BẢN CHÉP ÂM THANH 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:04.830 --> 00:00:09.919
Hello and welcome to Overthink.
00:00:11.070 --> 00:00:17.129
Where we discuss big ideas, but ideally in a fun and chill and exciting way.
00:00:17.609 --> 00:00:18.600
I'm your co-host, Dr.
00:00:18.600 --> 00:00:19.260
Ellie Anderson.
00:00:20.190 --> 00:00:24.089
I'm your other co-host and Ellie's trusty friend, uh, Dr.
00:00:24.089 --> 00:00:25.344
David Peña-Guzmán.
00:00:25.829 --> 00:00:27.660
Sorry, I, laughed at the end.
00:00:27.660 --> 00:00:27.940
Hold on.
00:00:27.940 --> 00:00:28.769
You just laughed.
00:00:29.050 --> 00:00:30.269
You know it's all good.
00:00:30.929 --> 00:00:32.670
You can laugh at your own name, David.
00:00:33.159 --> 00:00:39.149
This is the third episode of our series on the senses, which you can totally listen to separately, you don't need to listen to them in order.
00:00:39.509 --> 00:00:45.210
I will say this one feels kinda special though since podcasting is an auditory medium.
00:00:45.719 --> 00:00:47.850
We love hearing at Overthink.
00:00:48.268 --> 00:00:50.128
Hear us, hear you.
00:00:50.429 --> 00:00:51.179
We do.
00:00:52.259 --> 00:01:02.000
So I read a book years ago about how one of the major detracting factors to people's happiness is noise pollution.
00:01:02.429 --> 00:01:11.640
And you know, I absolutely hate vague references to books without citations, I cannot for the life of me remember where I read this.
00:01:11.644 --> 00:01:16.390
It was probably a positive psychology book on happiness because I was really into those in college.
00:01:16.829 --> 00:01:20.250
I, You really do hate those references without books.
00:01:20.250 --> 00:01:25.259
For our listeners, I'm to talk about an idea if I cannot locate the book on this podcast.
00:01:25.289 --> 00:01:27.159
It is, it is the bane of my existence.
00:01:27.159 --> 00:01:29.310
You're allowed to talk about own ideas.
00:01:29.459 --> 00:01:37.228
I just don't like it when like research shows and we can't cite one to five, ideally, studies on the research that is showing that, right.
00:01:37.650 --> 00:01:44.819
Well, either way, I'm happy that you're over to the dark side and mentioning ideas without having a citation for them.
00:01:44.819 --> 00:01:47.069
Ellie, I think we're making progress here.
00:01:47.278 --> 00:01:49.859
I can't believe you want to just stand by that, David.
00:01:49.859 --> 00:01:54.899
Let your, let yourself be the cohost who likes say shit without backing things.
00:01:54.899 --> 00:02:00.623
So don't forget, we both academics and presumably, thus have a deep investment in ethics.
00:02:00.954 --> 00:02:02.579
Yes, I, And we do, and we do.
00:02:02.579 --> 00:02:05.819
We just don't have the same citation practices, and that's different.
00:02:05.849 --> 00:02:07.500
Um, and I, I will stand by that.
00:02:08.008 --> 00:02:24.120
Now, your comment about noise pollution is hitting really close to home right now, uh, for me, on a personal level, because I just moved to a new neighborhood in San Francisco, I now live in the Tenderloin, is the noisiest neighborhood in the Bay Area.
00:02:24.300 --> 00:02:29.550
For a few days, actually for a few weeks, I've been having difficulty sleeping and even recording.
00:02:29.550 --> 00:02:43.539
If you listen to some of those YouTube interviews, you can hear the ambulances just rushing past my house because I am on an ambulance pathway, and so I'm really polluted by noise at this moment.
00:02:43.979 --> 00:02:48.014
David, I have been having my own struggles lately with this, and I'm sorry you're dealing with that.
00:02:48.014 --> 00:03:00.014
Not to like suddenly just jump on my own example, but this also feels close to home because there is major construction going on next door to my house right now, and I curse it every day as I'm trying to focus on my work.
00:03:00.164 --> 00:03:07.905
Like I wasn't even getting relief from earplugs, so I took to loudly listening to music while working, which I never do.
00:03:07.905 --> 00:03:09.824
I really like working in silence for the most part.
00:03:09.824 --> 00:03:19.215
But I just put on the first thing that I found on Spotify, which my parents share my Spotify account, was medieval church music written by Hildegard of Bingen.
00:03:22.030 --> 00:03:27.629
Um, yeah, so now I, I'm, I'm also experimenting, uh, with different kinds of music and noise.
00:03:27.659 --> 00:03:38.474
Uh, so for starters, I started putting a white noise machine on at night to drown out the noise from the outside, that has made a significant difference.
00:03:38.965 --> 00:03:50.954
Although, I am a little bit burnt because I have been socially roasted times for revealing I listen to white noise at the gym instead of like clubby, pumpy music.
00:03:51.194 --> 00:04:04.875
And my friends every like around, they all think I'm a sociopath because I'm just working out and doing exercise to brrrrrr, but I find it really relaxing.
00:04:04.879 --> 00:04:06.495
I find it very calming.
00:04:06.889 --> 00:04:09.870
Oh, you're just, you just need that space to think.
00:04:11.294 --> 00:04:12.824
About my next murder.
00:04:14.610 --> 00:04:17.490
Um, I was thinking about your research, but okay.
00:04:17.595 --> 00:04:19.485
Yeah, murder and research together.
00:04:19.485 --> 00:04:20.024
Who cares?
00:04:20.055 --> 00:04:31.620
Um uh, but the point here is that my new living quarters have really clarified for me the importance of the soundscape that we inhabit and the power that it has over our daily life.
00:04:32.160 --> 00:04:34.949
You know, from our moods to our social interactions.
00:04:35.310 --> 00:04:43.470
And I also ran into showing that noise is one of the most important determinants for student success.
00:04:43.470 --> 00:04:53.300
So students who live in noisier neighborhoods statistically perform less well than peers who come from quieter neighborhoods, because that's usually a marker of class.
00:04:53.925 --> 00:05:07.843
And you
Load full transcript
know, not only because noise puts one on edge, but also because it is an unremitting distractor that takes you out of your focus study or your exam or you know, just thinking about a problem.
00:05:08.084 --> 00:05:23.115
And so students in these noisier neighborhoods, according to this research, just can't focus on their homework as well and so they eventually start internalizing their low performance as I must be a bad student.
00:05:23.115 --> 00:05:29.913
So then that sensorial pollution or overload becomes a psychological polluter.
00:05:29.913 --> 00:05:42.394
And you know, obviously, again, like I said, there are clear class components here because it's usually members of the working class that live in the noisier corners of the urban space.
00:05:42.774 --> 00:05:53.863
Yeah, and I think indeed one hallmark of modern life is that many of us, especially urban dwellers, are constantly surrounded by sound and the ability escape
00:05:53.863 --> 00:05:53.954
Mm-hmm.
00:05:54.019 --> 00:05:56.115
that sound is a privilege.
00:05:56.834 --> 00:06:07.834
This way that so many of us are surrounded by sound constantly in our lives would have been truly unthinkable for humans in the majority of our life as a species.
00:06:07.834 --> 00:06:12.663
This idea that we are constantly surrounded by sound is a blip in the history of humanity.
00:06:13.103 --> 00:06:13.194
Mm-hmm.
00:06:13.194 --> 00:06:20.745
Zooming motorcycles, circling helicopters, train whistles, swooshing airplanes, sirens, the hiss of the subway.
00:06:21.425 --> 00:06:31.805
We are subject to constant noise, not to mention the devices of many of our homes, including say, the buzz of the refrigerator or the gush of the air conditioner.
00:06:31.865 --> 00:06:35.223
Um, if you have a window unit like I do
00:06:35.223 --> 00:06:35.434
Yes.
00:06:35.434 --> 00:06:35.533
Yes.
00:06:35.533 --> 00:06:36.254
it's really loud.
00:06:36.274 --> 00:06:37.973
I can't even watch TV and have it on
00:06:37.973 --> 00:06:38.064
Yes.
00:06:38.064 --> 00:06:38.644
at the same time.
00:06:39.004 --> 00:06:41.495
But maybe if I had a fancier air conditioner, it would be quieter.
00:06:41.954 --> 00:06:59.985
Well, and, and the deafening silence that you suddenly become aware of retroactively when the AC goes off, where you're like, oh, I thought it was silent before, but now I'm realizing how much noise I was being dis— how, how much it was distracting me, without me realizing just like barely below the threshold of conscious awareness.
00:07:00.509 --> 00:07:02.341
It's so awful about the students too.
00:07:02.497 --> 00:07:03.487
Yeah, of course.
00:07:03.487 --> 00:07:13.716
And I mean, this is one way of interpreting gated communities that they're getting themselves, not so much from physical contact, but from the noisiness of the surrounding landscape.
00:07:14.346 --> 00:07:22.206
But I feel like when we think about the ills of modern life, noise pollution isn't one of the things that comes to mind.
00:07:22.437 --> 00:07:28.177
So we can think about noise, we become aware of noise, and it registers as noise.
00:07:28.521 --> 00:07:40.401
But not really as pollution, which by definition indicates an excess of the thing in itself and, and an excess that takes on a poisonous quality.
00:07:40.581 --> 00:07:52.461
And so then the very term noise pollution, I think, forces us to rethink our relationship to noise because noise can indeed be toxic and noxious and polluting.
00:07:52.802 --> 00:08:00.396
Exactly, this is why I was so struck by the point in this book that I read about, its being linked to decreasing wellbeing.
00:08:00.982 --> 00:08:04.041
Yeah, this nameless book, nameless research.
00:08:05.182 --> 00:08:14.151
Um, no, but I, I, I think this speaks to a broader point about our sense of hearing, which is how much our culture takes it for granted.
00:08:15.776 --> 00:08:17.817
Today we are talking about hearing.
00:08:18.771 --> 00:08:22.072
How does the sense of hearing make its way into our everyday lives?
00:08:22.822 --> 00:08:26.961
To what extent does the sense of self tie up with hearing and inner voice?
00:08:27.427 --> 00:08:34.297
And how does Deaf culture call upon us to retool our understanding of the importance of hearing for human life?
00:08:40.072 --> 00:08:48.412
As we discussed with noise pollution, one of the things that seems really important about hearing is that we have a very limited ability to shut out sounds.
00:08:48.412 --> 00:08:50.062
If we can shut them out at all.
00:08:50.662 --> 00:08:55.402
And because of this hearing is sometimes considered the most passive of the senses.
00:08:55.761 --> 00:08:58.851
If I don't want to see something, I can just close my eyes.
00:08:59.272 --> 00:09:02.991
I don't want to taste something, I can refuse to open my mouth or plug my nose.
00:09:03.442 --> 00:09:06.471
But the sound of buzz saw just besieges me.
00:09:07.267 --> 00:09:10.596
Let alone the sound of a ringing in my ear that I just can't seem to shake.
00:09:11.062 --> 00:09:12.412
Oh yes.
00:09:12.772 --> 00:09:29.932
I read a paper on tinnitus actually in preparation for this episode, which talks about how tinnitus is associated with anxiety and fatigue because it forces someone to be constantly vigilant and that not only will the ringing in their ears continue, but get even worse.
00:09:29.932 --> 00:09:36.172
So it's not just about the actual annoyance of the ear ringing, but it's about the worry about what that means for the future.
00:09:36.802 --> 00:09:38.841
Wait, can I ask you a question about this research?
00:09:38.841 --> 00:09:51.772
Because is it that tinnitus is caused by anxiety and fatigue, or is it that anxiety and fatigue make a ringing in your ear not go away and it becomes constant?
00:09:51.772 --> 00:09:53.631
Because then you're thinking about it all the time?
00:09:53.871 --> 00:10:03.272
Neither the etiology is unclear, so we don't exactly know what causes tinnitus, but
the idea is that if you have tinnitus, you are more likely to have anxiety and fatigue.
00:10:03.351 --> 00:10:03.902
I see.
00:10:03.902 --> 00:10:04.501
I see.
00:10:04.761 --> 00:10:15.402
There is some suggestion that those who are predisposed to anxiety may be more likely to develop tinnitus, but the the point is really that if you have tinnitus, it's going to cause anxiety and fatigue for you.
00:10:15.542 --> 00:10:39.022
Oh this is now reminding me of the article that we discussed in our episode on vision, the the Hans Jonas article, "The Nobility of Sight." One of the things that he says there is that because hearing is relatively passive, most that we can do is decide whether to be in a state of attentive readiness about sound, because otherwise we have zero control.
00:10:39.547 --> 00:10:55.027
Hearing, we are entirely dependent on something external that outside our control, and that basically means that we can't choose the object of auditory experience in the same way that we can choose the objects of visual experience.
00:10:55.027 --> 00:10:59.856
So again, when I look at a field, I can let my eyes move this way and that way.
00:11:00.177 --> 00:11:20.466
But when I hear a soundscape, my ears cannot wander, our ears at some point, he says, are at the mercy of environmental action, and he says that action intrudes upon us without asking and decides for us what is going to be the most salient object of our auditory perception.
00:11:20.557 --> 00:11:20.886
Yeah.
00:11:20.886 --> 00:11:21.187
Yeah.
00:11:21.187 --> 00:11:22.297
So I hadn't thought about that way.
00:11:22.297 --> 00:11:35.496
Like I'm at a restaurant, for instance, I can to some extent choose to zone in on another person's conversation to just the din of the restaurant or the sound of clinking glasses, because I want to overhear what they're saying.
00:11:35.767 --> 00:11:40.506
But if they're super, super loud, then I have no choice but to listen to them.
00:11:40.506 --> 00:11:45.876
There's a point at which, like you said, the environment chooses the sound that I have to listen to.
00:11:45.876 --> 00:11:46.927
Same with the buzz saw, right?
00:11:46.932 --> 00:11:48.206
Or the ambulance in your case.
00:11:48.826 --> 00:12:05.152
Yeah, and I think this is a really good point because it adds that corrective to this interpretation of hearing as the most passive of the senses or as entirely passive because it does mean that we have a basic form of control, some kind of zoom function with the ears, right?
00:12:05.152 --> 00:12:13.042
Like you can zoom in on a conversation happening somewhere else, or you can zoom out of that conversation, uh, with the ears.
00:12:13.586 --> 00:12:19.131
In general, I think the point stands that we have a weaker sense of agency and voluntary control.
00:12:19.866 --> 00:12:32.466
When it comes to sensory input, in the case of hearing, so even if we can selectively attend to certain sounds, we simply cannot not hear a sudden sound in
our environment.
00:12:32.466 --> 00:12:32.677
Right?
00:12:32.677 --> 00:12:35.706
A glass breaks in restaurant, you have to hear it.
00:12:35.736 --> 00:12:36.966
You, you can't not.
00:12:37.596 --> 00:12:49.902
Yeah, and this sounds like something that one of the thinkers that we talked about in touch episode discusses in the book The Five Senses and this is the thinker whom we were calling in that episode, Michel Serres, because I thought Serres is how you pronounce it.
00:12:50.302 --> 00:12:59.136
And as it turns out, it's one of those weird French names that's from the southwestern region of France, the region closest to Spain.
00:12:59.797 --> 00:13:02.047
I find that lot of names from that region.
00:13:02.076 --> 00:13:04.807
I don't know how to pronounce in French, even though I speak French.
00:13:04.807 --> 00:13:10.136
And so I was thinking that it was like Serres, but it turns out it's actually pronounced like Serres.
00:13:10.267 --> 00:13:13.057
Anyway, this is a digression.
00:13:13.177 --> 00:13:17.317
Um, mea culpa, with the pronounce of Michel Serres' name.
00:13:17.542 --> 00:13:21.652
For what it's worth, I also said, Serres, always have said that.
00:13:21.652 --> 00:13:23.812
So I think we're both equally out of the loop.
00:13:23.947 --> 00:13:28.517
It really looks to me as a French speaker, like it would be pronounced Serres, so apologies.
00:13:28.537 --> 00:13:30.236
I'm going to say Michel Serres now.
00:13:30.677 --> 00:13:35.856
Serres says that vision provides a presence whereas sound does not.
00:13:36.456 --> 00:13:39.907
And this would be another main difference between hearing and the other senses.
00:13:40.116 --> 00:13:47.736
So the other senses like vision and touch give us presences and objects, but hearing
00:13:47.822 --> 00:13:47.912
Mm-hmm.
00:13:47.912 --> 00:13:50.991
gives us traces and events.
00:13:51.302 --> 00:13:53.706
The ontology is so much spookier.
00:13:54.131 --> 00:13:55.162
Oh my gosh, yes.
00:13:55.192 --> 00:13:57.892
Traces and events as opposed to, what did you say?
00:13:57.951 --> 00:13:58.192
Uh,
00:13:58.236 --> 00:13:59.277
Objects and presences.
00:13:59.437 --> 00:13:59.677
Yeah.
00:13:59.677 --> 00:14:00.876
Objects and presences.
00:14:00.876 --> 00:14:06.817
Well, and it's not just the ontology that is a little bit spookier to use your term.
00:14:06.996 --> 00:14:18.606
It's the process whereby sounds become hearing that a little bit spooky in itself because hearing, the act of hearing happens in three stages.
00:14:19.057 --> 00:14:28.417
First, you have the outer ear that has a very funny shape, you know, this kind of vortex of flesh, it acts as a funnel for sound.
00:14:28.417 --> 00:14:32.767
So it whirlwinds the sound into the inner ear.
00:14:34.274 --> 00:14:46.094
Then the, the sound reaches the eardrum, the eardrum moves a little bone that then moves another little bone, that then moves another little bone.
00:14:46.364 --> 00:14:46.844
Ooh.
00:14:46.849 --> 00:14:48.524
Like, like domino situation.
00:14:48.764 --> 00:14:50.413
Yes, very much so.
00:14:50.563 --> 00:15:00.703
And so the movement is now being transferred through three different bones, the last bone then presses against the inner ear, which is filled with fluid.
00:15:01.453 --> 00:15:12.524
And when the fluid vibrates from the pressure of that last bone, the hairs on the cochlea moves sending the signal then to the auditory portion of the brain.
00:15:12.884 --> 00:15:16.451
And you have a shift from one kind of movement to another.
00:15:16.541 --> 00:15:29.961
So you begin with airwaves then become movement of bones then become liquid waves before finally becoming electrical synapsis.
00:15:29.980 --> 00:15:33.910
It's just a, a lot of transformations of energy along the way.
00:15:34.691 --> 00:15:43.181
And the whole process is, somewhat slow, all things considered, at least compared to, you know, the movement of light, for example.
00:15:43.181 --> 00:15:45.221
So we're talking about a very different time scale here.
00:15:45.995 --> 00:16:09.355
That's fascinating, David, because it also corresponds to an idea you see in quite a lot of philosophy that associates hearing with time and um, you know, you're talking about it on a physiological level, but I think we can see this in a variety of different ways, because hearing is the most clearly temporal of the senses.
00:16:09.666 --> 00:16:21.515
To hear a noise requires that it unfolds for more than an instant, which is different from the other senses, especially from vision, where I can behold something with a single glance, literally in milliseconds.
00:16:21.725 --> 00:16:22.216
So what you've just
00:16:22.216 --> 00:16:22.306
Mm-hmm.
00:16:22.326 --> 00:16:23.046
been talking about
00:16:23.046 --> 00:16:23.115
Yeah.
00:16:23.296 --> 00:16:31.566
is the temporality of the ear, but I also think there's the temporality of the sound itself, and maybe those are really correlative, right?
00:16:32.046 --> 00:16:43.686
In fact, one of the most famous accounts of the philosophy of time uses listening to a melody as an example, this is Edmund Husserl's phenomenological work on internal time consciousness.
00:16:44.255 --> 00:16:50.706
Basically, Husserl points out that listening to a melody cannot happen in an instant, right?
00:16:51.066 --> 00:16:54.046
It requires development over time.
00:16:54.071 --> 00:17:08.830
When I'm hearing a particular note or chord, I'm also hearing the shadings of the previous notes or chords that just heard, and I am also what he calls protending or orienting myself towards the future sound that I might hear.
00:17:09.280 --> 00:17:23.691
So when we perceive a melody, we distinguish the tone that is given now, what is perceived, what we're hearing, from those which have gone by, which are no longer perceived right, we're hearing them in the present.
00:17:24.161 --> 00:17:30.490
And so there's a way that the sound is stretched out such that it is a
temporal object.
00:17:30.971 --> 00:17:42.721
And Husserl says that, sure, we say that the tone that I'm currently listening to is the perceived object, but it's actually also the case that the entire melody is perceived.
00:17:43.121 --> 00:17:45.611
Even though only the now point actually is.
00:17:45.701 --> 00:17:52.790
And so this approach to hearing a melody shows us that perception is not an instantaneous affair, but rather develops over time.
00:17:53.080 --> 00:18:08.980
And this leads Husserl to assert that perception is extended in the past and reaches toward the future, which I think is really different from the view of perception that you get stemming, say from vision, which is this instantaneous and detached approach.
00:18:09.401 --> 00:18:10.855
Yeah no, that's, that's right.
00:18:10.855 --> 00:18:20.036
The notion of synthesis here, uh, playing a really important role because for Husserl the object of perception is never the note necessarily, it's the melody.
00:18:20.096 --> 00:18:25.405
Um, at least when we're paying attention to something that is organized into a melodic structure.
00:18:25.736 --> 00:18:40.000
And one way to think about it is that if you had the same notes, but organized in a different way, you would have a very different object of auditory experience, even it's the same notes in the same number of notes.
00:18:40.181 --> 00:18:55.151
In fact, even if you had the same number of notes and the same notes organized in the same order, with different spacing in between them so that you stretch it out in time, would have a very different experience of that.
00:18:55.570 --> 00:18:59.921
Like playing something in slow motion, for example, speeding something up.
00:19:00.191 --> 00:19:16.605
And what I, what I really like about this, and I think this is what you're alluding to, Ellie, with this notion of retention and pretention is that it means that the present is always haunted by what comes before and what comes after in a virtual way.
00:19:16.945 --> 00:19:21.105
So the past and the future are always there, virtually in the present.
00:19:22.000 --> 00:19:24.010
Not positively, but virtually.
00:19:24.175 --> 00:19:24.566
Yeah.
00:19:24.566 --> 00:19:46.766
One example that you can think about in this regard as well is the fact that if I play a particular note, it's going to sound very different, this is sort of following up on what you were just saying, David, the notes before it are going to shape whether I hear this song as being in the minor scale or in a major scale, then is turn going to affect the emotions of it, right?
00:19:46.766 --> 00:19:57.925
And so there's this way that, as we said with Serres, the auditory object is um, not present, but is made up of traces and events because it is stretched out in time.
00:19:58.234 --> 00:20:05.795
And so I think this gets us back to Serres' point, that hearing involves hearing traces rather than presences.
00:20:06.349 --> 00:20:17.960
Yeah, and the comment
that you made about expectation about what you think is going to happen next in light of what has happened before is something that we see at work, not just in music, but in language as well.
00:20:18.259 --> 00:20:23.900
The phenomenologist, Alva Noë gives a really good example of this, where he says, I think he was in Germany at the time.
00:20:23.900 --> 00:20:27.170
And he speaks German and he also speaks English.
00:20:27.529 --> 00:20:35.630
And he was going on public transportation and had been speaking one language before for a while.
00:20:35.630 --> 00:20:55.250
So he was in a mental set of thinking in one language and expecting his interlocutors to use that language, I think German, and at some point somebody in the metro speaks to him in English and he's fully bilingual and he just couldn't understand the words.
00:20:55.255 --> 00:21:10.039
It was gibberish for him because that haunting presence of the past was so strong it made the present in that moment utterly incomprehensible, even though it was spoken in a language that he masters.
00:21:10.190 --> 00:21:21.859
And that's that I think a lot of bilingual people have had of just like past expectation, determining the meaning of the present, not just in connection to music, but in connection to everyday speech.
00:21:22.099 --> 00:21:29.630
This is a really interesting example that I think highlights way that our perceptions are always culturally encoded.
00:21:29.660 --> 00:21:45.619
A lot of the history of philosophy has gone wrong by assuming that we receive percept, like I receive bare sheer noises, rather than recognizing that sounds that we hear are always already being interpreted by us.
00:21:45.619 --> 00:21:51.890
And so when we hear something that is outside of our expectation, it is unintelligible for a moment, right?
00:21:52.039 --> 00:21:57.079
I don't hear a loud whirring noise over my apartment, I hear a helicopter.
00:21:57.680 --> 00:22:17.855
I remember one time when I was in Italy, I was up at the top of this beautiful villa alone after a hike and was just kind of like trolling the grounds, I heard the loudest sound ever it sounded like a giant airplane, but right over my head and I couldn't see anything to which it corresponded.
00:22:18.065 --> 00:22:23.224
And so I had this fantasy that it was like alien spaceship right above me.
00:22:23.224 --> 00:22:26.144
This was, this was well before Jordan Peele's Nope.
00:22:26.184 --> 00:22:28.305
Some abduction story.
00:22:28.724 --> 00:22:30.305
Because I, I just couldn't place it.
00:22:30.309 --> 00:22:33.755
And so there was this moment of being like, this doesn't fit in.
00:22:33.994 --> 00:22:37.055
What do I do with what I am hearing?
00:22:37.505 --> 00:22:41.194
Bit of woo woo story than Alva Noë's story.
00:22:42.184 --> 00:22:54.815
Well, and this is what one of our experts that we interviewed on hearing for our YouTube series, Christina Rotolo, means when she talks about ways of hearing that we have to
cultivate the ability to hear.
00:22:55.025 --> 00:23:00.605
And that takes time, and that happens culturally, it happens socially, it happens historically.
00:23:00.609 --> 00:23:09.454
So I'm here thinking even about I go out into nature, you know, there is an entire soundscape in the natural world that I don't know how to interpret.
00:23:09.454 --> 00:23:27.950
I don't know what it is that I am hearing when I am in the wild, somebody who has spent a good amount of time interpreting those sounds has that framework of expectation in place to say something like oh, well the cicadas are acting up tonight, which means the following.
00:23:27.950 --> 00:23:36.380
So they, they have a lot more discernment about differences those of us without that kind of training would just bulldoze over.
00:23:37.220 --> 00:23:49.670
I want to mention one other point that I think comes out of this experience of hearing that has to do with this idea we talked about earlier, that we hear traces rather than objects themselves.
00:23:49.970 --> 00:24:03.109
Because one thing, to get meta for a moment, that is quite interesting is that listeners are hearing our voices right now, weeks after we have recorded this episode.
00:24:04.039 --> 00:24:26.150
And you and I, David, contrary to what listeners may be picturing, you know, you might be thinking about us in the same room, we are hundreds of miles apart, and yet your voice is coming directly to me through my headphones and directly to listeners through their headphones or phones.
00:24:26.359 --> 00:24:30.740
And you might say that this is a peculiar feature of technology, right?
00:24:31.490 --> 00:24:34.700
It's technology that allows us to hear things at such great distances.
00:24:35.180 --> 00:25:04.690
But I think that those technological advances that we've seen in 100 or 150 years regarding sound, the invention of the phonograph, of the telephone, of CD players, of headphones, all kinds of auditory technological advancements have been enabled precisely by the fact hearing is a distal sense, that it allows us to relate, not in terms of a present object, but in terms of what Serres is going to call traces.
00:25:05.005 --> 00:25:31.974
Yeah, and I, I think that distal dimension really does mean that we, especially when you how slow sound is relative to the other senses, think about something like a lightning storm where you see the lightning right away, but then it takes a while for the sound to emerge, means that there is a really important gap between the source of the sound and then the experience or the perception of the sound that it produces.
00:25:32.335 --> 00:25:51.990
And this is a point that Derrida makes in some of his writings about technology and audio visual recordings of people that you know, it's not just that we are far away, it's also that by the time our listeners our voices, you and I could have died because there is a gap of time between those two ends.
00:25:52.009 --> 00:26:01.700
So there is that spectral dimension where we hear something, but we don't really know if the object that originally produced that is still there or not.
00:26:02.059 --> 00:26:09.269
And hence the element of the uncanny in hearing the voice of somebody that we know has died.
00:26:09.359 --> 00:26:25.130
Like when you know you have a voicemail or a video recording of somebody that passed away, it gives you really bizarre feeling of the presence of something that is absent and should no longer be present yet is.
00:26:25.984 --> 00:26:34.005
But I want to also disambiguate what you just talked about with the voicemail and the video recording, because you can also watch a video of somebody after they have died.
00:26:34.444 --> 00:26:34.505
Yeah.
00:26:34.505 --> 00:26:44.894
That video is showing you an image of them, which is ontologically distinct from the them that you would see ordinarily.
00:26:45.494 --> 00:26:58.565
And I think there's an argument to be made that the same is not true of hearing, that there is not an ontological difference between the trombone that you hear recorded and the trombone that you hear live.
00:26:59.315 --> 00:27:01.355
At least this is a view that some philosophers have held.
00:27:02.269 --> 00:27:02.690
Yes.
00:27:02.694 --> 00:27:18.319
And if that's the case, then it would mean that hearing somebody who has died, just only the voice without seeing them, would actually be the spookier phenomenon because it means that in principle, that person could still be around.
00:27:18.799 --> 00:27:25.819
I think this ontological difference can be understood in terms of our experience of causality at the level of perception.
00:27:25.819 --> 00:27:42.934
So when I see a person, the image of a person, and hear the sound, I immediately make a connection between that image and the sound in terms of cause and effect, whatever that object the person that is depicted is making the sound that I am hearing.
00:27:42.940 --> 00:27:50.430
But when we only have the sound without any visual correlate, we have the effect, but we don't have the cause.
00:27:50.710 --> 00:28:06.424
And so it means that there is costless effect just floating around that ambiguity about what truly caused the sound as an element of indeterminacy to our experience of sound, making ontologically distinct, as you said.
00:28:26.914 --> 00:28:36.785
One thing that came up for me when thinking about hearing is the way that we often use metaphors of hearing for understanding, sympathy, and empathy.
00:28:37.234 --> 00:28:39.154
As in the case I hear you.
00:28:39.740 --> 00:28:41.509
Or in Chicago parlance heard.
00:28:42.994 --> 00:28:44.375
Did people say that in Chicago?
00:28:44.375 --> 00:28:45.454
Just heard.
00:28:46.160 --> 00:28:49.160
I've been watching the Bear the TV show recently.
00:28:49.190 --> 00:28:50.299
It's so good.
00:28:51.230 --> 00:28:53.630
So that's what's coming to mind for me.
00:28:53.630 --> 00:28:55.609
It takes place in the
Chicago restaurant industry.
00:28:56.029 --> 00:29:09.799
But what you're speaking to, I, I think, is also about the way that hearing is used as a way of thinking about recognition, how we recognize other people as subjects, whether that's through sympathy or empathy or something else.
00:29:09.950 --> 00:29:15.890
And in fact, some philosophers have suggested that actually how we recognize ourselves.
00:29:16.460 --> 00:29:27.470
George Herbert Mead, for instance, early 20th century philosopher and sociologist, argues that the very sense of self emerges socially through the experience of hearing ourselves speak.
00:29:28.414 --> 00:29:29.444
Oh, whoa.
00:29:29.494 --> 00:29:38.015
So it is that speaking, we come to know we are agents because we see the effects of our own activity?
00:29:38.779 --> 00:29:49.650
Not even, it's not even about agency per se, it's more just about, although maybe kind of, it's more just about ourselves as a being in the world.
00:29:49.710 --> 00:29:58.289
So Mead believes that the essential feature of the self is, its reflexivity, ability to take itself as an object.
00:29:58.769 --> 00:30:03.589
And you might think that this means seeing yourself as an object, right?
00:30:03.589 --> 00:30:10.144
Most philosophies would thematize self-objectification as a visual or this objectification.
00:30:10.174 --> 00:30:11.154
Like in a mirror.
00:30:11.234 --> 00:30:13.700
Exactly, exactly the mirror stage and Lacan, for instance.
00:30:14.299 --> 00:30:19.309
But Mead thinks that it is an auditory process through what he calls vocal gesture.
00:30:19.744 --> 00:30:26.224
Going back to something that you said earlier, David, about the way that hearing is often considered a passive sense.
00:30:26.555 --> 00:30:31.265
Mead thinks it's actually the passivity of the sense of hearing that provides for the experience of self.
00:30:31.744 --> 00:30:33.755
So let me explain how this works.
00:30:34.204 --> 00:30:35.825
Because I obviously find it really interesting.
00:30:36.500 --> 00:30:37.400
Well, yeah, I do too.
00:30:37.400 --> 00:30:37.849
I do too.
00:30:37.849 --> 00:30:38.809
It's fascinating.
00:30:38.809 --> 00:30:40.555
Like getting, getting excited just talking about it.
00:30:40.944 --> 00:30:49.384
When we speak, the sound of our own voice, Mead says, assails our ears, just as it assails the ears of others.
00:30:49.835 --> 00:30:54.605
That is, we hear what we are saying in the same way that others hear them.
00:30:55.279 --> 00:31:03.769
This is different from other senses, so I might see or feel the movements of hands as others see or feel them.
00:31:04.309 --> 00:31:06.710
He notes that this is the case for those who are deaf.
00:31:07.400 --> 00:31:15.529
But the vocal gesture for those of us who hear has the least amount of gap between the way I experience it and the way others experience it.
00:31:15.529 --> 00:31:18.410
So I hear myself more similarly to how
00:31:18.410 --> 00:31:18.509
Hmm.
00:31:18.509
--> 00:31:26.289
others hear me, and in fact, in same way that others hear me, whereas I don't see myself or touch myself in quite the same way that others see or touch me.
00:31:26.650 --> 00:31:42.079
And this means that for Mead, the vocal gesture has provided the medium of social organization and human society above all, because it's so deeply organizes not only our relations to others, but actually our relation to ourselves that a self emerges out of it.
00:31:42.994 --> 00:31:43.535
Yeah, no.
00:31:43.535 --> 00:31:48.035
And if the self emerges out of it, then definitely would have to be considered fundamental.
00:31:48.545 --> 00:31:52.744
Although I, I have to say, I find this view a little bit bizarre.
00:31:52.789 --> 00:31:54.644
Oh yeah, it's for sure bizarre.
00:31:54.954 --> 00:31:56.105
I mean, but it's intuitive, right?
00:31:56.194 --> 00:32:07.525
I think a lot of people talk about there being an inner voice and hearing one's self speak as maybe the development of that inner voice that can happen on its own without externalization over time.
00:32:07.944 --> 00:32:17.615
But what's bizarre for me about this claim is the idea that we hear ourselves in the same way that other people hear us.
00:32:18.005 --> 00:32:28.625
And whenever I think about recognition, I always want to think about the role that mis-recognition plays in that logic of self recognition.
00:32:28.835 --> 00:32:33.214
Because I do think that there's always an element of mis-recognition that is at the core of subjectivity.
00:32:33.634 --> 00:32:38.855
And this is something that we have talked about in connection to the mirror stage in connection division, right?
00:32:38.855 --> 00:32:43.085
That when you look at a mirror, you recognize yourself, but there's always something off.
00:32:43.625 --> 00:32:45.424
In that case, the mirror is inverted.
00:32:45.424 --> 00:32:49.625
And so we always have this element of mis-recognition where something doesn't match.
00:32:50.224 --> 00:33:12.170
I think that that mis recognition also happens at the level of auditory experience and hearing oneself speak, which is why most people, when they hear a recording of their own voice, hate the way they sound, even though other people say, that's exactly what you sound to us, that's, that's your voice.
00:33:12.529 --> 00:33:12.690
Mm-hmm.
00:33:12.839 --> 00:33:25.462
I think that voice that we hear, maybe because of the closeness of our mouth to our ear and because it resonates inside our head, is actually fundamentally different than the way other people hear us.
00:33:25.468 --> 00:33:30.143
There is that gap between our inner voice and and our outer voice.
00:33:30.143 --> 00:33:38.752
But for the record, I also just really love the notion thinking of the self as having this inner speech.
00:33:38.903 --> 00:33:41.153
That's just not the way I think about experience.
00:33:41.542 --> 00:33:44.482
No, but whole point is that it doesn't have this inner speech.
00:33:44.482 --> 00:33:53.182
The whole point is that there's no difference the speech that one is saying and what others are hearing, that there's, that there's no gap there.
00:33:53.587 --> 00:34:08.108
I think I, I don't personally experience the hatred of hearing my own voice that others do, and maybe that's just because we have to listen to ourselves all time as we're, you know, spot checking our episodes before they get released.
00:34:08.557 --> 00:34:25.057
But I do find that, David, when you and I record, we have to turn off a feature that most video conferencing technologies have automatically, which is echo cancellation, which makes it so that you don't hear your own voice on the other person's computer as you are speaking.
00:34:25.657 --> 00:34:35.407
And you and I, because we have this feature off, unless we're wearing headphones, when we're on video together, we hear our own voices just like a split second after we speak.
00:34:35.788 --> 00:34:37.132
An echo yes.
00:34:37.208 --> 00:34:39.847
It is, it is so frustrating for both of us.
00:34:40.612 --> 00:34:41.963
Drives me to murder.
00:34:42.072 --> 00:34:42.972
It's impossible.
00:34:42.972 --> 00:34:43.913
That's how bad it is.
00:34:43.913 --> 00:34:44.362
Yes.
00:34:44.992 --> 00:35:00.382
No, but I, I mean, so I, I wonder the extent to which Mead's model of us hearing ourselves speak might not actually be better understood in terms of the automatic cancellation of the voice.
00:35:00.802 --> 00:35:13.163
For us, I think maybe our brain, I don't, I don't know if this is true now, I'm like full on speculating, but I wonder whether, it's not that we hear ourselves speak, it's actually that we tune out what we put out.
00:35:13.643 --> 00:35:19.132
So the brain knows the difference between are outside of our control versus those that are generated internally.
00:35:20.407 --> 00:35:20.617
Yeah.
00:35:20.623 --> 00:35:23.688
I think that does get overlooked in Mead's account.
00:35:24.413 --> 00:35:30.503
And so I'm not sure that I buy the idea that I really hear my own voice, let alone that I hear it in the same way that others hear it.
00:35:30.922 --> 00:35:43.762
And I'm here reminded of a claim Wittgenstein says he thinks that our relationship to our own words that we utter is totally different from other people's words.
00:35:43.822 --> 00:35:47.362
And he even doubts that we hear ourselves at all.
00:35:47.362 --> 00:35:52.023
There is no such thing hearing my own voice back to me.
00:35:52.682 --> 00:36:01.523
I think that might be right in the sense that it is so disorienting for us to hear the echo of our own voice when we are actually speaking.
00:36:01.643 --> 00:36:07.463
I think that that it's not it's not a normal experience.
00:36:07.463 --> 00:36:07.733
Right.
00:36:08.407 --> 00:36:15.547
So I'm personally really compelled by Mead's claim that the self emerges socially when we take a perspective on ourselves as an object.
00:36:16.418 --> 00:36:24.668
But I might buy the
philosopher Karen Hanson's criticism that it's not the vocal gesture that really succeeds in doing this for us.
00:36:25.237 --> 00:36:40.777
At most, the vocal gesture might be one part of our development of the sense of self Hanson argues, but she just doesn't think that it can be the organizer of social life and the mechanism of self-creation in the way that Mead thinks it is.
00:36:41.492 --> 00:36:41.983
Yeah.
00:36:41.987 --> 00:36:58.853
And in fact, I think that hearing our own voices in the same way that we hear other people's voices is often seen as a sign of pathology if anything, rather than the normal course of child development or the development of a self.
00:36:59.362 --> 00:37:07.943
For example, thinking that you hear another voice when it's your own voice is a hallmark the diagnosis of schizophrenia.
00:37:08.682 --> 00:37:21.577
Indeed researchers have argued that schizophrenia involves a disruption of the self, whereby one fails to recognize one's own activities, including inner speech or voices as one's own.
00:37:22.657 --> 00:37:33.577
The psychologist, Christopher Frith has some quite influential work on the idea that schizophrenia has to do with a breakdown of self-monitoring.
00:37:34.056 --> 00:37:52.014
So we might say then that non-pathological experience involves recognizing one's own voice in different way than one recognizes the voices of others, which is kind of the opposite of Mead's view, although it's also different from what you said a moment ago, David, which is that we don't hear our own voices at all, right.
00:37:52.304 --> 00:38:08.628
But either way, whether we're not hearing our own voices at all, or whether we're recognizing them differently from the way that we recognize the voices of others, I think the point here would be that what happens when we fail to recognize our voice as our own that we end up thinking it's coming from outside us.
00:38:09.034 --> 00:38:29.373
Yeah, no, and I think that view of schizophrenia as a disruption of the inner voice, or rather the projection of our inner voice onto an external source is pretty common, and it just shows how closely tied hearing or listening seem to be with our sense of self, especially in the medical imaginary.
00:38:29.733 --> 00:38:40.684
But I read an article on schizophrenia that argues that this inner speech model schizophrenia is precisely the wrong way to think about the phenomenon.
00:38:40.954 --> 00:38:44.884
Now the article is called Stop, Look, and Listen.
00:38:45.364 --> 00:39:09.784
And the authors basically argue that if you stop, look and listen to the phenomenon of schizophrenia you realize that so-called inner voice is not really there all because when we're just going through our everyday life, it's not as if we really have inherently linguistic flow of experience, right.
00:39:09.784 --> 00:39:24.550
It's not as if I look at the tree and a little voice in my head says this is a tree, then I turn a little bit to side and I see dog running, and then I have a thought in linguistic form that says the dog is running.
00:39:24.554 --> 00:39:41.260
It's not that there is language unfolding in and if that's the case that that's not happening, the authors say we need to no longer rely on the inner speech model for thinking about schizophrenia.
00:39:41.320 --> 00:39:54.369
And instead of thinking that schizophrenia is basically a misattribution of my inner speech onto external source, which thereby creates strange voices, we should think about schizophrenia.
00:39:54.940 --> 00:40:00.219
More as a disruption of the logic of self experience.
00:40:00.590 --> 00:40:06.489
And the way they talk about it is in terms of a form of hyper reflexivity.
00:40:06.494 --> 00:40:11.260
We become hyper reflexive when uh, schizophrenia enters the scene.
00:40:11.644 --> 00:40:18.574
Almost as if we are not failing to objectify ourselves, but objectifying ourselves too much?
00:40:19.090 --> 00:40:20.349
That's exactly right.
00:40:20.403 --> 00:40:27.572
Normally there are a lot of processes that are going on to prop up our sense of self.
00:40:28.043 --> 00:40:31.922
And these are processes that we don't need to think about explicitly.
00:40:31.922 --> 00:40:46.652
They're just in the background, they're on autopilot and they need to be in the background, but in schizophrenia, all these implicit processes suddenly get pushed to the foreground and we start thinking about them too much.
00:40:46.657 --> 00:40:53.132
We become fixated on them, and that creates a pathological rumination loop.
00:40:53.132 --> 00:41:00.092
We just get stuck thinking about these background processes we start basically overthinking our subjectivity.
00:41:00.333 --> 00:41:01.023
So
00:41:01.222 --> 00:41:04.123
Overthinking a word we often like here.
00:41:05.063 --> 00:41:12.393
and they use a really interesting example, like the basic bodily movements that are needed for making coffee in the morning.
00:41:12.603 --> 00:41:14.913
You know, I get up, I reach for the coffee.
00:41:15.539 --> 00:41:19.867
And it's not as if I am really, I I do those while I'm still half asleep, right?
00:41:19.867 --> 00:41:30.177
I don't need to think consciously extend hand 20 centimeters to the left, down push on the top of the French press.
00:41:30.282 --> 00:41:34.481
Such that you're like talking your talking to yourself or hearing yourself while you do that.
00:41:34.916 --> 00:41:36.086
Yes, exactly.
00:41:36.266 --> 00:41:43.646
And what happens in schizophrenia is that all those background movements then become the object of my attention.
00:41:43.646 --> 00:41:47.306
They become intentional objects and I start focusing on them.
00:41:47.737 --> 00:41:54.327
And once I, I start thinking about them, it actually disrupts the natural flow of the movements themselves.
00:41:54.536 --> 00:41:56.452
And it sort of paralyzes me.
00:41:56.753 --> 00:42:10.436
And the way the authors talk about it is that this hyper reflexivity
means that we start experiencing our own bodies, basically as a machine, and we start becoming alienated from our bodies.
00:42:10.737 --> 00:42:16.197
And eventually this alienation makes us lose our sense of reality.
00:42:16.197 --> 00:42:17.726
Like, am I real?
00:42:17.726 --> 00:42:25.016
If I have to think about these movements that now seem unorganic and mechanical?
00:42:25.601 --> 00:42:26.461
Derealization.
00:42:26.876 --> 00:42:32.677
Yes, that derealization Ellie is, is what they say schizophrenia is at its core.
00:42:32.907 --> 00:42:40.556
It is an alienation of ourselves from our own subjectivity that creates the sense that nothing is real.
00:42:41.817 --> 00:42:49.137
And it might be interesting to link this back to our earlier conversation about the temporality of hearing, although I do hear your point, David.
00:42:49.137 --> 00:42:49.556
Haha.
00:42:49.556 --> 00:42:58.286
I hear your point, that this model of schizophrenia is trying to push against notion of schizophrenia as a disruption of inner speech specifically.
00:42:58.286 --> 00:43:05.967
But I still think there's a way that both inner speech and a sense of temporality are potentially disrupted here.
00:43:05.996 --> 00:43:06.416
Right.
00:43:06.416 --> 00:43:12.166
And there's hyper reflexivity that is taking you out of the flow of time.
00:43:12.637 --> 00:43:13.217
Yes.
00:43:13.217 --> 00:43:35.351
And the only lingering question there would be to what extent are committed to the notion that what is happening in the head is a kind of speech when we are going through everyday experience as opposed to speech being a model that we project retroactively when we thematize our inner life.
00:43:35.382 --> 00:43:43.782
And my own sense is that speech is something that we project onto thought when we have to talk about what's happening.
00:43:43.992 --> 00:43:46.782
But it's not as if thought itself is linguistic.
00:43:54.237 --> 00:43:58.737
If you're enjoying, Overthink, please consider supporting the podcast by joining our Patreon.
00:43:59.097 --> 00:44:10.166
We are an independent, self-supporting podcast, and as a subscriber, you can help us cover our key production costs, gain access to our exclusive digital library of bonus content and more.
00:44:14.061 --> 00:44:20.711
In thinking about the senses, might be tempted to believe that because different senses make different kinds of information available to us.
00:44:20.952 --> 00:44:24.161
The absence of those senses would necessarily be lack.
00:44:24.282 --> 00:44:28.902
But disability activists and theorists call this conclusion into question.
00:44:28.902 --> 00:44:36.887
I think this is really a big aspect of critical disability studies, which is a burgeoning, contemporary and interdisciplinary field.
00:44:37.454 --> 00:44:39.322
David, tell us about this.
00:44:39.983 --> 00:44:40.523
Yeah.
00:44:40.552 --> 00:45:00.202
Experts in this field of critical disability studies make the argument that the impairment or the absence of a sense, such as hearing, need not and should not be interpreted as a lack, as an absence, or as a disability, it can be interpreted in a number of ways.
00:45:00.262 --> 00:45:12.443
So, for instance, in case of hearing, a number of Deaf culture experts argue that we should think about deafness as a unique culture rather than as a disability.
00:45:13.072 --> 00:45:24.132
Robert Sparrow, who specializes on this subject, this argument in an essay entitled Defending Deaf Culture, where he says, deafness is not a lack.
00:45:24.422 --> 00:45:25.862
It is not an absence.
00:45:26.012 --> 00:45:34.143
It is a culture with its own structure, its own history, of course, its own language.
00:45:34.682 --> 00:45:39.632
He says that there are two reasons for adopting a cultural understanding of deafness.
00:45:40.202 --> 00:45:47.012
One, and this is a really important one, is that this is already how members of the Deaf community see themselves.
00:45:47.163 --> 00:45:56.793
They see themselves as a political and cultural minority, and not as people who have experienced some kind of tragedy related to the lack of a particular sensory modality.
00:45:56.793 --> 00:45:58.652
That's not their self understanding.
00:45:59.132 --> 00:46:18.753
And the second reason for thinking about deafness culturally is that members of the Deaf community have their own language, and that is, of course, American Sign Language, which clearly maps onto our legal and political categories of what it means to be a cultural group.
00:46:18.902 --> 00:46:26.643
We often associate that with a shared heritage, history, language, as well as a few other things, but that's the one that's relevant.
00:46:27.782 --> 00:46:28.293
Okay.
00:46:28.532 --> 00:46:36.842
And is the claim that all people who are born with or develop hearing impairments of different kinds are automatically members of this culture?
00:46:37.413 --> 00:46:45.543
Or is it a culture that individuals then have to actively seek out and participate in to be included in?
00:46:45.632 --> 00:46:52.503
Cause I think we don't normally think about culture as things that you are literally born into by virtue of your embodiment alone.
00:46:53.117 --> 00:46:53.447
Yes.
00:46:53.447 --> 00:46:56.777
No, you're raising a really good point, Ellie here because.
00:46:56.987 --> 00:47:01.728
So first, let's take a step back because we need to differentiate between two
00:47:01.728 --> 00:47:09.257
deaf, with a lower case D and Deaf with an upper case D.
00:47:09.918 --> 00:47:17.958
Now the first, with the lower case, refers to people with any kind of hearing impairment that changes how they relate to the world.
00:47:18.467 --> 00:47:30.378
The second Deaf with an upper case is people who have a hearing impairment and who also identify as members of capital D Deaf culture.
00:47:30.858 --> 00:47:40.248
And so Deaf people with a capital D build a significant portion of their identity, not the totality
of it, of course, around their membership in this group.
00:47:40.697 --> 00:47:51.418
And so you are not automatically capital D Deaf if you are born or become lower case D deaf.
00:47:51.956 --> 00:48:06.469
But Sparrow does recognize that Deaf culture is kind of unique relative to other cultures because it does have this biological component or this biological requirement that other cultures just don't have, right?
00:48:06.469 --> 00:48:19.878
You don't have to have any kind of embodiment to be French or to be Mexican, there does have to be this requirement of some kind of hearing impairment for you to be a member of Deaf culture.
00:48:20.389 --> 00:48:28.938
And it's also a little bit bizarre because typically cultural identity is passed vertically from parents to their kids.
00:48:29.088 --> 00:48:38.148
But that's not the case with Deaf culture because the vast majority of people with hearing impairments of deaf people are born to hearing parents.
00:48:38.208 --> 00:48:43.548
And most hearing parents, you know, they're not members of capital D Deaf culture.
00:48:44.088 --> 00:48:53.188
Well, and you can have, you can have parents who don't hear, and children who do, like in the, the case of CODA that the movie came out, and this is part of Deaf culture too, right?
00:48:53.188 --> 00:48:54.489
The children of deaf adults.
00:48:55.233 --> 00:48:59.733
Yes, and that raises some about hearing people in Deaf culture.
00:48:59.764 --> 00:49:03.724
But in that we would say that those people are born into Deaf culture.
00:49:03.994 --> 00:49:06.574
But the other way around is the inverse.
00:49:06.574 --> 00:49:09.523
People are deaf are not members of Deaf culture.
00:49:09.528 --> 00:49:14.443
So they do have to go out find it on their own, usually when they're already adults.
00:49:15.423 --> 00:49:16.364
Although ideally before that.
00:49:17.278 --> 00:49:28.528
Yeah, and I think another way that we think about culture is in terms of shared experience, especially when that shared experience gets organized into habits and practices that are communal.
00:49:28.978 --> 00:49:34.739
And so those who are deaf have shared experiences of living in a world that has been built for the hearing.
00:49:35.338 --> 00:49:39.478
And these sets of shared experiences also give rise to cultural formations.
00:49:39.509 --> 00:49:55.768
So I saw a, production of Oedipus from Deaf West Theater, which is this awesome theater company, I've been going to see their shows since I was a kid, that is comprised of some deaf actors and some hearing actors.
00:49:55.978 --> 00:50:03.949
And these productions tends to attract both a lot of people who are, you know, part of the Deaf community and people outside of it, such as myself.
00:50:04.608 --> 00:50:10.393
And the ways that they organize the theatrical performances are so fascinating.
00:50:10.664 --> 00:50:19.798
Like for instance, they'll have hearing actors who at certain times will speak, but at other times
will sign and there will be subtitles up above.
00:50:19.804 --> 00:50:21.378
For those who don't, who don't ASL.
00:50:21.378 --> 00:50:21.588
Mm.
00:50:21.588 --> 00:50:21.998
Mm-hmm.
00:50:22.318 --> 00:50:33.568
And then there will be deaf actors who will sometimes like utter a noise or say certain words or phrases, but then at other points sign, sometimes they'll even have deaf actors and hearing actors paired one another.
00:50:33.568 --> 00:50:38.028
And so the hearing actor will be speaking while the deaf actor is signing or gesturing.
00:50:38.548 --> 00:50:55.768
And I think what you really see in the Deaf West production, such as this production of Oedipus, is that it doesn't feel like you are seeing a performance that is compensating for the fact that some of the actors and audience members have a quote, lack to go back to that absence model you talked about before, David.
00:50:55.978 --> 00:51:10.619
It really is this full and positive theatrical performance that is different in kind from the kind of performance that you would have of Oedipus it were being done, you know, in a more standard way that wasn't through this Deaf West production.
00:51:10.619 --> 00:51:19.402
And there's a whole set of possibilities, emotional possibilities, possibilities of interpretation that open up by virtue of the particular structure of the Deaf West productions.
00:51:19.887 --> 00:51:37.628
Yeah, and I, I'm not familiar with this production company, but I suspect this could be an example of what Sparrow means when he says that Deaf culture is a culture to a large extent because they have not just a language, but also shared institutions and shared cultural practices.
00:51:37.688 --> 00:51:38.018
Totally.
00:51:38.018 --> 00:51:39.980
That was kind of where I started with this.
00:51:40.402 --> 00:51:45.463
And so let me share a quote here because I think it neatly encapsulates all of this.
00:51:45.773 --> 00:52:02.523
And just to keep things in perspective, Sparrow ultimately wants to say that the Deaf community is not a subculture in the same way that like hippies are a subculture of American culture, he wants to say that they are a standalone culture.
00:52:02.523 --> 00:52:04.682
They are a cultural unit.
00:52:04.682 --> 00:52:06.563
And so has the following to say.
00:52:06.922 --> 00:52:18.322
He writes, unlike subcultures or even some ethnic cultures, Deaf people possess their own distinct languages, with a unique vocabulary in grammar.
00:52:18.922 --> 00:52:30.282
Deaf people also have a shared set of experiences relating to the consequences of deafness in a hearing culture, a shared history, and a distinct set of institutions.
00:52:30.592 --> 00:52:36.413
They have their own schools, clubs, meeting places, and even sporting competitions.
00:52:36.822 --> 00:52:45.023
The combination of the possession of a language and a set of institutions makes the claim of Deaf culture a particularly strong one.
00:52:45.467 --> 00:52:53.288
And I'm
struck by the end of that quote, David, where Sparrow says, the claim of Deaf culture is a particularly strong one.
00:52:53.288 --> 00:53:04.177
And so this suggests that there is a motivating force behind his piece, which is to right, make the claim deaf culture is a culture.
00:53:04.748 --> 00:53:23.467
I think when we think about it that way, we can imagine what it might look like if Deaf culture were recognized more as such within the I don't want to say broader culture that we live in, because that's going to risk the idea of subculture that you just, uh, is, is the wrong way of thinking about it.
00:53:23.978 --> 00:53:31.958
But maybe a, a kind of imbrication of cultures or an honoring of cultures within cultures without saying that they're subcultures.
00:53:32.878 --> 00:53:47.947
I think when one sees what a rich life Deaf people have, when society is organized with them in mind, whether it's through these schools, meeting places, sporting competitions, theatrical performances, a very different picture of deafness itself emerges.
00:53:47.947 --> 00:53:54.248
We don't see it as a gap or an absence of hearing, but rather as a mode of being.
00:53:55.387 --> 00:53:55.838
Yeah.
00:53:55.887 --> 00:54:01.838
And you know, even beyond that, it's not just that, it's a mode of being that it's not a lack.
00:54:02.318 --> 00:54:06.068
It might be a motive being that it's actually a gain.
00:54:06.068 --> 00:54:06.608
Mm.
00:54:06.608 --> 00:54:06.697
Yeah.
00:54:06.697 --> 00:54:21.458
Like benefit or plus, and there is a concept in critical disability studies called disability gain, which is about personal and collective benefits that come with certain so-called disabilities.
00:54:21.838 --> 00:54:34.507
For instance, in the case of hearing, there is really exciting research showing that some of the gains of being deaf tied to cognition and the use of ASL as one's mother tongue.
00:54:35.027 --> 00:54:35.518
Okay.
00:54:35.527 --> 00:54:43.327
One of the things about ASL is that of course it relies on the visualization of symbols through bodily movement right?
00:54:43.327 --> 00:55:04.733
That's what we call signing and having a native mastery of ASL has been linked to improved mental abilities, to being faster at generating mental images, to performing objectively better on tests related to mental rotation skills.
00:55:04.733 --> 00:55:12.713
You know, those, those, um, tests where they show you a really complicated asteroid looking shape, and have to guess what it would look like from the other side.
00:55:13.222 --> 00:55:31.273
People who are born into deaf culture and who speak ASL as their mother tongue do significantly better at those kinds of tasks perform really, really well and better than their hearing counterparts at facial recognition skills and spatial cognition tests.
00:55:31.882 --> 00:55:33.313
So here we see a lot of benefit.
00:55:34.268 --> 00:55:50.318
You can see that because if your way of communicating builds concepts through movement and motoric visualization, I can imagine that you think about those concepts as more inherently dynamic than someone who associates concepts with a static word or a sound.
00:55:50.768 --> 00:56:05.737
Yeah, and read this article that used a specific word for this power of ASL and the authors used the term metaphoric iconicity about the the prowess of ASL.
00:56:06.177 --> 00:56:20.288
Basically the idea is that when you are a native ASL speaker or somebody who masters it, you know, like native, you enact metaphors and concepts through movement and therefore you visualize them more.
00:56:20.288 --> 00:56:21.728
That's what we've talking about.
00:56:23.182 --> 00:56:36.172
The, the authors of this piece made the additional argument that culturally, this might be really important for us as we move into new forms of technology and new forms of communication in the 21st century.
00:56:36.177 --> 00:57:08.003
Because as we see the rise of mixed visual media, largely because of the internet and because of globalization, those of us who don't communicate with ASL might benefit from learning to think ASL communicators because that will allow us to deal with the visual dimensions of 21st century communication and textuality a lot better than than our spoken languages allow us to.
00:57:08.708 --> 00:57:09.197
Okay.
00:57:09.248 --> 00:57:20.632
Which, I mean, that does raise questions for me about the reliance in our culture on vision, and as we've talked about in our episode on vision, there are reasons for that.
00:57:20.632 --> 00:57:31.913
There are reasons why vision is in a sense the most focused on of the senses because it has such a large portion of the brain is devoted to it.
00:57:32.452 --> 00:57:40.972
But at the same time, I think we also raise some worries there and in other episodes about the emphasis on vision over and against other senses.
00:57:40.972 --> 00:57:51.742
And so I could see a, a way that what we're talking about would further the overreliance on vision that our culture has from a metaphorical or value laden perspective.
00:57:51.742 --> 00:57:52.012
Right.
00:57:52.012 --> 00:57:56.663
I think there's a sense in which our culture already is so image based.
00:57:57.163 --> 00:57:57.773
Mm-hmm.
00:57:57.952 --> 00:58:01.762
And that's not to dispute the, the claims of deaf gain that you're talking about at all, David.
00:58:01.762 --> 00:58:11.722
It's just to, to show that they can be, or I worry that they can be a little bit co-opted by a culture that is so hyper reliant on the visual.
00:58:12.547 --> 00:58:25.088
So if I were to put on the hat of the authors of this article on metaphoric iconicity, I think what they say is the difference is that maybe our mainstream visual culture tends to be relatively static.
00:58:25.496 --> 00:58:35.137
Whereas what is important about ASL, epistemology, and cognition is that movement and dynamism is built into it.
00:58:35.467 --> 00:58:43.898
So it has this cinematic quality to it where are enacting ideas moreso than just looking at them.
00:58:44.018 --> 00:58:46.148
So it requires interpretation and performance.
00:58:46.943 --> 00:58:54.592
So in that sense, this Deaf cultural gain is actually encouraging us to rethink not only hearing, but also vision.
00:58:57.527 --> 00:58:59.228
We hope you enjoy today's episode.
00:58:59.257 --> 00:59:04.898
Please rate and review us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to your podcasts.
00:59:05.108 --> 00:59:10.358
You can subscribe to our Patreon for exclusive access to bonus videos, Live Q and As, and more.
00:59:10.628 --> 00:59:19.898
To reach out to us and find episode info, go to overthinkpodcast.com and connect with us on Twitter and Instagram @overthink_pod
00:59:20.378 --> 00:59:27.427
We'd like to thank our audio editor, Aaron Morgan, our production assistant, Clare A'Hearn, and Samuel PK Smith for the original music.
00:59:27.608 --> 00:59:30.818
And to our listeners, thanks so much for overthinking with us.