BẢN CHÉP ÂM THANH 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:10.747 --> 00:00:16.358
Hi, this is Eloy Ortiz Oakley, and this is another episode of the Rand Podcast.
00:00:16.957 --> 00:00:24.917
The podcast where we pull back the curtains and break down the people, the policies, and the politics of our higher education system.
00:00:26.198 --> 00:00:31.088
In this episode, I get to sit down and talk about negotiated rulemaking.
00:00:31.097 --> 00:00:32.618
What is negotiated rulemaking?
00:00:32.628 --> 00:00:52.317
Well, negotiated rulemaking at the federal government level basically is the job of the agency, and in this case, the Department of Education, that is responsible for developing the regulations to implement federal policy, or in this case, a new law statute.
00:00:53.378 --> 00:01:13.353
I'm gonna sit down with two colleagues, two good friends, two great people who really understand the higher education landscape, who were part of recent rulemaking efforts at the Department of Education I get to sit down with Kristin Hultquist, who is the founder of HCM Strategies.
00:01:13.694 --> 00:01:25.243
she is an expert in higher education policy, and her firm supports and advises clients both at the state level, at the federal level, and at the institution level throughout the country.
00:01:26.304 --> 00:01:33.043
I know I've worked with her in my previous role as Chancellor of the California Community Colleges, and she and her team do a fabulous job.
00:01:33.933 --> 00:01:35.653
I also get to welcome Dr.
00:01:35.653 --> 00:01:36.334
Andy Vaughn.
00:01:37.134 --> 00:01:41.573
Andy is the President CEO of Alliant University.
00:01:42.153 --> 00:01:51.554
Alliant University serves several professional graduate programs throughout the country, and they do an amazing job at serving the needs of learners.
00:01:52.483 --> 00:01:59.914
So both Kristen and Andy recently came off their stints working on negotiated rulemaking.
00:02:01.254 --> 00:02:09.193
They worked on issues like Workforce Pell, accountability, and the new graduate student loan limits.
00:02:09.713 --> 00:02:31.514
so we'll hear from them about their experience with negotiated rulemaking, help us better understand what negotiated rulemaking is all about, because I know it's one of those things that a lot of people don't pay attention to, but the people that pay attention to it definitely pay attention to it because it is part of the policies and part of the politics of higher education.
00:02:31.514 --> 00:02:33.294
Yes, politics.
00:02:33.633 --> 00:02:45.433
In negotiated rulemaking, the administration, whichever administration is responsible for the rulemaking, certainly has their viewpoint of how the negotiated rulemaking should go.
00:02:45.473 --> 00:02:58.834
And in this case, in this current administration, This administration has put their emphasis on how rulemaking should go, which is very different than what it's been over the last couple of administrations.
00:02:59.514 --> 00:03:26.734
So I'll sit down and talk
Load full transcript
with Kristen and Andy about their experiences, have them break down some of the issues that they were involved in in their respective negotiated rulemaking rounds, and how they think about negotiated rulemaking going forward, and any advice they have for individuals who either become part of a negotiated rulemaking process or who want to respond to what comes out of negotiated rulemaking.
00:03:26.743 --> 00:03:53.614
It is something that no one should sit on the sidEloynes about, because all these negotiated rulemaking rounds have an impact on the higher education marketplace, and it's up to all of us to engage with the federal government, to engage with the Department of Education or the Department of Labor or the Department of Commerce when issues arise and regulations need to be established that will impact how we serve learners throughout America.
00:03:54.343 --> 00:04:03.633
So with all that as a backdrop, please enjoy my conversation with Kristen Hultquist and Andy Vaughn as we talk about negotiated rulemaking.
00:04:04.229 --> 00:04:06.998
Kristen and Andy, welcome to the Rand Podcast
00:04:07.875 --> 00:04:08.634
Great to be here
00:04:10.002 --> 00:04:11.432
It's great to have you both.
00:04:11.462 --> 00:04:17.023
I know both of you have got a million things going on, so I really appreciate you taking the time to be on the podcast.
00:04:17.663 --> 00:04:23.353
I know that you both have been very engaged lately at the federal level, and we'll jump into that.
00:04:23.793 --> 00:04:37.589
A lot of our listeners have had lots of questions about what's going on in Washington, DC, what's going on with that one big beautiful bill how are all these impacting higher education?
00:04:37.589 --> 00:04:44.709
But, most people don't get behind the curtain to ask: how did we actually get here with these regulations?
00:04:45.149 --> 00:04:59.720
And, the federal government, particularly the Department of Education, goes through this rulemaking process every time that a new bill is passed and signed or there's major changes that need to happen.
00:05:00.279 --> 00:05:07.160
And so we're gonna jump into that, given both of you have recent experience with negotiated rulemaking.
00:05:07.170 --> 00:05:10.500
But before we get into that let me ask you both a question.
00:05:10.500 --> 00:05:11.620
Kristen, I'll start with you.
00:05:12.300 --> 00:05:14.879
You've both been in and around higher education for a long time.
00:05:15.189 --> 00:05:19.819
What are you doing right now, and how did you get sucked into negotiated rulemaking?
00:05:20.574 --> 00:05:24.024
That is the operative action verb, sucked in.
00:05:24.733 --> 00:05:35.547
I received apparently in late November an invitation from the department to be the primary negotiator for public colleges and universities.
00:05:36.107 --> 00:05:40.726
I opened it and ignored it for three and a half weeks until they came knocking on my door
00:05:40.838 --> 00:05:43.809
That's what I usually did with Department of Education letters.
00:05:43.822 --> 00:05:45.252
Are you gonna respond?
00:05:45.252 --> 00:05:56.192
And I said,"Oh." And I had worked for about 18 months in the role of senior advisor for a prior administration, so I knew enough about neg reg to, like I said, lay it aside.
00:05:56.673 --> 00:06:01.682
But a couple people said I should take advantage of this opportunity, that this was pretty important legislation.
00:06:01.702 --> 00:06:03.673
And so I said yes.
00:06:03.762 --> 00:06:15.622
And it turns out that my MSU Denver, Metropolitan State University Denver, which I'm privileged to serve on the board of, I'm a trustee appointed by the governor and confirmed by the Senate nominated me.
00:06:15.862 --> 00:06:25.533
And the department thought that the public four years should have the primary seat, and so the alternate seat to, for our sector was given to the two years.
00:06:25.533 --> 00:06:29.843
And that became a little bit of a drama, but it all got worked out.
00:06:29.843 --> 00:06:38.473
We negotiators got along fabulously in the public sector and generally, and that's how I got to be at the table, and it was a party in two parts, December and in January
00:06:39.271 --> 00:06:46.420
And quickly describe I, I know all these negotiated rulemaking sessions have fancy acronyms and titles.
00:06:46.651 --> 00:06:52.860
What was the negotiated rulemaking that you participated on, and what was its aim?
00:06:53.944 --> 00:06:54.254
Sure.
00:06:54.264 --> 00:06:55.615
We were called AHEAD.
00:06:55.937 --> 00:06:56.497
All right
00:06:56.845 --> 00:06:59.204
don't know what it means, something about accountability.
00:06:59.584 --> 00:07:06.654
And essentially it tackled two parts of the legislation, that July 4th legislation from'25.
00:07:07.125 --> 00:07:12.944
One was the workforce Pell, and they separated that out and said,"We will only deal with those issues in a week.
00:07:13.394 --> 00:07:22.824
If we come to consensus before that week's up, you can go home." We came back in the new year and we tackled another set of issues, and those are the accountability provisions.
00:07:23.375 --> 00:07:37.365
And those are the accountability provisions that related to direct loans and what's now known as a new kind of common sense floor across all institutions Eloygible public and nonprofit, two and four, for-profits.
00:07:37.704 --> 00:07:39.685
So we worked on that in the second week in January.
00:07:41.002 --> 00:07:43.663
And remind us all, Kristen, what is your day job?
00:07:43.822 --> 00:07:44.963
'Cause you have a day job.
00:07:45.620 --> 00:07:46.451
I do have a day job.
00:07:46.451 --> 00:07:47.211
I have to pay the bills.
00:07:47.211 --> 00:07:49.290
I have four kids, three are in out-of-state colleges.
00:07:49.711 --> 00:07:50.281
Egads.
00:07:50.911 --> 00:08:00.031
I am the founder and CEO of a public policy and advocacy consulting firm that's largely focused on post-secondary education and career
competitive learning.
00:08:00.040 --> 00:08:17.000
It's called HCM Strategists, and we were founded during the Great Recession right at the tail end of the Bush administration and the last time that our Higher Education Act, our federal accountability, federal financing, federal policy framework was last authorized by Congress.
00:08:17.331 --> 00:08:19.350
That's when HCM Strategists was founded
00:08:20.588 --> 00:08:23.738
And in my humble opinion, one of the best strategy firms in the country,
00:08:23.757 --> 00:08:24.697
Oh, thank you.
00:08:24.747 --> 00:08:31.266
We are a bunch of first-gen scrappy staffers, and so we think our model works.
00:08:31.346 --> 00:08:32.557
Yes, it does work.
00:08:32.586 --> 00:08:33.256
It does work.
00:08:33.667 --> 00:08:34.596
All right, Andy.
00:08:35.216 --> 00:08:36.927
First let's just reverse it.
00:08:36.937 --> 00:08:44.596
Let's start with your day job, Andy,'cause you also have a day job, and then we'll jump into how you got sucked into negotiated rulemaking
00:08:45.009 --> 00:08:50.609
Yeah, some of these jobs are actually two or three X, so I think we're both in that cate-- all three of us are in that category.
00:08:50.609 --> 00:08:54.308
So I serve as president and CEO of Alliant University.
00:08:54.469 --> 00:08:56.739
Have done that for the last 11 years.
00:08:57.269 --> 00:09:04.619
And Alliant is primarily a graduate-level university professional practice programs, most of which lead to state licensure.
00:09:04.619 --> 00:09:07.979
We're a niche university that turned a niche into a larger group of students.
00:09:07.979 --> 00:09:09.658
We have about 5,000 students.
00:09:10.298 --> 00:09:17.339
We serve mostly mental health licensure, K-12 teacher licensure, and soon occupational therapy.
00:09:17.339 --> 00:09:19.658
We just started nursing licensure programs as well.
00:09:19.658 --> 00:09:29.339
We're the largest provider of licensed clinical psychologists in the entire United States, and about half of mental health workers in California come from Alliant and our California School of Professional Psychology.
00:09:29.339 --> 00:09:30.448
So that's my day job.
00:09:30.609 --> 00:09:34.509
How I got sucked into neg reg, a slightly different story.
00:09:35.328 --> 00:09:37.658
I actually leaned into it and wanted to be on there.
00:09:37.658 --> 00:09:46.538
I think some very close friends of mine, especially those in DC, thought I was crazy, tried to talk me out of that, and I really wanted to serve, and I'll tell you why.
00:09:46.769 --> 00:09:50.818
This actually dates back to the Biden administration during gainful employment.
00:09:51.528 --> 00:10:01.408
And let's face it, when neg reg, whether it's legislatively driven or it's executive level driven, doesn't always get it right on the first tranche or draft.
00:10:01.408 --> 00:10:02.438
It's just not the way it works.
00:10:02.438 --> 00:10:05.418
That's why they do neg reg, is we get it as right as we can.
00:10:06.278 --> 00:10:27.359
And I worked for 18 months with some colleagues from Alliant and a couple of attorneys from Duane Morris, and we really worked hard to get gainful employment to include exclusions for clinical psychology and mental health licensure programs, which are oftentimes overlooked as not as important as phys- as physical health.
00:10:27.359 --> 00:10:29.139
And we're a mental health university.
00:10:29.489 --> 00:10:40.719
We certainly understand how important mental health is, and I think more Americans are understanding that, and we advocate strong for mental health rights, and we advocate strong for mental health inclusion in legislation and regulation.
00:10:41.328 --> 00:10:50.719
And what I learned through the neg reg process is with the right facts and data and the right level of tenacity with respect, you can get things done.
00:10:50.729 --> 00:11:18.078
We did get gainful employment rewritten to include mental health licensure programs and extra time to measure income for those graduates based on the needs of licensure being completed post-graduation So Gameful Employment finally got published with the inclusion of mental health programs, and I got a taste of that activity and moving mountains, not gravel, in DC, and that was quite enjoyable.
00:11:18.078 --> 00:11:22.369
When the Title IV changes were being discussed in one big beautiful bill, we were early on that.
00:11:22.379 --> 00:11:28.428
We could clearly see as early as February of'25 that this was gonna be major impact.
00:11:28.428 --> 00:11:31.119
I think a lot of schools were in denial that this was gonna happen.
00:11:31.899 --> 00:11:43.229
So I started taking trips out to DC back in February, March, April, trying to see if we could impact some additional language in the one big beautiful bill about these changes.
00:11:43.359 --> 00:11:46.469
Some of that worked, most of it didn't, and that's fine.
00:11:46.469 --> 00:11:55.698
So at that point, when the bill was signed on July 4th by the president, I decided to jump in headfirst and see if I could get a nomination for the committee, and did.
00:11:55.729 --> 00:12:05.078
Became the pri- one of the primary negotiators for the RISE Committee, which we helped rewrite 17 federal regulations, mostly around Title IV, but not all.
00:12:05.519 --> 00:12:12.078
Probably the most important one and the one that gets the most notoriety is which programs are in the professional designation list.
00:12:12.078 --> 00:12:16.938
You've heard those stories over and over, even today, and that was probably the one that got the most attention.
00:12:16.948 --> 00:12:22.369
We had some full rooms with media every day at our committee sessions, and that's how it all happened, though I-
00:12:23.417 --> 00:12:29.447
That's an interesting comparison of the two, two different ways that people wind up in negotiated rulemaking.
00:12:29.586 --> 00:12:31.866
Andy, let me pull on a couple of threads that you mentioned.
00:12:32.917 --> 00:12:39.856
The changes that were happening were a direct impact to your university.
00:12:39.856 --> 00:12:46.797
So I think that's a great lesson for college leaders right now that, denial is not a strategy.
00:12:46.986 --> 00:12:58.317
That you actually got up and got over to DC and started asking questions, and fortunately were invited into the conversation around the rulemaking.
00:12:58.846 --> 00:13:09.086
So before rulemaking started, the initial regs, the draft regs, excluded many of your programs from that professional designation.
00:13:09.907 --> 00:13:16.277
How did the conversation go in negotiated rulemaking and what do you think led to your success?
00:13:16.277 --> 00:13:23.797
Because there's other programs, particularly in, I get questions all the time about, nursing being excluded.
00:13:23.807 --> 00:13:25.767
H- how were you successful?
00:13:26.918 --> 00:13:35.908
Firstly, I think it's understanding what the undersecretary is driving and the secretary are driving to their alignment to the legislation passed by Congress.
00:13:35.928 --> 00:13:39.288
And let's face it, the RISE committee was very rare.
00:13:39.339 --> 00:13:44.658
It's not often that negotiated rulemaking is dictated by legislation passed by Congress.
00:13:44.668 --> 00:13:45.828
That's almost unheard of.
00:13:46.538 --> 00:13:49.818
And so we had severe bumpers to work with and constraints.
00:13:49.818 --> 00:13:51.918
There are things we could not negotiate.
00:13:51.918 --> 00:13:54.948
When Congress speaks, you can't change the will of Congress and the president.
00:13:55.519 --> 00:14:08.609
There were very few things we could impact, and we really got to work on maybe about a dozen areas we could impact, maybe softening language in some places, and the professional designation list was probably the most important work we were doing.
00:14:09.278 --> 00:14:10.769
And you go in with facts and data.
00:14:10.769 --> 00:14:19.229
You go in thinking you've got the strategy that might turn the key turn the lock with a key, and you get a lot of schools on board.
00:14:19.229 --> 00:14:20.908
You certainly listen to a lot of schools.
00:14:20.908 --> 00:14:28.359
In my role, I probably talked to no less than four or five dozen different school presidents and financial aid officers, you name it.
00:14:28.788 --> 00:14:33.668
I had my phone and email wide open, texting wide open for input.
00:14:34.038 --> 00:14:50.649
It's probably the busiest three or four months I've ever had in my career trying to do our day jobs as we talked about earlier, and then running interference and also being open and inclusive to calls and, we were trying to make sure all the schools got their voices heard, and I think we did that pretty well.
00:14:51.278 --> 00:14:56.798
What we learned, though, is that you don't always have the right strategy when you go into neg reg.
00:14:56.798 --> 00:15:07.229
It's not until you're sitting in the room, which is why I
wanted to be there, that you understand the dynamics and the nuances of what either Congress wanted or what the department where they're trying to steer.
00:15:07.278 --> 00:15:15.908
And also it's clear that consensus is not often attained, and we were able to do that, and so were the next couple of committees.
00:15:16.818 --> 00:15:25.178
And I think we're very proud of that because you have so many different opinions and different people in the room representing different constituencies, it's really tough to get consensus.
00:15:25.318 --> 00:15:27.369
And we had to work a lot of hours together.
00:15:27.908 --> 00:15:30.188
I think most of the work was done outside of session.
00:15:30.198 --> 00:15:31.678
We'd go to dinner, go to drinks.
00:15:31.708 --> 00:15:36.899
We'd have conversations early in the morning at breakfast over coffee to try to get there as best we could.
00:15:37.589 --> 00:15:40.818
But I think the biggest lesson is, yeah, dive in headfirst.
00:15:40.818 --> 00:15:51.609
If something's gonna impact you, it may not work, but dive in headfirst because at the end of that process, I wanted to make sure that we said we did everything that we possibly could do.
00:15:51.609 --> 00:16:04.859
And even if it didn't work, I wouldn't have been satisfied if I could've not told my board and our university and all the universities we represented,"Hey, we tried everything we could," and and we certainly dove in that way
00:16:06.326 --> 00:16:18.307
I know that the learners and the faculty and the team at Alliant should be very appreciative of all the work that you put in here because it definitely made life a little easier, particularly for graduate students at Alliant University.
00:16:18.726 --> 00:16:20.317
Kristen, let me jump to you.
00:16:20.636 --> 00:16:28.386
You heard Andy's experience in rulemaking and I know that you were appointed as the public member, public institution member.
00:16:28.756 --> 00:16:30.297
How did you go into this?
00:16:30.307 --> 00:16:35.067
What was your thinking going into this and your experience in the rulemaking process?
00:16:36.421 --> 00:16:45.298
I was expecting to go in and just exercise my professional judgment.
00:16:45.298 --> 00:16:52.278
And as you said, I went to a AASCU institution in California and have about 30 years of experience in the field.
00:16:52.278 --> 00:16:58.879
And so I thought I would just go in and apply my skills of understanding, how does the undersecretary work?
00:16:58.989 --> 00:17:01.629
H-what, how does Congress express its wishes?
00:17:01.629 --> 00:17:03.538
What's the role of the general counsel?
00:17:03.609 --> 00:17:05.398
How are other people showing up?
00:17:05.509 --> 00:17:08.419
What do I think is the right policy solution here?
00:17:08.459 --> 00:17:10.538
How can I-- So I thought I'd bring all those skills.
00:17:10.929 --> 00:17:17.058
Turns out that a lot of stakeholders early on when they got the l- they s- there was a lot of gossip around
who's gonna get appointed to a head.
00:17:17.848 --> 00:17:24.239
And people started calling saying,"We think we see you're on the list." And so I ended up, I and Dr.
00:17:24.239 --> 00:17:26.538
Tanja Williams, who is the president of St.
00:17:26.538 --> 00:17:39.749
Pete College in Florida, we got deluged by the stakeholder group saying,"We would like you to join a conference call, and we will tell you what we want to have happen." And about after the fifth or sixth of those stakeholder calls, Dr.
00:17:39.749 --> 00:17:40.469
Williams texts me.
00:17:40.469 --> 00:17:41.368
She's"I have a day job.
00:17:41.368 --> 00:17:54.788
I can't help out anymore." And so at that point, we just kept saying,"Send us your letter." And so that began to give me a window into how much was I gonna listen to and confer with the constituents versus just exercise my best judgment.
00:17:55.328 --> 00:18:04.638
It helped that both the policy and government affairs teams at Association of Community Colleges and AASCU attended all, every day.
00:18:04.989 --> 00:18:06.618
They made themselves available.
00:18:06.929 --> 00:18:11.919
There were also friends in the community who put their own policy teams to to practice.
00:18:11.919 --> 00:18:28.679
So they, I was able to text my friends at the Data Quality Campaign in the middle of the session on Workforce Pell and say,"How many states can really do provide data to the secretary on this one metric?" For instance, it's placement in a job six months after completion of a program, and that job needs to be in field.
00:18:28.959 --> 00:18:30.179
How many can do that?
00:18:30.548 --> 00:18:34.999
And so they quickly said,"Here's, here's what the answer is." So I was able to engage that way.
00:18:34.999 --> 00:18:43.108
And so I would say for me, it was more of me being a policy wonk than me being a government relations person for state colleges.
00:18:43.159 --> 00:18:52.094
At the end of the day, I found our, as I mentioned earlier, we were a p- a play in two acts, a party in, in, in two sessions.
00:18:52.394 --> 00:18:54.153
They were very different rulemaking.
00:18:54.253 --> 00:18:56.384
One, it was very, AHEAD was very different than RISE.
00:18:56.619 --> 00:18:59.864
know, I think you guys were getting spammed by students in professional fields.
00:18:59.884 --> 00:19:00.894
My daughter's one of them.
00:19:00.894 --> 00:19:02.844
She's an aspiring physician assistant.
00:19:03.413 --> 00:19:04.854
But you were getting spammed with video.
00:19:05.163 --> 00:19:09.864
We didn't have any controversy in our Workforce Pell, our first one.
00:19:10.044 --> 00:19:11.304
We were creating something new.
00:19:11.834 --> 00:19:12.903
People were excited.
00:19:13.084 --> 00:19:16.453
People have been advocating for this for 15 years.
00:19:16.902 --> 00:19:19.781
Iowa has been at short-term credentials since the'70s.
00:19:19.791 --> 00:19:21.561
So people were really excited.
00:19:22.142 --> 00:19:46.680
And I would say in that session, I played the r- role more as we just described, as reminding people what can't be done in rulemaking And that is if Congress has stipulated, and they did, that in order to be Eloygible for this new program, 70% of your learners have to complete the program, and 70% of those completers have to go get jobs within six months, and s- those jobs need to be in field.
00:19:47.099 --> 00:19:52.859
We couldn't say we like 55," or"We don't like, we don't the placement metric.
00:19:53.009 --> 00:20:03.569
As, as long as students complete, that's enough,'cause it's not colleges' jobs to be concerned about placement into fields." None of those positions had any ground because the Congress had already spoken.
00:20:03.940 --> 00:20:14.140
So I found I spent a lot of time saying, like holding my tongue because I didn't need to publicly grandstand and because I knew that the department had no room to give there.
00:20:14.500 --> 00:20:16.109
So that's the first act.
00:20:16.130 --> 00:20:22.859
The second act of the play when we were doing the one accountability framework, that new basEloyne for all sectors.
00:20:22.859 --> 00:20:25.319
Again, bipartisan progress.
00:20:25.880 --> 00:20:35.900
My role was to be that person I probably represented my m- less states and more my sector in that one, and it was in closed doors, they call them caucuses.
00:20:36.430 --> 00:20:52.289
And they close the doors, and we negotiators, primary and alternates, as well as the department staff, c- go behind closed doors and they basically iron out some real disagreements that, that probably can't be ironed out in, in, in front of cameras and stakeholder groups.
00:20:52.339 --> 00:20:54.849
And I spent a lot of time there.
00:20:55.569 --> 00:21:02.920
Y- Eloy, you mentioned the expression,"Denial is not a strategy." I actually said,"Please don't give us more time.
00:21:02.930 --> 00:21:05.440
Please don't give us more exceptions.
00:21:05.990 --> 00:21:15.160
Let me tell you how simple this basEloyne is." And for-- Just to remind people, three years after you finish your program, could you make$1 more than a high school graduate?
00:21:15.440 --> 00:21:19.450
And it doesn't account for your lost wages, and it doesn't account for your direct costs.
00:21:19.740 --> 00:21:21.180
It doesn't account for your time.
00:21:21.180 --> 00:21:22.289
It's$1 more.
00:21:22.539 --> 00:21:23.990
We've made all this progress.
00:21:23.990 --> 00:21:25.670
Let's not get this tied up in the courts.
00:21:26.000 --> 00:21:27.670
And frankly, I said, we need to move forward.
00:21:27.670 --> 00:21:32.140
We need to turn the page and start working on what does it look like to reassess our low-value programs.
00:21:32.140 --> 00:21:42.599
Can they be redesigned or do they need to be phased out?" And you are exacerbating that denial phase that my faculty are gonna hit July 1 of 2026 when they realize, oh, this is real.
00:21:43.450 --> 00:21:49.400
And they're gonna
really want the next Congress to be Democrat, and they're really gonna want this to go away, and it needs to not.
00:21:49.410 --> 00:21:54.240
We need to be able to provide this assertion of value, and we need to build public confidence.
00:21:54.240 --> 00:21:56.269
So I spent a lot of time saying"Everyone take a beat.
00:21:56.329 --> 00:22:00.450
This is not bad." And so that was how I showed up in the second round.
00:22:01.384 --> 00:22:04.894
So let me ask you one additional question to what you just mentioned.
00:22:06.003 --> 00:22:22.183
This whole notion about accountability, when it was first coming up in public when there was actual talk about accountability and I know you can pull the through line all the way back to the Obama administration that began talking about accountability.
00:22:23.074 --> 00:22:36.394
But it wasn't until recently that things actually started to happen, and I know a lot of my colleagues express the notion that you just mentioned, which is, this will all go away.
00:22:36.394 --> 00:22:38.054
How do we make this all go away?
00:22:39.114 --> 00:22:45.894
But in, in my view, this began as a bipartisan issue before this administration.
00:22:46.834 --> 00:23:04.824
And talk to us about how you were able to, and how you're still able to talk to people about what happened and why this is important for higher education and not just something that we should try to figure out how to get away from as soon as we can.
00:23:05.476 --> 00:23:16.115
So I think we've mentioned a couple times in this conversation, how do you really put the learners at the center of what we do in post-secondary education?
00:23:17.026 --> 00:23:25.685
If you think about a first-generation learner whose parents have no prior experience with the system, whose children don't have any, you-- this is your first experience.
00:23:25.685 --> 00:23:26.496
You're a working adult.
00:23:26.506 --> 00:23:27.885
You wanna know what's good.
00:23:29.155 --> 00:23:33.596
Not being Eloygible to borrow direct loans is a pretty clear signal.
00:23:33.685 --> 00:23:35.826
I don't need a lot of economic sophistication.
00:23:36.145 --> 00:23:38.355
I don't need to know how to navigate a fancy portal.
00:23:38.965 --> 00:23:42.865
I just need to know that this hasn't met a standard.
00:23:42.895 --> 00:23:51.086
And we've already seen some excellent data that's coming out of the department in a something called a scorecard that happened in the Obama administration.
00:23:51.596 --> 00:23:55.036
and FAFSA simplification, which I was part of that, that effort.
00:23:55.605 --> 00:24:04.885
Now, when I apply for my FAFSA as a first-generation student, I immediately get, I immediately say where I wanna send my s- my results, right?
00:24:05.286 --> 00:24:11.316
And it immediately, it tells me that program at that college doesn't have minimal economic value.
00:24:12.096 --> 00:24:12.635
Warning.
00:24:13.165 --> 00:24:14.326
You can still apply.
00:24:14.635 -->
00:24:16.026
You can still borrow money.
00:24:16.355 --> 00:24:17.296
But buyer beware.
00:24:17.306 --> 00:24:24.786
I just feel like that's a very common sense consumer protection, and I think that's a bi- consumer protection is a bipartisan interest.
00:24:25.226 --> 00:24:27.875
Then you pull back the data, and we were able to see the data.
00:24:27.875 --> 00:24:34.945
Our friend Preston Cooper, who was with us on the negotiating rulemaking, and he's at the American Enterprise Institute he showed us some data.
00:24:34.945 --> 00:24:36.455
The department showed us some data.
00:24:36.885 --> 00:24:48.556
To be honest with you, this really ensnares the accountability floors, really ensnares some of our cosmetology programs that probably have gotten too long over time and are not related to industry demand anymore.
00:24:48.865 --> 00:24:52.056
That's a huge signal to a broken part of the sector.
00:24:52.145 --> 00:24:53.786
You gotta reform, and they knew that.
00:24:53.986 --> 00:24:55.355
They were very honest at the table.
00:24:56.135 --> 00:25:02.372
In the two-year sector, there's a lot of programs that we've always kinda scratched our head at don't know if general studies has any labor market value.
00:25:02.711 --> 00:25:05.672
Sure enough, they're the programs that are caught up in this.
00:25:06.162 --> 00:25:11.541
It's time to look at whether that is really in the best interest of students to give them a general studies degree.
00:25:12.122 --> 00:25:15.872
In my sector, in the public four years, it's the fine arts.
00:25:16.296 --> 00:25:31.236
And the reality is, is that we need to do a different job embedding career experiences in our fine arts programs, career coaching, and maybe encourage our fine arts majors to not borrow too much because their lifetime earnings are going to be lower as they pursue their passion in the arts.
00:25:31.695 --> 00:25:34.806
Or maybe they need a secondary credential to help pay the bills.
00:25:35.286 --> 00:25:37.375
But all these things are healthy conversations.
00:25:37.385 --> 00:25:41.365
So just even looking at the data like,"All right, what does this mean for you?
00:25:41.365 --> 00:25:45.546
What does this mean for you?" All those things were, it's about time we had that conversation.
00:25:46.172 --> 00:25:47.241
No, that's a great point.
00:25:47.622 --> 00:25:49.195
And uh, back to you, Andy.
00:25:49.195 --> 00:25:54.556
I think something very similar was going on with graduate student loans.
00:25:54.605 --> 00:26:16.036
I think when there was first talk about capping graduate student loans, I got several calls from colleagues,"Is this real?" And my first reaction was,"Absolutely real." Again, this is something that I was hearing in the Senate well before this administration came into office.
00:26:16.105 --> 00:26:22.665
There was just a lot of frustration with programs, graduate programs that had no ROIs.
00:26:22.705 --> 00:26:35.865
A few famous examples, particularly one for Southern California private university here that was just mind-blowing, the cost versus the return on investment for that program.
00:26:35.865 --> 00:26:38.195
So there was a lot of frustration already brewing.
00:26:38.905 --> 00:26:42.115
How did-- how were you thinking about it, Andy?
00:26:42.395 --> 00:26:47.405
Obviously, you jumped into negotiated rulemaking wanting to get out in front of it.
00:26:47.905 --> 00:27:02.576
But when you're talking to your colleagues about graduate programs and accessing loans and this whole notion about accountability, how do you think about it for Alliant and how do you think about it for the field?
00:27:03.596 --> 00:27:09.286
My job as a negotiator was to think about it for not just the field or Alliant, but for all of the private sector universities.
00:27:09.286 --> 00:27:17.566
And you mentioned an example, tax status does not dictate whether a program is affordable or has good outcomes, and I think that was the primary abuse.
00:27:17.566 --> 00:27:18.885
You hit it right on the nail there.
00:27:19.445 --> 00:27:35.228
So I think it's important that the negotiators I can speak only for the RISE Committee, but I think all the committees have been that way in the last couple of years, did a nice job of really opening up to represent the entire higher education sector of over 5,000 schools and colleges.
00:27:35.657 --> 00:27:45.067
And that was really our primary goal is to make sure all voices were heard, and we got to weigh a lot of different opinions and different different inputs from all kinds of different schools.
00:27:45.538 --> 00:27:46.317
And so you're right.
00:27:46.357 --> 00:27:54.028
I think the problem with the Grad PLUS loan, it was to the full height of the cost of attendance, which any school could come up with their own.
00:27:54.548 --> 00:27:59.337
Even if a program had bad outcomes, it really didn't matter to a lot of people.
00:27:59.337 --> 00:28:02.928
They just didn't see that message, or they didn't do the research.
00:28:03.278 --> 00:28:10.238
And if it was just signing a signature loan with no collateral required, no credit check in most cases, then that's just too easy.
00:28:10.698 --> 00:28:18.278
So part of our job was to figure out how to be fair and transparent but also how to help bring in and rein in the cost of college.
00:28:18.708 --> 00:28:23.137
Now, our job, I view, as just step one of two steps.
00:28:23.137 --> 00:28:25.788
Accreditation reform has got to be the second step in that.
00:28:26.228 --> 00:28:44.688
Colleges cannot do this alone, and one of the things I'd like to see come out of, I think it's the AIM Committee, the Accreditation Committee for Accreditation Reform, is to get the accreditors to sit at the table with the universities, especially for graduate-level licensure programs that have specialty accreditation that are very prescriptive about instructional cost and what has to be dEloyvered.
00:28:45.577 --> 00:28:53.008
This is
2026, not 1826, and it's time that everyone came to the table to use today's innovations to do just that.
00:28:53.508 --> 00:28:56.167
We still have a long way to go to lower the cost of college tuition.
00:28:56.167 --> 00:29:01.557
I view the RISE Committee and the work we did as step one, and that's to limit, especially on the graduate side.
00:29:01.557 --> 00:29:03.067
Undergraduate wasn't so much touched.
00:29:03.067 --> 00:29:04.748
It was really focused on graduate level.
00:29:04.748 --> 00:29:09.057
That's really where most of the impact is and was as of July 1st of this year.
00:29:09.788 --> 00:29:21.387
But again, we still have some work to do, and I really want to see the accreditation reform come in as step two to get the accreditors to understand they can't just say that's up to the colleges," because it is not in some cases.
00:29:21.407 --> 00:29:31.688
Not so much for institutional accreditation, but for programmatic or specialty accreditation, they have to work with the universities now in step two to lower the cost of college.
00:29:32.087 --> 00:29:42.488
So I think that the underlying goal, and it mostly bipartisanness to lower the cost of college tuition, to lower student debt, we all fully support that, and most universities do too.
00:29:42.488 --> 00:29:46.208
But the accreditors now have to have an active seat at that table to do that.
00:29:46.538 --> 00:29:52.317
And so I just wanted to make it clear that, hey, look, we represented 5,000 different schools, and not everyone got what they wanted.
00:29:52.758 --> 00:30:01.508
That's not the goal of negotiated rulemaking is to understand the different opinions and inputs and to try to come to the best possible solution where you can receive consensus.
00:30:02.170 --> 00:30:11.180
you mentioned something important along the way there, which is, this notion of accountability going forward and the role of the accreditors.
00:30:12.079 --> 00:30:45.660
A lot of people think about accreditation as just this broad accreditation, being able to access Title IV, but they forget about these very specialized programs like the ones that you have at Alliant, which require specialty licensure, specialty accreditation, and people forget about those because many of those requirements from those accreditors require a university like yours to limit the size of the class, limit the ratio between the instructor and the s- and the learners, and that for good reason.
00:30:45.660 --> 00:30:50.319
I just think about my time wrestling with the Board of Registered Nursing here in California.
00:30:50.420 --> 00:30:51.839
There is good reason for that.
00:30:52.079 --> 00:31:01.299
But the challenge is it doesn't seem to evolve with changing nature of teaching and learning, the changing nature of technology the need.
00:31:01.640 --> 00:31:13.640
I can't tell you how many times I wrestled with the Board of Regi- Registered Nursing during the pandemic, trying to get them to understand that if
we don't do something different about c- clinical placements, we're not gonna have nurses in a couple of years.
00:31:14.519 --> 00:31:19.190
So all of that has to be in, in the mix and like you I hope that we can get there as well.
00:31:19.769 --> 00:31:21.809
Kristen, let me turn to you now.
00:31:21.900 --> 00:31:24.190
You've served in the department.
00:31:24.190 --> 00:31:25.670
You've served at the federal level.
00:31:25.670 --> 00:31:27.670
You've worked with state government.
00:31:28.180 --> 00:31:39.400
What surprised you about your recent experience with negotiated rulemaking or any of the negotiated rulemaking efforts that have been making their way through the process?
00:31:40.460 --> 00:31:55.700
What surprised me in this bill, and then it played out in rulemaking, is just how enamored with time as a proxy for quality we are in federal policy.
00:31:56.720 --> 00:32:05.299
And it was you could start to see that there was no way to unbundle this besides take it head on.
00:32:06.079 --> 00:32:08.369
And we did it in 1 BBB.
00:32:08.420 --> 00:32:11.880
Again, the 1 BBB is, was budget reconciliation.
00:32:11.880 --> 00:32:14.650
It was how to pay for federal tax extensions.
00:32:15.259 --> 00:32:23.880
And we moved a package of higher ed policies in that package, but it had to be with-- It had to find savers and had to be within the existing policy framework.
00:32:24.369 --> 00:32:37.640
What surprised me is how, what are the painful consequences of having a federal accountability framework that's essentially federal government is co-equal investors with states in this proposition of affordable, equitable access.
00:32:38.240 --> 00:32:41.480
And we've got to blow up Higher Education Act.
00:32:41.490 --> 00:32:43.730
It's entirely too institution-centered.
00:32:43.730 --> 00:32:47.269
I'm sorry, I represented institutions proudly at the table.
00:32:47.619 --> 00:32:49.170
It's not learner-centered enough.
00:32:49.589 --> 00:32:53.529
It's enamored with ti- with time as the only proxy for quality.
00:32:53.900 --> 00:33:03.609
And as you both have said, the research around learning, the evidence around effective models like Align, the, it is not brought to bear at all.
00:33:03.609 --> 00:33:10.069
And so you'll you come to the table, you wanna make good policy, you can't when the framework is so outdated.
00:33:10.109 --> 00:33:23.230
And so I just-- I was surprised at the extent to which the matters that we need to reconcile really are not yet in statute and need to be because as we said, you can't do rulemaking until you get the statute.
00:33:23.579 --> 00:33:31.130
And so I really think it's time, and I wanna commend the Commission on American Workforce and Eloy was on it as one of the commissioners.
00:33:31.500 --> 00:33:43.930
It's a-- it calls for a national talent strategy, and its natural conclusion will not only be a higher priority in investing in talent, but doing it quite differently with a different intentional partnership with states.
00:33:44.569 --> 00:33:54.500
The other thing I was surprised by is the relative ease by which the Department of Education and the Department of Labor came together to co-design these regs, to collaborate with us negotiators.
00:33:54.769 --> 00:34:01.859
That is an-- that was uncommon in the day when I was at the Department of Education, so that's real progress about integration.
00:34:02.309 --> 00:34:10.840
And then what was surprising is how much people easily took that governors would have a central role in defining what a pathway of value would be.
00:34:11.230 --> 00:34:21.210
Nowhere else in Title IV do states have that kind of opportunity to really align what we do in the classroom with what is gonna help learners get good jobs and improve their lives.
00:34:21.210 --> 00:34:25.090
So that was major change that people accepted pretty easily.
00:34:25.090 --> 00:34:31.969
Now it's in a small program called Workforce Pell that'll roll out very slowly, I think, for learners, but it is transformational
00:34:32.940 --> 00:34:40.329
It is transformational and it's the first step toward, really transforming the way we think about credentialing in America.
00:34:40.329 --> 00:34:49.079
And it puts states in a different role, really in the driver's seat as you mentioned, which I think people don't really realize what this will lead to.
00:34:49.079 --> 00:34:52.150
Yes, we can argue that there's not a whole lot of money in Workforce Pell.
00:34:52.159 --> 00:34:54.150
We have a Pell shortfall.
00:34:54.150 --> 00:35:03.250
We're concerned about where we go from here, but this drives every governor to think about short-term credentials, but that's a topic for another podcast, and maybe we'll have you back for that one, Kristen.
00:35:03.650 --> 00:35:08.260
let me ask you both one last question as we begin to wrap up, and I'll start with you, Andy.
00:35:09.039 --> 00:35:33.730
As an institutional leader somebody who's directly involved in running a university day-to-day, what is your advice for leaders in the field on how to approach negotiated rulemaking or more broadly, any proposed changes that the department or administration wants to make that impact higher education?
00:35:34.746 --> 00:35:39.596
That answer is really informed by my experience in 2025.
00:35:39.596 --> 00:35:45.965
I was surprised how many school leaders really didn't jump into action until it was pretty much too late.
00:35:45.985 --> 00:35:50.275
I think there's the denial phase, and the denial phase happened for many months.
00:35:50.295 --> 00:36:01.076
And then there was,"Oh we'll just hope for a new White House or a new Congress eventually, and we'll erase this." And, the way the department did it this time and this administration did it was written in stone, not on paper.
00:36:01.545 --> 00:36:08.516
You've got several layers, including legislative backing of these regulations, which is not always the case.
00:36:08.596 -->
00:36:10.335
Matter of fact, that's usually not the case.
00:36:11.146 --> 00:36:14.295
And so th- we're gonna live with these for a very long time, if not forever.
00:36:14.346 --> 00:36:24.056
This is not a White House change in a few years y- to either party where these get cha-- th- this is-- We're living with this, and I think a lot of schools are still in denial about that.
00:36:24.315 --> 00:36:31.346
So my advice is to lean in fast, and it doesn't matter if you don't have public policy experience.
00:36:31.346 --> 00:36:32.155
I had none.
00:36:32.226 --> 00:36:34.445
It doesn't matter if you don't have any experience in D.C.
00:36:34.445 --> 00:36:35.186
or don't know where to start.
00:36:35.195 --> 00:36:37.315
You start knocking on doors, making phone calls.
00:36:37.996 --> 00:36:42.456
I made a list of 100 people, and I knew that 50 wouldn't even take my call or email.
00:36:42.496 --> 00:36:42.965
Fine.
00:36:43.425 --> 00:36:47.335
I knew the 50 that would, maybe 25 wouldn't wanna help or couldn't help.
00:36:47.376 --> 00:36:47.865
Fine.
00:36:48.476 --> 00:36:50.056
And so you just-- It's a numbers game.
00:36:50.056 --> 00:36:51.335
You just start somewhere.
00:36:51.456 --> 00:36:58.626
The most effective way to overcome anxiety is action, so you just act and you go, and you-- even if you don't know what you're doing.
00:36:58.635 --> 00:36:59.396
I certainly didn't.
00:36:59.396 --> 00:37:00.365
I'm still an amateur.
00:37:00.365 --> 00:37:01.715
I don't know what I'm doing on that front.
00:37:01.715 --> 00:37:02.715
But you just make it happen.
00:37:02.715 --> 00:37:07.135
You go in with authenticity, your facts and data, and you do the best you can.
00:37:07.135 --> 00:37:08.056
But do something.
00:37:08.065 --> 00:37:12.516
Don't just sit back and assume someone else is gonna do it, because no one is gonna come rescue your school.
00:37:12.525 --> 00:37:12.925
No one.
00:37:13.565 --> 00:37:14.376
You have to do it.
00:37:14.615 --> 00:37:15.545
You gotta jump in.
00:37:16.065 --> 00:37:21.925
And we got down to about five, six, seven people that were just golden in getting what we needed to get done.
00:37:21.945 --> 00:37:24.695
We found we found the right law firm.
00:37:24.706 --> 00:37:26.405
We found the right connections.
00:37:26.445 --> 00:37:30.905
I-- You'd be surprised how many people in Congress will actually take your meeting if you ask.
00:37:31.465 --> 00:37:33.925
And you go talk to people, and you're not always gonna agree.
00:37:33.936 --> 00:37:34.666
It's not the point.
00:37:35.266 --> 00:37:42.876
But you come with respect, you come with tenacity, and you come with the facts and data, and the rest just takes care of itself
00:37:44.047 --> 00:37:48.777
That's great advice, Andy, and I'm sure that's gonna serve you well for the rest of your career.
00:37:48.878 --> 00:37:53.307
Kristen, you give advice to lots of leaders all over the country.
00:37:53.307 --> 00:37:54.458
What would be your advice?
00:37:55.869 --> 00:38:08.719
So I'm gonna harken back to my favorite political scientist, John Kingdon, who wrote about agendas and alternatives in public policy, and he described that process that I've made a living on as windows of opportunity opening.
00:38:09.489 --> 00:38:24.559
Absolutely, negotiated rulemaking is a window of opportunity, and do not let the technical nature of its process detract you from being honest about the set of issues that you as an institution, you as a, member of our community see.
00:38:25.019 --> 00:38:34.269
Because as issues are laid on the table, just like a p- imagine a coin purse, and you empty it all out, and you're gonna sort your coins, and some are going to be handled in this rule package and some aren't.
00:38:34.820 --> 00:38:40.099
And I would say in both sessions, 70% of our coins were not dealt with in the final package.
00:38:40.460 --> 00:38:46.849
That doesn't mean that we now don't have increased departmental and congressional and community awareness of a couple things.
00:38:47.260 --> 00:38:50.840
We need enhanced UI wage records, and the feds should probably pay for part of it.
00:38:51.239 --> 00:38:53.820
We need money for state capacity implementation.
00:38:54.130 --> 00:38:57.329
Again, what does the evolving role between the feds and states look like?
00:38:57.750 --> 00:39:00.139
We need to look at seriously about transfer.
00:39:00.400 --> 00:39:03.269
Are we serious about transfer, or do we just want job placement?
00:39:03.679 --> 00:39:07.530
I think we're gonna probably see some course corrections in this legislation over time.
00:39:07.710 --> 00:39:12.630
So again, get all of your issues on the table, even if they don't seem technically related.
00:39:12.829 --> 00:39:15.420
That's how this wonderful Kingdon process goes.
00:39:15.719 --> 00:39:22.690
Once they're on the table, folks like me know how to pry open the next window and know how to try and advance change that way
00:39:23.596 --> 00:39:24.925
Great advice as well.
00:39:24.925 --> 00:39:27.936
And let me ask you one, one last question about that.
00:39:28.516 --> 00:39:37.873
If they're not able to get their thoughts and opinions in before rulemaking, do you see the role of public comment as an important part of this as well?
00:39:39.068 --> 00:39:39.969
Oh, absolutely.
00:39:40.048 --> 00:39:47.268
So we negotiators were told no by the department on excluding students who can...
00:39:47.398 --> 00:39:48.978
We love stackable credentials, right?
00:39:48.978 --> 00:39:52.588
What a wonderful concept about how to approach opportunity in this country.
00:39:53.349 --> 00:39:55.708
It's in the legislation not defined.
00:39:55.929 --> 00:40:08.998
We tried to make it real by saying,"If someone finishes one short-term credential and gets another one, whether it's a horizontal or a vertical, get another one, can you be excluded from the denominator of placement?
00:40:09.009 --> 00:40:20.389
Can you be res- excluded from the denominator of wages?" They said no to both of us, to both of those issues, and that really frustrated all of the public and private nonprofit four-years.
00:40:20.398 --> 00:40:21.179
Come on.
00:40:21.438 --> 00:40:25.349
You don't you want us to build these stackable pathways, but students can't avail themselves of it?
00:40:25.798 --> 00:40:26.358
And they said,"Nope.
00:40:26.798 --> 00:40:36.789
That's not what, that's not how we interpret the law." But r- but the public comments were so strong in reaffirming what we negotiators had said, they gave us half.
00:40:37.438 --> 00:40:38.989
Congress, I think, will give us the other half.
00:40:39.188 --> 00:40:43.528
The first half was you can exclude those students who can, who re-enroll from the wages.
00:40:43.798 --> 00:40:47.278
That's important because they may not necessarily be making great wages if they're re-enrolled.
00:40:47.809 --> 00:41:00.748
They did not in the placement stat, and I think that's just going to take congressional clarification of intent because if you read the statute, boy, are they clear they wanna see transfer happening and short-term credentials not being the end of a person's learning journey.
00:41:01.853 --> 00:41:01.873
Yeah.
00:41:02.523 --> 00:41:04.623
That's great advice from both of you.
00:41:04.793 --> 00:41:09.302
And look, I really appreciate you both taking the time out of your busy schedules.
00:41:09.313 --> 00:41:12.242
There's a lot going on in both of your organizations.
00:41:12.253 --> 00:41:16.293
So Andy and Kristen, thank you both for being on the Rant podcast
00:41:17.286 --> 00:41:17.786
pleasure.
00:41:17.876 --> 00:41:18.606
Thank you for having us
00:41:19.434 --> 00:41:19.494
Thank you.
00:41:19.494 --> 00:41:20.054
Appreciate you
00:41:20.960 --> 00:41:21.791
All right, folks.
00:41:21.791 --> 00:41:33.501
You've been listening to my conversation with Andy Vaughn, who leads Aligned University, and Christian Holquist, who heads or one of the founders and heads the HCM Strategy Group.
00:41:34.311 --> 00:41:37.891
They've been talking to us about their experience with negotiated rulemaking.
00:41:38.240 --> 00:41:43.590
I'll put information about both their organizations in the comment section of this podcast.
00:41:43.601 --> 00:41:47.110
If you're watching us on YouTube, please hit subscribe, continue to follow us.
00:41:47.110 --> 00:41:55.271
And if you're listening to us on your favorite audio podcast platform, please hit subscribe, download this episode, and share it with your friends.
00:41:55.490 --> 00:41:57.422
Thanks for joining us, everybody, and we'll see you all soon.