TRANSKRİPT 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:09.839
If that's the important part and the rest is just frosting, you should have made a whole six hour video about this external evidence, since it's doing all the heavy lifting.
00:00:12.240 --> 00:00:13.519
Challenge accepted.
00:00:13.839 --> 00:00:18.239
Someone made a six-hour video about gospel authorship because I asked for it.
00:00:18.559 --> 00:00:19.519
Six hours?
00:00:20.399 --> 00:00:22.480
I don't want to complain for that long.
00:00:22.719 --> 00:00:24.640
That probably deserves a look.
00:00:58.240 --> 00:01:08.959
When we did that 15-part series on gospel reliability, we went through like data point after data point after data point of what conservative these evangelical fundamentalist scholars have put out.
00:01:09.120 --> 00:01:11.680
And no one addresses their points.
00:01:11.920 --> 00:01:23.920
So I did a two and a half hour reply to Mike's six and a half hours, pointing out many of the flaws of the arguments, a great many of which were focused on the so-called internal evidence from the words of the Gospels themselves.
00:01:24.159 --> 00:01:33.359
In his live stream response to my response, a few times he backed right off the very weak internal evidence arguments he made, as if they were just for funsies.
00:01:33.599 --> 00:01:41.599
And again, I did say in that video on the Gospel of Matthew, the internal evidence isn't enough to establish traditional authorship.
00:01:41.920 --> 00:01:44.799
You need it's meant to support the external evidence.
00:01:45.040 --> 00:01:45.840
I totally agree.
00:02:03.280 --> 00:02:12.400
If that's the important part and the rest is just frosting, you should have made a whole six hour video about this external evidence, since it's doing all the heavy lifting.
00:02:12.560 --> 00:02:18.719
To which Dave Pallman of Faith Because of Reason said, Okay, Paul, you asked for it.
00:02:18.960 --> 00:02:19.759
And here we are.
00:02:19.840 --> 00:02:22.319
And the first thing to note is the video length.
00:02:22.479 --> 00:02:25.759
Six hours, zero minutes, and zero seconds.
00:02:26.000 --> 00:02:28.400
Exactly six per my request.
00:02:28.560 --> 00:02:30.080
That's a baller move.
00:02:30.479 --> 00:02:32.159
Do people still say baller move?
00:02:32.400 --> 00:02:32.800
You know what?
00:02:32.960 --> 00:02:33.360
Respect.
00:02:33.439 --> 00:02:34.400
That's a baller move.
00:02:34.560 --> 00:02:37.360
Well, I suspect there was some minor padding involved throughout.
00:02:37.520 --> 00:02:38.400
I respect it.
00:02:38.560 --> 00:02:41.919
Honestly, there was much to respect in this presentation.
00:02:42.080 --> 00:02:48.479
First, it was highly structured and well organized, which is very compatible with how my brain likes things to be.
00:02:48.719 --> 00:02:50.319
The roadmap is as follows.
00:02:50.560 --> 00:02:57.120
I shall begin by exploring some variations of the anonymity hypothesis in order to have a clear target at which to aim.
00:02:57.360 --> 00:03:11.360
After this, I shall consider and critique the main arguments for the anonymity of the Gospels, based on the alleged failure of the authors of the Gospels to identify themselves, and on the silence of the early patristics who quote from them.
00:03:11.599 --> 00:03:21.439
After this, I shall consider some preliminary difficulties faced by the anonymity hypothesis, wholly apart from the Mountain of Patristic testimony standing against it.
00:03:21.759 --> 00:03:35.280
Lastly, I shall detail 17 sources from before the time of Irenaeus in AD 180 that either name one gospel author, name all four gospel authors, or attribute the gospels to the apostles.
00:03:35.599 --> 00:03:44.719
This last task will constitute the greater portion of the video and serves as the primary grounds upon which the anonymity hypothesis should be rejected.
00:03:44.960 --> 00:03:46.319
There were clear transitions.
00:03:46.560 --> 00:03:56.800
Having laid to rest the two primary arguments for the proposition that the gospels were anonymous, the path is now clear to develop my case against the anonymity of the Gospels.
00:03:57.039 --> 00:03:58.879
And periodic recaps and summaries.
00:03:59.120 --> 00:04:12.960
To summarize this section, we have considered the argument that the gospel should be regarded as anonymous because their putative authors write about themselves in the third person, and because the Gospels lack explicit internal identifications of authorship.
00:04:13.280 --> 00:04:23.040
Unlike Michael Jones, whose communication style leaves it unclear to the audience, or at least to me, which points are supposed to be primary and which points are secondary.
00:04:23.199 --> 00:04:26.959
I'm like, okay, that's not the point I was making.
00:04:27.120 --> 00:04:27.839
Just moves on.
00:04:27.920 --> 00:04:37.439
Like again, missing the main points in that video, hitting on points that are gonna be so peripheral that I'm not even gonna really fight with them on.
00:04:37.519 --> 00:04:40.399
I mean, like again, wow, biggest points I'm trying to bring up.
00:04:40.480 --> 00:04:44.240
I'm not saying he ignores every point, but he ignores some of the biggest points.
00:04:44.560 --> 00:04:47.199
Dave never left these delineations in doubt.
00:04:47.360 --> 00:04:56.079
This is not the primary ground upon which Eusebius' literary dependence upon Papius in Ecclesiastical History 324 should be accepted.
00:04:56.240 --> 00:05:03.439
I acknowledge that this point is somewhat speculative, and I think that the case against the anonymity of the Gospels is strong enough without it.
00:05:03.600 --> 00:05:13.120
I have argued that some of Norelli's more tangential criticisms of Hill may have weight, but that his criticisms become weakest when Hill's evidence is the strongest.
00:05:13.439 --> 00:05:18.240
To the extent where Dave spent the last 20 minutes giving himself a report card.
00:05:18.560 --> 00:05:23.839
Obviously, this video has put forward numerous
Load full transcript
extremely controversial claims.
00:05:24.079 --> 00:05:42.480
So now that my full case against the anonymity thesis is on the table, and the 17 examples of people who knew the names before Irenaeus have been put forward, I want to briefly review each example and grade my confidence in each one on a scale from one to ten, where ten represents maximal confidence.
00:05:42.800 --> 00:05:52.560
Structurally, I'm very grateful for this report card mechanism because it forms a framework through which I can economically traverse my responses to his six hours of argumentation.
00:05:52.800 --> 00:06:01.680
But before we get to that, we must first talk about Dave's misguided straw man thesis and why his video was doomed to fail before he began.
00:06:01.839 --> 00:06:03.920
For context, here's the important data.
00:06:04.160 --> 00:06:07.360
The Gospels were written somewhere around 70 to 100 AD.
00:06:07.439 --> 00:06:11.759
Justin Margar quotes them heavily around 150 with no names attached.
00:06:11.920 --> 00:06:16.959
The first surviving source to attach the four familiar names is Irenaeus around 180.
00:06:17.120 --> 00:06:19.839
Every time I say 180, that's the gap I mean.
00:06:20.000 --> 00:06:27.920
Now the video Dave made is expressly intended to combat the idea that Irenaeus personally invented the gospel author names.
00:06:28.160 --> 00:06:35.759
Irenaeus is often identified as the bogeyman who attached the names that we know to the Gospels around AD 180.
00:06:35.920 --> 00:06:42.399
Irenaeus himself is personally responsible for affixing the names that we know to the Gospels.
00:06:42.639 --> 00:06:51.040
That simply does not wash with the idea that Irenaeus attached the names of recognized authorities to the Gospels that he liked.
00:06:51.199 --> 00:06:57.759
Irenaeus did not invent the names on the Gospels, as many popular critics of Christianity would have us believe.
00:06:58.000 --> 00:07:01.920
But it's clearly expressed in my video, that is not my position.
00:07:02.160 --> 00:07:08.399
I have never proposed that some single mastermind impose the titles on the entire church.
00:07:08.560 --> 00:07:14.720
Nor do critical scholars think the names of the gospels were handed down by a single ruling body like a church council.
00:07:14.879 --> 00:07:21.920
No institution or person in the early to mid-second century had the power to enforce such a decision across the Mediterranean world.
00:07:22.079 --> 00:07:24.079
And Dave knows this is not my position.
00:07:24.319 --> 00:07:34.959
Recently, the YouTube counter-apologist Paulagia has suggested that the names may have originated with an influential copy of the New Testament or the Gospels in Rome.
00:07:35.120 --> 00:07:52.079
As for the theory he actually puts forward regarding how the names may have become attached to the Gospels, it is less susceptible to easy refutation than certain versions of the anonymity hypothesis, showcased in the earlier quotations that try to blame the names on Irenaeus.
00:07:52.319 --> 00:08:04.399
And yet, Dave opened his video with my face and is framing this video for his audience as a response to me, but is arguing against a view that he himself admits is a view that I do not hold.
00:08:04.639 --> 00:08:06.079
That's a straw man argument.
00:08:06.399 --> 00:08:17.519
It is not until after the three-hour mark that he makes this clarification about me, and many of his viewers will have been long gone by then, leaving the video thinking that I have been refuted.
00:08:17.680 --> 00:08:26.000
Indeed, some of his deluded and deceived viewers are the ones who alerted me to the existence of this video in the first place, reveling in my alleged defeat.
00:08:26.240 --> 00:08:35.600
Paul is free to reject this model himself, but he is gaslighting apologists when he claims that no skeptic or critical scholar makes this claim.
00:08:35.840 --> 00:08:37.120
I made no such statement.
00:08:37.360 --> 00:08:38.720
Please stop gaslighting me.
00:08:38.799 --> 00:08:40.000
I'm not gaslighting you.
00:08:40.240 --> 00:08:48.799
This is Dave uncharitably hearing me make a broad statement about modern critical scholarship and giving me a hashtag not all scholars in response.
00:08:49.039 --> 00:08:52.960
One can, of course, frequently find a voice for nearly any view.
00:08:53.120 --> 00:08:58.559
For example, I can confidently say critical scholarship holds that Mark was the first gospel written.
00:08:58.720 --> 00:09:01.679
But Dave just posted a video on why Mark was written last.
00:09:02.000 --> 00:09:06.879
Matthew wrote first, Luke wrote second, and Mark combined them together.
00:09:07.200 --> 00:09:11.919
So to be clear, I was not intending to make such an absolute declaration.
00:09:12.080 --> 00:09:19.759
But far more important than clarifying my personal view, Dave knows the careful Steelman version of gospel anonymity arguments exists.
00:09:19.919 --> 00:09:23.600
He describes it himself and then aims at a different target.
00:09:23.919 --> 00:09:32.320
Though more careful proponents of the anonymity thesis will say that the names developed and caught on between AD 160 and 180.
00:09:32.480 --> 00:09:40.159
Some versions vaguely assert only that the names on the Gospels stuck to them somewhere between the time of Justin Martyr around A.D.
00:09:40.320 --> 00:09:43.919
160 and the time of Irenaeus around A.D.
00:09:44.080 --> 00:09:44.559
180.
00:09:44.799 --> 00:09:47.679
And makes proclamations compatible with the stronger version.
00:09:47.919 --> 00:09:56.879
If these names were attached to the Gospels sometime much later than their original composition, it must have happened sometime in the decades before A.D.
00:09:57.039 --> 00:09:57.679
180.
00:09:57.840 --> 00:10:03.919
The evidence is clear that Irenaeus inherited the names that had been on the Gospels for decades.
00:10:04.159 --> 00:10:17.840
And so when we do our report card on FBR, we'll score it against the position I actually
hold, that the four names become attached to the four gospels during the middle of the second century and had won broad agreement by the 180s.
00:10:18.000 --> 00:10:23.679
Justin Murder, writing around 150 to 160, still describes the Gospels as memoirs of the Apostles.
00:10:23.840 --> 00:10:27.600
Irenaeus, writing around 180, treats the names as settled.
00:10:27.759 --> 00:10:30.480
In between these points, we can watch the tradition spread.
00:10:30.720 --> 00:10:32.639
Irenaeus did not invent it.
00:10:32.799 --> 00:10:40.320
The open question is whether any independent source before about 150 ties these four names to these four texts.
00:10:40.559 --> 00:10:47.519
Before we get to the main course, for the sake of completeness and clarity, let's do some quick housekeeping to address the first hour of Dave's video.
00:10:47.759 --> 00:11:01.679
To summarize this section, we have considered the argument that the gospel should be regarded as anonymous because their putative authors write about themselves in the third person, and because the gospels lack explicit internal identifications of authorship.
00:11:01.919 --> 00:11:04.559
If people are making that argument, it's not a great one.
00:11:04.720 --> 00:11:20.639
But the reason this does have to come up is that many Christians are unaware that the Gospels are internally anonymous, that this is near universally agreed by scholars, and that this is a necessary precondition to even have a discussion about whether the Gospels are anonymous.
00:11:20.960 --> 00:11:33.279
If third person or lack of explicit internal identification are not strong evidence of the anonymity of these other ancient works, neither should it be taken to be strong evidence of the anonymity of the Gospels.
00:11:33.600 --> 00:11:34.000
Correct.
00:11:34.080 --> 00:11:36.159
It's a necessary precondition only.
00:11:36.399 --> 00:11:47.039
We have seen that the most pressing argument in favor of the anonymity hypothesis comes from quotations of the Gospels by earlier church fathers who do not name the Gospels when quoting them.
00:11:47.360 --> 00:11:47.759
Correct.
00:11:47.919 --> 00:11:53.519
Church fathers who quote the Gospels without attribution is consistent with anonymity hypothesis.
00:11:53.679 --> 00:11:55.360
It's an argument from silence, of course.
00:11:55.519 --> 00:12:03.600
Whether it is a good argument from silence or a bad argument from silence depends on your opinion about whether we should expect them to cite a name.
00:12:03.759 --> 00:12:17.440
A step further, church fathers who quote the gospels using an attribution other than the traditional names is not only consistent with the anonymity hypothesis, it bolsters it, because they went out of their way to make a non-author attribution.
00:12:17.679 --> 00:12:25.759
For example, the Didic refers to Matthew as the Lord's Gospel, and Justin refers to the Gospels as the memoirs of the Apostles.
00:12:26.000 --> 00:12:30.480
This is at least somewhat unexpected if we are to believe the Church Father knew the name.
00:12:30.639 --> 00:12:33.279
It's not definitive, but it favors anonymity.
00:12:33.519 --> 00:12:47.440
Third, I have compared these unnamed quotations of the Gospels in earlier church fathers with quotations of the Gospels in later church fathers, and we have seen that even the later church fathers only rarely name the Gospels when quoting them.
00:12:47.679 --> 00:12:52.240
There's a cavernous difference between rarely name them and never name them.
00:12:52.480 --> 00:13:04.000
Fourth, I have pointed out that these same church fathers likewise cite the Old Testament and the Epistles of Paul without naming the authors, even though these works are obviously not anonymous.
00:13:04.320 --> 00:13:06.799
You'll be making the opposite point about Paul later.
00:13:07.039 --> 00:13:15.600
Therefore, this cannot be used to argue that earlier writers who quoted the Gospels without naming the authors thought that the Gospels were anonymous.
00:13:15.840 --> 00:13:16.720
Of course we can.
00:13:16.879 --> 00:13:24.320
You can come up with reasons, maybe even good reasons in your opinion, why writers who knew the gospel authors didn't mention them.
00:13:24.480 --> 00:13:31.039
But it will always remain on the table that a candidate reason is that they didn't know the authors.
00:13:31.200 --> 00:13:36.639
Without a mind-reading time machine, that's not only a possibility, it's the default likelihood.
00:13:36.879 --> 00:13:45.200
Once the Gospels were collected together, and this seems to have happened pretty early, there would be a practical need to distinguish between them in some way.
00:13:45.519 --> 00:14:00.720
Skeptics agree, at least in principle, probably not on how early this happened, but the need for labels tells us nothing about how many labels were used, what labels were used, by whom, when, and to what degree such labels were connected to actual truth.
00:14:00.960 --> 00:14:07.600
Compare the virtually unanimous acceptance of the names on the Gospels to the genuinely anonymous book of Hebrews.
00:14:07.840 --> 00:14:12.879
Hebrews provides an interesting test case because it is uncontroversially anonymous.
00:14:13.120 --> 00:14:18.879
As such, it can tell us what we should expect our evidence to look like when dealing with an anonymous book.
00:14:19.120 --> 00:14:22.639
Dave may not agree with me, but I mentioned Hebrews in the original video.
00:14:22.879 --> 00:14:24.799
Using Hebrews here actually backfires.
00:14:24.960 --> 00:14:30.080
Origen commended people for attributing it to Paul, even though he didn't personally believe it.
00:14:30.240 --> 00:14:43.840
Despite significant doubts among leadership, questionable apostolic authorship may have been attributed to a cherished writing that was considered useful in segments of the Christian community in order to justify its continued use in the churches.
00:14:44.000 --> 00:14:48.559
Who knows what gospel debates
ended the same way, but were not recorded for posterity.
00:14:48.879 --> 00:14:58.399
It's simply a case of there being too many manuscripts with these names too quickly, if we suppose that the names originated with Irenaeus in AD 180.
00:14:58.799 --> 00:15:03.120
Too many too quickly is obviously a qualitative opinion, not a fact.
00:15:03.279 --> 00:15:06.000
There's no field-wide metric to establish such a thing.
00:15:06.240 --> 00:15:21.600
Consequently, it remains significant that there are virtually no anonymous manuscripts for any of the Gospels, despite the fact that our earliest full manuscripts of the Gospels date to later than the anonymity hypothesis claims that the four names would have been adopted.
00:15:21.840 --> 00:15:32.559
The only gospel fragment that exists that might possibly date to Irenaeus is P52, and that's a credit card-sized piece of the 18th chapter of the fourth gospel with no title at all.
00:15:32.720 --> 00:15:39.039
The next earliest fragments, P104, P90, P64, and P67, all have no title.
00:15:39.200 --> 00:15:44.559
Now, because these are all portions of the middle of the text, we are not surprised about a lack of title, to be sure.
00:15:44.720 --> 00:15:49.519
These manuscripts weigh into neither side of the debate, but are all technically anonymous.
00:15:49.840 --> 00:16:05.519
Of course, critics will be swift to point out that the earliest full manuscripts of the Gospels date to between the late 2nd and early 4th century, putting them later than the anonymity hypothesis claims that the names associated with the Gospels had stuck.
00:16:05.759 --> 00:16:13.200
Indeed, our earliest substantially complete gospel manuscripts post-date the period when traditional names are hypothesized to have become established.
00:16:13.440 --> 00:16:23.360
P66 and P75 are commonly dated to the late 2nd through 3rd centuries, while Codex Vicanus and Codex Sinaticus date to the 4th century.
00:16:23.519 --> 00:16:31.759
So the appearance of traditional author attributions in these manuscripts is entirely compatible with their having become established during the 2nd century.
00:16:31.919 --> 00:16:37.440
Simply declaring that there are too many manuscripts too quickly doesn't demonstrate otherwise.
00:16:37.679 --> 00:16:42.879
The bottom line is that the anonymous manuscripts did not simply vanish overnight.
00:16:43.039 --> 00:16:48.559
They would have survived and continued to exert influence over copyists for centuries to come.
00:16:48.720 --> 00:16:51.519
We might refer to this as scribal inertia.
00:16:51.759 --> 00:16:57.120
Scribal inertia assumes copyists passively reproduced manuscripts exactly as they found.
00:16:57.200 --> 00:17:00.879
However, early Christian scribal habits were dynamic and revising.
00:17:00.960 --> 00:17:07.279
Ancient critics like Celsus noted that Christians frequently revised, reordered, and remodeled gospel texts.
00:17:07.440 --> 00:17:12.400
Scribes routinely added reader aids, section headings, and paratextual updates.
00:17:12.559 --> 00:17:18.480
The assumption that anonymous manuscripts would have survived for centuries overlooks the physical realities of manuscript preservation.
00:17:18.640 --> 00:17:27.759
In papyrus codices, the opening and closing leaves, precisely where titles were commonly placed, were especially vulnerable to damage and loss, so were the most replaced.
00:17:27.920 --> 00:17:36.480
Once a standardized title collection was established by key Christian centers, subsequent copyists would naturally use these titles, even on existing manuscripts.
00:17:36.640 --> 00:17:43.200
While controversial and non-definitive, I like to point to P1, which is the first to preserve the beginning of the first gospel.
00:17:43.279 --> 00:17:45.359
And the header contains no title.
00:17:45.519 --> 00:17:48.400
The first manuscript where a title could be, and it's blank.
00:17:48.640 --> 00:17:54.960
This exception is P1, which is our earliest manuscript of the first chapter of Matthew's Gospel.
00:17:55.119 --> 00:18:01.039
Unlike all other manuscripts, it does lack the title, according to Matthew, at the top of the page.
00:18:01.200 --> 00:18:09.119
Now, because the manuscript is incomplete, we cannot say for sure that the title wasn't originally present as a cover page or a tag.
00:18:09.359 --> 00:18:15.039
Nevertheless, on its face, this does appear to be the one clear counterexample to my claim.
00:18:15.279 --> 00:18:22.880
In the end, I don't find the manuscript evidence too strongly support nor strongly negate either side of the anonymity hypothesis debate.
00:18:22.960 --> 00:18:26.240
It's compatible with either, in part because it is so sparse.
00:18:26.480 --> 00:18:29.039
With that down, let's get to Dave's witnesses.
00:18:29.279 --> 00:18:35.680
The primary exhibit will be a list of several people earlier than Irenaeus who knew the names on the Gospels.
00:18:35.920 --> 00:18:42.400
Indeed, it was a significant portion of the video, which we will now view through the lens of Dave's own report card rubric.
00:18:42.720 --> 00:18:48.079
Obviously, this video has put forward numerous extremely controversial claims.
00:18:48.319 --> 00:19:06.880
So now that my full case against the anonymity thesis is on the table, and the 17 examples of people who knew the names before Irenaeus have been put forward, I want to briefly review each example and grade my confidence in each one on a scale from 1 to 10, where 10 represents maximal confidence.
00:19:07.119 --> 00:19:14.640
To be clear, these numbers are a scale of my confidence relative to the evidence, not a percentage of probability.
00:19:14.880 --> 00:19:21.759
Broadly, the rubric will be that an explicit mention of a name is required to score a 10 out of 10.
00:19:21.920 --> 00:19:32.640
If the name is explicit, but one or two inferences are required to get there, a score of 7 to 9 out of 10 will be allotted based on how plausible the inferences are.
00:19:32.880 --> 00:19:46.160
Examples that are not explicit and require a few layers of inference to arrive at a name will be allotted a score of four to six out of ten, depending on how many inferences are involved and how plausible they are.
00:19:46.400 --> 00:19:56.640
A score of one to three out of ten will be reserved for sources that lack the names in any way and merely give us vague hints as to who wrote the Gospels.
00:19:57.039 --> 00:20:00.799
The first example we considered was Clement of Alexandria.
00:20:01.119 --> 00:20:04.640
He uncontroversially bears witness to all four names.
00:20:04.880 --> 00:20:07.599
So for that reason, he gets a 10 out of 10.
00:20:07.759 --> 00:20:13.279
The bigger concerns about Clement will regard whether or not he is independent of Irenaeus.
00:20:13.440 --> 00:20:16.640
Obviously, that could impact the significance of his witness.
00:20:16.799 --> 00:20:23.359
But our rating in this section is concerned with how confident we can be that each example names our Gospels.
00:20:23.599 --> 00:20:27.200
That is why Clement receives a rating of maximal confidence.
00:20:27.440 --> 00:20:31.359
Well, that scoring system isn't going to help defeat the anonymity hypothesis.
00:20:31.440 --> 00:20:41.519
We're looking for sources that clearly quote one or more of the canonical gospels, clearly attribute them to the traditional authors, and are writing before Justin Martyr.
00:20:41.759 --> 00:20:47.200
Writing at the same time or later than Irenaeus in 180 AD is irrelevant to the discussion.
00:20:47.359 --> 00:20:52.880
Scholarship places Clement's Demata at least a decade later, in the 190s and early 200 CE.
00:20:53.039 --> 00:21:00.640
In it, he mentions the death of Emperor Commodus on the 31st of December, 192 CE, which is a good enough anchor point for our purposes.
00:21:00.799 --> 00:21:06.799
And the last hypotypesis, where Clement's gospel order tradition comes from, is usually placed later still.
00:21:06.960 --> 00:21:10.880
Of course, Dave is aware of this, so he is attempting a different point.
00:21:11.119 --> 00:21:21.519
The far more important point that I will make is that Clement's account, regardless of when it was written, comes from sources that are earlier than and independent of Irenaeus.
00:21:21.759 --> 00:21:29.839
Eusebius reports that Clement of Alexandria explicitly cited Irenaeus by name among the earlier Christian writers whose works he drew upon.
00:21:29.920 --> 00:21:31.680
So they have some level of dependence.
00:21:31.920 --> 00:21:43.359
Dave spends time trying to nuance this dependence, which is very important for defeating the weaker Irenaeus name the Gospels hypothesis, but not particularly important for the stronger anonymity hypothesis.
00:21:43.440 --> 00:21:46.240
So I leave that as an exercise for the viewer if they wish.
00:21:46.480 --> 00:21:59.839
The fact that he doesn't attribute his tradition concerning the origins of the Gospels to Irenaeus, and instead attributes it to primitive elders, provides yet another reason to think that Clement's tradition is independent of Irenaeus's tradition.
00:22:00.160 --> 00:22:03.119
Tradition, and is earlier than the writings of Irenaeus.
00:22:03.440 --> 00:22:14.640
Again, I don't think that Irenaeus invented the tradition, and I also don't see how Clement, writing close to the third century, has anything other than tradition to even tell us where he got his traditions.
00:22:14.960 --> 00:22:18.720
The second example we considered was Theophilus of Antioch.
00:22:18.880 --> 00:22:28.160
I don't think it can be reasonably doubted that he names John as the author of the fourth gospel, for he both quotes from this gospel and attributes it to John by name.
00:22:28.400 --> 00:22:36.319
He certainly attributes in the beginning was the word to someone named John, but notice that he falls short of calling this John's son of Zebedee the disciple.
00:22:36.480 --> 00:22:41.279
If we're precise, Theophilus is referring merely to someone spirit-filled named John.
00:22:41.440 --> 00:22:43.839
I'm not going to quibble on this, but it could be quibbled.
00:22:44.079 --> 00:22:47.519
Theophilus of Antioch receives a score of 10 out of 10.
00:22:47.839 --> 00:22:48.240
Interesting.
00:22:48.400 --> 00:22:50.799
And when was Theophilus of Antioch writing this?
00:22:51.039 --> 00:22:56.079
Theophilus' apology to Autolychus is commonly dated to around A.D.
00:22:56.240 --> 00:22:59.759
180, making him a further contemporary of Irenaeus.
00:23:00.079 --> 00:23:01.839
That is what scholars generally say.
00:23:02.079 --> 00:23:10.559
If Theophilus is here, simply saying that Marcus Aurelius is the reigning emperor at the time of his writing, a date as early as A.D.
00:23:10.720 --> 00:23:12.720
161 becomes possible.
00:23:12.960 --> 00:23:23.039
I don't wish to hang any part of my argument on this possibility, but it should be noted because, if correct, then Theophilus was writing considerably earlier than Irenaeus.
00:23:23.279 --> 00:23:23.759
Gotcha.
00:23:23.920 --> 00:23:28.480
So either way, Theophilus of Antioch is not earlier than 150 CE.
00:23:28.559 --> 00:23:32.000
He lands right in the window where I say the names were catching on.
00:23:32.160 --> 00:23:36.720
And that's exactly what a tradition spreading between 150 and 180 would look like.
00:23:36.960 --> 00:23:45.920
The upshot here is that even if Theophilus is not, strictly speaking, earlier than Irenaeus, he is almost certainly independent of Irenaeus.
00:23:46.160 --> 00:23:50.160
Again, this is important for the Irenaeus version of the hypothesis, not mine.
00:23:50.400 --> 00:23:53.200
It does include the most interesting tidbit about this source.
00:23:53.440 --> 00:23:59.680
Theophilus once quotes Saint John by name, but he does not mention the name of any other evangelist.
00:23:59.920 --> 00:24:04.319
He has three quotations from Saint Matthew, and perhaps one from Saint Luke.
00:24:04.640 -->
00:24:11.759
To quote John by name in this period, but not Matthew and Luke by name fits remarkably well with the anonymity hypothesis.
00:24:12.000 --> 00:24:15.920
Our third example was the anti-Marcionite prologue to Luke.
00:24:16.079 --> 00:24:21.440
Again, it receives a score of 10 out of 10, since it certainly names all four Gospel authors.
00:24:21.599 --> 00:24:24.480
The controversy here regards the dating of this text.
00:24:24.880 --> 00:24:31.920
Controversy is putting it mildly, since scholarship is talking fourth century, not early second as we're looking for.
00:24:32.160 --> 00:24:43.680
While a date in the second half of the fourth century is likely for the prologues for Mark and John, and the second part of the prologue for Luke, the first part of the latter may have been written much earlier.
00:24:43.920 --> 00:24:51.519
Now, even if we grant that only the beginning of the prologue is original, we still get the name of Luke associated with the third gospel.
00:24:51.759 --> 00:24:56.799
That is enough to challenge the idea that the Gospels were anonymous prior to Irenaeus.
00:24:57.039 --> 00:25:06.400
FBR wants to push the date back due to some Greek composition, but his review doesn't mention that this Luke introduction he wants to date earlier closely parallels Irenaeus.
00:25:06.640 --> 00:25:14.319
In conclusion, we have seen that the anti-Marcionite prologue to Luke is earlier than the corresponding prologues for Mark and John.
00:25:14.640 --> 00:25:19.200
It is at least contemporary with Irenaeus, and plausibly a decade or two earlier.
00:25:19.599 --> 00:25:28.000
Plausible becomes implausible if the prologue quotes Irenaeus, but even granting this extreme, the work doesn't in fact the strong anonymity case.
00:25:28.319 --> 00:25:31.119
The fourth example was Melito of Sardis.
00:25:31.279 --> 00:25:40.000
Melito is one of the more controversial examples on this list, since concluding that he named the four gospels depends on the success of two projects.
00:25:40.240 --> 00:25:53.039
First, it requires an intertextual analysis of several church fathers who know the tradition about the four living creatures, and the conclusion that Irenaeus is modifying and repurposing an earlier source.
00:25:53.279 --> 00:25:57.920
Second, it requires identifying that source as Melito of Sardis.
00:25:58.079 --> 00:26:02.480
I think both steps are defensible, but the second is shakier than the first.
00:26:02.640 --> 00:26:04.880
We will give Melito a four out of ten.
00:26:05.279 --> 00:26:11.200
In his writing, Irenaeus matched the four named Gospels to the four creatures, following the order in Revelation.
00:26:11.359 --> 00:26:23.599
But Scholar Luke Stephen thinks some Ezekiel-based leftovers show that Irenaeus was reworking an older source, since putting the Gospels in Ezekiel's order yields the Western order of Matthew, John, Luke, and Mark.
00:26:23.759 --> 00:26:25.279
But from whom did he borrow this?
00:26:25.440 --> 00:26:32.640
Stephen suggests maybe Melito of Sardis' last extracts, a work no one has ever seen, is making this connection.
00:26:33.039 --> 00:26:34.480
How convenient.
00:26:37.759 --> 00:26:42.880
To be clear, no surviving fragment of Melito actually contains the Gospel Creature pairing.
00:26:42.960 --> 00:26:46.240
These are layers of speculation built atop layers of speculation.
00:26:46.400 --> 00:26:50.799
And as such, I find even a score of four of ten to be overly generous.
00:26:51.119 --> 00:27:03.200
I am aware that this section must have seemed to many viewers like building a house of cards, since there are numerous points at which Stephen's case for Melito of Sardis, being Irenaeus' source, might fail.
00:27:03.599 --> 00:27:05.920
Out of curiosity, when was this written?
00:27:06.160 --> 00:27:12.160
Hall dates Melito's apology fairly precisely between 169 and 177.
00:27:12.400 --> 00:27:17.119
But Dave speculates that the non-surviving passage could be from an earlier book.
00:27:17.440 --> 00:27:28.000
But the most likely source that Irenaeus would be drawing from, based on Stevens' analysis, is Melito's extracts, which may well have been written as early as AD 150.
00:27:28.240 --> 00:27:31.680
For FBR, there is no end to optimistic interpretation.
00:27:31.759 --> 00:27:33.519
But at least he acknowledges it as such.
00:27:33.839 --> 00:27:48.400
Even if Stevens has incorrectly identified Melito as Irenaeus' source, I think his case is quite compelling that Irenaeus was modifying an earlier source, and that this source knew the names Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John.
00:27:48.559 --> 00:27:56.079
And that alone is sufficient to undermine the idea that Irenaeus is the first person to name all four Gospels.
00:27:56.400 --> 00:27:57.839
Again, not my hypothesis.
00:27:58.000 --> 00:28:01.200
On the stronger version, this passage fails on both fronts.
00:28:01.440 --> 00:28:05.200
Our fifth example was Apollinaris of Heropolis.
00:28:05.359 --> 00:28:11.599
He definitely names Matthew as having written something, and we know that he is familiar with the Gospel of Matthew.
00:28:11.759 --> 00:28:19.519
But because he doesn't actually quote the Gospel in connection with what Matthew wrote, there is a small gap where doubt may still reside.
00:28:19.759 --> 00:28:23.279
In light of this, we will give Apollinaris a nine out of ten.
00:28:23.680 --> 00:28:34.559
For the criteria of quoting a passage and attributing it to one of the authors, this is a real gap, though not a defeater, since the fragment says the other side cites Matthew in support of its Passover dating.
00:28:34.640 --> 00:28:38.400
But before we quibble, let's make sure its place on the timeline makes it relevant.
00:28:38.640 --> 00:28:45.759
Ezra Abbott and Martin Hengel are examples of scholars who support this date, placing Apollinaris in 166.
00:28:46.160 --> 00:28:50.400
This places him between 10 and 20 years before Irenaeus.
00:28:50.559 --> 00:28:58.960
A few
scholars ate him as late as AD 175, although this is typically just asserted without any explanation of the reasoning.
00:28:59.279 --> 00:28:59.759
I see.
00:28:59.920 --> 00:29:10.640
So virtually at the same time as Irenaeus, and well within the predictions of the strong anonymity model, particularly when we're talking about just one of the four gospels and not even a firm connection.
00:29:10.880 --> 00:29:16.799
I just thought it worth noting that Apollinaris might easily be 30 years before Irenaeus.
00:29:17.039 --> 00:29:20.400
My hypothesis can live comfortably with that possibility.
00:29:20.559 --> 00:29:22.720
The anonymity hypothesis cannot.
00:29:23.039 --> 00:29:23.680
Sure it can.
00:29:23.839 --> 00:29:29.839
A name for one gospel in the 60s or 70s is just what a spreading tradition should produce.
00:29:30.160 --> 00:29:39.200
The Muratorian fragment, our sixth example, uncontroversially named Luke and John, so it receives a 10 out of 10 for those names.
00:29:39.440 --> 00:29:44.880
While the earlier segment is missing, it very likely also named Matthew and Mark.
00:29:45.039 --> 00:29:50.400
But because the names are not present, we will give it an 8 out of 10 for the names Matthew and Mark.
00:29:50.640 --> 00:29:54.559
Dave lives in a world where missing names counts as good evidence.
00:29:54.720 --> 00:29:58.480
But again, before I quibble, let's check the dating to see if it matters.
00:29:58.799 --> 00:30:03.359
Probably a date between AD 155 and 160 is reasonable.
00:30:03.759 --> 00:30:06.799
Reasonable is not the same as widely accepted.
00:30:06.960 --> 00:30:16.319
Most scholars date the fragment to late 2nd century, around 180 to 200 CE, while at the same time a significant minority actually puts it in the 4th century.
00:30:16.559 --> 00:30:18.880
FBR's view here is a distant third.
00:30:19.039 --> 00:30:20.160
Overly optimistic.
00:30:20.480 --> 00:30:23.119
Optimism doesn't alter the laws of physics.
00:30:23.440 --> 00:30:26.480
Let's say that I've dated the Muratorian fragment too early.
00:30:26.720 --> 00:30:27.200
You have.
00:30:27.440 --> 00:30:45.599
The fragment gives us a fairly direct timestamp as to when it was written, toward the end, saying, But Hermes wrote the shepherd very recently in our times in the city of Rome, while Bishop Pius, his brother, was occupying the episcopal chair of the church of the city of Rome.
00:30:45.839 --> 00:30:49.680
We thus have two time markers provided by the fragment itself.
00:30:49.839 --> 00:30:52.160
The early date depends on three Latin words.
00:30:52.319 --> 00:31:01.519
The fragment says Hermes wrote the shepherd nuperim temporis natrus, which I'm sure I've pronounced incorrectly, which is usually translated very recently in our own times.
00:31:01.759 --> 00:31:05.440
The Latin phrase doesn't have to describe the author's own lifetime.
00:31:05.599 --> 00:31:11.200
The early Christians routinely divided history into the age of the apostles and everything that came after it.
00:31:11.359 --> 00:31:17.599
Hirenaeus said Revelation appeared almost in our own generation, even though it came out almost a century earlier.
00:31:17.759 --> 00:31:25.039
In fact, the fragment itself keeps the shepherd out of the church reading because it came after their time, meaning after the apostles.
00:31:25.279 --> 00:31:32.880
So our times most likely means the post-apostolic age, and that says nothing about when the fragment itself was written.
00:31:33.119 --> 00:31:37.920
Also, these three words survive only in the Latin translation, copied by a scribe B.
00:31:38.079 --> 00:31:38.160
F.
00:31:38.240 --> 00:31:43.599
Westcott, described as either unable or unwilling to understand the work he was copying.
00:31:43.759 --> 00:31:46.799
That can't carry the weight of the whole early date.
00:31:46.960 --> 00:31:54.240
The fragment does say that Hermes was the brother of Bishop Pius and wrote while Pius held office, which is around 140 to 154.
00:31:54.400 --> 00:31:57.359
Now the shepherd himself points to around the year 100.
00:31:57.440 --> 00:32:01.200
It mentions Clement of Rome, it knows of no single ruling bishop.
00:32:01.359 --> 00:32:03.839
It hints that some of the first generation were still alive.
00:32:04.079 --> 00:32:08.160
Hermas says he was raised and sold as a slave, and never mentions a brother.
00:32:08.319 --> 00:32:13.039
Outside the fragment, the brother's story first shows up in a 4th century source.
00:32:13.279 --> 00:32:21.680
If the author lived in Pius's day, he got wrong the very fact his argument depends on, which is far easier to imagine from a writer centuries later.
00:32:21.839 --> 00:32:28.799
As Jeffrey Mark Hanneman argues, the more reasonable conclusion is that the fragment's whole statement is in error.
00:32:28.960 --> 00:32:35.119
That said, even Dave's maximally credulous dating is fine for the strong anonymity case.
00:32:35.279 --> 00:32:42.400
But if you care to dig in, I think you'll find the fourth century dating to be better supported if one must stray from consensus.
00:32:42.640 --> 00:32:47.440
Justin Martyr, our seventh example, does not name any of the Gospels.
00:32:47.599 --> 00:32:59.039
He does associate Mark with Peter, and his reference to the Gospels as having been written by apostles and their followers fits a little too conveniently with the four familiar names to be a coincidence.
00:32:59.279 --> 00:33:02.640
Because of this, I will grade Justin a three out of ten.
00:33:02.960 --> 00:33:09.119
In the video Dave is responding to, I spoke about Justin Murder as the key witness on my side of the argument.
00:33:09.279 --> 00:33:11.599
But the silence by itself is not my argument.
00:33:11.839 --> 00:33:22.960
The times during that period when church fathers like Justin Martyr quoted the canonical gospels, but generically call them memoirs of the apostles, is more something that I consider to be evidence against traditional knowledge.
00:33:23.200 -->
00:33:27.200
So I was kind of surprised to see him here, even if a three out of ten.
00:33:27.599 --> 00:33:34.640
So I will just briefly recap that he refers to the Gospels as the memoirs of the apostles and their followers.
00:33:34.880 --> 00:33:46.559
We saw that this was suggestive, inasmuch as the plurals require a minimum of four Gospels, two written by apostles and two written by their followers, as Martin Hengel surmises.
00:33:46.960 --> 00:33:57.440
In other words, Justin knows that some of the Gospels are attributed to apostles, Matthew and John, and others to the disciples of apostles, Mark and Luke.
00:33:57.680 --> 00:34:07.920
Scholars like Helmut Coaster and Arthur Bellanzoni argue that Justin's sayings of Jesus come from harmonies blending Matthew and Luke rather than from four distinct canonical books.
00:34:08.079 --> 00:34:19.920
As Watson and Michael Coke note regarding dialogue with Trifola 3, 8, the conjunction chi and does not neatly divide the Gospels into two distinct pairs, two apostles and two followers.
00:34:20.079 --> 00:34:28.079
Instead, it indicates that the general corpus as a whole was viewed as a joint production of the Gospels working alongside scribes or followers.
00:34:28.239 --> 00:34:42.000
Furthermore, Justin frequently incorporates extra canonical details, like Jesus born in a cave, fire on the Jordan at his baptism, and ploughs made in Joseph's shop, showing that his source materials were broader than just the four canonical gospels.
00:34:42.239 --> 00:34:47.199
Justin also quotes from the Gospel of Mark and calls it the memoirs of Peter.
00:34:47.440 --> 00:34:58.079
The phrase in dialogue with Trifo 1063, that is often translated as Peter's memoirs or his memoirs, uses the Greek pronoun Ao2, which literally translates to his or of him.
00:34:58.320 --> 00:35:05.199
Because Au2 is simply a pronoun, its antecedent is grammatically ambiguous and open to two distinct interpretations.
00:35:05.360 --> 00:35:11.440
If the pronoun refers back to Jesus, the main subject of the overall passage, the phrase translates to memoirs about him.
00:35:11.679 --> 00:35:14.880
In this reading, Justin is not naming Peter as the author at all.
00:35:15.039 --> 00:35:20.159
He's using O2 as an objective genitive, referring to the memoirs concerning Jesus' life.
00:35:20.239 --> 00:35:28.079
If the pronoun refers to Peter, who is mentioned in the immediate clause describing his name change, the phrase translates to his memoirs, Peter's memoirs.
00:35:28.239 --> 00:35:31.280
Dave's strongest point here is about what the passage says.
00:35:31.599 --> 00:35:34.480
Justin does name the source of one of the memoirs.
00:35:34.719 --> 00:35:44.559
He refers to the memoirs of Peter and says that it records Jesus changing the names of the Sons of Zebedee to Baenergies, or Sons of Thunder.
00:35:44.800 --> 00:35:46.800
That's what I'm going to call you from Alan.
00:35:47.679 --> 00:35:51.280
James and John, the sons of thunder.
00:35:51.840 --> 00:35:57.119
So the source of at least one of these memoirs was indeed associated with the name Peter.
00:35:57.280 --> 00:36:04.239
Across his extensive surviving works, Justin never once mentions the name Mark, nor does he mention Papias of Heropolis.
00:36:04.400 --> 00:36:08.239
Consequently, we have no explicit evidence that Justin knew this tradition.
00:36:08.400 --> 00:36:18.719
On the other hand, scholars point out that Justin drew upon harmonized gospel traditions, written collections of Jesus' sayings, and material transmitted through early Christian teaching, catechetal settings.
00:36:18.880 --> 00:36:25.679
Any of these could have carried the Boenergies detail to Justin without his ever consulting the standalone gospel attributed to Mark.
00:36:25.840 --> 00:36:28.800
Meanwhile, other writings circulated under Peter's name.
00:36:28.960 --> 00:36:38.400
Scholars have argued that Justin's reference could instead be to the Gospel of Peter, a text explicitly attributed to the Apostle rather than connected to him through later preserved tradition about Mark.
00:36:38.559 --> 00:36:46.320
Because the surviving portion of the Gospel of Peter contains only part of the Passion narrative, we cannot determine whether its lost sections included the Mulanergy's detail.
00:36:46.559 --> 00:36:53.280
Collectively, this material is difficult to square with the idea that Justin regarded the Gospels as anonymous.
00:36:53.519 --> 00:36:54.000
Not at all.
00:36:54.239 --> 00:36:57.760
Martyr remains prime evidence for the anonymity hypothesis.
00:36:57.920 --> 00:37:01.679
Dave also borrows an old explanation for why Justin leaves the names off.
00:37:01.840 --> 00:37:03.760
His audience just wouldn't have known them.
00:37:03.920 --> 00:37:06.159
He is throughout addressing heathens.
00:37:06.639 --> 00:37:12.480
Nor would there have been more propriety in his giving the names of the authors of the respective gospels.
00:37:12.719 --> 00:37:21.599
Of Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John, neither the emperor nor the generality of those heathens who might have read his apology had probably ever heard.
00:37:21.920 --> 00:37:25.119
Except Justin does name an apostolic author when it suits him.
00:37:25.280 --> 00:37:32.400
In Dialogue 814, he says the revelation came to a certain man with us whose name was John, one of the apostles of Christ.
00:37:32.559 --> 00:37:37.280
So Justin can name John for revelation, yet he never once names an evangelist.
00:37:37.360 --> 00:37:44.159
And Theophilus, writing to a pagan named Atolicus, names John without any worry about his audience, as Dave notes elsewhere.
00:37:44.400 --> 00:37:48.559
As we have formerly seen, Theophilus once quotes Saint John by name.
00:37:48.880 --> 00:37:50.880
Pagan readers were never the obstacle.
00:37:51.039 --> 00:37:53.519
For Justin, the names just weren't there yet.
00:37:53.760 --> 00:37:57.920
Our eighth example, and our first heretical example, is Marcion.
00:37:58.400 --> 00:38:08.559
We have no quotation from Marcion giving the names, but Tertullian's presentation of his argument appears to require the traditional authorship of Matthew, Mark, and John.
00:38:08.880 --> 00:38:13.599
The argument, as Tertullian presents it, makes no sense without that assumption.
00:38:13.840 --> 00:38:20.480
However, we are dependent for this information on Tertullian, who may not be representing Marcion accurately.
00:38:20.719 --> 00:38:24.320
Thus, we grade Marcion accordingly at 4 out of 10.
00:38:24.559 --> 00:38:26.239
That requires a bit more explanation.
00:38:26.559 --> 00:38:34.000
In his work Against Marcion, Tullian critiques an argument that he attributes to Marcion based on Galatians.
00:38:34.159 --> 00:38:41.840
According to Tertulian, Marcion used Galatians as an argument against the Gospels that he rejected, which would be Matthew, Mark, and John.
00:38:42.079 --> 00:38:48.400
Marcion's argument requires the apostolic authorship of Matthew, Mark, and John in order to work.
00:38:48.639 --> 00:39:03.280
Marcion isn't trying to discredit these Gospels by saying that they weren't written by apostles, rather, he grants that they were written by apostles, but then tries to discredit them on the basis that the apostles perverted the teachings of Jesus.
00:39:03.519 --> 00:39:14.559
The best explanation of the fact that Marcion chose the Gospel of Luke seems to me to be that its title and tradition already attributed it to a disciple of Paul.
00:39:14.719 --> 00:39:27.679
And since Marcion's argument assumes the traditional authorship of at least Matthew, Mark, and John, he supplies evidence, indirect though it may be, that these three Gospels were not anonymous by A.D.
00:39:27.840 --> 00:39:32.000
144, nearly 40 years before Irenaeus.
00:39:32.320 --> 00:39:50.480
More directly, in a hypothesis advanced by Martin Hangel, Marcion rejected Matthew and John because they bore the names of original apostles, whom Marcion viewed as having corrupted Christ's true message, rejected Mark because of its association with Peter, and adopted Luke because its established church tradition already linked it to Paul.
00:39:50.639 --> 00:39:58.800
On Hengel's view, Marcion stripped the name Luke off the text and called it simply the Gospel to claim he is restoring Paul's original preaching.
00:39:58.960 --> 00:40:06.079
The most obvious and glaring problem is that, as Dave acknowledges, none of these traditional author names are used by Marcion.
00:40:06.320 --> 00:40:08.159
His gospel is anonymous.
00:40:08.400 --> 00:40:20.559
We come to the Gospel of Marcion, which he presented about AD 144, which, as Tertullian critically pointed out, he designated the gospel, leaving out the author's name.
00:40:20.880 --> 00:40:29.519
There is no actual evidence in the primary sources that Marcion removed Luke's name from a manuscript title or that he defended his gospel by appealing to Lucan authorship.
00:40:29.599 -->
00:40:32.719
And this inference is far from universally accepted in scholarship.
00:40:32.880 --> 00:40:40.400
Judith Lew observes that there is nothing to suggest Marcion even knew his gospel by the name Luke, much less that he deliberately removed it.
00:40:40.559 --> 00:40:46.880
Some scholars suggest that Marcion may have only known one gospel, while others emphasize he accepted only one as authoritative.
00:40:47.039 --> 00:40:52.639
In either case, he had no practical need to affix an author's name to distinguish it from others in his collection.
00:40:52.800 --> 00:40:57.280
He called it simply the gospel, because for him, it was the only true one.
00:40:57.440 --> 00:41:07.360
Scholars like Lou argue that later Orthodox writers, including Irenaeus and Tertullian, approached Marcion's gospel through the lens of the subsequently established fourfold gospel tradition.
00:41:07.519 --> 00:41:17.119
Tertullian identified Marcion's anonymous text with Luke and treated it as a corrupted version of that gospel, even though there's no evidence that Marcion himself knew it by that name.
00:41:17.280 --> 00:41:25.599
This would not be dissimilar to a modern Disney Plus subscriber, identifying the movie where Luke Skywalker blew up the Death Star as Star Wars Episode 4 A New Hope.
00:41:25.760 --> 00:41:26.800
That's how we know it today.
00:41:26.960 --> 00:41:30.639
But when the film premiered in 1977, it was called simply Star Wars.
00:41:30.880 --> 00:41:33.519
From a little movie called The Star Wars.
00:41:33.679 --> 00:41:35.519
It's just Star Wars.
00:41:35.679 --> 00:41:42.320
The episode and subtitle were added in 1981, after the release of the first sequel, to distinguish it within the expanding series.
00:41:42.480 --> 00:42:01.440
Along with the other Gospels, Marcion also excluded Acts and the pastoral epistles from his canon, meaning that he did not accept two of the key sources later used to identify the author of our Gospel of Luke as Paul's traveling companion, the so-called we passages in Acts, and the reference to Luke as Paul's loyal companion in 2 Timothy 4.11.
00:42:01.599 --> 00:42:06.639
Accepting the traditional conclusion, while rejecting the evidence used to establish it, seems unlikely.
00:42:06.800 --> 00:42:20.400
In any case, Marcion clearly does not use the name of Luke or any Gospel name, and Dave rightly gives this one a relatively low score of confidence, as it is built on the idea that Marcion had information he deliberately withheld.
00:42:20.639 --> 00:42:37.280
Our ninth example comes to us from Heraclian, who, according to Origen, attributed one statement in the Gospel of John to the apostle rather than the Baptist, thereby implying that the name John was common to both the Baptist and the author of the Gospel.
00:42:37.519 --> 00:42:44.880
We are dependent on Origin for this material, but the context makes it highly unlikely that Origen is making it up.
00:42:45.119 --> 00:42:57.039
There is also some inference, plausible though it may be, involved in deriving the conclusion that Heraclion doesn't name the apostle as John because that name was shared with John the Baptist.
00:42:57.280 --> 00:43:01.599
Both of these factors will force us to moderate our confidence somewhat.
00:43:01.840 --> 00:43:05.360
Therefore, I will place Heraclion at 7 out of 10.
00:43:05.599 --> 00:43:15.119
When second century writers called the evangelist the disciple, or John the Disciple of the Lord, they were not automatically pointing to John the son of Zebedee, one of the twelve.
00:43:15.280 --> 00:43:19.440
Scholars like Carl Jung Bermund, Iner Thomason, and Michael Coke have shown this.
00:43:19.519 --> 00:43:27.119
In the Asian agnostic circles of that period, whose usage surfaces in both Ptolemy and Ayrenaeus, the title often belonged to someone else.
00:43:27.280 --> 00:43:32.639
It could designate a local authority in Ephesus, the beloved disciple, or the figure known as John the Elder.
00:43:32.800 --> 00:43:35.280
Nor do Heracleon's own words close the gap.
00:43:35.440 --> 00:43:40.719
Nothing in his surviving fragments mention apostolic authorship or ties to the gospel of Zibedee's son.
00:43:40.960 --> 00:43:49.039
Dave places Heracleon between 165 and 175 CE, but Alistair Logan puts his commentary on John in the late 170s or 180s.
00:43:49.199 --> 00:43:55.679
That would place it after Ptolemy, and roughly alongside or after Irenaeus's Against Heresies, around 180 CE.
00:43:55.840 --> 00:44:02.159
Irenaeus quotes Ptolemy's interpretation of the Johannean prologue, yet he shows No awareness that Heracleon ever wrote on John.
00:44:02.320 --> 00:44:09.280
Clement of Alexandria, writing in the 190s, knows how Heracleon read Luke and Matthew, but he too is silent about any treatment of John.
00:44:09.440 --> 00:44:13.360
The commentary first appears in the 230s, when Origen engages with it.
00:44:13.519 --> 00:44:23.039
And even on Dave's own date of 165 to 175, Heracleon sits inside the window, which is exactly where my model expects the names to start surfacing.
00:44:23.280 --> 00:44:36.000
The evidence is somewhat more conclusive in the case of Ptolemy the Gnostic, our tenth example, Irenaeus directly quotes Ptolemy as naming John in connection with material straight from the fourth gospel.
00:44:36.239 --> 00:44:51.920
While Irenaeus appears unlikely to be fabricating this material, because he is quoting an ideological opponent, and we cannot confirm this citation, apart from a vaguer reference in the letter to Flora, Ptolemy will drop from maximal confidence to 9 out of 10.
00:44:52.159 --> 00:44:56.320
That's a very high score for a passage we can't confidently assign to Ptolemy.
00:44:56.639 --> 00:45:06.880
The Greek text of Against Heresies 185, preserved by Epiphanius, does credit the prologue material to the John of the Disciple of the Lord, but nothing in the Greek says Ptolemy wrote it.
00:45:07.039 --> 00:45:12.639
The only line crediting
the passage to Ptolemy appears in the 4th century Latin translation of Irenaeus.
00:45:12.719 --> 00:45:17.360
And Christoph Marckes argues that line is a later gloss added by the redactor.
00:45:17.519 --> 00:45:22.000
Dave's 9 out of 10 rests entirely on this passage being Ptolemy's.
00:45:22.079 --> 00:45:26.239
Now, if we stick to what Ptolemy undeniably wrote, we're left with a letter to Flora.
00:45:26.400 --> 00:45:32.639
There he cites John 1.3, but does not attribute it to John or any name, but generically to the Apostle.
00:45:32.800 --> 00:45:34.800
The same title he gives Paul in that very letter.
00:45:34.960 --> 00:45:45.920
Ptolemy relies primarily on the Gospel of Matthew as his main authority, quoting Matthew's Jesus about eight or nine times, while citing John only once as a secondary proof text alongside Paul.
00:45:46.079 --> 00:45:50.880
This is more consistent of someone unaware of authored traditions than of someone familiar with them.
00:45:51.199 --> 00:45:58.079
Our eleventh example was Valentinus, who I surmised named John as the author of the fourth gospel.
00:45:58.320 --> 00:46:17.519
The inference here was based on the difficulty involved in explaining how three different Valentinians, Heraclian, Ptolemy, and the source behind the Excerpta Theododi, could all have managed to agree upon the Johannine authorship of the fourth gospel if this had not been taught by their founder.
00:46:17.840 --> 00:46:21.599
This is an inference, but I find it to be a very plausible one.
00:46:21.840 --> 00:46:25.440
Accordingly, we will rate Valentinus at five out of ten.
00:46:25.840 --> 00:46:28.400
That argument might not be clear from this summary.
00:46:28.639 --> 00:46:38.000
We have just concluded that two prominent Gnostics, Ptolemy and Heraclion, both associated the fourth gospel with the name of John the Apostle.
00:46:38.239 --> 00:46:40.800
We concluded no such thing, but carry on.
00:46:41.119 --> 00:46:44.159
However, these are not two random Gnostics.
00:46:44.480 --> 00:46:46.239
There is a connection between them.
00:46:46.480 --> 00:46:53.599
Both Ptolemy and Heraclian were students of Valentinus, the founder of Valentinian Gnosticism.
00:46:53.840 --> 00:47:08.800
Ordinarily, when two students of theology, who share the same teacher, converge on a specific theological belief like this, it is natural to attribute that convergence to that belief having been something taught to them by the teacher they shared.
00:47:09.039 --> 00:47:20.320
As Dale agrees, in the authentic surviving fragments of Valentinius' own writings, there are no explicit citations of the Gospel of John and no mentions of the name John as a Gospel author.
00:47:20.559 --> 00:47:23.039
I acknowledge that this point is somewhat speculative.
00:47:23.360 --> 00:47:31.760
Given that I'm unconvinced that these students are making said claims, inference about their teacher, built on top of that failed case, isn't going to move the needle.
00:47:32.000 --> 00:47:42.000
The twelfth example was the Docetist Acts of John, that the author identified John as the author of the fourth gospel is necessitated by three facts.
00:47:42.239 --> 00:47:44.800
First, he claims to be John the Apostle.
00:47:45.039 --> 00:47:48.000
Second, he claims to be the disciple that Jesus loved.
00:47:48.239 --> 00:47:54.880
And third, he had read the fourth gospel, which identifies its author as the disciple that Jesus loved.
00:47:55.119 --> 00:48:06.079
So although he doesn't come right out and say that John wrote a Gospel, we may be very confident that the author of the Acts of John believed that John the Apostle authored the fourth gospel.
00:48:06.239 --> 00:48:08.159
I will rate it at 8 out of 10.
00:48:08.320 --> 00:48:20.000
The leading critical editors of the Acts of John, Eric Janod and Jean-Daniel Castelli, date the text to be between 150 and 200 CE, making it contemporary with, or even post-dating, Irenaeus.
00:48:20.079 --> 00:48:38.639
In terms of preserving history, scholars like Martin Hengel, Richard Bacham, and Michael Coke argue that later tradition merged distinct early figures, such as John the son of Zebedee, John the Elder of Ephesus, the unnamed beloved disciple, and for some, John the Seer of Patmos, into a single legendary Ephesian John.
00:48:38.800 --> 00:48:46.719
The Acts of John reflects this secondary process of legendary harmonization, rather than an authentic, uncorrupted first century tradition.
00:48:46.880 --> 00:48:51.840
Nevertheless, this is another one that is too late to help and doesn't say what it's meant to say.
00:48:52.159 --> 00:48:55.440
Example number 13 was the Epistle of the Apostles.
00:48:55.679 --> 00:49:08.000
It opens by saying that the Apostles have written for the whole world, and in chapter 31, it pairs a quotation from John's Gospel with a statement by Jesus that his disciples had written this about him.
00:49:08.239 --> 00:49:13.519
John is also clearly the favorite apostle and the favorite gospel of the author of this work.
00:49:13.760 --> 00:49:25.199
Still, a lot of shaky inferences are required here to get to the conclusion that the author of the epistle regarded John as the author of the fourth gospel, so we will rank it at a two out of ten.
00:49:25.599 --> 00:49:28.559
No need to spend too much time piling onto a two out of ten.
00:49:28.880 --> 00:49:33.199
Sleeperhold, sleeperhold! Sleeperhold!
00:49:34.000 --> 00:49:40.159
As agreed, the epistle of the apostles never names the individual gospel titles nor individual evangelists.
00:49:40.320 --> 00:49:51.840
Attributing Jesus' deeds and words to the apostles as a collective group is similar to Justin's Memoirs of the Apostles, and is most expected in a scenario where individuals are not yet strongly associated.
00:50:17.599 --> 00:50:27.599
This example has earned its lowest ranking, as it quotes from no canonical gospels, doesn't use the word gospel to refer to any writings, and attributes no
individuals directly.
00:50:27.840 --> 00:50:45.199
That said, let me just add that though Dave prefers early dating of this to pre-just the murder times, many critical commentators date the document to the mid to late 2nd century, 150 to 200 CE, and thus is unhelpful even if it did have relevant data, which it indeed does not.
00:50:45.440 --> 00:50:48.960
We now come to my fifteenth example, the Gospel of Thomas.
00:50:49.199 --> 00:51:00.480
Jesus's rebuke of Peter's and Matthew's descriptions of himself in saying 13 seems to be best interpreted as an implied polemic against the Gospels of Mark and Matthew.
00:51:00.639 --> 00:51:03.280
This is indirect, but highly plausible.
00:51:03.440 --> 00:51:07.119
Therefore, I will rate the Gospel of Thomas as 6 out of 10.
00:51:07.360 --> 00:51:09.360
This is a creative argument, I'll give it that.
00:51:09.679 --> 00:51:14.000
This gospel is probably familiar with at least the synoptic gospels.
00:51:14.320 --> 00:51:21.519
In saying 13, there is an odd story where Jesus asks his disciples to compare him to other teachers.
00:51:22.079 --> 00:51:25.760
Peter, Matthew, and Thomas all offer their own answers.
00:51:26.159 --> 00:51:29.119
Peter compares Jesus to a righteous angel.
00:51:29.360 --> 00:51:32.000
Matthew compares Jesus to a wise philosopher.
00:51:32.239 --> 00:51:36.400
Jesus approves of Thomas's answer and rebukes Peter's and Matthew's.
00:51:36.639 --> 00:51:44.960
As far as we can tell, Matthew had no particular place of prominence in early Christianity aside from the belief that he authored the first Gospel.
00:51:45.280 --> 00:52:01.280
Many scholars have interpreted this story in the Gospel of Thomas as an implied polemic against the Gospel of Matthew, since the Gospel of Thomas has Jesus rebuke this depiction of him in favor of the depiction offered in the Gospel of Thomas.
00:52:01.519 --> 00:52:09.519
The sayings in the Gospel of Thomas must presuppose the existence of Matthew's Gospel and its attribution to Matthew.
00:52:09.760 --> 00:52:18.400
If Matthew in this passage represents Matthew's Gospel, then it becomes highly likely that Peter represents Mark's Gospel.
00:52:18.719 --> 00:52:32.239
If this hypothesis is correct, then we have early, independent, and somewhat hostile, albeit implied testimony, for the propositions that Peter was the source behind Mark and that Matthew wrote a gospel.
00:52:32.480 --> 00:52:36.400
Obviously, this is a controversial and speculative take, as Dave acknowledges.
00:52:36.559 --> 00:52:38.239
But what about when it was written?
00:52:38.559 --> 00:52:43.679
Standard estimates place it between AD 100 and 140.
00:52:43.840 --> 00:52:46.719
That's at least 40 years before Irenaeus.
00:52:46.960 --> 00:52:48.320
There is no standard estimate.
00:52:48.400 --> 00:52:52.960
The dating debate is divided, and FBR presents one side of it as if it's settled.
00:52:53.119 --> 00:53:07.119
Respected scholars Simon Gathercole and Jacob Rodriguez give
us a date range of 135 to 200 CE, and Mark Goodacre argues for any date after 135, almost entirely after FBR's optimistic interpretation.
00:53:07.280 --> 00:53:15.920
Goodacre and others conclude that the Gospel of Thomas is aware of the Barkokba revolt of 135 CE, making that the earliest possible date.
00:53:16.079 --> 00:53:26.800
Since the Gospel of Thomas is first quoted by others in 200-240 CE, it could easily be late 2nd century, which is why the experts allow this in their range.
00:53:27.039 --> 00:53:30.480
It's possibly earlier than murder, but not definitively so.
00:53:30.719 --> 00:53:33.599
The 16th example was Polycarp of Smyrna.
00:53:33.920 --> 00:53:42.159
We saw that by cross-referencing two passages in Against Heresies, Irenaeus tells us that Polycarp said that John authored the fourth gospel.
00:53:42.320 --> 00:53:51.280
I then extrapolated this to the entirety of Irenaeus' tradition concerning the origins of the Gospels in Against Heresies 311.
00:53:51.679 --> 00:54:01.440
I will therefore put it at 9 out of 10 that Polycarp named John as the author of the fourth gospel, and 7 out of 10 that he named the Synoptics.
00:54:01.760 --> 00:54:04.880
Again, I think this one is worth some context beyond the report card.
00:54:05.119 --> 00:54:10.239
Irenaeus was a student of Polycarp, both from himself and from other church fathers.
00:54:10.480 --> 00:54:19.360
Irenaeus claims he could remember much of the oral teaching of Polycarp of Smyrna, whom he calls that blessed and apostolic presbyter.
00:54:19.519 --> 00:54:33.760
Apparently Polycarp was in the habit of discoursing to them both about the teaching and miracles of Jesus, as these were handed on by John and the others who had seen the Lord, with whom Polycarp had been an associate.
00:54:33.920 --> 00:54:44.639
The authority of Irenaeus for saying these things is once more the trustworthy Polycarp, who received directly from the Apostles the truth transmitted by the church.
00:54:44.800 --> 00:54:56.880
There can be no doubt, therefore, that Irenaeus accepted John the Apostle as the author of the fourth gospel and believed it to have been published at Ephesus on the basis of Polycarp's testimony.
00:54:57.039 --> 00:55:07.840
But the most important point is that Polycarp was a disciple of the Apostle John, meaning that Polycarp's knowledge of the names on the Gospels goes back to the first century.
00:55:08.000 --> 00:55:17.280
Polycarp would be a clear example of someone who is a full generation earlier than Irenaeus and who knew the Gospels by the same names as Irenaeus.
00:55:17.440 --> 00:55:21.119
But this is a house of cards where every card is soggy.
00:55:21.519 --> 00:55:26.239
It is wetter than the worst day of Noah and Mrs.
00:55:26.400 --> 00:55:28.880
Noah when they're saying, Have we got enough wood?
00:55:29.039 --> 00:55:30.000
That is so wet.
00:55:30.239 --> 00:55:31.039
It was wet, wasn't it?
00:55:31.119 --> 00:55:31.519
It was wet.
00:55:31.679 --> 00:55:39.039
Irenaeus explicitly describes himself as a mere child or boy when he saw Polycarp and Smyrna, writing against heresies.
00:55:39.199 --> 00:55:50.400
Roughly 40 years later in Gaul, Irenaeus is relying on childhood reminiscences, which critical scholars regard as prone to confusion, idealization, and historical inaccuracy.
00:55:50.559 --> 00:56:01.599
These specific anecdotes he actually reports, such as John fleeing the Bath House, are second-hand stereotype stories rather than detailed verifiable records of Polycarp's theological instruction.
00:56:01.760 --> 00:56:11.599
Many Johannine scholars argue that Irenaeus confused John the Apostle, son of Zebedee, with John the Elder, a second-generation presbyter in Asia Minor mentioned by Papias.
00:56:11.840 --> 00:56:19.840
Scholars including Martin Hengel and Michael Koch think Polycarp's teacher was this non-apostolic elder John, whom Irenaeus merged with the Apostle.
00:56:20.000 --> 00:56:27.440
Eusebius himself corrects Irenaeus for making this very mistake about Papias, though Dave wants to frame this as sour grapes.
00:56:27.679 --> 00:56:38.000
The first thing we have to appreciate is that Eusebius did not like Papius, even going so far as to single him out as a man of very small intelligence.
00:56:38.320 --> 00:56:47.039
This strong dislike for Papius was born out of Eusebius' disdain for the millennialism enthusiastically embraced by Papius.
00:56:47.280 --> 00:56:53.679
More than this, Eusebius demonstrates a clear motivation to distance Papias from the Apostle John.
00:56:53.920 --> 00:57:04.719
Nevertheless, critical scholars view the John Polycarp Irenaeus chain not as an unbroken historical record, but as a secondary construct for combating heresy accusations.
00:57:04.880 --> 00:57:11.920
Irenaeus had a strong polemical incentive to construct a direct, simplified line of unbroken apostolic authority.
00:57:12.079 --> 00:57:18.159
Some scholars doubt that Irenaeus received his gospel attributions from Polycarp's oral teaching at all.
00:57:18.320 --> 00:57:21.119
There's no such claim in the writings of Polycarp.
00:57:21.280 --> 00:57:38.639
Irenaeus, in the second book of his work against heresies, writes as follows And all the elders that associated with John the disciple of the Lord in Asia bear witness that John delivered it to them, for he remained among them until the time of Trajan.
00:57:39.039 --> 00:57:42.400
The word it here likely refers to John's gospel.
00:57:42.639 --> 00:57:49.119
In Against Heresies 222-5, Uranius is arguing that Jesus lived past the age of 40, heading towards 50.
00:57:49.199 --> 00:57:58.239
The elders who knew John in Asia, he says, testify that John passed along that information, where that information is Jesus' age, not a gospel in general.
00:57:58.400 --> 00:58:03.360
Hill identifies the Apostolic Presbyter of Against Heresies Book 4 with Polycarp.
00:58:03.440 --> 00:58:11.360
The four gospel tradition sits in Book 3, and
David admits that stretching that identification to cover it is his own extrapolation.
00:58:11.599 --> 00:58:15.360
The seventeenth and final example was Papius of Heropolis.
00:58:15.679 --> 00:58:19.599
Papius fairly uncontroversially names Mark as a gospel author.
00:58:19.840 --> 00:58:22.960
I will rate my confidence here at 10 out of 10.
00:58:23.199 --> 00:58:37.840
Things are a little murkier with Matthew and John, since there's the question of whether or not Papius says that Matthew wrote in Hebrew, and our dependence upon the anti-Marcionite prologue for a direct statement that Papius named John as a gospel author.
00:58:38.000 --> 00:58:46.239
But these worries strike me as minimal, and so I put my confidence at 9 out of 10 that Papius names Matthew and John as Gospel authors.
00:58:46.480 --> 00:58:51.519
We have independent good reasons to think that Papius was familiar with the Gospel of Luke.
00:58:51.679 --> 00:58:56.320
However, to get to Papius naming the Gospel of Luke, we require C.
00:58:56.480 --> 00:58:56.559
E.
00:58:56.719 --> 00:58:57.760
Hill's thesis.
00:58:58.000 --> 00:59:05.039
Fortunately, I think that Hill's evidence is incredibly strong, especially when supplemented by the work of Dean Furlong.
00:59:05.199 --> 00:59:10.559
Therefore, I put it at 8.5 out of 10 that Papius named Luke as a gospel author.
00:59:10.800 --> 00:59:14.239
Well we know of Papius only from quotations by later authors.
00:59:14.480 --> 00:59:22.079
He is undoubtedly earlier than Justin Murder in our timeline, and would warrant very important consideration if it existed.
00:59:22.400 --> 00:59:23.760
Huge for me if true.
00:59:23.920 --> 00:59:31.119
As you'll recall, our criteria for gospel author attestation is quoting the gospel and attributing that to an author's name.
00:59:31.280 --> 00:59:42.239
As none of the extant quotations of Papius quote any of the canonical gospels, this low bar is not one that can even be crossed, which makes Dave's confidence levels here bewildering to me.
00:59:42.480 --> 00:59:47.360
The thing about there being no evidence being your evidence is that there's no evidence.
00:59:47.679 --> 00:59:50.639
Nevertheless, FBR makes a case for each.
00:59:50.960 --> 00:59:56.639
So Matthew composed the oracles in a Hebrew dialect, and everyone interpreted them as best he could.
00:59:56.960 --> 01:00:02.880
With no quotation provided, we cannot know to what literary composition that Papias is referring.
01:00:03.039 --> 01:00:07.119
But even worse, what he does say sounds like some other work.
01:00:07.360 --> 01:00:15.280
Near unanimous scholarly consensus holds that canonical Matthew was composed directly in Greek, not translated from Aramaic or Hebrew.
01:00:15.440 --> 01:00:25.280
Canonical Matthew takes over about 90% of Mark's material, much of it in nearly identical Greek, and relies on Greek Q or double attestation sources.
01:00:25.440 --> 01:00:34.480
It is implausible that an apostle and an eyewitness writing in Aramaic would rely verbatim on a non-eyewitness Greek text.
01:00:34.719 --> 01:00:44.159
The word translated as language here is the Greek word dialecto, and it can also be legitimately translated as style or dialect.
01:00:44.320 --> 01:00:50.239
On this interpretation, Papias would be saying that Matthew wrote for a Hellenistic Jewish audience.
01:01:01.119 --> 01:01:11.440
Some scholars have argued that the terms Ibodie dialecto do not refer to the Hebrew or Aramaic language, but rather to a Jewish style or literary form.
01:01:11.760 --> 01:01:19.039
In Hellenus the Creek, dialectos compared with a nationality explicitly means language, and Hermanuo means translation.
01:01:19.199 --> 01:01:24.079
Papias's words most naturally mean that Matthew wrote in Hebrew and was translated.
01:01:24.239 --> 01:01:28.000
Is the case for Matthew really built on such a minority of you?
01:01:28.159 --> 01:01:40.960
And it's not mentioned often enough that Papias recounts a bizarre version of the death of Judas, where the disciple becomes grotesquely obese, swelling so enormously that he cannot pass through a space wide enough for a wagon.
01:01:41.119 --> 01:01:48.559
His eyelids become so swollen that he cannot see, his genitals become hideously enlarged, and his body uses pus and worms.
01:01:48.800 --> 01:01:54.639
This is, of course, wildly different from the account in Matthew 27, which simply reports that Judas hanged himself.
01:01:54.800 --> 01:02:09.599
If the book Papius believed Matthew had written was the same as our canonical Matthew, it is striking that he would preserve such an extravagant alternative tradition about Judas' death without any apparent concern for its divergence from the alleged eyewitness account.
01:02:09.760 --> 01:02:18.159
It is by no means clear that what Papias was describing is the gospel we are debating, and many scholars, including conservatives, concede this.
01:02:18.400 --> 01:02:35.440
Papius fairly uncontroversially names Mark as a gospel author, in the very same passage, claiming that Mark, having become the interpreter of Peter, wrote down accurately, though not in order, whatsoever he remembered of the things said or done by Christ.
01:02:35.760 --> 01:02:49.360
Once again, Papius' surviving description contains no identifiable quotation from the gospel he attributes to Mark, leaving us unable to verify through direct textual comparison that he was referring to our canonical Mark.
01:02:49.519 --> 01:02:54.400
Canonical Mark is not a disjointed collection of raw notes or oral anecdotes.
01:02:54.559 --> 01:02:58.800
It possesses a deliberate, coherent narrative structure and theological design.
01:02:58.960 --> 01:03:14.480
Furthermore, internal features of Mark, like inaccuracies regarding Palestinian geography, misunderstandings of Jewish customs, antipatrine narrative themes, and reliance on Greek Septuagint Old Testament quotes, make direct dictation from Peter highly implausible.
01:03:14.639
--> 01:03:18.880
Dave then tries to take Papias further than most, attempting connections with John.
01:03:19.119 --> 01:03:32.400
For example, Papius lists the names of the apostles as they appear exclusively in the Gospel of John, which argues for his firsthand knowledge of the Gospel, combining the lists from John 1 and John 21.
01:03:32.719 --> 01:03:39.920
This demonstrates familiarity with the apostolic names circulating in Age of Meyer, not attestation of fourth Gospel's authorship.
01:03:40.159 --> 01:03:46.159
Also, consider this often neglected fragment of Papius from the anti-Marcionite prologue to John.
01:03:46.400 --> 01:04:02.880
The Gospel of John was made known and given to the churches by John while he yet remained in the body, as one Papius by name of Heropolis, a beloved disciple of John, has related in his exoteric, that is, in his last five books.
01:04:03.119 --> 01:04:10.239
The Latin anti-Marcionite prologue to John, which claims Papias served as John's scribe, dates to the 4th to 5th century.
01:04:10.480 --> 01:04:15.679
Skeptics will be swift to point out that the prologue contains some dubious historical information.
01:04:16.000 --> 01:04:16.800
Indeed, they will.
01:04:16.960 --> 01:04:26.880
It is heavily garbled, misnames Papias's work, mistakes Papius' elder John for the Apostle John, and anachronistically places Marcion's ministry in the lifetime of John.
01:04:27.119 --> 01:04:37.519
Importantly, however, the prologue is not the source of this information about John's authorship, for the prologue is merely passing on information obtained from Papius.
01:04:37.840 --> 01:04:38.639
That's the claim.
01:04:38.800 --> 01:04:46.239
If the prologue is wrong about so many other things, why should we be confident in his sourcing of material that would be from 200 years earlier?
01:04:46.400 --> 01:04:53.519
By what criteria do we determine that this unattested Papias claim is correct when the author is clearly an uncareful historian?
01:04:53.679 --> 01:05:03.519
In Papius' undisputed fragments, preserved by Eusebius, Papius never names John as the author of the fourth gospel, nor does Eusebius attribute any such statement to him.
01:05:03.679 --> 01:05:08.880
And then Dave dedicates more than half an hour to advocating for a hypothesis from C.E.
01:05:09.039 --> 01:05:09.360
Hill.
01:05:09.599 --> 01:05:13.360
To get to Papius naming the Gospel of Luke, we require C.
01:05:13.440 --> 01:05:13.519
E.
01:05:13.679 --> 01:05:14.719
Hill's thesis.
01:05:14.880 --> 01:05:26.559
In Ecclesiastical History 324, 5 through 13, Eusebius mentions a record that recounts the history of the writing of the four Gospels, Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John.
01:05:26.719 --> 01:05:31.599
Eusebius does not name the source of this record, but a literary analysis by C.
01:05:31.760 --> 01:05:31.840
E.
01:05:32.000 --> 01:05:40.800
Hill demonstrates close parallels between what Eusebius' source says about Matthew and Mark and what Papius says about Matthew and Mark.
01:05:41.039 --> 01:05:46.320
Eusebius demonstrates a clear motivation to distance Papius from the Apostle John.
01:05:46.480 --> 01:05:53.280
Eusebius is definitely presenting this account of the origins of Matthew and John as from a single written source.
01:05:53.440 --> 01:05:59.599
And though he does not name that source, there is no credible alternative to regarding it as Papius of.
01:06:00.159 --> 01:06:00.880
Heropolis.
01:06:01.199 --> 01:06:05.119
These common elements and concerns point to a common source.
01:06:05.280 --> 01:06:21.039
From a comparison with the other papian fragments on the Gospels in Eusebius, then, there is fairly conclusive support for regarding Eusebius's source in 324, 5 through 13 as being Papius' tradition about the fourth gospel.
01:06:21.280 --> 01:06:25.360
Even Dave knows the most important papius scholar isn't on board.
01:06:25.599 --> 01:06:40.239
In the most up-to-date collection of the fragments of Papius, Stephen Carlson, perhaps the world's leading papian scholar, includes ecclesiastical history 324, 5 through 13, as a potential citation of Papius.
01:06:40.400 --> 01:06:45.360
In fairness, Carlson ultimately doesn't think that this is a genuine fragment of Papius.
01:06:45.599 --> 01:06:45.840
Right.
01:06:46.000 --> 01:06:52.000
In his 2021 edition of the Papius Fragments, Carlson lists this passage among the possible citations.
01:06:52.239 --> 01:06:57.039
Then he concludes that a more fitting source for the core of the content seems to be Clement.
01:06:57.440 --> 01:07:01.599
Dave's own pick for the world's leading Papius scholar points away from Papias.
01:07:01.840 --> 01:07:02.800
Critical scholars like T.
01:07:02.880 --> 01:07:16.800
Scott Manor, Enrico Norelli, Michael Koch, and Francis Watson argue that Hill's thesis relies on overextending an unnamed Eusebian source and ignoring major textual, logical, and historical contradictions.
01:07:17.039 --> 01:07:19.199
Richard Bacham is only partially persuaded.
01:07:19.280 --> 01:07:25.920
He grants that Hill has made a good case for 324, 6 to 7, but thinks the source ends at 8A.
01:07:26.079 --> 01:07:28.400
Grammatical markers say this stretch doesn't work.
01:07:28.559 --> 01:07:33.679
Eusebius's use of a traditional source ends at Ecclesiastical History 324.
01:07:37.280 --> 01:07:47.039
Then in 8B, Eusebius introduces the Greek logical particle goon, signaling that he has finished citing his source and is transitioning into his own editorial commentary.
01:07:47.199 --> 01:07:54.800
The phrase they say in 324.11 does not establish that Eusebius is quoting a formal second-century Papian text.
01:07:54.880 --> 01:08:03.440
As Michael Koch observes, it could instead introduce an oral report, a popular Christian explanation, or Eusebius' own paraphrase of an earlier tradition.
01:08:03.599 --> 01:08:05.119
It would also create a contradiction.
01:08:05.199 --> 01:08:10.159
In Papius' undisputed fragment, he
explicitly acknowledges that Mark lacks order.
01:08:10.320 --> 01:08:23.680
In contrast, Ecclesiastical Histories 324, 11 to 13, maintains that the four gospels do not conflict, arguing that John wrote specifically to cover the period before John the Baptist's imprisonment, while the synoptics cover events after.
01:08:23.920 --> 01:08:35.279
Bacum and Norelli emphasize that Papius could not have simultaneously maintained that Mark lacked proper chronological order while authoring a harmonization scheme defending the order of all four gospels.
01:08:35.439 --> 01:08:43.279
As for a plausible alternative, Manner and Coke demonstrate that this passage represents Eusebius' own fourth century apologetic response to Origen.
01:08:43.359 --> 01:08:46.479
Eusebius isn't using Papian terms like memoirs.
01:08:46.560 --> 01:08:58.880
He's using Origen's exact terminology, referring to the Gospels as historical accounts, and directly echoing Origen's phrasing to claim that once his solution is understood, the Gospels no longer appear to disagree.
01:08:59.119 --> 01:09:12.640
Finally, Irenaeus read Papius' five-volume work directly, and he and later writers like Clement of Alexandria, Tertullian, and the author of the Meratorian fragment frequently discuss the origins and different beginnings of the Gospels.
01:09:12.800 --> 01:09:21.600
Yet none of these early writers ever quote or cite the specific harmonizing argument found in ecclesiastical histories featuring John the Baptist's imprisonment.
01:09:21.680 --> 01:09:31.279
If Papias had originated this solution, it is inexplicable that early authors struggling with gospel discrepancies completely ignored it until Eusebius.
01:09:31.600 --> 01:09:41.359
All this points to the conclusion that Papius and Heropolis, writing probably in the 120s, knew all four Gospels, Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John.
01:09:41.680 --> 01:09:42.720
Strongly disagree.
01:09:42.880 --> 01:09:49.279
In the end, Papias attaches no quotes from any canonical gospels to any named author.
01:09:49.520 --> 01:09:55.600
So, going back to the Gospel Anonymity Thesis, the Gospels were written somewhere around 70 to 100 AD.
01:09:55.680 --> 01:10:00.000
Justin Martyr quotes them heavily around 150, with no names attached.
01:10:00.159 --> 01:10:05.119
The first surviving source to attach the four familiar names is Irenaeus around 180.
01:10:05.520 --> 01:10:11.359
Careful proponents of the anonymity thesis will say that the names developed and caught on between A.D.
01:10:11.520 --> 01:10:13.279
160 and 180.
01:10:13.439 --> 01:10:21.119
Some versions vaguely assert only that the names on the Gospels stuck to them somewhere between the time of Justin Martyr around A.D.
01:10:21.279 --> 01:10:24.880
160 and the time of Irenaeus around A.D.
01:10:25.039 --> 01:10:25.520
180.
01:10:25.760 --> 01:10:40.960
Given these criteria, I've made my own report card of Dave's 17 so-called eyewitnesses, indicating which have a broad consensus dating prior to Justin Murder, each canonical gospel they directly cite, and attribute to the traditional author name, and then an overall past fail.
01:10:41.039 --> 01:10:46.720
You'll notice that none of these 17 examples are defeaters of the strong anonymity hypothesis.
01:10:46.880 --> 01:10:55.840
In fact, by my lights, many of these are circumstances that bolster the idea that there wasn't a coalescing of authors' names until the mid-second century.
01:10:56.000 --> 01:10:58.399
And I will incorporate them further into my projects.
01:10:58.560 --> 01:11:07.680
I do want to thank Dave for the effort it would have taken to put this together, his academic demeanor, his structural and methodological clarity, and what I read as good faith motives.
01:11:07.840 --> 01:11:11.600
He's clearly well read, but he's comfortable on the fringe.
01:11:11.760 --> 01:11:14.960
Matthew written in AD forty-two, Mark written last.
01:11:15.119 --> 01:11:20.239
These are positions that even the scholars he quotes approvingly, like Bacham and Hengel, don't share.
01:11:20.399 --> 01:11:28.399
So when Dave's dating of a witness lands decades earlier than the consensus, I'd encourage readers to treat that as a feature of Dave, not of the others.
01:11:28.560 --> 01:11:29.680
Thank you so much for watching.
01:11:29.840 --> 01:11:36.399
And for more of this former Christian taking a look at the claims of Christians, tap on the thumbnail on screen now, and I'll see you over there.
01:11:36.560 --> 01:11:37.760
Until next time.
01:11:38.319 --> 01:11:38.960
Later.