文字稿 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:26.000 --> 00:02:28.354
On the Mind and Matter Podcast, we learned together from the best scientists and thinkers alive today about how your mind-body reacts to what you feed it. Before starting Mind and Matter, I spent 10 years in academia doing scientific research. I got a PhD in neuroscience from Harvard University, where I focused on neuroendocrinology and the neuroscience of behavior, and before that I specialized in molecular, developmental, and evolutionary genetics. I used my scientific background to parse and translate the information guests share on the show and in addition to the podcast, I write long form content and send out a free weekly newsletter at the Mind and Matter substack at mind and matter dot substack dot com. I also offer private science based health consulting where we work one on one and apply the same rigorous evidence first approach you hear on the podcast, the personalized. We can obtain and analyze your biomarkers, work on diet and behavior strategies, review supplements and drugs that you might be taking or anything else related to general metabolic health. If you'd like more tailored guidance on your personal health, head to nickjikomes.com and fill out a short form or book time with me there. A great way to support my content in all of its forms is simply to visit mindandmatter.substack.com. You'll find a link to that in the episode description, and you'll also find a link to my current affiliate partners through my support page. These are products that I use myself that relate to physical, metabolic, or mental health. For example, one product I use every day is the AquaTru water filter, which removes heavy metals, microbes, and endocrine disruptors, you name it so that you have higher quality, drinking water. All of those links for health consulting, for my affiliate partners and the Substack page are all in the episode description. So thank you very much for listening and don't forget to check out mind and matter. dotsubstack.com for all of my content. Thank you for joining me today.
00:02:28.354 --> 00:02:45.652
Hi, Nick. Thank you for inviting me. It's a pleasure to be here. I'm Dr. Kimber, Stanhope, and I am a researcher and nutrition biology at the University, California Davis. I've devoted the last 30 years almost of my career, almost exclusively on human studies and people consuming sugar.
00:02:45.652 --> 00:02:50.354
So yeah, this is a topic I've covered in my writing and on the podcast before.
00:02:50.354 --> 00:03:27.000
The effects of fructose versus glucose, the effects of consuming sugars and carbohydrates of different kinds. A lot of it has focused on mechanism and physiological details. A lot of it is focused on animal research to some extent. And you know, the human literature to some extent, but this is really your focus. So today we're going to talk, most of the conversation probably about human clinical work that you and others have done. And of course, we'll tie it back to the
Load full transcript
mechanisms and the details of how this stuff works. But we will learn here, like, what do some of these things actually do in humans?
00:03:27.000 --> 00:04:40.831
How does something with high-fructose corn syrup compare to something like cane sugar in terms of what it actually does to our biomarkers and our health in human beings in a clinical setting? Let's start out with some basics here, just to give people a sense for some of the things that we're talking about and remind people of some of the differences here. People talk about sugar a lot. People's journalists talk about it, politicians talk about it, everyday people talk about it. What are the major different forms of sugars that people are exposed to when they go by things at the grocery store and bring them back home and consume them? Actually, let's go back and start what the major sugars are in nature before we get to the grocery store. Okay. And the three most prominent sugars start with the two prominent monosaccharides.
00:04:40.831 --> 00:06:02.000
And that is glucose and fructose. Glucose is in nearly every fruit and vegetable we consume. Fructose is also in every fruit and in tiny, tiny amounts and in vegetable. Together, they combine to make the third most prominent naturally occurring sugar, sucrose. sucrose is also in nearly every fruit, but in smaller quantities than fructose and glucose. And it's in sugar cane and sugar beets. But many people would be surprised to know the, by weight, the quantity of sucrose and sugarcane is only 10 percent. In sugar beets, it's only 20%. Now we judge our sugars with regard to sweetness based on sucrose. sucrose is considered one. glucose is 0.7, meaning it's only 70% as sweet as sucrose, whereas fructose is about 40% sweeter than sucrose or 1.4. Though the sweetness of fructose varies depending on temperature and depending on liquid versus solid state. It's sweetest when it's in a carbonated beverage liquid.
00:06:02.000 --> 00:06:31.370
So, however, let's talk about nature. The fruits are the main source of the sugars we consume naturally. And it's important to know that sugars on a per-weight basis in fruit range as low as 4% of the weight, all the way up to 16%. Most of the fruits have less than 10% of their weight as sugar.
00:06:31.370 --> 00:07:44.351
By that I mean I'm adding up the fructose plus the glucose plus the sucrose for a total sugar percentage. There's only about six of the fruits that have more than 10% of their weight by sugar, but it's six of our favorites. Apples, bananas, mangoes, grapes, and I'll stop with grapes because grapes have the highest. They're 16% of their weight as sugar. Now, those of you already know something about sugar are instantly saying, ooh, I eat too much grapes, cross it off the list. But it's important to compare that 16% to processed foods. Yes, 16% of the weight is sugar from grapes, but let's take a cookie. the highest selling cookie or best selling cookie in the United States is the Oreo. The Oreo is 38% of its weight as sugar.
00:07:44.351 --> 00:07:51.221
So more than twice as much sugar in an Oreo than the sugariest fruit?
00:07:51.221 --> 00:13:16.000
Right. And then there's a couple of other things to be aware of. The grape is providing also fiber and micronutrients, whereas the Oreo is almost void of any nutrition, except calories. The other thing to compare is the fiber, high in grapes, negligible in the Oreo, And the water content, grapes, have pretty much 80% to 82% of their weight is water. Oreos is almost no water. Therefore, you're going to eat more Oreos because you don't have water providing bulk and weight when you consume compared to grapes. You're more likely to overeat gray Oreo than a grape. Is another way of saying that just the total mass, including the water weight of a food, is a factor in how satiating the food is. We'll feel fuller if something just literally contains more water. Right. Exactly. There is a quicker stop on overeating when it's pure fruit and many researchers who've tried to do that study where they have people eat a high sugar solid food like an Oreo compared to a fruit and compare the difference, find it really difficult to keep their fruit eaters to eat the required amount of fruit so that they're eating the same amount of sugar. A lot of people tell people to eat this amount of fruit to get it up to where it is if they're eating an Oreo or something like that for the purposes of a study. So if everyone's eating the same amount of sugar, people actually struggle. You really... you have to push them to eat that much fruit. Exactly. Yes. And so they're not the same. So don't be running to cancel out grapes out of your diet. Grapes is a fruit. All fruits are healthy components of our diet. Yeah. Now, because of that, it's likely that most of our ancestors were eating pretty low sugar diets, but through processing over the years changed all that. It started with us learning nearly a thousand years ago how to isolate the sucrose out of sugar cane. However, that process was incredibly expensive, dangerous, and therefore it wasn't tell 500 plus years later before it sucrose even became available to the Gentry. And then it took another 200 years before the process was technologically advanced enough that it became cheap enough that the common man could consume it. And then this was helped along by learning that we could get sugar from sugar beats too. And that made the process even cheaper and sugar more available over time. It was early 1900s that somebody learned that, oh, we can take the starch from corn, add an enzyme, amylase, and turn that into a liquidy glucose syrup. And that became another common sweetener. And most people have used it sometime in their life, Karo corn syrup. But it wasn't until the 1960s that scientists learned that they could add an additional enzyme to that corn syrup and turn the glucose about 46% of them to be exact into fructose. And then they took that process and
extracted all that fructose they just made, purified it, and they learned how to make a syrup, sugar syrup that was 90% fructose. and that was the beginning of high fructose corn syrup. And one of the things it's important to know about high fructose corn syrup is you go on the website of the Corn refiner's and you will find that they say there are two types of high fructose corn syrup that they use a type that is 55% fructose.
00:13:16.000 --> 00:13:22.846
What that means is 55% of the carbohydrate in that syrup comes from fructose.
00:13:22.846 --> 00:14:12.282
And the other 45 is from glucose or short chain glucose. And they say that is the high fructose corn syrup used to sweeten beverages. They also then make a 42% fructose. And that is the fructose that's used to sweeten solid foods. We kind of have to take their word for it because there's no information on the food label that tells us how much fructose is in any high fructose corn syrup formulation. So we do know when they've added high fructose corn syrup to a product, because it's right there on the label, but we don't know which formulation. Right.
00:14:12.282 --> 00:14:18.683
Has anyone ever actually checked? Like, has anyone gone in and measured?
00:14:18.683 --> 00:15:09.898
Yes, that's where this was leading because a researcher, a colleague of mine, Dr. Michael Gorin at the University of Southern California did exactly that. He went and bought 20 to 30 cans of soda, all different kinds off the shelf. And he measured the fructose content using the absolutely three of the absolutely most precise methods available, including mass spectrometry. He had to do it three times because the results weren't expected. No, those beverages did not contain 55% of their carbohydrate as fructose. The average was 60% and the high went all the way up to 68%.
00:15:09.898 --> 00:15:13.277
And what were these beverages exactly?
00:15:13.277 --> 00:15:19.677
Well, the two that were highest were beverages from Coca-Cola and Pepsi.
00:15:19.677 --> 00:15:21.546
So like cans of soda?
00:15:21.546 --> 00:15:58.000
Yes, that he picked out them himself completely randomly. So you said 60 instead of instead of the expected 55% it was 60 plus. That was the average for all 20. Yeah. But the range went all the way up to 68%. Wow. And you would imagine. So I mean, you would imagine that these things are standardized Coca-Cola. I'm pretty sure Coca-Cola's got some pretty big, pretty sophisticated machinery in its facilities.
00:15:58.000 --> 00:16:03.556
It shouldn't be that difficult to get at 55, 45 exactly, right?
00:16:03.556 --> 00:17:27.253
Yes, but why should a manufacturer do that when there's no standard of identity for high fructose corn syrup at limited tea? The fructose content. So they can order a variation of high fructose corn syrup, saying, oh, let's test 50, 55, 60, 65, 70 to see what makes the best tasting product. Right. Okay. This is speculation in my mind. This to me explains why there was such variability, but I don't know for sure that's why. So. So there's variability. We're assuming high fructose corn syrup as 55, 45 in a beverage because that's what it's supposed to be. That's supposedly what it is. That's the standard for beverage. It's the 55, 45 formulation, 55% fructose. But no one with the exception of your colleague in the study, no one's checking the stuff that's on the shelves and actually measuring it. And we know, so there is variation. They measured it. Your colleague measured it. It goes way above 55, in many cases, it's 60 plus on average.
00:17:27.253 --> 00:17:29.988
So now we're like, why is that?
00:17:29.988 --> 00:20:21.000
It could be, maybe they're just sloppy in their manufacturing, but what you're saying is it could also be that they're running experiments basically. They're trying to see which batches, which fructose level is actually taste the best and people buy the most. Right. And you've read food incorporated. So I totally envision taste test panels being given a variety. I mean, think of it. Supposedly the recipe of Coca-Cola is one of the most highly guarded secrets in the world. Well, why do you have to guard that secret when it's only sugar and, you know, phosphoric acid and caramel flavoring and soda, you know, carbonated soda. So I think the percentage of high fructose corn syrup is likely to be a very, very painful from brand to brand. But I don't know for sure. I do know I discussed with an expert chemist whether there was any chance at all there could be residual enzyme in the coke that would change more glucose into fructose once the coke was in the can. He said, absolutely not. In fact, the makers of high fructose corn syrup got FDA to agree that it was okay for them to use the natural label because the definition of label, you know, natural when you process natural food is there's no processing ingredients left in the food. Well, they then make high fructose corn syrup by putting the enzyme attached to the column. So it's near the final product. So, so it's the definition here is no processing agents left over and that's a pretty big, um, right. It's a pretty big, uh, clever legal definition trick there. Right. Exactly. And therefore, they can't blame the 68% fructose on residual enzyme activity because they got the FDA to approve their product. as natural because there's no residual enzyme. Okay. So we assume, and it should be a reasonable assumption, even though it's not, we assume fructose in the form of high fructose corn syrup in a liquid beverage is going to be the 55, 45 fructose to glucose ratio.
00:20:21.000 --> 00:21:10.855
When people actually check this, they find all sorts of variability and it's very often higher than 55% fructose. more fructose than that. And so I guess one way of stirring the conversation at this point is to say, you know, obviously I kind of know where this is going to some extent, but I'll play devil's advocate. Who cares? It's fructose, it's glucose,
it's sugar. If I'm starving, my body will break down my muscles to make glucose, won't it? Like this is just, this is one of the best forms of energy out there. And so who cares? It's 55, 45, 60, 40. What difference does it really make?
00:21:10.855 --> 00:22:14.618
I'm laughing because that's exactly what my slide says in my presentation to students and the public. Who cares? Well, here's why we care. Our bodies don't treat them the same once they get to our liver. So let's start with glucose. Glucose we consume it. in our intestine, it gets pulled out of our intestine into the portal vein. The portal vein takes all that glucose immediately to the liver. Livers first stop. That gives the liver dibs on the glucose. And the liver can make the decision to pull that glucose in, use it for energy or to replenish the glycogen supply, or it can let it go and be delivered to the rest of the body. Now there's an enzyme called phosphofructokinase, PFK, that makes that decision. And PFK is regulated by the simple question.
00:22:14.618 --> 00:22:19.228
Does the liver need energy, or does it not need energy?
00:22:19.228 --> 00:22:29.030
When it needs energy, then that enzyme is turned on and the glucose is pulled in at the rate that the liver needs it.
00:22:29.030 --> 00:22:34.309
When the liver does not need energy, that enzyme is turned off.
00:22:34.309 --> 00:23:55.000
The glucose bypasses the liver and goes everywhere everywhere in the body, brain, muscles, fat cells. I'm sure you've seen that glucose peaks after you eat a meal, but they go down very quickly. That's because all that glucose went to the muscle, brain, fat cells, and it gets used within the first hour of eating. So, probably because the liver is a major site of glucose storage, you can store as glycogen extra glucose to save for later, basically. The liver is a central part of our body in terms of metabolic regulation. It's sort of like a fuel gauge for glucose, in a sense. If it needs some energy, it will take that glucose right away. And if it's got enough, it'll send it through the bloodstream to other parts of the body and other cells all over the body can use that glucose. So the liver is a site of storage of glucose. It's also a key site of regulation in terms of whether or not glucose from a meal gets sent out to the rest of the body or not.
00:23:55.000 --> 00:25:04.126
Right, exactly. So the story, let's talk about fructose. How is it different? Starts out exactly the same. The liver is again the first stop for all the fructose that went from the intestine into the portal vein. But when that fructose gets to the liver is when the story changes because there's a different enzyme that makes the decision. This enzyme is called fructose kinase and fructose kinase is not regulated. It's not regulated by energy needs at all. In fact, it's turned on all the time. Therefore, the majority of that fructose is automatically pulled into the liver, even though at the very same time the person had a milkshake and fries and a triple-decker hamburger. The fructose is in the liver. Basically, the study's been done with isotopes 86% of the fructose in a great big, big gulp ends up in the liver. And as little as 14% is going out to the blood.
00:25:04.126 --> 00:26:40.000
So the liver can dynamically regulate how much glucose it takes in, how much glucose it stores. It's keeping track of this. There's mechanisms to do that. It's sort of like I don't know what an analogy would be. You keep track of your money at home. You know how much your paycheck is bringing in, how much your monthly expenses are. If you need to spend a little bit more next month, you save a little bit less. If you want to save more for a rainy day, you can put more on your savings account. It's regulated. You're paying attention to what's going in, what's going out. You're saying that's kind of like glucose. Liver can pay attention to how much it needs and what the body needs and save more for later or send more to the body. regulated, it's keeping track of the expenses here. That's not the case with fructose. You're just sucking it all in no matter what else you eat, no matter how much fructose is actually coming into the body. Exactly. And that leaves the liver with an overload that it deals with the best it can. And it deals with it by storing as much of it as glycogen as it can. It uses some of it as energy turns some of it into lactate, lactates go up in subjects consuming fructose.
00:26:40.000 --> 00:28:14.362
But when all those pathways are saturated, then the fat-making pathway is up-regulated. And that's where we get the problem. then gets turned into fatty acids that are incorporated into triglycerides and those triglycerides have two major fates. One is to stay in the liver, the other is to go out into the bloodstream and neither of those fates are good. You go out into the bloodstream. You're also taking cholesterol with you because the triglyceride when it's sent to the blood gets packaged into very low density lipoprotein particles that carry a good amount of cholesterol to. So those particles go out in the blood and now we have two risk factors that are increased. The cholesterol, the LDL cholesterol and of course the circulating triglycerides. We have shown in subjects consuming fructose with three meals, starting after lunch, the circulating amounts of triglyceride in their blood go up within 30 minutes and stays up the rest of the day. A little bit of clearance between lunch and dinner, then it goes up again with dinner, a tiny drop, two hours after dinner, then strangely enough, it goes up again.
00:28:14.362 --> 00:34:34.000
So all the way, tell about 1 to 2 a.m. triglyceride levels are high with fructose consumption. And it's really because a sugar that scientists are starting to go, we need to stop just focusing on fasting triglycerides and look at how high it gets during the day and what effect does that have on heart disease? Right. Right.
So the standard in medicine really and the standard for when most people get blood work, even if they're like a health nut and they just like to get their biomarkers checked, almost always you're instructed and you're told to fast, you know, do an overnight fast basically eat dinner, go to sleep, wake up, and then draw the blood before your first meal of the day. And there's good reason for that, right? You get a nice baseline. It's good to be consistent because all these things change when we eat and stuff. But what you're saying is ideally, if you could have perfect information, you'd get the fasting snapshot of these bio markers, like triglycerides and other things. But you would also get them after eating ordinary meals to see how much the meal someone is actually consuming are increasing the levels and what the ceiling looks like not just the floor. Right. So and I said the other fate of that newly made triglyceride that you generated from your overdose of fructose is it just stays in the liver and it's stored as liver triglyceride. And it's because of that, we now have the fatty liver epidemic. And it's one of the saddest commentaries on health that when I was a child, there was no mention ever of fatty liver disease in children. And now it's incredibly common that they're finding fatty liver's. It's all you have to do is talk to a pediatrician like Robert Lustig to watch somebody go nuts over what sugar does to livers in children. Yeah. And I don't have the numbers in front of me, but I've posted these for people. But the numbers are alarming. It's not rare. It's actually alarmingly common for very young children, 8, 10, 12 years old, to have fatty liver close to the level that we used to just associate with, you know, a middle-aged alcoholic. Right, exactly. And so the problem fatty liver in of itself can lead to worse liver disease, the worst pain, cystic fibrosis, but long before you get there, liver fat also impairs and starts this vicious cycle going with insulin sensitivity or the opposite insulin resistance. Insulin resistance means your insulin is doing a lousy job. It's not getting all its tasks done well. And one of those tasks is to get glucose into cells so the cells can use it. insulin's job. It's the key to open the cell door so glucose can go in. When there's insulin resistance, those cell doors stay locked and the pancreas goes whoops! I need to send out more insulin. The doors are still locked and that helps a little but over time if insulin gets worst, the levels of insulin that gets pumped out by the pancreas are amazingly hot. Now, there's one bad thing about insulin resistance with regard to fat making in the liver. For some reason, insulin resistance causes even more fat to be made from the fructose or the glucose. So, fructoses at sufficiently high levels will stimulate triglyceride production in the liver, fatty liver. To some extent, in proportion to how much fructose you're consuming. But if you're also already insulin resistant, it will lead to more fatty liver from the same amount of fructoses. Yes, but it also might, from cause insulin resistance, We don't know for sure chicken versus egg when it comes to liver fat and insulin resistance is insulin resistance causing liver fat to go up or is liver fat causing insulin resistance to go up. We know each of them are true but we don't know what started it. But that's where we have this incredibly vicious cycle. And you need to consider the fructose as a fire on the cycle. But here's the cycle. Fat making, causing extra fat in the liver. That's causing insulin resistance, insulin resistance causes more fat making. And then you add sugar and there's the gasoline. Now, let's back up for a sec. We said that glucose is highly regulated. The liver is paying attention to how much glucose is stored, how much the rest of the body needs, and it can change how much is getting sucked in or redistributed to the rest of the body. It's a highly regulated process with glucose and there's checks and balances involved. That's not the case with fructose. So the question here, which I think brings us to sort of an evolutionary question is why?
00:34:34.000 --> 00:34:40.815
Why don't our bodies regulate fructose? Why would that even be the case? Why not regulate both?
00:34:40.815 --> 00:35:29.030
That is a question where Richard Johnson and I give two different answers. His answer is that it was an evolutionary advantage that the prehistoric man depended on the fruit doing this summer to rev up fat making to store fat to last dream the winter. I think it very well possible that we didn't develop the enzyme because there just isn't that much natural fructose. It's only in the fruit. Right. Okay. So then I think I agree with you here, But I'm going to play devil's advocate again here. But wait a minute, Dr. Stanhope, we're related to chimpanzees and monkeys that eat all kinds of fruit. Chimpanzees will eat all kinds of bananas all day long if they can do it.
00:35:29.030 --> 00:35:31.971
Aren't they exposed to all that fructose?
00:35:31.971 --> 00:39:56.000
Maybe that's what makes the Richard Johnson hypothesis more compelling. When you remember our ancestor, eight bananas, which is one of the highest fructose fruits. By, I don't know, I have no idea how many bananas a day a monkey eats. Yeah, but I actually, funny mention, I do. So I think that the Richard Johnson hypothesis is viable. It's interesting. It makes sense of a lot of things. And they're not necessarily mutually exclusive here, but I actually did a back of the envelope calculation in one of my articles about fructose. If you just look at the average chimpanzee and the average amount they're known to eat and you just do a basic calculation, think about the fact that they're not sitting at home having a door to ask to bring them the bananas. They're going out and climbing and doing all this stuff. And then they're eating the bananas and they're foraging for them
and they're using all of that energy to do it. But if you actually just do the math from what the average fructose consumption for a child is from sugar, sweet and beverages and processed foods and the average adult male chimpanzee is consuming, it's actually about the same if not higher for a human child today. So it's, um, I think people have a presumption that the chimpanzee must be eating more fructose than we are because we have this association between chimps and bananas in our minds, but chimps don't just eat fruit and they're probably not consuming as much fructose as the average human being is today. Right. In fact, I always thought of nuts as being the evolutionary survival food for the chimpanzees in prehistoric man. It's nuts that get ripe in the item and nuts that have this incredible fat content. Right. They have all the unsaturated fat. The stored for the winter. Yeah. I know that hypothesis was always in my head before any of us knew sugar was a problem. But you know, regardless of what the true details of the evolutionary story are, even if you assume that someone today is eating the same number of grams of fruit fructoses every day that an adult chimpanzee is eating. They're eating it from whole fruits out in the wild and human beings, they are primarily eating it from processed foods. And as you mentioned before, to tie some of this stuff together, that fruit in the wild is coming with micronutrients and fiber and also a different microbiome related to those things that is actually going to limit the amount of fructose that the liver sees. So an important distinction is how much fructose goes in your mouth or just how much your liver actually ends up seeing. And you can eat the same amount of grams of fructose from sugar, sweet and beverages as from bananas, but that's going to be a very different fructose load on the liver. Exactly. That would be a terrific study to do someday, but boy, getting funding for those types of studies. So the point is the source of the sugar, not just the raw amount you consume, will matter in terms of how much it gets to the liver, how quickly it's absorbed and so forth. Fructose and glucose are processed differently. For whatever reason, fructose is just not regulated like glucose is, so the liver can't tune the dials to slow down fructose absorption or intake, or storage, or whatever. Because it's processed in the liver differently than the glucose, the effects are different. If you're getting 55, 45 fructose glucose or 60, 40, or 70, 30 because Coca-Cola is trying out a new brand or whatever, that's going to have different physiological and metabolic health consequences for your liver and the rest of your body in terms of how much fructose is getting to your liver by whatever means. Exactly. Yes.
00:39:56.000 --> 00:41:47.679
And um, so let's dig into. Bye. a little bit more. Fructose gets to the liver by some means, by at some level. It can stimulate triglyceride production, fats synthesis, basically fatty liver. What else can it do? And I'm particularly keen on things that are related to oxidative stress. Well, the for sure thing we know is that it increases uric acid. And that's by a completely different pathway than the fact-making pathway. Basically, that is caused by the first few steps steps of the fat-making pathway are the steps of glycolysis. And those who remember their biochem really well know that the first few steps of of glycolysis don't produce energy, they actually require energy to start the engine running. And that energy comes in the form of ATP. And everybody that remembers anything remembers ATP, you use some of the energy and then you have an ADP and you use some of the energy and you have an AMP. And the T stands for try and the D stands for die and the M stands for M. And you froze on there. We still go on. Yeah, you can ignore that. It might do that a little bit. Go ahead. Oh, okay. Great.
00:41:47.679 --> 00:42:25.710
So basically when we over consume fructose, all of a sudden the amount of AMP. goes up because those first two steps of glycolysis are going ATP to ADP, ADP to AMP. It's kind of like running a business. You got to spend money to make money. And if you spend more than you end up making, you could be in the red rather than profitable. Right. So come up with an analogy for this.
00:42:25.710 --> 00:42:57.000
So when there is too much AMP around, then a new pathway gets up-regulated, and this is the Pentos phosphate pathway, and that pathway ends. I said that wrong. That's OK. Cut that out. not the PPP pathway, it is the pathway by which we get rid of the AMP. And that pathway, one of the end products is uric acid.
00:42:57.000 --> 00:46:15.000
Uric acid? Yeah. And I've heard of this before. And so what is uric acid and what problems can that cause? Well, for years and years and years, even probably, you know, in King Henry the seventh, they knew that uric acid causes gout. And gout is when uric acid in the blood gets so high, it crystallizes those crystals, cause pain. They're actually accumulated in joints and it can be extremely painful. And so we've known that forever, but now uric acid is also being connected to all sorts of other adverse effects, including oxidative stress, inflammation, increasing uric acid, even providing positive feedback on the fat-making process. So all sorts of reasons why uric acid could be a, it's definitely a byproduct that signals bad things are happening, but whether it's a mediator of all these things, we don't know yet, for sure. So one way of kind of saying all this is if one were to consume a particularly large dose of fructose, I don't know, because maybe you're drinking a soda and it's not 55, 45, it's 70, 30 or whatever, or maybe you have two or three or 10 sodas in a day, that's liquid fructose going right to the liver. You're getting this ATP depletion glycolysis effect. And one end result of that is you make more uric acid. And that's going to introduce
new problems like oxytate of stress and so forth, but also you're saying maybe even make some of those other problems like fat synthesis, even worse than they were before. Right. Exactly. That is a line of research that Richard Johnson is pursuing. He believes there is a strong connection between uric acid and additional fat making. Yeah. And my understanding too is, you know, just to give some evolutionary context here, for reasons we don't need to go into. The fact is our lineage of primates, the ones that humans belong to, are basically more sensitive to uric acid because we don't have the enzymes that break it down as much as other creatures do. So this is a particularly sensitive pathway or a vulnerable pathway for us to go down if we consume a lot of fructose. Exactly. Yes. So I already mentioned in passing that lactate levels go up when you consume fructose. And again, I assume this is just the body sending it on any place it can to use it. And there's still a lot of work to be done on the effects of the day long increase in lactate that I see in my subjects who consume three fructose drinks a day. Yeah.
00:46:15.000 --> 00:46:15.603
Is it a?
00:46:15.603 --> 00:49:12.000
It's certainly associated with insulin resistance. But whether it's mediating and making the insulin resistance worse, we don't know yet. Yeah. So glucose and fructose are processed differently in the liver. sufficiently high levels of fructose load on the liver, right? And we're going to distinguish between how much you consume and how much gets delivered. Just keep that in the back of your mind for those listening. But once the liver sees enough fructose, you get various problems. Fat synthesis in the liver, the uric acid thing, oxidative stress, bad stuff can happen. The question now becomes, okay, how much is too much exactly? And so when you start to do human studies, and I'll let you kind pick the ones that you talk about because you're going to know that best. But when you do head-to-head comparisons of cane sugar versus hyphructose corn syrup or this amount of fructose versus this amount of glucose, what are the differences there in terms of getting us to think about this question of how much fructose is too much? Can one can of soda with hyphructose corn syrup make a difference? Okay. Let's first start with the sucrose versus hyphructose corn syrup question to get that one out out of the way. I believe I am still the only one who has actually done ahead to head comparison in subjects going through the exact same study protocol, which meant then that I got called by an enormous number of reporters when early in the second term, it was announced that Trump would make us all healthier by getting Coca-Cola to switch out high fructose corn syrup. So this is like the RFK thing where he's like, let's go to cane sugar, which is sucrose, 50, 50 fructose glucose instead of the supposedly 55, 45 fructose glucose corn syrup. And this kind of goes back to the question that I
posed earlier, which is a 55, 45, 50, 50, does it really make a difference. Right and my study in which for sure I knew my high fructose corn syrup was 5545 shows it doesn't make a difference. I had a control group consuming aspertame. I had the group consuming three high fructose corn syrup drinks today. The other group three sucrose corn So, it goes drinks a day, absolutely equal calories based on energy requirement. And we saw for both sugars increases in pretty much every risk factor we measured compared to aspartame consumption.
00:49:12.000 --> 00:50:13.500
Got it. So, there were problems in terms of what happened in terms of some of the biomarkers you looked at, but they moved to the same extent for the 55-45 versus the 50-50 sugar sweeten beverages that you guys made and you guys knew exactly how much fruit chosen glucose was in there. Right. And we, of course, in our statistical analysis, were looking for, are there any differences between the two sugars with the regard to their risk factors? And the answer was a definite no. In fact, it was a very random, some of the risk factors were higher with high fructose corn syrup, a little bit, but not significantly.
00:50:13.500 --> 00:50:32.568
Some were higher with sucrose, but not... significantly. And so it was random. I think you said three drinks a day. So are we basically talking about like the equivalent to three sodas a day?
00:50:32.568 --> 00:50:44.449
Little more than that. Because I provide 25% of energy as sugar. Got it. And I often get asked, isn't that a whole lot?
00:50:44.449 --> 00:50:57.327
Well, the truth is when the study started, that was the USDA guideline or maximum sugar consumption. Don't go over 25% of energy.
00:50:57.327 --> 00:51:04.715
So you were using the high end of what was supposed to be the okay amount?
00:51:04.715 --> 00:52:16.000
Yes, exactly. So that's why we started with 25%. The studies I'm talking about now lasted all the way from 2008 to 2014. The guideline didn't change till 2015. So all the way up to 2014, 25% was okay. Yeah, okay, but 25% of calories coming from sugar, if you do it that. like for somebody that is, I know precisely, let's say for somebody that has a 2000 calorie requirement, it would be 0.66 times three. Let me, no, I'm doing it wrong, two and a half. I know it precisely because we have also studied subjects that were consuming 10 percent. And we saw increases in risk factors in them. And so that represented 10 percent of energy represents two thirds, two thirds, two One and two thirds cans of coke per day.
00:52:16.000 --> 00:53:03.675
Got it. Therefore, we have two and a half times that amount. So whatever that math is, 1.66 times 2.5 is how many cans of coke we're talking about. It's a little over four. Right. And so, and definitely, I don't think the average person is consuming for Yeah, so does a day. But a lot of people are and we've all probably done it at some point. Yeah. So it's it's it's what many people would consider
a high amount of sugar for the day, but it's not extraordinary like, you know, this is within the realm of what actual people are exposed.
00:53:03.675 --> 00:54:31.242
Right. And it's important to know when I do did my tasks for the sucrose versus hyphructose corn syrup, my participants were required to come to the clinical research study center and live there and consume my low sugar diet in four, three days so that the only sugar they were getting was from the drink. So unlike a person in the wild, they weren't adding this sugar sweet beverage on top of the higher sugar diet. They had a low baseline to start with. Yes, definitely. Yeah. So anyway, that's our sucrose versus high fructose corn syrup bottom line. It's only been tested in the 55% formulation. If it would be different at 68%, nobody knows. And again, this kind of connects to what we were talking about before. You guys knew that yours was 55, 45, and you were comparing it to 50, 50. But we have to assume that the stuff people are consuming and so do they buy at the stores, 55, 45, but you already told us people have checked, and they might be getting a whole lot more than that.
00:54:31.242 --> 00:54:39.644
Right. Exactly. So then your next question was how much is too much and what's the safe amount?
00:54:39.644 --> 00:56:05.000
All right. It's important to again remember what I said that my subjects were on the low sugar diet for three days before we did the final testing. But during my intervention phase where my subjects consumed their drinks for two weeks. I wasn't trying to monitor their sugar intake. I wasn't telling them you can't eat any other sugar. The only thing I told them was you may not drink any other sugar even fruit juice was out. Okay. So it's possible that during Actually, it was 11 days that my subjects lived at home and drank their three drinks per day with each meal. It's possible that they weren't eating high amounts of sugar, or it's possible they were eating, drinking that beverage with donuts, cookies, and ice cream. And so we don't know the amount of sugar during those 11 days. We do know then, we brought them back to the clinic, no sugar day one, no sugar day two, no sugar day three, and those were the conditions under which we did our major tests.
00:56:05.000 --> 00:58:06.364
So when I say, gee, we saw increases in risk factors in even the subjects consuming 10% of their energy as sugar. I'm not accounting for what they ate during those 11 days. But I am accounting for a washout effect. So I don't know for sure how much my results were affected by the 11 days that they got to eat other sugar versus how much my results are affected by the fact that I took away all other sugar sources. But given that 10% proved to be able to increase risk factors when consumed with meals that had no other sugar and that 10% meant that every breakfast, lunch and dinner they were consuming two thirds of a can a coke. Okay, got it. So yeah, so you can see these measurable
effects in naturalistic reason of you know, amounts of sugar sweet beverages that a lot of people are going to be consuming. Right, exactly. And it's important to know in that study, we also had two other groups. We had the group consuming 17.5% of their energy as high fructose corn syrup in the third group consuming 25. We got definite highly significant dose response effects. More sugar, the higher the increase. And that was for all the blood markers like LDL cholesterol, triglyceride, apolipoprotein be uric acid, but it was also for the change in liver fat and also for the decrease in insulin sensitivity. All those got significant dose response effects.
00:58:06.364 --> 00:58:35.000
Yeah. And you've also done studies, I believe, where you look at fructose versus glucose, sweet and beverages for weeks at a time, something like 10 weeks at a time, and you look at the effects on things. Some of the liver stuff we were talking about. Uric acid, other markers like retinol-binding protein and so forth.
00:58:35.000 --> 00:58:38.139
Can you talk a little bit about those?
00:58:38.139 --> 00:59:07.391
What happens when you give fructose versus glucose beverages for weeks at a time? Um, basically we saw everything at two weeks that we saw at 10 weeks, but what we don't, I want to clarify the point about inflammation. We have great animal data that shows sugar and fructose cause an upregulation of oxidative stress and inflammatory pathways in animals.
00:59:07.391 --> 01:00:12.175
And you know why this data is so good in animals? we can actually access the liver and measure these factors in the liver. Humans, we can't do that. So, our data showing inflammatory effects and oxidative stress effects is really minimal in humans because that's what the liver we're we're curtailed we can only access the blood. Right, right, you can't really go in, you know, if you're doing it... animal study, you can do it for 10 weeks or however long you want to do it. You can sacrifice the animals, take out their liver and measure everything that is possible to measure. You just can't do that in a human. Right. And therefore, and the other thing, it's the liver's job to keep those inflammatory markers and those oxidative stress markers out of the blood. The liver. Right.
01:00:12.175 --> 01:02:11.000
Not only does it make fat and store energy for us in terms of fat and glucose, but it's kind of like a protector to keep the bad things in the liver, get it excreted via connection with the kidneys, but keep it out of the blood. You can only discern so much about what's going on in the liver from what you can see in the biomarkers measured from the blood in a human. At the end of the day, if you really, really, truly wanted to know what was going on, you'd need to go into the liver and biopsy and really look around. And we just can't do that. So, that's an important thing to keep in mind when we think about human and animal studies. Obviously, the human studies are more relevant to humans with respect to what we can measure because they're in humans and we're humans. But the animal studies we can dig way deeper and look at things that we just can't look at in human beings that are always going to be invisible to us to some extent. Right. That's why you need animal studies plus the human studies and then of course you need the population studies, the epidemiology studies. Everybody knows epidemiology studies are limited because they don't show cause and effect. They're just showing relationships. Oh, when we have lots of sugar being consumed based on dietary reports, we have higher levels of triglyceride. But we don't know the sugar causes that until we do the human intervention study. Yeah. And that's what you did.
01:02:11.000 --> 01:05:17.000
But what makes epidemiology so important is they don't just look at the triglyceride levels. They look at the incidence of heart disease over years, 10 years, 20 years, 30 years. And they show connections between the amount of sugar consumed and death by heart disease. I can't do that with an intervention study. I do not get to go and plan a study where I'm going to give enough sugar to tell somebody acquires heart disease. Right. That's why we need all three. We need those animal studies for the mechanism. We need the population studies to show relationships between what we eat and actual disease. we need intervention studies to show the food causes an increase in risk factors but our intervention study is never going to show the food causes disease. Right, you can't do an intervention study for five years, 10 years, 50 years. It's just you just can't do it. Right. Or you can't ethically. Right. Right. Do it either. we're gonna give you something that we're hypothesizing will cause heart disease. Right. So yeah, that's just important to keep in mind. All of these study types have strengths and weaknesses. There's certain blind spots that are in one type of study that aren't in another one and vice versa. So you kind of need to be able to think across all levels. Sometimes people get too caught up or showvinistic you might say about looking at one or the other, they'll say, you know, I only look at randomized control trials or I only want to look at mechanistic data and you really need to have that full stack view to triangulate what's going on. I absolutely agree. However, there is a certain researchers who are taking advantage of the fact that people want perfect studies, One study that's gonna answer all the questions by evaluating the sugar research in done in clinical intervention studies and unfortunately when they evaluate them, they're using the same evaluation criteria they use for drug studies. And that very first most important criteria they use for drug studies is does this drug affect disease incidents? Not a risk factor. They want to know does it affect disease?
01:05:17.000 --> 01:07:05.822
So they apply that question to clinical dietary intervention
studies and of course the answer is no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no. And then immediately clinical dietary intervention studies are rated as very weak evidence. And then you see titles of research papers saying the studies that support the decrease in sugar by the US dietary guideline recommendations is very weak. Letting people know the data is really not that strong so take it or leave it when it comes to following this new dietary recommendation that says reduce your sugar consumption. Right. Right. Basically what you're saying is we're never going to be doing these intervention trials that are long enough to capture disease incidents. There's financial limitations on doing the study. There's logistical limitations on doing it that long. There's ethical limitations on doing something that could give someone all that research. So it's unfair to say that this is weak evidence when it's just a limitation we have to work with. mean that the studies aren't well done and telling us something important just because they don't last long enough to give someone a heart attack. Right. Exactly. And that is why, as you say, a purist who only wants to look at a certain kind of study because all the rest of them are invalid is not ever going to get the full picture. Yeah.
01:07:05.822 --> 01:08:14.000
So what would, if we step back, birds, I've used, you're, let me ask you this. If you were in charge of setting the guidelines, we said, okay, Kimberstan hope she's in charge, she is the czar of dietary guidelines of all kinds, or at least when it comes to sugar. What would be the guardrails you would set for people on how much is too much, what type of sugar or glucose versus fructose? What do you follow in your own life? What would you recommend? if you were setting the guidelines. Okay. I don't want to get into the rest of the guidelines, but the new guidelines with regard to no more than 10 grams of added sugar per meal and no more than five grams of added sugar in your snacks. That would be a maximum of 40 grams of sugar. That probably would be really good for the population if we got to that. Can I guarantee you 100 percent?
01:08:14.000 --> 01:08:30.301
I would say for a guy that consumes 3,000 calories to only consume 40 grams of fat would be good. Assuming his calories are being burnt because he's a big guy and he's exercise.
01:08:30.301 --> 01:08:36.287
Are you talking about 40 grams of fat or 40 grams of added sugar?
01:08:36.287 --> 01:11:39.000
Sorry. Definitely, 40 grams of added sugar. Okay. So but whether somebody who is consuming, who only requires 1600 calories a day, including women like me who are well over the age of 60, whether we can get by with 40 grams of added sugar a day. Not so sure. I can only tell you anecdotally that I'm consumed less than 40 grams of sugar a day easily. Maybe 10 at the most. Yeah. So is it fair to say there's going to be differences between people. Some of us are bigger than others. Some of us are younger than others. Men versus women. You know, all of the things. So it's not going to be one singular answer. It sort of sounds like you might say it's fair to say that it's probably a good idea to minimize added sugars as much as reasonably possible. And 40 grams of added sugars per day would be definitely towards the higher end of what anyone maybe should aim for. I would think 40 is probably safe for people under the age of 40. And especially they're exercising easily safe. Yeah, but if you are... older than 40 and you don't exercise. 40 grams might be too much. Right. Okay. I do know in all women will find this out. You know you get to a certain age. There is no leeway for discretionary calories or to stop exercising. Yeah. You do either and your weight goes up. So I have gotten stricter and stricter with sugar restriction as time gone by, not only because of my data but because I have to just for weight control. And let's go. They used to drive me crazy for a while when the American Bedroge Association was promoting soda and sugar fits in all lives you just balanced it out with physical activity. I don't remember, I don't know if you remember that. That was about 10 years ago. That was their big push. The sugars say if you just balance it out with activity. And for me, that was annoying personally because I knew I had to be perfect on both. I didn't get to not exercise and I sure didn't get to eat discretionary, very many discretionary calories of sugar.
01:11:39.000 --> 01:11:53.378
And so how much should people be thinking about the fructose versus glucose difference in the sugars that they do eat from whatever source?
01:11:53.378 --> 01:13:23.689
I counted as I think, well, okay, you're going to get me to talk about a different study we did, okay? This actually wasn't a different study. This was a different statistical comparison of subjects consuming high fructose corn syrup, glucose and fructose. And what we found was that for sure triglycerides in uric acid, APOC3 were way higher in subjects consuming fructose and then next was high fructose corn syrup and then next was glucose, minimal effects. Exactly what we expected, but what we weren't expecting was LDL and able lipoprotein B were highest when subjects consuming high fructose corn syrup. The fructose was actually a little bit lower and that was a surprise. And statistically, we analyzed this and showed, indeed, there was a significant interaction between fructose and glucose when they were consumed together in the form of hyphructose corn syrup.
01:13:23.689 --> 01:14:01.862
And what that means is well the glucose and hyphructose corn syrup then can't be considered perfectly safe. It interacts with fructose to somehow cause our LDL and apolipoprotein B to hang around a whole lot longer in our blood. The health significance of that? Probably not good. So what that also means is maybe we don't only just count our fructose and say, oh well,
01:14:01.862 --> 01:14:42.000
I think I'll eat
only glucose and less fructose when it's consumed together. They're interacting and we don't know for sure the effects. So watch your total sugar. Yeah. Just watch the whole thing. So glucose and fructose both affect the liver. They're handled differently by the liver. And certainly if you get too much fructose, however we define that, it can cause a variety of issues.
01:14:42.000 --> 01:14:42.363
What?
01:14:42.363 --> 01:16:23.837
Nick, you were frozen and the first thing I heard was issues. Okay. So glucose and fructose are both handled by the liver in different ways. So they have different effects. They're not interchangeable. Certainly, if you get sufficiently high fructose in the diet, however we decide to define that exactly, it can cause problems of various kinds. We talked about lipids and triglycerides and fatty liver. We've talked about uric acid and oxidative stress and so forth. So you don't want to get too much. Let's just say, so then we've got this problem for the ordinary person, which is even if you're thinking about these things, and even if you're looking at all of your food labels, it just tells you total sugar. It doesn't tell you glucose versus fructose. If you're really paying attention, you might look at the ingredients and say, okay, well, cane sugar or high fructose corn syrup. What would be some guardrails or guidelines that someone could actually use in the store? Would it be advisable by you to say avoid anything with added sugars as much as possible to certainly avoid things with high fructose corn syrup? If people are exposed in their normal diet going around every day to multiple processed foods that each have high fructose corn syrup, is it a good idea just to cut those things out? No, I think the most important monitor is that added sugar line on the nutrition label.
01:16:23.837 --> 01:16:25.583
How many grams of sugar?
01:16:25.583 --> 01:16:51.479
And if you want to go by for sure, it has to be less than 40, then you have to evaluate that product as to whether it can be consumed and still maintain the 40 gram guideline. Going down to determine whether it's hyphructose corn syrup versus sucrose, to me that's kind of less important. I think it's more important just to be looking at that total sugar.
01:16:51.479 --> 01:17:48.000
And so added sugar, not total sugar, added sugar. So the next thing I want to ask you about is, you know, we talked about sugars primarily, simple sugars like fructose and glucose, glucose, table sugar sucrose, the combination of the two. What about those types of sugars compared to other forms of carbohydrate that ultimately get broken down into sugar. So if I'm eating starch, it gets broken down into glucose in my body. There are the so-called complex carbohydrates. What are the difference between these things? And does that difference ultimately matter? Or does it all just become sugar? And we should think of it that way. It does matter with regard to your form of starch. Are you eating refined starch or are you eating whole grains as close to natural as possible?
01:17:48.000 --> 01:23:32.000
If you are eating whole grains as close to natural as possible, the delivery of that substrate into your blood is way slower than if you're eating white bread, white rice, refined starch. Basically starch is one of the, it's just like sugar. How sad it is that we've taken natural foods, isolated and pure fried the sugar and that sugar is now a major source of calories for the world. Okay. We've done kind of the same thing with our even when we're not stripping it down to sugar, we're taking these grain products and stripping out all the good stuff and leaving only refined starch. Is that refined starch better for you than sugar? Yes. But usually the person that's eating refined starch is also eating sugar and then Then what you have is a very refined ultra-process diet in which it's really hard to figure out where all the damage is coming from. From the sugar, from the ultra-process starch, from the fat, we do know that diet is a disaster. Right. Most people out there are eating the industrial diet. the eating process foods of all kinds, added sugars, processed grains and all the rest. There's really probably no one out there that's eliminating added sugars from the diet, but they're also eating white bread. You're probably getting all of these things. Right. Exactly. Well, that's not completely true. I know many people... people eat healthy but also really love their sourdough bread and can live with that. Absolutely live with that. But I do think our tendency to eat from packages rather than cooking from whole grains, beans, food is part of our epidemic of metabolic disease. You know, so the sugar is definitely a player, but to get rid of sugar and replace it with potato chips and refined bread and rice and it's possible to do that. There are you know it is possible to live a life of oh I don't eat sugar at at all. But I eat crackers, package crackers, package chips, you know, those are lunch in dinner. Breakfast, it's pop tart. No, I guess pop tarts would have the sugar in it. But maybe an ago waffle doesn't have that much. Yeah. Is it, I mean, would you say that it's fair to say that if someone was working to eliminate processed foods from their diet So you're getting as close to no added sugars as possible. So in other words, you're getting whatever sugars you do eat from whole foods like fruits. If you're getting to that point and you are getting most of your sugar intake from whole food sources, natural sources of sugar like fruit, can you, is it, once you get to that point, can you just kind of stop worrying about less because they're almost baked in guardrails because the fruit has the fiber and has the other things that are going to regulate your satiety and your consumption better than the processed foods with added sugars that you perhaps don't need to think about it as strenuously and think about the grams you're eating
every day, if you're at least taking efforts to make sure it's only coming from the whole food sources. I would say that's great with regard to monitoring sugar and it's also great and a practical way. The easiest way to get off the the high sugar diet is one, get it out of your house. And therefore, by not buying any project products with added sugar really helps on those moments where you're kind of in a funk and you really feel like pampering yourself and the easiest way to do that is grabbing a high sugar comfort food. So getting those out of the house is a good way to start, but you also have to learn to resist the sugar at the checkstand, the hardwurst or I mean you can't go anywhere where there's not packages easy to consume high sugar products right in front of you everywhere you go. But starting at the house is the best way to start and not buying high sugar foods is how you do it.
01:23:32.000 --> 01:23:41.502
What are you still doing this kind of clinical research today? And if so, what are you working on right now?
01:23:41.502 --> 01:25:55.954
No, my last study ended one year ago and it was comparing sugar sweetened beverage. In this case, it was super sweetened beverage with plain and simple orange juice. That's the study we just did. It was our a very well controlled study to the best of our ability in that we provided all dietary items our subjects consumed for six weeks. So everything that they ate, they didn't go home many other stuff. They went home, but they went home with our food. Got it. And so we no longer have a clinical research center where we can house subjects. Basically NIH stopped funding that kind of work because it was just so astronomically expensive. But our next best thing was to provide all the diet ourselves. But of course, we cannot watch our subjects all day long and know they consumed only our diet and the diet we provided. But we actually think they did and the reason we think they did is nobody gained weight the entire study. fact over that six-week period, both groups averaged a half kilo weight loss. So we do rather think most of the subjects were highly compliant and only ate our food. Most of them were college students and college students are very happy to have free food. And so what did you find in that study or in others with respected juice because I did want to ask you about juice. You know, we talked about whole fruits. We talked about sugar sweet beverages like soda. And then maybe in between you might say you've got fruit juice. It's made from fruit. It, you know, people think of it as a healthy food.
01:25:55.954 --> 01:26:02.819
Where does it land in terms of its effects and its sugar content and all that?
01:26:02.819 --> 01:26:33.000
I'm going to tell you, but it might make my, um, colleague who's going to first author this paper annoyed because this is my first public telling of the data and basically it surprised me a lot. First of all, let's start with the differences. The differences
were, or uric acid goes down with orange juice. Wow. Significantly and impressively.
01:26:33.000 --> 01:26:37.605
And what kind of orange juice are we talking about here?
01:26:37.605 --> 01:26:41.717
It was tropical, premium, low or no pulp, I think.
01:26:41.717 --> 01:26:42.539
Oh really?
01:26:42.539 --> 01:27:06.555
So it's tropical and it's no or low pulp. It's not like fresh squeezed in your kitchen or. We've wanted it to be the most relevant possible orange juice. And this is the best selling brand. And that's what we picked. And it was a great brand to pick because it was always available at Costco.
01:27:06.555 --> 01:27:41.342
And so that's where we got it. We just bought our intervention food straight off the Costco shelf. So that was a surprise that the Uric acid did not just go up. it significantly went down. Okay. Our second news that kind of makes orange juice look good, is the fact that both of the sugar sweeten beverages caused a novalype genesis to go up, but it went up much higher with the sucrose and that difference was significant.
01:27:41.342 --> 01:27:50.636
So sucrose caused the Nova Lipeogenesis to go up more than orange juice did, but they both caused it to increase.
01:27:50.636 --> 01:28:03.384
And can remind me here, what is the sugar content we're talking about here? Is it comparable? How is it different in the orange juice than the other thing?
01:28:03.384 --> 01:31:22.000
We made it as comparable as possible, but we called it this. We made it comparable by saying they were matched for total carbohydrate content, which might make for a one percent difference between the two. Right. It's when you're talking about a natural product that's simply being put in a thing, you don't we are certainly weren't going to analyze every single batch of orange juice to your same grams of carbohydrate and both dry the same number of grams of carbohydrate. And what does the sugar profile of the orange juice look like in terms of sucrose, glucose fructose. It is pretty much I think if I remember right 49.51 and I think it was fructose 51% and the glucose it was really close to 50. Right yeah whereas if it had been apple juice that would have been much, much higher in fructose than the sucrose would have been. Well, okay. And so... So headline results here. Very similar levels of overall carbohydrate sugar content. Both of them close to 50, 50 glucose fructose. The sucrose sweetened beverage caused more de novo lipogenesis and an increase in uric acid. And the orange juice caused a smaller increase in lipogenesis, but actually a decrease in uric acid. Very significant decrease in the idea as to why that would be. Well, the analysis shows that it is the vitamin C in orange juice that tracks closest to the change. We also, you know, we did a lot of targeted meta-belomax and which we were focused on the polyphenols in orange juice that we thought would be most likely to be mediating positive effects. And they weren't related to that improvement, those improvements. It was the vitamin C. I see. So you don't know for sure, but the effect was big, significant decrease in uric acid with orange juice. You looked at a bunch of stuff. You did Metabolomics, which basically means you measured a bunch of things in the orange juice and you said, what relates, what correlates with the uric acid decrease the best. A lot of stuff that you thought might didn't really relate to it and the thing that stuck out the most, which could be part of the explanation, is the vitamin C content. Right. Exactly. Now, that was the good news. The news that surprised me and I wasn't expecting was both of them increased lipoproteins and triglycerides and it was the same in both. Significant increases in the LDL, the APOB, the post-prandial triglycerides, with no difference between the two groups.
01:31:22.000 --> 01:31:35.239
Got it, got it. Interesting. So different pattern of changes, even though the carbohydrate and total sugar content is very close to the same, right?
01:31:35.239 --> 01:32:32.314
The orange juice had a different pattern of effects than the sucrose, sweet and beverage. Yeah, and so it's also interesting to evaluate my study that, remember I just said over the course of the study, my subjects lost weight. only a little bit. So everybody was either in energy balance or slight negative energy balance, but we still saw increases in risk factors. And that is important because I can give you a stack this big of research papers saying it's clear the effects of sugar are related to excess calories, not to inherent effects of sugar on metabolism. And this study clearly shows, no, that's not true. Yeah, it's the one.
01:32:32.314 --> 01:36:53.000
Yeah. Another way of saying that perhaps is you can't use maintaining your weight or even losing a little bit of weight as a proxy for everything's all good. Right. Yes. It's probably better than the person that's gaining weight and that is true because some of the effects we saw like on liver fat. We saw a tiny increase in liver fat in the subjects consuming the sucrose sweetened beverage that just missed being significant by tea test, whereas normally I see significant increases in subjects on ad lib diet. And so that shows you that the positive versus slight negative energy balance probably had an effect. Yeah, yeah, that makes sense. I mean, what can you tell me about juices more generally? You know, we talked about fatty liver disease and how it's going up in small children. We think of juices as being healthy, certainly healthier than soda's. We give lots of little kids, lots of juice boxes, including apple juice, which you mentioned earlier. What do we know about juices generally, especially as it relates to small children if we know anything about that, but should we think about that? Well, it's a shockingly little to the best of my knowledge. My study raised that represents the first very clear, well-controlled, randomized, controlled trial
study to look at this question over a long period of time and people who consume the identical diet. We need more studies like that but that study cost NIH basically close to $4 million dollars and getting funding like that from NIH is incredibly difficult. And you ask me what I'm doing now, well I'm retiring because I was unsuccessful as many positive results that I have generated with my NIH studies. You're supposed to be able to take those positive results, show your making progress and easily get more funding to do answer more questions. When it comes to sugar, it just doesn't work out that way. It was really each time I got a new study. it was really, I did not have success just renewing that grant by asking another question each time I had to start fresh with a whole new protocol, a whole new method to get NIH interested. and you're an established researcher, you're not a brand new researcher, you've already gotten results and published good papers. So I guess that just gives people a sense for how difficult it is to be successful and continue to get funding even when your Kimber Stanhope who's done an entire career of NIH's funded studies. Well, and the very last study, no actually my second of last study that I really wanted to do, And I really thought I was submitting a work of genius. Didn't get funded because for the first time, I chose to work with adolescents. I wanted to study kids 14 to 18. And the reason I wanted to study this group because my study was incorporated functional MRI, so I wanted to look at reward responses, but also risk factors. But my control beverage was milk rather than as per tame.
01:36:53.000 --> 01:39:43.000
So I wanted to look at sugar sweeten beverages versus milk, and then equal calorie situation, equals sugar situation. And the reason I did the biggest criticism of the study was after all that clinical work I've done I had no proof that I could do a study in subjects 14 to 18 year olds. I never thought for a second anybody would doubt that studying 18 to 40 year olds would not qualify me to study 14 to 18 year olds. And it didn't occur to me that I needed to somehow run all over campus and find somebody who's done studies in 14 to 18 year olds. Right, right. Wow. So those are the kind of criticisms you can run into even when you're established. Yeah. And sometimes the criticisms feel like they just don't think it's an important question. And for sugar research, I've gotten many reviewers saying, so what with regard to what you're hoping to find, people are going to eat sugar anyway. It's not going to make a difference. And maybe that's true. But I think it's possible we're seeing you know slow trends over time that suggests that people are being a little more prudent, certainly not as much as they need to be. Yeah, but people's people's the trends in intake do change over time they've changed many ways over many years. Right. They are going down. So the idea of being you're in need to study. Yeah. Who needs to study? Sure. Because people aren't getting to have a change is really the comment from a reviewer who just doesn't want to hear the results and doesn't think they're important. Yeah, yeah. And nothing you can do about that, you can design the best study in the world. And of course there are definitely times when it's very clear, let's say the reviewer from a paper I submitted for publication that this reviewer is clearly aligned with the sugar industry. and somewhat. Well, I wanted to ask you about that.
01:39:43.000 --> 01:39:59.891
Yeah, what does that look like? Can you give us some examples of what that actually looks like? Where does that funding come from and how prevalent is it?
01:39:59.891 --> 01:41:27.092
Well, supposedly you are absolutely not supposed to review a paper on sugar if you have any Connect. with the sugar industry. The researcher who I am convinced wrote and got my last paper rejected and the reason I know what's him is his paper, his review was actually almost a cut and paste of his review article. But he gets to claim no conflicts of interest because he hasn't received any funding from the sugar industry, corn refiner, ABA, you know, American Beverage Association in the last five years. Well, how difficult is it for the sugar industry to have a system where they have designated scientists and say, we of course will not be paying you for five years. Right. But for every review article, you write, crashing the science, suggesting sugar has negative health effects, you get
01:41:27.092 --> 01:43:34.000
X amount of money in six years. Five years. Yeah. And you do that. That's what is this? Is this hypothetical or do you know that that type of? But here's why I think it happened. Okay. Yeah, tell us this. Okay. I Was invited I don't know four years ago. I can't remember to invite right a commentary for nature cardiology which I happily did and This commentary was basically defending the science that supported the guidelines to decrease sugar consumption. And in that, I very specifically discussed a review written by a researcher called Edward Archer, whose name is Edward Archer, who's Attack on the science was the strongest of anybody I've ever, ever read, but also in my mind, the weakest, absolutely incredibly weak. So I addressed his review. And it got published along with the rest of the commentary. And in no time of all, he wrote a letter to the editor. The editor then gets a hold of me and asks me if I want to write a rebuttal. And I wrote the rebuttal to his letter. And again, I felt like his letter was so beneath a scientist that it made so little sense. For example, breast milk has sugar. Therefore, its clear sugar isn't dangerous.
01:43:34.000 --> 01:44:13.771
Well, breast milk has glucose and it doesn't have fructose. And you know, right, it really feels like it's argued he was reaching for arguments wherever he could is what you're saying exactly. And so his arguments were so easy to robot. I quickly sent
in this rebottle letter and the editor wrote back. Thanks. He will now see the rebuttal letter and he will decide whether he wants his Letter and the rebuttal letter published he gets to decide Right and my first reaction was
01:44:13.771 --> 01:44:27.779
Well, why didn't you tell me that in the first place? I was the bother to write it Right what's the point of having an editor and a third party? overseeing it the what?
01:44:27.779 --> 01:45:18.807
Yeah, I But see, I thought I knew what was gonna happen. I thought that my letter was so scientific, my rebuttal letter was so scientifically sound that he would fill silly and withdraw his letter. And that I had written my letter for no reason. The editor answered, I don't think so. And the editor was right. this guy allowed what I consider to be and an absolute embarrassing scientific document to be published right next to my letter describing why that was an embarrassing scientific document. And yeah, I don't know where it's just going yet, but where my mind is going right now is, why would he do that?
01:45:18.807 --> 01:45:22.394
Why would you embarrass yourself like that?
01:45:22.394 --> 01:45:26.895
Well, perhaps he's got... You're frozen at the moment.
01:45:26.895 --> 01:45:39.237
Oh, can you hear me? Oh, one second. Okay, Kimber, you got it. Oh, we froze. Give us one second here, folks. You might be a hiccup. Can you hear me?
01:45:39.237 --> 01:45:51.659
Yeah, that was a hiccup. So I'm wondering, does he have a certain number of papers that maybe someone wants him to get out there? That is in my mind.
01:45:51.659 --> 01:45:54.994
And when you said, is this hypothetical?
01:45:54.994 --> 01:51:02.000
This is the only proof I have. You can't prove it. And of course, no one is ever going to be able to prove these things because you don't know what private business deals someone has and what the terms are. But this is regardless of what's going on behind the scenes. This is certainly bizarre behavior. Right. And so that happened. And then two years later, my paper gets sent to this guy. And I know it's him because all the same arguments are in the review. So he's reviewing, he's reviewing your grant proposal and saying no, he was reviewing my data, my, my, my paper for publication at a very high journal. A journal that I never thought for a second would send this article to someone like that guy. Yeah. Yeah. But I discussed it with my best friend, Gemini. And Gemini said that reviewer journal article journal editors often try to find somebody who's going to have a conflicting opinion, which is fine, which is fine. But then you better make sure that conflicting opinion is scientifically grounded. And that's not what the circulation editor did. Instead, he said, Oh, her paper makes this guy so angry who wants the controversy never mind. Yeah. And people just so people know, people might be surprised, right? The presumption that you would naturally make is that all of these journal editors at nature and science and all these places, they're going to sit down and they're going to carefully look at both sides and they're going to carefully read the context of the surrounding literature and they're going to make an educated decision. But very often it's not like that. Very often they're just like this person says this, this person says that, there's no agreement. They don't really necessarily understand the field and the details of the field and then just make editorial decisions without really understanding the science. Right. And also I think editor decisions are also being influenced by the need to generate citations in hits. And therefore, I can do the most carefully designed study on sugar have the strongest most significant data ever seen, and send it to a high journal and not get it published. But another researcher can send a really badly, badly conducted study on a artificial sweetener that shows artificial sweeteners have negative effects and that will get published in a second. Because that's going to generate media coverage. Everybody loves to see the bad effects. Oh, you say I shouldn't eat sugar and so I'm supposed to have a sugar replacement instead. Well, they're just as bad. That is the kind of headline that generates clicks and generates, you know, all metric scores. Right. Right. Right. Yeah. Well, we talked about a lot today, including your research on sugar and related stuff. Are there any final thoughts you want to leave people with about dietary sugar and dietary fructose before we sign off? Oh, God, you are very, very extensive. So I can't think of any of my favorite points that usually I have to say, oh yes, because we do I don't think that's anything's coming to mind. We really covered a lot. And so great job. Thank you. Thank you. But in your view, added sugars are definitely something to think about. The fructose content of your diet is definitely something to think about. And you know, whatever the details and the magic cutoff might be that we point people to. to. It seems like you think that limiting added sugar intake in general is a good idea and that there's good evidence to back that up. And getting off the ultra-process foods to as much as possible is also a very good idea. All right, well, Professor Kimber, Stan Hope, Thank you very much for your time. Thank you so much Nick. Bye bye.
01:51:02.000 --> 01:52:52.867
Everyone, a great way to support my efforts is to visit my support page at mind and matter dot sub stack.com. A link to that page is in the episode description, or you can search for it on the sub-stack page itself. The support page has an up to date list of my affiliate partners. These are companies I work with and if you buy those products through those links or using the discount codes provided, those will get you a great deal on a variety of products related to optimizing physical, metabolic, or mental health and vitality. These are all products I use myself and some of them are directly related to podcast episodes or formulated by Mind and Matter guests. For example, there's a great product called Keto Sitra formulated by a kidney biologist who is on episode number 186. It contains the ketone body BHB together with several minerals in a precise ratio formulated with kidney health in mind. There are also links to products like physical technology devices to track your metabolic health, digital applications to help you find and learn about food and consumer products and more. One product I use every day is the Aqua True water filter. I recommend this to everyone because it gets everything out of your drinking water. heavy metals, microbes, endocrine disruptors, microplastics, you name it. Other charcoal or gravity based filters that a lot of people use don't get everything out, they just get some of the stuff out. So I really like the AquaTru product. You can look for a link to my affiliate partners on my support page or directly in the episode description to this episode, or you can go to mindandmatter.substac.com to find it there.