TRANSKRİPT 🔗
00:00:01
Speaker 1: We are talking a seismic shift. We're talking about the biggest investment boom in world history. Six people who were never elected now control the Western world. Who's more powerful, the president of America or the tech bros? The speed of change is unbelievable. And I say that as a finance analyst, I'm old enough to have been looking at the internet when it first came around.
00:00:22
Speaker 2: If thousands of people have to lose their jobs because of AI for it to become profitable, is that equation worth it? Tim Buckley, welcome to Stress Tested.
00:00:36
Speaker 1: Good morning, Ben. Great to be here.
00:00:38
Speaker 2: There's a lot to talk about, a lot that's happened even today and the last couple of weeks in the AI world and the backlash against data centers, some big moves from big companies and the government's just taken a big step as well. But before we get into that, would you just like to introduce yourself? You're an analyst and you've worked in the industry for over 30 years. Is that right?
00:01:00
Speaker 1: Yeah, showing my age, probably over 40 years or 40 years, should I say. But so I've had two careers, one 20 years in finance as a equities analyst for my sins. I was head of research at Citigroup at the time, the biggest bank in the world. I did that for about 10 years and I was an analyst for 10 years before that. And then I moved into a niche area at the time. It was the global technology cleantech space. And then from there, I've spent the last 15 years running a not-for-profit public interest think tank, fully funded by philanthropy. So we have no government funding, no corporate funding, no vested interests, but it is about aligning the energy system of the future with the climate science.
00:01:43
Speaker 2: And how has that been for you? Has it been a bit of a challenge trying to get the Australian public and the government on board?
00:01:50
Speaker 1: It Is it an absolute challenge? Absolutely. We have a lot of vested interest pushing back on the climate science, undermining it, pushing a delay, disinformation, misinformation. I come up across that every day. That's partly why I was actually grabbed to work in this area, because having a finance background, I can use financial data. And so I started by investing in China, looking at China, talking to Chinese companies, and whether or not China is doing it for altruistic global climate science reasons or whether they're doing it for industry dominance or they just want to have massive investments in growth industries of the future. I believe it's actually all of those. So I actually spent a lot of my time looking at what China is doing. And so when I'm talking to Australian audiences in particular, it's more about, well, let's know what our number one trade partner is doing. Let's look at how fast they're moving. And we can debate the climate science if you really want. I don't debate it. At the end of the day, I talk to actuaries, the biggest brains in the world. They all work for the big global insurance companies. And for 40, 50 years, they've been telling us the climate science is real. The cost of insurance is going through the roof. Everyone in Australia now knows that, but they've known it for 30, 40, 50 years. So I actually started going to Swiss Re, Munich Re, Two of the biggest insurers in the world and I spoke to their actuaries and they go, we've got zero doubt this is real and the financial implications of it are huge. So let's actually prepare, mitigate and offset to where we can.
00:03:28
Speaker 2: So let's talk about data centers. There's been a lot happening. This morning there was a report in the AFR that I just read and said that the Albanese government is going to ban data centers from being built near homes and recreational facilities. And this is a response to community backlash. And there's been a lot of that in recent weeks and months. I think the first time I really noticed it, I was down in Melbourne and we had a new financial report of starting We've got a really great reporter down there called Rowan Smith, and he's not really covered data centers before, but he's very on the pulse in Melbourne about what's happening. And I'm a financial editor at news.com, so he came over to me and said, do you do stories about data centers? I said, yeah, we've done a few.
00:04:23
Speaker 1: Often they don't.
00:04:25
Speaker 2: Really resonate that well, just because I feel like a lot of people don't don't know what it's like to live near one at this stage. Um, but then he said, oh, what about this? And he showed me some pictures of these giant concrete pylons that were in West Footscray in Melbourne. And he said, all the locals are calling it Mordor. Um, they're sick of it. They said, there's this noise that's coming out of it. And, um, you know, 24 hours a day, low humming sort of vibration type noise. And there was this huge backlash against it. And since then, I've just noticed that this backlash to data centers has really sort of come to the fore. It's all over my social media feed. I think a lot of young people are really very skeptical of AI from what I've seen. And a lot of these communities that live in these places where data centers are being built feel like they don't have agency over what's happening online. Um, and they're seeing some of the problems that are arising because of that. Um, and it came to a head over the last few weeks, next DC that built that more door in the commas, um, the data center was still being built in West foot's grade, the M three data center. Um, they released a statement to the ASX saying that their profit, um, expectations have been downgraded because of this big community backlash. I think their share price crashed 40% in one day. And we also saw Firmus, which is a NeoCloud data center provider. They were looking to list on the stock exchange and that flopped because of concerns over the firm's valuation. And all this happened
Load full transcript
in the space of a few weeks. And then we've got the prime minister reportedly coming out today saying that He's going to look at banning data centers being built near homes and community centers. To me, it feels like quite a big turning point against AI and data centers in Australia. Do you see it that way?
00:06:36
Speaker 1: I do. I think you've summarized it really well. No one had even heard of data centers two years ago, and now literally you can't open the financial review without finding five or ten articles every day. And part of that is the amount of capital that the global majors, the American IT majors are trying to deploy in this sector and the speed of change. The speed of change is unbelievable. And I say that as a finance analyst, I'm old enough to have been looking at the internet when it first came around and hit the financial markets. And we had the massive boom, massive hype, massive, it's going to change the world. And then the bubble collapsed. And 10 years later, Everything we were talking about came about. But in the meantime, you had financial carnage. And that's what we're starting to see today. But I liked how you actually married the issue of what the prime minister is saying today and this week, what the energy minister is saying yesterday with the train wreck that we've seen down in West Footscray. We've seen it over in WA. We've seen it in Lane Cove in Sydney, where local communities are getting up in arms and saying, no, we're going to protect our local community. And if you haven't done the right community engagement beforehand, you've got a train wreck. And I think the data center industry is a very, very, well, they were very aware of it six months ago. I was at a conference. I was on a panel with three data center developers and all of them talked about social license. I'm a finance guy. Finance people don't really worry about social license unless it's going to stop your project proposal. And then it's critical. And what they were saying was, The data centre industry is so close to following the offshore wind, the onshore wind and the grid transmission sector into a train wreck. We've got to build social licence. Otherwise, we just go the same way as the offshore wind industry in Australia has done, which is dead as a dodo. And the biggest data centre developers in Australia were saying that on a panel with me. I was there meant to be holding them to account. All I had to do was nod because they were actually saying, let's avoid the train wreck. And their real worry, and so I suppose what we were then debating was, is there a role for the government to step in and actually legislate it? And their answer was yes, because it's going to be the bad operators who will destroy it for everyone, just like the rogue operators in solar have done a lot of damage to regional social licence. So social licence becomes a yes or no decision. And if you're a developer of a concept, you want to deploy, I don't know, $ 32 billion. and the social licence isn't there, you've got nothing.
00:09:21
Speaker 2: I don't want to put you on the spot, but just that announcement from Anthony Albanese today, what's your first thoughts about that, banning data centres from being near homes?
00:09:36
Speaker 1: I think it's inevitable. The job of the government is to protect voters and the country and to keep vested interest in alignment. But Why am I so categoric on that? Victoria's actually just introduced legislation a couple of months ago saying you can't build a data centre within two kilometres of a school. So the industry knew this was coming. Now, Victoria, obviously more social progressive, well, they are at the moment until the next election. So that Victorian lesson set a benchmark. And what I understand the federal government's trying to do now is say, let's actually have a national set of rules. Let's legislate them so that they're not please, please, sir, will you comply? It will, no, these are the rules. These are the rules of engagement. You want to get fast approval, do this. You want a slow, but positive approval, go your own way. And if you want a fast no, then these are the conditions aware of fast no. Now fast no is far better than a slow, never yes. You can waste a lot of money investing in a project that's never going to get approved. And so what I think the federal government's trying to do, and I applaud them for it. We've got a situation where the Premier of New South Wales loves data centres. It involves a huge amount of investment in New South Wales. We're from New South Wales. We want investment. We want a healthy economy here. But then Victoria goes to the proponent, come down to us and we'll waiver a few of those rules. And then Queensland goes, I'll come to Queensland. We'll waiver a lot of the rules. And then Western Australia go, we love data centres. We haven't got any We'll waiver all the rules. And so you end up with a race to the bottom. At the end of the day, I think we need the data centers. A lot of them, we only have to look at the revenue growth of these companies. It's astronomical. You only have to look at the compute power of the AI changes that are coming. We're going to need data centers. We just need them to be built. And the only way you get them built is if you have a social license to operate. And so the federal government's saying, rather than a race to the bottom, let's set some rules. Let's consult with the industry, set some rules, consult with consumers as well. So it's balanced and then set some rules so that they don't waste time developing project proposals that are never going to get approved. Or even, sorry, even once they're approved, the community can then overrule them by just literally boycotting them as Mordor found.
00:12:09
Speaker 2: And Just on that social license and how people feel about data centers, what's the sense that you're getting from the public about data centers? I said before that I felt the
tide was turning a bit. Do you think people are really concerned about what's happening?
00:12:26
Speaker 1: I think people are very confused. We are talking a seismic shift. We're talking about the biggest investment boom in world history and what America is doing. America led the charge, like A year ago, 80% of all the data centers in the world were in America. And then America realized they ran out of social license really quickly when electricity prices went up 12% in one year. And the regulators turned around and said, well, that's because the data centers weren't required to bring your own energy, BEYONCE. A really silly acronym. No one's claiming credit for it, but bring your own clean new energy and you might get a social license. You might be allowed to proceed. America and even Trump acknowledge that, uh, if you don't bring your own new energy, you're going to cause a backlash from the local residents in the region because you're going to push up the cost of energy for everyone else. And so fortunately, Australia is a couple of years behind America, very, very favorable investment climate for, for American corporates. Um, but we're trying to avoid the train wreck of, um, another next DC and another and another, we've actually need some road rules. So what's the mood of the community? I would say more fear and unknown, um, and a fear that their rights are going to be overruled by very, very wealthy, um, self-interest center.
00:13:57
Speaker 2: Is there also a flip side to that? I mean, you mentioned that we need data centers if we're going to sort of keep up, uh, with the global AI boom. Um, Is there a flip side that these data centers, they're going to provide a huge economic benefit to the communities that they're in potentially? Is that right? Or do they not really?
00:14:18
Speaker 1: That's why we talk about, well, I'm talking about social license in a broader context, not just, I don't want a data center opposite my house. Of course, I'm going to fight that. But what about the people three kilometers away? They're the ones now up in arms as well. So it's about the wider social license at the end of the day. Not my backyard is a standard saying that we've had for, I don't know, 250 years of economic development. No one wants a massive industry built right next door to them. But there is a greater good requirement. We're all using our mobile phones. We all want increased productivity. And AI is a massive productivity enhancer.
00:14:57
Speaker 2: And people would have said the same things about power plants and things when they were built back in the day. Nobody would want a chemical plant or a, you know, a huge factory sort of outside their home.
00:15:10
Speaker 1: That's true. But what we maybe need to go back, maybe 50 years ago, social licence was far less of an issue, but coal mines are out in the regions. And compulsory acquisition legislation was brought in by the New South Wales government, by the Queensland government, to
actually acquire the properties most affected. And so when you're complaining about a coal mine literally next door to you, Invariably, the coal mine will just make you an offer. They'll get a non-disclosure agreement as well. They'll pay you double what your property is worth because the coal underground is worth 10 times, 50 times, 100 times that. So they ended up silencing the community, the local community. The people who are obviously 10, 20 years later, the coal mine gets bigger and bigger. It just uses the coal here and then creeps to the right. and then comes up against someone and that person then literally wakes up and finds they're looking over their fence at a coal mine and then they've got a train wreck. Now, a lot of them have known that was coming, but we're talking about a handful of people and most of the people are paid out. Compulsory acquisition solves the problem for most of them. It might destroy the local community, or it does in many of those cases, but you're building a freeway. You're not going to let one person say, could you just do a little U bend around my house? The federal government's got compulsory acquisition requirements. You've got to look at the greater good. At the end of the day, we're not China. They literally, when they built the biggest dam in the world, they literally moved a million people. Reports are they moved five million people. They didn't get any choice. That was compulsory acquisition without compensation. Pick them up and move them and build the biggest dam in the world. But fortunately, we are a democracy, but our government isn't. Still, we need a healthy economy. I don't want to go back to the Stone Age. I want jobs for my kids, and I want a strong, healthy, sustainable economy. So I want the data centers, and I want to use my phone. I want to have my productivity enhanced. I want to be able to do data searches like I study China. I don't read Chinese, but AI can, and it can summarize it in minutes, reports that I can't even read, and it summarizes them in English. I need to as an analyst, then fact check it, but I can read numbers in Chinese. I can't read the language. So the AI there, I've had to employ Chinese analysts, Chinese Australian analysts to read the reports and put them into English for me. So just one small example, but that means I can have my productivity go up. So I'm in favor of economic development. I just want it to be sustainable and we've got to look at the greater good. So we've got to work out, we need the data centers. Let's make sure that they tick as many boxes as possible and ideally net benefits. So you said net benefit to the local community. That's going to be hard. But at least make sure that there's enough benefit or enough compensation so that they can get on with their lives and not feel victimized. Because if they're victimized, they will fight. And even after you've got the approval, they could still win as Footscray showed.
00:18:27
Speaker 2: I mean, Aussies are very attached to their homes, aren't they? So any idea that something would come in and sort of disrupt their local environment, you can understand why they might be upset about that. Is there a solution that we could just put all these data centres in the desert? There must be a reason they're building it in communities. Why are data centres being built in cities now?
00:18:46
Speaker 1: It's proximity to the consumer. If you're 500 kilometres away from the consumer, you might find your phone takes two seconds, not one second, to answer your prompt. or a minute, not 10 seconds. Now, one versus two seconds, you can't even scratch in that time, but in a minute or five minutes or for serious compute, that is a problem. Once I found out it's a problem, proximity to the consumer is going to be a problem because the land cost is really high, let alone the ability, even once you bought the land, to actually then build on it and getting the council, the local council, the state government, the federal government, all three of them to approve it really slow. In Australia, everything's slow. So all sorts of issues. The closer to the consumer, the harder it is to build and the more expensive it is to build. But what they were saying was all the infrastructure is there. And so I met with New South Wales or Sydney Water and Sydney Water said, we've got a water problem. We don't have enough water. And even if we have enough water, we don't have enough water reticulation. We don't have enough pipes to get to North Ryde. I'm on the North Shore. North Ryde is a favourite data centre location. They go, if all the data centres that want to be built in North Ryde, there's not enough water pipes to get the water to actually cool the data centres. And so I was saying, well, we can just build another desal plant. We built one 20 years ago and it was a waste of time. because we didn't have a drought, you can use renewable energy to power desalination. We can get more. That's a finance analyst perspective. We need more water. I can build you water. And Sydney Water's response was, you can give me water, but if I can't get it to North Ryde, your water's a waste of time. And so it's the pipes, it's the infrastructure. So building in the middle of the city is all about accessing electricity and water and consumers. But now with the backlash we're seeing, the data center operators are realizing, well, maybe two-thirds of them can be in regional Australia. Or as some of them are threatening, maybe we could do it in India or Malaysia where social license is less of a problem and those governments are more focused on economic growth. Can they get around the whole social license? Now, to some degree, that's a threat. I think it's a bit of a hollow one, but the industry tells me it's real. that they will literally just go and build them in Singapore or in Malaysia or in India. Now, India is a different point. And that's why I was just in Western Australia. Western
Australia is going to have data centers. At the moment, it doesn't. They're all Sydney and Melbourne, almost all. South Australia then all of a sudden becomes relevant because what you need is compute power when the consumer needs it. Now, if you're trying to power that with the sun, why don't we follow the sun? The Sun is really good in Sydney, then it's good in South Australia, then it's good in Western Australia three hours later, and then it's good in India three hours after that. So in fact, if you own five data centers, you can actually stagger it. The consumer doesn't even know that the compute's being done in South Australia or Western Australia. The government will know if it's done in India. And so then you've got to bring the federal government along and say, well, hang on, national security says we don't want consumer data going offshore, whether it's to India, a trusted ally, or whether it's going to China, that's not going to be allowable, energy security. But even going into Malaysia, who's to say that the Malaysian data centres are ring-fenced enough to avoid North Korean hacking? And so we can... Data security is really, really topical.
00:22:19
Speaker 2: How big is the opportunity that Australia has in this space? Do you think this has the potential to sort of revitalise Australia?
00:22:28
Speaker 1: We have been... We, the financial review, the financial media, the financial economists have been really worried about a lack of economic growth in Australia. And now all of a sudden we're talking about the biggest investment boom in Australian history. And it's not just a boom the size of the Pilbara, our number one export source, iron ore, but we took 40 years or 30 years or 20 years to build that. The Northwest Shelf took 20, 30, 40 years to build for LNG. We're talking about doing that all in the next decade. So it's being truncated and that's the problem. And that's the opportunity. We're talking a hundred, $ 150 billion of investment in Australia in the coming five to 10 years. I would question, do we have enough workers? Do we have enough electricians? Um, we need every electrician to have two or three apprentices, uh, because we literally have a building boom and for every data center, you're going to need a wind farm, a solar farm, a battery energy storage system, a grid connection. You're then going to need that maintained for the next 20, 30, 40 years. You're going to need a lot of workers. And where I think the government's getting really nervous is we've got a renewable energy build-out, we've got a data centre build-out, and we've got a desperate need, and we've had a desperate need for 10 or 20 years to build a whole lot of homes for our younger population. We've got a housing crisis. We need workers for homes. So if they all run off, all the electricians run off and build data centres... Who's going to actually do the lights in the houses and we'll have a slowdown in housing construction or worse, housing costs, additional housing costs will just keep going up. So we've got to balance it, but let's look at it as the positive. You said, let's put the license rules on. Let's try and beef up the TAFE system. Fortunately, the Albanese government's been doing that for the last four years and we need to get a lot more apprentices, certified apprentices in electrical trades industries. Um, and that'll hopefully give us the workforce we need. We need to be wary about these anti-immigration backlash because historically Australia has always been able to get the workers we need because we just import them or everyone else has a data center boom going on. Um, so turning off the supply of new hardworking immigrants to me is really dumb. We need them. We need those workers where they're happy to work. They have brilliant work ethics. And they bring a whole lot of skills. And let's hope they go to the regions, do the construction jobs, get the skills required. So we need to move the TAFEs out to the regions. But all of that means we can actually have a thriving economy that's also sustainable.
00:25:13
Speaker 2: Yeah, it's an interesting idea, isn't it, that you could be paid to live near a data center. You could reap some of the economic benefits of it. you know, potentially off your power bill or something like that.
00:25:22
Speaker 1: Absolutely. I should give a shout out the one up at Curry, um, the Curry data center, two hours north of Sydney, just north of Newcastle. They've offered everyone in the suburb, not the Shire, everyone within that Curry suburb, 200 bucks a year for the life of the data center. And they made that really public so that anyone who's protesting against it is then having to come up against their local neighbor and say, well, hang on, you're trying to take 200 bucks out of my wallet. And not just my wallet, but every other house in the street, every other house in the community, that's a lot of money. And so all of a sudden, the community benefit is real. I do a lot of travel in regional Australia. They say, look, you guys from the Big Smoke, I'm from Sydney. You guys from the Big Smoke, you get all the benefit. We get all the costs. How about we get a share of the benefits that outweigh the cost to us? Give us the local jobs. Make sure our roads are enhanced, not degraded. make sure our council actually gets some revenue, ongoing revenue to pay. So the rates don't go up. Um, because if the data centers using two fifths of bugger or land, it's not going to pay a lot of rates. So like a wind turbine, let's make sure the council gets some fee, some extra fees. Um, and then 200 bucks a year per project. All of a sudden you're going to have communities going, bring the data centers over the blue mountains to, to Oberon Shire. And we'd love to have some DCs. I'd love to, um, We're going to lower my power bills. I've got a property out at Oberon. But let's do it for the whole community, not just the vested interests.
00:26:55
Speaker 2: And is
there a danger here? We saw this announcement today and you mentioned that Victoria have put some rules in place. Is there a danger that we could hit the brakes too hard and we could scare these big companies from investing in Australia?
00:27:08
Speaker 1: Yeah. There is, and that is the threat, that capital is totally borderless. It will go where the best risk-adjusted returns are. But I'll bring back the point you made really strongly, and I totally agree with you. American corporates see Australia as a geopolitical ally of America, as a safe place to invest. Korea and Japan, Australia is a trusted ally of those countries. So we understand do for all of the local noise of one nation versus libs versus greens versus labor versus teals we've got all that noise but relative to other countries we are pretty blessed um and foreign investors see that and so we do need to actually recognize that there's a bit of bluff in there of course the data centers want to don't want to have to pay social license fees for the next 30 years because that's money you're taking straight out of their um gold-plated pockets um But what I remind them is having 100% of nothing, you're better off getting 90% of something big. And when we're talking big, we're talking $ 32 billion a pop. These are pretty bloody big projects. Getting 90% of that is worth getting it. And so what Minister Bowen and Prime Minister Albanese are saying is if you tick all the boxes, we'll actually not just say you're going to get a tick or likely get approval once we've done due diligence, we'll fast track you. Now that is worth its weight in gold to the data center developer because he then gets to connect and they need power. They need compute today and next year, and they don't want to spend two years investing to find out they haven't got anything. And Australia has got a very bureaucratic system. I accept that. If we can fast track it, then that makes it worthwhile doing the right thing early. And one of the things most important to me is making sure that data centers actually help solve the climate science, not make it worse. And so to me, a data center operator is the best possible purchaser of energy in Australia because they're backed by global financial giants who are eminently bankable. They're going to operate an infrastructure facility for 20 or 30 years. They can sign a power purchase agreement tomorrow. And if you say it's for a new wind farm, a new solar farm, a new battery, that can unlock a $ 30 billion data center could unlock $ 30 billion of new firmed generation capacity. And as I mentioned, that one in Western Downs, it's right next to the biggest grid connection. So all of that can access the grid, no problem. That will then defray the cost of the grid for everyone in Queensland, which will then lower the power price, not just for the locals, but the whole of Queensland. And so everyone in Queensland gets a financial benefit because we created a win-win situation. So For every dollar a data center, you could get a dollar of new firm generation. And so and all of that could be or 95 percent of it could be zero emissions. So that actually allows Minister Bowen to get to his 82 percent renewables target even as energy demand goes through the roof because it's electricity demand and electricity is easy to decarbonize if done correctly. And so Australia actually delivers on its social license, on its global obligations, And we get sustainable economic growth. And I keep coming back to that. I'm all for economic growth. I'm a finance analyst. I love money. I love it. It powers the world, whether we like it or not. Finance powers the world. But if we can do it sustainably, that's even better. And if we can do it fast and sustainably, that's even good for the data center developers.
00:30:46
Speaker 2: What do you see Australia's position being like in comparison to other countries? Like, are we ahead of the game or are we sort of playing catch up?
00:30:56
Speaker 1: I think social license has been weaponized in Australia. I don't think Texas really gives a toss about local noise and flicker. And if you don't like it, move. It's the free market. It's Texas. But it's worth bearing in mind, Texas is the biggest builder, developer, operator of wind projects in the whole of America. It's the biggest operator of solar projects in the whole of America. It's the biggest operator of batteries in In America, it's got the biggest grid transmission system of any state in America, Texas, but they love money. They love development. And so it's about making sure that the. The consumer backlash you mentioned is very real in Texas because what the locals are saying, the Texans are saying is that data center is, I can see the impact of the data center on my electricity bill immediately. And my electricity bill has gone up 12% this year. It went up 12% last year. That's all slated to the data centre. Why does it go up?
00:31:59
Speaker 2: Is it because the data centres are using so much electricity that it puts pressure on the grid?
00:32:05
Speaker 1: Absolutely. So data centres are really power hungry. And so we've got something like 65 gigawatts of new data centre developments across gigawatts. That's huge. Like the Australian, the national electricity market, total capacity today is about 77 gigawatts. So we've got as many data center proposals on the table in the next five to 10 years, almost as the entire energy electricity system installed and operating today. So if you put all that extra load on data centers are also relatively price agnostic. In other words, they just need data. They need power to operate and to operate, to provide the data, to provide the compute. And so they're willing to pay high prices, but, um, Yeah, ultimately, they're just pushing the price onto everyone else. And they're taking power that was previously going to houses and industry. They're willing to pay a higher price. So, okay, put the price up.
Consumption for everyone else goes down, but they all pay the price. And so what Minister Bowen's been really clear, bring your own new energy. He says new clean energy. Minister Ayres says new energy. He drops the clean. I'm pushing back on Minister Ayres. I want it to be clean, new energy, because that is sustainable. But yeah, is there room for a gas peaker in there for 5%? No problem for me. But wind, solar, they're the lowest cost source of new generation. But then you've got a time issue. We know it takes you three to five years to build a wind farm in Australia, even once it's approved. It might take you only 18 months to build a solar project, 12 months to build a battery project, 18 months to build a data centre. So I can get my battery, my solar and my data centre all built in the same time. But if I've then got to wait two years for the wind Is my approval going to sit there on hold for two years? What I would argue the government will do is say, no, you've got a short-term target, a medium-term target, a long-term target. Bring 70% of your electricity as new within two years. Bring the other 20%, get up to 90% within four years. The last 10% do on a five, six, seven year view. You know, let's just be realistic. This is a 20, 30 year investment proposal. You can't get everything done. Wind takes a long time to build. So let's actually just make sure that the legislation isn't impossible to fulfill. But the minute you do that, you're leveraging the existing grid. If we're pumping more electricity through the existing grid, that lowers the per unit cost for everyone. So whether it's New South Wales, a data center in Queensland lowers the cost for everyone, then that actually builds social license financially to me. I'm a finance guy. But the silent majority are going to go, my power bill's gone down. Now, by the way, New South Wales residents on the 1st of July, 2026, got a 10% price cut to their electricity bill. We don't read about that very often, but we are actually seeing record high renewables in the New South Wales grid equate to lower power prices. I think we'll see the same thing next year. And so all of a sudden that social issue, we've had a lot of pushback. It takes a long time to build a wind farm, particularly in New South Wales. So it's taken time. But as you see the benefits flow through, the consumer buy-in to the energy system transformation that we have to have goes up. I think we can head that off at the pass for data centers. If they're air-cooled, if they're renewable energy powered, if they're close to the grid connectivity, so they're enhancing grid, if they have demand response flexibility, in other words, they turn down when we've got power shortages, right? They're not crippling the grid. They're enhancing the grid and then make sure we put them where people actually want to work and make sure they're real jobs there and make sure they're paying the local residents a bigger share of the benefits. So the cost benefit analysis is positive for the local area, for the regional area, and then for the state and federally. Um, to me, that's a win-win and we get, we unlock, I don't know, a hundred, $ 150 billion, a new investment in Australia. We unlock another 50 to 100 billion of new renewable energy and battery projects. That underpins economic growth sustainably for Australia for another decade. That's a win for me.
00:36:26
Speaker 2: It sounds like a win. I suppose there's a bigger issue as well in that we're talking about AI and I've heard people say that the goal of AI or the only way to make it financially viable is is to basically eliminate hundreds of millions of people's jobs. And there's also risks about what it poses to humanity in terms of, you know, it could be a threat to democracy. But I suppose the question is, are we going to, really benefit if AI takes all our jobs? I mean, you, you talked about that, uh, project in the Western towns, potentially employing up to 1400 people, but if thousands of people have to lose their jobs because of AI for it to become profitable, is that equation worth it?
00:37:27
Speaker 1: Ben, you you've nailed it. It's beyond my pay grade. I was only talking about the infrastructure to actually power AI. the bigger social license issue. Are we ever going to stop the tech pros of America dominating the world? Six people who were never elected now control the Western world. They don't control China. China's making sure of that, but China's building its own AI global leaders. But China is actually putting guardrails on it. They're saying we've got to pass the greater good test and they are putting constraints on In other words, China is trying to preempt the risk that America, I think it's already lost. We've lost that race. Who's more powerful, the president of America or the tech bros or who's actually controlling the president of America? That's beyond my pay grade. At the end of the day, we're not going to stop the AI revolution. Good luck to Minister Ayers as the science minister. He has to try and do that. He has to make sure that we actually see this as a benefit for humanity. I was only talking infrastructure. and power. I was not talking about the big issue that you just did. And I am fearful about that. I think it's too late. The idea that we're going to somehow stop the tech pros of America controlling everyone in Australia, all our data, all of our compute, sending algorithms, taking all of our artists and authors' IP, all of the media's IP, and then just start scraping it and taking it offshore and controlling it and not paying for it. Good luck to the federal government. I'd love them to stand up to the tech pros. Their history suggests they're not powerful enough. The tech pros are already, they need to get reelected. We are a democracy. I do agree with you. It's a threat to democracy, but I don't want to end on a really bearish note. That's just beyond my pay grade. It is a threat we have to collectively understand and we've got to give the government more power. Governments are great at stuffing things up, but they're the only way Australia can protect our sovereignty, in my view. So we've got to support them.
00:39:35
Speaker 2: Well, it's been great having you on the podcast, Tim. Thanks a lot for your time.
00:39:38
Speaker 1: Thanks very much for having me, Ben.
00:39:39
Speaker 2: Don't forget to subscribe to Stress Tested on YouTube or your podcast platform of choice. It helps us grow the show and get even bigger guests.