BẢN CHÉP ÂM THANH 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:10.250 --> 00:00:12.890
Hi everyone, this is part two of my episode on
2
00:00:12.910 --> 00:00:16.949
the abduction of Willowbrook employee Ethel Atwell. If you have
3
00:00:16.989 --> 00:00:19.910
not listened to part one, go back and listen now
4
00:00:20.030 --> 00:00:22.570
or you're going to be very lost. In part one,
5
00:00:22.649 --> 00:00:26.010
I briefly covered the history of the Willowbrook Institution on
6
00:00:26.050 --> 00:00:29.329
Staten Island, as well as the abduction of employees Shin
7
00:00:29.350 --> 00:00:33.869
Lee and Ethel Atwell on institution grounds. Shin Lee was
8
00:00:33.929 --> 00:00:36.770
abducted in July and found murdered in a shallow grave
9
00:00:36.810 --> 00:00:40.070
in the woods in on the grounds of Willowbrook in August.
10
00:00:40.770 --> 00:00:44.609
She had been sexually assaulted and strangled. In October, Ethel
11
00:00:44.719 --> 00:00:46.899
Atwell was abducted getting out of her car when she
12
00:00:46.960 --> 00:00:51.320
arrived for her shift. I went through the investigations, the
13
00:00:51.359 --> 00:00:55.539
similarities in circumstances, as well as the violence many workers
14
00:00:55.579 --> 00:00:58.100
who worked at Willowbrook faced and how that may have
15
00:00:58.159 --> 00:01:02.060
played into both women's abductions. Today... I want to pick
16
00:01:02.100 --> 00:01:04.379
back up with diving into the history of a man
17
00:01:04.420 --> 00:01:07.579
named Andre Rand, who had close ties to Willowbrook and
18
00:01:07.599 --> 00:01:12.000
would eventually face some criminal charges. Many believe he is
19
00:01:12.060 --> 00:01:14.680
a serial killer who is responsible for all of the
20
00:01:14.739 --> 00:01:18.939
crimes that are similar that happened in that area. Others
21
00:01:19.000 --> 00:01:23.049
think there was more than one person operating there. I'll
22
00:01:23.060 --> 00:01:26.030
go through the crimes most commonly suspected to be tied
23
00:01:26.049 --> 00:01:28.709
to him, as well as the cases he was charged
24
00:01:28.829 --> 00:01:32.670
in and then end the episode discussing the potential connection
25
00:01:32.750 --> 00:01:37.010
to Ethel Atwell and Shin Lee, or the other possibilities.
26
00:01:38.709 --> 00:01:40.810
I'm your host Megan, and each week on A Simpler
27
00:01:40.849 --> 00:01:44.489
Time True Crime, I cover older unsolved cases and challenge
28
00:01:44.530 --> 00:01:47.069
the idea that a simpler time meant a safer time.
29
00:01:47.870 --> 00:01:50.590
Today I'm bringing to you part two of the abduction
30
00:01:50.890 --> 00:01:58.109
of Ethel Atwell. There isn't a lot known about Andre
31
00:01:58.189 --> 00:02:06.560
Rand's early life. born Frank Rouchan in Manhattan on March 11, 1944,
32
00:02:06.560 --> 00:02:09.430
and he grew up in the Ithaca area. I wanted
33
00:02:09.439 --> 00:02:11.150
to point out his birth name because it does come
34
00:02:11.189 --> 00:02:14.289
up in older records, along with the name Frank Bruchette,
35
00:02:14.330 --> 00:02:17.669
which he gave himself. But to avoid jumping back and
36
00:02:17.710 --> 00:02:20.330
forth between three different names, I'm going to refer to
37
00:02:20.370 --> 00:02:23.650
him as Andre Rand from here on out. Rand's father
38
00:02:23.689 --> 00:02:27.319
died when he was 14. His mother reportedly struggled with
39
00:02:27.360 --> 00:02:30.620
her mental health and spent time at the Pilgrim Psychiatric
40
00:02:30.659 --> 00:02:34.360
Center on Long Island. Rand and his younger sister would
41
00:02:34.400 --> 00:02:38.780
visit there. His sister was later interviewed for the documentary Cropsey.
42
00:02:39.759 --> 00:02:42.060
And she said that despite what people may assume about
43
00:02:42.099 --> 00:02:45.900
Rand's childhood, neither of them had been physically or sexually abused.
44
00:02:46.780 --> 00:02:49.699
Other than her account, though, there really isn't much information
45
00:02:49.759 --> 00:02:53.139
available about his childhood or what he was like growing up.
46
00:02:54.240 --> 00:02:57.740
Rand reportedly served in the Army during the 1960s, but
47
00:02:57.780 --> 00:03:02.800
the details of his military service are unclear. By 1966,
48
00:03:02.800 --> 00:03:05.520
he was working at Willowbrook under the name Frank Bruchette.
49
00:03:06.319 --> 00:03:08.740
He held a variety of jobs there, and his position
50
00:03:08.800 --> 00:03:12.150
had been described as everything from a custodian to an
51
00:03:12.259 --> 00:03:16.490
orderly and then a physical therapy aide. He worked there
52
00:03:16.629 --> 00:03:20.129
until 1968, and his history there would have given him
53
00:03:20.210 --> 00:03:23.050
regular access to the people who lived at the institution.
54
00:03:24.310 --> 00:03:27.120
Even after he stopped working at Willowbrook, his connection to
55
00:03:27.139 --> 00:03:31.860
the property continued for years. Rand moved around quite a
56
00:03:31.879 --> 00:03:34.759
bit over the years, staying in shelters, boarding houses, and
57
00:03:34.800 --> 00:03:38.879
makeshift camps throughout Staten Island. Some of those camps were
58
00:03:38.919 --> 00:03:43.020
in the wooded areas surrounding Willowbrook. He knew the property well,
59
00:03:43.099 --> 00:03:45.719
including the buildings, the woods, and the large amount of
60
00:03:45.860 --> 00:03:50.599
undeveloped land surrounding the institution. There are stories that Andre
61
00:03:50.659 --> 00:03:55.270
Rand lived inside Willowbrook's underground tunnels. but it is difficult
62
00:03:55.310 --> 00:03:58.250
to separate what is documented from what became part of
63
00:03:58.310 --> 00:04:02.349
the larger Cropsey legend. If you haven't seen the documentary,
64
00:04:02.689 --> 00:04:05.129
which I highly recommend and will link in the show notes,
65
00:04:05.729 --> 00:04:09.930
Cropsey was essentially Staten Island's version of the boogeyman. The
66
00:04:09.969 --> 00:04:13.530
details change
Load full transcript
depending on who was telling the story, but
67
00:04:13.569 --> 00:04:17.519
Cropsey was usually described as an escaped patient or former
68
00:04:17.620 --> 00:04:21.240
employee from Willowbrook who lived in the abandoned buildings or
69
00:04:21.279 --> 00:04:24.149
tunnels beneath the property and and came out at night
70
00:04:24.209 --> 00:04:27.769
to take children. It was a story passed around at
71
00:04:27.810 --> 00:04:30.759
sleepovers and summer camps usually as a way to scare
72
00:04:30.800 --> 00:04:34.759
kids away from the woods. But when children really began
73
00:04:34.819 --> 00:04:38.740
disappearing on Staten Island, and Andre Rand was found camping
74
00:04:38.779 --> 00:04:43.899
near Willowbrook, the fictional Cropsey legend slowly became attached to him,
75
00:04:44.259 --> 00:04:49.730
making fact from fiction difficult. but more on those real
76
00:04:49.769 --> 00:04:51.540
cases in a bit because I want to try to
77
00:04:51.569 --> 00:04:55.720
keep this timeline as linear as possible. Please note that,
78
00:04:55.839 --> 00:04:58.939
unless otherwise indicated, Andre Rand is just a suspect in
79
00:04:58.980 --> 00:05:02.319
most of these cases and should be presumed innocent unless
80
00:05:02.420 --> 00:05:06.910
and until proven guilty in a court of law. Rand's
81
00:05:06.970 --> 00:05:09.730
first known crime against a child happened in the South
82
00:05:09.790 --> 00:05:13.589
Bronx in May of 1969, less than a year after
83
00:05:13.649 --> 00:05:17.529
he stopped working at Willowbrook. Some accounts give the date
84
00:05:17.670 --> 00:05:22.029
as May 5th, while others say May 25th. Rand reportedly
85
00:05:22.089 --> 00:05:25.360
approached a 9-year-old girl. He persuaded her to get into
86
00:05:25.399 --> 00:05:27.939
his car, and he drove her to a vacant lot.
87
00:05:28.779 --> 00:05:31.579
Once they were there, he removed both his clothing and
88
00:05:31.620 --> 00:05:35.480
the child's, and he attempted to sexually assault her. The
89
00:05:35.540 --> 00:05:39.829
attack was thankfully interrupted when a police patrol just happened
90
00:05:39.870 --> 00:05:43.430
to pass through the area and officers saw what was happening.
91
00:05:44.290 --> 00:05:48.759
Rand was arrested at the scene. He was initially charged
92
00:05:48.800 --> 00:05:52.480
with kidnapping and attempted rape, but ultimately pleaded guilty to
93
00:05:52.519 --> 00:05:56.519
sexual abuse. Rand was sentenced to four years in prison,
94
00:05:56.579 --> 00:06:00.959
but he served only 16 months before being released on parole.
95
00:06:01.990 --> 00:06:05.269
Records indicate that he was paroled in January of 72.
96
00:06:05.250 --> 00:06:09.290
Around that same period, he legally changed his name from
97
00:06:09.470 --> 00:06:14.610
Frank Ruchon to Andre Rand. The next case potentially tied
98
00:06:14.629 --> 00:06:18.889
to him was that of 5-year-old Alice Pereira. 5-year-old Alice
99
00:06:18.949 --> 00:06:22.310
Pereira
disappeared from the Tysons Lane Apartments in the New
100
00:06:22.329 --> 00:06:27.639
Dorp section of Staten Island on Friday, July 7, 1972.
101
00:06:27.639 --> 00:06:31.680
Alice lived there with her mother, Inez, and her 8-year-old brother, Angelo.
102
00:06:32.540 --> 00:06:35.720
That afternoon, Alice and Angelo were playing together in the
103
00:06:35.759 --> 00:06:39.560
lobby of the building. At around 3.30, Angelo left her
104
00:06:39.620 --> 00:06:42.939
alone for just a few moments, but when he came back,
105
00:06:43.240 --> 00:06:48.069
she was gone. Alice was wearing blue shorts with gold buttons,
106
00:06:48.209 --> 00:06:51.550
a red polo shirt, and red sneakers. There was a
107
00:06:51.569 --> 00:06:54.029
potential sighting of her at a park near the apartment
108
00:06:54.069 --> 00:06:57.790
complex shortly after she disappeared, but police were never able
109
00:06:57.829 --> 00:07:01.399
to definitively confirm that was her. Her mother reported her
110
00:07:01.439 --> 00:07:05.779
missing at around 6.15 that evening. Over the next several days,
111
00:07:05.839 --> 00:07:09.930
police searched the apartment complex and along the nearby railroad tracks.
112
00:07:10.670 --> 00:07:13.040
The people living in the neighborhood also got involved. They
113
00:07:13.060 --> 00:07:16.000
began collecting money for a reward, and they used sound
114
00:07:16.060 --> 00:07:20.319
equipment to broadcast appeals for anyone with information. There was
115
00:07:20.379 --> 00:07:23.319
apparently some difficulty getting the railroad to stop its trains
116
00:07:23.379 --> 00:07:25.920
long enough for police to search the tracks thoroughly, which,
117
00:07:26.439 --> 00:07:28.560
if you remember way back when to one of my
118
00:07:28.670 --> 00:07:31.470
early episodes on Aquila Hodrick who went missing from the
119
00:07:31.529 --> 00:07:35.170
Bronx in 1985, that was an issue in that search too.
120
00:07:36.480 --> 00:07:38.579
Even with all the effort, the search did not turn
121
00:07:38.680 --> 00:07:42.259
up any sign of Alice. Her parents were separated at
122
00:07:42.300 --> 00:07:44.740
the time, and her father was living in Manhattan, so
123
00:07:44.800 --> 00:07:47.750
police first looked into the possibility that he had taken her,
124
00:07:48.310 --> 00:07:52.189
but he had an alibi and was cleared. When exactly
125
00:07:52.329 --> 00:07:55.009
Andre Rand got on their radar is unclear, but the
126
00:07:55.110 --> 00:07:59.449
why isn't. Investigators learned that Andre Rand had been working
127
00:07:59.529 --> 00:08:03.170
as a painter at the Tyson's Lane complex when Alice disappeared.
128
00:08:03.939 --> 00:08:05.459
He had only been out of prison for a few
129
00:08:05.500 --> 00:08:08.519
months after serving time for sexually abusing the 9-year-old girl
130
00:08:08.620 --> 00:08:12.660
in the Bronx. Some write-ups on this case discuss witnesses
131
00:08:12.720 --> 00:08:15.500
seeing a girl who looked like Alice walking hand-in-hand that
132
00:08:15.579 --> 00:08:18.329
afternoon with a man who looked like Rand, but I
133
00:08:18.379 --> 00:08:22.209
haven't been able to locate that definitively in any primary sources.
134
00:08:23.410 --> 00:08:26.569
Andre Rand was questioned in Alice's disappearance, but police did
135
00:08:26.629 --> 00:08:29.509
not have enough evidence to charge him, and Alice's case
136
00:08:29.629 --> 00:08:33.190
went cold. The next case I'm going to touch on,
137
00:08:33.429 --> 00:08:35.230
I want to be clear that it has the least
138
00:08:35.289 --> 00:08:38.409
amount of evidence connected to Andre Rand, but I still
139
00:08:38.429 --> 00:08:42.889
want to tell you. So, 18-year-old Audrey Lynn Nirenberg disappeared
140
00:08:42.929 --> 00:08:45.500
from her family's home on Riders Street in Brooklyn in
141
00:08:45.539 --> 00:08:48.799
July of 77. At around 2 that afternoon, she told
142
00:08:48.860 --> 00:08:50.700
her mother she was going to walk two blocks to
143
00:08:50.740 --> 00:08:54.279
buy cigarettes and would be right back. She left carrying
144
00:08:54.320 --> 00:08:57.220
a brown bag on her shoulder that contained $ 2 in it.
145
00:08:58.620 --> 00:09:01.870
She never returned. Later that day, Audrey's father received a
146
00:09:01.909 --> 00:09:04.490
call from a man claiming he had taken her. The
147
00:09:04.529 --> 00:09:06.870
caller told him to gather as much money as possible
148
00:09:07.269 --> 00:09:11.470
and he said he would call again. Audrey's father contacted
149
00:09:11.509 --> 00:09:15.889
the FBI, but the second call never came. Audrey had
150
00:09:15.950 --> 00:09:20.200
previously been diagnosed with disorganized schizophrenia and she was taking medication.
151
00:09:20.740 --> 00:09:23.159
She'd gotten lost before and she commonly would go back
152
00:09:23.220 --> 00:09:25.899
to places she had been familiar with or had just visited.
153
00:09:26.700 --> 00:09:28.639
And when she got lost, she was always able to
154
00:09:28.679 --> 00:09:32.690
call her family for help. Because she left without identification
155
00:09:32.769 --> 00:09:36.870
or medication, investigators considered whether she could have become disoriented
156
00:09:37.029 --> 00:09:39.830
and had been admitted to a hospital as a Jane Doe.
157
00:09:40.809 --> 00:09:45.190
Hospitals were checked, but she was not located. The evening
158
00:09:45.250 --> 00:09:47.789
before she disappeared, Audrey had gone with her family to
159
00:09:47.830 --> 00:09:51.190
a movie theater on Forest Avenue in Staten Island. The
160
00:09:51.210 --> 00:09:54.190
theater was near an area where Rand had reportedly camped.
161
00:09:54.929 --> 00:09:57.740
A theory later developed that Audrey may have returned to
162
00:09:57.769 --> 00:10:01.289
Staten Island and encountered him. but there's just no evidence
163
00:10:01.340 --> 00:10:03.360
that she went back there or that she had ever
164
00:10:03.440 --> 00:10:06.820
met Rand. Still, you'll see her name connected to him
165
00:10:06.879 --> 00:10:08.919
a lot, so I at least wanted to mention it.
166
00:10:10.710 --> 00:10:13.049
Of course, as we move through the timeline, this is
167
00:10:13.110 --> 00:10:16.740
where we reach the cases of Ethel Atwell and Shin Lee,
168
00:10:17.200 --> 00:10:19.559
and I'll get back to their cases and possible connection
169
00:10:19.580 --> 00:10:24.340
to Rand later. In 1979, Andre Rand was accused of
170
00:10:24.399 --> 00:10:28.429
sexually assaulting two teenage girls. The details of that incident
171
00:10:28.750 --> 00:10:31.570
have never been released because they ended up opting not
172
00:10:31.590 --> 00:10:37.389
to press charges. Then, in early 1981, Andre Rand allegedly
173
00:10:37.529 --> 00:10:41.450
approached a nine-year-old girl in Staten Island in his green Volkswagen.
174
00:10:42.149 --> 00:10:44.450
He offered to give her a lollipop if she got
175
00:10:44.470 --> 00:10:48.279
into his vehicle. The girl declined, and sensing something was off,
176
00:10:48.340 --> 00:10:50.659
she ran home scared, where he followed her in his
177
00:10:50.720 --> 00:10:55.080
car the whole way. Although Rand was identified in this,
178
00:10:55.340 --> 00:11:00.139
no charges were filed. This incident and the green Volkswagen
179
00:11:00.490 --> 00:11:04.649
would prove significant because just a few months later, another
180
00:11:04.710 --> 00:11:09.529
child in Staten Island would go missing under eerily similar circumstances.
181
00:11:20.220 --> 00:11:23.080
Seven-year-old Holly Ann Hughes lived with her family in the
182
00:11:23.139 --> 00:11:26.850
Port Richmond section of Staten Island. On the evening of
183
00:11:26.899 --> 00:11:31.470
July 15, 1981, Holly was outside near the intersection of
184
00:11:31.549 --> 00:11:35.200
Richmond Terrace and Park Avenue. At some point, she and
185
00:11:35.259 --> 00:11:38.240
another little girl walked to a nearby deli, where Holly
186
00:11:38.279 --> 00:11:41.379
bought a bar of ivory soap. For years, it was
187
00:11:41.440 --> 00:11:43.919
reported that Holly's mother had sent her to the store,
188
00:11:44.379 --> 00:11:46.960
but her family later corrected that account and said Holly
189
00:11:47.000 --> 00:11:50.220
had gone there on her own. Holly was last seen
190
00:11:50.360 --> 00:11:54.240
at around 9.30pm that evening. She was wearing a beige
191
00:11:54.279 --> 00:11:58.139
bathing suit under blue shorts along with beige and brown sandals.
192
00:11:58.799 --> 00:12:02.779
She never made it back home. Holly's disappearance was reported
193
00:12:02.840 --> 00:12:05.919
to police and people in the neighborhood began offering information
194
00:12:06.039 --> 00:12:09.000
about what they had seen that night. Some of those
195
00:12:09.059 --> 00:12:13.070
witnesses placed Andre Rand in the area. Rand had a
196
00:12:13.110 --> 00:12:16.669
relative who lived in the same apartment building as Holly's family,
197
00:12:16.889 --> 00:12:19.980
her aunt specifically, so His presence around the building would
198
00:12:20.039 --> 00:12:24.419
not necessarily have seemed unusual on its own. However, witnesses
199
00:12:24.480 --> 00:12:28.450
reported seeing his green Volkswagen circling near the deli, and
200
00:12:28.500 --> 00:12:33.190
at least one account placed Holly inside his car. Another
201
00:12:33.250 --> 00:12:35.509
young girl would later say that Rand had been playing
202
00:12:35.590 --> 00:12:38.509
hide and seek with children that day, and had given
203
00:12:38.549 --> 00:12:43.200
Holly money to buy the soap. Rand reportedly admitted being
204
00:12:43.220 --> 00:12:45.779
with Holly earlier that day. He said, yep, I know her,
205
00:12:45.820 --> 00:12:48.740
I saw her, but he said he left and she
206
00:12:48.779 --> 00:12:54.250
left before she ever disappeared. Police questioned him shortly after
207
00:12:54.309 --> 00:12:58.590
she vanished, and they searched his car. But they didn't
208
00:12:58.629 --> 00:13:00.970
have enough evidence to arrest him or prove that Holly
209
00:13:01.009 --> 00:13:04.730
had ever been taken in his vehicle. Holly's family later
210
00:13:04.750 --> 00:13:07.669
said police discounted some of the neighborhood witnesses because they
211
00:13:07.700 --> 00:13:12.440
had criminal records. Police denied that the investigation had been mishandled,
212
00:13:12.919 --> 00:13:15.019
but either way, at that point, the case went nowhere.
213
00:13:16.149 --> 00:13:18.830
About a month after Holly disappeared, her mother, who was
214
00:13:18.950 --> 00:13:22.289
also named Holly but her last name was Cederholm, she
215
00:13:22.370 --> 00:13:25.080
received a call from a man who identified himself only
216
00:13:25.149 --> 00:13:28.399
as Sale. He claimed he was holding Holly and said
217
00:13:28.539 --> 00:13:31.419
he would return her if Cederholm met him and agreed
218
00:13:31.460 --> 00:13:36.019
to be filmed performing sex acts. Detectives accompanied her to
219
00:13:36.059 --> 00:13:39.379
the arranged meeting place at Penn Station, but of course
220
00:13:39.419 --> 00:13:42.639
he never appeared. Cederholm said she did not truly believe
221
00:13:42.700 --> 00:13:45.450
the man had Holly. By that point, she had already
222
00:13:45.490 --> 00:13:49.240
feared that her daughter was dead. No verified sighting of
223
00:13:49.279 --> 00:13:54.700
Holly ever followed after that. The next incident connected to
224
00:13:54.759 --> 00:13:57.490
Rand is one of the most bizarre things I've ever heard.
225
00:13:58.370 --> 00:14:01.250
This took place in 1983, and Andre Rand was working
226
00:14:01.330 --> 00:14:04.350
as a school bus driver at the time, so special
227
00:14:04.370 --> 00:14:06.429
shout out to the schools of Staten Island for vetting
228
00:14:06.470 --> 00:14:13.029
who they were allowing around children, like, seriously. On January 9, 1983,
229
00:14:13.029 --> 00:14:15.559
he pulled up to the Staten Island YMCA in his
230
00:14:15.600 --> 00:14:19.059
school bus and convinced 11 kids to get on, apparently
231
00:14:19.100 --> 00:14:20.720
telling them he was going to take them to a park.
232
00:14:21.919 --> 00:14:25.080
To be clear, this was not a YMCA-authorized trip, nor
233
00:14:25.120 --> 00:14:28.519
was it authorized by the children's parents. Rand even took
234
00:14:28.620 --> 00:14:32.370
the 11 children and he crossed state lines into New Jersey.
235
00:14:33.269 --> 00:14:35.850
He first stopped at a White Castle in Elizabeth, where
236
00:14:35.889 --> 00:14:39.149
he bought them hamburgers. From there, he continued north to
237
00:14:39.190 --> 00:14:43.309
Newark International Airport. This was years before the strict airport
238
00:14:43.330 --> 00:14:46.549
security we're familiar with today, and people could just enter
239
00:14:46.610 --> 00:14:50.350
the terminal simply to watch planes arrive and depart. Rand
240
00:14:50.409 --> 00:14:52.950
brought the children inside and spent part of the day
241
00:14:53.029 --> 00:14:57.730
with them watching the airplanes. The entire trip lasted approximately
242
00:14:57.850 --> 00:15:00.470
five hours, and during that time the children's parents had
243
00:15:00.690 --> 00:15:04.340
no idea where they were. He then, without incident, just
244
00:15:04.580 --> 00:15:08.000
drove back to the YMCA where he was promptly arrested.
245
00:15:09.019 --> 00:15:11.980
What's crazy is that despite everything we know about Rand,
246
00:15:12.480 --> 00:15:15.759
none of the kids on this trip reported any inappropriate behavior,
247
00:15:15.940 --> 00:15:21.370
you know, besides him kidnapping them. However, to correct my
248
00:15:21.419 --> 00:15:25.850
own language, Rand was charged with unlawful imprisonment rather than kidnapping.
249
00:15:26.649 --> 00:15:30.769
Under New York law, unlawful imprisonment generally involves restraining someone
250
00:15:30.809 --> 00:15:35.470
without consent and without legal authority, while kidnapping requires additional
251
00:15:35.529 --> 00:15:39.029
elements that make it a more serious offense. Because the
252
00:15:39.070 --> 00:15:42.850
children were returned and none reported being harmed, the case
253
00:15:42.929 --> 00:15:47.279
resulted in a comparatively short sentence. Rand was convicted in
254
00:15:47.320 --> 00:15:51.460
March of 83 and sentenced to just 10 months in jail.
255
00:15:52.679 --> 00:15:55.539
That's just wild to me. He took these kids across
256
00:15:55.759 --> 00:16:00.460
state lines. Just crazy. And even though this seems more
257
00:16:00.500 --> 00:16:03.210
benign in the grand scheme of his bigger alleged crimes,
258
00:16:03.409 --> 00:16:07.009
this is still pretty terrifying. because Rand demonstrated that he
259
00:16:07.049 --> 00:16:10.470
could approach a group of children, gain their cooperation, and
260
00:16:10.509 --> 00:16:14.710
transport them a significant distance without immediately raising enough alarm
261
00:16:14.750 --> 00:16:18.149
to stop him. He did not need to use visible force.
262
00:16:18.610 --> 00:16:21.929
Whatever explanation he gave, the children trusted him, or at
263
00:16:21.980 --> 00:16:26.000
least believed he had the authority to take them. Just
264
00:16:26.000 --> 00:16:28.620
12 days after Rand got out of jail for the
265
00:16:28.740 --> 00:16:33.519
YMCA incident, another young child in Staten Island would go missing.
266
00:16:35.570 --> 00:16:38.769
10-year-old Thais Jackson was living with her mother Gwendolyn and
267
00:16:38.809 --> 00:16:42.330
three siblings in the Mariner's Harbor Motel on Forest Avenue.
268
00:16:43.190 --> 00:16:45.830
The family had been staying there temporarily after a fire
269
00:16:45.870 --> 00:16:48.710
destroyed their apartment, and once they got on their feet,
270
00:16:48.809 --> 00:16:53.029
they were planning to move south. Thais had several serious
271
00:16:53.100 --> 00:16:58.179
health problems, including diabetes, asthma, high blood pressure, and Bright's disease,
272
00:16:58.279 --> 00:17:02.460
a kidney condition that required medication and ongoing treatment. On
273
00:17:02.500 --> 00:17:06.869
the afternoon of August 14, 1983, Thais' mother was asleep
274
00:17:06.950 --> 00:17:09.589
when another person staying at the motel asked her to
275
00:17:09.630 --> 00:17:13.390
go to the Crown Supermarket in the 900 block of
276
00:17:13.450 --> 00:17:18.599
Richmond Avenue and buy a package of chicken wings. Thais
277
00:17:18.660 --> 00:17:22.839
left at around 1.30 that afternoon. Some later missing persons
278
00:17:22.880 --> 00:17:26.059
listings say she was last seen at the supermarket, but
279
00:17:26.099 --> 00:17:29.079
her family said the last confirmed sighting was when she
280
00:17:29.140 --> 00:17:32.349
left the motel on her way there. It's not clear
281
00:17:32.390 --> 00:17:36.299
whether anyone ever verified she reached the store. When Gwendolyn
282
00:17:36.339 --> 00:17:39.420
woke at around 4.30 p.m., she learned that Thais had
283
00:17:39.440 --> 00:17:42.960
been gone for approximately three hours, and she immediately contacted police.
284
00:17:43.720 --> 00:17:46.619
Thais was familiar with the neighborhood, and she sometimes ran
285
00:17:46.720 --> 00:17:49.619
errands alone, although she also went with her sister or friends.
286
00:17:50.299 --> 00:17:52.599
Her mother described her as streetwise and said she was
287
00:17:52.759 --> 00:17:57.119
specifically warned about strangers. The fact that Thais had disappeared
288
00:17:57.160 --> 00:17:59.920
without the medication she needed only added to the urgency
289
00:17:59.960 --> 00:18:03.089
of finding her. When she was last seen, Thais was
290
00:18:03.119 --> 00:18:05.920
wearing a dark blue ski jacket with white trim a
291
00:18:05.960 --> 00:18:09.039
white ruffled shirt, blue jeans, and blue plastic mesh shoes.
292
00:18:09.660 --> 00:18:11.759
She had two purple combs in her hair and was
293
00:18:11.799 --> 00:18:14.430
wearing a gold necklace with a butterfly charm and a
294
00:18:14.490 --> 00:18:19.230
silver bangle bracelet. She also had several distinguishing features, including
295
00:18:19.269 --> 00:18:22.210
a mole on her left cheek, burn scars on her
296
00:18:22.250 --> 00:18:25.519
left wrist and elbow, and a left eye that turned inward.
297
00:18:26.559 --> 00:18:30.279
Thais' mother and uncle were questioned and they passed polygraph exams,
298
00:18:30.660 --> 00:18:32.920
and neither was considered a suspect. Those were kind of
299
00:18:32.940 --> 00:18:36.880
the only adults around. Andre Rand eventually became the primary
300
00:18:36.920 --> 00:18:41.200
suspect in Thais' disappearance for several reasons. She vanished only
301
00:18:41.200 --> 00:18:44.420
12 days after his release from jail for the YMCA incident.
302
00:18:45.089 --> 00:18:48.509
Rand was also known to camp inside Baron Hirsch Cemetery,
303
00:18:48.589 --> 00:18:50.710
which was less than half a mile from the motel
304
00:18:50.750 --> 00:18:53.950
where Thais and her family were staying. But most troubling,
305
00:18:54.029 --> 00:18:57.089
Gwendolyn later said that before her daughter had disappeared, she
306
00:18:57.130 --> 00:19:00.259
had noticed a man matching Rand's description hanging around the
307
00:19:00.319 --> 00:19:04.950
motel parking lot. Rand was questioned about Thais, but investigators
308
00:19:05.009 --> 00:19:08.170
did not develop enough evidence to charge him. He is
309
00:19:08.250 --> 00:19:11.670
still considered the prime suspect in her case, and she's
310
00:19:11.690 --> 00:19:16.000
never been found. The next disappearance potentially connected to Andre
311
00:19:16.079 --> 00:19:20.700
Rand was 22-year-old Henry Gaforio, who went by Hank. Hank
312
00:19:20.720 --> 00:19:24.380
was born December 7, 1961, and lived with his parents
313
00:19:24.440 --> 00:19:28.049
and three brothers on Hubberton Avenue in Port Richmond. His
314
00:19:28.089 --> 00:19:31.059
family described him as shy and very quiet. and he
315
00:19:31.119 --> 00:19:36.349
also had an intellectual disability. On Friday, June 8, 1984,
316
00:19:36.349 --> 00:19:39.529
Hank went out drinking in his neighborhood. This wasn't unusual
317
00:19:39.549 --> 00:19:41.869
for him, although relatives said he generally went out with
318
00:19:41.910 --> 00:19:46.109
his two older brothers. That night, however, he was apparently alone.
319
00:19:47.009 --> 00:19:49.170
He first stopped at a bar called Mugs Away, where
320
00:19:49.190 --> 00:19:52.000
the bartender refused to drink. to serve him. The available
321
00:19:52.019 --> 00:19:54.400
accounts don't explain whether he was turned away because he
322
00:19:54.440 --> 00:19:57.440
had already been drinking and appeared intoxicated, or if it
323
00:19:57.480 --> 00:20:00.680
was for some other reason. From there, Hank went to
324
00:20:00.720 --> 00:20:04.240
the Spa Lounge in Port Richmond. He remained there until
325
00:20:04.279 --> 00:20:07.369
the bar closed at approximately 4 o'clock on a Saturday morning,
326
00:20:07.380 --> 00:20:10.849
June 9th. Some accounts say Hank stopped at a diner
327
00:20:10.930 --> 00:20:14.990
or coffee shop afterward. A newspaper story published later that
328
00:20:15.029 --> 00:20:18.710
year was even headlined, SI man didn't linger over his
329
00:20:18.759 --> 00:20:22.920
cup of coffee. More recent summaries generally list the spa
330
00:20:22.980 --> 00:20:26.740
lounge as his last confirmed location, however, so it's difficult
331
00:20:26.779 --> 00:20:30.240
to say whether Hank was really there or if the
332
00:20:30.289 --> 00:20:35.009
diner sighting was independently verified. Either way, Hank never returned
333
00:20:35.029 --> 00:20:38.200
to his family's home. By 7 o'clock that evening, about
334
00:20:38.200 --> 00:20:40.380
15 hours after he was last known to be in
335
00:20:40.420 --> 00:20:44.940
Port Richmond, he had been reported missing. The possible connection
336
00:20:44.960 --> 00:20:47.559
to Andre Rand would come later. Hank lived in the
337
00:20:47.559 --> 00:20:50.940
90 block of Hepperton Avenue, the same block where Rand
338
00:20:50.980 --> 00:20:53.839
had lived just around the corner from Holly Ann Hughes'
339
00:20:53.880 --> 00:20:58.700
former home. Some later accounts, including those surrounding the documentary Cropsey,
340
00:20:58.869 --> 00:21:02.210
claim Hank was seen with Rand at a diner during
341
00:21:02.230 --> 00:21:05.819
the early morning hours of June 9th. That allegation has
342
00:21:05.880 --> 00:21:09.269
been repeated often, but it doesn't appear in the basic
343
00:21:09.400 --> 00:21:13.529
publicity or primary sources, so I can't say for sure.
344
00:21:13.710 --> 00:21:16.910
The spa lounge is where he was definitively last seen.
345
00:21:18.029 --> 00:21:22.069
There was one other strange overlap. When Holly Hughes disappeared
346
00:21:22.289 --> 00:21:26.400
in 1981, Hank was apparently seen standing behind a reporter
347
00:21:26.440 --> 00:21:30.900
during television coverage on the case. Some investigators interviewed years
348
00:21:30.940 --> 00:21:34.000
later considered that noteworthy, but Hank lived around the corner
349
00:21:34.019 --> 00:21:37.339
from Holly's family, and plenty of neighborhood residents had gathered
350
00:21:37.359 --> 00:21:41.920
while reporters covered her disappearance. So, whether that's really connected
351
00:21:41.980 --> 00:21:44.940
or related or not, it's just kind of eerie. But
352
00:21:44.980 --> 00:21:48.160
something that does stand out about Hank's disappearance is that
353
00:21:48.240 --> 00:21:52.180
it was another vulnerable person from Rand's immediate orbit who
354
00:21:52.220 --> 00:21:56.680
vanished without leaving behind any clear explanation. Rand's criminal history
355
00:21:56.720 --> 00:22:00.559
largely involved children,
but some of the other people associated
356
00:22:00.579 --> 00:22:04.480
with him had intellectual or developmental disabilities as well. Hank
357
00:22:04.599 --> 00:22:07.019
also lived close enough to Rand that the two men
358
00:22:07.039 --> 00:22:09.720
may have known one another simply from just interacting in
359
00:22:09.740 --> 00:22:11.710
the neighborhood. But I do want to be clear that
360
00:22:11.730 --> 00:22:14.970
there's no physical evidence out there connecting Andre Rand to
361
00:22:15.029 --> 00:22:19.730
Hank's disappearance. Even the reported diner sighting leaves important questions unanswered,
362
00:22:20.089 --> 00:22:23.039
like who saw them? How well did this witness know
363
00:22:23.160 --> 00:22:27.049
either man? And when was this found out? Right now,
364
00:22:27.069 --> 00:22:30.630
Hank's case remains classified as an endangered missing persons case
365
00:22:30.690 --> 00:22:35.619
with foul play suspected. If you're thinking to yourself, Megan,
366
00:22:35.740 --> 00:22:37.880
how many more of these cases are you going to
367
00:22:37.920 --> 00:22:40.559
tell me about where Andre Rand is in close proximity
368
00:22:40.940 --> 00:22:44.140
but is never charged? Well, this next case would be
369
00:22:44.240 --> 00:22:47.930
his undoing, but tragically, it would take another child dying
370
00:22:48.029 --> 00:23:01.759
before this dangerous predator was taken off the streets. The
371
00:23:01.799 --> 00:23:04.380
case that finally led to Andre Rand's arrest began on
372
00:23:04.440 --> 00:23:09.140
July 9, 1987, when 12-year-old Jennifer Schweiger went out for
373
00:23:09.180 --> 00:23:13.380
a walk near her family's home in Westerly. Jennifer had
374
00:23:13.420 --> 00:23:16.940
Down syndrome. She liked walking through the neighborhood, and people
375
00:23:16.980 --> 00:23:19.480
in the area knew her, so there was nothing alarming
376
00:23:19.519 --> 00:23:22.849
about her leaving the house that day. The concern came
377
00:23:22.910 --> 00:23:26.809
when she didn't return. As police worked to figure out
378
00:23:26.849 --> 00:23:30.089
where Jennifer had gone, witnesses began reporting that they had
379
00:23:30.150 --> 00:23:33.269
seen her with a man. He was a middle-aged man
380
00:23:33.450 --> 00:23:36.650
walking beside a green women's bicycle with a basket in
381
00:23:36.670 --> 00:23:40.680
the front. Some of the witnesses remembered Jennifer holding his hand.
382
00:23:41.140 --> 00:23:43.319
She wasn't crying or trying to get away from him.
383
00:23:43.500 --> 00:23:45.359
From what they could see, she appeared to be comfortable
384
00:23:45.400 --> 00:23:48.480
with him. This, of course, does not mean that Jennifer
385
00:23:48.519 --> 00:23:50.420
knew him well. It may have only meant that the
386
00:23:50.460 --> 00:23:55.410
man had convinced her he was safe. Retired detective Robert
387
00:23:55.470 --> 00:23:58.430
Jensen later said the description of the bicycle made him
388
00:23:58.470 --> 00:24:02.049
think of Andre Rand. Jensen knew Rand from an earlier
389
00:24:02.109 --> 00:24:04.809
case and remembered seeing him outside a shop right about
390
00:24:04.849 --> 00:24:08.470
a week before Jennifer disappeared. Rand had left the store
391
00:24:08.630 --> 00:24:12.910
on a green women's bicycle with a basket. Police brought
392
00:24:12.970 --> 00:24:15.869
Rand in for questioning, but Jennifer was still missing and
393
00:24:15.890 --> 00:24:18.569
they didn't have enough evidence to keep him in custody.
394
00:24:19.609 --> 00:24:22.230
At this point, Rand had spent several years moving around
395
00:24:22.329 --> 00:24:25.230
Staten Island. Sometimes, of course, he stayed, like I said,
396
00:24:25.259 --> 00:24:27.730
in shelters. Other times he'd be in abandoned buildings or
397
00:24:27.759 --> 00:24:31.130
he'd set up makeshift camps in the woods. One of
398
00:24:31.190 --> 00:24:34.289
those camps was on the ground of Willowbrook in the woods.
399
00:24:35.849 --> 00:24:38.890
Rand knew the property extremely well. He had worked at
400
00:24:38.930 --> 00:24:42.049
Willowbrook for years earlier, and he had of course continued
401
00:24:42.109 --> 00:24:45.950
returning to the grounds long after his employment ended. Even
402
00:24:46.069 --> 00:24:49.930
as the institution closed and the buildings were abandoned, Rand
403
00:24:49.970 --> 00:24:52.130
still spent time there and treated parts of the property
404
00:24:52.170 --> 00:24:56.029
almost like they belonged to him. The search focused heavily
405
00:24:56.369 --> 00:25:00.210
on the grounds of Willowbrook. which as we know is
406
00:25:00.339 --> 00:25:02.640
not an easy place to search because of all of
407
00:25:02.720 --> 00:25:06.740
the logistics and the setting there. People from across Staten
408
00:25:06.799 --> 00:25:10.579
Island joined the effort to find Jennifer. A woman named
409
00:25:10.779 --> 00:25:13.920
Donna who lived in the area helped form a volunteer
410
00:25:13.960 --> 00:25:17.930
group called Friends of Jennifer. The volunteers searched the woods,
411
00:25:18.089 --> 00:25:21.769
inside the empty buildings, and through sections of the tunnel system.
412
00:25:23.309 --> 00:25:27.170
According to Donna, they also found former Willowbrook residents living
413
00:25:27.250 --> 00:25:30.480
on the property. These were people who had once been
414
00:25:30.500 --> 00:25:34.660
housed inside the institution and had returned after leaving. Some
415
00:25:34.680 --> 00:25:37.619
were staying in the abandoned buildings or living in shelters
416
00:25:37.720 --> 00:25:43.410
they had built on the grounds. While volunteers searched, investigators
417
00:25:43.509 --> 00:25:48.730
continued building their case against Rand. The bicycle description fit him.
418
00:25:49.170 --> 00:25:52.049
Witnesses had seen Jennifer with a man that they believed
419
00:25:52.089 --> 00:25:54.609
was him, and they had been heading towards the
same
420
00:25:54.670 --> 00:25:57.740
property where he was known to camp. And of course,
421
00:25:57.759 --> 00:26:01.680
there was also his history. On August 4th, almost four
422
00:26:01.720 --> 00:26:05.519
weeks after Jennifer disappeared, Rand was arrested and charged with
423
00:26:05.579 --> 00:26:08.940
kidnapping her. He was held without bail and sent to
424
00:26:08.960 --> 00:26:12.329
the psychiatric unit at Kings County Hospital so doctors could
425
00:26:12.349 --> 00:26:16.359
determine whether he was competent to stand trial. The images
426
00:26:16.420 --> 00:26:18.920
of Rand after his arrest were shown all over the news.
427
00:26:19.000 --> 00:26:23.240
He was dirty and disheveled. He drooled, stumbled, and stared
428
00:26:23.289 --> 00:26:25.150
towards the cameras in a way that made him appear
429
00:26:25.230 --> 00:26:29.950
completely detached from whatever was happening around him. Some investigators
430
00:26:30.009 --> 00:26:34.509
believed he was deliberately exaggerating his behavior to appear mentally ill.
431
00:26:35.529 --> 00:26:39.109
Those images had an immediate effect on the case. Rand
432
00:26:39.130 --> 00:26:41.990
already had a frightening history, and now Staten Island was
433
00:26:42.049 --> 00:26:45.900
watching footage of this strange-looking man who lived in the
434
00:26:45.960 --> 00:26:49.259
woods being led into court for kidnapping a vulnerable child.
435
00:26:50.319 --> 00:26:53.960
Before Jennifer had even been found, many people had already
436
00:26:54.019 --> 00:26:56.559
decided they were looking at the person who killed her.
437
00:26:57.660 --> 00:27:01.049
But Jennifer was still out there somewhere. Among the people
438
00:27:01.089 --> 00:27:04.789
searching Willowbrook were retired New York City firefighter George Kramer
439
00:27:04.829 --> 00:27:08.250
and his wife. During one of their searches, George noticed
440
00:27:08.269 --> 00:27:11.250
something unusual on the ground. There was a mound of
441
00:27:11.329 --> 00:27:15.289
dirt with small pieces or balls of clay scattered around it,
442
00:27:15.450 --> 00:27:18.750
and that just didn't look right to him. Before George
443
00:27:18.789 --> 00:27:22.230
could examine it more closely, security officers reportedly made him
444
00:27:22.269 --> 00:27:25.210
and his wife leave the property. But he kept thinking
445
00:27:25.269 --> 00:27:29.670
about the mound, and he eventually returned. This time, George
446
00:27:29.769 --> 00:27:33.490
pushed a stick into the soil and struck something beneath
447
00:27:33.579 --> 00:27:37.000
what felt like a plastic bag. He brought what he
448
00:27:37.099 --> 00:27:40.660
had found to the attention of the Friends of Jennifer volunteers,
449
00:27:41.140 --> 00:27:45.079
and the group went back to the location. They carefully
450
00:27:45.160 --> 00:27:48.319
began removing some of the dirt, and it did not
451
00:27:48.359 --> 00:27:51.029
take long before they saw a part of a small
452
00:27:51.089 --> 00:27:57.369
hand and a foot. Police were called, and on August 12th,
453
00:27:57.369 --> 00:28:02.230
35 days after Jennifer disappeared, her body was removed from
454
00:28:02.289 --> 00:28:06.099
a shallow grave. She had been buried naked on the
455
00:28:06.180 --> 00:28:11.859
former Willowbrook property, approximately 150 yards from the campsite Rand
456
00:28:11.980 --> 00:28:15.670
had been using. It's hard to understand how close Jennifer
457
00:28:15.730 --> 00:28:18.710
was to the people looking for her. Volunteers and police
458
00:28:18.730 --> 00:28:21.369
had spent more than a month searching Willowbrook, and the
459
00:28:21.470 --> 00:28:24.710
general area around the grave had been searched before, but
460
00:28:24.829 --> 00:28:28.220
nobody saw her until George noticed that something about the
461
00:28:28.240 --> 00:28:32.019
ground looked different. Jennifer's body had been underground for more
462
00:28:32.059 --> 00:28:35.609
than a month during the summer. Because of decomposition, the
463
00:28:35.650 --> 00:28:39.170
medical examiner could not determine exactly how she died. There
464
00:28:39.190 --> 00:28:42.109
was no clear evidence that she'd been strangled, stabbed, or shot,
465
00:28:42.430 --> 00:28:46.319
but investigators also did not find forensic evidence directly connecting
466
00:28:46.359 --> 00:28:49.119
Rand to her body or to the act of burying her.
467
00:28:50.200 --> 00:28:55.599
After the discovery, prosecutors added a murder charge. Rand denied
468
00:28:55.700 --> 00:28:59.279
kidnapping or killing Jennifer. At first, he reported claims that
469
00:28:59.339 --> 00:29:01.960
he'd never met her. That became a difficult story to
470
00:29:02.000 --> 00:29:05.119
maintain because several people had seen them together. By the
471
00:29:05.140 --> 00:29:07.309
time the case went to trial, the defense acknowledged that
472
00:29:07.329 --> 00:29:10.410
Rand had encountered Jennifer, but argued that this did not
473
00:29:10.470 --> 00:29:14.130
prove he took her against her will. The trial began
474
00:29:14.329 --> 00:29:17.329
in 1988 and became one of the largest criminal cases
475
00:29:17.349 --> 00:29:22.549
Staten Island had ever handled. The evidence against Rand was circumstantial.
476
00:29:24.490 --> 00:29:27.380
There was no confession, no one had seen him physically
477
00:29:27.430 --> 00:29:30.220
force Jennifer to go anywhere, and no one witnessed her murder.
478
00:29:31.119 --> 00:29:34.339
What prosecutors had were people who saw Jennifer with him
479
00:29:34.440 --> 00:29:38.089
and the location where she was found. The witnesses placed
480
00:29:38.130 --> 00:29:40.500
Jennifer with Rand at different points as well. the two
481
00:29:40.599 --> 00:29:44.039
moved into the direction of willowbrook some saw them holding
482
00:29:44.079 --> 00:29:47.559
hands the description of the green bicycle matched the one
483
00:29:47.599 --> 00:29:51.180
rand had recently
been seen using jennifer was then found
484
00:29:51.240 --> 00:29:53.960
dead near his campsite on a property he knew extremely
485
00:29:54.039 --> 00:29:57.789
well of course the defense challenged all of this By
486
00:29:57.829 --> 00:29:59.789
the time of the trial, Rand's face had been shown
487
00:29:59.849 --> 00:30:03.359
repeatedly in newspapers, on TV, and his attorneys argued that
488
00:30:03.390 --> 00:30:06.859
the attention surrounding the case could have influenced what witnesses remembered.
489
00:30:07.660 --> 00:30:10.019
Rand had also become the kind of suspect people were
490
00:30:10.059 --> 00:30:13.539
already prepared to believe the worst about. He lived outside,
491
00:30:13.619 --> 00:30:15.940
he had a criminal record, and he looked frightening in
492
00:30:15.960 --> 00:30:20.549
the footage shown after his arrest. The defense also focused
493
00:30:20.609 --> 00:30:24.069
on everything the physical evidence could not prove. The medical
494
00:30:24.130 --> 00:30:27.599
examiner could not say how Jennifer died. Nothing found on
495
00:30:27.640 --> 00:30:30.460
her body identified Rand as the person who killed or
496
00:30:30.500 --> 00:30:33.859
buried her. Even if the jury believed he had walked
497
00:30:33.880 --> 00:30:36.720
with Jennifer, his attorneys argued that walking with her was
498
00:30:36.779 --> 00:30:40.480
not the same thing as kidnapping her. Prosecutors argued that
499
00:30:40.519 --> 00:30:42.920
Jennifer did not have to scream or fight for this
500
00:30:42.980 --> 00:30:46.029
to be an abduction. A child can be kidnapped through
501
00:30:46.089 --> 00:30:50.029
trust or deception. The fact that Jennifer appeared comfortable holding
502
00:30:50.089 --> 00:30:52.630
Rand's hand did not mean she understood where he was
503
00:30:52.670 --> 00:30:55.569
taking her or that she had agreed to remain there
504
00:30:55.589 --> 00:30:59.849
with him. The way New York's kidnapping law worked also mattered.
505
00:31:00.230 --> 00:31:03.509
Prosecutors did not have to prove exactly how Jennifer died
506
00:31:03.529 --> 00:31:07.490
to obtain a conviction for first-degree kidnapping. If the jury
507
00:31:07.549 --> 00:31:10.349
believed Rand abducted her and that she died before she
508
00:31:10.369 --> 00:31:14.130
could be safely returned, that was enough. It was separate
509
00:31:14.150 --> 00:31:18.299
from deciding whether the evidence proved that Rand intentionally murdered her.
510
00:31:20.259 --> 00:31:24.099
The jury ultimately found Andre Rand guilty of kidnapping Jennifer
511
00:31:24.140 --> 00:31:28.660
Schweiger in the first degree. They could not agree on
512
00:31:28.680 --> 00:31:32.200
the murder charge. That meant Rand was legally responsible for
513
00:31:32.259 --> 00:31:34.759
taking Jennifer and for the fact that she died during
514
00:31:34.799 --> 00:31:38.240
the abduction, but he was never convicted of deliberately killing her.
515
00:31:39.099 --> 00:31:41.339
Without a
known cause of death or physical evidence showing
516
00:31:41.359 --> 00:31:44.039
what happened at Willowbrook, some members of the jury were
517
00:31:44.079 --> 00:31:47.740
not willing to go that far. Rand was sentenced to
518
00:31:47.740 --> 00:31:51.900
25 years to life in prison. Jennifer was buried on
519
00:31:52.000 --> 00:31:56.299
August 17, 1987. At her funeral, people remembered her as
520
00:31:56.359 --> 00:31:58.960
an affectionate child who tried to comfort others when she
521
00:31:59.019 --> 00:32:02.380
saw they were upset. Her disappearance had brought hundreds of
522
00:32:02.440 --> 00:32:05.420
people together to search for her, and the group created
523
00:32:05.480 --> 00:32:08.259
in her name did not stop working after her funeral.
524
00:32:09.079 --> 00:32:12.740
Friends of Jennifer continued returning to Willowbrook grounds to look
525
00:32:12.799 --> 00:32:16.759
for the other missing children and adults whose cases had
526
00:32:16.799 --> 00:32:21.329
become connected to RAND. And prosecutors were also not done
527
00:32:21.349 --> 00:32:24.450
with Andre Rand. They wanted to take another look at
528
00:32:24.470 --> 00:32:28.009
the case of Holly Ann Hughes. For years, the evidence
529
00:32:28.069 --> 00:32:32.549
against Rand and Holly's disappearance had gone nowhere. That changed
530
00:32:32.650 --> 00:32:35.730
while he was serving his sentence for kidnapping Jennifer Schweiger.
531
00:32:36.690 --> 00:32:40.819
Investigators began taking another look at Staten Island's older missing
532
00:32:40.880 --> 00:32:44.220
child cases and speaking with people who had known Rand
533
00:32:44.259 --> 00:32:48.769
in prison. Several corrections officers and inmates claimed that Rand
534
00:32:48.809 --> 00:32:53.210
had made statements about abducting children. One inmate said Rand
535
00:32:53.289 --> 00:32:57.329
compared himself to Ted Bundy, allegedly telling him, quote, Bundy's
536
00:32:57.390 --> 00:33:02.589
thing was women. My thing is kids. Another claimed Rand
537
00:33:02.630 --> 00:33:08.650
had spoken specifically about Holly. The renewed investigation also brought
538
00:33:08.670 --> 00:33:13.069
attention back to evidence that had existed since 1981. Rand's
539
00:33:13.250 --> 00:33:16.069
aunt lived at the same Port Richmond apartment building as
540
00:33:16.130 --> 00:33:19.309
Holly and her family, and Rand was reportedly there on
541
00:33:19.349 --> 00:33:23.630
the day Holly disappeared. Witnesses remembered seeing his green Volkswagen
542
00:33:23.690 --> 00:33:27.349
repeatedly circling the area around the deli. Others said they
543
00:33:27.390 --> 00:33:30.970
saw Holly either inside the car or with Rand that evening.
544
00:33:31.690 --> 00:33:33.809
Of course, Rand himself even admitted that he had been
545
00:33:33.849 --> 00:33:36.690
with Holly that day. He claimed they played hide-and-seek and
546
00:33:36.710 --> 00:33:38.710
that he gave her money to buy soap because she
547
00:33:38.750 --> 00:33:42.490
was dirty, but insisted he left her there before she disappeared.
548
00:33:43.589 --> 00:33:47.089
Holly's mother also identified Rand's voice as the voice of
549
00:33:47.130 --> 00:33:49.769
the man who later called her claiming to have Holly
550
00:33:50.369 --> 00:33:53.299
and demanding that she perform sexual acts on camera in
551
00:33:53.359 --> 00:33:59.000
exchange for her daughter's return. In 2001, 20 years after
552
00:33:59.039 --> 00:34:02.359
Holly vanished, a Staten Island grand jury indicted Rand for
553
00:34:02.400 --> 00:34:07.450
first-degree kidnapping. Holly had never been found, and prosecutors apparently
554
00:34:07.509 --> 00:34:10.489
did not believe that they could prove exactly what happened
555
00:34:10.510 --> 00:34:13.030
to her after she disappeared so Rand was not charged
556
00:34:13.070 --> 00:34:17.510
with murder. They instead argued that the witness accounts Rand's
557
00:34:17.710 --> 00:34:21.110
own admission that he had interacted with Holly, his connection
558
00:34:21.150 --> 00:34:24.230
to her apartment building, and the statements he allegedly made
559
00:34:24.269 --> 00:34:26.730
in prison were enough to show that he had abducted her.
560
00:34:27.650 --> 00:34:31.050
New York has no statute of limitations for first-degree kidnapping,
561
00:34:31.369 --> 00:34:35.389
which allowed prosecutors to bring the case forward two decades later.
562
00:34:35.880 --> 00:34:41.340
and Rand was finally on trial in 2004. On October 19, 2004,
563
00:34:41.340 --> 00:34:46.440
the jury found Rand guilty of first-degree kidnapping. He was
564
00:34:46.500 --> 00:34:50.300
sentenced to another 25 years to life to be served
565
00:34:50.420 --> 00:34:55.570
consecutively to his sentence for kidnapping Jennifer. Rand is eligible
566
00:34:55.639 --> 00:34:59.550
for parole in 2037. At that point, he will be
567
00:34:59.550 --> 00:35:12.880
92 years old if he is still alive. Even among
568
00:35:12.940 --> 00:35:16.880
people who believe Andre Rand was responsible for Jennifer Schweiger's
569
00:35:16.960 --> 00:35:20.659
death and Holly Ann Hughes' disappearance, there's always been doubt
570
00:35:20.679 --> 00:35:23.630
that he was responsible for every case attached to his name.
571
00:35:24.429 --> 00:35:28.289
Rand was mentally ill, lived an extremely disorganized life, and
572
00:35:28.349 --> 00:35:31.849
often behaved in ways that were erratic and difficult to understand.
573
00:35:32.690 --> 00:35:35.389
Although he was considered competent to stand trial, that only
574
00:35:35.429 --> 00:35:37.929
meant he understood the proceedings and could assist in his
575
00:35:37.969 --> 00:35:41.289
own defense. It did not mean he was functioning normally.
576
00:35:42.150 --> 00:35:44.250
Some people have questioned whether a man who struggled to
577
00:35:44.289 --> 00:35:47.030
manage his own life could have abducted and murdered multiple
578
00:35:47.070 --> 00:35:50.929
people over a period of 15 years without leaving clear
579
00:35:51.130 --> 00:35:55.510
evidence behind. That has led to speculation that Rand may
580
00:35:55.530 --> 00:35:58.320
have had help or that an entirely separate predator was
581
00:35:58.429 --> 00:36:02.219
operating on Staten Island during the same years. Once Rand
582
00:36:02.260 --> 00:36:05.659
became the face of the Jennifer Schweiger case, he also
583
00:36:05.679 --> 00:36:10.070
became Staten Island's real-life version of Cropsey. From that point forward,
584
00:36:10.110 --> 00:36:13.989
almost any unexplained disappearance involving a child or a person
585
00:36:14.030 --> 00:36:17.050
with an intellectual disability seemed to circle back to him.
586
00:36:18.110 --> 00:36:21.460
Rand was certainly dangerous, and his history gave police legitimate
587
00:36:21.500 --> 00:36:25.559
reasons to investigate him. But being a believable suspect is
588
00:36:25.639 --> 00:36:28.400
not the same thing as being responsible for every missing
589
00:36:28.440 --> 00:36:32.489
person whose case had been placed beneath his name. Even
590
00:36:32.590 --> 00:36:36.230
if one of those connections was wrong, it means another
591
00:36:36.309 --> 00:36:39.500
person had to have committed a murder or abduction and
592
00:36:39.539 --> 00:36:43.699
was never seriously pursued because everyone was looking at Andre Rand.
593
00:36:44.699 --> 00:36:48.159
So coming back full circle here, let's revisit Ethel Atwell
594
00:36:48.260 --> 00:36:51.110
and Shin Lee and the arguments for and against Andre
595
00:36:51.210 --> 00:36:56.250
Rand being responsible. The strongest argument for connecting Andre Rand
596
00:36:56.289 --> 00:36:59.659
to Shin Lee and Ethel Atwell is the location. Both
597
00:36:59.760 --> 00:37:02.969
women worked at Willowbrook, and both disappeared from its grounds
598
00:37:03.239 --> 00:37:07.710
in 1978. Rand had worked there years earlier and knew
599
00:37:07.750 --> 00:37:11.409
the enormous property, including the wooded areas surrounding the buildings.
600
00:37:12.449 --> 00:37:15.139
Shin's body was later found buried in a shallow grave
601
00:37:15.260 --> 00:37:18.239
on those grounds, which is especially hard to ignore knowing
602
00:37:18.280 --> 00:37:20.739
that Jennifer Schweiger would be found in a shallow grave
603
00:37:20.760 --> 00:37:25.460
there nine years later, not far from Rand's campsite. Ethel
604
00:37:25.480 --> 00:37:28.349
disappeared only a few months after Shin was killed, and
605
00:37:28.389 --> 00:37:31.329
the location of her keys suggested that whoever attacked her
606
00:37:31.349 --> 00:37:34.909
may have taken her into those same woods. But there
607
00:37:34.969 --> 00:37:36.949
are a lot of things that do not point to
608
00:37:37.030 --> 00:37:40.579
Rand as well. Remember how in prison he bragged that
609
00:37:40.619 --> 00:37:44.320
he was like Ted Bundy except with kids? Well, Ethel
610
00:37:44.420 --> 00:37:46.579
Atwell
and Shin Lee were both in their 40s, so
611
00:37:46.840 --> 00:37:50.699
that doesn't really align. With Ethel's case, there is a
612
00:37:50.739 --> 00:37:53.519
composite sketch of a man seen around the parking lot
613
00:37:53.559 --> 00:37:56.269
that morning by another employee. And some people compare it
614
00:37:56.289 --> 00:37:59.150
to Rand and see a resemblance. I'll be honest, I
615
00:37:59.210 --> 00:38:01.329
personally don't, and I don't put a lot of stock
616
00:38:01.369 --> 00:38:04.590
in the composite because whoever it was, they could barely
617
00:38:04.630 --> 00:38:08.400
see that person. In Ethel's case, one of the most
618
00:38:08.539 --> 00:38:11.760
important clues may be what her co-workers heard her say.
619
00:38:12.860 --> 00:38:17.170
After a man repeatedly told her, come on, Ethel answered, no,
620
00:38:17.429 --> 00:38:21.800
you'll beat me, before screaming. That could suggest that she
621
00:38:21.889 --> 00:38:24.869
recognized the man and already had reason to believe he
622
00:38:24.889 --> 00:38:28.070
would hurt her. It's of course not proof she knew him,
623
00:38:28.190 --> 00:38:31.050
especially since we do not have the full exchange, but
624
00:38:31.090 --> 00:38:33.869
it opens the possibility that this was a targeted attack
625
00:38:34.289 --> 00:38:37.050
by somebody in her personal life or someone connected to
626
00:38:37.090 --> 00:38:40.670
her job. I will just add that in another source
627
00:38:40.710 --> 00:38:44.500
from 78, the exchange was described as, I won't go
628
00:38:44.539 --> 00:38:48.400
with you, you'll hurt me. which, if that's what was said,
629
00:38:48.659 --> 00:38:52.289
just that shift in language removes a little of the familiarity.
630
00:38:53.869 --> 00:38:58.469
There is nothing definitively connecting Shin Lee and Ethel Atwell's cases,
631
00:38:58.590 --> 00:39:01.800
but it's also possible that the same unidentified person who
632
00:39:01.840 --> 00:39:06.159
killed Shin was still moving around the grounds, particularly someone
633
00:39:06.199 --> 00:39:10.019
who knew employees' schedules and understood how dark and isolated
634
00:39:10.059 --> 00:39:14.239
that parking lot would be before sunrise. Rand fits part
635
00:39:14.280 --> 00:39:16.519
of that description, but he was far from the only
636
00:39:16.579 --> 00:39:21.989
person familiar with Willowbrook and its woods. And as we
637
00:39:22.030 --> 00:39:25.550
found out earlier, there were some very violent people working
638
00:39:25.730 --> 00:39:29.230
at the facility, which just breaks my heart for the
639
00:39:29.269 --> 00:39:32.639
people who lived there and the good people working there.
640
00:39:33.889 --> 00:39:37.920
Almost 50 years have passed since Ethel Atwell disappeared. I
641
00:39:37.940 --> 00:39:40.980
don't know what has been preserved in her case or
642
00:39:41.059 --> 00:39:44.019
in Shinley's in terms of forensic evidence that could potentially
643
00:39:44.079 --> 00:39:48.400
be retested. If she were still alive today, she'd be
644
00:39:48.440 --> 00:39:51.119
in her 90s. And while none of us could predict
645
00:39:51.159 --> 00:39:53.820
how long of a life Ethel would have naturally lived,
646
00:39:54.300 --> 00:39:57.909
she deserved to naturally live it beyond the 46 years,
647
00:39:58.389 --> 00:40:01.340
when her life was likely cut short by a violent predator.
648
00:40:02.489 --> 00:40:04.809
The same, of course, goes for Shin Lee and the
649
00:40:04.849 --> 00:40:09.610
many other unsolved cases I mentioned today. If you have
650
00:40:09.929 --> 00:40:13.550
any information on the abduction of Ethel Atwell or any
651
00:40:13.570 --> 00:40:16.849
of the cases I mentioned today, please contact New York
652
00:40:16.909 --> 00:40:18.969
Staten Island Police at 908-413-7258. You can also contact the
653
00:40:19.010 --> 00:40:20.449
Q Center for Missing Persons at 910-343-1131 or call the
654
00:40:20.469 --> 00:40:22.630
Q Center 24-hour tip line at 910-232-1687. All information submitted
655
00:40:22.670 --> 00:40:24.739
to the Q Center for Missing Persons is confidential. This
656
00:40:24.760 --> 00:40:26.920
has been another episode of A Simpler Time True Crime.
657
00:40:43.239 --> 00:40:45.280
If you just found me and you haven't rated the
658
00:40:45.320 --> 00:40:48.820
podcast yet, please go follow the podcast wherever you're listening
659
00:40:49.280 --> 00:40:52.159
and leave five stars. If you're on Apple, I read
660
00:40:52.300 --> 00:40:54.110
all of them and I often post them to my
661
00:40:54.139 --> 00:40:57.030
social media page because your kind words mean the world.
662
00:40:57.789 --> 00:41:00.409
I'm active on Instagram and TikTok and I do have
663
00:41:00.429 --> 00:41:03.170
a small Facebook page. If you have a case suggestion,
664
00:41:03.250 --> 00:41:07.570
please contact me at simplertimecrimepod at gmail.com. If you wish
665
00:41:07.610 --> 00:41:10.739
to support the show monetarily, I have a Spreaker Supporters Club.
666
00:41:11.119 --> 00:41:12.460
You can find the link at the bottom of the
667
00:41:12.500 --> 00:41:15.300
show notes. If you subscribe, you just download the Spreaker
668
00:41:15.340 --> 00:41:18.079
listening app or log in on Spreaker from your web
669
00:41:18.119 --> 00:41:21.150
browser and listen there and it gets you ad-free episodes.
670
00:41:22.150 --> 00:41:25.449
As always, thank you so much for listening and I'll
671
00:41:25.489 --> 00:41:52.940
see you again next Monday. Thank you.