TRANSKRİPT 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:00.160 --> 00:00:05.040
Corporate platforms as they exist today are essentially value capture devices.
00:00:05.200 --> 00:00:09.439
They'd rather be the troll under the bridge than the kid with the lemonade stand.
00:00:24.559 --> 00:00:26.480
Hello and welcome to Tech Won's Save Us.
00:00:26.559 --> 00:00:30.000
I'm your host, Paris Marks, and this week my guest is James Muldoon.
00:00:30.160 --> 00:00:38.079
James is the author of Platform Socialism, How to Reclaim Our Digital Future from Big Tech, and it comes out on January 20th from Pluto Press.
00:00:38.240 --> 00:00:41.039
You can find a link in the show notes if you want to pre-order or buy it.
00:00:41.200 --> 00:00:47.200
He's also a senior lecturer at the University of Exeter and the head of digital research at the Autonomy Think Tank.
00:00:47.359 --> 00:00:52.240
As you can probably guess, our conversation today revolves around James's book, Platform Socialism.
00:00:52.399 --> 00:01:02.960
We dig into the concepts that he discusses in the book and what a better approach to platforms that serves the public good over the profit motive of these major corporations might look like.
00:01:03.200 --> 00:01:20.640
And that involves, you know, a lot of important topics, whether these platforms are really serving the community as they often claim, whether antitrust and competition is the best way to approach this problem, and what dealing with the issue of platforms looks like on several different levels.
00:01:20.799 --> 00:01:44.879
You know, the municipal level and what happens in cities, the national level, and also the international level, recognizing that while many of the platforms that we rely on are based in the United States, just having the US and people in the United States decide what happens with them if they continue to be international is not, you know, an equitable or just approach to the governance of platforms.
00:01:45.200 --> 00:01:48.000
That international question needs to be dealt with.
00:01:48.159 --> 00:01:52.319
So this is a really great conversation, and I really enjoyed James's book.
00:01:52.400 --> 00:01:58.319
I would highly recommend picking it up if you're interested in these topics, which I think many of you will be.
00:01:58.480 --> 00:02:00.799
So definitely consider grabbing a copy.
00:02:01.040 --> 00:02:09.919
Tech Won't Save Us is part of the Harbinger Media Network, a group of left-wing podcasts that are made in Canada, and you can find out more about the other shows in the network by going to HarbingerMediaNetwork.com.
00:02:10.080 --> 00:02:14.159
If you like the show, you can leave a five-star review on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.
00:02:14.240 --> 00:02:18.800
And you can also share the episode on social media or with any friends or colleagues who you think would learn from it.
00:02:18.960 --> 00:02:26.560
And this episode, like every episode of Tech Won's Save Us, is free for everybody because listeners like you support the work that goes into making it every single week.
00:02:26.800 --> 00:02:42.240
So if you want to ensure I can keep having great conversations like this one with James, you can join supporters like JBG and Harry from Brilliant by going to patreon.com slash TechWon't Save Us, where you can become a supporter, join our Discord, get stickers, and help ensure I can keep making the show.
00:02:42.400 --> 00:02:45.039
So with that said, enjoy this week's conversation.
00:02:45.759 --> 00:02:48.080
James, welcome to Tech Won't Save Us.
00:02:48.560 --> 00:02:50.159
Thank you for having me on the podcast.
00:02:50.240 --> 00:02:51.199
I'm a big fan.
00:02:51.280 --> 00:02:58.560
I always listen to and I'm on my morning walk with my Daxons, Karl Barks and Barcas Aurelius, and they're going to be very excited to hear me on the show.
00:02:58.639 --> 00:03:00.000
So I'm looking forward to it.
00:03:00.719 --> 00:03:03.840
I'm looking forward to meeting these Dash Hounds.
00:03:04.000 --> 00:03:06.000
Um I know different pronunciation.
00:03:06.080 --> 00:03:07.280
I'm I'm in North America.
00:03:07.360 --> 00:03:11.039
So the Daxon community is happy with either pronunciation.
00:03:11.280 --> 00:03:12.080
Good, good.
00:03:13.360 --> 00:03:34.319
Um, but you know, you've written this really fantastic book called Platform Socialism that, you know, not only has a critique of these platforms that we use every single day that many of us rely on, but also how, you know, these ideas and how how we approach platforms can be improved for a different kind of society, a socialist society that puts, you know, people before profit.
00:03:34.560 --> 00:03:48.479
And so I am really excited to dig into this with you, but I want to start with some of the criticisms that you make of the platforms themselves and some of the ways, I guess, of seeing them that maybe is not the general discourse that we have around platforms.
00:03:48.639 --> 00:03:55.680
And you write that platforms are not neutral, despite some of the discourses that say that, um, but actually serve to shape the way that we use them.
00:03:55.840 --> 00:04:01.120
By extension, you know, how we live, how we conduct ourselves, the way our society operates to serve their interests.
00:04:01.199 --> 00:04:03.039
You call this a form of world building.
00:04:03.199 --> 00:04:07.759
Can you expand on that and explain why it is important for us to recognize that detail?
00:04:08.080 --> 00:04:14.879
Yeah, so my basic take is that corporate platforms as they exist today are essentially value capture devices.
00:04:15.280 --> 00:04:19.680
Their role is to appropriate the value-creating activity of their users.
00:04:19.839 --> 00:04:24.720
And so the way they do this is often acting as an intermediary or a gatekeeper.
00:04:25.120 --> 00:04:31.120
You know, they'll tell you that they're connecting people, they're bringing people together, building global communities and all that.
00:04:31.360 --> 00:04:38.079
But the
Load full transcript
reality is they've basically decided that they'd rather be the troll under the bridge than the kid with the lemonade stand.
00:04:38.240 --> 00:04:49.519
It's much more profitable for them to let other people do the work and charge them for things like transaction fees or subscription fees, or just like collect their data for advertising products.
00:04:49.680 --> 00:04:56.560
Um and so Brian Chesky, the CEO of Airbnb, has this famous line where he says the community is the product.
00:04:56.959 --> 00:05:04.319
A platform business is about attracting a loyal user base so you can find a way to profit from the things that they're doing.
00:05:04.480 --> 00:05:08.560
I think this value capture mechanism is really central to all of that.
00:05:08.800 --> 00:05:13.279
And so if you think about how platforms operate, there's there's really kind of two main problems.
00:05:13.439 --> 00:05:15.839
There's exploitation and control.
00:05:16.399 --> 00:05:29.839
And the first one is about how value is extracted from communities, and the second one is about how our actions are kind of influenced and controlled by the user interface design and small forms of like digital nudging.
00:05:30.079 --> 00:05:40.800
Um, I think the control element has received far more attention, this idea of like algorithmic management and platforms being designed to promote engagement and attention.
00:05:41.120 --> 00:05:46.720
This is where we can see that they're really not uh neutral technical devices at all, right?
00:05:46.959 --> 00:05:57.600
You know, when when Facebook talks about itself uh and and tries to describe what it's doing, it often alludes to this idea of opening up a space, you know, allowing people to connect.
00:05:57.680 --> 00:06:05.120
And it really gives this impression of neutrality or or it's just this kind of like beneficial party that's connecting people.
00:06:05.279 --> 00:06:12.720
Um and we already know, right, with their ranking algorithms that social media um apps can exercise this control over public debate.
00:06:12.959 --> 00:06:16.800
And it's not always just what the company thinks people want, right?
00:06:16.959 --> 00:06:18.879
Sometimes it's playing an active role in this.
00:06:18.959 --> 00:06:27.680
So Facebook, for example, approved a system called uh Project Amplify, which pushed positive news stories about the companies in users' news feeds.
00:06:27.839 --> 00:06:31.199
Uh and it's not all just about the ranking algorithms either.
00:06:31.360 --> 00:06:39.519
It's really about the entire user interface design that's that's trying to guide people's behavior in certain digital choice environments.
00:06:39.680 --> 00:06:47.920
So there are all these subtle techniques they have about, you know, creating artificial scarcity when you like want to click on a button and it's like, oh, there's only three left.
00:06:48.000 --> 00:07:05.360
You only have X number of seconds to decide, to having certain pre-selected settings on the apps, to creating this like fear of missing out, um, having these exploration cues to kind of keep you interested, staying on the platform, all of these things that is there to try and control our behavior.
00:07:05.600 --> 00:07:14.800
But what I find most interesting isn't really the control element as much as it is the exploitation, because I think ultimately the exploitation is the main game, right?
00:07:14.879 --> 00:07:18.240
How do you extract as much value as possible from users?
00:07:18.399 --> 00:07:22.000
Um and the control part is kind of just like a stepping stone.
00:07:22.160 --> 00:07:27.040
And if they needed to give up on it, but could still maintain the value extraction, then they would.
00:07:27.120 --> 00:07:28.720
And they'd be absolutely fine with that, right?
00:07:28.800 --> 00:07:30.720
Because that's really the main game in town.
00:07:30.879 --> 00:07:32.800
Um so I think there's those two devices.
00:07:32.959 --> 00:07:39.120
And in the book, I use a couple of different frameworks for setting that up, but I'll save that for another question.
00:07:39.519 --> 00:07:40.000
Perfect.
00:07:40.160 --> 00:07:47.920
I think that gives us a great overview of your approach to the platforms, the way that you understand them, looking at them through the lenses of control and exploitation.
00:07:48.079 --> 00:07:56.560
But I want to return to the point about world building just for a second as well, to kind of make a connection to the past that I think is a really important one.
00:07:56.720 --> 00:08:06.959
And you talk about how the Italian autonomous Marxists had a certain way of understanding the role of the factory in the community and how we can see kind of parallels to what the platform economy is doing today.
00:08:07.120 --> 00:08:08.399
Can you expand on that?
00:08:08.720 --> 00:08:17.680
Yeah, so the Italian autonomous Marxists were kind of writing in the 1970s, and one of their big ideas is this idea that you mentioned, the social factory.
00:08:17.839 --> 00:08:28.800
And, you know, writers like Antonio Negri and Maria Rosa della Costa are kind of writing at really one of the early stages of the rise of what used to be called information societies.
00:08:28.959 --> 00:08:31.920
This is kind of like a almost like a pre-internet term, right?
00:08:32.080 --> 00:08:38.240
When people were starting to see the ways computers and other forms of communication technology were changing the world.
00:08:38.559 --> 00:08:49.440
And this idea of a social factory is really thinking about how it's not just the workplace or the factory as the arena in which people are being exploited.
00:08:49.600 --> 00:08:52.480
It's a much broader field of social life.
00:08:52.720 --> 00:09:12.159
So some of the first people to see this are feminists like Della Costa, who really focuses attention on the sphere of reproductive labor, often done by women at home, um, which is also appropriated by capitalism and then at the same time kind of
denied uh existence as a true form of productive work.
00:09:12.320 --> 00:09:23.039
So when you want to look at how the field can be expanded and to think about not just the factory, but really the community who's exploited by capital.
00:09:23.200 --> 00:09:34.960
And I think if you use this as a starting point, you can start to look at how digital communities that exist online are being exploited in kind of some of the similar ways or using a similar framework.
00:09:35.120 --> 00:09:40.799
So it's not necessarily going to be about the old categories that we're used to talking about.
00:09:41.039 --> 00:09:50.559
So if you think back to, for example, like Marx's chapter on the working day in Capital, you know, he talks about how workers' time can be divided into two periods.
00:09:50.639 --> 00:09:59.679
You know, at the start of the day, theoretically, you know, you're working for yourself, you know, in insofar as you get a wage uh and you receive the value that you're producing.
00:09:59.840 --> 00:10:05.039
And then there's a second part, which is kind of, you know, shorter or longer depending on how exploited you are.
00:10:05.120 --> 00:10:10.399
But all this extra value you're producing is effectively just being stolen by your employer.
00:10:10.559 --> 00:10:12.480
This is the kind of idea of surplus value.
00:10:12.559 --> 00:10:17.279
You're kind of working free for someone else and they're just taking the value that you're producing.
00:10:17.519 --> 00:10:22.720
Now, if you think about online communities, it doesn't really make sense to say that they're laboring, right?
00:10:22.799 --> 00:10:26.480
You don't work on Facebook, although, you know, some people run their businesses there.
00:10:26.639 --> 00:10:28.399
People aren't receiving a wage.
00:10:28.559 --> 00:10:33.120
It's not really the same thing, but you can still see this idea of exploitation.
00:10:33.440 --> 00:10:39.840
And I think you can use some of the same ideas and metaphors, but you need to look at it from a different lens.
00:10:40.000 --> 00:10:44.960
And Marx liked to describe capitalism using certain gothic metaphors.
00:10:45.039 --> 00:10:48.080
You know, these are kind of like you find these all through his writings.
00:10:48.159 --> 00:10:59.120
And one of the analogies he uses in this chapter on the working day is that uh he liked to depict capital as like a vampire, you know, sucking value out of workers.
00:10:59.360 --> 00:11:04.000
Now, it's important to remember that the vampire is like dependent on their victim, right?
00:11:04.159 --> 00:11:12.799
So many of the platforms exist in order to extract value from communities, but the communities are also their main source of profit.
00:11:13.039 --> 00:11:25.519
I think this perspective is really important because even though these companies have huge market valuations, they've got this huge political power, the platforms are often little more than software through which we connect with others.
00:11:25.600 --> 00:11:32.799
And the real source of value, I think, is in our activity, is in that the kinds of social activity we have with each other.
00:11:32.960 --> 00:11:35.840
And we need to know that we could connect in other ways.
00:11:36.080 --> 00:11:38.799
We could connect through other systems and devices.
00:11:39.039 --> 00:11:52.080
And so, really, this idea of the power of our communities and the power of our social activities is a reminder that we can use this to reclaim ownership and control over the technology and to repurpose it for our own use.
00:11:52.559 --> 00:12:21.360
When you were talking about the Italian Autonomous Marxists and the social factory, what came to mind for me was Henry Ford in, I believe it would have been around the 1920s, when there's actually like a department of the Ford Corporation that's trying to shape the way that workers live, promoting certain means of dress, certain um types of living environments, promoting for them to have a particular type of home, to live in a certain way, like, you know, trying to shape the society that is around the factory.
00:12:21.440 --> 00:12:27.120
And so that is something that really resonated to me and that it reminded me of as I was reading that section of the book.
00:12:27.360 --> 00:12:39.440
But I think what you're talking about there, in terms of the way that community and the way that our interactions on these platforms create the value, reminds me of something else that you wrote in the book about community washing, right?
00:12:39.600 --> 00:12:49.120
The way that these platforms act like communities or say that they are promoting community when really they are taking advantage of it and using it for branding purposes.
00:12:49.440 --> 00:12:49.679
Yeah.
00:12:49.840 --> 00:13:03.519
So one of the stories I tell in the book is how from about 2015, 2016 onwards, at the beginning of what's now called the tech clash, a lot of these platforms start to pitch themselves as global community builders.
00:13:03.840 --> 00:13:05.679
Trump has a lot to do with this, right?
00:13:05.840 --> 00:13:25.039
And broader kind of the rise of populism and this broader shift in politics, where you start to see a little bit of left versus right and a little bit more of like open versus closed societies, you know, various ways in which people are trying to like rebrand politics and pitch new kinds of movements and new kinds of parties.
00:13:25.120 --> 00:13:43.679
And amidst all of this stuff that's going around, this real seismic shift, like Facebook in particular, Airbnb is falling not far behind, but they really start to promote this feel-good story of how they're going to be, you know, global leaders in creating these new forms of tech-enabled social life.
00:13:43.919 --> 00:13:59.440
And so this idea of like community washing is a kind of concept I talk about in the book to show how these companies use a marketing strategy of framing their business through the
language of community empowerment and fulfilling a social mission.
00:13:59.600 --> 00:14:07.679
Um, I think the reality, on the other hand, is that the very infrastructure that the companies are developing is designed to be as extractive as possible.
00:14:07.840 --> 00:14:14.639
It's designed to feed off communities, often with very little concern for the very communities that they're claiming to serve.
00:14:14.799 --> 00:14:34.960
So I think what you really see is this entirely cynical PR campaign that in reality is just this post hoc rationalization of what the company's doing and a kind of polish of the image of the company to really just try to recreate, I sense, a new purpose in the public's mind for what the company is about.
00:14:35.120 --> 00:14:45.360
Um I think it's really relevant that these stories of what the company is purportedly doing, their mission, are developed years after the founding of the company, right?
00:14:45.519 --> 00:14:51.200
So it's almost like the stories are developed in response to PR backlashes.
00:14:51.360 --> 00:15:00.240
The stories are developed as a way of basically glossing over what begins to look like very extractive forms of business models.
00:15:00.480 --> 00:15:04.240
I wrote this in, it was probably like 2019 when I actually wrote most of this book.
00:15:04.320 --> 00:15:07.200
So it's kind of at the end of what people are now calling web two.
00:15:07.440 --> 00:15:20.000
And I think this lens of community is only becoming more and more relevant given all of the more recent transformations about web 3 and the metaverse, because you can just see all the language coming up again.
00:15:20.240 --> 00:15:22.159
Oh, we're gonna decentralize communities.
00:15:22.240 --> 00:15:24.399
Oh, we're gonna, we're gonna empower users.
00:15:24.639 --> 00:15:27.120
And it's like, mate, did you remember Web 2?
00:15:27.360 --> 00:15:29.440
That's exactly what they told us the first time.
00:15:29.600 --> 00:15:31.679
This like, do you remember the sharing economy?
00:15:31.840 --> 00:15:33.279
Who's sharing stuff anymore?
00:15:33.360 --> 00:15:34.240
It's madness.
00:15:34.399 --> 00:15:36.320
So I think I'm kind of glad I write it.
00:15:36.399 --> 00:15:41.440
At first I thought it was going out of fashion because all these new kinds of ways of describing tech started coming up.
00:15:41.519 --> 00:15:46.080
But then thank you, Web3, community's back, and I think it's it's become relevant again.
00:15:46.960 --> 00:15:53.679
I think we can see like these narratives are are continually recycled to promote technology again and again.
00:15:53.840 --> 00:16:04.639
And we have a tendency to forget, you know, the promises that were made in the past and how they were broken effectively, and as you say, were more marketing tools than anything real.
00:16:04.960 --> 00:16:32.399
You know, I wonder if you also think that the desire to frame technology and you know, these platforms in particular, but you could you
could talk more broadly, as you were just saying, um, around community is also a response to, I think, a general kind of public feeling that community has eroded in the sense that people are more individualistic, that communities have been atomized after, you know, years of suburbanization and and other kind of trends in society.
00:16:32.639 --> 00:16:44.879
You know, I think we can see with the way of life that neoliberalism has promoted that, you know, is so focused on work, so focused on the individual, that there's kind of this erosion of social relationships that people have.
00:16:45.120 --> 00:16:54.159
And I wonder if the the technology companies are recognizing that and then saying, oh, look, our platforms are providing this community that you're missing in the rest of your life.
00:16:54.240 --> 00:17:02.240
So just come to us and we'll provide it, even though that is not in reality what they're doing, but they're benefiting from claiming that they're filling that void.
00:17:02.559 --> 00:17:02.799
Yeah.
00:17:02.879 --> 00:17:05.680
I mean, I think you've already hit the nail on the head with that one, right?
00:17:05.839 --> 00:17:08.240
Um, it's it's completely what's happening.
00:17:08.400 --> 00:17:24.960
And it really was about flipping the script because it's it's not something you really hear anymore, precisely because so many people's lives are spent online so much, and so much of what we consider community today is with, you know, our Twitter friends or whoever it is that we are, you know, connecting with.
00:17:25.200 --> 00:17:36.000
But like much early, you know, like over 10 years ago, there was this real moral panic that that the more people spent their lives on computers, the the less social they would be.
00:17:36.079 --> 00:17:37.279
They would become outcasts, right?
00:17:37.359 --> 00:17:45.359
Like remember the comic book guy on The Simpsons, like of that era, like being into computers and stuff like that, was kind of considered a little bit antisocial.
00:17:45.599 --> 00:17:56.000
And so I think this idea of like showing how technology enables new forms of community was very much about trying to have a new um PR angle.
00:17:56.160 --> 00:18:07.440
But I also think it raises a very interesting question of how do real life communities, many of which are online, actually regain control over the kinds of tech products they use?
00:18:07.519 --> 00:18:18.799
And I think this really opens up some quite difficult but very pressing um questions about, you know, what are online communities, how are they formed, what kinds of user groups do they have?
00:18:18.960 --> 00:18:42.240
What kinds of rights could communities be given over, let's say, the platforms they use or other services and goods that they use, what boundaries those communities have, whether there are kind of different tiers of like should developers have more power than ordinary users, should there be kind of people who use it every day versus people who use it, you know, once a year, raises a lot of questions about that as well.
00:18:42.559 --> 00:18:47.759
And, you know, I think that question leads really well into another topic that I wanted to explore, right?
00:18:47.839 --> 00:18:58.240
Because in the book you talk about how there's a lot of discussion around worker control of platforms or full nationalization of platforms, but each of those approaches has its own issues, right?
00:18:58.319 --> 00:19:04.319
It is not fully the solution to potentially what we would want to see happen with these platforms.
00:19:04.400 --> 00:19:12.960
Um, and you provide the framework of guild socialism as something that could potentially provide a response to this or or a means to approach platforms.
00:19:13.119 --> 00:19:20.000
So, can you talk about how you see the means of how we would retake control of these platforms and what might be the best way to structure it?
00:19:20.400 --> 00:19:24.480
So this is kind of like a pretty difficult multi-part question, basically.
00:19:24.720 --> 00:19:29.279
I want to talk about guild socialism because that's really central to my whole approach.
00:19:29.359 --> 00:19:36.799
And then after I, there's a little bit of a historical detour, I'm gonna then get back to how it might apply to some of these, you know, pressing questions today.
00:19:37.039 --> 00:19:38.079
That sounds good to me.
00:19:38.319 --> 00:19:47.839
Yeah, well, one of the main contributions of the book is to, you know, revive the ideas of guild socialism and uh one guy in particular, a guy called G.
00:19:48.000 --> 00:19:48.160
D.
00:19:48.240 --> 00:19:48.400
H.
00:19:48.559 --> 00:19:48.960
Cole.
00:19:49.359 --> 00:19:59.920
And I think he really provides some interesting ways for us to rethink digital platforms and how we could democratize platforms, how we could foster, you know, new forms of decentralized governance.
00:20:00.160 --> 00:20:02.160
So Cole was a guild socialist.
00:20:02.319 --> 00:20:16.400
He, you know, is around during the late 19th and early 20th century, and he was a member of the Fabian Society, which is a British socialist organization that helped found the Labour Party, among other things, and they founded the LSE, the London School of Economics.
00:20:16.559 --> 00:20:21.440
Um, and they were really a huge force on the left in the UK at the time.
00:20:21.599 --> 00:20:30.000
And Cole became a critic of the Fabian's tendency to think in terms of top-down and state-led forms of nationalization.
00:20:30.160 --> 00:20:41.599
So the Fabians being the kind of progressive left-wing society that they were, were very much in favor of ways in which the public could take control of, you know, forms of enterprises and services.
00:20:41.759 --> 00:20:50.720
Um, and Cole occupies a kind of more, slightly more libertarian, slight, slightly more decentralized position within the sphere of the left.
00:20:50.799 --> 00:20:59.599
Uh, and he thought that the Fabians lacked
what he considered forms of self-government in the workplace, or we might talk about local forms of decision making.
00:20:59.759 --> 00:21:10.880
So, how we could actually empower people uh in their workplaces and in their municipalities that weren't solely thinking of socialism in terms of state-led nationalization.
00:21:11.359 --> 00:21:17.200
And so this is a kind of minor tendency on the left, particularly in the UK at the time.
00:21:17.279 --> 00:21:21.359
Um, and you you might be able to call this like an associational socialism.
00:21:21.519 --> 00:21:25.920
I think I use the term associational democracy in the book, but I mean the same thing by both.
00:21:26.079 --> 00:21:41.599
And I think what Cole is really interested in doing is thinking about how we could create a more participatory society, how we could create organizations and institutions that themselves have an internal democratic structure, right?
00:21:41.759 --> 00:21:51.200
So, how do we have these kinds of you know, associations that have their own representatives that give people a say in how um social life is organized?
00:21:51.359 --> 00:22:01.920
And so think of things like you know, museums, art galleries, universities, schools, churches, all these organizations that might make up very Various aspects of different people's life.
00:22:02.079 --> 00:22:11.039
And the thing that makes this for Cole an associational socialism is that the role of the state is vastly decreased.
00:22:11.200 --> 00:22:32.160
And that it's reduced to really just a coordinating institution such that the way in which we live our lives becomes much more dependent on these kind of meso-level associations, maybe producer associations, workplaces, local municipal associations that might be run by councils or regional or state level authorities.
00:22:32.400 --> 00:22:36.880
And so it's really about trying to create these more participatory structures.
00:22:37.039 --> 00:22:38.960
This is really what Cole is getting at.
00:22:39.039 --> 00:22:55.920
And it's this kind of like much more federalist, much more local alternative on the left that isn't really given as much airtime today because the centralizing tendencies, both within the British Labour Party and within the left more generally, really won out.
00:22:56.079 --> 00:23:03.119
And so it's interesting to kind of go back and look to some of these more forgotten ways of thinking about organizing social life.
00:23:03.279 --> 00:23:05.039
So that's kind of this is the coal.
00:23:05.200 --> 00:23:07.200
How do you bring coal to the digital sphere?
00:23:07.279 --> 00:23:11.440
Because one of the chapters is called Guild Socialism for the Digital Economy.
00:23:11.599 --> 00:23:13.279
And it looks like a bit of a joke, right?
00:23:13.359 --> 00:23:17.680
Because guilds are these like weird medieval institutions for organizing workers.
00:23:17.759 --> 00:23:21.519
And what could that have to say about, you know, politics or digital life today?
00:23:21.759 --> 00:23:29.279
Well, we could think about the way in which digital platforms act as associations that bring these communities together.
00:23:29.519 --> 00:23:49.200
And of course, there's going to be a diverse range of communities, but what Cole would kind of want us to do is looking at the function that the community performs and thinking about how we can democratize platforms and how we can build these democratic structures to reflect the role that the platforms play.
00:23:49.359 --> 00:23:52.319
So, how can we empower communities of users?
00:23:52.400 --> 00:24:13.039
Um, and how can we do so by thinking about a different approach to governance and thinking about how we can cultivate alternative ecosystems of digital platforms, ways in which ownership of the platform could be distributed amongst its members and how governance could actually be changed to reflect this too.
00:24:13.200 --> 00:24:21.920
And there are aspects of this that do actually start sounding a lot like some of the things that the advocates of Web3 are talking about, right?
00:24:22.000 --> 00:24:25.920
Like I've had people write to me and say, oh, this, you know, sounds a lot like a DAO.
00:24:26.000 --> 00:24:28.799
It sounds a lot like this Web3 project I have.
00:24:28.960 --> 00:24:30.720
And I think there are overlaps here.
00:24:30.799 --> 00:24:40.160
I think when you talk about the kind of left tradition in socialism, and by that I mean like the more slightly more libertarian, slightly more federalist tradition.
00:24:40.319 --> 00:24:44.000
Um, I think there are some overlaps, but I think context is everything, right?
00:24:44.079 --> 00:24:48.319
It, you know, decentralization isn't a kind of end in itself.
00:24:48.480 --> 00:24:50.000
And Cole never thought that.
00:24:50.240 --> 00:24:57.039
Like his idea wasn't to get rid of the state because he thought uh that that would instantly lead to a better society.
00:24:57.200 --> 00:24:59.200
That's not not going to be the case at all.
00:24:59.440 --> 00:25:04.720
The idea for him was to empower individuals to have more control over their lives.
00:25:04.880 --> 00:25:15.680
And the best way to do this, he thought, was through these local communities, through these associations that would give them voice and give them power through collective forms of organizing.
00:25:16.079 --> 00:25:24.799
I think that's a really good description of you know guild socialism and trying to extend those concepts to today, to the digital platforms that we're dealing with.
00:25:24.960 --> 00:25:52.000
And, you know, I think that in making that description, you kind of illustrate how this more associational, um participatory means of governing these platforms would be preferred in your perspective rather than like a full nationalization controlled by a state bureaucracy or just simply worker control fully instead of having, you know, other stakeholders or people who um are involved in the use of the platform
involved in that democratic governance as well.
00:25:52.160 --> 00:26:04.559
I wonder though, you know, you talked about how Cole really kind of sees guild socialism as something that reduces the role of the state and focuses it on these really kind of local associational groups.
00:26:04.799 --> 00:26:08.480
What role do you see for the state in creating a platform socialism?
00:26:08.559 --> 00:26:14.640
And do you think that we need to go so far as what Cole is talking about in moving to such a local level?
00:26:14.960 --> 00:26:17.039
This raises some really interesting questions.
00:26:17.200 --> 00:26:22.240
So Cole at the beginning of the 20th century is a really big critic of the state, right?
00:26:22.400 --> 00:26:31.359
But I don't think we need to necessarily adapt everything that he said word for word for how we should treat digital platforms today.
00:26:31.599 --> 00:26:41.920
The approach of platform socialism is to think about the complex ecosystem of various forms of alternative ownership that needs to exist in the platform economy.
00:26:42.079 --> 00:27:00.480
So we need to think of platforms that are that are most suitable to kind of be owned by workers at a very local level, right up to national and international platforms that only really make sense as the function that they perform is one that necessarily needs to be at a much broader scale.
00:27:00.720 --> 00:27:05.839
And so here I talk in the book about using the principle of subsidiarity.
00:27:06.000 --> 00:27:15.759
You know, platforms should be owned and operated at the most local and proximate level that would enable them to carry out their services in a kind of efficient and sustainable way.
00:27:16.000 --> 00:27:18.720
So we need to think about the question of scale.
00:27:18.960 --> 00:27:21.680
So I'm not necessarily anti-nationalization.
00:27:21.759 --> 00:27:27.759
I just think it makes sense to look at different platforms from a different perspective depending on what they're doing.
00:27:27.920 --> 00:27:39.039
So I really think we need to get over this kind of binary framework of either state ownership on the one hand or solely workers' cooperatives or worker-owned platforms on the other.
00:27:39.200 --> 00:27:41.599
I think there are many different types of communities.
00:27:41.759 --> 00:27:44.480
They have different structures, they serve different purposes.
00:27:44.640 --> 00:27:52.640
And so one of the reasons I drew on what many people consider to be the pluralist socialist tradition of people like G.D.
00:27:52.799 --> 00:27:52.880
H.
00:27:52.960 --> 00:28:01.920
Cole and another author that I mentioned in the book called Otto Neurat, is that they don't necessarily reduce things to this one size fits all model.
00:28:02.079 --> 00:28:11.279
And there's a degree of tolerance to different ways of organizing associations, and there's this real emphasis on this ecosystem of alternative uh models.
00:28:11.440 --> 00:28:13.519
So, how do we think about that in practice?
00:28:13.680 --> 00:28:23.279
So I think for some of the smaller platforms, we could imagine things like a courier service or a domestic cleaning service or something that's, you know, really location-based.
00:28:23.359 --> 00:28:24.720
It's done in a local level.
00:28:24.960 --> 00:28:29.200
We can kind of imagine that being carried out by like a platform cooperative.
00:28:29.359 --> 00:28:38.799
So by workers owning a platform, um, democratically running it together, and kind of offering their services to a local neighborhood or a city, right?
00:28:38.960 --> 00:28:45.759
But there are some other platforms that it would be really hard to run as workers' cooperatives or sometimes unfair, right?
00:28:46.160 --> 00:28:52.960
Because they're not just about organizing the activities of a small group of people that are offering really discrete services.
00:28:53.200 --> 00:28:58.079
Sometimes platforms, firstly, they require a lot of investment and digital infrastructure.
00:28:58.240 --> 00:29:13.119
So this might be software, it might be, you know, data centers, or it might be big infrastructure like uh, for example, a ride hail service might require things like, you know, ownership of the cars or like the, you know, very complex software to run the system.
00:29:13.359 --> 00:29:27.680
And so in these kinds of instances, it might make more sense for a municipality or a city to kind of administer that service and maybe even in the case of ride hails to integrate it more properly into a public transport system, right?
00:29:27.839 --> 00:29:34.400
So, you know, obviously ride hail and cars are, you know, environmentally unsustainable and there are a lot of problems with that.
00:29:34.640 --> 00:29:48.720
Perhaps it would be good if such a service had to exist at all for it to kind of be shown to operate alongside and as a public transport system to kind of supplement more sustainable forms of transport.
00:29:48.880 --> 00:30:00.559
Anyway, the so the goal of the transformation is to organize platforms more democratically so that you can look at the function of the platform and then look at the kind of democratic structure that would be best suited to it.
00:30:00.720 --> 00:30:17.119
And I think the following cole in the turn towards a more local level is really just following this insight that that many democratic theorists have had, which is democracy operates most effectively at what kind of looks like the level of the city.
00:30:17.359 --> 00:30:24.319
It doesn't always make sense for services to be to you know run on a global scale or even a national one.
00:30:24.559 --> 00:30:27.839
But you did mention, you know, what is the role of the state in all of this?
00:30:27.920 --> 00:30:30.640
Now, I think we have to be a bit more realistic about this.
00:30:30.880 --> 00:30:39.519
Part of what I was doing in the book was kind of really sketching a vision for what the platform economy could look like if
organized in a more democratic way.
00:30:39.680 --> 00:30:54.319
But looking at the transition towards that, I think we can't neglect the important role of the state and what kind of role that would have to play, both in terms of like regulating platforms, but probably funding and setting up alternatives.
00:30:54.559 --> 00:31:10.240
I think that's when the small anarchist sitting on one shoulder has to give way to the small social democrat sitting on my other shoulder and say that there is still an important role for the state to play in these, but the final result will depend a lot on the kind of platform you have in mind.
00:31:10.720 --> 00:31:13.920
Making that distinction between the type of platforms is really important, right?
00:31:14.079 --> 00:31:38.720
Because we can see how some platforms would work a lot better if they are managed on the local level because local governments and cities are going to have a lot of impact on how they work and the people who use them, whereas there's other platforms that might make sense to exist on a more national level or regional level, even if they still have those kind of impacts and there can be that kind of like discourse between the different levels and whatnot.
00:31:38.880 --> 00:32:00.480
Um, I want to come back to the point on the role of kind of municipal governments and what this can look like on the municipal level, because where you did end by talking about the state there, I did also want to get to the question of regulation and what the approach should be, because obviously there's this larger conversation that's happening now around antitrust, around competition policy, around breaking up big tech.
00:32:00.559 --> 00:32:18.799
And I wonder what you think is the best approach in approaching these platforms through that lens and whether it is simply, you know, to break up these big companies and just have a bunch of smaller ones competing against one another, or whether we should look at the regulatory approaches to tech platforms in a different kind of way.
00:32:19.279 --> 00:32:32.000
So I think the question of regulation is really important and it's really become the kind of dominant framework, at least at a governmental level, of how we imagine our criticisms of big tech companies.
00:32:32.240 --> 00:32:43.599
And so both, you know, here in the UK and in the US, the government response is really centered around um trying to combat these anti-competitive practices of big tech.
00:32:43.759 --> 00:33:00.400
So Elizabeth Warren's phrase of like breaking up big tech, um, this idea of tightening their role as these um gatekeepers of digital markets, both in the EU and also in the US, there has been this kind of focus on regulations and on anti-competitive practices.
00:33:00.480 --> 00:33:08.079
Now, I think we should look at this, at least those of us on the left, with some hope and some skepticism.
00:33:08.319 --> 00:33:11.839
Basically, I think there's uh an essential point of truth here.
00:33:11.920 --> 00:33:14.880
You know, the the companies clearly do need more regulation.
00:33:15.119 --> 00:33:23.920
We need to prevent them from abusing their power as gatekeepers, from um stifling competition, from just buying up, you know, competitors.
00:33:24.079 --> 00:33:26.480
All of this is kind of pointing in the right direction.
00:33:26.720 --> 00:33:35.440
But at the same time, I think we need to realize that getting a more perfectly functioning market economy is not the end goal of people on the left, right?
00:33:35.599 --> 00:33:38.319
It's like there's a kind of elective affinity there.
00:33:38.400 --> 00:33:42.880
There's a way in which we can form alliances with liberals on these questions.
00:33:43.119 --> 00:33:55.920
But I think at the end of the day, uh we need to think of, you know, public and commons-based um forms of providing digital services that don't necessarily reduce everything to forms of market logic.
00:33:56.079 --> 00:34:26.000
And I think ultimately that is one of my emerging criticisms of some of the Web3 discourse, that at the basis of some of these web three solutions is this idea that you just start inserting digital tokens into online communities, Bitcoin, other forms of currency, and that eventually, you know, it will generate the right incentives within the system for a more broadly defined group of users to profit from what's going on.
00:34:26.159 --> 00:34:37.440
But I think this really, you know, as you yourself have pointed out in one of your articles, this really risks just extending these processes of commodification further into our digital lives, right?
00:34:37.599 --> 00:34:52.960
I think the best traditions that we can draw on are all those, you know, groups and movements that that promoted the free and open use of software that didn't have these kinds of market economies at their basis, that they weren't for-profit businesses.
00:34:53.199 --> 00:35:07.760
They were people that were trying to develop tools for humanity, that they wanted people to be able to have free access to this, that you know, the information and and the kind of services that are available should be there for anyone to use.
00:35:07.920 --> 00:35:19.519
And so I think this antitrust agenda should have our support to a degree, but we also need to know that it's not about creating more property or more personal property rights around data.
00:35:19.679 --> 00:35:26.719
It should be about finding non-commodified ways of opening up these services and these tools to the public.
00:35:27.280 --> 00:35:29.280
Obviously, I completely agree with that.
00:35:29.599 --> 00:35:32.719
I've just put your article at you, so you can't disagree with it.
00:35:32.960 --> 00:35:34.880
You're like, well, you contradict yourself.
00:35:35.840 --> 00:35:39.360
And, you know, you also have a recent article about Web3 and Jacobin.
00:35:39.519 --> 00:35:43.119
And so I will link that in the show notes so um people can go
check it out.
00:35:43.440 --> 00:35:44.480
Good luck, my man.
00:35:45.280 --> 00:35:46.000
You're welcome.
00:35:46.159 --> 00:35:46.880
You're welcome.
00:35:47.119 --> 00:35:49.280
Um, but I think it's a really good point.
00:35:49.360 --> 00:36:18.719
And, you know, sometimes I worry that the antitrust discourse being too focused on competition and the competitive lens is distracting from these kind of more commons-based or public solutions to the problem by framing everything through the lens of competition instead of recognizing that, you know, as you were talking about with how maybe things need to look differently on different levels and kind of if we're thinking about things through a platform socialist lens, that different platforms are going to need different forms of organization.
00:36:18.880 --> 00:36:28.960
That again, like the universal solution to problems that we have with platforms today is not just to make them all more competitive, but it will require a whole range of different solutions.
00:36:29.119 --> 00:36:32.880
And one of the ones that you propose as well is public utility regulation.
00:36:33.039 --> 00:36:36.800
And I wonder why you think that is probably an approach that needs to be looked at.
00:36:37.280 --> 00:36:44.159
The framework of public utilities gives you one important way to think about how platforms could be organized.
00:36:44.400 --> 00:36:53.360
The story I tell in the book is thinking about how private companies can essentially be taken over and converted into public platforms.
00:36:53.599 --> 00:36:59.920
For me, the real level at which it's best to think about this is on the level of the municipality.
00:37:00.159 --> 00:37:06.000
People often look to kind of like much older models, so, you know, like Cybus in Chile.
00:37:06.239 --> 00:37:20.960
But I think when you start to turn to more recent models, the most exciting kind of prototypes that have been developed, the most exciting experiments that we have are things like the Dcode project, you know, in Barcelona and Amsterdam that was run partly by Francesca Bria.
00:37:21.360 --> 00:37:25.599
So D-code stands for decentralized citizen-owned data ecosystems.
00:37:25.679 --> 00:37:31.599
It's a bit of a mouthful, but it's essentially about finding ways in which you can create new forms of data commons, right?
00:37:31.840 --> 00:37:37.679
Finding ways in which you can use a city's sensor network to kind of serve the public good.
00:37:38.000 --> 00:37:53.920
And so I think this is really where you start to think about public services that are using the same technology that some of these private companies are doing, but that are doing so in different ways and that aligned with citizens' interests, that are privacy protecting.
00:37:54.000 --> 00:37:59.039
Um, and you can see how a different use of this technology could begin to emerge, right?
00:37:59.119 --> 00:38:15.679
Because I think one of the tricks of the tech companies is to create the
tools in a certain way and to deploy them in a certain way where it looks like all of the negative externalities of them running as a capitalist enterprise are somehow natural byproducts of the tech itself.
00:38:15.840 --> 00:38:17.599
But technology is a tool, right?
00:38:17.679 --> 00:38:20.480
It doesn't necessarily have to run in a particular way.
00:38:20.559 --> 00:38:28.000
And I think some of these municipal alternatives are really good because they start to show you that you can create public benefit from the tech.
00:38:28.400 --> 00:38:42.320
And when you're thinking about the politics of some of these projects, you can start to look at the new municipalism movement that has kind of built up around the fearless cities network that was first held in Barcelona in 2017.
00:38:42.480 --> 00:38:50.719
And I think what's important about this is that it's not just about devolving power, it's not just about decentralizing power.
00:38:50.880 --> 00:38:54.639
It's also trying to intervene in how this power operates.
00:38:54.719 --> 00:39:01.920
And to think about the question of democracy, because things happening on a local level is not necessarily an end in itself.
00:39:02.000 --> 00:39:05.119
It's not necessarily going to lead to more just outcomes.
00:39:05.280 --> 00:39:10.559
It's really thinking about how democracy can operate better at this local level.
00:39:10.800 --> 00:39:13.039
And I think the politics is really important.
00:39:13.199 --> 00:39:33.760
So when you think about the decode pilots that happened, um, they happened on the back of a socialist being elected to the municipal government and a socialist platform that started using this tech through platforms like DeCidim to ask the people and to create a more participatory environment, ask people what do you want us to do on this municipal level?
00:39:33.840 --> 00:39:43.440
And the tech both enabled those new forms of democratic participation, but then was also deployed to think about how new forms of data commons could be created.
00:39:43.920 --> 00:39:54.559
I'm really happy that you brought up the new municipalist example, you know, that you gave in the book, because I think it does provide a good way to look at these issues and to think about how tech can be used in a different way.
00:39:54.719 --> 00:40:02.320
And I'll also note that there was a really good interview with Francesca Bria in uh the crypto syllabus recently that I'll link in the show notes for listeners as well.
00:40:02.480 --> 00:40:07.440
Um, I have two more questions for you that I want to explore before we end our conversation.
00:40:07.679 --> 00:40:09.519
The first is around search engines.
00:40:09.760 --> 00:40:10.800
I don't even know how to put it.
00:40:10.880 --> 00:40:19.360
Like Google just has so much power over everything that we do, and that really comes from its control over search, like one of these kind of fundamental tools of the internet itself.
00:40:19.440 --> 00:40:27.920
Um, and that has allowed it to expand into so many different areas and to get a ton of control over the internet, even including infrastructural aspects of it.
00:40:28.159 --> 00:40:47.679
In the book, you suggest that we should look at having a public search engine that would be oriented in a different way instead of to serve the interest that Google has, its profit, its continued control over the internet itself, but to instead encourage and show and demonstrate different values in how it is put together and managed.
00:40:47.840 --> 00:40:50.480
And so I wonder, you know, this is kind of a two-part question.
00:40:50.639 --> 00:40:56.000
What do you think a public search engine would look like and why do you think that is important?
00:40:56.239 --> 00:41:07.679
And secondly, do you think it is better to look at that as something that we need to build from scratch or where we kind of take over Google and reorient Google toward a public purpose?
00:41:08.159 --> 00:41:19.119
An internet search engine and a social media platform, I think are two of the platforms that I look at in the book that you just can't see them running, you know, as workers' cooperatives.
00:41:19.199 --> 00:41:23.199
And indeed, I think it wouldn't be good for them to run as workers' cooperatives.
00:41:23.280 --> 00:41:24.400
And I'll get to the Google.
00:41:24.480 --> 00:41:26.880
I'm just gonna have this like long lead-up to it.
00:41:26.960 --> 00:41:39.840
But one of the critiques of workers' cooperatives, at least within the socialist tradition, is that it's very hard using that structure to allow the broader community's voices and their interests to be taken into account, right?
00:41:40.000 --> 00:41:44.880
So let's say we get Google and we hand it over to its whatever, 100,000 employees.
00:41:45.119 --> 00:41:51.599
That's great for them as individuals, but it's not necessarily going to create the democratic structures for the community.
00:41:51.679 --> 00:41:57.519
And indeed, with Google, right, it's the international community to be able to have control over how it operates.
00:41:57.679 --> 00:42:04.960
And so I think you need to start looking at examples of services that are operated at the international level.
00:42:05.199 --> 00:42:13.039
And I think it should be a shock to all of us that we can't access the world's information through a public not-for-profit foundation, right?
00:42:13.119 --> 00:42:22.559
I think that's just insane that we have something like Wikipedia and we can see how good it is and how necessary and important that kind of a platform is.
00:42:22.719 --> 00:42:31.760
And then we can just say, oh, but it's fine that there's this company that's just harvesting all our data and organizing all our access to the world's knowledge.
00:42:31.920 --> 00:42:43.039
So I think when you're looking at a public search engine, the overriding principle is that it should be free, accessible for all to use, and it shouldn't be trying to turn a
quick buck from us.
00:42:43.119 --> 00:42:49.519
So I think something like a foundation, I think is probably the best option that you have for this.
00:42:49.760 --> 00:42:56.239
And I'm freely admit, at the international level, how do you democratize anything becomes an incredibly difficult question, right?
00:42:56.320 --> 00:43:01.039
So I don't think there's any like knockdown answers that fully rule out other possibilities.
00:43:01.199 --> 00:43:06.480
But I think something like a foundation is one way in which something like Google could be organized.
00:43:06.719 --> 00:43:20.719
Now, in the case of Google, I think just looking at their dominant market share and how much control they have over the search market, I suggest in the book that you should transform Google itself into a not-for-profit foundation.
00:43:20.880 --> 00:43:22.800
And that might be a bit controversial.
00:43:22.880 --> 00:43:26.800
Um, well, I mean, it is, it's kind of a mad idea uh at its basis.
00:43:27.039 --> 00:43:35.199
But I think really if you try to create a complete alternative, history has shown there'll be really hard to get user adoption, right?
00:43:35.360 --> 00:43:39.280
There are heaps of alternatives, some of them good, some of them not so good.
00:43:39.519 --> 00:43:46.719
But look at the struggle of DuckDuckGo, and you can see how difficult it is for people to kind of get up in that space.
00:43:46.880 --> 00:43:53.760
Now, I think if you converted it into a not for profit foundation, you would change certain aspects of how the service operated.
00:43:53.920 --> 00:43:57.679
Essentially, you would completely eliminate their advertising function, right?
00:43:57.760 --> 00:43:59.760
You you wouldn't need to run ads because.
00:44:00.159 --> 00:44:02.559
You wouldn't be running it as a for-profit service.
00:44:02.719 --> 00:44:04.960
That raises the question of how it'd be funded.
00:44:05.280 --> 00:44:11.519
I kind of talk about a few options in the book about, you know, global digital wealth fund, similar to like Norway or Australia.
00:44:11.760 --> 00:44:16.880
I talk about maybe having a levy on some of the big tech companies to kind of start it off.
00:44:17.119 --> 00:44:24.960
I float the possibility that might be somehow attached as an independent agency of the UN, similar to like the ILO or something like that.
00:44:25.119 --> 00:44:26.480
So there are a few different options.
00:44:26.639 --> 00:44:29.360
I think a lot of them could could potentially work.
00:44:29.599 --> 00:44:51.599
But essentially such a public search engine, I think, is if you turn Google into a foundation, you eliminate the advertising arm, what you end up seeing is something that I think would look quite similar to Wikipedia, at least in terms of its purpose of providing a service to people in terms of allowing them access to the world's knowledge.
00:44:52.239 --> 00:44:54.639
The idea of a public search engine is fantastic.
00:44:54.800 --> 00:44:58.239
And
I want to ask a quick follow-up, I guess, to that response.
00:44:58.480 --> 00:45:16.719
One of the things that I worry about when we talk about taking like a Facebook or a Google into public ownership and reorienting it is that over a couple decades now, these companies have basically built up a certain infrastructure and a certain way of developing their platforms.
00:45:16.880 --> 00:45:29.360
And I wonder if you worry it would be difficult to fully reorient them toward a public purpose after having different incentives kind of baked into their construction and their code over the course of such a long period.
00:45:29.679 --> 00:45:31.519
Yeah, it's a huge concern, right?
00:45:31.599 --> 00:45:37.920
And this kind of concern is what has worried leftists about taking over any kind of power in society, right?
00:45:38.079 --> 00:45:41.119
Like that's the problem of the civil service or the bureaucracy.
00:45:41.199 --> 00:45:42.400
That's the problem of the army.
00:45:42.480 --> 00:45:43.840
That's the problem of the state.
00:45:44.159 --> 00:46:06.320
Anytime you talk about trying to claim power, trying to retake public institutions, trying to re-orient them towards a different purpose, it becomes a very tricky question of what elements of that can be retrained or recoded or redesigned, and which elements would serve as a fundamental barrier to any kind of change.
00:46:06.480 --> 00:46:13.199
And we talked about that during the Corbyn era when it looked like labor might be, you know, close to an electoral victory.
00:46:13.360 --> 00:46:15.599
You know, many leftist groups have talked about that.
00:46:15.840 --> 00:46:29.519
I don't think I'm the right person to know conclusively, you know, whether the case of Google, you know, how it would go, but I think you framed the problem correctly in that, well, it's a very valid argument to say burn it all down.
00:46:29.599 --> 00:46:32.159
And like we need a new public search engine.
00:46:32.320 --> 00:46:45.280
I think the one maybe redeeming point is that at least in the case of a search engine, you can so clearly distinguish the socially beneficial element of it from the parasitic element.
00:46:45.760 --> 00:46:51.440
Like they didn't actually develop the parasitic element until after they created a useful product.
00:46:51.760 --> 00:46:56.480
They didn't know how to make money, you know, as was classically narrated by Shoshana Zuboff.
00:46:56.800 --> 00:46:58.960
They kind of had to develop that after the fact.
00:46:59.039 --> 00:47:14.320
So I think with a public search engine at least, maybe I'm not the one to talk about how the structure of Google works and who would have to be fired and which developers might stay on in a some kind of like utopian public Google and what even Google would be renamed.
00:47:14.480 --> 00:47:19.519
But it's so clear that it does something really, really well and in a useful way.
00:47:19.599 --> 00:47:28.880
And I do talk about some of the technical
aspects of how that might be changed, thinking about, you know, search engine optimization and the politics essentially around search.
00:47:29.039 --> 00:47:32.400
But I think that's essentially a conversation we need to have.
00:47:32.639 --> 00:47:43.360
We need to have a public discourse about how our knowledge is organized, and we need to have some degree of accountability over the algorithms that we use to organize that knowledge.
00:47:43.519 --> 00:47:47.679
You know, should individuals get different results based on their search history?
00:47:47.840 --> 00:47:51.119
You know, should they be able to turn that function on and off?
00:47:51.280 --> 00:47:58.880
Um, all those things are basically the politics of knowledge and the politics of knowledge in a digital age, but we don't have that discussion.
00:47:58.960 --> 00:48:02.159
We don't have that debate because it's a function of a private company.
00:48:02.239 --> 00:48:05.920
And so all of that is just uh information we don't need to know, right?
00:48:06.079 --> 00:48:07.199
How the algorithm works.
00:48:07.360 --> 00:48:14.400
So we're not even at the starting point of what it would look like to have that kind of discussion and we desperately need it.
00:48:14.800 --> 00:48:30.320
I appreciate that answer, and I completely agree that I think it's a discussion that needs to be had, and I think that you can see pros and cons of either approach, you know, starting from scratch or taking over Google and trying to reform it into something that is serving the public instead of the profit motives of this major company.
00:48:30.559 --> 00:48:43.760
But in your earlier response, you mentioned that one of the possible uh approaches is to have some sort of UN organization that is helping to spread, I guess, platform socialism or these more positive implementations.
00:48:43.920 --> 00:49:11.840
Uh couple of years ago now, I guess early on in the pandemic, I wrote about the need to nationalize Amazon and to have the various countries that it has a footprint in to take over what it does in those countries and then to potentially have something like the Universal Postal Union, which itself is a UN organization, do coordination between them because, in my estimation, the Amazon would be merged with public postal services in that idea of the future.
00:49:12.000 --> 00:49:28.079
And so I wonder how you would imagine a kind of UN organization or UN body helping to forward this vision that you have, especially after talking about how important it is to be focused on the local level and to have things as local as possible.
00:49:28.480 --> 00:49:36.960
So I think imagining democratic digital platforms on a global scale is both super necessary, but also incredibly difficult to do, right?
00:49:37.039 --> 00:49:40.480
Because we don't even have democracy itself on the international level.
00:49:40.639 --> 00:49:42.800
We don't even have a way of talking about that.
00:49:43.039 --> 00:49:52.480
But when you're talking about things like global supply chains, the international scope of social networks and logistics services, they're not bounded by a single nation state.
00:49:52.719 --> 00:49:59.920
And indeed, I think one of the things that we don't talk about enough is the forms of digital colonialism that underpin the tech sector, right?
00:50:00.079 --> 00:50:05.599
I think this is just a completely absent discussion that's been missing from a lot of the talk about tech.
00:50:05.760 --> 00:50:16.960
Because yeah, let's say we nationalize a service in the US, it's still going to require, you know, lithium mining, it's still going to require all these, you know, product assemblage, all of these things that take place.
00:50:17.039 --> 00:50:22.719
And we we couldn't expect that to remain the same if we wanted a kind of just outcome for that.
00:50:22.960 --> 00:50:25.920
So it's definitely an international question.
00:50:26.000 --> 00:50:28.559
It's definitely one that has that kind of scope.
00:50:28.800 --> 00:50:31.840
Now, we don't even have a language for talking about this, right?
00:50:31.920 --> 00:50:37.920
So we can talk about nationalizing Amazon, but you know, in your article on it, you confronted these issues.
00:50:38.000 --> 00:50:40.639
Well, it's it's not going to be a national question.
00:50:40.800 --> 00:50:48.719
It doesn't make sense for US companies to be nationalized in this way when they're delivering services that affect so many people in other nations around the world.
00:50:49.039 --> 00:50:55.119
So in the book, I propose the creation of what I call a global digital services organization.
00:50:55.440 --> 00:51:02.880
I suggest that it could be like a specialized agency of the UN, like the International Telecommunications Union or the ILO.
00:51:03.039 --> 00:51:07.679
And, you know, it could first be set up by a levy on the profits of tech companies.
00:51:08.000 --> 00:51:20.000
This is the kind of organization that we might turn to for providing some kind of funding and coordination and support for developers and for communities to build these alternative platforms, right?
00:51:20.159 --> 00:51:26.719
So you can imagine an organization like this, particularly if it had a kind of digital wealth fund behind it.
00:51:26.960 --> 00:51:43.599
So it had some capital to start with, investing in these services because some of the some of the prototypes that we have, some of the the small examples of non-commodified digital services, we could turn to things like Mastodon as like, you know, a social media alternative.
00:51:43.840 --> 00:51:50.719
These small projects have been developed are usually by literally like one or a handful of volunteers with no money.
00:51:50.880 --> 00:51:58.000
You know, imagine what we could achieve with better funded public services with, you know, enormous amounts of money behind it.
00:51:58.159 --> 00:52:07.280
The Deco project that I um alluded to earlier, in the Francesca Brea interview, she said that look, that had 5 million euros.
00:52:07.440 --> 00:52:13.519
And they created this like citywide, you know, data commons um really changed the conversation.
00:52:13.760 --> 00:52:24.639
So it's crazy how much money the the big tech companies have and how much of it gets poured into their products versus, you know, non-commodified public commons-based alternatives.
00:52:24.800 --> 00:52:30.880
And so I think that look, it's not out of the realm of possibility that that you know we could move towards something like this.
00:52:31.119 --> 00:52:33.679
But I think that international level is really important.
00:52:33.840 --> 00:52:47.840
I think it's when you start thinking about social media, um, public search engines, and a few other digital services, maybe a global digital services organization could provide the funding and coordination needed to get some of those projects off the ground.
00:52:48.159 --> 00:52:59.039
Yeah, I love that, you know, and there are so many examples of digital services and software and things like that that would have this kind of universal application that such an organization could help with.
00:52:59.280 --> 00:53:06.800
James, I have really enjoyed the conversation today in digging into platform socialism and understanding the ideas that are behind it.
00:53:06.960 --> 00:53:07.679
Thanks so much.
00:53:07.920 --> 00:53:09.039
Thank you very much, Paris.
00:53:09.119 --> 00:53:10.079
Good to be here.
00:53:10.719 --> 00:53:15.760
James Muldoon is the author of Platform Socialism, How to Reclaim Our Digital Future from Big Tech.
00:53:15.840 --> 00:53:18.000
And you can find a link to learn more in the show notes.
00:53:18.159 --> 00:53:23.519
He's also a senior lecturer at the University of Exeter and the head of digital research at the Autonomy Think Tank.
00:53:23.679 --> 00:53:27.039
You can follow James on Twitter at at James underscore Muldoon underscore.
00:53:27.199 --> 00:53:30.719
You can follow me at at ParisMarks, and you can follow the show at Tech Won't Save Us.
00:53:30.880 --> 00:53:36.000
Tech Won's Save Us is part of the Harbinger Media Network, and you can find out more about that at Harbinger Media Network.com.
00:53:36.159 --> 00:53:42.719
And if you want to support the work that goes into making the show every week, you can go to patreon.com slash tech won't save us and become a supporter of it.
00:53:42.880 --> 00:53:44.079
Thanks for listening.