TRANSKRİPT 🔗
WEBVTT
Kind: captions
Language: en
00:00:00.080 --> 00:00:02.550
Can you be certain that you can't know?
00:00:02.560 --> 00:00:04.470
It's not. Some things you can be certain
00:00:04.480 --> 00:00:06.150
you can't know. Some things you you're
00:00:06.160 --> 00:00:08.230
not sure. Maybe you maybe we could know
00:00:08.240 --> 00:00:10.310
them. First of all, we have to know that
00:00:10.320 --> 00:00:12.435
we don't know that we can't know.
00:00:12.445 --> 00:00:13.509
[laughter] We don't know that we can't
00:00:13.519 --> 00:00:15.990
know. But we maybe we can't. I can
00:00:16.000 --> 00:00:17.670
believe in the existence of all sorts of
00:00:17.680 --> 00:00:19.670
things [music] as a mysterion that
00:00:19.680 --> 00:00:21.349
somebody who thinks that nothing that
00:00:21.359 --> 00:00:23.670
exists is materious can't believe in.
00:00:23.680 --> 00:00:25.670
And turns out that's most of reality.
00:00:25.680 --> 00:00:27.910
Actually [laughter]
00:00:27.920 --> 00:00:30.790
>> you can believe in most of reality.
00:00:30.800 --> 00:00:32.950
>> Yeah. So we know we we think matter
00:00:32.960 --> 00:00:35.830
exists. Okay matter exists that's fine.
00:00:35.840 --> 00:00:38.389
Do we do we understand the full deep
00:00:38.399 --> 00:00:41.270
nature of matter? [music] No. [laughter]
00:00:41.280 --> 00:00:44.069
We don't. So if somebody to say well if
00:00:44.079 --> 00:00:45.670
you say it's a mystery then you have to
00:00:45.680 --> 00:00:47.750
deny it exists. You're going to deny
00:00:47.760 --> 00:00:49.190
everything exists in that way. And it's
00:00:49.200 --> 00:00:51.510
just it's not plausible. It's just not
00:00:51.520 --> 00:00:53.350
reasonable to think that way. The much
00:00:53.360 --> 00:00:55.270
more reasonable thing is to say, well,
00:00:55.280 --> 00:00:56.950
you know, it's just that our brains as
00:00:56.960 --> 00:00:58.470
they are now in this moment of
00:00:58.480 --> 00:01:01.270
evolutionary time and maybe forever will
00:01:01.280 --> 00:01:07.455
never get to the bottom of that.
00:01:07.465 --> 00:01:10.870
[music]
00:01:10.880 --> 00:01:14.469
Solomon and Smith. Welcome to Solomon
00:01:14.479 --> 00:01:16.710
and Smith. While neither of us are
00:01:16.720 --> 00:01:18.469
Solomon or Smith, together we are
00:01:18.479 --> 00:01:21.270
Solomon and Smith. Today we are talking
00:01:21.280 --> 00:01:24.390
to Colin Mcjin who is a philosopher.
00:01:24.400 --> 00:01:26.390
>> Is it Mcjin? I've been saying Mcin this
00:01:26.400 --> 00:01:27.350
entire time.
00:01:27.360 --> 00:01:29.109
>> Oh no, maybe it is Mcin. Shall I do it
00:01:29.119 --> 00:01:30.630
again? I don't know.
00:01:30.640 --> 00:01:32.069
>> No, let's leave that in. Let's leave
00:01:32.079 --> 00:01:33.590
that in. Leave it ambiguous.
00:01:33.600 --> 00:01:38.230
>> Mcjin slash McInn is a philosopher of
00:01:38.240 --> 00:01:42.230
many things of you know mind, language,
00:01:42.240 --> 00:01:46.710
hands, film. He is an
Load full transcript
archer. He is a
00:01:46.720 --> 00:01:49.030
tennis player. He is one of the greatest
00:01:49.040 --> 00:01:50.630
men I've had the pleasure of speaking
00:01:50.640 --> 00:01:53.990
with [laughter]
00:01:54.000 --> 00:01:57.350
>> in terms of sheer breadth of activity
00:01:57.360 --> 00:01:59.590
which does seem to be limitless.
00:01:59.600 --> 00:02:02.149
>> He's written 9 billion and3 books a
00:02:02.159 --> 00:02:04.149
handful of which we read in preparation
00:02:04.159 --> 00:02:06.149
for the interview. All of them quite
00:02:06.159 --> 00:02:06.709
good.
00:02:06.719 --> 00:02:10.309
>> He's a songwriter, a song inverter,
00:02:10.319 --> 00:02:13.190
guitarist, singer. But what do we talk
00:02:13.200 --> 00:02:15.670
to him about? Well, mostly mind and
00:02:15.680 --> 00:02:17.670
language. Mind and language. What's the
00:02:17.680 --> 00:02:19.510
deal with that? Well, what we talk about
00:02:19.520 --> 00:02:21.589
to this expert in these things is how
00:02:21.599 --> 00:02:23.589
little he knows about them. How little
00:02:23.599 --> 00:02:25.990
it is possible to know about them. Mind
00:02:26.000 --> 00:02:27.830
in particular. What is consciousness?
00:02:27.840 --> 00:02:29.190
How do we explain it? It's one of the
00:02:29.200 --> 00:02:31.589
great puzzles in philosophy, not only
00:02:31.599 --> 00:02:33.589
modern philosophy, but all philosophy,
00:02:33.599 --> 00:02:36.229
which has had various solutions over the
00:02:36.239 --> 00:02:39.190
centuries, but none conclusive. None
00:02:39.200 --> 00:02:41.030
have really cracked the code. Why is
00:02:41.040 --> 00:02:43.030
this? The argument here is that we
00:02:43.040 --> 00:02:45.509
simply can't answer the question that we
00:02:45.519 --> 00:02:47.830
have what is called a cognitive closure
00:02:47.840 --> 00:02:49.910
to certain elements of the mind of
00:02:49.920 --> 00:02:51.750
consciousness that would explain
00:02:51.760 --> 00:02:54.790
possibly quite simply how consciousness
00:02:54.800 --> 00:02:57.509
came from non-conciousness.
00:02:57.519 --> 00:02:59.350
This is one of the words that is used to
00:02:59.360 --> 00:03:01.830
describe these raw feelings and that we
00:03:01.840 --> 00:03:03.910
have what is called intentionality
00:03:03.920 --> 00:03:06.070
aboutness to be able to grasp something
00:03:06.080 --> 00:03:08.550
to focus on something. We're not just
00:03:08.560 --> 00:03:10.550
sort of chemical matter batting against
00:03:10.560 --> 00:03:12.149
each other, but seem to actually be able
00:03:12.159 --> 00:03:13.670
to look at something and say that is a
00:03:13.680 --> 00:03:15.910
thing. I will think about the thing,
00:03:15.920 --> 00:03:18.710
point myself at it, and then to another
00:03:18.720 --> 00:03:20.710
thing. So, we have to essentially deal
00:03:20.720 --> 00:03:23.350
with well, what do we know about not
00:03:23.360 --> 00:03:23.830
knowing?
00:03:23.840 --> 00:03:26.470
>> A glossery of terms that we felt
we
00:03:26.480 --> 00:03:29.030
should go over. Phenology, that's the
00:03:29.040 --> 00:03:31.030
study of sounds, the study of making
00:03:31.040 --> 00:03:33.270
noises in order to signify things.
00:03:33.280 --> 00:03:37.990
syntax that's the rules that determine
00:03:38.000 --> 00:03:41.190
sort of word order or linguistic input
00:03:41.200 --> 00:03:45.270
order. I see you. The study of these
00:03:45.280 --> 00:03:47.190
rules and what determines them. Then
00:03:47.200 --> 00:03:49.509
there is semantics that's the study of
00:03:49.519 --> 00:03:53.270
meaning. How uh symbols come to mean
00:03:53.280 --> 00:03:55.990
things. How the signifier interacts with
00:03:56.000 --> 00:03:58.710
the signified. And then pragmatics,
00:03:58.720 --> 00:04:01.190
that's sort of how meaning changes in a
00:04:01.200 --> 00:04:03.910
specific context or how it's interpreted
00:04:03.920 --> 00:04:06.229
given different contextual clues.
00:04:06.239 --> 00:04:07.509
Welcome to the channel. If you've never
00:04:07.519 --> 00:04:08.949
been here before, it would be very
00:04:08.959 --> 00:04:10.710
helpful if you could like this video and
00:04:10.720 --> 00:04:12.550
and leave a comment down below with your
00:04:12.560 --> 00:04:14.390
all with your own thoughts on these uh
00:04:14.400 --> 00:04:17.030
questions. We also have a Patreon. You
00:04:17.040 --> 00:04:20.069
gain access to uh exclusive content and
00:04:20.079 --> 00:04:23.030
also uh gain access to our book club
00:04:23.040 --> 00:04:25.270
which has just started up. It would be
00:04:25.280 --> 00:04:26.790
lovely to see you there. We're hugely
00:04:26.800 --> 00:04:28.950
grateful for all the support we get.
00:04:28.960 --> 00:04:30.950
>> Leave a comment about something you
00:04:30.960 --> 00:04:33.030
don't know. Include some knowledge you
00:04:33.040 --> 00:04:34.870
don't possess in the comment section. We
00:04:34.880 --> 00:04:36.870
can figure this out. Knowledge that is
00:04:36.880 --> 00:04:38.550
not inside of your brain.
00:04:38.560 --> 00:04:42.390
>> The exact number of feathers on Earth.
00:04:42.400 --> 00:04:45.510
Roughly 1.5 quadrillion.
00:04:45.520 --> 00:04:46.150
>> Okay.
00:04:46.160 --> 00:04:48.310
>> Let me get this a bit correct here. All
00:04:48.320 --> 00:04:48.629
right.
00:04:48.639 --> 00:04:50.070
>> Are you a darts player?
00:04:50.080 --> 00:04:51.909
>> No, not really. I I have them, but I
00:04:51.919 --> 00:04:53.430
don't play very often. I do many, many
00:04:53.440 --> 00:04:55.430
activities. I can play darts, but I'm
00:04:55.440 --> 00:04:57.670
not the, you know, a dedicated darts
00:04:57.680 --> 00:04:59.670
player. I do knife throwing.
00:04:59.680 --> 00:05:01.270
>> You do knife throwing.
00:05:01.280 --> 00:05:01.830
>> I do.
00:05:01.840 --> 00:05:02.790
>> Wow.
00:05:02.800 --> 00:05:06.550
>> I can throw a no spin throw left-handed
00:05:06.560 --> 00:05:08.550
from 10 ft.
00:05:08.560 --> 00:05:10.469
>> Is that impressive? It sounds
00:05:10.479 --> 00:05:11.749
impressive. Yeah.
00:05:11.759 --> 00:05:14.390
>> Yes. Especially for left-handed.
00:05:14.400 --> 00:05:15.830
>> Oh, yeah. Yeah. [laughter]
00:05:15.840 --> 00:05:18.790
>> And and no and no spin. You don't know.
00:05:18.800 --> 00:05:20.469
You don't know what a no spin throw is
00:05:20.479 --> 00:05:21.749
or
00:05:21.759 --> 00:05:23.909
>> I I can sort of intuit it that it
00:05:23.919 --> 00:05:26.070
doesn't spin in the air, but [laughter]
00:05:26.080 --> 00:05:27.909
>> you can you can you can deduce it from
00:05:27.919 --> 00:05:29.590
the semantics. We're going to be talking
00:05:29.600 --> 00:05:32.950
about language. I will give you a brief
00:05:32.960 --> 00:05:34.950
uh summary of that. Norm you don't
00:05:34.960 --> 00:05:36.710
actually throw knives to start with.
00:05:36.720 --> 00:05:38.629
It's really a spike
00:05:38.639 --> 00:05:40.550
>> specially designed for throwing.
00:05:40.560 --> 00:05:41.430
>> Okay?
00:05:41.440 --> 00:05:43.510
>> You don't just use a knife. It doesn't
00:05:43.520 --> 00:05:45.350
doesn't it's not aerodynamic. It doesn't
00:05:45.360 --> 00:05:46.629
throw well. There are many different
00:05:46.639 --> 00:05:48.230
shapes you can buy. You can buy them on
00:05:48.240 --> 00:05:50.310
Amazon. I'm sure I get most of mine. I
00:05:50.320 --> 00:05:52.790
have about I've got at least 30 knives
00:05:52.800 --> 00:05:55.670
now. So about [laughter] which I like
00:05:55.680 --> 00:05:59.350
the best spikes. Um just get one. Hang
00:05:59.360 --> 00:06:01.270
on a sec. [laughter]
00:06:01.280 --> 00:06:05.350
>> 11 in with a sharp point. It won't
00:06:05.360 --> 00:06:06.550
surprise you to learn they were
00:06:06.560 --> 00:06:09.029
initially used as a weapon of war.
00:06:09.039 --> 00:06:10.230
>> I see. Yes.
00:06:10.240 --> 00:06:12.710
>> Kill people with [laughter] to kill
00:06:12.720 --> 00:06:14.390
people. How you hold it when you're
00:06:14.400 --> 00:06:16.230
doing a nose spin throw. See my index
00:06:16.240 --> 00:06:18.950
finger. My son gave me for a Christmas
00:06:18.960 --> 00:06:21.909
present a few years ago a book about
00:06:21.919 --> 00:06:24.390
knife throwing.
00:06:24.400 --> 00:06:26.710
>> So [laughter] I read it when I got
00:06:26.720 --> 00:06:28.469
around to read it. Took me a while I got
00:06:28.479 --> 00:06:29.909
around to reading. I thought, "Oh, this
00:06:29.919 --> 00:06:32.150
explains how you throw a knife so as to
00:06:32.160 --> 00:06:34.150
make it stick, which is of course what
00:06:34.160 --> 00:06:36.070
you're aiming to do. The standard way of
00:06:36.080 --> 00:06:37.350
throwing a knife where you hold the
00:06:37.360 --> 00:06:41.350
blade end and you throw it and spin it."
00:06:41.360 --> 00:06:42.790
And that's what we all know as knife
00:06:42.800 --> 00:06:43.350
throwing.
00:06:43.360 --> 00:06:45.749
>> Yeah. from the movies, from the kung fu
00:06:45.759 -->
00:06:47.270
films, that's what you see.
00:06:47.280 --> 00:06:49.350
>> Now, the the trouble with that is it's
00:06:49.360 --> 00:06:52.629
not that hard to do a 180 from about 5
00:06:52.639 --> 00:06:55.350
ft, but you can only throw it from that
00:06:55.360 --> 00:06:58.629
location visav the target because it's
00:06:58.639 --> 00:07:00.150
spinning by the laws of physics, you
00:07:00.160 --> 00:07:01.830
know, and it will over spin if you go
00:07:01.840 --> 00:07:03.749
further back. If you want to do a 360,
00:07:03.759 --> 00:07:06.150
you've got to go almost double that. So,
00:07:06.160 --> 00:07:07.670
you can do the math, right? You see how
00:07:07.680 --> 00:07:09.830
wide that is. But it's very difficult to
00:07:09.840 --> 00:07:11.830
do and you can only do it from a
00:07:11.840 --> 00:07:14.230
specific spot. So the Russian guy, I
00:07:14.240 --> 00:07:15.749
forgotten his name now, said the best
00:07:15.759 --> 00:07:17.670
thing to do is learn to use the no spin.
00:07:17.680 --> 00:07:20.230
So he explained it and what's essential
00:07:20.240 --> 00:07:22.390
to it is you put your finger there.
00:07:22.400 --> 00:07:23.749
>> Okay. Now you might think, well, why is
00:07:23.759 --> 00:07:25.110
that going to make it not spin if it's
00:07:25.120 --> 00:07:26.309
going to spin the other way? Good
00:07:26.319 --> 00:07:28.790
question. All these are good questions.
00:07:28.800 --> 00:07:29.830
I'm trying to keep this
00:07:29.840 --> 00:07:31.029
>> We're all thinking it. We're all
00:07:31.039 --> 00:07:31.670
thinking.
00:07:31.680 --> 00:07:33.430
>> I'm going to try to be a bit briefer to
00:07:33.440 --> 00:07:35.749
get to the the main point of it, but it
00:07:35.759 --> 00:07:39.029
needs to be a about an 11 in toring
00:07:39.039 --> 00:07:41.749
knife like this, a spike like this.
00:07:41.759 --> 00:07:43.350
Otherwise, it's not going to be very
00:07:43.360 --> 00:07:45.029
good. So, I got they're quite cheap,
00:07:45.039 --> 00:07:47.510
actually. $20 for three. It's quite
00:07:47.520 --> 00:07:48.950
reasonable. These ones, I think, are the
00:07:48.960 --> 00:07:50.870
best. It's from a certain company. It's
00:07:50.880 --> 00:07:52.469
just the right shape. What you do to
00:07:52.479 --> 00:07:54.550
learn is you stand close to the target,
00:07:54.560 --> 00:07:57.110
and you try to do an O spin throw with
00:07:57.120 --> 00:08:00.070
your finger like this, pushing your tip
00:08:00.080 --> 00:08:01.830
of your finger on the back of the
00:08:01.840 --> 00:08:03.189
perhaps, you can even start to see why
00:08:03.199 --> 00:08:04.629
it stops the spin because it's being
00:08:04.639 --> 00:08:06.390
propelled from the middle. And you also
00:08:06.400 --> 00:08:08.309
release early than you think, earlier
00:08:08.319 --> 00:08:09.990
than you think. And it's not that hard
00:08:10.000 --> 00:08:12.550
from two or three feet to stick it. What
00:08:12.560 --> 00:08:13.990
you do is once you've
learned to to
00:08:14.000 --> 00:08:16.230
stick it say three times in succession.
00:08:16.240 --> 00:08:18.629
You're allowed to go back six inches and
00:08:18.639 --> 00:08:19.830
then when you've done that, you go back
00:08:19.840 --> 00:08:21.270
six inches and you do it again. You do
00:08:21.280 --> 00:08:23.189
it again. It took me oh a year, you
00:08:23.199 --> 00:08:25.830
know, of practicing twice a day to learn
00:08:25.840 --> 00:08:28.230
it. It's it's very difficult actually
00:08:28.240 --> 00:08:29.589
because it's very exact. You have to
00:08:29.599 --> 00:08:31.749
release exactly the right moment. You
00:08:31.759 --> 00:08:33.509
have to do your arm exactly this. If you
00:08:33.519 --> 00:08:36.790
see my out like this, you can't do
00:08:36.800 --> 00:08:39.269
anything like this at all.
00:08:39.279 --> 00:08:40.870
like this. Slide your finger down the
00:08:40.880 --> 00:08:42.230
back of the knife is good to stop it
00:08:42.240 --> 00:08:42.790
rotating.
00:08:42.800 --> 00:08:45.030
>> You're well placed for a very flamboyant
00:08:45.040 --> 00:08:47.750
political assassination now, should you,
00:08:47.760 --> 00:08:50.949
you know, be so inclined.
00:08:50.959 --> 00:08:53.990
>> Yes, I could. I in fact, I would say now
00:08:54.000 --> 00:08:56.441
I can throw it lethally now. I
00:08:56.451 --> 00:08:58.150
[laughter] can throw it. I can throw it
00:08:58.160 --> 00:09:00.389
from 10 10 paces. Not only is it going
00:09:00.399 --> 00:09:02.336
to stick, it's going to go in.
00:09:02.346 --> 00:09:03.590
[laughter]
00:09:03.600 --> 00:09:06.150
I can throw it as hard as I like. I'm
00:09:06.160 --> 00:09:07.269
not going to do it here because I mean
00:09:07.279 --> 00:09:09.269
>> no [laughter]
00:09:09.279 --> 00:09:11.750
>> a quick end to the interview.
00:09:11.760 --> 00:09:15.590
>> So it's so I I practice it over and
00:09:15.600 --> 00:09:17.990
over. Now the thing about it is when you
00:09:18.000 --> 00:09:21.590
do it it's very impressive. [laughter]
00:09:21.600 --> 00:09:24.870
It's very very impressive. I mean it's
00:09:24.880 --> 00:09:26.550
people look at you like whoa what did
00:09:26.560 --> 00:09:28.630
you just do with that? Because you see
00:09:28.640 --> 00:09:30.870
this knife going through the air, high
00:09:30.880 --> 00:09:33.590
velocity, you know, boom, into the
00:09:33.600 --> 00:09:35.269
target like that, you know, in such a
00:09:35.279 --> 00:09:37.670
way if there was a person there, it
00:09:37.680 --> 00:09:39.910
wouldn't be it wouldn't be good news.
00:09:39.920 --> 00:09:41.430
>> Can your neighbors see you? Do your
00:09:41.440 --> 00:09:43.829
neighbors like look over the fence,
00:09:43.839 --> 00:09:45.910
watch the eccentric, knife throwing
00:09:45.920 --> 00:09:47.509
philosopher, neighbor,
00:09:47.519 --> 00:09:50.230
>> I've trained people to do it. So, uh,
00:09:50.240 --> 00:09:53.110
that's what it's nice. So, I do that.
00:09:53.120 --> 00:09:54.790
But, you [laughter] know, also,
00:09:54.800 --> 00:09:56.710
>> could could this be your your greatest
00:09:56.720 --> 00:09:58.870
achievement if you sort of measure out?
00:09:58.880 --> 00:10:00.870
I know you've you've you've done much in
00:10:00.880 --> 00:10:02.070
your life, but could this be your
00:10:02.080 --> 00:10:03.670
greatest achievement, mastering the
00:10:03.680 --> 00:10:04.550
knife? It's
00:10:04.560 --> 00:10:07.110
>> my It's my most uh remarkable or
00:10:07.120 --> 00:10:08.630
unpredictable.
00:10:08.640 --> 00:10:11.829
Well, no, it's actually is not my most
00:10:11.839 --> 00:10:14.230
not my most remarkable, unpredictable.
00:10:14.240 --> 00:10:16.710
Um, you know a bit about me, right? My
00:10:16.720 --> 00:10:19.750
other interests in life, right? Athletic
00:10:19.760 --> 00:10:20.389
interests.
00:10:20.399 --> 00:10:21.910
>> Oh, no. We could get into athletic
00:10:21.920 --> 00:10:22.230
interest
00:10:22.240 --> 00:10:23.670
>> somewhat. I mean, it's kind of your list
00:10:23.680 --> 00:10:26.230
of interests is as long as the entirety
00:10:26.240 --> 00:10:28.630
of the Encyclopedia Britannica. So, it's
00:10:28.640 --> 00:10:30.870
a bit it's a bit complicated. What's
00:10:30.880 --> 00:10:32.630
this guy not written on? It's like, oh
00:10:32.640 --> 00:10:34.470
god, he's written a book on film. He's
00:10:34.480 --> 00:10:35.110
written a book.
00:10:35.120 --> 00:10:36.710
>> We haven't even moved to the things I
00:10:36.720 --> 00:10:39.990
can do in terms of activities.
00:10:40.000 --> 00:10:42.790
It's it makes my academic output seem
00:10:42.800 --> 00:10:45.190
minuscule in comparison. [laughter] I'm
00:10:45.200 --> 00:10:46.790
not really exaggerating that much. The
00:10:46.800 --> 00:10:48.470
thing I that is the most remarkable
00:10:48.480 --> 00:10:50.949
thing I can do is I do hold the school
00:10:50.959 --> 00:10:53.030
record in pole vault at my old school.
00:10:53.040 --> 00:10:54.710
>> Was was that in Blackpool or
00:10:54.720 --> 00:10:56.310
>> It was in Blackpool. Yeah, that's when I
00:10:56.320 --> 00:10:58.630
hold Blackpool Grammar. I was the I had
00:10:58.640 --> 00:11:00.630
the P I was the school champion
00:11:00.640 --> 00:11:01.990
obviously, but I did actually break the
00:11:02.000 --> 00:11:03.430
school record one time. You know, I'm a
00:11:03.440 --> 00:11:04.790
tennis player, right?
00:11:04.800 --> 00:11:05.430
>> Yes.
00:11:05.440 --> 00:11:07.030
>> I have a good two-handed backhand now. I
00:11:07.040 --> 00:11:09.110
had to learn that cuz my my arm I used
00:11:09.120 --> 00:11:11.269
to just play right-handed with one arm
00:11:11.279 --> 00:11:13.670
and now I play with two both sides, you
00:11:13.680 --> 00:11:15.670
know, but I play a lot. I play every day
00:11:15.680 --> 00:11:17.590
basically. I was a gymnast at school,
00:11:17.600 --> 00:11:19.990
trampolinist, table tennis. I was very
00:11:20.000 --> 00:11:21.509
good table tennis player. Still am. The
00:11:21.519 --> 00:11:23.030
main thing I can do, the thing I'm best
00:11:23.040 --> 00:11:24.949
at and enjoy the most is something most
00:11:24.959 --> 00:11:27.750
people haven't heard of, which is wave
00:11:27.760 --> 00:11:29.509
ski surfing
00:11:29.519 --> 00:11:31.509
>> where you it's a kayak. It's a kayak
00:11:31.519 --> 00:11:34.150
like thing. It's a bit like a surfboard
00:11:34.160 --> 00:11:36.470
in materials and shape, but you sit in
00:11:36.480 --> 00:11:37.030
it.
00:11:37.040 --> 00:11:39.110
>> There's a seat belt, there's foot straps
00:11:39.120 --> 00:11:40.790
as well, and you have a paddle
00:11:40.800 --> 00:11:42.310
obviously, and you surf. You surf a
00:11:42.320 --> 00:11:43.030
wave.
00:11:43.040 --> 00:11:45.750
>> M. Uh, and I also done w wind surfing
00:11:45.760 --> 00:11:47.350
and paddle boarding and all those kinds
00:11:47.360 --> 00:11:49.350
of things. I put a lot of time into kite
00:11:49.360 --> 00:11:50.949
surfing, but in the end didn't work out.
00:11:50.959 --> 00:11:52.389
It was too difficult to do it. You can't
00:11:52.399 --> 00:11:53.509
find an opportunity.
00:11:53.519 --> 00:11:55.670
>> So, let's let's move on to the the
00:11:55.680 --> 00:11:57.750
philosophy part. We start all our
00:11:57.760 --> 00:12:00.870
conversations with a poetic epigraph
00:12:00.880 --> 00:12:03.750
which I'll just quickly read. Shadows
00:12:03.760 --> 00:12:06.150
gesture messages on the grass and the
00:12:06.160 --> 00:12:08.790
graves like the palm prints pressed by
00:12:08.800 --> 00:12:10.790
my ancestors on the copper colored
00:12:10.800 --> 00:12:14.230
caves. I am a thing, a truth I do not
00:12:14.240 --> 00:12:17.030
understand. The eye is not filled by
00:12:17.040 --> 00:12:19.509
seeing. The work is not filled by the
00:12:19.519 --> 00:12:22.790
hand. Bells chime over the vineyards.
00:12:22.800 --> 00:12:25.910
Collared dove calls roll. An angel of
00:12:25.920 --> 00:12:28.550
the Lord guards the human being from the
00:12:28.560 --> 00:12:32.629
human soul.
00:12:32.639 --> 00:12:35.350
So to start off, let's talk a bit about
00:12:35.360 --> 00:12:37.990
the the current state of philosophy of
00:12:38.000 --> 00:12:40.310
mind and the philosophy of language in
00:12:40.320 --> 00:12:42.310
universities. There's a lot of
00:12:42.320 --> 00:12:45.590
specialization across academia um not
00:12:45.600 --> 00:12:47.590
only between separate subjects. So the
00:12:47.600 --> 00:12:50.230
biologists never talk to the computer
00:12:50.240 --> 00:12:51.829
scientists who never talk to the
00:12:51.839 --> 00:12:53.750
philosophers but also different kinds of
00:12:53.760 --> 00:12:55.829
philosophers also have a habit of not
00:12:55.839 --> 00:12:58.069
talking to each other even though
00:12:58.079 --> 00:13:01.750
subjects like language, mind and biology
00:13:01.760 --> 00:13:04.550
are obviously intimately related. How do
00:13:04.560 --> 00:13:07.350
you think
it would be possible to uh
00:13:07.360 --> 00:13:10.310
integrate philosophy of language more
00:13:10.320 --> 00:13:13.670
closely with philosophy of mind?
00:13:13.680 --> 00:13:15.269
>> Yeah, I mean you're right of course
00:13:15.279 --> 00:13:18.150
about that. It it arises presumably from
00:13:18.160 --> 00:13:20.069
just the specialization of subjects
00:13:20.079 --> 00:13:22.629
within universities which is artificial
00:13:22.639 --> 00:13:26.629
to begin with. Um when I was at
00:13:26.639 --> 00:13:28.069
University College London, the
00:13:28.079 --> 00:13:30.230
philosophy department was between
00:13:30.240 --> 00:13:32.230
literally between the psychology
00:13:32.240 --> 00:13:33.350
department and the linguistics
00:13:33.360 --> 00:13:34.949
department [laughter]
00:13:34.959 --> 00:13:36.550
and they would ask me to give talks to
00:13:36.560 --> 00:13:38.069
them every now and then. The linguistics
00:13:38.079 --> 00:13:39.750
and the psychology department which I
00:13:39.760 --> 00:13:42.870
did. Uh I was originally a psychologist
00:13:42.880 --> 00:13:45.269
of course so I wasn't that that's my
00:13:45.279 --> 00:13:47.670
first degrees in psychology and then I
00:13:47.680 --> 00:13:50.069
moved over to philosophy. My main
00:13:50.079 --> 00:13:52.069
interest when I was a psychology student
00:13:52.079 --> 00:13:54.710
towards the end was chsky.
00:13:54.720 --> 00:13:56.710
>> So of course I was interested in chsky's
00:13:56.720 --> 00:13:59.509
linguistics. So I was already quite
00:13:59.519 --> 00:14:01.590
knowledgeable about chsky before I went
00:14:01.600 --> 00:14:03.590
to Oxford to do and I was interested in
00:14:03.600 --> 00:14:06.310
philosophy of language there which is
00:14:06.320 --> 00:14:09.910
you know Davidson quin gripkkey
00:14:09.920 --> 00:14:11.670
that kind of stuff and they are quite
00:14:11.680 --> 00:14:13.430
different there's not much overlap.
00:14:13.440 --> 00:14:16.150
>> Yeah. So many philosophers of language
00:14:16.160 --> 00:14:18.550
in Oxford and elsewhere don't know much
00:14:18.560 --> 00:14:20.949
about Chsky which they really should
00:14:20.959 --> 00:14:23.269
know about Chsky. It's it really is a
00:14:23.279 --> 00:14:25.590
good idea you know to read a few of his
00:14:25.600 --> 00:14:28.470
books. Don't just you know read a
00:14:28.480 --> 00:14:30.629
summary of anything. You need to read
00:14:30.639 --> 00:14:32.790
several Chsky books because that you
00:14:32.800 --> 00:14:35.030
know he's he's the guy there. So that's
00:14:35.040 --> 00:14:36.470
when I was doing psychology there was
00:14:36.480 --> 00:14:38.389
that. So and I and I so I read the
00:14:38.399 --> 00:14:40.629
linguistics through Chsky and then then
00:14:40.639 --> 00:14:43.030
the philosophy. So those things all
00:14:43.040 --> 00:14:45.990
ought to be brought together. Uh Chsky's
00:14:46.000 --> 00:14:49.430
approach to language is biological.
00:14:49.440 --> 00:14:50.069
>> Yes.
00:14:50.079 --> 00:14:52.389
>> Always has been. So that leads you more
00:14:52.399 --> 00:14:54.790
toward biology as well.
00:14:54.800 --> 00:14:56.870
>> So I do think you need biology to be
00:14:56.880 --> 00:14:59.590
included in this multisell that we're
00:14:59.600 --> 00:15:00.470
talking about.
00:15:00.480 --> 00:15:02.389
>> Now how do you get people to do that?
00:15:02.399 --> 00:15:04.870
Well, how do you get people to do
00:15:04.880 --> 00:15:07.910
anything? I mean people are too special.
00:15:07.920 --> 00:15:09.670
They specialize too much. They're
00:15:09.680 --> 00:15:12.310
insecure about going beyond their
00:15:12.320 --> 00:15:13.910
specialtity
00:15:13.920 --> 00:15:15.750
and so and they and they find it
00:15:15.760 --> 00:15:16.870
difficult. I mean they found it hard
00:15:16.880 --> 00:15:20.150
enough to learn in graduate school about
00:15:20.160 --> 00:15:22.550
philosophy of language but now you've
00:15:22.560 --> 00:15:25.509
got to learn linguistics and psychology
00:15:25.519 --> 00:15:27.590
and so on or biology and then it's too
00:15:27.600 --> 00:15:28.790
much for them. I mean the only thing I
00:15:28.800 --> 00:15:31.189
can say is that people really should
00:15:31.199 --> 00:15:34.230
study up other other subjects which are
00:15:34.240 --> 00:15:35.269
relevant to the things they're
00:15:35.279 --> 00:15:36.870
interested in to give them the right
00:15:36.880 --> 00:15:38.710
perspective. I mean, I've grown to
00:15:38.720 --> 00:15:40.310
believe that you need to take an
00:15:40.320 --> 00:15:42.069
evolutionary perspective about many
00:15:42.079 --> 00:15:44.230
subjects that philosophers talk about
00:15:44.240 --> 00:15:46.230
and psychologists. Psychologists have
00:15:46.240 --> 00:15:48.629
adopted that now for longer. philosophy
00:15:48.639 --> 00:15:51.509
I think has been rather slow to see the
00:15:51.519 --> 00:15:55.189
virtues of of uh biological I want to
00:15:55.199 --> 00:15:57.189
say not not biological competence just
00:15:57.199 --> 00:15:58.710
under you don't have to know all about
00:15:58.720 --> 00:16:00.629
the species you know and genetics and
00:16:00.639 --> 00:16:02.310
everything but just the the way they
00:16:02.320 --> 00:16:03.910
understand things and the way they do
00:16:03.920 --> 00:16:06.629
things what they count as an explanation
00:16:06.639 --> 00:16:09.350
that kind of thing is good to know uh
00:16:09.360 --> 00:16:11.269
fortunately they have Richard Dawkins to
00:16:11.279 --> 00:16:13.910
read so that's possible to learn up a
00:16:13.920 --> 00:16:16.710
lot of good biology without uh too much
00:16:16.720 --> 00:16:19.749
pain you You know, you can just read
00:16:19.759 --> 00:16:21.350
I've read every single book by Richard
00:16:21.360 --> 00:16:23.509
Dawkins, literally some more than once,
00:16:23.519 --> 00:16:25.910
like The Selfish Gene. It's a it's an
00:16:25.920 --> 00:16:28.710
absolute gold mine of information
for
00:16:28.720 --> 00:16:31.030
philosophers to read about. It's well
00:16:31.040 --> 00:16:34.310
written. It's, you know, clear. It's
00:16:34.320 --> 00:16:36.150
perfect. You've got to try to get people
00:16:36.160 --> 00:16:38.710
to be a bit broader. This is true of
00:16:38.720 --> 00:16:40.629
philosophy in general. I mean people who
00:16:40.639 --> 00:16:42.150
doing philosophy of mind say not just
00:16:42.160 --> 00:16:43.990
philosophy of language they do need to
00:16:44.000 --> 00:16:45.829
know some psychology and they do need to
00:16:45.839 --> 00:16:48.550
know some biology but it you know people
00:16:48.560 --> 00:16:50.949
are finite people can't learn everything
00:16:50.959 --> 00:16:52.870
they're busy so it's maybe not that
00:16:52.880 --> 00:16:55.030
culpable on their part that they can't
00:16:55.040 --> 00:16:57.189
come up with everything but they should
00:16:57.199 --> 00:16:59.030
make a bit more of an effort and they
00:16:59.040 --> 00:17:00.629
should at least acknowledge that it
00:17:00.639 --> 00:17:02.470
would be good if they knew more about
00:17:02.480 --> 00:17:04.309
that I think even within philosophy of
00:17:04.319 --> 00:17:06.870
language actually even quite narrow
00:17:06.880 --> 00:17:09.909
people are also narrow even in that
00:17:09.919 --> 00:17:12.470
>> yes it's true all the all the languages
00:17:12.480 --> 00:17:14.710
use people don't talk to the semantics
00:17:14.720 --> 00:17:16.230
people very much yeah
00:17:16.240 --> 00:17:17.909
>> the Vickensteinian philosophers of
00:17:17.919 --> 00:17:19.510
language if there were any left there
00:17:19.520 --> 00:17:21.110
may not be anymore there left then
00:17:21.120 --> 00:17:23.110
you've got the formal semanticists you
00:17:23.120 --> 00:17:24.549
see they don't know they can't read
00:17:24.559 --> 00:17:26.710
Vickenstein Vickenstein scholars can't
00:17:26.720 --> 00:17:30.390
read Montigue you know or taski they're
00:17:30.400 --> 00:17:32.310
too difficult you know I for various
00:17:32.320 --> 00:17:33.909
reasons
00:17:33.919 --> 00:17:35.669
found myself having to work on
00:17:35.679 --> 00:17:37.270
Vickenstein and one of my early books is
00:17:37.280 --> 00:17:39.029
about Vickenstein when I was a student
00:17:39.039 --> 00:17:40.630
graduate student in Oxford. Nobody read
00:17:40.640 --> 00:17:41.990
Vickenstein
00:17:42.000 --> 00:17:42.390
>> really
00:17:42.400 --> 00:17:44.549
>> because cryp books that I did.
00:17:44.559 --> 00:17:44.950
>> Mhm.
00:17:44.960 --> 00:17:46.310
>> So that got me and I started teaching
00:17:46.320 --> 00:17:47.830
it. So then I became a Vickenstein
00:17:47.840 --> 00:17:50.950
expert sort of uh so I now wrote a book
00:17:50.960 --> 00:17:52.870
about it. So I think it's good to know
00:17:52.880 --> 00:17:55.430
that and it's good to know you know you
00:17:55.440 --> 00:17:57.270
need to know your task of course you
00:17:57.280 --> 00:17:59.830
need to know all that stuff. Grace you
00:17:59.840 --> 00:18:01.270
should I wrote a whole book in it didn't
00:18:01.280 --> 00:18:02.390
I? Yeah.
00:18:02.400 --> 00:18:02.789
>> Uh
00:18:02.799 --> 00:18:04.870
>> yeah that guide book which is from the
00:18:04.880 --> 00:18:07.350
undergrad based on my lectures.
00:18:07.360 --> 00:18:08.870
>> Yeah. You need to know that. I mean, I'm
00:18:08.880 --> 00:18:10.950
I'm interested in language in general,
00:18:10.960 --> 00:18:13.029
actually. But before I started speaking
00:18:13.039 --> 00:18:15.270
to you, I was just doing some what they
00:18:15.280 --> 00:18:19.669
call research on English accents.
00:18:19.679 --> 00:18:21.669
>> Got a couple here you can look into.
00:18:21.679 --> 00:18:23.350
>> Sometimes sometimes this subject comes
00:18:23.360 --> 00:18:26.150
up over here in the US uh because people
00:18:26.160 --> 00:18:27.669
wonder what my accent is and I say,
00:18:27.679 --> 00:18:29.190
well, I don't have a regional accent. I
00:18:29.200 --> 00:18:32.230
have a a kind of accent which is an
00:18:32.240 --> 00:18:34.310
amalgam of different ones. One of the
00:18:34.320 --> 00:18:36.470
things I've noticed
00:18:36.480 --> 00:18:38.950
since I left England, which is now 36
00:18:38.960 --> 00:18:41.510
years ago, that the pronunciation of the
00:18:41.520 --> 00:18:44.789
ooh sound has changed a bit. And to so
00:18:44.799 --> 00:18:46.549
when somebody says wants to say the word
00:18:46.559 --> 00:18:49.270
roof, they say roof
00:18:49.280 --> 00:18:50.470
>> roof roof
00:18:50.480 --> 00:18:53.110
>> roof roof roof roof
00:18:53.120 --> 00:18:54.710
>> instead of roof.
00:18:54.720 --> 00:18:56.950
>> So I say to my son who does this, my son
00:18:56.960 --> 00:18:58.950
is a doctor, you know, he's not some
00:18:58.960 --> 00:19:00.950
kind of vocal, you know, he's he has to
00:19:00.960 --> 00:19:05.190
talk. So he says going to the Lou or the
00:19:05.200 --> 00:19:09.909
reef or the room. So anyway, since AI
00:19:09.919 --> 00:19:11.990
now exists, I went in and I said, "Has
00:19:12.000 --> 00:19:13.909
there been a movement in English
00:19:13.919 --> 00:19:17.270
pronunciation of U to E?" And it says
00:19:17.280 --> 00:19:20.870
no, it's not. Nobody says reef. And
00:19:20.880 --> 00:19:23.283
that's true. They don't say reef.
00:19:23.293 --> 00:19:23.669
[laughter]
00:19:23.679 --> 00:19:26.230
>> What has happened apparently is
00:19:26.240 --> 00:19:27.430
>> that the [snorts] pronunciation of the
00:19:27.440 --> 00:19:29.110
ooh sound has moved from the back of the
00:19:29.120 --> 00:19:30.950
mouth to the middle or front of the
00:19:30.960 --> 00:19:32.630
mouth. And if you test it in yourself,
00:19:32.640 --> 00:19:35.270
you see it will make you say it like
00:19:35.280 --> 00:19:37.510
like it's an euth
00:19:37.520 --> 00:19:38.470
roof. Roof.
00:19:38.480 --> 00:19:40.390
>> I haven't noticed that you two say it's
00:19:40.400 --> 00:19:42.390
I haven't noticed that
you two say that
00:19:42.400 --> 00:19:45.510
say it that way. So many people older
00:19:45.520 --> 00:19:47.190
people from England don't say it at all.
00:19:47.200 --> 00:19:50.230
They say roof room. They don't say if
00:19:50.240 --> 00:19:52.390
you but if you try to say it forward
00:19:52.400 --> 00:19:57.343
room, it starts to turn into an e sound.
00:19:57.353 --> 00:19:57.360
[laughter]
00:19:57.360 --> 00:19:59.750
>> Yeah.
00:19:59.760 --> 00:20:01.830
So anyway, that's that's beside the
00:20:01.840 --> 00:20:03.990
point. So I don't know what to do about
00:20:04.000 --> 00:20:06.230
the fact that I mean also lingu
00:20:06.240 --> 00:20:08.390
linguists should know about philosophy
00:20:08.400 --> 00:20:10.390
of language. Yes, psychologist should
00:20:10.400 --> 00:20:11.990
know about philosophy of language as
00:20:12.000 --> 00:20:13.909
well as linguistics. They all should
00:20:13.919 --> 00:20:14.789
know about it.
00:20:14.799 --> 00:20:17.270
>> When which aspects of language like
00:20:17.280 --> 00:20:20.470
phenology, syntax, pragmatics, semantics
00:20:20.480 --> 00:20:23.029
do you think are sort of the oldest
00:20:23.039 --> 00:20:26.310
evolutionarily or most fundamental? And
00:20:26.320 --> 00:20:27.909
do you think any of them are anywhere
00:20:27.919 --> 00:20:29.909
near as old as consciousness?
00:20:29.919 --> 00:20:33.029
>> The building blocks of syntax and
00:20:33.039 --> 00:20:36.310
phenology probably not
00:20:36.320 --> 00:20:38.950
semantics. Um well maybe in some
00:20:38.960 --> 00:20:40.789
respects semantics depends how broad you
00:20:40.799 --> 00:20:42.630
get with what how far you want to go
00:20:42.640 --> 00:20:44.870
back. They are obviously very ancient
00:20:44.880 --> 00:20:47.110
because the human vocal system could
00:20:47.120 --> 00:20:49.190
produce noises well before language
00:20:49.200 --> 00:20:50.710
existed,
00:20:50.720 --> 00:20:53.029
right? Just like animals produce noises
00:20:53.039 --> 00:20:55.029
and the production of noises by animals
00:20:55.039 --> 00:20:56.870
presumably goes back well to the
00:20:56.880 --> 00:20:59.830
dinosaurs and earlier than that. So
00:20:59.840 --> 00:21:02.230
that's true. Now if you try to get it a
00:21:02.240 --> 00:21:04.230
little more specific,
00:21:04.240 --> 00:21:06.230
I think that the phenology that's
00:21:06.240 --> 00:21:08.950
characteristic of language is not
00:21:08.960 --> 00:21:11.590
recent. I mean is recent, I'm sorry.
00:21:11.600 --> 00:21:13.909
It's not old. It's not ancient. Uh
00:21:13.919 --> 00:21:16.630
because it's a very specific kind of of
00:21:16.640 --> 00:21:19.190
noise that you make with the mouth. And
00:21:19.200 --> 00:21:21.029
the vocal apparatus we know it did
00:21:21.039 --> 00:21:23.110
evolve fair fairly late. Language is
00:21:23.120 --> 00:21:24.950
supposed to have evolved in humans about
00:21:24.960 --> 00:21:27.990
200,000 years ago. So the and the vocal
00:21:28.000 --> 00:21:29.990
apparatus changed to accommodate that.
00:21:30.000 --> 00:21:31.190
So we don't have the same vocal
00:21:31.200 --> 00:21:32.630
apparatus we had before language came
00:21:32.640 --> 00:21:35.270
along. There's changed by because of the
00:21:35.280 --> 00:21:37.110
existence of language. In the case of
00:21:37.120 --> 00:21:39.510
syntax, well it depends a bit on what
00:21:39.520 --> 00:21:41.830
you're going to mean by syntax. But um
00:21:41.840 --> 00:21:45.029
you know Chumsk's view of this you know
00:21:45.039 --> 00:21:47.110
he's got this idea of merge which is a
00:21:47.120 --> 00:21:50.789
kind of set theoretic operation which
00:21:50.799 --> 00:21:53.110
involves recursion he thinks that was
00:21:53.120 --> 00:21:57.510
like one uh mutation
00:21:57.520 --> 00:22:01.110
uh and that produced the basic apparatus
00:22:01.120 --> 00:22:02.230
of language because it produced
00:22:02.240 --> 00:22:04.710
hierarchy and that kind of thing that's
00:22:04.720 --> 00:22:05.990
that would have been quite recent
00:22:06.000 --> 00:22:08.549
according to him but if you think of it
00:22:08.559 --> 00:22:10.470
uh for for example the way I described
00:22:10.480 --> 00:22:12.310
it in prehension. I think it's as old as
00:22:12.320 --> 00:22:14.149
the grip
00:22:14.159 --> 00:22:16.070
because I think that reference chy is
00:22:16.080 --> 00:22:17.190
not interested in reference. You see,
00:22:17.200 --> 00:22:19.350
he's interested in syntax.
00:22:19.360 --> 00:22:21.510
>> Some pe some authors writing about this
00:22:21.520 --> 00:22:24.470
have thought that the the grammar of
00:22:24.480 --> 00:22:27.190
subjects in predicate is connected to
00:22:27.200 --> 00:22:29.350
movement of the hand to hold like this
00:22:29.360 --> 00:22:31.510
kind of thing.
00:22:31.520 --> 00:22:34.390
>> Uh so it's hard to say you know if you
00:22:34.400 --> 00:22:36.390
if you interpret syntax in a narrow way
00:22:36.400 --> 00:22:37.590
then it's going to be recent. If you
00:22:37.600 --> 00:22:38.950
interpret it in a very broad way, it's
00:22:38.960 --> 00:22:40.549
going to be more ancient. Consciousness
00:22:40.559 --> 00:22:43.350
is undoubtedly, I think, much older than
00:22:43.360 --> 00:22:45.430
than language. Certainly than, you know,
00:22:45.440 --> 00:22:47.190
what we now think of as human language.
00:22:47.200 --> 00:22:49.029
That's consciousness goes back, you
00:22:49.039 --> 00:22:51.430
know, obviously to earliest creatures.
00:22:51.440 --> 00:22:53.669
When soon as you've got a brain, you
00:22:53.679 --> 00:22:55.029
start to have glimmerings of it at
00:22:55.039 --> 00:22:57.909
least. So once there's a some neurons
00:22:57.919 --> 00:22:59.430
bunched together, you know, in a spinal
00:22:59.440 --> 00:23:02.630
cord or even not a spinal cord, uh,
00:23:02.640 --> 00:23:04.630
you're going to start to get the first
00:23:04.640 --> 00:23:06.230
origins of language, origins of
00:23:06.240 -->
00:23:07.669
consciousness. I think they probably
00:23:07.679 --> 00:23:09.270
have to do with pain. I've written about
00:23:09.280 --> 00:23:11.110
this on my blog a bit. The first
00:23:11.120 --> 00:23:12.549
sensation was pain
00:23:12.559 --> 00:23:14.870
>> or discomfort or something like that.
00:23:14.880 --> 00:23:16.310
>> But if we mean by consciousness
00:23:16.320 --> 00:23:17.909
something involving intentionality,
00:23:17.919 --> 00:23:19.909
which is what people now think, well,
00:23:19.919 --> 00:23:21.270
that's going to be more recent, but
00:23:21.280 --> 00:23:22.549
still pretty old I would say because
00:23:22.559 --> 00:23:24.310
that's going to be as old as perception,
00:23:24.320 --> 00:23:24.789
vision,
00:23:24.799 --> 00:23:27.110
>> right? Sort of intentionality,
00:23:27.120 --> 00:23:29.750
perception, semantics. Are these sort of
00:23:29.760 --> 00:23:32.070
emerging simultaneously? Sort of
00:23:32.080 --> 00:23:34.070
different parts of the same phenomenon?
00:23:34.080 --> 00:23:37.909
>> Yeah. Yeah, I would think so. I mean in
00:23:37.919 --> 00:23:40.470
evolution often in the case of language
00:23:40.480 --> 00:23:43.270
I think almost certainly it didn't
00:23:43.280 --> 00:23:44.950
evolve from one thing. It's really a
00:23:44.960 --> 00:23:46.390
kind of lucky combination of things
00:23:46.400 --> 00:23:48.149
which coexisted and were brought
00:23:48.159 --> 00:23:49.830
together
00:23:49.840 --> 00:23:51.990
>> uh to produce. And also what do we mean
00:23:52.000 --> 00:23:54.230
by language? Chsky means by language not
00:23:54.240 --> 00:23:56.310
speech. He thinks that's to do with the
00:23:56.320 --> 00:23:57.430
sensory motor system.
00:23:57.440 --> 00:23:59.190
>> It's not communication is it? It's
00:23:59.200 --> 00:23:59.990
thought.
00:24:00.000 --> 00:24:01.669
>> He he thinks language is in the brain
00:24:01.679 --> 00:24:03.830
and it's not to do with communication at
00:24:03.840 --> 00:24:06.310
all. He thinks language arrived for
00:24:06.320 --> 00:24:09.830
thought to aid thought. Yeah, maybe. So
00:24:09.840 --> 00:24:11.909
if we're meaning speech, speech,
00:24:11.919 --> 00:24:13.830
language, spoken language, you know,
00:24:13.840 --> 00:24:15.909
then we get a different answer too. And
00:24:15.919 --> 00:24:19.029
it may well be that the uh the apparatus
00:24:19.039 --> 00:24:21.350
of language, the basic cognitive
00:24:21.360 --> 00:24:23.750
structures preceded speech by a long
00:24:23.760 --> 00:24:26.549
time. That mutation could have occurred
00:24:26.559 --> 00:24:29.190
long before it was ever joined onto the
00:24:29.200 --> 00:24:31.430
speech system.
00:24:31.440 --> 00:24:34.070
So nobody knows the answer to these
00:24:34.080 --> 00:24:35.830
questions of course I mean we're just
00:24:35.840 --> 00:24:37.510
speculating we're just speculating
00:24:37.520 --> 00:24:39.269
roughly what we think is the most
00:24:39.279 --> 00:24:41.990
intelligible chronology given the
00:24:42.000 --> 00:24:43.269
structure of the phenomenon you know
00:24:43.279 --> 00:24:44.789
what's what's going on the phenomenon
00:24:44.799 --> 00:24:47.110
the pragmatics is another question again
00:24:47.120 --> 00:24:49.190
because the pragmatics has to do with
00:24:49.200 --> 00:24:52.630
communication mainly uh which according
00:24:52.640 --> 00:24:53.990
to chsky has got nothing to do with
00:24:54.000 --> 00:24:56.149
language according to him communication
00:24:56.159 --> 00:24:57.350
and language have got nothing to do with
00:24:57.360 --> 00:24:59.350
each other it's just communication just
00:24:59.360 --> 00:25:02.630
an add-on later. But if we if we go to
00:25:02.640 --> 00:25:05.110
if we think about communication that
00:25:05.120 --> 00:25:06.789
obviously is shared by other animals
00:25:06.799 --> 00:25:09.110
even quite you know primitive animals as
00:25:09.120 --> 00:25:11.669
we as we always say uh obviously by
00:25:11.679 --> 00:25:14.310
dolphins, whales and whatnot. So there's
00:25:14.320 --> 00:25:15.909
an tremendous amount of signaling going
00:25:15.919 --> 00:25:17.750
on which communicates information from
00:25:17.760 --> 00:25:19.350
one animal to another that goes back to
00:25:19.360 --> 00:25:22.710
insects. Some of that mating rituals and
00:25:22.720 --> 00:25:24.870
so on is communicative. That's obviously
00:25:24.880 --> 00:25:26.630
going to be very ancient. So that's
00:25:26.640 --> 00:25:29.909
going to be the origin of pragmatics. M
00:25:29.919 --> 00:25:31.669
>> the use of language in communicative
00:25:31.679 --> 00:25:34.149
situations with speakers and hearers
00:25:34.159 --> 00:25:36.870
that's going to be old. In the case of
00:25:36.880 --> 00:25:40.149
human languages, the decisive turning
00:25:40.159 --> 00:25:42.789
point presumably had to do with
00:25:42.799 --> 00:25:44.470
integrating
00:25:44.480 --> 00:25:47.350
referential or intentional
00:25:47.360 --> 00:25:49.990
abilities with syntactic abilities,
00:25:50.000 --> 00:25:52.310
combinatorial abilities. [snorts]
00:25:52.320 --> 00:25:54.470
So Chsky always emphasizes the product
00:25:54.480 --> 00:25:55.830
productivity of language. you can make
00:25:55.840 --> 00:25:57.990
infinitely many sentences out of finite
00:25:58.000 --> 00:26:00.870
number of primitive
00:26:00.880 --> 00:26:05.110
uh items. Uh so that's that's one side
00:26:05.120 --> 00:26:07.430
of language the syntactic combinatorial
00:26:07.440 --> 00:26:09.510
and the other side is the referential
00:26:09.520 --> 00:26:11.830
side of it and they have different
00:26:11.840 --> 00:26:13.909
origins apparently and they didn't come
00:26:13.919 --> 00:26:15.190
together at the same just they happened
00:26:15.200 --> 00:26:17.669
to come together according to according
00:26:17.679 --> 00:26:21.190
to my my bookhension and people people I
00:26:21.200 --> 00:26:23.909
was uh reading at the time the first
00:26:23.919 -->
00:26:26.950
language was human language is probably
00:26:26.960 --> 00:26:29.590
gestural language not even a vocal one
00:26:29.600 --> 00:26:32.630
or was mainly v mainly gestural
00:26:32.640 --> 00:26:34.549
And the hands, the fingers, hands and
00:26:34.559 --> 00:26:36.390
fingers are quite well adapted. You see,
00:26:36.400 --> 00:26:38.390
as we know from sign language,
00:26:38.400 --> 00:26:39.909
>> if you want to signal things, you've got
00:26:39.919 --> 00:26:41.669
the fingers to and so on. You know,
00:26:41.679 --> 00:26:43.669
>> apparently language learners uh learn
00:26:43.679 --> 00:26:45.510
like a significant amount better if they
00:26:45.520 --> 00:26:48.070
if they write a lot in the target
00:26:48.080 --> 00:26:49.990
language as well. There is an intimate
00:26:50.000 --> 00:26:51.350
relationship
00:26:51.360 --> 00:26:53.750
>> that's probably quite deep between our
00:26:53.760 --> 00:26:55.750
hands, between our hand movements and
00:26:55.760 --> 00:26:57.110
our
00:26:57.120 --> 00:26:59.110
>> um yeah, our language. I I was going to
00:26:59.120 --> 00:27:01.590
say our lexicon, but maybe it's not.
00:27:01.600 --> 00:27:01.909
>> Yeah.
00:27:01.919 --> 00:27:03.269
>> Yeah. No, I think that's absolutely
00:27:03.279 --> 00:27:05.590
right that I think that being a a writer
00:27:05.600 --> 00:27:07.510
is more natural than being a speaker in
00:27:07.520 --> 00:27:09.590
some ways.
00:27:09.600 --> 00:27:12.230
>> But the hands the hands were in on it
00:27:12.240 --> 00:27:15.029
from early on. So, and if if you are a
00:27:15.039 --> 00:27:17.909
writer as I am, I love writing, you
00:27:17.919 --> 00:27:19.990
know, uh it feels like there was natural
00:27:20.000 --> 00:27:21.990
activity in the world to me. this this
00:27:22.000 --> 00:27:23.909
whole subject was debated long ago, you
00:27:23.919 --> 00:27:25.750
know, the origin of language and it's
00:27:25.760 --> 00:27:28.310
all very shrouded in mystery. Of course,
00:27:28.320 --> 00:27:28.950
>> of course.
00:27:28.960 --> 00:27:31.263
>> So, who's to know what to say?
00:27:31.273 --> 00:27:31.279
[clears throat]
00:27:31.279 --> 00:27:33.750
>> And part of it is it's almost it's one
00:27:33.760 --> 00:27:36.070
of those things and we get it a lot in
00:27:36.080 --> 00:27:39.110
in the subjects that you're expert in
00:27:39.120 --> 00:27:41.029
that language to discuss and describe
00:27:41.039 --> 00:27:43.190
it. We have to use it. And so, we get
00:27:43.200 --> 00:27:45.830
into semantic problems about semantics.
00:27:45.840 --> 00:27:48.230
The word language it seems simple enough
00:27:48.240 --> 00:27:50.149
but just now we've cracked it into maybe
00:27:50.159 --> 00:27:52.310
five different some of which not even
00:27:52.320 --> 00:27:53.750
that related things like oh
00:27:53.760 --> 00:27:56.070
communication and speech which might be
00:27:56.080 --> 00:27:58.149
you know a school book definition of
00:27:58.159 --> 00:28:00.070
language we can actually cut those out
00:28:00.080 --> 00:28:02.230
entirely and be left with language
00:28:02.240 --> 00:28:03.510
>> you
00:28:03.520 --> 00:28:05.590
>> so it's just how yeah how do we deal
00:28:05.600 --> 00:28:08.070
with we we inherit this language again I
00:28:08.080 --> 00:28:10.470
keep using the word about language which
00:28:10.480 --> 00:28:12.230
might not refer to language so in order
00:28:12.240 --> 00:28:14.710
to even conduct the study we have to cut
00:28:14.720 --> 00:28:17.750
through this this way that we even
00:28:17.760 --> 00:28:20.070
understand or comprehend. So it's this
00:28:20.080 --> 00:28:22.549
really weird sort of self-awareness,
00:28:22.559 --> 00:28:24.630
selfanalysis.
00:28:24.640 --> 00:28:26.950
What is language? Using language which
00:28:26.960 --> 00:28:29.510
wasn't primed to talk about it.
00:28:29.520 --> 00:28:30.950
>> Johnsky's whole view of this is that
00:28:30.960 --> 00:28:32.389
language has really got nothing to do
00:28:32.399 --> 00:28:34.149
with you nothing to do with
00:28:34.159 --> 00:28:36.310
communication. It's a cognitive
00:28:36.320 --> 00:28:39.510
structure in the brain you know which
00:28:39.520 --> 00:28:42.950
arose from a mutation of of some sort.
00:28:42.960 --> 00:28:44.630
uh and what so but most philosophers
00:28:44.640 --> 00:28:45.669
when they when they use the word
00:28:45.679 --> 00:28:48.630
language they're referring to speech of
00:28:48.640 --> 00:28:52.070
like Italian English Swedish you know
00:28:52.080 --> 00:28:53.990
but that's is John's way of looking at
00:28:54.000 --> 00:28:56.389
it is well that's just a folk way to
00:28:56.399 --> 00:28:57.750
think about things if you're doing real
00:28:57.760 --> 00:28:59.029
science you've got to analyze the
00:28:59.039 --> 00:28:59.909
phenomenon
00:28:59.919 --> 00:29:01.590
>> and find its essence and that's going to
00:29:01.600 --> 00:29:03.750
be in the head you know it's uh that's
00:29:03.760 --> 00:29:06.389
why he's an internalist about things
00:29:06.399 --> 00:29:09.029
>> in the um 20th century during like the
00:29:09.039 --> 00:29:11.510
the height of analytic philosophy there
00:29:11.520 --> 00:29:12.870
was this you know there's a sort of
00:29:12.880 --> 00:29:15.909
trend to try and use language or pay
00:29:15.919 --> 00:29:17.750
close attention to the logic of language
00:29:17.760 --> 00:29:21.350
in order to explain lots of uh different
00:29:21.360 --> 00:29:24.710
conundrums including the the conundrum
00:29:24.720 --> 00:29:27.110
of of consciousness.
00:29:27.120 --> 00:29:30.549
Why why do you think this doesn't work
00:29:30.559 --> 00:29:32.230
or why do you think it's impossible to
00:29:32.240 --> 00:29:35.269
understand the nature of meaning without
00:29:35.279 --> 00:29:38.549
understanding consciousness? Well, there
00:29:38.559 --> 00:29:41.350
are two aspects really to language as a
00:29:41.360 --> 00:29:43.029
competence.
There's the conscious aspect
00:29:43.039 --> 00:29:45.590
and there's the unconscious aspect.
00:29:45.600 --> 00:29:47.269
So, Chsy has always emphasized the
00:29:47.279 --> 00:29:49.029
unconscious aspect because there was
00:29:49.039 --> 00:29:51.190
opposition to that. And so, he never
00:29:51.200 --> 00:29:52.630
talked about consciousness in his
00:29:52.640 --> 00:29:54.549
earlier discussions of language. He only
00:29:54.559 --> 00:29:57.430
talked about the unconscious grasp of
00:29:57.440 --> 00:29:59.590
grammar. Now, there's all this interest
00:29:59.600 --> 00:30:02.389
in consciousness. So, that slowly seeped
00:30:02.399 --> 00:30:04.630
into linguistics.
00:30:04.640 --> 00:30:06.070
uh and now people are starting to see
00:30:06.080 --> 00:30:07.350
there's also the conscious aspect of
00:30:07.360 --> 00:30:08.470
language which of course is quite
00:30:08.480 --> 00:30:09.909
obvious you know we're consciously
00:30:09.919 --> 00:30:12.710
speaking to each other it couldn't be so
00:30:12.720 --> 00:30:14.310
those people of course they're a little
00:30:14.320 --> 00:30:15.830
bit reluctant sometimes to acknowledge
00:30:15.840 --> 00:30:17.350
that there's an unconscious aspect as
00:30:17.360 --> 00:30:18.870
well but there are both there are two
00:30:18.880 --> 00:30:23.350
aspects to it uh um and um as there are
00:30:23.360 --> 00:30:24.950
to many things you know as there is a
00:30:24.960 --> 00:30:27.110
perception you know we we've gradually
00:30:27.120 --> 00:30:29.350
found out from studies of psychological
00:30:29.360 --> 00:30:31.669
studies of vision say how much of it is
00:30:31.679 --> 00:30:34.549
unconscious but that doesn't mean it's a
00:30:34.559 --> 00:30:36.789
very strong conscious component as well.
00:30:36.799 --> 00:30:38.470
And we found out things like blind
00:30:38.480 --> 00:30:40.310
sights, subliminal perception, all those
00:30:40.320 --> 00:30:43.110
things which separate out [snorts]
00:30:43.120 --> 00:30:45.750
uh information processing visually from
00:30:45.760 --> 00:30:48.549
conscious information processing. So,
00:30:48.559 --> 00:30:50.630
but I think that in the case of uh of
00:30:50.640 --> 00:30:53.750
language, it's it's an easy step now
00:30:53.760 --> 00:30:55.350
that consciousness is allowed to be
00:30:55.360 --> 00:30:57.909
discussed uh to see that of course that
00:30:57.919 --> 00:30:59.990
is an aspect of language. See
00:31:00.000 --> 00:31:01.190
Vickenstein said nothing about
00:31:01.200 --> 00:31:03.830
consciousness in relation to he thinks
00:31:03.840 --> 00:31:05.669
it's use it's kind of it's a bit
00:31:05.679 --> 00:31:07.750
behavioristic
00:31:07.760 --> 00:31:09.269
>> and behavioristic views of language
00:31:09.279 --> 00:31:11.029
which were characteristic of the
00:31:11.039 --> 00:31:14.070
ordinary language kind of view uh those
00:31:14.080 --> 00:31:15.990
are not to do with consciousness. So you
00:31:16.000 --> 00:31:19.350
need
to bring uh consciousness into the
00:31:19.360 --> 00:31:20.870
study of language particularly
00:31:20.880 --> 00:31:23.190
intentionality
00:31:23.200 --> 00:31:25.029
uh because you know there's obviously
00:31:25.039 --> 00:31:25.990
there's a connection between
00:31:26.000 --> 00:31:29.029
intentionality and reference
00:31:29.039 --> 00:31:30.230
uh and if you want to understand
00:31:30.240 --> 00:31:31.430
reference it's good to understand
00:31:31.440 --> 00:31:32.630
intentionality.
00:31:32.640 --> 00:31:34.310
>> Could you go into that a bit more like
00:31:34.320 --> 00:31:36.950
what what is the how exactly is that
00:31:36.960 --> 00:31:38.870
relationship between intentionality and
00:31:38.880 --> 00:31:41.909
reference structured? uh intentionality
00:31:41.919 --> 00:31:43.669
is aboutness, isn't it? Ofness or
00:31:43.679 --> 00:31:45.110
aboutness. Your thoughts are about
00:31:45.120 --> 00:31:46.950
things, your emotions are about things.
00:31:46.960 --> 00:31:49.190
Well, your speech is about things. So,
00:31:49.200 --> 00:31:50.789
there are two views about that. One view
00:31:50.799 --> 00:31:54.630
is the ref the referential properties of
00:31:54.640 --> 00:31:57.269
speech derive from the intentional
00:31:57.279 --> 00:31:59.830
properties of thoughts.
00:31:59.840 --> 00:32:01.430
So, the intentional properties of
00:32:01.440 --> 00:32:03.430
thoughts are primitive and the other
00:32:03.440 --> 00:32:05.029
ones are derived from the reference
00:32:05.039 --> 00:32:07.190
derive derived from that with some other
00:32:07.200 --> 00:32:09.669
added ingredients probably. But the
00:32:09.679 --> 00:32:11.750
other side is to is the inversion of
00:32:11.760 --> 00:32:13.990
that which is that suppose that
00:32:14.000 --> 00:32:15.990
intentionality of thoughts is derived
00:32:16.000 --> 00:32:18.470
from the intentionality of language.
00:32:18.480 --> 00:32:20.710
>> So in the period of ordinary language
00:32:20.720 --> 00:32:22.870
philosophy and
00:32:22.880 --> 00:32:25.190
you know the behaviorism which dominated
00:32:25.200 --> 00:32:27.750
psychology for you know 50 years or so
00:32:27.760 --> 00:32:29.750
the tendency was to think that anything
00:32:29.760 --> 00:32:33.269
about the mind which was referential or
00:32:33.279 --> 00:32:35.909
had propositional was all derived from
00:32:35.919 --> 00:32:38.870
language spoken language. So that's not
00:32:38.880 --> 00:32:41.350
very not a very plausible position of
00:32:41.360 --> 00:32:43.430
course to think think that. Then you got
00:32:43.440 --> 00:32:45.830
Chney and you got Foder who really
00:32:45.840 --> 00:32:48.230
combined the two ideas
00:32:48.240 --> 00:32:50.470
by saying that actually intentionality
00:32:50.480 --> 00:32:52.950
is derived from the reference of the
00:32:52.960 --> 00:32:55.110
language of thought.
00:32:55.120 --> 00:32:55.430
>> Okay.
00:32:55.440 --> 00:32:57.430
>> So he's reducing
00:32:57.440 --> 00:32:59.909
meaning in language to thought. But then
00:32:59.919 --> 00:33:01.029
it turns out that thoughts are
00:33:01.039 --> 00:33:03.909
linguistic but not in the sense of a
00:33:03.919 --> 00:33:05.990
spoken language like English or Italian
00:33:06.000 --> 00:33:07.909
but in terms of an innate genetic
00:33:07.919 --> 00:33:08.470
language.
00:33:08.480 --> 00:33:11.430
>> This sort of mental ease idea
00:33:11.440 --> 00:33:11.990
>> what
00:33:12.000 --> 00:33:14.070
>> this mental ease idea the idea that
00:33:14.080 --> 00:33:15.110
there's an
00:33:15.120 --> 00:33:17.430
>> exactly language of thought and there's
00:33:17.440 --> 00:33:19.990
a lot to be said for that too. Um that
00:33:20.000 --> 00:33:22.710
idea is pretty good. Of course I was his
00:33:22.720 --> 00:33:24.230
colleague for a long time and and also
00:33:24.240 --> 00:33:26.470
his friend. We used to talk about this
00:33:26.480 --> 00:33:28.149
quite a bit and there's something
00:33:28.159 --> 00:33:31.350
correct about it except it it it's just
00:33:31.360 --> 00:33:34.389
it's the objection really is verbal. You
00:33:34.399 --> 00:33:36.710
know there's a representational system
00:33:36.720 --> 00:33:39.830
that's employed by thought. That's true.
00:33:39.840 --> 00:33:41.750
Are we going to call it language? Well,
00:33:41.760 --> 00:33:43.430
that's a bit of a semantic question as
00:33:43.440 --> 00:33:45.350
they say, right? It's like
00:33:45.360 --> 00:33:48.470
>> if you mean by that it's like a spoken
00:33:48.480 --> 00:33:50.230
language. It's not much like that
00:33:50.240 --> 00:33:51.590
because there's no noise going on when
00:33:51.600 --> 00:33:53.990
you think and you don't think for other
00:33:54.000 --> 00:33:55.269
people, you know, it's not communicative
00:33:55.279 --> 00:33:57.430
and so forth. But in the sense of
00:33:57.440 --> 00:33:58.710
structure, you know, you've got
00:33:58.720 --> 00:34:00.789
combinatorial structure. It's very
00:34:00.799 --> 00:34:02.470
similar.
00:34:02.480 --> 00:34:04.310
And that's why we use the notion of a
00:34:04.320 --> 00:34:07.029
proposition to say a proposition is the
00:34:07.039 --> 00:34:09.030
content of a thought or a belief, but
00:34:09.040 --> 00:34:11.909
also the meaning of a sentence.
00:34:11.919 --> 00:34:13.030
You know, you see that there's there's
00:34:13.040 --> 00:34:15.430
that connection between them. Uh again
00:34:15.440 --> 00:34:16.950
this is something that you know it's
00:34:16.960 --> 00:34:20.149
hard to be have a dogmatic position on.
00:34:20.159 --> 00:34:22.470
You know I'm I'm not
00:34:22.480 --> 00:34:24.310
against a language of thought idea at
00:34:24.320 --> 00:34:27.510
all suitably understood. I do think that
00:34:27.520 --> 00:34:29.430
you know lang spoken language has its
00:34:29.440 --> 00:34:32.230
own issues and problems and in one of
00:34:32.240 --> 00:34:34.470
the papers you of mine that you you were
00:34:34.480 -->
00:34:36.550
going to ask me about. I think you can
00:34:36.560 --> 00:34:38.149
have communication without language.
00:34:38.159 --> 00:34:39.990
They all they all can be dissociated
00:34:40.000 --> 00:34:41.190
from each other. You could have a
00:34:41.200 --> 00:34:42.629
language of thought not have a spoken
00:34:42.639 --> 00:34:43.829
language. You could have a language of
00:34:43.839 --> 00:34:45.430
thought, not have a communicative
00:34:45.440 --> 00:34:46.629
language. You could have communication
00:34:46.639 --> 00:34:48.790
without a language.
00:34:48.800 --> 00:34:49.750
Yes. All of that.
00:34:49.760 --> 00:34:51.109
>> So, we've already spoken about the
00:34:51.119 --> 00:34:52.790
difficulty of discussing language
00:34:52.800 --> 00:34:55.190
through language or kind of trying to
00:34:55.200 --> 00:34:56.869
break up what we understand as language
00:34:56.879 --> 00:34:58.870
through our own formations and and how
00:34:58.880 --> 00:35:00.870
much in the weeds you can get. But I
00:35:00.880 --> 00:35:02.310
think to even understand meaning or
00:35:02.320 --> 00:35:04.310
language is dependent somewhat on
00:35:04.320 --> 00:35:06.390
consciousness. And now consciousness is
00:35:06.400 --> 00:35:08.710
the real ultimate in this field in that
00:35:08.720 --> 00:35:09.910
you have to try to understand
00:35:09.920 --> 00:35:12.470
consciousness through consciousness. We
00:35:12.480 --> 00:35:14.710
have to understand how much our kind of
00:35:14.720 --> 00:35:17.589
surface level conscious experience can
00:35:17.599 --> 00:35:20.790
break into what actual consciousness is.
00:35:20.800 --> 00:35:22.790
Is it possible to understand it? Is it
00:35:22.800 --> 00:35:25.109
possible to grasp it? This sense of the
00:35:25.119 --> 00:35:27.430
sort of uh prehensile hand grasping
00:35:27.440 --> 00:35:29.750
anything. Can the mind grasp itself? And
00:35:29.760 --> 00:35:32.069
this has been one of your main um
00:35:32.079 --> 00:35:33.990
subjects of inquiry. This is one of your
00:35:34.000 --> 00:35:36.630
your biggest sort of uh breakthroughs as
00:35:36.640 --> 00:35:38.630
it were. the sense that perhaps it is
00:35:38.640 --> 00:35:42.710
true that our perceptual tools simply
00:35:42.720 --> 00:35:45.589
cannot grasp the nature or their source.
00:35:45.599 --> 00:35:48.150
They just cannot do it. So how do we
00:35:48.160 --> 00:35:50.470
reckon with this? You know in philosophy
00:35:50.480 --> 00:35:52.150
the pursuit of knowledge how do we
00:35:52.160 --> 00:35:53.910
reckon with the fact we might have hit a
00:35:53.920 --> 00:35:56.310
wall. We might have hit the edge of what
00:35:56.320 --> 00:35:58.710
we can know. There must be you know
00:35:58.720 --> 00:36:00.870
serious verberations just in
00:36:00.880 --> 00:36:04.230
terosophically philos philosophy of
00:36:04.240 --> 00:36:05.990
philosophy. Well, what do we do when we
00:36:06.000 --> 00:36:08.710
when we find something we can't know?
00:36:08.720 --> 00:36:11.589
>> Well, if we first of all, we have to
00:36:11.599 --> 00:36:13.430
know that we don't know that we can't
00:36:13.440 --> 00:36:14.870
know. If we don't know [laughter] that
00:36:14.880 --> 00:36:17.190
we can't know, but we maybe we can't
00:36:17.200 --> 00:36:19.109
know. Okay, that's one thing. Keep
00:36:19.119 --> 00:36:22.310
trying. Okay, if you if you because you
00:36:22.320 --> 00:36:23.910
know it's true. My critics often say,
00:36:23.920 --> 00:36:25.589
"Oh, people have thought you couldn't
00:36:25.599 --> 00:36:29.190
understand the stars, you know, and
00:36:29.200 --> 00:36:30.390
>> couldn't walk on the moon
00:36:30.400 --> 00:36:33.670
>> like that really." But it's right to say
00:36:33.680 --> 00:36:36.230
can you be certain that you can't know?
00:36:36.240 --> 00:36:38.150
It's not some things you can be certain
00:36:38.160 --> 00:36:41.109
you can't know. I mean um it's not but
00:36:41.119 --> 00:36:43.750
some things you you're not sure maybe we
00:36:43.760 --> 00:36:45.510
could know them. Then there of course
00:36:45.520 --> 00:36:48.310
there were more like science fictiony uh
00:36:48.320 --> 00:36:51.349
possibilities like brain augmentation
00:36:51.359 --> 00:36:54.230
use of AI you know all that kind of
00:36:54.240 --> 00:36:55.829
thing you could well all worth thinking
00:36:55.839 --> 00:36:57.990
about. I mean my starting point has
00:36:58.000 --> 00:37:01.349
always been humans at a certain stage of
00:37:01.359 --> 00:37:03.750
evolution. We haven't been around very
00:37:03.760 --> 00:37:05.910
long as a species. Our brain has
00:37:05.920 --> 00:37:08.390
developed in a certain way like all
00:37:08.400 --> 00:37:10.310
species do. There's going to be changes
00:37:10.320 --> 00:37:12.310
in the future. You know, we know from
00:37:12.320 --> 00:37:15.190
evolution the changes are massive over
00:37:15.200 --> 00:37:17.510
evolutionary time. So if you try to
00:37:17.520 --> 00:37:19.910
imagine life on earth a million years
00:37:19.920 --> 00:37:21.910
from now which is very short in terms of
00:37:21.920 --> 00:37:24.069
evolutionary time you know the human
00:37:24.079 --> 00:37:25.589
brain could be quite different by that
00:37:25.599 --> 00:37:28.230
point. If aliens came you know from
00:37:28.240 --> 00:37:31.270
another planet with different brains
00:37:31.280 --> 00:37:34.150
they could help us to understand things
00:37:34.160 --> 00:37:36.470
we'd find very difficult. All these are
00:37:36.480 --> 00:37:39.349
all possibilities you all possibilities.
00:37:39.359 --> 00:37:43.109
Some things seem pretty firm um about
00:37:43.119 --> 00:37:45.910
what what we can understand. Uh you know
00:37:45.920 --> 00:37:48.790
the the example of the bats.
00:37:48.800 --> 00:37:50.710
Most people can understand that point.
00:37:50.720 --> 00:37:52.950
Um or you know a blind can a blind man
00:37:52.960 --> 00:37:55.430
understand color?
00:37:55.440 -->
00:37:57.589
We can be pretty clear there. No is the
00:37:57.599 --> 00:37:59.349
answer. Unless of course their brain is
00:37:59.359 --> 00:38:02.069
changed. Of course if their brain a
00:38:02.079 --> 00:38:03.990
blind man's brain is changed so he so he
00:38:04.000 --> 00:38:06.310
can imagine colors then he's going to
00:38:06.320 --> 00:38:07.589
know what they are. And that's not
00:38:07.599 --> 00:38:09.910
impossible. But we have no technology
00:38:09.920 --> 00:38:11.589
that's going to do that obviously. So
00:38:11.599 --> 00:38:15.349
given the way the human brain is now uh
00:38:15.359 --> 00:38:17.670
certain things we won't certain things
00:38:17.680 --> 00:38:19.510
we certain we we know for certain that
00:38:19.520 --> 00:38:21.030
some things we don't know and we'll
00:38:21.040 --> 00:38:23.510
never know. Example I often give is how
00:38:23.520 --> 00:38:26.230
many dinosaurs were there. We don't
00:38:26.240 --> 00:38:27.349
we're never going to find out how many
00:38:27.359 --> 00:38:29.349
dinosaurs there were the exact number of
00:38:29.359 --> 00:38:31.589
individual dinosaurs. Why? Well the past
00:38:31.599 --> 00:38:33.829
is doesn't leave enough traces for you
00:38:33.839 --> 00:38:35.750
to know that things about the future
00:38:35.760 --> 00:38:38.550
you're not going to know. uh specific
00:38:38.560 --> 00:38:41.750
things, you know, will there be in the
00:38:41.760 --> 00:38:43.829
dummmits? Will a a city ever be built
00:38:43.839 --> 00:38:47.349
here pointing to a desert? Who knows?
00:38:47.359 --> 00:38:49.510
You don't know whether that's it seems
00:38:49.520 --> 00:38:51.430
likely. The answer is no. Will a city
00:38:51.440 --> 00:38:52.790
ever be built at the bottom of the
00:38:52.800 --> 00:38:56.630
Pacific Ocean? No. Not going to happen.
00:38:56.640 --> 00:38:57.990
Uh surprise surprise [clears throat]
00:38:58.000 --> 00:39:00.710
anything you know anything is possible.
00:39:00.720 --> 00:39:02.310
You might want to say it's like it's
00:39:02.320 --> 00:39:03.829
just like the question you see. Will
00:39:03.839 --> 00:39:05.510
anybody ever run the mile in two
00:39:05.520 --> 00:39:07.990
minutes? [snorts] I mean the answer is
00:39:08.000 --> 00:39:12.150
no but you all right you don't know you
00:39:12.160 --> 00:39:13.670
something may happen to
00:39:13.680 --> 00:39:16.150
>> define run [laughter]
00:39:16.160 --> 00:39:18.950
>> yeah I mean it's exactly I mean it turns
00:39:18.960 --> 00:39:21.109
into a pointless verbal question if you
00:39:21.119 --> 00:39:24.310
you do that so I mean the interesting
00:39:24.320 --> 00:39:26.230
really the the relevant question to to
00:39:26.240 --> 00:39:28.150
the question you were just asking me is
00:39:28.160 --> 00:39:31.190
what is it reasonable to believe is for
00:39:31.200 --> 00:39:33.750
us at this point in time a dead end and
00:39:33.760 --> 00:39:37.349
so we may as well accept that and see
00:39:37.359 --> 00:39:39.750
for me people think my view is negative
00:39:39.760 --> 00:39:41.990
it's not it's positive because I can
00:39:42.000 --> 00:39:43.750
believe in the existence of all sorts of
00:39:43.760 --> 00:39:46.230
things as a mysterion that somebody who
00:39:46.240 --> 00:39:47.910
thinks that nothing that exists is
00:39:47.920 --> 00:39:50.310
materious can't believe in and turns out
00:39:50.320 --> 00:39:52.732
that's most of reality actually
00:39:52.742 --> 00:39:53.990
[laughter]
00:39:54.000 --> 00:39:56.870
>> you can believe in most of reality
00:39:56.880 --> 00:39:58.950
>> yeah so we know we we think matter
00:39:58.960 --> 00:40:02.069
exists okay matter exists that's fine do
00:40:02.079 --> 00:40:04.630
we do we understand the full deep nature
00:40:04.640 --> 00:40:07.430
of matter No, [laughter]
00:40:07.440 --> 00:40:10.069
we don't. So if somebody to say, well,
00:40:10.079 --> 00:40:11.670
if you say it's a mystery, then you have
00:40:11.680 --> 00:40:13.829
to deny it exists. You're going to deny
00:40:13.839 --> 00:40:15.270
everything exists in that way. And it's
00:40:15.280 --> 00:40:17.670
just it's not plausible. It's just not
00:40:17.680 --> 00:40:19.510
reasonable to think that way. The much
00:40:19.520 --> 00:40:21.430
more reasonable thing is to say, well,
00:40:21.440 --> 00:40:23.109
you know, it's just that our brains as
00:40:23.119 --> 00:40:24.550
they are now in this moment of
00:40:24.560 --> 00:40:27.190
evolutionary time and maybe forever,
00:40:27.200 --> 00:40:28.710
we'll never get to the bottom of that.
00:40:28.720 --> 00:40:30.230
Will we ever understand the nature of
00:40:30.240 --> 00:40:33.990
time, space? Doubtful. The more the more
00:40:34.000 --> 00:40:35.589
you get used to this way of looking at
00:40:35.599 --> 00:40:38.310
things, the more you think I let me
00:40:38.320 --> 00:40:41.510
admit a a kind of um mistake on my part.
00:40:41.520 --> 00:40:43.030
When I first thought along these lines
00:40:43.040 --> 00:40:44.550
about consciousness, I thought
00:40:44.560 --> 00:40:47.349
consciousness was kind of unique in this
00:40:47.359 --> 00:40:48.950
respect. Now I don't think that I think
00:40:48.960 --> 00:40:51.589
it's one example among many of things
00:40:51.599 --> 00:40:52.710
that
00:40:52.720 --> 00:40:54.550
>> understand. It doesn't mean we can't
00:40:54.560 --> 00:40:55.910
understand some things about it, you
00:40:55.920 --> 00:40:58.710
know, and we can use it and so on, but
00:40:58.720 --> 00:41:01.430
um you have to be prepared to accept
00:41:01.440 --> 00:41:04.150
that something you're having all of us
00:41:04.160 --> 00:41:05.190
are having a lot of trouble
00:41:05.200 --> 00:41:06.870
understanding. [snorts] It may just be
00:41:06.880 --> 00:41:09.030
that we our brains are not cut out to
00:41:09.040 --> 00:41:11.510
understand them. There's that great
00:41:11.520 --> 00:41:13.349
sorry there's that great Voltater short
00:41:13.359 -->
00:41:17.510
story Magnum Magus where it's uh they
00:41:17.520 --> 00:41:19.829
discover a planet with I think it's on
00:41:19.839 --> 00:41:22.069
Saturn and the people on Saturn are
00:41:22.079 --> 00:41:24.470
equivalently large compared to the size
00:41:24.480 --> 00:41:26.150
of Saturn than we are to the size of the
00:41:26.160 --> 00:41:28.309
Earth and have brains that are larger
00:41:28.319 --> 00:41:30.950
and they understand uh infinitely more
00:41:30.960 --> 00:41:33.030
than us from our perspective but they're
00:41:33.040 --> 00:41:34.950
still just griping about all their
00:41:34.960 --> 00:41:37.510
things they still don't know. And then
00:41:37.520 --> 00:41:39.750
>> who who who who is it who wrote this? I
00:41:39.760 --> 00:41:41.190
never heard of this. I want
00:41:41.200 --> 00:41:42.710
>> Voltater. Um
00:41:42.720 --> 00:41:44.230
>> the act the actual Voltera
00:41:44.240 --> 00:41:46.069
>> the actual the actual Voltater. It's
00:41:46.079 --> 00:41:48.710
called Magny Maggas. Um
00:41:48.720 --> 00:41:50.630
>> I've got to read it. It's perfect for
00:41:50.640 --> 00:41:52.069
me.
00:41:52.079 --> 00:41:54.150
>> I admire I'm a great admirer of Voltater
00:41:54.160 --> 00:41:55.829
actually, but I didn't even know he
00:41:55.839 --> 00:41:57.510
wrote that. But yeah, I mean it's a very
00:41:57.520 --> 00:41:59.910
obvious way to think. People People
00:41:59.920 --> 00:42:01.829
sometimes act as if I just came up with
00:42:01.839 --> 00:42:03.990
this out of the blue in a moment of
00:42:04.000 --> 00:42:06.550
eccentricity. It's completely common.
00:42:06.560 --> 00:42:09.030
>> The book of Job, I mean, come on. Yeah.
00:42:09.040 --> 00:42:11.750
Where where were you when the earth was
00:42:11.760 --> 00:42:13.670
made? You don't know.
00:42:13.680 --> 00:42:14.630
>> Yeah. Sorry.
00:42:14.640 --> 00:42:16.309
>> And the other and the other point I
00:42:16.319 --> 00:42:18.470
often make and it's so obvious really is
00:42:18.480 --> 00:42:20.150
do you think other animals can know
00:42:20.160 --> 00:42:22.790
everything? Of course they can't.
00:42:22.800 --> 00:42:24.630
>> Do you think that our you know our now
00:42:24.640 --> 00:42:27.109
extinct close relatives the names do you
00:42:27.119 --> 00:42:29.109
think they can? Is it just only humans
00:42:29.119 --> 00:42:30.390
as they are now we've reached the
00:42:30.400 --> 00:42:31.910
pinnacle and that nothing about the
00:42:31.920 --> 00:42:33.990
universe will won't understand? It's not
00:42:34.000 --> 00:42:35.270
plausible.
00:42:35.280 --> 00:42:37.270
>> Yeah. But I think this is the important
00:42:37.280 --> 00:42:39.670
it's the important shift that this
00:42:39.680 --> 00:42:41.910
creates to think oh maybe well we can't
00:42:41.920 --> 00:42:43.589
understand the seat of our own knowledge
00:42:43.599 --> 00:42:45.430
which is really the big prize. We want
00:42:45.440 --> 00:42:47.349
to understand ourselves and there's a
00:42:47.359 --> 00:42:49.030
kind of sub clause we want to replicate
00:42:49.040 --> 00:42:51.829
ourselves. Can we build a human mind?
00:42:51.839 --> 00:42:54.630
Can we rebuild consciousness and so on
00:42:54.640 --> 00:42:56.390
but to acknowledge that you can't do
00:42:56.400 --> 00:42:58.230
that thing. I mean it's sort of because
00:42:58.240 --> 00:43:00.150
we have this tradition from the sort of
00:43:00.160 --> 00:43:01.990
religious tradition that humans are
00:43:02.000 --> 00:43:03.910
special. They are different. They do
00:43:03.920 --> 00:43:06.470
have a unique and total insight. And I
00:43:06.480 --> 00:43:08.710
think the secular philosophical strain
00:43:08.720 --> 00:43:10.710
sort of inherited that and did believe
00:43:10.720 --> 00:43:12.790
while we can't do it with this tool set.
00:43:12.800 --> 00:43:14.710
We can use the secular tool set and we
00:43:14.720 --> 00:43:17.030
can carve out the entirety of reality
00:43:17.040 --> 00:43:19.829
and understand it with this empiricist
00:43:19.839 --> 00:43:21.829
materialist viewpoint. And if there's
00:43:21.839 --> 00:43:23.990
something we can't apprehend, we hollow
00:43:24.000 --> 00:43:25.829
it out. Such as the people who, you
00:43:25.839 --> 00:43:28.069
know, there is no consciousness, just
00:43:28.079 --> 00:43:30.230
eliminate it. Anything you can't touch,
00:43:30.240 --> 00:43:32.390
can't feel, can't record, it cannot
00:43:32.400 --> 00:43:34.470
exist. And and there are many very good
00:43:34.480 --> 00:43:37.430
arguments against this this recently.
00:43:37.440 --> 00:43:38.950
>> You're speaking like a very good
00:43:38.960 --> 00:43:40.630
mysterious when you say that.
00:43:40.640 --> 00:43:42.790
>> Now, I've got a bit of a mysterion bone
00:43:42.800 --> 00:43:43.829
in my body. I got to say,
00:43:43.839 --> 00:43:45.670
>> I see you get it. You get it. You
00:43:45.680 --> 00:43:47.430
understand the point.
00:43:47.440 --> 00:43:49.349
>> Yeah. Because recently we had on the
00:43:49.359 --> 00:43:51.589
show Karen Kilby who completely
00:43:51.599 --> 00:43:53.190
different field. She's a theologian.
00:43:53.200 --> 00:43:56.150
Trinitarianism is her specialty. And she
00:43:56.160 --> 00:43:59.030
was talking about uh apehatic forms of
00:43:59.040 --> 00:44:00.150
of knowledge [clears throat] where you
00:44:00.160 --> 00:44:01.990
can only describe some something by what
00:44:02.000 --> 00:44:04.950
it isn't. And she was saying all these
00:44:04.960 --> 00:44:08.309
efforts to fully understand the trinity
00:44:08.319 --> 00:44:09.589
to break it down into a kind of
00:44:09.599 --> 00:44:12.470
mathematical formula 3 equals 1. We get
00:44:12.480 --> 00:44:15.349
it through all of these
00:44:15.359 --> 00:44:17.750
and winding lines of argument in fact
00:44:17.760 --> 00:44:20.309
miss the point that it is information
00:44:20.319 --> 00:44:23.510
beyond the human cranium. we cannot fit
00:44:23.520 --> 00:44:25.670
God or or
the Christian God in her
00:44:25.680 --> 00:44:27.990
example into this brain and therefore
00:44:28.000 --> 00:44:29.990
shouldn't try should acknowledge there
00:44:30.000 --> 00:44:33.190
are things we cannot know and in knowing
00:44:33.200 --> 00:44:34.710
that then we understand something about
00:44:34.720 --> 00:44:36.710
it in the way that we understand
00:44:36.720 --> 00:44:38.790
something about consciousness in knowing
00:44:38.800 --> 00:44:41.030
that there is some reason that we cannot
00:44:41.040 --> 00:44:43.589
apprehend directly whatever substance
00:44:43.599 --> 00:44:46.150
whatever interchange whatever uh sort of
00:44:46.160 --> 00:44:49.510
threshold there is between mind and body
00:44:49.520 --> 00:44:51.109
if that's how we describe it and that
00:44:51.119 --> 00:44:53.829
that in itself itself. It's not just a
00:44:53.839 --> 00:44:55.430
breakthrough on consciousness, but
00:44:55.440 --> 00:44:57.910
indeed on how we interpret the universe,
00:44:57.920 --> 00:44:59.190
the world, everything.
00:44:59.200 --> 00:45:00.870
>> Well, in in physics, of course, it's
00:45:00.880 --> 00:45:03.589
it's long been thought to be the right.
00:45:03.599 --> 00:45:05.589
Everybody know Newton already was making
00:45:05.599 --> 00:45:08.150
this point about gravity. And Chsky is
00:45:08.160 --> 00:45:11.030
always repeating that point that in that
00:45:11.040 --> 00:45:13.190
in that 17th century, the great puzzle
00:45:13.200 --> 00:45:15.670
of universe was motion. People were all
00:45:15.680 --> 00:45:17.109
trying to understand motion. M
00:45:17.119 --> 00:45:18.630
>> they won't wor about consciousness at
00:45:18.640 --> 00:45:21.750
all but motion they really and so
00:45:21.760 --> 00:45:23.750
there's a a tremendous effort on the
00:45:23.760 --> 00:45:25.990
part of all those thinkers they can't
00:45:26.000 --> 00:45:28.470
Newton and all those other people lock
00:45:28.480 --> 00:45:31.030
everybody motion is the problem where
00:45:31.040 --> 00:45:33.990
does it come from you know and and and
00:45:34.000 --> 00:45:36.150
Newton made the point that um all he's
00:45:36.160 --> 00:45:38.150
giving you is a mathematical formula to
00:45:38.160 --> 00:45:39.990
predict the motion of bodies he can't
00:45:40.000 --> 00:45:41.510
tell you what it where it comes from he
00:45:41.520 --> 00:45:43.430
can't tell you what gravity is he give
00:45:43.440 --> 00:45:46.309
you a law it's a mystery and Hume
00:45:46.319 --> 00:45:49.349
repeated the same thing in relation to
00:45:49.359 --> 00:45:52.390
Newton. Now, let's let's not get may
00:45:52.400 --> 00:45:54.069
maybe go too overboard with it, of
00:45:54.079 --> 00:45:55.109
course, because you know these
00:45:55.119 --> 00:45:58.069
theological defenses, you know, I think
00:45:58.079 --> 00:46:01.270
it's respectable in as a theologian to
00:46:01.280 --> 00:46:04.150
say things like the nature of God is a
00:46:04.160 --> 00:46:06.630
mystery. We can't expect our finite
00:46:06.640 --> 00:46:08.470
intelligence to grasp the infinite mind
00:46:08.480 --> 00:46:12.309
and okay, but if something uses a
00:46:12.319 --> 00:46:14.710
contradiction, you know, that's that's
00:46:14.720 --> 00:46:16.230
another story.
00:46:16.240 --> 00:46:18.150
You know, if you start if you see if the
00:46:18.160 --> 00:46:20.150
argument was you can't say that the
00:46:20.160 --> 00:46:22.069
trinity is true because it can't be that
00:46:22.079 --> 00:46:24.870
three is one. That's contradictory.
00:46:24.880 --> 00:46:26.550
>> That's a pretty good argument. You know,
00:46:26.560 --> 00:46:27.990
I mean, [laughter]
00:46:28.000 --> 00:46:30.870
>> it's like, you know, if suppose that the
00:46:30.880 --> 00:46:33.270
theological tradition said that God is
00:46:33.280 --> 00:46:35.670
both finite and infinite and some person
00:46:35.680 --> 00:46:38.069
said, hang on a minute, if he's
00:46:38.079 --> 00:46:39.670
infinite, he can't be finite. If he's
00:46:39.680 --> 00:46:41.270
finite, he can't be infinite. Those are
00:46:41.280 --> 00:46:43.750
contradictory. Oh, no, no. Oh, in God
00:46:43.760 --> 00:46:46.150
it's perfectly perfectly okay. Just our
00:46:46.160 --> 00:46:48.150
limited minds. Well, so what do you
00:46:48.160 --> 00:46:49.990
think that the you know this table can
00:46:50.000 --> 00:46:53.109
be brown and not brown? Do you what do
00:46:53.119 --> 00:46:55.030
you where's the are there any limits on
00:46:55.040 --> 00:46:58.710
this mysterion copout is as it may seem
00:46:58.720 --> 00:47:01.430
you see. So
00:47:01.440 --> 00:47:03.430
it's a matter of judgment case by case
00:47:03.440 --> 00:47:05.589
you've got to consider them. So in the
00:47:05.599 --> 00:47:07.109
case of the trinity, I'm I'm pretty
00:47:07.119 --> 00:47:09.750
skeptical about that way of expressing
00:47:09.760 --> 00:47:11.109
trinity.
00:47:11.119 --> 00:47:12.790
>> The another thing about this, of course,
00:47:12.800 --> 00:47:14.870
the trinity is a feature of one
00:47:14.880 --> 00:47:17.589
religion, right? It's not a feature of
00:47:17.599 --> 00:47:18.790
human thought. It's not that everybody
00:47:18.800 --> 00:47:20.710
in the world has come up with the idea
00:47:20.720 --> 00:47:23.030
that there's a trinity. It's not just a
00:47:23.040 --> 00:47:27.109
part of it's generated by
00:47:27.119 --> 00:47:29.030
theological problems arising within the
00:47:29.040 --> 00:47:31.030
Christian tradition. It's not part of
00:47:31.040 --> 00:47:32.950
just normal human thought about things.
00:47:32.960 --> 00:47:35.430
Yeah, this was sort of also Kilby's um
00:47:35.440 --> 00:47:37.510
position as well, but yes.
00:47:37.520 --> 00:47:38.870
>> Yeah.
00:47:38.880 --> 00:47:42.630
>> Um if some historian said Henry VII
00:47:42.640 --> 00:47:46.230
lived in uh in the 1500s and also in the
00:47:46.240 --> 00:47:50.150
200s and also in the 2000s, all those
00:47:50.160 --> 00:47:52.630
times,
you'd say, "No, he couldn't do
00:47:52.640 --> 00:47:54.710
that. It was not possible." Oh, yes, he
00:47:54.720 --> 00:47:56.309
could.
00:47:56.319 --> 00:47:58.150
>> Yeah. you. So anyway,
00:47:58.160 --> 00:48:00.550
>> Vladimir Shahov, if if you know the
00:48:00.560 --> 00:48:02.870
novelist Vladimir Shahov, he would make
00:48:02.880 --> 00:48:06.390
this claim and chase it for 600 pages
00:48:06.400 --> 00:48:09.270
and we'd all love it. [laughter]
00:48:09.280 --> 00:48:11.510
>> Yeah. I mean,
00:48:11.520 --> 00:48:13.990
I'm I'm I'm very I am also very much an
00:48:14.000 --> 00:48:15.589
anti-misterian, you know, in some ways
00:48:15.599 --> 00:48:17.270
because I'm I'm very naturalistic about
00:48:17.280 --> 00:48:19.190
things. So, uh
00:48:19.200 --> 00:48:21.430
>> yeah, you're you're curious ad mixture
00:48:21.440 --> 00:48:23.270
in that way. You're sort of on the one
00:48:23.280 --> 00:48:25.430
hand there's this uh there is quite a
00:48:25.440 --> 00:48:27.190
hard naturalism. There is the the
00:48:27.200 --> 00:48:29.349
consciousness almost certainly emerges
00:48:29.359 --> 00:48:31.910
from the brain naturalistically.
00:48:31.920 --> 00:48:34.069
But then there's this weird mystical
00:48:34.079 --> 00:48:36.549
level of it being completely beyond
00:48:36.559 --> 00:48:38.470
explanatory capacity.
00:48:38.480 --> 00:48:40.069
>> Yeah. Well, that's what that's the
00:48:40.079 --> 00:48:42.230
attraction of the mysterian viewpoint
00:48:42.240 --> 00:48:45.270
because you can then accept both things.
00:48:45.280 --> 00:48:47.270
>> It obviously is a simple biological
00:48:47.280 --> 00:48:48.870
phenomenon.
00:48:48.880 --> 00:48:50.790
>> It ought to be re like easy to
00:48:50.800 --> 00:48:53.589
understand as digestion or muscles or
00:48:53.599 --> 00:48:56.470
and yet it's completely not. So you
00:48:56.480 --> 00:48:57.750
start wondering well maybe we're just
00:48:57.760 --> 00:48:59.349
good at one kind of problem and not good
00:48:59.359 --> 00:49:01.430
at the other kind of problem
00:49:01.440 --> 00:49:03.109
>> but not that the objective world is
00:49:03.119 --> 00:49:05.190
different in that
00:49:05.200 --> 00:49:08.069
>> I like faculties
00:49:08.079 --> 00:49:09.589
>> that's what lead that's what led me in
00:49:09.599 --> 00:49:11.589
that direction really was to that kind
00:49:11.599 --> 00:49:12.870
of that kind of thought
00:49:12.880 --> 00:49:14.790
>> I like the idea of the aliens who
00:49:14.800 --> 00:49:17.510
understand consciousness intuitively but
00:49:17.520 --> 00:49:19.990
but really don't understand digestion
00:49:20.000 --> 00:49:22.230
they can't understand how on earth we
00:49:22.240 --> 00:49:24.950
got to the bottom of how digestion works
00:49:24.960 --> 00:49:27.190
>> like to them. That's just a problem. So,
00:49:27.200 --> 00:49:30.150
so beyond the
00:49:30.160 --> 00:49:31.589
>> clear, it's clear when you think about
00:49:31.599 --> 00:49:33.190
it whether a creature can understand
00:49:33.200 --> 00:49:35.430
something depends on the creature and
00:49:35.440 --> 00:49:38.069
what the resources the creature has to
00:49:38.079 --> 00:49:40.790
think and it varies from creature to
00:49:40.800 --> 00:49:42.150
creature. I mean, it's not going to be a
00:49:42.160 --> 00:49:43.829
uniform thing across all possible
00:49:43.839 --> 00:49:45.510
beings. In the case of consciousness,
00:49:45.520 --> 00:49:48.549
there's a very specific reason to be a
00:49:48.559 --> 00:49:51.510
mysterion, which is the the the faculty
00:49:51.520 --> 00:49:53.670
we have which brings us closest to
00:49:53.680 --> 00:49:55.109
consciousness is the one we call
00:49:55.119 --> 00:49:57.990
introspection, which other animals don't
00:49:58.000 --> 00:49:59.430
have or have only to a very limited
00:49:59.440 --> 00:50:01.750
degree. And we only have it to a limited
00:50:01.760 --> 00:50:03.030
degree too.
00:50:03.040 --> 00:50:05.430
>> Our outside access to consciousness
00:50:05.440 --> 00:50:07.589
through the brain and behavior is not
00:50:07.599 --> 00:50:11.430
direct access. So introspection we have.
00:50:11.440 --> 00:50:12.790
And the question would be why do we have
00:50:12.800 --> 00:50:15.109
introspection in terms of uh evolution
00:50:15.119 --> 00:50:17.670
and biology? What use is it? Well, it's
00:50:17.680 --> 00:50:21.510
not of much use if anything. So it's
00:50:21.520 --> 00:50:25.190
very primitive as a sense. We we don't
00:50:25.200 --> 00:50:27.190
even know what to call it. We call it
00:50:27.200 --> 00:50:28.870
introspection but it's just a label you
00:50:28.880 --> 00:50:30.630
know it does we don't have doesn't give
00:50:30.640 --> 00:50:32.230
you any description of what it kind of
00:50:32.240 --> 00:50:34.230
thing it is. So we have access to
00:50:34.240 --> 00:50:36.150
consciousness. We can think about it but
00:50:36.160 --> 00:50:38.390
we have very superficial access to it
00:50:38.400 --> 00:50:41.589
for obviously for very good reasons. So
00:50:41.599 --> 00:50:43.589
given that it's our best access is that
00:50:43.599 --> 00:50:45.750
our best access is very limited. Well
00:50:45.760 --> 00:50:46.950
then we're not going to know much about
00:50:46.960 --> 00:50:49.030
it.
00:50:49.040 --> 00:50:50.309
>> Yeah. And but I think this is an
00:50:50.319 --> 00:50:52.390
interesting point in in this in this
00:50:52.400 --> 00:50:53.990
book where you lay out that
00:50:54.000 --> 00:50:55.589
introspection while it gives you
00:50:55.599 --> 00:50:58.309
something it's pretty limited. And it's
00:50:58.319 --> 00:51:00.309
interesting I think because in so many
00:51:00.319 --> 00:51:02.390
sort of wisdom traditions, religious
00:51:02.400 --> 00:51:04.150
traditions through the ages,
00:51:04.160 --> 00:51:06.230
introspection or meditation which is
00:51:06.240 --> 00:51:08.470
kind of a variation on it are seen as
00:51:08.480 --> 00:51:10.870
the ultimate
arbiter of knowledge.
00:51:10.880 --> 00:51:12.549
Through this you can access things not
00:51:12.559 --> 00:51:15.030
merely of yourself but sort of the
00:51:15.040 --> 00:51:17.270
universal mind. It's it's the root. It
00:51:17.280 --> 00:51:19.829
is the the premium. If you can master
00:51:19.839 --> 00:51:21.750
introspection it beats all other kinds
00:51:21.760 --> 00:51:23.750
of knowledge. whereas you turn it on its
00:51:23.760 --> 00:51:25.510
head not only to say well it doesn't
00:51:25.520 --> 00:51:27.750
have any metaphysical importance but
00:51:27.760 --> 00:51:29.910
also that it's extremely narrow that
00:51:29.920 --> 00:51:32.870
what it can do is extremely limited. Why
00:51:32.880 --> 00:51:34.309
do you think it was the case that
00:51:34.319 --> 00:51:36.790
introspection over most of human history
00:51:36.800 --> 00:51:39.430
was was the absolute the best possible
00:51:39.440 --> 00:51:43.030
format for self-nowledge which now you
00:51:43.040 --> 00:51:45.910
say it's in fact barely anything. It
00:51:45.920 --> 00:51:47.510
could be the search for certainty
00:51:47.520 --> 00:51:49.670
because another rather paradoxical
00:51:49.680 --> 00:51:51.670
feature of this is we are certain of our
00:51:51.680 --> 00:51:53.030
own conscious states. We're not certain
00:51:53.040 --> 00:51:55.270
of the material world. So from a
00:51:55.280 --> 00:51:56.710
cartisian perspective, we know
00:51:56.720 --> 00:51:59.109
consciousness the best of anything. It's
00:51:59.119 --> 00:52:02.230
just very incomplete.
00:52:02.240 --> 00:52:04.470
Uh so people move from well we're
00:52:04.480 --> 00:52:05.829
certain of its existence. We're certain
00:52:05.839 --> 00:52:07.750
that we're in pain and so forth to we
00:52:07.760 --> 00:52:09.670
know all about pain. Well the thing we
00:52:09.680 --> 00:52:11.349
don't know of course about consciousness
00:52:11.359 --> 00:52:13.910
is how it relates to the brain. So you'd
00:52:13.920 --> 00:52:16.309
think we we would know that because we
00:52:16.319 --> 00:52:17.829
have we know what consciousness is from
00:52:17.839 --> 00:52:19.670
our introspection. But we don't seem to
00:52:19.680 --> 00:52:21.190
know one of the most basic facts about
00:52:21.200 --> 00:52:23.510
it, how it relates to the brain. It must
00:52:23.520 --> 00:52:25.670
relate to it in some intimate way. But
00:52:25.680 --> 00:52:27.750
we seem completely blind about that. And
00:52:27.760 --> 00:52:30.069
we have no way to try to fill that
00:52:30.079 --> 00:52:32.950
blindness. Nothing nothing you can think
00:52:32.960 --> 00:52:36.230
of would would even hypothetically
00:52:36.240 --> 00:52:38.630
bridge the gap between the two levels.
00:52:38.640 --> 00:52:40.309
So there's something very funny going on
00:52:40.319 --> 00:52:43.430
about our knowledge of our own mind.
00:52:43.440 --> 00:52:47.190
It's a strange kind of knowledge. Uh and
00:52:47.200 --> 00:52:49.109
it may be that it's just introspection
00:52:49.119 --> 00:52:52.950
is a very recent evolutionary adaptation
00:52:52.960 --> 00:52:54.710
which doesn't need to get any better
00:52:54.720 --> 00:52:56.309
than it is because it doesn't not doing
00:52:56.319 --> 00:52:57.510
very much for you in terms of
00:52:57.520 --> 00:52:59.829
reproduction of your genes and all of
00:52:59.839 --> 00:53:02.069
that. So it's not [snorts] surprising we
00:53:02.079 --> 00:53:03.430
don't know much about it. If you ask
00:53:03.440 --> 00:53:05.349
about animals, why don't animals have
00:53:05.359 --> 00:53:07.270
more introspection?
00:53:07.280 --> 00:53:09.829
You know why don't uh you know
00:53:09.839 --> 00:53:12.950
>> otter contemplate their Yeah. ect
00:53:12.960 --> 00:53:15.589
introspect more. Well, why would they?
00:53:15.599 --> 00:53:17.510
They're busy with trying to figure out
00:53:17.520 --> 00:53:19.589
their world and they've got to they've
00:53:19.599 --> 00:53:21.990
got to figure out how to get food. Uh
00:53:22.000 --> 00:53:23.430
I've actually come to see this more
00:53:23.440 --> 00:53:26.309
vividly recently. The absolutely central
00:53:26.319 --> 00:53:28.710
place of food in animal life compared to
00:53:28.720 --> 00:53:31.349
human life. Nearly all animal species
00:53:31.359 --> 00:53:33.030
are on the point of starvation all the
00:53:33.040 --> 00:53:35.430
time.
00:53:35.440 --> 00:53:37.190
Never can get enough food. Their whole
00:53:37.200 --> 00:53:39.109
life is devoted to getting food for
00:53:39.119 --> 00:53:41.510
themselves and for their offspring. We
00:53:41.520 --> 00:53:44.230
humans have cracked the problem at one
00:53:44.240 --> 00:53:45.829
time, you know, for many many thousands
00:53:45.839 --> 00:53:47.589
of years. We hadn't and we presumably
00:53:47.599 --> 00:53:49.270
were on the edge of starvation at all
00:53:49.280 --> 00:53:51.589
the time too. But now we we invented
00:53:51.599 --> 00:53:53.349
agriculture and all the other things
00:53:53.359 --> 00:53:55.910
we've done. And so humans can get food,
00:53:55.920 --> 00:53:58.549
but animals lives are devoted to getting
00:53:58.559 --> 00:53:59.829
food. So they've got no time to
00:53:59.839 --> 00:54:02.150
introspect their thoughts. And what's
00:54:02.160 --> 00:54:03.270
that got to do with getting
00:54:03.280 --> 00:54:05.030
>> Do you think introspection came as a
00:54:05.040 --> 00:54:08.069
result of the agricultural revolution?
00:54:08.079 --> 00:54:10.630
>> It could be. It could be. It's a it's a
00:54:10.640 --> 00:54:12.230
way to think about it. It gave humans
00:54:12.240 --> 00:54:16.870
the time uh to indulge in introspection.
00:54:16.880 --> 00:54:17.270
So
00:54:17.280 --> 00:54:19.430
>> yeah, we can imagine the the orangutang
00:54:19.440 --> 00:54:21.510
in the zoo which is now, you know, seven
00:54:21.520 --> 00:54:23.109
generations deep just living in
00:54:23.119 --> 00:54:25.670
captivity. Food food's done. And maybe
00:54:25.680 --> 00:54:27.030
yeah, maybe that, you know, when they're
00:54:27.040 --> 00:54:29.030
just staring at the cage, scratching the
00:54:29.040 --> 00:54:31.750
chin, but actually this is we'll see
00:54:31.760 --> 00:54:34.069
introspection develop before our eyes in
00:54:34.079 --> 00:54:36.309
these kind of
00:54:36.319 --> 00:54:38.309
>> those caged orangutangs will be quite
00:54:38.319 --> 00:54:40.309
good introspectively because they they
00:54:40.319 --> 00:54:42.150
will be passed down through their genes.
00:54:42.160 --> 00:54:44.870
And maybe the ones who maybe the ones
00:54:44.880 --> 00:54:46.630
who are more introspective will be able
00:54:46.640 --> 00:54:49.750
to uh obtain the affections of their
00:54:49.760 --> 00:54:51.510
feeders more easily and therefore
00:54:51.520 --> 00:54:53.510
they'll reproduce more than the ones
00:54:53.520 --> 00:54:56.069
that the human feeders don't you know
00:54:56.079 --> 00:54:59.030
favor as much with the good food. So be
00:54:59.040 --> 00:55:01.750
a thousand generations there selection
00:55:01.760 --> 00:55:04.309
towards good introspectors. It could be
00:55:04.319 --> 00:55:07.190
>> yeah a species of philosopher apes who
00:55:07.200 --> 00:55:08.710
gain their food through their great
00:55:08.720 --> 00:55:09.990
insight. So they [laughter] always
00:55:10.000 --> 00:55:11.349
reproduce more.
00:55:11.359 --> 00:55:12.870
>> Their nose kind of stupid
00:55:12.880 --> 00:55:14.870
>> and we become entirely dependent on the
00:55:14.880 --> 00:55:16.710
philosopher apes because [laughter]
00:55:16.720 --> 00:55:18.470
they're so much more introspective than
00:55:18.480 --> 00:55:20.790
we are.
00:55:20.800 --> 00:55:22.630
>> Um
00:55:22.640 --> 00:55:25.589
yes, [laughter]
00:55:25.599 --> 00:55:27.430
next question. Next question. So there's
00:55:27.440 --> 00:55:30.309
this idea that um the the reason that we
00:55:30.319 --> 00:55:33.109
see the mind as as separate from matter
00:55:33.119 --> 00:55:35.829
and our own introspective world as
00:55:35.839 --> 00:55:38.470
separate from the outside world is a
00:55:38.480 --> 00:55:40.790
sort of habit of the brain or a lie that
00:55:40.800 --> 00:55:43.109
our brain tells us in order to
00:55:43.119 --> 00:55:45.990
accommodate language. goes this is a
00:55:46.000 --> 00:55:48.549
theory that language only works if you
00:55:48.559 --> 00:55:50.309
have a dualistic
00:55:50.319 --> 00:55:52.630
worldview and that our brains are
00:55:52.640 --> 00:55:55.430
therefore tended towards dualism in
00:55:55.440 --> 00:55:57.109
order to support the existence of
00:55:57.119 --> 00:55:59.670
language. Do you think this is a
00:55:59.680 --> 00:56:01.190
>> I've never heard of this before?
00:56:01.200 --> 00:56:04.150
>> No, I I I I don't know where I picked it
00:56:04.160 --> 00:56:05.510
up. I think it was
00:56:05.520 --> 00:56:06.630
>> maybe you thought of it. Maybe you
00:56:06.640 --> 00:56:07.030
thought [laughter]
00:56:07.040 --> 00:56:08.710
>> maybe this is my Yeah, this is an
00:56:08.720 --> 00:56:10.870
original thought. But langu especially
00:56:10.880 --> 00:56:15.829
syntax it's very dualistic. It's very me
00:56:15.839 --> 00:56:18.789
in the world. I I I wonder I don't know
00:56:18.799 --> 00:56:21.109
is this is there any credence to this
00:56:21.119 --> 00:56:22.470
possibility. Is this
00:56:22.480 --> 00:56:23.910
>> I've never I've never thought about it
00:56:23.920 --> 00:56:26.150
for one second before I read your
00:56:26.160 --> 00:56:29.030
questions. [laughter]
00:56:29.040 --> 00:56:30.950
I don't have much I haven't got anything
00:56:30.960 --> 00:56:33.190
good to say about it. I mean I I always
00:56:33.200 --> 00:56:34.710
like
00:56:34.720 --> 00:56:37.670
very out there original ideas like that.
00:56:37.680 --> 00:56:39.750
I like the the shape of it, you know.
00:56:39.760 --> 00:56:42.069
It's good good to think about it. And
00:56:42.079 --> 00:56:43.829
even if it turns out not to have much to
00:56:43.839 --> 00:56:45.349
it, it's still interesting to think
00:56:45.359 --> 00:56:47.829
about it because now you've just as Papa
00:56:47.839 --> 00:56:50.150
says, falsifying things is just as good
00:56:50.160 --> 00:56:52.549
as if not better than trying to verify
00:56:52.559 --> 00:56:54.630
things. And you'll learn something where
00:56:54.640 --> 00:56:55.829
you where you think about and say that
00:56:55.839 --> 00:56:58.474
well or you might you might
00:56:58.484 --> 00:56:59.750
[clears throat] it might turn out that
00:56:59.760 --> 00:57:01.349
when you thought about it and falsified
00:57:01.359 --> 00:57:03.270
some versions of it there'll be a
00:57:03.280 --> 00:57:05.990
version that remains unfalsified that's
00:57:06.000 --> 00:57:08.069
slightly better which will give you some
00:57:08.079 --> 00:57:11.349
insight into it. Um I mean let let me
00:57:11.359 --> 00:57:12.630
just pause for a moment and see if
00:57:12.640 --> 00:57:14.309
anything pops into my mind about what
00:57:14.319 --> 00:57:17.510
you're saying. Uh because it does strike
00:57:17.520 --> 00:57:19.589
me that there may be something in it.
00:57:19.599 --> 00:57:22.069
Um, I mean it's true. I think that our
00:57:22.079 --> 00:57:24.390
mind is dualistic.
00:57:24.400 --> 00:57:26.069
I think that's true. We're naturally
00:57:26.079 --> 00:57:28.549
dualistic in a way that's not true to
00:57:28.559 --> 00:57:29.750
the reality.
00:57:29.760 --> 00:57:30.549
>> Yes,
00:57:30.559 --> 00:57:32.870
>> monism is much more likely to be true
00:57:32.880 --> 00:57:34.789
and all sorts of reasons to think that.
00:57:34.799 --> 00:57:37.349
But we somehow stuck with or we cleave
00:57:37.359 --> 00:57:40.309
to a dualistic picture of the world.
00:57:40.319 --> 00:57:42.069
>> I'm pretty sure it's panultural as well.
00:57:42.079 --> 00:57:45.109
I'm pretty sure China are dualistic.
00:57:45.119 --> 00:57:47.670
Australian
aboriges are dualistic.
00:57:47.680 --> 00:57:49.750
everybody just that's the baseline human
00:57:49.760 --> 00:57:53.030
condition. You think of minds in bodies
00:57:53.040 --> 00:57:54.549
in matter.
00:57:54.559 --> 00:57:55.270
>> But yeah,
00:57:55.280 --> 00:57:57.109
>> I mean there's there's a very general
00:57:57.119 --> 00:58:00.789
idea too about mathematics here that uh
00:58:00.799 --> 00:58:02.069
there there's one thing and then there's
00:58:02.079 --> 00:58:05.510
two things. So the idea of two is
00:58:05.520 --> 00:58:07.430
getting you up there into the number
00:58:07.440 --> 00:58:10.950
system. Uh so we do think we like to we
00:58:10.960 --> 00:58:13.190
like to in philosophy we like to have
00:58:13.200 --> 00:58:16.470
dualistic theories about things.
00:58:16.480 --> 00:58:18.870
We're not that happy with three things.
00:58:18.880 --> 00:58:21.109
We or four things, but do we like we're
00:58:21.119 --> 00:58:23.750
comfortable with it. So, uh, you know,
00:58:23.760 --> 00:58:26.390
we like ones and zeros. We we like that
00:58:26.400 --> 00:58:28.789
idea that there's two things like our
00:58:28.799 --> 00:58:30.950
brain is happy with that. We feel a
00:58:30.960 --> 00:58:32.789
little bit taxed with anything beyond
00:58:32.799 --> 00:58:37.990
it. So, if we now think about um I mean
00:58:38.000 --> 00:58:40.950
good and evil, right? All these kind
00:58:40.960 --> 00:58:43.510
binary oppositions, we like all of that.
00:58:43.520 --> 00:58:46.309
So if you could find in language a clear
00:58:46.319 --> 00:58:48.230
where you've got verbs and nouns, you
00:58:48.240 --> 00:58:49.990
know, you've got that kind of division,
00:58:50.000 --> 00:58:53.750
you could see that as reflecting that
00:58:53.760 --> 00:58:55.910
dualistic tendency.
00:58:55.920 --> 00:58:57.829
>> And then subjects and objects seems like
00:58:57.839 --> 00:58:59.109
the obvious one.
00:58:59.119 --> 00:59:02.630
>> Yeah, that would be one. Um I mean word
00:59:02.640 --> 00:59:04.309
and thing is another one. Word and
00:59:04.319 --> 00:59:06.549
object is another thing, another example
00:59:06.559 --> 00:59:08.710
of it. And that also may be an
00:59:08.720 --> 00:59:10.549
oversimplification. In fact, I think it
00:59:10.559 --> 00:59:12.789
probably is. I mean Frager, you know,
00:59:12.799 --> 00:59:15.190
Frager made that startling discovery
00:59:15.200 --> 00:59:17.670
that you can't just have the words and
00:59:17.680 --> 00:59:19.030
the object, you have to have the sense
00:59:19.040 --> 00:59:21.670
in addition to the word and the object
00:59:21.680 --> 00:59:24.470
intervening between the two. And then
00:59:24.480 --> 00:59:27.109
other people came like like Kaplan said,
00:59:27.119 --> 00:59:28.870
"Oh no, now we need character and
00:59:28.880 --> 00:59:31.910
content and now we need we add we have
00:59:31.920 --> 00:59:34.069
to keep adding layers all the time." And
00:59:34.079 --> 00:59:35.990
the human mind
starts to say, "Go to
00:59:36.000 --> 00:59:37.430
sleep." You know, [laughter]
00:59:37.440 --> 00:59:38.870
>> I'm going to do something else.
00:59:38.880 --> 00:59:40.950
>> It's too complicated. if I'm not being
00:59:40.960 --> 00:59:43.270
paid for it, if if no one's paying me to
00:59:43.280 --> 00:59:45.190
be a language philosopher, I'm not going
00:59:45.200 --> 00:59:46.150
to bother.
00:59:46.160 --> 00:59:46.630
>> Yeah.
00:59:46.640 --> 00:59:49.910
>> So, it's uh that's why, you know, I
00:59:49.920 --> 00:59:52.549
often things I write, I often come back
00:59:52.559 --> 00:59:55.030
to the pluralism about things. And
00:59:55.040 --> 00:59:57.349
pluralism seems absolutely right until
00:59:57.359 --> 00:59:59.750
you start to think, yeah, but it can't
00:59:59.760 --> 01:00:01.589
be plural all the way down. There should
01:00:01.599 --> 01:00:04.230
be more uniformity. Maybe there's
01:00:04.240 --> 01:00:08.390
pluralism within unity in some way. We
01:00:08.400 --> 01:00:09.750
don't want don't know what the unified
01:00:09.760 --> 01:00:10.069
thing is.
01:00:10.079 --> 01:00:12.150
>> Sounding pretty trinitarian if I do say
01:00:12.160 --> 01:00:13.030
so myself. [laughter]
01:00:13.040 --> 01:00:16.710
>> Oh yeah. I mean it's u so these are all
01:00:16.720 --> 01:00:19.190
these metaphysical things which you you
01:00:19.200 --> 01:00:21.109
have to toy with when you get into these
01:00:21.119 --> 01:00:24.150
these problems. Um I mean types of
01:00:24.160 --> 01:00:25.589
knowledge too. I've just been working on
01:00:25.599 --> 01:00:28.549
types of knowledge a bit uh as well. Did
01:00:28.559 --> 01:00:30.870
you see my most recent blogs about
01:00:30.880 --> 01:00:33.109
synthetic a priori and
01:00:33.119 --> 01:00:36.150
>> I I I confess I found them quite hard to
01:00:36.160 --> 01:00:37.430
follow but I was
01:00:37.440 --> 01:00:41.190
>> re [laughter]
01:00:41.200 --> 01:00:42.950
>> looking at the words
01:00:42.960 --> 01:00:45.349
>> I'm not surprised they hard they are
01:00:45.359 --> 01:00:47.430
hard to follow when I was writing them I
01:00:47.440 --> 01:00:49.910
I thought I'm on the edge of uh what can
01:00:49.920 --> 01:00:51.349
be understood at this point because it
01:00:51.359 --> 01:00:53.670
goes against all of my training and
01:00:53.680 --> 01:00:55.990
experience too to start thinking that
01:00:56.000 --> 01:00:58.789
way but the division between a priori
01:00:58.799 --> 01:01:00.870
and a posterior which we normally think
01:01:00.880 --> 01:01:02.870
of as very binary you know maybe that's
01:01:02.880 --> 01:01:05.589
not what what are Newton's laws you know
01:01:05.599 --> 01:01:08.789
Newton's three laws are they a hard to
01:01:08.799 --> 01:01:11.510
say and also things analytic synthetic
01:01:11.520 --> 01:01:13.750
you know is that is this are they are we
01:01:13.760 --> 01:01:15.829
just oversimplifying everything by
01:01:15.839 --> 01:01:19.109
saying that um and so
on right necessary
01:01:19.119 --> 01:01:20.390
contingent again
01:01:20.400 --> 01:01:22.549
>> yeah of course yeah god there's so many
01:01:22.559 --> 01:01:25.349
of them these these dualities
01:01:25.359 --> 01:01:28.549
>> each of them you can think why are we So
01:01:28.559 --> 01:01:30.390
uh you know in love with the idea of
01:01:30.400 --> 01:01:33.990
these dual realities when really this is
01:01:34.000 --> 01:01:35.430
what you know Vickenstein's
01:01:35.440 --> 01:01:37.430
investigations is really all revolves
01:01:37.440 --> 01:01:39.750
around this because in the spectators it
01:01:39.760 --> 01:01:42.710
was all about simple things probably
01:01:42.720 --> 01:01:44.549
dualities and then the investigations oh
01:01:44.559 --> 01:01:47.109
no it's all this many many kinds of
01:01:47.119 --> 01:01:49.670
things and he leaves it at that you know
01:01:49.680 --> 01:01:52.309
you can't really leave it at that
01:01:52.319 --> 01:01:53.910
you might say well there many kinds of
01:01:53.920 --> 01:01:56.150
tree true but there are ways you can
01:01:56.160 --> 01:01:59.270
unify that class here
01:01:59.280 --> 01:02:00.630
things you can say about trees in
01:02:00.640 --> 01:02:02.710
general the craving for generality which
01:02:02.720 --> 01:02:05.589
he talks about is real and it's not just
01:02:05.599 --> 01:02:07.670
a prejudice
01:02:07.680 --> 01:02:09.270
vickan is completely wrong you know
01:02:09.280 --> 01:02:11.829
about there being a multiplicity of
01:02:11.839 --> 01:02:13.829
speech acts [snorts]
01:02:13.839 --> 01:02:15.910
he doesn't even consider the question of
01:02:15.920 --> 01:02:18.549
can they all be divided into three basic
01:02:18.559 --> 01:02:21.270
groups assertions commands and questions
01:02:21.280 --> 01:02:22.630
he doesn't even consider it
01:02:22.640 --> 01:02:25.109
>> no this I suppose I'm thinking of in
01:02:25.119 --> 01:02:27.270
terms of brain lateralization It sounds
01:02:27.280 --> 01:02:29.829
very left versus right, you know,
01:02:29.839 --> 01:02:33.109
categorical versus perceptive. Again, in
01:02:33.119 --> 01:02:36.950
terms of our evolution, you know, it's a
01:02:36.960 --> 01:02:38.870
am I using the part of my brain that's
01:02:38.880 --> 01:02:41.190
there for getting stuff, getting food,
01:02:41.200 --> 01:02:43.430
noticing an apple? Oh, it's the category
01:02:43.440 --> 01:02:45.750
of apple. I can eat it. Or am I doing
01:02:45.760 --> 01:02:47.670
the the the part of the brain that's
01:02:47.680 --> 01:02:49.190
designed for like looking around,
01:02:49.200 --> 01:02:51.750
noticing a specific new environment for
01:02:51.760 --> 01:02:54.470
predators, those sorts of things. Yeah.
01:02:54.480 --> 01:02:56.390
Not sure if you've read McGillchrist's
01:02:56.400 --> 01:02:59.349
uh book, The Master in His Emissary or
01:02:59.359 --> 01:03:00.309
No. Yeah,
01:03:00.319 --> 01:03:01.750
>> it's quite good.
01:03:01.760 --> 01:03:02.549
>> Is it good?
01:03:02.559 --> 01:03:03.990
>> Yeah. Yeah, it's good. I I give it a
01:03:04.000 --> 01:03:05.270
read. It's quite it's, you know, it's
01:03:05.280 --> 01:03:07.510
it's one of these books that tries to
01:03:07.520 --> 01:03:09.910
explain everything, which I I have a
01:03:09.920 --> 01:03:12.630
sort of soft spot for, you know, the big
01:03:12.640 --> 01:03:14.950
big Germanic theory of everything
01:03:14.960 --> 01:03:17.029
through brain lateralization. And I
01:03:17.039 --> 01:03:18.470
think he has a bit more of a kooky
01:03:18.480 --> 01:03:20.470
reputation than he deserves.
01:03:20.480 --> 01:03:21.750
>> There's quite a bit to that. I think
01:03:21.760 --> 01:03:24.230
very naturalization is is a genuine
01:03:24.240 --> 01:03:25.910
thing for sure.
01:03:25.920 --> 01:03:27.910
>> And especially the first half of the
01:03:27.920 --> 01:03:29.510
book that is there are just a lot of
01:03:29.520 --> 01:03:31.670
really fascinating experiments in there
01:03:31.680 --> 01:03:34.470
about you know which which eye crows use
01:03:34.480 --> 01:03:36.309
and those sorts of things.
01:03:36.319 --> 01:03:38.710
>> The first half of two I seem to be
01:03:38.720 --> 01:03:42.870
detecting [laughter] a pattern here.
01:03:42.880 --> 01:03:45.990
>> Yeah. But I it's something about finding
01:03:46.000 --> 01:03:48.870
mankind finding himself in reality.
01:03:48.880 --> 01:03:50.549
We've got all these twos. two legs, two
01:03:50.559 --> 01:03:52.390
arms, two eyes, whatever. We're looking
01:03:52.400 --> 01:03:53.990
for this and we're finding it. It's
01:03:54.000 --> 01:03:55.750
similar to what you've said about how
01:03:55.760 --> 01:03:57.990
we're really good at spatial reasoning.
01:03:58.000 --> 01:04:01.029
Anything spacebased, extremely good at
01:04:01.039 --> 01:04:03.190
figuring that out. Um,
01:04:03.200 --> 01:04:05.510
>> yeah, extremely compelling and and it's
01:04:05.520 --> 01:04:07.109
this is kind of why we have this
01:04:07.119 --> 01:04:09.109
illusion of total understanding because
01:04:09.119 --> 01:04:12.309
our spatial reference is so powerful. It
01:04:12.319 --> 01:04:14.549
seems to apply even to cosmic scale. you
01:04:14.559 --> 01:04:16.390
know, rockets take off and do not
01:04:16.400 --> 01:04:19.270
explode because our spatial reasoning is
01:04:19.280 --> 01:04:21.190
so perfectly attuned to reality. And
01:04:21.200 --> 01:04:22.789
because of that, we're like, well, we
01:04:22.799 --> 01:04:24.630
got knowledge of everything. But maybe
01:04:24.640 --> 01:04:27.430
we like to see things in twos and space
01:04:27.440 --> 01:04:29.510
because we walk through space with our
01:04:29.520 --> 01:04:32.470
two legs. And again, this is a sense of
01:04:32.480 --> 01:04:34.870
really you are the limit. And if if the
01:04:34.880 --> 01:04:36.870
whole of reality seems to reflect
01:04:36.880 --> 01:04:39.029
humanity, and this is really you see it
01:04:39.039 --> 01:04:40.789
a lot in
theology, you see it a lot in
01:04:40.799 --> 01:04:42.870
spiritualism. If it is the case that we
01:04:42.880 --> 01:04:45.190
are just a mirror of everything, perhaps
01:04:45.200 --> 01:04:46.870
that says a little bit less about
01:04:46.880 --> 01:04:49.430
everything and a bit more about the
01:04:49.440 --> 01:04:52.789
thinker, the person projecting into the
01:04:52.799 --> 01:04:54.390
world, which isn't to say everything we
01:04:54.400 --> 01:04:56.630
recognize is not true or false, but
01:04:56.640 --> 01:04:58.230
really that we can see it through a kind
01:04:58.240 --> 01:05:00.069
of human-shaped silhouette and
01:05:00.079 --> 01:05:01.349
everything through the silhouette is
01:05:01.359 --> 01:05:02.549
legitimate,
01:05:02.559 --> 01:05:05.430
>> but everything else is just uh unclear
01:05:05.440 --> 01:05:06.150
to us.
01:05:06.160 --> 01:05:08.630
>> Right. Right. Absolutely. No, I can I
01:05:08.640 --> 01:05:10.309
completely agree. I mean, it makes
01:05:10.319 --> 01:05:12.549
perfect sense because, of course, we're
01:05:12.559 --> 01:05:15.190
animals and all animals live in space.
01:05:15.200 --> 01:05:17.270
All of their life and their ability to
01:05:17.280 --> 01:05:18.789
survive depends on their understanding
01:05:18.799 --> 01:05:20.710
of space. So, of course, we're very,
01:05:20.720 --> 01:05:23.510
very good at space. It goes back to the
01:05:23.520 --> 01:05:25.990
earliest organisms will surely have been
01:05:26.000 --> 01:05:29.349
attuned to space more than anything. So,
01:05:29.359 --> 01:05:31.190
yeah, I mean, we this is a conscient way
01:05:31.200 --> 01:05:35.109
of think thinking of course too. Um time
01:05:35.119 --> 01:05:37.109
time is another you could also you could
01:05:37.119 --> 01:05:39.430
introduce time in the same breath or
01:05:39.440 --> 01:05:41.829
time raises other questions but in the
01:05:41.839 --> 01:05:43.910
case of space we obviously had an
01:05:43.920 --> 01:05:45.510
extremely good practical understanding
01:05:45.520 --> 01:05:49.589
of space because when we get theoretical
01:05:49.599 --> 01:05:52.230
the extent of space then we get we lose
01:05:52.240 --> 01:05:55.670
it completely there but but yeah but get
01:05:55.680 --> 01:05:57.750
the brain is then a space organ right
01:05:57.760 --> 01:05:59.910
it's it's geared to understand space but
01:05:59.920 --> 01:06:01.750
that means it's using all its resources
01:06:01.760 --> 01:06:04.069
on one aspect of reality and ignoring
01:06:04.079 --> 01:06:05.990
everything else. Well, it's not that
01:06:06.000 --> 01:06:07.270
relevant.
01:06:07.280 --> 01:06:10.549
>> So, it's pretty bad at other things. Um,
01:06:10.559 --> 01:06:13.270
okay. It's the way that's the way that's
01:06:13.280 --> 01:06:14.549
the way things are.
01:06:14.559 --> 01:06:16.789
>> Amazing to imagine just a time brain.
01:06:16.799 --> 01:06:18.470
We've been communicating this entire
01:06:18.480 --> 01:06:20.390
time with
with phenology, with mouth
01:06:20.400 --> 01:06:22.950
sounds, with language. I um would like
01:06:22.960 --> 01:06:25.109
to go back to this uh thing you were
01:06:25.119 --> 01:06:28.870
hinting at earlier about non-llinguistic
01:06:28.880 --> 01:06:31.829
forms of communication. Um, so about 10
01:06:31.839 --> 01:06:33.589
years ago, you wrote a paper called
01:06:33.599 --> 01:06:36.069
meaning without language that I dug up.
01:06:36.079 --> 01:06:38.390
Um, where and I think it's quite a
01:06:38.400 --> 01:06:40.870
radical claim. You argue that it's
01:06:40.880 --> 01:06:42.950
possible to communicate meaning or
01:06:42.960 --> 01:06:44.710
intentionality,
01:06:44.720 --> 01:06:47.670
specifically Gryian intentions, maybe go
01:06:47.680 --> 01:06:50.549
briefly into what those are, without any
01:06:50.559 --> 01:06:53.990
utterance of any kind of of symbol
01:06:54.000 --> 01:06:57.510
through some sort of uh direct brain
01:06:57.520 --> 01:07:01.589
connection. Could you develop this?
01:07:01.599 --> 01:07:03.910
>> Uh yeah, I know the paper. You mean it's
01:07:03.920 --> 01:07:07.510
all to do with this dissociation of
01:07:07.520 --> 01:07:10.230
aspects of the thing we call language.
01:07:10.240 --> 01:07:13.750
So I'm dissociating communication from
01:07:13.760 --> 01:07:16.870
language meaning that that syntactic
01:07:16.880 --> 01:07:19.349
semantic structure that we've got in our
01:07:19.359 --> 01:07:22.870
heads. So the basic idea of it is if you
01:07:22.880 --> 01:07:25.349
think about animal communication, they
01:07:25.359 --> 01:07:27.109
don't use language in the way that we
01:07:27.119 --> 01:07:29.349
use language. what what people sometimes
01:07:29.359 --> 01:07:32.150
sloppily say whale language or dolphin
01:07:32.160 --> 01:07:34.710
language and if you just mean by that
01:07:34.720 --> 01:07:37.190
you know a signaling system it's okay
01:07:37.200 --> 01:07:39.109
but it doesn't have the properties of of
01:07:39.119 --> 01:07:40.789
a human language and chsky is always
01:07:40.799 --> 01:07:42.630
pointing that out uh it's not
01:07:42.640 --> 01:07:44.710
hierarchical it's not recursive it's not
01:07:44.720 --> 01:07:46.789
this and all sorts of complexities in
01:07:46.799 --> 01:07:49.190
human language that are not there now if
01:07:49.200 --> 01:07:51.270
you go beyond that you even get down to
01:07:51.280 --> 01:07:54.390
you know uh reptiles and even insects
01:07:54.400 --> 01:07:56.870
they communicate with each other they
01:07:56.880 --> 01:08:00.870
have to u especially because of mating
01:08:00.880 --> 01:08:02.309
they have to mate with each other so
01:08:02.319 --> 01:08:05.190
they have to communicate um so they have
01:08:05.200 --> 01:08:06.789
that communication means conveying
01:08:06.799 --> 01:08:08.630
information
01:08:08.640 --> 01:08:10.150
so they convey information let's take
01:08:10.160 --> 01:08:14.470
the way um a bird a male bird dances for
01:08:14.480
--> 01:08:16.309
the female
01:08:16.319 --> 01:08:18.630
>> all those elaborate displays it's
01:08:18.640 --> 01:08:20.070
communicating the information about
01:08:20.080 --> 01:08:21.749
reproductive fitness that's what we
01:08:21.759 --> 01:08:22.709
would say about it
01:08:22.719 --> 01:08:24.390
>> but isn't that the utter isn't that the
01:08:24.400 --> 01:08:26.550
utterance of a symbol
01:08:26.560 --> 01:08:28.789
Yes. So that so then there's no there's
01:08:28.799 --> 01:08:30.309
no language there in the sense that the
01:08:30.319 --> 01:08:32.870
bird the male bird is speaking to the
01:08:32.880 --> 01:08:36.229
other one speak to somebody they they
01:08:36.239 --> 01:08:39.749
have to use an external medium. You see
01:08:39.759 --> 01:08:42.630
that's not the same as a language.
01:08:42.640 --> 01:08:45.669
>> Uh so need be anything with reference or
01:08:45.679 --> 01:08:48.470
needn't be predication. There needn't be
01:08:48.480 --> 01:08:51.030
uh you know logical particles nothing
01:08:51.040 --> 01:08:53.510
like that. It's just anything which gets
01:08:53.520 --> 01:08:55.110
the message across is going to do the
01:08:55.120 --> 01:08:56.309
job.
01:08:56.319 --> 01:08:58.229
But it isn't getting isn't doing that
01:08:58.239 --> 01:09:00.149
dance and getting the message across
01:09:00.159 --> 01:09:03.110
that seems like a maybe it's a
01:09:03.120 --> 01:09:05.510
primordial form of language but it still
01:09:05.520 --> 01:09:07.749
feels like a symbolism is there.
01:09:07.759 --> 01:09:09.430
>> Well you can say you can call it
01:09:09.440 --> 01:09:11.110
symbolic I think that's reasonable but
01:09:11.120 --> 01:09:13.349
the concept of symbol is extremely broad
01:09:13.359 --> 01:09:14.709
isn't it?
01:09:14.719 --> 01:09:15.349
>> Yeah
01:09:15.359 --> 01:09:18.470
>> very very broad. So if we expand it in
01:09:18.480 --> 01:09:20.950
that way but but if you see if you try
01:09:20.960 --> 01:09:25.110
to compare uh that kind of symbol with a
01:09:25.120 --> 01:09:28.070
word in language let's take the word and
01:09:28.080 --> 01:09:29.590
you see you see immediately the
01:09:29.600 --> 01:09:31.749
differences in the properties of those
01:09:31.759 --> 01:09:33.669
two symbol they're both called symbols
01:09:33.679 --> 01:09:35.189
but
01:09:35.199 --> 01:09:36.470
they've got different properties because
01:09:36.480 --> 01:09:39.110
and is all these complicated things it
01:09:39.120 --> 01:09:40.870
can do the way it interacts with the
01:09:40.880 --> 01:09:44.070
word not you know all those things
01:09:44.080 --> 01:09:46.229
um and then Chsky's f fancy kind
01:09:46.239 --> 01:09:49.030
syntactic transformations and all that.
01:09:49.040 --> 01:09:50.709
That's what they don't have any of that.
01:09:50.719 --> 01:09:52.630
So [snorts] there could be if we get
01:09:52.640 --> 01:09:55.750
more not just animals on earth but more
01:09:55.760 --> 01:09:57.270
science fiction kind of way
of looking
01:09:57.280 --> 01:09:59.270
at things you can imagine some aliens
01:09:59.280 --> 01:10:01.189
who've developed. So they just send out
01:10:01.199 --> 01:10:02.630
a brain signal into the
01:10:02.640 --> 01:10:04.390
electromagnetically
01:10:04.400 --> 01:10:06.229
into the air and they communicate by
01:10:06.239 --> 01:10:08.070
that just goes into the other a receptor
01:10:08.080 --> 01:10:10.470
in the other in in the other animals
01:10:10.480 --> 01:10:13.830
other aliens brain and it gets a copy of
01:10:13.840 --> 01:10:16.470
what was in the sender's brain. So it
01:10:16.480 --> 01:10:18.790
communicates as long as it does the job
01:10:18.800 --> 01:10:20.630
it communicates. You see you you can
01:10:20.640 --> 01:10:23.270
communicate I can communicate to you
01:10:23.280 --> 01:10:24.630
things linguistically and I can
01:10:24.640 --> 01:10:26.310
communicate the same thing non-
01:10:26.320 --> 01:10:28.950
linguistically.
01:10:28.960 --> 01:10:33.510
>> If I say to you uh whenever I do this it
01:10:33.520 --> 01:10:36.870
means I want to leave the place we're in
01:10:36.880 --> 01:10:39.030
and I do so I so instead of saying to
01:10:39.040 --> 01:10:41.430
you I want to leave here I've used
01:10:41.440 --> 01:10:43.350
language I just do this. It's not
01:10:43.360 --> 01:10:46.310
language. I've just I've just told you
01:10:46.320 --> 01:10:48.470
that's the symbol for so now you know I
01:10:48.480 --> 01:10:50.790
want to leave I haven't used as my
01:10:50.800 --> 01:10:54.550
medium hasn't is not linguistic
01:10:54.560 --> 01:10:55.189
>> or or even
01:10:55.199 --> 01:10:56.630
>> that's what I meant by any that's what I
01:10:56.640 --> 01:10:57.030
meant by
01:10:57.040 --> 01:10:58.950
>> sure and even in linguistics you could
01:10:58.960 --> 01:11:01.910
say you know could it's it's getting
01:11:01.920 --> 01:11:04.709
quite hot in here means please open the
01:11:04.719 --> 01:11:08.470
window it's not just helpful information
01:11:08.480 --> 01:11:11.430
about the temperature of the room um
01:11:11.440 --> 01:11:13.430
it's you know it's connected to a
01:11:13.440 --> 01:11:14.950
specific
01:11:14.960 --> 01:11:16.070
um function.
01:11:16.080 --> 01:11:19.030
>> I mean, what about when the the birds,
01:11:19.040 --> 01:11:22.229
the uh the baby birds, you know, waiting
01:11:22.239 --> 01:11:24.149
for the food and they open their mouth
01:11:24.159 --> 01:11:27.030
to get the food? They're communicating
01:11:27.040 --> 01:11:28.790
to the mother that they're really
01:11:28.800 --> 01:11:32.310
hungry, but is opening your mouth and
01:11:32.320 --> 01:11:35.750
going berserk. It's that language.
01:11:35.760 --> 01:11:37.830
It's just it communicates it.
01:11:37.840 --> 01:11:39.990
>> I really think philosophers in general
01:11:40.000 --> 01:11:42.870
should pay more attention to animals. I
01:11:42.880 --> 01:11:45.350
think it's a massive missed or missed
01:11:45.360 --> 01:11:47.910
opportunity over many centuries that
01:11:47.920 --> 01:11:50.070
that philosophers just didn't think
01:11:50.080 --> 01:11:52.630
animals were meaningful. No, no souls
01:11:52.640 --> 01:11:54.229
don't bother about even the ones that
01:11:54.239 --> 01:11:56.390
kind of look identical to us with a bit
01:11:56.400 --> 01:11:58.470
more hair can't have any relevance
01:11:58.480 --> 01:12:00.790
possible to the study of knowledge or
01:12:00.800 --> 01:12:02.870
mankind or development. But even you
01:12:02.880 --> 01:12:04.229
know the sort of the the the less
01:12:04.239 --> 01:12:06.470
developed which is itself a sort of
01:12:06.480 --> 01:12:08.709
mistaken term but just to look at all
01:12:08.719 --> 01:12:10.550
life the way it interacts the way it
01:12:10.560 --> 01:12:12.550
seems and not accidentally give it human
01:12:12.560 --> 01:12:14.550
characteristics as we tend to but just
01:12:14.560 --> 01:12:16.229
to observe because I think there's a lot
01:12:16.239 --> 01:12:18.870
there's a huge untapped field of this is
01:12:18.880 --> 01:12:21.510
all of reality minus one part
01:12:21.520 --> 01:12:25.189
>> ourselves I totally agree with you I
01:12:25.199 --> 01:12:26.870
think it's a huge lack particularly in
01:12:26.880 --> 01:12:29.430
philosophy of mind
01:12:29.440 --> 01:12:31.189
you know trying to understand concepts
01:12:31.199 --> 01:12:33.270
like intention or emotion and you're not
01:12:33.280 --> 01:12:35.270
considering animals is just you're just
01:12:35.280 --> 01:12:39.750
hampering yourself completely. So, um
01:12:39.760 --> 01:12:42.149
let's expand on this point a little bit.
01:12:42.159 --> 01:12:44.390
Uh things like things philosophers ought
01:12:44.400 --> 01:12:46.790
to know and don't know. They should
01:12:46.800 --> 01:12:48.950
definitely know their Darwin. Uh and I
01:12:48.960 --> 01:12:50.790
would even recommend reading Darwin's
01:12:50.800 --> 01:12:55.030
own works fairly assiduously. Since I
01:12:55.040 --> 01:12:57.750
retired, which is now, how many years
01:12:57.760 --> 01:12:59.910
ago is it? 12 13 years ago, I've had
01:12:59.920 --> 01:13:02.550
more time to read. You see, before that
01:13:02.560 --> 01:13:04.550
I was I didn't have any time. I decided
01:13:04.560 --> 01:13:06.950
to read the origin of species. It's a
01:13:06.960 --> 01:13:08.790
long book. It's fairly difficult book.
01:13:08.800 --> 01:13:10.870
Has either of you ever read that book?
01:13:10.880 --> 01:13:13.110
>> Yeah, I read it. I did the Beagle, which
01:13:13.120 --> 01:13:14.790
is like a fun adventure story, then
01:13:14.800 --> 01:13:16.229
straight into origin. I was like, "All
01:13:16.239 --> 01:13:18.550
right, time to really start paying
01:13:18.560 --> 01:13:19.510
attention.
01:13:19.520 --> 01:13:21.270
>> I don't need to ple I don't need to
01:13:21.280 --> 01:13:23.350
preach to you then." Anyway, now I've
01:13:23.360 --> 01:13:24.870
read all the books by Darwin
because
01:13:24.880 --> 01:13:27.030
they're all brilliant, all extremely
01:13:27.040 --> 01:13:30.310
useful to philosophy. So um the voyage
01:13:30.320 --> 01:13:32.149
of the beagle is a great book in many
01:13:32.159 --> 01:13:34.310
ways all sorts of good things about it.
01:13:34.320 --> 01:13:36.310
Our species is invaluable to try and
01:13:36.320 --> 01:13:38.630
understand because a lot of the detail
01:13:38.640 --> 01:13:40.470
that Darwin produces in that it's not
01:13:40.480 --> 01:13:43.110
produced by other biologists who write
01:13:43.120 --> 01:13:45.830
you know books for the general audience.
01:13:45.840 --> 01:13:48.310
So you get you get how how Darwin came
01:13:48.320 --> 01:13:50.310
up with the idea and it comes across
01:13:50.320 --> 01:13:52.790
more persuasively because he knew he was
01:13:52.800 --> 01:13:54.149
creating it as he went along and it took
01:13:54.159 --> 01:13:56.310
him a long time to come up with it. And
01:13:56.320 --> 01:13:59.030
then I've even read his book on worms
01:13:59.040 --> 01:14:01.669
which is quite interesting too. Uh I've
01:14:01.679 --> 01:14:03.669
read the descent of man because I was
01:14:03.679 --> 01:14:05.750
interested in that. I also read
01:14:05.760 --> 01:14:08.470
expression of emotion in animals and and
01:14:08.480 --> 01:14:11.590
humans which is very interesting too.
01:14:11.600 --> 01:14:13.750
They're very all very very good for
01:14:13.760 --> 01:14:15.910
philosophers to read and not you know
01:14:15.920 --> 01:14:17.430
it's not they're not like reading a
01:14:17.440 --> 01:14:19.350
physics textbook and they're not hard to
01:14:19.360 --> 01:14:20.229
read.
01:14:20.239 --> 01:14:22.390
>> So people should know that and you know
01:14:22.400 --> 01:14:24.550
like I say I read all of Dawkins. People
01:14:24.560 --> 01:14:26.070
should re people should definitely know
01:14:26.080 --> 01:14:28.070
their Dawkins better than they do. Other
01:14:28.080 --> 01:14:31.430
people do, other uh scientists too have
01:14:31.440 --> 01:14:33.030
written about these things. You people
01:14:33.040 --> 01:14:34.390
philosophers should try to read a bit
01:14:34.400 --> 01:14:38.229
more broadly in science. um they they
01:14:38.239 --> 01:14:40.870
they in recent years they've done the
01:14:40.880 --> 01:14:43.270
wrong thing though which they they've
01:14:43.280 --> 01:14:45.430
discovered psychology
01:14:45.440 --> 01:14:48.229
and certain should know better really
01:14:48.239 --> 01:14:50.790
have persuaded them that philosophy is
01:14:50.800 --> 01:14:53.990
really psychology such we get xfi and
01:14:54.000 --> 01:14:55.830
all of that rubbish. So what the problem
01:14:55.840 --> 01:14:57.270
with it is that the philosophers have
01:14:57.280 --> 01:14:59.189
never been trained in psychology. So
01:14:59.199 --> 01:15:02.070
they don't know methodology at all and
01:15:02.080 --> 01:15:03.350
they don't know how to evaluate
01:15:03.360 --> 01:15:05.270
experiments. And they think they can
01:15:05.280 --> 01:15:07.430
just say psychologists have discovered
01:15:07.440 --> 01:15:11.350
this and they just generalize it when no
01:15:11.360 --> 01:15:12.950
respectful psychologist would ever
01:15:12.960 --> 01:15:14.950
generalize an experimental result in the
01:15:14.960 --> 01:15:16.790
way philosophers do because they don't
01:15:16.800 --> 01:15:18.149
know how. They're not scientists
01:15:18.159 --> 01:15:20.950
philosophers for the most part and
01:15:20.960 --> 01:15:22.070
particularly not psychological
01:15:22.080 --> 01:15:24.310
scientists. Psychologists are almost the
01:15:24.320 --> 01:15:26.149
most scientific scientists there are
01:15:26.159 --> 01:15:27.750
because it's so difficult for them to
01:15:27.760 --> 01:15:29.750
get any good solid results. So they have
01:15:29.760 --> 01:15:32.790
to be very very careful. If you go to a
01:15:32.800 --> 01:15:35.030
a presentation, a paper reading by a
01:15:35.040 --> 01:15:37.590
psychologist to psychologists, the
01:15:37.600 --> 01:15:39.590
person will lay out their experiment on
01:15:39.600 --> 01:15:41.750
the you know explain their experiment,
01:15:41.760 --> 01:15:43.510
how many subjects they had, what methods
01:15:43.520 --> 01:15:46.397
they used, explain their results
01:15:46.407 --> 01:15:46.950
[snorts]
01:15:46.960 --> 01:15:50.229
and that will be it. And then the whole
01:15:50.239 --> 01:15:52.470
discussion is taken up with the design
01:15:52.480 --> 01:15:54.390
of the experiment, the evaluation of the
01:15:54.400 --> 01:15:57.590
results and so on. Nobody's going into
01:15:57.600 --> 01:15:59.590
big generalizations about ethics, you
01:15:59.600 --> 01:16:01.030
know, and that kind of thing, which
01:16:01.040 --> 01:16:02.950
people have done recently. So, it annoys
01:16:02.960 --> 01:16:04.630
me really when these really
01:16:04.640 --> 01:16:07.350
psychologically ignorant philosophers
01:16:07.360 --> 01:16:08.870
are trying to preach to other people
01:16:08.880 --> 01:16:10.390
like me because I don't use a lot of
01:16:10.400 --> 01:16:12.470
psychology when I write. We should know
01:16:12.480 --> 01:16:14.310
more psych. I say I'm no more psychology
01:16:14.320 --> 01:16:15.830
than you'll ever know. I've got two
01:16:15.840 --> 01:16:18.950
degrees in psychology. I I am one. I
01:16:18.960 --> 01:16:20.630
know how to do it. I used to teach it
01:16:20.640 --> 01:16:22.229
for God's sake at one time. Taught very
01:16:22.239 --> 01:16:24.550
much psychology.
01:16:24.560 --> 01:16:26.550
You can't be as naive as you are being
01:16:26.560 --> 01:16:29.030
about this. The psychologists always
01:16:29.040 --> 01:16:30.310
disagree with each other a lot about
01:16:30.320 --> 01:16:32.950
these five especially their significance
01:16:32.960 --> 01:16:35.110
what they prove about human nature and
01:16:35.120 --> 01:16:36.709
human behavior. They're very cautious
01:16:36.719 --> 01:16:38.470
about it quite rightly. There are some
01:16:38.480 --> 01:16:42.470
areas where psychology is as scientific
01:16:42.480 --> 01:16:46.149
as biology like vision
01:16:46.159 --> 01:16:47.910
the psychology of vision is pretty
01:16:47.920 --> 01:16:51.270
sophisticated but social psychology it's
01:16:51.280 --> 01:16:53.510
totally speculative.
01:16:53.520 --> 01:16:55.590
Um so
01:16:55.600 --> 01:16:57.030
uh it goes back to what we were saying
01:16:57.040 --> 01:16:59.110
that you need to know more about things
01:16:59.120 --> 01:17:00.229
but one of the things you need to know
01:17:00.239 --> 01:17:03.270
is don't just take things as as if the
01:17:03.280 --> 01:17:05.189
psychologist have discovered this and
01:17:05.199 --> 01:17:07.350
it's a hard fact that we can all take on
01:17:07.360 --> 01:17:09.750
board. It's almost never like that. One
01:17:09.760 --> 01:17:11.430
of the reason I gave up psychology was I
01:17:11.440 --> 01:17:13.350
realized it was not a science. You could
01:17:13.360 --> 01:17:15.189
never get any good results and you got
01:17:15.199 --> 01:17:17.189
more results than possible [laughter]
01:17:17.199 --> 01:17:19.110
in psychology.
01:17:19.120 --> 01:17:20.870
I used to do experiments. I could never
01:17:20.880 --> 01:17:23.350
get good conclusions out to them. It was
01:17:23.360 --> 01:17:23.590
just
01:17:23.600 --> 01:17:25.189
>> It's just some stuff that happened.
01:17:25.199 --> 01:17:27.030
Yeah. [laughter]
01:17:27.040 --> 01:17:30.229
>> You just can't get them.
01:17:30.239 --> 01:17:31.990
>> Yeah. Well, so wind to an end now,
01:17:32.000 --> 01:17:33.750
Colin. It's been a delight speaking to
01:17:33.760 --> 01:17:36.229
you. Thanks so much for making the time.
01:17:36.239 --> 01:17:39.030
>> What time is it? It's 2:30. You want you
01:17:39.040 --> 01:17:40.550
want to have any further discussion or
01:17:40.560 --> 01:17:41.189
you want to
01:17:41.199 --> 01:17:45.199
>> in future by all means.