BẢN CHÉP ÂM THANH 🔗
00:00:09
Speaker 1: Discord says it's cracking down on abuse.
00:00:12
Speaker 2: Starting next month, the messaging app will require users to prove their age or be shut out from access to adult servers.
00:00:20
Speaker 1: Earlier this year, Discord announced that it would start analyzing everyone's account data to figure out how old its users are.
00:00:28
Speaker 3: That's all my gamers out there, what the hell are we using now?
00:00:30
Speaker 4: The Discord is definitely not on our list of things to use.
00:00:33
Speaker 1: So if you use Discord, you need to uninstall that shit right now, because they're about to start spying on every message you sent. If the platform thought you were underage, it would ask for ID, and if you didn't give it, it would kick you off the platform. Welcome to the fight over age verification.
00:00:50
Speaker 2: I think, in practice, Discord and a lot of these online platforms are seeing age verification as a silver bullet, the end, all, the all answer to this problem of young people's safety online. And I mean it's I think a more complicated problem. As we've seen the technology is not reliable, It is not accessible or fully privacy protective at the moment, or accurate to be used at such a large scale.
00:01:17
Speaker 1: Rin Alijaji's the Associate director of State Affairs of the Electronic Frontier Foundation. She says that even though age verification rules are put in place to keep children safe online, the reality what these rules actually do is a lot more complicated.
00:01:34
Speaker 2: I don't disagree with the issue of young people needing privacy and safety online, but I find it ironic that now these services are asking you to submit these deeply personal pieces of information like your ID or your face, or your credit card information or sometimes their mortgage application to prove your age.
00:01:54
Speaker 1: In response to legislation. Some apps have had versions of age verification for a while now, but when Discord tried it, people got really mad. And at first this might not make a whole lot of sense because from the outside, it looks like a bunch of gamer nerds are threatening to boycott a messaging platform that they've used for over a decade in some cases, over just an ID check. I mean, what gives right? And you might be thinking, but Dexter, I'm not a gamer, I'm not a nerd. I don't use Discord. Well, here's the thing. If you want to buy a computer or a phone, or literally almost anything that has a screen on it, there's a new law that's about to bring this to you. So today we'll talk about how a bunch of gamers suddenly found their way into politics, why age verification might actually harm kids, and how pretty soon you're gonna get dragged into this fight, whether you want to be or not. Kaleidoscope and iHeart podcasts. This is kill Switch. I'm Dexter Thomas. Let's get into it.
00:02:59
Speaker 5: I'm all right, I'm.
00:03:35
Speaker 3: Goodbye.
00:03:41
Speaker 1: So I feel like most people
Load full transcript
watching or listening to this know what Discord is, but just in case broad strokes here right, It's a chat app. Roughly one hundred minial people use a daily. They can do text chat, group messages, you can do voice chat, you can do video, you can share your screen, and I think most people know it as oh, this is what gamers use. I know that's not quite it, but what other uses would you say people use Discord for.
00:04:10
Speaker 2: Yeah, it definitely started in the gaming community and is still to this day very big for gamers, which the video game industry is huge. There's millions of people that game every day. But Discord has then since moved to things like fandoms, to political discussions. I have friends whose you know, soccer teams are on Discord. They just you know, talk to their friends on there.
00:04:32
Speaker 1: I know people who their knitting club is entirely on Discord. I've taught college classes, and the stuff that the college uses sucks, and so we've used Discord. So I've been pretty bought into Discord. Honestly, Discord as a platform wasn't specifically built for kids. It actually requires users to be at least thirteen years old to sign up. Gamers definitely use it a lot. But if you can think of almost any hobby, there's probably a community dedicated to that topic on Discord. So even though Discord is used by a bunch of pretty diverse communities, a lot of people weren't all that familiar with it. Actually, some people's first impression about Discord is what they got when the lawsuits started happening. A family in Camden County is suing the makers of the gaming app Roadblocks, as well as.
00:05:19
Speaker 3: The community app Discord, saying neither do enough to protect children from sexual predators.
00:05:24
Speaker 2: So in February early February, Discord announced that they will be rolling out mandatory age verification around the world, with full implementation in early March. And what that means is that if Discord had either estimated you to be under eighteen, or if it doesn't have enough information about you or your account, you would be automatically put into a teen appropriate experience. It's what they were calling it, which means basically any content filters, there would be restrictions on who can contact you via direct messages, or who can add you as a friend, if you can or can't speak on things like stage channels, which are about the spaces where a lot of community events happen on Discord.
00:06:08
Speaker 1: Discord is saying that they want to be able to verify how old you are as a user. How does this work?
00:06:14
Speaker 2: So what Discord has said is that initially they would get information about you based on how you interact on that platform. If you've been a Discord user for years, they've garnered all this data about what information you interact with, who you've talked to, and has estimated sort of where you may be. Services like YouTube actually rulled similar ways of age estimation previously,
and there were stories all over the Internet of people being put into brackets where they weren't just because for example, they enjoy cartoons. So now if the YouTube has decided they're twelve instead of actually a fifty year old.
00:06:52
Speaker 1: You're trying to watch some old school Tom and Jerry or whatever, and it thinks you're twelve exactly.
00:06:56
Speaker 2: So what discord that is that most adults would be so through this system to be an adult because of the data that they already have about you. But if you were estimated to be an adult and were locked into this teaen appropriate experience, then you would have to go through a third party vendor and provide either your government issued ID or go through a face scan that would then estimate how old you are, which both have their own sets of problems and have been notoriously reported to be very unreliable, especially for people of color, for trans people, for people with disabilities. A lot of these facial estimation services also require things like a liveness check where they ask you to move your head or open your mouth, and those again look a lot different for people with disabilities or people who may not be able to do those things.
00:07:49
Speaker 1: So in February, when they announced that they were rolling out mandatory age verification for users worldwide, the reaction was pretty immediate.
00:07:57
Speaker 2: What this is insanity.
00:07:59
Speaker 4: So in order to verify that I'm over the age of thirteen, I have to upload my driver's license or a scan of my face to Discord.
00:08:09
Speaker 3: While I would love to trust Discord with that information, I just also I think it's kind of a dangerous precedent.
00:08:15
Speaker 1: No if it sounds like people are all of a sudden getting mad at it. Nowhere there's some more context of this. Just a few months before the age verification announcement, Discord was in the headlines for a very different reason.
00:08:28
Speaker 3: Well, this one's exciting. Discord says that seventy thousand users may have had their government issued IDs compromised. The recent attack exposed them and the hackers. They claim they've got nearly two point two million, quite a bit more than what Discord claims.
00:08:42
Speaker 1: In twenty twenty five, Discord had a major data breach through a third party customer support system called Zendesk. This is the vendor that they were using for age verification in the UK. This breach exposed users phone numbers, IP addresses, physical addresses, and in some cases billing information. So Discord coming back just a few months after that hack was announced and saying, uh, yeah, we're gonna need your government ID now and maybe even a scanning your face. A lot of people saw that and said, yeah, that's not going to happen. And that's aside from the fact that these tools just don't really work. When Discord tested an age verification system in the UK last summer, kids figured out how to get around it almost immediately. One popular method was taking a screenshot from a video game character, submitting that is your face and boom, age verification passed.
00:09:34
Speaker 2: Their story is all over the internet of different ways to bypass these services or these age verification mandates. And four for Media actually just put out an article about this YouTube video from I think twenty eighteen of a woman moving her head slowly and it was used I think for some sort of trading purposes, but people are now using it as a way to bypass these age verification.
00:09:57
Speaker 1: The outrage online was so massive. Within just a few weeks, Discord announced that they were pausing the rollout of the age verification process. But this brings us back to the question of why Discord would force users all over the world to submit their identity. Was it just them trying to cover their backs so they don't get hit with another child safety lawsuit. Well, in some case Discord actually had to do this.
00:10:20
Speaker 6: The United Kingdom has begun enforcing an age verification aspect if it's twenty twenty three Online Safety Act, requiring platforms to ensure that young users do not have access to harmful content online.
00:10:32
Speaker 1: The first of its kind Online Safety Act in the UK now requires apps like Discord to force British users to submit age verification. So Discord was already doing this in the UK, as well as in Australia, which now has a new social media ban.
00:10:48
Speaker 5: The world's first nationwide social media ban four children has been in effect for a few days now in Australia. A country's new law bands kids under sixteen from more than ten platforms, including TikTok and Instagram.
00:11:01
Speaker 1: So one important detail here though Australia's social media band does not cover Discord, but Discord said that they included Australian users. Anyway, to go above and beyond in demonstrating its quote ongoing commitment to team safety. The fact that Discord was doing more than it really needed to, not just complying with the UK law, but complying in advance for countries like Australia, made a lot of people angry.
00:11:27
Speaker 2: Gamers probably wanted to see Discord flight back. They wanted to see Discord not just fold and decide to comply there and fight for their users. I think in late stage capitalism you can't really expect a platform to care about their users more than they care about their bottom line dollar. But that is the sense I get from the Discord community and how they perceive the platform and services values to be.
00:11:56
Speaker 1: After all that backlash, Discord has said that they're moving the roll out of the age verification process until later this year, but that initial outrage does seem to have had an effect on how Discord is going about all of this.
00:12:10
Speaker 2: Another thing that they announced also that they are going to have stricter requirements for partners that offer things like facial estimation,
including that that process needs to happen on device and doesn't go like to the third party, which is a high bar. And the companies that they were initially going with, PERSONA and Kid, did not.
00:12:31
Speaker 1: Meet that bar, so that's interesting. Already the people that they were comfortable going with had nobody pushed back. They have now decided, actually, these people weren't good enough. So gamers have won a battle. It's probably too soon though to say that they've won the war, but then again, maybe Discord is just an easy target here. Maybe complying in advance is inevitable because even if you're not in the UK or Australia, and even if you're not a Discord user, there's another law that's about to change what happens when you first boot up almost any new computer or any new phone that's after the break. There's a law that just passed called the Digital Age Assurance Act. This is in California. Can you talk to me about that?
00:13:29
Speaker 2: AB ten forty three. It did pass last year in the California legislature and was signed by Governor Newsom last October. It goes into effect in twenty twenty seven. AB ten forty three requires all operating systems and app stores to create age brackets that segment their users based on their ages. So those brackets are between I think it's like thirteen and sixteen, sixteen and eighteen, and then eighteen and older, and users are Once you've opened your new blacktop or your phone, you're then asked to say what your birth date is or your age, and then they place you in that bracket. And then it requires that operating system or your phone your laptop to collect this information and send that to every application that asks for your age, And it requires applications to ask right if they are deemed not to be used by minors, your watch, your digital scale, you'll have to tell them how old you are.
00:14:30
Speaker 1: So California's Digital Age Assurance Act requires any operating system. This means Windows, this means Mac, O West, but even phone operating systems like iOS and Android. They have to collect your age when you set up a device and share that information with apps on request, so developers know whether they're dealing with a child, a teenager, or an adult.
00:14:49
Speaker 2: A big problem that we see there is what about families that use one device? What happens there if multiple people share a device or low income households often don't have mo multiple devices for people to use. What age would you then tell the operating system you were?
00:15:06
Speaker 1: Another big issue with this law is that it relies on self reporting. A kid could type in any birthday that they want and say that they're over eighteen. But now with this law, operating systems are required to ask anyway. If they don't ask, there's consequences. You can be fined per infraction right.
00:15:29
Speaker 2: Up to twenty five hundred dollars per affected child, or seventy five hundred dollars for intentional violations.
00:15:37
Speaker 1: Which is kind of nuts. If there's a family with two kids and both of them get on the computer and you did not properly get their age, five thousand dollars two kids.
00:15:49
Speaker 2: Yeah, and there are other concerns about open source and who is an operating system here. Also they define it to include things like mobile devices and computers very broadly, and virtually any digital device that runs a software that has built in the last three decades would fall into that category.
00:16:11
Speaker 1: See anything, yeah, yeah.
00:16:12
Speaker 2: And by virtue of how open source works, people can change that software. People can tinker with it and make it their own. And it's still very unclear to people who's liable there. And imagine you're a software developer, small shop of for people who started an open source project and now you're hit with this huge fine for a small startup. That's a recipe for over censorship and a chilling effect of people not wanting to get hit with another fine.
00:16:45
Speaker 1: So, just to clarify here, if someone lies about their age during the age verification process and the software doesn't catch that they're lying, that's not covered in the law. You only get in trouble if your software doesn't ask. So if this law is just mandating to ask how old someone is and not actually do anything with it, okay, well it's ineffective. But what's the actual problem here, Well, a lot of people see this as a foot in the door for something more nefarious. Once the government has a law demanding that Apple or Microsoft collect information on you just in order to turn on your computer or your phone, the concern is that next they can start stacking other laws on top of that that really start monitoring you, making you afraid to speak your mind online, or even afraid to speak your mind into your own notes app. And let's just be clear here, most people aren't even aware of this argument. Most people aren't aware of these laws. Those of us who are are again kind of nerds, and a lot of these nerds are putting pressure on the people who make the software to fight back. So is anyone doing anything about this? Well? Yeah, One operating system called Midnight BSD has included in their terms and conditions that you're just straight up not allowed to use their software in California, and they explicitly state that this rule is a protest against that California law. Say whatever you want, but you can't say that's not a principal stand. But Midnight BSD is a really niche project, and it's basically run by one lead developer, and he can pretty easily make those personal decisions if he wants to. But what some people are hoping for is someone with more swayed to actually fight the laws themselves.
00:18:25
Speaker 2: At the end of the day, I think there is a bottom line of California's a huge state.
00:18:31
Speaker 1: Yes, Also we're talking about technology and Silicon valleyes here, Like banning California from using your software, especially when your software is the thing that makes your computer run, is kind of nuts.
00:18:48
Speaker 2: Yeah, And I think California will have to contend with that fact that these laws will end up pushing certain companies and certain services out of the state because they just can't comply with them.
00:19:02
Speaker 1: Also, speaking of laws, let's talk about lawsuits. More specifically a lawsuit that almost everyone's heard of by now, the big case against Meta and YouTube in California.
00:19:13
Speaker 7: A jury found YouTube and Meta, the parent company of Instagram and Facebook, liable for designing their platforms to be addictive for children and teens. Despite knowing it could harm their mental health. All told, the companies would pay six million dollars in damages.
00:19:30
Speaker 1: So that lawsuit wasn't about age verification, and to be honest, getting into what it actually was about is probably an entirely different episode. But I'll just point this out. When it comes to asking, Okay, what do we do about social media platforms other than just hitting in the companies with a fine that's basically lunch money for them, The conversation keeps coming back to this age verification thing. The day before that verdict in California, Meta was ordered by a New Mexico court to pay three hundred and seventy five million dollars for child safety violations, and the Attorney General again brought up age verification as a solution.
00:20:05
Speaker 4: We're going to be asking for changes to the design features of the platform itself, real age verification, changes to the algorithm, and independent monitor to oversee those changes, and fundamentally a demand that they do business differently in New Mexico.
00:20:21
Speaker 1: This line of thinking might be what's motivating Discord to comply in advance, especially as a response to the lawsuits that they've already had to face.
00:20:30
Speaker 2: It's a fear of liability. There must be a big conference room somewhere where all of the legal advisors came together and said, the only way to make all these lawsuits go away is to figure out a way to make sure that there are certain restrictions for people under eighteen. And I think as it's been rolling out in practice, they've realized that just because you don't want to face this huge fine or liability doesn't mean that the answer is as easy as just require age verification.
00:21:04
Speaker 1: And yet age verification is only becoming more prevalent. Just back in March, Apple rolled out device level age verification in the UK. Users who don't confirm that they're eighteen or older don't just lose access to certain apps or websites, but Apple will turn on monitoring of their messages, of their shared photo albums, their airdrop and FaceTime calls, and similar things are coming to the US starting this summer. New users in Utah and Louisiana will have their age information shared with the app store to comply with new age
restriction laws in those states. Again, there's nothing wrong with letting companies have access to all your data if that's what you want. What's slowly being lost. Here is one of the things that makes the Internet what it is, the right to decide how much information you want to share, whether that's nothing, everything, or somewhere in between.
00:21:53
Speaker 2: And I think one cornerstone of what the Internet has stood for, and one piece that EFF has fought for, is the right to anonymity. And how the right to anonymity allows you to speak freely online. That is a nonpartisan issue, that is not something that's politically affiliated. People of all walks of lives have turned to the Internet to share their stories and to make community and to be someone that they might not feel comfortable being in the analog world, so to speak. You know, you see people having very open and frank conversations online and that is precisely because these conversations are not linked to your government issued ID. It's precisely because you're not worried that someone's going to know who you are or where you live and they're going to come and track you down. And we all also benefit from the information that anonymity has granted us. Talk about whistleblowers or advocates in governments where they're not allowed to speak if their government issued ID was associated with their Discord account or their Twitter account. They're way less likely to share what they would share, right. There is a sense of lack of control and privacy when you have everything that you put out on the Internet associated it with your government. It should I do, especially in today's day and age, where speech and political speech is targeted. I think there's more fear there as well.
00:23:19
Speaker 1: All right, So we've heard a lot about the problems with age verification laws, but at the end of the day, do they actually help kids even a little bit? After the break, I try to play Devil's advocate and immediately get shut down. Just kind of Devil's advocate here. If Discord has asked me my age, they've got a feature which is going to guess how old I am, and so it might never actually ask me for my ID. It might be able to figure it out based on how old my account is or the kinds of messages that I send. You know, I'm I'm talking about taxes with my friends. Not a lot of kids talk about taxes in the stock market or whatever. You're probably okay, right, So if age verification is even if it's a bit annoying, who can argue against protecting kids and also anonymity. I'm not afraid if people know what I think. I say everything with my chest. What's the big deal here? And I'm not doing anything wrong. I'm not doing anything illegal. What's the big deal with something that will put a little friction in front of trolls, scammers, thieves, bad people getting to either meet or kids. What's wrong with that?
00:24:42
Speaker 2: I think if we had proof that that age verification actually did that, I may say, you know why, you have a point, But we don't have proof that age verification can actually protect children. And we see that constant collection and storing of your information exposes us to my harms both online and offline. And even when you were talking about the fact that, like, oh, I send messages to my friend about taxes. But how creepy is it that we have come to a point where we have just felt like it's normal that discord is reading our messages and knows what we're talking about. That's pretty crazy to me.
00:25:23
Speaker 1: It comes down to a question that nobody's really solved yet. Who is actually responsible for protecting kids online?
00:25:30
Speaker 2: We've heard stories from Australia of parents themselves using their own faces to bypass these gates. For their children to be able to use social media, and I think that brings in this big question of where the government sits in parenting and the ability for parents to choose what is and is not appropriate for their children. And this is putting the government squarely in the middle of that that relationship between a parent and their young person.
00:25:58
Speaker 1: You could say that the Internet is a terrible place for kids right now, and you'd be partially right. There's a study out there, the reports that nearly half of teenagers surveyed say that social media has negative effects on people their age. That's pretty serious. But social media can also be a positive for us. I mean, right now, there are kids learning history, learning languages, learning new art forums, or finding communities of other kids just like them around the world. This is stuff that is not going to happen on encyclopedia dot com. It happens on social media. Those kids deserve a safe way to interact with the world, and this can be done. But the key to that might not be what we're doing right now making laws that give companies even more information about ourselves, like giving them our ID or maybe even our face, when they already have a bunch of information about us. Actually, Rinn says that part of the way forward might actually be reducing the information these companies have about us and about kids.
00:26:59
Speaker 2: I'd say it's too pronged really here. First one is if legislators really wanted to protect people online, young people, adults, they really need to pass a strong, comprehensive privacy law, which means that instead of building more surveillance and censorship, we are targeting and addressing the massive collection and processing of our personal data, which is the root cause of all of these problems online, the reason why young people are fed ads about harmful things, or if a young person looks at one user who might cover one topic, then they're now being fed constantly with this information. A comprehensive federal privacy law would target that, and that's where we see lawmakers energy and focus would be most helpful and would have a lasting impact, not just for young people but
adults too, because we all are being used as data points and ways to make money off of our information for these companies. And then the second aspect I think is education. We have to approach that issue from a more holistic perspective where we talk about education, where we talk about parents' role in protecting their children. We really need to invest into a more robust parental control system for these platforms and for operating systems as well, and education for how to use them for parents. A lot of them already exists. There's colleagues at EFF where parents themselves who use those parental controls, and I think people really need to invest in learning how those work. And also, digital literacy in schools is way behind. We haven't taught young people about social media, you know, the things that people are pointing out us, the issue behind discord or behind roadblocks, being predators online. Taking that age old advice of don't talk to strangers and don't share information about yourself and just modernizing the advice that young people are getting about how to engage in the digital world or on the internet is all so key for us.
00:29:01
Speaker 1: We're also in a stage right now where there's books being strongly discouraged or pulled out of libraries which are just about history exactly. This is what happened during slavery, this is what happened after slavery, Like those things are being pulled from curriculum. And if the bar is not appropriate for minors, okay, porn is not appropriate for miners. Most people aren't going to fight with you on that. But if you decide that learning about a period of history is not appropriate for school at all and thus children, then yeah, you can start blocking whatever you want.
00:29:40
Speaker 2: I love that you made that connection immediately, because they do use the exact same language that they use in book bands to implement these age vacation mandates for banning horn from minor materials. I'll also mention that people will likely see in different states these bills come into effect the coming years, where things like Twitter or now x, Facebook, Instagram all start implementing age gates as well, because that's what these bills require. Another thing that we also try to warn against is how these bills define harmful to minors. They define the concept of harmful to minors to be so broad that any attorney general can decide, you know, I don't want anyone under eighteen to read anything about reproductive rights or access to abortion care. I think that's harmful of minors. So next thing, you know, Plant Parenthood's website needs to be under an age gate, or sexual health education is under an age gate. We are at this point it is coming to people. It will be everyone's problem in due time. So I definitely recommend for people who may not be nerds to join the conversation because it does impact more than just the people that care about the Internet, and it's a civil rights issue, it's a free speech issue, it is an access to information issue, and we always welcome people to the fight.
00:31:09
Speaker 1: Welcoming people to the fight is a really interesting way to put it, because in this episode, yes, we've called it a fight, but for a lot of people, I'm not sure the age verification has ever felt like a proper fight so until very recently, and I'm speaking stereotypically broadbrush here. On one side, you had a bunch of nerds who were talking about civil liberties and computer code, and on the other side, there's a bunch of politicians who don't even know how to turn on a computer, and they're just being fooled by big tech companies who don't really care what happens. They're just making money off of all of us. That's not a fight, at least, it's not a fair fight. It's a bunch of policymakers making decisions that affect people who don't even really know what's happening. But now more of us know that this fight is happening partially because some gamers got big mad about their little discord chat rooms. This is a good thing, and after listening to this, maybe you have some opinions about age verification, and that's also a really good thing. If you want to know more, we got some links in the show notes to everything we reference. But whatever your stance is on all this right now, please do not leave this fight to the handful of nerds and the politicians, because we cannot figure all this out without hearing from everyone. Thank you so much for listening to kill Switch. You can email us at kill Switch at Kalaidoscope dot NYC or on Instagram. We're at killswitchpod and if you like the show, leave us a review. It helps other people find the show, which helps us keep doing our thing. Kill Switch is hosted by Me Dexter Thomas. It's produced by Sena Ozaki, darl luck Potts, and Julian Nutter. Our theme song is by me and Kyle Murdoch and Kyle also mixed the show from Kaleidoscope. Our executive producers are Ozma Lashin, Mangesh Hatikadur, and Kate Osborne from iHeart Our. Executive producers are between a Norvel and Nikki Etour. Get you on the next one.