BẢN CHÉP ÂM THANH 🔗
1
00:00:00,077 --> 00:00:01,942
>> Peter Robinson:
Historian Neil Ferguson,
2
00:00:01,942 --> 00:00:06,165
Professor Kotkin is always right,
that's rule number one.
3
00:00:06,165 --> 00:00:09,008
Rule number two, see rule number one.
4
00:00:09,008 --> 00:00:12,573
Professor Kotkin,
on Uncommon Knowledge, now.
5
00:00:12,573 --> 00:00:23,126
[MUSIC]
6
00:00:23,126 --> 00:00:25,910
>> Peter Robinson: Welcome to
Uncommon Knowledge, I'm Peter Robinson,
7
00:00:25,910 --> 00:00:27,994
a fellow here at the Hoover Institution.
8
00:00:27,994 --> 00:00:32,165
Stephen Kotkin is the author
of nine big works of history,
9
00:00:32,165 --> 00:00:37,018
including the first two volumes of
his biography of Joseph Stalin,
10
00:00:37,018 --> 00:00:43,769
Paradoxes of Power, 1878 to 1928, and
Waiting for Hitler, 1929 to 1941.
11
00:00:43,769 --> 00:00:47,215
Professor Kotkin is now completing,
you are, aren't you?
12
00:00:47,215 --> 00:00:53,536
Is now completing the third and final
volume, Stalin, Totalitarian Superpower.
13
00:00:53,536 --> 00:00:56,446
And because he has so
much time on his hands,
14
00:00:56,446 --> 00:01:00,863
he's amusing himself by writing
a history of Siberia on the side.
15
00:01:00,863 --> 00:01:05,999
A believer in the application of
history to contemporary policy-making,
16
00:01:05,999 --> 00:01:11,378
Stephen Kotkins consults widely and
finds himself inundated with requests for
17
00:01:11,378 --> 00:01:14,440
interviews, but
he accepts [COUGH] very few.
18
00:01:14,440 --> 00:01:20,062
[LAUGH] Stephen, thank you for joining us.
19
00:01:20,062 --> 00:01:21,415
>> Stephen Kotkin: Thank you.
20
00:01:21,415 --> 00:01:25,700
>> Peter Robinson: Five questions for
Stephen Kotkin, here's the first one.
21
00:01:25,700 --> 00:01:31,388
The coup attempt, June 24,
under the command of Yevgeny Prigozhin,
22
00:01:31,388 --> 00:01:35,118
the Wagner group,
a private Russian militia,
23
00:01:35,118 --> 00:01:39,333
occupies Russian military
headquarters in Rostov.
24
00:01:39,333 --> 00:01:40,083
>> Stephen Kotkin: Rostov.
25
00:01:40,083 --> 00:01:42,013
>> Peter Robinson: Rostov, thank you.
26
00:01:42,013 --> 00:01:46,220
Prigozhin uploads a video calling the
Russian oligarchy crooked and corrupt, and
27
00:01:46,220 --> 00:01:47,908
the war in Ukraine unnecessary.
28
00:01:47,908 --> 00:01:52,332
Then he sends an armored
column north toward Moscow.
29
00:01:52,332 --> 00:01:55,858
The column shoots down several
Russian aircraft as it advances.
30
00:01:55,858 --> 00:02:01,132
President Putin appears on television
to denounce the men he calls traitors.
31
00:02:01,132 --> 00:02:06,288
Once the force gets about two thirds
of the way to Moscow, they turn around.
32
00:02:06,288 --> 00:02:11,586
Prigozhin disappears,
reportedly leaving Russia for Balarussia.
33
00:02:11,586 --> 00:02:14,580
Putin reassures the country
that order has been restored.
34
00:02:14,580 --> 00:02:19,984
[COUGH] Stephen Kotkin in foreign affairs,
interviewed on June 24th,
35
00:02:19,984 --> 00:02:25,654
as the coup attempt was taking place,
quote, after all the Sturm und Drag,
36
00:02:25,654 --> 00:02:30,548
drawing, we could be right back
where we started, close quote.
37
00:02:30,548 --> 00:02:36,338
Stephen, what happened, and
are we right back where we started?
38
00:02:39,064 --> 00:02:43,903
>> Stephen Kotkin: So,
Prigozhin had a catering business.
39
00:02:43,903 --> 00:02:48,978
It was pretty successful because he got
Kremlin contracts and then military
40
00:02:48,978 --> 00:02:54,368
contracts, and like many government
contracts, there were no bid contracts,
41
00:02:54,368 --> 00:02:58,510
meaning he didn't have to be
better than the other caterers.
42
00:02:58,510 --> 00:03:04,354
So you have a business that's making
money, you need some protection.
43
00:03:04,354 --> 00:03:10,056
So he establishes a little bit of
protection for himself and his businesses.
44
00:03:10,056 --> 00:03:12,632
That turns out to be
an even bigger business.
45
00:03:12,632 --> 00:03:18,420
That's a mercenary army, and
turns out that there's minerals in Africa.
46
00:03:18,420 --> 00:03:19,776
Who knew?
47
00:03:19,776 --> 00:03:22,939
And so he gets into that business as well.
48
00:03:22,939 --> 00:03:29,267
And so pretty soon,
he's a multibillion dollar business.
49
00:03:29,267 --> 00:03:34,470
And in the beginning of June,
the defense minister
50
00:03:34,470 --> 00:03:42,102
announces that these businesses will
now report to the defense ministry.
51
00:03:42,102 --> 00:03:46,525
So let's imagine that, I don't know,
you build Microsoft or
52
00:03:46,525 --> 00:03:49,278
you build Apple or you build whatever,
53
00:03:49,278 --> 00:03:54,462
it's built a little differently here
than over in Russia, but imagine.
54
00:03:54,462 --> 00:03:58,689
And all of a sudden the secretary
of defense announces, well,
55
00:03:58,689 --> 00:04:04,209
it's a great business, I own that business
now, and we don't need you anymore.
56
00:04:04,209 --> 00:04:07,866
So he decides he's not gonna
give up his businesses.
57
00:04:07,866 --> 00:04:13,563
He's gonna march on, first the military
headquarters for the war in Ukraine,
58
00:04:13,563 --> 00:04:18,593
which is in the south of Russia, and
then he's gonna march on Moscow.
59
00:04:18,593 --> 00:04:22,869
And he's got armed fighters
with heavy weapons, and
60
00:04:22,869 --> 00:04:25,728
Moscow is defended by riot police.
61
00:04:25,728 --> 00:04:31,806
Riot police are fine if you're just
beating up demonstrators with no weapons,
62
00:04:31,806 --> 00:04:33,903
they can get that job done.
63
00:04:33,903 --> 00:04:38,085
But against people with heavy weapons,
who are battle hardened,
64
00:04:38,085 --> 00:04:40,182
it's a different proposition.
65
00:04:40,182 --> 00:04:46,680
So Prigozhin starts marching, not himself,
he stays in the headquarters, in a bunker,
66
00:04:46,680 --> 00:04:52,592
and he sends his men, about 8,000,
and they're closing in on the capital.
67
Load full transcript
00:04:52,592 --> 00:05:00,496
>> Peter Robinson: Putin went nose to
nose with a pretender and Putin blinked.
68
00:05:00,496 --> 00:05:01,567
>> Stephen Kotkin: Kind of.
69
00:05:01,567 --> 00:05:02,709
>> Peter Robinson: [LAUGH]
>> Stephen Kotkin: So,
70
00:05:02,709 --> 00:05:08,598
Prigozhin is not gonna give up
his businesses just like that,
71
00:05:08,598 --> 00:05:12,798
he didn't gain them without working hard.
72
00:05:12,798 --> 00:05:16,042
>> Peter Robinson: Hold on,
this was purely about money.
73
00:05:16,042 --> 00:05:18,640
>> Stephen Kotkin: No,
it's never purely about money in Russia.
74
00:05:18,640 --> 00:05:22,867
Money and
power is the same variable in Russia, but
75
00:05:22,867 --> 00:05:25,534
you get money by being in power.
76
00:05:25,534 --> 00:05:30,038
Hank Paulson was at Goldman,
made his 500 million, and
77
00:05:30,038 --> 00:05:32,841
then he became treasury secretary.
78
00:05:32,841 --> 00:05:35,154
That's not the way you do it in Russia.
79
00:05:35,154 --> 00:05:40,394
First you become treasury secretary,
and then you make your 500 million.
80
00:05:40,394 --> 00:05:43,321
So you need to have connections to power.
81
00:05:43,321 --> 00:05:47,564
And by the way, he pays off everybody, so
82
00:05:47,564 --> 00:05:53,628
the people who are supposed to
stop him from taking Moscow,
83
00:05:53,628 --> 00:05:56,306
they're on his payroll.
84
00:05:56,306 --> 00:05:57,692
This is Russia.
85
00:05:57,692 --> 00:06:03,455
And so what we see is,
people don't rally around Putin and
86
00:06:03,455 --> 00:06:07,576
his regime while this group is marching.
87
00:06:07,576 --> 00:06:14,649
The military doesn't come out and
make statements, they don't send troops.
88
00:06:14,649 --> 00:06:21,012
There's no rallying of the political
forces around Putin with statements.
89
00:06:21,012 --> 00:06:23,134
Everyone's playing a waiting game.
90
00:06:23,134 --> 00:06:26,891
Maybe this guy could be successful,
maybe not.
91
00:06:26,891 --> 00:06:31,248
So you have three pieces to the regime
that are important to know.
92
00:06:31,248 --> 00:06:37,616
First, you got the aura, the mystique,
the fact that you are the power,
93
00:06:37,616 --> 00:06:42,653
therefore you know more,
you're watching everything,
94
00:06:42,653 --> 00:06:46,682
you're infallible in your decision making.
95
00:06:46,682 --> 00:06:52,269
So that mystique, that aura,
he lost already, way before these events,
96
00:06:52,269 --> 00:06:58,140
he lost it in Ukraine, because the war
has been such a catastrophe for Russia.
97
00:06:58,140 --> 00:07:02,761
So he destroyed his own aura and
mystique, so that didn't change,
98
00:07:02,761 --> 00:07:04,716
that had already happened.
99
00:07:04,716 --> 00:07:09,914
And the credit for that goes to
the Ukrainians, in their resistance,
100
00:07:09,914 --> 00:07:13,714
their courage, their ingenuity,
they did that.
101
00:07:13,714 --> 00:07:17,550
The other piece, though,
is the levers of power, right?
102
00:07:17,550 --> 00:07:21,360
So you lose your aura, but
you're still sitting in the Kremlin.
103
00:07:21,360 --> 00:07:27,535
So you've got control over the television
stations, the security police,
104
00:07:27,535 --> 00:07:32,761
the tax police, there's nothing
you don't have control over.
105
00:07:32,761 --> 00:07:35,907
The gas industry, the central bank,
106
00:07:35,907 --> 00:07:39,742
there's no reason for
Putin to steal money and
107
00:07:39,742 --> 00:07:44,578
put it abroad, because all
the money is his if he wants it.
108
00:07:44,578 --> 00:07:46,668
So that's what the Kremlin is.
109
00:07:46,668 --> 00:07:51,328
So no mystique, no aura, that's gone,
but the levers of power.
110
00:07:51,328 --> 00:07:55,717
But then here's the third piece,
the third piece is,
111
00:07:55,717 --> 00:07:59,639
what's the alternative,
if any, to this guy?
112
00:07:59,639 --> 00:08:05,122
Is this, Guy forever or
could we imagine somebody else?
113
00:08:05,122 --> 00:08:08,054
And maybe that somebody
else could be better.
114
00:08:08,054 --> 00:08:13,046
Maybe that somebody else could
get us out of the situation that
115
00:08:13,046 --> 00:08:14,870
this guy's got us in.
116
00:08:14,870 --> 00:08:19,717
So the other people are watching is
Prigozhin, that somebody else, especially,
117
00:08:19,717 --> 00:08:24,426
because they're on his payroll, not
because they're doing that much for him,
118
00:08:24,426 --> 00:08:27,840
but just because he's got to
keep all his flanks covered.
119
00:08:27,840 --> 00:08:31,507
So the so called FSB,
the security service,
120
00:08:31,507 --> 00:08:35,668
that's the successor to the KGB,
I'm guessing.
121
00:08:35,668 --> 00:08:38,613
I mean, they haven't shown me
the paperwork for some reason, but
122
00:08:38,613 --> 00:08:40,830
I'm guessing those guys
are on the payroll here.
123
00:08:40,830 --> 00:08:44,270
If you have a multibillion
dollar business, and those are.
124
00:08:44,270 --> 00:08:47,917
That's the security apparatus
they're gonna wanna cut.
125
00:08:47,917 --> 00:08:53,049
And so the idea about maybe
somebody could be better,
126
00:08:53,049 --> 00:08:58,525
that's his conundrum, you see,
because if he empowers
127
00:08:58,525 --> 00:09:03,789
somebody else to crack down and
to destroy prigozhin.
128
00:09:03,789 --> 00:09:07,748
If he empowers somebody
to put the lid back on,
129
00:09:07,748 --> 00:09:12,834
all of a sudden people think
that person looks pretty good.
130
00:09:12,834 --> 00:09:17,713
That person can not only put the lid
back on against this crazy coup,
131
00:09:17,713 --> 00:09:21,751
but could, in fact,
replace the Tsar and the Kremlin.
132
00:09:21,751 --> 00:09:26,852
So the dilemma for him is the same way he
got into the pickle in the first place.
133
00:09:26,852 --> 00:09:32,009
You appoint loyalists who are incompetent
because they're not smart enough
134
00:09:32,009 --> 00:09:37,097
to take you down, but then you have
incompetent people running your stuff.
135
00:09:37,097 --> 00:09:42,979
But if you appoint somebody who's
decisive, well, that person's decisive.
136
00:09:42,979 --> 00:09:44,689
And that third piece.
137
00:09:44,689 --> 00:09:47,689
This guy might be better.
138
00:09:47,689 --> 00:09:50,368
And so that's the big upshot from this.
139
00:09:50,368 --> 00:09:51,619
>> Peter Robinson: Stephen,
140
00:09:51,619 --> 00:09:57,742
you are describing exactly
the dynamics of the mob.
141
00:09:57,742 --> 00:10:01,897
This is the way they talk to each other
on all those tapes that the FBI pulled
142
00:10:01,897 --> 00:10:04,729
together on the Mulberry
street with John Gotti.
143
00:10:04,729 --> 00:10:07,723
>> Stephen Kotkin: Yeah, well, so I'm
from New York and I worked in New Jersey.
144
00:10:07,723 --> 00:10:09,118
I mean [LAUGH].
145
00:10:09,118 --> 00:10:11,722
It's not like it's a father.
146
00:10:11,722 --> 00:10:16,195
And I watched the Godfather way back then,
and I even read the book.
147
00:10:16,195 --> 00:10:19,291
>> Peter Robinson: Serious
question about Russia.
148
00:10:19,291 --> 00:10:24,918
George Kennan in 1947,
in his famous article on foreign affairs,
149
00:10:24,918 --> 00:10:29,888
Kennan argued that the Soviets
had to treat the outside world as
150
00:10:29,888 --> 00:10:34,688
hostile because doing so
provided the only justification.
151
00:10:34,688 --> 00:10:38,761
Now, I'm going to quote Kennan, quote, for
152
00:10:38,761 --> 00:10:44,402
the dictatorship, without which
they did not know how to rule,
153
00:10:44,402 --> 00:10:48,685
for cruelties they did
not dare not inflict, for
154
00:10:48,685 --> 00:10:52,153
sacrifices they felt bound to demand.
155
00:10:52,153 --> 00:10:54,595
The dictatorship they did not know,
156
00:10:54,595 --> 00:10:57,520
without which they did
not know how to rule.
157
00:10:57,520 --> 00:11:03,425
Ivan the terrible, Peter the Great,
your boy, Joseph Stalin, Vladimir Putin.
158
00:11:03,425 --> 00:11:06,395
This has been going on for centuries.
159
00:11:06,395 --> 00:11:09,820
Imperial Japan gives way
to a liberal democracy.
160
00:11:09,820 --> 00:11:14,000
Nazi Germany gives way to a stable,
liberal democracy.
161
00:11:14,000 --> 00:11:20,160
Russia is the Russia of a thousand years,
why?
162
00:11:20,160 --> 00:11:22,105
What is it about, a serious question.
163
00:11:22,105 --> 00:11:24,486
What is it about Russia?
164
00:11:24,486 --> 00:11:28,155
>> Stephen Kotkin: So here is that
other piece, that third piece,
165
00:11:28,155 --> 00:11:34,028
the alternative piece, because for
us, the alternative to authoritarian
166
00:11:34,028 --> 00:11:39,186
regime is what happened in Japan or
what happened in West Germany.
167
00:11:39,186 --> 00:11:43,671
It is the possibility of democracy,
or rule of law, or
168
00:11:43,671 --> 00:11:48,360
constitutional order,
however you wanna describe it.
169
00:11:48,360 --> 00:11:53,517
But in the Russian case,
the alternative to the power
170
00:11:53,517 --> 00:11:58,453
in the Kremlin is chaos,
collapse, apocalypse.
171
00:11:58,453 --> 00:12:03,888
And so Putin is a calamity,
he's a disaster.
172
00:12:03,888 --> 00:12:06,903
But the alternative to him is potentially,
173
00:12:06,903 --> 00:12:12,452
in the minds of the people around him,
dissolution, loss of the Russian state.
174
00:12:12,452 --> 00:12:17,218
And so as bad as he is, and
he is calamitous across the board,
175
00:12:17,218 --> 00:12:21,618
the alternative, in their mind,
could be much worse.
176
00:12:21,618 --> 00:12:27,607
And so they're kind of stuck in this
inability to get to an alternative
177
00:12:27,607 --> 00:12:32,593
that's viable,
that doesn't equal collapse or chaos.
178
00:12:32,593 --> 00:12:37,638
So there are six possible futures
to Russia, and there have been for
179
00:12:37,638 --> 00:12:41,456
a really long time,
maybe at least this is my view.
180
00:12:41,456 --> 00:12:45,122
The first one is France.
181
00:12:45,122 --> 00:12:52,400
You have absolutist monarchy,
big bureaucracy.
182
00:12:52,400 --> 00:12:59,059
You have a revolutionary tradition,
really messy, bloody and messy.
183
00:12:59,059 --> 00:13:03,700
You're threatening your neighbors,
right, Napoleon.
184
00:13:03,700 --> 00:13:07,238
You blink your eye, it takes a while, and
185
00:13:07,238 --> 00:13:11,697
then you've overcome your
absolutist tradition.
186
00:13:11,697 --> 00:13:15,494
You still have a big bureaucracy because
you're descended from an absolutist
187
00:13:15,494 --> 00:13:18,552
tradition, but
you're not an absolutist monarchy anymore.
188
00:13:18,552 --> 00:13:21,820
Your revolutionary tradition
has settled down, and
189
00:13:21,820 --> 00:13:24,949
you're not threatening
your neighbors anymore.
190
00:13:24,949 --> 00:13:31,125
And so France, now we can argue that
there are imperfections in France,
191
00:13:31,125 --> 00:13:34,782
and some of us may not
see France as a model.
192
00:13:34,782 --> 00:13:38,898
We're just talking about Russia and
France.
193
00:13:38,898 --> 00:13:42,390
And so what we've got in Russia,
if it got to France,
194
00:13:42,390 --> 00:13:44,725
that would be a major achievement.
195
00:13:44,725 --> 00:13:47,287
So that's been the story for a long time.
196
00:13:47,287 --> 00:13:51,505
Can they get to France, now you can
look at where they are now, and
197
00:13:51,505 --> 00:13:53,806
you can see where France is now, and
198
00:13:53,806 --> 00:13:57,977
you can see that the distance to
travel there is not that slight.
199
00:13:57,977 --> 00:14:00,235
But anyway, that's the good outcome.
200
00:14:00,235 --> 00:14:04,996
That solves not only the war in Ukraine,
but it solves the Russia problem as well,
201
00:14:04,996 --> 00:14:08,446
because they can be who they are,
just like the French, but
202
00:14:08,446 --> 00:14:11,280
they don't threaten
their neighbors anymore.
203
00:14:11,280 --> 00:14:18,090
Okay, so France,
the second option is authoritarian leader,
204
00:14:18,090 --> 00:14:22,131
but
don't threaten your neighbors.
205
00:14:22,131 --> 00:14:27,620
In other words, solve the Ukraine problem,
but not the Russia problem.
206
00:14:27,620 --> 00:14:31,100
You're still stuck with some
type of authoritarianism,
207
00:14:31,100 --> 00:14:33,096
which is difficult to overcome.
208
00:14:33,096 --> 00:14:39,050
But you recognize that trying to take
over your neighbors is a losing game for
209
00:14:39,050 --> 00:14:42,035
Russia, not just for the neighbors.
210
00:14:42,035 --> 00:14:46,166
So authoritarianism, that's no
longer a threat to the neighbors.
211
00:14:46,166 --> 00:14:51,110
The distance to that is much shorter,
and that's actually the potential
212
00:14:51,110 --> 00:14:55,416
solution to the Ukraine situation
over a longer period of time,
213
00:14:55,416 --> 00:14:58,865
that would be winning the peace,
not just the war.
214
00:14:58,865 --> 00:15:06,200
Your third one, which is relatively new,
is Chinese puppet regime.
215
00:15:06,200 --> 00:15:11,986
This sounds absurd, how could we get
a Chinese puppet regime in Russia?
216
00:15:11,986 --> 00:15:15,456
Stalin was the big brother,
Mao was the little brother, etc.
217
00:15:15,456 --> 00:15:19,550
But the Chinese interest in Russia,
218
00:15:19,550 --> 00:15:25,227
as we've seen now over
the past couple of decades,
219
00:15:25,227 --> 00:15:29,849
is very much a partner to be anti western,
220
00:15:29,849 --> 00:15:35,676
to protect China against
the existence of the west.
221
00:15:35,676 --> 00:15:40,443
Doesn't matter what the west does,
whether it promotes democracy or
222
00:15:40,443 --> 00:15:43,369
doesn't promote democracy, it exists.
223
00:15:43,369 --> 00:15:49,010
It exists as a successful alternative
that has resonance around the world,
224
00:15:49,010 --> 00:15:50,605
including in China.
225
00:15:50,605 --> 00:15:56,400
And so allowing Russia to fall
into that orbit is something
226
00:15:56,400 --> 00:16:01,142
that seems unlikely
the Chinese would permit.
227
00:16:01,142 --> 00:16:06,344
And so if their guy gets in trouble,
it's possible that they
228
00:16:06,344 --> 00:16:11,884
might want another guy who's not
in trouble and loyal to them.
229
00:16:11,884 --> 00:16:14,794
So, for example, Nikolai Patrushev,
230
00:16:14,794 --> 00:16:19,852
who is probably the most China
person inside the Russian regime.
231
00:16:19,852 --> 00:16:24,792
I think this would be a catastrophic
outcome for Russia, as well as for
232
00:16:24,792 --> 00:16:26,612
many other reasons.
233
00:16:26,612 --> 00:16:31,492
And you can judge how far away we
potentially are from that outcome.
234
00:16:31,492 --> 00:16:33,652
Let's go to number four.
235
00:16:33,652 --> 00:16:39,192
Number four is the biggest
North Korea you've ever seen.
236
00:16:40,892 --> 00:16:46,593
You've got an isolated place that is not
part of the international system and
237
00:16:46,593 --> 00:16:50,112
is therefore incentivized only for
mischief.
238
00:16:51,862 --> 00:16:54,762
And it's
mischief across the board.
239
00:16:55,782 --> 00:17:01,086
And the Chinese are okay with this
up to a point because it's not
240
00:17:01,086 --> 00:17:07,207
quite the puppet regime, but
it's not that far from the puppet regime.
241
00:17:07,207 --> 00:17:11,324
And the problem is like the Kim
dynasty in North Korea.
242
00:17:11,324 --> 00:17:15,760
They get away with things even though
they're completely dependent on China.
243
00:17:15,760 --> 00:17:18,953
Because China can't give up the north
244
00:17:18,953 --> 00:17:23,851
Korean regime because then it
gets a pro-US South Korea.
245
00:17:23,851 --> 00:17:24,388
>> Peter Robinson: Right.
246
00:17:24,388 --> 00:17:29,852
>> Stephen Kotkin: All the way up to the
Chinese border, and we win the Korean war.
247
00:17:29,852 --> 00:17:38,444
And so they tolerate the misbehavior
of their client in North Korea.
248
00:17:38,444 --> 00:17:42,702
And we have something similar to this
dynamic in the Russian case now.
249
00:17:42,702 --> 00:17:47,318
We have increasing isolation from
the world economy nowhere near as close as
250
00:17:47,318 --> 00:17:48,337
North Korea is.
251
00:17:48,337 --> 00:17:52,925
But much closer to North Korea's
than we were a year and a half ago.
252
00:17:52,925 --> 00:17:53,701
>> Peter Robinson: Right.
253
00:17:53,701 --> 00:18:00,022
>> Stephen Kotkin: And we have a person
in Moscow who gives the Chinese grief.
254
00:18:00,022 --> 00:18:03,602
He ruins their relations with Europe.
255
00:18:05,262 --> 00:18:06,236
In other words,
256
00:18:06,236 --> 00:18:11,102
the Europeans don't like the Chinese
support of the Russian war in Ukraine.
257
00:18:11,102 --> 00:18:16,507
And Xi Jinping announces that he,
through his great diplomacy,
258
00:18:16,507 --> 00:18:21,336
has gotten Russia to promise
not to use nuclear weapons.
259
00:18:21,336 --> 00:18:23,227
And the Chinese run this up to flagpole.
260
00:18:23,227 --> 00:18:26,933
And four days later, the Russians
announced that they're putting
261
00:18:26,933 --> 00:18:29,087
tactical nuclear weapons in Belarus.
262
00:18:29,087 --> 00:18:29,645
>> Peter Robinson: Right.
>> Stephen Kotkin: So
263
00:18:29,645 --> 00:18:34,365
there's your incipient north
Korean situation, potentially.
264
00:18:34,365 --> 00:18:38,672
This is the path we're currently on now.
265
00:18:38,672 --> 00:18:39,905
It's not a good path.
266
00:18:39,905 --> 00:18:44,770
Because if you have capabilities and
you're incentivized to just do mischief.
267
00:18:44,770 --> 00:18:49,870
If you're spoliation as far as the eye can
see, then this comes to the fifth one,
268
00:18:49,870 --> 00:18:54,516
which is their fear, and
that's the anarchy, the collapse, right?
269
00:18:54,516 --> 00:18:57,916
The Tsar empire collapsed,
came back as the Soviet Union.
270
00:18:57,916 --> 00:18:59,340
The Soviet Union collapsed.
271
00:18:59,340 --> 00:19:01,692
It didn't come back as anything, really.
272
00:19:01,692 --> 00:19:04,372
And so could Russia potentially collapse?
273
00:19:04,372 --> 00:19:05,540
It can't be excluded.
274
00:19:05,540 --> 00:19:08,236
It's not structured the same
way as the Soviet Union.
275
00:19:08,236 --> 00:19:10,932
The Soviet Union was a chocolate bar.
276
00:19:10,932 --> 00:19:14,121
If you know your chocolate bars,
they have these creases.
277
00:19:14,121 --> 00:19:15,588
>> Peter Robinson: Right.
>> Stephen Kotkin: In them already.
278
00:19:15,588 --> 00:19:19,547
And one crease was Ukraine and
another crease was Estonia and
279
00:19:19,547 --> 00:19:21,532
another crease was Georgia.
280
00:19:21,532 --> 00:19:25,198
And so you could just break off
the chocolate bar at the creases and
281
00:19:25,198 --> 00:19:27,276
you got 15 pieces of chocolate.
282
00:19:27,276 --> 00:19:30,404
It was pre-structured to dissolve.
283
00:19:30,404 --> 00:19:31,460
Russia is not like that.
284
00:19:31,460 --> 00:19:33,828
It doesn't have the structure
of the Soviet Union.
285
00:19:33,828 --> 00:19:38,847
But it's got a volatile
North Caucasus where Chechnya and
286
00:19:38,847 --> 00:19:42,818
other places have tried
to get out of Russia.
287
00:19:42,818 --> 00:19:46,925
And so it wouldn't be the same
dynamic as the Soviet Union, but
288
00:19:46,925 --> 00:19:49,842
it's a potentially troublesome outcome.
289
00:19:49,842 --> 00:19:51,274
And then the sixth,
290
00:19:51,274 --> 00:19:55,938
you always have a sixth because
that's the one you have no idea.
291
00:19:55,938 --> 00:20:00,609
It's something that might happen that
you don't foresee, you don't predict.
292
00:20:00,609 --> 00:20:03,174
That's why you don't make
any money in the markets.
293
00:20:03,174 --> 00:20:06,654
That sixth one,
which is also a possibility.
294
00:20:06,654 --> 00:20:12,845
But if you look at these, there's only
really two that are solutions for
295
00:20:12,845 --> 00:20:19,768
the Ukraine living as a neighbor alongside
Russia in peace and not just Ukraine.
296
00:20:19,768 --> 00:20:20,964
>> Peter Robinson: France and?
297
00:20:20,964 --> 00:20:24,290
>> Stephen Kotkin: And the authoritarian
leader who's no longer a threat to
298
00:20:24,290 --> 00:20:28,523
the neighbors because recognizes that
Russia pays a price for that too.
299
00:20:28,523 --> 00:20:31,582
>> Peter Robinson: Steven Ukraine
specifically.
300
00:20:31,582 --> 00:20:33,638
Let me set this up with
two brief overviews.
301
00:20:33,638 --> 00:20:37,102
American involvement then
the present situation on the ground.
302
00:20:37,102 --> 00:20:38,166
American involvement.
303
00:20:38,166 --> 00:20:42,086
Russia invades Ukraine on February 24,
2022.
304
00:20:42,086 --> 00:20:45,616
By April, we're sending
the Ukrainians howitzers [COUGH].
305
00:20:45,616 --> 00:20:49,318
By June, we're sending them
the HIMARS rocket launcher.
306
00:20:49,318 --> 00:20:53,702
And we now know that the Ukrainians only
fire the rocket launcher when we give them
307
00:20:53,702 --> 00:20:54,802
a specific target.
308
00:20:56,572 --> 00:20:59,596
In December,
we send them the Patriot system.
309
00:20:59,596 --> 00:21:02,814
Early this year,
we begin sending them armored vehicles and
310
00:21:02,814 --> 00:21:05,028
then we promise them the Abrams tank.
311
00:21:05,028 --> 00:21:06,005
And just last week,
312
00:21:06,005 --> 00:21:10,116
President Biden announced that he's going
to begin sending them cluster bombs.
313
00:21:10,116 --> 00:21:14,813
Forbes quote, America's military
role in Ukraine reflects
314
00:21:14,813 --> 00:21:18,524
a pattern of gradual escalation,
close quote.
315
00:21:18,524 --> 00:21:20,483
Situation on the ground.
316
00:21:20,483 --> 00:21:25,121
When the Ukrainian counter
offensive began this past spring,
317
00:21:25,121 --> 00:21:29,862
Russia occupied about 17%
of Ukrainian territory.
318
00:21:29,862 --> 00:21:33,437
The Russians had dug in, they'd
established trenches, minefields and
319
00:21:33,437 --> 00:21:34,462
so forth.
320
00:21:34,462 --> 00:21:38,987
So far in this offensive,
the Ukrainians have been recapturing
321
00:21:38,987 --> 00:21:43,182
territory at the rate of less
than 50 sq miles per week.
322
00:21:43,182 --> 00:21:46,487
Graham Allison in the Washington Post,
qoute.
323
00:21:46,487 --> 00:21:52,561
If Ukrainian forces are no more successful
in the weeks ahead than they have been so
324
00:21:52,561 --> 00:21:57,592
far, Ukraine will not recapture
all its territory for 16 years.
325
00:21:58,852 --> 00:22:05,932
We have escalated and escalated and
escalated and the Ukrainians are stuck.
326
00:22:05,932 --> 00:22:08,628
How does this end?
327
00:22:08,628 --> 00:22:09,133
>> Stephen Kotkin: Yeah, so
328
00:22:09,133 --> 00:22:12,364
it's heartbreaking what
the Ukrainians have endured.
329
00:22:12,364 --> 00:22:14,212
This is a criminal aggression.
330
00:22:16,072 --> 00:22:18,932
Their country is being wrecked and
wrecked on purpose.
331
00:22:20,152 --> 00:22:24,121
Their women are being raped,
their children are being kidnapped,
332
00:22:24,121 --> 00:22:27,604
their cultural artifacts
are being destroyed or looted and
333
00:22:27,604 --> 00:22:32,271
taken back to Moscow to disprove the
existence of a separate Ukrainian nation,
334
00:22:32,271 --> 00:22:35,792
right, destroying the cultural artifacts.
335
00:22:35,792 --> 00:22:40,626
And so I've been supportive of
Ukraine from the beginning.
336
00:22:40,626 --> 00:22:47,959
And they did win the victory of preventing
their capital from being captured.
337
00:22:47,959 --> 00:22:51,664
And having an occupation regime and
a puppet government and
338
00:22:51,664 --> 00:22:54,252
being forced into insurgency.
339
00:22:54,252 --> 00:22:58,469
However, they're not winning the war,
340
00:22:58,469 --> 00:23:02,132
despite that tremendous victory.
341
00:23:02,132 --> 00:23:05,020
And I've been saying this,
unfortunately, for 15 months.
342
00:23:05,020 --> 00:23:05,772
I see Shirley.
343
00:23:05,772 --> 00:23:10,670
She asks me every meeting,
do I still
think that Ukraine is not winning the war?
344
00:23:10,670 --> 00:23:15,182
Surely, don't you ask me that,
everyone, every one of these sessions?
345
00:23:15,182 --> 00:23:20,100
So you not only have to win the war,
you have to win the peace,
346
00:23:20,100 --> 00:23:22,042
which is the hard part.
347
00:23:23,062 --> 00:23:28,462
We lost the war in Vietnam,
and arguably we won the peace.
348
00:23:28,462 --> 00:23:34,032
It's one of the most pro-American
countries in the world, Vietnam.
349
00:23:34,032 --> 00:23:38,688
And it's gonna become closer and
closer to us over time.
350
00:23:38,688 --> 00:23:42,706
Whether we deserve this or not,
we can argue about the history and
351
00:23:42,706 --> 00:23:44,000
how we got there.
352
00:23:44,000 --> 00:23:47,969
So you can even lose the war and
win the peace, but you can, of course,
353
00:23:47,969 --> 00:23:50,272
win the war and lose the peace.
354
00:23:50,272 --> 00:23:54,792
And so the question then becomes,
how do you define victory?
355
00:23:54,792 --> 00:23:58,121
What does winning the peace look like for
Ukraine?
356
00:23:58,121 --> 00:24:03,840
And the territorial definition
is something I've never held to,
357
00:24:03,840 --> 00:24:06,808
and it's loosening now finally.
358
00:24:06,808 --> 00:24:11,426
The idea that Ukraine wins the war
by regaining all of its territory,
359
00:24:11,426 --> 00:24:14,213
because this is a criminal aggression and
360
00:24:14,213 --> 00:24:19,798
it is their territory under international
law, and the Russians should get out.
361
00:24:19,798 --> 00:24:22,130
I mean, it's perfectly understandable.
362
00:24:23,310 --> 00:24:26,770
Winning the peace means joining the west.
363
00:24:28,570 --> 00:24:33,711
We've spent I don't know how many decades
in the United States trashing the West.
364
00:24:33,711 --> 00:24:36,714
We have whole departments
here at Stanford,
365
00:24:36,714 --> 00:24:39,722
that's their mission, trashing the West.
366
00:24:39,722 --> 00:24:43,614
And we trash the West endlessly,
and lo and behold,
367
00:24:43,614 --> 00:24:47,850
the Ukrainians are willing
to die to join the West.
368
00:24:47,850 --> 00:24:50,569
They're not asking to
join a rules based order,
369
00:24:50,569 --> 00:24:54,540
they're not asking to join
a liberal international system.
370
00:24:54,540 --> 00:24:57,885
This is not a seminar at Brookings or
371
00:24:57,885 --> 00:25:04,220
an article in foreign affairs,
they wanna join the West.
372
00:25:04,220 --> 00:25:06,167
And so what does that mean?
373
00:25:06,167 --> 00:25:10,908
It means a security
guarantee of some sort, and
374
00:25:10,908 --> 00:25:13,880
it means accession to the EU.
375
00:25:13,880 --> 00:25:14,974
>> Peter Robinson: Not NATO.
376
00:25:14,974 --> 00:25:16,544
>> Stephen Kotkin: We'll get to that.
377
00:25:16,544 --> 00:25:18,215
>> Peter Robinson: All right.
>> Stephen Kotkin: So, once again,
378
00:25:18,215 --> 00:25:20,310
the EU may be imperfect.
379
00:25:20,310 --> 00:25:25,128
Some people in the audience here
may have issues with the EU,
380
00:25:25,128 --> 00:25:30,040
but the EU is the instrument to
transform Ukraine's domestic
381
00:25:30,040 --> 00:25:35,047
institutions the way it happened
in Poland, and also to anchor
382
00:25:35,047 --> 00:25:40,250
it in this Western community of values and
institutions, both.
383
00:25:41,510 --> 00:25:42,828
So how do they do that?
384
00:25:42,828 --> 00:25:47,587
Well, first,
they need this security guarantee and
385
00:25:47,587 --> 00:25:52,086
NATO cannot,
>> Stephen Kotkin: It
386
00:25:52,086 --> 00:25:57,020
cannot bring a country into the alliance
while that country is at war.
387
00:25:58,080 --> 00:26:01,680
It's not really thinkable.
388
00:26:01,680 --> 00:26:04,732
Moreover, NATO is not
the only option here.
389
00:26:04,732 --> 00:26:07,282
You can have what I call bilateral plus,
390
00:26:07,282 --> 00:26:11,639
I can use things like that because
I've never served in government.
391
00:26:11,639 --> 00:26:16,479
And we have secretaries of state and
others here in the audience,
392
00:26:16,479 --> 00:26:21,860
and I'm just in the Hoover ivory tower,
so I can talk like this.
393
00:26:21,860 --> 00:26:23,812
What's bilateral plus?
394
00:26:23,812 --> 00:26:28,962
Bilateral plus is kinda like what we
have with South Korea or with Israel, or
395
00:26:28,962 --> 00:26:34,680
you could use other examples where we have
a bilateral guarantee of their security.
396
00:26:36,420 --> 00:26:40,884
But the plus part is,
others may wanna join the bilateral.
397
00:26:40,884 --> 00:26:43,713
So for example,
Poland might wanna join, or
398
00:26:43,713 --> 00:26:48,708
the Baltic states might wanna join, or
Scandinavian states might wanna join.
399
00:26:48,708 --> 00:26:53,021
So you don't have to jump
from nothing into NATO,
400
00:26:53,021 --> 00:26:57,962
you can jump from a US led bilateral plus,
potentially.
401
00:26:57,962 --> 00:27:02,747
If you get a security guarantee, which
has to be sold to the American public.
402
00:27:02,747 --> 00:27:03,269
>> Peter Robinson: Yes, it does.
403
00:27:03,269 --> 00:27:05,411
>> Stephen Kotkin: Because
we are a democracy, and
404
00:27:05,411 --> 00:27:07,559
none of that work has been done.
405
00:27:07,559 --> 00:27:12,390
If you get a bilateral plus,
then you can have an EU
406
00:27:12,390 --> 00:27:17,811
accession process where you
need a judiciary, right?
407
00:27:17,811 --> 00:27:21,010
An impartial, uncorrupt judiciary.
408
00:27:21,010 --> 00:27:24,488
You need a civil service,
you need free and open media,
409
00:27:24,488 --> 00:27:27,210
you need a dynamic market economy.
410
00:27:27,210 --> 00:27:32,294
You need a whole lot of things that
Ukraine didn't have before the Russian
411
00:27:32,294 --> 00:27:37,600
aggression, and they need badly,
they have a wartime government now.
412
00:27:37,600 --> 00:27:40,633
And that transformation is hard, but
413
00:27:40,633 -->
00:27:46,680
the EU accession process does
facilitate that transformation.
414
00:27:46,680 --> 00:27:51,621
Think about reconstruction,
people talk about $400 billion of
415
00:27:51,621 --> 00:27:57,680
reconstruction funds, which is now
the minimum estimate to rebuild Ukraine.
416
00:27:57,680 --> 00:28:05,135
And of course, we know that Ukraine's
pre-war GDP was 180 billion.
417
00:28:05,135 --> 00:28:08,255
So take the United States,
what are we, 25 trillion?
418
00:28:08,255 --> 00:28:09,983
I don't know, I might be probably off.
419
00:28:09,983 --> 00:28:12,943
But we have economists
in the room who know.
420
00:28:12,943 --> 00:28:14,325
>> Peter Robinson: 29?
421
00:28:14,325 --> 00:28:15,602
Sold.
422
00:28:15,602 --> 00:28:19,374
>> Stephen Kotkin: So let's put double
that of reconstruction funds from
423
00:28:19,374 --> 00:28:25,260
the outside into the US economy, and
let's see none of that money disappear.
424
00:28:25,260 --> 00:28:27,660
None of that money will be stolen.
425
00:28:27,660 --> 00:28:30,699
There'll be nothing like the COVID funds,
426
00:28:30,699 --> 00:28:33,924
which were a tiny fraction of US GDP,
right?
427
00:28:33,924 --> 00:28:38,283
So they desperately need those
institutions for reconstruction,
428
00:28:38,283 --> 00:28:41,423
to absorb those reconstruction funds,
right?
429
00:28:41,423 --> 00:28:47,446
The Marshall plan worked because there
were functioning institutions in Europe.
430
00:28:47,446 --> 00:28:51,910
You have to give the money to something,
to some people, and so
431
00:28:51,910 --> 00:28:54,840
this is winning the peace.
432
00:28:54,840 --> 00:28:58,796
Some type of security guarantee and
EU accession process,
433
00:28:58,796 --> 00:29:01,608
it can't be like the Western Balkans.
434
00:29:01,608 --> 00:29:05,920
The Western Balkans began
their European Union accession
435
00:29:05,920 --> 00:29:09,264
process when
Professor Condoleezza Rice and
436
00:29:09,264 --> 00:29:13,664
I were on a conference panel
here together at Stanford, and
437
00:29:13,664 --> 00:29:19,744
I was a PhD student at Berkeley, and
Ronald Reagan was president almost, right?
438
00:29:19,744 --> 00:29:24,929
So it can't be that,
it can't be tick a box, okay.
439
00:29:24,929 --> 00:29:28,952
Five years later, tick another box,
ten years after that, tick a box.
440
00:29:28,952 --> 00:29:33,552
The EU needs to reform and get its
act together to be ready for Ukraine.
441
00:29:33,552 --> 00:29:39,800
And then, of course, there are issues
because Ukraine is not rich.
442
00:29:39,800 --> 00:29:44,455
And in the EU right now,
there are countries that are recipients,
443
00:29:44,455 --> 00:29:47,080
not just donors of EU funds.
444
00:29:47,080 --> 00:29:48,689
Ukraine comes in and
445
00:29:48,689 --> 00:29:53,528
all of those recipients of
current EU funds, guess what?
446
00:29:53,528 --> 00:29:56,883
They become donors of EU funds.
447
00:29:56,883 --> 00:29:59,340
So go sell that to your public at home,
right?
448
00:29:59,340 --> 00:30:03,400
So we're nowhere near understanding
this winning the peace problem.
449
00:30:03,400 --> 00:30:06,500
Now, connect that to territory,
which is where you began.
450
00:30:07,520 --> 00:30:09,520
It would be better, and
451
00:30:09,520 --> 00:30:15,532
I'm in favor of Ukraine recapturing
as much of its territory as it can.
452
00:30:15,532 --> 00:30:19,879
If it recaptures the territory,
all of it, and
453
00:30:19,879 --> 00:30:27,397
doesn't get EU accession with a security
guarantee, it doesn't win the peace.
454
00:30:27,397 --> 00:30:32,200
If it fails to recapture all of its
territory, but it gets a security
455
00:30:32,200 --> 00:30:38,332
guarantee in EU accession, that's winning
the peace, that's joining the West.
456
00:30:38,332 --> 00:30:39,876
Remember South Korea?
457
00:30:39,876 --> 00:30:43,260
No peace treaty, just an armistice.
458
00:30:43,260 --> 00:30:47,349
That's all they have on the Korean
peninsula is an armistice, and yet we
459
00:30:47,349 --> 00:30:52,420
have a security guarantee for South Korea,
and we have our troops stationed there.
460
00:30:52,420 --> 00:30:56,100
And so it's a bad outcome,
461
00:30:56,100 --> 00:31:00,904
the Korean peninsula is volatile.
462
00:31:00,904 --> 00:31:05,109
The North Korean regime is a troublemaker,
463
00:31:05,109 --> 00:31:09,552
as we know, and
the families were separated.
464
00:31:09,552 --> 00:31:11,463
It's an imperfect outcome.
465
00:31:11,463 --> 00:31:15,866
Still, if Ukraine got on
a trajectory like South Korea,
466
00:31:15,866 --> 00:31:20,925
South Korea is one of the most
successful societies in the world.
467
00:31:20,925 --> 00:31:25,353
And so there you are, but
we're far from that right now.
468
00:31:25,353 --> 00:31:30,810
>> Peter Robinson: So Stephen,
that is not just plausible.
469
00:31:30,810 --> 00:31:37,170
That's a way, it makes sense,
it's something that could be acted upon.
470
00:31:37,170 --> 00:31:42,336
But it feels to me as though
it would be of the scale
471
00:31:42,336 --> 00:31:50,023
of Harry Truman in the 1950s with
the Marshall plan, the creation.
472
00:31:50,023 --> 00:31:55,189
In other words,
an enormous amount would rest on
473
00:31:55,189 --> 00:32:01,741
whether this country was capable
of an An act of diplomatic and
474
00:32:01,741 --> 00:32:07,165
sustained diplomatic and
political creativity.
475
00:32:07,165 --> 00:32:08,266
Is that correct?
476
00:32:08,266 --> 00:32:10,844
>> Stephen Kotkin: We are, we are capable.
477
00:32:10,844 --> 00:32:12,523
Look around the world.
478
00:32:12,523 --> 00:32:16,699
We have all sorts of friends and
allies and partnerships.
479
00:32:16,699 --> 00:32:18,151
You want to enumerate them.
480
00:32:18,151 --> 00:32:20,193
We don't have enough time in the show.
481
00:32:20,193 --> 00:32:24,966
We want to talk about Australia or
the five Eyes together.
482
00:32:24,966 --> 00:32:27,459
You want to talk about Japan and
South Korea.
483
00:32:27,459 --> 00:32:30,004
You want to add Taiwan to this picture.
484
00:32:30,004 --> 00:32:32,084
You want to talk about Israel.
485
00:32:32,084 --> 00:32:33,912
You want to talk about the Emirates.
486
00:32:33,912 --> 00:32:35,836
You want to talk about the European Union.
487
00:32:35,836 --> 00:32:37,417
You want to talk about Canada?
488
00:32:37,417 --> 00:32:40,111
I mean, we do this.
489
00:32:40,111 --> 00:32:41,247
This is who we are.
490
00:32:41,247 --> 00:32:45,159
This is why we're prosperous and
successful,
491
00:32:45,159 --> 00:32:50,157
because it's better to have
friends than not have friends.
492
00:32:50,157 --> 00:32:54,656
And it's better to have friends
who are rich and smart and
493
00:32:54,656 --> 00:32:59,063
have really good tech companies and
other companies and
494
00:32:59,063 --> 00:33:03,576
are there when you're in trouble or
vice versa, right?
495
00:33:03,576 --> 00:33:04,771
That's the formula.
496
00:33:04,771 --> 00:33:06,298
It's not rocket science.
497
00:33:06,298 --> 00:33:08,385
I understand it clearly.
498
00:33:08,385 --> 00:33:10,165
So it's not rocket science.
499
00:33:10,165 --> 00:33:11,376
So it can be done.
500
00:33:11,376 --> 00:33:13,033
And the Europeans have stepped up.
501
00:33:13,033 --> 00:33:18,244
You know, we have this narrative
that we've had this gradual,
502
00:33:18,244 --> 00:33:22,104
grudging, hesitant support for
Ukraine, and
503
00:33:22,104 --> 00:33:27,137
it's first no and then yes and
then no and then yes and then no.
504
00:33:27,137 --> 00:33:29,738
That's a false narrative.
505
00:33:29,738 --> 00:33:34,048
We have supported, and
as the Europeans have,
506
00:33:34,048 --> 00:33:39,329
including Pacifist Germany and
I could go on as our friends
507
00:33:39,329 --> 00:33:44,424
in East Asia have,
have supported Ukraine to the hilt.
508
00:33:44,424 --> 00:33:50,466
And, the scale of the support
has been phenomenal.
509
00:33:50,466 --> 00:33:54,647
Yes, do we know more now than
we knew at the beginning?
510
00:33:54,647 --> 00:33:59,996
Well, yeah, it's a war, and war is
a learning process and it has surprises.
511
00:33:59,996 --> 00:34:02,797
So it's the wrong headline.
512
00:34:02,797 --> 00:34:06,869
The headline is western unity and resolve.
513
00:34:06,869 --> 00:34:10,581
And the west includes our friends,
like Australia,
514
00:34:10,581 --> 00:34:13,477
which is in the global south, by the way.
515
00:34:13,477 --> 00:34:18,787
It includes the first island chain
in the Pacific and on it goes.
516
00:34:18,787 --> 00:34:23,717
So the current administration
made a decision.
517
00:34:23,717 --> 00:34:26,657
It didn't want a wider war.
518
00:34:26,657 --> 00:34:32,429
It was going to support Ukraine, but it
didn't want a wider war because it thought
519
00:34:32,429 --> 00:34:38,119
that that was dangerous, a bad idea, and
an opportunity cost that was too high,
520
00:34:38,119 --> 00:34:42,152
given the challenges and
opportunities we face in Asia.
521
00:34:42,152 --> 00:34:48,397
And so from the beginning, it's wanted to
support Ukraine without widening the war.
522
00:34:48,397 --> 00:34:52,526
Now, you can argue whether that was
a good decision or a bad decision.
523
00:34:52,526 --> 00:34:54,016
I think it was a good decision.
524
00:34:54,016 --> 00:34:55,542
We don't have a wider war.
525
00:34:55,542 --> 00:34:58,070
This is not a world war.
526
00:34:58,070 --> 00:35:04,903
We don't have American boys and
girls being killed at scale there.
527
00:35:04,903 --> 00:35:08,563
We don't have the war
spreading to the Levante.
528
00:35:08,563 --> 00:35:12,915
Right, the eastern Mediterranean,
or spreading to Iran or
529
00:35:12,915 --> 00:35:17,112
spreading to the South Caucasus and
who knows where else?
530
00:35:17,112 --> 00:35:22,232
And we don't have superpowers
on nuclear alert.
531
00:35:22,232 --> 00:35:27,369
And so we've achieved an enormous amount,
thanks to the Ukrainians,
532
00:35:27,369 --> 00:35:31,830
but also the solidarity of
the west without widening the war.
533
00:35:31,830 --> 00:35:35,137
And that's an achievement
that has come at a cost.
534
00:35:35,137 --> 00:35:38,959
And the cost has been
the appearance of hesitant,
535
00:35:38,959 --> 00:35:43,878
grudging commitment to Ukraine
over certain weapons systems.
536
00:35:43,878 --> 00:35:46,455
People say, well,
why don't you send them tanks?
537
00:35:46,455 --> 00:35:49,665
And we did send them tanks,
but here's the problem.
538
00:35:49,665 --> 00:35:52,655
How long does a tank
last on the battlefield?
539
00:35:52,655 --> 00:35:55,098
A modern tank on a battlefield today?
540
00:35:55,098 --> 00:35:59,060
In World War Two eastern front,
it was four and a half days.
541
00:35:59,060 --> 00:36:01,530
Now it's about 14 days.
542
00:36:01,530 --> 00:36:07,681
So you send a tank, you have to send
a workshop to rebuild the tank.
543
00:36:07,681 --> 00:36:11,518
And behind the workshop, the workshop's
got to be close to the battlefield.
544
00:36:11,518 --> 00:36:13,574
You can't take a broken tank and
say, you know what?
545
00:36:13,574 --> 00:36:17,649
I'll ship it to California now and
get it repaired.
546
00:36:17,649 --> 00:36:22,656
So, can we send workshops to
Ukraine to repair the Abrams or
547
00:36:22,656 --> 00:36:26,678
the other fantastic
armored vehicles we have?
548
00:36:26,678 --> 00:36:31,659
And then behind that, you need assembly
lines because you send tanks and they last
549
00:36:31,659 --> 00:36:36,509
14 days, and some of them can be repaired
and some of them can't be repaired.
550
00:36:36,509 --> 00:36:38,834
And so you need new tanks, and
551
00:36:38,834 --> 00:36:43,581
you need a lot of tanks if you're
going to have tank warfare.
552
00:36:43,581 --> 00:36:49,954
And so you need to send an assembly line,
as it were, not just the mechanical shops.
553
00:36:49,954 --> 00:36:54,598
And so commitments like that
are not just about weapons.
554
00:36:54,598 --> 00:36:56,038
They're much deeper.
555
00:36:56,038 --> 00:37:00,193
They're about supply chain,
they're about military industrial complex.
556
00:37:00,193 --> 00:37:05,076
And so when people clamor for
things to be sent to Ukraine,
557
00:37:05,076 --> 00:37:09,471
they're not factoring in
these other dimensions.
558
00:37:09,471 --> 00:37:12,122
And in any case,
war is mostly about munitions.
559
00:37:12,122 --> 00:37:16,063
And as we discussed nine months ago,
we were going to run out.
560
00:37:16,063 --> 00:37:19,891
>> Peter Robinson: Stephen, the defense
of Taiwan runs through Ukraine.
561
00:37:19,891 --> 00:37:23,193
>> Stephen Kotkin: So
we had a debate about the pivot to Asia.
562
00:37:23,193 --> 00:37:26,610
Let's say that it was
an unsuccessful debate.
563
00:37:26,610 --> 00:37:30,928
The terms were, they were absurd.
564
00:37:30,928 --> 00:37:37,097
The US pivoting to Asia would be
like the Hoover institution, right?
565
00:37:37,097 --> 00:37:39,718
Pivoting to conservatism.
566
00:37:39,718 --> 00:37:41,685
People would say, well, yeah.
567
00:37:41,685 --> 00:37:44,517
I mean, what do you mean,
pivot, we've kind of been there.
568
00:37:44,517 --> 00:37:47,625
This is our 2nd 100 years.
569
00:37:47,625 --> 00:37:49,494
We were already in Asia.
570
00:37:49,494 --> 00:37:54,577
We had an Asian fleet
from way before predating
571
00:37:54,577 --> 00:37:59,408
the Hoover institution, our Asian fleet.
572
00:37:59,408 --> 00:38:03,167
So the pivot to Asia debate
was a little bit cockamamie.
573
00:38:03,167 --> 00:38:08,378
I'm going to use that technical
term here because we're on air,
574
00:38:08,378 --> 00:38:10,377
and the idea was that we.
575
00:38:10,377 --> 00:38:13,395
We're over committed in all
these other places, and
576
00:38:13,395 --> 00:38:17,095
we need to under commit there and
shift all the resources to Asia.
577
00:38:17,095 --> 00:38:19,079
So what did we discover?
578
00:38:19,079 --> 00:38:25,083
We discovered that the pivot to Asia
was the transatlantic alliance.
579
00:38:25,083 --> 00:38:31,003
So, all of those friends of
ours could be on our side
580
00:38:31,003 --> 00:38:37,350
in confronting tyranny and
coercion in Asia at scale.
581
00:38:37,350 --> 00:38:41,523
And so if we supported Ukraine,
we enhanced,
582
00:38:41,523 --> 00:38:46,338
strengthened our China
policy across the board, and
583
00:38:46,338 --> 00:38:50,092
China got much weaker as a result of this.
584
00:38:50,092 --> 00:38:57,586
It lost Europe as an opponent of the US
in China policy over this Ukraine.
585
00:38:57,586 --> 00:39:03,514
And so you look at the investment we've
now made again in our alliances, and
586
00:39:03,514 --> 00:39:08,897
once again at the NATO summit,
we had several of our asian partners.
587
00:39:08,897 --> 00:39:10,805
In fact, they're there right now.
588
00:39:10,805 --> 00:39:13,174
Their dinner is probably over.
589
00:39:13,174 --> 00:39:17,388
They're probably a lot drunker than these
poor people who don't have any
wine and
590
00:39:17,388 --> 00:39:18,558
food in front of them.
591
00:39:18,558 --> 00:39:19,755
Their business is done.
592
00:39:19,755 --> 00:39:24,284
But if you read the communique,
the headline in the media, forgive me for
593
00:39:24,284 --> 00:39:27,220
this, is Ukraine does
not get NATO accession.
594
00:39:27,220 --> 00:39:27,860
>> Peter Robinson: Right.
595
00:39:27,860 --> 00:39:29,640
>> Stephen Kotkin: Read the communique.
596
00:39:29,640 --> 00:39:31,231
It's all about China and
597
00:39:31,231 --> 00:39:35,263
it's all about standing up to
China's coercion in East Asia.
598
00:39:35,263 --> 00:39:36,734
It's careful language.
599
00:39:36,734 --> 00:39:39,114
It says that China's not an enemy.
600
00:39:39,114 --> 00:39:41,157
We want to work with China.
601
00:39:41,157 --> 00:39:43,270
It's very well written.
602
00:39:43,270 --> 00:39:48,882
And then it enumerates all the activities
that China is doing that are coercive and
603
00:39:48,882 --> 00:39:53,945
that are threatening the international
order, liberty, prosperity.
604
00:39:53,945 --> 00:39:57,847
And the Europeans signed onto this.
605
00:39:57,847 --> 00:40:03,028
They signed onto paragraph after
paragraph about China in this communique.
606
00:40:03,028 --> 00:40:05,925
So I'm looking at that, thinking, yeah.
607
00:40:05,925 --> 00:40:06,955
>> Peter Robinson: Okay.
608
00:40:06,955 --> 00:40:07,827
>> Stephen Kotkin: For sure.
609
00:40:07,827 --> 00:40:11,770
>> Peter Robinson: Stephen,
let me give you a last question.
610
00:40:11,770 --> 00:40:13,722
I'm going to give you a quotation, and
611
00:40:13,722 --> 00:40:16,522
then I'm going to give you
some recent poll results.
612
00:40:16,522 --> 00:40:21,701
Here's the quotation,
the quotation goes back, this is 1838,
613
00:40:21,701 --> 00:40:27,800
Abraham Lincoln, the young men's
lyceum of Springfield, Illinois.
614
00:40:27,800 --> 00:40:31,520
At what point is the approach
of danger to be expected?
615
00:40:31,520 --> 00:40:36,832
I answer, if it ever reach us,
it must spring up amongst us.
616
00:40:36,832 --> 00:40:38,856
It cannot come from abroad.
617
00:40:38,856 --> 00:40:43,872
If destruction be our lot, we must
ourselves be its author and finisher.
618
00:40:43,872 --> 00:40:50,140
As a nation of free men, we must live
through all time or die by suicide.
619
00:40:51,160 --> 00:40:56,204
Here's the poll,
in a Wall Street Journal poll in 1998,
620
00:40:56,204 --> 00:41:03,370
not that long ago, 70% of Americans
said patriotism was important to them.
621
00:41:03,370 --> 00:41:08,206
By this past spring,
that figure had dropped to 38%,
622
00:41:08,206 --> 00:41:12,018
and among adults under 30, only 23%.
623
00:41:12,018 --> 00:41:13,138
Let me repeat that.
624
00:41:13,138 --> 00:41:17,077
The proportion of Americans
under 30 who say that
625
00:41:17,077 --> 00:41:22,210
love of country matters to
them is less than one in four.
626
00:41:22,210 --> 00:41:23,970
Last question, Stephen.
627
00:41:23,970 --> 00:41:25,830
What makes you so cheerful?
628
00:41:27,010 --> 00:41:30,590
>> Stephen Kotkin: You wonder why Hoover
has a K through 12 education program?
629
00:41:31,770 --> 00:41:33,230
Wonder no longer.
630
00:41:34,290 --> 00:41:39,087
People don't know their own country,
they don't know their institutions,
631
00:41:39,087 --> 00:41:41,210
they don't know their history.
632
00:41:41,210 --> 00:41:43,570
But that's not their fault,
that's our fault.
633
00:41:43,570 --> 00:41:47,190
We have to do better at
communicating who we are.
634
00:41:47,190 --> 00:41:50,625
You asked the question about
Russia 1,000 years of history,
635
00:41:50,625 --> 00:41:52,410
can they overcome their history?
636
00:41:53,710 --> 00:41:56,846
Yes, France overcame its history, right,
637
00:41:56,846 --> 00:42:00,030
as I just described in
talking about Russia.
638
00:42:00,030 --> 00:42:01,930
But we overcame our history, too.
639
00:42:03,990 --> 00:42:09,995
We had some very big issues when we
were founded as a republican and
640
00:42:09,995 --> 00:42:11,936
we had a civil war.
641
00:42:11,936 --> 00:42:16,742
Not only did we have a civil war,
we had a civil rights
642
00:42:16,742 --> 00:42:21,549
movement after reconstruction
in the south didn't
643
00:42:21,549 --> 00:42:27,000
succeed the way some people
envisioned it should.
644
00:42:27,000 --> 00:42:32,443
And so that story is a really big story,
overcoming our past but
645
00:42:32,443 --> 00:42:38,412
with the institutions that we were
granted from the outset, right?
646
00:42:38,412 --> 00:42:41,394
This category, citizenship, is a miracle.
647
00:42:41,394 --> 00:42:45,588
It's exclusionary,
in the 18th century civic revolution,
648
00:42:45,588 --> 00:42:48,764
there are a lot of people
who are not citizens.
649
00:42:48,764 --> 00:42:52,828
In fact, they're not even
considered people, it's terrible.
650
00:42:52,828 --> 00:42:57,096
But over time, that category,
citizenship, can expand, and
651
00:42:57,096 --> 00:43:00,980
people who were not included
in it can be included in it.
652
00:43:00,980 --> 00:43:06,102
So is the exclusion the story,
which is terrible and long lasting and
653
00:43:06,102 --> 00:43:11,842
affects a lot of people, or is the
brilliance of the category citizenship and
654
00:43:11,842 --> 00:43:14,308
its capaciousness over time?
655
00:43:14,308 --> 00:43:19,165
The story, and
I would argue they're both the story,
656
00:43:19,165 --> 00:43:22,316
but one triumphs over the other.
657
00:43:22,316 --> 00:43:24,261
It's not 100% triumph,
658
00:43:24,261 --> 00:43:29,720
it's not a triumph where you're done
because this is something that's ongoing.
659
00:43:30,780 --> 00:43:37,268
And the strength of our system is we can
denounce it, that's just incredible.
660
00:43:37,268 --> 00:43:42,147
Imagine you can denounce your
system because you have the freedom
661
00:43:42,147 --> 00:43:47,020
to denounce your system,
that's what your system gives you.
662
00:43:47,020 --> 00:43:51,068
So you can have an industry
that's west bashing.
663
00:43:51,068 --> 00:43:57,913
I used to teach Plato to NATO back
when I was, how to say this politely,
664
00:43:57,913 --> 00:44:03,500
I was on loan to a different
institution for 33 years.
665
00:44:03,500 --> 00:44:09,708
And I taught the Plato to NATO course,
we capped it at 325 students,
666
00:44:09,708 --> 00:44:15,556
which was a significant portion
of the entering freshman class.
667
00:44:15,556 --> 00:44:19,436
And I did it year after year and
it wasn't a requirement.
668
00:44:19,436 --> 00:44:24,550
And they showed up because we
offered western civilization.
669
00:44:24,550 --> 00:44:29,050
And the professor knew how to pan, I mean,
the professor knew how to lecture.
670
00:44:30,270 --> 00:44:32,302
And so it can be done.
671
00:44:32,302 --> 00:44:36,525
We've done it before,
there have been highs and lows, and
672
00:44:36,525 --> 00:44:40,190
some of those lows we've lived through.
673
00:44:40,190 --> 00:44:45,294
You quoted that poll from 1998,
but I remember the 70s,
674
00:44:45,294 --> 00:44:52,640
and certainly that was not a high point
in American civilization or patriotism.
675
00:44:52,640 --> 00:44:57,203
But so it is in there, and
it's on us to recuperate it and
676
00:44:57,203 --> 00:45:00,894
to broadcast it and
to engage people with it,
677
00:45:00,894 --> 00:45:05,776
including engaging them in it
when they disagree with it.
678
00:45:05,776 --> 00:45:09,840
Once again,
that's the great strength of our system.
679
00:45:09,840 --> 00:45:14,328
And so you can't be anything
other than optimistic with that.
680
00:45:14,328 --> 00:45:18,479
Okay, we have a certain media
environment right now, and
681
00:45:18,479 --> 00:45:21,880
the media business model is destruction.
682
00:45:21,880 --> 00:45:26,192
It's scandal, it's destruction, it's tear
down, that's how they make their money.
683
00:45:26,192 --> 00:45:30,128
We're a free and open society, and
we have to live with that problem.
684
00:45:30,128 --> 00:45:34,675
That's a problem we can't wish away
because the solution to that problem
685
00:45:34,675 --> 00:45:39,280
provided by authoritarian regimes
is not a solution, it's worse.
686
00:45:39,280 --> 00:45:43,583
And so we did this with radio,
we did this with television,
687
00:45:43,583 --> 00:45:46,650
now we have to do it with social media.
688
00:45:46,650 --> 00:45:49,730
It's hard, but it can be done.
689
00:45:49,730 --> 00:45:54,468
But it can't be done by
shutting things down, right,
690
00:45:54,468 --> 00:45:59,412
it can't be done by being afraid,
afraid to engage, and
691
00:45:59,412 --> 00:46:05,700
it can't be done by behaving like
those critics who wanna shut you down.
692
00:46:05,700 --> 00:46:11,759
You can't win as an American with
the strength of our institutions,
693
00:46:11,759 --> 00:46:18,763
by doing things that are not consonant
with American values and institutions.
694
00:46:18,763 -->
00:46:23,232
You can't behave like the people
trying to destroy you because then you
695
00:46:23,232 --> 00:46:26,368
become like those people
trying to destroy you.
696
00:46:26,368 --> 00:46:29,024
So it's a delicate balance to figure out.
697
00:46:29,024 --> 00:46:31,442
And we hear many inspiring,
698
00:46:31,442 --> 00:46:37,040
concrete proposals here at Hoover
about how we can go about this.
699
00:46:37,040 --> 00:46:42,144
We have our center for the revitalization
of American institutions,
700
00:46:42,144 --> 00:46:48,520
which is off the ground and it's gonna
be a monster in terms of its influence.
701
00:46:48,520 --> 00:46:53,405
And then we have 100 million
plus people who are eligible
702
00:46:53,405 --> 00:46:56,530
to be president of the United States,
703
00:46:56,530 --> 00:47:02,698
100 plus million people in our
country are eligible to be president.
704
00:47:02,698 --> 00:47:05,305
And then we have those two
leading candidates who we have.
705
00:47:05,305 --> 00:47:06,924
>> [LAUGH]
>> Stephen Kotkin: So yeah,
706
00:47:06,924 --> 00:47:09,121
I'm very optimistic.
707
00:47:09,121 --> 00:47:13,313
>> [LAUGH]
>> Peter Robinson: Stephen, okay,
708
00:47:13,313 --> 00:47:16,656
three sentences for
709
00:47:16,656 --> 00:47:22,751
one of the 75% of Americans 30 or
710
00:47:22,751 --> 00:47:28,960
under who says he's not a patriot.
711
00:47:28,960 --> 00:47:32,872
>> Stephen Kotkin: It's okay
to say you're not a patriot,
712
00:47:32,872 --> 00:47:36,560
our patriotism allows for that.
713
00:47:36,560 --> 00:47:42,264
But I wanna tell you something
about why I'm a patriot.
714
00:47:42,264 --> 00:47:45,080
That's the conversation to have with them,
right?
715
00:47:45,080 --> 00:47:50,005
The conversation is not to belittle them,
not to dismiss their views and
716
00:47:50,005 --> 00:47:53,814
feelings, not to say you're young and
you're a fool.
717
00:47:53,814 --> 00:47:57,910
It's to say, well, this is why I'm a
patriot, this is the history that we have
718
00:47:57,910 --> 00:48:01,717
in this country, these are the
institutions Institutions that we have.
719
00:48:01,717 --> 00:48:04,550
This is the opportunity that we have.
720
00:48:04,550 --> 00:48:10,625
And this is why you can have a successful
life, and you can do things that other
721
00:48:10,625 --> 00:48:17,100
people elsewhere who are less fortunate
can barely dream of, let alone achieve.
722
00:48:17,100 --> 00:48:23,980
And so you engage, and if they still
are holding to their views, that's okay.
723
00:48:23,980 --> 00:48:28,605
It's a free country, and
they can be who they are.
724
00:48:28,605 --> 00:48:33,413
Our only problem is those who
wanna take the system down.
725
00:48:33,413 --> 00:48:40,467
Those people who don't just complain
about hypocrisy, I'm good with hypocrisy.
726
00:48:40,467 --> 00:48:44,109
Hypocrisy is, let's just say,
727
00:48:44,109 --> 00:48:49,582
it's not in deficit,
hypocrisy is everywhere.
728
00:48:49,582 --> 00:48:51,535
And I've engaged in it on occasion.
729
00:48:51,535 --> 00:48:53,544
It was always by accident,
but it happened.
730
00:48:53,544 --> 00:48:56,412
>> Peter Robinson: [LAUGH]
>> Stephen Kotkin: But what I love about
731
00:48:56,412 --> 00:49:01,482
hypocrisy is, it calls you out for
failing to live up to your ideals.
732
00:49:01,482 --> 00:49:02,493
>> Peter Robinson: To your own ideals.
733
00:49:02,493 --> 00:49:06,138
>> Stephen Kotkin: It says, you promised
this and you failed to deliver,
734
00:49:06,138 --> 00:49:07,809
so you're a hypocrite.
735
00:49:07,809 --> 00:49:14,801
It doesn't say your ideals are evil,
it says, you failed.
736
00:49:14,801 --> 00:49:17,538
You made promises, and
you didn't redeem them.
737
00:49:17,538 --> 00:49:21,101
So I'll take all
the hypocrisy they can throw.
738
00:49:21,101 --> 00:49:26,817
I just don't want them to
destroy the ideals as evil.
739
00:49:26,817 --> 00:49:31,299
And when they talk to me about,
well, we get rid of capitalism,
740
00:49:31,299 --> 00:49:36,030
that'll solve a lot of problems,
I say, why don't we have a little
741
00:49:36,030 --> 00:49:40,688
discussion about Stalin's Soviet Union and
how that worked out?
742
00:49:40,688 --> 00:49:43,750
Or Mao's China or Khmer Rouge in Cambodia,
743
00:49:43,750 --> 00:49:47,309
if you prefer a smaller
scale version of genocide,
744
00:49:47,309 --> 00:49:52,708
you can engage them in conversation
based upon your specialized knowledge.
745
00:49:52,708 --> 00:49:59,011
That can get at the trashing of
the ideals and institutions as the evil.
746
00:49:59,011 --> 00:50:03,620
But as long as you're talking about
hypocrisy, you're good, right?
747
00:50:03,620 --> 00:50:07,973
I mean, I don't wanna bring Ronald Reagan
into the question, well, why not?
748
00:50:07,973 --> 00:50:10,325
Why not bring Ronald Reagan in, right?
749
00:50:10,325 --> 00:50:15,194
So, on occasion, would tell a joke or
750
00:50:15,194 --> 00:50:19,158
two, you saw this firsthand.
751
00:50:19,158 --> 00:50:25,325
So this guy goes up and parks the car
next to Congress, and the policeman says,
752
00:50:25,325 --> 00:50:30,756
I'm sorry, sir, you can't park here,
politicians work inside.
753
00:50:30,756 --> 00:50:32,982
And the guy says, it's okay,
I locked the door.
754
00:50:32,982 --> 00:50:36,231
>> Peter Robinson: [LAUGH]
>> Stephen Kotkin: Right?
755
00:50:36,231 --> 00:50:38,480
That's us, that's who we are.
756
00:50:38,480 --> 00:50:40,874
So, yeah, we have crime, it turns out.
757
00:50:40,874 --> 00:50:42,237
Who knew?
758
00:50:42,237 --> 00:50:43,009
>> Peter Robinson: Stephen Kotkin.
759
00:50:43,009 --> 00:50:44,179
>> Stephen Kotkin: We're hypocrites.
760
00:50:44,179 --> 00:50:46,749
>> Peter Robinson: Stephen Kotkin,
thank you.
761
00:50:46,749 --> 00:50:56,437
>> [APPLAUSE]
>> Peter Robinson: For
762
00:50:56,437 --> 00:51:01,268
uncommon knowledge and the Hoover
institution, I'm Peter Robinson.
763
00:51:01,268 --> 00:51:05,399
>> [APPLAUSE]
764
00:51:05,399 --> 00:51:05,899
[MUSIC]