heritage and so on. I was fascinated by, during the week, what Hancock prospecting have done... Gina Reinhart, Hancock Prospecting, are a sponsor of this network. They have been... Gina Hancock has put, I think it's $ 200 million to providing housing and home for homeless
veterans. Now, this is something which is astonishing. They opened another two in Brisbane this week. Ben Robert Smith was there. He was there for the opening. Have a listen to Ben Roberts-Smith and then Gina Hancock about this project, which is done to... There are something like 6,000... Sorry.
00:24:18
Speaker 5: What did I say?
00:24:19
Speaker 2: Gina Hancock. Sorry, Gina Reinhardt. There are about something like 6,000 veterans that are homeless. Have a listen.
00:24:27
Speaker 10: From myself and from all veterans in Australia.
00:24:32
Speaker 10: Mrs Reinhart, we are so extremely grateful for what you do and what you have continued to do for us. We are grateful for the voice you give us with the politicians and to the Australian people. I don't believe the current government is taking our issues seriously.
00:24:51
Speaker 11: The government might attend medal ceremonies. and other photograph opportunities, but won't open the doors of the unused or scarcely used barracks or other defence accommodation facilities to let our veterans in and out of the cold. To let our veterans have a safer place to live, a place they can use and call home.
00:25:20
Speaker 5: Caroline.
00:25:21
Speaker 7: I think it's wonderful. I mean, Gina Reinhart is so pilloried in other media outlets. You know, look at how the ABC treated her recently. And yet she is the one who is stepping up and helping some of the most vulnerable people in our society, veterans who served this country and are then left out onto the streets. I mean, she should be applauded for that. It's nothing to do with her being a sponsor here. or, you know, a conservative voice in Australia. This is about her doing the right thing for people who need it the most. And the government has shunned these people. Look at how the Defence Minister has treated them in recent weeks.
00:25:57
Speaker 6: I mean, put aside Matt Keogh, who is absolutely disgraceful as Veterans Affairs Minister and isn't fit to serve on the backbench or anywhere in Parliament. You know, what this is, this is part of a broader... story, I think. And you hear all of these complaints in the left media about, oh, these terrible billionaires, terrible billionaires, they never give anything back. Here's one who really does genuinely give stuff back to children's hospitals, to veterans, to an amazing array of charities, sports, all sorts of things that touch the fabric of our lives and the people who need it the most. And yet, what does she get? Well, because she's so successful and she runs against the grain of what establishment politics are, well, they pillory her, and it's disgraceful.
00:26:41
Speaker 5: Absolutely, and she's.
00:26:42
Speaker 2: Doing the job that the government should be doing. So there you have it. We're going to take a short break. Come back, lots more to talk about. We've got Richard Kemp, we've got Peter Ridd, we've got all sorts of things happening here on Outsiders. Back in a tick.
00:27:00
Speaker 5: Hello, you're watching Outsiders.
00:27:02
Speaker 6: I'm James Morrow, here with our regular ringleader, Rowan Dean, and ringing in for Rita this week, the captivating Caroline Marcus.
00:27:10
Speaker 5: All right, let's get into it, shall we?
00:27:12
Speaker 6: Now, you know, normally this is the part of the program where I tell you about something really horrendous that the left has done, or provide an update on the increasingly powerless immigration status of someone like Minnesota Congresswoman Ilhan Omar. who is rumored to have already fled the United States as investigators dive into her citizenship applications and tax returns. But instead, today, I want to do something, show you something that is simply unabashedly cool and suggest that when we talk about America and American innovation, it's simply a mistake to count the USA out.
00:27:53
Speaker 5: So what am I talking about? Oh, yeah.
00:27:57
Speaker 6: Only this, a flying car. Now I know what you're thinking, but that's not AI. That's an actual, legit flying roadster invented by Elon Musk and his Tesla team who decided to finally make a car that doesn't look as sexy as a giant computer mouse on wheels.
00:28:26
Speaker 5: Oh, by the way, this thing can also do this.
00:28:56
Speaker 6: And I'm told that folks in Victoria are already lining up with their local Tesla dealerships to buy these things because, well, how useful would they be with all the potholes?
00:29:12
Speaker 5: Very funny.
00:29:13
Speaker 6: But what is less funny is the predictable reaction of the left, which is so lacking in fun and imagination, they've decided that flying cars, you know, the things that we were all promised when we were kids, well, they've decided they're a bad thing because, ah, well, you know, Elon Musk. Social media has been full of scolds who say that because every other problem in the world hasn't yet been solved, we need to not have anything fun. Like, you know, as I say, flying cars. One fellow, speaking for many, Dr. Paul Saladino, said, I don't want flying cars. I want rivers and oceans. I can swim in with friends. I want food that isn't full of toxic chemicals and clean soil to grow it in. I want raw nature and wilderness and places on the earth I can get lost without seeing another human. As the Taco Bell girl says, why can't we have both? Of course, this attitude has been around forever. When America first launched its space program, folks were angry that the money wasn't being given to the poor instead. That said, I was pretty pleased to see that not everyone has joined the Killjoy Brigade. Even the Washington Post, which is about as fun and anti-fun and anti-cool as you can imagine, editorialized, quote, here's what's fun about technological progress. The world would be far worse off if people invested only in research and development that could generate immediate market value. And they pointed out plenty of things that seemed to have no use at the time they were invented, like
the laser, which underpins so many of our technology today, or experiments like in how atoms behave that later became the basis for technology like MRI machines that save so many lives now. The Post noted, quote, whether Musk's ultra-cool vehicle demo marks another sneakily transformative moment remains to be seen. It may end up leading to minimal changes in how we lead our daily lives. Or this week might be remembered as the dawn of a new era of flying cars. And the Post goes on to say a growing U.S. economy makes such gambles possible. And when they pay off, they pay off for everyone. Yes, this is the thing. Technology and optimism and economic growth are our future. not lefty doomsaying and asking for handouts. Now, for my money, I thought what an ex-account called The Objectivist had to say summed it up perfectly. A flying car is what men do when they are free. A wealth tax is what politicians do to the men who built it. One of them needs the other to survive, and it isn't Elon Musk.
00:31:59
Speaker 5: Damn straight. So, you know, I'm just thinking here. I wonder if I can retrofit thrusters like that on the Mustang.
00:32:13
Speaker 1: Great stuff.
00:32:13
Speaker 5: Thanks, James.
00:32:14
Speaker 2: OK, let's bring in our wonderful guest, British Colonel Richard Kemp. Richard, great to see you, as always. Thanks so much for coming on the show. Now, I want to get to Iran and Russia and all of that stuff, But first of all, Europe, France, what is going on with the scenes coming out of France? You know, town halls on fire, you know, monuments toppling. What is happening, Richard, in France?
00:32:41
Speaker 1: Well, as you know, Rowan, the French specialise in violent rioting in probably a way more extreme than most other European countries do. This started off, as far as I understand it, as a protest against school conditions and lack of funding for schools, but it's rapidly been taken over. It's probably actually started by the hard left, no doubt. I've no doubt. I've got no proof for this, but it would be amazing if they weren't being supported also by Russia and China, China in particular, who obviously have an interest in both cases in destabilizing Europe and the West. So I think that it's much more than a genuine protest about school conditions. After all, they've been burning schools down rather than doing anything that's going to improve schools. So I think that's the reality. And, of course, we've seen... You won't see any French flags flying at these protests. What you will see, though, is a lot of Palestinian flags. So it tells you also about other elements of the French population that have become deeply involved in this rioting.
00:33:47
Speaker 2: Is this civil war? Could we see civil war, Richard?
00:33:51
Speaker 1: I don't know. I mean, I certainly have been predicting civil war in Europe for quite a long time now. I didn't necessarily think it would start in France, although it's in some ways the obvious place. Whether this is clamped down eventually and dies out... or whether it continues and develops into a full-blown conflict, I think either option is possible. Some people believe also that this is kind of a left-wing dress rehearsal for what might be brought about if Marine Le Pen wins the French general election, the French presidential election, which, of course, would be totally unacceptable to them and would certainly be met with this kind of violence.
00:34:33
Speaker 6: Well, Colonel, I've just been watching this, and, I mean, to me, this looks fairly clearly like an Islamo-communist insurrection that's been developing out of the no-go zones and other parts But what does the French government need to do to take back control of this? I have been shocked to see so little force, even seems to be a lack of curfews that I can tell, but I don't know why they're not using non-lethal or even lethal force to deal with... We just saw a few hours ago the spire on the town hall of Limoges collapse. We're seeing chimney pots being thrown off of the roofs of buildings onto police. We're seeing people evicted from... their shops, to have their shops looted and burned. How does French civil society, how does the French government.
00:35:18
Speaker 5: Get a hold of this?
00:35:20
Speaker 6: Because it seems out of control and it's been getting worse for weeks, not burning out.
00:35:25
Speaker 1: Absolutely. And the only way to achieve control, in my view, is by significant deployment of the French armed forces. I know that some elements have been used already, but that's what's required. The police clearly... cannot cope with what's going on on the streets of France. It's not quite the same, but in some ways reminiscent of what happened in Northern Ireland in the 1960s, when the British government had to send very, very significant military forces in to deal with severe rioting in particular, and later... terrorism. And so that, you know, we might, unless the French are able to get control of it in that way, we might well see it developing in something much more, as Rowan was suggesting, maybe even something like a civil war.
00:36:12
Speaker 7: Colonel, you're in Israel. Let's move on to what's happening domestically there, because the elections are coming up for the presidential elections, that is. Do you think that Benjamin Netanyahu will get back in?
00:36:29
Speaker 1: I think it's highly likely, if you will. And frankly, in my view, it's the best hope Israel's got of continuing the successes it's had over the last three years since the 7th of October of suppressing Iran and suppressing the Iranian terrorist proxies in the region. He's a very experienced man. As you know, he's the longest-serving prime minister that Israel has ever had. He has very, very close relations with the critical ally of Israel, the United States of America, and President Trump personally. So I think that, you know, it's obviously not for me to really say what shouldn't happen in Israel.
I'm a Brit and not even a Jew. So, you know, it's not really my business. But I would say that he's certainly got a very strong chance, and I think the polls are showing that might happen. One of the options, of course, is... depending on how he is able to shape the outcome of the elections, is potentially unity government, which... would give maybe the other leading candidate, Gabi Eisenkot, a former IDF general. And he might then lead a unity government with perhaps Netanyahu as prime minister for the first two years and Eisenkot as prime minister for the second two years. That might be an option which could possibly work if Netanyahu isn't able to put together a coalition with an overall majority.
00:37:59
Speaker 2: And, Richard, this takes us to Iran and what is happening? When will we see the Iranian regime topple? What is Trump doing with the business with the Russian oil and easing sanctions and so on? And just to top it all off, what is the mother of all bombs and will it be dropped?
00:38:22
Speaker 1: A couple of good questions there, Rowan. I think the first point you raised, which is when is Iran, when is this regime going to be toppled? Now, as I read it, and obviously I don't have any inside information, but as I read the situation today, President Trump is very, very keen on avoiding returning to large-scale military operations against Iran until after the midterm elections. I think once those have happened, whatever the outcome of them, it gives him two election-free years in which he can do whatever he thinks is best without worrying too much about the outcome of elections. So I think that would be probably his ideal situation. But the situation in in the Middle East is deteriorating at the moment, obviously inspired largely by Iran. But we've seen— as you know, we've seen significant attacks by the Houthis against Saudi Arabia. We've seen shipping hit on various seaways here, in some cases quite severe hits. So it may be that President Trump has to make a larger-scale intervention before the midterms. And I've certainly seen in the time I've been here a relatively large buildup of U.S. air power here in Israel. So that may be either indicative of of more imminent action, or it might mean something they're preparing for a longer-term action. As far as the diesel and the deals that have been made and the lifting of sanctions with Russia, that obviously is partly at least a direct result of the increased oil prices that have occurred as a result of Iran's actions in the Strait of Hormuz. But also, I think it's related to peace talks that have been going on between Russia and President Trump's allies in Miami, not his allies, his peace envoys in Miami, Kushner and Witkoff. And there's certainly, I think, perhaps fairly strong indications that they might lead somewhere. We don't know where. We know broadly the terms that that are being considered by those peace talks. And it may be that this is a kind of concession Trump is making to the Russians, as well as trying to reduce fuel prices in the US, but a concession towards Russia maybe coming towards the negotiating table. James?
00:40:55
Speaker 6: Well, indeed, I mean, but the political problem is that the calculus between doing that deal for diesel, which is a relatively small amount, which really won't have much effect on the price of... petrol at the pump in the United States. The political cost of that for the Trump administration seems to have been that it has played straight into the hands of everybody who accuses him of being in the pocket of Putin or too close to Putin and too anti-Zelensky. So the politics of it, I don't know that that works for Trump going into the midterms. I'd love your thoughts on that.
00:41:29
Speaker 1: Well, I think you've got a good point there. But on the other hand, I spend quite a lot of time in America and I get a fairly strong view from the US that American support for the war in Ukraine is not very popular. It certainly isn't as popular as it is in Britain and other European countries. And he's been, in the last day or so, Trump has been emphasising his priority is ending this war. And so that element of it might well play out well in the midterms. It's a difficult situation to actually get one's head around, but I think that could be quite a useful point for him.
00:42:09
Speaker 2: Colonel Richard Kemp, always great to chat to you. We'll do the mother of bombs, of all bombs, next time, but I hate to think what that one's all about. Thank you so much, Colonel Richard Kemp, for talking to us from Israel. Coming up after the break, Emissions Impossible. Peter Ridd, right here on Outsiders. Don't go away, back in a tick. Yes, Emissions Impossible, it's our mission and we accept it gleefully to point out the madness of the Net zero and sanity every week. Well, net zero is built on the climate change cult, the theory that the science is settled. Well, of course, the science is settled if the data is correct. This extraordinary story yesterday about the Bureau of Meteorology, something I've talked about many times, we've talked about on this show many times over the past 10 years. Have a listen to The Australian's Graham Lloyd, who broke this story yesterday.
00:43:01
Speaker 12: An audit of Bond's raw data, which it claims... is a representation of what was originally written down, has found big problems. Large blocks of temperatures have been copied and pasted from one year into another, sometimes 40 years apart.
00:43:22
Speaker 2: So joining us is Peter Ridd, great friend from up there on the Great Barrier Reef. Peter, so Graham Lloyd's thing, we don't need to go into too much specific details, but basically Graham Lloyd has compared the handwritten data from the BOM, which is the Bureau of Meteorology, He specifically points to Observatory in Sydney, but others as well, where they've gone back and compared the handwritten temperature data around New South Wales and Australia and
compared it to what's digitally online, and the two don't match. And, in fact, they've discovered mass duplications, like a whole month from one year has been replicated or even the wrong seasons have been replicated. And they are saying, statistically, this is just impossible. The Bureau of Meteorology, too, there, to play devil's advocate, have said, no, no, no, no, there may be mistakes, but it's generally OK. But the point is, if data is not 100% correct, if it is compromised, Peter, what does this mean? You're a scientist. You work with data. You rely on data. You're an entire life's work at the Great Barrier. Reef is all about data.
00:44:27
Speaker 13: It just shows a general, complete lack of quality assurance in the Bureau of Meteorology, which is much wider... Now, what does it mean for the actual climate record? Well, they've adjusted a lot of the old temperatures downwards, which makes climate change look a little bit worse than.
00:44:42
Speaker 5: It really is.
00:44:43
Speaker 13: But it's the quality assurance thing. Now, remember, they've been told there have been problems over many years. People like Jennifer Marahasi, Bill Johnson, or even one of my own PhD students, John McLean, have been saying this. And they say, oh, well, there's small problems. But how does this happen? How did this happen? get through the trap. And remember, this is not just the Australian Bureau of Meteorology. Similar adjustments to the climate record have been made in America. So, for example, the incredibly famous dust bowls of the 1930s have been more or less obliterated. And then it goes actually even further than that, that if you then go to the climate science in general, there's often no quality assurance.
00:45:26
Speaker 14: And this really matters, by the way.
00:45:27
Speaker 13: Just right at the moment, there's legal action being taken by some of the conservation groups against the West Australian gas field, they're actually claiming that because of climate change, it's going to kill, I don't know, 30 million corals on the Great Barrier Reef every year or every time it bleaches. And therefore, those gas fields must be closed down. So this general lack of quality assurance is an incredibly important problem for Australia. What it actually shows is we need to have somebody, we need 100 scientists doing this quality assurance and rather than these two gentlemen who've actually done it for free, the actual report was done by scientists for free, we need to pay this to be done and to make sure that the fundamental data and lots of other papers are actually reliable.
00:46:12
Speaker 2: James?
00:46:13
Speaker 6: What has been the reaction of the Bureau of Meteorology to these revelations that their own work has been fairly slipshod and that this is having, you would imagine, potentially billions of dollars of impact on the Australian economy as policymakers use this dodgy data to feed a narrative around climate change that isn't true.
00:46:37
Speaker 14: It's not good enough.
00:46:38
Speaker 13: They just say, OK, yeah, there were some mistakes, we'll fix them. But that's not the point. You've got to ask, how did this happen? How did these get through? how much wider is the problem? Because it's right through the scientific community. When you actually often point out problems in the scientific community, they'll say, oh, well, you know, it's just a little problem. But the bigger question is, well, how did that happen? And was there a motivation behind that? And all these other questions. You've got to actually get to the root cause of the problem. And the Bureau is not actually accepting that they have to do that. And neither are most of the other scientific organisations involved that are involved in climate science.
00:47:17
Speaker 2: Caro?
00:47:18
Speaker 7: Peter, what makes me particularly cynical about the Bureau's response is some of the detail in this report. For example, this audit found that at the Sydney Observatory, maximum temperature adjustments were positive in every year between 1910 and 2020. 2020. So there were only these changes were only one way to make it look like the maximums were higher. I mean, how do you interpret that?
00:47:46
Speaker 13: Well, there's all sorts of ways you can interpret it, and I won't go into all the options, but the bare minimum, you've got to ask the question, how did this happen?
00:47:54
Speaker 14: And by the way, that's not all.
00:47:55
Speaker 13: There were many other very, very strange cut and paste things that went on with this data. So you can't just say, oh, well, we'll just fix them. You've got to start to ask why that has happened and how you can stop this happening in the future and whether it's happened in a vast variety of other areas of climate change, which I can guarantee you it has.
00:48:20
Speaker 2: And I think, Peter, the point is, so last week there was a Greens candidate down in Victoria who was saying, oh, it was 26 degrees in Victoria in October, did a little video as if this was shocking, and then went on to directly link that to climate change, the need for net zero, the need for et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. It took me five minutes, Peter, to go back and discover that Back in... from 1902 to 1926, every other year in Victoria, there was at least a temperature of..... an upper limit of 26, sometimes 30, 31. So, the point is that this data predicates the entire climate change ideology that the planet is getting Now, none of us were around 100 years ago, or not many, and so we rely on the data, Peter, if we're going to be forming policy, if the data is going to be is wrong, then it's likely the policy is wrong. You've seen this on the Great Barrier Reef. What's the latest now? You know, we saw only a year or so ago that the data all changed. Oh, now suddenly the Great Barrier Reef's looking a lot healthier. Where are we now, Peter?
00:49:35
Speaker 14: Well, it's funny you say that. I mean, with the
actual proper data on the Great Barrier Reef, it's at record amounts.
00:49:40
Speaker 13: But then there's another organisation, if we're going to talk about changing data, there's an organisation called the Global Coral Reef Monitoring Network, which has changed the data, the historic coral reef data from 1980 to 2020, because it wasn't frightening enough.
00:49:56
Speaker 14: And in the last report, they've actually changed this. So yet another organisation that has turned out to be unreliable.
00:50:03
Speaker 13: Now, our Bureau of Meteorology, we rely upon them to be, you know, to be trustworthy. We've got a big El Nino coming up. We could have all sorts of fires down in the south. Do you trust the Bureau of Meteorology to report this, you know, fairly? Will they mention, for example, if there is a huge dust storm that goes through Melbourne, that actually this has happened before in 1983?
00:50:25
Speaker 1: No.
00:50:26
Speaker 14: Or that there's been massive bushfires in 1939.
00:50:28
Speaker 13: The problem is that because you see things like that from the Bureau of Meteorology, essentially making you question their whole trustworthiness, well, I really don't think you can have much faith in a great deal of what they say. And that's a shame because the Bureau does such wonderful work with their weather radars and all the rest of it, and you've got this small group within the Bureau of Meteorology, their climate department, and well, I don't trust them and I suggest that other people shouldn't either.
00:50:57
Speaker 2: And I think this is the key point, is that once trust is gone, you know, it's very hard to win it back. But more importantly, younger people who may not have experienced certain temperatures or a heatwave or a cold spell or a storm or a hurricane or whatever, they see something, they think it's the first time, they believe the argument that, oh, this has never happened before, which is why we must have accurate data from the past. as you know only full well. Peter Ridd, thanks as always for coming on and chatting to us on Outsiders. We'll let you get back onto the Great Barrier Reef. Peter does a great job up there in Townsville. Coming up, what's more on the show? In a tick. Hello, you're watching Outsiders with James, last refuge of a scoundrel. Morrow, Caroline, my country, right or wrong? Marcus and myself, Rowan, ask not what your country can do for you, Dean. The grubs of the left love to mock patriotism, which just means love of country, and nationalism, which they dismiss as white supremacy or racism or whatever else. But you either love your country and everything it has bestowed upon you, the town you grew up in, the education you received, the economic opportunities you have been afforded, the holidays, the adventures, the pleasurable moments of relaxation, of partying and having fun or enjoying leisure and sporting activities that are and were denied. to 99.9% of the rest of humanity. You either love those
things, your country, or you dismiss them as irrelevant, falsely believing that you would have achieved the life you are living all by yourself, regardless of the country you call home. Worse, of course, than dismissing or being apathetic to your country is actively hating it. The scenes coming out of France at the moment, verging on civil war, between the anarchist forces of the hard left in cahoots with violent, angry mobs is, in my opinion, the inevitable result of leftist hatred of la patrie, the French nation and culture. It may be fuelled by the communists, but the foot soldiers are the armies of young first- or second-generation migrant men fed on a diet of hatred of France, of so-called French colonialism, all in the name of the left's beloved multiculturalisme. It is no surprise to me that the primary targets for these mobs are the symbols of patriotism, the town halls, the monuments, a war against civility, a war against tradition and patriotism. And that is what makes the left in this country and most Western nations so despicable. They actively encourage our kids to hate their country, to be ashamed of it and to dismiss its culture and history as irrelevant or worse, as somehow evil, racist, colonialist, imperialist, white supremacist. These are the vile slurs hurled at poor old Australia by the modern left. On a side note, it literally infuriates me that the left and indeed the entire woke so-called progressive elites of Australia endlessly bang on about how precious the relationship between clearly part Aboriginal Australians and so-called country is. yet dismiss as irrelevant any notion of a relationship between non-Aboriginal Australians and their country of birth. And the cruel irony of this is, of course, in, typically, the perversion of language by the left. The word indigenous, which is a direct derivation from the Latin word indigena, literally means a person born in a particular place. That's it. It has nothing to do with ancestry or colour of skin or culture or heritage. It literally means a person who was born in such and such a place. I am an Indigenous Canberran. I am also an Indigenous Australian. I do not need to be welcomed into my own country. Thank you very much. In fact, I actually resent it as much as I would resent some clown standing on my front porch, blowing cigarette smoke in my face and muttering gobbledygook at me before letting me in to my own home. And as for acknowledging that somebody else owns the land other than the people who, you know, actually own the land, no.
00:55:28
Speaker 5: No way. Forget it.
00:55:31
Speaker 2: That's what I call theft through incantation and shame on those corporations and councils that go along with such nonsense. But back to patriotism. In the same way that if you work for a large company, they might reward loyalty with various bonus programs or whatever, or in the same way that the local footy team plays better when there's a large home crowd giving them their support,
patriotism is a vital ingredient in the social cohesion, I hate that phrase, but that's the one everybody uses, of a nation. Patriotism oils the wheels. We all benefit from this wonderful country and we demand an awful lot of it. We demand security, we demand a sound economy, we demand protection of our assets, clean streets, safe public spaces. We don't always get them and we punish political parties who fail in their duty to provide them, as Victorian Labor is about to find out. But pride in your country is important both at home and abroad. This nation has achieved an awful lot in just over 200 years and every one of us should share in and celebrate that success. And unlike every other commentator and politician in this country, I am not now going to make some gratuitous qualification to that factual statement. Patriotism is the last refuge of a scoundrel. As Samuel Johnson famously said in 1775, the left loves to use this quotation to suggest those who are patriotic are scoundrels. But in fact, as is universally the case, the left have got it completely back to front. Johnson wasn't attacking patriotism per se, as his biographer Boswell makes perfectly clear. He was attacking those who hide behind the cloak of patriotism or fake patriotism. He was attacking frauds, in other words. Samuel Johnson was actually a profound supporter of patriotism and wrote a pamphlet on it. distinguishing true patriots from false patriots. His description of a false patriot, to my mind, accurately describes the modern woke so-called progressive left, the culture of grievance and victimhood. When Johnson wrote, quote, Still less does the true patriot circulate opinions which he knows to be false. No man who loves his country fills the nation with clamorous complaints. That, to me, is the perfect definition of the modern left, be it on climate change, the economy, immigration, First Nations, crime, radical Islam, anti-Semitism, on and on it goes, the modern left that fills this nation with falsehoods and clamorous complaints. Sorry, I forgot they're not lies any more, they're just a change of position. Do you now concede... Good morning, Pete... you lied to the Australian public?
00:58:25
Speaker 7: We changed our position.
00:58:28
Speaker 1: But I digress.
00:58:29
Speaker 2: Patriotism is important for a country internally and externally. Anthems and flags are important. We have a beautiful Australian flag with a fabulous history all of its own. But the Labor Party and the Prime Minister are so embarrassed by it, they always manage to stick the two Indigenous flags as the focal point, even when they're overseas, which is a farce. We have a beautiful anthem with its own quirky lyrics, but how many kids ever get to sing it? Certainly not at school, although One Nation have said they... will change that. I remember a couple of years ago, I mentioned it here on Outsiders at the time, I had the misfortune of being in inner Melbourne, South Yarra, that sort of area, on the morning of January 26, a couple of years ago. Not a single shop up and down Chapel Street had a single indication that it was Australia Day. No flag, no bunting, nothing, no cafe, no shop, no cars going past, nothing. You literally wouldn't have had the faintest idea it was the National Day. A nation that carries itself proudly with head held high, both at home and abroad, is one that will attract the best people, that will attract business opportunities and that will garner respect for its people wherever they go. I remember fondly many years ago being in Greece with a group of English people. We were trying to get a cab, but it was mid-afternoon and none of the drivers were interested. They were on their break until I tried a trick which I and many other Australians have successfully used before. I said, excuse me. I'm from Australia and I was wondering, bang, that's as far as I needed to go. Australian, why didn't you say so? We love Australians. Where would you like to go? But that was back when Australians were open, friendly, honest, fiercely patriotic and hugely respected wherever we went. We even had pop songs that went to number one around the world all about how great it was to be an Aussie. Yes, for a brief moment in time, that was Australia's internationally recognised national anthem. Everywhere you went, they all knew the lyrics. We were the envy of the world. Back then, our athletes would sing Advanced Australia Fair from the podiums of the world full of pride. They may not have known every single word, but they put their hearts and their souls into it. Is it still the same today, I wonder, after 30 years of Australian black armband, self-flagellation and self-denigration? Are today's Aussie athletes, for example, as well-versed in our national anthem? Have a look at the Gillaroos, the Australian women's rugby team, at the opener to the match in Sydney on Friday night. What can I say? A sullen, stubborn refusal to even pretend to mouth the words from most of the team, with only a handful of well-done girls to those ones who did bother. The left has a hell of a lot to answer for in this country. On another note, having successfully destroyed patriotism and love of country in Australia, the left is now hell bent on destroying the thing we were once most famous for, our free speech and our straight talking. On this show, I've always said what happens in Britain is only ever a warning for what will happen here within a few years. And so we saw again this week. For many years now on the show, we have mocked what has become known as two tier Two-tier policing in Britain, which is where rather than solve crimes like pickpocketing and theft, the British police have taken it upon themselves to police what everyday people say and think.
01:02:30
Speaker 5: Whoa!
01:02:31
Speaker 2: From silly limericks about transgenders to comments about immigration, the UK police force will be on to you. They've become a laughingstock. With The
Times last year reporting that over 30 people a day are arrested in Britain over online so-called offensive messaging. At the same time, we've seen any number of people arrested simply for what amounts to political incorrectness. But laugh no more. It is clear that the police, as enforcers of safe opinions, has now come here to Australia.
01:03:07
Speaker 5: So, common sense would say if they're uncomfortable.
01:03:09
Speaker 1: Who? Did that guy I was speaking to call you over?
01:03:11
Speaker 14: It was a very decent conversation.
01:03:13
Speaker 2: Here's the issue, guys.
01:03:15
Speaker 5: We're in Australia.
01:03:17
Speaker 2: We have this idea of, like.
01:03:19
Speaker 1: Are we not? Is this communist Russia?
01:03:21
Speaker 14: Is this communist China?
01:03:26
Speaker 15: But it's even more intrusive in New Zealand have a look at this clip.
01:03:28
Speaker 14: I Racial disarmament.
01:03:57
Speaker 13: Now we can see what's happening in Great Britain, around Europe, what's happening here in New Zealand.
01:04:02
Speaker 14: They are charging me. That's the initial charge. Racial disarmament. If anybody's brought racial unity, it's been me.
01:04:11
Speaker 2: Yes, that's Pentecostalist Pastor Brian Tamaki being served a summons to appear in Manukua District Court tomorrow. I probably pronounced that wrong. 9am tomorrow morning, he's there facing three charges of inciting violence racial disharmony under Section 131 of the, you guessed it, Human Rights Act. The charges relate to comments he made in June criticising Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi over alleged persecution of Christians in India and comments where he, Brian Tamaki, called for New Zealand to be purged, quote, of Hindus, Sikhs and Muslims. I would have thought that's his opinion and he's welcome to it. For all I know, there are plenty of Sikhs and Hindus who'd like to see New Zealand, sorry, Aratoria, or whatever it's called, purged of Pentecostalists. That's free speech. But it looks like instead the Kiwi cops are more interested in purging free speech. Still, when it comes to controlling free speech, thank goodness Annika Wells doesn't intend using her draconian Orwellian digital duty of care to control ours? Or does she? You be the judge.
01:05:23
Speaker 4: If adults listen to manosphere podcasts or people post their views about the government or make memes or want to say the moon landing was fake, they can continue to do so without restriction. We are controlling. We are not controlling free speech.
01:05:43
Speaker 2: Many a truth is revealed through the slip of the careless tongue. Samuel Johnson didn't say that.
01:05:50
Speaker 5: I did.
01:05:56
Speaker 2: Joining us now to talk US news, President of the Centre of the American Experiment, the great John Heinrich. John, great to see you. Thanks for coming on the show. Now, let's get... There's so much we could talk about, but let's kick off with Ilhan Omar. We've talked about her many times on the show before. She's the Somalian-born Democrat congresswoman who has now... is now under investigation. What's the latest, John?
01:06:20
Speaker 16: Well, a search warrant was executed on her house in the District of Columbia, not by the FBI, but by Homeland Security Investigations, which presumably means that the crime that is being investigated relates to immigration. But at this point, Rowan, we don't know exactly what it is that they're looking into, and we don't know what evidence they were looking for at her house. We'll find out a lot more when the search warrant is unsealed. In the meantime, Ilhan Omar herself has not been seen since Monday. She's gone to ground.
01:06:55
Speaker 1: James?
01:06:56
Speaker 6: Well, tell us what exactly is happening here with these investigations, because, you know, I know some of these things are still sealed, but there would have had to have been somebody signing off on the search warrant and so on.
01:07:07
Speaker 5: So in terms of.
01:07:09
Speaker 6: whether there's not necessarily fire but smoke, there's probable cause that there is some issue around either her finances or her immigration status or both here.
01:07:19
Speaker 5: Am I right?
01:07:21
Speaker 2: Well, that's right.
01:07:21
Speaker 16: A magistrate in the District of Columbia, and I don't think there are any Republican magistrates, you know, in D.C., signed off on the search warrant that takes probable cause, number one, that a crime has been committed, and number two, that there's likely to be evidence relevant to that crime in the place that you want to search. A magistrate signed off on that search warrant. So, you know, it's a reasonably serious investigation. I think the indications are it probably relates somehow to to immigration. But again, we don't know the details yet.
01:07:53
Speaker 12: Caroline.
01:07:54
Speaker 7: Jonah, Katie Zachariah yesterday set a new record for being the shortest serving press secretary under Donald Trump. She lasted just a few days in the job. Do you think that President Trump had much choice here in firing her or giving her an opportunity to get out, as he sort of put it, And what do you make of the reaction to her? Because I have found it somewhat hypocritical. Even here in Australia, a lot of the focus has been on this woman's appearance, physical appearance. From outlets on the left, who usually would be the first one to say, never talk about a woman's appearance. Your take?
01:08:36
Speaker 16: Well, unless she's a conservative woman, that's completely different. I feel sorry for Katie Zachariah. She didn't have a good first 15 minutes on the job, but Trump was awfully quick to give her the hook. I didn't think she was that bad. I want to add this, too, because there's been all this controversy about her not really being a lawyer because she's never been admitted to practice law in any state. And that's got nothing to do with her job as White House press secretary. But what I pointed out on
Powerline is that this is the same situation we see with Abdul El-Sayed, who's running for the Senate. He calls himself a doctor and talks about it a lot in his campaign, but he has never been licensed to practice medicine in any state, just like Katie Zachariah has never been licensed to practice law. Same thing, but the press has savaged Zachariah hasn't said a word about El-Sayed.
01:09:32
Speaker 2: John, wash your mouth out with soap. You're suggesting some kind of different standards between the left and the right. John, what are you doing, mate? Come on. Now, you mentioned the whack jobs that the Democrat are putting up for the midterms. There's that Abdul character, there's the crazy guy in Texas. There's all sorts of people. How are the midterms shaping up And is Trump's kind of weird Russia sanctions lifting thing, is that all tied up with the midterms?
01:10:05
Speaker 16: Well, first of all, Rowan, it is looking like a good year for the Democrats. The generic ballot for the House of Representatives, they're on the average up about eight points. Everyone expects that they will take control of the House. The Senate should be closer. They need a net pickup of four seats to take control. They're guaranteed at least one pickup. There's seven other close races. And if you average the polls in those seven races, the Democrat is leading in every one of them, but they are all within the margin of error. And so it's going to be very close. Personally, I find it hard to believe that James Tallarico can win in Texas or Abdul El-Sayed in Michigan or that Iowa is going to elect a Democrat to the Senate. But I guess we will have to see. Now, you mentioned Trump's executive order negating sanctions against Russia that were just passed this year. in the Lindsey Graham Act, it's called, that would sanction other countries that buy Russian oil. And Trump has put those sanctions on hold. Why did he do that? Obviously, he wants to see Russian oil flowing into the marketplace to help to keep down the price of gasoline globally. And that's obviously in the interest of the United States. I don't tie it to the midterms. They're too soon for this action to have any any impact. What I would say, Rowan, is that this is good for the U.S. Trump is being criticized for letting down Ukraine, but he did not run as the candidate of Ukraine first. He ran as the candidate of America first. And I think this action is consistent with that.
01:11:46
Speaker 5: Yeah, fair enough.
01:11:47
Speaker 6: Hey, John, I want to ask you about another story that's been bubbling along here, and I don't think we've paid enough attention to it. The latest revelations about Special Counsel Jack Smith and the data gathering that he undertook against even ordinary American citizens, even American citizens who bought MAGA hats as part of their investigations into Trump. Tell us about this, because this seems like an incredible abuse of power that was happening under the Democrat regime.
01:12:14
Speaker 16: James, things are slowly leaking out about this special counsel investigation that Jack Smith did, which got dismissed at the end of the day. But yes, he was going out and subpoenaing records. He was getting the names and addresses of all the people who ordered those red MAGA hats from various vendors. Now, what was he going to do with the names of people who ordered MAGA hats?
01:12:39
Speaker 2: I don't know.
01:12:40
Speaker 16: He also collected bank information about thousands of people who made donations to Trump's campaign. Typically, you know, $ 20 donations, $ 30 donations. And again, what on earth? How could that possibly have been relevant to any legitimate investigation?
01:12:58
Speaker 2: Well, you mentioned the MAGA hats. What about my MAGA socks? I've got some great MAGA socks. Our dear friend Tina, who brought us those, they're fantastic.
01:13:06
Speaker 16: You're probably at his list, though.
01:13:08
Speaker 5: He's probably got your name.
01:13:10
Speaker 2: Now, listen, talking about, you know, leaks coming from the uppermost inner circles of the White House, obviously I'm very close, I have very close contacts with Donald Trump, and I've heard your name being bandied around for the new press secretary, John. I thought you'd be perfect. But we don't want to lose you for the show, mate. You know, we've got to keep you for the show. All you need is a blonde wig and you're away.
01:13:31
Speaker 16: I was going to say, well, I don't fit the profile. There's a stereotype and there's a reason for it.
01:13:39
Speaker 5: I don't fit it.
01:13:41
Speaker 2: John Hynderaker, always great to chat to you. Thanks so much for coming on Outsiders and we'll chat again soon. Thanks, mate. After the break, we've got some wallies, we've got Caroline's got her editorial, we've got celebrities, so much more coming up. Don't go away. Back in a tick.
01:14:00
Speaker 7: Hello you're watching Outsiders with your hosts Rowan Righteous Among the Nations Dean and James the Gentle Gentile Morrow and myself Caroline Marcus filling in for Rita Panahy. We're now just eight weeks away from an anniversary we should never have had to mark. One year since the worst terror attack this country has ever seen. And yet, what have our leaders actually done in that time to confront the problem that was at the very heart of this massacre? I'm talking, of course, not of guns, but the people who allegedly pulled the trigger, radical Islamists. If you consider what's been revealed in recent days alone, you'd say, well, not much at all. And another Bondi seems, sadly, increasingly inevitable. First, there's the leader of the Australian Islamic Center, allegedly linked to the Omani pilot who tried to carry out his own 9-11 with an Israeli plane. Without factoring in, he'd come face to face with a bunch of terror-weary Israelis, tackling him in the cockpit like something out of a Tom Cruise flick. I mean, of course, Tom Cruise's older action stuff,
not his recent $ 350 million flop set to become one of the worst in box office history. But I digress. Co-pilot Hammam al-Hammami told UAE prosecutors he was radicalised while studying in Melbourne and had become acquainted with people connected to the Multicultural Youth Centre. This week, the preacher who manages that organisation, Sheikh Abu Hamza, rejected any connection to the hijacker, instead blaming his own position on Gaza for what he calls... the false accusations.
01:15:57
Speaker 17: It is also because we stand by the people in Gaza. The reason also is because I oppose terrorism. That's why I oppose the terrorist Zionists.
01:16:11
Speaker 7: It's always the Jews, isn't it? Even when the link between the pilot and the centre came from the United Arab Emirates Attorney General. Then again, this sheikh has something of a habit of demonising Jews. Sorry, I mean Zionists.
01:16:27
Speaker 17: I've always said and I've always believed that these Zionists are not normal.
01:16:31
Speaker 2: They're blood-sucking human beings. They're scavengers. They're not humans, I swear by Allah.
01:16:39
Speaker 7: So, yeah, this is the bloke running one of the biggest Islamic organisations in the country. A registered charity, by the way, which made more than $ 3. 8 million in revenue in 2025. The financial year before that, it received $ 660, 000 in funding from the government. There have been comparable grants in the years preceding that, including as much as $ 834, 000 in 2022. No wonder the Sheikh looks so happy posing with Labor figures here with State Victorian MP Kathleen Matthews-Ward and Minister Anthony Carbines. And you want to know where else Labor has been splashing our cash? on this Western Sydney Islamic media organisation, which sure has been busy publishing content like this.
01:17:35
Speaker 15: We have serious enemies, mortal enemies, whether we like it or not. Zionists are Jewish supremacists, as some scholars call them, are mortal enemies of Islam.
01:17:54
Speaker 7: And despite a well-established record of divisive drivel like that, this outlet, One Path, was gifted a $ 308, 000 federal grant after the Bondi massacre. The grant committee must have just missed this video dismissing the anti-Semitic attacks that led up to December 14 as one big hoax. Cue the menacing music.
01:18:19
Speaker 2: It was all fake.
01:18:22
Speaker 4: The Jewish childcare centre firebombing, the swastikas on cars, the graffiti on synagogues, the explosive-laden caravan.
01:18:31
Speaker 5: It was all a sham.
01:18:34
Speaker 7: Multiculturalism Minister Anne Ali this week terminated the grant, but only after the story was exposed by the Daily Telegraph. Why should it take journalists to do the government's due diligence? The same paper revealed yesterday a Western Sydney charity worker who'd appeared on the podcast had been spearheading fundraising efforts for a Hamas-linked charity in Gaza. Some of the millions raised allegedly from Australian donors,
including New South Wales schools and youth organisations. She now lives overseas and her lawyer says she was not aware of alleged Hamas connections to the charity. It took mere minutes for me to dig up more disturbing videos from one path side, like this one, where women wearing niqabs interview a prominent Australian anti-Israel activist. It looks like a parody, but it's not.
01:19:35
Speaker 4: How do you manage a conversation with people who do not share the same values as you?
01:19:39
Speaker 18: Is that a productive conversation to have?
01:19:43
Speaker 8: You never go into a conversation with a Zionist.
01:19:46
Speaker 15: That's rule number one.
01:19:49
Speaker 7: Yes, because we're blood-sucking scavengers after all. For too long, the government has brushed off justified concerns about radical Islam and hate preachers as perhaps just a fringe Jewish problem, one that was politically inconvenient for senior figures whose seats boast a high proportion of Muslim voters. For all the uncertainty over former Treasurer Josh Frydenberg's true political ambitions, he is certainly right about this extremism being a problem for all Australians.
01:20:24
Speaker 13: When anti-Semitism moves from the shameful fringe to the public square, it's no longer.
01:20:29
Speaker 1: About the Jews. It's actually about everyone else.
01:20:33
Speaker 13: It's a sign that society is crumbling before our very eyes.
01:20:38
Speaker 7: And under this government and its far too weak and sluggish response to those who preach hate, our society is crumbling to the point of no return.
01:20:54
Speaker 1: Great stuff.
01:20:55
Speaker 2: Thank you very much, Caroline. That was great. Now, back to this duty of care bill and to talk more about it, I'm pleased to say we're joined by Margaret Chambers from the Institute of Public Affairs, the IPA. Margaret, great to see you. Thanks for coming on the show. Now, you've been with Michael Schellenberger during the week. He's done great work, great friend of this show, on pointing out the absurdities, the fact that the Americans can see right through this entire attack on our free speech. Where are we now with the Digital Duty of Care Bill, Margaret, and what are the problems that still are there, despite the fact that Annika Wells and her Orwellian eSafety Commissioner seem to think it's all absolutely fine?
01:21:37
Speaker 8: Well, thank you for having me on the show. Where we're at now is currently that they've introduced it to Parliament, where it'll end up getting kicked off to a committee in the Senate, you know, dominated by the Greens, where they'll try to extract, you know, maximum benefit for the Greens at the committee stage. So, yeah, I've been around with Michael Schellenberger. around Australia in the last couple of weeks, talking to the media. And as you said, like, it was just clear as day to Michael, as soon as he saw the bill, you know, what we're dealing with, because it's just so typical for these censors. They're always trying to censor people We've seen the same pattern again in the EU, in the UK. But, yeah, this really is the worst in the world. And, yeah, it really... It needs to be abandoned. It needs to be put in the bin. Even though they've tried to, you know, put on some cosmetic edits, the key fundamental issue with the bill remains, and that is that it's a single overarching duty across the entire internet to create a safe online environment, which, Reid, is a sanitised, government-approved feed... For all Australians, it's deeply, deeply troublesome and it needs to be abandoned.
01:22:39
Speaker 1: James.
01:22:39
Speaker 6: Talk to us a bit about that word safety, because one of the things that struck me about watching the speech that the minister gave at the press club was the way in which she kept appealing to this concept of safety and, you know, was talking about the so-called abuse that was heaped on the e-safety commissioner and, oh, some of the mean things people have said about her and saying... I'm so sorry that this has happened to you. And the two of them hugged after the speech. This seems to me like a very dangerous rule where we start to define safety as never being exposed to criticism.
01:23:18
Speaker 2: Mm, that's exactly right.
01:23:19
Speaker 8: And, I mean, you've got to remember that the eSafety Commissioner's position was originally established as the Office of the Children's eSafety Commissioner under the Turnbull government about 10 years ago. So, I mean, that shows you all that you need to know. You know, it's all about safety. I mean, they keep talking about how this is to do with children but if it's really to do with the children then why is a great portion of the bill devoted to censoring content for adults so you know this is a deeply cynical exercise they're happy to use whatever words they can to sort of eliminate and sanitize debate on the issue and i think safety is just one of those words that it's difficult to challenge when you say it's about safety but really you have to see through this it's not about.
01:23:57
Speaker 5: That at all Caroline.
01:23:59
Speaker 7: Margaret, Michael Schellenberger identified this concept of sock puppets, which he said would be created from this legislation. Talk to us about what that means and how the legislation would create these sock puppets. James put it as sort of government created bots, essentially. How would you describe them?
01:24:24
Speaker 8: Yeah, I mean, they're fake accounts. It's really interesting that the government's used this phrase, sock puppets, because I think maybe in Australia we have the idea that these are kind of like playful, harmless children's sock puppets. But, you know, overseas where the term actually comes from, it's a pejorative term to describe when you don't actually know if you're talking to somebody who's a real user or if it's somebody who's disguising themselves as somebody else. And that's exactly what the
government's doing. You know, the eSafety Commissioner can set up all these accounts online unlimited accounts if she wants to, to essentially spout government propaganda. So it's a disinformation campaign. About two years ago with the misinformation bills, the government tried to ban this kind of thing. And I guess their conclusion from that is if you can't beat them, join them. So now they're just joining in with these sock puppets that they will use to spread disinformation.
01:25:12
Speaker 2: And yet, Margaret, you had Annika Wells at the National Press Club the other day say, oh, no, no, no, no, there's none of that, that's not in there, we've changed it, we've done this, we've done that. Are those dangers still within the bill as it stands, Margaret?
01:25:29
Speaker 5: Yes, absolutely.
01:25:30
Speaker 8: Yes, they're right there in Section 205. You know, the viewers at home can Google it for yourself. You'll see what the provision says. It says that the government can create these soft puppet accounts, which are fake or fictitious identities, in which they can observe, download and monitor content online. You know, the government, if you were being charitable, which I'm not inclined to be, they would say that, you know, they're using it to test compliance.
01:25:54
Speaker 5: With the law. But, I mean, how do you do that?
01:25:56
Speaker 8: You have to generate content to do that, to see what the platform... does with the content. So this is a disinformation operation. You can just imagine the kind of content that eSafety will be generating through this provision. It really is diabolical. And it's just one example of how terrible the bill is.
01:26:13
Speaker 2: And Margaret, at the IPA, you brought Michael Schellenberger out and that generated a lot of publicity. What can people do who are concerned? Can they go on the IPA? Is there information there on your website?
01:26:25
Speaker 8: Yeah, you absolutely should follow the IPA on the socials. You should join as an IPA member. You can follow me at FromTheChambers on Instagram, where I'll be covering this issue in more depth. I think it's really important because it affects what? Just, you know, every Australian online, what you can see. And this is the new public square. The social media, it needs to be kept free from government intervention. So it really, it does matter to every single Australian. I cannot stress that enough. This bill really is important.
01:26:54
Speaker 2: Margaret Chambers, thanks so much. And I'm sure many people will be doing that, just that. Thanks so much for coming on the show and we'll speak again soon. Well, let's take a short break. Wally of the Week coming up. I wonder if Annika might get a little look in there.
01:27:08
Speaker 5: Who knows?
01:27:08
Speaker 2: Back in a tick. Yes, you're watching Outsiders and thank you so much for watching us every Sunday morning. We certainly do appreciate it. I appreciate Caroline Marcus being here, doing a great job filling in for Rita. Now let's do our Wollies of the Week. I can't go past this one. Tucker Carlson, I've criticised him before. As far as I'm concerned, he's as mad as a cut snake, or worse. Have a listen.
01:27:38
Speaker 19: The nature of war results in the deaths of innocents, and if you look at that enough on a screen, it's like if you look at pornography enough or bestiality videos all day, after a while, it's kind of an attractive horse, I get it. I'm not into it personally, but it's not crazy. We are shaped by the worlds around us, of course.
01:27:57
Speaker 2: And there are still people out there in our parliaments who take Tucker Carlson seriously. What an absolute joke.
01:28:04
Speaker 5: Rowan, I'm going to vote nay on that one. Sorry.
01:28:10
Speaker 2: Getting off my high horse.
01:28:11
Speaker 7: I don't know where to go with that one.
01:28:15
Speaker 2: You know what?
01:28:15
Speaker 7: I'm going to move on to Greta Thunberg because first she was a climate activist.
01:28:20
Speaker 5: How dare you?
01:28:21
Speaker 7: Then she popped up in, you know, protesting Israel and trying to get into Gaza. Now she's in France backing the protesters. Take a look.
01:28:33
Speaker 18: I'm here because this is one of the places where it started. They've been going for almost three weeks now. The French students are now showing the world how we should be standing up and how we should be revolting against an extremely violent system.
01:28:48
Speaker 2: And they're leading by example.
01:28:50
Speaker 7: And later on in the clip, you actually see there's a bonfire that's been lit outside the school that they're riding in front of. I mean, but they're the nonviolent ones. And we've seen some of the scenes that we showed earlier in the show.
01:29:04
Speaker 2: She is a complete idiot, that woman. She was an idiot when she was a schoolgirl. She was an idiot with her Palestinian thing. We weren't allowed to say she was an idiot at the time because she was too young to be called an idiot, even though she was an idiot.
01:29:16
Speaker 5: But we thought it.
01:29:17
Speaker 2: But the number of Australian parents who allowed their daughters particularly, but kids, to run along and listen to the stupidity coming out of that girl's mouth on climate change, and they corrupted an entire generation when it was clear to anyone with eyes in their head that the girl was an idiot. It was clear to Donald Trump. It was clear to anybody. Rowan... I still can't get over it.
01:29:40
Speaker 5: Rowan, it's worse than that.
01:29:42
Speaker 6: It's not just about the kids and the generation of kids went off and skipped a day of school. I mean, look, we all know they don't learn that much in school these days anyway. But, no, we rewrote the entire rules of the global economy and the Australian economy because she was used by some very sinister forces and they put her up on the podium at the United Nations and she went around and she was on the cover of
Time magazine doing.
01:30:06
Speaker 5: The whole, how dare you sort of routine. And everybody bowed down to this, everybody.
01:30:11
Speaker 2: Not everybody.
01:30:12
Speaker 5: Not everybody.
01:30:14
Speaker 2: One TV show in Australia.
01:30:16
Speaker 6: Fine, Rowan, but the fact is we've still got net zero and we've still got Paris as a result. So, you know, this is the thing, though. This is actually kind of grim. It's kind of depressing now. The relevance deprivation thing. Nobody cares about climate anymore. That's gone way down the list of things people care about. The whole grift and the con has been exposed. And, yes, Rowan, by people like us right here on this program. So this relevance deprivation thing... What does she do for the rest of her life? She's going to be out. She's going to be out playing, you know, the Rudy Hill RSL Greatest Hits Tour soon, getting up in front of a bunch of old boomers and going.
01:30:51
Speaker 5: How dare you? And they'll go, yay!
01:30:53
Speaker 2: Yeah, but it's worse. Sorry.
01:30:55
Speaker 7: Who else suffers from relevance deprivation syndrome? And it is our own version of Greta Thunberg here in Australia. She even has the same initials, GT. That's Grace Tame, because a month or so after issuing a grovelling apology for saying and saying that actually she does believe Israeli sexual assault survivors from October 7. She didn't mean what she told Hamish McDonald on the ABC release. She says she was taken out of context. She says this at a rally on October 7. Take a look.
01:31:29
Speaker 15: We know about the cynical weaponisation of anti-Semitism, which is.
01:31:34
Speaker 20: Just another tool to distract and divide us.
01:31:38
Speaker 18: To my right here are two lovely gentlemen handing a sign that says Jews Against the Occupation.
01:31:45
Speaker 20: This is not about religion.
01:31:50
Speaker 7: Just a little aside about this fringe, ultra-fringe group, Jews Against the Occupation. They don't believe Hamas and Hezbollah are a terrorist organisation, so that tells you something about them. I wouldn't give her any oxygen, guys, but the ABC continues to pay her our money, so we need to expose what she's saying.
01:32:07
Speaker 5: And she was Australian of the Year. Absolute disgrace.
01:32:08
Speaker 6: But, you know, Caroline, too, there's also that footage there. This is a great illustration of how, you know, everything is now just the omnicause and it all sort of flows through Palestine. But, you know, you saw the Indigenous flag there, you saw this, you saw that.
01:32:20
Speaker 5: It's always.
01:32:21
Speaker 6: It is now just this big blanc-mange of omnicause, anti-Western, anti-Jewish is part of that, you know, tearing everything down. And that's why, you know, they look to the protesters in France, they say, oh, we want to do that here. It has to be called out because the whole delegitimisation of Israel, you know, leads ultimately to the delegitimisation of.
01:32:47
Speaker 5: of Australia.
01:32:47
Speaker 6: Every time they do a welcome to country, every time they talk about stolen land, there's... In their minds, there's no difference between where we are and the West Bank, and both are illegitimate, according.
01:32:58
Speaker 2: To the left.
01:32:59
Speaker 7: Yeah, that's why there's so much overlap between the protests you see, the Invasion Day protests... Exactly.
01:33:05
Speaker 5: and.
01:33:05
Speaker 7: The anti-Israel protests.
01:33:05
Speaker 2: But the reality is we see in France... I mean, Greta Thunberg, we laugh at it and joke about it, but she's gone right to the heart of where we, as we've been discussing, the imagery, the images coming out of France at the moment, mass destruction, chaos, anarchy. People will die soon. I think that's inevitable. There's so much violence, the tottering of towers coming down, town halls being taken over, Palestinian flags going up. Greta Thunberg has positioned herself in the heart of that. There is a global, certainly a European-wide threat of chaos and nihilism and anarchy throughout Europe, and hopefully we don't see it here.
01:33:43
Speaker 5: But that's why.
01:33:44
Speaker 2: But they are leading it. People like Greta Thunberg are... are pushing themselves to the forefront of a very dangerous and sinister war.
01:33:52
Speaker 6: That's why everybody has to recognise what the Palestine flag stands for. It is now a declaration of war against the West.
01:34:01
Speaker 7: But speaking of these riots in France, you know who's a big cheerleader for them is Marine Faruqi, who was obviously almost our Greens leader in this country. Her son, Osman Faruqi, former journalist who's now set up an independent podcast, and he said this about the riots.
01:34:21
Speaker 21: I think, like in Spain, the kind of electoral left... is hoping that this reemergence of mass civil disobedience might give them some juice until the election. I am just finding it kind of inspiring to watch a generation of young people recognize.
01:34:35
Speaker 2: The system is broken.
01:34:37
Speaker 21: Everything's broken. It's time to take to the streets. It's time to shut down schools. It's time to have our voices heard.
01:34:42
Speaker 7: I don't know how he did that mental gymnastics to turn this into something about the far right and how they'll be exposed through this, but it takes some work.
01:34:52
Speaker 6: But, you know, it proves that they don't..... that they actually literally don't have a program beyond, hey, let's burn it all down.
01:35:00
Speaker 5: Then what?
01:35:00
Speaker 2: Well, one of the ones they're copying is, of course, that Hassan Paika. You've covered him, James, on US Report. We've covered him here. This is this character who dresses in a Mao suit. on an American podcast, a pretty vile character. Have a listen to him.
01:35:16
Speaker 7: You once said, let the streets soak in red capitalist blood. How was the Oscar parties this year?
01:35:21
Speaker 1: It was weird. I think housing should be free.
01:35:29
Speaker 2: But how much does your house cost?
01:35:32
Speaker 1: It was $ 2. 7 million.
01:35:33
Speaker 2: Okay, so it was $ 2.
01:35:35
Speaker 1: 7 million. I mean, I have a mortgage.
01:35:39
Speaker 2: She's very good, that girl. You watch her whole thing, she absolutely skewers the hypocrisy of this idiot, wandering around in a mouse suit, preaching socialism, capitalism, communism, hardcore communism, in fact, and he's a complete hypocrite, making a fortune out of his podcast.
01:35:54
Speaker 5: What a joke.
01:35:54
Speaker 6: This is a guy who said America deserved 9-11. He has said also... He says the most outrageous, racist, terrible... things over and over again. And there's this section of the left. And I'd have to say, really, a lot of it is the, I would call it the downwardly mobile, upper middle class, educated young left. And that's a very important group now that has latched on to Hassan Piker and people like him for some sense of meaning, because they recognize that the generational compact has been broken. But then they wind up going and this guy talks to him and there you have it.
01:36:31
Speaker 5: Yep.
01:36:31
Speaker 2: OK, so we've got to vote for our Wally of the Week. I reckon it's Tucker Carlson in a canter.
01:36:37
Speaker 5: Oh, I think he's the main guy.
01:36:39
Speaker 7: I don't think he could go past someone who's, you know, talking about bestiality.
01:36:44
Speaker 2: On the hoof, on the hoof. There we go. He won it, as I said, in a canter. Tucker Carlson, Wally of the Week. Annika Wells, we'll give her a.
01:36:53
Speaker 5: Honourable mention.
01:36:54
Speaker 2: Honourable mention. Yeah, her and the safety commissioner. We're going to take a short break, come back with some celebrity stupidness. Yes, we've often talked on Outsiders about celebrities are better to keep their political opinions to themselves. I've got two examples here, one who does and one who doesn't. Let's kick off with Harry Styles, who is a pop singer I'm not particularly familiar with, but I'm sure there are plenty of people who are. Here he is with his opinions out there on the centre stage.
01:37:29
Speaker 14: Please continue looking after each other.
01:37:32
Speaker 2: And remember your friends, the people you love, the people.
01:37:36
Speaker 1: Who don't look like you and aren't born.
01:37:38
Speaker 14: Where you're from.
01:37:39
Speaker 1: They deserve respect and love.
01:37:46
Speaker 2: Now that bit of silliness was countered by Metallica, a group I do know about. So here's the, I think he's the lead guitarist at Metallica. Have a listen.
01:37:56
Speaker 22: We're here to forget about all the outside. Metallica's agenda is love, energy and heavy music, baby!
01:38:12
Speaker 2: So there you go. The real rock stars know keep out of politics. They always did. They've always known it. You go back to the 60s and 70s, a lot of them kept well out of politics. Even the Dylans and that went, I'm out of here, I don't want to know. Stay clear of it, folks.
01:38:26
Speaker 5: I'm just a little concerned, Rowan. Here we go.
01:38:30
Speaker 6: Have a call for management after the show because you put that Harry Styles clip on the screen. And you did not give a disturbing content warning. And I think anybody who was going to see those pins sticking out of those little gym shorts there should have been given fair warning to get the kiddies out of the room. You know, go get a cup of tea while we do this one because that's a At least.
01:38:56
Speaker 7: He wasn't wearing a dress and heels, which Harry Styles has been known to do. By the way, Rowan, he was a former member of One Direction. So that's how he... You don't even know who One Direction is.
01:39:07
Speaker 2: A boy band.
01:39:07
Speaker 7: How many directions does he know?
01:39:12
Speaker 2: Which direction did they go? Down?
01:39:14
Speaker 7: The prophecy of him saying, everyone should be welcome, welcome everyone onto your land to Americans, is that this British singer has spent about £ 30 million buying up four properties in the very lucrative suburb of Hampstead in London, where he's building a multimillion-dollar compound, private compound, I don't suppose he'll be letting in a lot.
01:39:38
Speaker 5: Of people off the streets.
01:39:38
Speaker 2: No, he won't be letting many people in, or maybe he'll be giving it back to the Druids or the Celts, because he's on stolen land or whatever.
01:39:45
Speaker 5: James?
01:39:46
Speaker 6: Yeah, oh, well, I mean, look, we've got a whole bunch of things here. Will Smith's daughter was doing some odd stuff.
01:39:53
Speaker 5: I don't know. Have a look.
01:39:55
Speaker 20: New security footage showing singer Kelly Clarkson inside this Brooklyn shop called Art of Play. The moment has sparked a feud that's taken over social media. On Saturday, Clarkson posted that she tried to buy this mechanical bird named Molly, writing she literally was looked at as if I couldn't afford it and was told he could find something comparable for me.
01:40:17
Speaker 7: Bit awkward, but that was not Will Smith's daughter. That was Kelly Clarkson, who won the first American Idol. I think it was the first one. Now, she's made headlines this week, guys, because she walked into a store in Brooklyn in New York and she wanted to buy this bird, a mechanical bird on the wall, which cost $ 15, 000. But the shop says they told her it's mounted to the wall. You can't buy it. We have some cheaper birds available. And she blasted them on X, saying, she felt like Julia Roberts' character in Pretty Woman because they wouldn't sell her this damn bird. Anyway, the bird is now valued at $ 15 million.
01:40:53
Speaker 12: What?
01:40:54
Speaker 7: Thanks, Kelly Clarkson.
01:40:56
Speaker 5: Is it like.
01:40:58
Speaker 6: It sings.
01:40:59
Speaker 5: OK.
01:40:59
Speaker 2: That's it.
01:41:00
Speaker 5: It's a singing bird.
01:41:01
Speaker 7: It's a singing bird.
01:41:02
Speaker 5: It's a dead parrot. She isn't right. It's a dead parrot. Maybe she should just get the fish that sings on the wall.
01:41:06
Speaker 2: I know.
01:41:07
Speaker 7: I think there's only, like.
01:41:08
Speaker 5: $ 10. Anyway.
01:41:10
Speaker 2: OK, so now we've got Will Smith's daughter, apparently. Let's have a look at Will Smith's daughter. She's got the Elaine moves.
01:41:28
Speaker 5: Yeah, a bit of the Elaine.
01:41:31
Speaker 2: I dance almost that bad, Will Smith's daughter.
01:41:34
Speaker 7: I'd rather see Will Smith and his Prince of Bel-Air moves.
01:41:37
Speaker 5: There we go.
01:41:37
Speaker 2: That's it for Outsiders. Thank you so much, Caroline, and we'll see you again next Sunday morning at 9am. Thank you so much.
01:41:44
Speaker 5: Have a good day.