BẢN CHÉP ÂM THANH 🔗
[0:00] Welcome to Lawyer on the Line.
[0:07] Welcome back to Lawyer on the Line, the podcast that gets you free information about
[0:13] workers' compensation per sworn injury, automobile accident, trucks accident cases.
[0:18] I'm Roger Riedmiller and this is Mark Scott and today's podcast is all about when is a
[0:29] car collision, a workers' compensation case, and why is that important?
[0:37] Yeah, many different reasons is important.
[0:41] One of the first things is who's going to pay my medical bills and we see that there's
[0:46] a process, but it depends on which system you're in.
[0:49] It can be a more con case possibly, could just be straight person-to-person crash where there's
[0:56] no outside situations like work that that fall into it and you go to your car insurance.
[1:02] But what do you see often, well, type of cases, at Riedmillerr, Anderson, and Scott are law
[1:09] firm here.
[1:10] We see a lot of truck auto collisions that involve work comp issues and personal injury issues
[1:20] and the number one issue that seems to come into play is what, when is a collision, something
[1:30] that arose out of and was in the course of employment and therefore falls under work comp,
[1:37] but there's also a negligence claim against another person who contributed or caused the accident.
[1:45] So what do you look at to determine whether there is a connection to work that makes it
[1:50] fall under the work comp umbrella?
[1:52] Well, the first thing we always look at is what was the person doing while they're driving
[1:59] a vehicle or maybe they're riding in a vehicle, but what was the purpose of the trip?
[2:05] I know you always ask when somebody comes in on a personal injury case, what were you
[2:10] doing that day?
[2:11] What was the purpose of your drive, right?
[2:13] Even if you're not looking for whether or not this is work related, you want to know where
[2:19] they were going, right?
[2:21] Maybe they were coming home from a bar or that's a problem, it could be a problem.
[2:28] So we learn what was the purpose of the trip?
[2:33] Sometimes that's kind of obvious, driving a delivery van pretty likely you're in the scope
[2:39] and course of employment, but that could be a factor, but can they be in their own car?
[2:46] Well they could be in their own car and still be delivering for an employer.
[2:54] So you'd really need to dig down and find out what were they doing at that moment and when
[3:01] you have a vehicle truck auto collision, where precisely was it?
[3:09] For example, I mean if somebody is off the road and they have a collision with another vehicle
[3:16] off the road, maybe they were fooling around and just having fun and that's going to lead
[3:24] someone to conclude that they deviated from their course of employment, to understand.
[3:31] And deviation can be a big issue for both the PI and the work comp claim.
[3:37] When you stray off course, your employer was expecting to deliver a product somewhere
Load full transcript
[3:43] in town and it's in the north part of town, but you're in the south part of town, to
[3:50] go visit a friend or whatever, that's probably not going to be work related and probably
[3:57] will also impact the PI case.
[3:59] So we help out a situation where they're on an errand for the employer, they need a soda,
[4:06] so they stop at a convenience store, does that a deviation that kicks in out of the system?
[4:12] That's an excellent question.
[4:14] From all of the case work that I've done, but also the cases I've read, the deviation
[4:20] has to be significant.
[4:23] If it's a slight deviation for a short period of time, even to go get a drink or go get
[4:29] smokes or I guess we used to be a smoking society, we did a lot of that and we did a lot of
[4:37] that during work.
[4:39] So we would get a cigarette and those cases are out there, those are not significant
[4:47] deviation, those are not going to kill your work comp claim or your PI claim, but it's
[4:53] all part of the analysis of whether or not it rose out of the course of employment.
[4:59] For example, traveling nurses, salesmen, it's intrinsic in their work, it's a critical
[5:10] part of what they do for living to travel from point A to point B to provide either the
[5:17] sales delivery or the nursing services.
[5:22] Trucker is the most common, that is an intrinsic part, travel is a intrinsic part of their
[5:27] occupation because it's in their name, trucker, drive a truck.
[5:34] We often look at, are they on the clock?
[5:37] Now, just because you're on the clock doesn't make it work related, remember that there's
[5:45] the deviation exception if you're involved in high jinx or tomfoolery, sometimes like
[5:54] we are around here, if you get injured during those types of activities, the work comp claim
[6:04] and the PI claim for that matter could be denied because it's not in the course and the scope
[6:10] of employment.
[6:11] Well, it's during employment, but it's not in the scope of what you're supposed to be
[6:18] doing during employment.
[6:22] But I've seen this quite often in personal injury and work comp claims.
[6:28] The boss says, I need you to go to the restaurant and get everybody a meal, we've already ordered
[6:37] it and they want you to go pick it up and you volunteer, I don't know why you would do
[6:42] that.
[6:43] There's free meal, free meal, maybe, there's reasons, well, on the way to go pick up the meal,
[6:51] you're on lunch break, but you're doing that for the benefit of the business because everybody
[6:57] else has stayed behind, it was able to continue to work, it was a benefit for many different
[7:02] reasons for the business that somebody go pick up the meal.
[7:06] No, it takes a lot of analysis to figure this out, sometimes I'm sure.
[7:10] Yeah, so there is no simple answer to determining whether or not the accident arose out in
[7:17] the course of employment, it is a factual question, I understand.
[7:21] So I've seen some cases where, or situations where the employer lets a worker take the
[7:29] work van home every day, then they come back into work.
[7:36] But if they get there at home, the boss says we've got a job for you to get to, but they
[7:42] don't make it to work before they have that crash, they're on the way to a job, and that
[7:47] kind of situation, work home.
[7:50] That's more difficult, yeah, I think that you might have to prove that that travel was an
[7:55] intrinsic part of their employment, that they did that same task of the boss telling
[8:02] them to go here, go there.
[8:06] That's a good question though, because it's called the coming and going rule, and generally
[8:12] speaking, if you're going or coming from work, once you clock out, and before you clock
[8:21] in, and before you leave the premises or arrive on the premises, you're not covered by
[8:32] work comp, okay, you need to be on the premises, once you get on the premises, you're covered
[8:37] by work comp, when you're coming to work, once you leave the premises, and I've had cases
[8:46] where people are in the parking lot, auto collisions in the parking lot, that's a work
[8:52] comp, and that's a PI case, because they didn't get out of the company parking lot, and some
[9:00] supervisor of theirs did like the way they worked that day, and maybe I don't know, they
[9:05] cause an accident.
[9:08] There's two cases there, a work comp and a personal injury claim, so I'm seeing there's
[9:12] a distinction, but why does it matter?
[9:15] Well, I think it's so important that you not ignore the work comp claim, because many people
[9:26] don't want to follow work comp claim against their employer.
[9:29] They feel like they're suing their employer, they don't understand that it's merely an
[9:34] administrative process, and that administrative process is paid for and handled by the work
[9:41] comp insurance company for the employer, but they don't want to, they think they're suing
[9:47] the employer, and so they ignore the work comp claim, and file the personal injury claim
[9:54] against the driver of the other vehicle that they feel caused all of their injuries.
[10:00] The number one problem with that is that they then try to get their no fault benefits to
[10:08] pay for their medical bills and loss wages, and if they fill out their paperwork truthfully,
[10:14] and I strongly urge people to do that, don't falsify those insurance papers you get in
[10:19] big trouble, but if you file them truthfully, I don't, what do you think their chances
[10:26] are of being denied?
[10:28] Right, and know that form you're talking about, the application for personal injury protection
[10:33] benefits has your list, and answer a lot of questions, and one of those questions is, did
[10:38] this happen in during work?
[10:40] I think they use the, in the scope of employment, something like that, but that's the one
[10:46] you question that, you mark it, yes, Pip's not going to want
to pay their medical or
[10:51] their wage loss.
[10:53] So if you ignored the work comp and you didn't file anything with the employer to give them
[10:58] proper notice, and then you fill out an application through your own insurance for those benefits
[11:04] to pay your medical bills, pay your loss wages, you're going to be denied there, and you're
[11:10] going to be left with, what, you know, health insurance maybe is going to be there for
[11:17] you.
[11:18] Well, but health insurance, I have read, I don't know how many countless health insurance
[11:23] policies, and I've never seen one that says, well, even if it's work-related, we'll pay
[11:30] benefits.
[11:31] So it's an analysis you've got to do to protect yourself so you can get your benefits from
[11:36] it, whoever's the proper party is what I'm hearing.
[11:40] I also believe that failure to file your work comp claim, I think could be a mitigation
[11:48] or failure to mitigate your damages in the personal injury claim.
[11:51] I could see that.
[11:52] Is there a defense such as that in personal life, not had that situation arise, but anytime
[11:59] there's been a recommendation for medical care, and you don't follow it, following that medical
[12:06] care would have probably made the condition improve faster, yeah, that's, that can be
[12:10] a big problem, that can be used against you.
[12:14] The other thing that I see quite often is that in personal injury claims where there is
[12:21] a workers' compensation carrier involved for the accident victim, they have a work comp
[12:27] claim, right?
[12:28] Yes, they do.
[12:29] How does that work in the context of the personal injury claim?
[12:31] So in a work comp claim that the law doesn't want you getting duplicative benefits.
[12:37] So if you make a recovery in the personal injury case, the work comp carrier has its hands
[12:43] out to get reimbursed for what it's paid for you, whether that be medical benefits or wage
[12:48] loss benefits, they'll have their hand out, trying to get reimbursed for that.
[12:54] But I know you have ways that are reasonable and legal to reduce that lane, correct?
[13:02] Yes, yes, there's one that we don't really see that often is if a co-employee is negligent
[13:09] and that causes your injury in the work comp setting, then that reduction does play with
[13:15] how much the work comp carrier can get back.
[13:19] Other areas are certain damages, so if there is a loss of consortium claim, that is a claim
[13:24] of the spouse for what the relationship has lost because of the injury, that part can be carved
[13:31] out, which is very important.
[13:35] So those are two areas.
[13:37] There was a case, and I don't know if it's still a good law or not, but I read a case not
[13:42] too long ago where they talked about a lack of duplicative recoveries that they would
[13:50] look at the work comp claim and the personal injury claim and make a determination as to
[13:55] whether or not your recovery in the PI claim is duplicated in the work comp claim.
[14:00] Is that still the law?
[14:01] Yes, that still comes into effect.
[14:04] So if your work comps paid it, then there would be an offset, but if there's not a duplicative
[14:11] recovery, you could reduce the worker's compensation claim substantially.
[14:17] And reducing the worker's compensation lean substantially does what?
[14:23] Say that one more time for me.
[14:24] Reducing the worker's compensation lean substantially, it provides what to the injured individual?
[14:32] Well, if you reduce that down, then the recovery is going to be larger.
[14:36] It puts more money in their pocket, right?
[14:38] That's the whole purpose of what we're doing, right?
[14:40] So that's one of the points I think of the actual benefit of having a worker's compensation
[14:49] claim is that in the end there's this analysis as Mark says of whether or not this is a duplicated
[14:59] recovery.
[15:01] And so if you can reduce that work comp claim because the PI case is not a duplicated recovery
[15:08] in the grand scheme of things, as long as they property file the work comp claim and got
[15:12] all the benefits, they're actually recovering more.
[15:17] They're in a better position than if they had ignored the work comp claim completely.
[15:22] Definitely.
[15:23] Okay.
[15:24] The other note I made on this subject is that medical care in work comp has no limit.
[15:34] Some people think that health insurance has no limit.
[15:37] Yeah, that's not true.
[15:38] And there are some policies that actually have a cap on what that policy can pay over
[15:44] the lifetime.
[15:45] I haven't had injury for that was an issue, but it most certainly can happen.
[15:50] Plus, even without that cap, you're at a pocket for deductible and copay.
[15:57] But you don't have those in work comp, correct?
[15:59] No, that's correct.
[16:01] I mean, yes, that's correct.
[16:04] The first compensation in Kansas, the best aspect of this system is that medical care is
[16:13] unlimited in dollar amount.
[16:16] In to some extent, even time, meaning I represent people now that I have represented for over
[16:23] 20 years, and they still have an open and active workers compensation medical case.
[16:30] They can't get any more disability benefits because of the nature of their injury.
[16:36] They've exhausted all of that, but they're still getting medical attention, medical care.
[16:41] And I don't even, I have no idea how many dollars because it's not relevant.
[16:48] There's no, there's no defense that we've paid too much.
[16:53] There's a limit.
[16:55] There is no limit, right?
[16:56] And so it's a really, really unique aspect of personal injury where it can go on forever,
[17:07] for your lifetime.
[17:09] They use the term for the lifetime of the injury, and that just means that if you get injured
[17:16] in an automobile accident and you injure your right leg and it's permanent and you need
[17:23]
treatment on that right leg for a long period of time.
[17:29] And then one day, and I hate to be gruesome or have modeling here, but one day you lose
[17:36] that leg completely in an accident.
[17:39] The fact that you lost that leg will cut off the medical care for the leg, obviously, as
[17:45] it relates to the work comp claim.
[17:48] And so, well, that's called a subsequent intervening accident, okay, and if you have one
[17:56] of those and it sufficiently eliminates the need for the medical care that you were getting
[18:04] prior to that accident, then medical care can be cut off.
[18:08] I think I've had that happen once, guys, you're rare.
[18:11] And I've had numerous times where getting ready to try to resolve a claim and not just purely
[18:16] personal injury type claim, and the client will say, well, I want to leave my medical open.
[18:22] And I've got to have that discussion within that.
[18:25] We don't get to leave medical open in a personal injury case.
[18:29] We can put forth information on the reasonable expectation of future medical expenses.
[18:34] And if I have a doctor that supports that, that would be something that we could present
[18:39] to a jury or to the adjuster and try to get that recovered, but can't leave it open.
[18:44] So it's all in the settlement of the case and how you take care of those issues right
[18:50] in.
[18:51] But many people believe in a work comp want to close out their case.
[18:54] And I warn them about that because Medicare will eventually cover you.
[19:03] If you make it to age 65, you definitely have it or if you get qualified for Medicare through
[19:08] social security disability.
[19:11] If you don't take into consideration that fact that you're going to have Medicare and
[19:17] you're somewhere within, I think it's 30 months of Medicare, eligibility, then Medicare can
[19:25] come in and say, well, we're not going to provide you any Medicare benefits for this injury.
[19:32] And if you've closed out the case, then you're really up a creek without a paddle because you're
[19:39] not going to get medical care unless you can come up with money out of your own pocket
[19:44] to pay for it or you go get health insurance and health insurance will cover it.
[19:51] And health insurance, I think the law still is they can't deny preexisting condition.
[19:57] Right.
[19:58] That's that is still the status, but they can deny work comp.
[20:01] So it's a tough, it's a tough pickle.
[20:04] If you've been involved in one of these unique type of accidents where it's both a work
[20:09] comp and a personal injury, you need to talk to a lawyer.
[20:12] As you can see from Mark and Mike conversation here today, it's complicated.
[20:17] Give us a call.
[20:18] We'll answer your questions.
[20:19] There's no obligation.
[20:20] 263-0001 or you could go through 1-6, I should say.
[20:26] You could also go to warrioronalign.com, say that, right?
[20:30] Yes you did.
[20:31] Okay.
[20:32] And visit our website and get all kinds of free information.
[20:36] We also ask that you, as you're watching this video, if you have questions, please comment.
[20:41] We will read those comments.
[20:42] It might lead to a future podcast, and so we're always happy to answer questions.
[20:48] Thank you for watching our podcast and we will see you next time.
[20:52] Don't forget to like and subscribe.
[20:57] Thanks for watching.
[20:58] Be sure to hit that like and subscribe button and leave us a review in the comments.