TRANSKRİPT 🔗
JB: Welcome to this edition of The Need for Courage by Marquette Center for Peacemaking. I'm your host today, John Byrne. And with me today is Dr. Christopher Gooding. Dr. Gooding is assistant teacher, teach teacher professor, Department of Theology here at Marquette. done a lot of work in a whole host of areas, but wanted to focus on on a few things. I know that you're involved in something called the International Justice Mission. was a long time ago. Tell us about that and what that experience did for you. Yeah, so when I graduated from college, I immediately went to work for International Justice Mission in Mumbai, India. which that International Justice Mission is a organization that deals with a whole bunch of different issues depending on what country that they operate in, their global organization. And in some places they're working on land seizure issues, in some places they're working on, illegal detention, providing people habeas corpus. in some in India, the focus is on human trafficking. and there are multiple offices in India. The Mumbai office was focused on sex trafficking specifically, but I did end up liaising and working with offices that were working on labor trafficking. as well. Labor traffic. Yeah, that's a that's also a major issue that people don't realize. Those numbers are almost more than human trafficking in terms of victims, but obviously both both are horrific. Well and the resources in the US for that particular problem are not nearly as thick. I mean, you know, resources for sex trafficking victims could be a lot thicker. But n I'd have to say that ninety percent of the time when I run into a trafficking organization, it's in the US. Its focus is on sex trafficking. and labor trafficking is really an under under focused on issue. and inevitably I go to trafficking conferences and I run into immigrants' rights groups and they tell me that they're running into situations here in the US, especially among say agricultural workers, that are almost identical to the kinds of labor trafficking issues that our South India offices would run into with with labor trafficking. I I I have heard from my my research that when you were in Mumbai, this is a a personal related question, that you when the Mumbai bombings occurred, that was something that happened at the same time that you were there. What impact did that have on you personally and professionally? Yeah, it's kind of crazy. I mean, I think for most Americans of my generation, the most, you know, profound terrorist attack that they've ever experienced, either directly or indirectly, is nine eleven. I was on the opposite coast when that happened, so much more directly impacted by seven eleven, which were the the the Mumbai train bombings that you mentioned. what ended up happening, if you know for listeners that aren't familiar with it, a a group that was never identified. We have no idea who who did this. ended up putting bombs on the train system in Mumbai on the western line, which is the busiest of the three major above-ground train lines that run through the commuter trains that run through the city every day. and they they dropped these backpacks into the train cars, which then exploded. and they put them in the the primarily the first class men's cars, which are the cars that I took to work every single day. The Western Line was the was the train that I took to work every single day. And it happened during rush hour, which was normally when I was on the trains. the only reason why I was not is because my boss decided to do an off site training that particular day. And so I went home roughly half an hour early and missed rush hour. So what no all these years later, how how has that impacted you both again, like I say, personally and professionally? Yeah, it was it was very interesting living in Mumbai in the aftermath of that. we were very worried that the local Muslim population was going to be scapegoated for it, even though again there was no evidence of it we don't we have no idea who did this, right? And I can't remember what the casualty total was, but it was pretty significant. and we were particularly worried just given Mumbai's history of there's a pretty substantial Muslim minority, it's a it's a majority Hindu city, and there have been forms of communal violence between the t you know, mostly From the Hindu majority toward the Muslim minority in that particular city. And we were worried about scapegoating because politicians were already getting up there barking about, you know, various different talking points that they had used to get elected before. And thankfully that did not end up resulting, but it was a strange experience getting on the trains a couple days later. You know, everybody kind of held their breath. 'cause I I did end up going back to work after a w a weekend off and you know, still used the same trains that that blew up. it was interesting to kind of i look at the difference in experience in nine eleven ended up happening, my freshman year of college. And it was it was interesting seeing a different response. in India than I s than I I felt like I saw in the US. I mean famously war on terror kicks off after that. We get into Patriot Act. Yeah, Patriot Act. We get into two major wars. you know, there's this sense of like sometimes outright vengeance. And and in India it was just like, yeah, this happens. You know, it was everybody just kind of goes on with their life. And it was such a stark difference. in response. and so yeah, I th that's still something that I think about quite a bit. You also had an interesting career turn, if you will, originally considering a career in law, but then becoming a theology professor and academic and doctor. talk a bit about that. What what made you make those adjustments and just give us a sense of the career journey? Yeah, after working at for International Justice Mission, which the work that I I did there was mostly I did a lot of you
Load full transcript
know, as an intern I did a lot of office supply stuff. But I also ended up going to into court into a custody court for survivors of sex trafficking and talking with essentially the the US equivalent I think would be a CASA, a court appointed social advocate. Okay. for women who were coming out because a lot of times they were both underage and there were custody issues because oftentimes their parents were involved. so I went from doing that, which was very r rewarding work, you know. I I I don't think I've ever had as much job satisfaction since doing that particular position because this these were, you know, people who were in very real forms of need. I came back to the US and started working as a paralegal in the free clinic system in the in in Southern California. I worked for the Legal Aid Foundation of Los Angeles, LAFLA. and I was doing mostly defense side unlawful retainer, which is what you in California you call evictions and family law stuff. And I found that that was not where I was called to. I probably could have done the unlawful detainer stuff for a lot longer, because that seemed to be but the family law stuff was, you know, God bless anybody who goes into that for for long periods of time because I I could not. but I also had mentors that were in the criminal system, which that was what I was looking to do. And as I was forming those mentorships and understanding some of the issues that they were dealing with and sometimes even seeing it directly, following them around, I just came to have more and more questions about the way in which we do criminal justice interventions in the United States. I think it first started, I got really in involved in the restorative justice movement, and I started questioning about whether or not the structures we oftentimes use in order to deal with various different Kinds of offenses were really oriented toward outcomes that were beneficial for both the individual who offended and the individual who was offended against. This is something that restorative justice advocates talk about a lot. In in the system that we have, oftentimes the the victim is oftentimes sidelined. You know, the the the case is between the individual and the state and repair for the individual who survived this or their family, is oftentimes kind of a secondary consideration. and also, you know, you can go through a carceral system and not find that there is any moment of like accountability transformation, that kind of thing, which is what restorative justice advocates aim for through having a different sort of set of interventions. And so I got involved with that first. But then as I was pursuing my education, I started reading I had a mentor in the PhD program here, Steve Long, who started a reading group around Michelle Alexander's New Jim Crow. And that had kind of solidified some questions that I had already had. do we in in many of the criminal inter criminal justice interventions that we do in the United States, are they even necessary in the first place? because I think that many individuals when they first hear or may first pick up a book like New Jim Crow, the assumption is that, you know, everybody who is in the carceral system is a is Jeffrey Dahmer, you know, is a is a mass murdering, you know, And in reality, the the situation is is far more complicated. That there's vast racial disparities in who's arrested, there's vast mental health disparities and who's in our carceral system. in Wisconsin, we now actually have to publish the numbers on this. And our our teams that work on this through Micah have reported that after doing surveys of those numbers anywhere from between 40% and 60% in any given institution in Wisconsin, the person is incarcerated for what is at core a mental health issue. So you know, you start to ask questions of like, you know, is this even how we should be i interacting, how solving this particular social issue? but also the the concern that we just locked way too many people up. The US is the world's number one incarcerator, and that's both by number and by percentage of population. we lock up more people than countries that are larger than us, like China. Right. And we lock up more people than countries that are ostensibly more authorit authoritarian than us, like Russia. and so the the questions compounded, but also I I I found that there wasn't as much support. in criminal justice systems as I initially thought. Support meaning what? support for anybody who's working in the system as well. So support for for folks that are going through our carceral systems, but also I was looking to go into criminal defense work when I got, you know, it's kind of an interesting thing on IJM working more on the prosecutorial side and then going from you know coming into the situation here And thinking, okay, maybe actually I need to go more on the defense side. I had a colleague who was a couple of years older than me who went through wanted the to go the same path, went through law school, started up a p a position as a a criminal defense attorney, public defender. Right. And she said that her starting caseload was something like three hundred cases, you know, two hundred to three hundred cases. that's a that's b obviously a long time ago I had this conversation and an estimate, but you know, you can only spend if that's your starting caseload as an individual public defender, you can only spend maybe fifteen minutes looking at a case before you actually have to defend it in court. Of course. And at that point, you are better off with a trained monkey as an advocate than, you know, the equal you know, equal impact having you in there and having, you know, so made a you made the decision though Not and this isn't a criticism, not to try to change the system 'cause it obviously people have tried. Yeah. But to go into theology, and that is, I'm assuming you can deal with issues like restorative justice issues, discernment and all other
types of areas and help sort of train is my words, the next generation so that they'll try to make some of these changes with that. Maybe not that specifically, kinda generally your themes in terms of changing? That was that was the general th the actual precipitating incident was I had a roommate who cared for me very much and and was able to speak truth in my life and he said, Chris, you are miserable doing what you're doing. don't and you're spending all your free time reading these thick books on New Testament ethics, so go to grad school but go to s go to grad school for theology rather than for law. And you need people like that in your life. but yeah, long term one colleague who does that that I know that does restorative justice research has put it this way. Restorative justice interventions are perhaps the most researched but least implemented of all policy sort of platforms in an academic world. And so th part of the thinking was there y you you ha you have enough direct workers perhaps in the system and I could do that and I was already finding in the free clinic that I was having some of these issues and I was like, I don't know how much effectiveness that I have as an individual worker in this particular system. But maybe I can do some winning hearts and minds work, get in a classroom with with with you know, students that will, eventually be going on into similar kinds of work. And it's more about sort of winning hearts and minds. that's the the more heavy lift for the work right now. than it is a matter of like we need more people to serve, say for example, as as public defenders or prosecutors or I was able to interview Doctor Gabe Velez who who's who's done work in the restorative justice space. So I got a little little bit of tutorial on on that which I was not as familiar with. I I understand the concept but I didn't realize the phraseology of it. But let's ask you a few different things. this is a a program where we talk about peacemaking and courage and issues like that. And when you talk about criminal justice issues, I think one of the questions that comes up constantly is where is the human dignity there? Yeah. so what have you learned over time? about that and what how do you define I mean I think we don't understand the terms, but how would you define human dignity and the importance it plays in in day to day work, regardless of where you sit? Yeah. That's a that's a great question. because there are so many times that I run into individuals who are impacted by the system that precisely what they don't feel is a is a sense of dignity. I I probably the best definition of human dignity that I could give is is actually influenced by my interactions with Catholic social teaching. you know, which is in Catholic social teaching, this is about labor, not necessarily about criminal justice issues, but if you are prevented from fully participating in aspects of human life, then it's an attack on your human dignity. So dignity has
something something to do with being able to be a participant in the political, economic and social places that you are located. and that's a lot of what you know some people find that they are are They they have attacked if they are going through, you know, say for example, a a particularly punitive system. just to give examples of, you know, some things that that looks like. I've been involved in both Wisdom and Micah, which are faith-based organizations that are working against mass incarceration since, you know, becoming an educator. And One of the great things about it is that it continues to pull me into relationships with folks that have been impacted by the system who are doing organizing of various sorts. And to give you an example of a of a practice that we do that robs people of their human dignity, one of the drivers that Micah has been focusing on for mass incarceration now has been a phenomenon that's called crimeless revocations, which is when you get thrown you you were in the system. You get released, you're on probation, and you get thrown back into the system, sometimes for a long period of time, not because you committed a new crime, but because you committed a somewhat fiddly parole violation. and so the worst example that I can think of that d that deprived a person of their human dignity, we ran into a guy, in our casework in wisdom who got reincarcerated for accepting a job. He so he as a as a condition of his release, he needed to seek employment. We all need to do that. Sure. he had to he so he went and he interviewed for a job. he got a job offer from the employer. And as a condition of his parole, he was told you need to get authorization from your probation officer. in order to accept a job. So he did he followed the procedure. He reached out to his probation officer and he said, Hey, I was offered this job. Can I take it? And she did not respond to him for a period of about three weeks. And the employer, after I think maybe a week or two, got back to this guy and said, Hey, you were a really promising applicant, but we're kind of under a crunch here. We need to fill this position now. So if you don't give me a response by the by the end of the week, I'm afraid I'm gonna have With somebody else. And so he took the job. His probation officer stopped ghosting him, found out about it, and he was reincarcerated for that. now I don't know about you, but I don't want my tax money going to incarcerating that guy for getting a job. That seems like something he's doing everything that we want him to do, right? And then that's on the parole officer, obviously. Yeah, yeah. Yeah. Wow. But that's that's what a crimeless ev revocation looks like. It's when it's when an individual is reincarcerated for a somewhat fiddly parole violation rather than the example. Where where is that person today? I actually don't know because I don't have I'm not the individual who who shared this story. It was actually David Liners originally who had
contact with this person. Gotcha. But yeah, no, I mean that's probably one of the best examples that I that I've you know you share stories in organizing and so that's that's one of the more compelling ones. But there are other examples, you know, being reincarcerated because you have a a brother that's across state lines and you have a new nephew that you want to go see, you know, things like that. so that that's the the the an example of, you know, a way in which the system could potentially rob you of your dic dignity by preventing you from participating in something that makes, you know, gainful employment. Something that makes us human. So you're you're at a Catholic university but not but and you're a Mennonite. And I know the Mennonites have a number of themes, but one that I know I wanted to ask you about, we mentioned this pre recording, is the traditions of peace and discipleship. Yeah. Talk talk a bit about that. Maybe talk initially about you made a decision to come to this university. Maybe what was I I think you've already implied what were some of the reasons why You were drawn here, but maybe a little bit about that and then how your Mennonite I don't say background but environment sh shapes those issues. Yeah, I was originally drawn to a Catholic university as a Mennonite because I thought actually the peace tradition would be a better fit. I I I know of several Catholic institutions that have centers for peacemaking. it's less common in some Protestant ones. and interestingly enough, I've experienced sometimes more friction and say for example, between the the the peace emphasis of my own tradition and say for example a a very s staunch just war Lutheran faculty than I would at an institution like Marquette that's very open to, you know, not just like, yeah, you can you can believe in nonviolence here, but like How do actually do this? Let's study it. Let's get better at this. Let's equip students to go out there and practice this. and so yeah, that and I do a lot of stuff on labor and so Catholic social teaching on labor. I wanted to interact with Catholic thinkers around that. So the decision to come and be educated, because I got my doctorate at Marquette, and to join the faculty of a Catholic institution was based on those that sense of fit. as far as what it means to be to be Mennonite, Mennonites are a part of the Anabaptist branch of the Christian tree, which includes individu like which includes groups like us, the Mennonites. it also includes the Amish, the Church of the Brethren, the Hutterites, the Quakers, and other groups. And the emphasis within Anabaptism, the the unique contribution to world Christianity from the Anabaptist tradition is a is a a very politically and ethically serious form of discipleship that emphasizes taking on Jesus' politics of enemy love, taking on his emphasis on nonviolence. On mutual aid within communities, like for example, is practiced by early Christian communities in the Book of Acts.
and so some Mennonite communities, the Hutterites are probably the best example of this, do live communally and on compounds where, you know, they make the genes that everybody wears in the community. So, so yeah, very community focused. There's also an emphasis within the Anabaptist churches on Your allegiance goes to Christ and to Christ alone. and because of that, your allegiance specifically does not go to the nation-state in which you are located. to show allegiance to both Christ and the nation-state would be to to quote Jesus and Luke, serve two masters, and no one can do that. and so people in my tradition typically also don't participate in any of the some sociologists refer to it as American civil religion, the the sort of ritual acts that that that Americans practice that point one's allegiance toward an entity called the United States of America. so that don't serve in the military or vote something like that. We do vote. you do vote. That's that's fine. and in fact that's that's well, there is you will find variance, I will say, in Anabaptist communities. Some we actually do make decisions, a lot of us do, not all of us do, make decisions by consensus. Okay. so I've actually been a part of that process quite a bit. getting everybody on the same page and having a discussion and having not uniformity of opinion. But at the very least there's a clear direction that the church is discerning. Most individuals are on board with it. And anybody who has who is not entirely on board is willing to say, I'm willing to get out of the way in order to for this decision to be made. So there because of that, there are some Anabaptist groups that are, you know, voting is is is is something less than consensus and therefore it's something that Anabaptists shouldn't participate in. But in the communities in which I run an MC USA, you know, we do GOTV drives, for God's sake. So yeah, it's voting is not seen as a particularly problematic. But serving in the military, yes, that would be seen as problematic given the given the position on non voting. that the denomination takes based on the nonviolence of Jesus and the resistance to military service in the early church. It would also include it also has traditionally included any governmental office that might be involved in, say, for example, the execution of the death penalty as well. and so you I don't know that there's anything debarring. I don't know that we've s explicitly talked a lot about in MCUSE MCUSA, say for example, debarring serving as as a police officer who might need to draw you know have a weapon and kill somebody. But in general, you will not run into that. because of the because of the the call to nonviolence. so yeah that would be but also it it means that I'm a big Brewers fan. I'm I'm very glad to for the first time in my life be able to watch them in the World Series. But every single time I go to a Brewers game and the national anthem plays, I might be the only person that I can see in a stadium of 50,000 people who is not standing for the national anthem. I really appreciate your Dr. Gooding talking about all all these issues, giving us clarity there. I want to get you out of here on this. given all that you've talked about, y your career decision to move from the legal profession for all the reasons you outlined, that you're in what we're calling a mor moral theology, ethical you know, umbrella of life and all the things that you've talked about and all the chaos that's going on globally as well as domestic. But you're teaching new new generations. Are you generally hopeful that things will, whatever things are, will change? And there's so many things that obviously need to change or be modified, whatever, but just in general, are you hopeful going forward? I I am. I don't know if the hope, the hope ultimately comes from the from the conviction that that Christ has conquered sin, death, and evil, and not necessarily from anything that I anything that I can point to. but the the biggest concern that I have on a regular basis as a as an educator and something that you know when I see it in fits and starts gives me hope. there's a sociologist by the name of Robert Putnam who talks about he wrote a book a while back called Bowling Alone Biggest issue that I think that I try to convince my students in a classroom that they need to address mode the most immediately is Americans are dropping out of participation in voluntary organizations for the common good at pretty staggering rates. originally in my discipline this was seen as a problem of like they're leaving church, this is a theological problem. But it's not just churches that folks are leaving. There are also less members of the NAACP than there were in the than there were in the seventies. There's less people joining Micah and other grassroots organ. There's less people joining rec leagues and bowling leagues, which is why the the title of the book is Bowling Alone. And so the thing that I really tell my students is like, look, just get involved. Find a community to believe in. Join a, you know, join a church, join a synagogue, join a mosque, join A house of worship, join a union, join you know, join a grassroots organization for the common good, join a a PTA, you know. and and that's the the the biggest thing that I I am constantly telling them. And what gives me hope is is seeing individuals who kind of discover this and you know develop a a social conscience of some sort. But thank you so much for sharing your thoughts, your time today. Really appreciate it. Thank you. Yeah, thanks for having me.