BẢN CHÉP ÂM THANH 🔗
Getting your cap table right, with CapQuest’s Antoine Bruna and Marco Banfi
FWDstart Podcast
Jamie Lane
Antoine and Marco, thank you so much for joining me on the pod.
Antoine Bruna
Thank you so much for having us.
Jamie
I think I want to start with what brought you here initially. For the most part, with startups, we’re solving a problem that we’ve encountered previously. I don’t think we all dream of cap table management as a child and that’s ultimately what we want to work in.
I’m curious about how you arrived at the problem. Both of you were operators previously. Obviously, you’re still operators, needless to say. But can you talk to me about the experience that led you to creating CapQuest, the problem you encountered and why you’re building today?
Antoine
We’ve been operators in the past. Personally, it’s the third company I’ve founded. Marco has also been in a couple of companies before. We were co-founders in a previous entity together called Repeat.
In that business, we raised $12 million from an array of angels, family offices, VCs and so forth, from three continents, with different jurisdictions and different needs. There were 47 investors.
Jamie
That’s a complicated cap table.
Antoine
It starts to be at some point. And 63 employees on an ESOP. Managing that every month was a hassle. You go from updating your Excel spreadsheets to investor reporting to ESOP management, all of these things that weren’t worth our time when we were growing fast and scaling the business.
We wanted automated tools for it. We looked at what the market was providing at the time. We had an ADGM holdco. US-centric products weren’t the right fit for us. We always thought, after Repeat, is there a place for us to build a company for this market that understands how the system works?
That’s how we came to the conclusion of building CapQuest. We have a third co-founder, Anvita. Apart from her brilliant background with Lazada, Rocket and Naspers, she also has a small holding with investments in, I think, something like 17 portfolio companies.
She came with the lens of the issues an investor faces when dealing with portfolio companies and their cap tables. The three of us combined forces on that angle to create CapQuest.
Committing to the problem
Jamie
There’s still some distance between experiencing that problem yourself and going, “I’m going to commit the next minimum 10 years of my life, fingers crossed, to solving that problem.”
What gave you the conviction that you were the right person and wanted to take this on? Because it’s quite an undertaking.
Antoine
It’s a longer journey on that side, to be honest. To go back a little further, when I started my career, I was 19.
A bit of a fun story there. I kind of lied my way into a full-time job. I was doing my degree at Bocconi. After a year, I thought, let me get some experience on the ground, and I ended up applying to different audit firms. I got into Mazars, a French audit firm, and they asked me, “Do you have your degree?”
I said, “Yes, of course I have my degree.” They waited two years for me to complete it and give it to them.
I was a financial consultant at the time. I did two years of auditing, then four years of transaction services, mainly for the private equity market in Europe. When I came here in 2015, I started a financial consultancy firm called ArrowFin Consulting. I was doing fractional CFO work, as well as managing private investments for a lot of investors, some of whom became LPs in funds that started raising in the region from 2015 to 2020.
You go back to what you know how to do and what you’re an expert in. After Repeat, which was a heavy B2B2C business within the restaurant space, I was happy to go back to my roots, so to speak. Something that made sense and that I was comfortable developing.
That was why I always thought my next venture would be within the financial space, even though this is at the bridge between legal tech and fintech. Also, once you’ve started building ventures, you can’t do anything else.
If you’ve got the drive and like the journey, I’d love to talk about all the different stages you have to go through and the focus you need at every stage. I’m a big believer in how things work over a timeline. We never thought of doing anything other than starting another venture.
Marco Banfi
Just adding to that point, we didn’t jump in headfirst without deliberating a lot about the process. We spent close to six to eight months in a design stage with CFOs and CEOs across the region.
We were very lucky to speak to CFOs and founders of early-stage, growth-stage and enterprise-level companies all over the world, to validate the problem they were having, but also to show them early on what our approach was going to be. We validated that and got great feedback across the board.
There were also some great tailwinds to what we were building, and we knew that going into it. For example, companies are staying private longer. In 1989, the average company going public was only six years old. Today, companies are 12 years old on average when they IPO.
During that entire journey of staying private, you need to manage your equity even more. You have secondaries, buybacks, more employees coming in and out, and all of that needs to be properly managed. All the more reason for a private company that helps with this entire flow.
Another tailwind is the complexity of financial instruments. Twenty or 30 years ago, SAFEs and KISSes didn’t exist. It was a lot more direct equity. You’re seeing increasing complexity there. ESOPs are also a growing trend across different markets.
We knew all these things coming into it and said, “This is a great tailwind to what we’re building, and a solution we know needs to be built with the region in mind.” That’s how we jumped into it.
Local depth and global reach
Jamie
You mentioned the global validation as well. You’re building for the region, but at the same time, this is
Load full transcript
applicable anywhere in many respects. Was that something you thought about from the outset?
Antoine
Absolutely. Our approach was always that emerging markets, and the growth they’ve been seeing in the venture space, need something like CapQuest. We always thought we needed local depth for every market, but still a global reach. That’s how we built CapQuest.
To talk about that validation process, it’s something you realise when you’re on your second or third venture. There’s a tendency when you create your first startup to have this idea in your bedroom and think, “Obviously everybody’s going to buy. It’s such a great idea.” You don’t go out and validate it. You start coding and producing, and it’s a lot of time wasted.
Whereas when you’ve been there, you understand that we need to build something for the market. We need to hear what the market needs. But it’s definitely something we built with a global reach in mind.
Jamie
Does building for emerging markets change how you approach it relative to another solution? If so, how?
Antoine
It’s a question of how you adapt to their different needs. As emerging markets grow, they’re also building with a local touch on what’s been done in more mature markets. There’s a lot more adaptability you need, both in terms of customer service and how you approach a product. That’s a journey Marco is there for.
Marco
At the core infrastructure layer, equity management and capital management remain relatively standardised. But there are particular nuances, whether related to taxation, rights or other laws around ESOPs, that you need to adapt to on a country-by-country basis. You need to take those step by step.
Companies headquartered in Delaware, for example, have some degree of standardisation independently of where they are. What you build is agnostic enough for these. The structure we’ve built is applicable to a series of other markets, but you have to get into each one and understand the nuances.
Today, we’re active in 11 different countries. For each one, we’ve had to adapt different elements of the product. That’s a journey we’re going to continue, with a heavy emphasis on the Middle East and Europe.
Jamie
How deliberate has that distribution to 11 countries been? Has it been inbound or outbound? How have they found you?
Marco
Our predominant focus was always the Middle East and Europe. We knew there was a big demand and a lack of competitors focused on building for these regions. But through outbound and inbound, clients began coming in. We had clients in Brazil, the US and elsewhere.
Antoine
Singapore and so forth. It’s also been quite opportunistic. We always had the aim of reaching these markets. We didn’t think it would happen that quickly, to be honest. You meet people who meet people, the word gets out and you get a certain amount of inbound.
Outbound, especially at our stage, remains a very strong focus of how we acquire market share. You need to go as broadly as possible, while still having some qualification elements.
What a cap table actually represents
Jamie
Let’s take a step back, because we’ve danced around it to a certain extent. Can we characterise succinctly exactly what CapQuest is and what it solves for? We’ve touched on it in different capacities, but if we could do that, I think it’d be great.
Antoine
At its core, it’s an equity management system. We’re in a category called cap table management software, but the cap table is just the output of an entire process of managing different elements of equity, whether that’s stakeholders, instruments through which you fundraise, ESOPs, investor management and so forth.
It’s equity management at large. What does that mean in terms of how you approach it as a company or founder? It’s a tool with different aspects you’ll use throughout the lifetime of your company.
When you’re setting up, the first thing you do is incorporate. That’s already your first equity event. It might be a simple one, and at that stage everything is pretty peachy. But then you hire employees, start building ESOP plans, do your first pre-seed, your seed and so forth. You’re getting investors on board, maybe on SAFEs, and you need to convert those SAFEs.
All these different elements combine into a simple output, which is your cap table. What we do is make sure all those steps are covered and automated to the maximum extent, bringing best practice to founders.
The idea is to cut the learning curve. When you talk to investors, especially VCs, you need to be savvy enough in the lingo and your approach to negotiations that they think you should be part of the table. That’s what we think we’re doing here, making sure there’s an inclusionary system within CapQuest. The earlier you use it, the more savvy you can be about managing your equity.
Jamie
Do you think that literacy is lacking among founders, maybe regionally, and they only find out later, when it’s too late?
Marco
We always say cap table management is at the crossroads of legal frameworks and financial modelling. Both can be daunting alone, let alone together. Absolutely. Our entire ethos as a product and a company is to help founders bridge that gap in understanding, which a lot of the time they postpone, thinking, “We’ll figure out these details later.”
Jamie
We’re focused on building. That’ll figure itself out at a later point.
Marco
Exactly. Then that later point arrives and you realise that maybe you’ve over-diluted yourself or raised SAFEs in an incorrect format.
Our job has also been to educate the market about being more proactive and taking these steps ahead of time. Be responsible and diligent so that when the due diligence or compliance process comes, you’re ready and prepared with a solid cap table.
Antoine
To go back to what you’re saying, I think that was the case maybe 10 years ago. I’ve been in the industry for 12 years. Ten years ago, you had extremely savvy startup entrepreneurs who understood it, but
first-time founders probably had no clue.
Even discussions around distributing preferred shares with founders in 2017 were kind of, “Why should I give preferred shares? They get the same shares I do.”
Jamie
This is still a discourse.
Antoine
Really?
Jamie
Yes.
Antoine
Interesting. But at least it’s gotten a lot better. About Dubai in particular, and the GCC at large, because we don’t have the same access to capital as the US, you find founders here who are real hustlers and need to learn very fast, to cut the learning curve as much as possible.
The growth in knowledge and practices has been amazing in the last 10 years. That’s why we’re also growing very fast on that side. It made our job a lot easier on the educational part, for sure.
When a spreadsheet stops being enough
Jamie
How early do you need to get your ducks in a row on a platform like this? Historically, there could be the argument that a spreadsheet and a good lawyer will get you pretty far. Does that argument still hold?
Antoine
It’s going to be more expensive if you go with a law firm. Budget management at the beginning is quite important. But it really varies.
There are certain businesses that are bootstrapped, don’t think about ESOPs until Series A, and don’t specifically need software like CapQuest to start with. But things have changed a lot with SAFEs. You were restricted in raising the rounds we see now, especially early on, when valuation was based on current metrics.
Imagine your pre-seed valuation. I don’t know if you remember the scorecard metrics, where you had five points and the maximum valuation you could get was $2.5 million. You can raise $2 million if your valuation is $2.5 million pre-revenue. Now we’re seeing pre-revenue companies raising on SAFEs with caps of $10 million, $15 million, sometimes $20 million. The need starts very early. It’s really evolved.
I think SAFEs did a lot of good. At the end of the day, our entire industry is banking on the future. Having early-stage companies able to raise on future valuations makes sense in how you approach early-stage investments. I’d say the need for CapQuest starts earlier and earlier.
Marco
One thing we’ve also noticed, talking about increasing complexity, is that VCs are asking for things like reverse vesting for founders, even early on. That has to be managed properly, with the right maths in terms of cadence and vesting structure.
If you’re simple enough, a spreadsheet will do the job, but increasingly we’re seeing complexity even at earlier stages that would justify using platforms like ours.
Will AI replace the dashboard?
Jamie
One of the things I’m interested in at the moment is this idea that software like CRMs, and dashboards generally, could become much less important. Jason Lemkin at SaaStr is a big trumpeter of the idea that the dashboard itself becomes obsolete. You’ll have an agent plug-in and can ask questions through Claude. The underlying software still matters, but people might not open it as much.
It’s something I’ve experienced a little. I use Attio as my CRM, for example. I haven’t opened Attio in six months. I have no idea what’s going on in that platform, but I’ll access it through Claude.
When you think about where CapQuest is going, if we extrapolate much further into the future, do you think people will spend less time inside the product, or use it through something else? I’m curious about your perspective.
Antoine
I think you’re absolutely right. We’re currently developing our connectors for any kind of AI tool you might be using, facilitating input, output and so forth. We understood that quite early on.
We have a beautiful dashboard on CapQuest, but it was never something we thought we needed to spend so much time on. Especially now, everybody wants to build their own dashboards. Internally, there isn’t a third-party software dashboard we look at. They’re all inbuilt dashboards.
The other element linked to how people approach this software, and the SaaS industry in general with AI, comes down to the complexity of the processes the software runs and its maintenance. It’s great to build your own in-house elements with Claude, but you need to maintain them. There are storage elements to take into account.
I understand there are a lot of shifts in the SaaS industry. But to say it’s completely dead because everybody can build their own? I don’t think I’d start building an ERP tomorrow.
Jamie
There is this discourse. I spend far too much time on X, but one of the main points of contention at the moment is around beehiiv, the newsletter platform. I use it myself. One of the ideas is that it’s become too expensive, it’s VC-backed, and I’m just going to vibe code my own newsletter email platform.
That ignores an enormous amount of complexity around email deliverability and the different products that plug in at different stages and cost a fortune. In reality, my subscription is subsidised by enterprise users for the most part. The unit economics don’t make sense for me, but they’re able to make it make sense.
Why can this not be vibe coded?
Marco
I want to touch on the point you mentioned. For upper-tier SaaS used at enterprise level, where the ticket cost is in the hundreds of thousands, when that becomes a significant line in your P&L as a tech company, it justifies the CFO and CTO sitting down and saying, “This $650,000 SaaS we’re paying for, can we do something in-house?”
There’s going to be pressure on that side of the buy-versus-build question, 100%. On the lower end, with lighter SaaS products, you might see a proliferation of vibe-coded competitors. There might be pressure there as well.
You have to find yourself in a situation where you’re adding a tremendous amount of value at a price point that justifies the CFO saying, “I don’t want this to be on me. I don’t want my tech team to waste time on it or take on the technical debt that comes with it.”
The analogy I love hearing is that we
all have recipes and ingredients to make bread at home. Few people actually make bread at home. In our particular instance, this is niche enough that there’s strong domain expertise in what we’re building and our understanding of it. All the integrations we’re working on, in terms of signatures, automations and the AI elements we’re putting in place, facilitate and strengthen the product.
Antoine
When we started CapQuest, we looked into whether we could vibe code this ourselves. It turns out we couldn’t.
Equity management is at the crossroads of legal tech and fintech. What our clients count on us for, on the fintech side, is making sure that the formulas automating vesting, SAFE conversions, anti-dilution clauses, liquidity premises on exit scenarios and so forth are correct.
Jamie
Can’t afford mistakes, I would say.
Antoine
We cannot. Exactly. Thankfully, we don’t. They count on us to have the maths right, so they don’t need to spend hours, days or weeks figuring out the maths for their software to work.
The second element is updates to the legal environment. Just last year, I think it was Commercial Law 10 of 2025 in the UAE that allowed different share classes on the mainland. There are lots of different circulars. In Brazil, we recently had one about new holdco structures and SBCs. In France, you have shifts in the environment around stock options and BSPCEs.
We’re at the forefront of getting that news and making sure the software complies with those elements. Compliance is a big part, including IFRS 13 and IFRS 2, especially on expense-based reporting. We do a lot of education with late-stage companies about the methodologies around these things.
The reason you pay for this software is either that it optimises revenue or optimises costs. We fall into the second category. They trust us to give them the most compliant cap table, with correct calculations and an up-to-date understanding of the legal system. It’s not their job to go through those phases. It’s not core business.
Jamie
It’s not core business. Presumably, over time, the more data you have, that becomes a differentiator and a moat in itself, in terms of recommendations and advice generally.
Antoine
Big time. The number of phone calls I get from clients asking, “What do you think about that?” It’s always a thing between founders. If we want to ask something, we don’t ask Google. We call other founders.
For us to have enough data that we can benchmark what’s happening in the market, what’s the post-money cap for a specific industry at a particular stage? What percentage should I allocate to my ESOP pool? That’s where we come in and give them confidence that they’ve got the right data. They couldn’t get that by vibe coding.
Those benchmarks set us apart a lot. The more markets we’re in, the more comparative analysis we can do. A lot of founders ask me, “What are the VC-backed companies doing?” They want to make sure they don’t rock the boat and go in with a structure that makes sense. I get it. It’s something we help a lot of founders and clients with.
Building a leaner company with AI
Jamie
Is it a fun time to build software?
Marco
It’s a fun time to build software, definitely. There are a lot of shifting and changing elements. Every day brings something new, but fundamentally, the tools and malleability AI is bringing have been really interesting for us.
The speed at which you can go to market with tools, test and understand what’s sticking and working for clients is increasing a lot. The feedback loop has certainly gotten faster. In that sense, it’s been really interesting.
Jamie
Is it a very different experience from your previous startups? Just in terms of velocity and speed.
Antoine
Completely. Velocity, number of people. At Repeat, we had a team of 20 engineers in Turkey for a mobile app, and a team in Dubai. We had a large team on product, a large team on QA and so forth.
Today, you don’t need the same number of people. You’re integrated with AI on product design, QA and engineering. Marco’s at the forefront of all those elements. When you ask whether it’s fun to build software today, I just think it’s fun to build a business. Software can be one way to do it. It could be anything else. The same fundamentals apply.
Marco
Now you can look at that from a marketing and sales perspective. All the automations across the company’s functions have been really interesting, whether that’s automating emails or marketing functions generally.
Antoine
I’ll ask you something, because at the end of the day you’re also building a business. It is fun, but I think it’s for a special kind of person who’s a bit masochistic.
Jamie
100%. Does that change how much you need to fundraise today, if you can keep the team much leaner than you would have previously? You could have used geographic arbitrage on the engineering side, but not across the different functions.
We have a fundraise to announce as well, so please disclose said details and we can pick that apart.
Antoine
Thank you so much. We raised $1 million in our pre-seed round, backed by some of the best people in the ecosystem, top-tier angel investors and Oraseya Capital. We’re very happy to be backed by them.
Has AI changed the way we fundraise? We haven’t seen a big difference, I have to say. There are fewer rounds. There used to be a lot more bridge rounds, especially early on. Today, financial projections make it such that there are much larger early-stage rounds, and you’re covering yourself in one or two rounds before Series A. That’s what we’ve experienced.
In terms of the amount raised, that’s more a factor of the business’s growth. We still abide by the rule of 40 in the SaaS industry. What’s your year-on-year growth plus your EBITDA margin? Do you get more than 40%? It has to make sense under that guise, and you still need to raise to make the machine work.
I’ve spoken to founders who find themselves with AI bills at the end of the
month that can rival a small team.
Jamie
Tell me about it.
Antoine
You definitely still need to raise.
Jamie
The fundamentals remain the same at the end of the day.
Antoine
Exactly.
Why distribution still takes people
Jamie
Has the ambition in terms of how quickly you can grow changed, though?
Antoine
That, for sure. You’ve spoken to a lot of founders. Do you see people, with the impetus of using AI, thinking, “I can grow markets and size so much faster”?
Jamie
I think that’s the biggest thing. Scaling into additional markets that previously would have been three or four years down the road. From the outset, going, “I can supercharge distribution here and build globally from day one,” ostensibly. That’s a big shift from what I’ve seen.
Antoine
I’d differentiate that. On product building, for sure, you’re faster. But on distribution, there are a lot of AI tools out there, and I’m wondering whether we’re at a stage where their efficiency supersedes certain old-school techniques.
In terms of pure success rates, we’ve tested and seen that cold calling in the region is still extremely potent. I’ve seen AI tools where you can simulate a person’s voice. I don’t know if you’ve encountered people using them.
Jamie
I’m yet to be convinced by AI SDRs.
Antoine
So far, us too. That doesn’t mean you don’t superpower your SDRs and account executives with AI. But in terms of having those people and the job they need to do, it’s not at a level where we think we can just go so much faster.
Superpowering that side of the business has helped us grow much faster. I think it’s also a question of product-market fit. To come back to fundamentals, do you have a product where it takes much longer to build brand recognition and grow in different markets?
Jamie
It’s not one size fits all. It’s entirely contingent on what you’re building and for what market, B2B, B2C and so on.
Antoine
And the ambition as well, for sure.
Jamie
Definitely. Is this still a very consultative product in terms of your dealings with clients and customers?
Antoine
Less and less, but there’s a component with certain clients where Remy, our CRO, has directly sold my expertise as part of the package of getting on board with CapQuest. I’d love to have a little more sleep, but it’s also a pleasure. I understand it, and it’s something we’d like to grow in the business.
One of the things we’ve seen with other companies, the US incumbents, is poor customer support and ticket queues rather than speaking to a person. A big differentiator for us has been the human touch, being able to get in contact and get your answer in two minutes, rather than long email chains where two days later you’re still not convinced about what you need to do.
Jamie
Could that advisory part become something meaningful that can be productised?
Antoine
I was a consultant for six years, then afterwards, so nearly eight years of my life. I haven’t poured all my thoughts into it. It’s tough to have something streamlined as a product. I know there are a lot of AI consultants now. I’m yet to be fully convinced on that side, but it’s a professional bias.
Jamie
A forward-deployed cap table management adviser.
Marco
On your previous point, it’s interesting because the cap table touches on a series of other elements that are fundamental when raising, like valuation logic, structures and how much to raise.
Jamie
It’s that intersection of literally everything.
Marco
Exactly. We’re not immune to those questions. They invariably come to us given our domain expertise and knowledge. We end up answering, or at least helping them with questions and strategising about the best approach for different companies, stages and where they are. That’s why I smile, because it ends up being exactly that.
Doing the things that don’t scale
Jamie
The argument is that initially you do the things that don’t scale, and that helps you get to the point where you can scale. It’s your point of differentiation versus the global incumbents, who are a bit more corporate in their outlook and how they operate.
Marco
That’s been fundamental for us. We’re building here, we’re present in the different ecosystems, whether it’s DIFC or Dubai Founders HQ, and we work closely with founders on the ground, listening to their challenges and what they’re going through.
Doing those initial things that don’t scale gives you great grassroots feedback into the product and what you’re building. You understand how to iterate that into the product and build something focused on the region.
Antoine
One of the things I’m thankful for is giving sessions and classes on cap table management, fundraising instruments and financial projections to accelerators like Sandbox by Oraseya, Antler, Station F in France, REACH in the US and others.
It’s always great to bring up the level of knowledge within the industry. The consultative and advisory part is something we built into the company’s DNA, because I love doing it. I was doing it before CapQuest and I’ll continue doing it after. It takes time.
To touch on your point about the timeline, you’re absolutely right that there are different things you need to do at different stages. I’ve seen founders look at very mature companies, look at the processes they have and think, “I need to do the same.” Big mistake.
You’re not at the maturity level where you’ve exhausted every distribution channel, so you’re using that method to incrementally make a difference to your P&L. You have to understand what works at what stage.
We’re at a stage where walking around Dubai Founders HQ, just going to the bathroom, I get stopped 10 times by clients. “By the way, this scenario…” It’s a pleasure, but it’s also necessary at our stage.
Jamie
I think it’s a good point and a good lesson for people. Not everything needs to be immediately transactional. Sometimes people get caught up in that. Good things can happen with goodwill.
Antoine
I believe in it 100%.
Our CRO would love us to be more transactional. There’s that element. But at the end of the day, what do you want to be remembered for five years down the line? How do people talk about you?
A lot of people say, “I don’t care what people say about me.” Please, really? I’d rather people say, “We’re using CapQuest. Antoine, great guy. Marco, fantastic.” Even if they’re not clients, let them say that about us. Down the line, when they raise and have employees, they’ll be with us.
Pricing around growth, not locked features
Jamie
You obviously have a vested interest in these startups and companies succeeding. To that end, can we talk about the business model and how pricing works? A company comes in early, and you want them to graduate up the scale. That’s great for them, but it’s great for you as well.
Marco
We grow as they grow, as we say.
Antoine
It’s funny, because founders scroll through LinkedIn, seeing all the announcements. This guy’s raised, that guy’s raised. They can get FOMO or think, “This guy raised? I can’t believe it.” We’re now in a position where everybody who raises, it’s, “Amazing. Go, go, go. That’s great.”
I’ve never been happier to see other founders succeed. We have the biggest vested interest in this market succeeding, and all the other markets we’re in.
In terms of pricing, that’s how we structured it. There were different value metrics we tested at the beginning, thinking about what could work. The first thing was not to feature-lock anyone.
If your approach is giving out knowledge and best practices, you don’t want a startup locked out of specific parts of your software, leaving them in the dark on how to do an ESOP or model their next fundraising round. Feature-locking is a big element of our competitors’ pricing.
The only value metric we put in place is the number of stakeholders. That grows as you grow, adding investors and employees. Our startup package covers zero to 15 stakeholders. That’s $150 a month on an annual basis. Our growth package covers 15 to 30 stakeholders. That’s $200 a month. Above 30 stakeholders is our enterprise package.
We’re also launching our freemium plan, which will be for accelerators and so forth, up to a limited number of stakeholders. For paying customers, everything we ship in terms of additional features, and we have a lot upcoming that Marco will discuss, they’ll all have access to it.
For the price our clients are paying, every month we ship new features, they get added value. That’s how we like to grow with them.
How customer requests shape the roadmap
Jamie
How do you approach feature releases and the product roadmap? There’s so much you can do. How do you prioritise?
Marco
We have a 24-month roadmap ready to go in terms of demand. It’s a great question. A lot of the time, we have enterprise requests that are quite urgent. The great thing about being agile at our stage is that when a big enterprise client approaches us and says, “We’ve been speaking to other players,
but we need this particular element and no one says they can do it. Can you?” We can say, “Actually, we can. Give us a couple of weeks.” And they say, “We’re in.”
That’s been the case for a lot of features we’ve added in a relatively short time. It was an initial demand from enterprise clients saying they’d love this and asking whether we could incorporate it. A lot of the time, the answer is yes.
Antoine
Like the integration with DocuSign.
Marco
Like the DocuSign integration, which was a request from one of our great clients, Holo. We got that done in about a month. That’s one demand directly from the market. It might be one client, but we know it will extrapolate to other clients down the line. The use cases only build. We’ve done it for grants, and now we’ll expand it to other features.
We’re always listening to what the market says, but also understanding the pain points founders have at different stages. This quarter, for example, we’re excited to launch a data room feature. In that fundraising journey, not everyone has enough complexity in their cap table to justify using CapQuest’s entire capability. But they all need a data room, with the right sharing capabilities and analytics, which something like Dropbox or Google Drive might not offer at this stage.
We listened to the market and understood this was a pain point. What could we offer that they didn’t have? It’s exciting for founders to have visibility over who’s interacting with what in their data room. That fits into the founder’s journey. They’ll eventually need a cap table, but right now they might need a data room more.
Later on, for more mature founders who need sophisticated investor reporting, that’s also something we’re launching this quarter. It attempts to standardise what’s a very saturated approach to investor reporting.
We brought together the best practices we know in the market and Antoine’s expertise to define a feature that simplifies the entire flow. We’ve vetted it with VCs to check that it meets their requirements too.
We’re looking at the founder’s journey, from earlier to more mature stages. What features can we plug into those different timelines, and what pain points can we help handle?
Making decisions and disagreeing as co-founders
Antoine
On the boring side of how we do things internally, and I don’t know if this will be useful for others, our approach to decision-making is very methodical. We use a lot of scorecards, having categories and classifying them with a score, then having your tier A, tier B and tier C elements.
It’s great to be intuitive, but there’s a survivorship bias to intuition. You think, “My gut is right. Look at all the things I’ve succeeded at,” and you look at the decisions you’ve made. A kind of vibe decision-making approach.
Without methodology, only the people who’ve made it think they made the right choice. Having that methodology means we can go to sleep at night without wondering whether we made the right call.
Jamie
Have you ever fundamentally disagreed?
Marco
I don’t think on anything too strong. What we agreed early on is that if there are disagreements and we deliberate, ultimately the person who owns that domain makes the decision. We agreed to disagree but commit.
Even if there’s a strategy element you disagree with, jump wholeheartedly into that decision and commit as if you’d also been part of it. You’ll understand whether it was the right decision faster if everyone’s on board, and you can pivot and change accordingly.
Don’t be in a position where you disagree, the decision is made, and then you impede the process. Jump in 100% with conviction. That’s always been our approach to working together. It may not be exactly what I want, but let’s commit 100% to this strategy. We’ll understand whether it was right and make the decision accordingly. I don’t think there’s been anything significant.
Antoine
I’m telling you, Marco, for both of us, our relationship has been the longest relationship we’ve had in our lives. Did we have arguments? For sure. But effectively, disagree and commit. No resentment, and rely on his expertise.
There are things I don’t even want to hear about. I trust him 100%, and I think it’s the same the other way around. Having a co-founder you can do two entire businesses with is a blessing. It’s also such a relief.
Jamie
For sure. It’s a rarity, it really is.
Competing with US incumbents
Jamie
I want to talk about Pulley, if we can. For context, I’ll try to tee it up a little, and Antoine, you can do a better job than me.
Pulley, a US-based cap table management platform, had raised $50 million and recently wound down operations. A pretty stacked cap table, Founders Fund and so on. It’s a puzzling one to a certain extent, and I’m keen to get your thoughts, Antoine. I think you have feelings on the subject.
Antoine
I have a take on the matter. It’s an unverified take, but it comes from my knowledge of how I built CapQuest. By the way, Yin Wu, the founder of Pulley, is a YC graduate and also had the backing of that community. A great start.
But Pulley was operating in the most competitive market in the world, a very mature market, against Carta and a lot of other US players. Cake comes to mind.
Jamie
Is it a very saturated market?
Antoine
We’ve been told that time and time again. The US is a great market, but so saturated. That’s why we always talk about emerging markets.
From these US incumbents, there’s a categorisation of the world as US companies and non-US-based companies. “Others.” That’s how they name the rest of the world. I don’t like that attitude too much, to be honest.
Pulley was operating in that very competitive market. Just vibing on the cap table side without verticalising, I think, was a bit of their mistake in a market where Carta does that.
For US-based companies, the need for 409A valuations is a big thing. Carta offers that, and Pulley was offering it too, at broken prices, to be honest. It has a cost. When you have that many valuers inside your company, I’ve seen Pulley’s cost base. It was quite massive.
Jamie
Really?
Antoine
In terms of what they raised, how they grew and the cost base, there was an element of, “YOLO, we’re back in the 2010s. We raise a lot, we burn a lot, and we’ll beat the competition with broken prices and overspending.”
It’s also a bit of my traditional background, having been around more PE firms at the beginning of my career. I strongly believe unit economics need to make sense from day one. I praise a lot of these AI companies for what they’re doing and producing, but I’m still yet to understand the unit economics of that industry.
Jamie
Don’t ask these questions.
Antoine
I’m so sorry. We’re not supposed to talk about it.
Jamie
Don’t ask questions you don’t want the answer to.
Antoine
Exactly. On our side, we wanted to make sure CapQuest functions on a unit economics basis. I think Pulley didn’t think about that, and ultimately that’s what brings down a lot of companies. That’s my take.
Growth, unit economics and burn
Jamie
Can you remain competitive when you have to reconcile the unit economics at an early stage? Isn’t the idea to grow at all costs and figure it out later? Where do you fall on that tension? Because it has worked in other industries.
You’re erring on this side and you’ve diagnosed the problem Pulley experienced. Carta is present in the region as well. What’s your solution in this context, in terms of how you intend to plot your growth?
Antoine
A lot of people look at this in terms of pricing. We start with a broken price, and eventually we’ll be able to surge-price our way to profitability, to name Uber. That’s great. But it’s not so much a question of price as what you’re spending at which moment.
To come back to the timeline, there are cases where you’re acquiring a specific client, not all clients, where the cost of acquisition might not make sense today. Fortunately, we’re in a business where switching costs are high. More so, apparently, with CapQuest than with Carta. It’s something built in for the long term.
I remain a big believer in strong unit economics from the get-go. There’s still spending for growth, but with measured impact that makes sense overall. If you look at a specific sliver of time, you might think it doesn’t make sense in terms of CAC. But it always comes back to LTV.
If your LTV is two transactions, one month or two months, then you’re broken. If it’s four, five or 10 years, it still makes sense. Growth at all costs, I think, isn’t a unit economics problem. It’s a burn problem. Your unit economics might still make sense, but you could be burning cash every month at a very high level.
It’s more about the overall picture than purely unit economics. You can be burning a lot of money for growth. If the unit economics still make sense, then it makes sense over the long term to burn that money for growth.
Building across markets and beyond tech
Jamie
What are some of the dangers? The first that springs to mind is geopolitical instability or a downturn in the macroeconomic environment. We’ve seen it to a certain extent in the drawdown in funding volumes. The regional headline figure is, I think, maybe 7% down, based on MAGNiTT for H1. But that conceals massive funding rounds, and underneath it there’s maybe a 33% volume drawdown.
Is that a concern for capital management software with an emerging-market focus, that these markets are more liable to be affected? If fewer startups are being funded, does that become an issue?
Antoine
I’ll be honest with you. Geographical diversification and distribution are things we want to look at, because venture winters can happen across the map, but they’re stronger in some markets than others.
It’s not just us. In the industry at large, even funds are revising their investment theses. We’ve had discussions with some of them about geographical distribution. There was a time when, as a VC fund in MENA, you were funding MENA-based companies with revenue in MENA, focused on developing the region. Today, a lot of them are asking what’s out there and what the possibilities are for becoming cross-border.
Jamie
Diaspora is hot right now. It’s a convenient way to hedge your exposure, for sure.
Antoine
At the same time, Dubai is such a great sandbox to build your business. We should be super proud when companies from here spread their wings internationally.
The hegemony of the US venture space and startup industry has been its capacity not only to capture one of the world’s biggest markets, but also to export those products across the world. I want the top 40 unicorns we have in the country by 2030 to be built with this in mind, looking at Asia and Africa. Why not Europe and the US?
I’d love them to feel threatened by our ecosystem, to think, “We’ve got to look out for these guys coming from Dubai. They build a great product and they’re coming for us,” not the other way around.
Jamie
It’s a big world.
Marco
To touch on your point, it’s not only geographical diversification. We’re seeing greater sophistication in equity, in financial instruments and in its distribution at an employment level. In addition to being company-stage agnostic and geographically agnostic, we’re also vertical agnostic.
In the US, a lot of manufacturing companies have ESOPs because the average employee tenure is quite long, and employees want to participate in equity. You’re seeing this trend of distributing equity move outside tech companies and into more traditional businesses.
As that grows, it will counterbalance, to some extent, the variances and volatility we may see in the market.
ESOPs, secondaries and getting paid before an IPO
Jamie
We’ve heard with frustrating frequency that there’s a very clogged-up pipeline of startups that will go public at some point, whether in Saudi Arabia, the UAE or through a dual listing. One of the interesting things recently is the
massive secondary component in Tabby’s latest round. I think they’ve distributed maybe $100 million in liquidity at this point.
That ties into ESOPs and how important it is to get them right early, rather than trying to do it retrospectively, because it helps massively with buy-in. We’ve even seen Alaan provide secondary liquidity at Series A, which is rare. Talk to me a little about ESOPs.
Antoine
On the ESOP side, but also the secondary side. I remember in 2017 we took offices where every startup took offices at the time, in Shatha Tower. We were with Careem, Checkout, Property Finder, all these guys, and Repeat.
I’ll always remember the week Careem got bought by Uber. Suddenly, the number of Porsches in the parking lot skyrocketed.
Jamie
It reminds me of The Simpsons episode where there’s a massive dividend at the nuclear power plant and all of a sudden everyone’s arriving in Ferraris. Essentially that story.
Antoine
It was real life. It was exactly that, Jamie. We saw all these Porsches and nice cars. The parking lot looked a lot different. We went from Toyotas and Nissans to Porsches and Jeep Wranglers. It was kind of, wow, okay.
It was real-life proof that the ESOP model, in creating liquidity for your employees and as a talent acquisition and retention tool, makes absolute sense.
I want to make it clear that an ESOP isn’t a replacement for the wage component of how you acquire and retain talent. It should be the carrot for all the hard work involved in building something. There’s real upside to that.
As you mentioned with companies like Alaan, and without naming them, we’ve seen in our own client list a lot of employees able to have exercise periods before going public and monetise them. That’s interesting and something I don’t think we saw 10 years ago.
Marco
No, that’s right.
Antoine
The secondaries part is also tied into the slight DPI issue that exists in the market.
Jamie
Slight?
Antoine
I’m being political, of course. I don’t have the numbers off the top of my head, but yes, the slight issue. Secondaries, especially for early-stage investors, are a route we’re seeing more and more. That’s consolidating a good pipeline of potential exits for funds, not just employees.
Why going public isn’t an exit event
Antoine
Going public, hot take, for me isn’t an exit event. It’s a way to render an illiquid asset liquid over time, for sure, but it isn’t a way to sell all your shares and crash the share price, as we’ve seen time and time again. It shouldn’t be thought of as a financial instrument in that manner.
It makes something illiquid liquid, but it’s still a matter of holding on, seeing the share price increase and getting other institutional investors to buy in. There are all those elements to take into account.
We’re all banking a lot on these IPOs, these upcoming, “Very soon, it’s coming tomorrow” IPOs. It’ll be a great signal of what the entire market has been building for the last 10 years and how it makes a very illiquid asset liquid in the region. I’m fully behind them, really.
Jamie
I think we all are. I’m sick of writing about it, so I need to get them over the line. I have pieces ready to go for when this finally comes to fruition. I think I’ve been sitting on some of them for three years at this point. I’m sick and tired of it. Come on, guys, let’s rock and roll.
Antoine
I don’t mind them staying private longer.
Jamie
That’s true.
Antoine
Please call me.
Jamie
Guys, this was great. Antoine, Marco, thank you so much. This was terrific.