TRANSKRİPT 🔗
The Creativity Question: Hello and welcome to this new episode of the creativity question where we explore what creativity is and how it works. Today I'm very, very happy because I have a guest I've known for quite a long time. He is a designer, a facilitator and creative data strategist. And currently he is the head of the interaction design program at Copenhagen Institute of Interaction. He has two decades of experience working across multidisciplinary teams across cultural, educational and social impact sectors. And his work centers on research, social impact and community-based design interventions. Prior to this institute, he helped establish Data for Change as a nonprofit organization. Data for Change works within a wide array of civil society organizations, activists, human rights defenders and creative talent collaborating at the intersection of data, design, technology and journalism to forge real change and lasting impact, which is obviously fabulous. Before that, he served as design director at Data and Design Studio Beyond Worlds in London. And earlier in his career, he ran his own studio and design collective in Rotterdam. in the Netherlands, Content Context, where he also taught graphic design at the William de Kooning Academy and lecturing in the fashion department on design, communication and lifestyle strengths. Prior to founding his own studio, he works also as a designer at GMT and design at Sam, Sam Seymour, sorry about my pronunciation, Seymour Design in New York. Thank you. And Winterhouse Studio.
Michael Brenner: That's okay. Sang seamware design. Yeah.
The Creativity Question: ⁓ Across these roles, he has had the opportunity to work on and lead projects for organizations including the UN World Bank, Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, the Guggenheim Museum, MoMA, The New York Times, Cooper, Hewitt, Al Gore, and Queen's Circuit of Talent, among others. Wow, that was a long biography. ⁓ Please welcome Mr. Michael Brandner. Welcome, Michael. Thank you for being here.
Michael Brenner: Sorry. Thank you, Favi. Are you kidding me? Thanks for reading off that but I mean when you were I was like, Well, who's who's she talking about? parts of it, many of it's much of it's ⁓ a big ⁓ a big creative blur, let's say. But yeah, no no no. I I I remember every single minute of it. It's it's been quite a quite a
The Creativity Question: Do you remember all of this?
Michael Brenner: Unconventional design path for someone who was classically trained as a graphic designer back in the day.
The Creativity Question: But this is what makes creativity amazing, doesn't ⁓ it? So let's start with the first question of this podcast, which is, Michael, what does creativity mean to you?
Michael Brenner: Yeah. Okay. well, you know, Fabi, I was really hoping that we would ⁓ explore some things together and figure out what it means because to be honest, I have so many different weird, unconnected ideas that maybe we'll be able to figure out some sort of ⁓ some sort of common narrative through the mess that's in this head.
The Creativity Question: ⁓ that's daunting. So you want me to answer my own question?
Michael Brenner: Yeah yeah no no no no I mean we're gonna we're gonna traverse a bunch of different things. But I mean I've I you know I've been thinking about this like prior to to coming to coming on it mean to be creative in the creative act? And I've been since I've also taken on this new role at the at the at the institute and you know one of the primary Advantages of the institute itself is that it's it's it's democratizing design, right? The program itself is an interaction design program, but the the idea of interaction design when it first started out has kind of outpaced itself and outlived itself. That it's basically now we're just talking about design and the design of interactions. And the idea of the design of interactions is really like how do we connect the dots and how do we bridge uncommon things? And really, it's this kind of like collision of domains where it's like, you know, now we're talking about like service design, we're talking about UXUI, we're talking about, you know, beyond just physical computing, talking about you know, with with our, you know, frenemy AI, what what are we going to do with that and how is it changing the quote unquote creative space and the design landscape and what are the ethics behind its creation and all of the things that were created that were then Hoovered up by all of these, you know, LLMs to create quote unquote these platforms. You know, like what happens what happens to the, you know, give credit where credit's due. And then, you know, we're just kind of all sitting here interacting with this chatbot effectively, and it's returning results that were, hey, this is pretty, pretty cool, but you know, what's What's beyond that? What are the implications of it? And and and how can we actually use it as a more, let's say, creative I don't want to say a co-creator, but a tool in which we're not fully surrendering our agency and decisions over to because we're simply wowed by the quite mediocre and average things at outputs. So, you know, we're we're we're quite focused in and around you know, how can we create more equitable and accessible futures and optimistic futures that are more desirable for everyone and having a more positive outlook and having a having a let's say you know ⁓ an optimistic view of AI and how we can kind of flip the script on its head so that's more of a a tool that gives us agency rather than something that we should fear and so that we actually control it rather than the other way around. So I know we just went like but so back to your original question. What does creativity mean to me? I think it's really this idea of taking something that might be uncommon and finding another thing that it could potentially connect to and seeing what that connection creates. So. It's Let's take the example of a pencil, for example.
Load full transcript
So there was this amazing book that was written in the 1950s, 1958. I'll send a link to it so we can it's so by this guy, Leonard Reed, who was an economist. And he took the the basic idea of the pencil that no single person contains the entire knowledge to create the pencil, right? Because the pencil is just more than a piece of wood with a piece of graphite on it. and the the the foil that's stamped into it, the little metal part that holds in the eraser into the top, right? It takes millions and millions of people around the world to get those raw materials. Those raw materials then need to be transformed into stuff. So whether it be the shaft of wood that the pencil holds or the graphite need those things need to be cut down, milled. Those things need to be then, you know put through machines, but who's making that machine? How did that machine come into play? So it's like the the entire idea of any single human containing the knowledge to be able to create or do something is completely absurd. But collectively and together we can link our dots and build those bridges to your body of knowledge, my body of knowledge. And when we get together and we start creating things, in building up those ideas and then realizing those ideas. that's where I think real true creativity is. It's not it's not a solo act. You know, John Maeda used or said, was it design design design produces solutions to problems and art asks questions. But I would slightly change that and actually say design provides answers to problems and art pr in asks the questions, right? Because solutions, the solutions are an answer to a question. And sometimes the solutions or the the answers are great and sometimes they're not. So it all it all depends on the context, right? And how and how things are are put together. But you know, it's ⁓ it's yeah, it's just it's those collisions of ideas and
The Creativity Question: Yeah.
Michael Brenner: The act of, yeah, building bridges between uncommon things and even common things and just creating something new from that. There's another thing that I've been really playing around with, ⁓ this idea of elegant utility. So something that's connected in such a way that has elegance to it, right? It may seem effortless, it may seem seamless, it might seem absolutely beautiful to someone. But then to someone else, it may not seem beautiful at all or effortless at all, right? There might be friction there, or there might not be friction there. But for the person that I would say that it that it feels beautiful and seamless and frictionless for, and if it's adding value to their life and you know, making things better for them without imposing or creating a set of consequences that significantly impact someone else's. way of being or way of living or way of existing, then I think that there's something really beautiful in that. But then there's also the idea that things then need to come with or the things that we're creating or designing with the big question of why? Why are we doing this and and and what are the appro ⁓ the intended consequences, but then w you know, we also have to speculate about the unintended consequences. And right now we are in one of the biggest human experiments that just was unleashed on us five years ago. Like no one even longer, like with the advent of the iPhone or any kind of digital tech that platforms, they were all designed in vacuums, released into the world with the idea of let's see where it goes. We've seen where it's gone and it's time to tap the brakes and figure out how we can Kind of regained control a little bit. Probably there's lots it to unpack in there.
The Creativity Question: I can see why you're a teacher because it's fascinating what you're telling me. ⁓ I think it's beautiful to think that creativity is a collaboration act. I think that too. I always think when people ask you, can you be more creative? It's always puzzling to me because creativity is never one person or one brain. product, it's actually a product of experiences and exchange and conversations and problems as well, like you were saying. So it is fascinating. And what's more fascinating is I find that every guest I'm having here is giving me a different answer. And that's beautiful and exciting and also shows how human it fundamentally is.
Michael Brenner: Yes. Yeah. Absolutely. I mean, that's why we don't have one of anything, right? If you think about all the things like the the the types of chairs, tables, pens, types of keys, like types of rubber bands. Like literally rubber bands have one function to hold well, they don't have one function. They have many functions. But look at all the different types of rubber bands we have, right? Based on what you perceive. Again, you know, this is what comes back to like what you perceive to be. Aesthetically pleasing or functional to you, you're going to choose you're going to choose that type of rubber band, right? Or that type of chair. Or, you know, that's why we're also we don't all look the same or act the same or think the same. You know, the the the idea that Yeah, it's it's the the the real power of creativity is having diverse perspectives and lived experiences, professional experiences, levels of experience, like it's scales, right? Different scales. Looking at a particular question and finding an answer that meets not only their frameworks and mental models, but also other people's and is scalable enough and inclusive enough to be adaptable, right? I a a lot of the times now even in design or creativity, it's it's the bridging of those systems and even trying to figure out how we can improve the systems that we fundamentally have. And then you know what's really, really interesting and we don't talk about enough, is what about non human actors? What about people and species who are creative that that you know we we deem ⁓ Not to be, or we don't look at their acts as being creative because they're quote unquote not
human. I mean, nature itself is super creative, like it literally it's created the entire planet that we live on, right? That that that system and that computer has been programmed, but it's evolving. It's evolving as we're putting input into it and as we're disturbing it, it's evolving to survive. I mean, we've we've damaged it severely, but somehow it's still kicking on. And I think at some point, and we're already seeing it within the the climate crisis, it rebelling. So is that a way, is that a creative way of nature, you know, dealing with the human problem?
The Creativity Question: Maybe, maybe nature is asking for help. It's asking for our creativity to solve this disaster we created.
Michael Brenner: ⁓ for sure. It's screaming. It's screaming. Well that's but but but ⁓ even within that, it's like we need to stop looking at nature as something that is is something to be dominated by humans and and look at a more centrist view where it's humans amongst nature and everything that we do and create h taps directly into it. And it's absolutely absurd. It's absolutely it's like, you know, di ⁓ nature colonialism that we're that we think that we can just come in, do whatever the heck we want, and then not suffer the consequences of it.
The Creativity Question: That's very true. I want to know what are your influences. Because you said yourself, I read your beautiful biography and you've done bits of everything and you come from the States and also you lived in different countries and I'm sure that your influences must come from everywhere. Right?
Michael Brenner: From the people that I meet and from the places that I've traveled to and had the experiences of of working with, alongside of and who have always been, you know, like with the with once I really got into the, let's say, area of data and design, it it completely changed everything the way that I that I saw and Data as a design material and looking at it, that it gave it it basically gave me the ability to look at the world through different lenses. Because I mean, even if you think about data, like I mean, data can be anything. If you can if you can observe something, if you can measure something, if you can then capture those measurements in a kind of systematic way, put those things together, pull insights from it, synthesize information, turn that information into knowledge, and then that knowledge pass it on to someone else, and it becomes wisdom. But all of those different domain is That I've had the opportunity to let's say observe and work with the data have completely changed the way that I see things, and you start connecting those dots, right? But even though the absurd idea that humans are taking observations, condensing it down into abstract metrics. In other communication tools to make it more understandable. And now we're at the point of no, we need to unpack those things and start telling the stories behind those things so that people can understand it better. It's like a
weird like game of translation. And it's like, okay, we're gonna we're gonna abstract this thing to then unpack it to then make it ⁓ comprehensible again. But ⁓ it needs to kind of go through that weird translation process and abstraction to to I guess yeah to ⁓ not I guess but to to to make meaning of it once you start putting everything together. I I I think that I really find myself Really inspired by science. There's I I'm not great at math. I love the idea of math. I can do basic maths like your calculus, those kinds of things, but I really love quantum physics because it's like it's it's it's it's amazing at how people can take math and make it so elegant to be able to explore the world. One of my favorite
The Creativity Question: Thanks
Michael Brenner: Two of my favorite people, Niels deGrasse Tyson, and also there's an Italian ⁓ quantum physicist, ⁓ Carlo Rovelli Rovelli. I love his books. I love like because he he takes he takes such complicated ideas, and again, in a very creative way, makes them very accessible so that you can understand what the smallest possible thing is that we can measure.
The Creativity Question: Carlo Rovelli. Me too.
Michael Brenner: Based on our current tools, which by the way are absolutely insane that we can make tools and synthesize things to capture the smallest possible thing that we currently know and the largest possible thing that we currently know. Obviously, as technology and science grows, because the whole point of science is to prove itself wrong, which is amazing. And I wish that design had more and the creative sector had more of that kind of philosophy behind it. Prove yourself wrong, because then you get onto something greater, right? I the idea that we've landed on the thing that's going to be the solution, it's like, well, th it it is only in the sense that right now, based on all the information that we currently have, it might be a great solution. But then ten years down the road, we should revisit that thing. Primarily, let's say the big the big fac like social media, for example, or even digit like d smartphones or now even AI. Like there should be some sort of review process that's more ⁓ humanity-based for some of these larger, you know, developments that we've designed to say, hey, you know what? Actually, this isn't working. It's like, you know, GDP being the worst metric to understand how. It's an invented number. How how how societies are advancing. Meanwhile, you have Bhutan, who's created the happiness index. And that in and instead of it's it's an it's an amazing project and like that's that is that is a that is an indicator that puts people first. And you can actually better tell how a country's progressing by their happiness index, just based on the different metrics and variables that are associated with it than GDP.
The Creativity Question: That is fantastic. I want to go live in Bhutan just to see how that works. ⁓ that's amazing. Yeah, we need more of this. do you think that we should review, for instance, social media? That's a hot topic, isn't it? Should we find a creative way to socialize outside our phones? Or rather, for younger people?
Michael Brenner: Hehehe. Well, I I mean, obviously, I mean But that's but that ⁓ so
The Creativity Question: I see that younger people don't spend time outside chatting, which is what I used to do when I was 15 all the time. Right?
Michael Brenner: So there's Yeah. Well that's I mean we we had the privilege, we can call it a privilege now, of growing up in an era where technology was still warm. And what I mean by warm technologies is that it had a lot of ⁓ tactile, like tangibleness to it, you know? ⁓ the telephone. Rotary dials, push buttons, these types of things, even early gaming systems, arcade games, ⁓ TVs. There you know, the it was less glossy, there was more texture to it, there was a warmth and a humanity to it. But actually with the youngest generation, I don't even know what we're on anymore. So it's like d past Gen Z, Gen, Gen Alpha, Gen There's actually a bit like let's okay, so let's say like twelve, like twelve to eighteen year olds that are currently on this planet. There's I think actually quite a big rebellion against the technology that was developed in the early two thousands. Like you see people more adapting to old digital ⁓ cameras. There's an ups there's an upsurge in buying DVDs.
The Creativity Question: I think it's Gen Alpha.
Michael Brenner: in vinyl in cassettes. There's a ton of people now that like the maker space is kind of even more accessible and more open source because people are sharing more that you see a lot of beautiful physical tangible pieces of tech coming out that are cutting against the grain of you know whatever Apple or Google Samsung you know like who whomever has put it Sony whoever's putting that technology out so it's it's It's it's gonna be interesting to see what the backlash is going to be. I saw a video the other day, it was funny, it it popped up in one of my feeds, and there was this punk band. I think the kids must have been like twelve or thirteen, but it was an anti-AI protest song. And I was like, okay, there's some hope. There's some hope for this. I'll find the link and send it to you, but it was amazing. It was just like a complete anthem, like you would have seen maybe the early days of ⁓ the Ramones or No FX or even some like early Green Day. you know, i it felt like it had that kind of raw, honest energy to it. But then of course they had all of that catalogue and history to perfect the sound, so it sounds a little bit too polished.
The Creativity Question: Oh my God, I love that. I really need to see it. mean, so creativity is now about... I have this feeling that for you, creativity is a very human connection sort of tool, right? It's always... And I mean, your experience also tells us that you've always worked in human rights and to improve society, to help people.
Michael Brenner: Yeah, it's it's it's
hilarious. Yeah.
The Creativity Question: which is obviously really commendable. And what are you doing now in terms of projects? Are you purely teaching or are you also starting some projects with your students?
Michael Brenner: So as ts so so that's a great question. And so I mean, they are my projects. In terms of like the you know, there's a great there's a good ad teasing there's there's a great responsibility in terms of, you know, providing space for social impact and and creating
The Creativity Question: ⁓ wow.
Michael Brenner: The fact that the the hang on let me I need to I need to phrase this carefully. This'll be a this will be a this will be an edit. ⁓ the institute the institute has been very generous and open with me to take me on with my unconventional design path to help explore more how we can implement the the learnings that I've taken from the field field work that I've done to create, you know, social impact, but then to put that into education. It's always been something that's been part of the the institute. And it's something that you know, is is is really at the core. And so that's why we made the connection and it was like, yeah, let's do this. Let's let's let's push it as far as we possibly can and make sure because in in traditional design education, everyone talks about impact. But then it's never really part of the curriculum. And here it's at the heart and soul of the curriculum. And then allowing space for people to be able to explore what that means for themselves. Again, you know, like the idea of this elegant utility and people being able to call, you know, like what they think is beautiful and and how we can generate and create things that other people may feel the same way or may not feel the same way. ⁓ that they'll that they'll find some value and purpose in what we're creating. Is is yeah, it it's it they've could they've carved out a beautiful space for it. And and that's what really sets it apart and really makes it wonderful. So it's a wonderful program to explore and to find out what what Different definitions of what does creativity mean to you, what does design mean to you. You know, we have people that are anthropologists, art history backgrounds, ⁓ neuroscientists, artists, people who have worked on farms before. But then you also have people who are have been classically trained as designers. And so when you get them together and put them you know, into a a program for 12 months and they traverse through these various briefs, the outputs that are created are absolutely profoundly just magnificent in the sense that they're robust, they're there's there there's a true sense of humanity to them. And you can see that they're looking beyond sometimes what traditional ⁓ programs may may be looking at and also ⁓ just the kind of what we've been taught design is. So there's that space for definition, there's that space for transformation, for exploration, and for growth. ⁓ So in terms of projects, obviously like project projects, like the classic idea of projects, not so much these days. I mean there are some things here and there, but primarily you know, shaping the the course curriculum and then we do have projects that we take in that people, you know, the the the cohort and the participants do work on. ⁓ so it's ⁓ it's it's more in that realm these days. but you know, there's always space.
The Creativity Question: Yes, of course. This brings me to your early days because I want to... This is another of the questions I always do to my guests, which is, I want to know one moment of struggle and one moment of breakthrough of your career, if there are any that stand out.
Michael Brenner: You know? Yeah, yeah. Nice. Yeah. ⁓ yeah, there's there's every every every week there's a struggle and every week there's a kind of breakthrough. ⁓ but like real momentous ones, I think.
The Creativity Question: This is funny because everyone says the same and I feel the same as well. It's always a struggle. It goes on every time you have to come up with a new idea, a new solution, new inspiration. It is a struggle. I think we kind of thrive in struggling people who are designers.
Michael Brenner: Yeah. It's always a struggle, right? I s ⁓ absolutely in friction, right? So So that was one thing that I wanted to mention before about creativity. It's like creativity is is born out of friction. It's it's it's when you feel as though you can't do the thing that you want to do. So then you figure out a way to do that thing. And that thing can be anything, right? It just you find a way out of it, or you find a way into it, or you find your way around it, or you find your way on the other side of the that particular thing. It could be a positive thing, could be a neutral thing, could be a negative thing, it doesn't matter. It's just like you're you're
The Creativity Question: Yeah.
Michael Brenner: On the other side of that thing. ⁓ I think, I think one, and and this is very cliche, and it's very, I'm sure every seasoned designer says it at a certain point. but just letting go of the idea that you're perfectionism, embracing things that are imperfect, and realizing that that is perfect. And Very early on, those those moments of tension that maybe there was like communication issues where I couldn't necessarily get an idea across, realizing that maybe there just wasn't enough information that was put into it, and that was based too much on assumption. And those assumptions led to a very poor decision-making line of inquiry. I d yeah, it's I would say that one of the biggest struggles was probably keeping The studio alive in the Netherlands. That was that was very difficult. And that tested me on a d a lot of different levels. ⁓ and a lot of that also there was a bit of ⁓ you know, at the end of the day it came down to a little bit of a language barrier, or maybe a big language barrier. An integration on my own side, even yeah. I mean, you know, so and then that
at that kind of moment it was like, okay, you know.
The Creativity Question: Could be.
Michael Brenner: Putting everything under the microscope and realizing there's gotta be other ways of existing in the unknown and in the void, embracing it to be able to kind of get to the next step and feel comfortable with that. So, and that happens now all the time, like even throughout the pandemic. Like throughout any like, I mean this is also a very difficult question to answer. solely because and you see all of the memes all the time. It's like we started our careers in the middle of Well, at least you know, from the is coming from the perspective of the states, you know, ⁓ a war in three different countries between Iraq, Afghanistan, and you know, in the region, even in Yemen, ⁓ you know, everything's spilling out, financial crises, you know, it just felt like we were constantly jumping over one crisis after another to like jump into something and reinventing. So that's why I think it's like every three or four years. Maybe for our generation it feels natural to just be like, Okay, let's just
The Creativity Question: Yeah.
Michael Brenner: explode everything and do something else.
The Creativity Question: I feel that. I remember 2008 as well when there was the crash and I was just finishing my Masters in London and I was ready to go and start finally working in London and this happened and I found myself working in a bookshop because of course without any title, I mean without any experience in the field.
Michael Brenner: Yeah. Yeah.
The Creativity Question: It was really difficult at the time to find work. And yeah, I feel like we have had it a little bit harder than our parents maybe because there's always something coming up. The pandemic was a big one. But yeah.
Michael Brenner: Right. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, I mean even look at look at what's happening now. I mean, we've got the yeah, it's insane. It's absolutely insane. And the consequences of those actions and the design of democracy has had profound. Not sure how creative American democracy is. I mean it is. It is when it functions really well. But it's very, very creative, right? I mean
The Creativity Question: ⁓ God. I it's very creative.
Michael Brenner: Yeah, it's very, very creative. Lots of lots of lots of loopholes to get around things.
The Creativity Question: ⁓ my God. Anyway. And what was your moment of breakthrough, Michael, when you said, ⁓ my God, I really need this project. You know, when you had an idea and you thought this will work and it actually did and it all turned out exactly like you wanted or even better. That's difficult, isn't it? It's almost as difficult as the struggling one. Because I...
Michael Brenner: This is it. Okay. Yeah, no, so so so this so this so no there is there is one particular moment. there was a project ⁓ when I was still at Data for Change, we were at a we were at a design sprint or one of our Data for Change design sprints in ⁓ Beirut. I think this was twenty eighteen. And we had an amazing group come from Yemen called the Yemen polling center. They had the shortest distance to travel.
The Creativity Question: Great.
Michael Brenner: However, they basically they had to drive through ⁓ two active war zones on a bus take like two or three flights to basic they traveled for three days in something that should have taken maybe you know like six or eight hours. And when they finally got to ⁓ Beirut to to work. with with the creative team, there was a little piece of tech that came out of that project because they were still sending people, their researchers out into the field. into, you know, obviously taking as many safety precautions as possible, but you never know where violence or you know, something may erupt. So there was there was actually ⁓ a moment where we're or we were all sitting around and this little Bluetooth Hub came up as an idea based on a Raspberry Pi that could be powered by a little Samsung phone that didn't need much battery. And basically, we designed a little kind of portable polling station that could be dropped off at secure locations that people could go to connect, actually not through Bluetooth, but through the little Raspberry Pi's kind of Wi-Fi enabled ⁓ transmitter with their ⁓ phone. We eventually got the Bluetooth working and they could fill out the survey. ⁓ and then people could, you know, the the researchers could then go and pick up the hub rather than having people, you know, going door to door and having conversations so everyone could go at a time when they felt safe. The other cool thing about that was is that there was some storage capacity on it as well. So we could Yemen the Yemen polling center could also upload some much needed educational materials because schools were were basically shut down. There's no know there's intermittent electricity, there's intermittent internet. But because it basically acted as like a local area mesh network, people could also then daisy chain and share information with each other. So that that really felt like a moment where it was like, okay, you know, there's things that we can create that are super, let's say, low fi but have high value and have high ⁓ impact for the people that are using them. And it doesn't have to be super flashy. It doesn't have to it it does it did one thing well and that was enable people to connect and gain and and and access information. And that was it. It didn't try to be fancy. It didn't try to be flashy. It was just like hey here's this and I'll I'll send you you know some some photos and some documentation of it. But it was an amazing Yeah, it was it was it was really an amazing moment. ⁓
The Creativity Question: Please do. Everyone needs to see this.
Michael Brenner: And then you know, working with you know, I I'm I'm talking on behalf of the team now that that that created this, but you know, being there and being part of it and helping them think through things, it was ⁓ no, it was
wild. It was absolutely wild. So yeah.
The Creativity Question: It must have been. I'm so jealous. It's such a great thing. You see, it sounds like something, some kind of cliche, but it is not. I deeply believe that when you do something, it also actually has a good impact on people and you can see it. It makes such a difference. I don't believe in being in our work. or any work for what matters, if it doesn't do anything good for people. We must at least try to have a positive impact, whether it's in our day job, in our other projects. ⁓ I think that this is the most rewarding thing. I'm not just saying it because I want to sound nice. It actually is. It is.
Michael Brenner: Yeah, I mean, you know, there's
The Creativity Question: And that's such a beautiful project. Thank you for sharing that.
Michael Brenner: Yeah. There's there's ⁓ actually to this to this exact point, I was just speaking with an amazing designer and strategist earlier today, and her name is Jenna ⁓ Date, and she was saying that she tells she was just telling her team that, you know, like what whatever positivity, openness, humanity, sympathy, empathy that you bring to a project, it will inherently transmit itself into that project and come out on the other side with that project. And it was just It was just a very beautiful idea it's a very beautiful idea, but it's also a very true idea, right? The more that you put out positive It's dangerous word, but we're gonna say energy, right? People vibrate, people have energies. I mean, you and vibrate at different frequencies, and there's people that you get along with amazingly, and there's people that you don't get along with amazingly. That's just a fact of life. And chances are the people that maybe you don't get along with so amazingly is that you're just vibrating at different frequencies, and the energies and the the those frequencies are, you know.
The Creativity Question: You
Michael Brenner: Congruent to each other rather than ⁓ kind of in balance.
The Creativity Question: That's very true. Yes, I totally agree with that. So that was a success. That's beautiful. ⁓ Tell us how your ⁓ opinion, if it has changed about creativity over time, if not opinion, sorry, your idea of creativity, has it changed since you started when you were a young student in New York?
Michael Brenner: Yeah.
The Creativity Question: and how.
Michael Brenner: Yes, absolutely. Absolutely. Like book it was it was it was more based on like any young designer, what's the cool thing that I can make or the formal thing or like you know, like wow, you know, design, it's all about, you know, form and you know, sometimes it's about function or how cool can we make it, or you know, and now it's more about how useful can we make it and what's the purpose and the value that it adds to someone's existence and Also, you know, thinking about it from a holistic standpoint, what happens after that thing is no longer useful, what happens to it next? And then how does
it kind of go back into the system without doing too much harm?
The Creativity Question: That is something that really worries me, for example. I stopped buying too many clothes, not only clothes, I found myself second guessing how many things I'm buying and why I'm buying them and what I'm going to do with them. Even when I don't need them anymore, I think, okay, can I recycle this? Can I give it to someone? Can this be useful instead of being...
Michael Brenner: Right. Yeah.
The Creativity Question: thrown away, which will probably end up in Southeast Asia, beautiful beach and ruin their lives. Because that's what happened. That's what we are doing most of the time. We have been doing for decades. And it's sad. It is sad.
Michael Brenner: I mean yeah. I mean There's there's enough of everything on Earth. I forget what the exact Okay, so let's get into the let's get into the data and the statistics of it. Basically the the the in the nineties we started to hit overconsumption, like of one earth. Now I think we're overconsuming by like two two point one earths every year now. So that's a big problem. But then also in terms of
The Creativity Question: Yeah.
Michael Brenner: The things that we make, especially like in and around clothing, I think that there's enough stuff on Earth, we have to look this up, that it's like good for seven generations. Like if you stop producing if you stop producing everything today, there would be enough of everything, clothing, ⁓ things for seven generations worth of human beings.
The Creativity Question: I know this. I think that this is coming from a documentary on Netflix because I remember the exact expression. No, it's true. I think I watched it. It was about clothing. It was about the fashion industry. And it's insane if we think about that. So this is something we can think about creatively, like how can we dress ourselves without consuming and throwing everything away while...
Michael Brenner: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. ⁓ it's it's it's absolutely crazy.
The Creativity Question: Also, there's a part of the world that can't even have some of this stuff. The imbalance is also really shocking.
Michael Brenner: Yeah. The the the insanity of the timeline or the reality that we live in is that we have all of the data, we have all of the material, we have all of the things that we need to create a global society in which everyone prospers. And and that we take care of each other.
The Creativity Question: Yeah. Yes. And that's our proposal for the next generation. I mean, for us towards the next generation to help them improving and trying to say to achieve it. Everything. ⁓ I want to ask you a couple of last questions because I kept you, I'm very aware I kept you here forever. And thank you so much for your time, Michael. I always ask the mic guests.
Michael Brenner: Yeah. Yeah, exactly. Achieve it. Yeah. No worries.
The Creativity Question: to, I mean, and it's really, really good to have any from you because you're also a
teacher and a mentor. So what's your advice for ⁓ kids who want to start a creative career now?
Michael Brenner: The old the old the old cliches that literally anything is possible. ⁓ I would say that what's that? That I mean that the but it's it is. It's true though. Like it it's it's a matter of and but this also comes from a position of extreme privilege, right? So it depends yeah, it so it's
The Creativity Question: I love that. I love that anything is possible. It's true.
Michael Brenner: To just to literally just just to don't let anyone ever, ever tell you that you cannot do something in terms of making yourself successful. If your heart isn't in it, and if you honestly believe that you can get through whatever it is on the other side and be where you want to be, then there's there's there's no reason for you not to do that thing. Because a lot of the times the pressures, whether it be from family, whether it be from society, that you should have to live your life a certain way, you know, w we we all see those old kind of benchmarks crumbling and that the world in which they were constructed in doesn't exist anymore. And so what's great about that is that it's completely left a nice big open canvas for us to rewrite that and to redefine what success is, right? You have one country with the majority of the world who measures GDP and then you have another country in the world, Bhutan, who measures GNP, gross national ⁓ no sorry, g GNH, gross national happiness, right? So, yeah, yeah. So it's like, you know, be be like Bhutan in terms of their gross national happiness. Maybe not in some other aspects, but you know, ⁓ you know, but that but that idea to cut against the grain and to challenge authority and
The Creativity Question: And hooray for Bhutan, I'd say. Yeah. amazing.
Michael Brenner: to challenge the preconceived conceptions that we have, not to assume anything. You're never gonna know everything. To it the the sooner that you accept that and know that and understand that as a as a human being in general, whether it be design or not, it's ⁓ it makes things a lot easier.
The Creativity Question: That's true. And also knowing that even not being perfect is also OK. And you can be happy without being the first in everything. And then before I leave you, tell us where people can find you, Where can they find you? Do have a website? Do you have books coming out or they came out? Anything.
Michael Brenner: Yeah. 'Cause there's no such thing. Yeah. Right. Yeah. So I I I don't I do not have currently have a website. I have a PDF. I have yeah I have a view only I have a view only ⁓ Google Slides that I can link you out to. I have a LinkedIn profile, I have an Instagram profile, ⁓ so I'll send you a bunch of links. But ⁓ if you really want to find me physically, you can find me at the Institute in Bergamo in an 11th century monastery.
The Creativity Question: That's great as well. I mean, what's better than that? Everyone go find Michael in Bergamo in Italy, where he is currently teaching. We will put all his links anyway, sorry, handles ⁓ on the website of the creativity question. And thank you so much, Michael. That was delightful. It was fantastic. Thank you for all this time you dedicated to us.
Michael Brenner: No, thank you so much for for providing the space and this great ⁓ great platform for for everyone to come on and talk about their their ideas and visions of what ⁓ creativity can be.
The Creativity Question: Yes. Thank you so much. I'll see you soon. Thank you.
Michael Brenner: Yes, absolutely. Thank you. Ciao.
The Creativity Question: Hello.